Test: BIOMD0000000113.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000113.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000113.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000113.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL7007141507.JPG

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: vk  W_star  Y  Z 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  VCell  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  BioUML 
timeresult vk W_star Y Z
0.0BioUML1,13208E00,00000E01,60000E01,50000E-1
0.0ByoDyn1,13208E00,00000E01,60000E01,50000E-1
0.0MathSBML-0,00000E01,60000E01,50000E-1
0.0Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,60000E01,50000E-1
0.0SBWOdeSolver-0,00000E01,60000E01,50000E-1
0.0VCell-0,00000E01,60000E01,50000E-1
0.0copasi-1,00000E01,60000E01,50000E-1
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-0,00000E01,60000E01,50000E-1
0.0min 1,13208E0 0,00000E0 1,60000E0 1,50000E-1
0.0max 1,13208E0 1,00000E0 1,60000E0 1,50000E-1
0.0mean 1,13208E0 0,00000E0 1,60000E0 1,50000E-1
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML1,92296E02,80070E-21,75159E02,65940E-1
0.2ByoDyn1,92296E02,80070E-21,75159E02,65940E-1
0.2MathSBML-2,80070E-21,75159E02,65940E-1
0.2Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,75158E02,65940E-1
0.2SBWOdeSolver-2,80069E-21,75158E02,65940E-1
0.2VCell-2,80070E-21,75159E02,65940E-1
0.2copasi-8,12700E-11,75159E02,65940E-1
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,80070E-21,75159E02,65940E-1
0.2min 1,92296E0 0,00000E0 1,75158E0 2,65940E-1
0.2max 1,92296E0 8,12700E-1 1,75159E0 2,65940E-1
0.2mean 1,92296E0 2,80070E-2 1,75159E0 2,65940E-1
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML2,10709E04,06663E-21,90371E02,94403E-1
0.4ByoDyn2,10709E04,06663E-21,90371E02,94403E-1
0.4MathSBML-4,06663E-21,90371E02,94403E-1
0.4Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,90370E02,94404E-1
0.4SBWOdeSolver-4,06666E-21,90370E02,94404E-1
0.4VCell-4,06663E-21,90371E02,94403E-1
0.4copasi-7,05693E-11,90371E02,94403E-1
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,06663E-21,90371E02,94403E-1
0.4min 2,10709E0 0,00000E0 1,90370E0 2,94403E-1
0.4max 2,10709E0 7,05693E-1 1,90371E0 2,94404E-1
0.4mean 2,10709E0 4,06663E-2 1,90371E0 2,94403E-1
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML2,43808E06,72046E-21,95900E03,47069E-1
0.6ByoDyn2,43808E06,72046E-21,95900E03,47069E-1
0.6MathSBML-6,72046E-21,95900E03,47069E-1
0.6Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,95897E03,47087E-1
0.6SBWOdeSolver-6,72108E-21,95897E03,47087E-1
0.6VCell-6,72046E-21,95900E03,47069E-1
0.6copasi-6,48549E-11,95900E03,47071E-1
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,72046E-21,95900E03,47069E-1
0.6min 2,43808E0 0,00000E0 1,95897E0 3,47069E-1
0.6max 2,43808E0 6,48549E-1 1,95900E0 3,47087E-1
0.6mean 2,43808E0 6,72046E-2 1,95900E0 3,47069E-1
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML5,15183E04,65525E-17,01391E-18,67417E-1
0.8ByoDyn5,15183E04,65525E-17,01391E-18,67417E-1
0.8MathSBML-4,65526E-17,01392E-18,67415E-1
0.8Oscill8 Core-0,00000E07,01610E-18,67443E-1
0.8SBWOdeSolver-4,65412E-17,01607E-18,67453E-1
0.8VCell-4,65525E-17,01391E-18,67417E-1
0.8copasi-9,72350E-17,01402E-18,67377E-1
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,65525E-17,01391E-18,67417E-1
0.8min 5,15183E0 0,00000E0 7,01391E-1 8,67377E-1
0.8max 5,15183E0 9,72350E-1 7,01610E-1 8,67453E-1
0.8mean 5,15183E0 4,65525E-1 7,01392E-1 8,67417E-1
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML1,70591E05,02884E-11,27201E02,33123E-1
1.0ByoDyn1,70591E05,02884E-11,27201E02,33123E-1
1.0MathSBML-5,02884E-11,27201E02,33123E-1
1.0Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,27200E02,33141E-1
1.0SBWOdeSolver-5,02884E-11,27200E02,33139E-1
1.0VCell-5,02884E-11,27201E02,33123E-1
1.0copasi-8,72965E-11,27202E02,33123E-1
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,02884E-11,27201E02,33123E-1
