Test BIOMD0000000145.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000145.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000145.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: DormandPrince
generated code	: BIOMD0000000145.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: plot
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: PLC Rdg Rpkc APLC Galpha_GTP Rer Rip3 Ca_ER Raplc IP3 Rcyt2 Rcyt1 Ca_Cyt DG Rgalpha_gtp
Simulators: ByoDyn copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner SBToolbox2 Oscill8 Core SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

PLC

Rdg

Rpkc

APLC

Galpha_GTP

Rer

Rip3

Ca_ER

Raplc

IP3

Rcyt2

Rcyt1

Ca_Cyt

Rgalpha_gtp

0.0

BioUML

1,00000E0

9,90099E-3

4,54545E-2

9,00000E0

1,00000E0

9,99578E-1

6,39959E-5

1,00000E3

6,92308E-1

1,00000E0

9,09091E-2

2,00000E2

1,00000E0

1,66667E-1

2,55999E-6

0.0

ByoDyn

1,00000E0

9,90099E-3

4,54545E-2

9,00000E0

1,00000E0

9,99578E-1

6,39959E-5

1,00000E3

6,92308E-1

1,00000E0

9,09091E-2

2,00000E2

1,00000E0

1,66667E-1

2,55999E-6

0.0

MathSBML

1,00000E0

9,00000E0

1,00000E0

1,00000E3

1,00000E0

2,00000E2

1,00000E0

0.0

Oscill8 Core

9,00000E0

1,00000E0

1,00000E3

1,00000E0

2,00000E2

0.0

SBToolbox2

1,00000E0

9,90100E-3

4,54550E-2

9,00000E0

1,00000E0

9,99580E-1

6,39960E-5

1,00000E3

6,92310E-1

1,00000E0

9,09090E-2

2,00000E2

1,00000E0

1,66670E-1

2,56000E-6

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

9,00000E0

1,00000E0

1,00000E3

1,00000E0

2,00000E2

0.0

copasi

1,00000E0

9,00000E0

1,00000E0

1,00000E3

1,00000E0

2,00000E2

1,00000E0

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,00000E0

9,00000E0

1,00000E0

1,00000E3

1,00000E0

2,00000E2

1,00000E0

0.0

jsim

1,00000E0

9,90099E-3

4,54546E-2

9,00000E0

1,00000E0

9,99578E-1

6,39959E-5

1,00000E3

6,92308E-1

1,00000E0

9,09091E-2

2,00000E2

1,00000E0

1,66667E-1

2,55999E-6

0.0

min

1,00000E0

9,90099E-3

4,54545E-2

9,00000E0

1,00000E0

9,99578E-1

6,39959E-5

1,00000E3

6,92308E-1

1,00000E0

9,09090E-2

2,00000E2

1,00000E0

1,66667E-1

2,55999E-6

0.0

max

1,00000E0

9,90100E-3

4,54550E-2

9,00000E0

1,00000E0

9,99580E-1

6,39960E-5

1,00000E3

6,92310E-1

1,00000E0

9,09091E-2

2,00000E2

1,00000E0

1,66670E-1

2,56000E-6

0.0

mean

1,00000E0

9,90099E-3

4,54546E-2

9,00000E0

1,00000E0

9,99578E-1

6,39959E-5

1,00000E3

6,92308E-1

1,00000E0

9,09091E-2

2,00000E2

1,00000E0

1,66667E-1

2,55999E-6

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

1,21343E0

8,17666E-1

3,41724E-1

8,78657E0

9,25273E-1

9,99578E-1

3,78023E-1

9,99738E2

6,87172E-1

2,11765E1

9,19367E-2

2,02490E2

2,11765E1

1,68392E-1

1,87637E-6

0.2

ByoDyn

1,21343E0

8,17666E-1

3,41724E-1

8,78657E0

9,25273E-1

9,99578E-1

3,78023E-1

9,99738E2

6,87172E-1

2,11765E1

9,19367E-2

2,02490E2

2,11765E1

1,68392E-1

1,87637E-6

0.2

MathSBML

1,21343E0

8,78657E0

9,25273E-1

9,99738E2

2,11765E1

2,02490E2

2,11765E1

0.2

Oscill8 Core

8,78657E0

2,00254E0

1,00000E3

2,11764E1

2,02600E2

0.2

SBToolbox2

1,21339E0

8,17790E-1

3,41727E-1

8,78661E0

9,24502E-1

9,99580E-1

3,78334E-1

9,99741E2

6,87175E-1

2,11857E1

9,19170E-2

2,02443E2

2,11857E1

1,68355E-1

1,87016E-6

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

8,78657E0

9,25272E-1

9,99738E2

2,11764E1

2,02490E2

0.2

copasi

1,21343E0

8,78657E0

9,25275E-1

9,99738E2

2,11765E1

2,02490E2

2,11765E1

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,21343E0

8,78657E0

9,25273E-1

9,99738E2

2,11765E1

2,02490E2

2,11765E1

0.2

jsim

1,21343E0

8,17666E-1

3,41724E-1

8,78657E0

9,25273E-1

9,99578E-1

3,78023E-1

9,99738E2

6,87172E-1

2,11765E1

9,19367E-2

2,02490E2

2,11765E1

1,68392E-1

1,87637E-6

0.2

min

1,21339E0

8,17666E-1

3,41724E-1

8,78657E0

9,24502E-1

9,99578E-1

3,78023E-1

9,99738E2

6,87172E-1

2,11764E1

9,19170E-2

2,02443E2

2,11765E1

1,68355E-1

1,87016E-6

0.2

max

1,21343E0

8,17790E-1

3,41727E-1

8,78661E0

2,00254E0

9,99580E-1

3,78334E-1

1,00000E3

6,87175E-1

2,11857E1

9,19367E-2

2,02600E2

2,11857E1

1,68392E-1

1,87637E-6

0.2

mean

1,21343E0

8,17666E-1

3,41724E-1

8,78657E0

9,25273E-1

9,99578E-1

3,78023E-1

9,99738E2

6,87172E-1

2,11765E1

9,19367E-2

2,02490E2

2,11765E1

1,68392E-1

1,87637E-6

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

1,42180E0

9,21301E-1

4,00199E-1

8,57820E0

7,71781E-1

9,99576E-1

7,19375E-1

9,98542E2

6,81990E-1

3,42150E1

9,67475E-2

2,14220E2

3,42150E1

1,76426E-1

9,08273E-7

0.4

ByoDyn

1,42180E0

9,21301E-1

4,00199E-1

8,57820E0

7,71781E-1

9,99576E-1

7,19375E-1

9,98542E2

6,81990E-1

3,42150E1

9,67475E-2

2,14220E2

3,42150E1

1,76426E-1

9,08273E-7

0.4

MathSBML

1,42180E0

8,57820E0

7,71781E-1

9,98542E2

3,42150E1

2,14220E2

3,42150E1

0.4

Oscill8 Core

8,57820E0

3,98147E0

1,00000E3

3,42147E1

2,05200E2

0.4

SBToolbox2

1,42179E0

9,21410E-1

4,00238E-1

8,57821E0

7,70968E-1

9,99580E-1

7,19824E-1

9,98543E2

6,81990E-1

3,42411E1

9,67362E-2

2,14191E2

3,42411E1

1,76410E-1

9,04468E-7

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

8,57820E0

7,71782E-1

9,98542E2

3,42147E1

2,14220E2

0.4

copasi

1,42180E0

8,57820E0

7,71782E-1

9,98542E2

3,42150E1

2,14220E2

3,42150E1

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,42180E0

8,57820E0

7,71781E-1

9,98542E2

3,42150E1

2,14220E2

3,42150E1

0.4

jsim

1,42180E0

9,21301E-1

4,00199E-1

8,57820E0

7,71781E-1

9,99576E-1

7,19375E-1

9,98542E2

6,81990E-1

3,42150E1

9,67475E-2

2,14220E2

3,42150E1

1,76426E-1

9,08273E-7

0.4

min

1,42179E0

9,21301E-1

4,00199E-1

8,57820E0

7,70968E-1

9,99576E-1

7,19375E-1

9,98542E2

6,81990E-1

3,42147E1

9,67362E-2

2,05200E2

3,42150E1

1,76410E-1

9,04468E-7

0.4

max

1,42180E0

9,21410E-1

4,00238E-1

8,57821E0

3,98147E0

9,99580E-1

7,19824E-1

1,00000E3

6,81990E-1

3,42411E1

9,67475E-2

2,14220E2

3,42411E1

1,76426E-1

9,08273E-7

0.4

mean

1,42180E0

9,21301E-1

4,00199E-1

8,57820E0

7,71781E-1

9,99576E-1

7,19375E-1

9,98542E2

6,81990E-1

3,42150E1

9,67475E-2

2,14220E2

3,42150E1

1,76426E-1

9,08273E-7

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

1,62522E0

9,47495E-1

4,33029E-1

8,37478E0

6,25197E-1

9,99574E-1

8,30684E-1

9,96917E2

6,76762E-1

4,24801E1

1,03170E-1

2,30076E2

4,24801E1

1,87042E-1

3,91118E-7

0.6

ByoDyn

1,62522E0

9,47495E-1

4,33029E-1

8,37478E0

6,25197E-1

9,99574E-1

8,30684E-1

9,96917E2

6,76762E-1

4,24801E1

1,03170E-1

2,30076E2

4,24801E1

1,87042E-1

3,91118E-7

0.6

MathSBML

1,62522E0

8,37478E0

6,25197E-1

9,96917E2

4,24801E1

2,30076E2

4,24801E1

0.6

Oscill8 Core

8,37478E0

7,88765E0

1,00000E3

4,24799E1

2,07800E2

0.6

SBToolbox2

1,62520E0

9,47574E-1

4,33087E-1

8,37480E0

6,24352E-1

9,99570E-1

8,31023E-1

9,96915E2

6,76766E-1

4,25143E1

1,03160E-1

2,30060E2

4,25143E1

1,87036E-1

3,89012E-7

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

8,37478E0

6,25199E-1

9,96917E2

4,24799E1

2,30076E2

0.6

copasi

1,62522E0

8,37478E0

6,25197E-1

9,96917E2

4,24801E1

2,30076E2

4,24801E1

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,62522E0

8,37478E0

6,25197E-1

9,96917E2

4,24801E1

2,30076E2

4,24801E1

0.6

jsim

1,62522E0

9,47495E-1

4,33029E-1

8,37478E0

6,25197E-1

9,99574E-1

8,30684E-1

9,96917E2

6,76762E-1

4,24801E1

1,03170E-1

2,30076E2

4,24801E1

1,87042E-1

3,91118E-7

0.6

min

1,62520E0

9,47495E-1

4,33029E-1

8,37478E0

6,24352E-1

9,99570E-1

8,30684E-1

9,96915E2

6,76762E-1

4,24799E1

1,03160E-1

2,07800E2

4,24801E1

1,87036E-1

3,89012E-7

0.6

max

1,62522E0

9,47574E-1

4,33087E-1

8,37480E0

7,88765E0

9,99574E-1

8,31023E-1

1,00000E3

6,76766E-1

4,25143E1

1,03170E-1

2,30076E2

4,25143E1

1,87042E-1

3,91118E-7

0.6

mean

1,62522E0

9,47495E-1

4,33029E-1

8,37478E0

6,25197E-1

9,99574E-1

8,30684E-1

9,96917E2

6,76762E-1

4,24801E1

1,03170E-1

2,30076E2

4,24801E1

1,87042E-1

3,91118E-7

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

1,82382E0

9,57657E-1

4,56728E-1

8,17618E0

4,99564E-1

9,99572E-1

8,73156E-1

9,95145E2

6,71490E-1

4,75570E1

1,10001E-1

2,47194E2

4,75570E1

1,98200E-1

1,59443E-7

0.8

ByoDyn

1,82382E0

9,57657E-1

4,56728E-1

8,17618E0

4,99564E-1

9,99572E-1

8,73156E-1

9,95145E2

6,71490E-1

4,75570E1

1,10001E-1

2,47194E2

4,75570E1

1,98200E-1

1,59443E-7

0.8

MathSBML

1,82382E0

8,17618E0

4,99564E-1

9,95145E2

4,75570E1

2,47194E2

4,75570E1

0.8

Oscill8 Core

8,17618E0

1,55981E1

1,00000E3

4,75568E1

2,10400E2

0.8

SBToolbox2

1,82382E0

9,57734E-1

4,56787E-1

8,17618E0

4,98727E-1

9,99570E-1

8,73480E-1

9,95147E2

6,71491E-1

4,76033E1

1,09993E-1

2,47180E2

4,76033E1

1,98185E-1

1,58381E-7

0.8

SBWOdeSolver

8,17618E0

4,99568E-1

9,95145E2

4,75568E1

2,47194E2

0.8

copasi

1,82382E0

8,17618E0

4,99564E-1

9,95145E2

4,75570E1

2,47194E2

4,75570E1

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,82382E0

8,17618E0

4,99564E-1

9,95145E2

4,75570E1

2,47194E2

4,75570E1

0.8

jsim

1,82382E0

9,57657E-1

4,56728E-1

8,17618E0

4,99564E-1

9,99572E-1

8,73156E-1

9,95145E2

6,71490E-1

4,75570E1

1,10001E-1

2,47194E2

4,75570E1

1,98200E-1

1,59443E-7

0.8

min

1,82382E0

9,57657E-1

4,56728E-1

8,17618E0

4,98727E-1

9,99570E-1

8,73156E-1

9,95145E2

6,71490E-1

4,75568E1

1,09993E-1

2,10400E2

4,75570E1

1,98185E-1

1,58381E-7

0.8

max

1,82382E0

9,57734E-1

4,56787E-1

8,17618E0

1,55981E1

9,99572E-1

8,73480E-1

1,00000E3

6,71491E-1

4,76033E1

1,10001E-1

2,47194E2

4,76033E1

1,98200E-1

1,59443E-7

0.8

mean

1,82382E0

9,57657E-1

4,56728E-1

8,17618E0

4,99564E-1

9,99572E-1

8,73156E-1

9,95145E2

6,71490E-1

4,75570E1

1,10001E-1

2,47194E2

4,75570E1

1,98200E-1

1,59443E-7

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

2,01772E0

9,62279E-1

4,75472E-1

7,98228E0

3,96981E-1

9,99570E-1

8,91846E-1

9,93315E2

6,66174E-1

5,05075E1

1,16879E-1

2,64696E2

5,05075E1

2,09296E-1

6,35794E-8

1.0

ByoDyn

2,01772E0

9,62279E-1

4,75472E-1

7,98228E0

3,96981E-1

9,99570E-1

8,91846E-1

9,93315E2

6,66174E-1

5,05075E1

1,16879E-1

2,64696E2

5,05075E1

2,09296E-1

6,35794E-8

1.0

MathSBML

2,01772E0

7,98228E0

3,96981E-1

9,93315E2

5,05075E1

2,64696E2

5,05075E1

1.0

Oscill8 Core

7,98228E0

3,08176E1

1,00000E3

5,05074E1

2,13000E2

1.0

SBToolbox2

2,01774E0

9,62354E-1

4,75535E-1

7,98226E0

3,96109E-1

9,99570E-1

8,92128E-1

9,93319E2

6,66176E-1

5,05572E1

1,16875E-1

2,64682E2

5,05572E1

2,09285E-1

6,30272E-8

1.0

SBWOdeSolver

7,98229E0

3,96984E-1

9,93315E2

5,05074E1

2,64696E2

1.0

copasi

2,01772E0

7,98228E0

3,96980E-1

9,93315E2

5,05075E1

2,64696E2

5,05075E1

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,01772E0

7,98228E0

3,96981E-1

9,93315E2

5,05075E1

2,64696E2

5,05075E1

1.0

jsim

2,01772E0

9,62279E-1

4,75472E-1

7,98228E0

3,96981E-1

9,99570E-1

8,91846E-1

9,93315E2

6,66174E-1

5,05075E1

1,16879E-1

2,64696E2

5,05075E1

2,09296E-1

6,35794E-8

1.0

min

2,01772E0

9,62279E-1

4,75472E-1

7,98226E0

3,96109E-1

9,99570E-1

8,91846E-1

9,93315E2

6,66174E-1

5,05074E1

1,16875E-1

2,13000E2

5,05075E1

2,09285E-1

