Test: BIOMD0000000125.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000125.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: Imex
generated code: BIOMD0000000125.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-10
ATOL 1.0E-12
RTOL 1.0E-7
STEP 1.0E-4

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000125.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL2451230486.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: y2  x2  x0  x1 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  SBToolbox2  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  BioUML 
timeresult y2 x2 x0 x1
0.0BioUML0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E0
0.0MathSBML0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Oscill8 Core0,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E0
0.0SBToolbox20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver0,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E0
0.0copasi0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E0
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E0
0.0min 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0max 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0mean 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML3,51518E-27,03036E-21,00000E03,62406E-1
0.2ByoDyn3,50462E-27,00924E-21,00000E03,62538E-1
0.2MathSBML3,50460E-27,00921E-21,00000E03,62539E-1
0.2Oscill8 Core3,50475E-27,00949E-2-3,62537E-1
0.2SBToolbox23,50239E-27,00487E-21,00000E03,62551E-1
0.2SBWOdeSolver3,50475E-27,00949E-2-3,62537E-1
0.2copasi3,50462E-27,00924E-21,00000E03,62538E-1
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner3,50462E-27,00924E-21,00000E03,62538E-1
0.2min 3,50239E-2 7,00487E-2 1,00000E0 3,62537E-1
0.2max 3,50475E-2 7,00949E-2 1,00000E0 3,62551E-1
0.2mean 3,50462E-2 7,00924E-2 1,00000E0 3,62538E-1
0.2relative error(%) 0,300,300,000,00
0.4BioUML1,23161E-12,46322E-11,00000E06,59266E-1
0.4ByoDyn1,23104E-12,46208E-11,00000E06,59360E-1
0.4MathSBML1,23104E-12,46208E-11,00000E06,59360E-1
0.4Oscill8 Core1,23105E-12,46211E-1-6,59357E-1
0.4SBToolbox21,23007E-12,46015E-11,00000E06,59421E-1
0.4SBWOdeSolver1,23105E-12,46211E-1-6,59357E-1
0.4copasi1,23104E-12,46208E-11,00000E06,59360E-1
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner1,23104E-12,46208E-11,00000E06,59360E-1
0.4min 1,23007E-1 2,46015E-1 1,00000E0 6,59357E-1
0.4max 1,23105E-1 2,46211E-1 1,00000E0 6,59421E-1
0.4mean 1,23104E-1 2,46208E-1 1,00000E0 6,59360E-1
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML2,43927E-14,87853E-11,00000E09,02069E-1
0.6ByoDyn2,43803E-14,87606E-11,00000E09,02377E-1
0.6MathSBML2,43803E-14,87606E-11,00000E09,02377E-1
0.6Oscill8 Core2,43804E-14,87608E-1-9,02374E-1
0.6SBToolbox22,43607E-14,87222E-11,00000E09,02508E-1
0.6SBWOdeSolver2,43804E-14,87608E-1-9,02374E-1
0.6copasi2,43803E-14,87606E-11,00000E09,02377E-1
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,43803E-14,87606E-11,00000E09,02377E-1
0.6min 2,43607E-1 4,87222E-1 1,00000E0 9,02374E-1
0.6max 2,43804E-1 4,87608E-1 1,00000E0 9,02508E-1
0.6mean 2,43803E-1 4,87606E-1 1,00000E0 9,02377E-1
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML3,82483E-17,64967E-11,00000E01,10099E0
0.8ByoDyn3,82416E-17,64831E-11,00000E01,10134E0
0.8MathSBML3,82416E-17,64831E-11,00000E01,10134E0
0.8Oscill8 Core3,82416E-17,64833E-1-1,10134E0
0.8SBToolbox23,82167E-17,64342E-11,00000E01,10157E0
0.8SBWOdeSolver3,82416E-17,64833E-1-1,10134E0
0.8copasi3,82416E-17,64831E-11,00000E01,10134E0
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner3,82416E-17,64831E-11,00000E01,10134E0
0.8min 3,82167E-1 7,64342E-1 1,00000E0 1,10134E0
0.8max 3,82416E-1 7,64833E-1 1,00000E0 1,10157E0
0.8mean 3,82416E-1 7,64831E-1 1,00000E0 1,10134E0
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML5,28483E-11,05697E01,00000E01,26383E0
1.0ByoDyn5,28482E-11,05696E01,00000E01,26424E0
1.0MathSBML5,28482E-11,05696E01,00000E01,26424E0
