Test: BIOMD0000000115.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000115.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
plots: plot
comparison: comparison of simulators

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000115.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL8910960676.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: fy  y  x 
Simulators: BioUML  ByoDyn  MathSBML  Oscill8 Core  SBToolbox2  SBWOdeSolver  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  jsim 
timesimulation fy y x
var error var error var error
0.0 BioUML2,06543E-10,001,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 ByoDyn2,06543E-10,001,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 MathSBML - - 1,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 Oscill8 Core - - 1,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 SBToolbox22,06540E-10,001,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 copasi - - 1,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 jsim2,06543E-10,001,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.2 BioUML7,60903E-20,007,49986E-10,001,27857E00,00
0.2 ByoDyn7,60903E-20,007,49986E-10,001,27857E00,00
0.2 MathSBML - - 7,49986E-10,001,27857E00,00
0.2 Oscill8 Core - - 6,99772E-16,71,33326E04,3
0.2 SBToolbox27,62609E-20,227,50438E-10,001,27778E00,00
0.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 7,49988E-10,001,27857E00,00
0.2 copasi - - 7,49986E-10,001,27857E00,00
0.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 7,49986E-10,001,27857E00,00
0.2 jsim7,60903E-20,007,49986E-10,001,27857E00,00
0.4 BioUML3,62937E-20,006,16737E-10,001,47617E00,00
0.4 ByoDyn3,62937E-20,006,16737E-10,001,47617E00,00
0.4 MathSBML - - 6,16737E-10,001,47617E00,00
0.4 Oscill8 Core - - 5,35750E-113,11,57537E06,7
0.4 SBToolbox23,63475E-20,156,16966E-10,001,47533E00,00
0.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 6,16739E-10,001,47617E00,00
0.4 copasi - - 6,16737E-10,001,47617E00,00
0.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 6,16737E-10,001,47617E00,00
0.4 jsim3,62937E-20,006,16737E-10,001,47617E00,00
0.6 BioUML2,00789E-20,005,29682E-10,001,64917E00,00
0.6 ByoDyn2,00789E-20,005,29682E-10,001,64917E00,00
0.6 MathSBML - - 5,29682E-10,001,64917E00,00
0.6 Oscill8 Core - - 4,46230E-115,71,76759E07,2
0.6 SBToolbox22,00352E-20,225,29385E-10,001,64860E00,00
0.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 5,29684E-10,001,64916E00,00
0.6 copasi - - 5,29683E-10,001,64916E00,00
0.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 5,29682E-10,001,64917E00,00
0.6 jsim2,00789E-20,005,29682E-10,001,64917E00,00
0.8 BioUML1,27425E-20,004,71883E-10,001,80721E00,00
0.8 ByoDyn1,27425E-20,004,71883E-10,001,80721E00,00
0.8 MathSBML - - 4,71883E-10,001,80721E00,00
0.8 Oscill8 Core - - 3,97463E-115,71,93248E06,9
0.8 SBToolbox21,26731E-20,554,71228E-10,001,80679E00,00
0.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,71884E-10,001,80721E00,00
0.8 copasi - - 4,71883E-10,001,80721E00,00
0.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,71883E-10,001,80721E00,00
0.8 jsim1,27425E-20,004,71883E-10,001,80721E00,00
1.0 BioUML9,18104E-30,004,34363E-10,001,95438E00,00
1.0 ByoDyn9,18104E-30,004,34363E-10,001,95438E00,00