6,30272E-8

1.0

max

2,01774E0

9,62354E-1

4,75535E-1

7,98229E0

3,08176E1

9,99570E-1

8,92128E-1

1,00000E3

6,66176E-1

5,05572E1

1,16879E-1

2,64696E2

5,05572E1

2,09296E-1

6,35794E-8

1.0

mean

2,01772E0

9,62279E-1

4,75472E-1

7,98228E0

3,96981E-1

9,99570E-1

8,91846E-1

9,93315E2

6,66174E-1

5,05075E1

1,16879E-1

2,64696E2

5,05075E1

2,09296E-1

6,35794E-8

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

2,20701E0

9,64394E-1

4,90945E-1

7,79299E0

3,15650E-1

9,99567E-1

9,00215E-1

9,91459E2

6,60815E-1

5,20436E1

1,23672E-1

2,82251E2

5,20436E1

2,20121E-1

2,54134E-8

1.2

ByoDyn

2,20701E0

9,64394E-1

4,90945E-1

7,79299E0

3,15650E-1

9,99567E-1

9,00215E-1

9,91459E2

6,60815E-1

5,20436E1

1,23672E-1

2,82251E2

5,20436E1

2,20121E-1

2,54134E-8

1.2

MathSBML

2,20701E0

7,79299E0

3,15650E-1

9,91459E2

5,20436E1

2,82251E2

5,20436E1

1.2

Oscill8 Core

7,79299E0

6,08594E1

1,00000E3

5,20435E1

2,15600E2

1.2

SBToolbox2

2,20698E0

9,64453E-1

4,91005E-1

7,79302E0

3,14781E-1

9,99570E-1

9,00450E-1

9,91461E2

6,60812E-1

5,20891E1

1,23669E-1

2,82234E2

5,20891E1

2,20115E-1

2,51374E-8

1.2

SBWOdeSolver

7,79299E0

3,15653E-1

9,91459E2

5,20435E1

2,82251E2

1.2

copasi

2,20701E0

7,79299E0

3,15650E-1

9,91459E2

5,20436E1

2,82251E2

5,20436E1

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,20701E0

7,79299E0

3,15650E-1

9,91459E2

5,20436E1

2,82251E2

5,20436E1

1.2

jsim

2,20701E0

9,64394E-1

4,90945E-1

7,79299E0

3,15650E-1

9,99567E-1

9,00215E-1

9,91459E2

6,60815E-1

5,20436E1

1,23672E-1

2,82251E2

5,20436E1

2,20121E-1

2,54134E-8

1.2

min

2,20698E0

9,64394E-1

4,90945E-1

7,79299E0

3,14781E-1

9,99567E-1

9,00215E-1

9,91459E2

6,60812E-1

5,20435E1

1,23669E-1

2,15600E2

5,20436E1

2,20115E-1

2,51374E-8

1.2

max

2,20701E0

9,64453E-1

4,91005E-1

7,79302E0

6,08594E1

9,99570E-1

9,00450E-1

1,00000E3

6,60815E-1

5,20891E1

1,23672E-1

2,82251E2

5,20891E1

2,20121E-1

2,54134E-8

1.2

mean

2,20701E0

9,64394E-1

4,90945E-1

7,79299E0

3,15650E-1

9,99567E-1

9,00215E-1

9,91459E2

6,60815E-1

5,20436E1

1,23672E-1

2,82251E2

5,20436E1

2,20121E-1

2,54134E-8

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

2,39181E0

9,65171E-1

5,04019E-1

7,60819E0

2,52470E-1

9,99565E-1

9,03254E-1

9,89592E2

6,55416E-1

5,26419E1

1,30323E-1

2,99705E2

5,26419E1

2,30595E-1

1,04011E-8

1.4

ByoDyn

2,39181E0

9,65171E-1

5,04019E-1

7,60819E0

2,52470E-1

9,99565E-1

9,03254E-1

9,89592E2

6,55416E-1

5,26419E1

1,30323E-1

2,99705E2

5,26419E1

2,30595E-1

1,04011E-8

1.4

MathSBML

2,39181E0

7,60819E0

2,52470E-1

9,89592E2

5,26419E1

2,99705E2

5,26419E1

1.4

Oscill8 Core

7,60819E0

1,20159E2

1,00000E3

5,26418E1

2,18200E2

1.4

SBToolbox2

2,39183E0

9,65219E-1

5,04066E-1

7,60817E0

2,51658E-1

9,99560E-1

9,03442E-1

9,89593E2

6,55418E-1

5,26803E1

1,30314E-1

2,99688E2

5,26803E1

2,30587E-1

1,02690E-8

1.4

SBWOdeSolver

7,60819E0

2,52472E-1

9,89592E2

5,26419E1

2,99705E2

1.4

copasi

2,39181E0

7,60819E0

2,52470E-1

9,89592E2

5,26419E1

2,99705E2

5,26419E1

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,39181E0

7,60819E0

2,52470E-1

9,89592E2

5,26419E1

2,99705E2

5,26419E1

1.4

jsim

2,39181E0

9,65171E-1

5,04019E-1

7,60819E0

2,52470E-1

9,99565E-1

9,03254E-1

9,89592E2

6,55416E-1

5,26419E1

1,30323E-1

2,99705E2

5,26419E1

2,30595E-1

1,04011E-8

1.4

min

2,39181E0

9,65171E-1

5,04019E-1

7,60817E0

2,51658E-1

9,99560E-1

9,03254E-1

9,89592E2

6,55416E-1

5,26418E1

1,30314E-1

2,18200E2

5,26419E1

2,30587E-1

1,02690E-8

1.4

max

2,39183E0

9,65219E-1

5,04066E-1

7,60819E0

1,20159E2

9,99565E-1

9,03442E-1

1,00000E3

6,55418E-1

5,26803E1

1,30323E-1

2,99705E2

5,26803E1

2,30595E-1

1,04011E-8

1.4

mean

2,39181E0

9,65171E-1

5,04019E-1

7,60819E0

2,52470E-1

9,99565E-1

9,03254E-1

9,89592E2

6,55416E-1

5,26419E1

1,30323E-1

2,99705E2

5,26419E1

2,30595E-1

1,04011E-8

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

1.6

BioUML

2,57224E0

9,65145E-1

5,15226E-1

7,42776E0

2,04121E-1

9,99562E-1

9,03154E-1

9,87724E2

6,49975E-1

5,26220E1

1,36807E-1

3,16978E2

5,26220E1

2,40686E-1

4,44415E-9

1.6

ByoDyn

2,57224E0

9,65145E-1

5,15226E-1

7,42776E0

2,04121E-1

9,99562E-1

9,03154E-1

9,87724E2

6,49975E-1

5,26220E1

1,36807E-1

3,16978E2

5,26220E1

2,40686E-1

4,44415E-9

1.6

MathSBML

2,57224E0

7,42776E0

2,04121E-1

9,87724E2

5,26220E1

3,16978E2

5,26220E1

1.6

Oscill8 Core

7,42776E0

2,37209E2

1,00000E3

5,26219E1

2,20800E2

1.6

SBToolbox2

2,57228E0

9,65183E-1

5,15267E-1

7,42772E0

2,03396E-1

9,99560E-1

9,03310E-1

9,87724E2

6,49973E-1

5,26531E1

1,36799E-1

3,16962E2

5,26531E1

2,40680E-1

4,38143E-9

1.6

SBWOdeSolver

7,42776E0

2,04123E-1

9,87724E2

5,26219E1

3,16978E2

1.6

copasi

2,57224E0

7,42776E0

2,04121E-1

9,87724E2

5,26219E1

3,16978E2

5,26219E1

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,57224E0

7,42776E0

2,04121E-1

9,87724E2

5,26220E1

3,16978E2

5,26220E1

1.6

jsim

2,57224E0

9,65146E-1

5,15226E-1

7,42776E0

2,04121E-1

9,99562E-1

9,03154E-1

9,87724E2

6,49975E-1

5,26220E1

1,36807E-1

3,16978E2

5,26220E1

2,40686E-1

4,44415E-9

1.6

min

2,57224E0

9,65145E-1

5,15226E-1

7,42772E0

2,03396E-1

9,99560E-1

9,03154E-1

9,87724E2

6,49973E-1

5,26219E1

1,36799E-1

2,20800E2

5,26219E1

2,40680E-1

4,38143E-9

1.6

max

2,57228E0

9,65183E-1

5,15267E-1

7,42776E0

2,37209E2

9,99562E-1

9,03310E-1

1,00000E3

6,49975E-1

5,26531E1

1,36807E-1

3,16978E2

5,26531E1

2,40686E-1

4,44415E-9

1.6

mean

2,57224E0

9,65146E-1

5,15226E-1

7,42776E0

2,04121E-1

9,99562E-1

9,03154E-1

9,87724E2

6,49975E-1

5,26220E1

1,36807E-1

3,16978E2

5,26220E1

2,40686E-1

4,44415E-9

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

1.8

BioUML

2,74838E0

9,64596E-1

5,24920E-1

7,25162E0

1,67542E-1

9,99560E-1

9,01008E-1

9,85860E2

6,44496E-1

5,21975E1

1,43110E-1

3,34022E2

5,21975E1

2,50387E-1

2,01712E-9

1.8

ByoDyn

2,74838E0

9,64596E-1

5,24920E-1

7,25162E0

1,67542E-1

9,99560E-1

9,01008E-1

9,85860E2

6,44496E-1

5,21975E1

1,43110E-1

3,34022E2

5,21975E1

2,50387E-1

2,01712E-9

1.8

MathSBML

2,74838E0

7,25162E0

1,67542E-1

9,85860E2

5,21975E1

3,34022E2

5,21975E1

1.8

Oscill8 Core

7,25162E0

4,68254E2

1,00000E3

5,21974E1

2,23400E2

1.8

SBToolbox2

2,74843E0

9,64627E-1

5,24949E-1

7,25157E0

1,66896E-1

9,99560E-1

9,01137E-1

9,85858E2

6,44499E-1

5,22222E1

1,43104E-1

3,34009E2

5,22222E1

2,50384E-1

1,98652E-9

1.8

SBWOdeSolver

7,25162E0

1,67543E-1

9,85860E2

5,21974E1

3,34022E2

1.8

copasi

2,74838E0

7,25162E0

1,67541E-1

9,85860E2

5,21975E1

3,34023E2

5,21975E1

1.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,74838E0

7,25162E0

1,67542E-1

9,85860E2

5,21975E1

3,34022E2

5,21975E1

1.8

jsim

2,74838E0

9,64596E-1

5,24920E-1

7,25162E0

1,67542E-1

9,99560E-1

9,01008E-1

9,85860E2

6,44496E-1

5,21975E1

1,43110E-1

3,34022E2

5,21975E1

2,50387E-1

2,01712E-9

1.8

min

2,74838E0

9,64596E-1

5,24920E-1

7,25157E0

1,66896E-1

9,99560E-1

9,01008E-1

9,85858E2

6,44496E-1

5,21974E1

1,43104E-1

2,23400E2

5,21975E1

2,50384E-1

1,98652E-9

1.8

max

2,74843E0

9,64627E-1

5,24949E-1

7,25162E0

4,68254E2

9,99560E-1

9,01137E-1

1,00000E3

6,44499E-1

5,22222E1

1,43110E-1

3,34023E2

5,22222E1

2,50387E-1

2,01712E-9

1.8

mean

2,74838E0

9,64596E-1

5,24920E-1

7,25162E0

1,67542E-1

9,99560E-1

9,01008E-1

9,85860E2

6,44496E-1

5,21975E1

1,43110E-1

3,34022E2

5,21975E1

2,50387E-1

2,01712E-9

1.8

relative error(%)

0,00

2.0

BioUML

2,92035E0

9,63682E-1

5,33356E-1

7,07965E0

1,40114E-1

9,99557E-1

8,97412E-1

9,84003E2

6,38978E-1

5,15116E1

1,49229E-1

3,50808E2

5,15116E1

2,59702E-1

9,86668E-10

2.0

ByoDyn

2,92035E0

9,63682E-1

5,33356E-1

7,07965E0

1,40114E-1

9,99557E-1

8,97412E-1

9,84003E2

6,38978E-1

5,15116E1

1,49229E-1

3,50808E2

5,15116E1

2,59702E-1

9,86668E-10

2.0

MathSBML

2,92035E0

7,07965E0

1,40114E-1

9,84003E2

5,15116E1

3,50808E2

5,15116E1

2.0

Oscill8 Core

7,07965E0

9,24311E2

1,00000E3

5,15115E1

2,26000E2

2.0

SBToolbox2

2,92040E0

9,63710E-1

5,33382E-1

7,07960E0

1,39558E-1

9,99560E-1

8,97512E-1

9,84000E2

6,38976E-1

5,15308E1

1,49228E-1

3,50802E2

5,15308E1

2,59698E-1

9,71184E-10

2.0

SBWOdeSolver

7,07965E0

1,40115E-1

9,84003E2

5,15116E1

3,50808E2

2.0

copasi

2,92035E0

7,07965E0

1,40114E-1

9,84003E2

5,15116E1

3,50808E2

5,15116E1

2.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,92035E0

7,07965E0

1,40114E-1

9,84003E2

5,15116E1

3,50808E2

5,15116E1

2.0

jsim

2,92035E0

9,63682E-1

5,33356E-1

7,07965E0

1,40114E-1

9,99557E-1

8,97412E-1

9,84003E2

6,38978E-1

5,15116E1

1,49229E-1

3,50808E2

5,15116E1

2,59702E-1

9,86668E-10

2.0

min

2,92035E0

9,63682E-1

5,33356E-1

7,07960E0

1,39558E-1

9,99557E-1

8,97412E-1

9,84000E2

6,38976E-1

5,15115E1

1,49228E-1

2,26000E2

5,15116E1

2,59698E-1

9,71184E-10

2.0

max

2,92040E0

9,63710E-1

5,33382E-1

7,07965E0

9,24311E2

9,99560E-1

8,97512E-1

1,00000E3

6,38978E-1

5,15308E1

1,49229E-1

3,50808E2

5,15308E1

2,59702E-1

9,86668E-10

2.0

mean

2,92035E0

9,63682E-1

5,33356E-1

7,07965E0

1,40114E-1

9,99557E-1

8,97412E-1

9,84003E2

6,38978E-1

5,15116E1

1,49229E-1

3,50808E2

5,15116E1

2,59702E-1

9,86668E-10

2.0

relative error(%)

0,00

2.2

BioUML

3,08824E0

9,62497E-1

5,40726E-1

6,91176E0

1,19697E-1

9,99555E-1

8,92715E-1

9,82155E2

6,33423E-1

5,06600E1

1,55161E-1

3,67314E2

5,06600E1

2,68639E-1

5,25506E-10

2.2

ByoDyn

3,08824E0

9,62497E-1

5,40726E-1

6,91176E0

1,19697E-1

9,99555E-1

8,92715E-1

9,82155E2

6,33423E-1

5,06600E1

1,55161E-1

3,67314E2

5,06600E1

2,68639E-1

5,25506E-10

2.2

MathSBML

3,08824E0

6,91176E0

1,19697E-1

9,82155E2

5,06600E1

3,67314E2

5,06600E1

2.2

Oscill8 Core

6,91176E0

1,82452E3

1,00000E3

5,06600E1

2,28600E2

2.2

SBToolbox2

3,08827E0

9,62515E-1

5,40745E-1

6,91173E0

1,19224E-1

9,99552E-1

8,92797E-1

9,82160E2

6,33422E-1

5,06751E1

1,55156E-1

3,67310E2

5,06751E1

2,68633E-1

5,17275E-10

2.2

SBWOdeSolver

6,91176E0

1,19698E-1

9,82155E2

5,06600E1

3,67314E2

2.2

copasi

3,08824E0

6,91176E0

1,19697E-1

9,82155E2

5,06600E1

3,67314E2

5,06600E1

2.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,08824E0

6,91176E0

1,19697E-1

9,82155E2

5,06600E1

3,67314E2

5,06600E1

2.2

jsim

3,08824E0

9,62497E-1

5,40726E-1

6,91176E0

1,19697E-1

9,99555E-1

8,92715E-1

9,82155E2

6,33423E-1

5,06600E1

1,55161E-1

3,67314E2

5,06600E1

2,68639E-1

5,25506E-10

2.2

min

3,08824E0

9,62497E-1

5,40726E-1

6,91173E0

1,19224E-1

9,99552E-1

8,92715E-1

9,82155E2

6,33422E-1

5,06600E1

1,55156E-1

2,28600E2

5,06600E1

2,68633E-1

5,17275E-10

2.2

max

3,08827E0

9,62515E-1

5,40745E-1

6,91176E0

1,82452E3

9,99555E-1

8,92797E-1

1,00000E3

6,33423E-1

5,06751E1

1,55161E-1

3,67314E2

5,06751E1

2,68639E-1

5,25506E-10

2.2

mean

3,08824E0

9,62497E-1

5,40726E-1

6,91176E0

1,19697E-1

9,99555E-1

8,92715E-1

9,82155E2

6,33423E-1

5,06600E1

1,55161E-1

3,67314E2

5,06600E1

2,68639E-1

5,25506E-10

2.2

relative error(%)