1.0Oscill8 Core5,28482E-11,05696E0-1,26424E0
1.0SBToolbox25,28126E-11,05623E09,99001E-21,26276E0
1.0SBWOdeSolver5,28482E-11,05696E0-1,26424E0
1.0copasi5,28482E-11,05696E01,00000E01,26424E0
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner5,28482E-11,05696E06,66134E-141,26424E0
1.0min 5,28126E-1 1,05623E0 6,66134E-14 1,26276E0
1.0max 5,28482E-1 1,05696E0 1,00000E0 1,26424E0
1.0mean 5,28482E-1 1,05696E0 1,00000E0 1,26424E0
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML6,74661E-11,34932E01,00000E01,39721E0
1.2ByoDyn6,39699E-11,27940E00,00000E01,03507E0
1.2MathSBML6,39699E-11,27940E00,00000E01,03507E0
1.2Oscill8 Core6,74745E-11,34949E0-1,39761E0
1.2SBToolbox26,39636E-11,27924E00,00000E01,03526E0
1.2SBWOdeSolver6,42607E-11,28521E0-1,05000E0
1.2copasi6,74745E-11,34949E01,00000E01,39761E0
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner6,39699E-11,27940E00,00000E01,03507E0
1.2min 6,39636E-1 1,27924E0 0,00000E0 1,03507E0
1.2max 6,74745E-1 1,34949E0 1,00000E0 1,39761E0
1.2mean 6,39699E-1 1,27940E0 0,00000E0 1,03526E0
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML8,16203E-11,63241E01,00000E01,50646E0
1.4ByoDyn6,93231E-11,38646E00,00000E08,47446E-1
1.4MathSBML6,93231E-11,38646E00,00000E08,47446E-1
1.4Oscill8 Core8,16333E-11,63267E0-1,50680E0
1.4SBToolbox26,93613E-11,38724E00,00000E08,47444E-1
1.4SBWOdeSolver6,98055E-11,39611E0-8,59667E-1
1.4copasi8,16335E-11,63267E01,00000E01,50681E0
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner6,93231E-11,38646E00,00000E08,47446E-1
1.4min 6,93231E-1 1,38646E0 0,00000E0 8,47444E-1
1.4max 8,16335E-1 1,63267E0 1,00000E0 1,50681E0
1.4mean 6,93613E-1 1,38724E0 0,00000E0 8,47446E-1
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML9,50051E-11,90010E01,00000E01,59606E0
1.6ByoDyn7,06335E-11,41267E00,00000E06,93830E-1
1.6MathSBML7,06336E-11,41267E00,00000E06,93830E-1
1.6Oscill8 Core9,50136E-11,90027E0-1,59620E0
1.6SBToolbox27,07003E-11,41402E00,00000E06,93647E-1
1.6SBWOdeSolver7,12286E-11,42457E0-7,03836E-1
1.6copasi9,50138E-11,90028E01,00000E01,59621E0
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner7,06335E-11,41267E00,00000E06,93830E-1
1.6min 7,06335E-1 1,41267E0 0,00000E0 6,93647E-1
1.6max 9,50138E-1 1,90028E0 1,00000E0 1,59621E0
1.6mean 7,07003E-1 1,41402E0 0,00000E0 6,93830E-1
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML1,07411E02,14821E01,00000E01,66912E0
1.8ByoDyn6,91910E-11,38382E00,00000E05,68060E-1
1.8MathSBML6,91911E-11,38382E00,00000E05,68060E-1
1.8Oscill8 Core1,07432E02,14865E0-1,66940E0
1.8SBToolbox26,92720E-11,38543E00,00000E05,67748E-1
1.8SBWOdeSolver6,98420E-11,39684E0-5,76253E-1
1.8copasi1,07433E02,14865E01,00000E01,66940E0
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner6,91910E-11,38382E00,00000E05,68060E-1
1.8min 6,91910E-1 1,38382E0 0,00000E0 5,67748E-1
1.8max 1,07433E0 2,14865E0 1,00000E0 1,66940E0
1.8mean 6,92720E-1 1,38543E0 0,00000E0 5,68060E-1
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML1,18748E02,37496E01,00000E01,72882E0
2.0ByoDyn6,59506E-11,31901E00,00000E04,65088E-1
2.0MathSBML6,59506E-11,31901E00,00000E04,65088E-1
2.0Oscill8 Core1,18799E02,37597E0-1,72933E0
2.0SBToolbox26,60378E-11,32078E00,00000E04,64674E-1
2.0SBWOdeSolver6,66177E-11,33235E0-4,71796E-1
2.0copasi1,18799E02,37598E01,00000E01,72933E0
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner6,59506E-11,31901E00,00000E04,65088E-1
2.0min 6,59506E-1 1,31901E0 0,00000E0 4,64674E-1
2.0max 1,18799E0 2,37598E0 1,00000E0 1,72933E0
2.0mean 6,60378E-1 1,32078E0 0,00000E0 4,65088E-1
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML1,29066E02,58133E01,00000E01,77824E0
2.2ByoDyn6,16114E-11,23223E00,00000E03,80782E-1
2.2MathSBML6,16115E-11,23223E00,00000E03,80782E-1
2.2Oscill8 Core1,29086E02,58172E0-1,77839E0
2.2SBToolbox26,16977E-11,23393E00,00000E03,80285E-1
2.2SBWOdeSolver6,22674E-11,24535E0-3,86274E-1
2.2copasi1,29086E02,58172E01,00000E01,77839E0