1.0min 1,70591E0 0,00000E0 1,27200E0 2,33123E-1
1.0max 1,70591E0 8,72965E-1 1,27202E0 2,33141E-1
1.0mean 1,70591E0 5,02884E-1 1,27201E0 2,33123E-1
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML1,78694E03,55251E-11,52520E02,45283E-1
1.2ByoDyn1,78694E03,55251E-11,52520E02,45283E-1
1.2MathSBML-3,55251E-11,52520E02,45283E-1
1.2Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,52520E02,45283E-1
1.2SBWOdeSolver-3,55256E-11,52519E02,45283E-1
1.2VCell-3,55251E-11,52520E02,45283E-1
1.2copasi-7,09636E-11,52521E02,45283E-1
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,55251E-11,52520E02,45283E-1
1.2min 1,78694E0 0,00000E0 1,52519E0 2,45283E-1
1.2max 1,78694E0 7,09636E-1 1,52521E0 2,45283E-1
1.2mean 1,78694E0 3,55251E-1 1,52520E0 2,45283E-1
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML1,92050E02,37124E-11,73471E02,65563E-1
1.4ByoDyn1,92050E02,37124E-11,73471E02,65563E-1
1.4MathSBML-2,37124E-11,73471E02,65563E-1
1.4Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,73471E02,65564E-1
1.4SBWOdeSolver-2,37130E-11,73471E02,65564E-1
1.4VCell-2,37124E-11,73471E02,65563E-1
1.4copasi-5,77575E-11,73472E02,65564E-1
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,37124E-11,73471E02,65563E-1
1.4min 1,92050E0 0,00000E0 1,73471E0 2,65563E-1
1.4max 1,92050E0 5,77575E-1 1,73472E0 2,65564E-1
1.4mean 1,92050E0 2,37124E-1 1,73471E0 2,65563E-1
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML2,08971E01,57231E-11,89279E02,91692E-1
1.6ByoDyn2,08971E01,57231E-11,89279E02,91692E-1
1.6MathSBML-1,57231E-11,89279E02,91692E-1
1.6Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,89278E02,91695E-1
1.6SBWOdeSolver-1,57241E-11,89278E02,91695E-1
1.6VCell-1,57231E-11,89279E02,91692E-1
1.6copasi-4,78803E-11,89280E02,91693E-1
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,57231E-11,89279E02,91692E-1
1.6min 2,08971E0 0,00000E0 1,89278E0 2,91692E-1
1.6max 2,08971E0 4,78803E-1 1,89280E0 2,91695E-1
1.6mean 2,08971E0 1,57231E-1 1,89279E0 2,91692E-1
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML2,38880E01,29364E-11,96203E03,39103E-1
1.8ByoDyn2,38880E01,29364E-11,96203E03,39103E-1
1.8MathSBML-1,29364E-11,96203E03,39103E-1
1.8Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,96197E03,39134E-1
1.8SBWOdeSolver-1,29381E-11,96198E03,39128E-1
1.8VCell-1,29364E-11,96203E03,39103E-1
1.8copasi-4,25205E-11,96203E03,39107E-1
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,29364E-11,96203E03,39103E-1
1.8min 2,38880E0 0,00000E0 1,96197E0 3,39103E-1
1.8max 2,38880E0 4,25205E-1 1,96203E0 3,39134E-1
1.8mean 2,38880E0 1,29364E-1 1,96203E0 3,39103E-1
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML5,67587E04,65124E-16,77061E-19,90615E-1
2.0ByoDyn5,67587E04,65124E-16,77061E-19,90615E-1
2.0MathSBML-4,65126E-16,77062E-19,90609E-1
2.0Oscill8 Core-0,00000E06,77438E-19,90795E-1
2.0SBWOdeSolver-4,64842E-16,77422E-19,90912E-1
2.0VCell-4,65124E-16,77061E-19,90615E-1
2.0copasi-7,37555E-16,77074E-19,90516E-1
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,65124E-16,77061E-19,90615E-1
2.0min 5,67587E0 0,00000E0 6,77061E-1 9,90516E-1
2.0max 5,67587E0 7,37555E-1 6,77438E-1 9,90912E-1
2.0mean 5,67587E0 4,65124E-1 6,77062E-1 9,90615E-1
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML1,71871E05,64879E-11,24602E02,35037E-1
2.2ByoDyn1,71871E05,64879E-11,24602E02,35037E-1
2.2MathSBML-5,64878E-11,24602E02,35037E-1
2.2Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,24598E02,35092E-1
2.2SBWOdeSolver-5,64884E-11,24595E02,35095E-1
2.2VCell-5,64879E-11,24602E02,35037E-1
2.2copasi-8,12692E-11,24604E02,35034E-1
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,64879E-11,24602E02,35037E-1
2.2min 1,71871E0 0,00000E0 1,24595E0 2,35034E-1
2.2max 1,71871E0 8,12692E-1 1,24604E0 2,35095E-1
2.2mean 1,71871E0 5,64879E-1 1,24602E0 2,35037E-1
2.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
2.4BioUML1,77617E04,13897E-11,50460E02,43661E-1