0,00

2.4

BioUML

3,25214E0

9,61101E-1

5,47176E-1

6,74786E0

1,04592E-1

9,99552E-1

8,87133E-1

9,80320E2

6,27833E-1

4,97066E1

1,60907E-1

3,83527E2

4,97066E1

2,77210E-1

3,06359E-10

2.4

ByoDyn

3,25214E0

9,61101E-1

5,47176E-1

6,74786E0

1,04592E-1

9,99552E-1

8,87133E-1

9,80320E2

6,27833E-1

4,97066E1

1,60907E-1

3,83527E2

4,97066E1

2,77210E-1

3,06359E-10

2.4

MathSBML

3,25214E0

6,74786E0

1,04592E-1

9,80320E2

4,97066E1

3,83527E2

4,97066E1

2.4

Oscill8 Core

6,74786E0

3,60143E3

1,00000E3

4,97066E1

2,31200E2

2.4

SBToolbox2

3,25216E0

9,61117E-1

5,47196E-1

6,74784E0

1,04196E-1

9,99550E-1

8,87202E-1

9,80322E2

6,27827E-1

4,97180E1

1,60903E-1

3,83518E2

4,97180E1

2,77209E-1

3,01730E-10

2.4

SBWOdeSolver

6,74786E0

1,04592E-1

9,80320E2

4,97066E1

3,83527E2

2.4

copasi

3,25214E0

6,74786E0

1,04592E-1

9,80320E2

4,97066E1

3,83527E2

4,97066E1

2.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,25214E0

6,74786E0

1,04592E-1

9,80320E2

4,97066E1

3,83527E2

4,97066E1

2.4

jsim

3,25214E0

9,61101E-1

5,47176E-1

6,74786E0

1,04592E-1

9,99552E-1

8,87133E-1

9,80320E2

6,27833E-1

4,97066E1

1,60907E-1

3,83527E2

4,97066E1

2,77210E-1

3,06359E-10

2.4

min

3,25214E0

9,61101E-1

5,47176E-1

6,74784E0

1,04196E-1

9,99550E-1

8,87133E-1

9,80320E2

6,27827E-1

4,97066E1

1,60903E-1

2,31200E2

4,97066E1

2,77209E-1

3,01730E-10

2.4

max

3,25216E0

9,61117E-1

5,47196E-1

6,74786E0

3,60143E3

9,99552E-1

8,87202E-1

1,00000E3

6,27833E-1

4,97180E1

1,60907E-1

3,83527E2

4,97180E1

2,77210E-1

3,06359E-10

2.4

mean

3,25214E0

9,61101E-1

5,47176E-1

6,74786E0

1,04592E-1

9,99552E-1

8,87133E-1

9,80320E2

6,27833E-1

4,97066E1

1,60907E-1

3,83527E2

4,97066E1

2,77210E-1

3,06359E-10

2.4

relative error(%)

0,00

2.6

BioUML

3,41217E0

9,59532E-1

5,52823E-1

6,58783E0

9,34791E-2

9,99550E-1

8,80802E-1

9,78498E2

6,22208E-1

4,86941E1

1,66470E-1

3,99434E2

4,86941E1

2,85426E-1

1,95478E-10

2.6

ByoDyn

3,41217E0

9,59532E-1

5,52823E-1

6,58783E0

9,34791E-2

9,99550E-1

8,80802E-1

9,78498E2

6,22208E-1

4,86941E1

1,66470E-1

3,99434E2

4,86941E1

2,85426E-1

1,95478E-10

2.6

MathSBML

3,41217E0

6,58783E0

9,34791E-2

9,78498E2

4,86941E1

3,99434E2

4,86941E1

2.6

Oscill8 Core

6,58783E0

7,10885E3

1,00000E3

4,86941E1

2,33800E2

2.6

SBToolbox2

3,41222E0

9,59543E-1

5,52840E-1

6,58778E0

9,31475E-2

9,99550E-1

8,80856E-1

9,78496E2

6,22205E-1

4,87025E1

1,66470E-1

3,99435E2

4,87025E1

2,85426E-1

1,92724E-10

2.6

SBWOdeSolver

6,58784E0

9,34795E-2

9,78498E2

4,86941E1

3,99434E2

2.6

copasi

3,41217E0

6,58783E0

9,34790E-2

9,78498E2

4,86941E1

3,99434E2

4,86941E1

2.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,41217E0

6,58783E0

9,34791E-2

9,78498E2

4,86941E1

3,99434E2

4,86941E1

2.6

jsim

3,41217E0

9,59532E-1

5,52823E-1

6,58783E0

9,34791E-2

9,99550E-1

8,80802E-1

9,78498E2

6,22208E-1

4,86941E1

1,66470E-1

3,99434E2

4,86941E1

2,85426E-1

1,95478E-10

2.6

min

3,41217E0

9,59532E-1

5,52823E-1

6,58778E0

9,31475E-2

9,99550E-1

8,80802E-1

9,78496E2

6,22205E-1

4,86941E1

1,66470E-1

2,33800E2

4,86941E1

2,85426E-1

1,92724E-10

2.6

max

3,41222E0

9,59543E-1

5,52840E-1

6,58784E0

7,10885E3

9,99550E-1

8,80856E-1

1,00000E3

6,22208E-1

4,87025E1

1,66470E-1

3,99435E2

4,87025E1

2,85426E-1

1,95478E-10

2.6

mean

3,41217E0

9,59532E-1

5,52823E-1

6,58783E0

9,34791E-2

9,99550E-1

8,80802E-1

9,78498E2

6,22208E-1

4,86941E1

1,66470E-1

3,99434E2

4,86941E1

2,85426E-1

1,95478E-10

2.6

relative error(%)

0,00

2.8

BioUML

3,56839E0

9,57817E-1

5,57760E-1

6,43161E0

8,53521E-2

9,99547E-1

8,73810E-1

9,76691E2

6,16550E-1

4,76508E1

1,71852E-1

4,15028E2

4,76508E1

2,93300E-1

1,35862E-10

2.8

ByoDyn

3,56839E0

9,57817E-1

5,57760E-1

6,43161E0

8,53521E-2

9,99547E-1

8,73810E-1

9,76691E2

6,16550E-1

4,76508E1

1,71852E-1

4,15028E2

4,76508E1

2,93300E-1

1,35862E-10

2.8

MathSBML

3,56839E0

6,43161E0

8,53521E-2

9,76691E2

4,76508E1

4,15028E2

4,76508E1

2.8

Oscill8 Core

6,43161E0

1,40321E4

1,00000E3

4,76508E1

2,36400E2

2.8

SBToolbox2

3,56844E0

9,57825E-1

5,57776E-1

6,43156E0

8,50776E-2

9,99550E-1

8,73854E-1

9,76695E2

6,16548E-1

4,76568E1

1,71854E-1

4,15024E2

4,76568E1

2,93301E-1

1,34123E-10

2.8

SBWOdeSolver

6,43161E0

8,53528E-2

9,76691E2

4,76509E1

4,15028E2

2.8

copasi

3,56839E0

6,43161E0

8,53521E-2

9,76691E2

4,76508E1

4,15028E2

4,76508E1

2.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,56839E0

6,43161E0

8,53521E-2

9,76691E2

4,76508E1

4,15028E2

4,76508E1

2.8

jsim

3,56839E0

9,57817E-1

5,57760E-1

6,43161E0

8,53521E-2

9,99547E-1

8,73810E-1

9,76691E2

6,16550E-1

4,76508E1

1,71852E-1

4,15028E2

4,76508E1

2,93300E-1

1,35862E-10

2.8

min

3,56839E0

9,57817E-1

5,57760E-1

6,43156E0

8,50776E-2

9,99547E-1

8,73810E-1

9,76691E2

6,16548E-1

4,76508E1

1,71852E-1

2,36400E2

4,76508E1

2,93300E-1

1,34123E-10

2.8

max

3,56844E0

9,57825E-1

5,57776E-1

6,43161E0

1,40321E4

9,99550E-1

8,73854E-1

1,00000E3

6,16550E-1

4,76568E1

1,71854E-1

4,15028E2

4,76568E1

2,93301E-1

1,35862E-10

2.8

mean

3,56839E0

9,57817E-1

5,57760E-1

6,43161E0

8,53521E-2

9,99547E-1

8,73810E-1

9,76691E2

6,16550E-1

4,76508E1

1,71852E-1

4,15028E2

4,76508E1

2,93300E-1

1,35862E-10

2.8

relative error(%)

0,00

3.0

BioUML

3,72091E0

9,55969E-1

5,62065E-1

6,27909E0

7,94510E-2

9,99545E-1

8,66213E-1

9,74901E2

6,10860E-1

4,65955E1

1,77056E-1

4,30300E2

4,65955E1

3,00846E-1

1,02009E-10

3.0

ByoDyn

3,72091E0

9,55969E-1

5,62065E-1

6,27909E0

7,94510E-2

9,99545E-1

8,66213E-1

9,74901E2

6,10860E-1

4,65955E1

1,77056E-1

4,30300E2

4,65955E1

3,00846E-1

1,02009E-10

3.0

MathSBML

3,72091E0

6,27909E0

7,94510E-2

9,74901E2

4,65955E1

4,30300E2

4,65955E1

3.0

Oscill8 Core

6,27909E0

2,76978E4

1,00000E3

4,65955E1

2,39000E2

3.0

SBToolbox2

3,72095E0

9,55977E-1

5,62070E-1

6,27905E0

7,92224E-2

9,99540E-1

8,66247E-1

9,74897E2

6,10857E-1

4,65999E1

1,77055E-1

4,30302E2

4,65999E1

3,00849E-1

1,00841E-10

3.0

SBWOdeSolver

6,27909E0

7,94517E-2

9,74901E2

4,65956E1

4,30300E2

3.0

copasi

3,72091E0

6,27909E0

7,94510E-2

9,74901E2

4,65955E1

4,30300E2

4,65955E1

3.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,72091E0

6,27909E0

7,94510E-2

9,74901E2

4,65955E1

4,30300E2

4,65955E1

3.0

jsim

3,72091E0

9,55969E-1

5,62065E-1

6,27909E0

7,94510E-2

9,99545E-1

8,66213E-1

9,74901E2

6,10860E-1

4,65955E1

1,77056E-1

4,30300E2

4,65955E1

3,00846E-1

1,02009E-10

3.0

min

3,72091E0

9,55969E-1

5,62065E-1

6,27905E0

7,92224E-2

9,99540E-1

8,66213E-1

9,74897E2

6,10857E-1

4,65955E1

1,77055E-1

2,39000E2

4,65955E1

3,00846E-1

1,00841E-10

3.0

max

3,72095E0

9,55977E-1

5,62070E-1

6,27909E0

2,76978E4

9,99545E-1

8,66247E-1

1,00000E3

6,10860E-1

4,65999E1

1,77056E-1

4,30302E2

4,65999E1

3,00849E-1

1,02009E-10

3.0

mean

3,72091E0

9,55969E-1

5,62065E-1

6,27909E0

7,94510E-2

9,99545E-1

8,66213E-1

9,74901E2

6,10860E-1

4,65955E1

1,77056E-1

4,30300E2

4,65955E1

3,00846E-1

1,02009E-10

3.0

relative error(%)

0,00

3.2

BioUML

3,86982E0

9,54001E-1

5,65800E-1

6,13018E0

7,52078E-2

9,99542E-1

8,58050E-1

9,73127E2

6,05140E-1

4,55406E1

1,82086E-1

4,45245E2

4,55406E1

3,08076E-1

8,19016E-11

3.2

ByoDyn

3,86982E0

9,54001E-1

5,65800E-1

6,13018E0

7,52078E-2

9,99542E-1

8,58050E-1

9,73127E2

6,05140E-1

4,55406E1

1,82086E-1

4,45245E2

4,55406E1

3,08076E-1

8,19016E-11

3.2

MathSBML

3,86982E0

6,13018E0

7,52078E-2

9,73127E2

4,55406E1

4,45245E2

4,55406E1

3.2

Oscill8 Core

6,13018E0

5,46723E4

1,00000E3

4,55406E1

2,41600E2

3.2

SBToolbox2

3,86986E0

9,54005E-1

5,65806E-1

6,13014E0

7,50097E-2

9,99540E-1

8,58078E-1

9,73129E2

6,05140E-1

4,55440E1

1,82090E-1

4,45243E2

4,55440E1

3,08078E-1

8,10413E-11

3.2

SBWOdeSolver

6,13018E0

7,52083E-2

9,73127E2

4,55406E1

4,45245E2

3.2

copasi

3,86982E0

6,13018E0

7,52079E-2

9,73127E2

4,55406E1

4,45245E2

4,55406E1

3.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,86982E0

6,13018E0

7,52078E-2

9,73127E2

4,55406E1

4,45245E2

4,55406E1

3.2

jsim

3,86982E0

9,54001E-1

5,65800E-1

6,13018E0

7,52078E-2

9,99542E-1

8,58050E-1

9,73127E2

6,05140E-1

4,55406E1

1,82086E-1

4,45245E2

4,55406E1

3,08076E-1

8,19016E-11

3.2

min

3,86982E0

9,54001E-1

5,65800E-1

6,13014E0

7,50097E-2

9,99540E-1

8,58050E-1

9,73127E2

6,05140E-1

4,55406E1

1,82086E-1

2,41600E2

4,55406E1

3,08076E-1

8,10413E-11

3.2

max

3,86986E0

9,54005E-1

5,65806E-1

6,13018E0

5,46723E4

9,99542E-1

8,58078E-1

1,00000E3

6,05140E-1

4,55440E1

1,82090E-1

4,45245E2

4,55440E1

3,08078E-1

8,19016E-11

3.2

mean

3,86982E0

9,54001E-1

5,65800E-1

6,13018E0

7,52078E-2

9,99542E-1

8,58050E-1

9,73127E2

6,05140E-1

4,55406E1

1,82086E-1

4,45245E2

4,55406E1

3,08076E-1

8,19016E-11

3.2

relative error(%)

0,00

3.4

BioUML

4,01519E0

9,51917E-1

5,69018E-1

5,98481E0

7,22010E-2

9,99540E-1

8,49342E-1

9,71373E2

5,99392E-1

4,44942E1

1,86944E-1

4,59855E2

4,44942E1

3,15001E-1

6,95687E-11

3.4

ByoDyn

4,01519E0

9,51917E-1

5,69018E-1

5,98481E0

7,22010E-2

9,99540E-1

8,49342E-1

9,71373E2

5,99392E-1

4,44942E1

1,86944E-1

4,59855E2

4,44942E1

3,15001E-1

6,95687E-11

3.4

MathSBML

4,01519E0

5,98481E0

7,22010E-2

9,71373E2

4,44942E1

4,59855E2

4,44942E1

3.4

Oscill8 Core

5,98481E0

1,07917E5

1,00000E3

4,44942E1

2,44200E2

3.4

SBToolbox2

4,01525E0

9,51924E-1

5,69029E-1

5,98475E0

7,20302E-2

9,99540E-1

8,49363E-1

9,71371E2

5,99389E-1

4,44967E1

1,86948E-1

4,59855E2

4,44967E1

3,15004E-1

6,89122E-11

3.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,98481E0

7,22014E-2

9,71373E2

4,44942E1

4,59855E2

3.4

copasi

4,01519E0

5,98481E0

7,22011E-2

9,71373E2

4,44942E1

4,59856E2

4,44942E1

3.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,01519E0

5,98481E0

7,22010E-2

9,71373E2

4,44942E1

4,59855E2

4,44942E1

3.4

jsim

4,01519E0

9,51917E-1

5,69018E-1

5,98481E0

7,22010E-2

9,99540E-1

8,49342E-1

9,71373E2

5,99392E-1

4,44942E1

1,86944E-1

4,59856E2

4,44942E1

3,15001E-1

6,95687E-11

3.4

min

4,01519E0

9,51917E-1

5,69018E-1

5,98475E0

7,20302E-2

9,99540E-1

8,49342E-1

9,71371E2

5,99389E-1

4,44942E1

1,86944E-1

2,44200E2

4,44942E1

3,15001E-1

6,89122E-11

3.4

max

4,01525E0

9,51924E-1

5,69029E-1

5,98481E0

1,07917E5

9,99540E-1

8,49363E-1

1,00000E3

5,99392E-1

4,44967E1

1,86948E-1

4,59856E2

4,44967E1

3,15004E-1

6,95687E-11

3.4

mean

4,01519E0

9,51917E-1

5,69018E-1

5,98481E0

7,22010E-2

9,99540E-1

8,49342E-1

9,71373E2

5,99392E-1

4,44942E1

1,86944E-1

4,59855E2

4,44942E1

3,15001E-1

6,95687E-11

3.4

relative error(%)

0,00

3.6

BioUML

4,15711E0

9,49721E-1

5,71764E-1

5,84289E0

7,01197E-2

9,99537E-1

8,40104E-1

9,69638E2

5,93615E-1

4,34616E1

1,91634E-1

4,74126E2

4,34616E1

3,21632E-1

6,18869E-11

3.6

ByoDyn

4,15711E0

9,49721E-1

5,71764E-1

5,84289E0

7,01197E-2

9,99537E-1

8,40104E-1

9,69638E2

5,93615E-1

4,34616E1

1,91634E-1

4,74126E2

4,34616E1

3,21632E-1

6,18869E-11

3.6

MathSBML

4,15711E0

5,84289E0

7,01196E-2

9,69638E2

4,34616E1

4,74126E2

4,34616E1

3.6

Oscill8 Core

5,84289E0

2,13016E5

1,00000E3

4,34616E1

2,46800E2

3.6

SBToolbox2

4,15718E0

9,49723E-1

5,71767E-1

5,84282E0

6,99816E-2

9,99540E-1

8,40119E-1

9,69639E2

5,93614E-1

4,34634E1

1,91637E-1

4,74134E2

4,34634E1

3,21635E-1

6,13996E-11

3.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,84289E0

7,01199E-2

9,69638E2

4,34616E1

4,74126E2

3.6

copasi

4,15711E0

5,84289E0

7,01197E-2

9,69638E2

4,34616E1

4,74126E2

4,34616E1

3.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,15711E0

5,84289E0

7,01197E-2

9,69638E2

4,34616E1

4,74126E2

4,34616E1

3.6

jsim

4,15711E0

9,49721E-1

5,71764E-1

5,84289E0

7,01197E-2

9,99537E-1

8,40104E-1

9,69638E2

5,93615E-1

4,34616E1

1,91634E-1

4,74126E2

4,34616E1

3,21632E-1

6,18869E-11

3.6

min

4,15711E0

9,49721E-1

5,71764E-1

5,84282E0

6,99816E-2

9,99537E-1

8,40104E-1

9,69638E2

5,93614E-1

4,34616E1

1,91634E-1

2,46800E2

4,34616E1

3,21632E-1

6,13996E-11

3.6

max

4,15718E0

9,49723E-1

5,71767E-1

5,84289E0

2,13016E5

9,99540E-1

8,40119E-1

1,00000E3

5,93615E-1

4,34634E1

1,91637E-1

4,74134E2

4,34634E1

3,21635E-1

6,18869E-11

3.6

mean

4,15711E0

9,49721E-1

5,71764E-1

5,84289E0

7,01197E-2

9,99537E-1

8,40104E-1

9,69638E2

5,93615E-1

4,34616E1

1,91634E-1

4,74126E2

4,34616E1

3,21632E-1

6,18869E-11

3.6

relative error(%)