1.0 MathSBML - - 4,34363E-10,001,95438E00,00
1.0 Oscill8 Core - - 3,70986E-114,52,08238E06,5
1.0 SBToolbox29,12517E-30,614,33690E-10,001,95399E00,00
1.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,34363E-10,001,95439E00,00
1.0 copasi - - 4,34363E-10,001,95438E00,00
1.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,34363E-10,001,95438E00,00
1.0 jsim9,18104E-30,004,34363E-10,001,95438E00,00
1.2 BioUML7,35488E-30,004,10746E-10,002,09368E00,00
1.2 ByoDyn7,35488E-30,004,10746E-10,002,09368E00,00
1.2 MathSBML - - 4,10746E-10,002,09368E00,00
1.2 Oscill8 Core - - 3,56703E-113,02,22405E06,2
1.2 SBToolbox27,31138E-30,594,10130E-10,002,09328E00,00
1.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,10747E-10,002,09368E00,00
1.2 copasi - - 4,10746E-10,002,09368E00,00
1.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,10746E-10,002,09368E00,00
1.2 jsim7,35488E-30,004,10746E-10,002,09368E00,00
1.4 BioUML6,38875E-30,003,96440E-10,002,22739E00,00
1.4 ByoDyn6,38875E-30,003,96440E-10,002,22739E00,00
1.4 MathSBML - - 3,96440E-10,002,22739E00,00
1.4 Oscill8 Core - - 3,49088E-111,82,36116E06,0
1.4 SBToolbox26,35228E-30,573,95873E-10,002,22698E00,00
1.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,96440E-10,002,22739E00,00
1.4 copasi - - 3,96440E-10,002,22739E00,00
1.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,96440E-10,002,22739E00,00
1.4 jsim6,38875E-30,003,96440E-10,002,22739E00,00
1.6 BioUML5,88148E-30,003,88276E-10,002,35717E00,00
1.6 ByoDyn5,88148E-30,003,88276E-10,002,35717E00,00
1.6 MathSBML - - 3,88276E-10,002,35717E00,00
1.6 Oscill8 Core - - 3,45121E-111,02,49575E05,9
1.6 SBToolbox25,85005E-30,533,87748E-10,002,35668E00,00
1.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,88276E-10,002,35717E00,00
1.6 copasi - - 3,88276E-10,002,35717E00,00
1.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,88276E-10,002,35717E00,00
1.6 jsim5,88148E-30,003,88276E-10,002,35717E00,00
1.8 BioUML5,63662E-30,003,84146E-10,002,48411E00,00
1.8 ByoDyn5,63662E-30,003,84146E-10,002,48411E00,00
1.8 MathSBML - - 3,84146E-10,002,48411E00,00
1.8 Oscill8 Core - - 3,43149E-110,62,62892E05,8
1.8 SBToolbox25,61282E-30,423,83735E-10,002,48357E00,00
1.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,84146E-10,002,48411E00,00
1.8 copasi - - 3,84146E-10,002,48411E00,00
1.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,84146E-10,002,48411E00,00
1.8 jsim5,63662E-30,003,84146E-10,002,48411E00,00
2.0 BioUML5,55207E-30,003,82689E-10,002,60892E00,00
2.0 ByoDyn5,55207E-30,003,82689E-10,002,60892E00,00
2.0 MathSBML - - 3,82689E-10,002,60892E00,00
2.0 Oscill8 Core - - 3,42268E-110,52,76127E05,8
2.0 SBToolbox25,53178E-30,373,82334E-10,002,60836E00,00
2.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,82689E-10,002,60892E00,00
2.0 copasi - - 3,82690E-10,002,60892E00,00
2.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,82689E-10,002,60892E00,00
2.0 jsim5,55207E-30,003,82689E-10,002,60892E00,00
2.2 BioUML5,57231E-30,003,83039E-10,002,73202E00,00
2.2 ByoDyn5,57231E-30,003,83039E-10,002,73202E00,00
2.2 MathSBML - - 3,83039E-10,002,73202E00,00
2.2 Oscill8 Core - - 3,41984E-110,62,89314E05,9
2.2 SBToolbox25,55266E-30,353,82699E-10,002,73146E00,00
2.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,83040E-10,002,73202E00,00