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner6,16114E-11,23223E00,00000E03,80782E-1
2.2min 6,16114E-1 1,23223E0 0,00000E0 3,80285E-1
2.2max 1,29086E0 2,58172E0 1,00000E0 1,77839E0
2.2mean 6,16977E-1 1,23393E0 0,00000E0 3,80782E-1
2.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
2.4BioUML1,38237E02,76475E01,00000E01,81804E0
2.4ByoDyn5,66783E-11,13357E00,00000E03,11758E-1
2.4MathSBML5,66783E-11,13357E00,00000E03,11758E-1
2.4Oscill8 Core1,38312E02,76623E0-1,81856E0
2.4SBToolbox25,67560E-11,13512E00,00000E03,11234E-1
2.4SBWOdeSolver5,73054E-11,14611E0-3,16255E-1
2.4copasi1,38312E02,76624E01,00000E01,81856E0
2.4edu.kgi.roadRunner5,66783E-11,13357E00,00000E03,11758E-1
2.4min 5,66783E-1 1,13357E0 0,00000E0 3,11234E-1
2.4max 1,38312E0 2,76624E0 1,00000E0 1,81856E0
2.4mean 5,67560E-1 1,13512E0 0,00000E0 3,11758E-1
2.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
2.6BioUML1,46451E02,92902E01,00000E01,85100E0
2.6ByoDyn5,15092E-11,03018E00,00000E02,55246E-1
2.6MathSBML5,15092E-11,03018E00,00000E02,55246E-1
2.6Oscill8 Core1,46523E02,93046E0-1,85145E0
2.6SBToolbox25,15746E-11,03145E00,00000E02,54716E-1
2.6SBWOdeSolver5,20962E-11,04192E0-2,58928E-1
2.6copasi1,46523E02,93046E01,00000E01,85145E0
2.6edu.kgi.roadRunner5,15092E-11,03018E00,00000E02,55246E-1
2.6min 5,15092E-1 1,03018E0 0,00000E0 2,54716E-1
2.6max 1,46523E0 2,93046E0 1,00000E0 1,85145E0
2.6mean 5,15746E-1 1,03145E0 0,00000E0 2,55246E-1
2.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
2.8BioUML1,53727E03,07455E01,00000E01,87806E0
2.8ByoDyn4,63517E-19,27035E-10,00000E02,08978E-1
2.8MathSBML4,63517E-19,27035E-10,00000E02,08978E-1
2.8Oscill8 Core1,53784E03,07568E0-1,87838E0
2.8SBToolbox24,64047E-19,28101E-10,00000E02,08435E-1
2.8SBWOdeSolver4,68926E-19,37852E-1-2,11992E-1
2.8copasi1,53784E03,07569E01,00000E01,87838E0
2.8edu.kgi.roadRunner4,63517E-19,27035E-10,00000E02,08978E-1
2.8min 4,63517E-1 9,27035E-1 0,00000E0 2,08435E-1
2.8max 1,53784E0 3,07569E0 1,00000E0 1,87838E0
2.8mean 4,64047E-1 9,28101E-1 0,00000E0 2,08978E-1
2.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
3.0BioUML1,60118E03,20236E01,00000E01,90016E0
3.0ByoDyn4,13715E-18,27430E-10,00000E01,71096E-1
3.0MathSBML4,13715E-18,27431E-10,00000E01,71096E-1
3.0Oscill8 Core1,60170E03,20340E0-1,90042E0
3.0SBToolbox24,14132E-18,28267E-10,00000E01,70533E-1
3.0SBWOdeSolver4,18637E-18,37274E-1-1,73565E-1
3.0copasi1,60170E03,20341E01,00000E01,90043E0
3.0edu.kgi.roadRunner4,13715E-18,27430E-10,00000E01,71096E-1
3.0min 4,13715E-1 8,27430E-1 0,00000E0 1,70533E-1
3.0max 1,60170E0 3,20341E0 1,00000E0 1,90043E0
3.0mean 4,14132E-1 8,28267E-1 0,00000E0 1,71096E-1
3.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
3.2BioUML1,65701E03,31402E01,00000E01,91820E0
3.2ByoDyn3,66738E-17,33475E-10,00000E01,40082E-1
3.2MathSBML3,66738E-17,33475E-10,00000E01,40082E-1
3.2Oscill8 Core1,65760E03,31519E0-1,91847E0
3.2SBToolbox23,67020E-17,34039E-10,00000E01,39538E-1
3.2SBWOdeSolver3,71172E-17,42343E-1-1,42103E-1
3.2copasi1,65760E03,31519E01,00000E01,91848E0
3.2edu.kgi.roadRunner3,66738E-17,33475E-10,00000E01,40082E-1
3.2min 3,66738E-1 7,33475E-1 0,00000E0 1,39538E-1
3.2max 1,65760E0 3,31519E0 1,00000E0 1,91848E0
3.2mean 3,67020E-1 7,34039E-1 0,00000E0 1,40082E-1
3.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
3.4BioUML1,70564E03,41127E01,00000E01,93297E0
3.4ByoDyn3,23197E-16,46395E-10,00000E01,14689E-1
3.4MathSBML3,23197E-16,46395E-10,00000E01,14689E-1
3.4Oscill8 Core1,70631E03,41263E0-1,93325E0
3.4SBToolbox23,23351E-16,46695E-10,00000E01,14201E-1
3.4SBWOdeSolver3,27158E-16,54317E-1-1,16344E-1
3.4copasi1,70632E03,41263E01,00000E01,93325E0
3.4edu.kgi.roadRunner3,23197E-16,46395E-10,00000E01,14689E-1
3.4min 3,23197E-1 6,46395E-1 0,00000E0 1,14201E-1
3.4max 1,70632E0 3,41263E0 1,00000E0 1,93325E0
3.4mean 3,23351E-1 6,46695E-1 0,00000E0 1,14689E-1
3.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