0,00

3.8

BioUML

4,29567E0

9,47414E-1

5,74076E-1

5,70433E0

6,87351E-2

9,99535E-1

8,30344E-1

9,67923E2

5,87813E-1

4,24460E1

1,96158E-1

4,88052E2

4,24460E1

3,27980E-1

5,71420E-11

3.8

ByoDyn

4,29567E0

9,47414E-1

5,74076E-1

5,70433E0

6,87351E-2

9,99535E-1

8,30344E-1

9,67923E2

5,87813E-1

4,24460E1

1,96158E-1

4,88052E2

4,24460E1

3,27980E-1

5,71420E-11

3.8

MathSBML

4,29567E0

5,70433E0

6,87351E-2

9,67923E2

4,24460E1

4,88052E2

4,24460E1

3.8

Oscill8 Core

5,70433E0

4,20468E5

1,00000E3

4,24460E1

2,49400E2

3.8

SBToolbox2

4,29572E0

9,47416E-1

5,74082E-1

5,70428E0

6,86181E-2

9,99534E-1

8,30360E-1

9,67924E2

5,87810E-1

4,24470E1

1,96156E-1

4,88058E2

4,24470E1

3,27982E-1

5,67533E-11

3.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,70433E0

6,87353E-2

9,67923E2

4,24460E1

4,88052E2

3.8

copasi

4,29567E0

5,70433E0

6,87351E-2

9,67923E2

4,24460E1

4,88052E2

4,24460E1

3.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,29567E0

5,70433E0

6,87351E-2

9,67923E2

4,24460E1

4,88052E2

4,24460E1

3.8

jsim

4,29567E0

9,47414E-1

5,74076E-1

5,70433E0

6,87351E-2

9,99535E-1

8,30344E-1

9,67923E2

5,87813E-1

4,24460E1

1,96158E-1

4,88052E2

4,24460E1

3,27980E-1

5,71420E-11

3.8

min

4,29567E0

9,47414E-1

5,74076E-1

5,70428E0

6,86181E-2

9,99534E-1

8,30344E-1

9,67923E2

5,87810E-1

4,24460E1

1,96156E-1

2,49400E2

4,24460E1

3,27980E-1

5,67533E-11

3.8

max

4,29572E0

9,47416E-1

5,74082E-1

5,70433E0

4,20468E5

9,99535E-1

8,30360E-1

1,00000E3

5,87813E-1

4,24470E1

1,96158E-1

4,88058E2

4,24470E1

3,27982E-1

5,71420E-11

3.8

mean

4,29567E0

9,47414E-1

5,74076E-1

5,70433E0

6,87351E-2

9,99535E-1

8,30344E-1

9,67923E2

5,87813E-1

4,24460E1

1,96158E-1

4,88052E2

4,24460E1

3,27980E-1

5,71420E-11

3.8

relative error(%)

0,00

4.0

BioUML

4,43095E0

9,44996E-1

5,75987E-1

5,56905E0

6,78802E-2

9,99533E-1

8,20067E-1

9,66231E2

5,81986E-1

4,14495E1

2,00520E-1

5,01626E2

4,14495E1

3,34055E-1

5,43516E-11

4.0

ByoDyn

4,43095E0

9,44996E-1

5,75987E-1

5,56905E0

6,78802E-2

9,99533E-1

8,20067E-1

9,66231E2

5,81986E-1

4,14495E1

2,00520E-1

5,01626E2

4,14495E1

3,34055E-1

5,43516E-11

4.0

MathSBML

4,43095E0

5,56905E0

6,78802E-2

9,66231E2

4,14495E1

5,01626E2

4,14495E1

4.0

Oscill8 Core

5,56905E0

8,29955E5

1,00000E3

4,14495E1

2,52000E2

4.0

SBToolbox2

4,43102E0

9,44998E-1

5,75994E-1

5,56898E0

6,77724E-2

9,99530E-1

8,20072E-1

9,66232E2

5,81986E-1

4,14506E1

2,00522E-1

5,01632E2

4,14506E1

3,34060E-1

5,40064E-11

4.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,56905E0

6,78803E-2

9,66231E2

4,14495E1

5,01626E2

4.0

copasi

4,43095E0

5,56905E0

6,78802E-2

9,66231E2

4,14495E1

5,01626E2

4,14495E1

4.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,43095E0

5,56905E0

6,78802E-2

9,66231E2

4,14495E1

5,01626E2

4,14495E1

4.0

jsim

4,43095E0

9,44996E-1

5,75987E-1

5,56905E0

6,78802E-2

9,99533E-1

8,20067E-1

9,66231E2

5,81986E-1

4,14495E1

2,00520E-1

5,01626E2

4,14495E1

3,34055E-1

5,43516E-11

4.0

min

4,43095E0

9,44996E-1

5,75987E-1

5,56898E0

6,77724E-2

9,99530E-1

8,20067E-1

9,66231E2

5,81986E-1

4,14495E1

2,00520E-1

2,52000E2

4,14495E1

3,34055E-1

5,40064E-11

4.0

max

4,43102E0

9,44998E-1

5,75994E-1

5,56905E0

8,29955E5

9,99533E-1

8,20072E-1

1,00000E3

5,81986E-1

4,14506E1

2,00522E-1

5,01632E2

4,14506E1

3,34060E-1

5,43516E-11

4.0

mean

4,43095E0

9,44996E-1

5,75987E-1

5,56905E0

6,78802E-2

9,99533E-1

8,20067E-1

9,66231E2

5,81986E-1

4,14495E1

2,00520E-1

5,01626E2

4,14495E1

3,34055E-1

5,43516E-11

4.0

relative error(%)

0,00

4.2

BioUML

4,56301E0

9,42466E-1

5,77526E-1

5,43699E0

6,74326E-2

9,99530E-1

8,09275E-1

9,64561E2

5,76136E-1

4,04733E1

2,04722E-1

5,14844E2

4,04733E1

3,39866E-1

5,29323E-11

4.2

ByoDyn

4,56301E0

9,42466E-1

5,77526E-1

5,43699E0

6,74326E-2

9,99530E-1

8,09275E-1

9,64561E2

5,76136E-1

4,04733E1

2,04722E-1

5,14844E2

4,04733E1

3,39866E-1

5,29323E-11

4.2

MathSBML

4,56301E0

5,43699E0

6,74326E-2

9,64561E2

4,04733E1

5,14844E2

4,04733E1

4.2

Oscill8 Core

5,43699E0

1,63823E6

1,00000E3

4,04733E1

2,54600E2

4.2

SBToolbox2

4,56307E0

9,42465E-1

5,77531E-1

5,43693E0

6,73439E-2

9,99530E-1

8,09281E-1

9,64564E2

5,76132E-1

4,04736E1

2,04726E-1

5,14857E2

4,04736E1

3,39872E-1

5,26546E-11

4.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,43699E0

6,74327E-2

9,64561E2

4,04734E1

5,14843E2

4.2

copasi

4,56301E0

5,43699E0

6,74326E-2

9,64561E2

4,04733E1

5,14844E2

4,04733E1

4.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,56301E0

5,43699E0

6,74326E-2

9,64561E2

4,04733E1

5,14844E2

4,04733E1

4.2

jsim

4,56301E0

9,42466E-1

5,77526E-1

5,43699E0

6,74326E-2

9,99530E-1

8,09275E-1

9,64561E2

5,76136E-1

4,04733E1

2,04722E-1

5,14844E2

4,04733E1

3,39866E-1

5,29323E-11

4.2

min

4,56301E0

9,42465E-1

5,77526E-1

5,43693E0

6,73439E-2

9,99530E-1

8,09275E-1

9,64561E2

5,76132E-1

4,04733E1

2,04722E-1

2,54600E2

4,04733E1

3,39866E-1

5,26546E-11

4.2

max

4,56307E0

9,42466E-1

5,77531E-1

5,43699E0

1,63823E6

9,99530E-1

8,09281E-1

1,00000E3

5,76136E-1

4,04736E1

2,04726E-1

5,14857E2

4,04736E1

3,39872E-1

5,29323E-11

4.2

mean

4,56301E0

9,42466E-1

5,77526E-1

5,43699E0

6,74326E-2

9,99530E-1

8,09275E-1

9,64561E2

5,76136E-1

4,04733E1

2,04722E-1

5,14844E2

4,04733E1

3,39866E-1

5,29323E-11

4.2

relative error(%)

0,00

4.4

BioUML

4,69195E0

9,39820E-1

5,78717E-1

5,30805E0

6,73036E-2

9,99528E-1

7,97969E-1

9,62916E2

5,70264E-1

3,95181E1

2,08766E-1

5,27699E2

3,95181E1

3,45421E-1

5,25282E-11

4.4

ByoDyn

4,69195E0

9,39820E-1

5,78717E-1

5,30805E0

6,73036E-2

9,99528E-1

7,97969E-1

9,62916E2

5,70264E-1

3,95181E1

2,08766E-1

5,27699E2

3,95181E1

3,45421E-1

5,25282E-11

4.4

MathSBML

4,69195E0

5,30805E0

6,73036E-2

9,62916E2

3,95181E1

5,27699E2

3,95181E1

4.4

Oscill8 Core

5,30805E0

3,23368E6

1,00000E3

3,95181E1

2,57200E2

4.4

SBToolbox2

4,69203E0

9,39822E-1

5,78718E-1

5,30797E0

6,72186E-2

9,99530E-1

7,97971E-1

9,62915E2

5,70262E-1

3,95181E1

2,08772E-1

5,27713E2

3,95181E1

3,45427E-1

5,22627E-11

4.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,30805E0

6,73037E-2

9,62916E2

3,95181E1

5,27699E2

4.4

copasi

4,69195E0

5,30805E0

6,73036E-2

9,62916E2

3,95181E1

5,27699E2

3,95181E1

4.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,69195E0

5,30805E0

6,73036E-2

9,62916E2

3,95181E1

5,27699E2

3,95181E1

4.4

jsim

4,69195E0

9,39820E-1

5,78717E-1

5,30805E0

6,73036E-2

9,99528E-1

7,97969E-1

9,62916E2

5,70264E-1

3,95181E1

2,08766E-1

5,27699E2

3,95181E1

3,45421E-1

5,25282E-11

4.4

min

4,69195E0

9,39820E-1

5,78717E-1

5,30797E0

6,72186E-2

9,99528E-1

7,97969E-1

9,62915E2

5,70262E-1

3,95181E1

2,08766E-1

2,57200E2

3,95181E1

3,45421E-1

5,22627E-11

4.4

max

4,69203E0

9,39822E-1

5,78718E-1

5,30805E0

3,23368E6

9,99530E-1

7,97971E-1

1,00000E3

5,70264E-1

3,95181E1

2,08772E-1

5,27713E2

3,95181E1

3,45427E-1

5,25282E-11

4.4

mean

4,69195E0

9,39820E-1

5,78717E-1

5,30805E0

6,73036E-2

9,99528E-1

7,97969E-1

9,62916E2

5,70264E-1

3,95181E1

2,08766E-1

5,27699E2

3,95181E1

3,45421E-1

5,25282E-11

4.4

relative error(%)

0,00

4.6

BioUML

4,81783E0

9,37056E-1

5,79584E-1

5,18217E0

6,74285E-2

9,99525E-1

7,86152E-1

9,61295E2

5,64373E-1

3,85840E1

2,12656E-1

5,40186E2

3,85840E1

3,50728E-1

5,29192E-11

4.6

ByoDyn

4,81783E0

9,37056E-1

5,79584E-1

5,18217E0

6,74285E-2

9,99525E-1

7,86152E-1

9,61295E2

5,64373E-1

3,85840E1

2,12656E-1

5,40186E2

3,85840E1

3,50728E-1

5,29192E-11

4.6

MathSBML

4,81783E0

5,18217E0

6,74285E-2

9,61295E2

3,85840E1

5,40186E2

3,85840E1

4.6

Oscill8 Core

5,18217E0

6,38289E6

1,00000E3

3,85840E1

2,59800E2

4.6

SBToolbox2

4,81790E0

9,37054E-1

5,79592E-1

5,18210E0

6,73555E-2

9,99530E-1

7,86151E-1

9,61297E2

5,64368E-1

3,85842E1

2,12663E-1

5,40205E2

3,85842E1

3,50740E-1

5,26910E-11

4.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,18218E0

6,74285E-2

9,61295E2

3,85840E1

5,40185E2

4.6

copasi

4,81783E0

5,18217E0

6,74285E-2

9,61295E2

3,85840E1

5,40186E2

3,85840E1

4.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,81783E0

5,18217E0

6,74285E-2

9,61295E2

3,85840E1

5,40186E2

3,85840E1

4.6

jsim

4,81783E0

9,37056E-1

5,79584E-1

5,18217E0

6,74285E-2

9,99525E-1

7,86152E-1

9,61295E2

5,64373E-1

3,85840E1

2,12656E-1

5,40186E2

3,85840E1

3,50728E-1

5,29192E-11

4.6

min

4,81783E0

9,37054E-1

5,79584E-1

5,18210E0

6,73555E-2

9,99525E-1

7,86151E-1

9,61295E2

5,64368E-1

3,85840E1

2,12656E-1

2,59800E2

3,85840E1

3,50728E-1

5,26910E-11

4.6

max

4,81790E0

9,37056E-1

5,79592E-1

5,18218E0

6,38289E6

9,99530E-1

7,86152E-1

1,00000E3

5,64373E-1

3,85842E1

2,12663E-1

5,40205E2

3,85842E1

3,50740E-1

5,29192E-11

4.6

mean

4,81783E0

9,37056E-1

5,79584E-1

5,18217E0

6,74285E-2

9,99525E-1

7,86152E-1

9,61295E2

5,64373E-1

3,85840E1

2,12656E-1

5,40186E2

3,85840E1

3,50728E-1

5,29192E-11

4.6

relative error(%)

0,00

4.8

BioUML

4,94072E0

9,34172E-1

5,80145E-1

5,05928E0

6,77607E-2

9,99523E-1

7,73827E-1

9,59700E2

5,58464E-1

3,76710E1

2,16393E-1

5,52298E2

3,76710E1

3,55794E-1

5,39698E-11

4.8

ByoDyn

4,94072E0

9,34172E-1

5,80145E-1

5,05928E0

6,77607E-2

9,99523E-1

7,73827E-1

9,59700E2

5,58464E-1

3,76710E1

2,16393E-1

5,52298E2

3,76710E1

3,55794E-1

5,39698E-11

4.8

MathSBML

4,94072E0

5,05928E0

6,77607E-2

9,59700E2

3,76710E1

5,52298E2

3,76710E1

4.8

Oscill8 Core

5,05928E0

1,25990E7

1,00000E3

3,76710E1

2,62400E2

4.8

SBToolbox2

4,94082E0

9,34172E-1

5,80150E-1

5,05918E0

6,76894E-2

9,99520E-1

7,73822E-1

9,59698E2

5,58459E-1

3,76706E1

2,16399E-1

5,52322E2

3,76706E1

3,55800E-1

5,37424E-11

4.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,05928E0

6,77607E-2

9,59700E2

3,76710E1

5,52298E2

4.8

copasi

4,94072E0

5,05928E0

6,77607E-2

9,59700E2

3,76710E1

5,52298E2

3,76710E1

4.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,94072E0

5,05928E0

6,77607E-2

9,59700E2

3,76710E1

5,52298E2

3,76710E1

4.8

jsim

4,94072E0

9,34172E-1

5,80145E-1

5,05928E0

6,77607E-2

9,99523E-1

7,73827E-1

9,59700E2

5,58464E-1

3,76710E1

2,16393E-1

5,52298E2

3,76710E1

3,55794E-1

5,39698E-11

4.8

min

4,94072E0

9,34172E-1

5,80145E-1

5,05918E0

6,76894E-2

9,99520E-1

7,73822E-1

9,59698E2

5,58459E-1

3,76706E1

2,16393E-1

2,62400E2

3,76706E1

3,55794E-1

5,37424E-11

4.8

max

4,94082E0

9,34172E-1

5,80150E-1

5,05928E0

1,25990E7

9,99523E-1

7,73827E-1

1,00000E3

5,58464E-1

3,76710E1

2,16399E-1

5,52322E2

3,76710E1

3,55800E-1

5,39698E-11

4.8

mean

4,94072E0

9,34172E-1

5,80145E-1

5,05928E0

6,77607E-2

9,99523E-1

7,73827E-1

9,59700E2

5,58464E-1

3,76710E1

2,16393E-1

5,52298E2

3,76710E1

3,55794E-1

5,39698E-11

4.8

relative error(%)