2.2 copasi - - 3,83040E-10,002,73202E00,00
2.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,83039E-10,002,73202E00,00
2.2 jsim5,57231E-30,003,83039E-10,002,73202E00,00
2.4 BioUML5,66641E-30,003,84655E-10,002,85365E00,00
2.4 ByoDyn5,66641E-30,003,84655E-10,002,85365E00,00
2.4 MathSBML - - 3,84655E-10,002,85365E00,00
2.4 Oscill8 Core - - 3,42027E-111,03,02470E06,0
2.4 SBToolbox25,64929E-30,303,84364E-10,002,85314E00,00
2.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,84656E-10,002,85365E00,00
2.4 copasi - - 3,84656E-10,002,85365E00,00
2.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,84655E-10,002,85365E00,00
2.4 jsim5,66641E-30,003,84655E-10,002,85365E00,00
2.6 BioUML5,81734E-30,003,87207E-10,002,97393E00,00
2.6 ByoDyn5,81734E-30,003,87207E-10,002,97393E00,00
2.6 MathSBML - - 3,87207E-10,002,97393E00,00
2.6 Oscill8 Core - - 3,42247E-111,53,15605E06,1
2.6 SBToolbox25,79964E-30,303,86911E-10,002,97344E00,00
2.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,87207E-10,002,97393E00,00
2.6 copasi - - 3,87207E-10,002,97393E00,00
2.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,87207E-10,002,97393E00,00
2.6 jsim5,81734E-30,003,87207E-10,002,97393E00,00
2.8 BioUML6,01654E-30,003,90499E-10,003,09288E00,00
2.8 ByoDyn6,01654E-30,003,90499E-10,003,09288E00,00
2.8 MathSBML - - 3,90499E-10,003,09288E00,00
2.8 Oscill8 Core - - 3,42566E-112,23,28726E06,3
2.8 SBToolbox25,99799E-30,313,90200E-10,003,09242E00,00
2.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,90499E-10,003,09288E00,00
2.8 copasi - - 3,90499E-10,003,09288E00,00
2.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,90499E-10,003,09288E00,00
2.8 jsim6,01654E-30,003,90499E-10,003,09288E00,00
3.0 BioUML6,26104E-30,003,94431E-10,003,21046E00,00
3.0 ByoDyn6,26104E-30,003,94431E-10,003,21046E00,00
3.0 MathSBML - - 3,94431E-10,003,21046E00,00
3.0 Oscill8 Core - - 3,42937E-113,03,41833E06,5
3.0 SBToolbox26,24124E-30,323,94117E-10,003,21006E00,00
3.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,94432E-10,003,21046E00,00
3.0 copasi - - 3,94432E-10,003,21046E00,00
3.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,94431E-10,003,21046E00,00
3.0 jsim6,26104E-30,003,94431E-10,003,21046E00,00
3.2 BioUML6,55214E-30,003,98968E-10,003,32659E00,00
3.2 ByoDyn6,55214E-30,003,98968E-10,003,32659E00,00
3.2 MathSBML - - 3,98968E-10,003,32659E00,00
3.2 Oscill8 Core - - 3,43337E-113,93,54931E06,7
3.2 SBToolbox26,52988E-30,343,98623E-10,003,32624E00,00
3.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,98968E-10,003,32659E00,00
3.2 copasi - - 3,98968E-10,003,32659E00,00
3.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,98968E-10,003,32659E00,00
3.2 jsim6,55214E-30,003,98968E-10,003,32659E00,00
3.4 BioUML6,89502E-30,004,04123E-10,003,44114E00,00
3.4 ByoDyn6,89502E-30,004,04123E-10,003,44114E00,00
3.4 MathSBML - - 4,04123E-10,003,44114E00,00
3.4 Oscill8 Core - - 3,43753E-114,93,68018E06,9
3.4 SBToolbox26,86778E-30,404,03718E-10,003,44086E00,00
3.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,04123E-10,003,44114E00,00
3.4 copasi - - 4,04123E-10,003,44114E00,00
3.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,04123E-10,003,44114E00,00
