Test BIOMD0000000103.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000103.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000103.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: DormandPrince
generated code	: BIOMD0000000103.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: -
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-14
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000103.gif

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: C9_starX C9X_C3_star AC9_starX C9 AC9 A C3 AC9X C3_starX C9_star AC9_starX_C3_star C9_starX_C3_star AC9X_C3_star C9X AC9_star X C3_star
Simulators: ByoDyn copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner Jarnac SBToolbox2 VCell Oscill8 Core SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

C9_starX

C9X_C3_star

AC9_starX

AC9

AC9X

C3_starX

C9_star

AC9_starX_C3_star

C9_starX_C3_star

AC9X_C3_star

C9X

AC9_star

C3_star

0.0

BioUML

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

ByoDyn

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

Jarnac

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

MathSBML

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

SBToolbox2

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

VCell

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

copasi

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

jsim

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

min

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

max

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

mean

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

0,00000E0

2,00000E1

2,00000E2

0,00000E0

4,00000E1

0,00000E0

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

4,73087E-9

2,21456E-7

3,74678E-11

1,96851E1

1,55892E-1

1,98429E1

1,99995E2

1,24947E-3

5,59227E-5

1,84218E-6

5,25919E-17

6,64069E-15

1,75397E-9

1,57764E-1

1,45895E-8

3,98409E1

5,01241E-3

0.2

ByoDyn

4,73087E-9

2,21456E-7

3,74678E-11

1,96851E1

1,55892E-1

1,98429E1

1,99995E2

1,24947E-3

5,59227E-5

1,84218E-6

5,25919E-17

6,64069E-15

1,75397E-9

1,57764E-1

1,45895E-8

3,98409E1

5,01241E-3

0.2

Jarnac

4,72996E-9

4,22106E-6

3,74607E-11

1,96851E1

1,55892E-1

1,98429E1

1,99995E2

1,24945E-3

5,45819E-5

1,84163E-6

4,10935E-15

1,27229E-13

1,89429E-7

1,57761E-1

1,45852E-8

3,98409E1

5,00957E-3

0.2

MathSBML

4,72903E-9

2,21311E-7

3,72807E-11

1,96851E1

1,55892E-1

1,98429E1

1,99995E2

1,24946E-3

5,59252E-5

1,84228E-6

6,49005E-17

6,90656E-15

1,74481E-9

1,57764E-1

1,45807E-8

3,98409E1

5,01241E-3

0.2

Oscill8 Core

4,73903E-9

2,21784E-7

3,76871E-11

1,96851E1

1,55892E-1

1,98429E1

1,99995E2

1,24949E-3

5,59349E-5

1,84255E-6

5,31265E-17

6,66949E-15

1,75881E-9

1,57764E-1

1,46106E-8

3,98409E1

5,01243E-3

0.2

SBToolbox2

4,96705E-9

2,18479E-7

4,10664E-11

1,96853E1

1,55898E-1

1,98431E1

1,99990E2

1,24879E-3

5,62210E-5

1,85247E-6

5,26474E-17

6,36515E-15

1,71618E-9

1,57764E-1

1,43870E-8

3,98412E1

5,01145E-3

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

4,73164E-9

2,21493E-7

3,74798E-11

1,96851E1

1,55892E-1

1,98429E1

1,99995E2

1,24953E-3

5,59262E-5

1,84229E-6

5,26376E-17

6,64452E-15

1,75454E-9

1,57764E-1

1,45919E-8

3,98409E1

5,01246E-3

0.2

VCell

4,74391E-9

2,21834E-7

3,76240E-11

1,96851E1

1,55889E-1

1,98429E1

1,99995E2

1,25046E-3

5,59819E-5

1,84412E-6

5,29189E-17

6,67131E-15

1,75907E-9

1,57762E-1

1,46141E-8

3,98409E1

5,01321E-3

0.2

copasi

4,73087E-9

2,21456E-7

3,74664E-11

1,96851E1

1,55892E-1

1,98429E1

1,99995E2

1,24947E-3

5,59227E-5

1,84218E-6

5,37038E-17

6,65772E-15

1,75387E-9

1,57764E-1

1,45895E-8

3,98409E1

5,01241E-3

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,22118E-9

1,90419E-7

1,67198E-12

1,98331E1

7,85520E-3

1,99959E1

1,99996E2

6,29590E-5

4,77260E-5

1,58400E-6

2,00290E-18

5,05678E-15

7,54262E-11

1,58951E-1

6,27397E-10

3,98409E1

3,99024E-3

0.2

jsim

4,73087E-9

2,21456E-7

3,74678E-11

1,96851E1

1,55892E-1

1,98429E1

1,99995E2

1,24947E-3

5,59227E-5

1,84218E-6

5,25919E-17

6,64069E-15

1,75397E-9

1,57764E-1

1,45895E-8

3,98409E1

5,01241E-3

0.2

min

4,22118E-9

1,90419E-7

1,67198E-12

1,96851E1

7,85520E-3

1,98429E1

1,99990E2

6,29590E-5

4,77260E-5

1,58400E-6

2,00290E-18

5,05678E-15

7,54262E-11

1,57761E-1

6,27397E-10

3,98409E1

3,99024E-3

0.2

max

4,96705E-9

4,22106E-6

4,10664E-11

1,98331E1

1,55898E-1

1,99959E1

1,99996E2

1,25046E-3

5,62210E-5

1,85247E-6

4,10935E-15

1,27229E-13

1,89429E-7

1,58951E-1

1,46141E-8

3,98412E1

5,01321E-3

0.2

mean

4,73087E-9

2,21456E-7

3,74678E-11

1,96851E1

1,55892E-1

1,98429E1

1,99995E2

1,24947E-3

5,59239E-5

1,84223E-6

5,27831E-17

6,65112E-15

1,75397E-9

1,57764E-1

1,45895E-8

3,98409E1

5,01241E-3

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

4,12994E-8

1,99095E-6

6,47572E-10

1,93801E1

3,03836E-1

1,96913E1

1,99988E2

4,87953E-3

2,53861E-4

8,26610E-6

4,14264E-15

2,64214E-13

3,12203E-8

3,11196E-1

1,29607E-7

3,96837E1

1,19442E-2

0.4

ByoDyn

4,12994E-8

1,99095E-6

6,47572E-10

1,93801E1

3,03836E-1

1,96913E1

1,99988E2

4,87953E-3

2,53861E-4

8,26610E-6

4,14264E-15

2,64214E-13

3,12203E-8

3,11196E-1

1,29607E-7

3,96837E1

1,19442E-2

0.4

Jarnac

4,12679E-8

3,62899E-5

6,47079E-10

1,93801E1

3,03836E-1

1,96913E1

1,99988E2

4,87913E-3

2,42206E-4

8,25655E-6

3,06501E-13

4,86141E-12

3,19628E-6

3,11171E-1

1,29457E-7

3,96837E1

1,19184E-2

0.4

MathSBML

4,12985E-8

1,99085E-6

6,46973E-10

1,93801E1

3,03836E-1

1,96913E1

1,99988E2

4,87952E-3

2,53864E-4

8,26619E-6

4,23997E-15

2,65101E-13

3,11851E-8

3,11196E-1

1,29603E-7

3,96837E1

1,19442E-2

0.4

Oscill8 Core

4,13122E-8

1,99144E-6

6,48096E-10

1,93801E1

3,03836E-1

1,96913E1

1,99988E2

4,87960E-3

2,53878E-4

8,26661E-6

4,14758E-15

2,64375E-13

3,12322E-8

3,11196E-1

1,29638E-7

3,96837E1

1,19443E-2

0.4

SBToolbox2

4,21005E-8

1,97472E-6

6,67436E-10

1,93796E1

3,03841E-1

1,96913E1

1,99990E2

4,87799E-3

2,54590E-4

8,29213E-6

3,92439E-15

2,52070E-13

3,06221E-8

3,11197E-1

1,28534E-7

3,96833E1

1,19414E-2

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

4,13029E-8

1,99113E-6

6,47676E-10

1,93801E1

3,03836E-1

1,96913E1

1,99988E2

4,87964E-3

2,53870E-4

8,26637E-6

4,14441E-15

2,64292E-13

3,12255E-8

3,11196E-1

1,29618E-7

3,96837E1

1,19443E-2

0.4

VCell

4,13299E-8

1,99169E-6

6,48172E-10

1,93801E1

3,03833E-1

1,96913E1

1,99988E2

4,88046E-3

2,53938E-4

8,26860E-6

4,14782E-15

2,64495E-13

3,12387E-8

3,11195E-1

1,29654E-7

3,96837E1

1,19449E-2

0.4

copasi

4,12994E-8

1,99095E-6

6,47574E-10

1,93801E1

3,03836E-1

1,96913E1

1,99988E2

4,87953E-3

2,53861E-4

8,26610E-6

4,14863E-15

2,64230E-13

3,12205E-8

3,11196E-1

1,29607E-7

3,96837E1

1,19442E-2

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,34085E-8

1,51067E-6

2,62079E-11

1,96685E1

1,54271E-2

1,99919E1

1,99992E2

2,47756E-4

1,89796E-4

6,27205E-6

1,25346E-16

1,59794E-13

1,18516E-9

3,15829E-1

4,92003E-9

3,96837E1

7,95894E-3

0.4

jsim

4,12994E-8

1,99095E-6

6,47572E-10

1,93801E1

3,03836E-1

1,96913E1

1,99988E2

4,87953E-3

2,53861E-4

8,26610E-6

4,14264E-15

2,64214E-13

3,12203E-8

3,11196E-1

1,29607E-7

3,96837E1

1,19442E-2

0.4

min

3,34085E-8

1,51067E-6

2,62079E-11

1,93796E1

1,54271E-2

1,96913E1

1,99988E2

2,47756E-4

1,89796E-4

6,27205E-6

1,25346E-16

1,59794E-13

1,18516E-9

3,11171E-1

4,92003E-9

3,96833E1

7,95894E-3

0.4

max

4,21005E-8

3,62899E-5

6,67436E-10

1,96685E1

3,03841E-1

1,99919E1

1,99992E2

4,88046E-3

2,54590E-4

8,29213E-6

3,06501E-13

4,86141E-12

3,19628E-6

3,15829E-1

1,29654E-7

3,96837E1

1,19449E-2

0.4

mean

4,12994E-8

1,99095E-6

6,47573E-10

1,93801E1

3,03836E-1

1,96913E1

1,99988E2

4,87953E-3

2,53863E-4

8,26615E-6

4,14600E-15

2,64261E-13

3,12204E-8

3,11196E-1

1,29607E-7

3,96837E1

1,19442E-2

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

1,50213E-7

7,40796E-6

3,49711E-9

1,90845E1

4,44216E-1

1,95451E1

1,99979E2

1,07209E-2

6,35793E-4

2,04679E-5

5,62504E-14

2,41633E-12

1,72485E-7

4,60497E-1

4,76485E-7

3,95281E1

2,06440E-2

0.6

ByoDyn

1,50213E-7

7,40796E-6

3,49711E-9

1,90845E1

4,44216E-1

1,95451E1

1,99979E2

1,07209E-2

6,35793E-4

2,04679E-5

5,62504E-14

2,41633E-12

1,72485E-7

4,60497E-1

4,76485E-7

3,95281E1

2,06440E-2

0.6

Jarnac

1,49956E-7

1,29441E-4

3,49115E-9

1,90845E1

4,44215E-1

1,95450E1

1,99979E2

1,07186E-2

5,93539E-4

2,04159E-5

3,96659E-12

4,27662E-11

1,68464E-5

4,60401E-1

4,75273E-7

3,95281E1

2,05475E-2

0.6

MathSBML

1,50214E-7

7,40800E-6

3,49658E-9

1,90845E1

4,44216E-1

1,95451E1

1,99979E2

1,07209E-2

6,35795E-4

2,04680E-5

5,67012E-14

2,42071E-12

1,72447E-7

4,60497E-1

4,76491E-7

3,95281E1

2,06440E-2

0.6

Oscill8 Core

1,50232E-7

7,40874E-6

3,49813E-9

1,90845E1

4,44215E-1

1,95451E1

1,99979E2

1,07210E-2

6,35816E-4

2,04686E-5

5,62781E-14

2,41704E-12

1,72513E-7

4,60497E-1

4,76533E-7

3,95281E1

2,06441E-2

0.6

SBToolbox2

1,52403E-7

7,39615E-6

3,58676E-9

1,90848E1

4,44229E-1

1,95454E1

1,99980E2

1,07174E-2

6,37332E-4

2,05201E-5

5,65557E-14

2,40493E-12

1,72001E-7

4,60498E-1

4,75579E-7

3,95284E1

2,06385E-2

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,50221E-7

7,40840E-6

3,49748E-9

1,90845E1

4,44215E-1

1,95451E1

1,99979E2

1,07210E-2

6,35809E-4

2,04684E-5

5,62665E-14

2,41682E-12

1,72504E-7

4,60497E-1

4,76512E-7

3,95281E1

2,06441E-2

0.6

VCell

1,50265E-7

7,40917E-6

3,49850E-9

1,90845E1

4,44213E-1

1,95451E1

1,99979E2

1,07217E-2

6,35887E-4

2,04709E-5

5,62810E-14

2,41753E-12

1,72528E-7

4,60496E-1

4,76560E-7

3,95281E1

2,06446E-2

0.6

copasi

1,50213E-7

7,40796E-6

3,49712E-9

1,90845E1

4,44216E-1

1,95451E1

1,99979E2

1,07209E-2

6,35793E-4

2,04679E-5

5,62622E-14

2,41635E-12

1,72485E-7

4,60497E-1

4,76485E-7

3,95281E1

2,06440E-2

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,11546E-7

5,05563E-6

1,29981E-10

1,95060E1

2,27250E-2

1,99881E1

1,99988E2

5,48455E-4

4,24521E-4

1,39685E-5

1,39597E-15

1,19809E-12

5,89182E-9

4,70672E-1

1,62761E-8

3,95283E1

1,19032E-2

0.6

jsim

1,50213E-7

7,40796E-6

3,49711E-9

1,90845E1

4,44216E-1

1,95451E1

1,99979E2

1,07209E-2

6,35793E-4

2,04679E-5

5,62504E-14

2,41633E-12

1,72485E-7

4,60497E-1

4,76485E-7

3,95281E1

2,06440E-2

0.6

min

1,11546E-7

5,05563E-6

1,29981E-10

1,90845E1

2,27250E-2

1,95450E1

1,99979E2

5,48455E-4

4,24521E-4

1,39685E-5

1,39597E-15

1,19809E-12

5,89182E-9

4,60401E-1

1,62761E-8

3,95281E1

1,19032E-2

0.6

max

1,52403E-7

1,29441E-4

3,58676E-9

1,95060E1

4,44229E-1

1,99881E1

1,99988E2

1,07217E-2

6,37332E-4

2,05201E-5

3,96659E-12

4,27662E-11

1,68464E-5

4,70672E-1

4,76560E-7

3,95284E1

2,06446E-2

0.6

mean

1,50214E-7

7,40798E-6

3,49712E-9

1,90845E1

4,44215E-1

1,95451E1

1,99979E2

1,07209E-2

6,35794E-4

2,04679E-5

5,62723E-14

2,41658E-12

1,72485E-7

4,60497E-1

4,76485E-7

3,95281E1

2,06440E-2

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

3,79894E-7

1,90770E-5

1,16720E-8

1,87981E1

5,77395E-1

1,94040E1

1,99968E2

1,86145E-2

1,23957E-3

3,94614E-5

3,67459E-13

1,19612E-11

5,86213E-7

6,05857E-1

1,21232E-6

3,93743E1

3,09691E-2

0.8

ByoDyn

3,79894E-7

1,90770E-5

1,16720E-8

1,87981E1

5,77395E-1

1,94040E1

1,99968E2

1,86145E-2

1,23957E-3

3,94614E-5

3,67459E-13

1,19612E-11

5,86213E-7

6,05857E-1

1,21232E-6

3,93743E1

3,09691E-2

0.8

Jarnac

3,78747E-7

3,20129E-4

1,16367E-8

1,87980E1

5,77392E-1

1,94039E1

1,99968E2

1,86069E-2

1,13297E-3

3,92865E-5

2,48100E-11

2,03862E-10

5,48726E-5

6,05609E-1

1,20694E-6

3,93743E1

3,07203E-2

0.8

MathSBML

3,79895E-7

1,90770E-5

1,16709E-8

1,87981E1

5,77395E-1

1,94040E1

1,99968E2

1,86145E-2

1,23957E-3

3,94615E-5

3,68017E-13

1,19641E-11

5,86143E-7

6,05857E-1

1,21233E-6

3,93743E1

3,09691E-2

0.8

Oscill8 Core

3,79923E-7

1,90782E-5

1,16738E-8

1,87981E1

5,77394E-1

1,94040E1

1,99968E2

1,86146E-2

1,23960E-3

3,94623E-5

3,67568E-13

1,19634E-11

5,86273E-7

6,05856E-1

1,21239E-6

3,93743E1

3,09692E-2

0.8

SBToolbox2

3,83353E-7

1,90416E-5

1,18341E-8

1,87981E1

5,77411E-1

1,94036E1

1,99970E2

1,86097E-2

1,24151E-3

3,95298E-5

3,64491E-13

1,18527E-11

5,83621E-7

6,05865E-1

1,20989E-6

3,93746E1

3,09627E-2

0.8

SBWOdeSolver

3,79910E-7

1,90778E-5

1,16729E-8

1,87981E1

5,77394E-1

1,94040E1

1,99968E2

1,86147E-2

1,23959E-3

3,94621E-5

3,67538E-13

1,19630E-11

5,86261E-7

6,05856E-1

1,21237E-6

3,93743E1

3,09692E-2

0.8

VCell

3,79971E-7

1,90787E-5

1,16745E-8

1,87981E1

5,77392E-1

1,94040E1

1,99968E2

1,86153E-2

1,23968E-3

3,94649E-5

3,67572E-13

1,19646E-11

5,86296E-7

6,05855E-1

1,21243E-6

3,93743E1

3,09697E-2

0.8

copasi

3,79894E-7

1,90770E-5

1,16720E-8

1,87981E1

5,77395E-1

1,94040E1

1,99968E2

1,86145E-2

1,23957E-3

3,94614E-5

3,67498E-13

1,19612E-11

5,86214E-7

6,05857E-1

1,21232E-6

3,93743E1

3,09691E-2

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,61567E-7

1,18819E-5

4,02457E-10

1,93457E1

2,97577E-2

1,99845E1

1,99983E2

9,59361E-4

7,50182E-4

2,45783E-5

7,66793E-15

4,98414E-12

1,82847E-8

6,23520E-1

3,78141E-8

3,93748E1

1,58204E-2

0.8

jsim

3,79894E-7

1,90770E-5

1,16720E-8

1,87981E1

5,77395E-1

1,94040E1

1,99968E2

1,86145E-2

1,23957E-3

3,94614E-5

3,67459E-13

1,19612E-11

5,86213E-7

6,05857E-1

1,21232E-6

3,93743E1

3,09691E-2

0.8

min

2,61567E-7

1,18819E-5

4,02457E-10

1,87980E1

2,97577E-2

1,94036E1

1,99968E2

9,59361E-4

7,50182E-4

2,45783E-5

7,66793E-15

4,98414E-12

1,82847E-8

6,05609E-1

3,78141E-8

3,93743E1

1,58204E-2

0.8

max

3,83353E-7

3,20129E-4

1,18341E-8

1,93457E1

5,77411E-1

1,99845E1

1,99983E2

1,86153E-2

1,24151E-3

3,95298E-5

2,48100E-11

2,03862E-10

5,48726E-5

6,23520E-1

1,21243E-6

3,93748E1

3,09697E-2

0.8

mean

3,79894E-7

1,90770E-5

1,16720E-8

1,87981E1

5,77395E-1

1,94040E1

1,99968E2

1,86145E-2

1,23957E-3

3,94615E-5

3,67518E-13

1,19621E-11

5,86214E-7

6,05857E-1

1,21232E-6

3,93743E1

3,09691E-2

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

7,85183E-7

4,00135E-5

2,98452E-8

1,85203E1

7,03719E-1

1,92679E1

1,99955E2

2,84111E-2

2,09919E-3

6,60980E-5

1,59737E-12

4,20299E-11

1,52122E-6

7,47452E-1

2,51215E-6

3,92220E1

4,27851E-2

1.0

ByoDyn

7,85183E-7

4,00135E-5

2,98452E-8

1,85203E1

7,03719E-1

1,92679E1

1,99955E2

2,84111E-2

2,09919E-3

6,60980E-5

1,59737E-12

4,20299E-11

1,52122E-6

7,47452E-1

2,51215E-6

3,92220E1

4,27851E-2

1.0

Jarnac

7,81499E-7

6,45789E-4

2,97052E-8

1,85201E1

7,03711E-1

1,92678E1

1,99955E2

2,83914E-2

1,87931E-3

6,56486E-5

1,03610E-10

6,90366E-10

1,36942E-4

7,46934E-1

2,49507E-6

3,92220E1

4,22637E-2

1.0

MathSBML

7,85148E-7

4,00111E-5

2,98237E-8

1,85203E1

7,03719E-1

1,92679E1

1,99955E2

2,84110E-2

2,09922E-3

6,60994E-5

1,58578E-12

4,18489E-11

1,51995E-6

7,47452E-1

2,51213E-6

3,92220E1

4,27850E-2

1.0

Oscill8 Core

7,85223E-7

4,00153E-5

2,98482E-8

1,85203E1

7,03718E-1

1,92679E1

1,99955E2

2,84113E-2

2,09922E-3

6,60991E-5

1,59771E-12

4,20359E-11

1,52133E-6

7,47451E-1

2,51225E-6

3,92220E1

4,27852E-2

1.0

SBToolbox2

7,91039E-7

3,99815E-5

3,02067E-8

1,85204E1

7,03735E-1

1,92677E1

1,99960E2

2,84038E-2

2,10192E-3

6,61922E-5

1,60258E-12

4,19586E-11

1,51873E-6

7,47461E-1

2,50964E-6

3,92218E1

4,27756E-2

1.0

SBWOdeSolver

7,85209E-7

4,00149E-5

2,98471E-8

1,85203E1

7,03718E-1

1,92679E1

1,99955E2

2,84113E-2

2,09922E-3

6,60989E-5

1,59764E-12

4,20350E-11

1,52132E-6

7,47451E-1

2,51223E-6

3,92220E1

4,27853E-2

1.0

VCell

7,85288E-7

4,00158E-5

2,98494E-8

1,85203E1

7,03716E-1

1,92679E1

1,99955E2

2,84119E-2

2,09931E-3

6,61018E-5

1,59769E-12

4,20380E-11

1,52136E-6

7,47450E-1

2,51229E-6

3,92220E1

4,27857E-2

1.0

copasi

7,85183E-7

4,00135E-5

2,98452E-8

1,85203E1

7,03719E-1

1,92679E1

1,99955E2

2,84111E-2

2,09919E-3

6,60980E-5

1,59739E-12

4,20299E-11

1,52122E-6

7,47452E-1

2,51215E-6

3,92220E1

4,27851E-2

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,05377E-7

2,30080E-5

9,62603E-10

1,91875E1

3,65338E-2

1,99810E1

1,99979E2

1,47501E-3

1,16503E-3

3,80067E-5

2,85929E-14

1,50137E-11

4,38319E-8

7,74407E-1

7,23848E-8

3,92229E1

1,97079E-2

1.0

jsim

7,85183E-7

4,00135E-5

2,98452E-8

1,85203E1

7,03719E-1

1,92679E1

1,99955E2

2,84111E-2

2,09919E-3

6,60980E-5

1,59737E-12

4,20299E-11

1,52122E-6

7,47452E-1

2,51215E-6

3,92220E1

4,27851E-2

1.0

min

5,05377E-7

2,30080E-5

9,62603E-10

1,85201E1

3,65338E-2

1,92677E1

1,99955E2

1,47501E-3

1,16503E-3

3,80067E-5

2,85929E-14

1,50137E-11

4,38319E-8

7,46934E-1

7,23848E-8

3,92218E1

1,97079E-2

1.0

max

7,91039E-7

6,45789E-4

3,02067E-8

1,91875E1

7,03735E-1

1,99810E1

1,99979E2

2,84119E-2

2,10192E-3

6,61922E-5

1,03610E-10

6,90366E-10

1,36942E-4

7,74407E-1

2,51229E-6

3,92229E1

4,27857E-2

1.0

mean

7,85183E-7

4,00135E-5

2,98452E-8

1,85203E1

7,03719E-1

1,92679E1

1,99955E2

2,84111E-2

2,09920E-3

6,60985E-5

1,59752E-12

4,20299E-11

1,52122E-6

7,47452E-1

2,51215E-6

3,92220E1

4,27851E-2

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

1,42603E-6

7,35620E-5

6,43727E-8

1,82509E1

8,23516E-1

1,91365E1

1,99941E2

3,99705E-2

3,24507E-3

1,01085E-4

5,34664E-12

1,18461E-10

3,32143E-6

8,85451E-1

4,56248E-6

3,90713E1

5,59654E-2

1.2

ByoDyn

1,42603E-6

7,35620E-5

6,43727E-8

1,82509E1

8,23516E-1

1,91365E1

1,99941E2

3,99705E-2

3,24507E-3

1,01085E-4

5,34664E-12

1,18461E-10

3,32143E-6

8,85451E-1

4,56248E-6

3,90713E1

5,59654E-2

1.2

Jarnac

1,41645E-6

1,14319E-3

6,39402E-8

1,82505E1

8,23499E-1

1,91363E1

1,99941E2

3,99277E-2

2,84638E-3

1,00112E-4

3,33999E-10

1,87629E-9

2,88327E-4

8,84503E-1

4,51859E-6

3,90713E1

5,50092E-2

1.2

MathSBML

1,42604E-6

7,35629E-5

6,43670E-8

1,82509E1

8,23516E-1

1,91365E1

1,99941E2

3,99705E-2

3,24508E-3

1,01084E-4

5,36692E-12

1,18546E-10

3,32103E-6

8,85451E-1

4,56257E-6

3,90713E1

5,59654E-2

1.2

Oscill8 Core

1,42608E-6

7,35645E-5

6,43773E-8

1,82509E1

8,23515E-1

1,91365E1

1,99941E2

3,99707E-2

3,24512E-3

1,01086E-4

5,34751E-12

1,18474E-10

3,32162E-6

8,85451E-1

4,56262E-6

3,90713E1

5,59656E-2

1.2

SBToolbox2

1,43522E-6

7,35198E-5

6,50682E-8

1,82507E1

8,23539E-1

1,91367E1

1,99940E2

3,99607E-2

3,24864E-3

1,01214E-4

5,36706E-12

1,18317E-10

3,31754E-6

8,85462E-1

4,55883E-6

3,90710E1

5,59521E-2

1.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,42607E-6

7,35642E-5

6,43759E-8

1,82509E1

8,23515E-1

1,91365E1

1,99941E2

3,99707E-2

3,24512E-3

1,01086E-4

5,34738E-12

1,18473E-10

3,32161E-6

8,85451E-1

4,56260E-6

3,90713E1

5,59656E-2

1.2

VCell

1,42617E-6

7,35651E-5

6,43790E-8

1,82509E1

8,23514E-1

1,91365E1

1,99941E2

3,99712E-2

3,24521E-3

1,01089E-4

5,34738E-12

1,18477E-10

3,32164E-6

8,85450E-1

4,56266E-6

3,90713E1

5,59660E-2

1.2

copasi

1,42603E-6

7,35620E-5

6,43727E-8

1,82509E1

8,23516E-1

1,91365E1

1,99941E2

3,99705E-2

3,24507E-3

1,01085E-4

5,34663E-12

1,18461E-10

3,32143E-6

8,85451E-1

4,56248E-6

3,90713E1

5,59654E-2

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,63881E-7

3,94141E-5

1,95552E-9

1,90314E1

4,30618E-2

1,99776E1

1,99975E2

2,09014E-3