3.6BioUML1,74789E03,49578E01,00000E01,94507E0
3.6ByoDyn2,83392E-15,66783E-10,00000E09,38997E-2
3.6MathSBML2,83392E-15,66783E-10,00000E09,38997E-2
3.6Oscill8 Core1,74862E03,49724E0-1,94535E0
3.6SBToolbox22,83434E-15,66872E-10,00000E09,34608E-2
3.6SBWOdeSolver2,86906E-15,73811E-1-9,52543E-2
3.6copasi1,74862E03,49724E01,00000E01,94535E0
3.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,83392E-15,66783E-10,00000E09,38997E-2
3.6min 2,83392E-1 5,66783E-1 0,00000E0 9,34608E-2
3.6max 1,74862E0 3,49724E0 1,00000E0 1,94535E0
3.6mean 2,83434E-1 5,66872E-1 0,00000E0 9,38997E-2
3.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
3.8BioUML1,78450E03,56901E01,00000E01,95499E0
3.8ByoDyn2,47397E-14,94794E-10,00000E07,68786E-2
3.8MathSBML2,47397E-14,94794E-10,00000E07,68786E-2
3.8Oscill8 Core1,78524E03,57048E0-1,95526E0
3.8SBToolbox22,47354E-14,94710E-10,00000E07,64805E-2
3.8SBWOdeSolver2,50496E-15,00992E-1-7,79877E-2
3.8copasi1,78524E03,57048E01,00000E01,95526E0
3.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,47397E-14,94794E-10,00000E07,68786E-2
3.8min 2,47354E-1 4,94710E-1 0,00000E0 7,64805E-2
3.8max 1,78524E0 3,57048E0 1,00000E0 1,95526E0
3.8mean 2,47397E-1 4,94794E-1 0,00000E0 7,68786E-2
3.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
4.0BioUML1,81615E03,63231E01,00000E01,96314E0
4.0ByoDyn2,15140E-14,30280E-10,00000E06,29429E-2
4.0MathSBML2,15140E-14,30280E-10,00000E06,29428E-2
4.0Oscill8 Core1,81684E03,63368E0-1,96337E0
4.0SBToolbox22,15022E-14,30040E-10,00000E06,25720E-2
4.0SBWOdeSolver2,17859E-14,35718E-1-6,38509E-2
4.0copasi1,81684E03,63369E01,00000E01,96337E0
4.0edu.kgi.roadRunner2,15140E-14,30280E-10,00000E06,29429E-2
4.0min 2,15022E-1 4,30040E-1 0,00000E0 6,25720E-2
4.0max 1,81684E0 3,63369E0 1,00000E0 1,96337E0
4.0mean 2,15140E-1 4,30280E-1 0,00000E0 6,29429E-2
4.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
4.2BioUML1,84346E03,68692E01,00000E01,96983E0
4.2ByoDyn1,86449E-13,72897E-10,00000E05,15333E-2
4.2MathSBML1,86449E-13,72897E-10,00000E05,15332E-2
4.2Oscill8 Core1,84404E03,68809E0-1,97001E0
4.2SBToolbox21,86271E-13,72548E-10,00000E05,12003E-2
4.2SBWOdeSolver1,88823E-13,77646E-1-5,22767E-2
4.2copasi1,84405E03,68809E01,00000E01,97001E0
4.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,86449E-13,72897E-10,00000E05,15333E-2
4.2min 1,86271E-1 3,72548E-1 0,00000E0 5,12003E-2
4.2max 1,84405E0 3,68809E0 1,00000E0 1,97001E0
4.2mean 1,86449E-1 3,72897E-1 0,00000E0 5,15333E-2
4.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
4.4BioUML1,86699E03,73398E01,00000E01,97533E0
4.4ByoDyn1,61090E-13,22179E-10,00000E04,21919E-2
4.4MathSBML1,61090E-13,22179E-10,00000E04,21918E-2
4.4Oscill8 Core1,86740E03,73481E0-1,97545E0
4.4SBToolbox21,60878E-13,21752E-10,00000E04,19027E-2
4.4SBWOdeSolver1,63155E-13,26311E-1-4,28006E-2
4.4copasi1,86740E03,73481E01,00000E01,97545E0
4.4edu.kgi.roadRunner1,61090E-13,22179E-10,00000E04,21919E-2
4.4min 1,60878E-1 3,21752E-1 0,00000E0 4,19027E-2
4.4max 1,86740E0 3,73481E0 1,00000E0 1,97545E0
4.4mean 1,61090E-1 3,22179E-1 0,00000E0 4,21919E-2
4.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
4.6BioUML1,88725E03,77450E01,00000E01,97985E0
4.6ByoDyn1,38798E-12,77595E-10,00000E03,45438E-2
4.6MathSBML1,38798E-12,77595E-10,00000E03,45437E-2
4.6Oscill8 Core1,88742E03,77484E0-1,97990E0
4.6SBToolbox21,38563E-12,77126E-10,00000E03,42927E-2
4.6SBWOdeSolver1,40589E-12,81178E-1-3,50421E-2
4.6copasi1,88742E03,77484E01,00000E01,97990E0
4.6edu.kgi.roadRunner1,38798E-12,77595E-10,00000E03,45438E-2
4.6min 1,38563E-1 2,77126E-1 0,00000E0 3,42927E-2
4.6max 1,88742E0 3,77484E0 1,00000E0 1,97990E0
4.6mean 1,38798E-1 2,77595E-1 0,00000E0 3,45438E-2
4.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
4.8BioUML1,90439E03,80878E01,00000E01,98350E0
4.8ByoDyn1,19294E-12,38589E-10,00000E02,82820E-2
4.8MathSBML1,19294E-12,38589E-10,00000E02,82821E-2
4.8Oscill8 Core1,90453E03,80907E0-1,98354E0