0,00

5.0

BioUML

5,06069E0

9,31163E-1

5,80418E-1

4,93931E0

6,82668E-2

9,99521E-1

7,60998E-1

9,58132E2

5,52538E-1

3,67791E1

2,19978E-1

5,64031E2

3,67791E1

3,60627E-1

5,56004E-11

5.0

ByoDyn

5,06069E0

9,31163E-1

5,80418E-1

4,93931E0

6,82668E-2

9,99521E-1

7,60998E-1

9,58132E2

5,52538E-1

3,67791E1

2,19978E-1

5,64031E2

3,67791E1

3,60627E-1

5,56004E-11

5.0

MathSBML

5,06069E0

4,93931E0

6,82668E-2

9,58132E2

3,67791E1

5,64031E2

3,67791E1

5.0

Oscill8 Core

4,93931E0

2,48690E7

1,00000E3

3,67791E1

2,65000E2

5.0

SBToolbox2

5,06080E0

9,31160E-1

5,80425E-1

4,93920E0

6,82025E-2

9,99520E-1

7,60990E-1

9,58130E2

5,52530E-1

3,67790E1

2,19990E-1

5,64060E2

3,67790E1

3,60640E-1

5,53915E-11

5.0

SBWOdeSolver

4,93931E0

6,82668E-2

9,58132E2

3,67791E1

5,64031E2

5.0

copasi

5,06069E0

4,93931E0

6,82668E-2

9,58132E2

3,67791E1

5,64031E2

3,67791E1

5.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,06069E0

4,93931E0

6,82668E-2

9,58132E2

3,67791E1

5,64031E2

3,67791E1

5.0

jsim

5,06069E0

9,31163E-1

5,80418E-1

4,93931E0

6,82668E-2

9,99521E-1

7,60998E-1

9,58132E2

5,52538E-1

3,67791E1

2,19978E-1

5,64031E2

3,67791E1

3,60627E-1

5,56004E-11

5.0

min

5,06069E0

9,31160E-1

5,80418E-1

4,93920E0

6,82025E-2

9,99520E-1

7,60990E-1

9,58130E2

5,52530E-1

3,67790E1

2,19978E-1

2,65000E2

3,67790E1

3,60627E-1

5,53915E-11

5.0

max

5,06080E0

9,31163E-1

5,80425E-1

4,93931E0

2,48690E7

9,99521E-1

7,60998E-1

1,00000E3

5,52538E-1

3,67791E1

2,19990E-1

5,64060E2

3,67791E1

3,60640E-1

5,56004E-11

5.0

mean

5,06069E0

9,31163E-1

5,80418E-1

4,93931E0

6,82668E-2

9,99521E-1

7,60998E-1

9,58132E2

5,52538E-1

3,67791E1

2,19978E-1

5,64031E2

3,67791E1

3,60627E-1

5,56004E-11

5.0

relative error(%)

0,00

5.2

BioUML

5,17783E0

9,28025E-1

5,80420E-1

4,82217E0

6,89230E-2

9,99518E-1

7,47672E-1

9,56592E2

5,46597E-1

3,59078E1

2,23415E-1

5,75379E2

3,59078E1

3,65232E-1

5,77693E-11

5.2

ByoDyn

5,17783E0

9,28025E-1

5,80420E-1

4,82217E0

6,89230E-2

9,99518E-1

7,47672E-1

9,56592E2

5,46597E-1

3,59078E1

2,23415E-1

5,75379E2

3,59078E1

3,65232E-1

5,77693E-11

5.2

MathSBML

5,17783E0

4,82217E0

6,89230E-2

9,56592E2

3,59078E1

5,75379E2

3,59078E1

5.2

Oscill8 Core

4,82217E0

4,90883E7

1,00000E3

3,59078E1

2,67600E2

5.2

SBToolbox2

5,17798E0

9,28023E-1

5,80425E-1

4,82202E0

6,88583E-2

9,99520E-1

7,47664E-1

9,56592E2

5,46591E-1

3,59074E1

2,23422E-1

5,75409E2

3,59074E1

3,65246E-1

5,75536E-11

5.2

SBWOdeSolver

4,82217E0

6,89231E-2

9,56592E2

3,59078E1

5,75379E2

5.2

copasi

5,17783E0

4,82217E0

6,89230E-2

9,56592E2

3,59078E1

5,75379E2

3,59078E1

5.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,17783E0

4,82217E0

6,89230E-2

9,56592E2

3,59078E1

5,75379E2

3,59078E1

5.2

jsim

5,17783E0

9,28025E-1

5,80420E-1

4,82217E0

6,89230E-2

9,99518E-1

7,47672E-1

9,56592E2

5,46597E-1

3,59078E1

2,23415E-1

5,75379E2

3,59078E1

3,65232E-1

5,77693E-11

5.2

min

5,17783E0

9,28023E-1

5,80420E-1

4,82202E0

6,88583E-2

9,99518E-1

7,47664E-1

9,56592E2

5,46591E-1

3,59074E1

2,23415E-1

2,67600E2

3,59074E1

3,65232E-1

5,75536E-11

5.2

max

5,17798E0

9,28025E-1

5,80425E-1

4,82217E0

4,90883E7

9,99520E-1

7,47672E-1

1,00000E3

5,46597E-1

3,59078E1

2,23422E-1

5,75409E2

3,59078E1

3,65246E-1

5,77693E-11

5.2

mean

5,17783E0

9,28025E-1

5,80420E-1

4,82217E0

6,89230E-2

9,99518E-1

7,47672E-1

9,56592E2

5,46597E-1

3,59078E1

2,23415E-1

5,75379E2

3,59078E1

3,65232E-1

5,77693E-11

5.2

relative error(%)

0,00

5.4

BioUML

5,29218E0

9,24755E-1

5,80163E-1

4,70782E0

6,97129E-2

9,99516E-1

7,33858E-1

9,55081E2

5,40643E-1

3,50569E1

2,26705E-1

5,86335E2

3,50569E1

3,69616E-1

6,04633E-11

5.4

ByoDyn

5,29218E0

9,24755E-1

5,80163E-1

4,70782E0

6,97129E-2

9,99516E-1

7,33858E-1

9,55081E2

5,40643E-1

3,50569E1

2,26705E-1

5,86335E2

3,50569E1

3,69616E-1

6,04633E-11

5.4

MathSBML

5,29218E0

4,70782E0

6,97129E-2

9,55081E2

3,50569E1

5,86335E2

3,50569E1

5.4

Oscill8 Core

4,70782E0

9,68943E7

1,00000E3

3,50569E1

2,70200E2

5.4

SBToolbox2

5,29232E0

9,24752E-1

5,80171E-1

4,70768E0

6,96513E-2

9,99520E-1

7,33848E-1

9,55078E2

5,40637E-1

3,50557E1

2,26714E-1

5,86378E2

3,50557E1

3,69631E-1

6,02501E-11

5.4

SBWOdeSolver

4,70782E0

6,97129E-2

9,55081E2

3,50569E1

5,86335E2

5.4

copasi

5,29218E0

4,70782E0

6,97129E-2

9,55081E2

3,50569E1

5,86335E2

3,50569E1

5.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,29218E0

4,70782E0

6,97129E-2

9,55081E2

3,50569E1

5,86335E2

3,50569E1

5.4

jsim

5,29218E0

9,24755E-1

5,80163E-1

4,70782E0

6,97129E-2

9,99516E-1

7,33858E-1

9,55081E2

5,40643E-1

3,50569E1

2,26705E-1

5,86335E2

3,50569E1

3,69616E-1

6,04633E-11

5.4

min

5,29218E0

9,24752E-1

5,80163E-1

4,70768E0

6,96513E-2

9,99516E-1

7,33848E-1

9,55078E2

5,40637E-1

3,50557E1

2,26705E-1

2,70200E2

3,50557E1

3,69616E-1

6,02501E-11

5.4

max

5,29232E0

9,24755E-1

5,80171E-1

4,70782E0

9,68943E7

9,99520E-1

7,33858E-1

1,00000E3

5,40643E-1

3,50569E1

2,26714E-1

5,86378E2

3,50569E1

3,69631E-1

6,04633E-11

5.4

mean

5,29218E0

9,24755E-1

5,80163E-1

4,70782E0

6,97129E-2

9,99516E-1

7,33858E-1

9,55081E2

5,40643E-1

3,50569E1

2,26705E-1

5,86335E2

3,50569E1

3,69616E-1

6,04633E-11

5.4

relative error(%)

0,00

5.6

BioUML

5,40382E0

9,21347E-1

5,79662E-1

4,59618E0

7,06252E-2

9,99514E-1

7,19569E-1

9,53600E2

5,34677E-1

3,42259E1

2,29849E-1

5,96895E2

3,42259E1

3,73785E-1

6,36911E-11

5.6

ByoDyn

5,40382E0

9,21347E-1

5,79662E-1

4,59618E0

7,06252E-2

9,99514E-1

7,19569E-1

9,53600E2

5,34677E-1

3,42259E1

2,29849E-1

5,96895E2

3,42259E1

3,73785E-1

6,36911E-11

5.6

MathSBML

5,40382E0

4,59618E0

7,06252E-2

9,53600E2

3,42259E1

5,96895E2

3,42259E1

5.6

Oscill8 Core

4,59618E0

1,91257E8

1,00000E3

3,42259E1

2,72800E2

5.6

SBToolbox2

5,40396E0

9,21345E-1

5,79667E-1

4,59604E0

7,05626E-2

9,99510E-1

7,19549E-1

9,53599E2

5,34668E-1

3,42250E1

2,29860E-1

5,96939E2

3,42250E1

3,73802E-1

6,34666E-11

5.6

SBWOdeSolver

4,59618E0

7,06252E-2

9,53600E2

3,42259E1

5,96895E2

5.6

copasi

5,40382E0

4,59618E0

7,06252E-2

9,53600E2

3,42259E1

5,96895E2

3,42259E1

5.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,40382E0

4,59618E0

7,06252E-2

9,53600E2

3,42259E1

5,96895E2

3,42259E1

5.6

jsim

5,40382E0

9,21347E-1

5,79662E-1

4,59618E0

7,06252E-2

9,99514E-1

7,19569E-1

9,53600E2

5,34677E-1

3,42259E1

2,29849E-1

5,96895E2

3,42259E1

3,73785E-1

6,36911E-11

5.6

min

5,40382E0

9,21345E-1

5,79662E-1

4,59604E0

7,05626E-2

9,99510E-1

7,19549E-1

9,53599E2

5,34668E-1

3,42250E1

2,29849E-1

2,72800E2

3,42250E1

3,73785E-1

6,34666E-11

5.6

max

5,40396E0

9,21347E-1

5,79667E-1

4,59618E0

1,91257E8

9,99514E-1

7,19569E-1

1,00000E3

5,34677E-1

3,42259E1

2,29860E-1

5,96939E2

3,42259E1

3,73802E-1

6,36911E-11

5.6

mean

5,40382E0

9,21347E-1

5,79662E-1

4,59618E0

7,06252E-2

9,99514E-1

7,19569E-1

9,53600E2

5,34677E-1

3,42259E1

2,29849E-1

5,96895E2

3,42259E1

3,73785E-1

6,36911E-11

5.6

relative error(%)

0,00

5.8

BioUML

5,51282E0

9,17799E-1

5,78928E-1

4,48718E0

7,16529E-2

9,99512E-1

7,04818E-1

9,52150E2

5,28701E-1

3,34146E1

2,32850E-1

6,07053E2

3,34146E1

3,77743E-1

6,74801E-11

5.8

ByoDyn

5,51282E0

9,17799E-1

5,78928E-1

4,48718E0

7,16529E-2

9,99512E-1

7,04818E-1

9,52150E2

5,28701E-1

3,34146E1

2,32850E-1

6,07053E2

3,34146E1

3,77743E-1

6,74801E-11

5.8

MathSBML

5,51282E0

4,48718E0

7,16529E-2

9,52150E2

3,34146E1

6,07053E2

3,34146E1

5.8

Oscill8 Core

4,48718E0

3,77518E8

1,00000E3

3,34146E1

2,75400E2

5.8

SBToolbox2

5,51297E0

9,17794E-1

5,78933E-1

4,48703E0

7,15907E-2

9,99510E-1

7,04795E-1

9,52146E2

5,28694E-1

3,34132E1

2,32863E-1

6,07100E2

3,34132E1

3,77760E-1

6,72457E-11

5.8

SBWOdeSolver

4,48718E0

7,16530E-2

9,52150E2

3,34146E1

6,07052E2

5.8

copasi

5,51282E0

4,48718E0

7,16529E-2

9,52150E2

3,34146E1

6,07053E2

3,34146E1

5.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,51282E0

4,48718E0

7,16529E-2

9,52150E2

3,34146E1

6,07053E2

3,34146E1

5.8

jsim

5,51282E0

9,17799E-1

5,78928E-1

4,48718E0

7,16529E-2

9,99512E-1

7,04818E-1

9,52150E2

5,28701E-1

3,34146E1

2,32850E-1

6,07053E2

3,34146E1

3,77743E-1

6,74801E-11

5.8

min

5,51282E0

9,17794E-1

5,78928E-1

4,48703E0

7,15907E-2

9,99510E-1

7,04795E-1

9,52146E2

5,28694E-1

3,34132E1

2,32850E-1

2,75400E2

3,34132E1

3,77743E-1

6,72457E-11

5.8

max

5,51297E0

9,17799E-1

5,78933E-1

4,48718E0

3,77518E8

9,99512E-1

7,04818E-1

1,00000E3

5,28701E-1

3,34146E1

2,32863E-1

6,07100E2

3,34146E1

3,77760E-1

6,74801E-11

5.8

mean

5,51282E0

9,17799E-1

5,78928E-1

4,48718E0

7,16529E-2

9,99512E-1

7,04818E-1

9,52150E2

5,28701E-1

3,34146E1

2,32850E-1

6,07053E2

3,34146E1

3,77743E-1

6,74801E-11

5.8

relative error(%)

0,00

6.0

BioUML

5,61923E0

9,14105E-1

5,77972E-1

4,38077E0

7,27921E-2

9,99509E-1

6,89625E-1

9,50732E2

5,22717E-1

3,26224E1

2,35709E-1

6,16804E2

3,26224E1

3,81496E-1

7,18749E-11

6.0

ByoDyn

5,61923E0

9,14105E-1

5,77972E-1

4,38077E0

7,27921E-2

9,99509E-1

6,89625E-1

9,50732E2

5,22717E-1

3,26224E1

2,35709E-1

6,16804E2

3,26224E1

3,81496E-1

7,18749E-11

6.0

MathSBML

5,61923E0

4,38077E0

7,27921E-2

9,50732E2

3,26224E1

6,16804E2

3,26224E1

6.0

Oscill8 Core

4,38077E0

7,45172E8

1,00000E3

3,26224E1

2,78000E2

6.0

SBToolbox2

5,61938E0

9,14104E-1

5,77980E-1

4,38062E0

7,27280E-2

9,99510E-1

6,89602E-1

9,50732E2

5,22710E-1

3,26214E1

2,35726E-1

6,16862E2

3,26214E1

3,81516E-1

7,16220E-11

6.0

SBWOdeSolver

4,38077E0

7,27921E-2

9,50733E2

3,26224E1

6,16803E2

6.0

copasi

5,61923E0

4,38077E0

7,27921E-2

9,50732E2

3,26224E1

6,16804E2

3,26224E1

6.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,61923E0

4,38077E0

7,27921E-2

9,50732E2

3,26224E1

6,16804E2

3,26224E1

6.0

jsim

5,61923E0

9,14105E-1

5,77972E-1

4,38077E0

7,27921E-2

9,99509E-1

6,89625E-1

9,50732E2

5,22717E-1

3,26224E1

2,35709E-1

6,16804E2

3,26224E1

3,81496E-1

7,18749E-11

6.0

min

5,61923E0

9,14104E-1

5,77972E-1

4,38062E0

7,27280E-2

9,99509E-1

6,89602E-1

9,50732E2

5,22710E-1

3,26214E1

2,35709E-1

2,78000E2

3,26214E1

3,81496E-1

7,16220E-11

6.0

max

5,61938E0

9,14105E-1

5,77980E-1

4,38077E0

7,45172E8

9,99510E-1

6,89625E-1

1,00000E3

5,22717E-1

3,26224E1

2,35726E-1

6,16862E2

3,26224E1

3,81516E-1

7,18749E-11

6.0

mean

5,61923E0

9,14105E-1

5,77972E-1

4,38077E0

7,27921E-2

9,99509E-1

6,89625E-1

9,50732E2

5,22717E-1

3,26224E1

2,35709E-1

6,16804E2

3,26224E1

3,81496E-1

7,18749E-11

6.0

relative error(%)