2.4ByoDyn1,77617E04,13897E-11,50460E02,43661E-1
2.4MathSBML-4,13896E-11,50460E02,43661E-1
2.4Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,50459E02,43662E-1
2.4SBWOdeSolver-4,13914E-11,50458E02,43660E-1
2.4VCell-4,13897E-11,50460E02,43661E-1
2.4copasi-6,52320E-11,50462E02,43662E-1
2.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,13897E-11,50460E02,43661E-1
2.4min 1,77617E0 0,00000E0 1,50458E0 2,43660E-1
2.4max 1,77617E0 6,52320E-1 1,50462E0 2,43662E-1
2.4mean 1,77617E0 4,13897E-1 1,50460E0 2,43661E-1
2.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
2.6BioUML1,90766E02,90372E-11,71802E02,63600E-1
2.6ByoDyn1,90766E02,90372E-11,71802E02,63600E-1
2.6MathSBML-2,90372E-11,71802E02,63601E-1
2.6Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,71801E02,63602E-1
2.6SBWOdeSolver-2,90389E-11,71799E02,63600E-1
2.6VCell-2,90372E-11,71802E02,63600E-1
2.6copasi-5,20101E-11,71803E02,63602E-1
2.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,90372E-11,71802E02,63600E-1
2.6min 1,90766E0 0,00000E0 1,71799E0 2,63600E-1
2.6max 1,90766E0 5,20101E-1 1,71803E0 2,63602E-1
2.6mean 1,90766E0 2,90372E-1 1,71802E0 2,63600E-1
2.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
2.8BioUML2,07221E02,02327E-11,88142E02,88966E-1
2.8ByoDyn2,07221E02,02327E-11,88142E02,88966E-1
2.8MathSBML-2,02326E-11,88142E02,88966E-1
2.8Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,88140E02,88970E-1
2.8SBWOdeSolver-2,02344E-11,88139E02,88967E-1
2.8VCell-2,02327E-11,88142E02,88966E-1
2.8copasi-4,20461E-11,88142E02,88969E-1
2.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,02327E-11,88142E02,88966E-1
2.8min 2,07221E0 0,00000E0 1,88139E0 2,88966E-1
2.8max 2,07221E0 4,20461E-1 1,88142E0 2,88970E-1
2.8mean 2,07221E0 2,02327E-1 1,88142E0 2,88966E-1
2.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
3.0BioUML2,34696E01,62114E-11,96268E03,32373E-1
3.0ByoDyn2,34696E01,62114E-11,96268E03,32373E-1
3.0MathSBML-1,62114E-11,96268E03,32373E-1
3.0Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,96262E03,32404E-1
3.0SBWOdeSolver-1,62138E-11,96262E03,32396E-1
3.0VCell-1,62114E-11,96268E03,32373E-1
3.0copasi-3,64266E-11,96268E03,32379E-1
3.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,62114E-11,96268E03,32373E-1
3.0min 2,34696E0 0,00000E0 1,96262E0 3,32373E-1
3.0max 2,34696E0 3,64266E-1 1,96268E0 3,32404E-1
3.0mean 2,34696E0 1,62114E-1 1,96268E0 3,32373E-1
3.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
3.2BioUML6,19325E04,33317E-16,67564E-11,12142E0
3.2ByoDyn6,19325E04,33317E-16,67564E-11,12142E0
3.2MathSBML-4,33321E-16,67564E-11,12141E0
3.2Oscill8 Core-0,00000E06,68127E-11,12166E0
3.2SBWOdeSolver-4,32910E-16,68124E-11,12186E0
3.2VCell-4,33317E-16,67564E-11,12142E0
3.2copasi-6,20037E-16,67567E-11,12125E0
3.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,33317E-16,67564E-11,12142E0
3.2min 6,19325E0 0,00000E0 6,67564E-1 1,12125E0
3.2max 6,19325E0 6,20037E-1 6,68127E-1 1,12186E0
3.2mean 6,19325E0 4,33317E-1 6,67564E-1 1,12142E0
3.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
3.4BioUML1,74616E06,05189E-11,21833E02,39150E-1
3.4ByoDyn1,74616E06,05189E-11,21833E02,39150E-1
3.4MathSBML-6,05188E-11,21834E02,39150E-1
3.4Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,21825E02,39274E-1
3.4SBWOdeSolver-6,05187E-11,21821E02,39280E-1
3.4VCell-6,05189E-11,21833E02,39150E-1
3.4copasi-7,77376E-11,21837E02,39143E-1
3.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,05189E-11,21833E02,39150E-1
3.4min 1,74616E0 0,00000E0 1,21821E0 2,39143E-1
3.4max 1,74616E0 7,77376E-1 1,21837E0 2,39280E-1
3.4mean 1,74616E0 6,05189E-1 1,21833E0 2,39150E-1
3.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
3.6BioUML1,76559E04,52196E-11,48369E02,42068E-1
3.6ByoDyn1,76559E04,52196E-11,48369E02,42068E-1
3.6MathSBML-4,52195E-11,48369E02,42068E-1
3.6Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,48368E02,42070E-1
3.6SBWOdeSolver-4,52221E-11,48365E02,42068E-1