1,66731E-3

5,41600E-5

8,34487E-14

3,68710E-11

8,92393E-8

9,23369E-1

1,22584E-7

3,90728E1

2,35635E-2

1.2

jsim

1,42603E-6

7,35620E-5

6,43727E-8

1,82509E1

8,23516E-1

1,91365E1

1,99941E2

3,99705E-2

3,24507E-3

1,01085E-4

5,34664E-12

1,18461E-10

3,32143E-6

8,85451E-1

4,56248E-6

3,90713E1

5,59654E-2

1.2

min

8,63881E-7

3,94141E-5

1,95552E-9

1,82505E1

4,30618E-2

1,91363E1

1,99940E2

2,09014E-3

1,66731E-3

5,41600E-5

8,34487E-14

3,68710E-11

8,92393E-8

8,84503E-1

1,22584E-7

3,90710E1

2,35635E-2

1.2

max

1,43522E-6

1,14319E-3

6,50682E-8

1,90314E1

8,23539E-1

1,99776E1

1,99975E2

3,99712E-2

3,24864E-3

1,01214E-4

3,33999E-10

1,87629E-9

2,88327E-4

9,23369E-1

4,56266E-6

3,90728E1

5,59660E-2

1.2

mean

1,42604E-6

7,35625E-5

6,43727E-8

1,82509E1

8,23516E-1

1,91365E1

1,99941E2

3,99705E-2

3,24508E-3

1,01085E-4

5,34738E-12

1,18467E-10

3,32143E-6

8,85451E-1

4,56248E-6

3,90713E1

5,59654E-2

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

2,36635E-6

1,23325E-4

1,23329E-7

1,79894E1

9,37097E-1

1,90097E1

1,99925E2

5,31610E-2

4,70433E-3

1,45000E-4

1,49067E-11

2,86072E-10

6,42910E-6

1,02001E0

7,55585E-6

3,89220E1

7,03909E-2

1.4

ByoDyn

2,36635E-6

1,23325E-4

1,23329E-7

1,79894E1

9,37097E-1

1,90097E1

1,99925E2

5,31610E-2

4,70433E-3

1,45000E-4

1,49067E-11

2,86072E-10

6,42910E-6

1,02001E0

7,55585E-6

3,89220E1

7,03909E-2

1.4

Jarnac

2,34485E-6

1,84721E-3

1,22208E-7

1,79889E1

9,37064E-1

1,90093E1

1,99925E2

5,30784E-2

4,04362E-3

1,43134E-4

8,98584E-10

4,37104E-9

5,39339E-4

1,01843E0

7,45862E-6

3,89221E1

6,87941E-2

1.4

MathSBML

2,36634E-6

1,23324E-4

1,23318E-7

1,79894E1

9,37097E-1

1,90097E1

1,99925E2

5,31609E-2

4,70435E-3

1,45000E-4

1,49026E-11

2,85878E-10

6,42837E-6

1,02001E0

7,55588E-6

3,89220E1

7,03908E-2

1.4

Oscill8 Core

2,36643E-6

1,23328E-4

1,23335E-7

1,79894E1

9,37097E-1

1,90097E1

1,99925E2

5,31612E-2

4,70439E-3

1,45001E-4

1,49086E-11

2,86098E-10

6,42940E-6

1,02001E0

7,55604E-6

3,89220E1

7,03910E-2

1.4

SBToolbox2

2,37989E-6

1,23237E-4

1,24516E-7

1,79897E1

9,37134E-1

1,90098E1

1,99921E2

5,31483E-2

4,70895E-3

1,45161E-4

1,49255E-11

2,85244E-10

6,41898E-6

1,02006E0

7,54885E-6

3,89220E1

7,03730E-2

1.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,36641E-6

1,23328E-4

1,23334E-7

1,79894E1

9,37096E-1

1,90097E1

1,99925E2

5,31612E-2

4,70438E-3

1,45001E-4

1,49084E-11

2,86096E-10

6,42938E-6

1,02001E0

7,55602E-6

3,89220E1

7,03910E-2

1.4

VCell

2,36652E-6

1,23329E-4

1,23337E-7

1,79894E1

9,37095E-1

1,90097E1

1,99925E2

5,31616E-2

4,70448E-3

1,45004E-4

1,49082E-11

2,86101E-10

6,42939E-6

1,02001E0

7,55607E-6

3,89220E1

7,03913E-2

1.4

copasi

2,36635E-6

1,23325E-4

1,23329E-7

1,79894E1

9,37097E-1

1,90097E1

1,99925E2

5,31610E-2

4,70433E-3

1,45000E-4

1,49067E-11

2,86072E-10

6,42910E-6

1,02001E0

7,55585E-6

3,89220E1

7,03909E-2

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,35700E-6

6,20424E-5

3,54932E-9

1,88773E1

4,93496E-2

1,99744E1

1,99970E2

2,79974E-3

2,25523E-3

7,29453E-5

2,05651E-13

7,86420E-11

1,62317E-7

1,07044E0

1,90765E-7

3,89244E1

2,73849E-2

1.4

jsim

2,36635E-6

1,23325E-4

1,23329E-7

1,79894E1

9,37097E-1

1,90097E1

1,99925E2

5,31610E-2

4,70433E-3

1,45000E-4

1,49067E-11

2,86072E-10

6,42910E-6

1,02001E0

7,55585E-6

3,89220E1

7,03909E-2

1.4

min

1,35700E-6

6,20424E-5

3,54932E-9

1,79889E1

4,93496E-2

1,90093E1

1,99921E2

2,79974E-3

2,25523E-3

7,29453E-5

2,05651E-13

7,86420E-11

1,62317E-7

1,01843E0

1,90765E-7

3,89220E1

2,73849E-2

1.4

max

2,37989E-6

1,84721E-3

1,24516E-7

1,88773E1

9,37134E-1

1,99744E1

1,99970E2

5,31616E-2

4,70895E-3

1,45161E-4

8,98584E-10

4,37104E-9

5,39339E-4

1,07044E0

7,55607E-6

3,89244E1

7,03913E-2

1.4

mean

2,36635E-6

1,23325E-4

1,23329E-7

1,79894E1

9,37097E-1

1,90097E1

1,99925E2

5,31610E-2

4,70434E-3

1,45000E-4

1,49074E-11

2,86072E-10

6,42910E-6

1,02001E0

7,55585E-6

3,89220E1

7,03909E-2

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

1.6

BioUML

3,67306E-6

1,93099E-4

2,16494E-7

1,77357E1

1,04476E0

1,88874E1

1,99907E2

6,78587E-2

6,50096E-3

1,98307E-4

3,62992E-11

6,15982E-10

1,13849E-5

1,15129E0

1,16863E-5

3,87741E1

8,59492E-2

1.6

ByoDyn

3,67306E-6

1,93099E-4

2,16494E-7

1,77357E1

1,04476E0

1,88874E1

1,99907E2

6,78587E-2

6,50096E-3

1,98307E-4

3,62992E-11

6,15982E-10

1,13849E-5

1,15129E0

1,16863E-5

3,87741E1

8,59492E-2

1.6

Jarnac

3,62976E-6

2,79005E-3

2,13941E-7

1,77348E1

1,04470E0

1,88867E1

1,99907E2

6,77134E-2

5,47657E-3

1,95031E-4

2,11473E-9

9,08232E-9

9,24617E-4

1,14883E0

1,14932E-5

3,87743E1

8,34621E-2

1.6

MathSBML

3,67304E-6

1,93098E-4

2,16480E-7

1,77357E1

1,04476E0

1,88874E1

1,99907E2

6,78586E-2

6,50099E-3

1,98309E-4

3,62498E-11

6,15450E-10

1,13840E-5

1,15129E0

1,16864E-5

3,87741E1

8,59491E-2

1.6

Oscill8 Core

3,67315E-6

1,93104E-4

2,16503E-7

1,77357E1

1,04476E0

1,88874E1

1,99907E2

6,78589E-2

6,50102E-3

1,98309E-4

3,63032E-11

6,16030E-10

1,13854E-5

1,15129E0

1,16866E-5

3,87741E1

8,59494E-2

1.6

SBToolbox2

3,69116E-6

1,92862E-4

2,18208E-7

1,77359E1

1,04477E0

1,88870E1

1,99910E2

6,78440E-2

6,50632E-3

1,98514E-4

3,60374E-11

6,11020E-10

1,13504E-5

1,15126E0

1,16709E-5

3,87741E1

8,59284E-2

1.6

SBWOdeSolver

3,67313E-6

1,93103E-4

2,16501E-7

1,77357E1

1,04476E0

1,88874E1

1,99907E2

6,78589E-2

6,50102E-3

1,98309E-4

3,63028E-11

6,16027E-10

1,13854E-5

1,15129E0

1,16866E-5

3,87741E1

8,59494E-2

1.6

VCell

3,67326E-6

1,93104E-4

2,16506E-7

1,77357E1

1,04476E0

1,88874E1

1,99907E2

6,78593E-2

6,50111E-3

1,98312E-4

3,63020E-11

6,16031E-10

1,13853E-5

1,15128E0

1,16866E-5

3,87741E1

8,59496E-2

1.6

copasi

3,67306E-6

1,93099E-4

2,16494E-7

1,77357E1

1,04476E0

1,88874E1

1,99907E2

6,78587E-2

6,50096E-3

1,98307E-4

3,62992E-11

6,15982E-10

1,13849E-5

1,15129E0

1,16863E-5

3,87741E1

8,59492E-2

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,00372E-6

9,17975E-5

5,93215E-9

1,87251E1

5,54050E-2

1,99713E1

1,99966E2

3,59896E-3

2,92699E-3

9,42705E-5

4,47788E-13

1,51285E-10

2,71853E-7

1,21566E0

2,79049E-7

3,87777E1

3,11701E-2

1.6

jsim

3,67306E-6

1,93099E-4

2,16494E-7

1,77357E1

1,04476E0

1,88874E1

1,99907E2

6,78587E-2

6,50096E-3

1,98307E-4

3,62992E-11

6,15982E-10

1,13850E-5

1,15129E0

1,16863E-5

3,87741E1

8,59492E-2

1.6

min

2,00372E-6

9,17975E-5

5,93215E-9

1,77348E1

5,54050E-2

1,88867E1

1,99907E2

3,59896E-3

2,92699E-3

9,42705E-5

4,47788E-13

1,51285E-10

2,71853E-7

1,14883E0

2,79049E-7

3,87741E1

3,11701E-2

1.6

max

3,69116E-6

2,79005E-3

2,18208E-7

1,87251E1

1,04477E0

1,99713E1

1,99966E2

6,78593E-2

6,50632E-3

1,98514E-4

2,11473E-9

9,08232E-9

9,24617E-4

1,21566E0

1,16866E-5

3,87777E1

8,59496E-2

1.6

mean

3,67306E-6

1,93099E-4

2,16494E-7

1,77357E1

1,04476E0

1,88874E1

1,99907E2

6,78587E-2

6,50098E-3

1,98308E-4

3,62992E-11

6,15982E-10

1,13849E-5

1,15129E0

1,16863E-5

3,87741E1

8,59492E-2

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

1.8

BioUML

5,41516E-6

2,86824E-4

3,55306E-7

1,74893E1

1,14678E0

1,87692E1

1,99889E2

8,39474E-2

8,65609E-3

2,61371E-4

7,96240E-11

1,21382E-9

1,88260E-5

1,27941E0

1,71459E-5

3,86277E1

1,02535E-1

1.8

ByoDyn

5,41516E-6

2,86824E-4

3,55306E-7

1,74893E1

1,14678E0

1,87692E1

1,99889E2

8,39474E-2

8,65609E-3

2,61371E-4

7,96240E-11

1,21382E-9

1,88260E-5

1,27941E0

1,71459E-5

3,86277E1

1,02535E-1

1.8

Jarnac

5,33497E-6

4,00056E-3

3,50041E-7

1,74881E1

1,14668E0

1,87681E1

1,99889E2

8,37088E-2

7,14734E-3

2,55998E-4

4,48868E-9

1,72742E-8

1,48233E-3

1,27578E0

1,67932E-5

3,86279E1

9,88640E-2

1.8

MathSBML

5,41515E-6

2,86824E-4

3,55311E-7

1,74893E1

1,14678E0

1,87692E1

1,99889E2

8,39474E-2

8,65609E-3

2,61372E-4

7,96287E-11

1,21367E-9

1,88262E-5

1,27941E0

1,71459E-5

3,86277E1

1,02535E-1

1.8

Oscill8 Core

5,41527E-6

2,86830E-4

3,55319E-7

1,74893E1

1,14678E0

1,87692E1

1,99889E2

8,39476E-2

8,65616E-3

2,61373E-4

7,96314E-11

1,21390E-9

1,88266E-5

1,27941E0

1,71462E-5

3,86277E1

1,02535E-1

1.8

SBToolbox2

5,43918E-6

2,86404E-4

3,57703E-7

1,74892E1

1,14680E0

1,87691E1

1,99890E2

8,39303E-2

8,66246E-3

2,61628E-4

7,84355E-11

1,19887E-9

1,87520E-5

1,27945E0

1,71197E-5

3,86274E1

1,02507E-1

1.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,41525E-6

2,86830E-4

3,55316E-7

1,74893E1

1,14678E0

1,87692E1

1,99889E2

8,39476E-2

8,65616E-3

2,61373E-4

7,96309E-11

1,21389E-9

1,88265E-5

1,27941E0

1,71462E-5

3,86277E1

1,02535E-1

1.8

VCell

5,41540E-6

2,86830E-4

3,55321E-7

1,74893E1

1,14678E0

1,87692E1

1,99889E2

8,39480E-2

8,65625E-3

2,61376E-4

7,96289E-11

1,21389E-9

1,88265E-5

1,27941E0

1,71462E-5

3,86277E1

1,02535E-1

1.8

copasi

5,41516E-6

2,86824E-4

3,55306E-7

1,74893E1

1,14678E0

1,87692E1

1,99889E2

8,39474E-2

8,65609E-3

2,61371E-4

7,96239E-11

1,21382E-9

1,88260E-5

1,27941E0

1,71459E-5

3,86277E1

1,02535E-1

1.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,82206E-6

1,29547E-4

9,30952E-9

1,85750E1

6,12356E-2

1,99684E1

1,99961E2

4,48317E-3

3,68078E-3

1,18045E-4

8,87027E-13

2,68960E-10

4,27494E-7

1,35905E0

3,89339E-7

3,86326E1

3,49173E-2

1.8

jsim

5,41516E-6

2,86824E-4

3,55306E-7

1,74893E1

1,14678E0

1,87692E1

1,99888E2

8,39474E-2

8,65609E-3

2,61371E-4

7,96240E-11

1,21382E-9

1,88260E-5

1,27941E0

1,71459E-5

3,86277E1

1,02535E-1

1.8

min

2,82206E-6

1,29547E-4

9,30952E-9

1,74881E1

6,12356E-2

1,87681E1

1,99888E2

4,48317E-3

3,68078E-3

1,18045E-4

8,87027E-13

2,68960E-10

4,27494E-7

1,27578E0

3,89339E-7

3,86274E1

3,49173E-2

1.8

max

5,43918E-6

4,00056E-3

3,57703E-7

1,85750E1

1,14680E0

1,99684E1

1,99961E2

8,39480E-2

8,66246E-3

2,61628E-4

4,48868E-9

1,72742E-8

1,48233E-3

1,35905E0

1,71462E-5

3,86326E1

1,02535E-1

1.8

mean

5,41516E-6

2,86824E-4

3,55308E-7

1,74893E1

1,14678E0

1,87692E1

1,99889E2

8,39474E-2

8,65609E-3

2,61372E-4

7,96263E-11

1,21382E-9

1,88261E-5

1,27941E0

1,71459E-5

3,86277E1

1,02535E-1

1.8

relative error(%)

0,00

2.0

BioUML

7,66306E-6

4,08534E-4

5,52778E-7

1,72499E1

1,24342E0

1,86552E1

1,99868E2

1,01318E-1

1,11882E-2

3,34465E-4

1,60719E-10

2,22859E-9

2,94812E-5

1,40452E0

2,41213E-5

3,84825E1

1,20049E-1

2.0

ByoDyn

7,66306E-6

4,08534E-4

5,52778E-7

1,72499E1

1,24342E0

1,86552E1

1,99868E2

1,01318E-1

1,11882E-2

3,34465E-4

1,60719E-10

2,22859E-9

2,94812E-5

1,40452E0

2,41213E-5

3,84825E1

1,20049E-1

2.0

Jarnac

7,52406E-6

5,50398E-3

5,42744E-7

1,72483E1

1,24328E0

1,86535E1

1,99868E2

1,00947E-1

9,05509E-3

3,26116E-4

8,77599E-9

3,06170E-8

2,25338E-3

1,39940E0

2,35188E-5

3,84828E1

1,14858E-1

2.0

MathSBML

7,66304E-6

4,08533E-4

5,52777E-7

1,72499E1

1,24342E0

1,86552E1

1,99868E2

1,01318E-1

1,11882E-2

3,34466E-4

1,60677E-10

2,22810E-9

2,94811E-5

1,40452E0

2,41213E-5

3,84825E1

1,20049E-1

2.0

Oscill8 Core

7,66319E-6

4,08541E-4

5,52795E-7

1,72499E1

1,24342E0

1,86552E1

1,99868E2

1,01318E-1

1,11883E-2

3,34467E-4

1,60732E-10

2,22872E-9

2,94820E-5

1,40452E0

2,41217E-5

3,84825E1

1,20049E-1

2.0

SBToolbox2

7,70216E-6

4,08292E-4

5,57778E-7

1,72494E1

1,24354E0

1,86552E1

1,99870E2

1,01290E-1

1,11968E-2

3,34798E-4

1,61054E-10

2,22294E-9

2,94438E-5

1,40456E0

2,40992E-5

3,84824E1

1,20010E-1

2.0

SBWOdeSolver

7,66317E-6

4,08540E-4

5,52793E-7

1,72499E1

1,24342E0

1,86552E1

1,99868E2

1,01318E-1

1,11883E-2

3,34467E-4

1,60731E-10

2,22871E-9

2,94820E-5

1,40452E0

2,41217E-5

3,84825E1

1,20049E-1

2.0

VCell

7,66336E-6

4,08541E-4

5,52801E-7

1,72499E1

1,24342E0

1,86552E1

1,99868E2

1,01318E-1

1,11884E-2

3,34471E-4

1,60730E-10

2,22872E-9

2,94819E-5

1,40452E0

2,41217E-5

3,84825E1

1,20049E-1

2.0

copasi

7,66306E-6

4,08534E-4

5,52778E-7

1,72499E1

1,24342E0

1,86552E1

1,99868E2

1,01318E-1

1,11882E-2

3,34465E-4

1,60719E-10

2,22859E-9

2,94812E-5

1,40452E0

2,41213E-5

3,84825E1

1,20049E-1

2.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,82917E-6

1,76120E-4

1,39017E-8

1,84267E1

6,68487E-2

1,99656E1

1,99957E2

5,44793E-3

4,51479E-3

1,44179E-4

1,63078E-12

4,49320E-10

6,39633E-7

1,50066E0

5,23328E-7

3,84892E1

3,86247E-2

2.0

jsim

7,66306E-6

4,08534E-4

5,52778E-7

1,72499E1

1,24342E0

1,86552E1

1,99868E2

1,01318E-1

1,11882E-2

3,34465E-4

1,60719E-10

2,22859E-9

2,94812E-5

1,40452E0

2,41213E-5

3,84825E1

1,20049E-1

2.0

min

3,82917E-6

1,76120E-4

1,39017E-8

1,72483E1

6,68487E-2

1,86535E1

1,99868E2

5,44793E-3

4,51479E-3

1,44179E-4

1,63078E-12

4,49320E-10

6,39633E-7

1,39940E0

5,23328E-7

3,84824E1

3,86247E-2

2.0

max

7,70216E-6

5,50398E-3

5,57778E-7

1,84267E1

1,24354E0

1,99656E1

1,99957E2

1,01318E-1

1,11968E-2

3,34798E-4

8,77599E-9

3,06170E-8

2,25338E-3

1,50066E0

2,41217E-5

3,84892E1

1,20049E-1

2.0

mean

7,66306E-6

4,08534E-4

5,52778E-7

1,72499E1

1,24342E0

1,86552E1

1,99868E2

1,01318E-1

1,11882E-2

3,34465E-4

1,60724E-10

2,22859E-9

2,94812E-5

1,40452E0

2,41213E-5

3,84825E1

1,20049E-1

2.0

relative error(%)

0,00

2.2

BioUML

1,04879E-5

5,62316E-4

8,23401E-7

1,70174E1

1,33495E0

1,85451E1

1,99847E2

1,19867E-1

1,41132E-2

4,17783E-4

3,03127E-10

3,86208E-9

4,41661E-5

1,52675E0

3,27918E-5

3,83387E1

1,38397E-1

2.2

ByoDyn

1,04879E-5

5,62316E-4

8,23401E-7

1,70174E1

1,33495E0

1,85451E1

1,99847E2

1,19867E-1

1,41132E-2

4,17783E-4

3,03127E-10

3,86208E-9

4,41661E-5

1,52675E0

3,27918E-5

3,83387E1

1,38397E-1

2.2

Jarnac

1,02596E-5

7,32169E-3

8,05463E-7

1,70151E1

1,33474E0

1,85426E1

1,99847E2

1,19316E-1

1,11964E-2

4,05371E-4

1,60459E-8

5,12265E-8

3,28053E-3

1,51976E0

3,18168E-5

3,83391E1

1,31312E-1

2.2

MathSBML

1,04879E-5

5,62315E-4

8,23393E-7

1,70174E1

1,33495E0

1,85451E1

1,99847E2

1,19867E-1

1,41132E-2

4,17784E-4

3,02987E-10

3,86106E-9

4,41657E-5

1,52675E0

3,27919E-5

3,83387E1

1,38397E-1

2.2

Oscill8 Core

1,04880E-5

5,62324E-4

8,23423E-7

1,70174E1

1,33495E0

1,85451E1

1,99847E2

1,19867E-1

1,41133E-2

4,17785E-4

3,03148E-10

3,86228E-9

4,41672E-5

1,52675E0

3,27923E-5

3,83387E1

1,38397E-1

2.2

SBToolbox2

1,05322E-5

5,61449E-4

8,28803E-7

1,70174E1

1,33501E0

1,85451E1

1,99850E2

1,19841E-1

1,41225E-2

4,18178E-4

2,98799E-10

3,81384E-9

4,39884E-5

1,52678E0

3,27388E-5

3,83385E1

1,38355E-1

2.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,04880E-5

5,62324E-4

8,23420E-7

1,70174E1

1,33495E0

1,85451E1

1,99847E2

1,19867E-1

1,41133E-2

4,17785E-4

3,03147E-10

3,86227E-9

4,41672E-5

1,52675E0

3,27922E-5

3,83387E1

1,38397E-1

2.2

VCell

1,04882E-5

5,62324E-4

8,23429E-7

1,70174E1

1,33495E0

1,85451E1

1,99847E2

1,19868E-1

1,41134E-2

4,17789E-4

3,03142E-10

3,86227E-9

4,41670E-5

1,52674E0

3,27923E-5

3,83387E1

1,38398E-1

2.2

copasi

1,04879E-5

5,62316E-4

8,23401E-7

1,70174E1

1,33495E0

1,85451E1

1,99847E2

1,19867E-1

1,41132E-2

4,17783E-4

3,03126E-10

3,86208E-9

4,41661E-5

1,52675E0

3,27918E-5

3,83387E1

1,38397E-1

2.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,04132E-6

2,32310E-4

1,99414E-8

1,82803E1

7,22513E-2

1,99630E1

1,99952E2

6,48896E-3

5,42719E-3

1,72583E-4

2,82246E-12

7,13760E-10

9,19299E-7

1,64050E0

6,82515E-7

3,83473E1

4,22906E-2

2.2

jsim

1,04879E-5

5,62316E-4

8,23401E-7

1,70174E1

1,33495E0

1,85451E1

1,99847E2

1,19867E-1

1,41132E-2

4,17783E-4

3,03127E-10

3,86208E-9

4,41661E-5

1,52675E0

3,27918E-5

3,83387E1

1,38397E-1

2.2

min

5,04132E-6

2,32310E-4

1,99414E-8

1,70151E1

7,22513E-2

1,85426E1

1,99847E2

6,48896E-3

5,42719E-3

1,72583E-4

2,82246E-12

7,13760E-10

9,19299E-7

1,51976E0

6,82515E-7

3,83385E1

4,22906E-2

2.2

max

1,05322E-5

7,32169E-3

8,28803E-7

1,82803E1

1,33501E0

1,99630E1

1,99952E2

1,19868E-1

1,41225E-2

4,18178E-4

1,60459E-8

5,12265E-8

3,28053E-3

1,64050E0

3,27923E-5

3,83473E1

1,38398E-1

2.2

mean

1,04879E-5

5,62316E-4

8,23401E-7

1,70174E1

1,33495E0

1,85451E1

1,99847E2

1,19867E-1

1,41132E-2

4,17783E-4

3,03127E-10

3,86208E-9

4,41661E-5

1,52675E0

3,27918E-5

3,83387E1

1,38397E-1

2.2

relative error(%)

0,00

2.4

BioUML

1,39609E-5

7,52277E-4

1,18302E-6

1,67913E1

1,42159E0

1,84388E1

1,99824E2

1,39499E-1

1,74449E-2

5,11450E-4

5,40341E-10

6,37855E-9

6,37761E-5

1,64620E0

4,33272E-5

3,81960E1

1,57493E-1

2.4

ByoDyn

1,39609E-5

7,52277E-4

1,18302E-6

1,67913E1

1,42159E0

1,84388E1

1,99824E2

1,39499E-1

1,74449E-2

5,11450E-4

5,40341E-10

6,37855E-9

6,37761E-5

1,64620E0

4,33272E-5

3,81960E1

1,57493E-1

2.4

Jarnac

1,36025E-5

9,47115E-3

1,15261E-6

1,67884E1

1,42129E0

1,84353E1

1,99824E2

1,38710E-1

1,35655E-2

4,93663E-4

2,77474E-8

8,16905E-8

4,60766E-3

1,63694E0

4,18190E-5

3,81967E1

1,48099E-1

2.4

MathSBML

1,39609E-5

7,52277E-4

1,18302E-6

1,67913E1

1,42159E0

1,84388E1

1,99824E2

1,39499E-1

1,74449E-2

5,11450E-4

5,40315E-10

6,37821E-9

6,37765E-5

1,64620E0

4,33271E-5

3,81960E1

1,57493E-1

2.4

Oscill8 Core

1,39611E-5

7,52287E-4

1,18305E-6

1,67913E1

1,42159E0

1,84388E1

1,99824E2

1,39499E-1

1,74450E-2

5,11452E-4

5,40374E-10

6,37883E-9

6,37774E-5

1,64620E0

4,33277E-5

3,81960E1

1,57493E-1

2.4

SBToolbox2

1,40299E-5

7,51820E-4

1,19346E-6

1,67916E1

1,42169E0

1,84384E1

1,99822E2

1,39458E-1

1,74575E-2

5,11924E-4

5,41259E-10

6,36065E-9

6,36899E-5

1,64628E0

4,32840E-5

3,81957E1

1,57435E-1

2.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,39611E-5

7,52286E-4

1,18304E-6

1,67913E1

1,42159E0

1,84388E1

1,99824E2

1,39499E-1

1,74450E-2

5,11452E-4

5,40373E-10

6,37882E-9

6,37774E-5

1,64620E0

4,33277E-5

3,81960E1

1,57493E-1

2.4

VCell

1,39613E-5

7,52286E-4

1,18305E-6

1,67913E1

1,42159E0

1,84388E1

1,99824E2

1,39500E-1

1,74451E-2

5,11455E-4

5,40367E-10

6,37882E-9

6,37772E-5

1,64620E0

4,33277E-5

3,81960E1

1,57493E-1

2.4

copasi

1,39609E-5

7,52277E-4

1,18302E-6

1,67913E1

1,42159E0

1,84388E1

1,99824E2

1,39499E-1

1,74449E-2

5,11450E-4

5,40340E-10

6,37855E-9

6,37761E-5

1,64620E0

4,33272E-5

3,81960E1

1,57493E-1

2.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,47389E-6

2,98876E-4

2,76717E-8

1,81358E1

7,74502E-2

1,99604E1

1,99947E2

7,60218E-3

6,41617E-3

2,03171E-4

4,64733E-12

1,08763E-9

1,27807E-6

1,77862E0

8,68210E-7

3,82071E1

4,59137E-2

2.4

jsim

1,39609E-5

7,52277E-4

1,18302E-6

1,67913E1

1,42159E0

1,84388E1

1,99824E2

1,39499E-1

1,74449E-2

5,11450E-4

5,40341E-10

6,37855E-9

6,37761E-5

1,64620E0

4,33272E-5

3,81960E1

1,57493E-1

2.4

min

6,47389E-6

2,98876E-4

2,76717E-8

1,67884E1

7,74502E-2

1,84353E1

1,99822E2

7,60218E-3

6,41617E-3

2,03171E-4

4,64733E-12

1,08763E-9

1,27807E-6

1,63694E0

8,68210E-7

3,81957E1

4,59137E-2

2.4

max

1,40299E-5

9,47115E-3

1,19346E-6

1,81358E1

1,42169E0

1,99604E1

1,99947E2

1,39500E-1

1,74575E-2

5,11924E-4

2,77474E-8

8,16905E-8

4,60766E-3

1,77862E0

4,33277E-5

3,82071E1

1,57493E-1

2.4

mean

1,39609E-5

7,52277E-4

1,18302E-6

1,67913E1

1,42159E0

1,84388E1

1,99824E2

1,39499E-1

1,74449E-2

5,11450E-4

5,40354E-10

6,37855E-9

6,37763E-5

1,64620E0

4,33272E-5

3,81960E1

1,57493E-1

2.4

relative error(%)

