Test BIOMD0000000093.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000093.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000093.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: DormandPrince
generated code	: BIOMD0000000093.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: plot
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-11
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: JAK IFNRJ2_star_SOCS1 STAT1n_star_PPN PPX IFNRJ2_star_SOCS1_STAT1c IFNRJ2_star_STAT1c_star STAT1c_star_STAT1c_star RJ IFNRJ STAT1n_star STAT1n_star_STAT1n_star STAT1c_star_STAT1c_star_PPX PPN STAT1n_STAT1n_star R IFNRJ2_star IFNRJ2_star_SHP2_SOCS1_STAT1c IFNRJ2_star_STAT1c IFNRJ2 IFNRJ2_star_SHP2 STAT1c IFNR SOCS1 mRNAn SHP2 STAT1n STAT1c_star_PPX IFNRJ2_star_SHP2_STAT1c IFNRJ2_star_SHP2_SOCS1 mRNAc STAT1c_star STAT1n_star_STAT1n_star_PPN STAT1c_STAT1c_star
Simulators: ByoDyn copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner SBToolbox2 VCell Oscill8 Core SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

JAK

IFNRJ2_star_SOCS1

STAT1n_star_PPN

PPX

IFNRJ2_star_SOCS1_STAT1c

IFNRJ2_star_STAT1c_star

STAT1c_star_STAT1c_star

IFNRJ

STAT1n_star

STAT1n_star_STAT1n_star

STAT1c_star_STAT1c_star_PPX

PPN

STAT1n_STAT1n_star

IFNRJ2_star

IFNRJ2_star_SHP2_SOCS1_STAT1c

IFNRJ2_star_STAT1c

IFNRJ2

IFNRJ2_star_SHP2

STAT1c

IFNR

SOCS1

mRNAn

SHP2

STAT1n

STAT1c_star_PPX

IFNRJ2_star_SHP2_STAT1c

IFNRJ2_star_SHP2_SOCS1

mRNAc

STAT1c_star

STAT1n_star_STAT1n_star_PPN

STAT1c_STAT1c_star

0.0

BioUML

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

ByoDyn

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

MathSBML

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

SBToolbox2

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

VCell

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

copasi

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

-8,30269E-16

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

7,05729E-14

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

4,44089E-15

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

2,84217E-14

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

jsim

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

min

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

-8,30269E-16

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

max

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

4,44089E-15

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

7,05729E-14

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

mean

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0,00000E0

6,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E1

0,00000E0

1,00000E3

0,00000E0

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

8,34118E0

3,55986E-60

1,21784E-37

5,00000E1

1,05085E-60

1,78283E-25

1,55164E-27

1,59391E0

6,49000E-2

1,96389E-34

8,98086E-32

8,97663E-31

6,00000E1

3,04042E-39

8,01476E0

1,01166E-9

3,56924E-63

2,38211E-10

7,15870E-6

3,06333E-12

1,00000E3

3,26413E-1

2,50096E-47

2,45635E-38

1,00000E2

1,19617E-41

2,89863E-15

6,25235E-13

1,28059E-62

2,54374E-43

2,50981E-12

5,88282E-35

1,15953E-17

0.2

ByoDyn

8,34118E0

3,55970E-60

1,21783E-37

5,00000E1

1,05079E-60

1,78283E-25

1,55164E-27

1,59391E0

6,49000E-2

1,96388E-34

8,98085E-32

8,97662E-31

6,00000E1

3,04038E-39

8,01476E0

1,01166E-9

3,56900E-63

2,38211E-10

7,15870E-6

3,06333E-12

1,00000E3

3,26413E-1

2,50090E-47

2,45634E-38

1,00000E2

1,19614E-41

2,89863E-15

6,25235E-13

1,28052E-62

2,54371E-43

2,50981E-12

5,88279E-35

1,15953E-17

0.2

MathSBML

8,34118E0

2,70017E-60

1,08611E-37

5,00000E1

8,01129E-61

1,79292E-25

1,57345E-27

1,59391E0

6,49000E-2

1,84358E-34

9,50722E-32

9,50325E-31

6,00000E1

2,71211E-39

8,01476E0

1,01155E-9

2,67456E-63

2,38156E-10

7,15847E-6

3,06263E-12

1,00000E3

3,26413E-1

1,88847E-47

2,30581E-38

1,00000E2

9,03576E-42

2,89965E-15

6,25165E-13

9,82954E-63

2,26769E-43

2,50953E-12

5,52286E-35

1,15993E-17

0.2

Oscill8 Core

1,63067E-41

-9,92037E-13

5,00000E1

1,30346E-41

2,04913E-21

1,59389E0

6,49020E-2

-1,40735E-10

6,62274E-16

5,24789E-24

6,00000E1

8,01478E0

1,27784E-9

9,24525E-44

6,48740E-10

7,16178E-6

1,00000E3

3,26411E-1

3,17209E-29

1,07778E-21

1,00000E2

-1,40892E-10

3,27138E-12

1,47882E-43

7,09299E-26

6,93029E-10

1,64157E-14

0.2

SBToolbox2

8,34118E0

-6,89666E-58

-3,10335E-36

5,00000E1

-3,19545E-58

-1,00559E-25

-3,08650E-27

1,59393E0

6,48916E-2

-2,17058E-33

-4,28119E-31

-4,27655E-30

6,00000E1

-7,73348E-38

8,01475E0

9,92725E-10

-1,84594E-60

2,42968E-10

6,87245E-6

3,12888E-12

1,00000E3

3,26422E-1

-1,49403E-45

-2,71703E-37

1,00000E2

-7,11069E-40

3,25908E-15

6,69740E-13

-3,59222E-60

-6,50439E-42

2,68892E-12

-6,48911E-34

1,30365E-17

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

8,34119E0

3,54937E-60

1,23801E-37

5,00000E1

1,05936E-60

1,79293E-25

1,56449E-27

1,59389E0

6,49020E-2

1,98936E-34

9,07274E-32

9,06846E-31

6,00000E1

3,09074E-39

8,01478E0

1,01230E-9

3,65181E-63

2,38434E-10

7,16176E-6

3,06624E-12

1,00000E3

3,26411E-1

2,55434E-47

2,48822E-38

1,00000E2

1,22167E-41

2,90378E-15

6,26062E-13

1,29000E-62

2,58589E-43

2,51313E-12

5,95910E-35

1,16158E-17

0.2

VCell

8,34118E0

1,92729E-58

1,97866E-36

5,00000E1

6,36435E-59

1,78546E-25

2,53497E-27

1,59390E0

6,49010E-2

1,44169E-33

2,95317E-31

2,95006E-30

6,00000E1

4,93246E-38

8,01477E0

1,01190E-9

2,46827E-61

2,38324E-10

7,15952E-6

3,06483E-12

1,00000E3

3,26412E-1

8,51144E-46

1,80454E-37

1,00000E2

4,05694E-40

2,90252E-15

6,25761E-13

7,54212E-61

4,14453E-42

2,51193E-12

4,31069E-34

1,16108E-17

0.2

copasi

8,34118E0

1,22519E-45

-1,10494E-17

5,00000E1

4,33586E-46

-5,91567E-15

1,55694E-27

1,59391E0

6,49000E-2

-1,03212E-15

1,98079E-19

9,06626E-31

6,00000E1

1,87158E-14

8,01476E0

1,01167E-9

1,81793E-48

2,38211E-10

7,15870E-6

3,06780E-12

1,00000E3

3,26413E-1

4,30261E-33

2,94531E-25

1,00000E2

-1,03379E-15

-9,06626E-31

6,25234E-13

5,05052E-48

1,27120E-29

2,51005E-12

1,10494E-17

1,15971E-17

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,34118E0

-1,00132E-46

7,87399E-18

5,00000E1

-3,45388E-47

5,40679E-14

1,52809E-27

1,59391E0

6,49000E-2

2,21817E-15

-6,00306E-20

8,79852E-31

6,00000E1

-5,48525E-14

8,01476E0

1,01165E-9

-1,40140E-49

2,38207E-10

7,15870E-6

3,02695E-12

1,00000E3

3,26413E-1

-3,84374E-34

-4,89999E-26

1,00000E2

2,21943E-15

-8,79852E-31

6,25235E-13

-3,99292E-49

-1,45077E-30

2,49581E-12

-7,87399E-18

1,14625E-17

0.2

jsim

8,34118E0

3,30026E-43

6,02108E-29

5,00000E1

1,75516E-42

2,88841E-19

4,82738E-22

1,35958E0

2,98463E-1

8,02796E-28

6,43884E-25

3,47338E-23

6,00000E1

6,43969E-29

6,83646E0

2,93262E-7

7,06918E-43

7,72036E-7

3,90769E-4

1,00201E-7

1,00000E3

1,50471E0

2,49977E-33

1,72393E-27

1,00000E2

1,07893E-31

8,24336E-11

2,30272E-7

1,30245E-43

2,14656E-30

5,76223E-10

5,16857E-26

1,65275E-9

0.2

min

8,34118E0

-1,00132E-46

-9,92037E-13

5,00000E1

-3,45388E-47

-5,91567E-15

-3,08650E-27

1,35958E0

6,48916E-2

-1,40735E-10

-6,00306E-20

-4,27655E-30

6,00000E1

-5,48525E-14

6,83646E0

9,92725E-10

-1,40140E-49

2,38156E-10

6,87245E-6

3,02695E-12

1,00000E3

3,26411E-1

-3,84374E-34

-4,89999E-26

1,00000E2

-1,40892E-10

-9,06626E-31

6,25165E-13

-3,99292E-49

-1,45077E-30

2,49581E-12

-7,87399E-18

1,14625E-17

0.2

max

8,34119E0

1,63067E-41

7,87399E-18

5,00000E1

1,30346E-41

5,40679E-14

2,04913E-21

1,59393E0

2,98463E-1

2,21817E-15

6,62274E-16

3,47338E-23

6,00000E1

1,87158E-14

8,01478E0

2,93262E-7

7,06918E-43

7,72036E-7

3,90769E-4

1,00201E-7

1,00000E3

1,50471E0

3,17209E-29

1,07778E-21

1,00000E2

2,21943E-15

8,24336E-11

2,30272E-7

1,47882E-43

7,09299E-26

6,93029E-10

1,10494E-17

1,65275E-9

0.2

mean

8,34118E0

3,55970E-60

1,21783E-37

5,00000E1

1,05936E-60

1,78919E-25

1,56449E-27

1,59391E0

6,49000E-2

1,96388E-34

9,50722E-32

9,06846E-31

6,00000E1

3,06556E-39

8,01476E0

1,01167E-9

3,65181E-63

2,38324E-10

7,15870E-6

3,06553E-12

1,00000E3

3,26413E-1

2,55434E-47

2,48822E-38

1,00000E2

1,19614E-41

2,90109E-15

6,25761E-13

1,29000E-62

2,58589E-43

2,51193E-12

5,92094E-35

1,16108E-17

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

7,16854E0

3,16461E-52

6,60421E-32

5,00000E1

1,97223E-52

2,59503E-21

9,56820E-23

2,61462E0

2,16503E-1

5,17885E-29

1,14652E-26

1,14540E-25

6,00000E1

1,64639E-33

6,61957E0

4,10107E-8

1,38316E-54

1,96321E-8

1,67179E-4

2,60100E-10

1,00000E3

5,48973E-1

2,79510E-41

6,48168E-33

1,00000E2

1,33184E-35

1,03102E-12

1,07285E-10

2,35359E-54

1,38321E-37

4,32299E-10

1,54886E-29

4,12460E-15

0.4

ByoDyn

7,16854E0

3,16460E-52

6,60421E-32

5,00000E1

1,97222E-52

2,59503E-21

9,56820E-23

2,61462E0

2,16503E-1

5,17885E-29

1,14652E-26

1,14540E-25

6,00000E1

1,64639E-33

6,61957E0

4,10107E-8

1,38315E-54

1,96321E-8

1,67179E-4

2,60100E-10

1,00000E3

5,48973E-1

2,79510E-41

6,48168E-33

1,00000E2

1,33184E-35

1,03102E-12

1,07285E-10

2,35358E-54

1,38320E-37

4,32299E-10

1,54886E-29

4,12460E-15

0.4

MathSBML

7,16854E0

3,13430E-52

6,54661E-32

5,00000E1

1,98314E-52

2,59659E-21

9,59487E-23

2,61462E0

2,16503E-1

5,16989E-29

1,16039E-26

1,15928E-25

6,00000E1

1,63211E-33

6,61957E0

4,10103E-8

1,39750E-54

1,96313E-8

1,67179E-4

2,60088E-10

1,00000E3

5,48973E-1

2,72154E-41

6,47041E-33

1,00000E2

1,29696E-35

1,03086E-12

1,07274E-10

2,36666E-54

1,37101E-37

4,32254E-10

1,54621E-29

4,12396E-15

0.4

Oscill8 Core

1,46762E-38

-2,32252E-12

5,00000E1

1,23354E-38

4,53087E-21

2,61461E0

2,16505E-1

-1,02534E-10

1,01091E-15

3,81459E-23

6,00000E1

6,61958E0

4,10326E-8

1,21230E-40

2,00779E-8

1,67209E-4

1,00000E3

5,48970E-1

5,86177E-28

4,77252E-21

1,00000E2

-1,02856E-10

1,18653E-10

1,31926E-40

6,06806E-25

9,37512E-10

4,23058E-14

0.4

SBToolbox2

7,16821E0

-5,08447E-53

1,14810E-31

5,00000E1

-2,00188E-52

2,45128E-21

9,06780E-23

2,61505E0

2,16413E-1

7,02775E-29

1,26755E-26

1,26606E-25

6,00000E1

2,85934E-33

6,61909E0

4,09590E-8

-3,04906E-54

2,02964E-8

1,65185E-4

2,69845E-10

1,00000E3

5,49066E-1

6,50630E-41

8,79882E-33

1,00000E2

3,09140E-35

1,23184E-12

1,17785E-10

-2,13867E-54

2,40883E-37

4,74925E-10

2,09999E-29

4,92797E-15

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

7,16855E0

3,18507E-52

6,63922E-32

5,00000E1

1,99264E-52

2,60075E-21

9,59880E-23

2,61461E0

2,16505E-1

5,20183E-29

1,15085E-26

1,14973E-25

6,00000E1

1,65511E-33

6,61958E0

4,10210E-8

1,40460E-54

1,96397E-8

1,67209E-4

2,60202E-10

1,00000E3

5,48970E-1

2,81314E-41

6,51044E-33

1,00000E2

1,34042E-35

1,03180E-12

1,07344E-10

2,37718E-54

1,39055E-37

4,32539E-10

1,55573E-29

4,12771E-15

0.4

VCell

7,16854E0

3,20595E-52

6,62083E-32

5,00000E1

2,00317E-52

2,59539E-21

9,57029E-23

2,61462E0

2,16504E-1

5,18335E-29

1,14693E-26

1,14581E-25

6,00000E1

1,65051E-33

6,61957E0

4,10116E-8

1,40918E-54

1,96330E-8

1,67182E-4

2,60112E-10

1,00000E3

5,48972E-1

2,81524E-41

6,48733E-33

1,00000E2

1,34133E-35

1,03116E-12

1,07294E-10

2,38786E-54

1,38672E-37

4,32334E-10

1,55020E-29

4,12516E-15

0.4

copasi

7,16854E0

4,47682E-42

-2,40542E-17

5,00000E1

3,51778E-42

7,05729E-15

9,58230E-23

2,61462E0

2,16503E-1

-1,76623E-15

8,94745E-19

1,15058E-25

6,00000E1

-9,17301E-14

6,61957E0

4,10107E-8

3,10569E-44

1,96321E-8

1,67179E-4

2,60093E-10

1,00000E3

5,48973E-1

1,96717E-31

2,81481E-24

1,00000E2

-1,76950E-15

1,02289E-12

1,07285E-10

3,81501E-44

2,59476E-28

4,32299E-10

2,40542E-17

4,12460E-15

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,16854E0

-1,48667E-42

2,56187E-17

5,00000E1

-1,10604E-42

7,99361E-14

9,58351E-23

2,61462E0

2,16503E-1

7,84359E-16

-7,61108E-19

1,15028E-25

6,00000E1

-5,20730E-14

6,61957E0

4,10107E-8

-9,25065E-45

1,96321E-8

1,67179E-4

2,60037E-10

1,00000E3

5,48973E-1

-7,33803E-32

-1,80949E-24

1,00000E2

7,87994E-16

1,02318E-12

1,07286E-10

-1,22695E-44

-1,28259E-28

4,32293E-10

-2,56187E-17

4,12422E-15

0.4

jsim

7,16848E0

9,14485E-37

2,26253E-24

5,00000E1

1,16659E-35

6,35891E-16

1,92620E-18

1,90658E0

9,08963E-1

1,35906E-23

5,28954E-21

3,10993E-19

6,00000E1

2,60814E-24

4,82714E0

6,61135E-6

1,08278E-35

2,95487E-5

7,92360E-3

4,87912E-6

1,00000E3

2,34135E0

2,21475E-28

3,16241E-23

1,00000E2

9,13876E-27

8,02172E-9

1,92957E-5

7,65905E-37

8,69380E-26

2,51977E-8

9,47421E-22

1,61303E-7

0.4

min

7,16821E0

-1,48667E-42

-2,32252E-12

5,00000E1

-1,10604E-42

2,45128E-21

9,06780E-23

1,90658E0

2,16413E-1

-1,02534E-10

-7,61108E-19

1,14540E-25

6,00000E1

-9,17301E-14

4,82714E0

4,09590E-8

-9,25065E-45

1,96313E-8

1,65185E-4

2,60037E-10

1,00000E3

5,48970E-1

-7,33803E-32

-1,80949E-24

1,00000E2

-1,02856E-10

1,02289E-12

1,07274E-10

-1,22695E-44

-1,28259E-28

4,32254E-10

-2,56187E-17

4,12396E-15

0.4

max

7,16855E0

9,14485E-37

2,56187E-17

5,00000E1

1,16659E-35

7,99361E-14

1,92620E-18

2,61505E0

9,08963E-1

7,84359E-16

1,01091E-15

3,10993E-19

6,00000E1

2,60814E-24

6,61958E0

6,61135E-6

1,08278E-35

2,95487E-5

7,92360E-3

4,87912E-6

1,00000E3

2,34135E0

5,86177E-28

4,77252E-21

1,00000E2

7,87994E-16

8,02172E-9

1,92957E-5

7,65905E-37

6,06806E-25

2,51977E-8

2,40542E-17

1,61303E-7

0.4

mean

7,16854E0

3,18507E-52

6,62083E-32

5,00000E1

1,99264E-52

2,59867E-21

9,58351E-23

2,61462E0

2,16503E-1

5,18335E-29

1,16039E-26

1,15058E-25

6,00000E1

1,64845E-33

6,61957E0

4,10107E-8

1,40460E-54

1,96330E-8

1,67179E-4

2,60106E-10

1,00000E3

5,48973E-1

2,81524E-41

6,51044E-33

1,00000E2

1,34042E-35

1,03109E-12

1,07294E-10

2,37718E-54

1,39055E-37

4,32334E-10

1,55296E-29

4,12516E-15

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

6,29873E0

9,88538E-48

1,19833E-28

5,00000E1

9,64233E-48

5,47289E-19

4,74251E-20

3,28517E0

4,14188E-1

6,11712E-26

8,77971E-24

8,76650E-23

6,00000E1

2,98285E-30

5,59065E0

3,11831E-7

1,04159E-49

2,25374E-7

9,55580E-4

3,07883E-9

1,00000E3

7,08077E-1

7,81268E-38

7,66112E-30

1,00000E2

3,70818E-32

2,84071E-11

1,91073E-9

1,13216E-49

2,51695E-34

7,73009E-9

1,82642E-26

1,13650E-13

0.6

ByoDyn

6,29873E0

9,88537E-48

1,19833E-28

5,00000E1

9,64233E-48

5,47289E-19

4,74251E-20

3,28517E0

4,14188E-1

6,11712E-26

8,77971E-24

8,76650E-23

6,00000E1

2,98285E-30

5,59065E0

3,11831E-7

1,04159E-49

2,25374E-7

9,55580E-4

3,07883E-9

1,00000E3

7,08077E-1

7,81268E-38

7,66112E-30

1,00000E2

3,70818E-32

2,84071E-11

1,91073E-9

1,13216E-49

2,51695E-34

7,73009E-9

1,82642E-26

1,13650E-13

0.6

MathSBML

6,29873E0

9,84754E-48

1,19814E-28

5,00000E1

9,65686E-48

5,47240E-19

4,74299E-20

3,28517E0

4,14188E-1

6,12170E-26

8,79396E-24

8,78074E-23

6,00000E1

2,98241E-30

5,59065E0

3,11831E-7

1,04439E-49

2,25373E-7

9,55580E-4

3,07881E-9

1,00000E3

7,08077E-1

7,79011E-38

7,66685E-30

1,00000E2

3,69768E-32

2,84060E-11

1,91069E-9

1,13252E-49

2,51650E-34

7,72995E-9

1,82780E-26

1,13646E-13

0.6

Oscill8 Core

8,28792E-37

-3,32681E-12

5,00000E1

1,07896E-36

6,25766E-20

3,28516E0

4,14190E-1

-8,58163E-11

1,31671E-15

2,01515E-22

6,00000E1

5,59067E0

3,11875E-7

1,50823E-38

2,25766E-7

9,55676E-4

1,00000E3

7,08074E-1

3,10775E-27

1,05068E-20

1,00000E2

-8,62100E-11

1,92982E-9

1,09366E-38

2,10547E-24

8,16383E-9

1,68581E-13

0.6

SBToolbox2

6,29838E0

1,58071E-47

1,67240E-28

5,00000E1

1,60666E-47

5,53779E-19

4,93283E-20

3,28566E0

4,14095E-1

7,57289E-26

9,84538E-24

9,82894E-23

6,00000E1

4,16008E-30

5,59019E0

3,11027E-7

1,82626E-49

2,26997E-7

9,51313E-4

3,10708E-9

1,00000E3

7,08180E-1

1,25913E-37

9,48672E-30

1,00000E2

5,96447E-32

3,03571E-11

1,96849E-9

1,83816E-49

3,51698E-34

7,96733E-9

2,25971E-26

1,21454E-13

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

6,29874E0

1,30878E-47

1,34963E-28

5,00000E1

1,37811E-47

5,49711E-19

4,81844E-20

3,28516E0

4,14190E-1

6,59680E-26

9,14659E-24

9,13234E-23

6,00000E1

3,35863E-30

5,59067E0

3,11875E-7

1,60556E-49

2,25424E-7

9,55677E-4

3,07954E-9

1,00000E3

7,08074E-1

9,30382E-38

8,26259E-30

1,00000E2

4,41253E-32

2,84200E-11

1,91135E-9

1,56747E-49

2,83605E-34

7,73261E-9

1,96923E-26

1,13702E-13

0.6

VCell

6,29873E0

9,88732E-48

1,19846E-28

5,00000E1

9,64445E-48

5,47311E-19

4,74279E-20

3,28517E0

4,14189E-1

6,11766E-26

8,78034E-24

8,76713E-23

6,00000E1

2,98318E-30

5,59065E0

3,11833E-7

1,04185E-49

2,25377E-7

9,55585E-4

3,07888E-9

1,00000E3

7,08076E-1

7,81386E-38

7,66180E-30

1,00000E2

3,70873E-32

2,84081E-11

1,91077E-9

1,13240E-49

2,51723E-34

7,73027E-9

1,82659E-26

1,13655E-13

0.6

copasi

6,29873E0

3,92673E-40

-6,29056E-17

5,00000E1

5,10612E-40

-4,15135E-16

4,75318E-20

3,28517E0

4,14188E-1

-4,12761E-15

2,41883E-18

8,81815E-23

6,00000E1

1,23117E-14

5,59065E0

3,11831E-7

7,02911E-42

2,25374E-7

9,55580E-4

3,07883E-9

1,00000E3

7,08077E-1

1,65862E-30

1,04318E-23

1,00000E2

-4,13610E-15

2,83952E-11

1,91073E-9

5,16287E-42

1,45306E-27

7,73009E-9

6,29056E-17

1,13650E-13

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,29873E0

-2,37777E-40

2,29182E-17

5,00000E1

-2,87100E-40

8,70415E-14

4,74762E-20

3,28517E0

4,14188E-1

-5,91726E-16

-1,74974E-18

8,78593E-23

6,00000E1

-3,85886E-14

5,59065E0

3,11831E-7

-3,73148E-42

2,25374E-7

9,55580E-4

3,07876E-9

1,00000E3

7,08077E-1

-1,03045E-30

-8,14611E-24

1,00000E2

-5,89351E-16

2,84075E-11

1,91073E-9

-3,02023E-42

-1,04046E-27

7,73010E-9

-2,29182E-17

1,13651E-13

0.6

jsim

6,29831E0

2,47035E-33

6,03338E-22

5,00000E1

5,18518E-32

3,67605E-14

1,38861E-16

2,05320E0

1,56976E0

2,21965E-21

5,73159E-19

3,69143E-17

6,00000E1

7,52272E-22

3,49486E0

3,37042E-5

8,26271E-32

1,94133E-4

3,88922E-2

3,98634E-5

1,00000E3

2,80345E0

1,02710E-25

5,62275E-21

9,99998E1

4,04968E-24

9,00677E-8

2,05403E-4

3,28644E-33

2,50756E-23

1,73526E-7

1,68307E-19

1,81700E-6

0.6

min

6,29831E0

-2,37777E-40

-3,32681E-12

5,00000E1

-2,87100E-40

-4,15135E-16

4,74251E-20

2,05320E0

4,14095E-1

-8,58163E-11

-1,74974E-18

8,76650E-23

6,00000E1

-3,85886E-14

3,49486E0

3,11027E-7

-3,73148E-42

2,25373E-7

9,51313E-4

3,07876E-9

1,00000E3

7,08074E-1

-1,03045E-30

-8,14611E-24

9,99998E1

-8,62100E-11

2,83952E-11

1,91069E-9

-3,02023E-42

-1,04046E-27

7,72995E-9

-2,29182E-17

1,13646E-13

0.6

max

6,29874E0

2,47035E-33

2,29182E-17

5,00000E1

5,18518E-32

8,70415E-14

1,38861E-16

3,28566E0

1,56976E0

2,21965E-21

1,31671E-15

3,69143E-17

6,00000E1

1,23117E-14

5,59067E0

3,37042E-5

8,26271E-32

1,94133E-4

3,88922E-2

3,98634E-5

1,00000E3

2,80345E0

1,02710E-25

1,05068E-20

1,00000E2

4,04968E-24

9,00677E-8

2,05403E-4

3,28644E-33

2,50756E-23

1,73526E-7

6,29056E-17

1,81700E-6

0.6

mean

6,29873E0

1,30878E-47

1,19846E-28

5,00000E1

1,37811E-47

5,48511E-19

4,75318E-20

3,28517E0

4,14188E-1

6,11766E-26

9,14659E-24

8,81815E-23

6,00000E1

3,17091E-30

5,59065E0

3,11831E-7

1,60556E-49

2,25377E-7

9,55580E-4

3,07885E-9