3.6VCell-4,52196E-11,48369E02,42068E-1
3.6copasi-6,18097E-11,48372E02,42070E-1
3.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,52196E-11,48369E02,42068E-1
3.6min 1,76559E0 0,00000E0 1,48365E0 2,42068E-1
3.6max 1,76559E0 6,18097E-1 1,48372E0 2,42070E-1
3.6mean 1,76559E0 4,52196E-1 1,48369E0 2,42068E-1
3.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
3.8BioUML1,89505E03,24762E-11,70093E02,61676E-1
3.8ByoDyn1,89505E03,24762E-11,70093E02,61676E-1
3.8MathSBML-3,24761E-11,70094E02,61676E-1
3.8Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,70092E02,61678E-1
3.8SBWOdeSolver-3,24786E-11,70090E02,61676E-1
3.8VCell-3,24762E-11,70093E02,61676E-1
3.8copasi-4,84813E-11,70096E02,61679E-1
3.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,24762E-11,70093E02,61676E-1
3.8min 1,89505E0 0,00000E0 1,70090E0 2,61676E-1
3.8max 1,89505E0 4,84813E-1 1,70096E0 2,61679E-1
3.8mean 1,89505E0 3,24762E-1 1,70093E0 2,61676E-1
3.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
4.0BioUML2,05537E02,31401E-11,86946E02,86348E-1
4.0ByoDyn2,05537E02,31401E-11,86946E02,86348E-1
4.0MathSBML-2,31400E-11,86946E02,86348E-1
4.0Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,86944E02,86352E-1
4.0SBWOdeSolver-2,31423E-11,86942E02,86346E-1
4.0VCell-2,31401E-11,86946E02,86348E-1
4.0copasi-3,83672E-11,86947E02,86352E-1
4.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,31401E-11,86946E02,86348E-1
4.0min 2,05537E0 0,00000E0 1,86942E0 2,86346E-1
4.0max 2,05537E0 3,83672E-1 1,86947E0 2,86352E-1
4.0mean 2,05537E0 2,31401E-1 1,86946E0 2,86348E-1
4.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
4.2BioUML2,31058E01,83205E-11,96132E03,26548E-1
4.2ByoDyn2,31058E01,83205E-11,96132E03,26548E-1
4.2MathSBML-1,83205E-11,96132E03,26549E-1
4.2Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,96126E03,26575E-1
4.2SBWOdeSolver-1,83232E-11,96125E03,26569E-1
4.2VCell-1,83205E-11,96132E03,26548E-1
4.2copasi-3,24607E-11,96132E03,26556E-1
4.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,83205E-11,96132E03,26548E-1
4.2min 2,31058E0 0,00000E0 1,96125E0 3,26548E-1
4.2max 2,31058E0 3,24607E-1 1,96132E0 3,26575E-1
4.2mean 2,31058E0 1,83205E-1 1,96132E0 3,26549E-1
4.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
4.4BioUML6,68950E03,81837E-16,77590E-11,25643E0
4.4ByoDyn6,68950E03,81837E-16,77590E-11,25643E0
4.4MathSBML-3,81844E-16,77587E-11,25642E0
4.4Oscill8 Core-0,00000E06,79962E-11,25492E0
4.4SBWOdeSolver-3,81439E-16,80001E-11,25506E0
4.4VCell-3,81837E-16,77590E-11,25643E0
4.4copasi-5,12275E-16,77542E-11,25621E0
4.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,81837E-16,77590E-11,25643E0
4.4min 6,68950E0 0,00000E0 6,77542E-1 1,25492E0
4.4max 6,68950E0 5,12275E-1 6,80001E-1 1,25643E0
4.4mean 6,68950E0 3,81837E-1 6,77590E-1 1,25642E0
4.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
4.6BioUML1,79779E06,34813E-11,18802E02,46919E-1
4.6ByoDyn1,79779E06,34813E-11,18802E02,46919E-1
4.6MathSBML-6,34811E-11,18803E02,46918E-1
4.6Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,18787E02,47151E-1
4.6SBWOdeSolver-6,34780E-11,18783E02,47162E-1
4.6VCell-6,34813E-11,18802E02,46919E-1
4.6copasi-7,55652E-11,18808E02,46901E-1
4.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,34813E-11,18802E02,46919E-1
4.6min 1,79779E0 0,00000E0 1,18783E0 2,46901E-1
4.6max 1,79779E0 7,55652E-1 1,18808E0 2,47162E-1
4.6mean 1,79779E0 6,34813E-1 1,18802E0 2,46919E-1
4.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
4.8BioUML1,75522E04,80985E-11,46246E02,40510E-1
4.8ByoDyn1,75522E04,80985E-11,46246E02,40510E-1
4.8MathSBML-4,80984E-11,46247E02,40510E-1
4.8Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,46245E02,40512E-1
4.8SBWOdeSolver-4,81005E-11,46243E02,40510E-1
4.8VCell-4,80985E-11,46246E02,40510E-1
4.8copasi-5,97446E-11,46250E02,40512E-1
4.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,80985E-11,46246E02,40510E-1
4.8min 1,75522E0 0,00000E0 1,46243E0 2,40510E-1