0,00

6.2

BioUML

5,72312E0

9,10262E-1

5,76804E-1

4,27688E0

7,40413E-2

9,99507E-1

6,74010E-1

9,49347E2

5,16726E-1

3,18489E1

2,38427E-1

6,26143E2

3,18489E1

3,85048E-1

7,69371E-11

6.2

ByoDyn

5,72312E0

9,10262E-1

5,76804E-1

4,27688E0

7,40413E-2

9,99507E-1

6,74010E-1

9,49347E2

5,16726E-1

3,18489E1

2,38427E-1

6,26143E2

3,18489E1

3,85048E-1

7,69371E-11

6.2

MathSBML

5,72312E0

4,27688E0

7,40413E-2

9,49347E2

3,18489E1

6,26143E2

3,18489E1

6.2

Oscill8 Core

4,27688E0

1,47088E9

1,00000E3

3,18489E1

2,80600E2

6.2

SBToolbox2

5,72328E0

9,10254E-1

5,76813E-1

4,27672E0

7,39757E-2

9,99510E-1

6,73980E-1

9,49343E2

5,16716E-1

3,18476E1

2,38443E-1

6,26205E2

3,18476E1

3,85075E-1

7,66660E-11

6.2

SBWOdeSolver

4,27688E0

7,40413E-2

9,49347E2

3,18489E1

6,26143E2

6.2

copasi

5,72312E0

4,27688E0

7,40413E-2

9,49347E2

3,18489E1

6,26143E2

3,18489E1

6.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,72312E0

4,27688E0

7,40413E-2

9,49347E2

3,18489E1

6,26143E2

3,18489E1

6.2

jsim

5,72312E0

9,10262E-1

5,76804E-1

4,27688E0

7,40413E-2

9,99507E-1

6,74010E-1

9,49347E2

5,16726E-1

3,18489E1

2,38427E-1

6,26143E2

3,18489E1

3,85048E-1

7,69371E-11

6.2

min

5,72312E0

9,10254E-1

5,76804E-1

4,27672E0

7,39757E-2

9,99507E-1

6,73980E-1

9,49343E2

5,16716E-1

3,18476E1

2,38427E-1

2,80600E2

3,18476E1

3,85048E-1

7,66660E-11

6.2

max

5,72328E0

9,10262E-1

5,76813E-1

4,27688E0

1,47088E9

9,99510E-1

6,74010E-1

1,00000E3

5,16726E-1

3,18489E1

2,38443E-1

6,26205E2

3,18489E1

3,85075E-1

7,69371E-11

6.2

mean

5,72312E0

9,10262E-1

5,76804E-1

4,27688E0

7,40413E-2

9,99507E-1

6,74010E-1

9,49347E2

5,16726E-1

3,18489E1

2,38427E-1

6,26143E2

3,18489E1

3,85048E-1

7,69371E-11

6.2

relative error(%)

0,00

6.4

BioUML

5,82454E0

9,06263E-1

5,75434E-1

4,17546E0

7,54010E-2

9,99505E-1

6,57998E-1

9,47996E2

5,10731E-1

3,10937E1

2,41006E-1

6,35067E2

3,10937E1

3,88404E-1

8,27462E-11

6.4

ByoDyn

5,82454E0

9,06263E-1

5,75434E-1

4,17546E0

7,54010E-2

9,99505E-1

6,57998E-1

9,47996E2

5,10731E-1

3,10937E1

2,41006E-1

6,35067E2

3,10937E1

3,88404E-1

8,27462E-11

6.4

MathSBML

5,82454E0

4,17546E0

7,54010E-2

9,47996E2

3,10937E1

6,35067E2

3,10937E1

6.4

Oscill8 Core

4,17546E0

2,90332E9

1,00000E3

3,10937E1

2,83200E2

6.4

SBToolbox2

5,82470E0

9,06258E-1

5,75445E-1

4,17530E0

7,53326E-2

9,99506E-1

6,57968E-1

9,47988E2

5,10722E-1

3,10923E1

2,41027E-1

6,35135E2

3,10923E1

3,88428E-1

8,24462E-11

6.4

SBWOdeSolver

4,17546E0

7,54010E-2

9,47996E2

3,10937E1

6,35067E2

6.4

copasi

5,82454E0

4,17546E0

7,54010E-2

9,47996E2

3,10937E1

6,35067E2

3,10937E1

6.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,82454E0

4,17546E0

7,54010E-2

9,47996E2

3,10937E1

6,35067E2

3,10937E1

6.4

jsim

5,82454E0

9,06263E-1

5,75434E-1

4,17546E0

7,54010E-2

9,99505E-1

6,57998E-1

9,47996E2

5,10731E-1

3,10937E1

2,41006E-1

6,35067E2

3,10937E1

3,88404E-1

8,27462E-11

6.4

min

5,82454E0

9,06258E-1

5,75434E-1

4,17530E0

7,53326E-2

9,99505E-1

6,57968E-1

9,47988E2

5,10722E-1

3,10923E1

2,41006E-1

2,83200E2

3,10923E1

3,88404E-1

8,24462E-11

6.4

max

5,82470E0

9,06263E-1

5,75445E-1

4,17546E0

2,90332E9

9,99506E-1

6,57998E-1

1,00000E3

5,10731E-1

3,10937E1

2,41027E-1

6,35135E2

3,10937E1

3,88428E-1

8,27462E-11

6.4

mean

5,82454E0

9,06263E-1

5,75434E-1

4,17546E0

7,54010E-2

9,99505E-1

6,57998E-1

9,47996E2

5,10731E-1

3,10937E1

2,41006E-1

6,35067E2

3,10937E1

3,88404E-1

8,27462E-11

6.4

relative error(%)

0,00

6.6

BioUML

5,92356E0

9,02106E-1

5,73869E-1

4,07644E0

7,68733E-2

9,99503E-1

6,41617E-1

9,46679E2

5,04732E-1

3,03564E1

2,43448E-1

6,43572E2

3,03564E1

3,91569E-1

8,94011E-11

6.6

ByoDyn

5,92356E0

9,02106E-1

5,73869E-1

4,07644E0

7,68733E-2

9,99503E-1

6,41617E-1

9,46679E2

5,04732E-1

3,03564E1

2,43448E-1

6,43572E2

3,03564E1

3,91569E-1

8,94011E-11

6.6

MathSBML

5,92356E0

4,07644E0

7,68733E-2

9,46679E2

3,03564E1

6,43572E2

3,03564E1

6.6

Oscill8 Core

4,07644E0

5,73078E9

1,00000E3

3,03564E1

2,85800E2

6.6

SBToolbox2

5,92377E0

9,02099E-1

5,73879E-1

4,07623E0

7,68028E-2

9,99500E-1

6,41588E-1

9,46670E2

5,04718E-1

3,03548E1

2,43471E-1

6,43643E2

3,03548E1

3,91594E-1

8,90747E-11

6.6

SBWOdeSolver

4,07644E0

7,68734E-2

9,46679E2

3,03564E1

6,43571E2

6.6

copasi

5,92356E0

4,07644E0

7,68734E-2

9,46679E2

3,03564E1

6,43572E2

3,03564E1

6.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,92356E0

4,07644E0

7,68733E-2

9,46679E2

3,03564E1

6,43572E2

3,03564E1

6.6

jsim

5,92356E0

9,02106E-1

5,73869E-1

4,07644E0

7,68733E-2

9,99503E-1

6,41617E-1

9,46679E2

5,04732E-1

3,03564E1

2,43448E-1

6,43572E2

3,03564E1

3,91569E-1

8,94011E-11

6.6

min

5,92356E0

9,02099E-1

5,73869E-1

4,07623E0

7,68028E-2

9,99500E-1

6,41588E-1

9,46670E2

5,04718E-1

3,03548E1

2,43448E-1

2,85800E2

3,03548E1

3,91569E-1

8,90747E-11

6.6

max

5,92377E0

9,02106E-1

5,73879E-1

4,07644E0

5,73078E9

9,99503E-1

6,41617E-1

1,00000E3

5,04732E-1

3,03564E1

2,43471E-1

6,43643E2

3,03564E1

3,91594E-1

8,94011E-11

6.6

mean

5,92356E0

9,02106E-1

5,73869E-1

4,07644E0

7,68733E-2

9,99503E-1

6,41617E-1

9,46679E2

5,04732E-1

3,03564E1

2,43448E-1

6,43572E2

3,03564E1

3,91569E-1

8,94011E-11

6.6

relative error(%)

0,00

6.8

BioUML

6,02023E0

8,97784E-1

5,72118E-1

3,97977E0

7,84620E-2

9,99501E-1

6,24899E-1

9,45396E2

4,98733E-1

2,96365E1

2,45754E-1

6,51654E2

2,96365E1

3,94546E-1

9,70237E-11

6.8

ByoDyn

6,02023E0

8,97784E-1

5,72118E-1

3,97977E0

7,84620E-2

9,99501E-1

6,24899E-1

9,45396E2

4,98733E-1

2,96365E1

2,45754E-1

6,51654E2

2,96365E1

3,94546E-1

9,70237E-11

6.8

MathSBML

6,02023E0

3,97977E0

7,84620E-2

9,45396E2

2,96365E1

6,51654E2

2,96365E1

6.8

Oscill8 Core

3,97977E0

1,13118E10

1,00000E3

2,96365E1

2,88400E2

6.8

SBToolbox2

6,02044E0

8,97776E-1

5,72128E-1

3,97956E0

7,83892E-2

9,99500E-1

6,24861E-1

9,45391E2

4,98724E-1

2,96348E1

2,45775E-1

6,51728E2

2,96348E1

3,94575E-1

9,66636E-11

6.8

SBWOdeSolver

3,97977E0

7,84620E-2

9,45396E2

2,96365E1

6,51654E2

6.8

copasi

6,02023E0

3,97977E0

7,84620E-2

9,45396E2

2,96365E1

6,51654E2

2,96365E1

6.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,02023E0

3,97977E0

7,84620E-2

9,45396E2

2,96365E1

6,51654E2

2,96365E1

6.8

jsim

6,02023E0

8,97784E-1

5,72118E-1

3,97977E0

7,84620E-2

9,99501E-1

6,24899E-1

9,45396E2

4,98733E-1

2,96365E1

2,45754E-1

6,51654E2

2,96365E1

3,94546E-1

9,70237E-11

6.8

min

6,02023E0

8,97776E-1

5,72118E-1

3,97956E0

7,83892E-2

9,99500E-1

6,24861E-1

9,45391E2

4,98724E-1

2,96348E1

2,45754E-1

2,88400E2

2,96348E1

3,94546E-1

9,66636E-11

6.8

max

6,02044E0

8,97784E-1

5,72128E-1

3,97977E0

1,13118E10

9,99501E-1

6,24899E-1

1,00000E3

4,98733E-1

2,96365E1

2,45775E-1

6,51728E2

2,96365E1

3,94575E-1

9,70237E-11

6.8

mean

6,02023E0

8,97784E-1

5,72118E-1

3,97977E0

7,84620E-2

9,99501E-1

6,24899E-1

9,45396E2

4,98733E-1

2,96365E1

2,45754E-1

6,51654E2

2,96365E1

3,94546E-1

9,70237E-11

6.8

relative error(%)

0,00

7.0

BioUML

6,11460E0

8,93295E-1

5,70189E-1

3,88540E0

8,01719E-2

9,99499E-1

6,07877E-1

9,44150E2

4,92733E-1

2,89337E1

2,47926E-1

6,59311E2

2,89337E1

3,97340E-1

1,05762E-10

7.0

ByoDyn

6,11460E0

8,93295E-1

5,70189E-1

3,88540E0

8,01719E-2

9,99499E-1

6,07877E-1

9,44150E2

4,92733E-1

2,89337E1

2,47926E-1

6,59311E2

2,89337E1

3,97340E-1

1,05762E-10

7.0

MathSBML

6,11460E0

3,88540E0

8,01719E-2

9,44150E2

2,89337E1

6,59311E2

2,89337E1

7.0

Oscill8 Core

3,88540E0

2,23280E10

1,00000E3

2,89337E1

2,91000E2

7.0

SBToolbox2

6,11481E0

8,93281E-1

5,70200E-1

3,88519E0

8,00947E-2

9,99500E-1

6,07842E-1

9,44142E2

4,92720E-1

2,89325E1

2,47950E-1

6,59394E2

2,89325E1

3,97372E-1

1,05351E-10

7.0

SBWOdeSolver

3,88540E0

8,01719E-2

9,44150E2

2,89337E1

6,59311E2

7.0

copasi

6,11460E0

3,88540E0

8,01719E-2

9,44150E2

2,89337E1

6,59311E2

2,89337E1

7.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,11460E0

3,88540E0

8,01719E-2

9,44150E2

2,89337E1

6,59311E2

2,89337E1

7.0

jsim

6,11460E0

8,93295E-1

5,70189E-1

3,88540E0

8,01719E-2

9,99499E-1

6,07877E-1

9,44150E2

4,92733E-1

2,89337E1

2,47926E-1

6,59311E2

2,89337E1

3,97340E-1

1,05762E-10

7.0

min

6,11460E0

8,93281E-1

5,70189E-1

3,88519E0

8,00947E-2

9,99499E-1

6,07842E-1

9,44142E2

4,92720E-1

2,89325E1

2,47926E-1

2,91000E2

2,89325E1

3,97340E-1

1,05351E-10

7.0

max

6,11481E0

8,93295E-1

5,70200E-1

3,88540E0

2,23280E10

9,99500E-1

6,07877E-1

1,00000E3

4,92733E-1

2,89337E1

2,47950E-1

6,59394E2

2,89337E1

3,97372E-1

1,05762E-10

7.0

mean

6,11460E0

8,93295E-1

5,70189E-1

3,88540E0

8,01719E-2

9,99499E-1

6,07877E-1

9,44150E2

4,92733E-1

2,89337E1

2,47926E-1

6,59311E2

2,89337E1

3,97340E-1

1,05762E-10

7.0

relative error(%)

0,00

7.2

BioUML

6,20674E0

8,88632E-1

5,68088E-1

3,79326E0

8,20091E-2

9,99497E-1

5,90589E-1

9,42940E2

4,86736E-1

2,82476E1

2,49965E-1

6,66542E2

2,82476E1

3,99955E-1

1,15795E-10

7.2

ByoDyn

6,20674E0

8,88632E-1

5,68088E-1

3,79326E0

8,20091E-2

9,99497E-1

5,90589E-1

9,42940E2

4,86736E-1

2,82476E1

2,49965E-1

6,66542E2

2,82476E1

3,99955E-1

1,15795E-10

7.2

MathSBML

6,20674E0

3,79326E0

8,20091E-2

9,42940E2

2,82476E1

6,66542E2

2,82476E1

7.2

Oscill8 Core

3,79326E0

4,40726E10

1,00000E3

2,82476E1

2,93600E2

7.2

SBToolbox2

6,20699E0

8,88623E-1

5,68099E-1

3,79301E0

8,19306E-2

9,99500E-1

5,90546E-1

9,42933E2

4,86716E-1

2,82455E1

2,49988E-1

6,66628E2

2,82455E1

3,99986E-1

1,15351E-10

7.2

SBWOdeSolver

3,79326E0

8,20092E-2

9,42940E2

2,82476E1

6,66542E2

7.2

copasi

6,20674E0

3,79326E0

8,20091E-2

9,42940E2

2,82476E1

6,66542E2

2,82476E1

7.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,20674E0

3,79326E0

8,20091E-2

9,42940E2

2,82476E1

6,66542E2

2,82476E1

7.2

jsim

6,20674E0

8,88632E-1

5,68088E-1

3,79326E0

8,20091E-2

9,99497E-1

5,90589E-1

9,42940E2

4,86736E-1

2,82476E1

2,49965E-1

6,66542E2

2,82476E1

3,99955E-1

1,15795E-10

7.2

min

6,20674E0

8,88623E-1

5,68088E-1

3,79301E0

8,19306E-2

9,99497E-1

5,90546E-1

9,42933E2

4,86716E-1

2,82455E1

2,49965E-1

2,93600E2

2,82455E1

3,99955E-1

1,15351E-10

7.2

max

6,20699E0

8,88632E-1

5,68099E-1

3,79326E0

4,40726E10

9,99500E-1

5,90589E-1

1,00000E3

4,86736E-1

2,82476E1

2,49988E-1

6,66628E2

2,82476E1

3,99986E-1

1,15795E-10

7.2

mean

6,20674E0

8,88632E-1

5,68088E-1

3,79326E0

8,20091E-2

9,99497E-1

5,90589E-1

9,42940E2

4,86736E-1

2,82476E1

2,49965E-1

6,66542E2

2,82476E1

3,99955E-1

1,15795E-10

7.2

relative error(%)

0,00

7.4

BioUML

6,29670E0

8,83793E-1

5,65822E-1

3,70330E0

8,39810E-2

9,99495E-1

5,73073E-1

9,41767E2

4,80742E-1

2,75778E1

2,51874E-1

6,73346E2

2,75778E1

4,02395E-1

1,27340E-10

7.4

ByoDyn

6,29670E0

8,83793E-1

5,65822E-1

3,70330E0

8,39810E-2

9,99495E-1

5,73073E-1

9,41767E2

4,80742E-1

2,75778E1

2,51874E-1

6,73346E2

2,75778E1

4,02395E-1

1,27340E-10

7.4

MathSBML

6,29670E0

3,70330E0

8,39810E-2

9,41767E2

2,75778E1

6,73346E2

2,75778E1

7.4

Oscill8 Core

3,70330E0

8,69934E10

1,00000E3

2,75778E1

2,96200E2

7.4

SBToolbox2

6,29694E0

8,83778E-1

5,65829E-1

3,70306E0

8,38955E-2

9,99500E-1

5,73031E-1

9,41757E2

4,80732E-1

2,75764E1

2,51903E-1

6,73436E2

2,75764E1

4,02429E-1

1,26821E-10

7.4

SBWOdeSolver

3,70330E0

8,39811E-2

9,41767E2

2,75778E1

6,73346E2

7.4

copasi

6,29670E0

3,70330E0

8,39810E-2

9,41767E2

2,75778E1

6,73346E2

2,75778E1

7.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,29670E0

3,70330E0

8,39810E-2

9,41767E2

2,75778E1

6,73346E2

2,75778E1

7.4

jsim

6,29670E0

8,83793E-1

5,65822E-1

3,70330E0

8,39810E-2

9,99495E-1

5,73073E-1

9,41767E2

4,80742E-1

2,75778E1

2,51874E-1

6,73346E2

2,75778E1

4,02395E-1

1,27340E-10

7.4

min

6,29670E0

8,83778E-1

5,65822E-1

3,70306E0

8,38955E-2

9,99495E-1

5,73031E-1

9,41757E2

4,80732E-1

2,75764E1

2,51874E-1

2,96200E2

2,75764E1

4,02395E-1

1,26821E-10

7.4

max

6,29694E0

8,83793E-1

5,65829E-1

3,70330E0

8,69934E10

9,99500E-1

5,73073E-1

1,00000E3

4,80742E-1

2,75778E1

2,51903E-1

6,73436E2

2,75778E1

4,02429E-1

1,27340E-10

7.4

mean

6,29670E0

8,83793E-1

5,65822E-1

3,70330E0

8,39810E-2

9,99495E-1

5,73073E-1

9,41767E2

4,80742E-1

2,75778E1

2,51874E-1

6,73346E2

2,75778E1

4,02395E-1

1,27340E-10

7.4

relative error(%)