1,00000E3

7,08077E-1

9,30382E-38

8,26259E-30

1,00000E2

3,70818E-32

2,84078E-11

1,91077E-9

1,56747E-49

2,83605E-34

7,73027E-9

1,89852E-26

1,13655E-13

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

5,63023E0

1,24167E-44

2,15650E-26

5,00000E1

1,66854E-44

2,10601E-17

3,35401E-18

3,72862E0

6,34941E-1

8,08697E-24

8,49446E-22

8,47696E-21

6,00000E1

5,35948E-28

4,80425E0

1,21941E-6

2,45765E-46

1,17429E-6

3,10198E-3

1,65485E-8

1,00000E3

8,25978E-1

1,92004E-35

1,01352E-27

1,00000E2

9,07661E-30

2,78235E-10

1,36610E-8

1,93669E-46

4,54278E-32

5,54991E-8

2,41040E-24

1,11323E-12

0.8

ByoDyn

5,63023E0

1,24167E-44

2,15650E-26

5,00000E1

1,66854E-44

2,10601E-17

3,35401E-18

3,72862E0

6,34941E-1

8,08697E-24

8,49445E-22

8,47696E-21

6,00000E1

5,35948E-28

4,80425E0

1,21941E-6

2,45765E-46

1,17429E-6

3,10198E-3

1,65485E-8

1,00000E3

8,25978E-1

1,92004E-35

1,01352E-27

1,00000E2

9,07660E-30

2,78235E-10

1,36610E-8

1,93669E-46

4,54278E-32

5,54991E-8

2,41040E-24

1,11323E-12

0.8

MathSBML

5,63023E0

1,24186E-44

2,15690E-26

5,00000E1

1,67282E-44

2,10586E-17

3,35374E-18

3,72862E0

6,34941E-1

8,08903E-24

8,49584E-22

8,47835E-21

6,00000E1

5,36048E-28

4,80425E0

1,21941E-6

2,46732E-46

1,17429E-6

3,10198E-3

1,65484E-8

1,00000E3

8,25978E-1

1,91933E-35

1,01378E-27

1,00000E2

9,07341E-30

2,78232E-10

1,36609E-8

1,94015E-46

4,54358E-32

5,54989E-8

2,41102E-24

1,11322E-12

0.8

Oscill8 Core

1,30441E-35

-4,11714E-12

5,00000E1

2,37045E-35

3,45183E-18

3,72861E0

6,34942E-1

-7,15767E-11

1,82451E-15

9,02699E-21

6,00000E1

4,80427E0

1,21952E-6

4,43876E-37

1,17472E-6

3,10218E-3

1,00000E3

8,25976E-1

9,90047E-27

1,83071E-20

1,00000E2

-7,19779E-11

1,36876E-8

2,31127E-37

4,94752E-24

5,58799E-8

1,18197E-12

0.8

SBToolbox2

5,62987E0

1,72789E-44

2,71123E-26

5,00000E1

2,41803E-44

2,12477E-17

3,43481E-18

3,72915E0

6,34862E-1

9,40119E-24

9,22255E-22

9,20218E-21

6,00000E1

6,73430E-28

4,80378E0

1,21786E-6

3,71465E-46

1,17803E-6

3,09469E-3

1,66217E-8

1,00000E3

8,26088E-1

2,64646E-35

1,17845E-27

1,00000E2

1,24901E-29

2,87681E-10

1,38575E-8

2,73432E-46

5,71735E-32

5,63126E-8

2,80059E-24

1,15102E-12

0.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,63024E0

1,28056E-44

2,18283E-26

5,00000E1

1,72896E-44

2,10791E-17

3,35857E-18

3,72861E0

6,34942E-1

8,13161E-24

8,51623E-22

8,49864E-21

6,00000E1

5,42464E-28

4,80427E0

1,21952E-6

2,55309E-46

1,17446E-6

3,10218E-3

1,65510E-8

1,00000E3

8,25976E-1

1,96046E-35

1,01913E-27

1,00000E2

9,26553E-30

2,78320E-10

1,36640E-8

2,00260E-46

4,59867E-32

5,55114E-8

2,42360E-24

1,11357E-12

0.8

VCell

5,63023E0

1,24175E-44

2,15660E-26

5,00000E1

1,66865E-44

2,10605E-17

3,35409E-18

3,72862E0

6,34942E-1

8,08727E-24

8,49471E-22

8,47722E-21

6,00000E1

5,35972E-28

4,80425E0

1,21941E-6

2,45783E-46

1,17430E-6

3,10199E-3

1,65486E-8

1,00000E3

8,25978E-1

1,92014E-35

1,01356E-27

1,00000E2

9,07708E-30

2,78239E-10

1,36611E-8

1,93681E-46

4,54298E-32

5,54997E-8

2,41049E-24

1,11325E-12

0.8

copasi

5,63023E0

9,16764E-39

-1,07795E-16

5,00000E1

1,59502E-38

-2,69838E-15

3,35541E-18

3,72862E0

6,34941E-1

-5,29788E-15

5,66290E-18

8,48918E-21

6,00000E1

3,10320E-14

4,80425E0

1,21941E-6

2,87325E-40

1,17429E-6

3,10198E-3

1,65485E-8

1,00000E3

8,25978E-1

7,64985E-30

2,98056E-23

1,00000E2

-5,31118E-15

2,78227E-10

1,36610E-8

1,59740E-40

5,17628E-27

5,54992E-8

1,07795E-16

1,11323E-12

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,63023E0

-6,38857E-39

3,14555E-17

5,00000E1

-1,09281E-38

1,01474E-13

3,35567E-18

3,72862E0

6,34941E-1

1,53307E-15

-2,69689E-18

8,48866E-21

6,00000E1

-4,28587E-14

4,80425E0

1,21941E-6

-1,94421E-40

1,17429E-6

3,10198E-3

1,65484E-8

1,00000E3

8,25978E-1

-5,39417E-30

-1,91051E-23

1,00000E2

1,53612E-15

2,78213E-10

1,36610E-8

-1,10249E-40

-3,68771E-27

5,54991E-8

-3,14555E-17

1,11324E-12

0.8

jsim

5,62866E0

4,38147E-31

2,29697E-20

5,00000E1

1,28698E-29

5,06143E-13

2,08913E-15

2,00302E0

2,15002E0

5,85633E-20

1,13982E-17

8,07503E-16

6,00000E1

3,10596E-20

2,58305E0

9,48299E-5

3,12551E-29

6,35767E-4

1,07295E-1

1,59385E-4

9,99998E2

3,04561E0

6,01634E-24

1,62118E-19

9,99989E1

2,26700E-22

4,34622E-7

9,64040E-4

8,24720E-31

1,03531E-21

5,82500E-7

4,84804E-18

8,79928E-6

0.8

min

5,62866E0

-6,38857E-39

-4,11714E-12

5,00000E1

-1,09281E-38

-2,69838E-15

3,35374E-18

2,00302E0

6,34862E-1

-7,15767E-11

-2,69689E-18

8,47696E-21

6,00000E1

-4,28587E-14

2,58305E0

1,21786E-6

-1,94421E-40

1,17429E-6

3,09469E-3

1,65484E-8

9,99998E2

8,25976E-1

-5,39417E-30

-1,91051E-23

9,99989E1

-7,19779E-11

2,78213E-10

1,36609E-8

-1,10249E-40

-3,68771E-27

5,54989E-8

-3,14555E-17

1,11322E-12

0.8

max

5,63024E0

4,38147E-31

3,14555E-17

5,00000E1

1,28698E-29

5,06143E-13

2,08913E-15

3,72915E0

2,15002E0

1,53307E-15

1,82451E-15

8,07503E-16

6,00000E1

3,10320E-14

4,80427E0

9,48299E-5

3,12551E-29

6,35767E-4

1,07295E-1

1,59385E-4

1,00000E3

3,04561E0

6,01634E-24

1,62118E-19

1,00000E2

1,53612E-15

4,34622E-7

9,64040E-4

8,24720E-31

1,03531E-21

5,82500E-7

1,07795E-16

8,79928E-6

0.8

mean

5,63023E0

1,28056E-44

2,15690E-26

5,00000E1

1,72896E-44

2,10698E-17

3,35567E-18

3,72862E0

6,34941E-1

8,08903E-24

8,51623E-22

8,48918E-21

6,00000E1

5,39256E-28

4,80425E0

1,21941E-6

2,55309E-46

1,17430E-6

3,10198E-3

1,65485E-8

1,00000E3

8,25978E-1

1,96046E-35

1,01913E-27

1,00000E2

9,07708E-30

2,78237E-10

1,36611E-8

2,00260E-46

4,59867E-32

5,54997E-8

2,41731E-24

1,11325E-12

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

5,10228E0

2,74729E-42

1,10864E-24

5,00000E1

4,72892E-42

3,24760E-16

8,29067E-17

4,01827E0

8,64586E-1

3,26579E-22

2,68494E-20

2,67787E-19

6,00000E1

2,75081E-26

4,18639E0

3,34765E-6

8,87622E-44

4,00618E-6

7,42378E-3

5,82481E-8

1,00000E3

9,15893E-1

1,26109E-33

4,09586E-26

1,00000E2

5,93698E-28

1,55775E-9

5,97264E-8

5,45050E-44

2,34245E-30

2,43701E-7

9,71662E-23

6,23311E-12

1.0

ByoDyn

5,10228E0

2,74728E-42

1,10864E-24

5,00000E1

4,72892E-42

3,24760E-16

8,29067E-17

4,01827E0

8,64586E-1

3,26579E-22

2,68494E-20

2,67787E-19

6,00000E1

2,75081E-26

4,18639E0

3,34765E-6

8,87622E-44

4,00618E-6

7,42378E-3

5,82481E-8

1,00000E3

9,15893E-1

1,26109E-33

4,09586E-26

1,00000E2

5,93698E-28

1,55775E-9

5,97264E-8

5,45050E-44

2,34245E-30

2,43701E-7

9,71662E-23

6,23311E-12

1.0

MathSBML

5,10228E0

2,72810E-42

1,10618E-24

5,00000E1

4,71073E-42

3,24586E-16

8,28177E-17

4,01827E0

8,64586E-1

3,26003E-22

2,68142E-20

2,67436E-19

6,00000E1

2,74473E-26

4,18639E0

3,34765E-6

8,85184E-44

4,00616E-6

7,42379E-3

5,82477E-8

1,00000E3

9,15893E-1

1,25752E-33

4,08864E-26

1,00000E2

5,92026E-28

1,55766E-9

5,97251E-8

5,41869E-44

2,33724E-30

2,43696E-7

9,69954E-23

6,23276E-12

1.0

Oscill8 Core

1,04012E-34

-4,71257E-12

5,00000E1

2,44105E-34

8,34126E-17

4,01826E0

8,64586E-1

-5,80540E-11

2,19654E-15

2,70831E-19

6,00000E1

4,18640E0

3,34785E-6

5,75988E-36

4,00678E-6

7,42412E-3

1,00000E3

9,15891E-1

2,40934E-26

2,83554E-20

1,00000E2

-5,84082E-11

5,97629E-8

2,32388E-36

9,58094E-24

2,44048E-7

6,31348E-12

1.0

SBToolbox2

5,10188E0

3,20006E-42

1,28554E-24

5,00000E1

5,57578E-42

3,21367E-16

8,19719E-17

4,01874E0

8,64526E-1

3,56314E-22

2,77660E-20

2,76892E-19

6,00000E1

3,18804E-26

4,18596E0

3,34417E-6

1,05553E-43

4,01350E-6

7,40925E-3

5,84123E-8

1,00000E3

9,15993E-1

1,56958E-33

4,46976E-26

1,00000E2

7,37772E-28

1,59115E-9

6,02626E-8

6,27942E-44

2,71905E-30

2,45947E-7

1,05957E-22

6,36672E-12

1.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,10229E0

2,76272E-42

1,11099E-24

5,00000E1

4,75933E-42

3,24959E-16

8,29786E-17

4,01826E0

8,64586E-1

3,27043E-22

2,68780E-20

2,68071E-19

6,00000E1

2,75662E-26

4,18640E0

3,34787E-6

8,94072E-44

4,00659E-6

7,42412E-3

5,82545E-8

1,00000E3

9,15891E-1

1,26544E-33

4,10169E-26

1,00000E2

5,95720E-28

1,55810E-9

5,97358E-8

5,48323E-44

2,34746E-30

2,43740E-7

9,73037E-23

6,23451E-12

1.0

VCell

5,10228E0

2,74737E-42

1,10866E-24

5,00000E1

4,72908E-42

3,24763E-16

8,29078E-17

4,01827E0

8,64586E-1

3,26585E-22

2,68499E-20

2,67791E-19

6,00000E1

2,75087E-26

4,18639E0

3,34766E-6

8,87656E-44

4,00619E-6

7,42379E-3

5,82483E-8

1,00000E3

9,15893E-1

1,26112E-33

4,09594E-26

1,00000E2

5,93714E-28

1,55776E-9

5,97267E-8

5,45069E-44

2,34251E-30

2,43702E-7

9,71681E-23

6,23316E-12

1.0

copasi

5,10228E0

1,02103E-37

-1,65038E-16

5,00000E1

2,26867E-37

-1,24540E-14

8,29107E-17

4,01827E0

8,64586E-1

-5,24060E-15

1,09144E-17

2,67845E-19

6,00000E1

4,62435E-15

4,18639E0

3,34765E-6

5,13337E-39

4,00618E-6

7,42378E-3

5,82481E-8

1,00000E3

9,15893E-1

2,62827E-29

7,05280E-23

1,00000E2

-5,25920E-15

1,55775E-9

5,97264E-8

2,23168E-39

1,47697E-26

2,43701E-7

1,65038E-16

6,23311E-12

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,10228E0

-6,98592E-38

5,85150E-17

5,00000E1

-1,55972E-37

6,08402E-14

8,29422E-17

4,01827E0

8,64586E-1

3,06681E-15

-4,29011E-18

2,68046E-19

6,00000E1

4,80385E-15

4,18639E0

3,34765E-6

-3,53699E-39

4,00618E-6

7,42378E-3

5,82481E-8

1,00000E3

9,15893E-1

-1,75970E-29

-3,61657E-23

1,00000E2

3,07306E-15

1,55772E-9

5,97263E-8

-1,52930E-39

-9,08207E-27

2,43701E-7

-5,85150E-17

6,23312E-12

1.0

jsim

5,09817E0

1,82368E-29

3,09848E-19

5,00000E1

6,85208E-28

3,24495E-12

1,37047E-14

1,86108E0

2,59733E0

5,85187E-19

9,20762E-17

7,20125E-15

6,00000E1

4,55346E-19

1,94356E0

1,93868E-4

2,37572E-27

1,43806E-3

2,16720E-1

4,33551E-4

9,99996E2

3,15462E0

1,16868E-22

1,77619E-18

9,99966E1

4,21090E-21

1,34012E-6

2,92121E-3

4,56078E-29

1,51780E-20

1,33859E-6

5,30590E-17

2,72374E-5

1.0

min

5,09817E0

-6,98592E-38

-4,71257E-12

5,00000E1

-1,55972E-37

-1,24540E-14

8,19719E-17

1,86108E0

8,64526E-1

-5,80540E-11

-4,29011E-18

2,67436E-19

6,00000E1

2,74473E-26

1,94356E0

3,34417E-6

-3,53699E-39

4,00616E-6

7,40925E-3

5,82477E-8

9,99996E2

9,15891E-1

-1,75970E-29

-3,61657E-23

9,99966E1

-5,84082E-11

1,55766E-9

5,97251E-8

-1,52930E-39

-9,08207E-27

2,43696E-7

-5,85150E-17

6,23276E-12

1.0

max

5,10229E0

1,82368E-29

5,85150E-17

5,00000E1

6,85208E-28

3,24495E-12

1,37047E-14

4,01874E0

2,59733E0

3,06681E-15

2,19654E-15

7,20125E-15

6,00000E1

4,80385E-15

4,18640E0

1,93868E-4

2,37572E-27

1,43806E-3

2,16720E-1

4,33551E-4

1,00000E3

3,15462E0

1,16868E-22

1,77619E-18

1,00000E2

3,07306E-15

1,34012E-6

2,92121E-3

4,56078E-29

1,51780E-20

1,33859E-6

1,65038E-16

2,72374E-5

1.0

mean

5,10228E0

2,76272E-42

1,10866E-24

5,00000E1

4,75933E-42

3,24761E-16

8,29107E-17

4,01827E0

8,64586E-1

3,26585E-22

2,68780E-20

2,68046E-19

6,00000E1

2,97233E-26

4,18639E0

3,34765E-6

8,94072E-44

4,00619E-6

7,42379E-3

5,82482E-8

1,00000E3

9,15893E-1

1,26544E-33

4,10169E-26

1,00000E2

5,93714E-28

1,55776E-9

5,97267E-8

5,48323E-44

2,34746E-30

2,43702E-7

9,72359E-23

6,23316E-12

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

4,67626E0

2,05759E-40

2,60182E-23

5,00000E1

4,32510E-40

2,83794E-15

1,06419E-15

4,20039E0

1,09393E0

6,28369E-21

4,22082E-19

4,20719E-18

6,00000E1

6,44506E-25

3,69014E0

7,39171E-6

9,90777E-42

1,05137E-5

1,46933E-2

1,57711E-7

1,00000E3

9,86122E-1

3,62389E-32

7,88658E-25

1,00000E2

1,69887E-26

6,15083E-9

1,92272E-7

4,97109E-42

5,51440E-29

7,88053E-7

1,86614E-21

2,46134E-11

1.2

ByoDyn

4,67626E0

2,05759E-40

2,60182E-23

5,00000E1

4,32510E-40

2,83794E-15

1,06419E-15

4,20039E0

1,09393E0

6,28369E-21

4,22082E-19

4,20719E-18

6,00000E1

6,44506E-25

3,69014E0

7,39171E-6

9,90777E-42

1,05137E-5

1,46933E-2

1,57711E-7

1,00000E3

9,86122E-1

3,62389E-32

7,88658E-25

1,00000E2

1,69887E-26

6,15083E-9

1,92272E-7

4,97109E-42

5,51440E-29

7,88053E-7

1,86614E-21

2,46134E-11

1.2

MathSBML

4,67626E0

2,04731E-40

2,59865E-23

5,00000E1

4,30844E-40

2,83727E-15

1,06365E-15

4,20039E0

1,09393E0

6,27812E-21

4,21801E-19

4,20439E-18

6,00000E1

6,43725E-25

3,69014E0

7,39171E-6

9,86956E-42

1,05137E-5

1,46933E-2

1,57711E-7

1,00000E3

9,86122E-1

3,61756E-32

7,87958E-25

1,00000E2

1,69594E-26

6,15068E-9

1,92270E-7

4,94618E-42

5,50764E-29

7,88046E-7

1,86449E-21

2,46128E-11

1.2

Oscill8 Core

5,47472E-34

-5,12918E-12

5,00000E1

1,57346E-33

1,06634E-15

4,20038E0

1,09393E0

-4,52146E-11

2,49159E-15

4,22159E-18

6,00000E1

3,69015E0

7,39204E-6

4,48897E-35

1,05146E-5

1,46937E-2

1,00000E3

9,86120E-1

4,96773E-26

4,01642E-20

1,00000E2

-4,54765E-11

1,92324E-7

1,48111E-35

1,64006E-23

7,88399E-7

2,47045E-11

1.2

SBToolbox2

4,67592E0

2,44854E-40

3,01897E-23

5,00000E1

5,25040E-40

2,81324E-15

1,05485E-15

4,20085E0

1,09393E0

6,86392E-21

4,37270E-19

4,35775E-18

6,00000E1

7,47335E-25

3,68969E0

7,38595E-6

1,22029E-41

1,05318E-5

1,46686E-2

1,58148E-7

1,00000E3

9,86223E-1

4,51339E-32

8,61701E-25

1,00000E2

2,11186E-26

6,26597E-9

1,93818E-7

5,88119E-42

6,40632E-29

7,94580E-7

2,03718E-21

2,50744E-11

1.2

SBWOdeSolver

4,67627E0

2,06252E-40

2,60474E-23

5,00000E1

4,33673E-40

2,83925E-15

1,06489E-15

4,20038E0

1,09393E0

6,28951E-21

4,22411E-19

4,21047E-18

6,00000E1

6,45228E-25

3,69015E0

7,39206E-6

9,93721E-42

1,05145E-5

1,46937E-2

1,57724E-7

1,00000E3

9,86120E-1

3,62907E-32

7,89390E-25

1,00000E2

1,70128E-26

6,15190E-9

1,92295E-7

4,98415E-42

5,52062E-29

7,88149E-7

1,86786E-21

2,46177E-11

1.2

VCell

4,67626E0

2,05763E-40

2,60186E-23

5,00000E1

4,32519E-40

2,83796E-15

1,06420E-15

4,20039E0

1,09393E0

6,28376E-21

4,22086E-19

4,20723E-18

6,00000E1

6,44515E-25

3,69014E0

7,39171E-6

9,90799E-42

1,05137E-5

1,46933E-2

1,57711E-7

1,00000E3

9,86122E-1

3,62395E-32

7,88668E-25

1,00000E2

1,69890E-26

6,15086E-9

1,92272E-7

4,97119E-42

5,51448E-29

7,88056E-7

1,86616E-21

2,46135E-11

1.2

copasi

4,67626E0

7,30968E-37

-2,33547E-16

5,00000E1

1,97406E-36

4,56648E-15

1,06424E-15

4,20039E0

1,09393E0

-7,17218E-15

1,88531E-17

4,20763E-18

6,00000E1

-4,62788E-14

3,69014E0

7,39171E-6

5,38449E-38

1,05137E-5

1,46933E-2

1,57711E-7

1,00000E3

9,86122E-1

7,41777E-29

1,43141E-22

1,00000E2

-7,19612E-15

6,15083E-9

1,92272E-7

1,92918E-38

3,54646E-26

7,88053E-7

2,33547E-16

2,46134E-11

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,67626E0

-4,56231E-37

9,34505E-17

5,00000E1

-1,25519E-36

5,46230E-14

1,06535E-15

4,20039E0

1,09393E0

3,46697E-15

-6,70798E-18

4,21894E-18

6,00000E1

-2,18825E-14

3,69014E0

7,39171E-6

-3,46396E-38

1,05137E-5

1,46933E-2

1,57711E-7

1,00000E3

9,86122E-1

-4,46073E-29

-6,34515E-23

1,00000E2

3,47675E-15

6,15083E-9

1,92271E-7

-1,21278E-38

-1,88392E-26

7,88052E-7

-9,34505E-17

2,46136E-11

1.2

jsim

4,66775E0

3,10866E-28

2,20342E-18

5,00000E1

1,41148E-26

1,30103E-11

5,41011E-14

1,68264E0

2,90629E0

3,21432E-18

4,27600E-16

3,70291E-14

6,00000E1

3,52489E-18

1,48619E0

3,25610E-4

6,69698E-26

2,59468E-3

3,61055E-1

9,28504E-4

9,99991E2

3,18156E0

1,14775E-21

1,07272E-17

9,99923E1

3,95814E-20

3,13933E-6

6,75963E-3

9,91990E-28

1,17494E-19

2,44311E-6

3,20063E-16

6,40741E-5

1.2

min

4,66775E0

-4,56231E-37

-5,12918E-12

5,00000E1

-1,25519E-36

2,81324E-15

1,05485E-15

1,68264E0

1,09393E0

-4,52146E-11

-6,70798E-18

4,20439E-18

6,00000E1

-4,62788E-14

1,48619E0

7,38595E-6

-3,46396E-38

1,05137E-5

1,46686E-2

1,57711E-7

9,99991E2

9,86120E-1

-4,46073E-29

-6,34515E-23

9,99923E1

-4,54765E-11

6,15068E-9

1,92270E-7

-1,21278E-38

-1,88392E-26

7,88046E-7

-9,34505E-17

2,46128E-11

1.2

max

4,67627E0

3,10866E-28

9,34505E-17

5,00000E1

1,41148E-26

1,30103E-11

5,41011E-14

4,20085E0

2,90629E0

3,46697E-15

2,49159E-15

3,70291E-14

6,00000E1

3,52489E-18

3,69015E0

3,25610E-4

6,69698E-26

2,59468E-3

3,61055E-1

9,28504E-4

1,00000E3

3,18156E0

1,14775E-21

1,07272E-17

1,00000E2

3,47675E-15

3,13933E-6

6,75963E-3

9,91990E-28

1,17494E-19

2,44311E-6

3,20063E-16

6,40741E-5

1.2

mean

4,67626E0

2,06252E-40

2,60186E-23

5,00000E1

4,33673E-40

2,83860E-15

1,06424E-15

4,20039E0

1,09393E0

6,28376E-21

4,22411E-19

4,21047E-18

6,00000E1

6,44510E-25

3,69014E0

7,39171E-6

9,93721E-42

1,05137E-5

1,46933E-2

1,57711E-7

1,00000E3

9,86122E-1

3,62907E-32

7,89390E-25

1,00000E2

1,69890E-26

6,15085E-9

1,92272E-7

4,98415E-42

5,52062E-29

7,88056E-7

1,86701E-21

2,46136E-11

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

4,32645E0

7,36933E-39

3,57395E-22

5,00000E1

1,82832E-38

1,68680E-14

8,74476E-15

4,30551E0

1,31686E0

7,29026E-20

4,12208E-18

4,10624E-17

6,00000E1

8,83814E-24

3,28434E0

1,40938E-5

4,96021E-40

2,31024E-5

2,55524E-2

3,57480E-7

1,00000E3

1,04211E0

5,91797E-31

9,15673E-24

1,00000E2

2,76240E-25

1,91428E-8

5,02705E-7

2,10361E-40

7,59869E-28

2,06994E-6

2,16100E-20

7,66085E-11

1.4

ByoDyn

4,32645E0

7,36933E-39

3,57395E-22

5,00000E1

1,82832E-38

1,68680E-14

8,74476E-15

4,30551E0

1,31686E0

7,29026E-20

4,12208E-18

4,10624E-17

6,00000E1

8,83814E-24

3,28434E0

1,40938E-5

4,96021E-40

2,31024E-5

2,55524E-2

3,57480E-7

1,00000E3

1,04211E0

5,91797E-31

9,15673E-24

1,00000E2

2,76240E-25

1,91428E-8

5,02705E-7

2,10361E-40

7,59869E-28

2,06994E-6

2,16100E-20

7,66085E-11

1.4

MathSBML

4,32645E0

7,35029E-39

3,57174E-22

5,00000E1

1,82406E-38

1,68661E-14

8,74255E-15

4,30551E0

1,31686E0

7,28683E-20

4,12063E-18

4,10480E-17

6,00000E1

8,83270E-24

3,28434E0

1,40938E-5

4,94786E-40

2,31024E-5

2,55524E-2

3,57480E-7

1,00000E3

1,04211E0

5,91299E-31

9,15242E-24

1,00000E2

2,76010E-25

1,91426E-8

5,02703E-7

2,09763E-40

7,59396E-28

2,06993E-6

2,15998E-20

7,66076E-11

1.4

Oscill8 Core

2,17717E-33

-5,38196E-12

5,00000E1

7,37641E-33

8,75304E-15

4,30550E0

1,31686E0

-3,30241E-11

2,79532E-15

4,11226E-17

6,00000E1

3,28436E0

1,40943E-5

2,47258E-34

2,31038E-5

2,55530E-2

1,00000E3

1,04211E0

9,13641E-26

5,34738E-20

1,00000E2

-3,31568E-11

5,02782E-7

6,93568E-35

2,57380E-23

2,07034E-6

7,67112E-11

1.4

SBToolbox2

4,32604E0

7,93371E-39

4,02694E-22

5,00000E1

1,96367E-38

1,66407E-14

8,57874E-15

4,30598E0

1,31687E0

7,79305E-20

4,20555E-18

4,18868E-17

6,00000E1

9,95145E-24

3,28388E0

1,40836E-5

5,24685E-40

2,31353E-5

2,55128E-2

3,58379E-7

1,00000E3

1,04224E0

7,09134E-31

9,79080E-24

1,00000E2

3,30374E-25

1,94590E-8

5,06235E-7

2,20010E-40

8,57250E-28

2,08506E-6

2,30851E-20

7,78726E-11

1.4

SBWOdeSolver

4,32646E0

7,38159E-39

3,57697E-22

5,00000E1

1,83168E-38

1,68741E-14

8,74932E-15

4,30550E0

1,31686E0

7,29555E-20

4,12463E-18

4,10878E-17

6,00000E1

8,84560E-24

3,28435E0

1,40943E-5

4,97025E-40

2,31038E-5

2,55530E-2

3,57504E-7

1,00000E3

1,04211E0

5,92385E-31

9,16339E-24

1,00000E2

2,76513E-25

1,91455E-8

5,02752E-7

2,10747E-40

7,60514E-28

2,07014E-6

2,16256E-20

7,66191E-11

1.4

VCell

4,32645E0

7,36947E-39

3,57400E-22

5,00000E1

1,82835E-38

1,68681E-14

8,74481E-15

4,30550E0