4.8max 1,75522E0 5,97446E-1 1,46250E0 2,40512E-1
4.8mean 1,75522E0 4,80985E-1 1,46246E0 2,40510E-1
4.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
5.0BioUML1,88267E03,50219E-11,68348E02,59788E-1
5.0ByoDyn1,88267E03,50219E-11,68348E02,59788E-1
5.0MathSBML-3,50217E-11,68348E02,59789E-1
5.0Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,68347E02,59790E-1
5.0SBWOdeSolver-3,50239E-11,68345E02,59788E-1
5.0VCell-3,50219E-11,68348E02,59788E-1
5.0copasi-4,62654E-11,68351E02,59792E-1
5.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,50219E-11,68348E02,59788E-1
5.0min 1,88267E0 0,00000E0 1,68345E0 2,59788E-1
5.0max 1,88267E0 4,62654E-1 1,68351E0 2,59792E-1
5.0mean 1,88267E0 3,50219E-1 1,68348E0 2,59788E-1
5.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
5.2BioUML2,03911E02,52562E-11,85695E02,83826E-1
5.2ByoDyn2,03911E02,52562E-11,85695E02,83826E-1
5.2MathSBML-2,52561E-11,85695E02,83826E-1
5.2Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,85693E02,83830E-1
5.2SBWOdeSolver-2,52582E-11,85691E02,83827E-1
5.2VCell-2,52562E-11,85695E02,83826E-1
5.2copasi-3,59655E-11,85697E02,83830E-1
5.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,52562E-11,85695E02,83826E-1
5.2min 2,03911E0 0,00000E0 1,85691E0 2,83826E-1
5.2max 2,03911E0 3,59655E-1 1,85697E0 2,83830E-1
5.2mean 2,03911E0 2,52562E-1 1,85695E0 2,83826E-1
5.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
5.4BioUML2,27829E01,98066E-11,95832E03,21398E-1
5.4ByoDyn2,27829E01,98066E-11,95832E03,21398E-1
5.4MathSBML-1,98065E-11,95832E03,21398E-1
5.4Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,95826E03,21419E-1
5.4SBWOdeSolver-1,98091E-11,95826E03,21413E-1
5.4VCell-1,98066E-11,95832E03,21398E-1
5.4copasi-2,97590E-11,95832E03,21407E-1
5.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,98066E-11,95832E03,21398E-1
5.4min 2,27829E0 0,00000E0 1,95826E0 3,21398E-1
5.4max 2,27829E0 2,97590E-1 1,95832E0 3,21419E-1
5.4mean 2,27829E0 1,98066E-1 1,95832E0 3,21398E-1
5.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
5.6BioUML6,92632E03,16734E-17,75083E-11,32448E0
5.6ByoDyn6,92632E03,16734E-17,75083E-11,32448E0
5.6MathSBML-3,16743E-17,75056E-11,32448E0
5.6Oscill8 Core-0,00000E07,95938E-11,30300E0
5.6SBWOdeSolver-3,16847E-17,96244E-11,30287E0
5.6VCell-3,16734E-17,75083E-11,32448E0
5.6copasi-4,08309E-17,74594E-11,32460E0
5.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,16734E-17,75083E-11,32448E0
5.6min 6,92632E0 0,00000E0 7,74594E-1 1,30287E0
5.6max 6,92632E0 4,08309E-1 7,96244E-1 1,32460E0
5.6mean 6,92632E0 3,16734E-1 7,75083E-1 1,32448E0
5.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
5.8BioUML1,88907E06,57521E-11,15350E02,60764E-1
5.8ByoDyn1,88907E06,57521E-11,15350E02,60764E-1
5.8MathSBML-6,57519E-11,15351E02,60762E-1
5.8Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,15325E02,61148E-1
5.8SBWOdeSolver-6,57454E-11,15321E02,61170E-1
5.8VCell-6,57521E-11,15350E02,60764E-1
5.8copasi-7,42450E-11,15358E02,60725E-1
5.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,57521E-11,15350E02,60764E-1
5.8min 1,88907E0 0,00000E0 1,15321E0 2,60725E-1
5.8max 1,88907E0 7,42450E-1 1,15358E0 2,61170E-1
5.8mean 1,88907E0 6,57521E-1 1,15350E0 2,60764E-1
5.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
6.0BioUML1,74512E05,04411E-11,44092E02,38993E-1
6.0ByoDyn1,74512E05,04411E-11,44092E02,38993E-1
6.0MathSBML-5,04409E-11,44093E02,38993E-1
6.0Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,44092E02,38996E-1
6.0SBWOdeSolver-5,04433E-11,44089E02,38994E-1
6.0VCell-5,04411E-11,44092E02,38993E-1
6.0copasi-5,86227E-11,44097E02,38996E-1
6.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,04411E-11,44092E02,38993E-1
6.0min 1,74512E0 0,00000E0 1,44089E0 2,38993E-1
6.0max 1,74512E0 5,86227E-1 1,44097E0 2,38996E-1
6.0mean 1,74512E0 5,04411E-1 1,44092E0 2,38993E-1
6.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
6.2BioUML1,87049E03,70617E-11,66566E02,57934E-1