3.4 jsim6,89502E-30,004,04123E-10,003,44114E00,00
3.6 BioUML7,29902E-30,004,09958E-10,003,55391E00,00
3.6 ByoDyn7,29902E-30,004,09958E-10,003,55391E00,00
3.6 MathSBML - - 4,09958E-10,003,55391E00,00
3.6 Oscill8 Core - - 3,44177E-116,03,81097E07,2
3.6 SBToolbox27,26849E-30,424,09528E-10,003,55368E00,00
3.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,09959E-10,003,55391E00,00
3.6 copasi - - 4,09958E-10,003,55391E00,00
3.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,09958E-10,003,55391E00,00
3.6 jsim7,29902E-30,004,09958E-10,003,55391E00,00
3.8 BioUML7,77887E-30,004,16586E-10,003,66464E00,00
3.8 ByoDyn7,77887E-30,004,16586E-10,003,66464E00,00
3.8 MathSBML - - 4,16586E-10,003,66464E00,00
3.8 Oscill8 Core - - 3,44606E-117,23,94166E07,6
3.8 SBToolbox27,74015E-30,504,16061E-10,003,66461E00,00
3.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,16587E-10,003,66464E00,00
3.8 copasi - - 4,16587E-10,003,66464E00,00
3.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,16586E-10,003,66464E00,00
3.8 jsim7,77887E-30,004,16586E-10,003,66464E00,00
4.0 BioUML8,35711E-30,004,24183E-10,003,77299E00,00
4.0 ByoDyn8,35711E-30,004,24183E-10,003,77299E00,00
4.0 MathSBML - - 4,24183E-10,003,77299E00,00
4.0 Oscill8 Core - - 3,45038E-118,54,07226E07,9
4.0 SBToolbox28,30932E-30,574,23570E-10,003,77314E00,00
4.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,24184E-10,003,77298E00,00
4.0 copasi - - 4,24183E-10,003,77299E00,00
4.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,24183E-10,003,77299E00,00
4.0 jsim8,35711E-30,004,24183E-10,003,77299E00,00
4.2 BioUML9,06875E-30,004,33016E-10,003,87846E00,00
4.2 ByoDyn9,06875E-30,004,33016E-10,003,87846E00,00
4.2 MathSBML - - 4,33016E-10,003,87846E00,00
4.2 Oscill8 Core - - 3,45470E-120,14,20278E08,4
4.2 SBToolbox29,01105E-30,644,32323E-10,003,87872E00,00
4.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,33017E-10,003,87845E00,00
4.2 copasi - - 4,33017E-10,003,87846E00,00
4.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,33016E-10,003,87846E00,00
4.2 jsim9,06875E-30,004,33016E-10,003,87846E00,00
4.4 BioUML9,97028E-30,004,43499E-10,003,98035E00,00
4.4 ByoDyn9,97028E-30,004,43499E-10,003,98035E00,00
4.4 MathSBML - - 4,43499E-10,003,98035E00,00
4.4 Oscill8 Core - - 3,45903E-121,84,33321E08,8
4.4 SBToolbox29,88844E-30,824,42579E-10,003,98100E00,00
4.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,43501E-10,003,98035E00,00
4.4 copasi - - 4,43500E-10,003,98035E00,00
4.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,43499E-10,003,98035E00,00
4.4 jsim9,97028E-30,004,43499E-10,003,98035E00,00
4.6 BioUML1,11587E-20,004,56299E-10,004,07762E00,00
4.6 ByoDyn1,11587E-20,004,56299E-10,004,07762E00,00
4.6 MathSBML - - 4,56299E-10,004,07762E00,00
4.6 Oscill8 Core - - 3,46336E-123,94,46355E09,4
4.6 SBToolbox21,10556E-20,924,55233E-10,004,07844E00,00
4.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,56302E-10,004,07762E00,00
4.6 copasi - - 4,56300E-10,004,07762E00,00
4.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,56299E-10,004,07762E00,00
4.6 jsim1,11587E-20,004,56299E-10,004,07762E00,00
4.8 BioUML1,28150E-20,004,72561E-10,004,16854E00,00
4.8 ByoDyn1,28150E-20,004,72561E-10,004,16854E00,00
4.8 MathSBML - - 4,72561E-10,004,16854E00,00