4.8SBToolbox21,19047E-12,38088E-10,00000E02,80629E-2
4.8SBWOdeSolver1,20842E-12,41685E-1-2,86901E-2
4.8copasi1,90453E03,80907E01,00000E01,98354E0
4.8edu.kgi.roadRunner1,19294E-12,38589E-10,00000E02,82820E-2
4.8min 1,19047E-1 2,38088E-1 0,00000E0 2,80629E-2
4.8max 1,90453E0 3,80907E0 1,00000E0 1,98354E0
4.8mean 1,19294E-1 2,38589E-1 0,00000E0 2,82821E-2
4.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
5.0BioUML1,91879E03,83758E01,00000E01,98644E0
5.0ByoDyn1,02301E-12,04602E-10,00000E02,31554E-2
5.0MathSBML1,02301E-12,04602E-10,00000E02,31554E-2
5.0Oscill8 Core1,91914E03,83829E0-1,98652E0
5.0SBToolbox21,02035E-12,04070E-10,00000E02,29595E-2
5.0SBWOdeSolver1,03635E-12,07271E-1-2,34895E-2
5.0copasi1,91914E03,83829E01,00000E01,98652E0
5.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,02301E-12,04602E-10,00000E02,31554E-2
5.0min 1,02035E-1 2,04070E-1 0,00000E0 2,29595E-2
5.0max 1,91914E0 3,83829E0 1,00000E0 1,98652E0
5.0mean 1,02301E-1 2,04602E-1 0,00000E0 2,31554E-2
5.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
5.2BioUML1,93120E03,86241E01,00000E01,98887E0
5.2ByoDyn8,75486E-21,75097E-10,00000E01,89580E-2
5.2MathSBML8,75486E-21,75097E-10,00000E01,89580E-2
5.2Oscill8 Core1,93159E03,86319E0-1,98897E0
5.2SBToolbox28,72827E-21,74562E-10,00000E01,87863E-2
5.2SBWOdeSolver8,86957E-21,77391E-1-1,92315E-2
5.2copasi1,93159E03,86319E01,00000E01,98897E0
5.2edu.kgi.roadRunner8,75486E-21,75097E-10,00000E01,89580E-2
5.2min 8,72827E-2 1,74562E-1 0,00000E0 1,87863E-2
5.2max 1,93159E0 3,86319E0 1,00000E0 1,98897E0
5.2mean 8,75486E-2 1,75097E-1 0,00000E0 1,89580E-2
5.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
5.4BioUML1,94192E03,88385E01,00000E01,99091E0
5.4ByoDyn7,47830E-21,49566E-10,00000E01,55215E-2
5.4MathSBML7,47830E-21,49566E-10,00000E01,55215E-2
5.4Oscill8 Core1,94219E03,88437E0-1,99097E0
5.4SBToolbox27,45262E-21,49053E-10,00000E01,53747E-2
5.4SBWOdeSolver7,57670E-21,51534E-1-1,57455E-2
5.4copasi1,94219E03,88438E01,00000E01,99097E0
5.4edu.kgi.roadRunner7,47830E-21,49566E-10,00000E01,55215E-2
5.4min 7,45262E-2 1,49053E-1 0,00000E0 1,53747E-2
5.4max 1,94219E0 3,88438E0 1,00000E0 1,99097E0
5.4mean 7,47830E-2 1,49566E-1 0,00000E0 1,55215E-2
5.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
5.6BioUML1,95117E03,90235E01,00000E01,99260E0
5.6ByoDyn6,37688E-21,27538E-10,00000E01,27079E-2
5.6MathSBML6,37688E-21,27538E-10,00000E01,27079E-2
5.6Oscill8 Core1,95119E03,90238E0-1,99260E0
5.6SBToolbox26,35242E-21,27051E-10,00000E01,25831E-2
5.6SBWOdeSolver6,46110E-21,29222E-1-1,28913E-2
5.6copasi1,95119E03,90238E01,00000E01,99260E0
5.6edu.kgi.roadRunner6,37688E-21,27538E-10,00000E01,27079E-2
5.6min 6,35242E-2 1,27051E-1 0,00000E0 1,25831E-2
5.6max 1,95119E0 3,90238E0 1,00000E0 1,99260E0
5.6mean 6,37688E-2 1,27538E-1 0,00000E0 1,27079E-2
5.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
5.8BioUML1,95857E03,91714E01,00000E01,99389E0
5.8ByoDyn5,42903E-21,08581E-10,00000E01,04044E-2
5.8MathSBML5,42903E-21,08581E-10,00000E01,04044E-2
5.8Oscill8 Core1,95882E03,91765E0-1,99394E0
5.8SBToolbox25,40580E-21,08115E-10,00000E01,02967E-2
5.8SBWOdeSolver5,50099E-21,10020E-1-1,05545E-2
5.8copasi1,95883E03,91765E01,00000E01,99395E0
5.8edu.kgi.roadRunner5,42903E-21,08581E-10,00000E01,04044E-2
5.8min 5,40580E-2 1,08115E-1 0,00000E0 1,02967E-2
5.8max 1,95883E0 3,91765E0 1,00000E0 1,99395E0
5.8mean 5,42903E-2 1,08581E-1 0,00000E0 1,04044E-2
5.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
6.0BioUML1,96504E03,93009E01,00000E01,99499E0
6.0ByoDyn4,61528E-29,23057E-20,00000E08,51839E-3
6.0MathSBML4,61528E-29,23056E-20,00000E08,51838E-3
6.0Oscill8 Core1,96530E03,93059E0-1,99504E0
6.0SBToolbox24,59304E-29,18604E-20,00000E08,42414E-3
6.0SBWOdeSolver4,67666E-29,35331E-2-8,64128E-3
6.0copasi1,96530E03,93060E01,00000E01,99504E0
6.0edu.kgi.roadRunner4,61528E-29,23057E-20,00000E08,51839E-3
6.0min 4,59304E-2 9,18604E-2 0,00000E0 8,42414E-3