1,31686E0

7,29034E-20

4,12212E-18

4,10627E-17

6,00000E1

8,83826E-24

3,28435E0

1,40938E-5

4,96033E-40

2,31024E-5

2,55524E-2

3,57481E-7

1,00000E3

1,04211E0

5,91806E-31

9,15683E-24

1,00000E2

2,76245E-25

1,91429E-8

5,02706E-7

2,10366E-40

7,59880E-28

2,06995E-6

2,16102E-20

7,66088E-11

1.4

copasi

4,32645E0

3,83015E-36

-3,18703E-16

5,00000E1

1,21668E-35

1,49448E-14

8,74579E-15

4,30550E0

1,31686E0

-9,56089E-15

3,28204E-17

4,10734E-17

6,00000E1

7,76884E-14

3,28434E0

1,40938E-5

3,89324E-37

2,31024E-5

2,55524E-2

3,57480E-7

1,00000E3

1,04211E0

1,80927E-28

2,68133E-22

1,00000E2

-9,59090E-15

1,91428E-8

5,02705E-7

1,18908E-37

7,54318E-26

2,06994E-6

3,18703E-16

7,66085E-11

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,32645E0

-2,15502E-36

1,25331E-16

5,00000E1

-7,00371E-36

7,59393E-14

8,74919E-15

4,30550E0

1,31686E0

2,34394E-15

-7,15406E-18

4,11231E-17

6,00000E1

-1,19246E-14

3,28435E0

1,40938E-5

-2,27640E-37

2,31024E-5

2,55524E-2

3,57480E-7

1,00000E3

1,04211E0

-9,73684E-29

-1,00597E-22

1,00000E2

2,35566E-15

1,91428E-8

5,02704E-7

-6,74930E-38

-3,51839E-26

2,06994E-6

-1,25331E-16

7,66087E-11

1.4

jsim

4,31136E0

2,91161E-27

1,01888E-17

5,00000E1

1,53667E-25

3,81555E-11

1,52442E-13

1,49674E0

3,09501E0

1,18207E-17

1,37205E-15

1,31839E-13

6,00000E1

1,77610E-17

1,15374E0

4,79992E-4

9,67349E-25

4,03249E-3

5,29181E-1

1,69257E-3

9,99983E2

3,15762E0

7,11663E-21

4,34637E-17

9,99853E1

2,35198E-19

6,12113E-6

1,30568E-2

1,15163E-26

5,92013E-19

3,83176E-6

1,29508E-15

1,25497E-4

1.4

min

4,31136E0

-2,15502E-36

-5,38196E-12

5,00000E1

-7,00371E-36

1,49448E-14

8,57874E-15

1,49674E0

1,31686E0

-3,30241E-11

-7,15406E-18

4,10480E-17

6,00000E1

-1,19246E-14

1,15374E0

1,40836E-5

-2,27640E-37

2,31024E-5

2,55128E-2

3,57480E-7

9,99983E2

1,04211E0

-9,73684E-29

-1,00597E-22

9,99853E1

-3,31568E-11

1,91426E-8

5,02703E-7

-6,74930E-38

-3,51839E-26

2,06993E-6

-1,25331E-16

7,66076E-11

1.4

max

4,32646E0

2,91161E-27

1,25331E-16

5,00000E1

1,53667E-25

3,81555E-11

1,52442E-13

4,30598E0

3,09501E0

2,34394E-15

2,79532E-15

1,31839E-13

6,00000E1

7,76884E-14

3,28436E0

4,79992E-4

9,67349E-25

4,03249E-3

5,29181E-1

1,69257E-3

1,00000E3

3,15762E0

7,11663E-21

4,34637E-17

1,00000E2

2,35566E-15

6,12113E-6

1,30568E-2

1,15163E-26

5,92013E-19

3,83176E-6

1,29508E-15

1,25497E-4

1.4

mean

4,32645E0

7,38159E-39

3,57400E-22

5,00000E1

1,83168E-38

1,68680E-14

8,74579E-15

4,30550E0

1,31686E0

7,29034E-20

4,12463E-18

4,10878E-17

6,00000E1

8,84193E-24

3,28434E0

1,40938E-5

4,97025E-40

2,31024E-5

2,55524E-2

3,57481E-7

1,00000E3

1,04211E0

5,92385E-31

9,16339E-24

1,00000E2

2,76245E-25

1,91429E-8

5,02706E-7

2,10747E-40

7,60514E-28

2,06995E-6

2,16179E-20

7,66088E-11

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

1.6

BioUML

4,03503E0

1,54840E-37

3,32974E-21

5,00000E1

4,41936E-37

7,59395E-14

5,20610E-14

4,35452E0

1,52937E0

5,86370E-19

2,85282E-17

2,84006E-16

6,00000E1

8,21996E-23

2,94750E0

2,41908E-5

1,38894E-38

4,46785E-5

4,04683E-2

7,12976E-7

1,00000E3

1,08754E0

6,41408E-30

7,37054E-23

1,00000E2

2,98088E-24

5,01533E-8

1,13111E-6

5,10803E-39

7,10225E-27

4,67958E-6

1,73479E-19

2,00726E-10

1.6

ByoDyn

4,03503E0

1,54840E-37

3,32974E-21

5,00000E1

4,41936E-37

7,59395E-14

5,20610E-14

4,35452E0

1,52937E0

5,86370E-19

2,85282E-17

2,84006E-16

6,00000E1

8,21996E-23

2,94750E0

2,41908E-5

1,38894E-38

4,46785E-5

4,04683E-2

7,12976E-7

1,00000E3

1,08754E0

6,41408E-30

7,37054E-23

1,00000E2

2,98088E-24

5,01533E-8

1,13111E-6

5,10803E-39

7,10225E-27

4,67958E-6

1,73479E-19

2,00726E-10

1.6

MathSBML

4,03503E0

1,54890E-37

3,32975E-21

5,00000E1

4,42499E-37

7,59383E-14

5,20594E-14

4,35452E0

1,52937E0

5,86355E-19

2,85272E-17

2,83996E-16

6,00000E1

8,21997E-23

2,94750E0

2,41908E-5

1,39176E-38

4,46785E-5

4,04683E-2

7,12976E-7

1,00000E3

1,08754E0

6,41444E-30

7,37035E-23

1,00000E2

2,98104E-24

5,01532E-8

1,13111E-6

5,11182E-39

7,10227E-27

4,67958E-6

1,73474E-19

2,00725E-10

1.6

Oscill8 Core

7,07444E-33

-5,48494E-12

5,00000E1

2,74563E-32

5,20909E-14

4,35451E0

1,52937E0

-2,14492E-11

3,15041E-15

2,84237E-16

6,00000E1

2,94751E0

2,41915E-5

1,05890E-33

4,46806E-5

4,04690E-2

1,00000E3

1,08753E0

1,54491E-25

6,84720E-20

1,00000E2

-2,14234E-11

1,13122E-6

2,59992E-34

3,79018E-23

4,68009E-6

2,00843E-10

1.6

SBToolbox2

4,03454E0

1,95793E-37

3,93721E-21

5,00000E1

5,77817E-37

7,57702E-14

5,21788E-14

4,35508E0

1,52944E0

6,50724E-19

2,99466E-17

2,98048E-16

6,00000E1

9,71025E-23

2,94688E0

2,41782E-5

1,86373E-38

4,47495E-5

4,04102E-2

7,15015E-7

1,00000E3

1,08766E0

8,18180E-30

8,18237E-23

1,00000E2

3,79184E-24

5,10358E-8

1,13960E-6

6,48378E-39

8,41301E-27

4,71616E-6

1,92339E-19

2,04257E-10

1.6

SBWOdeSolver

4,03504E0

1,55048E-37

3,33203E-21

5,00000E1

4,42579E-37

7,59619E-14

5,20831E-14

4,35451E0

1,52937E0

5,86718E-19

2,85426E-17

2,84149E-16

6,00000E1

8,22560E-23

2,94751E0

2,41915E-5

1,39117E-38

4,46806E-5

4,04690E-2

7,13013E-7

1,00000E3

1,08753E0

6,41918E-30

7,37492E-23

1,00000E2

2,98323E-24

5,01589E-8

1,13119E-6

5,11551E-39

7,10715E-27

4,67994E-6

1,73582E-19

2,00748E-10

1.6

VCell

4,03503E0

1,54842E-37

3,32978E-21

5,00000E1

4,41943E-37

7,59397E-14

5,20613E-14

4,35451E0

1,52937E0

5,86375E-19

2,85284E-17

2,84007E-16

6,00000E1

8,22004E-23

2,94750E0

2,41908E-5

1,38897E-38

4,46786E-5

4,04683E-2

7,12977E-7

1,00000E3

1,08754E0

6,41416E-30

7,37060E-23

1,00000E2

2,98091E-24

5,01534E-8

1,13111E-6

5,10811E-39

7,10232E-27

4,67959E-6

1,73480E-19

2,00726E-10

1.6

copasi

4,03503E0

1,60531E-35

-4,53193E-16

5,00000E1

5,82584E-35

7,80453E-14

5,20701E-14

4,35452E0

1,52937E0

-1,62866E-14

6,73511E-17

2,84172E-16

6,00000E1

7,42098E-14

2,94750E0

2,41908E-5

2,14185E-36

4,46785E-5

4,04683E-2

7,12976E-7

1,00000E3

1,08754E0

3,98364E-28

5,08617E-22

1,00000E2

-1,63317E-14

5,01533E-8

1,13111E-6

5,73784E-37

1,50258E-25

4,67958E-6

4,53193E-16

2,00726E-10

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,03503E0

-8,09680E-36

1,79143E-16

5,00000E1

-3,02060E-35

1,03473E-13

5,20735E-14

4,35452E0

1,52937E0

6,98075E-15

1,18804E-17

2,84217E-16

6,00000E1

5,57072E-14

2,94750E0

2,41908E-5

-1,13112E-36

4,46785E-5

4,04683E-2

7,12976E-7

1,00000E3

1,08754E0

-1,89515E-28

-1,04979E-22

1,00000E2

6,99664E-15

5,01533E-8

1,13111E-6

-2,92597E-37

-5,72340E-26

4,67958E-6

-1,79143E-16

2,00726E-10

1.6

jsim

4,01113E0

1,78343E-26

3,47029E-17

5,00000E1

1,06407E-24

8,98439E-11

3,39406E-13

1,31822E0

3,18946E0

3,27351E-17

3,39424E-15

3,62294E-13

6,00000E1

6,59392E-17

9,08736E-1

6,46178E-4

8,67058E-24

5,65131E-3

7,09349E-1

2,75148E-3

9,99972E2

3,10239E0

3,17743E-20

1,32757E-16

9,99751E1

1,00797E-18

1,04855E-5

2,21956E-2

8,54959E-26

2,19787E-18

5,41189E-6

3,94997E-15

2,16010E-4

1.6

min

4,01113E0

-8,09680E-36

-5,48494E-12

5,00000E1

-3,02060E-35

7,57702E-14

5,20594E-14

1,31822E0

1,52937E0

-2,14492E-11

1,18804E-17

2,83996E-16

6,00000E1

8,21996E-23

9,08736E-1

2,41782E-5

-1,13112E-36

4,46785E-5

4,04102E-2

7,12976E-7

9,99972E2

1,08753E0

-1,89515E-28

-1,04979E-22

9,99751E1

-2,14234E-11

5,01532E-8

1,13111E-6

-2,92597E-37

-5,72340E-26

4,67958E-6

-1,79143E-16

2,00725E-10

1.6

max

4,03504E0

1,78343E-26

1,79143E-16

5,00000E1

1,06407E-24

8,98439E-11

3,39406E-13

4,35508E0

3,18946E0

6,98075E-15

3,39424E-15

3,62294E-13

6,00000E1

7,42098E-14

2,94751E0

6,46178E-4

8,67058E-24

5,65131E-3

7,09349E-1

2,75148E-3

1,00000E3

3,10239E0

3,17743E-20

1,32757E-16

1,00000E2

6,99664E-15

1,04855E-5

2,21956E-2

8,54959E-26

2,19787E-18

5,41189E-6

3,94997E-15

2,16010E-4

1.6

mean

4,03503E0

1,55048E-37

3,32978E-21

5,00000E1

4,42579E-37

7,59508E-14

5,20735E-14

4,35452E0

1,52937E0

5,86375E-19

2,85426E-17

2,84172E-16

6,00000E1

8,96793E-23

2,94750E0

2,41908E-5

1,39176E-38

4,46786E-5

4,04683E-2

7,12976E-7

1,00000E3

1,08754E0

6,41918E-30

7,37492E-23

1,00000E2

2,98104E-24

5,01534E-8

1,13111E-6

5,11551E-39

7,10715E-27

4,67959E-6

1,73531E-19

2,00726E-10

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

1.8

BioUML

3,78928E0

2,17504E-36

2,31244E-20

5,00000E1

6,99993E-36

2,77326E-13

2,43026E-13

4,36213E0

1,72891E0

3,57517E-18

1,52210E-16

1,51430E-15

6,00000E1

5,69852E-22

2,66430E0

3,83753E-5

2,50577E-37

7,84982E-5

5,97191E-2

1,29147E-6

1,00000E3

1,12498E0

5,09645E-29

4,49737E-22

1,00000E2

2,35799E-23

1,15370E-7

2,27266E-6

8,15319E-38

4,94852E-26

9,44815E-6

1,05564E-18

4,61776E-10

1.8

ByoDyn

3,78928E0

2,17504E-36

2,31244E-20

5,00000E1

6,99993E-36

2,77326E-13

2,43026E-13

4,36213E0

1,72891E0

3,57517E-18

1,52210E-16

1,51430E-15

6,00000E1

5,69852E-22

2,66430E0

3,83753E-5

2,50577E-37

7,84982E-5

5,97191E-2

1,29147E-6

1,00000E3

1,12498E0

5,09645E-29

4,49737E-22

1,00000E2

2,35799E-23

1,15370E-7

2,27266E-6

8,15319E-38

4,94852E-26

9,44815E-6

1,05564E-18

4,61776E-10

1.8

MathSBML

3,78928E0

2,17116E-36

2,31163E-20

5,00000E1

6,99327E-36

2,77311E-13

2,42994E-13

4,36213E0

1,72891E0

3,57422E-18

1,52180E-16

1,51401E-15

6,00000E1

5,69652E-22

2,66430E0

3,83753E-5

2,50372E-37

7,84982E-5

5,97191E-2

1,29147E-6

1,00000E3

1,12498E0

5,09405E-29

4,49618E-22

1,00000E2

2,35689E-23

1,15370E-7

2,27266E-6

8,13782E-38

4,94676E-26

9,44814E-6

1,05536E-18

4,61774E-10

1.8

Oscill8 Core

1,97437E-32

-5,45119E-12

5,00000E1

8,58285E-32

2,43125E-13

4,36213E0

1,72891E0

-1,04602E-11

3,57994E-15

1,51513E-15

6,00000E1

2,66431E0

3,83761E-5

3,74772E-33

7,85010E-5

5,97199E-2

1,00000E3

1,12498E0

2,45058E-25

8,54109E-20

1,00000E2

-1,02538E-11

2,27283E-6

8,23961E-34

5,32508E-23

9,44884E-6

4,61915E-10

1.8

SBToolbox2

3,78875E0

2,73085E-36

2,73649E-20

5,00000E1

9,09187E-36

2,76966E-13

2,43803E-13

4,36269E0

1,72897E0

3,97178E-18

1,59970E-16

1,59102E-15

6,00000E1

6,73615E-22

2,66366E0

3,83568E-5

3,33410E-37

7,86103E-5

5,96376E-2

1,29509E-6

1,00000E3

1,12509E0

6,50753E-29

4,99832E-22

1,00000E2

3,00132E-23

1,17350E-7

2,28893E-6

1,02524E-37

5,86788E-26

9,51929E-6

1,17151E-18

4,69698E-10

1.8

SBWOdeSolver

3,78928E0

2,17743E-36

2,31377E-20

5,00000E1

7,00835E-36

2,77394E-13

2,43111E-13

4,36213E0

1,72891E0

3,57694E-18

1,52274E-16

1,51494E-15

6,00000E1

5,70179E-22

2,66431E0

3,83762E-5

2,50910E-37

7,85011E-5

5,97199E-2

1,29153E-6

1,00000E3

1,12498E0

5,09984E-29

4,49960E-22

1,00000E2

2,35955E-23

1,15381E-7

2,27280E-6

8,16305E-38

4,95138E-26

9,44875E-6

1,05616E-18

4,61820E-10

1.8

VCell

3,78928E0

2,17506E-36

2,31246E-20

5,00000E1

7,00001E-36

2,77327E-13

2,43027E-13

4,36213E0

1,72891E0

3,57519E-18

1,52210E-16

1,51431E-15

6,00000E1

5,69856E-22

2,66430E0

3,83753E-5

2,50580E-37

7,84982E-5

5,97191E-2

1,29147E-6

1,00000E3

1,12498E0

5,09650E-29

4,49740E-22

1,00000E2

2,35801E-23

1,15371E-7

2,27267E-6

8,15327E-38

4,94856E-26

9,44816E-6

1,05565E-18

4,61777E-10

1.8

copasi

3,78928E0

5,75974E-35

-6,55461E-16

5,00000E1

2,32825E-34

3,03048E-13

2,43050E-13

4,36213E0

1,72891E0

-1,80565E-14

2,05581E-16

1,51483E-15

6,00000E1

5,64106E-14

2,66430E0

3,83753E-5

9,65723E-36

7,84982E-5

5,97191E-2

1,29147E-6

1,00000E3

1,12498E0

8,30853E-28

1,11763E-21

1,00000E2

-1,81270E-14

1,15370E-7

2,27266E-6

2,33048E-36

3,02391E-25

9,44815E-6

6,55461E-16

4,61776E-10

1.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,78928E0

-2,47263E-35

2,25648E-16

5,00000E1

-1,04640E-34

5,72875E-14

2,43056E-13

4,36213E0

1,72891E0

-1,28659E-15

1,27794E-16

1,51490E-15

6,00000E1

1,17350E-13

2,66430E0

3,83753E-5

-4,46336E-36

7,84982E-5

5,97191E-2

1,29147E-6

1,00000E3

1,12498E0

-3,15432E-28

1,69349E-22

1,00000E2

-1,27211E-15

1,15370E-7

2,27266E-6

-1,01853E-36

-6,00791E-26

9,44815E-6

-2,25648E-16

4,61776E-10

1.8

jsim

3,75441E0

7,98599E-26

9,43312E-17

5,00000E1

5,27782E-24

1,80295E-10

6,37422E-13

1,15414E0

3,21488E0

7,36546E-17

6,94770E-15

8,23783E-13

6,00000E1

1,95293E-16

7,25992E-1

8,14934E-4

5,45125E-23

7,35449E-3

8,91652E-1

4,11016E-3

9,99958E2

3,02842E0

1,11128E-19

3,29463E-16

9,99615E1

3,39021E-18

1,63341E-5

3,43498E-2

4,55654E-25

6,50935E-18

7,09225E-6

9,78707E-15

3,38204E-4

1.8

min

3,75441E0

-2,47263E-35

-5,45119E-12

5,00000E1

-1,04640E-34

5,72875E-14

2,42994E-13

1,15414E0

1,72891E0

-1,04602E-11

1,27794E-16

1,51401E-15

6,00000E1

5,69652E-22

7,25992E-1

3,83568E-5

-4,46336E-36

7,84982E-5

5,96376E-2

1,29147E-6

9,99958E2

1,12498E0

-3,15432E-28

1,69349E-22

9,99615E1

-1,02538E-11

1,15370E-7

2,27266E-6

-1,01853E-36

-6,00791E-26

7,09225E-6

-2,25648E-16

4,61774E-10

1.8

max

3,78928E0

7,98599E-26

2,25648E-16

5,00000E1

5,27782E-24

1,80295E-10

6,37422E-13

4,36269E0

3,21488E0

7,36546E-17

6,94770E-15

8,23783E-13

6,00000E1

1,17350E-13

2,66431E0

8,14934E-4

5,45125E-23

7,35449E-3

8,91652E-1

4,11016E-3

1,00000E3

3,02842E0

1,11128E-19

3,29463E-16

1,00000E2

3,39021E-18

1,63341E-5

3,43498E-2

4,55654E-25

6,50935E-18

9,51929E-6

9,78707E-15

3,38204E-4

1.8

mean

3,78928E0

2,17743E-36

2,31246E-20

5,00000E1

7,00835E-36

2,77327E-13

2,43056E-13

4,36213E0

1,72891E0

3,57517E-18

1,52274E-16

1,51490E-15

6,00000E1

6,21897E-22

2,66430E0

3,83753E-5

2,50910E-37

7,84982E-5

5,97191E-2

1,29147E-6

1,00000E3

1,12498E0

5,09984E-29

4,49960E-22

1,00000E2

2,35799E-23

1,15371E-7

2,27267E-6

8,16305E-38

4,95138E-26

9,44815E-6

1,05591E-18

4,61777E-10

1.8

relative error(%)

0,00

2.0

BioUML

3,57984E0

2,23141E-35

1,27627E-19

5,00000E1

7,96827E-35

8,60467E-13

9,38421E-13

4,33897E0

1,91401E0

1,75553E-17

6,62805E-16

6,58971E-15

6,00000E1

3,13942E-21

2,42358E0

5,72688E-5

3,20565E-36

1,28006E-4

8,34010E-2

2,17047E-6

1,00000E3

1,15626E0

3,17612E-28

2,21009E-21

1,00000E2

1,46287E-22

2,39757E-7

4,18073E-6

9,37862E-37

2,74023E-25

1,74671E-5

5,17318E-18

9,59716E-10

2.0

ByoDyn

3,57984E0

2,23141E-35

1,27627E-19

5,00000E1

7,96827E-35

8,60467E-13

9,38421E-13

4,33897E0

1,91401E0

1,75553E-17

6,62805E-16

6,58971E-15

6,00000E1

3,13942E-21

2,42358E0

5,72688E-5

3,20565E-36

1,28006E-4

8,34010E-2

2,17047E-6

1,00000E3

1,15626E0

3,17612E-28

2,21009E-21

1,00000E2

1,46287E-22

2,39757E-7

4,18073E-6

9,37862E-37

2,74023E-25

1,74671E-5

5,17318E-18

9,59716E-10

2.0

MathSBML

3,57984E0

2,22733E-35

1,27573E-19

5,00000E1

7,95523E-35

8,60416E-13

9,38286E-13

4,33897E0

1,91401E0

1,75499E-17

6,62662E-16

6,58829E-15

6,00000E1

3,13812E-21

2,42358E0

5,72688E-5

3,19986E-36

1,28006E-4

8,34010E-2

2,17047E-6

1,00000E3

1,15626E0

3,17432E-28

2,20941E-21

1,00000E2

1,46206E-22

2,39756E-7

4,18072E-6

9,35852E-37

2,73908E-25

1,74671E-5

5,17160E-18

9,59711E-10

2.0

Oscill8 Core

4,89586E-32

-5,29290E-12

5,00000E1

2,34142E-31

9,38718E-13

4,33896E0

1,91401E0

-2,63214E-14

4,55415E-15

6,59239E-15

6,00000E1

2,42359E0

5,72698E-5

1,14282E-32

1,28010E-4

8,34019E-2

1,00000E3

1,15626E0

3,69875E-25

1,05741E-19

1,00000E2

3,76373E-13

4,18097E-6

2,29099E-33

7,22734E-23

1,74681E-5

9,59886E-10

2.0

SBToolbox2

3,57934E0

2,45034E-35

1,44138E-19

5,00000E1

8,79390E-35

8,51122E-13

9,24360E-13

4,33956E0

1,91412E0

1,88194E-17

6,78500E-16

6,74390E-15

6,00000E1

3,54210E-21

2,42294E0

5,72366E-5

3,49182E-36

1,28128E-4

8,32926E-2

2,17522E-6

1,00000E3

1,15640E0

3,81842E-28

2,37016E-21

1,00000E2

1,75374E-22

2,43242E-7

4,20504E-6

1,00229E-36

3,10054E-25

1,75754E-5

5,54030E-18

9,73662E-10

2.0

SBWOdeSolver

3,57984E0

2,23349E-35

1,27689E-19

5,00000E1

7,97636E-35

8,60640E-13

9,38698E-13

4,33896E0

1,91401E0

1,75627E-17

6,63040E-16

6,59204E-15

6,00000E1

3,14095E-21

2,42359E0

5,72698E-5

3,20925E-36

1,28010E-4

8,34019E-2

2,17055E-6

1,00000E3

1,15626E0

3,17791E-28

2,21102E-21

1,00000E2

1,46369E-22

2,39776E-7

4,18094E-6

9,38826E-37

2,74157E-25

1,74680E-5

5,17534E-18

9,59791E-10

2.0

VCell

3,57984E0

2,23159E-35

1,27634E-19

5,00000E1

7,96898E-35

8,60481E-13

9,38444E-13

4,33896E0

1,91401E0

1,75562E-17

6,62829E-16

6,58995E-15

6,00000E1

3,13961E-21

2,42358E0

5,72689E-5

3,20596E-36

1,28006E-4

8,34011E-2

2,17048E-6

1,00000E3

1,15626E0

3,17634E-28

2,21020E-21

1,00000E2

1,46298E-22

2,39760E-7

4,18076E-6

9,37943E-37

2,74040E-25

1,74672E-5

5,17343E-18

9,59726E-10

2.0

copasi

3,57984E0

1,90175E-34

-8,40651E-16

5,00000E1

8,33259E-34

8,86313E-13

9,38472E-13

4,33897E0

1,91401E0

-1,73192E-14

7,43925E-16

6,59102E-15

6,00000E1

-2,96928E-14

2,42358E0

5,72688E-5

3,82997E-35

1,28006E-4

8,34010E-2

2,17047E-6

1,00000E3

1,15626E0

1,75746E-27

3,21184E-21

1,00000E2

-1,74125E-14

2,39757E-7

4,18073E-6

8,56710E-36

6,91305E-25

1,74671E-5

8,40651E-16

9,59716E-10

2.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,57984E0

-5,53607E-35

1,64934E-16

5,00000E1

-2,74149E-34

6,02185E-13

9,38459E-13

4,33897E0

1,91401E0

-3,71520E-15

6,31406E-16

6,59073E-15

6,00000E1

3,05581E-14

2,42358E0

5,72688E-5

-1,34592E-35

1,28006E-4

8,34010E-2

2,17047E-6

1,00000E3

1,15626E0

-3,32671E-28

1,78921E-21

1,00000E2

-3,73011E-15

2,39757E-7

4,18073E-6

-2,61618E-36

9,49398E-26

1,74671E-5

-1,64934E-16

9,59716E-10

2.0

jsim

3,53210E0

2,81863E-25

2,16123E-16

5,00000E1

2,03234E-23

3,20969E-10

1,05536E-12

1,00724E0

3,19236E0

1,41825E-16

1,23460E-14

1,62444E-12

6,00000E1

4,86954E-16

5,88203E-1

9,79445E-4

2,61186E-22

9,06417E-3

1,06884E0

5,75753E-3

9,99940E2

2,94390E0

3,22326E-19

6,98935E-16

9,99447E1

9,47656E-18

2,36832E-5

4,95144E-2

1,88523E-24

1,62304E-17

8,79816E-6

2,07270E-14

4,92980E-4

2.0

min

3,53210E0

-5,53607E-35

-5,29290E-12

5,00000E1

-2,74149E-34

6,02185E-13

9,24360E-13

1,00724E0

1,91401E0

-2,63214E-14

6,31406E-16

6,58829E-15

6,00000E1

-2,96928E-14

5,88203E-1

5,72366E-5

-1,34592E-35

1,28006E-4

8,32926E-2

2,17047E-6

9,99940E2

1,15626E0

-3,32671E-28

1,78921E-21

9,99447E1

-1,74125E-14

2,39756E-7

4,18072E-6

-2,61618E-36

9,49398E-26

8,79816E-6

-1,64934E-16

9,59711E-10

2.0

max

3,57984E0

2,81863E-25

2,16123E-16

5,00000E1

2,03234E-23

3,20969E-10

1,05536E-12

4,33956E0

3,19236E0

1,41825E-16

1,23460E-14

1,62444E-12

6,00000E1

3,05581E-14

2,42359E0

9,79445E-4

2,61186E-22

9,06417E-3

1,06884E0

5,75753E-3

1,00000E3

2,94390E0

3,22326E-19

6,98935E-16

1,00000E2

3,76373E-13

2,36832E-5

4,95144E-2

1,88523E-24

1,62304E-17

1,75754E-5

2,07270E-14

4,92980E-4

2.0

mean

3,57984E0

2,23349E-35

1,27634E-19

5,00000E1

7,97636E-35

8,60474E-13

9,38459E-13

4,33897E0

1,91401E0

1,75553E-17

6,63040E-16

6,59102E-15

6,00000E1

3,14028E-21

2,42358E0

5,72688E-5

3,20925E-36

1,28006E-4

8,34010E-2

2,17048E-6

1,00000E3

1,15626E0

3,17791E-28

2,21102E-21

1,00000E2

1,46298E-22

2,39758E-7

4,18076E-6

9,38826E-37

2,74157E-25

1,74671E-5

5,17438E-18

9,59726E-10

2.0

relative error(%)