4.8 Oscill8 Core - - 3,46769E-126,44,59381E010,2
4.8 SBToolbox21,26550E-21,24,71058E-10,004,17004E00,00
4.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,72565E-10,004,16854E00,00
4.8 copasi - - 4,72563E-10,004,16854E00,00
4.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,72561E-10,004,16854E00,00
4.8 jsim1,28150E-20,004,72561E-10,004,16854E00,00
5.0 BioUML1,53208E-20,004,94453E-10,004,25007E00,00
5.0 ByoDyn1,53208E-20,004,94453E-10,004,25007E00,00
5.0 MathSBML - - 4,94453E-10,004,25007E00,00
5.0 Oscill8 Core - - 3,47201E-129,54,72398E011,1
5.0 SBToolbox21,50620E-21,74,92315E-10,004,25240E00,00
5.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,94459E-10,004,25006E00,00
5.0 copasi - - 4,94456E-10,004,25007E00,00
5.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,94453E-10,004,25007E00,00
5.0 jsim1,53208E-20,004,94453E-10,004,25007E00,00
5.2 BioUML1,96377E-20,005,26689E-10,004,31596E00,00
5.2 ByoDyn1,96377E-20,005,26689E-10,004,31596E00,00
5.2 MathSBML - - 5,26689E-10,004,31596E00,00
5.2 Oscill8 Core - - 3,47634E-133,64,85406E012,4
5.2 SBToolbox21,91657E-22,45,23428E-10,004,31979E00,00
5.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 5,26701E-10,004,31594E00,00
5.2 copasi - - 5,26695E-10,004,31595E00,00
5.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 5,26689E-10,004,31596E00,00
5.2 jsim1,96377E-20,005,26689E-10,004,31596E00,00
5.4 BioUML2,90252E-20,005,82130E-10,004,35023E00,00
5.4 ByoDyn2,90252E-20,005,82130E-10,004,35023E00,00
5.4 MathSBML - - 5,82130E-10,004,35023E00,00
5.4 Oscill8 Core - - 3,48066E-139,64,98406E014,4
5.4 SBToolbox22,79360E-23,85,76417E-10,004,35697E00,00
5.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 5,82155E-10,004,35020E00,00
5.4 copasi - - 5,82141E-10,004,35022E00,00
5.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 5,82130E-10,004,35023E00,00
5.4 jsim2,90252E-20,005,82130E-10,004,35023E00,00
5.6 BioUML6,36559E-20,007,14873E-10,004,29022E00,00
5.6 ByoDyn6,36559E-20,007,14873E-10,004,29022E00,00
5.6 MathSBML - - 7,14874E-10,004,29022E00,00
5.6 Oscill8 Core - - 3,48498E-150,15,11397E018,7
5.6 SBToolbox25,84120E-28,26,98640E-10,004,30899E00,00
5.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 7,14998E-10,004,29007E00,00
5.6 copasi - - 7,14907E-10,004,29018E00,00
5.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 7,14873E-10,004,29022E00,00
5.6 jsim6,36559E-20,007,14873E-10,004,29022E00,00
5.8 BioUML5,56491E-10,001,48172E00,003,52912E00,00
5.8 ByoDyn5,56491E-10,001,48172E00,003,52912E00,00
5.8 MathSBML - - 1,48173E00,003,52911E00,00
5.8 Oscill8 Core - - 3,48930E-174,65,24380E043,8
5.8 SBToolbox24,82153E-113,41,37570E00,003,64707E00,00
5.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,48173E00,003,52900E00,00
5.8 copasi - - 1,48195E00,003,52887E00,00
5.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,48172E00,003,52912E00,00
5.8 jsim5,56491E-10,001,48172E00,003,52912E00,00
6.0 BioUML8,34132E-10,002,09650E00,002,72694E00,00
6.0 ByoDyn8,34132E-10,002,09650E00,002,72694E00,00
6.0 MathSBML - - 2,09650E00,002,72693E00,00
6.0 Oscill8 Core - - 3,49362E-183,35,37354E095,8
6.0 SBToolbox28,35008E-10,112,09984E00,162,74412E00,00
6.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 2,09639E00,002,72703E00,00