0,00

7.6

BioUML

6,38452E0

8,78772E-1

5,63398E-1

3,61548E0

8,60962E-2

9,99493E-1

5,55372E-1

9,40631E2

4,74754E-1

2,69238E1

2,53654E-1

6,79721E2

2,69238E1

4,04663E-1

1,40662E-10

7.6

ByoDyn

6,38452E0

8,78772E-1

5,63398E-1

3,61548E0

8,60962E-2

9,99493E-1

5,55372E-1

9,40631E2

4,74754E-1

2,69238E1

2,53654E-1

6,79721E2

2,69238E1

4,04663E-1

1,40662E-10

7.6

MathSBML

6,38452E0

3,61548E0

8,60962E-2

9,40631E2

2,69238E1

6,79721E2

2,69238E1

7.6

Oscill8 Core

3,61548E0

1,71713E11

1,00000E3

2,69238E1

2,98800E2

7.6

SBToolbox2

6,38476E0

8,78758E-1

5,63409E-1

3,61524E0

8,60084E-2

9,99490E-1

5,55326E-1

9,40626E2

4,74738E-1

2,69221E1

2,53682E-1

6,79814E2

2,69221E1

4,04696E-1

1,40090E-10

7.6

SBWOdeSolver

3,61548E0

8,60963E-2

9,40631E2

2,69238E1

6,79721E2

7.6

copasi

6,38452E0

3,61548E0

8,60962E-2

9,40631E2

2,69238E1

6,79721E2

2,69238E1

7.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,38452E0

3,61548E0

8,60962E-2

9,40631E2

2,69238E1

6,79721E2

2,69238E1

7.6

jsim

6,38452E0

8,78772E-1

5,63398E-1

3,61548E0

8,60962E-2

9,99493E-1

5,55372E-1

9,40631E2

4,74754E-1

2,69238E1

2,53654E-1

6,79721E2

2,69238E1

4,04663E-1

1,40662E-10

7.6

min

6,38452E0

8,78758E-1

5,63398E-1

3,61524E0

8,60084E-2

9,99490E-1

5,55326E-1

9,40626E2

4,74738E-1

2,69221E1

2,53654E-1

2,98800E2

2,69221E1

4,04663E-1

1,40090E-10

7.6

max

6,38476E0

8,78772E-1

5,63409E-1

3,61548E0

1,71713E11

9,99493E-1

5,55372E-1

1,00000E3

4,74754E-1

2,69238E1

2,53682E-1

6,79814E2

2,69238E1

4,04696E-1

1,40662E-10

7.6

mean

6,38452E0

8,78772E-1

5,63398E-1

3,61548E0

8,60962E-2

9,99493E-1

5,55372E-1

9,40631E2

4,74754E-1

2,69238E1

2,53654E-1

6,79721E2

2,69238E1

4,04663E-1

1,40662E-10

7.6

relative error(%)

0,00

7.8

BioUML

6,47026E0

8,73564E-1

5,60822E-1

3,52974E0

8,83645E-2

9,99492E-1

5,37530E-1

9,39533E2

4,68773E-1

2,62853E1

2,55307E-1

6,85669E2

2,62853E1

4,06764E-1

1,56081E-10

7.8

ByoDyn

6,47026E0

8,73564E-1

5,60822E-1

3,52974E0

8,83645E-2

9,99492E-1

5,37530E-1

9,39533E2

4,68773E-1

2,62853E1

2,55307E-1

6,85669E2

2,62853E1

4,06764E-1

1,56081E-10

7.8

MathSBML

6,47026E0

3,52974E0

8,83645E-2

9,39533E2

2,62853E1

6,85669E2

2,62853E1

7.8

Oscill8 Core

3,52974E0

3,38939E11

1,00000E3

2,62853E1

3,01400E2

7.8

SBToolbox2

6,47052E0

8,73551E-1

5,60831E-1

3,52948E0

8,82717E-2

9,99490E-1

5,37482E-1

9,39527E2

4,68754E-1

2,62832E1

2,55338E-1

6,85772E2

2,62832E1

4,06802E-1

1,55423E-10

7.8

SBWOdeSolver

3,52974E0

8,83646E-2

9,39533E2

2,62853E1

6,85669E2

7.8

copasi

6,47026E0

3,52974E0

8,83645E-2

9,39533E2

2,62853E1

6,85669E2

2,62853E1

7.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,47026E0

3,52974E0

8,83645E-2

9,39533E2

2,62853E1

6,85669E2

2,62853E1

7.8

jsim

6,47026E0

8,73564E-1

5,60822E-1

3,52974E0

8,83645E-2

9,99492E-1

5,37530E-1

9,39533E2

4,68773E-1

2,62853E1

2,55307E-1

6,85669E2

2,62853E1

4,06764E-1

1,56081E-10

7.8

min

6,47026E0

8,73551E-1

5,60822E-1

3,52948E0

8,82717E-2

9,99490E-1

5,37482E-1

9,39527E2

4,68754E-1

2,62832E1

2,55307E-1

3,01400E2

2,62832E1

4,06764E-1

1,55423E-10

7.8

max

6,47052E0

8,73564E-1

5,60831E-1

3,52974E0

3,38939E11

9,99492E-1

5,37530E-1

1,00000E3

4,68773E-1

2,62853E1

2,55338E-1

6,85772E2

2,62853E1

4,06802E-1

1,56081E-10

7.8

mean

6,47026E0

8,73564E-1

5,60822E-1

3,52974E0

8,83645E-2

9,99492E-1

5,37530E-1

9,39533E2

4,68773E-1

2,62853E1

2,55307E-1

6,85669E2

2,62853E1

4,06764E-1

1,56081E-10

7.8

relative error(%)

0,00

8.0

BioUML

6,55396E0

8,68167E-1

5,58100E-1

3,44604E0

9,07970E-2

9,99490E-1

5,19591E-1

9,38472E2

4,62801E-1

2,56620E1

2,56835E-1

6,91192E2

2,56620E1

4,08701E-1

1,73991E-10

8.0

ByoDyn

6,55396E0

8,68167E-1

5,58100E-1

3,44604E0

9,07970E-2

9,99490E-1

5,19591E-1

9,38472E2

4,62801E-1

2,56620E1

2,56835E-1

6,91192E2

2,56620E1

4,08701E-1

1,73991E-10

8.0

MathSBML

6,55396E0

3,44604E0

9,07970E-2

9,38472E2

2,56620E1

6,91192E2

2,56620E1

8.0

Oscill8 Core

3,44604E0

6,69020E11

1,00000E3

2,56620E1

3,04000E2

8.0

SBToolbox2

6,55422E0

8,68154E-1

5,58112E-1

3,44578E0

9,06982E-2

9,99490E-1

5,19540E-1

9,38460E2

4,62780E-1

2,56598E1

2,56864E-1

6,91294E2

2,56598E1

4,08738E-1

1,73234E-10

8.0

SBWOdeSolver

3,44604E0

9,07971E-2

9,38472E2

2,56620E1

6,91192E2

8.0

copasi

6,55396E0

3,44604E0

9,07970E-2

9,38472E2

2,56620E1

6,91192E2

2,56620E1

8.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,55396E0

3,44604E0

9,07970E-2

9,38472E2

2,56620E1

6,91192E2

2,56620E1

8.0

jsim

6,55396E0

8,68167E-1

5,58100E-1

3,44604E0

9,07970E-2

9,99490E-1

5,19591E-1

9,38472E2

4,62801E-1

2,56620E1

2,56835E-1

6,91192E2

2,56620E1

4,08701E-1

1,73991E-10

8.0

min

6,55396E0

8,68154E-1

5,58100E-1

3,44578E0

9,06982E-2

9,99490E-1

5,19540E-1

9,38460E2

4,62780E-1

2,56598E1

2,56835E-1

3,04000E2

2,56598E1

4,08701E-1

1,73234E-10

8.0

max

6,55422E0

8,68167E-1

5,58112E-1

3,44604E0

6,69020E11

9,99490E-1

5,19591E-1

1,00000E3

4,62801E-1

2,56620E1

2,56864E-1

6,91294E2

2,56620E1

4,08738E-1

1,73991E-10

8.0

mean

6,55396E0

8,68167E-1

5,58100E-1

3,44604E0

9,07970E-2

9,99490E-1

5,19591E-1

9,38472E2

4,62801E-1

2,56620E1

2,56835E-1

6,91192E2

2,56620E1

4,08701E-1

1,73991E-10

8.0

relative error(%)

0,00

8.2

BioUML

6,63568E0

8,62576E-1

5,55237E-1

3,36432E0

9,34064E-2

9,99488E-1

5,01601E-1

9,37450E2

4,56840E-1

2,50534E1

2,58240E-1

6,96291E2

2,50534E1

4,10479E-1

1,94871E-10

8.2

ByoDyn

6,63568E0

8,62576E-1

5,55237E-1

3,36432E0

9,34064E-2

9,99488E-1

5,01601E-1

9,37450E2

4,56840E-1

2,50534E1

2,58240E-1

6,96291E2

2,50534E1

4,10479E-1

1,94871E-10

8.2

MathSBML

6,63568E0

3,36432E0

9,34064E-2

9,37450E2

2,50534E1

6,96291E2

2,50534E1

8.2

Oscill8 Core

3,36432E0

1,32055E12

1,00000E3

2,50534E1

3,06600E2

8.2

SBToolbox2

6,63594E0

8,62558E-1

5,55243E-1

3,36406E0

9,33053E-2

9,99490E-1

5,01546E-1

9,37441E2

4,56818E-1

2,50516E1

2,58271E-1

6,96395E2

2,50516E1

4,10514E-1

1,94032E-10

8.2

SBWOdeSolver

3,36432E0

9,34065E-2

9,37450E2

2,50534E1

6,96291E2

8.2

copasi

6,63568E0

3,36432E0

9,34065E-2

9,37450E2

2,50534E1

6,96291E2

2,50534E1

8.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,63568E0

3,36432E0

9,34064E-2

9,37450E2

2,50534E1

6,96291E2

2,50534E1

8.2

jsim

6,63568E0

8,62576E-1

5,55237E-1

3,36432E0

9,34065E-2

9,99488E-1

5,01601E-1

9,37450E2

4,56840E-1

2,50534E1

2,58240E-1

6,96291E2

2,50534E1

4,10479E-1

1,94871E-10

8.2

min

6,63568E0

8,62558E-1

5,55237E-1

3,36406E0

9,33053E-2

9,99488E-1

5,01546E-1

9,37441E2

4,56818E-1

2,50516E1

2,58240E-1

3,06600E2

2,50516E1

4,10479E-1

1,94032E-10

8.2

max

6,63594E0

8,62576E-1

5,55243E-1

3,36432E0

1,32055E12

9,99490E-1

5,01601E-1

1,00000E3

4,56840E-1

2,50534E1

2,58271E-1

6,96395E2

2,50534E1

4,10514E-1

1,94871E-10

8.2

mean

6,63568E0

8,62576E-1

5,55237E-1

3,36432E0

9,34064E-2

9,99488E-1

5,01601E-1

9,37450E2

4,56840E-1

2,50534E1

2,58240E-1

6,96291E2

2,50534E1

4,10479E-1

1,94871E-10

8.2

relative error(%)

0,00

8.4

BioUML

6,71547E0

8,56786E-1

5,52238E-1

3,28453E0

9,62070E-2

9,99487E-1

4,83607E-1

9,36465E2

4,50891E-1

2,44593E1

2,59525E-1

7,00970E2

2,44593E1

4,12100E-1

2,19314E-10

8.4

ByoDyn

6,71547E0

8,56786E-1

5,52238E-1

3,28453E0

9,62070E-2

9,99487E-1

4,83607E-1

9,36465E2

4,50891E-1

2,44593E1

2,59525E-1

7,00970E2

2,44593E1

4,12100E-1

2,19314E-10

8.4

MathSBML

6,71547E0

3,28453E0

9,62070E-2

9,36465E2

2,44593E1

7,00970E2

2,44593E1

8.4

Oscill8 Core

3,28453E0

2,60659E12

1,00000E3

2,44593E1

3,09200E2

8.4

SBToolbox2

6,71572E0

8,56764E-1

5,52246E-1

3,28428E0

9,60962E-2

9,99490E-1

4,83546E-1

9,36452E2

4,50872E-1

2,44574E1

2,59551E-1

7,01075E2

2,44574E1

4,12133E-1

2,18301E-10

8.4

SBWOdeSolver

3,28453E0

9,62071E-2

9,36465E2

2,44593E1

7,00970E2

8.4

copasi

6,71547E0

3,28453E0

9,62071E-2

9,36465E2

2,44593E1

7,00970E2

2,44593E1

8.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,71547E0

3,28453E0

9,62070E-2

9,36465E2

2,44593E1

7,00970E2

2,44593E1

8.4

jsim

6,71547E0

8,56786E-1

5,52238E-1

3,28453E0

9,62070E-2

9,99487E-1

4,83607E-1

9,36465E2

4,50891E-1

2,44593E1

2,59525E-1

7,00970E2

2,44593E1

4,12100E-1

2,19314E-10

8.4

min

6,71547E0

8,56764E-1

5,52238E-1

3,28428E0

9,60962E-2

9,99487E-1

4,83546E-1

9,36452E2

4,50872E-1

2,44574E1

2,59525E-1

3,09200E2

2,44574E1

4,12100E-1

2,18301E-10

8.4

max

6,71572E0

8,56786E-1

5,52246E-1

3,28453E0

2,60659E12

9,99490E-1

4,83607E-1

1,00000E3

4,50891E-1

2,44593E1

2,59551E-1

7,01075E2

2,44593E1

4,12133E-1

2,19314E-10

8.4

mean

6,71547E0

8,56786E-1

5,52238E-1

3,28453E0

9,62070E-2

9,99487E-1

4,83607E-1

9,36465E2

4,50891E-1

2,44593E1

2,59525E-1

7,00970E2

2,44593E1

4,12100E-1

2,19314E-10

8.4

relative error(%)

0,00

8.6

BioUML

6,79336E0

8,50795E-1

5,49110E-1

3,20664E0

9,92148E-2

9,99485E-1

4,65655E-1

9,35519E2

4,44957E-1

2,38793E1

2,60692E-1

7,05233E2

2,38793E1

4,13570E-1

2,48054E-10

8.6

ByoDyn

6,79336E0

8,50795E-1

5,49110E-1

3,20664E0

9,92148E-2

9,99485E-1

4,65655E-1

9,35519E2

4,44957E-1

2,38793E1

2,60692E-1

7,05233E2

2,38793E1

4,13570E-1

2,48054E-10

8.6

MathSBML

6,79336E0

3,20664E0

9,92148E-2

9,35519E2

2,38793E1

7,05233E2

2,38793E1

8.6

Oscill8 Core

3,20664E0

5,14505E12

1,00000E3

2,38793E1

3,11800E2

8.6

SBToolbox2

6,79363E0

8,50777E-1

5,49118E-1

3,20637E0

9,91008E-2

9,99480E-1

4,65594E-1

9,35504E2

4,44938E-1

2,38771E1

2,60718E-1

7,05339E2

2,38771E1

4,13610E-1

2,46918E-10

8.6

SBWOdeSolver

3,20664E0

9,92149E-2

9,35519E2

2,38793E1

7,05233E2

8.6

copasi

6,79336E0

3,20664E0

9,92149E-2

9,35519E2

2,38793E1

7,05233E2

2,38793E1

8.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,79336E0

3,20664E0

9,92148E-2

9,35519E2

2,38793E1

7,05233E2

2,38793E1

8.6

jsim

6,79336E0

8,50795E-1

5,49110E-1

3,20664E0

9,92148E-2

9,99485E-1

4,65655E-1

9,35519E2

4,44957E-1

2,38793E1

2,60692E-1

7,05233E2

2,38793E1

4,13570E-1

2,48054E-10

8.6

min

6,79336E0

8,50777E-1

5,49110E-1

3,20637E0

9,91008E-2

9,99480E-1

4,65594E-1

9,35504E2

4,44938E-1

2,38771E1

2,60692E-1

3,11800E2

2,38771E1

4,13570E-1

2,46918E-10

8.6

max

6,79363E0

8,50795E-1

5,49118E-1

3,20664E0

5,14505E12

9,99485E-1

4,65655E-1

1,00000E3

4,44957E-1

2,38793E1

2,60718E-1

7,05339E2

2,38793E1

4,13610E-1

2,48054E-10

8.6

mean

6,79336E0

8,50795E-1

5,49110E-1

3,20664E0

9,92148E-2

9,99485E-1

4,65655E-1

9,35519E2

4,44957E-1

2,38793E1

2,60692E-1

7,05233E2

2,38793E1

4,13570E-1

2,48054E-10

8.6

relative error(%)