0,00

2.2

BioUML

3,39970E0

1,77981E-34

5,85771E-19

5,00000E1

6,95947E-34

2,34360E-12

3,11298E-12

4,29282E0

2,08401E0

7,24647E-17

2,45262E-15

2,43677E-14

6,00000E1

1,43827E-20

2,21700E0

8,14056E-5

3,11250E-35

1,96681E-4

1,11449E-1

3,43573E-6

1,00000E3

1,18270E0

1,62858E-27

9,13005E-21

1,00000E2

7,46666E-22

4,59295E-7

7,16666E-6

8,29748E-36

1,26193E-24

3,00947E-5

2,13102E-17

1,83864E-9

2.2

ByoDyn

3,39970E0

1,77981E-34

5,85771E-19

5,00000E1

6,95947E-34

2,34360E-12

3,11298E-12

4,29282E0

2,08401E0

7,24647E-17

2,45262E-15

2,43677E-14

6,00000E1

1,43827E-20

2,21700E0

8,14056E-5

3,11250E-35

1,96681E-4

1,11449E-1

3,43573E-6

1,00000E3

1,18270E0

1,62858E-27

9,13005E-21

1,00000E2

7,46666E-22

4,59295E-7

7,16666E-6

8,29748E-36

1,26193E-24

3,00947E-5

2,13102E-17

1,83864E-9

2.2

MathSBML

3,39970E0

1,77754E-34

5,85589E-19

5,00000E1

6,95069E-34

2,34350E-12

3,11265E-12

4,29282E0

2,08401E0

7,24482E-17

2,45223E-15

2,43639E-14

6,00000E1

1,43783E-20

2,21700E0

8,14059E-5

3,10804E-35

1,96680E-4

1,11449E-1

3,43573E-6

1,00000E3

1,18270E0

1,62790E-27

9,12796E-21

1,00000E2

7,46357E-22

4,59293E-7

7,16666E-6

8,28478E-36

1,26154E-24

3,00947E-5

2,13054E-17

1,83863E-9

2.2

Oscill8 Core

1,10533E-31

-5,02143E-12

5,00000E1

5,73045E-31

3,11378E-12

4,29281E0

2,08400E0

9,88308E-12

6,83747E-15

2,43756E-14

6,00000E1

2,21700E0

8,14068E-5

3,09376E-32

1,96685E-4

1,11450E-1

1,00000E3

1,18270E0

5,37155E-25

1,33114E-19

1,00000E2

1,04919E-11

7,16700E-6

5,73925E-33

9,59567E-23

3,00960E-5

1,83886E-9

2.2

SBToolbox2

3,39923E0

1,92870E-34

6,57286E-19

5,00000E1

7,56036E-34

2,31560E-12

3,05995E-12

4,29339E0

2,08422E0

7,73074E-17

2,50208E-15

2,48513E-14

6,00000E1

1,61213E-20

2,21641E0

8,13600E-5

3,32151E-35

1,96821E-4

1,11310E-1

3,44262E-6

1,00000E3

1,18284E0

1,94227E-27

9,74418E-21

1,00000E2

8,87752E-22

4,65580E-7

7,20465E-6

8,72215E-36

1,41878E-24

3,02665E-5

2,27103E-17

1,86378E-9

2.2

SBWOdeSolver

3,39970E0

1,78123E-34

5,86016E-19

5,00000E1

6,96553E-34

2,34400E-12

3,11376E-12

4,29281E0

2,08400E0

7,24908E-17

2,45336E-15

2,43751E-14

6,00000E1

1,43887E-20

2,21700E0

8,14068E-5

3,11550E-35

1,96685E-4

1,11450E-1

3,43583E-6

1,00000E3

1,18270E0

1,62937E-27

9,13334E-21

1,00000E2

7,47027E-22

4,59326E-7

7,16697E-6

8,30482E-36

1,26247E-24

3,00960E-5

2,13178E-17

1,83877E-9

2.2

VCell

3,39970E0

1,77992E-34

5,85796E-19

5,00000E1

6,95993E-34

2,34363E-12

3,11302E-12

4,29282E0

2,08401E0

7,24671E-17

2,45268E-15

2,43683E-14

6,00000E1

1,43833E-20

2,21700E0

8,14057E-5

3,11272E-35

1,96681E-4

1,11450E-1

3,43574E-6

1,00000E3

1,18270E0

1,62867E-27

9,13035E-21

1,00000E2

7,46706E-22

4,59299E-7

7,16670E-6

8,29802E-36

1,26199E-24

3,00949E-5

2,13109E-17

1,83866E-9

2.2

copasi

3,39970E0

6,30778E-34

-1,01177E-15

5,00000E1

2,90669E-33

2,36378E-12

3,11303E-12

4,29282E0

2,08401E0

-1,70550E-14

2,56722E-15

2,43695E-14

6,00000E1

-1,22444E-13

2,21700E0

8,14056E-5

1,45088E-34

1,96681E-4

1,11449E-1

3,43573E-6

1,00000E3

1,18270E0

4,13270E-27

1,06185E-20

1,00000E2

-1,72051E-14

4,59295E-7

7,16667E-6

3,11227E-35

1,92546E-24

3,00947E-5

1,01177E-15

1,83864E-9

2.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,39970E0

-2,53080E-35

1,30035E-16

5,00000E1

-3,06658E-34

2,10498E-12

3,11302E-12

4,29282E0

2,08401E0

-8,55731E-16

2,41614E-15

2,43693E-14

6,00000E1

1,13010E-13

2,21700E0

8,14056E-5

-2,10064E-35

1,96681E-4

1,11449E-1

3,43573E-6

1,00000E3

1,18270E0

5,25232E-28

8,53930E-21

1,00000E2

-9,34682E-16

4,59295E-7

7,16667E-6

-2,00274E-36

9,82155E-25

3,00947E-5

-1,30035E-16

1,83864E-9

2.2

jsim

3,33745E0

8,26737E-25

4,33824E-16

5,00000E1

6,43058E-23

5,21288E-10

1,58878E-12

8,77927E-1

3,13810E0

2,42498E-16

1,97028E-14

2,87117E-12

6,00000E1

1,06184E-15

4,83273E-1

1,13523E-3

1,01115E-21

1,07249E-2

1,23618E0

7,67174E-3

9,99920E2

2,85418E0

8,07231E-19

1,31375E-15

9,99248E1

2,29246E-17

3,24852E-5

6,75531E-2

6,39851E-24

3,53908E-17

1,04756E-5

3,88877E-14

6,79948E-4

2.2

min

3,33745E0

-2,53080E-35

-5,02143E-12

5,00000E1

-3,06658E-34

2,10498E-12

1,58878E-12

8,77927E-1

2,08400E0

-1,70550E-14

2,41614E-15

2,43639E-14

6,00000E1

-1,22444E-13

4,83273E-1

8,13600E-5

-2,10064E-35

1,96680E-4

1,11310E-1

3,43573E-6

9,99920E2

1,18270E0

5,25232E-28

8,53930E-21

9,99248E1

-1,72051E-14

4,59293E-7

7,16666E-6

-2,00274E-36

9,82155E-25

1,04756E-5

-1,30035E-16

1,83863E-9

2.2

max

3,39970E0

8,26737E-25

4,33824E-16

5,00000E1

6,43058E-23

5,21288E-10

3,11378E-12

4,29339E0

3,13810E0

9,88308E-12

1,97028E-14

2,87117E-12

6,00000E1

1,13010E-13

2,21700E0

1,13523E-3

1,01115E-21

1,07249E-2

1,23618E0

7,67174E-3

1,00000E3

2,85418E0

8,07231E-19

1,31375E-15

1,00000E2

1,04919E-11

3,24852E-5

6,75531E-2

6,39851E-24

3,53908E-17

3,02665E-5

3,88877E-14

6,79948E-4

2.2

mean

3,39970E0

1,78123E-34

5,85796E-19

5,00000E1

6,96553E-34

2,34362E-12

3,11302E-12

4,29282E0

2,08401E0

7,24671E-17

2,45336E-15

2,43695E-14

6,00000E1

1,43860E-20

2,21700E0

8,14057E-5

3,11550E-35

1,96681E-4

1,11449E-1

3,43574E-6

1,00000E3

1,18270E0

1,62937E-27

9,13334E-21

1,00000E2

7,46706E-22

4,59297E-7

7,16670E-6

8,30482E-36

1,26247E-24

3,00947E-5

2,13144E-17

1,83866E-9

2.2

relative error(%)

0,00

2.4

BioUML

3,24349E0

1,15541E-33

2,31149E-18

5,00000E1

4,89291E-33

5,73879E-12

9,12048E-12

4,22952E0

2,23883E0

2,59480E-16

7,94367E-15

7,88682E-14

6,00000E1

5,66494E-20

2,03821E0

1,11226E-4

2,41085E-34

2,87901E-4

1,43667E-1

5,17915E-6

1,00000E3

1,20528E0

7,11649E-27

3,27190E-20

1,00000E2

3,24762E-21

8,23145E-7

1,15968E-5

5,92169E-35

4,99671E-24

4,89511E-5

7,61485E-17

3,29546E-9

2.4

ByoDyn

3,24349E0

1,15541E-33

2,31149E-18

5,00000E1

4,89291E-33

5,73879E-12

9,12048E-12

4,22952E0

2,23883E0

2,59480E-16

7,94367E-15

7,88682E-14

6,00000E1

5,66494E-20

2,03821E0

1,11226E-4

2,41085E-34

2,87901E-4

1,43667E-1

5,17915E-6

1,00000E3

1,20528E0

7,11649E-27

3,27190E-20

1,00000E2

3,24762E-21

8,23145E-7

1,15968E-5

5,92169E-35

4,99671E-24

4,89511E-5

7,61485E-17

3,29546E-9

2.4

MathSBML

3,24349E0

1,15546E-33

2,31151E-18

5,00000E1

4,89352E-33

5,73879E-12

9,12048E-12

4,22952E0

2,23883E0

2,59481E-16

7,94368E-15

7,88682E-14

6,00000E1

5,66501E-20

2,03821E0

1,11225E-4

2,41133E-34

2,87901E-4

1,43667E-1

5,17916E-6

1,00000E3

1,20528E0

7,11667E-27

3,27191E-20

1,00000E2

3,24770E-21

8,23145E-7

1,15968E-5

5,92211E-35

4,99676E-24

4,89511E-5

7,61488E-17

3,29546E-9

2.4

Oscill8 Core

2,31525E-31

-4,64736E-12

5,00000E1

1,28514E-30

9,12245E-12

4,22952E0

2,23882E0

1,92895E-11

1,25590E-14

7,88894E-14

6,00000E1

2,03821E0

1,11227E-4

7,60605E-32

2,87906E-4

1,43667E-1

1,00000E3

1,20528E0

7,58223E-25

1,78872E-19

1,00000E2

2,01090E-11

1,15973E-5

1,32204E-32

1,26682E-22

4,89529E-5

3,29574E-9

2.4

SBToolbox2

3,24295E0

1,34241E-33

2,65214E-18

5,00000E1

5,78617E-33

5,69621E-12

9,04528E-12

4,23014E0

2,23912E0

2,81547E-16

8,20528E-15

8,14353E-14

6,00000E1

6,49101E-20

2,03749E0

1,11169E-4

2,85489E-34

2,88086E-4

1,43490E-1

5,18982E-6

1,00000E3

1,20544E0

8,74447E-27

3,55188E-20

1,00000E2

3,97530E-21

8,34716E-7

1,16584E-5

6,77432E-35

5,74722E-24

4,92336E-5

8,25168E-17

3,34180E-9

2.4

SBWOdeSolver

3,24349E0

1,15620E-33

2,31232E-18

5,00000E1

4,89659E-33

5,73962E-12

9,12244E-12

4,22952E0

2,23882E0

2,59561E-16

7,94574E-15

7,88887E-14

6,00000E1

5,66699E-20

2,03821E0

1,11227E-4

2,41286E-34

2,87907E-4

1,43667E-1

5,17928E-6

1,00000E3

1,20528E0

7,11950E-27

3,27292E-20

1,00000E2

3,24898E-21

8,23192E-7

1,15973E-5

5,92623E-35

4,99853E-24

4,89529E-5

7,61721E-17

3,29565E-9

2.4

VCell

3,24349E0

1,15546E-33

2,31156E-18

5,00000E1

4,89315E-33

5,73883E-12

9,12058E-12

4,22952E0

2,23883E0

2,59486E-16

7,94380E-15

7,88695E-14

6,00000E1

5,66511E-20

2,03821E0

1,11226E-4

2,41097E-34

2,87901E-4

1,43667E-1

5,17917E-6

1,00000E3

1,20528E0

7,11677E-27

3,27197E-20

1,00000E2

3,24775E-21

8,23151E-7

1,15969E-5

5,92198E-35

4,99686E-24

4,89513E-5

7,61502E-17

3,29548E-9

2.4

copasi

3,24349E0

2,27162E-33

-1,18720E-15

5,00000E1

1,07435E-32

5,76165E-12

9,12062E-12

4,22952E0

2,23883E0

-2,00628E-14

8,09639E-15

7,88722E-14

6,00000E1

9,55974E-14

2,03821E0

1,11226E-4

5,71940E-34

2,87901E-4

1,43667E-1

5,17915E-6

1,00000E3

1,20528E0

1,12868E-26

3,48746E-20

1,00000E2

-2,03987E-14

8,23145E-7

1,15968E-5

1,21059E-34

6,02156E-24

4,89511E-5

1,18720E-15

3,29546E-9

2.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,24349E0

6,66693E-34

1,41980E-16

5,00000E1

2,31023E-33

5,53424E-12

9,12059E-12

4,22952E0

2,23883E0

4,20952E-15

7,90166E-15

7,88714E-14

6,00000E1

1,14252E-13

2,03821E0

1,11226E-4

9,40325E-35

2,87901E-4

1,43667E-1

5,17915E-6

1,00000E3

1,20528E0

5,32371E-27

3,19339E-20

1,00000E2

3,94274E-15

8,23145E-7

1,15968E-5

3,20273E-35

4,58002E-24

4,89511E-5

-1,41980E-16

3,29546E-9

2.4

jsim

3,16541E0

2,09402E-24

7,84833E-16

5,00000E1

1,74232E-22

7,88035E-10

2,22362E-12

7,65384E-1

3,06398E0

3,78279E-16

2,89415E-14

4,65819E-12

6,00000E1

2,08176E-15

4,02620E-1

1,27969E-3

3,30062E-21

1,23012E-2

1,39096E0

9,82471E-3

9,99898E2

2,76279E0

1,79765E-18

2,24565E-15

9,99019E1

4,94307E-17

4,26503E-5

8,82447E-2

1,85439E-23

6,93818E-17

1,20895E-5

6,63421E-14

8,97842E-4

2.4

min

3,16541E0

6,66693E-34

-4,64736E-12

5,00000E1

2,31023E-33

5,53424E-12

2,22362E-12

7,65384E-1

2,23882E0

-2,00628E-14

7,90166E-15

7,88682E-14

6,00000E1

5,66494E-20

4,02620E-1

1,11169E-4

9,40325E-35

2,87901E-4

1,43490E-1

5,17915E-6

9,99898E2

1,20528E0

5,32371E-27

3,19339E-20

9,99019E1

-2,03987E-14

8,23145E-7

1,15968E-5

3,20273E-35

4,58002E-24

1,20895E-5

-1,41980E-16

3,29546E-9

2.4

max

3,24349E0

2,09402E-24

7,84833E-16

5,00000E1

1,74232E-22

7,88035E-10

9,12245E-12

4,23014E0

3,06398E0

1,92895E-11

2,89415E-14

4,65819E-12

6,00000E1

1,14252E-13

2,03821E0

1,27969E-3

3,30062E-21

1,23012E-2

1,39096E0

9,82471E-3

1,00000E3

2,76279E0

1,79765E-18

2,24565E-15

1,00000E2

2,01090E-11

4,26503E-5

8,82447E-2

1,85439E-23

6,93818E-17

4,92336E-5

6,63421E-14

8,97842E-4

2.4

mean

3,24349E0

1,15620E-33

2,31156E-18

5,00000E1

4,89659E-33

5,73881E-12

9,12058E-12

4,22952E0

2,23883E0

2,59561E-16

7,94574E-15

7,88722E-14

6,00000E1

6,07900E-20

2,03821E0

1,11226E-4

2,41286E-34

2,87901E-4

1,43667E-1

5,17916E-6

1,00000E3

1,20528E0

7,11950E-27

3,27292E-20

1,00000E2

3,24898E-21

8,23148E-7

1,15969E-5

5,92623E-35

4,99853E-24

4,89511E-5

7,61611E-17

3,29548E-9

2.4

relative error(%)

0,00

2.6

BioUML

3,10703E0

6,31892E-33

8,04168E-18

5,00000E1

2,87120E-32

1,28634E-11

2,40987E-11

4,15349E0

2,37882E0

8,25360E-16

2,30274E-14

2,28463E-13

6,00000E1

1,96711E-19

1,88230E0

1,47073E-4

1,54680E-33

4,04834E-4

1,79752E-1

7,49665E-6

9,99999E2

1,22473E0

2,72141E-26

1,04158E-19

1,00000E2

1,23609E-20

1,39562E-6

1,78874E-5

3,53372E-34

1,74438E-23

7,59036E-5

2,41703E-16

5,58783E-9

2.6

ByoDyn

3,10703E0

6,31892E-33

8,04168E-18

5,00000E1

2,87120E-32

1,28634E-11

2,40987E-11

4,15349E0

2,37882E0

8,25360E-16

2,30274E-14

2,28463E-13

6,00000E1

1,96711E-19

1,88230E0

1,47073E-4

1,54680E-33

4,04834E-4

1,79752E-1

7,49665E-6

9,99999E2

1,22473E0

2,72141E-26

1,04158E-19

1,00000E2

1,23609E-20

1,39562E-6

1,78874E-5

3,53372E-34

1,74438E-23

7,59036E-5

2,41703E-16

5,58783E-9

2.6

MathSBML

3,10703E0

6,31904E-33

8,04171E-18

5,00000E1

2,87128E-32

1,28634E-11

2,40986E-11

4,15349E0

2,37882E0

8,25361E-16

2,30274E-14

2,28463E-13

6,00000E1

1,96712E-19

1,88230E0

1,47073E-4

1,54687E-33

4,04834E-4

1,79752E-1

7,49665E-6

9,99999E2

1,22473E0

2,72144E-26

1,04158E-19

1,00000E2

1,23610E-20

1,39562E-6

1,78874E-5

3,53381E-34

1,74439E-23

7,59036E-5

2,41703E-16

5,58783E-9

2.6

Oscill8 Core

4,57323E-31

-4,18056E-12

5,00000E1

2,68809E-30

2,41031E-11

4,15349E0

2,37882E0

2,82205E-11

2,78686E-14

2,28515E-13

6,00000E1

1,88230E0

1,47075E-4

1,73016E-31

4,04841E-4

1,79753E-1

9,99999E2

1,22473E0

1,05240E-24

2,74408E-19

1,00000E2

2,92500E-11

1,78879E-5

2,84884E-32

1,70738E-22

7,59059E-5

5,58819E-9

2.6

SBToolbox2

3,10636E0

7,98393E-33

9,46348E-18

5,00000E1

3,74361E-32

1,28281E-11

2,41365E-11

4,15414E0

2,37926E0

9,12732E-16

2,41144E-14

2,39143E-13

6,00000E1

2,31110E-19

1,88152E0

1,46996E-4

2,06095E-33

4,05072E-4

1,79539E-1

7,51241E-6

1,00000E3

1,22487E0

3,46066E-26

1,15252E-19

1,00000E2

1,56435E-20

1,41590E-6

1,79821E-5

4,47356E-34

2,05907E-23

7,63481E-5

2,66863E-16

5,66908E-9

2.6

SBWOdeSolver

3,10703E0

6,32271E-33

8,04423E-18

5,00000E1

2,87308E-32

1,28650E-11

2,41031E-11

4,15349E0

2,37882E0

8,25584E-16

2,30326E-14

2,28514E-13

6,00000E1

1,96774E-19

1,88230E0

1,47075E-4

1,54793E-33

4,04841E-4

1,79753E-1

7,49681E-6

9,99999E2

1,22473E0

2,72242E-26

1,04186E-19

1,00000E2

1,23654E-20

1,39569E-6

1,78879E-5

3,53610E-34

1,74494E-23

7,59060E-5

2,41768E-16

5,58810E-9

2.6

VCell

3,10703E0

6,31914E-33

8,04185E-18

5,00000E1

2,87130E-32

1,28635E-11

2,40989E-11

4,15349E0

2,37882E0

8,25374E-16

2,30277E-14

2,28465E-13

6,00000E1

1,96716E-19

1,88230E0

1,47074E-4

1,54686E-33

4,04835E-4

1,79752E-1

7,49666E-6

9,99999E2

1,22473E0

2,72148E-26

1,04160E-19

1,00000E2

1,23612E-20

1,39563E-6

1,78874E-5

3,53385E-34

1,74442E-23

7,59038E-5

2,41707E-16

5,58786E-9

2.6

copasi

3,10703E0

8,87698E-33

-1,36722E-15

5,00000E1

4,29592E-32

1,28895E-11

2,40991E-11

4,15349E0

2,37882E0

-1,81845E-14

2,32209E-14

2,28475E-13

6,00000E1

1,25557E-13

1,88230E0

1,47073E-4

2,42390E-33

4,04834E-4

1,79752E-1

7,49665E-6

9,99999E2

1,22473E0

3,39220E-26

1,07182E-19

1,00000E2

-1,90821E-14

1,39562E-6

1,78874E-5

5,07958E-34

1,89841E-23

7,59036E-5

1,36722E-15

5,58783E-9

2.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,10703E0

5,23125E-33

2,24336E-16

5,00000E1

2,26063E-32

1,26752E-11

2,40991E-11

4,15349E0

2,37882E0

9,27685E-15

2,29751E-14

2,28477E-13

6,00000E1

4,44594E-14

1,88230E0

1,47074E-4

1,16876E-33

4,04834E-4

1,79752E-1

7,49665E-6

9,99999E2

1,22473E0

2,44235E-26

1,03148E-19

1,00000E2

8,45320E-15

1,39562E-6

1,78874E-5

2,87404E-34

1,68504E-23

7,59036E-5

-2,24336E-16

5,58783E-9

2.6

jsim

3,01212E0

4,71265E-24

1,30702E-15

4,99999E1

4,16833E-22

1,12529E-9

2,94071E-12

6,68197E-1

2,97843E0

5,49337E-16

3,98480E-14

7,06019E-12

6,00000E1

3,74601E-15

3,40074E-1

1,41161E-3

9,37818E-21

1,37732E-2

1,53194E0

1,21855E-2

9,99873E2

2,67204E0

3,63894E-18

3,55897E-15

9,98765E1

9,71213E-17

5,40645E-5

1,11321E-1

4,72853E-23

1,24844E-16

1,36192E-5

1,04924E-13

1,14486E-3

2.6

min

3,01212E0

5,23125E-33

-4,18056E-12

4,99999E1

2,26063E-32

1,26752E-11

2,94071E-12

6,68197E-1

2,37882E0

-1,81845E-14

2,29751E-14

2,28463E-13

6,00000E1

1,96711E-19

3,40074E-1

1,46996E-4

1,16876E-33

4,04834E-4

1,79539E-1

7,49665E-6

9,99873E2

1,22473E0

2,44235E-26

1,03148E-19

9,98765E1

-1,90821E-14

1,39562E-6

1,78874E-5

2,87404E-34

1,68504E-23

1,36192E-5

-2,24336E-16

5,58783E-9

2.6

max

3,10703E0

4,71265E-24

1,30702E-15

5,00000E1

4,16833E-22

1,12529E-9

2,41365E-11

4,15414E0

2,97843E0

2,82205E-11

3,98480E-14

7,06019E-12

6,00000E1

1,25557E-13

1,88230E0

1,41161E-3

9,37818E-21

1,37732E-2

1,53194E0

1,21855E-2

1,00000E3

2,67204E0

3,63894E-18

3,55897E-15

1,00000E2

2,92500E-11

5,40645E-5

1,11321E-1

4,72853E-23

1,24844E-16

7,63481E-5

1,04924E-13

1,14486E-3

2.6

mean

3,10703E0

6,32271E-33

8,04185E-18

5,00000E1

2,87308E-32

1,28635E-11

2,40991E-11

4,15349E0

2,37882E0

8,25374E-16

2,30326E-14

2,28477E-13

6,00000E1

2,13942E-19

1,88230E0

1,47074E-4

1,54793E-33

4,04835E-4

1,79752E-1

7,49666E-6

9,99999E2

1,22473E0

2,72242E-26

1,04186E-19

1,00000E2

1,23654E-20

1,39563E-6

1,78874E-5

3,53610E-34

1,74494E-23

7,59036E-5

2,41737E-16

5,58786E-9

2.6

relative error(%)