6.2ByoDyn1,87049E03,70617E-11,66566E02,57934E-1
6.2MathSBML-3,70616E-11,66566E02,57935E-1
6.2Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,66565E02,57936E-1
6.2SBWOdeSolver-3,70638E-11,66563E02,57934E-1
6.2VCell-3,70617E-11,66566E02,57934E-1
6.2copasi-4,49649E-11,66570E02,57938E-1
6.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,70617E-11,66566E02,57934E-1
6.2min 1,87049E0 0,00000E0 1,66563E0 2,57934E-1
6.2max 1,87049E0 4,49649E-1 1,66570E0 2,57938E-1
6.2mean 1,87049E0 3,70617E-1 1,66566E0 2,57934E-1
6.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
6.4BioUML2,02337E02,69179E-11,84391E02,81390E-1
6.4ByoDyn2,02337E02,69179E-11,84391E02,81390E-1
6.4MathSBML-2,69178E-11,84391E02,81390E-1
6.4Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,84390E02,81393E-1
6.4SBWOdeSolver-2,69199E-11,84388E02,81390E-1
6.4VCell-2,69179E-11,84391E02,81390E-1
6.4copasi-3,44531E-11,84394E02,81395E-1
6.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,69179E-11,84391E02,81390E-1
6.4min 2,02337E0 0,00000E0 1,84388E0 2,81390E-1
6.4max 2,02337E0 3,44531E-1 1,84394E0 2,81395E-1
6.4mean 2,02337E0 2,69179E-1 1,84391E0 2,81390E-1
6.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
6.6BioUML2,24914E02,09278E-11,95393E03,16765E-1
6.6ByoDyn2,24914E02,09278E-11,95393E03,16765E-1
6.6MathSBML-2,09277E-11,95393E03,16766E-1
6.6Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,95389E03,16781E-1
6.6SBWOdeSolver-2,09301E-11,95388E03,16775E-1
6.6VCell-2,09278E-11,95393E03,16765E-1
6.6copasi-2,79349E-11,95393E03,16776E-1
6.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,09278E-11,95393E03,16765E-1
6.6min 2,24914E0 0,00000E0 1,95388E0 3,16765E-1
6.6max 2,24914E0 2,79349E-1 1,95393E0 3,16781E-1
6.6mean 2,24914E0 2,09278E-1 1,95393E0 3,16766E-1
6.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
6.8BioUML5,06428E02,57025E-11,39133E08,47679E-1
6.8ByoDyn5,06428E02,57025E-11,39133E08,47679E-1
6.8MathSBML-2,57031E-11,39121E08,47781E-1
6.8Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,35818E08,76778E-1
6.8SBWOdeSolver-2,58767E-11,35916E08,75919E-1
6.8VCell-2,57025E-11,39133E08,47679E-1
6.8copasi-3,21285E-11,38924E08,49543E-1
6.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,57025E-11,39133E08,47679E-1
6.8min 5,06428E0 0,00000E0 1,35818E0 8,47679E-1
6.8max 5,06428E0 3,21285E-1 1,39133E0 8,76778E-1
6.8mean 5,06428E0 2,57025E-1 1,39121E0 8,47781E-1
6.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
7.0BioUML2,04437E06,74622E-11,11221E02,84643E-1
7.0ByoDyn2,04437E06,74622E-11,11221E02,84643E-1
7.0MathSBML-6,74621E-11,11222E02,84638E-1
7.0Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,11186E02,85186E-1
7.0SBWOdeSolver-6,74514E-11,11181E02,85224E-1
7.0VCell-6,74622E-11,11221E02,84643E-1
7.0copasi-7,34220E-11,11233E02,84563E-1
7.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,74622E-11,11221E02,84643E-1
7.0min 2,04437E0 0,00000E0 1,11181E0 2,84563E-1
7.0max 2,04437E0 7,34220E-1 1,11233E0 2,85224E-1
7.0mean 2,04437E0 6,74622E-1 1,11221E0 2,84643E-1
7.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
7.2BioUML1,73537E05,24581E-11,41907E02,37531E-1
7.2ByoDyn1,73537E05,24581E-11,41907E02,37531E-1
7.2MathSBML-5,24579E-11,41907E02,37532E-1
7.2Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,41906E02,37534E-1
7.2SBWOdeSolver-5,24602E-11,41903E02,37532E-1
7.2VCell-5,24581E-11,41907E02,37531E-1
7.2copasi-5,81929E-11,41912E02,37535E-1
7.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,24581E-11,41907E02,37531E-1
7.2min 1,73537E0 0,00000E0 1,41903E0 2,37531E-1
7.2max 1,73537E0 5,81929E-1 1,41912E0 2,37535E-1
7.2mean 1,73537E0 5,24581E-1 1,41907E0 2,37532E-1
7.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
7.4BioUML1,85850E03,87949E-11,64748E02,56112E-1
7.4ByoDyn1,85850E03,87949E-11,64748E02,56112E-1
7.4MathSBML-3,87948E-11,64749E02,56113E-1
7.4Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,64748E02,56114E-1