0,00

2.6

BioUML

1,81532E-5

9,82515E-4

1,64870E-6

1,65715E1

1,50359E0

1,83361E1

1,99800E2

1,60123E-1

2,11947E-2

6,15527E-4

9,18314E-10

1,01145E-8

8,92787E-5

1,76300E0

5,58863E-5

3,80546E1

1,77253E-1

2.6

ByoDyn

1,81532E-5

9,82515E-4

1,64870E-6

1,65715E1

1,50359E0

1,83361E1

1,99800E2

1,60123E-1

2,11947E-2

6,15527E-4

9,18314E-10

1,01145E-8

8,92787E-5

1,76300E0

5,58863E-5

3,80546E1

1,77253E-1

2.6

Jarnac

1,76113E-5

1,19660E-2

1,59942E-6

1,65679E1

1,50317E0

1,83315E1

1,99800E2

1,59029E-1

1,61550E-2

5,90818E-4

4,57734E-8

1,25083E-7

6,27902E-3

1,75103E0

5,36403E-5

3,80555E1

1,65105E-1

2.6

MathSBML

1,81532E-5

9,82514E-4

1,64870E-6

1,65715E1

1,50359E0

1,83361E1

1,99800E2

1,60123E-1

2,11947E-2

6,15528E-4

9,18225E-10

1,01139E-8

8,92789E-5

1,76300E0

5,58863E-5

3,80546E1

1,77253E-1

2.6

Oscill8 Core

1,81534E-5

9,82526E-4

1,64873E-6

1,65715E1

1,50359E0

1,83361E1

1,99800E2

1,60123E-1

2,11948E-2

6,15530E-4

9,18364E-10

1,01149E-8

8,92804E-5

1,76300E0

5,58869E-5

3,80546E1

1,77253E-1

2.6

SBToolbox2

1,82272E-5

9,80844E-4

1,65891E-6

1,65716E1

1,50366E0

1,83363E1

1,99800E2

1,60087E-1

2,12065E-2

6,16108E-4

9,02386E-10

9,96799E-9

8,88829E-5

1,76302E0

5,57902E-5

3,80548E1

1,77200E-1

2.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,81533E-5

9,82526E-4

1,64873E-6

1,65715E1

1,50359E0

1,83361E1

1,99800E2

1,60123E-1

2,11948E-2

6,15530E-4

9,18363E-10

1,01149E-8

8,92803E-5

1,76300E0

5,58869E-5

3,80546E1

1,77253E-1

2.6

VCell

1,81536E-5

9,82525E-4

1,64874E-6

1,65715E1

1,50359E0

1,83361E1

1,99800E2

1,60123E-1

2,11949E-2

6,15533E-4

9,18350E-10

1,01149E-8

8,92799E-5

1,76299E0

5,58868E-5

3,80546E1

1,77253E-1

2.6

copasi

1,81532E-5

9,82515E-4

1,64870E-6

1,65715E1

1,50359E0

1,83361E1

1,99800E2

1,60123E-1

2,11947E-2

6,15527E-4

9,18314E-10

1,01145E-8

8,92787E-5

1,76300E0

5,58863E-5

3,80546E1

1,77253E-1

2.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,14146E-6

3,76539E-4

3,73436E-8

1,79931E1

8,24520E-2

1,99580E1

1,99943E2

8,78365E-3

7,47990E-3

2,35857E-4

7,33817E-12

1,60043E-9

1,72795E-6

1,91504E0

1,08155E-6

3,80683E1

4,94925E-2

2.6

jsim

1,81532E-5

9,82515E-4

1,64870E-6

1,65715E1

1,50359E0

1,83361E1

1,99800E2

1,60123E-1

2,11947E-2

6,15527E-4

9,18314E-10

1,01145E-8

8,92787E-5

1,76300E0

5,58863E-5

3,80546E1

1,77253E-1

2.6

min

8,14146E-6

3,76539E-4

3,73436E-8

1,65679E1

8,24520E-2

1,83315E1

1,99800E2

8,78365E-3

7,47990E-3

2,35857E-4

7,33817E-12

1,60043E-9

1,72795E-6

1,75103E0

1,08155E-6

3,80546E1

4,94925E-2

2.6

max

1,82272E-5

1,19660E-2

1,65891E-6

1,79931E1

1,50366E0

1,99580E1

1,99943E2

1,60123E-1

2,12065E-2

6,16108E-4

4,57734E-8

1,25083E-7

6,27902E-3

1,91504E0

5,58869E-5

3,80683E1

1,77253E-1

2.6

mean

1,81532E-5

9,82515E-4

1,64870E-6

1,65715E1

1,50359E0

1,83361E1

1,99800E2

1,60123E-1

2,11947E-2

6,15528E-4

9,18314E-10

1,01145E-8

8,92788E-5

1,76300E0

5,58863E-5

3,80546E1

1,77253E-1

2.6

relative error(%)

0,00

2.8

BioUML

2,31349E-5

1,25709E-3

2,23860E-6

1,63578E1

1,58115E0

1,82370E1

1,99776E2

1,81653E-1

2,53723E-2

7,30025E-4

1,49819E-9

1,54886E-8

1,21706E-4

1,87724E0

7,06162E-5

3,79143E1

1,97601E-1

2.8

ByoDyn

2,31349E-5

1,25709E-3

2,23860E-6

1,63578E1

1,58115E0

1,82370E1

1,99776E2

1,81653E-1

2,53723E-2

7,30025E-4

1,49819E-9

1,54886E-8

1,21706E-4

1,87724E0

7,06162E-5

3,79143E1

1,97601E-1

2.8

Jarnac

2,23419E-5

1,48160E-2

2,16173E-6

1,63532E1

1,58059E0

1,82308E1

1,99776E2

1,80177E-1

1,89557E-2

6,96597E-4

7,25221E-8

1,84961E-7

8,33850E-3

1,86209E0

6,73782E-5

3,79156E1

1,82220E-1

2.8

MathSBML

2,31349E-5

1,25709E-3

2,23860E-6

1,63578E1

1,58115E0

1,82370E1

1,99776E2

1,81653E-1

2,53724E-2

7,30026E-4

1,49792E-9

1,54871E-8

1,21706E-4

1,87724E0

7,06162E-5

3,79143E1

1,97601E-1

2.8

Oscill8 Core

2,31352E-5

1,25710E-3

2,23864E-6

1,63578E1

1,58115E0

1,82370E1

1,99776E2

1,81653E-1

2,53725E-2

7,30028E-4

1,49826E-9

1,54891E-8

1,21708E-4

1,87724E0

7,06168E-5

3,79143E1

1,97601E-1

2.8

SBToolbox2

2,32461E-5

1,25600E-3

2,25755E-6

1,63578E1

1,58134E0

1,82371E1

1,99780E2

1,81592E-1

2,53874E-2

7,30686E-4

1,49735E-9

1,54181E-8

1,21463E-4

1,87730E0

7,05270E-5

3,79140E1

1,97522E-1

2.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,31351E-5

1,25710E-3

2,23864E-6

1,63578E1

1,58115E0

1,82370E1

1,99776E2

1,81653E-1

2,53725E-2

7,30028E-4

1,49826E-9

1,54891E-8

1,21708E-4

1,87724E0

7,06168E-5

3,79143E1

1,97601E-1

2.8

VCell

2,31354E-5

1,25710E-3

2,23865E-6

1,63578E1

1,58115E0

1,82370E1

1,99776E2

1,81654E-1

2,53726E-2

7,30031E-4

1,49823E-9

1,54890E-8

1,21707E-4

1,87724E0

7,06167E-5

3,79143E1

1,97601E-1

2.8

copasi

2,31349E-5

1,25709E-3

2,23860E-6

1,63578E1

1,58115E0

1,82370E1

1,99776E2

1,81653E-1

2,53723E-2

7,30025E-4

1,49819E-9

1,54886E-8

1,21706E-4

1,87724E0

7,06162E-5

3,79143E1

1,97601E-1

2.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,00578E-5

4,65986E-4

4,92149E-8

1,78522E1

8,72631E-2

1,99558E1

1,99938E2

1,00296E-2

8,61657E-3

2,70557E-4

1,11809E-11

2,28591E-9

2,28134E-6

2,04979E0

1,32350E-6

3,79311E1

5,30259E-2

2.8

jsim

2,31349E-5

1,25709E-3

2,23860E-6

1,63578E1

1,58115E0

1,82370E1

1,99776E2

1,81653E-1

2,53723E-2

7,30025E-4

1,49819E-9

1,54886E-8

1,21706E-4

1,87724E0

7,06162E-5

3,79143E1

1,97601E-1

2.8

min

1,00578E-5

4,65986E-4

4,92149E-8

1,63532E1

8,72631E-2

1,82308E1

1,99776E2

1,00296E-2

8,61657E-3

2,70557E-4

1,11809E-11

2,28591E-9

2,28134E-6

1,86209E0

1,32350E-6

3,79140E1

5,30259E-2

2.8

max

2,32461E-5

1,48160E-2

2,25755E-6

1,78522E1

1,58134E0

1,99558E1

1,99938E2

1,81654E-1

2,53874E-2

7,30686E-4

7,25221E-8

1,84961E-7

8,33850E-3

2,04979E0

7,06168E-5

3,79311E1

1,97601E-1

2.8

mean

2,31349E-5

1,25709E-3

2,23860E-6

1,63578E1

1,58115E0

1,82370E1

1,99776E2

1,81653E-1

2,53724E-2

7,30026E-4

1,49819E-9

1,54886E-8

1,21706E-4

1,87724E0

7,06162E-5

3,79143E1

1,97601E-1

2.8

relative error(%)

0,00

3.0

BioUML

2,89754E-5

1,58000E-3

2,97182E-6

1,61498E1

1,65448E0

1,81413E1

1,99750E2

2,04010E-1

2,99855E-2

8,54904E-4

2,35919E-9

2,30109E-8

1,62146E-4

1,98904E0

8,76510E-5

3,77752E1

2,18464E-1

3.0

ByoDyn

2,89754E-5

1,58000E-3

2,97182E-6

1,61498E1

1,65448E0

1,81413E1

1,99750E2

2,04010E-1

2,99855E-2

8,54904E-4

2,35919E-9

2,30109E-8

1,62146E-4

1,98904E0

8,76510E-5

3,77752E1

2,18464E-1

3.0

Jarnac

2,78468E-5

1,80274E-2

2,85583E-6

1,61442E1

1,65375E0

1,81333E1

1,99750E2

2,02063E-1

2,19571E-2

8,10708E-4

1,10952E-7

2,65358E-7

1,08291E-2

1,97021E0

8,31123E-5

3,77769E1

1,99347E-1

3.0

MathSBML

2,89754E-5

1,58000E-3

2,97182E-6

1,61498E1

1,65448E0

1,81413E1

1,99750E2

2,04010E-1

2,99855E-2

8,54905E-4

2,35902E-9

2,30100E-8

1,62146E-4

1,98904E0

8,76509E-5

3,77752E1

2,18464E-1

3.0

Oscill8 Core

2,89757E-5

1,58002E-3

2,97187E-6

1,61498E1

1,65448E0

1,81413E1

1,99750E2

2,04010E-1

2,99856E-2

8,54907E-4

2,35929E-9

2,30117E-8

1,62148E-4

1,98904E0

8,76516E-5

3,77752E1

2,18464E-1

3.0

SBToolbox2

2,90995E-5

1,57791E-3

2,99208E-6

1,61493E1

1,65465E0

1,81412E1

1,99750E2

2,03958E-1

3,00014E-2

8,55667E-4

2,32992E-9

2,27510E-8

1,61590E-4

1,98912E0

8,75209E-5

3,77751E1

2,18382E-1

3.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,89757E-5

1,58002E-3

2,97186E-6

1,61498E1

1,65448E0

1,81413E1

1,99750E2

2,04010E-1

2,99856E-2

8,54907E-4

2,35929E-9

2,30117E-8

1,62148E-4

1,98904E0

8,76516E-5

3,77752E1

2,18464E-1

3.0

VCell

2,89759E-5

1,58002E-3

2,97187E-6

1,61498E1

1,65448E0

1,81413E1

1,99750E2

2,04010E-1

2,99857E-2

8,54910E-4

2,35925E-9

2,30115E-8

1,62147E-4

1,98904E0

8,76515E-5

3,77752E1

2,18464E-1

3.0

copasi

2,89754E-5

1,58000E-3

2,97182E-6

1,61498E1

1,65448E0

1,81413E1

1,99750E2

2,04010E-1

2,99855E-2

8,54904E-4

2,35919E-9

2,30109E-8

1,62146E-4

1,98904E0

8,76510E-5

3,77752E1

2,18464E-1

3.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,22359E-5

5,67871E-4

6,35475E-8

1,77130E1

9,18897E-2

1,99536E1

1,99933E2

1,13365E-2

9,82435E-3

3,07186E-4

1,65201E-11

3,18226E-9

2,95088E-6

2,18290E0

1,59488E-6

3,77954E1

5,65126E-2

3.0

jsim

2,89754E-5

1,58000E-3

2,97182E-6

1,61498E1

1,65448E0

1,81413E1

1,99750E2

2,04010E-1

2,99855E-2

8,54904E-4

2,35919E-9

2,30109E-8

1,62146E-4

1,98904E0

8,76510E-5

3,77752E1

2,18464E-1

3.0

min

1,22359E-5

5,67871E-4

6,35475E-8

1,61442E1

9,18897E-2

1,81333E1

1,99750E2

1,13365E-2

9,82435E-3

3,07186E-4

1,65201E-11

3,18226E-9

2,95088E-6

1,97021E0

1,59488E-6

3,77751E1

5,65126E-2

3.0

max

2,90995E-5

1,80274E-2

2,99208E-6

1,77130E1

1,65465E0

1,99536E1

1,99933E2

2,04010E-1

3,00014E-2

8,55667E-4

1,10952E-7

2,65358E-7

1,08291E-2

2,18290E0

8,76516E-5

3,77954E1

2,18464E-1

3.0

mean

2,89754E-5

1,58000E-3

2,97182E-6

1,61498E1

1,65448E0

1,81413E1

1,99750E2

2,04010E-1

2,99855E-2

8,54904E-4

2,35919E-9

2,30109E-8

1,62146E-4

1,98904E0

8,76510E-5

3,77752E1

2,18464E-1

3.0

relative error(%)

0,00

3.2

BioUML

3,57425E-5

1,95519E-3

3,86826E-6

1,59473E1

1,72379E0

1,80488E1

1,99723E2

2,27118E-1

3,50403E-2

9,90084E-4

3,60167E-9

3,32928E-8

2,11733E-4

2,09848E0

1,07112E-4

3,76372E1

2,39774E-1

3.2

ByoDyn

3,57425E-5

1,95519E-3

3,86826E-6

1,59473E1

1,72379E0

1,80488E1

1,99723E2

2,27118E-1

3,50403E-2

9,90084E-4

3,60167E-9

3,32928E-8

2,11733E-4

2,09848E0

1,07112E-4

3,76372E1

2,39774E-1

3.2

Jarnac

3,41754E-5

2,16033E-2

3,69825E-6

1,59406E1

1,72285E0

1,80387E1

1,99723E2

2,24603E-1

2,51479E-2

9,32814E-4

1,64628E-7

3,70750E-7

1,37923E-2

2,07545E0

1,00904E-4

3,76394E1

2,16396E-1

3.2

MathSBML

3,57426E-5

1,95519E-3

3,86824E-6

1,59473E1

1,72379E0

1,80488E1

1,99723E2

2,27118E-1

3,50403E-2

9,90085E-4

3,60066E-9

3,32883E-8

2,11733E-4

2,09848E0

1,07112E-4

3,76372E1

2,39774E-1

3.2

Oscill8 Core

3,57428E-5

1,95520E-3

3,86831E-6

1,59473E1

1,72379E0

1,80488E1

1,99723E2

2,27118E-1

3,50404E-2

9,90086E-4

3,60181E-9

3,32938E-8

2,11736E-4

2,09848E0

1,07112E-4

3,76372E1

2,39774E-1

3.2

SBToolbox2

3,58952E-5

1,95274E-3

3,89516E-6

1,59472E1

1,72401E0

1,80486E1

1,99720E2

2,27052E-1

3,50575E-2

9,90934E-4

3,57390E-9

3,30030E-8

2,11083E-4

2,09857E0

1,06950E-4

3,76372E1

2,39678E-1

3.2

SBWOdeSolver

3,57428E-5

1,95520E-3

3,86831E-6

1,59473E1

1,72379E0

1,80488E1

1,99723E2

2,27118E-1

3,50404E-2

9,90086E-4

3,60181E-9

3,32937E-8

2,11736E-4

2,09848E0

1,07112E-4

3,76372E1

2,39774E-1

3.2

VCell

3,57431E-5

1,95520E-3

3,86832E-6

1,59473E1

1,72379E0

1,80488E1

1,99723E2

2,27119E-1

3,50405E-2

9,90090E-4

3,60176E-9

3,32936E-8

2,11735E-4

2,09848E0

1,07112E-4

3,76372E1

2,39774E-1

3.2

copasi

3,57425E-5

1,95519E-3

3,86826E-6

1,59473E1

1,72379E0

1,80488E1

1,99723E2

2,27118E-1

3,50403E-2

9,90084E-4

3,60167E-9

3,32928E-8

2,11733E-4

2,09848E0

1,07112E-4

3,76372E1

2,39774E-1

3.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,46880E-5

6,82811E-4

8,06070E-8

1,75755E1

9,63377E-2

1,99516E1

1,99928E2

1,27007E-2

1,11015E-2

3,45665E-4

2,37636E-11

4,33212E-9

3,74944E-6

2,31440E0

1,89636E-6

3,76611E1

5,99518E-2

3.2

jsim

3,57425E-5

1,95519E-3

3,86826E-6

1,59473E1

1,72379E0

1,80488E1

1,99723E2

2,27118E-1

3,50403E-2

9,90084E-4

3,60167E-9

3,32928E-8

2,11733E-4

2,09848E0

1,07112E-4

3,76372E1

2,39774E-1

3.2

min

1,46880E-5

6,82811E-4

8,06070E-8

1,59406E1

9,63377E-2

1,80387E1

1,99720E2

1,27007E-2

1,11015E-2

3,45665E-4

2,37636E-11

4,33212E-9

3,74944E-6

2,07545E0

1,89636E-6

3,76372E1

5,99518E-2

3.2

max

3,58952E-5

2,16033E-2

3,89516E-6

1,75755E1

1,72401E0

1,99516E1

1,99928E2

2,27119E-1

3,50575E-2

9,90934E-4

1,64628E-7

3,70750E-7

1,37923E-2

2,31440E0

1,07112E-4

3,76611E1

2,39774E-1

3.2

mean

3,57426E-5

1,95519E-3

3,86826E-6

1,59473E1

1,72379E0

1,80488E1

1,99723E2

2,27118E-1

3,50403E-2

9,90085E-4

3,60167E-9

3,32928E-8

2,11733E-4

2,09848E0

1,07112E-4

3,76372E1

2,39774E-1

3.2

relative error(%)

0,00

3.4

BioUML

4,35026E-5

2,38647E-3

4,94847E-6

1,57502E1

1,78925E0

1,79594E1

1,99695E2

2,50907E-1

4,05412E-2

1,13545E-3

5,35027E-9

4,70551E-8

2,71644E-4

2,20565E0

1,29106E-4

3,75002E1

2,61467E-1

3.4

ByoDyn

4,35026E-5

2,38647E-3

4,94847E-6

1,57502E1

1,78925E0

1,79594E1

1,99695E2

2,50907E-1

4,05412E-2

1,13545E-3

5,35027E-9

4,70551E-8

2,71644E-4

2,20565E0

1,29106E-4

3,75002E1

2,61467E-1

3.4

Jarnac

4,13730E-5

2,55433E-2

4,70558E-6

1,57423E1

1,78806E0

1,79468E1

1,99695E2

2,47716E-1

2,85156E-2

1,06254E-3

2,37762E-7

5,06026E-7

1,72675E-2

2,17789E0

1,20798E-4

3,75030E1

2,33283E-1

3.4

MathSBML

4,35026E-5

2,38647E-3

4,94848E-6

1,57502E1

1,78925E0

1,79594E1

1,99695E2

2,50907E-1

4,05412E-2

1,13545E-3

5,34995E-9

4,70537E-8

2,71645E-4

2,20565E0

1,29106E-4

3,75002E1

2,61467E-1

3.4

Oscill8 Core

4,35029E-5

2,38649E-3

4,94853E-6

1,57502E1

1,78925E0

1,79594E1

1,99695E2

2,50907E-1

4,05413E-2

1,13545E-3

5,35046E-9

4,70563E-8

2,71648E-4

2,20565E0

1,29107E-4

3,75002E1

2,61467E-1

3.4

SBToolbox2

4,36999E-5

2,38458E-3

4,98704E-6

1,57501E1

1,78951E0

1,79594E1

1,99693E2

2,50819E-1

4,05594E-2

1,13632E-3

5,35215E-9

4,68971E-8

2,71178E-4

2,20580E0

1,28946E-4

3,75004E1

2,61346E-1

3.4

SBWOdeSolver

4,35029E-5

2,38649E-3

4,94853E-6

1,57502E1

1,78925E0

1,79594E1

1,99695E2

2,50907E-1

4,05413E-2

1,13545E-3

5,35045E-9

4,70563E-8

2,71648E-4

2,20565E0

1,29107E-4

3,75002E1

2,61467E-1

3.4

VCell

4,35032E-5

2,38648E-3

4,94854E-6

1,57502E1

1,78925E0

1,79594E1

1,99695E2

2,50907E-1

4,05414E-2

1,13545E-3

5,35038E-9

4,70560E-8

2,71646E-4

2,20565E0

1,29107E-4

3,75002E1

2,61467E-1

3.4

copasi

4,35026E-5

2,38647E-3

4,94847E-6

1,57502E1

1,78925E0

1,79594E1

1,99695E2

2,50907E-1

4,05412E-2

1,13545E-3

5,35027E-9

4,70551E-8

2,71644E-4

2,20565E0

1,29106E-4

3,75002E1

2,61467E-1

3.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,74255E-5

8,11393E-4

1,00660E-7

1,74397E1

1,00613E-1

1,99497E1

1,99923E2

1,41191E-2

1,24461E-2

3,85913E-4

3,33878E-11

5,78268E-9

4,69001E-6

2,44432E0

2,22846E-6

3,75283E1

6,33423E-2

3.4

jsim

4,35026E-5

2,38647E-3

4,94847E-6

1,57502E1

1,78925E0

1,79594E1

1,99695E2

2,50907E-1

4,05412E-2

1,13545E-3

5,35027E-9

4,70551E-8

2,71644E-4

2,20565E0

1,29106E-4

3,75002E1

2,61467E-1

3.4

min

1,74255E-5

8,11393E-4

1,00660E-7

1,57423E1

1,00613E-1

1,79468E1

1,99693E2

1,41191E-2

1,24461E-2

3,85913E-4

3,33878E-11

5,78268E-9

4,69001E-6

2,17789E0

2,22846E-6

3,75002E1

6,33423E-2

3.4

max

4,36999E-5

2,55433E-2

4,98704E-6

1,74397E1

1,78951E0

1,99497E1

1,99923E2

2,50907E-1

4,05594E-2

1,13632E-3

2,37762E-7

5,06026E-7

1,72675E-2

2,44432E0

1,29107E-4

3,75283E1

2,61467E-1

3.4

mean

4,35026E-5

2,38647E-3

4,94847E-6

1,57502E1

1,78925E0

1,79594E1

1,99695E2

2,50907E-1

4,05412E-2

1,13545E-3

5,35032E-9

4,70551E-8

2,71645E-4

2,20565E0

1,29106E-4

3,75002E1

2,61467E-1

3.4

relative error(%)

0,00

3.6

BioUML

5,23200E-5

2,87759E-3

6,23353E-6

1,55583E1

1,85105E0

1,78731E1

1,99667E2

2,75310E-1

4,64913E-2

1,29085E-3

7,75702E-9

6,51368E-8

3,43084E-4

2,31065E0

1,53728E-4

3,73643E1

2,83484E-1

3.6

ByoDyn

5,23200E-5

2,87759E-3

6,23353E-6

1,55583E1

1,85105E0

1,78731E1

1,99667E2

2,75310E-1

4,64913E-2

1,29085E-3

7,75702E-9

6,51368E-8

3,43084E-4

2,31065E0

1,53728E-4

3,73643E1

2,83484E-1

3.6

Jarnac

4,94814E-5

2,98445E-2

5,89431E-6

1,55490E1

1,84957E0

1,78577E1

1,99667E2

2,71326E-1

3,20476E-2

1,19948E-3

3,35237E-7

6,76440E-7

2,12920E-2

2,27759E0

1,42821E-4

3,73679E1

2,49937E-1

3.6

MathSBML

5,23200E-5

2,87759E-3

6,23353E-6

1,55583E1

1,85105E0

1,78731E1

1,99667E2

2,75310E-1

4,64914E-2

1,29085E-3

7,75574E-9

6,51317E-8

3,43085E-4

2,31065E0

1,53728E-4

3,73643E1

2,83484E-1

3.6

Oscill8 Core

5,23203E-5

2,87760E-3

6,23360E-6

1,55583E1

1,85105E0

1,78731E1

1,99667E2

2,75310E-1

4,64915E-2

1,29085E-3

7,75727E-9

6,51383E-8

3,43088E-4

2,31065E0

1,53729E-4

3,73643E1

2,83484E-1

3.6

SBToolbox2

5,25222E-5

2,87344E-3

6,26980E-6

1,55582E1

1,85132E0

1,78728E1

1,99670E2

2,75237E-1

4,65098E-2

1,29188E-3

7,65262E-9

6,43734E-8

3,41850E-4

2,31073E0

1,53496E-4

3,73645E1

2,83374E-1

3.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,23203E-5

2,87760E-3

6,23360E-6

1,55583E1

1,85105E0

1,78731E1

1,99667E2

2,75310E-1

4,64915E-2

1,29085E-3

7,75726E-9

6,51383E-8

3,43088E-4

2,31065E0

1,53729E-4

3,73643E1

2,83484E-1

3.6

VCell

5,23207E-5

2,87760E-3

6,23362E-6

1,55583E1

1,85105E0

1,78731E1

1,99667E2

2,75310E-1

4,64916E-2

1,29085E-3

7,75720E-9

6,51382E-8

3,43087E-4

2,31065E0

1,53729E-4

3,73643E1

2,83484E-1

3.6

copasi

5,23200E-5

2,87759E-3

6,23353E-6

1,55583E1

1,85105E0

1,78731E1

1,99667E2

2,75310E-1

4,64913E-2

1,29085E-3

7,75702E-9

6,51368E-8

3,43084E-4

2,31065E0

1,53728E-4

3,73643E1

2,83484E-1

3.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,04593E-5

9,54172E-4

1,23974E-7

1,73056E1

1,04721E-1

1,99479E1

1,99919E2

1,55883E-2

1,38565E-2

4,27851E-4

4,59418E-11

7,58568E-9

5,78566E-6

2,57267E0

2,59159E-6

3,73969E1

6,66835E-2

3.6

jsim

5,23200E-5

2,87759E-3

6,23353E-6

1,55583E1

1,85105E0

1,78731E1

1,99667E2

2,75310E-1

4,64913E-2

1,29085E-3

7,75702E-9

6,51368E-8

3,43084E-4

2,31065E0

1,53728E-4

3,73643E1

2,83484E-1

3.6

min

2,04593E-5

9,54172E-4

1,23974E-7

1,55490E1

1,04721E-1

1,78577E1

1,99667E2

1,55883E-2

1,38565E-2

4,27851E-4

4,59418E-11

7,58568E-9

5,78566E-6

2,27759E0

2,59159E-6

3,73643E1

6,66835E-2

3.6

max

5,25222E-5

2,98445E-2

6,26980E-6

1,73056E1

1,85132E0

1,99479E1

1,99919E2

2,75310E-1

4,65098E-2

1,29188E-3

3,35237E-7

6,76440E-7

2,12920E-2

2,57267E0

1,53729E-4

3,73969E1

2,83484E-1

3.6

mean

5,23200E-5

2,87759E-3

6,23353E-6

1,55583E1

1,85105E0

1,78731E1

1,99667E2

2,75310E-1

4,64914E-2

1,29085E-3

7,75702E-9

6,51368E-8

3,43085E-4

2,31065E0

1,53728E-4

3,73643E1

2,83484E-1

3.6

relative error(%)