6.0 copasi - - 2,09650E00,002,72690E00,00
6.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 2,09650E00,002,72694E00,00
6.0 jsim8,34132E-10,002,09650E00,002,72694E00,00
6.2 BioUML8,13377E-10,002,02283E00,002,58746E00,00
6.2 ByoDyn8,13377E-10,002,02283E00,002,58746E00,00
6.2 MathSBML - - 2,02283E00,002,58745E00,00
6.2 Oscill8 Core - - 3,49793E-182,75,50319E0112
6.2 SBToolbox28,16094E-10,332,03198E00,452,59731E00,00
6.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 2,02282E00,002,58745E00,00
6.2 copasi - - 2,02281E00,002,58743E00,00
6.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 2,02283E00,002,58746E00,00
6.2 jsim8,13377E-10,002,02283E00,002,58746E00,00
6.4 BioUML7,83347E-10,001,93053E00,002,48451E00,00
6.4 ByoDyn7,83347E-10,001,93053E00,002,48451E00,00
6.4 MathSBML - - 1,93053E00,002,48451E00,00
6.4 Oscill8 Core - - 3,50224E-181,95,63276E0126
6.4 SBToolbox27,86298E-10,381,93898E00,442,49334E00,00
6.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,93052E00,002,48451E00,00
6.4 copasi - - 1,93051E00,002,48449E00,00
6.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,93053E00,002,48451E00,00
6.4 jsim7,83347E-10,001,93053E00,002,48451E00,00
6.6 BioUML7,50895E-10,001,84471E00,002,39292E00,00
6.6 ByoDyn7,50895E-10,001,84471E00,002,39292E00,00
6.6 MathSBML - - 1,84471E00,002,39292E00,00
6.6 Oscill8 Core - - 3,50654E-181,05,76224E0140
6.6 SBToolbox27,54032E-10,421,85247E00,422,40060E00,00
6.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,84470E00,002,39292E00,00
6.6 copasi - - 1,84469E00,002,39291E00,00
6.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,84471E00,002,39292E00,00
6.6 jsim7,50895E-10,001,84471E00,002,39292E00,00
6.8 BioUML7,16642E-10,001,76551E00,002,31121E00,00
6.8 ByoDyn7,16642E-10,001,76551E00,002,31121E00,00
6.8 MathSBML - - 1,76551E00,002,31121E00,00
6.8 Oscill8 Core - - 3,51085E-180,15,89163E0154
6.8 SBToolbox27,20003E-10,471,77288E00,422,31775E00,00
6.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,76550E00,002,31120E00,00
6.8 copasi - - 1,76549E00,002,31119E00,00
6.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,76551E00,002,31121E00,00
6.8 jsim7,16642E-10,001,76551E00,002,31121E00,00
7.0 BioUML6,81063E-10,001,69238E00,002,23864E00,00
7.0 ByoDyn6,81063E-10,001,69238E00,002,23864E00,00
7.0 MathSBML - - 1,69238E00,002,23864E00,00
7.0 Oscill8 Core - - 3,51515E-179,26,02094E0168
7.0 SBToolbox26,84480E-10,501,69905E00,392,24425E00,00
7.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,69238E00,002,23864E00,00
7.0 copasi - - 1,69237E00,002,23863E00,00
7.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,69238E00,002,23864E00,00
7.0 jsim6,81063E-10,001,69238E00,002,23864E00,00
7.2 BioUML6,44667E-10,001,62481E00,002,17458E00,00
7.2 ByoDyn6,44667E-10,001,62481E00,002,17458E00,00
7.2 MathSBML - - 1,62481E00,002,17458E00,00
7.2 Oscill8 Core - - 3,51945E-178,36,15017E0182
7.2 SBToolbox26,48135E-10,541,63098E00,382,17926E00,00
7.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,62481E00,002,17458E00,00
7.2 copasi - - 1,62480E00,002,17457E00,00
7.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,62481E00,002,17458E00,00
7.2 jsim6,44667E-10,001,62481E00,002,17458E00,00
7.4 BioUML6,07977E-10,001,56233E00,002,11843E00,00