7.4SBWOdeSolver-3,87968E-11,64746E02,56111E-1
7.4VCell-3,87949E-11,64748E02,56112E-1
7.4copasi-4,43373E-11,64753E02,56117E-1
7.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,87949E-11,64748E02,56112E-1
7.4min 1,85850E0 0,00000E0 1,64746E0 2,56111E-1
7.4max 1,85850E0 4,43373E-1 1,64753E0 2,56117E-1
7.4mean 1,85850E0 3,87949E-1 1,64748E0 2,56112E-1
7.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
7.6BioUML2,00812E02,83034E-11,83038E02,79031E-1
7.6ByoDyn2,00812E02,83034E-11,83038E02,79031E-1
7.6MathSBML-2,83033E-11,83038E02,79031E-1
7.6Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,83037E02,79033E-1
7.6SBWOdeSolver-2,83053E-11,83035E02,79031E-1
7.6VCell-2,83034E-11,83038E02,79031E-1
7.6copasi-3,35934E-11,83041E02,79037E-1
7.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,83034E-11,83038E02,79031E-1
7.6min 2,00812E0 0,00000E0 1,83035E0 2,79031E-1
7.6max 2,00812E0 3,35934E-1 1,83041E0 2,79037E-1
7.6mean 2,00812E0 2,83034E-1 1,83038E0 2,79031E-1
7.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
7.8BioUML2,22249E02,18287E-11,94835E03,12543E-1
7.8ByoDyn2,22249E02,18287E-11,94835E03,12543E-1
7.8MathSBML-2,18286E-11,94835E03,12544E-1
7.8Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,94832E03,12553E-1
7.8SBWOdeSolver-2,18304E-11,94831E03,12547E-1
7.8VCell-2,18287E-11,94835E03,12543E-1
7.8copasi-2,67527E-11,94836E03,12554E-1
7.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,18287E-11,94835E03,12543E-1
7.8min 2,22249E0 0,00000E0 1,94831E0 3,12543E-1
7.8max 2,22249E0 2,67527E-1 1,94836E0 3,12554E-1
7.8mean 2,22249E0 2,18287E-1 1,94835E0 3,12544E-1
7.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
8.0BioUML3,36743E02,34937E-11,77834E05,06151E-1
8.0ByoDyn3,36743E02,34937E-11,77834E05,06151E-1
8.0MathSBML-2,34939E-11,77831E05,06172E-1
8.0Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,77414E05,09837E-1
8.0SBWOdeSolver-2,35190E-11,77440E05,09615E-1
8.0VCell-2,34937E-11,77834E05,06151E-1
8.0copasi-2,79935E-11,77787E05,06539E-1
8.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,34937E-11,77834E05,06151E-1
8.0min 3,36743E0 0,00000E0 1,77414E0 5,06151E-1
8.0max 3,36743E0 2,79935E-1 1,77834E0 5,09837E-1
8.0mean 3,36743E0 2,34937E-1 1,77831E0 5,06172E-1
8.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
8.2BioUML2,29850E06,85990E-11,06037E03,24619E-1
8.2ByoDyn2,29850E06,85990E-11,06037E03,24619E-1
8.2MathSBML-6,85989E-11,06038E03,24611E-1
8.2Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,06003E03,25188E-1
8.2SBWOdeSolver-6,85865E-11,05993E03,25277E-1
8.2VCell-6,85990E-11,06037E03,24619E-1
8.2copasi-7,27720E-11,06055E03,24465E-1
8.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,85990E-11,06037E03,24619E-1
8.2min 2,29850E0 0,00000E0 1,05993E0 3,24465E-1
8.2max 2,29850E0 7,27720E-1 1,06055E0 3,25277E-1
8.2mean 2,29850E0 6,85990E-1 1,06037E0 3,24619E-1
8.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
8.4BioUML1,72612E05,42709E-11,39688E02,36146E-1
8.4ByoDyn1,72612E05,42709E-11,39688E02,36146E-1
8.4MathSBML-5,42707E-11,39688E02,36146E-1
8.4Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,39688E02,36149E-1
8.4SBWOdeSolver-5,42735E-11,39684E02,36147E-1
8.4VCell-5,42709E-11,39688E02,36146E-1
8.4copasi-5,82780E-11,39695E02,36150E-1
8.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,42709E-11,39688E02,36146E-1
8.4min 1,72612E0 0,00000E0 1,39684E0 2,36146E-1
8.4max 1,72612E0 5,82780E-1 1,39695E0 2,36150E-1
8.4mean 1,72612E0 5,42709E-1 1,39688E0 2,36146E-1
8.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
8.6BioUML1,84670E04,03372E-11,62896E02,54321E-1
8.6ByoDyn1,84670E04,03372E-11,62896E02,54321E-1
8.6MathSBML-4,03370E-11,62896E02,54321E-1
8.6Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,62896E02,54322E-1
8.6SBWOdeSolver-4,03395E-11,62892E02,54318E-1
8.6VCell-4,03372E-11,62896E02,54321E-1
8.6copasi-4,42116E-11,62901E02,54326E-1
8.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,03372E-11,62896E02,54321E-1