6.0max 1,96530E0 3,93060E0 1,00000E0 1,99504E0
6.0mean 4,61528E-2 9,23057E-2 0,00000E0 8,51839E-3
6.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
6.2BioUML1,97074E03,94148E01,00000E01,99593E0
6.2ByoDyn3,91816E-27,83632E-20,00000E06,97427E-3
6.2MathSBML3,91816E-27,83632E-20,00000E06,97426E-3
6.2Oscill8 Core1,97078E03,94155E0-1,99594E0
6.2SBToolbox23,89736E-27,79477E-20,00000E06,89330E-3
6.2SBWOdeSolver3,97042E-27,94084E-2-7,07488E-3
6.2copasi1,97078E03,94155E01,00000E01,99594E0
6.2edu.kgi.roadRunner3,91816E-27,83632E-20,00000E06,97427E-3
6.2min 3,89736E-2 7,79477E-2 0,00000E0 6,89330E-3
6.2max 1,97078E0 3,94155E0 1,00000E0 1,99594E0
6.2mean 3,91816E-2 7,83632E-2 0,00000E0 6,97427E-3
6.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
6.4BioUML1,97521E03,95042E01,00000E01,99664E0
6.4ByoDyn3,32212E-26,64424E-20,00000E05,71005E-3
6.4MathSBML3,32212E-26,64424E-20,00000E05,71005E-3
6.4Oscill8 Core1,97541E03,95082E0-1,99668E0
6.4SBToolbox23,30310E-26,60624E-20,00000E05,64149E-3
6.4SBWOdeSolver3,36655E-26,73311E-2-5,79242E-3
6.4copasi1,97541E03,95082E01,00000E01,99668E0
6.4edu.kgi.roadRunner3,32212E-26,64424E-20,00000E05,71005E-3
6.4min 3,30310E-2 6,60624E-2 0,00000E0 5,64149E-3
6.4max 1,97541E0 3,95082E0 1,00000E0 1,99668E0
6.4mean 3,32212E-2 6,64424E-2 0,00000E0 5,71005E-3
6.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
6.6BioUML1,97915E03,95831E01,00000E01,99725E0
6.6ByoDyn2,81342E-25,62684E-20,00000E04,67499E-3
6.6MathSBML2,81342E-25,62684E-20,00000E04,67499E-3
6.6Oscill8 Core1,97932E03,95864E0-1,99728E0
6.6SBToolbox22,79624E-25,59239E-20,00000E04,61696E-3
6.6SBWOdeSolver2,85115E-25,70230E-2-4,74243E-3
6.6copasi1,97932E03,95865E01,00000E01,99728E0
6.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,81342E-25,62684E-20,00000E04,67499E-3
6.6min 2,79624E-2 5,59239E-2 0,00000E0 4,61696E-3
6.6max 1,97932E0 3,95865E0 1,00000E0 1,99728E0
6.6mean 2,81342E-2 5,62684E-2 0,00000E0 4,67499E-3
6.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
6.8BioUML1,98255E03,96510E01,00000E01,99776E0
6.8ByoDyn2,37999E-24,75997E-20,00000E03,82756E-3
6.8MathSBML2,37998E-24,75997E-20,00000E03,82755E-3
6.8Oscill8 Core1,98262E03,96525E0-1,99777E0
6.8SBToolbox22,36433E-24,72860E-20,00000E03,77810E-3
6.8SBWOdeSolver2,41198E-24,82396E-2-3,88277E-3
6.8copasi1,98263E03,96525E01,00000E01,99777E0
6.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,37999E-24,75997E-20,00000E03,82756E-3
6.8min 2,36433E-2 4,72860E-2 0,00000E0 3,77810E-3
6.8max 1,98263E0 3,96525E0 1,00000E0 1,99777E0
6.8mean 2,37999E-2 4,75997E-2 0,00000E0 3,82756E-3
6.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
7.0BioUML1,98524E03,97048E01,00000E01,99815E0
7.0ByoDyn2,01124E-24,02248E-20,00000E03,13374E-3
7.0MathSBML2,01124E-24,02248E-20,00000E03,13373E-3
7.0Oscill8 Core1,98541E03,97082E0-1,99818E0
7.0SBToolbox21,99683E-23,99362E-20,00000E03,09099E-3
7.0SBWOdeSolver2,03834E-24,07668E-2-3,17895E-3
7.0copasi1,98541E03,97082E01,00000E01,99818E0
7.0edu.kgi.roadRunner2,01124E-24,02248E-20,00000E03,13374E-3
7.0min 1,99683E-2 3,99362E-2 0,00000E0 3,09099E-3
7.0max 1,98541E0 3,97082E0 1,00000E0 1,99818E0
7.0mean 2,01124E-2 4,02248E-2 0,00000E0 3,13374E-3
7.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
7.2BioUML1,98775E03,97549E01,00000E01,99851E0
7.2ByoDyn1,69798E-23,39596E-20,00000E02,56569E-3
7.2MathSBML1,69798E-23,39596E-20,00000E02,56569E-3
7.2Oscill8 Core1,98776E03,97551E0-1,99851E0
7.2SBToolbox21,68497E-23,36996E-20,00000E02,52929E-3
7.2SBWOdeSolver1,72090E-23,44181E-2-2,60270E-3
7.2copasi1,98776E03,97551E01,00000E01,99851E0
7.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,69798E-23,39596E-20,00000E02,56569E-3
7.2min 1,68497E-2 3,36996E-2 0,00000E0 2,52929E-3
7.2max 1,98776E0 3,97551E0 1,00000E0 1,99851E0
7.2mean 1,69798E-2 3,39596E-2 0,00000E0 2,56569E-3
7.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
7.4BioUML1,98959E03,97918E01,00000E01,99876E0