7.4 ByoDyn6,07977E-10,001,56233E00,002,11843E00,00
7.4 MathSBML - - 1,56233E00,002,11843E00,00
7.4 Oscill8 Core - - 3,52374E-177,46,27931E0196
7.4 SBToolbox26,11392E-10,561,56792E00,362,12232E00,00
7.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,56232E00,002,11843E00,00
7.4 copasi - - 1,56231E00,002,11842E00,00
7.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,56233E00,002,11843E00,00
7.4 jsim6,07977E-10,001,56233E00,002,11843E00,00
7.6 BioUML5,71498E-10,001,50451E00,002,06964E00,00
7.6 ByoDyn5,71498E-10,001,50451E00,002,06964E00,00
7.6 MathSBML - - 1,50450E00,002,06964E00,00
7.6 Oscill8 Core - - 3,52803E-176,56,40836E0209
7.6 SBToolbox25,74853E-10,591,50963E00,342,07285E00,00
7.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,50450E00,002,06964E00,00
7.6 copasi - - 1,50449E00,002,06964E00,00
7.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,50451E00,002,06964E00,00
7.6 jsim5,71498E-10,001,50451E00,002,06964E00,00
7.8 BioUML5,35697E-10,001,45097E00,002,02770E00,00
7.8 ByoDyn5,35697E-10,001,45097E00,002,02770E00,00
7.8 MathSBML - - 1,45097E00,002,02770E00,00
7.8 Oscill8 Core - - 3,53232E-175,76,53733E0222
7.8 SBToolbox25,38911E-10,601,45565E00,322,03026E00,00
7.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,45096E00,002,02770E00,00
7.8 copasi - - 1,45096E00,002,02770E00,00
7.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,45097E00,002,02770E00,00
7.8 jsim5,35697E-10,001,45097E00,002,02770E00,00
8.0 BioUML5,00979E-10,001,40137E00,001,99213E00,00
8.0 ByoDyn5,00979E-10,001,40137E00,001,99213E00,00
8.0 MathSBML - - 1,40137E00,001,99213E00,00
8.0 Oscill8 Core - - 3,53661E-174,86,66621E0234
8.0 SBToolbox25,04038E-10,611,40562E00,301,99406E00,00
8.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,40137E00,001,99212E00,00
8.0 copasi - - 1,40136E00,001,99212E00,00
8.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,40137E00,001,99213E00,00
8.0 jsim5,00979E-10,001,40137E00,001,99213E00,00
8.2 BioUML4,67682E-10,001,35542E00,001,96246E00,00
8.2 ByoDyn4,67682E-10,001,35542E00,001,96246E00,00
8.2 MathSBML - - 1,35542E00,001,96246E00,00
8.2 Oscill8 Core - - 3,54089E-173,96,79501E0246
8.2 SBToolbox24,70557E-10,611,35930E00,291,96385E00,00
8.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,35541E00,001,96246E00,00
8.2 copasi - - 1,35541E00,001,96246E00,00
8.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,35542E00,001,96246E00,00
8.2 jsim4,67682E-10,001,35542E00,001,96246E00,00
8.4 BioUML4,36067E-10,001,31283E00,001,93828E00,00
8.4 ByoDyn4,36067E-10,001,31283E00,001,93828E00,00
8.4 MathSBML - - 1,31283E00,001,93828E00,00
8.4 Oscill8 Core - - 3,54517E-173,06,92372E0257
8.4 SBToolbox24,38724E-10,611,31636E00,271,93912E00,00
8.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,31282E00,001,93828E00,00
8.4 copasi - - 1,31283E00,001,93827E00,00
8.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,31283E00,001,93828E00,00
8.4 jsim4,36067E-10,001,31283E00,001,93828E00,00
8.6 BioUML4,06325E-10,001,27338E00,001,91915E00,00
8.6 ByoDyn4,06325E-10,001,27338E00,001,91915E00,00
8.6 MathSBML - - 1,27338E00,001,91915E00,00
8.6 Oscill8 Core - - 3,54945E-172,17,05234E0267
8.6 SBToolbox24,08778E-10,601,27663E00,261,91967E00,00
8.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,27338E00,001,91915E00,00