8.6min 1,84670E0 0,00000E0 1,62892E0 2,54318E-1
8.6max 1,84670E0 4,42116E-1 1,62901E0 2,54326E-1
8.6mean 1,84670E0 4,03372E-1 1,62896E0 2,54321E-1
8.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
8.8BioUML1,99329E02,95182E-11,81636E02,76742E-1
8.8ByoDyn1,99329E02,95182E-11,81636E02,76742E-1
8.8MathSBML-2,95181E-11,81636E02,76742E-1
8.8Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,81635E02,76744E-1
8.8SBWOdeSolver-2,95201E-11,81633E02,76740E-1
8.8VCell-2,95182E-11,81636E02,76742E-1
8.8copasi-3,32207E-11,81640E02,76749E-1
8.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,95182E-11,81636E02,76742E-1
8.8min 1,99329E0 0,00000E0 1,81633E0 2,76740E-1
8.8max 1,99329E0 3,32207E-1 1,81640E0 2,76749E-1
8.8mean 1,99329E0 2,95182E-1 1,81636E0 2,76742E-1
8.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
9.0BioUML2,19786E02,25970E-11,94172E03,08652E-1
9.0ByoDyn2,19786E02,25970E-11,94172E03,08652E-1
9.0MathSBML-2,25970E-11,94172E03,08652E-1
9.0Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,94171E03,08656E-1
9.0SBWOdeSolver-2,25985E-11,94169E03,08650E-1
9.0VCell-2,25970E-11,94172E03,08652E-1
9.0copasi-2,60482E-11,94174E03,08663E-1
9.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,25970E-11,94172E03,08652E-1
9.0min 2,19786E0 0,00000E0 1,94169E0 3,08650E-1
9.0max 2,19786E0 2,60482E-1 1,94174E0 3,08663E-1
9.0mean 2,19786E0 2,25970E-1 1,94172E0 3,08652E-1
9.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
9.2BioUML2,93045E02,26484E-11,87145E04,29192E-1
9.2ByoDyn2,93045E02,26484E-11,87145E04,29192E-1
9.2MathSBML-2,26485E-11,87144E04,29201E-1
9.2Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,87100E04,29556E-1
9.2SBWOdeSolver-2,26521E-11,87110E04,29469E-1
9.2VCell-2,26484E-11,87145E04,29192E-1
9.2copasi-2,57962E-11,87125E04,29353E-1
9.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,26484E-11,87145E04,29192E-1
9.2min 2,93045E0 0,00000E0 1,87100E0 4,29192E-1
9.2max 2,93045E0 2,57962E-1 1,87145E0 4,29556E-1
9.2mean 2,93045E0 2,26484E-1 1,87144E0 4,29201E-1
9.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
9.4BioUML2,68874E06,90366E-19,93901E-13,88293E-1
9.4ByoDyn2,68874E06,90366E-19,93901E-13,88293E-1
9.4MathSBML-6,90367E-19,93916E-13,88278E-1
9.4Oscill8 Core-0,00000E09,93798E-13,88526E-1
9.4SBWOdeSolver-6,90289E-19,93654E-13,88675E-1
9.4VCell-6,90366E-19,93901E-13,88293E-1
9.4copasi-7,19535E-19,94160E-13,88024E-1
9.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,90366E-19,93901E-13,88293E-1
9.4min 2,68874E0 0,00000E0 9,93654E-1 3,88024E-1
9.4max 2,68874E0 7,19535E-1 9,94160E-1 3,88675E-1
9.4mean 2,68874E0 6,90366E-1 9,93901E-1 3,88293E-1
9.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
9.6BioUML1,71762E05,59542E-11,37434E02,34874E-1
9.6ByoDyn1,71762E05,59542E-11,37434E02,34874E-1
9.6MathSBML-5,59539E-11,37435E02,34874E-1
9.6Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,37435E02,34875E-1
9.6SBWOdeSolver-5,59566E-11,37430E02,34873E-1
9.6VCell-5,59542E-11,37434E02,34874E-1
9.6copasi-5,87452E-11,37442E02,34878E-1
9.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,59542E-11,37434E02,34874E-1
9.6min 1,71762E0 0,00000E0 1,37430E0 2,34873E-1
9.6max 1,71762E0 5,87452E-1 1,37442E0 2,34878E-1
9.6mean 1,71762E0 5,59542E-1 1,37434E0 2,34874E-1
9.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00
9.8BioUML1,83508E04,17606E-11,61009E02,52557E-1
9.8ByoDyn1,83508E04,17606E-11,61009E02,52557E-1
9.8MathSBML-4,17604E-11,61009E02,52558E-1
9.8Oscill8 Core-0,00000E01,61009E02,52558E-1
9.8SBWOdeSolver-4,17626E-11,61006E02,52555E-1
9.8VCell-4,17606E-11,61009E02,52557E-1
9.8copasi-4,44604E-11,61015E02,52564E-1
9.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,17606E-11,61009E02,52557E-1
9.8min 1,83508E0 0,00000E0 1,61006E0 2,52555E-1
9.8max 1,83508E0 4,44604E-1 1,61015E0 2,52564E-1
9.8mean 1,83508E0 4,17606E-1 1,61009E0 2,52557E-1
9.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,00