0,00

2.8

BioUML

2,98701E0

2,98992E-32

2,51496E-17

5,00000E1

1,44616E-31

2,67625E-11

5,83583E-11

4,06812E0

2,50464E0

2,37523E-15

6,07832E-14

6,02611E-13

6,00000E1

6,14018E-19

1,74542E0

1,89202E-4

8,46315E-33

5,50356E-4

2,19334E-1

1,04862E-5

9,99999E2

1,24159E0

9,29614E-26

2,99992E-19

1,00000E2

4,20234E-20

2,25792E-6

2,64970E-5

1,81276E-33

5,47456E-23

1,13045E-4

6,94079E-16

9,04104E-9

2.8

ByoDyn

2,98701E0

2,98992E-32

2,51496E-17

5,00000E1

1,44616E-31

2,67625E-11

5,83583E-11

4,06812E0

2,50464E0

2,37523E-15

6,07832E-14

6,02611E-13

6,00000E1

6,14018E-19

1,74542E0

1,89202E-4

8,46315E-33

5,50356E-4

2,19334E-1

1,04862E-5

9,99999E2

1,24159E0

9,29614E-26

2,99992E-19

1,00000E2

4,20234E-20

2,25792E-6

2,64970E-5

1,81276E-33

5,47456E-23

1,13045E-4

6,94079E-16

9,04104E-9

2.8

MathSBML

2,98701E0

2,98992E-32

2,51496E-17

5,00000E1

1,44616E-31

2,67624E-11

5,83583E-11

4,06812E0

2,50464E0

2,37522E-15

6,07831E-14

6,02610E-13

6,00000E1

6,14017E-19

1,74542E0

1,89202E-4

8,46319E-33

5,50356E-4

2,19334E-1

1,04862E-5

9,99999E2

1,24159E0

9,29617E-26

2,99992E-19

1,00000E2

4,20235E-20

2,25792E-6

2,64970E-5

1,81277E-33

5,47456E-23

1,13045E-4

6,94078E-16

9,04104E-9

2.8

Oscill8 Core

8,66169E-31

-3,63022E-12

5,00000E1

5,33438E-30

5,83677E-11

4,06812E0

2,50464E0

3,66966E-11

6,63187E-14

6,02730E-13

6,00000E1

1,74542E0

1,89204E-4

3,70501E-31

5,50364E-4

2,19335E-1

9,99999E2

1,24159E0

1,46030E-24

4,95825E-19

1,00000E2

3,79305E-11

2,64978E-5

5,84127E-32

2,44569E-22

1,13048E-4

9,04150E-9

2.8

SBToolbox2

2,98640E0

3,70100E-32

2,91914E-17

5,00000E1

1,83867E-31

2,65866E-11

5,80762E-11

4,06873E0

2,50512E0

2,59745E-15

6,30934E-14

6,25218E-13

6,00000E1

7,11456E-19

1,74469E0

1,89097E-4

1,09505E-32

5,50539E-4

2,19086E-1

1,05050E-5

1,00000E3

1,24170E0

1,16314E-25

3,28260E-19

1,00000E2

5,23177E-20

2,28769E-6

2,66190E-5

2,24334E-33

6,37470E-23

1,13625E-4

7,57747E-16

9,16042E-9

2.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,98702E0

2,99152E-32

2,51567E-17

5,00000E1

1,44699E-31

2,67653E-11

5,83678E-11

4,06812E0

2,50464E0

2,37579E-15

6,07952E-14

6,02729E-13

6,00000E1

6,14188E-19

1,74542E0

1,89204E-4

8,46857E-33

5,50364E-4

2,19335E-1

1,04864E-5

9,99999E2

1,24159E0

9,29918E-26

3,00063E-19

1,00000E2

4,20370E-20

2,25802E-6

2,64978E-5

1,81383E-33

5,47610E-23

1,13048E-4

6,94243E-16

9,04143E-9

2.8

VCell

2,98701E0

2,99000E-32

2,51501E-17

5,00000E1

1,44620E-31

2,67626E-11

5,83588E-11

4,06812E0

2,50464E0

2,37525E-15

6,07838E-14

6,02616E-13

6,00000E1

6,14027E-19

1,74542E0

1,89202E-4

8,46340E-33

5,50357E-4

2,19334E-1

1,04862E-5

9,99999E2

1,24159E0

9,29635E-26

2,99996E-19

1,00000E2

4,20242E-20

2,25793E-6

2,64971E-5

1,81281E-33

5,47465E-23

1,13045E-4

6,94088E-16

9,04108E-9

2.8

copasi

2,98701E0

3,54927E-32

-1,47497E-15

5,00000E1

1,77563E-31

2,67866E-11

5,83667E-11

4,06812E0

2,50464E0

-8,80265E-15

6,10271E-14

6,02793E-13

6,00000E1

1,62945E-13

1,74542E0

1,89202E-4

1,06635E-32

5,50356E-4

2,19334E-1

1,04862E-5

9,99999E2

1,24159E0

1,03520E-25

3,04209E-19

1,00000E2

-1,12333E-14

2,25792E-6

2,64970E-5

2,18021E-33

5,70325E-23

1,13045E-4

1,47497E-15

9,04104E-9

2.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,98701E0

2,76292E-32

3,38178E-16

5,00000E1

1,31171E-31

2,65752E-11

5,83591E-11

4,06812E0

2,50464E0

1,16893E-14

6,07056E-14

6,02635E-13

6,00000E1

5,75204E-14

1,74542E0

1,89202E-4

7,56245E-33

5,50356E-4

2,19334E-1

1,04862E-5

9,99999E2

1,24159E0

8,87697E-26

2,98671E-19

1,00000E2

9,32585E-15

2,25792E-6

2,64971E-5

1,66351E-33

5,39229E-23

1,13045E-4

-3,38178E-16

9,04104E-9

2.8

jsim

2,87455E0

9,62983E-24

2,03626E-15

4,99999E1

9,01284E-22

1,53472E-9

3,71960E-12

5,84721E-1

2,88725E0

7,54141E-16

5,21335E-14

1,01299E-11

6,00000E1

6,28498E-15

2,91152E-1

1,53069E-3

2,37648E-20

1,51321E-2

1,65886E0

1,47227E-2

9,99845E2

2,58340E0

6,80941E-18

5,30663E-15

9,98488E1

1,76829E-16

6,66023E-5

1,36493E-1

1,08531E-22

2,09451E-16

1,50551E-5

1,56108E-13

1,41893E-3

2.8

min

2,87455E0

2,76292E-32

-3,63022E-12

4,99999E1

1,31171E-31

2,65752E-11

3,71960E-12

5,84721E-1

2,50464E0

-8,80265E-15

5,21335E-14

6,02610E-13

6,00000E1

6,14017E-19

2,91152E-1

1,89097E-4

7,56245E-33

5,50356E-4

2,19086E-1

1,04862E-5

9,99845E2

1,24159E0

8,87697E-26

2,98671E-19

9,98488E1

-1,12333E-14

2,25792E-6

2,64970E-5

1,66351E-33

5,39229E-23

1,50551E-5

-3,38178E-16

9,04104E-9

2.8

max

2,98702E0

9,62983E-24

2,03626E-15

5,00000E1

9,01284E-22

1,53472E-9

5,83678E-11

4,06873E0

2,88725E0

3,66966E-11

6,63187E-14

1,01299E-11

6,00000E1

1,62945E-13

1,74542E0

1,53069E-3

2,37648E-20

1,51321E-2

1,65886E0

1,47227E-2

1,00000E3

2,58340E0

6,80941E-18

5,30663E-15

1,00000E2

3,79305E-11

6,66023E-5

1,36493E-1

1,08531E-22

2,09451E-16

1,13625E-4

1,56108E-13

1,41893E-3

2.8

mean

2,98701E0

2,99152E-32

2,51501E-17

5,00000E1

1,44699E-31

2,67625E-11

5,83588E-11

4,06812E0

2,50464E0

2,37525E-15

6,07838E-14

6,02729E-13

6,00000E1

6,62822E-19

1,74542E0

1,89202E-4

8,46857E-33

5,50357E-4

2,19334E-1

1,04862E-5

9,99999E2

1,24159E0

9,29918E-26

3,00063E-19

1,00000E2

4,20370E-20

2,25792E-6

2,64971E-5

1,81383E-33

5,47610E-23

1,13045E-4

6,94165E-16

9,04108E-9

2.8

relative error(%)

0,00

3.0

BioUML

2,88081E0

1,24993E-31

7,17960E-17

5,00000E1

6,39162E-31

5,22485E-11

1,31179E-10

3,97603E0

2,61714E0

6,27427E-15

1,48092E-13

1,46711E-12

6,00000E1

1,74946E-18

1,62451E0

2,37780E-4

4,04038E-32

7,26996E-4

2,61995E-1

1,42458E-5

9,99999E2

1,25630E0

2,88287E-25

7,93101E-19

9,99999E1

1,29694E-19

3,50950E-6

3,79195E-5

8,17044E-33

1,56840E-22

1,62665E-4

1,82944E-15

1,40537E-8

3.0

ByoDyn

2,88081E0

1,24993E-31

7,17960E-17

5,00000E1

6,39162E-31

5,22485E-11

1,31179E-10

3,97603E0

2,61714E0

6,27427E-15

1,48092E-13

1,46711E-12

6,00000E1

1,74946E-18

1,62451E0

2,37780E-4

4,04038E-32

7,26996E-4

2,61995E-1

1,42458E-5

9,99999E2

1,25630E0

2,88287E-25

7,93101E-19

9,99999E1

1,29694E-19

3,50950E-6

3,79195E-5

8,17044E-33

1,56840E-22

1,62665E-4

1,82944E-15

1,40537E-8

3.0

MathSBML

2,88081E0

1,24993E-31

7,17959E-17

5,00000E1

6,39165E-31

5,22485E-11

1,31179E-10

3,97603E0

2,61714E0

6,27426E-15

1,48092E-13

1,46711E-12

6,00000E1

1,74945E-18

1,62451E0

2,37780E-4

4,04042E-32

7,26996E-4

2,61995E-1

1,42458E-5

9,99999E2

1,25630E0

2,88287E-25

7,93100E-19

9,99999E1

1,29694E-19

3,50950E-6

3,79195E-5

8,17047E-33

1,56840E-22

1,62665E-4

1,82944E-15

1,40537E-8

3.0

Oscill8 Core

1,60504E-30

-3,00491E-12

5,00000E1

1,02405E-29

1,31197E-10

3,97603E0

2,61714E0

4,47428E-11

1,53793E-13

1,46736E-12

6,00000E1

1,62451E0

2,37782E-4

7,61151E-31

7,27004E-4

2,61995E-1

9,99999E2

1,25630E0

2,07614E-24

1,01732E-18

9,99999E1

4,61703E-11

3,79204E-5

1,16240E-31

3,88641E-22

1,62669E-4

1,40543E-8

3.0

SBToolbox2

2,88030E0

1,35893E-31

7,97194E-17

5,00000E1

6,98071E-31

5,14764E-11

1,28356E-10

3,97654E0

2,61771E0

6,63613E-15

1,50050E-13

1,48588E-12

6,00000E1

1,93954E-18

1,62381E0

2,37653E-4

4,33882E-32

7,27061E-4

2,61730E-1

1,42653E-5

1,00000E3

1,25639E0

3,40206E-25

8,39313E-19

1,00000E2

1,52393E-19

3,54850E-6

3,80594E-5

8,63697E-33

1,74632E-22

1,63348E-4

1,93209E-15

1,42100E-8

3.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,88081E0

1,25052E-31

7,18137E-17

5,00000E1

6,39486E-31

5,22533E-11

1,31197E-10

3,97603E0

2,61714E0

6,27558E-15

1,48118E-13

1,46736E-12

6,00000E1

1,74989E-18

1,62451E0

2,37782E-4

4,04266E-32

7,27004E-4

2,61995E-1

1,42461E-5

9,99999E2

1,25630E0

2,88370E-25

7,93267E-19

9,99999E1

1,29732E-19

3,50963E-6

3,79204E-5

8,17472E-33

1,56879E-22

1,62669E-4

1,82982E-15

1,40542E-8

3.0

VCell

2,88081E0

1,24995E-31

7,17969E-17

5,00000E1

6,39175E-31

5,22487E-11

1,31180E-10

3,97603E0

2,61714E0

6,27433E-15

1,48094E-13

1,46712E-12

6,00000E1

1,74948E-18

1,62451E0

2,37780E-4

4,04047E-32

7,26996E-4

2,61995E-1

1,42459E-5

9,99999E2

1,25630E0

2,88291E-25

7,93109E-19

9,99999E1

1,29697E-19

3,50951E-6

3,79196E-5

8,17062E-33

1,56842E-22

1,62666E-4

1,82946E-15

1,40537E-8

3.0

copasi

2,88081E0

1,36258E-31

-1,44541E-15

5,00000E1

7,10298E-31

5,22808E-11

1,31188E-10

3,97603E0

2,61714E0

4,93552E-16

1,48357E-13

1,46744E-12

6,00000E1

2,48954E-13

1,62451E0

2,37780E-4

4,55349E-32

7,26996E-4

2,61995E-1

1,42458E-5

9,99999E2

1,25630E0

3,04341E-25

7,98603E-19

9,99999E1

-5,79949E-15

3,50949E-6

3,79195E-5

8,96852E-33

1,60099E-22

1,62665E-4

1,44541E-15

1,40537E-8

3.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,88081E0

1,20519E-31

4,96864E-16

5,00000E1

6,11392E-31

5,20857E-11

1,31180E-10

3,97603E0

2,61714E0

1,79893E-14

1,47956E-13

1,46715E-12

6,00000E1

7,38455E-14

1,62451E0

2,37780E-4

3,84017E-32

7,26996E-4

2,61995E-1

1,42458E-5

9,99999E2

1,25630E0

2,82168E-25

7,91274E-19

9,99999E1

1,17377E-14

3,50950E-6

3,79195E-5

7,85331E-33

1,55711E-22

1,62665E-4

-4,96864E-16

1,40537E-8

3.0

jsim

2,75033E0

1,81675E-23

3,00494E-15

4,99999E1

1,79316E-21

2,01598E-9

4,54114E-12

5,13287E-1

2,79439E0

9,90305E-16

6,54891E-14

1,38988E-11

6,00000E1

9,95212E-15

2,52562E-1

1,63722E-3

5,47317E-20

1,63766E-2

1,77210E0

1,74057E-2

9,99817E2

2,49777E0

1,19341E-17

7,52848E-15

9,98191E1

3,02250E-16

8,01362E-5

1,63473E-1

2,28220E-22

3,31645E-16

1,63943E-5

2,20968E-13

1,71786E-3

3.0

min

2,75033E0

1,20519E-31

-3,00491E-12

4,99999E1

6,11392E-31

5,14764E-11

4,54114E-12

5,13287E-1

2,61714E0

4,93552E-16

6,54891E-14

1,46711E-12

6,00000E1

1,74945E-18

2,52562E-1

2,37653E-4

3,84017E-32

7,26996E-4

2,61730E-1

1,42458E-5

9,99817E2

1,25630E0

2,82168E-25

7,91274E-19

9,98191E1

-5,79949E-15

3,50949E-6

3,79195E-5

7,85331E-33

1,55711E-22

1,63943E-5

-4,96864E-16

1,40537E-8

3.0

max

2,88081E0

1,81675E-23

3,00494E-15

5,00000E1

1,79316E-21

2,01598E-9

1,31197E-10

3,97654E0

2,79439E0

4,47428E-11

1,53793E-13

1,38988E-11

6,00000E1

2,48954E-13

1,62451E0

1,63722E-3

5,47317E-20

1,63766E-2

1,77210E0

1,74057E-2

1,00000E3

2,49777E0

1,19341E-17

7,52848E-15

1,00000E2

4,61703E-11

8,01362E-5

1,63473E-1

2,28220E-22

3,31645E-16

1,63348E-4

2,20968E-13

1,71786E-3

3.0

mean

2,88081E0

1,25052E-31

7,17969E-17

5,00000E1

6,39486E-31

5,22486E-11

1,31180E-10

3,97603E0

2,61714E0

6,27433E-15

1,48094E-13

1,46736E-12

6,00000E1

1,84471E-18

1,62451E0

2,37780E-4

4,04266E-32

7,26996E-4

2,61995E-1

1,42459E-5

9,99999E2

1,25630E0

2,88370E-25

7,93267E-19

9,99999E1

1,29732E-19

3,50950E-6

3,79196E-5

8,17472E-33

1,56879E-22

1,62665E-4

1,82945E-15

1,40537E-8

3.0

relative error(%)

0,00

3.2

BioUML

2,78628E0

4,69469E-31

1,89404E-16

5,00000E1

2,52309E-30

9,65615E-11

2,76501E-10

3,87925E0

2,71728E0

1,53904E-14

3,36682E-13

3,33287E-12

6,00000E1

4,60611E-18

1,51710E0

2,92901E-4

1,71432E-31

9,36899E-4

3,07294E-1

1,88725E-5

9,99999E2

1,26918E0

8,22241E-25

1,94706E-18

9,99999E1

3,68114E-19

5,26916E-6

5,26745E-5

3,29256E-32

4,15245E-22

2,27223E-4

4,47758E-15

2,11020E-8

3.2

ByoDyn

2,78628E0

4,69469E-31

1,89404E-16

5,00000E1

2,52309E-30

9,65615E-11

2,76501E-10

3,87925E0

2,71728E0

1,53904E-14

3,36682E-13

3,33287E-12

6,00000E1

4,60611E-18

1,51710E0

2,92901E-4

1,71432E-31

9,36899E-4

3,07294E-1

1,88725E-5

9,99999E2

1,26918E0

8,22241E-25

1,94706E-18

9,99999E1

3,68114E-19

5,26916E-6

5,26745E-5

3,29256E-32

4,15245E-22

2,27223E-4

4,47758E-15

2,11020E-8

3.2

MathSBML

2,78628E0

4,69507E-31

1,89408E-16

5,00000E1

2,52338E-30

9,65616E-11

2,76502E-10

3,87925E0

2,71728E0

1,53906E-14

3,36684E-13

3,33289E-12

6,00000E1

4,60620E-18

1,51710E0

2,92901E-4

1,71459E-31

9,36899E-4

3,07294E-1

1,88725E-5

9,99999E2

1,26918E0

8,22268E-25

1,94709E-18

9,99999E1

3,68126E-19

5,26916E-6

5,26745E-5

3,29290E-32

4,15253E-22

2,27223E-4

4,47763E-15

2,11020E-8

3.2

Oscill8 Core

2,98528E-30

-2,31253E-12

5,00000E1

1,94860E-29

2,76535E-10

3,87925E0

2,71728E0

5,23840E-11

3,43295E-13

3,33338E-12

6,00000E1

1,51710E0

2,92902E-4

1,53516E-30

9,36908E-4

3,07294E-1

9,99999E2

1,26918E0

3,12026E-24

2,20174E-18

9,99999E1

5,39880E-11

5,26756E-5

2,30126E-31

6,94832E-22

2,27228E-4

2,11027E-8

3.2

SBToolbox2

2,78561E0

5,86782E-31

2,21474E-16

5,00000E1

3,24209E-30

9,60704E-11

2,75871E-10

3,87987E0

2,71800E0

1,69250E-14

3,50845E-13

3,47103E-12

6,00000E1

5,37461E-18

1,51630E0

2,92736E-4

2,24070E-31

9,37001E-4

3,06968E-1

1,89034E-5

1,00000E3

1,26931E0

1,03989E-24

2,14282E-18

1,00000E2

4,62762E-19

5,33701E-6

5,28944E-5

4,11174E-32

4,87410E-22

2,28322E-4

4,91417E-15

2,13742E-8

3.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,78628E0

4,69649E-31

1,89446E-16

5,00000E1

2,52424E-30

9,65681E-11

2,76535E-10

3,87925E0

2,71728E0

1,53933E-14

3,36733E-13

3,33338E-12

6,00000E1

4,60711E-18

1,51710E0

2,92903E-4

1,71518E-31

9,36908E-4

3,07294E-1

1,88728E-5

9,99999E2

1,26918E0

8,22453E-25

1,94742E-18

9,99999E1

3,68208E-19

5,26934E-6

5,26756E-5

3,29413E-32

4,15337E-22

2,27228E-4

4,47840E-15

2,11027E-8

3.2

VCell

2,78628E0

4,69477E-31

1,89406E-16

5,00000E1

2,52313E-30

9,65619E-11

2,76502E-10

3,87925E0

2,71728E0

1,53905E-14

3,36684E-13

3,33289E-12

6,00000E1

4,60616E-18

1,51710E0

2,92901E-4

1,71435E-31

9,36900E-4

3,07294E-1

1,88725E-5

9,99999E2

1,26918E0

8,22252E-25

1,94708E-18

9,99999E1

3,68119E-19

5,26918E-6

5,26746E-5

3,29262E-32

4,15249E-22

2,27224E-4

4,47762E-15

2,11020E-8

3.2

copasi

2,78628E0

4,91747E-31

-1,29662E-15

5,00000E1

2,67130E-30

9,65952E-11

2,76519E-10

3,87925E0

2,71728E0

1,74830E-14

3,36913E-13

3,33358E-12

6,00000E1

1,14884E-13

1,51710E0

2,92901E-4

1,82955E-31

9,36899E-4

3,07293E-1

1,88725E-5

9,99999E2

1,26918E0

8,46305E-25

1,95412E-18

9,99999E1

2,11471E-15

5,26916E-6

5,26745E-5

3,46228E-32

4,19841E-22

2,27223E-4

1,29662E-15

2,11019E-8

3.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,78628E0

4,61050E-31

7,38856E-16

5,00000E1

2,46871E-30

9,64386E-11

2,76502E-10

3,87925E0

2,71728E0

2,76322E-14

3,36410E-13

3,33293E-12

6,00000E1

6,28138E-14

1,51710E0

2,92901E-4

1,67235E-31

9,36899E-4

3,07294E-1

1,88725E-5

9,99999E2

1,26918E0

8,13467E-25

1,94428E-18

9,99999E1

1,22771E-14

5,26916E-6

5,26746E-5

3,22857E-32

4,13670E-22

2,27223E-4

-7,38856E-16

2,11020E-8

3.2

jsim

2,63756E0

3,20612E-23

4,24155E-15

4,99999E1

3,32912E-21

2,56721E-9

5,38873E-12

4,52304E-1

2,70246E0

1,25531E-15

7,96224E-14

1,83797E-11

6,00000E1

1,50158E-14

2,21867E-1

1,73188E-3

1,16278E-19

1,75098E-2

1,87241E0

2,02062E-2

9,99786E2

2,41569E0

1,97920E-17

1,02516E-14

9,97878E1

4,90005E-16

9,45423E-5

1,91983E-1

4,45824E-22

5,00359E-16

1,76387E-5

3,00190E-13

2,03951E-3

3.2

min

2,63756E0

4,61050E-31

-2,31253E-12

4,99999E1

2,46871E-30

9,60704E-11

5,38873E-12

4,52304E-1

2,70246E0

1,25531E-15

7,96224E-14

3,33287E-12

6,00000E1

4,60611E-18

2,21867E-1

2,92736E-4

1,67235E-31

9,36899E-4

3,06968E-1

1,88725E-5

9,99786E2

1,26918E0

8,13467E-25

1,94428E-18

9,97878E1

3,68114E-19

5,26916E-6

5,26745E-5

3,22857E-32

4,13670E-22

1,76387E-5

-7,38856E-16

2,11019E-8

3.2

max

2,78628E0

3,20612E-23

4,24155E-15

5,00000E1

3,32912E-21

2,56721E-9

2,76535E-10

3,87987E0

2,71800E0

5,23840E-11

3,50845E-13

1,83797E-11

6,00000E1

1,14884E-13

1,51710E0

1,73188E-3

1,16278E-19

1,75098E-2

1,87241E0

2,02062E-2

1,00000E3

2,41569E0

1,97920E-17

1,02516E-14

1,00000E2

5,39880E-11

9,45423E-5

1,91983E-1

4,45824E-22

5,00359E-16

2,28322E-4

3,00190E-13

2,03951E-3

3.2

mean

2,78628E0

4,69649E-31

1,89408E-16

5,00000E1

2,52424E-30

9,65617E-11

2,76502E-10

3,87925E0

2,71728E0

1,53933E-14

3,36684E-13

3,33338E-12

6,00000E1

4,99086E-18

1,51710E0

2,92901E-4

1,71518E-31

9,36900E-4

3,07294E-1

1,88725E-5

9,99999E2

1,26918E0

8,22453E-25

1,94742E-18

9,99999E1

4,62762E-19

5,26917E-6

5,26746E-5

3,29413E-32

4,15337E-22

2,27223E-4

4,47762E-15

2,11020E-8

3.2

relative error(%)

0,00

3.4

BioUML

2,70168E0

1,60602E-30

4,66385E-16

5,00000E1

9,02483E-30

1,70142E-10

5,51059E-10

3,77939E0

2,80609E0

3,53886E-14

7,20593E-13

7,12776E-12

6,00000E1

1,13193E-17

1,42119E0

3,54590E-4

6,56214E-31

1,18182E-3

3,54788E-1

2,44602E-5

9,99998E2

1,28049E0

2,17982E-24

4,48085E-18

9,99999E1

9,71108E-19

7,67579E-6

7,12995E-5

1,20330E-31

1,02620E-21

3,09313E-4

1,02726E-14

3,07426E-8

3.4

ByoDyn

2,70168E0

1,60602E-30

4,66385E-16

5,00000E1

9,02483E-30

1,70142E-10

5,51059E-10

3,77939E0

2,80609E0

3,53886E-14

7,20593E-13

7,12776E-12

6,00000E1

1,13193E-17

1,42119E0

3,54590E-4

6,56214E-31

1,18182E-3

3,54788E-1

2,44602E-5

9,99998E2

1,28049E0

2,17982E-24

4,48085E-18

9,99999E1

9,71108E-19

7,67579E-6

7,12995E-5

1,20330E-31

1,02620E-21

3,09313E-4

1,02726E-14

3,07426E-8

3.4

MathSBML

2,70168E0

1,60610E-30

4,66395E-16

5,00000E1

9,02625E-30

1,70142E-10

5,51060E-10

3,77939E0

2,80609E0

3,53890E-14

7,20598E-13

7,12780E-12

6,00000E1

1,13196E-17

1,42119E0

3,54590E-4

6,56363E-31

1,18182E-3

3,54788E-1

2,44602E-5

9,99998E2

1,28049E0

2,17990E-24

4,48090E-18

9,99999E1

9,71145E-19

7,67579E-6

7,12995E-5

1,20339E-31

1,02623E-21

3,09313E-4

1,02727E-14

3,07426E-8

3.4

Oscill8 Core

5,73418E-30

-1,56039E-12

5,00000E1

3,78149E-29

5,51119E-10

3,77939E0

2,80608E0

5,96461E-11

7,27484E-13

7,12871E-12

6,00000E1

1,42120E0

3,54592E-4

3,12460E-30

1,18183E-3

3,54788E-1

9,99998E2

1,28049E0

5,08992E-24

4,76998E-18

9,99999E1

6,14005E-11

7,13007E-5

4,66160E-31

1,36012E-21

3,09318E-4

3,07435E-8

3.4

SBToolbox2

2,70106E0

1,95484E-30

5,34730E-16

5,00000E1

1,12150E-29

1,68605E-10

5,46011E-10

3,77993E0

2,80687E0

3,83161E-14

7,42276E-13

7,33799E-12

6,00000E1

1,29510E-17

1,42043E0

3,54395E-4

8,24538E-31

1,18175E-3

3,54447E-1

2,44923E-5

1,00000E3

1,28063E0

2,69148E-24

4,85522E-18

1,00000E2

1,19173E-18

7,76329E-6

7,15477E-5

1,45966E-31

1,18113E-21

3,10589E-4

1,10999E-14

3,10932E-8

3.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,70168E0

1,60669E-30

4,66477E-16

5,00000E1

9,02855E-30

1,70153E-10

5,51120E-10

3,77939E0

2,80608E0

3,53944E-14

7,20691E-13

7,12872E-12

6,00000E1

1,13215E-17

1,42120E0

3,54592E-4

6,56524E-31

1,18183E-3

3,54788E-1

2,44605E-5

9,99998E2

1,28049E0

2,18033E-24

4,48159E-18

9,99999E1

9,71333E-19

7,67601E-6

7,13007E-5

1,20381E-31

1,02641E-21

3,09319E-4

1,02743E-14

3,07435E-8

3.4

VCell

2,70168E0

1,60604E-30

4,66389E-16

5,00000E1

9,02496E-30

1,70142E-10

5,51062E-10

3,77939E0

2,80609E0

3,53888E-14

7,20597E-13

7,12779E-12

6,00000E1

1,13194E-17

1,42120E0

3,54590E-4

6,56224E-31

1,18182E-3

3,54788E-1

2,44602E-5

9,99998E2

1,28049E0

2,17984E-24

4,48088E-18

9,99999E1

9,71118E-19

7,67581E-6

7,12996E-5

1,20332E-31

1,02621E-21

3,09313E-4

1,02726E-14

3,07426E-8

3.4

copasi

2,70168E0

1,64790E-30

-8,93752E-16

5,00000E1

9,31651E-30

1,70178E-10

5,51086E-10

3,77939E0

2,80609E0

4,29482E-14

7,20640E-13

7,12897E-12

6,00000E1

1,87539E-13

1,42119E0

3,54590E-4

6,80521E-31

1,18182E-3

3,54788E-1

2,44602E-5

9,99998E2

1,28049E0

2,21488E-24

4,48894E-18

9,99999E1

7,64081E-15

7,67578E-6

7,12995E-5

1,23728E-31

1,03242E-21

3,09313E-4

8,93752E-16

3,07425E-8

3.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,70168E0

1,59070E-30

1,15008E-15

5,00000E1

8,92260E-30

1,70044E-10

5,51061E-10

3,77939E0

2,80609E0

5,01377E-14

7,20021E-13

7,12784E-12

6,00000E1

7,88208E-15

1,42119E0

3,54590E-4

6,47816E-31

1,18182E-3

3,54788E-1

2,44602E-5

9,99998E2

1,28049E0

2,16727E-24

4,47607E-18

9,99999E1

1,48032E-14

7,67579E-6

7,12995E-5

1,19089E-31

1,02391E-21

3,09313E-4

-1,15008E-15

3,07426E-8

3.4

jsim

2,53469E0

5,34797E-23

5,77091E-15

4,99999E1

5,83186E-21

3,18542E-9

6,24892E-12

4,00317E-1

2,61314E0

1,54698E-15

9,42781E-14

2,35705E-11

6,00000E1

2,17519E-14

1,97246E-1

1,81549E-3

2,30609E-19

1,85377E-2

1,96071E0

2,30979E-2

9,99755E2

2,33745E0

3,13179E-17

1,34917E-14

9,97551E1

7,59610E-16

1,09703E-4

2,21761E-1

8,18084E-22

7,24772E-16

1,87928E-5

3,94112E-13

2,38180E-3

3.4

min

2,53469E0

1,59070E-30

-1,56039E-12

4,99999E1

8,92260E-30

1,68605E-10

6,24892E-12

4,00317E-1

2,61314E0

1,54698E-15

9,42781E-14

7,12776E-12

6,00000E1

1,13193E-17

1,97246E-1

3,54395E-4

6,47816E-31

1,18175E-3

3,54447E-1

2,44602E-5

9,99755E2

1,28049E0

2,16727E-24

4,47607E-18

9,97551E1

9,71108E-19

7,67578E-6

7,12995E-5

1,19089E-31

1,02391E-21

1,87928E-5

-1,15008E-15

3,07425E-8

3.4

max

2,70168E0

5,34797E-23

5,77091E-15

5,00000E1

5,83186E-21

3,18542E-9

5,51120E-10

3,77993E0

2,80687E0

5,96461E-11

7,42276E-13

2,35705E-11

6,00000E1

1,87539E-13

1,42120E0

1,81549E-3

2,30609E-19

1,85377E-2

1,96071E0

2,30979E-2

1,00000E3

2,33745E0

3,13179E-17

1,34917E-14

1,00000E2

6,14005E-11

1,09703E-4

2,21761E-1

8,18084E-22

7,24772E-16

3,10589E-4

3,94112E-13

2,38180E-3

3.4

mean

2,70168E0

1,60669E-30

4,66395E-16

5,00000E1

9,02855E-30

1,70142E-10

5,51061E-10

3,77939E0

2,80609E0

3,53944E-14

7,20598E-13

7,12871E-12

6,00000E1

1,21363E-17

1,42119E0

3,54590E-4

6,56524E-31

1,18182E-3

3,54788E-1

2,44602E-5

9,99998E2

1,28049E0

2,18033E-24

4,48159E-18

9,99999E1

1,19173E-18

7,67580E-6

7,12996E-5

1,20381E-31

1,02641E-21

3,09313E-4

1,02727E-14

3,07426E-8

3.4

relative error(%)