0,00

8.8

BioUML

6,86940E0

8,44599E-1

5,45856E-1

3,13060E0

1,02448E-1

9,99484E-1

4,47792E-1

9,34610E2

4,39037E-1

2,33130E1

2,61743E-1

7,09085E2

2,33130E1

4,14892E-1

2,82001E-10

8.8

ByoDyn

6,86940E0

8,44599E-1

5,45856E-1

3,13060E0

1,02448E-1

9,99484E-1

4,47792E-1

9,34610E2

4,39037E-1

2,33130E1

2,61743E-1

7,09085E2

2,33130E1

4,14892E-1

2,82001E-10

8.8

MathSBML

6,86940E0

3,13060E0

1,02448E-1

9,34610E2

2,33130E1

7,09085E2

2,33130E1

8.8

Oscill8 Core

3,13060E0

1,01556E13

1,00000E3

2,33130E1

3,14400E2

8.8

SBToolbox2

6,86966E0

8,44573E-1

5,45861E-1

3,13034E0

1,02320E-1

9,99480E-1

4,47733E-1

9,34595E2

4,39015E-1

2,33106E1

2,61776E-1

7,09193E2

2,33106E1

4,14927E-1

2,80631E-10

8.8

SBWOdeSolver

3,13060E0

1,02448E-1

9,34610E2

2,33130E1

7,09085E2

8.8

copasi

6,86940E0

3,13060E0

1,02448E-1

9,34610E2

2,33130E1

7,09085E2

2,33130E1

8.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,86940E0

3,13060E0

1,02448E-1

9,34610E2

2,33130E1

7,09085E2

2,33130E1

8.8

jsim

6,86940E0

8,44599E-1

5,45856E-1

3,13060E0

1,02448E-1

9,99484E-1

4,47792E-1

9,34610E2

4,39037E-1

2,33130E1

2,61743E-1

7,09085E2

2,33130E1

4,14892E-1

2,82001E-10

8.8

min

6,86940E0

8,44573E-1

5,45856E-1

3,13034E0

1,02320E-1

9,99480E-1

4,47733E-1

9,34595E2

4,39015E-1

2,33106E1

2,61743E-1

3,14400E2

2,33106E1

4,14892E-1

2,80631E-10

8.8

max

6,86966E0

8,44599E-1

5,45861E-1

3,13060E0

1,01556E13

9,99484E-1

4,47792E-1

1,00000E3

4,39037E-1

2,33130E1

2,61776E-1

7,09193E2

2,33130E1

4,14927E-1

2,82001E-10

8.8

mean

6,86940E0

8,44599E-1

5,45856E-1

3,13060E0

1,02448E-1

9,99484E-1

4,47792E-1

9,34610E2

4,39037E-1

2,33130E1

2,61743E-1

7,09085E2

2,33130E1

4,14892E-1

2,82001E-10

8.8

relative error(%)

0,00

9.0

BioUML

6,94364E0

8,38194E-1

5,42482E-1

3,05636E0

1,05926E-1

9,99482E-1

4,30062E-1

9,33738E2

4,33136E-1

2,27601E1

2,62682E-1

7,12532E2

2,27601E1

4,16069E-1

3,22297E-10

9.0

ByoDyn

6,94364E0

8,38194E-1

5,42482E-1

3,05636E0

1,05926E-1

9,99482E-1

4,30062E-1

9,33738E2

4,33136E-1

2,27601E1

2,62682E-1

7,12532E2

2,27601E1

4,16069E-1

3,22297E-10

9.0

MathSBML

6,94364E0

3,05636E0

1,05926E-1

9,33738E2

2,27601E1

7,12532E2

2,27601E1

9.0

Oscill8 Core

3,05636E0

2,00458E13

1,00000E3

2,27601E1

3,17000E2

9.0

SBToolbox2

6,94387E0

8,38168E-1

5,42483E-1

3,05613E0

1,05798E-1

9,99480E-1

4,30001E-1

9,33726E2

4,33111E-1

2,27583E1

2,62714E-1

7,12646E2

2,27583E1

4,16106E-1

3,20730E-10

9.0

SBWOdeSolver

3,05636E0

1,05926E-1

9,33738E2

2,27601E1

7,12532E2

9.0

copasi

6,94364E0

3,05636E0

1,05926E-1

9,33738E2

2,27601E1

7,12532E2

2,27601E1

9.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,94364E0

3,05636E0

1,05926E-1

9,33738E2

2,27601E1

7,12532E2

2,27601E1

9.0

jsim

6,94364E0

8,38194E-1

5,42482E-1

3,05636E0

1,05926E-1

9,99482E-1

4,30062E-1

9,33738E2

4,33136E-1

2,27601E1

2,62682E-1

7,12532E2

2,27601E1

4,16069E-1

3,22297E-10

9.0

min

6,94364E0

8,38168E-1

5,42482E-1

3,05613E0

1,05798E-1

9,99480E-1

4,30001E-1

9,33726E2

4,33111E-1

2,27583E1

2,62682E-1

3,17000E2

2,27583E1

4,16069E-1

3,20730E-10

9.0

max

6,94387E0

8,38194E-1

5,42483E-1

3,05636E0

2,00458E13

9,99482E-1

4,30062E-1

1,00000E3

4,33136E-1

2,27601E1

2,62714E-1

7,12646E2

2,27601E1

4,16106E-1

3,22297E-10

9.0

mean

6,94364E0

8,38194E-1

5,42482E-1

3,05636E0

1,05926E-1

9,99482E-1

4,30062E-1

9,33738E2

4,33136E-1

2,27601E1

2,62682E-1

7,12532E2

2,27601E1

4,16069E-1

3,22297E-10

9.0

relative error(%)

0,00

9.2

BioUML

7,01612E0

8,31578E-1

5,38993E-1

2,98388E0

1,09673E-1

9,99481E-1

4,12510E-1

9,32904E2

4,27253E-1

2,22204E1

2,63509E-1

7,15581E2

2,22204E1

4,17107E-1

3,70377E-10

9.2

ByoDyn

7,01612E0

8,31578E-1

5,38993E-1

2,98388E0

1,09673E-1

9,99481E-1

4,12510E-1

9,32904E2

4,27253E-1

2,22204E1

2,63509E-1

7,15581E2

2,22204E1

4,17107E-1

3,70377E-10

9.2

MathSBML

7,01612E0

2,98388E0

1,09673E-1

9,32904E2

2,22204E1

7,15581E2

2,22204E1

9.2

Oscill8 Core

2,98388E0

3,95675E13

1,00000E3

2,22204E1

3,19600E2

9.2

SBToolbox2

7,01639E0

8,31553E-1

5,38996E-1

2,98361E0

1,09535E-1

9,99480E-1

4,12450E-1

9,32897E2

4,27227E-1

2,22188E1

2,63543E-1

7,15692E2

2,22188E1

4,17144E-1

3,68499E-10

9.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,98388E0

1,09673E-1

9,32904E2

2,22204E1

7,15581E2

9.2

copasi

7,01612E0

2,98388E0

1,09673E-1

9,32904E2

2,22204E1

7,15581E2

2,22204E1

9.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,01612E0

2,98388E0

1,09673E-1

9,32904E2

2,22204E1

7,15581E2

2,22204E1

9.2

jsim

7,01612E0

8,31578E-1

5,38993E-1

2,98388E0

1,09673E-1

9,99481E-1

4,12510E-1

9,32904E2

4,27253E-1

2,22204E1

2,63509E-1

7,15581E2

2,22204E1

4,17107E-1

3,70377E-10

9.2

min

7,01612E0

8,31553E-1

5,38993E-1

2,98361E0

1,09535E-1

9,99480E-1

4,12450E-1

9,32897E2

4,27227E-1

2,22188E1

2,63509E-1

3,19600E2

2,22188E1

4,17107E-1

3,68499E-10

9.2

max

7,01639E0

8,31578E-1

5,38996E-1

2,98388E0

3,95675E13

9,99481E-1

4,12510E-1

1,00000E3

4,27253E-1

2,22204E1

2,63543E-1

7,15692E2

2,22204E1

4,17144E-1

3,70377E-10

9.2

mean

7,01612E0

8,31578E-1

5,38993E-1

2,98388E0

1,09673E-1

9,99481E-1

4,12510E-1

9,32904E2

4,27253E-1

2,22204E1

2,63509E-1

7,15581E2

2,22204E1

4,17107E-1

3,70377E-10

9.2

relative error(%)

0,00

9.4

BioUML

7,08688E0

8,24748E-1

5,35393E-1

2,91312E0

1,13714E-1

9,99479E-1

3,95178E-1

9,32107E2

4,21390E-1

2,16934E1

2,64230E-1

7,18240E2

2,16934E1

4,18009E-1

4,28058E-10

9.4

ByoDyn

7,08688E0

8,24748E-1

5,35393E-1

2,91312E0

1,13714E-1

9,99479E-1

3,95178E-1

9,32107E2

4,21390E-1

2,16934E1

2,64230E-1

7,18240E2

2,16934E1

4,18009E-1

4,28058E-10

9.4

MathSBML

7,08688E0

2,91312E0

1,13714E-1

9,32107E2

2,16934E1

7,18240E2

2,16934E1

9.4

Oscill8 Core

2,91312E0

7,81007E13

1,00000E3

2,16934E1

3,22200E2

9.4

SBToolbox2

7,08711E0

8,24719E-1

5,35399E-1

2,91289E0

1,13563E-1

9,99480E-1

3,95108E-1

9,32098E2

4,21372E-1

2,16914E1

2,64262E-1

7,18357E2

2,16914E1

4,18052E-1

4,25830E-10

9.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,91312E0

1,13714E-1

9,32107E2

2,16934E1

7,18240E2

9.4

copasi

7,08688E0

2,91312E0

1,13715E-1

9,32107E2

2,16934E1

7,18240E2

2,16934E1

9.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,08688E0

2,91312E0

1,13714E-1

9,32107E2

2,16934E1

7,18240E2

2,16934E1

9.4

jsim

7,08688E0

8,24748E-1

5,35393E-1

2,91312E0

1,13714E-1

9,99479E-1

3,95178E-1

9,32107E2

4,21390E-1

2,16934E1

2,64230E-1

7,18240E2

2,16934E1

4,18009E-1

4,28058E-10

9.4

min

7,08688E0

8,24719E-1

5,35393E-1

2,91289E0

1,13563E-1

9,99479E-1

3,95108E-1

9,32098E2

4,21372E-1

2,16914E1

2,64230E-1

3,22200E2

2,16914E1

4,18009E-1

4,25830E-10

9.4

max

7,08711E0

8,24748E-1

5,35399E-1

2,91312E0

7,81007E13

9,99480E-1

3,95178E-1

1,00000E3

4,21390E-1

2,16934E1

2,64262E-1

7,18357E2

2,16934E1

4,18052E-1

4,28058E-10

9.4

mean

7,08688E0

8,24748E-1

5,35393E-1

2,91312E0

1,13714E-1

9,99479E-1

3,95178E-1

9,32107E2

4,21390E-1

2,16934E1

2,64230E-1

7,18240E2

2,16934E1

4,18009E-1

4,28058E-10

9.4

relative error(%)

0,00

9.6

BioUML

7,15596E0

8,17701E-1

5,31686E-1

2,84404E0

1,18079E-1

9,99478E-1

3,78106E-1

9,31345E2

4,15550E-1

2,11790E1

2,64845E-1

7,20516E2

2,11790E1

4,18779E-1

4,97655E-10

9.6

ByoDyn

7,15596E0

8,17701E-1

5,31686E-1

2,84404E0

1,18079E-1

9,99478E-1

3,78106E-1

9,31345E2

4,15550E-1

2,11790E1

2,64845E-1

7,20516E2

2,11790E1

4,18779E-1

4,97655E-10

9.6

MathSBML

7,15596E0

2,84404E0

1,18079E-1

9,31345E2

2,11790E1

7,20516E2

2,11790E1

9.6

Oscill8 Core

2,84404E0

1,54160E14

1,00000E3

2,11790E1

3,24800E2

9.6

SBToolbox2

7,15624E0

8,17676E-1

5,31692E-1

2,84376E0

1,17919E-1

9,99480E-1

3,78036E-1

9,31338E2

4,15528E-1

2,11770E1

2,64881E-1

7,20634E2

2,11770E1

4,18821E-1

4,95042E-10

9.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,84404E0

1,18079E-1

9,31345E2

2,11790E1

7,20517E2

9.6

copasi

7,15596E0

2,84404E0

1,18079E-1

9,31345E2

2,11790E1

7,20516E2

2,11790E1

9.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,15596E0

2,84404E0

1,18079E-1

9,31345E2

2,11790E1

7,20516E2

2,11790E1

9.6

jsim

7,15596E0

8,17701E-1

5,31686E-1

2,84404E0

1,18079E-1

9,99478E-1

3,78106E-1

9,31345E2

4,15550E-1

2,11790E1

2,64845E-1

7,20516E2

2,11790E1

4,18779E-1

4,97655E-10

9.6

min

7,15596E0

8,17676E-1

5,31686E-1

2,84376E0

1,17919E-1

9,99478E-1

3,78036E-1

9,31338E2

4,15528E-1

2,11770E1

2,64845E-1

3,24800E2

2,11770E1

4,18779E-1

4,95042E-10

9.6

max

7,15624E0

8,17701E-1

5,31692E-1

2,84404E0

1,54160E14

9,99480E-1

3,78106E-1

1,00000E3

4,15550E-1

2,11790E1

2,64881E-1

7,20634E2

2,11790E1

4,18821E-1

4,97655E-10

9.6

mean

7,15596E0

8,17701E-1

5,31686E-1

2,84404E0

1,18079E-1

9,99478E-1

3,78106E-1

9,31345E2

4,15550E-1

2,11790E1

2,64845E-1

7,20516E2

2,11790E1

4,18779E-1

4,97655E-10

9.6

relative error(%)

0,00

9.8

BioUML

7,22341E0

8,10437E-1

5,27878E-1

2,77659E0

1,22799E-1

9,99477E-1

3,61330E-1

9,30620E2

4,09733E-1

2,06768E1

2,65359E-1

7,22419E2

2,06768E1

4,19421E-1

5,82138E-10

9.8

ByoDyn

7,22341E0

8,10437E-1

5,27878E-1

2,77659E0

1,22799E-1

9,99477E-1

3,61330E-1

9,30620E2

4,09733E-1

2,06768E1

2,65359E-1

7,22419E2

2,06768E1

4,19421E-1

5,82138E-10

9.8

MathSBML

7,22341E0

2,77659E0

1,22799E-1

9,30620E2

2,06768E1

7,22419E2

2,06768E1

9.8

Oscill8 Core

2,77659E0

3,04289E14

1,00000E3

2,06768E1

3,27400E2

9.8

SBToolbox2

7,22367E0

8,10403E-1

5,27876E-1

2,77633E0

1,22635E-1

9,99480E-1

3,61263E-1

9,30609E2

4,09714E-1

2,06745E1

2,65390E-1

7,22532E2

2,06745E1

4,19461E-1

5,79013E-10

9.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,77659E0

1,22800E-1

9,30620E2

2,06768E1

7,22419E2

9.8

copasi

7,22341E0

2,77659E0

1,22800E-1

9,30620E2

2,06768E1

7,22419E2

2,06768E1

9.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,22341E0

2,77659E0

1,22799E-1

9,30620E2

2,06768E1

7,22419E2

2,06768E1

9.8

jsim

7,22341E0

8,10437E-1

5,27878E-1

2,77659E0

1,22799E-1

9,99477E-1

3,61330E-1

9,30620E2

4,09733E-1

2,06768E1

2,65359E-1

7,22419E2

2,06768E1

4,19421E-1

5,82138E-10

9.8

min

7,22341E0

8,10403E-1

5,27876E-1

2,77633E0

1,22635E-1

9,99477E-1

3,61263E-1

9,30609E2

4,09714E-1

2,06745E1

2,65359E-1

3,27400E2

2,06745E1

4,19421E-1

5,79013E-10

9.8

max

7,22367E0

8,10437E-1

5,27878E-1

2,77659E0

3,04289E14

9,99480E-1

3,61330E-1

1,00000E3

4,09733E-1

2,06768E1

2,65390E-1

7,22532E2

2,06768E1

4,19461E-1

5,82138E-10

9.8

mean

7,22341E0

8,10437E-1

5,27878E-1

2,77659E0

1,22799E-1

9,99477E-1

3,61330E-1

9,30620E2

4,09733E-1

2,06768E1

2,65359E-1

7,22419E2

2,06768E1

4,19421E-1

5,82138E-10

9.8

relative error(%)

0,00

Test: BIOMD0000000145.xml - Ok

Reaction graph

Plots

Comparison with other simulators