0,00

3.8

BioUML

6,22573E-5

3,43215E-3

7,74490E-6

1,53713E1

1,90935E0

1,77898E1

1,99637E2

3,00265E-1

5,28925E-2

1,45611E-3

1,10046E-8

8,85026E-8

4,27283E-4

2,41355E0

1,81059E-4

3,72294E1

3,05769E-1

3.8

ByoDyn

6,22573E-5

3,43215E-3

7,74490E-6

1,53713E1

1,90935E0

1,77898E1

1,99637E2

3,00265E-1

5,28925E-2

1,45611E-3

1,10046E-8

8,85026E-8

4,27283E-4

2,41355E0

1,81059E-4

3,72294E1

3,05769E-1

3.8

Jarnac

5,85383E-5

3,45012E-2

7,28067E-6

1,53605E1

1,90754E0

1,77710E1

1,99638E2

2,95362E-1

3,57304E-2

1,34321E-3

4,62625E-7

8,87557E-7

2,59003E-2

2,37463E0

1,66982E-4

3,72338E1

2,66292E-1

3.8

MathSBML

6,22573E-5

3,43215E-3

7,74491E-6

1,53713E1

1,90935E0

1,77898E1

1,99637E2

3,00265E-1

5,28925E-2

1,45611E-3

1,10041E-8

8,85008E-8

4,27284E-4

2,41355E0

1,81059E-4

3,72294E1

3,05769E-1

3.8

Oscill8 Core

6,22577E-5

3,43217E-3

7,74498E-6

1,53713E1

1,90935E0

1,77898E1

1,99637E2

3,00265E-1

5,28926E-2

1,45611E-3

1,10049E-8

8,85046E-8

4,27287E-4

2,41355E0

1,81060E-4

3,72294E1

3,05769E-1

3.8

SBToolbox2

6,25070E-5

3,42803E-3

7,79435E-6

1,53708E1

1,90964E0

1,77895E1

1,99640E2

3,00171E-1

5,29102E-2

1,45717E-3

1,09380E-8

8,78543E-8

4,26087E-4

2,41366E0

1,80797E-4

3,72293E1

3,05634E-1

3.8

SBWOdeSolver

6,22576E-5

3,43217E-3

7,74498E-6

1,53713E1

1,90935E0

1,77898E1

1,99637E2

3,00265E-1

5,28926E-2

1,45611E-3

1,10049E-8

8,85045E-8

4,27287E-4

2,41355E0

1,81060E-4

3,72294E1

3,05769E-1

3.8

VCell

6,22581E-5

3,43217E-3

7,74500E-6

1,53713E1

1,90935E0

1,77898E1

1,99637E2

3,00265E-1

5,28927E-2

1,45611E-3

1,10048E-8

8,85043E-8

4,27286E-4

2,41355E0

1,81060E-4

3,72294E1

3,05769E-1

3.8

copasi

6,22573E-5

3,43215E-3

7,74490E-6

1,53713E1

1,90935E0

1,77898E1

1,99637E2

3,00265E-1

5,28925E-2

1,45611E-3

1,10046E-8

8,85027E-8

4,27283E-4

2,41355E0

1,81059E-4

3,72294E1

3,05769E-1

3.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,37995E-5

1,11167E-3

1,50815E-7

1,71731E1

1,08667E-1

1,99462E1

1,99914E2

1,71054E-2

1,53308E-2

4,71403E-4

6,20515E-11

9,79744E-9

7,04945E-6

2,69950E0

2,98604E-6

3,72669E1

6,99746E-2

3.8

jsim

6,22573E-5

3,43215E-3

7,74490E-6

1,53713E1

1,90935E0

1,77898E1

1,99637E2

3,00265E-1

5,28925E-2

1,45611E-3

1,10046E-8

8,85026E-8

4,27283E-4

2,41355E0

1,81059E-4

3,72294E1

3,05769E-1

3.8

min

2,37995E-5

1,11167E-3

1,50815E-7

1,53605E1

1,08667E-1

1,77710E1

1,99637E2

1,71054E-2

1,53308E-2

4,71403E-4

6,20515E-11

9,79744E-9

7,04945E-6

2,37463E0

2,98604E-6

3,72293E1

6,99746E-2

3.8

max

6,25070E-5

3,45012E-2

7,79435E-6

1,71731E1

1,90964E0

1,99462E1

1,99914E2

3,00265E-1

5,29102E-2

1,45717E-3

4,62625E-7

8,87557E-7

2,59003E-2

2,69950E0

1,81060E-4

3,72669E1

3,05769E-1

3.8

mean

6,22573E-5

3,43215E-3

7,74491E-6

1,53713E1

1,90935E0

1,77898E1

1,99637E2

3,00265E-1

5,28925E-2

1,45611E-3

1,10046E-8

8,85027E-8

4,27283E-4

2,41355E0

1,81059E-4

3,72294E1

3,05769E-1

3.8

relative error(%)

0,00

4.0

BioUML

7,33749E-5

4,05365E-3

9,50429E-6

1,51890E1

1,96432E0

1,77092E1

1,99607E2

3,25713E-1

5,97452E-2

1,63103E-3

1,53093E-8

1,18250E-7

5,25484E-4

2,51443E0

2,11166E-4

3,70955E1

3,28270E-1

4.0

ByoDyn

7,33749E-5

4,05365E-3

9,50429E-6

1,51890E1

1,96432E0

1,77092E1

1,99607E2

3,25713E-1

5,97452E-2

1,63103E-3

1,53093E-8

1,18250E-7

5,25484E-4

2,51443E0

2,11166E-4

3,70955E1

3,28270E-1

4.0

Jarnac

6,85772E-5

3,95057E-2

8,88048E-6

1,51767E1

1,96213E0

1,76868E1

1,99608E2

3,19757E-1

3,95505E-2

1,49328E-3

6,26191E-7

1,14520E-6

3,11237E-2

2,46907E0

1,93277E-4

3,71009E1

2,82290E-1

4.0

MathSBML

7,33749E-5

4,05365E-3

9,50429E-6

1,51890E1

1,96432E0

1,77092E1

1,99607E2

3,25713E-1

5,97453E-2

1,63103E-3

1,53078E-8

1,18245E-7

5,25485E-4

2,51443E0

2,11166E-4

3,70955E1

3,28270E-1

4.0

Oscill8 Core

7,33753E-5

4,05367E-3

9,50437E-6

1,51890E1

1,96432E0

1,77092E1

1,99607E2

3,25713E-1

5,97454E-2

1,63103E-3

1,53097E-8

1,18253E-7

5,25488E-4

2,51443E0

2,11166E-4

3,70955E1

3,28270E-1

4.0

SBToolbox2

7,36804E-5

4,05018E-3

9,57016E-6

1,51886E1

1,96472E0

1,77086E1

1,99610E2

3,25594E-1

5,97624E-2

1,63210E-3

1,53076E-8

1,17856E-7

5,24528E-4

2,51460E0

2,10892E-4

3,70954E1

3,28108E-1

4.0

SBWOdeSolver

7,33752E-5

4,05367E-3

9,50437E-6

1,51890E1

1,96432E0

1,77092E1

1,99607E2

3,25713E-1

5,97454E-2

1,63103E-3

1,53097E-8

1,18253E-7

5,25488E-4

2,51443E0

2,11166E-4

3,70955E1

3,28270E-1

4.0

VCell

7,33757E-5

4,05367E-3

9,50439E-6

1,51890E1

1,96432E0

1,77092E1

1,99607E2

3,25713E-1

5,97455E-2

1,63104E-3

1,53095E-8

1,18252E-7

5,25487E-4

2,51443E0

2,11166E-4

3,70955E1

3,28270E-1

4.0

copasi

7,33749E-5

4,05365E-3

9,50429E-6

1,51890E1

1,96432E0

1,77092E1

1,99607E2

3,25713E-1

5,97452E-2

1,63103E-3

1,53093E-8

1,18250E-7

5,25484E-4

2,51443E0

2,11166E-4

3,70955E1

3,28270E-1

4.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,74554E-5

1,28438E-3

1,81447E-7

1,70422E1

1,12457E-1

1,99446E1

1,99909E2

1,86675E-2

1,68674E-2

5,16494E-4

8,24227E-11

1,24788E-8

8,49442E-6

2,82481E0

3,41196E-6

3,71383E1

7,32149E-2

4.0

jsim

7,33749E-5

4,05365E-3

9,50429E-6

1,51890E1

1,96432E0

1,77092E1

1,99607E2

3,25713E-1

5,97452E-2

1,63103E-3

1,53093E-8

1,18250E-7

5,25484E-4

2,51443E0

2,11166E-4

3,70955E1

3,28270E-1

4.0

min

2,74554E-5

1,28438E-3

1,81447E-7

1,51767E1

1,12457E-1

1,76868E1

1,99607E2

1,86675E-2

1,68674E-2

5,16494E-4

8,24227E-11

1,24788E-8

8,49442E-6

2,46907E0

3,41196E-6

3,70954E1

7,32149E-2

4.0

max

7,36804E-5

3,95057E-2

9,57016E-6

1,70422E1

1,96472E0

1,99446E1

1,99909E2

3,25713E-1

5,97624E-2

1,63210E-3

6,26191E-7

1,14520E-6

3,11237E-2

2,82481E0

2,11166E-4

3,71383E1

3,28270E-1

4.0

mean

7,33749E-5

4,05365E-3

9,50429E-6

1,51890E1

1,96432E0

1,77092E1

1,99607E2

3,25713E-1

5,97453E-2

1,63103E-3

1,53093E-8

1,18250E-7

5,25484E-4

2,51443E0

2,11166E-4

3,70955E1

3,28270E-1

4.0

relative error(%)

0,00

4.2

BioUML

8,57309E-5

4,74546E-3

1,15335E-5

1,50114E1

2,01612E0

1,76314E1

1,99577E2

3,51600E-1

6,70490E-2

1,81540E-3

2,09242E-8

1,55616E-7

6,38941E-4

2,61336E0

2,44103E-4

3,69625E1

3,50939E-1

4.2

ByoDyn

8,57309E-5

4,74546E-3

1,15335E-5

1,50114E1

2,01612E0

1,76314E1

1,99577E2

3,51600E-1

6,70490E-2

1,81540E-3

2,09242E-8

1,55616E-7

6,38941E-4

2,61336E0

2,44103E-4

3,69625E1

3,50939E-1

4.2

Jarnac

7,96280E-5

4,48482E-2

1,07090E-5

1,49973E1

2,01349E0

1,76049E1

1,99577E2

3,44447E-1

4,34942E-2

1,64925E-3

8,32888E-7

1,45537E-6

3,69908E-2

2,56098E0

2,21687E-4

3,69692E1

2,97881E-1

4.2

MathSBML

8,57309E-5

4,74546E-3

1,15335E-5

1,50114E1

2,01612E0

1,76314E1

1,99577E2

3,51600E-1

6,70490E-2

1,81540E-3

2,09235E-8

1,55614E-7

6,38942E-4

2,61336E0

2,44103E-4

3,69625E1

3,50939E-1

4.2

Oscill8 Core

8,57313E-5

4,74548E-3

1,15336E-5

1,50114E1

2,01612E0

1,76314E1

1,99577E2

3,51600E-1

6,70491E-2

1,81540E-3

2,09247E-8

1,55619E-7

6,38946E-4

2,61336E0

2,44104E-4

3,69625E1

3,50939E-1

4.2

SBToolbox2

8,60456E-5

4,73971E-3

1,15976E-5

1,50108E1

2,01645E0

1,76313E1

1,99580E2

3,51500E-1

6,70657E-2

1,81661E-3

2,07384E-8

1,54289E-7

6,37103E-4

2,61344E0

2,43772E-4

3,69625E1

3,50791E-1

4.2

SBWOdeSolver

8,57313E-5

4,74548E-3

1,15336E-5

1,50114E1

2,01612E0

1,76314E1

1,99577E2

3,51600E-1

6,70491E-2

1,81540E-3

2,09247E-8

1,55619E-7

6,38946E-4

2,61336E0

2,44104E-4

3,69625E1

3,50939E-1

4.2

VCell

8,57317E-5

4,74548E-3

1,15336E-5

1,50114E1

2,01611E0

1,76314E1

1,99577E2

3,51600E-1

6,70493E-2

1,81540E-3

2,09245E-8

1,55619E-7

6,38944E-4

2,61336E0

2,44104E-4

3,69625E1

3,50939E-1

4.2

copasi

8,57309E-5

4,74546E-3

1,15335E-5

1,50114E1

2,01612E0

1,76314E1

1,99577E2

3,51600E-1

6,70490E-2

1,81540E-3

2,09242E-8

1,55616E-7

6,38941E-4

2,61336E0

2,44103E-4

3,69625E1

3,50939E-1

4.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,14359E-5

1,47275E-3

2,16133E-7

1,69129E1

1,16095E-1

1,99431E1

1,99904E2

2,02717E-2

1,84644E-2

5,63050E-4

1,07845E-10

1,56953E-8

1,01335E-5

2,94865E0

3,86944E-6

3,70111E1

7,64038E-2

4.2

jsim

8,57309E-5

4,74546E-3

1,15335E-5

1,50114E1

2,01612E0

1,76314E1

1,99577E2

3,51600E-1

6,70490E-2

1,81540E-3

2,09242E-8

1,55616E-7

6,38941E-4

2,61336E0

2,44103E-4

3,69625E1

3,50939E-1

4.2

min

3,14359E-5

1,47275E-3

2,16133E-7

1,49973E1

1,16095E-1

1,76049E1

1,99577E2

2,02717E-2

1,84644E-2

5,63050E-4

1,07845E-10

1,56953E-8

1,01335E-5

2,56098E0

3,86944E-6

3,69625E1

7,64038E-2

4.2

max

8,60456E-5

4,48482E-2

1,15976E-5

1,69129E1

2,01645E0

1,99431E1

1,99904E2

3,51600E-1

6,70657E-2

1,81661E-3

8,32888E-7

1,45537E-6

3,69908E-2

2,94865E0

2,44104E-4

3,70111E1

3,50939E-1

4.2

mean

8,57309E-5

4,74546E-3

1,15335E-5

1,50114E1

2,01612E0

1,76314E1

1,99577E2

3,51600E-1

6,70490E-2

1,81540E-3

2,09242E-8

1,55616E-7

6,38941E-4

2,61336E0

2,44103E-4

3,69625E1

3,50939E-1

4.2

relative error(%)

0,00

4.4

BioUML

9,93812E-5

5,51079E-3

1,38545E-5

1,48382E1

2,06488E0

1,75562E1

1,99545E2

3,77873E-1

7,48022E-2

2,00897E-3

2,81421E-8

2,01982E-7

7,68907E-4

2,71041E0

2,79914E-4

3,68305E1

3,73729E-1

4.4

ByoDyn

9,93812E-5

5,51079E-3

1,38545E-5

1,48382E1

2,06488E0

1,75562E1

1,99545E2

3,77873E-1

7,48022E-2

2,00897E-3

2,81421E-8

2,01982E-7

7,68907E-4

2,71041E0

2,79914E-4

3,68305E1

3,73729E-1

4.4

Jarnac

9,17164E-5

5,05173E-2

1,27810E-5

1,48223E1

2,06176E0

1,75251E1

1,99545E2

3,69375E-1

4,75481E-2

1,81064E-3

1,09033E-6

1,82421E-6

4,35265E-2

2,65043E0

2,52177E-4

3,68385E1

3,13022E-1

4.4

MathSBML

9,93813E-5

5,51079E-3

1,38545E-5

1,48382E1

2,06488E0

1,75562E1

1,99545E2

3,77873E-1

7,48023E-2

2,00897E-3

2,81404E-8

2,01977E-7

7,68909E-4

2,71041E0

2,79914E-4

3,68305E1

3,73729E-1

4.4

Oscill8 Core

9,93816E-5

5,51081E-3

1,38546E-5

1,48382E1

2,06488E0

1,75562E1

1,99545E2

3,77873E-1

7,48024E-2

2,00897E-3

2,81427E-8

2,01986E-7

7,68913E-4

2,71041E0

2,79915E-4

3,68305E1

3,73729E-1

4.4

SBToolbox2

9,97419E-5

5,50451E-3

1,39304E-5

1,48380E1

2,06529E0

1,75558E1

1,99544E2

3,77759E-1

7,48164E-2

2,01014E-3

2,79858E-8

2,00686E-7

7,66942E-4

2,71059E0

2,79542E-4

3,68306E1

3,73568E-1

4.4

SBWOdeSolver

9,93816E-5

5,51081E-3

1,38545E-5

1,48382E1

2,06488E0

1,75562E1

1,99545E2

3,77873E-1

7,48024E-2

2,00897E-3

2,81427E-8

2,01986E-7

7,68913E-4

2,71041E0

2,79915E-4

3,68305E1

3,73729E-1

4.4

VCell

9,93821E-5

5,51080E-3

1,38546E-5

1,48382E1

2,06488E0

1,75562E1

1,99545E2

3,77873E-1

7,48025E-2

2,00898E-3

2,81425E-8

2,01985E-7

7,68911E-4

2,71041E0

2,79915E-4

3,68305E1

3,73729E-1

4.4

copasi

9,93812E-5

5,51079E-3

1,38545E-5

1,48382E1

2,06488E0

1,75562E1

1,99545E2

3,77873E-1

7,48022E-2

2,00897E-3

2,81421E-8

2,01982E-7

7,68907E-4

2,71041E0

2,79914E-4

3,68305E1

3,73729E-1

4.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,57492E-5

1,67724E-3

2,55128E-7

1,67851E1

1,19586E-1

1,99417E1

1,99899E2

2,19153E-2

2,01202E-2

6,10999E-4

1,39194E-10

1,95165E-8

1,19795E-5

3,07103E0

4,35843E-6

3,68852E1

7,95409E-2

4.4

jsim

9,93812E-5

5,51079E-3

1,38545E-5

1,48382E1

2,06488E0

1,75562E1

1,99545E2

3,77873E-1

7,48022E-2

2,00897E-3

2,81421E-8

2,01982E-7

7,68907E-4

2,71041E0

2,79914E-4

3,68305E1

3,73729E-1

4.4

min

3,57492E-5

1,67724E-3

2,55128E-7

1,48223E1

1,19586E-1

1,75251E1

1,99544E2

2,19153E-2

2,01202E-2

6,10999E-4

1,39194E-10

1,95165E-8

1,19795E-5

2,65043E0

4,35843E-6

3,68305E1

7,95409E-2

4.4

max

9,97419E-5

5,05173E-2

1,39304E-5

1,67851E1

2,06529E0

1,99417E1

1,99899E2

3,77873E-1

7,48164E-2

2,01014E-3

1,09033E-6

1,82421E-6

4,35265E-2

3,07103E0

2,79915E-4

3,68852E1

3,73729E-1

4.4

mean

9,93812E-5

5,51079E-3

1,38545E-5

1,48382E1

2,06488E0

1,75562E1

1,99545E2

3,77873E-1

7,48023E-2

2,00897E-3

2,81421E-8

2,01982E-7

7,68908E-4

2,71041E0

2,79914E-4

3,68305E1

3,73729E-1

4.4

relative error(%)

0,00

4.6

BioUML

1,14379E-4

6,35273E-3

1,64888E-5

1,46692E1

2,11075E0

1,74835E1

1,99513E2

4,04485E-1

8,30024E-2

2,21151E-3

3,72980E-8

2,58879E-7

9,16632E-4

2,80564E0

3,18629E-4

3,66995E1

3,96599E-1

4.6

ByoDyn

1,14379E-4

6,35273E-3

1,64888E-5

1,46692E1

2,11075E0

1,74835E1

1,99513E2

4,04485E-1

8,30024E-2

2,21151E-3

3,72980E-8

2,58879E-7

9,16632E-4

2,80564E0

3,18629E-4

3,66995E1

3,96599E-1

4.6

Jarnac

1,04864E-4

5,64999E-2

1,51102E-5

1,46513E1

2,10709E0

1,74474E1

1,99513E2

3,94485E-1

5,16985E-2

1,97700E-3

1,40679E-6

2,25792E-6

5,07526E-2

2,73749E0

2,84703E-4

3,67090E1

3,27675E-1

4.6

MathSBML

1,14379E-4

6,35272E-3

1,64888E-5

1,46692E1

2,11075E0

1,74835E1

1,99513E2

4,04485E-1

8,30024E-2

2,21151E-3

3,72971E-8

2,58876E-7

9,16634E-4

2,80564E0

3,18628E-4

3,66995E1

3,96598E-1

4.6

Oscill8 Core

1,14380E-4

6,35275E-3

1,64889E-5

1,46692E1

2,11075E0

1,74835E1

1,99513E2

4,04485E-1

8,30026E-2

2,21151E-3

3,72987E-8

2,58882E-7

9,16638E-4

2,80564E0

3,18629E-4

3,66995E1

3,96599E-1

4.6

SBToolbox2

1,14797E-4

6,34701E-3

1,65831E-5

1,46687E1

2,11124E0

1,74834E1

1,99510E2

4,04354E-1

8,30133E-2

2,21262E-3

3,72706E-8

2,58071E-7

9,14934E-4

2,80584E0

3,18225E-4

3,66992E1

3,96421E-1

4.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,14380E-4

6,35275E-3

1,64889E-5

1,46692E1

2,11075E0

1,74835E1

1,99513E2

4,04485E-1

8,30026E-2

2,21151E-3

3,72987E-8

2,58882E-7

9,16638E-4

2,80564E0

3,18629E-4

3,66995E1

3,96599E-1

4.6

VCell

1,14380E-4

6,35274E-3

1,64890E-5

1,46692E1

2,11075E0

1,74835E1

1,99513E2

4,04486E-1

8,30027E-2

2,21151E-3

3,72984E-8

2,58882E-7

9,16636E-4

2,80564E0

3,18629E-4

3,66995E1

3,96599E-1

4.6

copasi

1,14379E-4

6,35273E-3

1,64888E-5

1,46692E1

2,11075E0

1,74835E1

1,99513E2

4,04485E-1

8,30024E-2

2,21151E-3

3,72980E-8

2,58879E-7

9,16632E-4

2,80564E0

3,18629E-4

3,66995E1

3,96599E-1

4.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,04027E-5

1,89822E-3

2,98687E-7

1,66589E1

1,22936E-1

1,99405E1

1,99894E2

2,35958E-2

2,18330E-2

6,60271E-4

1,77433E-10

2,40168E-8

1,40449E-5

3,19198E0

4,87882E-6

3,67606E1

8,26257E-2

4.6

jsim

1,14379E-4

6,35273E-3

1,64888E-5

1,46692E1

2,11075E0

1,74835E1

1,99513E2

4,04485E-1

8,30024E-2

2,21151E-3

3,72980E-8

2,58879E-7

9,16632E-4

2,80564E0

3,18629E-4

3,66995E1

3,96599E-1

4.6

min

4,04027E-5

1,89822E-3

2,98687E-7

1,46513E1

1,22936E-1

1,74474E1

1,99510E2

2,35958E-2

2,18330E-2

6,60271E-4

1,77433E-10

2,40168E-8

1,40449E-5

2,73749E0

4,87882E-6

3,66992E1

8,26257E-2

4.6

max

1,14797E-4

5,64999E-2

1,65831E-5

1,66589E1

2,11124E0

1,99405E1

1,99894E2

4,04486E-1

8,30133E-2

2,21262E-3

1,40679E-6

2,25792E-6

5,07526E-2

3,19198E0

3,18629E-4

3,67606E1

3,96599E-1

4.6

mean

1,14379E-4

6,35273E-3

1,64888E-5

1,46692E1

2,11075E0

1,74835E1

1,99513E2

4,04485E-1

8,30024E-2

2,21151E-3

3,72980E-8

2,58879E-7

9,16633E-4

2,80564E0

3,18629E-4

3,66995E1

3,96599E-1

4.6

relative error(%)

0,00

4.8

BioUML

1,30776E-4

7,27422E-3

1,94582E-5

1,45043E1

2,15386E0

1,74133E1

1,99480E2

4,31391E-1

9,16462E-2

2,42274E-3

4,87719E-8

3,27989E-7

1,08335E-3

2,89913E0

3,60266E-4

3,65693E1

4,19508E-1

4.8

ByoDyn

1,30776E-4

7,27422E-3

1,94582E-5

1,45043E1

2,15386E0

1,74133E1

1,99480E2

4,31391E-1

9,16462E-2

2,42274E-3

4,87719E-8

3,27989E-7

1,08335E-3

2,89913E0

3,60266E-4

3,65693E1

4,19508E-1

4.8

Jarnac

1,19090E-4

6,27821E-2

1,77097E-5

1,44844E1

2,14960E0

1,73717E1

1,99481E2

4,19727E-1

5,59323E-2

2,14786E-3

1,79112E-6

2,76269E-6

5,86874E-2

2,82221E0

3,19208E-4

3,65806E1

3,41812E-1

4.8

MathSBML

1,30776E-4

7,27422E-3

1,94582E-5

1,45043E1

2,15386E0

1,74133E1

1,99480E2

4,31391E-1

9,16463E-2

2,42274E-3

4,87700E-8

3,27984E-7

1,08336E-3

2,89913E0

3,60266E-4

3,65693E1

4,19508E-1

4.8

Oscill8 Core

1,30777E-4

7,27424E-3

1,94583E-5

1,45043E1

2,15386E0

1,74133E1

1,99480E2

4,31391E-1

9,16464E-2

2,42274E-3

4,87727E-8

3,27994E-7

1,08336E-3

2,89913E0

3,60267E-4

3,65693E1

4,19508E-1

4.8

SBToolbox2

1,31207E-4

7,26696E-3

1,95546E-5

1,45038E1

2,15429E0

1,74129E1

1,99480E2

4,31267E-1

9,16559E-2

2,42392E-3

4,85515E-8

3,26280E-7

1,08098E-3

2,89929E0

3,59833E-4

3,65694E1

4,19338E-1

4.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,30777E-4

7,27424E-3

1,94583E-5

1,45043E1

2,15386E0

1,74133E1

1,99480E2

4,31391E-1

9,16464E-2

2,42274E-3

4,87727E-8

3,27994E-7

1,08336E-3

2,89913E0

3,60267E-4

3,65693E1

4,19508E-1

4.8

VCell

1,30777E-4

7,27424E-3

1,94584E-5

1,45043E1

2,15386E0

1,74133E1

1,99480E2

4,31391E-1

9,16465E-2

2,42275E-3

4,87724E-8

3,27993E-7

1,08336E-3

2,89913E0

3,60267E-4

3,65693E1

4,19508E-1

4.8

copasi

1,30776E-4

7,27422E-3

1,94582E-5

1,45043E1

2,15386E0

1,74133E1

1,99480E2

4,31391E-1

9,16462E-2

2,42274E-3

4,87719E-8

3,27989E-7

1,08335E-3

2,89913E0

3,60266E-4

3,65693E1

4,19508E-1

4.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,54035E-5

2,13609E-3

3,47055E-7

1,65341E1

1,26148E-1

1,99393E1

1,99889E2

2,53107E-2

2,36012E-2

7,10797E-4

2,23615E-10

2,92747E-8

1,63423E-5

3,31152E0

5,43041E-6

3,66374E1

8,56579E-2

4.8

jsim

1,30776E-4

7,27422E-3

1,94582E-5

1,45043E1

2,15386E0

1,74133E1

1,99480E2

4,31391E-1

9,16463E-2

2,42274E-3

4,87719E-8

3,27989E-7

1,08335E-3

2,89913E0

3,60266E-4

3,65693E1

4,19508E-1

4.8

min

4,54035E-5

2,13609E-3

3,47055E-7

1,44844E1

1,26148E-1

1,73717E1

1,99480E2

2,53107E-2

2,36012E-2

7,10797E-4

2,23615E-10

2,92747E-8

1,63423E-5

2,82221E0

5,43041E-6

3,65693E1

8,56579E-2

4.8

max

1,31207E-4

6,27821E-2

1,95546E-5

1,65341E1

2,15429E0

1,99393E1

1,99889E2

4,31391E-1

9,16559E-2

2,42392E-3

1,79112E-6

2,76269E-6

5,86874E-2

3,31152E0

3,60267E-4

3,66374E1

4,19508E-1

4.8

mean

1,30776E-4

7,27422E-3

1,94582E-5

1,45043E1

2,15386E0

1,74133E1

1,99480E2

4,31391E-1

9,16463E-2

2,42274E-3

4,87719E-8

3,27989E-7

1,08335E-3

2,89913E0

3,60266E-4

3,65693E1

4,19508E-1

4.8

relative error(%)