0,00

3.6

BioUML

2,62559E0

5,06053E-30

1,08081E-15

5,00000E1

2,96000E-29

2,87502E-10

1,04552E-9

3,67772E0

2,88458E0

7,68739E-14

1,46257E-12

1,44556E-11

6,00000E1

2,61785E-17

1,33516E0

4,22819E-4

2,29428E-30

1,46313E-3

4,04046E-1

3,10993E-5

9,99998E2

1,29043E0

5,41846E-24

9,74196E-18

9,99999E1

2,40197E-18

1,08887E-5

9,43408E-5

4,03507E-31

2,38688E-21

4,11633E-4

2,22641E-14

4,36142E-8

3.6

ByoDyn

2,62559E0

5,06053E-30

1,08081E-15

5,00000E1

2,96000E-29

2,87502E-10

1,04552E-9

3,67772E0

2,88458E0

7,68739E-14

1,46257E-12

1,44556E-11

6,00000E1

2,61785E-17

1,33516E0

4,22819E-4

2,29428E-30

1,46313E-3

4,04046E-1

3,10993E-5

9,99998E2

1,29043E0

5,41846E-24

9,74196E-18

9,99999E1

2,40197E-18

1,08887E-5

9,43408E-5

4,03507E-31

2,38688E-21

4,11633E-4

2,22641E-14

4,36142E-8

3.6

MathSBML

2,62559E0

5,06074E-30

1,08082E-15

5,00000E1

2,96030E-29

2,87502E-10

1,04552E-9

3,67772E0

2,88458E0

7,68742E-14

1,46257E-12

1,44556E-11

6,00000E1

2,61788E-17

1,33516E0

4,22819E-4

2,29464E-30

1,46313E-3

4,04046E-1

3,10993E-5

9,99998E2

1,29043E0

5,41862E-24

9,74200E-18

9,99999E1

2,40203E-18

1,08887E-5

9,43408E-5

4,03529E-31

2,38691E-21

4,11633E-4

2,22642E-14

4,36142E-8

3.6

Oscill8 Core

1,16274E-29

-7,55194E-13

5,00000E1

7,67743E-29

1,04562E-9

3,67772E0

2,88458E0

6,65586E-11

1,47001E-12

1,44573E-11

6,00000E1

1,33516E0

4,22821E-4

6,59138E-30

1,46315E-3

4,04046E-1

9,99998E2

1,29043E0

9,05617E-24

1,00663E-17

9,99999E1

6,84241E-11

9,43422E-5

9,89116E-31

2,78206E-21

4,11639E-4

4,36154E-8

3.6

SBToolbox2

2,62500E0

5,76164E-30

1,21259E-15

5,00000E1

3,40103E-29

2,84422E-10

1,03081E-9

3,67824E0

2,88537E0

8,19356E-14

1,49111E-12

1,47293E-11

6,00000E1

2,93099E-17

1,33438E0

4,22585E-4

2,61140E-30

1,46290E-3

4,03700E-1

3,11344E-5

1,00000E3

1,29056E0

6,49723E-24

1,03910E-17

1,00000E2

2,86370E-18

1,10021E-5

9,46278E-5

4,50372E-31

2,68761E-21

4,13152E-4

2,36846E-14

4,40697E-8

3.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,62559E0

5,06227E-30

1,08100E-15

5,00000E1

2,96109E-29

2,87519E-10

1,04562E-9

3,67772E0

2,88458E0

7,68853E-14

1,46275E-12

1,44573E-11

6,00000E1

2,61831E-17

1,33516E0

4,22821E-4

2,29523E-30

1,46315E-3

4,04046E-1

3,10996E-5

9,99998E2

1,29043E0

5,41960E-24

9,74340E-18

9,99999E1

2,40247E-18

1,08890E-5

9,43422E-5

4,03662E-31

2,38730E-21

4,11639E-4

2,22673E-14

4,36154E-8

3.6

VCell

2,62559E0

5,06079E-30

1,08085E-15

5,00000E1

2,96016E-29

2,87505E-10

1,04554E-9

3,67772E0

2,88458E0

7,68760E-14

1,46260E-12

1,44559E-11

6,00000E1

2,61793E-17

1,33516E0

4,22820E-4

2,29442E-30

1,46314E-3

4,04046E-1

3,10994E-5

9,99998E2

1,29043E0

5,41867E-24

9,74222E-18

9,99999E1

2,40206E-18

1,08887E-5

9,43411E-5

4,03530E-31

2,38695E-21

4,11634E-4

2,22647E-14

4,36145E-8

3.6

copasi

2,62559E0

5,13735E-30

-1,09162E-16

5,00000E1

3,01638E-29

2,87544E-10

1,04556E-9

3,67772E0

2,88458E0

8,95700E-14

1,46252E-12

1,44576E-11

6,00000E1

1,66205E-13

1,33516E0

4,22819E-4

2,34473E-30

1,46314E-3

4,04046E-1

3,10993E-5

9,99998E2

1,29043E0

5,46864E-24

9,75045E-18

9,99999E1

1,28438E-14

1,08887E-5

9,43408E-5

4,10210E-31

2,39499E-21

4,11633E-4

1,33935E-14

4,36142E-8

3.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,62559E0

5,03313E-30

1,91070E-15

5,00000E1

2,94126E-29

2,87421E-10

1,04552E-9

3,67772E0

2,88458E0

9,10510E-14

1,46142E-12

1,44557E-11

6,00000E1

-3,08584E-14

1,33516E0

4,22819E-4

2,27800E-30

1,46314E-3

4,04046E-1

3,10993E-5

9,99998E2

1,29043E0

5,40020E-24

9,73297E-18

9,99999E1

1,42656E-14

1,08887E-5

9,43408E-5

4,01154E-31

2,38326E-21

4,11633E-4

1,23002E-14

4,36142E-8

3.6

jsim

2,44046E0

8,50259E-23

7,61491E-15

4,99999E1

9,72529E-21

3,86690E-9

7,11125E-12

3,56026E-1

2,52746E0

1,86374E-15

1,09246E-13

2,94570E-11

6,00000E1

3,04372E-14

1,77331E-1

1,88899E-3

4,31083E-19

1,94678E-2

2,03805E0

2,60571E-2

9,99722E2

2,26313E0

4,75989E-17

1,72549E-14

9,97214E1

1,13340E-15

1,25511E-4

2,52570E-1

1,42279E-21

1,01409E-15

1,98628E-5

5,02788E-13

2,74278E-3

3.6

min

2,44046E0

5,03313E-30

-7,55194E-13

4,99999E1

2,94126E-29

2,84422E-10

7,11125E-12

3,56026E-1

2,52746E0

1,86374E-15

1,09246E-13

1,44556E-11

6,00000E1

-3,08584E-14

1,77331E-1

4,22585E-4

2,27800E-30

1,46290E-3

4,03700E-1

3,10993E-5

9,99722E2

1,29043E0

5,40020E-24

9,73297E-18

9,97214E1

2,40197E-18

1,08887E-5

9,43408E-5

4,01154E-31

2,38326E-21

1,98628E-5

1,23002E-14

4,36142E-8

3.6

max

2,62559E0

8,50259E-23

7,61491E-15

5,00000E1

9,72529E-21

3,86690E-9

1,04562E-9

3,67824E0

2,88537E0

6,65586E-11

1,49111E-12

2,94570E-11

6,00000E1

1,66205E-13

1,33516E0

1,88899E-3

4,31083E-19

1,94678E-2

2,03805E0

2,60571E-2

1,00000E3

2,26313E0

4,75989E-17

1,72549E-14

1,00000E2

6,84241E-11

1,25511E-4

2,52570E-1

1,42279E-21

1,01409E-15

4,13152E-4

5,02788E-13

2,74278E-3

3.6

mean

2,62559E0

5,06227E-30

1,08085E-15

5,00000E1

2,96109E-29

2,87504E-10

1,04552E-9

3,67772E0

2,88458E0

7,68853E-14

1,46257E-12

1,44573E-11

6,00000E1

2,61812E-17

1,33516E0

4,22819E-4

2,29523E-30

1,46314E-3

4,04046E-1

3,10993E-5

9,99998E2

1,29043E0

5,41960E-24

9,74340E-18

9,99999E1

2,86370E-18

1,08887E-5

9,43411E-5

4,03662E-31

2,38730E-21

4,11633E-4

2,22644E-14

4,36145E-8

3.6

relative error(%)

0,00

3.8

BioUML

2,55682E0

1,48254E-29

2,37354E-15

5,00000E1

8,99068E-29

4,68187E-10

1,89921E-9

3,57522E0

2,95377E0

1,58787E-13

2,83233E-12

2,79713E-11

6,00000E1

5,73718E-17

1,25763E0

4,97510E-4

7,40233E-30

1,78183E-3

4,54657E-1

3,88754E-5

9,99998E2

1,29919E0

1,27213E-23

2,01398E-17

9,99998E1

5,61106E-18

1,50876E-5

1,22346E-4

1,25371E-30

5,26116E-21

5,36954E-4

4,58814E-14

6,04380E-8

3.8

ByoDyn

2,55682E0

1,48254E-29

2,37354E-15

5,00000E1

8,99068E-29

4,68187E-10

1,89921E-9

3,57522E0

2,95377E0

1,58787E-13

2,83233E-12

2,79713E-11

6,00000E1

5,73718E-17

1,25763E0

4,97510E-4

7,40233E-30

1,78183E-3

4,54657E-1

3,88754E-5

9,99998E2

1,29919E0

1,27213E-23

2,01398E-17

9,99998E1

5,61106E-18

1,50876E-5

1,22346E-4

1,25371E-30

5,26116E-21

5,36954E-4

4,58814E-14

6,04380E-8

3.8

MathSBML

2,55682E0

1,48241E-29

2,37347E-15

5,00000E1

8,99022E-29

4,68184E-10

1,89918E-9

3,57522E0

2,95377E0

1,58783E-13

2,83227E-12

2,79708E-11

6,00000E1

5,73703E-17

1,25763E0

4,97510E-4

7,40211E-30

1,78183E-3

4,54657E-1

3,88754E-5

9,99998E2

1,29919E0

1,27209E-23

2,01393E-17

9,99998E1

5,61091E-18

1,50876E-5

1,22346E-4

1,25358E-30

5,26102E-21

5,36954E-4

4,58803E-14

6,04380E-8

3.8

Oscill8 Core

2,49879E-29

9,70539E-14

5,00000E1

1,64841E-28

1,89937E-9

3,57522E0

2,95377E0

7,31617E-11

2,84060E-12

2,79743E-11

6,00000E1

1,25763E0

4,97512E-4

1,46295E-29

1,78184E-3

4,54657E-1

9,99998E2

1,29919E0

1,72163E-23

2,05038E-17

9,99998E1

7,50774E-11

1,22348E-4

2,21496E-30

5,72507E-21

5,36961E-4

6,04394E-8

3.8

SBToolbox2

2,55615E0

1,84704E-29

2,71699E-15

5,00000E1

1,14314E-28

4,65837E-10

1,89535E-9

3,57574E0

2,95465E0

1,71896E-13

2,92435E-12

2,88618E-11

6,00000E1

6,55161E-17

1,25681E0

4,97232E-4

9,55269E-30

1,78138E-3

4,54287E-1

3,89168E-5

1,00000E3

1,29935E0

1,56857E-23

2,18205E-17

1,00000E2

6,87125E-18

1,52468E-5

1,22705E-4

1,56647E-30

6,04852E-21

5,38904E-4

4,95582E-14

6,10777E-8

3.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,55682E0

1,48299E-29

2,37391E-15

5,00000E1

8,99365E-29

4,68212E-10

1,89937E-9

3,57522E0

2,95377E0

1,58808E-13

2,83263E-12

2,79743E-11

6,00000E1

5,73808E-17

1,25763E0

4,97512E-4

7,40508E-30

1,78184E-3

4,54657E-1

3,88758E-5

9,99998E2

1,29919E0

1,27237E-23

2,01425E-17

9,99998E1

5,61211E-18

1,50880E-5

1,22348E-4

1,25414E-30

5,26200E-21

5,36962E-4

4,58875E-14

6,04394E-8

3.8

VCell

2,55682E0

1,48260E-29

2,37360E-15

5,00000E1

8,99107E-29

4,68190E-10

1,89923E-9

3,57522E0

2,95377E0

1,58791E-13

2,83238E-12

2,79718E-11

6,00000E1

5,73734E-17

1,25763E0

4,97511E-4

7,40268E-30

1,78183E-3

4,54657E-1

3,88755E-5

9,99998E2

1,29919E0

1,27217E-23

2,01403E-17

9,99998E1

5,61125E-18

1,50877E-5

1,22347E-4

1,25376E-30

5,26131E-21

5,36956E-4

4,58825E-14

6,04383E-8

3.8

copasi

2,55682E0

1,49620E-29

1,41163E-15

5,00000E1

9,09821E-29

4,68229E-10

1,89928E-9

3,57522E0

2,95377E0

1,76973E-13

2,83233E-12

2,79749E-11

6,00000E1

1,96962E-13

1,25763E0

4,97510E-4

7,50616E-30

1,78183E-3

4,54657E-1

3,88754E-5

9,99998E2

1,29919E0

1,27920E-23

2,01496E-17

9,99998E1

1,83980E-14

1,50876E-5

1,22346E-4

1,26633E-30

5,27175E-21

5,36954E-4

5,17256E-14

6,04380E-8

3.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,55682E0

1,47782E-29

3,33092E-15

5,00000E1

8,95804E-29

4,68090E-10

1,89922E-9

3,57522E0

2,95377E0

1,72708E-13

2,83086E-12

2,79716E-11

6,00000E1

-1,49365E-14

1,25763E0

4,97510E-4

7,37292E-30

1,78183E-3

4,54657E-1

3,88754E-5

9,99998E2

1,29919E0

1,26941E-23

2,01243E-17

9,99998E1

1,40556E-14

1,50876E-5

1,22346E-4

1,24949E-30

5,25523E-21

5,36954E-4

3,93016E-14

6,04380E-8

3.8

jsim

2,35381E0

1,29722E-22

9,79332E-15

4,99999E1

1,55497E-20

4,60747E-9

7,96799E-12

3,18291E-1

2,44599E0

2,20471E-15

1,24361E-13

3,60169E-11

6,00000E1

4,13445E-14

1,61086E-1

1,95332E-3

7,65550E-19

2,03081E-2

2,10544E0

2,90627E-2

9,99689E2

2,19272E0

6,98662E-17

2,15397E-14

9,96867E1

1,63639E-15

1,41867E-4

2,84193E-1

2,36245E-21

1,37739E-15

2,08552E-5

6,26047E-13

3,12066E-3

3.8

min

2,35381E0

1,47782E-29

1,41163E-15

4,99999E1

8,95804E-29

4,65837E-10

7,96799E-12

3,18291E-1

2,44599E0

2,20471E-15

1,24361E-13

2,79708E-11

6,00000E1

-1,49365E-14

1,61086E-1

4,97232E-4

7,37292E-30

1,78138E-3

4,54287E-1

3,88754E-5

9,99689E2

1,29919E0

1,26941E-23

2,01243E-17

9,96867E1

5,61091E-18

1,50876E-5

1,22346E-4

1,24949E-30

5,25523E-21

2,08552E-5

3,93016E-14

6,04380E-8

3.8

max

2,55682E0

1,29722E-22

9,70539E-14

5,00000E1

1,55497E-20

4,60747E-9

1,89937E-9

3,57574E0

2,95465E0

7,31617E-11

2,92435E-12

3,60169E-11

6,00000E1

1,96962E-13

1,25763E0

1,95332E-3

7,65550E-19

2,03081E-2

2,10544E0

2,90627E-2

1,00000E3

2,19272E0

6,98662E-17

2,15397E-14

1,00000E2

7,50774E-11

1,41867E-4

2,84193E-1

2,36245E-21

1,37739E-15

5,38904E-4

6,26047E-13

3,12066E-3

3.8

mean

2,55682E0

1,48299E-29

2,37391E-15

5,00000E1

8,99365E-29

4,68189E-10

1,89922E-9

3,57522E0

2,95377E0

1,58808E-13

2,83233E-12

2,79743E-11

6,00000E1

5,73771E-17

1,25763E0

4,97510E-4

7,40508E-30

1,78183E-3

4,54657E-1

3,88754E-5

9,99998E2

1,29919E0

1,27237E-23

2,01425E-17

9,99998E1

6,87125E-18

1,50876E-5

1,22347E-4

1,25414E-30

5,26200E-21

5,36954E-4

4,58850E-14

6,04383E-8

3.8

relative error(%)

0,00

4.0

BioUML

2,49438E0

4,07010E-29

4,96823E-15

5,00000E1

2,55017E-28

7,37789E-10

3,31894E-9

3,47268E0

3,01463E0

3,13577E-13

5,26014E-12

5,19053E-11

6,00000E1

1,19840E-16

1,18748E0

5,78547E-4

2,22322E-29

2,13856E-3

5,06239E-1

4,78688E-5

9,99997E2

1,30690E0

2,83822E-23

3,98072E-17

9,99998E1

1,24556E-17

2,04727E-5

1,55859E-4

3,63893E-30

1,10537E-20

6,88094E-4

9,03962E-14

8,20163E-8

4.0

ByoDyn

2,49438E0

4,07010E-29

4,96823E-15

5,00000E1

2,55017E-28

7,37789E-10

3,31894E-9

3,47268E0

3,01463E0

3,13577E-13

5,26014E-12

5,19053E-11

6,00000E1

1,19840E-16

1,18748E0

5,78547E-4

2,22322E-29

2,13856E-3

5,06239E-1

4,78688E-5

9,99997E2

1,30690E0

2,83822E-23

3,98072E-17

9,99998E1

1,24556E-17

2,04727E-5

1,55859E-4

3,63893E-30

1,10537E-20

6,88094E-4

9,03962E-14

8,20163E-8

4.0

MathSBML

2,49438E0

4,06987E-29

4,96825E-15

5,00000E1

2,55032E-28

7,37788E-10

3,31892E-9

3,47268E0

3,01463E0

3,13577E-13

5,26012E-12

5,19051E-11

6,00000E1

1,19840E-16

1,18748E0

5,78547E-4

2,22345E-29

2,13856E-3

5,06239E-1

4,78688E-5

9,99997E2

1,30690E0

2,83826E-23

3,98071E-17

9,99998E1

1,24558E-17

2,04726E-5

1,55859E-4

3,63865E-30

1,10538E-20

6,88094E-4

9,03960E-14

8,20163E-8

4.0

Oscill8 Core

5,60462E-29

9,91141E-13

5,00000E1

3,70807E-28

3,31919E-9

3,47268E0

3,01462E0

7,95103E-11

5,26874E-12

5,19102E-11

6,00000E1

1,18748E0

5,78549E-4

3,40203E-29

2,13857E-3

5,06239E-1

9,99997E2

1,30690E0

3,38801E-23

4,02127E-17

9,99998E1

8,13809E-11

1,55860E-4

5,17347E-30

1,15945E-20

6,88102E-4

8,20180E-8

4.0

SBToolbox2

2,49380E0

4,73922E-29

5,50608E-15

5,00000E1

3,00302E-28

7,31844E-10

3,28844E-9

3,47314E0

3,01548E0

3,31604E-13

5,35096E-12

5,27726E-11

6,00000E1

1,32528E-16

1,18676E0

5,78236E-4

2,62032E-29

2,13782E-3

5,05890E-1

4,79062E-5

1,00000E3

1,30704E0

3,35296E-23

4,21262E-17

1,00000E2

1,46230E-17

2,06540E-5

1,56212E-4

4,20562E-30

1,22982E-20

6,90106E-4

9,54006E-14

8,27432E-8

4.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,49438E0

4,07121E-29

4,96893E-15

5,00000E1

2,55092E-28

7,37825E-10

3,31919E-9

3,47268E0

3,01462E0

3,13615E-13

5,26065E-12

5,19103E-11

6,00000E1

1,19857E-16

1,18748E0

5,78549E-4

2,22395E-29

2,13857E-3

5,06239E-1

4,78692E-5

9,99997E2

1,30690E0

2,83871E-23

3,98119E-17

9,99998E1

1,24577E-17

2,04731E-5

1,55860E-4

3,64004E-30

1,10553E-20

6,88103E-4

9,04068E-14

8,20180E-8

4.0

VCell

2,49438E0

4,07024E-29

4,96835E-15

5,00000E1

2,55027E-28

7,37794E-10

3,31897E-9

3,47268E0

3,01463E0

3,13583E-13

5,26021E-12

5,19060E-11

6,00000E1

1,19843E-16

1,18748E0

5,78548E-4

2,22331E-29

2,13856E-3

5,06239E-1

4,78689E-5

9,99997E2

1,30690E0

2,83831E-23

3,98079E-17

9,99998E1

1,24560E-17

2,04727E-5

1,55859E-4

3,63906E-30

1,10540E-20

6,88096E-4

9,03979E-14

8,20167E-8

4.0

copasi

2,49438E0

4,09255E-29

4,30655E-15

5,00000E1

2,56932E-28

7,37822E-10

3,31902E-9

3,47268E0

3,01463E0

3,41598E-13

5,26038E-12

5,19105E-11

6,00000E1

2,13072E-13

1,18748E0

5,78548E-4

2,24298E-29

2,13856E-3

5,06239E-1

4,78688E-5

9,99997E2

1,30690E0

2,84787E-23

3,98187E-17

9,99998E1

2,82991E-14

2,04726E-5

1,55859E-4

3,66083E-30

1,10669E-20

6,88094E-4

1,01968E-13

8,20163E-8

4.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,49438E0

4,06179E-29

6,07784E-15

5,00000E1

2,54440E-28

7,37704E-10

3,31895E-9

3,47268E0

3,01463E0

3,30825E-13

5,25833E-12

5,19058E-11

6,00000E1

9,88830E-14

1,18748E0

5,78548E-4

2,21785E-29

2,13856E-3

5,06239E-1

4,78688E-5

9,99997E2

1,30690E0

2,83406E-23

3,97839E-17

9,99998E1

1,74429E-14

2,04727E-5

1,55859E-4

3,63121E-30

1,10441E-20

6,88094E-4

7,91873E-14

8,20163E-8

4.0

jsim

2,27386E0

1,90983E-22

1,23247E-14

4,99998E1

2,39768E-20

5,40274E-9

8,81367E-12

2,86124E-1

2,36902E0

2,56966E-15

1,39498E-13

4,32218E-11

6,00000E1

5,47389E-14

1,47721E-1

2,00938E-3

1,29999E-18

2,10664E-2

2,16389E0

3,20963E-2

9,99655E2

2,12614E0

9,94845E-17

2,63390E-14

9,96515E1

2,29616E-15

1,58681E-4

3,16435E-1

3,76765E-21

1,82346E-15

2,17769E-5

7,63557E-13

3,51379E-3

4.0

min

2,27386E0

4,06179E-29

4,30655E-15

4,99998E1

2,54440E-28

7,31844E-10

8,81367E-12

2,86124E-1

2,36902E0

2,56966E-15

1,39498E-13

4,32218E-11

6,00000E1

1,19840E-16

1,47721E-1

5,78236E-4

2,21785E-29

2,13782E-3

5,05890E-1

4,78688E-5

9,99655E2

1,30690E0

2,83406E-23

3,97839E-17

9,96515E1

1,24556E-17

2,04726E-5

1,55859E-4

3,63121E-30

1,10441E-20

2,17769E-5

7,91873E-14

8,20163E-8

4.0

max

2,49438E0

1,90983E-22

9,91141E-13

5,00000E1

2,39768E-20

5,40274E-9

3,31919E-9

3,47314E0

3,01548E0

7,95103E-11

5,35096E-12

5,27726E-11

6,00000E1

2,13072E-13

1,18748E0

2,00938E-3

1,29999E-18

2,10664E-2

2,16389E0

3,20963E-2

1,00000E3

2,12614E0

9,94845E-17

2,63390E-14

1,00000E2

8,13809E-11

1,58681E-4

3,16435E-1

3,76765E-21

1,82346E-15

6,90106E-4

7,63557E-13

3,51379E-3

4.0

mean

2,49438E0

4,07121E-29

4,96893E-15

5,00000E1

2,55092E-28

7,37792E-10

3,31895E-9

3,47268E0

3,01463E0

3,13615E-13

5,26021E-12

5,19060E-11

6,00000E1

1,26192E-16

1,18748E0

5,78548E-4

2,22395E-29

2,13856E-3

5,06239E-1

4,78689E-5

9,99997E2

1,30690E0

2,83871E-23

3,98119E-17

9,99998E1

1,46230E-17

2,04727E-5

1,55859E-4

3,64004E-30

1,10553E-20

6,88094E-4

9,04024E-14

8,20167E-8

4.0

relative error(%)