7.4ByoDyn1,43220E-22,86440E-20,00000E02,10061E-3
7.4MathSBML1,43220E-22,86440E-20,00000E02,10061E-3
7.4Oscill8 Core1,98973E03,97946E0-1,99878E0
7.4SBToolbox21,42063E-22,84126E-20,00000E02,06999E-3
7.4SBWOdeSolver1,45158E-22,90315E-2-2,13091E-3
7.4copasi1,98973E03,97946E01,00000E01,99878E0
7.4edu.kgi.roadRunner1,43220E-22,86440E-20,00000E02,10061E-3
7.4min 1,42063E-2 2,84126E-2 0,00000E0 2,06999E-3
7.4max 1,98973E0 3,97946E0 1,00000E0 1,99878E0
7.4mean 1,43220E-2 2,86440E-2 0,00000E0 2,10061E-3
7.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
7.6BioUML1,99136E03,98273E01,00000E01,99900E0
7.6ByoDyn1,20698E-22,41397E-20,00000E01,71983E-3
7.6MathSBML1,20698E-22,41397E-20,00000E01,71983E-3
7.6Oscill8 Core1,99139E03,98278E0-1,99900E0
7.6SBToolbox21,19673E-22,39346E-20,00000E01,69412E-3
7.6SBWOdeSolver1,22334E-22,44668E-2-1,74464E-3
7.6copasi1,99139E03,98279E01,00000E01,99900E0
7.6edu.kgi.roadRunner1,20698E-22,41397E-20,00000E01,71983E-3
7.6min 1,19673E-2 2,39346E-2 0,00000E0 1,69412E-3
7.6max 1,99139E0 3,98279E0 1,00000E0 1,99900E0
7.6mean 1,20698E-2 2,41397E-2 0,00000E0 1,71983E-3
7.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
7.8BioUML1,99267E03,98534E01,00000E01,99916E0
7.8ByoDyn1,01636E-22,03271E-20,00000E01,40808E-3
7.8MathSBML1,01636E-22,03271E-20,00000E01,40808E-3
7.8Oscill8 Core1,99279E03,98558E0-1,99918E0
7.8SBToolbox21,00729E-22,01447E-20,00000E01,38626E-3
7.8SBWOdeSolver1,03015E-22,06031E-2-1,42839E-3
7.8copasi1,99279E03,98558E01,00000E01,99918E0
7.8edu.kgi.roadRunner1,01636E-22,03271E-20,00000E01,40808E-3
7.8min 1,00729E-2 2,01447E-2 0,00000E0 1,38626E-3
7.8max 1,99279E0 3,98558E0 1,00000E0 1,99918E0
7.8mean 1,01636E-2 2,03271E-2 0,00000E0 1,40808E-3
7.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
8.0BioUML1,99395E03,98790E01,00000E01,99933E0
8.0ByoDyn8,55178E-31,71036E-20,00000E01,15284E-3
8.0MathSBML8,55178E-31,71036E-20,00000E01,15284E-3
8.0Oscill8 Core1,99396E03,98792E0-1,99933E0
8.0SBToolbox28,46990E-31,69398E-20,00000E01,13414E-3
8.0SBWOdeSolver8,66808E-31,73362E-2-1,16947E-3
8.0copasi1,99396E03,98792E01,00000E01,99933E0
8.0edu.kgi.roadRunner8,55178E-31,71036E-20,00000E01,15284E-3
8.0min 8,46990E-3 1,69398E-2 0,00000E0 1,13414E-3
8.0max 1,99396E0 3,98792E0 1,00000E0 1,99933E0
8.0mean 8,55178E-3 1,71036E-2 0,00000E0 1,15284E-3
8.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
8.2BioUML1,99485E03,98970E01,00000E01,99944E0
8.2ByoDyn7,19038E-31,43808E-20,00000E09,43864E-4
8.2MathSBML7,19038E-31,43808E-20,00000E09,43864E-4
8.2Oscill8 Core1,99495E03,98989E0-1,99945E0
8.2SBToolbox27,11794E-31,42357E-20,00000E09,28058E-4
8.2SBWOdeSolver7,28832E-31,45766E-2-9,57477E-4
8.2copasi1,99495E03,98989E01,00000E01,99945E0
8.2edu.kgi.roadRunner7,19038E-31,43808E-20,00000E09,43864E-4
8.2min 7,11794E-3 1,42357E-2 0,00000E0 9,28058E-4
8.2max 1,99495E0 3,98989E0 1,00000E0 1,99945E0
8.2mean 7,19038E-3 1,43808E-2 0,00000E0 9,43864E-4
8.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
8.4BioUML1,99574E03,99149E01,00000E01,99955E0
8.4ByoDyn6,04154E-31,20831E-20,00000E07,72771E-4
8.4MathSBML6,04154E-31,20831E-20,00000E07,72771E-4
8.4Oscill8 Core1,99577E03,99154E0-1,99955E0
8.4SBToolbox25,97813E-31,19562E-20,00000E07,59521E-4
8.4SBWOdeSolver6,12395E-31,22479E-2-7,83915E-4
8.4copasi1,99577E03,99155E01,00000E01,99955E0
8.4edu.kgi.roadRunner6,04154E-31,20831E-20,00000E07,72771E-4
8.4min 5,97813E-3 1,19562E-2 0,00000E0 7,59521E-4
8.4max 1,99577E0 3,99155E0 1,00000E0 1,99955E0
8.4mean 6,04154E-3 1,20831E-2 0,00000E0 7,72771E-4
8.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
8.6BioUML1,99639E03,99279E01,00000E01,99962E0
8.6ByoDyn5,07293E-31,01459E-20,00000E06,32691E-4
8.6MathSBML5,07293E-31,01459E-20,00000E06,32691E-4
8.6Oscill8 Core1,99647E03,99293E0-1,99963E0
8.6SBToolbox25,01764E-31,00356E-20,00000E06,21608E-4
8.6SBWOdeSolver5,14223E-31,02845E-2-6,41815E-4
8.6copasi1,99646E03,99293E01,00000E01,99963E0