0,00

5.0

BioUML

1,48620E-4

8,27806E-3

2,27839E-5

1,43434E1

2,19434E0

1,73454E1

1,99447E2

4,58547E-1

1,00730E-1

2,64241E-3

6,29909E-8

4,11155E-7

1,27029E-3

2,99092E0

4,04835E-4

3,64401E1

4,42421E-1

5.0

ByoDyn

1,48620E-4

8,27806E-3

2,27839E-5

1,43434E1

2,19434E0

1,73454E1

1,99447E2

4,58547E-1

1,00730E-1

2,64241E-3

6,29909E-8

4,11155E-7

1,27029E-3

2,99092E0

4,04835E-4

3,64401E1

4,42421E-1

5.0

Jarnac

1,34407E-4

6,93489E-2

2,05918E-5

1,43214E1

2,18943E0

1,72979E1

1,99448E2

4,45053E-1

6,02366E-2

2,32277E-3

2,25273E-6

3,34465E-6

6,73457E-2

2,90467E0

3,55627E-4

3,64533E1

3,55406E-1

5.0

MathSBML

1,48620E-4

8,27806E-3

2,27839E-5

1,43434E1

2,19434E0

1,73454E1

1,99447E2

4,58547E-1

1,00730E-1

2,64241E-3

6,29899E-8

4,11152E-7

1,27029E-3

2,99092E0

4,04835E-4

3,64401E1

4,42421E-1

5.0

Oscill8 Core

1,48621E-4

8,27809E-3

2,27840E-5

1,43434E1

2,19434E0

1,73454E1

1,99447E2

4,58547E-1

1,00730E-1

2,64241E-3

6,29919E-8

4,11160E-7

1,27030E-3

2,99092E0

4,04836E-4

3,64401E1

4,42421E-1

5.0

SBToolbox2

1,49085E-4

8,26985E-3

2,28875E-5

1,43430E1

2,19480E0

1,73450E1

1,99450E2

4,58420E-1

1,00735E-1

2,64350E-3

6,27460E-8

4,09240E-7

1,26760E-3

2,99110E0

4,04360E-4

3,64400E1

4,42250E-1

5.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,48621E-4

8,27809E-3

2,27840E-5

1,43434E1

2,19434E0

1,73454E1

1,99447E2

4,58547E-1

1,00730E-1

2,64241E-3

6,29919E-8

4,11160E-7

1,27030E-3

2,99092E0

4,04836E-4

3,64401E1

4,42421E-1

5.0

VCell

1,48622E-4

8,27808E-3

2,27840E-5

1,43434E1

2,19434E0

1,73454E1

1,99447E2

4,58547E-1

1,00730E-1

2,64241E-3

6,29915E-8

4,11159E-7

1,27030E-3

2,99092E0

4,04836E-4

3,64401E1

4,42421E-1

5.0

copasi

1,48620E-4

8,27806E-3

2,27839E-5

1,43434E1

2,19434E0

1,73454E1

1,99447E2

4,58547E-1

1,00730E-1

2,64241E-3

6,29909E-8

4,11155E-7

1,27029E-3

2,99092E0

4,04835E-4

3,64401E1

4,42421E-1

5.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,07580E-5

2,39120E-3

4,00476E-7

1,64108E1

1,29227E-1

1,99383E1

1,99884E2

2,70577E-2

2,54231E-2

7,62510E-4

2,78886E-10

3,53727E-8

1,88836E-5

3,42967E0

6,01292E-6

3,65154E1

8,86372E-2

5.0

jsim

1,48620E-4

8,27806E-3

2,27839E-5

1,43434E1

2,19434E0

1,73454E1

1,99447E2

4,58547E-1

1,00730E-1

2,64241E-3

6,29909E-8

4,11155E-7

1,27029E-3

2,99092E0

4,04835E-4

3,64401E1

4,42421E-1

5.0

min

5,07580E-5

2,39120E-3

4,00476E-7

1,43214E1

1,29227E-1

1,72979E1

1,99447E2

2,70577E-2

2,54231E-2

7,62510E-4

2,78886E-10

3,53727E-8

1,88836E-5

2,90467E0

6,01292E-6

3,64400E1

8,86372E-2

5.0

max

1,49085E-4

6,93489E-2

2,28875E-5

1,64108E1

2,19480E0

1,99383E1

1,99884E2

4,58547E-1

1,00735E-1

2,64350E-3

2,25273E-6

3,34465E-6

6,73457E-2

3,42967E0

4,04836E-4

3,65154E1

4,42421E-1

5.0

mean

1,48620E-4

8,27806E-3

2,27839E-5

1,43434E1

2,19434E0

1,73454E1

1,99447E2

4,58547E-1

1,00730E-1

2,64241E-3

6,29909E-8

4,11155E-7

1,27029E-3

2,99092E0

4,04835E-4

3,64401E1

4,42421E-1

5.0

relative error(%)

0,00

5.2

BioUML

1,67958E-4

9,36691E-3

2,64866E-5

1,41863E1

2,23232E0

1,72798E1

1,99414E2

4,85914E-1

1,10248E-1

2,87022E-3

8,04316E-8

5,10374E-7

1,47865E-3

3,08108E0

4,52333E-4

3,63117E1

4,65304E-1

5.2

ByoDyn

1,67958E-4

9,36691E-3

2,64866E-5

1,41863E1

2,23232E0

1,72798E1

1,99414E2

4,85914E-1

1,10248E-1

2,87022E-3

8,04316E-8

5,10374E-7

1,47865E-3

3,08108E0

4,52333E-4

3,63117E1

4,65304E-1

5.2

Jarnac

1,50828E-4

7,61848E-2

2,37676E-5

1,41620E1

2,22668E0

1,72258E1

1,99414E2

4,70419E-1

6,45990E-2

2,50128E-3

2,80154E-6

4,00980E-6

7,67390E-2

2,98494E0

3,93884E-4

3,63270E1

3,68439E-1

5.2

MathSBML

1,67958E-4

9,36691E-3

2,64867E-5

1,41863E1

2,23232E0

1,72798E1

1,99414E2

4,85914E-1

1,10248E-1

2,87022E-3

8,04297E-8

5,10368E-7

1,47865E-3

3,08108E0

4,52333E-4

3,63117E1

4,65304E-1

5.2

Oscill8 Core

1,67959E-4

9,36693E-3

2,64868E-5

1,41863E1

2,23232E0

1,72798E1

1,99414E2

4,85914E-1

1,10248E-1

2,87022E-3

8,04328E-8

5,10380E-7

1,47866E-3

3,08108E0

4,52334E-4

3,63117E1

4,65304E-1

5.2

SBToolbox2

1,68470E-4

9,35892E-3

2,66056E-5

1,41856E1

2,23286E0

1,72796E1

1,99410E2

4,85772E-1

1,10245E-1

2,87117E-3

8,03582E-8

5,09082E-7

1,47613E-3

3,08126E0

4,51826E-4

3,63116E1

4,65117E-1

5.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,67959E-4

9,36693E-3

2,64868E-5

1,41863E1

2,23232E0

1,72798E1

1,99414E2

4,85914E-1

1,10248E-1

2,87022E-3

8,04328E-8

5,10380E-7

1,47866E-3

3,08108E0

4,52334E-4

3,63117E1

4,65304E-1

5.2

VCell

1,67959E-4

9,36693E-3

2,64868E-5

1,41863E1

2,23232E0

1,72798E1

1,99414E2

4,85914E-1

1,10248E-1

2,87023E-3

8,04323E-8

5,10379E-7

1,47865E-3

3,08108E0

4,52334E-4

3,63117E1

4,65304E-1

5.2

copasi

1,67958E-4

9,36691E-3

2,64866E-5

1,41863E1

2,23232E0

1,72798E1

1,99414E2

4,85914E-1

1,10248E-1

2,87022E-3

8,04316E-8

5,10374E-7

1,47865E-3

3,08108E0

4,52333E-4

3,63117E1

4,65304E-1

5.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,64721E-5

2,66385E-3

4,59183E-7

1,62890E1

1,32178E-1

1,99373E1

1,99878E2

2,88344E-2

2,72970E-2

8,15345E-4

3,44483E-10

4,23977E-8

2,16808E-5

3,54645E0

6,62599E-6

3,63947E1

9,15634E-2

5.2

jsim

1,67958E-4

9,36691E-3

2,64866E-5

1,41863E1

2,23232E0

1,72798E1

1,99414E2

4,85914E-1

1,10248E-1

2,87022E-3

8,04316E-8

5,10374E-7

1,47865E-3

3,08108E0

4,52333E-4

3,63117E1

4,65304E-1

5.2

min

5,64721E-5

2,66385E-3

4,59183E-7

1,41620E1

1,32178E-1

1,72258E1

1,99410E2

2,88344E-2

2,72970E-2

8,15345E-4

3,44483E-10

4,23977E-8

2,16808E-5

2,98494E0

6,62599E-6

3,63116E1

9,15634E-2

5.2

max

1,68470E-4

7,61848E-2

2,66056E-5

1,62890E1

2,23286E0

1,99373E1

1,99878E2

4,85914E-1

1,10248E-1

2,87117E-3

2,80154E-6

4,00980E-6

7,67390E-2

3,54645E0

4,52334E-4

3,63947E1

4,65304E-1

5.2

mean

1,67958E-4

9,36691E-3

2,64867E-5

1,41863E1

2,23232E0

1,72798E1

1,99414E2

4,85914E-1

1,10248E-1

2,87022E-3

8,04316E-8

5,10374E-7

1,47865E-3

3,08108E0

4,52333E-4

3,63117E1

4,65304E-1

5.2

relative error(%)

0,00

5.4

BioUML

1,88833E-4

1,05433E-2

3,05870E-5

1,40329E1

2,26790E0

1,72164E1

1,99379E2

5,13455E-1

1,20195E-1

3,10591E-3

1,01621E-7

6,27807E-7

1,70960E-3

3,16965E0

5,02750E-4

3,61842E1

4,88124E-1

5.4

ByoDyn

1,88833E-4

1,05433E-2

3,05870E-5

1,40329E1

2,26790E0

1,72164E1

1,99379E2

5,13455E-1

1,20195E-1

3,10591E-3

1,01621E-7

6,27807E-7

1,70960E-3

3,16965E0

5,02750E-4

3,61842E1

4,88124E-1

5.4

Jarnac

1,68359E-4

8,32736E-2

2,72474E-5

1,40063E1

2,26148E0

1,71555E1

1,99380E2

4,95785E-1

6,90073E-2

2,68294E-3

3,44790E-6

4,76398E-6

8,68757E-2

3,06307E0

4,33898E-4

3,62019E1

3,80896E-1

5.4

MathSBML

1,88833E-4

1,05433E-2

3,05870E-5

1,40329E1

2,26790E0

1,72164E1

1,99379E2

5,13455E-1

1,20195E-1

3,10591E-3

1,01620E-7

6,27804E-7

1,70960E-3

3,16965E0

5,02750E-4

3,61842E1

4,88124E-1

5.4

Oscill8 Core

1,88834E-4

1,05433E-2

3,05871E-5

1,40329E1

2,26790E0

1,72164E1

1,99379E2

5,13455E-1

1,20195E-1

3,10591E-3

1,01623E-7

6,27813E-7

1,70961E-3

3,16965E0

5,02751E-4

3,61842E1

4,88124E-1

5.4

SBToolbox2

1,89361E-4

1,05341E-2

3,07069E-5

1,40323E1

2,26838E0

1,72156E1

1,99380E2

5,13325E-1

1,20195E-1

3,10692E-3

1,01254E-7

6,25265E-7

1,70637E-3

3,16982E0

5,02221E-4

3,61842E1

4,87949E-1

5.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,88834E-4

1,05433E-2

3,05871E-5

1,40329E1

2,26790E0

1,72164E1

1,99379E2

5,13455E-1

1,20195E-1

3,10591E-3

1,01623E-7

6,27813E-7

1,70961E-3

3,16965E0

5,02751E-4

3,61842E1

4,88124E-1

5.4

VCell

1,88834E-4

1,05433E-2

3,05872E-5

1,40329E1

2,26789E0

1,72164E1

1,99379E2

5,13455E-1

1,20195E-1

3,10591E-3

1,01622E-7

6,27812E-7

1,70960E-3

3,16965E0

5,02751E-4

3,61842E1

4,88124E-1

5.4

copasi

1,88833E-4

1,05433E-2

3,05870E-5

1,40329E1

2,26790E0

1,72164E1

1,99379E2

5,13455E-1

1,20195E-1

3,10591E-3

1,01622E-7

6,27807E-7

1,70960E-3

3,16965E0

5,02750E-4

3,61842E1

4,88124E-1

5.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,25512E-5

2,95436E-3

5,23404E-7

1,61685E1

1,35005E-1

1,99364E1

1,99873E2

3,06388E-2

2,92214E-2

8,69238E-4

4,21734E-10

5,04401E-8

2,47453E-5

3,66190E0

7,26923E-6

3,62752E1

9,44363E-2

5.4

jsim

1,88833E-4

1,05433E-2

3,05870E-5

1,40329E1

2,26790E0

1,72164E1

1,99379E2

5,13455E-1

1,20195E-1

3,10591E-3

1,01622E-7

6,27807E-7

1,70960E-3

3,16965E0

5,02750E-4

3,61842E1

4,88124E-1

5.4

min

6,25512E-5

2,95436E-3

5,23404E-7

1,40063E1

1,35005E-1

1,71555E1

1,99379E2

3,06388E-2

2,92214E-2

8,69238E-4

4,21734E-10

5,04401E-8

2,47453E-5

3,06307E0

7,26923E-6

3,61842E1

9,44363E-2

5.4

max

1,89361E-4

8,32736E-2

3,07069E-5

1,61685E1

2,26838E0

1,99364E1

1,99873E2

5,13455E-1

1,20195E-1

3,10692E-3

3,44790E-6

4,76398E-6

8,68757E-2

3,66190E0

5,02751E-4

3,62752E1

4,88124E-1

5.4

mean

1,88833E-4

1,05433E-2

3,05870E-5

1,40329E1

2,26790E0

1,72164E1

1,99379E2

5,13455E-1

1,20195E-1

3,10591E-3

1,01622E-7

6,27807E-7

1,70960E-3

3,16965E0

5,02750E-4

3,61842E1

4,88124E-1

5.4

relative error(%)

0,00

5.6

BioUML

2,11287E-4

1,18095E-2

3,51048E-5

1,38831E1

2,30119E0

1,71551E1

1,99345E2

5,41135E-1

1,30565E-1

3,34917E-3

1,27141E-7

7,65773E-7

1,96428E-3

3,25670E0

5,56065E-4

3,60576E1

5,10852E-1

5.6

ByoDyn

2,11287E-4

1,18095E-2

3,51048E-5

1,38831E1

2,30119E0

1,71551E1

1,99345E2

5,41135E-1

1,30565E-1

3,34917E-3

1,27141E-7

7,65773E-7

1,96428E-3

3,25670E0

5,56065E-4

3,60576E1

5,10852E-1

5.6

Jarnac

1,87006E-4

9,05989E-2

3,10403E-5

1,38540E1

2,29393E0

1,70868E1

1,99346E2

5,21113E-1

7,34501E-2

2,86734E-3

4,20254E-6

5,61280E-6

9,77609E-2

3,13914E0

4,75580E-4

3,60778E1

3,92767E-1

5.6

MathSBML

2,11287E-4

1,18095E-2

3,51048E-5

1,38831E1

2,30119E0

1,71551E1

1,99345E2

5,41135E-1

1,30565E-1

3,34917E-3

1,27139E-7

7,65768E-7

1,96428E-3

3,25670E0

5,56065E-4

3,60576E1

5,10852E-1

5.6

Oscill8 Core

2,11287E-4

1,18095E-2

3,51050E-5

1,38831E1

2,30119E0

1,71551E1

1,99345E2

5,41135E-1

1,30565E-1

3,34917E-3

1,27142E-7

7,65780E-7

1,96429E-3

3,25670E0

5,56066E-4

3,60576E1

5,10852E-1

5.6

SBToolbox2

2,11845E-4

1,17986E-2

3,52313E-5

1,38825E1

2,30170E0

1,71547E1

1,99346E2

5,41012E-1

1,30563E-1

3,35026E-3

1,26636E-7

7,62526E-7

1,96045E-3

3,25689E0

5,55496E-4

3,60574E1

5,10682E-1

5.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,11287E-4

1,18095E-2

3,51050E-5

1,38831E1

2,30119E0

1,71551E1

1,99345E2

5,41135E-1

1,30565E-1

3,34917E-3

1,27142E-7

7,65780E-7

1,96429E-3

3,25670E0

5,56066E-4

3,60576E1

5,10852E-1

5.6

VCell

2,11288E-4

1,18095E-2

3,51050E-5

1,38831E1

2,30119E0

1,71551E1

1,99345E2

5,41135E-1

1,30565E-1

3,34918E-3

1,27142E-7

7,65779E-7

1,96428E-3

3,25670E0

5,56065E-4

3,60576E1

5,10852E-1

5.6

copasi

2,11287E-4

1,18095E-2

3,51048E-5

1,38831E1

2,30119E0

1,71551E1

1,99345E2

5,41135E-1

1,30565E-1

3,34917E-3

1,27141E-7

7,65773E-7

1,96428E-3

3,25670E0

5,56065E-4

3,60576E1

5,10852E-1

5.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,90002E-5

3,26299E-3

5,93359E-7

1,60495E1

1,37711E-1

1,99357E1

1,99868E2

3,24687E-2

3,11946E-2

9,24126E-4

5,12061E-10

5,95944E-8

2,80884E-5

3,77602E0

7,94214E-6

3,61570E1

9,72558E-2

5.6

jsim

2,11287E-4

1,18095E-2

3,51048E-5

1,38831E1

2,30119E0

1,71551E1

1,99345E2

5,41135E-1

1,30565E-1

3,34917E-3

1,27141E-7

7,65773E-7

1,96428E-3

3,25670E0

5,56065E-4

3,60576E1

5,10852E-1

5.6

min

6,90002E-5

3,26299E-3

5,93359E-7

1,38540E1

1,37711E-1

1,70868E1

1,99345E2

3,24687E-2

3,11946E-2

9,24126E-4

5,12061E-10

5,95944E-8

2,80884E-5

3,13914E0

7,94214E-6

3,60574E1

9,72558E-2

5.6

max

2,11845E-4

9,05989E-2

3,52313E-5

1,60495E1

2,30170E0

1,99357E1

1,99868E2

5,41135E-1

1,30565E-1

3,35026E-3

4,20254E-6

5,61280E-6

9,77609E-2

3,77602E0

5,56066E-4

3,61570E1

5,10852E-1

5.6

mean

2,11287E-4

1,18095E-2

3,51048E-5

1,38831E1

2,30119E0

1,71551E1

1,99345E2

5,41135E-1

1,30565E-1

3,34917E-3

1,27141E-7

7,65773E-7

1,96428E-3

3,25670E0

5,56065E-4

3,60576E1

5,10852E-1

5.6

relative error(%)

0,00

5.8

BioUML

2,35357E-4

1,31678E-2

4,00595E-5

1,37366E1

2,33231E0

1,70959E1

1,99310E2

5,68921E-1

1,41352E-1

3,59973E-3

1,57624E-7

9,26756E-7

2,24380E-3

3,34226E0

6,12249E-4

3,59318E1

5,33462E-1

5.8

ByoDyn

2,35357E-4

1,31678E-2

4,00595E-5

1,37366E1

2,33231E0

1,70959E1

1,99310E2

5,68921E-1

1,41352E-1

3,59973E-3

1,57624E-7

9,26756E-7

2,24380E-3

3,34226E0

6,12249E-4

3,59318E1

5,33462E-1

5.8

Jarnac

2,06770E-4

9,81443E-2

3,51546E-5

1,37051E1

2,32413E0

1,70197E1

1,99311E2

5,46369E-1

7,79164E-2

3,05406E-3

5,07648E-6

6,56158E-6

1,09397E-1

3,21320E0

5,18838E-4

3,59549E1

4,04046E-1

5.8

MathSBML

2,35357E-4

1,31678E-2

4,00595E-5

1,37366E1

2,33231E0

1,70959E1

1,99310E2

5,68921E-1

1,41352E-1

3,59973E-3

1,57621E-7

9,26750E-7

2,24381E-3

3,34226E0

6,12249E-4

3,59318E1

5,33462E-1

5.8

Oscill8 Core

2,35358E-4

1,31678E-2

4,00596E-5

1,37366E1

2,33231E0

1,70959E1

1,99310E2

5,68921E-1

1,41352E-1

3,59973E-3

1,57625E-7

9,26763E-7

2,24381E-3

3,34226E0

6,12250E-4

3,59318E1

5,33462E-1

5.8

SBToolbox2

2,35965E-4

1,31568E-2

4,02042E-5

1,37361E1

2,33293E0

1,70957E1

1,99310E2

5,68784E-1

1,41341E-1

3,60063E-3

1,57401E-7

9,24447E-7

2,24013E-3

3,34246E0

6,11620E-4

3,59315E1

5,33280E-1

5.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,35358E-4

1,31678E-2

4,00596E-5

1,37366E1

2,33231E0

1,70959E1

1,99310E2

5,68921E-1

1,41352E-1

3,59973E-3

1,57625E-7

9,26763E-7

2,24381E-3

3,34226E0

6,12250E-4

3,59318E1

5,33462E-1

5.8

VCell

2,35359E-4

1,31678E-2

4,00596E-5

1,37366E1

2,33231E0

1,70959E1

1,99310E2

5,68921E-1

1,41352E-1

3,59973E-3

1,57625E-7

9,26762E-7

2,24381E-3

3,34226E0

6,12250E-4

3,59318E1

5,33462E-1

5.8

copasi

2,35357E-4

1,31678E-2

4,00595E-5

1,37366E1

2,33231E0

1,70959E1

1,99310E2

5,68921E-1

1,41352E-1

3,59973E-3

1,57624E-7

9,26756E-7

2,24380E-3

3,34226E0

6,12249E-4

3,59318E1

5,33462E-1

5.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,58234E-5

3,58998E-3

6,69260E-7

1,59318E1

1,40301E-1

1,99350E1

1,99863E2

3,43221E-2

3,32150E-2

9,79950E-4

6,16977E-10

6,99585E-8

3,17209E-5

3,88884E0

8,64421E-6

3,60399E1

1,00022E-1

5.8

jsim

2,35357E-4

1,31678E-2

4,00595E-5

1,37366E1

2,33231E0

1,70959E1

1,99310E2

5,68921E-1

1,41352E-1

3,59973E-3

1,57624E-7

9,26756E-7

2,24380E-3

3,34226E0

6,12249E-4

3,59318E1

5,33462E-1

5.8

min

7,58234E-5

3,58998E-3

6,69260E-7

1,37051E1

1,40301E-1

1,70197E1

1,99310E2

3,43221E-2

3,32150E-2

9,79950E-4

6,16977E-10

6,99585E-8

3,17209E-5

3,21320E0

8,64421E-6

3,59315E1

1,00022E-1

5.8

max

2,35965E-4

9,81443E-2

4,02042E-5

1,59318E1

2,33293E0

1,99350E1

1,99863E2

5,68921E-1

1,41352E-1

3,60063E-3

5,07648E-6

6,56158E-6

1,09397E-1

3,88884E0

6,12250E-4

3,60399E1

5,33462E-1

5.8

mean

2,35357E-4

1,31678E-2

4,00595E-5

1,37366E1

2,33231E0

1,70959E1

1,99310E2

5,68921E-1

1,41352E-1

3,59973E-3

1,57624E-7

9,26756E-7

2,24380E-3

3,34226E0

6,12249E-4

3,59318E1

5,33462E-1

5.8

relative error(%)

0,00

6.0

BioUML

2,61081E-4

1,46202E-2

4,54695E-5

1,35935E1

2,36135E0

1,70386E1

1,99274E2

5,96782E-1

1,52549E-1

3,85728E-3

1,93759E-7

1,11340E-6

2,54924E-3

3,42638E0

6,71267E-4

3,58068E1

5,55928E-1

6.0

ByoDyn

2,61081E-4

1,46202E-2

4,54695E-5

1,35935E1

2,36135E0

1,70386E1

1,99274E2

5,96782E-1

1,52549E-1

3,85728E-3

1,93759E-7

1,11340E-6

2,54924E-3

3,42638E0

6,71267E-4

3,58068E1

5,55928E-1

6.0

Jarnac

2,27650E-4

1,05893E-1

3,95974E-5

1,35594E1

2,35220E0

1,69541E1

1,99275E2

5,71522E-1

8,23958E-2

3,24270E-3

6,08101E-6

7,61535E-6

1,21782E-1

3,28532E0

5,63573E-4

3,58330E1

4,14731E-1

6.0

MathSBML

2,61081E-4

1,46203E-2

4,54696E-5

1,35935E1

2,36135E0

1,70386E1

1,99274E2

5,96782E-1

1,52549E-1

3,85728E-3

1,93753E-7

1,11338E-6

2,54925E-3

3,42638E0

6,71267E-4

3,58068E1

5,55928E-1

6.0

Oscill8 Core

2,61082E-4

1,46203E-2

4,54697E-5

1,35935E1

2,36135E0

1,70386E1

1,99274E2

5,96782E-1

1,52549E-1

3,85728E-3

1,93761E-7

1,11340E-6

2,54925E-3

3,42638E0

6,71267E-4

3,58068E1

5,55928E-1

6.0

SBToolbox2

2,61722E-4

1,46090E-2

4,56252E-5

1,35932E1

2,36196E0

1,70378E1

1,99276E2

5,96640E-1

1,52528E-1

3,85804E-3

1,93550E-7

1,11100E-6

2,54536E-3

3,42658E0

6,70608E-4

3,58066E1

5,55748E-1

6.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,61082E-4

1,46203E-2

4,54697E-5

1,35935E1

2,36135E0

1,70386E1

1,99274E2

5,96782E-1

1,52549E-1

3,85728E-3

1,93761E-7

1,11340E-6

2,54925E-3

3,42638E0

6,71267E-4

3,58068E1

5,55928E-1

6.0

VCell

2,61082E-4

1,46203E-2

4,54697E-5

1,35935E1

2,36134E0

1,70386E1

1,99274E2

5,96782E-1

1,52549E-1

3,85729E-3

1,93760E-7

1,11340E-6

2,54925E-3

3,42638E0

6,71267E-4

3,58068E1

5,55928E-1

6.0

copasi

2,61081E-4

1,46202E-2

4,54695E-5

1,35935E1

2,36135E0

1,70386E1

1,99274E2

5,96782E-1

1,52549E-1

3,85728E-3

1,93759E-7

1,11340E-6

2,54924E-3

3,42638E0

6,71267E-4

3,58068E1

5,55928E-1

6.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,30247E-5

3,93558E-3

7,51313E-7

1,58155E1

1,42778E-1

1,99344E1

1,99858E2

3,61973E-2

3,52811E-2

1,03665E-3

7,38087E-10

8,16339E-8

3,56532E-5

4,00039E0

9,37486E-6

3,59241E1

1,02734E-1

6.0

jsim

2,61081E-4

1,46202E-2

4,54695E-5

1,35935E1

2,36135E0

1,70386E1

1,99274E2

5,96782E-1

1,52549E-1

3,85728E-3

1,93759E-7

1,11340E-6

2,54924E-3

3,42638E0

6,71267E-4

3,58068E1

5,55928E-1

6.0

min

8,30247E-5

3,93558E-3

7,51313E-7

1,35594E1

1,42778E-1

1,69541E1

1,99274E2

3,61973E-2

3,52811E-2

1,03665E-3

7,38087E-10

8,16339E-8

3,56532E-5

3,28532E0

9,37486E-6

3,58066E1

1,02734E-1

6.0

max

2,61722E-4

1,05893E-1

4,56252E-5

1,58155E1

2,36196E0

1,99344E1

1,99858E2

5,96782E-1

1,52549E-1

3,85804E-3

6,08101E-6

7,61535E-6

1,21782E-1

4,00039E0

6,71267E-4

3,59241E1

5,55928E-1

6.0

mean

2,61081E-4

1,46203E-2

4,54696E-5

1,35935E1

2,36135E0

1,70386E1

1,99274E2

5,96782E-1

1,52549E-1

3,85728E-3

1,93759E-7

1,11340E-6

2,54924E-3

3,42638E0

6,71267E-4

3,58068E1

5,55928E-1

6.0

relative error(%)

0,00

6.2

BioUML

2,88492E-4

1,61688E-2

5,13531E-5

1,34536E1

2,38840E0

1,69832E1

1,99239E2

6,24691E-1

1,64148E-1

4,12154E-3

2,36291E-7

1,32849E-6

2,88163E-3

3,50911E0

7,33074E-4

3,56827E1

5,78227E-1

6.2

ByoDyn

2,88492E-4

1,61688E-2

5,13531E-5

1,34536E1

2,38840E0

1,69832E1

1,99239E2

6,24691E-1

1,64148E-1

4,12154E-3

2,36291E-7

1,32849E-6

2,88163E-3

3,50911E0

7,33074E-4

3,56827E1

5,78227E-1

6.2

Jarnac

2,49643E-4

1,13830E-1

4,43747E-5

1,34168E1

2,37821E0

1,68899E1

1,99240E2

5,96542E-1

8,68785E-2

3,43288E-3

7,22753E-6

8,77880E-6

1,34913E-1

3,35557E0

6,09685E-4

3,57122E1

4,24824E-1

6.2

MathSBML

2,88492E-4

1,61688E-2

5,13530E-5

1,34536E1

2,38840E0

1,69832E1

1,99239E2

6,24691E-1

1,64148E-1

4,12154E-3

2,36290E-7

1,32849E-6

2,88163E-3

3,50911E0

7,33074E-4

3,56827E1

5,78227E-1

6.2

Oscill8 Core

2,88493E-4

1,61688E-2

5,13532E-5

1,34536E1

2,38840E0

1,69832E1

1,99239E2

6,24691E-1

1,64148E-1

4,12154E-3

2,36293E-7

1,32850E-6

2,88164E-3

3,50911E0

7,33075E-4

3,56827E1

5,78227E-1

6.2

SBToolbox2

2,89150E-4

1,61544E-2

5,15057E-5

1,34533E1

2,38899E0

1,69829E1

1,99240E2

6,24572E-1

1,64134E-1

4,12259E-3

2,35274E-7

1,32287E-6

2,87637E-3

3,50926E0

7,32401E-4

3,56827E1

5,78062E-1

6.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,88493E-4

1,61688E-2

5,13532E-5

1,34536E1

2,38840E0

1,69832E1

1,99239E2

6,24691E-1

1,64148E-1

4,12154E-3

2,36293E-7

1,32850E-6

2,88164E-3

3,50911E0

7,33075E-4

3,56827E1

5,78227E-1

6.2

VCell

2,88494E-4

1,61688E-2

5,13533E-5

1,34536E1

2,38840E0

1,69832E1

1,99239E2

6,24691E-1

1,64148E-1

4,12155E-3

2,36292E-7

1,32850E-6

2,88163E-3

3,50911E0

7,33075E-4

3,56827E1

5,78227E-1

6.2

copasi

2,88492E-4

1,61688E-2

5,13531E-5

1,34536E1

2,38840E0

1,69832E1

1,99239E2

6,24691E-1

1,64148E-1

4,12154E-3

2,36291E-7

1,32849E-6

2,88163E-3

3,50911E0

7,33074E-4

3,56827E1

5,78227E-1

6.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,06077E-5

4,29997E-3

8,39711E-7

1,57006E1

1,45146E-1

1,99339E1

1,99853E2

3,80922E-2

3,73914E-2

1,09417E-3

8,77084E-10

9,47253E-8

3,98954E-5

4,11067E0

1,01335E-5

3,58094E1

1,05393E-1

6.2

jsim

2,88492E-4

1,61688E-2

5,13531E-5

1,34536E1

2,38840E0

1,69832E1

1,99239E2

6,24691E-1

1,64148E-1

4,12154E-3

2,36291E-7

1,32849E-6

2,88163E-3

3,50911E0

7,33074E-4

3,56827E1

5,78227E-1

6.2

min

9,06077E-5

4,29997E-3

8,39711E-7

1,34168E1

1,45146E-1

1,68899E1

1,99239E2

3,80922E-2

3,73914E-2

1,09417E-3

8,77084E-10

9,47253E-8

3,98954E-5

3,35557E0

1,01335E-5

3,56827E1

1,05393E-1

6.2

max

2,89150E-4

1,13830E-1

5,15057E-5

1,57006E1

2,38899E0

1,99339E1

1,99853E2

6,24691E-1

1,64148E-1

4,12259E-3

7,22753E-6

8,77880E-6

1,34913E-1

4,11067E0

7,33075E-4

3,58094E1

5,78227E-1

6.2

mean

2,88492E-4

1,61688E-2

5,13531E-5

1,34536E1

2,38840E0

1,69832E1

1,99239E2

6,24691E-1

1,64148E-1

4,12154E-3

2,36291E-7

1,32849E-6

2,88163E-3

3,50911E0

7,33074E-4

3,56827E1

5,78227E-1

6.2

relative error(%)