0,00

4.2

BioUML

2,43743E0

1,05414E-28

9,96117E-15

5,00000E1

6,80308E-28

1,12901E-9

5,60247E-9

3,37073E0

3,06805E0

5,94821E-13

9,40963E-12

9,27737E-11

6,00000E1

2,39771E-16

1,12377E0

6,65784E-4

6,26173E-29

2,53366E-3

5,58442E-1

5,81541E-5

9,99996E2

1,31367E0

6,04911E-23

7,55756E-17

9,99997E1

2,64116E-17

2,72636E-5

1,95407E-4

9,93606E-30

2,22461E-20

8,67889E-4

1,71065E-13

1,09231E-7

4.2

ByoDyn

2,43743E0

1,05414E-28

9,96117E-15

5,00000E1

6,80308E-28

1,12901E-9

5,60247E-9

3,37073E0

3,06805E0

5,94821E-13

9,40963E-12

9,27737E-11

6,00000E1

2,39771E-16

1,12377E0

6,65784E-4

6,26173E-29

2,53366E-3

5,58442E-1

5,81541E-5

9,99996E2

1,31367E0

6,04911E-23

7,55756E-17

9,99997E1

2,64116E-17

2,72636E-5

1,95407E-4

9,93606E-30

2,22461E-20

8,67889E-4

1,71065E-13

1,09231E-7

4.2

MathSBML

2,43743E0

1,05421E-28

9,96127E-15

5,00000E1

6,80364E-28

1,12901E-9

5,60246E-9

3,37073E0

3,06805E0

5,94822E-13

9,40961E-12

9,27736E-11

6,00000E1

2,39774E-16

1,12377E0

6,65784E-4

6,26255E-29

2,53366E-3

5,58442E-1

5,81541E-5

9,99996E2

1,31367E0

6,04926E-23

7,55757E-17

9,99997E1

2,64122E-17

2,72636E-5

1,95407E-4

9,93690E-30

2,22463E-20

8,67889E-4

1,71066E-13

1,09231E-7

4.2

Oscill8 Core

1,28079E-28

1,92277E-12

5,00000E1

8,54872E-28

5,60285E-9

3,37073E0

3,06804E0

8,56729E-11

9,41931E-12

9,27816E-11

6,00000E1

1,12377E0

6,65785E-4

8,13236E-29

2,53367E-3

5,58443E-1

9,99996E2

1,31367E0

6,71541E-23

7,60270E-17

9,99997E1

8,73475E-11

1,95409E-4

1,23253E-29

2,28725E-20

8,67898E-4

1,09233E-7

4.2

SBToolbox2

2,43683E0

1,27231E-28

1,11384E-14

5,00000E1

8,35072E-28

1,12434E-9

5,59400E-9

3,37114E0

3,06895E0

6,34252E-13

9,65045E-12

9,50922E-11

6,00000E1

2,67467E-16

1,12300E0

6,65426E-4

7,77310E-29

2,53261E-3

5,58090E-1

5,81958E-5

1,00000E3

1,31377E0

7,22479E-23

8,06494E-17

1,00000E2

3,13295E-17

2,75024E-5

1,95821E-4

1,20126E-29

2,49801E-20

8,70341E-4

1,82017E-13

1,10192E-7

4.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,43744E0

1,05440E-28

9,96244E-15

5,00000E1

6,80487E-28

1,12906E-9

5,60286E-9

3,37073E0

3,06804E0

5,94884E-13

9,41044E-12

9,27817E-11

6,00000E1

2,39802E-16

1,12377E0

6,65785E-4

6,26359E-29

2,53367E-3

5,58443E-1

5,81546E-5

9,99996E2

1,31367E0

6,05004E-23

7,55836E-17

9,99997E1

2,64156E-17

2,72641E-5

1,95409E-4

9,93882E-30

2,22490E-20

8,67899E-4

1,71084E-13

1,09233E-7

4.2

VCell

2,43743E0

1,05417E-28

9,96138E-15

5,00000E1

6,80329E-28

1,12902E-9

5,60251E-9

3,37073E0

3,06805E0

5,94830E-13

9,40973E-12

9,27748E-11

6,00000E1

2,39776E-16

1,12377E0

6,65784E-4

6,26194E-29

2,53366E-3

5,58442E-1

5,81542E-5

9,99996E2

1,31367E0

6,04927E-23

7,55768E-17

9,99997E1

2,64123E-17

2,72637E-5

1,95408E-4

9,93637E-30

2,22466E-20

8,67891E-4

1,71068E-13

1,09231E-7

4.2

copasi

2,43743E0

1,05800E-28

9,71016E-15

5,00000E1

6,83624E-28

1,12903E-9

5,60258E-9

3,37073E0

3,06805E0

6,32630E-13

9,41033E-12

9,27809E-11

6,00000E1

9,05536E-14

1,12377E0

6,65784E-4

6,29824E-29

2,53366E-3

5,58442E-1

5,81542E-5

9,99996E2

1,31367E0

6,06214E-23

7,55913E-17

9,99997E1

3,81483E-14

2,72636E-5

1,95407E-4

9,97637E-30

2,22630E-20

8,67889E-4

1,76270E-13

1,09231E-7

4.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,43743E0

1,05261E-28

1,12435E-14

5,00000E1

6,79234E-28

1,12892E-9

5,60248E-9

3,37073E0

3,06805E0

6,14585E-13

9,40743E-12

9,27744E-11

6,00000E1

4,04997E-14

1,12377E0

6,65784E-4

6,25130E-29

2,53366E-3

5,58442E-1

5,81542E-5

9,99996E2

1,31367E0

6,04255E-23

7,55424E-17

9,99997E1

2,00407E-14

2,72636E-5

1,95407E-4

9,92118E-30

2,22310E-20

8,67889E-4

1,59287E-13

1,09231E-7

4.2

jsim

2,19987E0

2,72582E-22

1,52270E-14

4,99998E1

3,58250E-20

6,24826E-9

9,64465E-12

2,58674E-1

2,29663E0

2,95893E-15

1,54568E-13

5,10398E-11

6,00000E1

7,08749E-14

1,36631E-1

2,05804E-3

2,12236E-18

2,17507E-2

2,21434E0

3,51414E-2

9,99621E2

2,06323E0

1,37939E-16

3,16417E-14

9,96157E1

3,14268E-15

1,75874E-4

3,49125E-1

5,80009E-21

2,36076E-15

2,26344E-5

9,14864E-13

3,92069E-3

4.2

min

2,19987E0

1,05261E-28

9,71016E-15

4,99998E1

6,79234E-28

1,12434E-9

9,64465E-12

2,58674E-1

2,29663E0

2,95893E-15

1,54568E-13

5,10398E-11

6,00000E1

2,39771E-16

1,36631E-1

6,65426E-4

6,25130E-29

2,53261E-3

5,58090E-1

5,81541E-5

9,99621E2

1,31367E0

6,04255E-23

7,55424E-17

9,96157E1

2,64116E-17

2,72636E-5

1,95407E-4

9,92118E-30

2,22310E-20

2,26344E-5

1,59287E-13

1,09231E-7

4.2

max

2,43744E0

2,72582E-22

1,92277E-12

5,00000E1

3,58250E-20

6,24826E-9

5,60286E-9

3,37114E0

3,06895E0

8,56729E-11

9,65045E-12

9,50922E-11

6,00000E1

9,05536E-14

1,12377E0

2,05804E-3

2,12236E-18

2,17507E-2

2,21434E0

3,51414E-2

1,00000E3

2,06323E0

1,37939E-16

3,16417E-14

1,00000E2

8,73475E-11

1,75874E-4

3,49125E-1

5,80009E-21

2,36076E-15

8,70341E-4

9,14864E-13

3,92069E-3

4.2

mean

2,43743E0

1,05440E-28

9,96244E-15

5,00000E1

6,80487E-28

1,12901E-9

5,60248E-9

3,37073E0

3,06805E0

5,94884E-13

9,40973E-12

9,27748E-11

6,00000E1

2,53634E-16

1,12377E0

6,65784E-4

6,26359E-29

2,53366E-3

5,58442E-1

5,81542E-5

9,99996E2

1,31367E0

6,05004E-23

7,55836E-17

9,99997E1

3,13295E-17

2,72637E-5

1,95408E-4

9,93882E-30

2,22490E-20

8,67889E-4

1,71076E-13

1,09231E-7

4.2

relative error(%)

0,00

4.4

BioUML

2,38529E0

2,59044E-28

1,92114E-14

5,00000E1

1,71728E-27

1,68274E-9

9,16706E-9

3,26986E0

3,11486E0

1,08810E-12

1,62739E-11

1,60316E-10

6,00000E1

4,61448E-16

1,06569E0

7,59047E-4

1,66438E-28

2,96716E-3

6,10954E-1

6,97998E-5

9,99996E2

1,31960E0

1,23711E-22

1,38371E-16

9,99997E1

5,37378E-17

3,56993E-5

2,41505E-4

2,56751E-29

4,30678E-20

1,07917E-3

3,12179E-13

1,43041E-7

4.4

ByoDyn

2,38529E0

2,59044E-28

1,92114E-14

5,00000E1

1,71728E-27

1,68274E-9

9,16706E-9

3,26986E0

3,11486E0

1,08810E-12

1,62739E-11

1,60316E-10

6,00000E1

4,61448E-16

1,06569E0

7,59047E-4

1,66438E-28

2,96716E-3

6,10954E-1

6,97998E-5

9,99996E2

1,31960E0

1,23711E-22

1,38371E-16

9,99997E1

5,37378E-17

3,56993E-5

2,41505E-4

2,56751E-29

4,30678E-20

1,07917E-3

3,12179E-13

1,43041E-7

4.4

MathSBML

2,38529E0

2,59018E-28

1,92111E-14

5,00000E1

1,71720E-27

1,68274E-9

9,16699E-9

3,26986E0

3,11486E0

1,08808E-12

1,62737E-11

1,60314E-10

6,00000E1

4,61440E-16

1,06569E0

7,59047E-4

1,66431E-28

2,96716E-3

6,10954E-1

6,97998E-5

9,99996E2

1,31960E0

1,23709E-22

1,38369E-16

9,99997E1

5,37368E-17

3,56993E-5

2,41505E-4

2,56719E-29

4,30670E-20

1,07917E-3

3,12174E-13

1,43041E-7

4.4

Oscill8 Core

2,91863E-28

2,88882E-12

5,00000E1

1,97469E-27

9,16762E-9

3,26986E0

3,11486E0

9,17520E-11

1,62845E-11

1,60328E-10

6,00000E1

1,06569E0

7,59049E-4

1,95398E-28

2,96718E-3

6,10954E-1

9,99996E2

1,31960E0

1,31720E-22

1,38873E-16

9,99997E1

9,29926E-11

2,41507E-4

2,93118E-29

4,37894E-20

1,07918E-3

1,43043E-7

4.4

SBToolbox2

2,38470E0

3,05374E-28

2,11244E-14

5,00000E1

2,05099E-27

1,67447E-9

9,13496E-9

3,27020E0

3,11573E0

1,14722E-12

1,65860E-11

1,63301E-10

6,00000E1

5,06264E-16

1,06503E0

7,58664E-4

2,00434E-28

2,96586E-3

6,10633E-1

6,98371E-5

1,00000E3

1,31971E0

1,44410E-22

1,45993E-16

1,00000E2

6,23170E-17

3,59708E-5

2,41919E-4

3,02938E-29

4,75464E-20

1,08168E-3

3,28474E-13

1,44128E-7

4.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,38530E0

2,59103E-28

1,92136E-14

5,00000E1

1,71769E-27

1,68280E-9

9,16762E-9

3,26986E0

3,11486E0

1,08820E-12

1,62751E-11

1,60328E-10

6,00000E1

4,61500E-16

1,06569E0

7,59048E-4

1,66482E-28

2,96718E-3

6,10954E-1

6,98002E-5

9,99996E2

1,31960E0

1,23728E-22

1,38384E-16

9,99997E1

5,37451E-17

3,56999E-5

2,41507E-4

2,56815E-29

4,30728E-20

1,07918E-3

3,12209E-13

1,43043E-7

4.4

VCell

2,38529E0

2,59051E-28

1,92117E-14

5,00000E1

1,71733E-27

1,68275E-9

9,16712E-9

3,26986E0

3,11486E0

1,08811E-12

1,62740E-11

1,60317E-10

6,00000E1

4,61456E-16

1,06569E0

7,59047E-4

1,66443E-28

2,96717E-3

6,10954E-1

6,97999E-5

9,99996E2

1,31960E0

1,23714E-22

1,38373E-16

9,99997E1

5,37389E-17

3,56995E-5

2,41505E-4

2,56758E-29

4,30685E-20

1,07917E-3

3,12183E-13

1,43041E-7

4.4

copasi

2,38529E0

2,59722E-28

1,94526E-14

5,00000E1

1,72261E-27

1,68277E-9

9,16719E-9

3,26986E0

3,11486E0

1,13212E-12

1,62751E-11

1,60325E-10

6,00000E1

2,25206E-13

1,06569E0

7,59047E-4

1,67051E-28

2,96716E-3

6,10954E-1

6,97998E-5

9,99996E2

1,31960E0

1,23885E-22

1,38393E-16

9,99997E1

4,44098E-14

3,56993E-5

2,41505E-4

2,57515E-29

4,30894E-20

1,07917E-3

3,12655E-13

1,43041E-7

4.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,38529E0

2,58765E-28

2,06832E-14

5,00000E1

1,71529E-27

1,68265E-9

9,16707E-9

3,26986E0

3,11486E0

1,10935E-12

1,62712E-11

1,60317E-10

6,00000E1

-2,58832E-15

1,06569E0

7,59047E-4

1,66236E-28

2,96716E-3

6,10954E-1

6,97998E-5

9,99996E2

1,31960E0

1,23609E-22

1,38326E-16

9,99997E1

2,16346E-14

3,56993E-5

2,41505E-4

2,56466E-29

4,30450E-20

1,07917E-3

2,99061E-13

1,43041E-7

4.4

jsim

2,13119E0

3,78608E-22

1,85186E-14

4,99998E1

5,20735E-20

7,13963E-9

1,04587E-11

2,35214E-1

2,22876E0

3,37333E-15

1,69510E-13

5,94372E-11

6,00000E1

8,99945E-14

1,27348E-1

2,10009E-3

3,34649E-18

2,23681E-2

2,25766E0

3,81840E-2

9,99587E2

2,00385E0

1,86821E-16

3,74338E-14

9,95797E1

4,20812E-15

1,93375E-4

3,82109E-1

8,65509E-21

2,99730E-15

2,34341E-5

1,07944E-12

4,33999E-3

4.4

min

2,13119E0

2,58765E-28

1,85186E-14

4,99998E1

1,71529E-27

1,67447E-9

1,04587E-11

2,35214E-1

2,22876E0

3,37333E-15

1,69510E-13

5,94372E-11

6,00000E1

-2,58832E-15

1,27348E-1

7,58664E-4

1,66236E-28

2,96586E-3

6,10633E-1

6,97998E-5

9,99587E2

1,31960E0

1,23609E-22

1,38326E-16

9,95797E1

5,37368E-17

3,56993E-5

2,41505E-4

2,56466E-29

4,30450E-20

2,34341E-5

2,99061E-13

1,43041E-7

4.4

max

2,38530E0

3,78608E-22

2,88882E-12

5,00000E1

5,20735E-20

7,13963E-9

9,16762E-9

3,27020E0

3,11573E0

9,17520E-11

1,65860E-11

1,63301E-10

6,00000E1

2,25206E-13

1,06569E0

2,10009E-3

3,34649E-18

2,23681E-2

2,25766E0

3,81840E-2

1,00000E3

2,00385E0

1,86821E-16

3,74338E-14

1,00000E2

9,29926E-11

1,93375E-4

3,82109E-1

8,65509E-21

2,99730E-15

1,08168E-3

1,07944E-12

4,33999E-3

4.4

mean

2,38529E0

2,59103E-28

1,92136E-14

5,00000E1

1,71769E-27

1,68274E-9

9,16707E-9

3,26986E0

3,11486E0

1,08820E-12

1,62740E-11

1,60317E-10

6,00000E1

4,61478E-16

1,06569E0

7,59047E-4

1,66482E-28

2,96716E-3

6,10954E-1

6,97998E-5

9,99996E2

1,31960E0

1,23728E-22

1,38384E-16

9,99997E1

6,23170E-17

3,56994E-5

2,41505E-4

2,56815E-29

4,30728E-20

1,07917E-3

3,12196E-13

1,43041E-7

4.4

relative error(%)

0,00

4.6

BioUML

2,33736E0

6,06991E-28

3,57713E-14

5,00000E1

4,12343E-27

2,44910E-9

1,45834E-8

3,17046E0

3,15584E0

1,92613E-12

2,72994E-11

2,68698E-10

6,00000E1

8,57361E-16

1,01258E0

8,58147E-4

4,19786E-28

3,43888E-3

6,63495E-1

8,28678E-5

9,99995E2

1,32478E0

2,43712E-22

2,45158E-16

9,99996E1

1,05317E-16

4,60368E-5

2,94643E-4

6,31111E-29

8,04990E-20

1,32474E-3

5,51274E-13

1,84477E-7

4.6

ByoDyn

2,33736E0

6,06991E-28

3,57713E-14

5,00000E1

4,12343E-27

2,44910E-9

1,45834E-8

3,17046E0

3,15584E0

1,92613E-12

2,72994E-11

2,68698E-10

6,00000E1

8,57361E-16

1,01258E0

8,58147E-4

4,19786E-28

3,43888E-3

6,63495E-1

8,28678E-5

9,99995E2

1,32478E0

2,43712E-22

2,45158E-16

9,99996E1

1,05317E-16

4,60368E-5

2,94643E-4

6,31111E-29

8,04990E-20

1,32474E-3

5,51274E-13

1,84477E-7

4.6

MathSBML

2,33736E0

6,07013E-28

3,57714E-14

5,00000E1

4,12356E-27

2,44910E-9

1,45833E-8

3,17046E0

3,15584E0

1,92613E-12

2,72994E-11

2,68697E-10

6,00000E1

8,57363E-16

1,01258E0

8,58147E-4

4,19808E-28

3,43889E-3

6,63495E-1

8,28678E-5

9,99995E2

1,32478E0

2,43715E-22

2,45158E-16

9,99996E1

1,05318E-16

4,60368E-5

2,94643E-4

6,31135E-29

8,04993E-20

1,32474E-3

5,51273E-13

1,84477E-7

4.6

Oscill8 Core

6,53664E-28

3,88774E-12

5,00000E1

4,49551E-27

1,45841E-8

3,17046E0

3,15584E0

9,78960E-11

2,73113E-11

2,68716E-10

6,00000E1

1,01258E0

8,58148E-4

4,63633E-28

3,43890E-3

6,63495E-1

9,99995E2

1,32478E0

2,53267E-22

2,45716E-16

9,99996E1

9,83304E-11

2,94645E-4

6,85346E-29

8,13265E-20

1,32475E-3

1,84479E-7

4.6

SBToolbox2

2,33686E0

6,83023E-28

3,86223E-14

5,00000E1

4,68112E-27

2,43451E-9

1,44879E-8

3,17075E0

3,15663E0

2,00671E-12

2,76417E-11

2,71932E-10

6,00000E1

9,23822E-16

1,01195E0

8,57739E-4

4,75891E-28

3,43733E-3

6,63200E-1

8,29006E-5

9,99990E2

1,32491E0

2,77116E-22

2,55575E-16

1,00000E2

1,19038E-16

4,63408E-5

2,95044E-4

7,04943E-29

8,72301E-20

1,32733E-3

5,73294E-13

1,85701E-7

4.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,33736E0

6,07112E-28

3,57750E-14

5,00000E1

4,12432E-27

2,44919E-9

1,45842E-8

3,17046E0

3,15584E0

1,92630E-12

2,73013E-11

2,68717E-10

6,00000E1

8,57450E-16

1,01258E0

8,58149E-4

4,19888E-28

3,43890E-3

6,63495E-1

8,28683E-5

9,99995E2

1,32478E0

2,43743E-22

2,45179E-16

9,99996E1

1,05330E-16

4,60375E-5

2,94645E-4

6,31255E-29

8,05075E-20

1,32475E-3

5,51321E-13

1,84480E-7

4.6

VCell

2,33736E0

6,07005E-28

3,57718E-14

5,00000E1

4,12353E-27

2,44911E-9

1,45834E-8

3,17046E0

3,15584E0

1,92616E-12

2,72996E-11

2,68700E-10

6,00000E1

8,57374E-16

1,01258E0

8,58147E-4

4,19797E-28

3,43889E-3

6,63495E-1

8,28679E-5

9,99995E2

1,32478E0

2,43717E-22

2,45161E-16

9,99996E1

1,05319E-16

4,60369E-5

2,94643E-4

6,31126E-29

8,05003E-20

1,32475E-3

5,51280E-13

1,84477E-7

4.6

copasi

2,33736E0

6,07996E-28

3,65326E-14

5,00000E1

4,13136E-27

2,44912E-9

1,45835E-8

3,17046E0

3,15584E0

1,97159E-12

2,73007E-11

2,68708E-10

6,00000E1

-5,88025E-14

1,01258E0

8,58147E-4

4,20728E-28

3,43888E-3

6,63495E-1

8,28678E-5

9,99995E2

1,32478E0

2,43935E-22

2,45186E-16

9,99996E1

4,59190E-14

4,60368E-5

2,94643E-4

6,32285E-29

8,05258E-20

1,32474E-3

5,61261E-13

1,84477E-7

4.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,33736E0

6,06490E-28

3,74344E-14

5,00000E1

4,11980E-27

2,44902E-9

1,45834E-8

3,17046E0

3,15584E0

1,94720E-12

2,72963E-11

2,68699E-10

6,00000E1

1,01322E-15

1,01258E0

8,58147E-4

4,19402E-28

3,43889E-3

6,63495E-1

8,28678E-5

9,99995E2

1,32478E0

2,43555E-22

2,45099E-16

9,99996E1

2,15976E-14

4,60368E-5

2,94643E-4

6,30577E-29

8,04660E-20

1,32474E-3

5,38105E-13

1,84477E-7

4.6

jsim

2,06730E0

5,13425E-22

2,22183E-14

4,99998E1

7,38770E-20

8,07263E-9

1,12546E-11

2,15126E-1

2,16525E0

3,81401E-15

1,84282E-13

6,83794E-11

6,00000E1

1,12327E-13

1,19511E-1

2,13626E-3

5,11597E-18

2,29254E-2

2,29464E0

4,12117E-2

9,99552E2

1,94779E0

2,47811E-16

4,36997E-14

9,95435E1

5,52673E-15

2,11120E-4

4,15253E-1

1,25637E-20

3,74066E-15

2,41818E-5

1,25673E-12

4,77048E-3

4.6

min

2,06730E0

6,06490E-28

2,22183E-14

4,99998E1

4,11980E-27

2,43451E-9

1,12546E-11

2,15126E-1

2,16525E0

3,81401E-15

1,84282E-13

6,83794E-11

6,00000E1

-5,88025E-14

1,19511E-1

8,57739E-4

4,19402E-28

3,43733E-3

6,63200E-1

8,28678E-5

9,99552E2

1,32478E0

2,43555E-22

2,45099E-16

9,95435E1

1,05317E-16

4,60368E-5

2,94643E-4

6,30577E-29

8,04660E-20

2,41818E-5

5,38105E-13

1,84477E-7

4.6

max

2,33736E0

5,13425E-22

3,88774E-12

5,00000E1

7,38770E-20

8,07263E-9

1,45842E-8

3,17075E0

3,15663E0

9,78960E-11

2,76417E-11

2,71932E-10

6,00000E1

1,12327E-13

1,01258E0

2,13626E-3

5,11597E-18

2,29254E-2

2,29464E0

4,12117E-2

9,99995E2

1,94779E0

2,47811E-16

4,36997E-14

1,00000E2

9,83304E-11

2,11120E-4

4,15253E-1

1,25637E-20

3,74066E-15

1,32733E-3

1,25673E-12

4,77048E-3

4.6

mean

2,33736E0

6,07112E-28

3,57750E-14

5,00000E1

4,12432E-27

2,44911E-9

1,45834E-8

3,17046E0

3,15584E0

1,92630E-12

2,72996E-11

2,68700E-10

6,00000E1

8,57412E-16

1,01258E0

8,58147E-4

4,19888E-28

3,43889E-3

6,63495E-1

8,28679E-5

9,99995E2

1,32478E0

2,43743E-22

2,45179E-16

9,99996E1

1,19038E-16

4,60369E-5

2,94643E-4

6,31255E-29

8,05075E-20

1,32474E-3

5,51300E-13

1,84477E-7

4.6

relative error(%)