8.6 copasi - - 1,27338E00,001,91915E00,00
8.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,27338E00,001,91915E00,00
8.6 jsim4,06325E-10,001,27338E00,001,91915E00,00
8.8 BioUML3,78580E-10,001,23686E00,001,90470E00,00
8.8 ByoDyn3,78580E-10,001,23686E00,001,90470E00,00
8.8 MathSBML - - 1,23686E00,001,90470E00,00
8.8 Oscill8 Core - - 3,55373E-171,37,18088E0277
8.8 SBToolbox23,80788E-10,581,23978E00,241,90482E00,00
8.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,23686E00,001,90470E00,00
8.8 copasi - - 1,23685E00,001,90470E00,00
8.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,23686E00,001,90470E00,00
8.8 jsim3,78580E-10,001,23686E00,001,90470E00,00
9.0 BioUML3,52897E-10,001,20309E00,001,89452E00,00
9.0 ByoDyn3,52897E-10,001,20309E00,001,89452E00,00
9.0 MathSBML - - 1,20309E00,001,89452E00,00
9.0 Oscill8 Core - - 3,55800E-170,47,30934E0286
9.0 SBToolbox23,54906E-10,571,20574E00,221,89426E00,00
9.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,20309E00,001,89452E00,00
9.0 copasi - - 1,20308E00,001,89452E00,00
9.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,20309E00,001,89452E00,00
9.0 jsim3,52897E-10,001,20309E00,001,89452E00,00
9.2 BioUML3,29296E-10,001,17190E00,001,88825E00,00
9.2 ByoDyn3,29296E-10,001,17190E00,001,88825E00,00
9.2 MathSBML - - 1,17190E00,001,88825E00,00
9.2 Oscill8 Core - - 3,56227E-169,67,43771E0294
9.2 SBToolbox23,31059E-10,541,17427E00,201,88768E00,00
9.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,17190E00,001,88824E00,00
9.2 copasi - - 1,17190E00,001,88825E00,00
9.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,17190E00,001,88825E00,00
9.2 jsim3,29296E-10,001,17190E00,001,88825E00,00
9.4 BioUML3,07761E-10,001,14319E00,001,88550E00,00
9.4 ByoDyn3,07761E-10,001,14319E00,001,88550E00,00
9.4 MathSBML - - 1,14319E00,001,88550E00,00
9.4 Oscill8 Core - - 3,56654E-168,87,56600E0301
9.4 SBToolbox23,09338E-10,511,14532E00,191,88469E00,00
9.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,14318E00,001,88550E00,00
9.4 copasi - - 1,14318E00,001,88550E00,00
9.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,14319E00,001,88550E00,00
9.4 jsim3,07761E-10,001,14319E00,001,88550E00,00
9.6 BioUML2,88249E-10,001,11683E00,001,88589E00,00
9.6 ByoDyn2,88249E-10,001,11683E00,001,88589E00,00
9.6 MathSBML - - 1,11683E00,001,88589E00,00
9.6 Oscill8 Core - - 3,57080E-168,07,69420E0308
9.6 SBToolbox22,89603E-10,471,11865E00,161,88490E00,00
9.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,11684E00,001,88588E00,00
9.6 copasi - - 1,11683E00,001,88589E00,00
9.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,11683E00,001,88589E00,00
9.6 jsim2,88249E-10,001,11683E00,001,88589E00,00
9.8 BioUML2,70702E-10,001,09276E00,001,88904E00,00
9.8 ByoDyn2,70702E-10,001,09276E00,001,88904E00,00
9.8 MathSBML - - 1,09276E00,001,88904E00,00
9.8 Oscill8 Core - - 3,57506E-167,37,82231E0314
9.8 SBToolbox22,71873E-10,431,09438E00,151,88790E00,00
9.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,09276E00,001,88904E00,00
9.8 copasi - - 1,09275E00,001,88904E00,00
9.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,09276E00,001,88904E00,00
9.8 jsim2,70702E-10,001,09276E00,001,88904E00,00
Max relative error13,4 83,3 314