0,00

6.4

BioUML

3,17622E-4

1,78152E-2

5,77273E-5

1,33167E1

2,41357E0

1,69297E1

1,99202E2

6,52621E-1

1,76141E-1

4,39222E-3

2,86020E-7

1,57501E-6

3,24195E-3

3,59049E0

7,97623E-4

3,55593E1

6,00338E-1

6.4

ByoDyn

3,17622E-4

1,78152E-2

5,77273E-5

1,33167E1

2,41357E0

1,69297E1

1,99202E2

6,52621E-1

1,76141E-1

4,39222E-3

2,86020E-7

1,57501E-6

3,24195E-3

3,59049E0

7,97623E-4

3,55593E1

6,00338E-1

6.4

Jarnac

2,72742E-4

1,21938E-1

4,94916E-5

1,32772E1

2,40228E0

1,68270E1

1,99204E2

6,21404E-1

9,13553E-2

3,62424E-3

8,52756E-6

1,00563E-5

1,48785E-1

3,42399E0

6,57071E-4

3,55924E1

4,34327E-1

6.4

MathSBML

3,17623E-4

1,78152E-2

5,77273E-5

1,33167E1

2,41357E0

1,69297E1

1,99202E2

6,52621E-1

1,76141E-1

4,39222E-3

2,86015E-7

1,57500E-6

3,24195E-3

3,59049E0

7,97623E-4

3,55593E1

6,00338E-1

6.4

Oscill8 Core

3,17623E-4

1,78153E-2

5,77274E-5

1,33167E1

2,41357E0

1,69297E1

1,99202E2

6,52621E-1

1,76141E-1

4,39222E-3

2,86023E-7

1,57502E-6

3,24196E-3

3,59049E0

7,97624E-4

3,55593E1

6,00338E-1

6.4

SBToolbox2

3,18324E-4

1,77996E-2

5,78965E-5

1,33158E1

2,41413E0

1,69293E1

1,99200E2

6,52494E-1

1,76120E-1

4,39310E-3

2,85226E-7

1,56995E-6

3,23647E-3

3,59068E0

7,96878E-4

3,55588E1

6,00166E-1

6.4

SBWOdeSolver

3,17623E-4

1,78153E-2

5,77274E-5

1,33167E1

2,41357E0

1,69297E1

1,99202E2

6,52621E-1

1,76141E-1

4,39222E-3

2,86023E-7

1,57502E-6

3,24196E-3

3,59049E0

7,97624E-4

3,55593E1

6,00338E-1

6.4

VCell

3,17624E-4

1,78153E-2

5,77275E-5

1,33167E1

2,41356E0

1,69297E1

1,99202E2

6,52621E-1

1,76142E-1

4,39222E-3

2,86022E-7

1,57502E-6

3,24195E-3

3,59049E0

7,97624E-4

3,55593E1

6,00338E-1

6.4

copasi

3,17622E-4

1,78152E-2

5,77273E-5

1,33167E1

2,41357E0

1,69297E1

1,99202E2

6,52621E-1

1,76141E-1

4,39222E-3

2,86020E-7

1,57501E-6

3,24195E-3

3,59049E0

7,97623E-4

3,55593E1

6,00338E-1

6.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,85755E-5

4,68334E-3

9,34643E-7

1,55869E1

1,47408E-1

1,99335E1

1,99848E2

4,00053E-2

3,95443E-2

1,15245E-3

1,03575E-9

1,09340E-7

4,44571E-5

4,21971E0

1,09194E-5

3,56959E1

1,07999E-1

6.4

jsim

3,17622E-4

1,78152E-2

5,77273E-5

1,33167E1

2,41357E0

1,69297E1

1,99202E2

6,52621E-1

1,76141E-1

4,39222E-3

2,86020E-7

1,57501E-6

3,24195E-3

3,59049E0

7,97623E-4

3,55593E1

6,00338E-1

6.4

min

9,85755E-5

4,68334E-3

9,34643E-7

1,32772E1

1,47408E-1

1,68270E1

1,99200E2

4,00053E-2

3,95443E-2

1,15245E-3

1,03575E-9

1,09340E-7

4,44571E-5

3,42399E0

1,09194E-5

3,55588E1

1,07999E-1

6.4

max

3,18324E-4

1,21938E-1

5,78965E-5

1,55869E1

2,41413E0

1,99335E1

1,99848E2

6,52621E-1

1,76142E-1

4,39310E-3

8,52756E-6

1,00563E-5

1,48785E-1

4,21971E0

7,97624E-4

3,56959E1

6,00338E-1

6.4

mean

3,17623E-4

1,78152E-2

5,77273E-5

1,33167E1

2,41357E0

1,69297E1

1,99202E2

6,52621E-1

1,76141E-1

4,39222E-3

2,86020E-7

1,57501E-6

3,24195E-3

3,59049E0

7,97623E-4

3,55593E1

6,00338E-1

6.4

relative error(%)

0,00

6.6

BioUML

3,48500E-4

1,95612E-2

6,46086E-5

1,31828E1

2,43693E0

1,68780E1

1,99166E2

6,80546E-1

1,88521E-1

4,66901E-3

3,43804E-7

1,85605E-6

3,63115E-3

3,67056E0

8,64856E-4

3,54368E1

6,22241E-1

6.6

ByoDyn

3,48500E-4

1,95612E-2

6,46086E-5

1,31828E1

2,43693E0

1,68780E1

1,99166E2

6,80546E-1

1,88521E-1

4,66901E-3

3,43804E-7

1,85605E-6

3,63115E-3

3,67056E0

8,64856E-4

3,54368E1

6,22241E-1

6.6

Jarnac

2,96940E-4

1,30201E-1

5,49522E-5

1,31406E1

2,42447E0

1,67655E1

1,99168E2

6,46085E-1

9,58176E-2

3,81643E-3

9,99264E-6

1,14517E-5

1,63388E-1

3,49066E0

7,05627E-4

3,54737E1

4,43249E-1

6.6

MathSBML

3,48501E-4

1,95612E-2

6,46087E-5

1,31828E1

2,43693E0

1,68780E1

1,99166E2

6,80546E-1

1,88521E-1

4,66901E-3

3,43800E-7

1,85604E-6

3,63116E-3

3,67056E0

8,64856E-4

3,54368E1

6,22241E-1

6.6

Oscill8 Core

3,48501E-4

1,95612E-2

6,46088E-5

1,31828E1

2,43693E0

1,68780E1

1,99166E2

6,80546E-1

1,88521E-1

4,66901E-3

3,43806E-7

1,85606E-6

3,63116E-3

3,67056E0

8,64857E-4

3,54368E1

6,22241E-1

6.6

SBToolbox2

3,49251E-4

1,95456E-2

6,47971E-5

1,31820E1

2,43757E0

1,68773E1

1,99170E2

6,80406E-1

1,88491E-1

4,66966E-3

3,43431E-7

1,85230E-6

3,62577E-3

3,67076E0

8,64036E-4

3,54370E1

6,22061E-1

6.6

SBWOdeSolver

3,48501E-4

1,95612E-2

6,46088E-5

1,31828E1

2,43693E0

1,68780E1

1,99166E2

6,80546E-1

1,88521E-1

4,66901E-3

3,43806E-7

1,85606E-6

3,63116E-3

3,67056E0

8,64857E-4

3,54368E1

6,22241E-1

6.6

VCell

3,48502E-4

1,95612E-2

6,46089E-5

1,31828E1

2,43693E0

1,68780E1

1,99166E2

6,80546E-1

1,88521E-1

4,66902E-3

3,43805E-7

1,85606E-6

3,63116E-3

3,67056E0

8,64857E-4

3,54368E1

6,22241E-1

6.6

copasi

3,48500E-4

1,95612E-2

6,46086E-5

1,31828E1

2,43693E0

1,68780E1

1,99166E2

6,80546E-1

1,88521E-1

4,66901E-3

3,43804E-7

1,85605E-6

3,63115E-3

3,67056E0

8,64856E-4

3,54368E1

6,22241E-1

6.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,06931E-4

5,08585E-3

1,03629E-6

1,54745E1

1,49569E-1

1,99331E1

1,99843E2

4,19348E-2

4,17384E-2

1,21144E-3

1,21596E-9

1,25590E-7

4,93475E-5

4,32753E0

1,17319E-5

3,55835E1

1,10552E-1

6.6

jsim

3,48500E-4

1,95612E-2

6,46086E-5

1,31828E1

2,43693E0

1,68780E1

1,99166E2

6,80546E-1

1,88521E-1

4,66901E-3

3,43804E-7

1,85605E-6

3,63115E-3

3,67056E0

8,64856E-4

3,54368E1

6,22241E-1

6.6

min

1,06931E-4

5,08585E-3

1,03629E-6

1,31406E1

1,49569E-1

1,67655E1

1,99166E2

4,19348E-2

4,17384E-2

1,21144E-3

1,21596E-9

1,25590E-7

4,93475E-5

3,49066E0

1,17319E-5

3,54368E1

1,10552E-1

6.6

max

3,49251E-4

1,30201E-1

6,47971E-5

1,54745E1

2,43757E0

1,99331E1

1,99843E2

6,80546E-1

1,88521E-1

4,66966E-3

9,99264E-6

1,14517E-5

1,63388E-1

4,32753E0

8,64857E-4

3,55835E1

6,22241E-1

6.6

mean

3,48500E-4

1,95612E-2

6,46087E-5

1,31828E1

2,43693E0

1,68780E1

1,99166E2

6,80546E-1

1,88521E-1

4,66901E-3

3,43804E-7

1,85605E-6

3,63115E-3

3,67056E0

8,64856E-4

3,54368E1

6,22241E-1

6.6

relative error(%)

0,00

6.8

BioUML

3,81153E-4

2,14082E-2

7,20129E-5

1,30518E1

2,45857E0

1,68279E1

1,99129E2

7,08444E-1

2,01279E-1

4,95164E-3

4,10553E-7

2,17489E-6

4,05013E-3

3,74936E0

9,34714E-4

3,53150E1

6,43919E-1

6.8

ByoDyn

3,81153E-4

2,14082E-2

7,20129E-5

1,30518E1

2,45857E0

1,68279E1

1,99129E2

7,08444E-1

2,01279E-1

4,95164E-3

4,10553E-7

2,17489E-6

4,05013E-3

3,74936E0

9,34714E-4

3,53150E1

6,43919E-1

6.8

Jarnac

3,22226E-4

1,38606E-1

6,07596E-5

1,30067E1

2,44488E0

1,67053E1

1,99131E2

6,70561E-1

1,00257E-1

4,00913E-3

1,16342E-5

1,29686E-5

1,78712E-1

3,55562E0

7,55248E-4

3,53561E1

4,51597E-1

6.8

MathSBML

3,81153E-4

2,14082E-2

7,20129E-5

1,30518E1

2,45857E0

1,68279E1

1,99129E2

7,08444E-1

2,01279E-1

4,95164E-3

4,10551E-7

2,17489E-6

4,05014E-3

3,74936E0

9,34714E-4

3,53150E1

6,43919E-1

6.8

Oscill8 Core

3,81154E-4

2,14083E-2

7,20130E-5

1,30518E1

2,45857E0

1,68279E1

1,99129E2

7,08444E-1

2,01279E-1

4,95164E-3

4,10555E-7

2,17490E-6

4,05014E-3

3,74936E0

9,34715E-4

3,53150E1

6,43919E-1

6.8

SBToolbox2

3,81928E-4

2,13914E-2

7,22066E-5

1,30511E1

2,45922E0

1,68274E1

1,99130E2

7,08308E-1

2,01248E-1

4,95228E-3

4,09614E-7

2,16891E-6

4,04394E-3

3,74955E0

9,33882E-4

3,53151E1

6,43746E-1

6.8

SBWOdeSolver

3,81154E-4

2,14083E-2

7,20130E-5

1,30518E1

2,45857E0

1,68279E1

1,99129E2

7,08444E-1

2,01279E-1

4,95164E-3

4,10555E-7

2,17490E-6

4,05014E-3

3,74936E0

9,34715E-4

3,53150E1

6,43919E-1

6.8

VCell

3,81155E-4

2,14083E-2

7,20131E-5

1,30518E1

2,45857E0

1,68279E1

1,99129E2

7,08444E-1

2,01279E-1

4,95165E-3

4,10555E-7

2,17490E-6

4,05014E-3

3,74936E0

9,34715E-4

3,53150E1

6,43918E-1

6.8

copasi

3,81153E-4

2,14082E-2

7,20129E-5

1,30518E1

2,45857E0

1,68279E1

1,99129E2

7,08444E-1

2,01279E-1

4,95164E-3

4,10553E-7

2,17489E-6

4,05013E-3

3,74936E0

9,34714E-4

3,53150E1

6,43919E-1

6.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,15675E-4

5,50764E-3

1,14481E-6

1,53634E1

1,51631E-1

1,99329E1

1,99837E2

4,38792E-2

4,39722E-2

1,27109E-3

1,41965E-9

1,43587E-7

5,45755E-5

4,43415E0

1,25704E-5

3,54723E1

1,13051E-1

6.8

jsim

3,81153E-4

2,14082E-2

7,20129E-5

1,30518E1

2,45857E0

1,68279E1

1,99129E2

7,08444E-1

2,01279E-1

4,95164E-3

4,10553E-7

2,17489E-6

4,05013E-3

3,74936E0

9,34714E-4

3,53150E1

6,43919E-1

6.8

min

1,15675E-4

5,50764E-3

1,14481E-6

1,30067E1

1,51631E-1

1,67053E1

1,99129E2

4,38792E-2

4,39722E-2

1,27109E-3

1,41965E-9

1,43587E-7

5,45755E-5

3,55562E0

1,25704E-5

3,53150E1

1,13051E-1

6.8

max

3,81928E-4

1,38606E-1

7,22066E-5

1,53634E1

2,45922E0

1,99329E1

1,99837E2

7,08444E-1

2,01279E-1

4,95228E-3

1,16342E-5

1,29686E-5

1,78712E-1

4,43415E0

9,34715E-4

3,54723E1

6,43919E-1

6.8

mean

3,81153E-4

2,14082E-2

7,20129E-5

1,30518E1

2,45857E0

1,68279E1

1,99129E2

7,08444E-1

2,01279E-1

4,95164E-3

4,10553E-7

2,17489E-6

4,05014E-3

3,74936E0

9,34714E-4

3,53150E1

6,43919E-1

6.8

relative error(%)

0,00

7.0

BioUML

4,15606E-4

2,33577E-2

7,99549E-5

1,29236E1

2,47857E0

1,67796E1

1,99092E2

7,36294E-1

2,14406E-1

5,23982E-3

4,87235E-7

2,53493E-6

4,49975E-3

3,82692E0

1,00713E-3

3,51940E1

6,65354E-1

7.0

ByoDyn

4,15606E-4

2,33577E-2

7,99549E-5

1,29236E1

2,47857E0

1,67796E1

1,99092E2

7,36294E-1

2,14406E-1

5,23982E-3

4,87235E-7

2,53493E-6

4,49975E-3

3,82692E0

1,00713E-3

3,51940E1

6,65354E-1

7.0

Jarnac

3,48589E-4

1,47137E-1

6,69158E-5

1,28756E1

2,46359E0

1,66463E1

1,99094E2

6,94816E-1

1,04667E-1

4,20201E-3

1,34637E-5

1,46101E-5

1,94745E-1

3,61895E0

8,05829E-4

3,52396E1

4,59382E-1

7.0

MathSBML

4,15606E-4

2,33577E-2

7,99549E-5

1,29236E1

2,47857E0

1,67796E1

1,99092E2

7,36294E-1

2,14406E-1

5,23982E-3

4,87230E-7

2,53492E-6

4,49975E-3

3,82692E0

1,00713E-3

3,51940E1

6,65354E-1

7.0

Oscill8 Core

4,15606E-4

2,33577E-2

7,99550E-5

1,29236E1

2,47857E0

1,67796E1

1,99092E2

7,36294E-1

2,14406E-1

5,23982E-3

4,87238E-7

2,53494E-6

4,49976E-3

3,82692E0

1,00713E-3

3,51940E1

6,65354E-1

7.0

SBToolbox2

4,16404E-4

2,33380E-2

8,01506E-5

1,29232E1

2,47917E0

1,67791E1

1,99090E2

7,36177E-1

2,14371E-1

5,24068E-3

4,85260E-7

2,52503E-6

4,49219E-3

3,82714E0

1,00631E-3

3,51942E1

6,65198E-1

7.0

SBWOdeSolver

4,15606E-4

2,33577E-2

7,99550E-5

1,29236E1

2,47857E0

1,67796E1

1,99092E2

7,36294E-1

2,14406E-1

5,23982E-3

4,87238E-7

2,53494E-6

4,49976E-3

3,82692E0

1,00713E-3

3,51940E1

6,65354E-1

7.0

VCell

4,15607E-4

2,33577E-2

7,99551E-5

1,29236E1

2,47856E0

1,67796E1

1,99092E2

7,36294E-1

2,14406E-1

5,23982E-3

4,87237E-7

2,53494E-6

4,49975E-3

3,82692E0

1,00713E-3

3,51940E1

6,65354E-1

7.0

copasi

4,15606E-4

2,33577E-2

7,99549E-5

1,29236E1

2,47857E0

1,67796E1

1,99092E2

7,36294E-1

2,14406E-1

5,23982E-3

4,87235E-7

2,53493E-6

4,49975E-3

3,82692E0

1,00713E-3

3,51940E1

6,65354E-1

7.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,24812E-4

5,94883E-3

1,26038E-6

1,52535E1

1,53597E-1

1,99327E1

1,99832E2

4,58369E-2

4,62443E-2

1,33134E-3

1,64886E-9

1,63448E-7

6,01494E-5

4,53959E0

1,34340E-5

3,53622E1

1,15498E-1

7.0

jsim

4,15606E-4

2,33577E-2

7,99549E-5

1,29236E1

2,47857E0

1,67796E1

1,99092E2

7,36294E-1

2,14406E-1

5,23982E-3

4,87235E-7

2,53493E-6

4,49975E-3

3,82692E0

1,00713E-3

3,51940E1

6,65354E-1

7.0

min

1,24812E-4

5,94883E-3

1,26038E-6

1,28756E1

1,53597E-1

1,66463E1

1,99090E2

4,58369E-2

4,62443E-2

1,33134E-3

1,64886E-9

1,63448E-7

6,01494E-5

3,61895E0

1,34340E-5

3,51940E1

1,15498E-1

7.0

max

4,16404E-4

1,47137E-1

8,01506E-5

1,52535E1

2,47917E0

1,99327E1

1,99832E2

7,36294E-1

2,14406E-1

5,24068E-3

1,34637E-5

1,46101E-5

1,94745E-1

4,53959E0

1,00713E-3

3,53622E1

6,65354E-1

7.0

mean

4,15606E-4

2,33577E-2

7,99549E-5

1,29236E1

2,47857E0

1,67796E1

1,99092E2

7,36294E-1

2,14406E-1

5,23982E-3

4,87235E-7

2,53493E-6

4,49975E-3

3,82692E0

1,00713E-3

3,51940E1

6,65354E-1

7.0

relative error(%)

0,00

7.2

BioUML

4,51881E-4

2,54109E-2

8,84486E-5

1,27981E1

2,49700E0

1,67328E1

1,99055E2

7,64075E-1

2,27894E-1

5,53326E-3

5,74874E-7

2,93973E-6

4,98079E-3

3,90328E0

1,08204E-3

3,50738E1

6,86534E-1

7.2

ByoDyn

4,51881E-4

2,54109E-2

8,84486E-5

1,27981E1

2,49700E0

1,67328E1

1,99055E2

7,64075E-1

2,27894E-1

5,53326E-3

5,74874E-7

2,93973E-6

4,98079E-3

3,90328E0

1,08204E-3

3,50738E1

6,86534E-1

7.2

Jarnac

3,76015E-4

1,55780E-1

7,34220E-5

1,27472E1

2,48066E0

1,65885E1

1,99057E2

7,18830E-1

1,09041E-1

4,39480E-3

1,54922E-5

1,63790E-5

2,11471E-1

3,68069E0

8,57266E-4

3,51241E1

4,66618E-1

7.2

MathSBML

4,51881E-4

2,54109E-2

8,84485E-5

1,27981E1

2,49700E0

1,67328E1

1,99055E2

7,64075E-1

2,27894E-1

5,53326E-3

5,74873E-7

2,93973E-6

4,98079E-3

3,90328E0

1,08204E-3

3,50738E1

6,86534E-1

7.2

Oscill8 Core

4,51881E-4

2,54109E-2

8,84487E-5

1,27981E1

2,49700E0

1,67328E1

1,99055E2

7,64075E-1

2,27894E-1

5,53326E-3

5,74877E-7

2,93974E-6

4,98080E-3

3,90328E0

1,08204E-3

3,50738E1

6,86533E-1

7.2

SBToolbox2

4,52724E-4

2,53904E-2

8,86622E-5

1,27973E1

2,49765E0

1,67324E1

1,99057E2

7,63949E-1

2,27850E-1

5,53394E-3

5,73252E-7

2,93065E-6

4,97297E-3

3,90346E0

1,08109E-3

3,50733E1

6,86374E-1

7.2

SBWOdeSolver

4,51881E-4

2,54109E-2

8,84487E-5

1,27981E1

2,49700E0

1,67328E1

1,99055E2

7,64075E-1

2,27894E-1

5,53326E-3

5,74877E-7

2,93974E-6

4,98080E-3

3,90328E0

1,08204E-3

3,50738E1

6,86533E-1

7.2

VCell

4,51882E-4

2,54109E-2

8,84488E-5

1,27981E1

2,49700E0

1,67328E1

1,99055E2

7,64075E-1

2,27894E-1

5,53326E-3

5,74876E-7

2,93974E-6

4,98080E-3

3,90328E0

1,08204E-3

3,50738E1

6,86533E-1

7.2

copasi

4,51881E-4

2,54109E-2

8,84486E-5

1,27981E1

2,49700E0

1,67328E1

1,99055E2

7,64075E-1

2,27894E-1

5,53326E-3

5,74874E-7

2,93973E-6

4,98079E-3

3,90328E0

1,08204E-3

3,50738E1

6,86534E-1

7.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,34341E-4

6,40951E-3

1,38313E-6

1,51448E1

1,55471E-1

1,99326E1

1,99827E2

4,78065E-2

4,85533E-2

1,39214E-3

1,90571E-9

1,85291E-7

6,60771E-5

4,64386E0

1,43219E-5

3,52532E1

1,17892E-1

7.2

jsim

4,51881E-4

2,54109E-2

8,84486E-5

1,27981E1

2,49700E0

1,67328E1

1,99055E2

7,64075E-1

2,27894E-1

5,53326E-3

5,74874E-7

2,93973E-6

4,98079E-3

3,90328E0

1,08204E-3

3,50738E1

6,86534E-1

7.2

min

1,34341E-4

6,40951E-3

1,38313E-6

1,27472E1

1,55471E-1

1,65885E1

1,99055E2

4,78065E-2

4,85533E-2

1,39214E-3

1,90571E-9

1,85291E-7

6,60771E-5

3,68069E0

1,43219E-5

3,50733E1

1,17892E-1

7.2

max

4,52724E-4

1,55780E-1

8,86622E-5

1,51448E1

2,49765E0

1,99326E1

1,99827E2

7,64075E-1

2,27894E-1

5,53394E-3

1,54922E-5

1,63790E-5

2,11471E-1

4,64386E0

1,08204E-3

3,52532E1

6,86534E-1

7.2

mean

4,51881E-4

2,54109E-2

8,84486E-5

1,27981E1

2,49700E0

1,67328E1

1,99055E2

7,64075E-1

2,27894E-1

5,53326E-3

5,74874E-7

2,93973E-6

4,98079E-3

3,90328E0

1,08204E-3

3,50738E1

6,86533E-1

7.2

relative error(%)

0,00

7.4

BioUML

4,89998E-4

2,75690E-2

9,75072E-5

1,26752E1

2,51394E0

1,66875E1

1,99018E2

7,91768E-1

2,41733E-1

5,83168E-3

6,74543E-7

3,39297E-6

5,49403E-3

3,97847E0

1,15936E-3

3,49544E1

7,07442E-1

7.4

ByoDyn

4,89998E-4

2,75690E-2

9,75072E-5

1,26752E1

2,51394E0

1,66875E1

1,99018E2

7,91768E-1

2,41733E-1

5,83168E-3

6,74543E-7

3,39297E-6

5,49403E-3

3,97847E0

1,15936E-3

3,49544E1

7,07442E-1

7.4

Jarnac

4,04489E-4

1,64522E-1

8,02786E-5

1,26213E1

2,49619E0

1,65317E1

1,99020E2

7,42588E-1

1,13371E-1

4,58721E-3

1,77308E-5

1,82775E-5

2,28876E-1

3,74090E0

9,09457E-4

3,50096E1

4,73317E-1

7.4

MathSBML

4,89998E-4

2,75690E-2

9,75073E-5

1,26752E1

2,51394E0

1,66875E1

1,99018E2

7,91768E-1

2,41733E-1

5,83168E-3

6,74539E-7

3,39296E-6

5,49403E-3

3,97847E0

1,15936E-3

3,49544E1

7,07442E-1

7.4

Oscill8 Core

4,89998E-4

2,75690E-2

9,75074E-5

1,26752E1

2,51394E0

1,66875E1

1,99018E2

7,91768E-1

2,41733E-1

5,83168E-3

6,74546E-7

3,39299E-6

5,49403E-3

3,97847E0

1,15936E-3

3,49544E1

7,07442E-1

7.4

SBToolbox2

4,90890E-4

2,75476E-2

9,77409E-5

1,26744E1

2,51471E0

1,66872E1

1,99020E2

7,91631E-1

2,41675E-1

5,83210E-3

6,73588E-7

3,38587E-6

5,48619E-3

3,97869E0

1,15831E-3

3,49544E1

7,07278E-1

7.4

SBWOdeSolver

4,89998E-4

2,75690E-2

9,75074E-5

1,26752E1

2,51394E0

1,66875E1

1,99018E2

7,91768E-1

2,41733E-1

5,83168E-3

6,74546E-7

3,39299E-6

5,49403E-3

3,97847E0

1,15936E-3

3,49544E1

7,07442E-1

7.4

VCell

4,89999E-4

2,75690E-2

9,75075E-5

1,26752E1

2,51394E0

1,66876E1

1,99018E2

7,91768E-1

2,41734E-1

5,83168E-3

6,74546E-7

3,39299E-6

5,49403E-3

3,97847E0

1,15936E-3

3,49544E1

7,07442E-1

7.4

copasi

4,89998E-4

2,75690E-2

9,75072E-5

1,26752E1

2,51394E0

1,66875E1

1,99018E2

7,91768E-1

2,41733E-1

5,83168E-3

6,74543E-7

3,39297E-6

5,49403E-3

3,97847E0

1,15936E-3

3,49544E1

7,07442E-1

7.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,44264E-4

6,88977E-3

1,51322E-6

1,50374E1

1,57255E-1

1,99326E1

1,99822E2

4,97866E-2

5,08977E-2

1,45346E-3

2,19238E-9

2,09237E-7

7,23661E-5

4,74699E0

1,52334E-5

3,51452E1

1,20233E-1

7.4

jsim

4,89998E-4

2,75690E-2

9,75072E-5

1,26752E1

2,51394E0

1,66875E1

1,99018E2

7,91768E-1

2,41733E-1

5,83168E-3

6,74543E-7

3,39297E-6

5,49403E-3

3,97847E0

1,15936E-3

3,49544E1

7,07442E-1

7.4

min

1,44264E-4

6,88977E-3

1,51322E-6

1,26213E1

1,57255E-1

1,65317E1

1,99018E2

4,97866E-2

5,08977E-2

1,45346E-3

2,19238E-9

2,09237E-7

7,23661E-5

3,74090E0

1,52334E-5

3,49544E1

1,20233E-1

7.4

max

4,90890E-4

1,64522E-1

9,77409E-5

1,50374E1

2,51471E0

1,99326E1

1,99822E2

7,91768E-1

2,41734E-1

5,83210E-3

1,77308E-5

1,82775E-5

2,28876E-1

4,74699E0

1,15936E-3

3,51452E1

7,07442E-1

7.4

mean

4,89998E-4

2,75690E-2

9,75072E-5

1,26752E1

2,51394E0

1,66875E1

1,99018E2

7,91768E-1

2,41733E-1

5,83168E-3

6,74543E-7

3,39297E-6

5,49403E-3

3,97847E0

1,15936E-3

3,49544E1

7,07442E-1

7.4

relative error(%)