8.6edu.kgi.roadRunner5,07293E-31,01459E-20,00000E06,32691E-4
8.6min 5,01764E-3 1,00356E-2 0,00000E0 6,21608E-4
8.6max 1,99647E0 3,99293E0 1,00000E0 1,99963E0
8.6mean 5,07293E-3 1,01459E-2 0,00000E0 6,32691E-4
8.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
8.8BioUML1,99699E03,99397E01,00000E01,99969E0
8.8ByoDyn4,25697E-38,51393E-30,00000E05,18004E-4
8.8MathSBML4,25697E-38,51393E-30,00000E05,18004E-4
8.8Oscill8 Core1,99705E03,99409E0-1,99970E0
8.8SBToolbox24,20837E-38,41674E-30,00000E05,08632E-4
8.8SBWOdeSolver4,31519E-38,63038E-3-5,25473E-4
8.8copasi1,99705E03,99409E01,00000E01,99970E0
8.8edu.kgi.roadRunner4,25697E-38,51393E-30,00000E05,18004E-4
8.8min 4,20837E-3 8,41674E-3 0,00000E0 5,08632E-4
8.8max 1,99705E0 3,99409E0 1,00000E0 1,99970E0
8.8mean 4,25697E-3 8,51393E-3 0,00000E0 5,18004E-4
8.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
9.0BioUML1,99750E03,99501E01,00000E01,99975E0
9.0ByoDyn3,57013E-37,14026E-30,00000E04,24106E-4
9.0MathSBML3,57013E-37,14026E-30,00000E04,24106E-4
9.0Oscill8 Core1,99753E03,99506E0-1,99975E0
9.0SBToolbox23,52658E-37,05308E-30,00000E04,16023E-4
9.0SBWOdeSolver3,61902E-37,23805E-3-4,30221E-4
9.0copasi1,99753E03,99506E01,00000E01,99975E0
9.0edu.kgi.roadRunner3,57013E-37,14026E-30,00000E04,24106E-4
9.0min 3,52658E-3 7,05308E-3 0,00000E0 4,16023E-4
9.0max 1,99753E0 3,99506E0 1,00000E0 1,99975E0
9.0mean 3,57013E-3 7,14026E-3 0,00000E0 4,24106E-4
9.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
9.2BioUML1,99788E03,99575E01,00000E01,99979E0
9.2ByoDyn2,99242E-35,98484E-30,00000E03,47228E-4
9.2MathSBML2,99242E-35,98485E-30,00000E03,47229E-4
9.2Oscill8 Core1,99794E03,99588E0-1,99980E0
9.2SBToolbox22,95460E-35,90921E-30,00000E03,40466E-4
9.2SBWOdeSolver3,03345E-36,06690E-3-3,52235E-4
9.2copasi1,99794E03,99588E01,00000E01,99980E0
9.2edu.kgi.roadRunner2,99242E-35,98484E-30,00000E03,47228E-4
9.2min 2,95460E-3 5,90921E-3 0,00000E0 3,40466E-4
9.2max 1,99794E0 3,99588E0 1,00000E0 1,99980E0
9.2mean 2,99242E-3 5,98485E-3 0,00000E0 3,47229E-4
9.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
9.4BioUML1,99825E03,99650E01,00000E01,99983E0
9.4ByoDyn2,50685E-35,01369E-30,00000E02,84287E-4
9.4MathSBML2,50685E-35,01369E-30,00000E02,84287E-4
9.4Oscill8 Core1,99828E03,99656E0-1,99983E0
9.4SBToolbox22,47388E-34,94767E-30,00000E02,78593E-4
9.4SBWOdeSolver2,54125E-35,08251E-3-2,88385E-4
9.4copasi1,99828E03,99656E01,00000E01,99983E0
9.4edu.kgi.roadRunner2,50685E-35,01369E-30,00000E02,84287E-4
9.4min 2,47388E-3 4,94767E-3 0,00000E0 2,78593E-4
9.4max 1,99828E0 3,99656E0 1,00000E0 1,99983E0
9.4mean 2,50685E-3 5,01369E-3 0,00000E0 2,84287E-4
9.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
9.6BioUML1,99854E03,99708E01,00000E01,99986E0
9.6ByoDyn2,09898E-34,19796E-30,00000E02,32754E-4
9.6MathSBML2,09898E-34,19796E-30,00000E02,32754E-4
9.6Oscill8 Core1,99856E03,99713E0-1,99986E0
9.6SBToolbox22,06956E-34,13903E-30,00000E02,27839E-4
9.6SBWOdeSolver2,12782E-34,25565E-3-2,36110E-4
9.6copasi1,99856E03,99713E01,00000E01,99986E0
9.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,09898E-34,19796E-30,00000E02,32754E-4
9.6min 2,06956E-3 4,13903E-3 0,00000E0 2,27839E-4
9.6max 1,99856E0 3,99713E0 1,00000E0 1,99986E0
9.6mean 2,09898E-3 4,19796E-3 0,00000E0 2,32754E-4
9.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
9.8BioUML1,99877E03,99754E01,00000E01,99989E0
9.8ByoDyn1,75661E-33,51323E-30,00000E01,90563E-4
9.8MathSBML1,75661E-33,51323E-30,00000E01,90563E-4
9.8Oscill8 Core1,99880E03,99760E0-1,99989E0
9.8SBToolbox21,73109E-33,46218E-30,00000E01,86443E-4
9.8SBWOdeSolver1,78078E-33,56155E-3-1,93310E-4
9.8copasi1,99880E03,99760E01,00000E01,99989E0
9.8edu.kgi.roadRunner1,75661E-33,51323E-30,00000E01,90563E-4
9.8min 1,73109E-3 3,46218E-3 0,00000E0 1,86443E-4
9.8max 1,99880E0 3,99760E0 1,00000E0 1,99989E0
9.8mean 1,75661E-3 3,51323E-3 0,00000E0 1,90563E-4
9.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00