0,00

7.6

BioUML

5,29976E-4

2,98329E-2

1,07143E-4

1,25548E1

2,52946E0

1,66438E1

1,98980E2

8,19357E-1

2,55915E-1

6,13481E-3

7,87373E-7

3,89850E-6

6,04015E-3

4,05252E0

1,23902E-3

3,48357E1

7,28069E-1

7.6

ByoDyn

5,29976E-4

2,98329E-2

1,07143E-4

1,25548E1

2,52946E0

1,66438E1

1,98980E2

8,19357E-1

2,55915E-1

6,13481E-3

7,87373E-7

3,89850E-6

6,04015E-3

4,05252E0

1,23902E-3

3,48357E1

7,28069E-1

7.6

Jarnac

4,33995E-4

1,73350E-1

8,74851E-5

1,24979E1

2,51023E0

1,64761E1

1,98983E2

7,66078E-1

1,17653E-1

4,77899E-3

2,01899E-5

2,03077E-5

2,46942E-1

3,79963E0

9,62299E-4

3,48962E1

4,79495E-1

7.6

MathSBML

5,29976E-4

2,98329E-2

1,07143E-4

1,25548E1

2,52946E0

1,66438E1

1,98980E2

8,19357E-1

2,55915E-1

6,13481E-3

7,87370E-7

3,89849E-6

6,04015E-3

4,05252E0

1,23902E-3

3,48357E1

7,28069E-1

7.6

Oscill8 Core

5,29976E-4

2,98329E-2

1,07143E-4

1,25548E1

2,52946E0

1,66438E1

1,98980E2

8,19357E-1

2,55915E-1

6,13481E-3

7,87376E-7

3,89851E-6

6,04015E-3

4,05252E0

1,23902E-3

3,48357E1

7,28069E-1

7.6

SBToolbox2

5,30902E-4

2,98098E-2

1,07390E-4

1,25536E1

2,53019E0

1,66435E1

1,98980E2

8,19221E-1

2,55853E-1

6,13507E-3

7,86268E-7

3,89066E-6

6,03184E-3

4,05279E0

1,23796E-3

3,48356E1

7,27907E-1

7.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,29976E-4

2,98329E-2

1,07143E-4

1,25548E1

2,52946E0

1,66438E1

1,98980E2

8,19357E-1

2,55915E-1

6,13481E-3

7,87376E-7

3,89851E-6

6,04015E-3

4,05252E0

1,23902E-3

3,48357E1

7,28069E-1

7.6

VCell

5,29977E-4

2,98329E-2

1,07143E-4

1,25548E1

2,52946E0

1,66438E1

1,98980E2

8,19357E-1

2,55915E-1

6,13481E-3

7,87375E-7

3,89851E-6

6,04015E-3

4,05252E0

1,23902E-3

3,48357E1

7,28069E-1

7.6

copasi

5,29976E-4

2,98329E-2

1,07143E-4

1,25548E1

2,52946E0

1,66438E1

1,98980E2

8,19357E-1

2,55915E-1

6,13481E-3

7,87373E-7

3,89850E-6

6,04015E-3

4,05252E0

1,23902E-3

3,48357E1

7,28069E-1

7.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,54583E-4

7,38969E-3

1,65078E-6

1,49311E1

1,58953E-1

1,99327E1

1,99817E2

5,17759E-2

5,32763E-2

1,51523E-3

2,51113E-9

2,35407E-7

7,90235E-5

4,84898E0

1,61677E-5

3,50383E1

1,22523E-1

7.6

jsim

5,29976E-4

2,98329E-2

1,07143E-4

1,25548E1

2,52946E0

1,66438E1

1,98980E2

8,19357E-1

2,55915E-1

6,13481E-3

7,87373E-7

3,89850E-6

6,04015E-3

4,05252E0

1,23902E-3

3,48357E1

7,28069E-1

7.6

min

1,54583E-4

7,38969E-3

1,65078E-6

1,24979E1

1,58953E-1

1,64761E1

1,98980E2

5,17759E-2

5,32763E-2

1,51523E-3

2,51113E-9

2,35407E-7

7,90235E-5

3,79963E0

1,61677E-5

3,48356E1

1,22523E-1

7.6

max

5,30902E-4

1,73350E-1

1,07390E-4

1,49311E1

2,53019E0

1,99327E1

1,99817E2

8,19357E-1

2,55915E-1

6,13507E-3

2,01899E-5

2,03077E-5

2,46942E-1

4,84898E0

1,23902E-3

3,50383E1

7,28069E-1

7.6

mean

5,29976E-4

2,98329E-2

1,07143E-4

1,25548E1

2,52946E0

1,66438E1

1,98980E2

8,19357E-1

2,55915E-1

6,13481E-3

7,87373E-7

3,89850E-6

6,04015E-3

4,05252E0

1,23902E-3

3,48357E1

7,28069E-1

7.6

relative error(%)

0,00

7.8

BioUML

5,71831E-4

3,22036E-2

1,17368E-4

1,24368E1

2,54362E0

1,66015E1

1,98942E2

8,46825E-1

2,70430E-1

6,44237E-3

9,14541E-7

4,46025E-6

6,61981E-3

4,12546E0

1,32094E-3

3,47178E1

7,48402E-1

7.8

ByoDyn

5,71831E-4

3,22036E-2

1,17368E-4

1,24368E1

2,54362E0

1,66015E1

1,98942E2

8,46825E-1

2,70430E-1

6,44237E-3

9,14541E-7

4,46025E-6

6,61981E-3

4,12546E0

1,32094E-3

3,47178E1

7,48402E-1

7.8

Jarnac

4,64516E-4

1,82253E-1

9,50401E-5

1,23769E1

2,52285E0

1,64216E1

1,98946E2

7,89286E-1

1,21881E-1

4,96991E-3

2,28800E-5

2,24709E-5

2,65650E-1

3,85694E0

1,01569E-3

3,47839E1

4,85167E-1

7.8

MathSBML

5,71831E-4

3,22036E-2

1,17368E-4

1,24368E1

2,54362E0

1,66015E1

1,98942E2

8,46825E-1

2,70430E-1

6,44237E-3

9,14540E-7

4,46024E-6

6,61981E-3

4,12546E0

1,32094E-3

3,47178E1

7,48401E-1

7.8

Oscill8 Core

5,71831E-4

3,22037E-2

1,17368E-4

1,24368E1

2,54362E0

1,66015E1

1,98942E2

8,46825E-1

2,70430E-1

6,44237E-3

9,14545E-7

4,46026E-6

6,61982E-3

4,12546E0

1,32094E-3

3,47178E1

7,48401E-1

7.8

SBToolbox2

5,72781E-4

3,21776E-2

1,17614E-4

1,24359E1

2,54425E0

1,66006E1

1,98940E2

8,46711E-1

2,70373E-1

6,44301E-3

9,11054E-7

4,44397E-6

6,60966E-3

4,12569E0

1,31992E-3

3,47177E1

7,48252E-1

7.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,71831E-4

3,22037E-2

1,17368E-4

1,24368E1

2,54362E0

1,66015E1

1,98942E2

8,46825E-1

2,70430E-1

6,44237E-3

9,14545E-7

4,46026E-6

6,61982E-3

4,12546E0

1,32094E-3

3,47178E1

7,48401E-1

7.8

VCell

5,71832E-4

3,22037E-2

1,17368E-4

1,24368E1

2,54362E0

1,66015E1

1,98942E2

8,46825E-1

2,70431E-1

6,44238E-3

9,14544E-7

4,46026E-6

6,61982E-3

4,12546E0

1,32094E-3

3,47178E1

7,48401E-1

7.8

copasi

5,71831E-4

3,22036E-2

1,17368E-4

1,24368E1

2,54362E0

1,66015E1

1,98942E2

8,46825E-1

2,70430E-1

6,44237E-3

9,14542E-7

4,46025E-6

6,61981E-3

4,12546E0

1,32094E-3

3,47178E1

7,48402E-1

7.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,65297E-4

7,90929E-3

1,79593E-6

1,48260E1

1,60567E-1

1,99328E1

1,99812E2

5,37732E-2

5,56876E-2

1,57741E-3

2,86428E-9

2,63926E-7

8,60557E-5

4,94986E0

1,71239E-5

3,49325E1

1,24761E-1

7.8

jsim

5,71831E-4

3,22036E-2

1,17368E-4

1,24368E1

2,54362E0

1,66015E1

1,98942E2

8,46825E-1

2,70430E-1

6,44237E-3

9,14541E-7

4,46025E-6

6,61981E-3

4,12546E0

1,32094E-3

3,47178E1

7,48402E-1

7.8

min

1,65297E-4

7,90929E-3

1,79593E-6

1,23769E1

1,60567E-1

1,64216E1

1,98940E2

5,37732E-2

5,56876E-2

1,57741E-3

2,86428E-9

2,63926E-7

8,60557E-5

3,85694E0

1,71239E-5

3,47177E1

1,24761E-1

7.8

max

5,72781E-4

1,82253E-1

1,17614E-4

1,48260E1

2,54425E0

1,99328E1

1,99812E2

8,46825E-1

2,70431E-1

6,44301E-3

2,28800E-5

2,24709E-5

2,65650E-1

4,94986E0

1,32094E-3

3,49325E1

7,48402E-1

7.8

mean

5,71831E-4

3,22036E-2

1,17368E-4

1,24368E1

2,54362E0

1,66015E1

1,98942E2

8,46825E-1

2,70430E-1

6,44237E-3

9,14542E-7

4,46025E-6

6,61981E-3

4,12546E0

1,32094E-3

3,47178E1

7,48401E-1

7.8

relative error(%)

0,00

8.0

BioUML

6,15577E-4

3,46819E-2

1,28192E-4

1,23212E1

2,55648E0

1,65606E1

1,98904E2

8,74158E-1

2,85269E-1

6,75410E-3

1,05728E-6

5,08230E-6

7,23362E-3

4,19733E0

1,40504E-3

3,46006E1

7,68431E-1

8.0

ByoDyn

6,15577E-4

3,46819E-2

1,28192E-4

1,23212E1

2,55648E0

1,65606E1

1,98904E2

8,74158E-1

2,85269E-1

6,75410E-3

1,05728E-6

5,08230E-6

7,23362E-3

4,19733E0

1,40504E-3

3,46006E1

7,68431E-1

8.0

Jarnac

4,96034E-4

1,91219E-1

1,02942E-4

1,22583E1

2,53413E0

1,63681E1

1,98908E2

8,12203E-1

1,26051E-1

5,15973E-3

2,58109E-5

2,47684E-5

2,84981E-1

3,91287E0

1,06955E-3

3,46726E1

4,90351E-1

8.0

MathSBML

6,15577E-4

3,46819E-2

1,28192E-4

1,23212E1

2,55648E0

1,65606E1

1,98904E2

8,74158E-1

2,85269E-1

6,75410E-3

1,05727E-6

5,08229E-6

7,23363E-3

4,19733E0

1,40504E-3

3,46006E1

7,68431E-1

8.0

Oscill8 Core

6,15577E-4

3,46820E-2

1,28192E-4

1,23212E1

2,55648E0

1,65606E1

1,98904E2

8,74158E-1

2,85269E-1

6,75410E-3

1,05728E-6

5,08231E-6

7,23363E-3

4,19733E0

1,40504E-3

3,46006E1

7,68431E-1

8.0

SBToolbox2

6,16568E-4

3,46542E-2

1,28452E-4

1,23208E1

2,55722E0

1,65596E1

1,98908E2

8,74052E-1

2,85210E-1

6,75474E-3

1,05362E-6

5,06496E-6

7,22270E-3

4,19752E0

1,40396E-3

3,46008E1

7,68290E-1

8.0

SBWOdeSolver

6,15577E-4

3,46820E-2

1,28192E-4

1,23212E1

2,55648E0

1,65606E1

1,98904E2

8,74158E-1

2,85269E-1

6,75410E-3

1,05728E-6

5,08231E-6

7,23363E-3

4,19733E0

1,40504E-3

3,46006E1

7,68431E-1

8.0

VCell

6,15578E-4

3,46819E-2

1,28192E-4

1,23212E1

2,55648E0

1,65606E1

1,98904E2

8,74158E-1

2,85270E-1

6,75411E-3

1,05728E-6

5,08232E-6

7,23363E-3

4,19733E0

1,40504E-3

3,46006E1

7,68431E-1

8.0

copasi

6,15577E-4

3,46819E-2

1,28192E-4

1,23212E1

2,55648E0

1,65606E1

1,98904E2

8,74158E-1

2,85269E-1

6,75410E-3

1,05728E-6

5,08230E-6

7,23362E-3

4,19733E0

1,40504E-3

3,46006E1

7,68431E-1

8.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,76407E-4

8,44863E-3

1,94879E-6

1,47221E1

1,62100E-1

1,99330E1

1,99806E2

5,57771E-2

5,81305E-2

1,63997E-3

3,25424E-9

2,94920E-7

9,34690E-5

5,04964E0

1,81012E-5

3,48277E1

1,26947E-1

8.0

jsim

6,15577E-4

3,46819E-2

1,28192E-4

1,23212E1

2,55648E0

1,65606E1

1,98904E2

8,74158E-1

2,85269E-1

6,75410E-3

1,05728E-6

5,08230E-6

7,23362E-3

4,19733E0

1,40504E-3

3,46006E1

7,68431E-1

8.0

min

1,76407E-4

8,44863E-3

1,94879E-6

1,22583E1

1,62100E-1

1,63681E1

1,98904E2

5,57771E-2

5,81305E-2

1,63997E-3

3,25424E-9

2,94920E-7

9,34690E-5

3,91287E0

1,81012E-5

3,46006E1

1,26947E-1

8.0

max

6,16568E-4

1,91219E-1

1,28452E-4

1,47221E1

2,55722E0

1,99330E1

1,99806E2

8,74158E-1

2,85270E-1

6,75474E-3

2,58109E-5

2,47684E-5

2,84981E-1

5,04964E0

1,40504E-3

3,48277E1

7,68431E-1

8.0

mean

6,15577E-4

3,46819E-2

1,28192E-4

1,23212E1

2,55648E0

1,65606E1

1,98904E2

8,74158E-1

2,85269E-1

6,75410E-3

1,05728E-6

5,08230E-6

7,23362E-3

4,19733E0

1,40504E-3

3,46006E1

7,68431E-1

8.0

relative error(%)

0,00

8.2

BioUML

6,61227E-4

3,72685E-2

1,39624E-4

1,22079E1

2,56811E0

1,65210E1

1,98866E2

9,01343E-1

3,00423E-1

7,06974E-3

1,21686E-6

5,76885E-6

7,88213E-3

4,26814E0

1,49124E-3

3,44841E1

7,88148E-1

8.2

ByoDyn

6,61227E-4

3,72685E-2

1,39624E-4

1,22079E1

2,56811E0

1,65210E1

1,98866E2

9,01343E-1

3,00423E-1

7,06974E-3

1,21686E-6

5,76885E-6

7,88213E-3

4,26814E0

1,49124E-3

3,44841E1

7,88148E-1

8.2

Jarnac

5,28528E-4

2,00238E-1

1,11187E-4

1,21419E1

2,54411E0

1,63155E1

1,98870E2

8,34820E-1

1,30158E-1

5,34826E-3

2,89921E-5

2,72009E-5

3,04914E-1

3,96747E0

1,12376E-3

3,45623E1

4,95064E-1

8.2

MathSBML

6,61227E-4

3,72685E-2

1,39624E-4

1,22079E1

2,56811E0

1,65210E1

1,98866E2

9,01343E-1

3,00423E-1

7,06974E-3

1,21686E-6

5,76885E-6

7,88213E-3

4,26814E0

1,49124E-3

3,44841E1

7,88148E-1

8.2

Oscill8 Core

6,61227E-4

3,72685E-2

1,39624E-4

1,22079E1

2,56811E0

1,65210E1

1,98866E2

9,01343E-1

3,00423E-1

7,06974E-3

1,21686E-6

5,76886E-6

7,88214E-3

4,26814E0

1,49124E-3

3,44841E1

7,88148E-1

8.2

SBToolbox2

6,62261E-4

3,72389E-2

1,39904E-4

1,22069E1

2,56889E0

1,65206E1

1,98868E2

9,01225E-1

3,00347E-1

7,07004E-3

1,21413E-6

5,75403E-6

7,87089E-3

4,26843E0

1,48999E-3

3,44839E1

7,88006E-1

8.2

SBWOdeSolver

6,61227E-4

3,72685E-2

1,39624E-4

1,22079E1

2,56811E0

1,65210E1

1,98866E2

9,01343E-1

3,00423E-1

7,06974E-3

1,21686E-6

5,76886E-6

7,88214E-3

4,26814E0

1,49124E-3

3,44841E1

7,88148E-1

8.2

VCell

6,61229E-4

3,72685E-2

1,39625E-4

1,22079E1

2,56811E0

1,65210E1

1,98866E2

9,01343E-1

3,00423E-1

7,06975E-3

1,21686E-6

5,76887E-6

7,88214E-3

4,26814E0

1,49124E-3

3,44841E1

7,88148E-1

8.2

copasi

6,61227E-4

3,72685E-2

1,39624E-4

1,22079E1

2,56811E0

1,65210E1

1,98866E2

9,01343E-1

3,00423E-1

7,06974E-3

1,21686E-6

5,76885E-6

7,88213E-3

4,26814E0

1,49124E-3

3,44841E1

7,88148E-1

8.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,87912E-4

9,00770E-3

2,10946E-6

1,46193E1

1,63555E-1

1,99333E1

1,99801E2

5,77866E-2

6,06035E-2

1,70286E-3

3,68344E-9

3,28515E-7

1,01269E-4

5,14835E0

1,90988E-5

3,47240E1

1,29083E-1

8.2

jsim

6,61227E-4

3,72685E-2

1,39624E-4

1,22079E1

2,56811E0

1,65210E1

1,98866E2

9,01343E-1

3,00423E-1

7,06974E-3

1,21686E-6

5,76885E-6

7,88213E-3

4,26814E0

1,49124E-3

3,44841E1

7,88148E-1

8.2

min

1,87912E-4

9,00770E-3

2,10946E-6

1,21419E1

1,63555E-1

1,63155E1

1,98866E2

5,77866E-2

6,06035E-2

1,70286E-3

3,68344E-9

3,28515E-7

1,01269E-4

3,96747E0

1,90988E-5

3,44839E1

1,29083E-1

8.2

max

6,62261E-4

2,00238E-1

1,39904E-4

1,46193E1

2,56889E0

1,99333E1

1,99801E2

9,01343E-1

3,00423E-1

7,07004E-3

2,89921E-5

2,72009E-5

3,04914E-1

5,14835E0

1,49124E-3

3,47240E1

7,88148E-1

8.2

mean

6,61227E-4

3,72685E-2

1,39624E-4

1,22079E1

2,56811E0

1,65210E1

1,98866E2

9,01343E-1

3,00423E-1

7,06974E-3

1,21686E-6

5,76885E-6

7,88213E-3

4,26814E0

1,49124E-3

3,44841E1

7,88148E-1

8.2

relative error(%)

0,00

8.4

BioUML

7,08791E-4

3,99638E-2

1,51675E-4

1,20968E1

2,57857E0

1,64828E1

1,98828E2

9,28365E-1

3,15882E-1

7,38903E-3

1,39460E-6

6,52420E-6

8,56584E-3

4,33793E0

1,57944E-3

3,43684E1

8,07546E-1

8.4

ByoDyn

7,08791E-4

3,99638E-2

1,51675E-4

1,20968E1

2,57857E0

1,64828E1

1,98828E2

9,28365E-1

3,15882E-1

7,38903E-3

1,39460E-6

6,52420E-6

8,56584E-3

4,33793E0

1,57944E-3

3,43684E1

8,07546E-1

8.4

Jarnac

5,61980E-4

2,09300E-1

1,19772E-4

1,20277E1

2,55287E0

1,62639E1

1,98832E2

8,57128E-1

1,34200E-1

5,53529E-3

3,24326E-5

2,97688E-5

3,25428E-1

4,02080E0

1,17825E-3

3,44531E1

4,99324E-1

8.4

MathSBML

7,08791E-4

3,99638E-2

1,51675E-4

1,20968E1

2,57857E0

1,64828E1

1,98828E2

9,28365E-1

3,15882E-1

7,38903E-3

1,39460E-6

6,52419E-6

8,56584E-3

4,33793E0

1,57944E-3

3,43684E1

8,07545E-1

8.4

Oscill8 Core

7,08792E-4

3,99638E-2

1,51675E-4

1,20968E1

2,57857E0

1,64828E1

1,98828E2

9,28365E-1

3,15882E-1

7,38903E-3

1,39461E-6

6,52421E-6

8,56585E-3

4,33793E0

1,57944E-3

3,43684E1

8,07546E-1

8.4

SBToolbox2

7,09869E-4

3,99331E-2

1,51969E-4

1,20960E1

2,57938E0

1,64818E1

1,98830E2

9,28244E-1

3,15785E-1

7,38898E-3

1,39260E-6

6,51125E-6

8,55432E-3

4,33824E0

1,57812E-3

3,43682E1

8,07404E-1

8.4

SBWOdeSolver

7,08792E-4

3,99638E-2

1,51675E-4

1,20968E1

2,57857E0

1,64828E1

1,98828E2

9,28365E-1

3,15882E-1

7,38903E-3

1,39461E-6

6,52421E-6

8,56585E-3

4,33793E0

1,57944E-3

3,43684E1

8,07546E-1

8.4

VCell

7,08793E-4

3,99638E-2

1,51675E-4

1,20968E1

2,57857E0

1,64828E1

1,98828E2

9,28365E-1

3,15882E-1

7,38904E-3

1,39461E-6

6,52422E-6

8,56584E-3

4,33793E0

1,57944E-3

3,43684E1

8,07545E-1

8.4

copasi

7,08791E-4

3,99638E-2

1,51675E-4

1,20968E1

2,57857E0

1,64828E1

1,98828E2

9,28365E-1

3,15882E-1

7,38903E-3

1,39460E-6

6,52420E-6

8,56584E-3

4,33793E0

1,57944E-3

3,43684E1

8,07546E-1

8.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,99813E-4

9,58653E-3

2,27803E-6

1,45176E1

1,64935E-1

1,99337E1

1,99796E2

5,98005E-2

6,31055E-2

1,76603E-3

4,15440E-9

3,64840E-7

1,09461E-4

5,24598E0

2,01157E-5

3,46212E1

1,31168E-1

8.4

jsim

7,08791E-4

3,99638E-2

1,51675E-4

1,20968E1

2,57857E0

1,64828E1

1,98828E2

9,28365E-1

3,15882E-1

7,38903E-3

1,39460E-6

6,52420E-6

8,56584E-3

4,33793E0

1,57944E-3

3,43684E1

8,07546E-1

8.4

min

1,99813E-4

9,58653E-3

2,27803E-6

1,20277E1

1,64935E-1

1,62639E1

1,98828E2

5,98005E-2

6,31055E-2

1,76603E-3

4,15440E-9

3,64840E-7

1,09461E-4

4,02080E0

2,01157E-5

3,43682E1

1,31168E-1

8.4

max

7,09869E-4

2,09300E-1

1,51969E-4

1,45176E1

2,57938E0

1,99337E1

1,99796E2

9,28365E-1

3,15882E-1

7,38904E-3

3,24326E-5

2,97688E-5

3,25428E-1

5,24598E0

1,57944E-3

3,46212E1

8,07546E-1

8.4

mean

7,08791E-4

3,99638E-2

1,51675E-4

1,20968E1

2,57857E0

1,64828E1

1,98828E2

9,28365E-1

3,15882E-1

7,38903E-3

1,39460E-6

6,52420E-6

8,56584E-3

4,33793E0

1,57944E-3

3,43684E1

8,07545E-1

8.4

relative error(%)

0,00

8.6

BioUML

7,58279E-4

4,27685E-2

1,64352E-4

1,19878E1

2,58790E0

1,64458E1

1,98790E2

9,55215E-1

3,31636E-1

7,71172E-3

1,59188E-6

7,35274E-6

9,28520E-3

4,40673E0

1,66956E-3

3,42535E1

8,26616E-1

8.6

ByoDyn

7,58279E-4

4,27685E-2

1,64352E-4

1,19878E1

2,58790E0

1,64458E1

1,98790E2

9,55215E-1

3,31636E-1

7,71172E-3

1,59188E-6

7,35274E-6

9,28520E-3

4,40673E0

1,66956E-3

3,42535E1

8,26616E-1

8.6

Jarnac

5,96369E-4

2,18395E-1

1,28694E-4

1,19156E1

2,56045E0

1,62133E1

1,98794E2

8,79121E-1

1,38172E-1

5,72067E-3

3,61410E-5

3,24722E-5

3,46502E-1

4,07290E0

1,23292E-3

3,43449E1

5,03148E-1

8.6

MathSBML

7,58279E-4

4,27685E-2

1,64352E-4

1,19878E1

2,58790E0

1,64458E1

1,98790E2

9,55215E-1

3,31636E-1

7,71172E-3

1,59188E-6

7,35274E-6

9,28521E-3

4,40673E0

1,66956E-3

3,42535E1

8,26616E-1

8.6

Oscill8 Core

7,58279E-4

4,27685E-2

1,64352E-4

1,19878E1

2,58790E0

1,64458E1

1,98790E2

9,55215E-1

3,31636E-1

7,71172E-3

1,59189E-6

7,35275E-6

9,28521E-3

4,40673E0

1,66956E-3

3,42535E1

8,26616E-1

8.6

SBToolbox2

7,59384E-4

4,27360E-2

1,64651E-4

1,19872E1

2,58867E0

1,64449E1

1,98790E2

9,55098E-1

3,31542E-1

7,71177E-3

1,58843E-6

7,33488E-6

9,27275E-3

4,40698E0

1,66824E-3

3,42533E1

8,26483E-1

8.6

SBWOdeSolver

7,58279E-4

4,27685E-2

1,64352E-4

1,19878E1

2,58790E0

1,64458E1

1,98790E2

9,55215E-1

3,31636E-1

7,71172E-3

1,59189E-6

7,35275E-6

9,28521E-3

4,40673E0

1,66956E-3

3,42535E1

8,26616E-1

8.6

VCell

7,58280E-4

4,27685E-2

1,64352E-4

1,19878E1

2,58790E0

1,64458E1

1,98790E2

9,55215E-1

3,31636E-1

7,71172E-3

1,59189E-6

7,35276E-6

9,28521E-3

4,40673E0

1,66957E-3

3,42535E1

8,26616E-1

8.6

copasi

7,58279E-4

4,27685E-2

1,64352E-4

1,19878E1

2,58790E0

1,64458E1

1,98790E2

9,55215E-1

3,31636E-1

7,71172E-3

1,59188E-6

7,35274E-6

9,28520E-3

4,40673E0

1,66956E-3

3,42535E1

8,26616E-1

8.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,12109E-4

1,01851E-2

2,45461E-6

1,44170E1

1,66241E-1

1,99341E1

1,99791E2

6,18179E-2

6,56353E-2

1,82945E-3

4,66968E-9

4,04024E-7

1,18050E-4

5,34257E0

2,11512E-5

3,45195E1

1,33202E-1

8.6

jsim

7,58279E-4

4,27685E-2

1,64352E-4

1,19878E1

2,58790E0

1,64458E1

1,98790E2

9,55215E-1

3,31636E-1

7,71172E-3

1,59188E-6

7,35274E-6

9,28520E-3

4,40673E0

1,66956E-3

3,42535E1

8,26616E-1

8.6

min

2,12109E-4

1,01851E-2

2,45461E-6

1,19156E1

1,66241E-1

1,62133E1

1,98790E2

6,18179E-2

6,56353E-2

1,82945E-3

4,66968E-9

4,04024E-7

1,18050E-4

4,07290E0

2,11512E-5

3,42533E1

1,33202E-1

8.6

max

7,59384E-4

2,18395E-1

1,64651E-4

1,44170E1

2,58867E0

1,99341E1

1,99791E2

9,55215E-1

3,31636E-1

7,71177E-3

3,61410E-5

3,24722E-5

3,46502E-1

5,34257E0

1,66957E-3

3,45195E1

8,26616E-1

8.6

mean

7,58279E-4

4,27685E-2

1,64352E-4

1,19878E1

2,58790E0

1,64458E1

1,98790E2

9,55215E-1

3,31636E-1

7,71172E-3

1,59188E-6

7,35274E-6

9,28521E-3

4,40673E0

1,66956E-3

3,42535E1

8,26616E-1

8.6

relative error(%)

0,00

8.8

BioUML

8,09696E-4

4,56828E-2

1,77661E-4

1,18809E1

2,59617E0

1,64100E1

1,98751E2

9,81881E-1

3,47677E-1

8,03755E-3

1,81010E-6

8,25899E-6

1,00406E-2

4,47454E0

1,76153E-3

3,41392E1

8,45354E-1

8.8

ByoDyn

8,09696E-4

4,56828E-2

1,77661E-4

1,18809E1

2,59617E0

1,64100E1

1,98751E2

9,81881E-1

3,47677E-1

8,03755E-3

1,81010E-6

8,25899E-6

1,00406E-2

4,47454E0

1,76153E-3

3,41392E1

8,45354E-1

8.8

Jarnac

6,31674E-4

2,27515E-1

1,37948E-4

1,18056E1

2,56691E0

1,61635E1

1,98756E2

9,00794E-1

1,42073E-1

5,90423E-3

4,01251E-5

3,53108E-5

3,68112E-1

4,12381E0

1,28770E-3

3,42377E1

5,06554E-1

8.8

MathSBML

8,09696E-4

4,56828E-2

1,77661E-4

1,18809E1

2,59617E0

1,64100E1

1,98751E2

9,81881E-1

3,47677E-1

8,03755E-3

1,81010E-6

8,25898E-6

1,00406E-2

4,47454E0

1,76153E-3

3,41392E1

8,45354E-1

8.8

Oscill8 Core

8,09697E-4

4,56828E-2

1,77661E-4

1,18809E1

2,59617E0

1,64100E1

1,98751E2

9,81881E-1

3,47677E-1

8,03756E-3

1,81010E-6

8,25900E-6

1,00406E-2

4,47454E0

1,76153E-3

3,41392E1

8,45354E-1

8.8

SBToolbox2

8,10834E-4

4,56479E-2

1,77963E-4

1,18803E1

2,59695E0

1,64098E1

1,98750E2

9,81780E-1

3,47587E-1

8,03787E-3

1,80408E-6

8,23238E-6

1,00267E-2

4,47481E0

1,76026E-3

3,41393E1

8,45240E-1

8.8

SBWOdeSolver

8,09697E-4

4,56828E-2

1,77661E-4

1,18809E1

2,59617E0

1,64100E1

1,98751E2

9,81881E-1

3,47677E-1

8,03756E-3

1,81010E-6

8,25900E-6

1,00406E-2

4,47454E0

1,76153E-3

3,41392E1

8,45354E-1

8.8

VCell

8,09698E-4

4,56828E-2

1,77661E-4

1,18809E1

2,59617E0

1,64100E1

1,98751E2

9,81881E-1

3,47677E-1

8,03756E-3

1,81010E-6

8,25901E-6

1,00406E-2

4,47454E0

1,76153E-3

3,41392E1

8,45354E-1

8.8

copasi

8,09696E-4

4,56828E-2

1,77661E-4

1,18809E1

2,59617E0

1,64100E1

1,98751E2

9,81881E-1

3,47677E-1

8,03755E-3

1,81010E-6

8,25899E-6

1,00406E-2

4,47454E0

1,76153E-3

3,41392E1

8,45354E-1

8.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,24799E-4

1,08033E-2

2,63926E-6

1,43175E1

1,67476E-1

1,99346E1

1,99786E2

6,38377E-2

6,81915E-2

1,89307E-3

5,23189E-9

4,46197E-7

1,27040E-4

5,43813E0

2,22043E-5

3,44187E1

1,35187E-1

8.8

jsim

8,09696E-4

4,56828E-2

1,77661E-4

1,18809E1

2,59617E0

1,64100E1

1,98751E2

9,81881E-1

3,47677E-1

8,03755E-3

1,81010E-6

8,25899E-6

1,00406E-2

4,47454E0

1,76153E-3

3,41392E1

8,45354E-1

8.8

min

2,24799E-4

1,08033E-2

2,63926E-6

1,18056E1

1,67476E-1

1,61635E1

1,98750E2

6,38377E-2

6,81915E-2

1,89307E-3

5,23189E-9

4,46197E-7

1,27040E-4

4,12381E0

2,22043E-5

3,41392E1

1,35187E-1

8.8

max

8,10834E-4

2,27515E-1

1,77963E-4

1,43175E1

2,59695E0

1,99346E1

1,99786E2

9,81881E-1

3,47677E-1

8,03787E-3

4,01251E-5

3,53108E-5

3,68112E-1

5,43813E0

1,76153E-3

3,44187E1

8,45354E-1

8.8

mean

8,09696E-4

4,56828E-2

1,77661E-4

1,18809E1

2,59617E0

1,64100E1

1,98751E2

9,81881E-1

3,47677E-1

8,03755E-3

1,81010E-6

8,25899E-6

1,00406E-2

4,47454E0

1,76153E-3

3,41392E1

8,45354E-1

8.8

relative error(%)

0,00

9.0

BioUML

8,63049E-4

4,87070E-2

1,91610E-4

1,17760E1

2,60341E0

1,63754E1

1,98713E2

1,00835E0

3,63994E-1

8,36630E-3

2,05069E-6

9,24752E-6

1,08325E-2

4,54141E0

1,85523E-3

3,40257E1

8,63753E-1

9.0

ByoDyn

8,63049E-4

4,87070E-2

1,91610E-4

1,17760E1

2,60341E0

1,63754E1

1,98713E2

1,00835E0

3,63994E-1

8,36630E-3

2,05069E-6

9,24752E-6

1,08325E-2

4,54141E0

1,85523E-3

3,40257E1

8,63753E-1

9.0

Jarnac

6,67873E-4

2,36653E-1

1,47528E-4

1,16977E1

2,57231E0

1,61147E1

1,98718E2

9,22142E-1

1,45899E-1

6,08583E-3

4,43926E-5

3,82841E-5

3,90236E-1

4,17357E0

1,34250E-3

3,41315E1

5,09560E-1

9.0

MathSBML

8,63050E-4

4,87070E-2

1,91610E-4

1,17760E1

2,60341E0

1,63754E1

1,98713E2

1,00835E0

3,63994E-1

8,36630E-3

2,05069E-6

9,24751E-6

1,08325E-2

4,54141E0

1,85523E-3

3,40257E1

8,63753E-1

9.0

Oscill8 Core

8,63050E-4

4,87070E-2

1,91610E-4

1,17760E1

2,60341E0

1,63754E1

1,98713E2

1,00835E0

3,63994E-1

8,36630E-3

2,05070E-6

9,24753E-6

1,08325E-2

4,54141E0

1,85523E-3

3,40257E1

8,63753E-1

9.0

SBToolbox2

8,64222E-4

4,86704E-2

1,91922E-4

1,17754E1

2,60423E0

1,63748E1

1,98710E2

1,00823E0

3,63892E-1

8,36645E-3

2,04477E-6

9,22038E-6

1,08180E-2

4,54164E0

1,85388E-3

3,40255E1

8,63641E-1

9.0

SBWOdeSolver

8,63050E-4

4,87070E-2

1,91610E-4

1,17760E1

2,60341E0

1,63754E1

1,98713E2

1,00835E0

3,63994E-1

8,36630E-3

2,05070E-6

9,24753E-6

1,08325E-2

4,54141E0

1,85523E-3

3,40257E1

8,63753E-1

9.0

VCell

8,63051E-4

4,87070E-2

1,91610E-4

1,17760E1

2,60341E0

1,63754E1

1,98713E2

1,00835E0

3,63994E-1

8,36631E-3

2,05070E-6

9,24754E-6

1,08325E-2

4,54141E0

1,85523E-3

3,40257E1

8,63753E-1

9.0

copasi

8,63049E-4

4,87070E-2

1,91610E-4

1,17760E1

2,60341E0

1,63754E1

1,98713E2

1,00835E0

3,63994E-1

8,36630E-3

2,05069E-6

9,24752E-6

1,08325E-2

4,54141E0

1,85523E-3

3,40257E1

8,63753E-1

9.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,37881E-4

1,14413E-2

2,83206E-6

1,42190E1

1,68643E-1

1,99351E1

1,99781E2

6,58589E-2

7,07731E-2

1,95687E-3

5,84369E-9

4,91489E-7

1,36435E-4

5,53267E0

2,32743E-5

3,43189E1

1,37123E-1

9.0

jsim

8,63049E-4

4,87070E-2

1,91610E-4

1,17760E1

2,60341E0

1,63754E1

1,98713E2

1,00835E0

3,63994E-1

8,36630E-3

2,05069E-6

9,24752E-6

1,08325E-2

4,54141E0

1,85523E-3

3,40257E1

8,63754E-1

9.0

min

2,37881E-4

1,14413E-2

2,83206E-6

1,16977E1

1,68643E-1

1,61147E1

1,98710E2

6,58589E-2

7,07731E-2

1,95687E-3

5,84369E-9

4,91489E-7

1,36435E-4

4,17357E0

2,32743E-5

3,40255E1

1,37123E-1

9.0

max

8,64222E-4

2,36653E-1

1,91922E-4

1,42190E1

2,60423E0

1,99351E1

1,99781E2

1,00835E0

3,63994E-1

8,36645E-3

4,43926E-5

3,82841E-5

3,90236E-1

5,53267E0

1,85523E-3

3,43189E1

8,63754E-1

9.0

mean

8,63050E-4

4,87070E-2

1,91610E-4

1,17760E1

2,60341E0

1,63754E1

1,98713E2

1,00835E0

3,63994E-1

8,36630E-3

2,05069E-6

9,24752E-6

1,08325E-2

4,54141E0

1,85523E-3

3,40257E1

8,63753E-1

9.0

relative error(%)

0,00

9.2

BioUML

9,18342E-4

5,18413E-2

2,06204E-4

1,16731E1

2,60969E0

1,63419E1

1,98674E2

1,03462E0

3,80579E-1

8,69773E-3

2,31515E-6

1,03230E-5

1,16611E-2

4,60734E0

1,95060E-3

3,39128E1

8,81811E-1

9.2

ByoDyn

9,18342E-4

5,18413E-2

2,06204E-4

1,16731E1

2,60969E0

1,63419E1

1,98674E2

1,03462E0

3,80579E-1

8,69773E-3

2,31515E-6

1,03230E-5

1,16611E-2

4,60734E0

1,95060E-3

3,39128E1

8,81811E-1

9.2

Jarnac

7,04945E-4

2,45801E-1

1,57429E-4

1,15916E1

2,57669E0

1,60667E1

1,98680E2

9,43163E-1

1,49650E-1

6,26532E-3

4,89502E-5

4,13913E-5

4,12852E-1

4,22224E0

1,39724E-3

3,40263E1

5,12185E-1

9.2

MathSBML

9,18342E-4

5,18413E-2

2,06204E-4

1,16731E1

2,60969E0

1,63419E1

1,98674E2

1,03462E0

3,80579E-1

8,69773E-3

2,31515E-6

1,03230E-5

1,16611E-2

4,60734E0

1,95060E-3

3,39128E1

8,81811E-1

9.2

Oscill8 Core

9,18342E-4

5,18413E-2

2,06204E-4

1,16731E1

2,60969E0

1,63419E1

1,98674E2

1,03462E0

3,80579E-1

8,69773E-3

2,31516E-6

1,03230E-5

1,16611E-2

4,60734E0

1,95060E-3

3,39128E1

8,81811E-1

9.2

SBToolbox2

9,19546E-4

5,18027E-2

2,06530E-4

1,16725E1

2,61052E0

1,63409E1

1,98670E2

1,03450E0

3,80457E-1

8,69754E-3

2,31032E-6

1,02995E-5

1,16454E-2

4,60766E0

1,94918E-3

3,39126E1

8,81702E-1

9.2

SBWOdeSolver

9,18342E-4

5,18413E-2

2,06204E-4

1,16731E1

2,60969E0

1,63419E1

1,98674E2

1,03462E0

3,80579E-1

8,69773E-3

2,31516E-6

1,03230E-5

1,16611E-2

4,60734E0

1,95060E-3

3,39128E1

8,81811E-1

9.2

VCell

9,18344E-4

5,18414E-2

2,06204E-4

1,16731E1

2,60969E0

1,63419E1

1,98674E2

1,03462E0

3,80579E-1

8,69773E-3

2,31516E-6

1,03230E-5

1,16611E-2

4,60734E0

1,95060E-3

3,39128E1

8,81811E-1

9.2

copasi

9,18342E-4

5,18413E-2

2,06204E-4

1,16731E1

2,60969E0

1,63419E1

1,98674E2

1,03462E0

3,80579E-1

8,69773E-3

2,31516E-6

1,03230E-5

1,16611E-2

4,60734E0

1,95060E-3

3,39128E1

8,81811E-1

9.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,51355E-4

1,20988E-2

3,03307E-6

1,41216E1

1,69744E-1

1,99357E1

1,99775E2

6,78807E-2

7,33789E-2

2,02080E-3

6,50777E-9

5,40032E-7

1,46238E-4

5,62620E0

2,43602E-5

3,42200E1

1,39010E-1

9.2

jsim

9,18342E-4

5,18413E-2

2,06204E-4

1,16731E1

2,60969E0

1,63419E1

1,98674E2

1,03462E0

3,80579E-1

8,69773E-3

2,31515E-6

1,03230E-5

1,16611E-2

4,60734E0

1,95060E-3

3,39128E1

8,81811E-1

9.2

min

2,51355E-4

1,20988E-2

3,03307E-6

1,15916E1

1,69744E-1

1,60667E1

1,98670E2

6,78807E-2

7,33789E-2

2,02080E-3

6,50777E-9

5,40032E-7

1,46238E-4

4,22224E0

2,43602E-5

3,39126E1

1,39010E-1

9.2

max

9,19546E-4

2,45801E-1

2,06530E-4

1,41216E1

2,61052E0

1,99357E1

1,99775E2

1,03462E0

3,80579E-1

8,69773E-3

4,89502E-5

4,13913E-5

4,12852E-1

5,62620E0

1,95060E-3

3,42200E1

8,81811E-1

9.2

mean

9,18342E-4

5,18413E-2

2,06204E-4

1,16731E1

2,60969E0

1,63419E1

1,98674E2

1,03462E0

3,80579E-1

8,69773E-3

2,31516E-6

1,03230E-5

1,16611E-2

4,60734E0

1,95060E-3

3,39128E1

8,81811E-1

9.2

relative error(%)

0,00

9.4

BioUML

9,75576E-4

5,50859E-2

2,21447E-4

1,15720E1

2,61504E0

1,63095E1

1,98635E2

1,06068E0

3,97422E-1

9,03160E-3

2,60499E-6

1,14902E-5

1,25266E-2

4,67237E0

2,04754E-3

3,38007E1

8,99523E-1

9.4

ByoDyn

9,75576E-4

5,50859E-2

2,21447E-4

1,15720E1

2,61504E0

1,63095E1

1,98635E2

1,06068E0

3,97422E-1

9,03160E-3

2,60499E-6

1,14902E-5

1,25266E-2

4,67237E0

2,04754E-3

3,38007E1

8,99523E-1

9.4

Jarnac

7,42868E-4

2,54952E-1

1,67646E-4

1,14875E1

2,58011E0

1,60195E1

1,98642E2

9,63852E-1

1,53322E-1

6,44260E-3

5,38044E-5

4,46312E-5

4,35936E-1

4,26984E0

1,45186E-3

3,39222E1

5,14446E-1

9.4

MathSBML

9,75576E-4

5,50859E-2

2,21447E-4

1,15720E1

2,61504E0

1,63095E1

1,98635E2

1,06068E0

3,97422E-1

9,03160E-3

2,60499E-6

1,14902E-5

1,25266E-2

4,67237E0

2,04754E-3

3,38007E1

8,99523E-1

9.4

Oscill8 Core

9,75576E-4

5,50859E-2

2,21447E-4

1,15720E1

2,61504E0

1,63095E1

1,98635E2

1,06068E0

3,97422E-1

9,03160E-3

2,60500E-6

1,14902E-5

1,25266E-2

4,67237E0

2,04754E-3

3,38007E1

8,99523E-1

9.4

SBToolbox2

9,76805E-4

5,50450E-2

2,21787E-4

1,15707E1

2,61591E0

1,63089E1

1,98639E2

1,06058E0

3,97291E-1

9,03111E-3

2,60091E-6

1,14686E-5

1,25106E-2

4,67269E0

2,04599E-3

3,38006E1

8,99423E-1

9.4

SBWOdeSolver

9,75576E-4

5,50859E-2

2,21447E-4

1,15720E1

2,61504E0

1,63095E1

1,98635E2

1,06068E0

3,97422E-1

9,03160E-3

2,60500E-6

1,14902E-5

1,25266E-2

4,67237E0

2,04754E-3

3,38007E1

8,99523E-1

9.4

VCell

9,75577E-4

5,50859E-2

2,21447E-4

1,15720E1

2,61504E0

1,63095E1

1,98635E2

1,06068E0

3,97422E-1

9,03160E-3

2,60500E-6

1,14902E-5

1,25266E-2

4,67237E0

2,04754E-3

3,38007E1

8,99522E-1

9.4

copasi

9,75576E-4

5,50859E-2

2,21447E-4

1,15720E1

2,61504E0

1,63095E1

1,98635E2

1,06068E0

3,97422E-1

9,03160E-3

2,60499E-6

1,14902E-5

1,25266E-2

4,67237E0

2,04754E-3

3,38007E1

8,99523E-1

9.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,65219E-4

1,27759E-2

3,24235E-6

1,40253E1

1,70780E-1

1,99364E1

1,99770E2

6,99023E-2

7,60077E-2

2,08483E-3

7,22687E-9

5,91956E-7

1,56454E-4

5,71875E0

2,54612E-5

3,41221E1

1,40848E-1

9.4

jsim

9,75576E-4

5,50859E-2

2,21447E-4

1,15720E1

2,61504E0

1,63095E1

1,98635E2

1,06068E0

3,97422E-1

9,03160E-3

2,60499E-6

1,14902E-5

1,25266E-2

4,67237E0

2,04754E-3

3,38007E1

8,99523E-1

9.4

min

2,65219E-4

1,27759E-2

3,24235E-6

1,14875E1

1,70780E-1

1,60195E1

1,98635E2

6,99023E-2

7,60077E-2

2,08483E-3

7,22687E-9

5,91956E-7

1,56454E-4

4,26984E0

2,54612E-5

3,38006E1

1,40848E-1

9.4

max

9,76805E-4

2,54952E-1

2,21787E-4

1,40253E1

2,61591E0

1,99364E1

1,99770E2

1,06068E0

3,97422E-1

9,03160E-3

5,38044E-5

4,46312E-5

4,35936E-1

5,71875E0

2,04754E-3

3,41221E1

8,99523E-1

9.4

mean

9,75576E-4

5,50859E-2

2,21447E-4

1,15720E1

2,61504E0

1,63095E1

1,98635E2

1,06068E0

3,97422E-1

9,03160E-3

2,60499E-6

1,14902E-5

1,25266E-2

4,67237E0

2,04754E-3

3,38007E1

8,99523E-1

9.4

relative error(%)

0,00

9.6

BioUML

1,03475E-3

5,84406E-2

2,37344E-4

1,14728E1

2,61951E0

1,62782E1

1,98597E2

1,08652E0

4,14513E-1

9,36770E-3

2,92176E-6

1,27539E-5

1,34294E-2

4,73651E0

2,14595E-3

3,36893E1

9,16885E-1

9.6

ByoDyn

1,03475E-3

5,84406E-2

2,37344E-4

1,14728E1

2,61951E0

1,62782E1

1,98597E2

1,08652E0

4,14513E-1

9,36770E-3

2,92176E-6

1,27539E-5

1,34294E-2

4,73651E0

2,14595E-3

3,36893E1

9,16885E-1

9.6

Jarnac

7,81619E-4

2,64101E-1

1,78171E-4

1,13852E1

2,58260E0

1,59731E1

1,98604E2

9,84209E-1

1,56916E-1

6,61756E-3

5,89608E-5

4,80027E-5

4,59466E-1

4,31642E0

1,50628E-3

3,38190E1

5,16360E-1

9.6

MathSBML

1,03475E-3

5,84406E-2

2,37344E-4

1,14728E1

2,61951E0

1,62782E1

1,98597E2

1,08652E0

4,14513E-1

9,36770E-3

2,92176E-6

1,27539E-5

1,34294E-2

4,73651E0

2,14595E-3

3,36893E1

9,16885E-1

9.6

Oscill8 Core

1,03475E-3

5,84406E-2

2,37344E-4

1,14728E1

2,61951E0

1,62782E1

1,98597E2

1,08652E0

4,14513E-1

9,36770E-3

2,92176E-6

1,27539E-5

1,34294E-2

4,73651E0

2,14595E-3

3,36893E1

9,16885E-1

9.6

SBToolbox2

1,03602E-3

5,83988E-2

2,37683E-4

1,14718E1

2,62041E0

1,62770E1

1,98600E2

1,08645E0

4,14374E-1

9,36718E-3

2,91676E-6

1,27286E-5

1,34128E-2

4,73683E0

2,14440E-3

3,36898E1

9,16794E-1

9.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,03475E-3

5,84406E-2

2,37344E-4

1,14728E1

2,61951E0

1,62782E1

1,98597E2

1,08652E0

4,14513E-1

9,36770E-3

2,92176E-6

1,27539E-5

1,34294E-2

4,73651E0

2,14595E-3

3,36893E1

9,16885E-1

9.6

VCell

1,03475E-3

5,84406E-2

2,37344E-4

1,14728E1

2,61951E0

1,62782E1

1,98597E2

1,08652E0

4,14513E-1

9,36770E-3

2,92176E-6

1,27539E-5

1,34294E-2

4,73651E0

2,14595E-3

3,36893E1

9,16885E-1

9.6

copasi

1,03475E-3

5,84406E-2

2,37344E-4

1,14728E1

2,61951E0

1,62782E1

1,98597E2

1,08652E0

4,14513E-1

9,36770E-3

2,92176E-6

1,27539E-5

1,34294E-2

4,73651E0

2,14595E-3

3,36893E1

9,16885E-1

9.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,79471E-4

1,34725E-2

3,45994E-6

1,39299E1

1,71755E-1

1,99372E1

1,99765E2

7,19227E-2

7,86584E-2

2,14893E-3

8,00374E-9

6,47393E-7

1,67083E-4

5,81032E0

2,65765E-5

3,40252E1

1,42639E-1

9.6

jsim

1,03475E-3

5,84406E-2

2,37344E-4

1,14728E1

2,61951E0

1,62782E1

1,98597E2

1,08652E0

4,14513E-1

9,36770E-3

2,92176E-6

1,27539E-5

1,34294E-2

4,73651E0

2,14595E-3

3,36893E1

9,16885E-1

9.6

min

2,79471E-4

1,34725E-2

3,45994E-6

1,13852E1

1,71755E-1

1,59731E1

1,98597E2

7,19227E-2

7,86584E-2

2,14893E-3

8,00374E-9

6,47393E-7

1,67083E-4

4,31642E0

2,65765E-5

3,36893E1

1,42639E-1

9.6

max

1,03602E-3

2,64101E-1

2,37683E-4

1,39299E1

2,62041E0

1,99372E1

1,99765E2

1,08652E0

4,14513E-1

9,36770E-3

5,89608E-5

4,80027E-5

4,59466E-1

5,81032E0

2,14595E-3

3,40252E1

9,16885E-1

9.6

mean

1,03475E-3

5,84406E-2

2,37344E-4

1,14728E1

2,61951E0

1,62782E1

1,98597E2

1,08652E0

4,14513E-1

9,36770E-3

2,92176E-6

1,27539E-5

1,34294E-2

4,73651E0

2,14595E-3

3,36893E1

9,16885E-1

9.6

relative error(%)

0,00

9.8

BioUML

1,09587E-3

6,19055E-2

2,53898E-4

1,13754E1

2,62315E0

1,62479E1

1,98558E2

1,11214E0

4,31844E-1

9,70580E-3

3,26702E-6

1,41190E-5

1,43696E-2

4,79979E0

2,24577E-3

3,35786E1

9,33897E-1

9.8

ByoDyn

1,09587E-3

6,19055E-2

2,53898E-4

1,13754E1

2,62315E0

1,62479E1

1,98558E2

1,11214E0

4,31844E-1

9,70580E-3

3,26702E-6

1,41190E-5

1,43696E-2

4,79979E0

2,24577E-3

3,35786E1

9,33897E-1

9.8

Jarnac

8,21177E-4

2,73242E-1

1,88999E-4

1,12847E1

2,58422E0

1,59276E1

1,98566E2

1,00423E0

1,60429E-1

6,79010E-3

6,44248E-5

5,15042E-5

4,83419E-1

4,36201E0

1,56044E-3

3,37168E1

5,17945E-1

9.8

MathSBML

1,09587E-3

6,19055E-2

2,53898E-4

1,13754E1

2,62315E0

1,62479E1

1,98558E2

1,11214E0

4,31844E-1

9,70580E-3

3,26702E-6

1,41190E-5

1,43696E-2

4,79979E0

2,24577E-3

3,35786E1

9,33897E-1

9.8

Oscill8 Core

1,09587E-3

6,19055E-2

2,53898E-4

1,13754E1

2,62315E0

1,62479E1

1,98558E2

1,11214E0

4,31844E-1

9,70580E-3

3,26702E-6

1,41190E-5

1,43696E-2

4,79979E0

2,24577E-3

3,35786E1

9,33897E-1

9.8

SBToolbox2

1,09716E-3

6,18625E-2

2,54237E-4

1,13739E1

2,62400E0

1,62470E1

1,98560E2

1,11203E0

4,31707E-1

9,70514E-3

3,26186E-6

1,40934E-5

1,43530E-2

4,80006E0

2,24430E-3

3,35789E1

9,33827E-1

9.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,09587E-3

6,19055E-2

2,53898E-4

1,13754E1

2,62315E0

1,62479E1

1,98558E2

1,11214E0

4,31844E-1

9,70580E-3

3,26702E-6

1,41190E-5

1,43696E-2

4,79979E0

2,24577E-3

3,35786E1

9,33897E-1

9.8

VCell

1,09587E-3

6,19055E-2

2,53898E-4

1,13754E1

2,62314E0

1,62479E1

1,98558E2

1,11214E0

4,31844E-1

9,70580E-3

3,26702E-6

1,41191E-5

1,43696E-2

4,79979E0

2,24577E-3

3,35786E1

9,33897E-1

9.8

copasi

1,09587E-3

6,19055E-2

2,53898E-4

1,13754E1

2,62315E0

1,62479E1

1,98558E2

1,11214E0

4,31844E-1

9,70580E-3

3,26702E-6

1,41190E-5

1,43696E-2

4,79979E0

2,24577E-3

3,35786E1

9,33897E-1

9.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,94109E-4

1,41884E-2

3,68589E-6

1,38356E1

1,72670E-1

1,99380E1

1,99760E2

7,39412E-2

8,13301E-2

2,21306E-3

8,84117E-9

7,06473E-7

1,78130E-4

5,90093E0

2,77052E-5

3,39291E1

1,44382E-1

9.8

jsim

1,09587E-3

6,19055E-2

2,53898E-4

1,13754E1

2,62315E0

1,62479E1

1,98558E2

1,11214E0

4,31844E-1

9,70580E-3

3,26702E-6

1,41190E-5

1,43696E-2

4,79979E0

2,24577E-3

3,35786E1

9,33897E-1

9.8

min

2,94109E-4

1,41884E-2

3,68589E-6

1,12847E1

1,72670E-1

1,59276E1

1,98558E2

7,39412E-2

8,13301E-2

2,21306E-3

8,84117E-9

7,06473E-7

1,78130E-4

4,36201E0

2,77052E-5

3,35786E1

1,44382E-1

9.8

max

1,09716E-3

2,73242E-1

2,54237E-4

1,38356E1

2,62400E0

1,99380E1

1,99760E2

1,11214E0

4,31844E-1

9,70580E-3

6,44248E-5

5,15042E-5

4,83419E-1

5,90093E0

2,24577E-3

3,39291E1

9,33897E-1

9.8

mean

1,09587E-3

6,19055E-2

2,53898E-4

1,13754E1

2,62315E0

1,62479E1

1,98558E2

1,11214E0

4,31844E-1

9,70580E-3

3,26702E-6

1,41190E-5

1,43696E-2

4,79979E0

2,24577E-3

3,35786E1

9,33897E-1

9.8

relative error(%)

0,00