0,00

4.8

BioUML

2,29313E0

1,36203E-27

6,45082E-14

4,99999E1

9,46103E-27

3,48852E-9

2,26150E-8

3,07282E0

3,19167E0

3,30930E-12

4,45427E-11

4,38034E-10

6,00000E1

1,54277E-15

9,63846E-1

9,62879E-4

1,00945E-27

3,94840E-3

7,15822E-1

9,74142E-5

9,99994E2

1,32929E0

4,64041E-22

4,21581E-16

9,99995E1

1,99484E-16

5,85501E-5

3,55285E-4

1,48232E-28

1,45729E-19

1,60737E-3

9,44826E-13

2,34640E-7

4.8

ByoDyn

2,29313E0

1,36203E-27

6,45082E-14

4,99999E1

9,46103E-27

3,48852E-9

2,26150E-8

3,07282E0

3,19167E0

3,30930E-12

4,45427E-11

4,38034E-10

6,00000E1

1,54277E-15

9,63846E-1

9,62879E-4

1,00945E-27

3,94840E-3

7,15822E-1

9,74142E-5

9,99994E2

1,32929E0

4,64041E-22

4,21581E-16

9,99995E1

1,99484E-16

5,85501E-5

3,55285E-4

1,48232E-28

1,45729E-19

1,60737E-3

9,44826E-13

2,34640E-7

4.8

MathSBML

2,29313E0

1,36175E-27

6,45058E-14

4,99999E1

9,46018E-27

3,48851E-9

2,26148E-8

3,07282E0

3,19167E0

3,30921E-12

4,45419E-11

4,38026E-10

6,00000E1

1,54271E-15

9,63846E-1

9,62879E-4

1,00936E-27

3,94840E-3

7,15822E-1

9,74142E-5

9,99994E2

1,32929E0

4,64020E-22

4,21570E-16

9,99995E1

1,99475E-16

5,85501E-5

3,55285E-4

1,48195E-28

1,45724E-19

1,60737E-3

9,44801E-13

2,34640E-7

4.8

Oscill8 Core

1,42733E-27

4,92015E-12

4,99999E1

9,98926E-27

2,26161E-8

3,07282E0

3,19167E0

1,04314E-10

4,45560E-11

4,38061E-10

6,00000E1

9,63847E-1

9,62881E-4

1,07451E-27

3,94841E-3

7,15822E-1

9,99994E2

1,32929E0

4,75365E-22

4,22202E-16

9,99995E1

1,03368E-10

3,55288E-4

1,56171E-28

1,46675E-19

1,60738E-3

2,34643E-7

4.8

SBToolbox2

2,29261E0

1,58863E-27

7,02714E-14

5,00000E1

1,11758E-26

3,47510E-9

2,25752E-8

3,07310E0

3,19248E0

3,47436E-12

4,53904E-11

4,46135E-10

6,00000E1

1,67687E-15

9,63193E-1

9,62422E-4

1,20356E-27

3,94648E-3

7,15537E-1

9,74463E-5

9,99990E2

1,32940E0

5,33565E-22

4,42917E-16

1,00000E2

2,27869E-16

5,89268E-5

3,55720E-4

1,73343E-28

1,59378E-19

1,61035E-3

9,89976E-13

2,36155E-7

4.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,29314E0

1,36227E-27

6,45142E-14

4,99999E1

9,46287E-27

3,48862E-9

2,26161E-8

3,07282E0

3,19167E0

3,30956E-12

4,45455E-11

4,38062E-10

6,00000E1

1,54291E-15

9,63847E-1

9,62881E-4

1,00967E-27

3,94841E-3

7,15822E-1

9,74146E-5

9,99994E2

1,32929E0

4,64094E-22

4,21614E-16

9,99995E1

1,99506E-16

5,85508E-5

3,55288E-4

1,48263E-28

1,45743E-19

1,60738E-3

9,44899E-13

2,34643E-7

4.8

VCell

2,29313E0

1,36206E-27

6,45090E-14

4,99999E1

9,46123E-27

3,48853E-9

2,26151E-8

3,07282E0

3,19167E0

3,30933E-12

4,45430E-11

4,38037E-10

6,00000E1

1,54279E-15

9,63846E-1

9,62879E-4

1,00947E-27

3,94840E-3

7,15822E-1

9,74143E-5

9,99994E2

1,32929E0

4,64049E-22

4,21585E-16

9,99995E1

1,99487E-16

5,85502E-5

3,55286E-4

1,48235E-28

1,45731E-19

1,60737E-3

9,44834E-13

2,34640E-7

4.8

copasi

2,29313E0

1,36358E-27

6,57614E-14

4,99999E1

9,47335E-27

3,48854E-9

2,26152E-8

3,07282E0

3,19167E0

3,35266E-12

4,45443E-11

4,38047E-10

6,00000E1

-1,05396E-13

9,63846E-1

9,62879E-4

1,01097E-27

3,94840E-3

7,15822E-1

9,74142E-5

9,99994E2

1,32929E0

4,64333E-22

4,21620E-16

9,99995E1

4,38784E-14

5,85501E-5

3,55285E-4

1,48421E-28

1,45765E-19

1,60737E-3

9,43846E-13

2,34640E-7

4.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,29313E0

1,36115E-27

6,63479E-14

4,99999E1

9,45454E-27

3,48844E-9

2,26150E-8

3,07282E0

3,19167E0

3,32890E-12

4,45390E-11

4,38036E-10

6,00000E1

-1,36802E-13

9,63846E-1

9,62879E-4

1,00874E-27

3,94840E-3

7,15822E-1

9,74142E-5

9,99994E2

1,32929E0

4,63806E-22

4,21505E-16

9,99995E1

2,03195E-14

5,85501E-5

3,55285E-4

1,48134E-28

1,45683E-19

1,60737E-3

9,28412E-13

2,34640E-7

4.8

jsim

2,00771E0

6,81630E-22

2,63459E-14

4,99998E1

1,02579E-19

9,04322E-9

1,20321E-11

1,97888E-1

2,10591E0

4,28238E-15

1,98862E-13

7,78323E-11

6,00000E1

1,38086E-13

1,12837E-1

2,16721E-3

7,60788E-18

2,34288E-2

2,32600E0

4,42141E-2

9,99517E2

1,89487E0

3,22667E-16

5,04227E-14

9,95073E1

7,13467E-15

2,29054E-4

4,48440E-1

1,77939E-20

4,59795E-15

2,48827E-5

1,44612E-12

5,21107E-3

4.8

min

2,00771E0

1,36115E-27

2,63459E-14

4,99998E1

9,45454E-27

3,47510E-9

1,20321E-11

1,97888E-1

2,10591E0

4,28238E-15

1,98862E-13

7,78323E-11

6,00000E1

-1,36802E-13

1,12837E-1

9,62422E-4

1,00874E-27

3,94648E-3

7,15537E-1

9,74142E-5

9,99517E2

1,32929E0

4,63806E-22

4,21505E-16

9,95073E1

1,99475E-16

5,85501E-5

3,55285E-4

1,48134E-28

1,45683E-19

2,48827E-5

9,28412E-13

2,34640E-7

4.8

max

2,29314E0

6,81630E-22

4,92015E-12

5,00000E1

1,02579E-19

9,04322E-9

2,26161E-8

3,07310E0

3,19248E0

1,04314E-10

4,53904E-11

4,46135E-10

6,00000E1

1,38086E-13

9,63847E-1

2,16721E-3

7,60788E-18

2,34288E-2

2,32600E0

4,42141E-2

9,99994E2

1,89487E0

3,22667E-16

5,04227E-14

1,00000E2

1,03368E-10

2,29054E-4

4,48440E-1

1,77939E-20

4,59795E-15

1,61035E-3

1,44612E-12

5,21107E-3

4.8

mean

2,29313E0

1,36227E-27

6,45142E-14

4,99999E1

9,46287E-27

3,48853E-9

2,26150E-8

3,07282E0

3,19167E0

3,30956E-12

4,45430E-11

4,38037E-10

6,00000E1

1,54278E-15

9,63846E-1

9,62879E-4

1,00967E-27

3,94840E-3

7,15822E-1

9,74142E-5

9,99994E2

1,32929E0

4,64094E-22

4,21614E-16

9,99995E1

2,27869E-16

5,85502E-5

3,55286E-4

1,48263E-28

1,45743E-19

1,60737E-3

9,44830E-13

2,34640E-7

4.8

relative error(%)

0,00

5.0

BioUML

2,25218E0

2,93780E-27

1,12981E-13

4,99999E1

2,08263E-26

4,87268E-9

3,42642E-8

2,97718E0

3,22298E0

5,53291E-12

7,08636E-11

6,96257E-10

6,00000E1

2,69612E-15

9,18999E-1

1,07303E-3

2,32395E-27

4,49511E-3

7,67722E-1

1,13488E-4

9,99993E2

1,33318E0

8,56489E-22

7,05481E-16

9,99995E1

3,66260E-16

7,35291E-5

4,23869E-4

3,33983E-28

2,56229E-19

1,92976E-3

1,57577E-12

2,94694E-7

5.0

ByoDyn

2,25218E0

2,93780E-27

1,12981E-13

4,99999E1

2,08263E-26

4,87268E-9

3,42642E-8

2,97718E0

3,22298E0

5,53291E-12

7,08636E-11

6,96257E-10

6,00000E1

2,69612E-15

9,18999E-1

1,07303E-3

2,32395E-27

4,49511E-3

7,67722E-1

1,13488E-4

9,99993E2

1,33318E0

8,56489E-22

7,05481E-16

9,99995E1

3,66260E-16

7,35291E-5

4,23869E-4

3,33983E-28

2,56229E-19

1,92976E-3

1,57577E-12

2,94694E-7

5.0

MathSBML

2,25218E0

2,93670E-27

1,12976E-13

4,99999E1

2,08238E-26

4,87266E-9

3,42637E-8

2,97718E0

3,22298E0

5,53271E-12

7,08620E-11

6,96241E-10

6,00000E1

2,69599E-15

9,18999E-1

1,07303E-3

2,32364E-27

4,49511E-3

7,67722E-1

1,13488E-4

9,99993E2

1,33318E0

8,56434E-22

7,05455E-16

9,99995E1

3,66237E-16

7,35291E-5

4,23869E-4

3,33851E-28

2,56216E-19

1,92976E-3

1,57571E-12

2,94693E-7

5.0

Oscill8 Core

3,02782E-27

5,98965E-12

4,99999E1

2,15641E-26

3,42657E-8

2,97718E0

3,22298E0

1,11318E-10

7,08787E-11

6,96296E-10

6,00000E1

9,19001E-1

1,07303E-3

2,41872E-27

4,49512E-3

7,67722E-1

9,99993E2

1,33318E0

8,69831E-22

7,06173E-16

9,99995E1

1,08122E-10

4,23872E-4

3,45409E-28

2,57305E-19

1,92978E-3

2,94697E-7

5.0

SBToolbox2

2,25170E0

3,22265E-27

1,20410E-13

5,00000E1

2,30070E-26

4,84100E-9

3,39910E-8

2,97745E0

3,22375E0

5,72225E-12

7,15255E-11

7,02435E-10

6,00000E1

2,86800E-15

9,18415E-1

1,07255E-3

2,55710E-27

4,49300E-3

7,67475E-1

1,13510E-4

9,99990E2

1,33330E0

9,54480E-22

7,30065E-16

9,99990E1

4,05865E-16

7,39255E-5

4,24260E-4

3,63055E-28

2,74010E-19

1,93265E-3

1,62695E-12

2,96285E-7

5.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,25218E0

2,93830E-27

1,12991E-13

4,99999E1

2,08299E-26

4,87281E-9

3,42657E-8

2,97718E0

3,22298E0

5,53330E-12

7,08676E-11

6,96296E-10

6,00000E1

2,69635E-15

9,19001E-1

1,07303E-3

2,32441E-27

4,49512E-3

7,67722E-1

1,13489E-4

9,99993E2

1,33318E0

8,56578E-22

7,05531E-16

9,99995E1

3,66297E-16

7,35300E-5

4,23872E-4

3,34045E-28

2,56251E-19

1,92978E-3

1,57588E-12

2,94697E-7

5.0

VCell

2,25218E0

2,93785E-27

1,12983E-13

4,99999E1

2,08267E-26

4,87269E-9

3,42643E-8

2,97718E0

3,22298E0

5,53295E-12

7,08640E-11

6,96261E-10

6,00000E1

2,69615E-15

9,19000E-1

1,07303E-3

2,32399E-27

4,49511E-3

7,67722E-1

1,13488E-4

9,99993E2

1,33318E0

8,56502E-22

7,05487E-16

9,99995E1

3,66265E-16

7,35293E-5

4,23870E-4

3,33989E-28

2,56232E-19

1,92977E-3

1,57578E-12

2,94694E-7

5.0

copasi

2,25218E0

2,94053E-27

1,14674E-13

4,99999E1

2,08487E-26

4,87270E-9

3,42647E-8

2,97718E0

3,22298E0

5,57111E-12

7,08665E-11

6,96285E-10

6,00000E1

-1,03071E-14

9,19000E-1

1,07303E-3

2,32687E-27

4,49511E-3

7,67722E-1

1,13488E-4

9,99993E2

1,33318E0

8,56926E-22

7,05551E-16

9,99995E1

3,86680E-14

7,35291E-5

4,23869E-4

3,34336E-28

2,56286E-19

1,92976E-3

1,57243E-12

2,94694E-7

5.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,25218E0

2,93629E-27

1,14953E-13

4,99999E1

2,08150E-26

4,87261E-9

3,42642E-8

2,97718E0

3,22298E0

5,54803E-12

7,08594E-11

6,96259E-10

6,00000E1

-1,13480E-13

9,19000E-1

1,07303E-3

2,32265E-27

4,49511E-3

7,67722E-1

1,13488E-4

9,99993E2

1,33318E0

8,56148E-22

7,05385E-16

9,99995E1

1,61184E-14

7,35291E-5

4,23869E-4

3,33809E-28

2,56166E-19

1,92976E-3

1,56193E-12

2,94694E-7

5.0

jsim

1,95201E0

8,88011E-22

3,09225E-14

4,99998E1

1,39724E-19

1,00476E-8

1,27913E-11

1,83058E-1

2,05051E0

4,77999E-15

2,13240E-13

8,77627E-11

6,00000E1

1,67474E-13

1,07104E-1

2,19353E-3

1,10363E-17

2,38836E-2

2,35238E0

4,71822E-2

9,99483E2

1,84491E0

4,13207E-16

5,75861E-14

9,94712E1

9,06982E-15

2,47127E-4

4,81568E-1

2,46521E-20

5,57579E-15

2,55417E-5

1,64703E-12

5,66077E-3

5.0

min

1,95201E0

2,93629E-27

3,09225E-14

4,99998E1

2,08150E-26

4,84100E-9

1,27913E-11

1,83058E-1

2,05051E0

4,77999E-15

2,13240E-13

8,77627E-11

6,00000E1

-1,13480E-13

1,07104E-1

1,07255E-3

2,32265E-27

4,49300E-3

7,67475E-1

1,13488E-4

9,99483E2

1,33318E0

8,56148E-22

7,05385E-16

9,94712E1

3,66237E-16

7,35291E-5

4,23869E-4

3,33809E-28

2,56166E-19

2,55417E-5

1,56193E-12

2,94693E-7

5.0

max

2,25218E0

8,88011E-22

5,98965E-12

5,00000E1

1,39724E-19

1,00476E-8

3,42657E-8

2,97745E0

3,22375E0

1,11318E-10

7,15255E-11

7,02435E-10

6,00000E1

1,67474E-13

9,19001E-1

2,19353E-3

1,10363E-17

2,38836E-2

2,35238E0

4,71822E-2

9,99993E2

1,84491E0

4,13207E-16

5,75861E-14

9,99995E1

1,08122E-10

2,47127E-4

4,81568E-1

2,46521E-20

5,57579E-15

1,93265E-3

1,64703E-12

5,66077E-3

5.0

mean

2,25218E0

2,93830E-27

1,12991E-13

4,99999E1

2,08299E-26

4,87268E-9

3,42642E-8

2,97718E0

3,22298E0

5,53330E-12

7,08640E-11

6,96261E-10

6,00000E1

2,69614E-15

9,19000E-1

1,07303E-3

2,32441E-27

4,49511E-3

7,67722E-1

1,13488E-4

9,99993E2

1,33318E0

8,56578E-22

7,05531E-16

9,99995E1

4,05865E-16

7,35292E-5

4,23870E-4

3,34045E-28

2,56251E-19

1,92976E-3

1,57577E-12

2,94694E-7

5.0

relative error(%)

0,00

5.2

BioUML

2,21413E0

6,11108E-27

1,92651E-13

4,99999E1

4,41371E-26

6,68545E-9

5,08227E-8

2,88373E0

3,25032E0

9,02267E-12

1,10161E-10

1,08139E-9

6,00000E1

4,58714E-15

8,77613E-1

1,18838E-3

5,14088E-27

5,07825E-3

8,19016E-1

1,31133E-4

9,99992E2

1,33652E0

1,53638E-21

1,15148E-15

9,99994E1

6,53529E-16

9,12786E-5

5,00800E-4

7,24349E-28

4,38625E-19

2,29455E-3

2,56322E-12

3,65862E-7

5.2

ByoDyn

2,21413E0

6,11108E-27

1,92651E-13

4,99999E1

4,41371E-26

6,68545E-9

5,08227E-8

2,88373E0

3,25032E0

9,02267E-12

1,10161E-10

1,08139E-9

6,00000E1

4,58714E-15

8,77613E-1

1,18838E-3

5,14088E-27

5,07825E-3

8,19016E-1

1,31133E-4

9,99992E2

1,33652E0

1,53638E-21

1,15148E-15

9,99994E1

6,53529E-16

9,12786E-5

5,00800E-4

7,24349E-28

4,38625E-19

2,29455E-3

2,56322E-12

3,65862E-7

5.2

MathSBML

2,21413E0

6,11087E-27

1,92645E-13

4,99999E1

4,41336E-26

6,68543E-9

5,08222E-8

2,88373E0

3,25032E0

9,02245E-12

1,10159E-10

1,08138E-9

6,00000E1

4,58699E-15

8,77613E-1

1,18838E-3

5,14058E-27

5,07825E-3

8,19016E-1

1,31133E-4

9,99992E2

1,33652E0

1,53632E-21

1,15145E-15

9,99994E1

6,53505E-16

9,12785E-5

5,00800E-4

7,24286E-28

4,38611E-19

2,29455E-3

2,56316E-12

3,65862E-7

5.2

Oscill8 Core

6,23351E-27

7,10409E-12

4,99999E1

4,51524E-26

5,08247E-8

2,88373E0

3,25031E0

1,19346E-10

1,10178E-10

1,08145E-9

6,00000E1

8,77614E-1

1,18838E-3

5,27667E-27

5,07827E-3

8,19015E-1

9,99992E2

1,33652E0

1,55201E-21

1,15225E-15

9,99994E1

1,12604E-10

5,00803E-4

7,40541E-28

4,39847E-19

2,29457E-3

3,65866E-7

5.2

SBToolbox2

2,21364E0

7,04043E-27

2,08629E-13

5,00000E1

5,14387E-26

6,65734E-9

5,06998E-8

2,88394E0

3,25112E0

9,44726E-12

1,12166E-10

1,10047E-9

6,00000E1

4,95653E-15

8,77005E-1

1,18783E-3

6,04187E-27

5,07570E-3

8,18774E-1

1,31156E-4

9,99990E2

1,33665E0

1,74903E-21

1,20651E-15

9,99990E1

7,39099E-16

9,17821E-5

5,01234E-4

8,36289E-28

4,76880E-19

2,29801E-3

2,67851E-12

3,67887E-7

5.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,21413E0

6,11203E-27

1,92666E-13

4,99999E1

4,41440E-26

6,68563E-9

5,08247E-8

2,88373E0

3,25031E0

9,02325E-12

1,10167E-10

1,08145E-9

6,00000E1

4,58749E-15

8,77614E-1

1,18838E-3

5,14180E-27

5,07827E-3

8,19015E-1

1,31134E-4

9,99992E2

1,33652E0

1,53652E-21

1,15155E-15

9,99994E1

6,53589E-16

9,12795E-5

5,00803E-4

7,24470E-28

4,38659E-19

2,29457E-3

2,56338E-12

3,65866E-7

5.2

VCell

2,21413E0

6,11117E-27

1,92653E-13

4,99999E1

4,41378E-26

6,68547E-9

5,08229E-8

2,88373E0

3,25031E0

9,02274E-12

1,10162E-10

1,08140E-9

6,00000E1

4,58718E-15

8,77613E-1

1,18838E-3

5,14097E-27

5,07826E-3

8,19015E-1

1,31133E-4

9,99992E2

1,33652E0

1,53639E-21

1,15149E-15

9,99994E1

6,53537E-16

9,12788E-5

5,00801E-4

7,24360E-28

4,38629E-19

2,29455E-3

2,56324E-12

3,65863E-7

5.2

copasi

2,21413E0

6,11555E-27

1,94695E-13

4,99999E1

4,41805E-26

6,68546E-9

5,08232E-8

2,88373E0

3,25032E0

9,05715E-12

1,10165E-10

1,08143E-9

6,00000E1

-9,63568E-14

8,77613E-1

1,18838E-3

5,14710E-27

5,07825E-3

8,19016E-1

1,31133E-4

9,99992E2

1,33652E0

1,53702E-21

1,15158E-15

9,99994E1

3,49795E-14

9,12786E-5

5,00800E-4

7,24949E-28

4,38710E-19

2,29455E-3

2,55516E-12

3,65862E-7

5.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,21413E0

6,10858E-27

1,94692E-13

4,99999E1

4,41180E-26

6,68538E-9

5,08227E-8

2,88373E0

3,25032E0

9,03274E-12

1,10156E-10

1,08140E-9

6,00000E1

-1,20383E-13

8,77613E-1

1,18838E-3

5,13860E-27

5,07825E-3

8,19016E-1

1,31133E-4

9,99992E2

1,33652E0

1,53589E-21

1,15136E-15

9,99994E1

1,14686E-14

9,12786E-5

5,00800E-4

7,24047E-28

4,38541E-19

2,29455E-3

2,54090E-12

3,65862E-7

5.2

jsim

1,89985E0

1,13751E-21

3,59702E-14

4,99997E1

1,87068E-19

1,10822E-8

1,35328E-11

1,70263E-1

1,99881E0

5,30851E-15

2,27414E-13

9,81387E-11

6,00000E1

2,00678E-13

1,02140E-1

2,21575E-3

1,56556E-17

2,42951E-2

2,37437E0

5,01086E-2

9,99449E2

1,79771E0

5,21294E-16

6,51730E-14

9,94353E1

1,13717E-14

2,65296E-4

5,14548E-1

3,34831E-20

6,68034E-15

2,61631E-5

1,85888E-12

6,11872E-3

5.2

min

1,89985E0

6,10858E-27

3,59702E-14

4,99997E1

4,41180E-26

6,65734E-9

1,35328E-11

1,70263E-1

1,99881E0

5,30851E-15

2,27414E-13

9,81387E-11

6,00000E1

-1,20383E-13

1,02140E-1

1,18783E-3

5,13860E-27

5,07570E-3

8,18774E-1

1,31133E-4

9,99449E2

1,33652E0

1,53589E-21

1,15136E-15

9,94353E1

6,53505E-16

9,12785E-5

5,00800E-4

7,24047E-28

4,38541E-19

2,61631E-5

1,85888E-12

3,65862E-7

5.2

max

2,21413E0

1,13751E-21

7,10409E-12

5,00000E1

1,87068E-19

1,10822E-8

5,08247E-8

2,88394E0

3,25112E0

1,19346E-10

1,12166E-10

1,10047E-9

6,00000E1

2,00678E-13

8,77614E-1

2,21575E-3

1,56556E-17

2,42951E-2

2,37437E0

5,01086E-2

9,99992E2

1,79771E0

5,21294E-16

6,51730E-14

9,99994E1

1,12604E-10

2,65296E-4

5,14548E-1

3,34831E-20

6,68034E-15

2,29801E-3

2,67851E-12

6,11872E-3

5.2

mean

2,21413E0

6,11203E-27

1,92666E-13

4,99999E1

4,41440E-26

6,68546E-9

5,08227E-8

2,88373E0

3,25032E0

9,02325E-12

1,10162E-10

1,08140E-9

6,00000E1

4,58716E-15

8,77613E-1

1,18838E-3

5,14180E-27

5,07825E-3

8,19016E-1

1,31133E-4

9,99992E2

1,33652E0

1,53652E-21

1,15155E-15

9,99994E1

7,39099E-16

9,12787E-5

5,00801E-4

7,24470E-28

4,38659E-19

2,29455E-3

2,56319E-12

3,65863E-7

5.2

relative error(%)

0,00

5.4

BioUML

2,17867E0

1,22954E-26

3,20513E-13

4,99999E1

9,03349E-26

9,02374E-9

7,39297E-8

2,79258E0

3,27417E0

1,43801E-11

1,67655E-10

1,64428E-9

6,00000E1

7,61455E-15

8,39317E-1

1,30871E-3

1,09628E-26

5,69696E-3

8,69550E-1

1,50387E-4

9,99991E2

1,33935E0

2,68457E-21

1,83685E-15

9,99993E1

1,13587E-15

1,12116E-4

5,86452E-4

1,51682E-27

7,32621E-19

2,70429E-3

4,07488E-12

4,49423E-7

5.4

ByoDyn

2,17867E0

1,22954E-26

3,20513E-13

4,99999E1

9,03349E-26

9,02374E-9

7,39297E-8

2,79258E0

3,27417E0

1,43801E-11

1,67655E-10

1,64428E-9

6,00000E1

7,61455E-15

8,39317E-1

1,30871E-3

1,09628E-26

5,69696E-3

8,69550E-1

1,50387E-4

9,99991E2

1,33935E0

2,68457E-21

1,83685E-15

9,99993E1

1,13587E-15

1,12116E-4

5,86452E-4

1,51682E-27

7,32621E-19

2,70429E-3

4,07488E-12

4,49423E-7

5.4

MathSBML

2,17867E0

1,22961E-26

3,20512E-13

4,99999E1

9,03387E-26

9,02374E-9

7,39295E-8

2,79258E0

3,27417E0

1,43801E-11

1,67655E-10

1,64428E-9

6,00000E1

7,61451E-15

8,39317E-1

1,30871E-3

1,09638E-26

5,69696E-3

8,69550E-1

1,50387E-4

9,99991E2

1,33935E0

2,68458E-21

1,83684E-15

9,99993E1

1,13587E-15

1,12116E-4

5,86452E-4

1,51680E-27

7,32618E-19

2,70429E-3

4,07486E-12

4,49423E-7

5.4

Oscill8 Core

1,24599E-26

8,27715E-12

4,99999E1

9,17134E-26

7,39323E-8

2,79258E0

3,27417E0

1,29013E-10

1,67675E-10

1,64436E-9

6,00000E1

8,39318E-1

1,30871E-3

1,11544E-26

5,69697E-3

8,69550E-1

9,99991E2

1,33935E0

2,70281E-21

1,83772E-15

9,99993E1

1,16826E-10

5,86455E-4

1,53945E-27

7,34006E-19

2,70431E-3

4,49427E-7

5.4

SBToolbox2

2,17822E0

1,32501E-26

3,39646E-13

5,00000E1

9,78789E-26

8,95979E-9

7,32469E-8

2,79273E0

3,27491E0

1,48301E-11

1,68988E-10

1,65656E-9

6,00000E1

8,05412E-15

8,38774E-1

1,30821E-3

1,17882E-26

5,69427E-3

8,69345E-1

1,50400E-4

9,99990E2

1,33945E0

2,96192E-21

1,89549E-15

9,99990E1

1,24637E-15

1,12635E-4

5,86825E-4

1,61488E-27

7,78918E-19

2,70758E-3

4,19539E-12

4,51504E-7

5.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,17867E0

1,22969E-26

3,20535E-13

4,99999E1

9,03479E-26

9,02394E-9

7,39324E-8

2,79258E0

3,27417E0

1,43810E-11

1,67663E-10

1,64436E-9

6,00000E1

7,61507E-15

8,39318E-1

1,30871E-3

1,09645E-26

5,69697E-3

8,69550E-1

1,50387E-4

9,99991E2

1,33935E0

2,68480E-21

1,83696E-15

9,99993E1

1,13596E-15

1,12117E-4

5,86455E-4

1,51706E-27

7,32673E-19

2,70431E-3

4,07512E-12

4,49427E-7

5.4

VCell

2,17867E0

1,22956E-26

3,20516E-13

4,99999E1

9,03361E-26

9,02376E-9

7,39299E-8

2,79258E0

3,27417E0

1,43802E-11

1,67656E-10

1,64429E-9

6,00000E1

7,61461E-15

8,39317E-1

1,30871E-3

1,09629E-26

5,69696E-3

8,69550E-1

1,50387E-4

9,99991E2

1,33935E0

2,68460E-21

1,83686E-15

9,99993E1

1,13588E-15

1,12117E-4

5,86453E-4

1,51684E-27

7,32627E-19

2,70430E-3

4,07491E-12

4,49424E-7

5.4

copasi

2,17867E0

1,23037E-26

3,22873E-13

4,99999E1

9,04139E-26

9,02376E-9

7,39304E-8

2,79258E0

3,27417E0

1,44125E-11

1,67661E-10

1,64434E-9

6,00000E1

-4,04651E-14

8,39317E-1

1,30871E-3

1,09747E-26

5,69696E-3

8,69550E-1

1,50387E-4

9,99991E2

1,33935E0

2,68557E-21

1,83701E-15

9,99993E1

3,28332E-14

1,12116E-4

5,86452E-4

1,51800E-27

7,32755E-19

2,70429E-3

4,07423E-12

4,49423E-7

5.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,17867E0

1,22914E-26

3,22557E-13

4,99999E1

9,03037E-26

9,02370E-9

7,39298E-8

2,79258E0

3,27417E0

1,43843E-11

1,67650E-10

1,64429E-9

6,00000E1

-1,34029E-13

8,39317E-1

1,30871E-3

1,09589E-26

5,69696E-3

8,69550E-1

1,50387E-4

9,99991E2

1,33935E0

2,68390E-21

1,83671E-15

9,99993E1

6,18680E-15

1,12116E-4

5,86452E-4

1,51632E-27

7,32512E-19

2,70429E-3

4,04728E-12

4,49423E-7

5.4

jsim

1,85092E0

1,43518E-21

4,15128E-14

4,99997E1

2,46591E-19

1,21437E-8

1,42574E-11

1,59190E-1

1,95055E0

5,86966E-15

2,41389E-13

1,08930E-10

6,00000E1

2,37872E-13

9,78051E-2

2,23434E-3

2,17629E-17

2,46677E-2

2,39248E0

5,29867E-2

9,99415E2

1,75311E0

6,48823E-16

7,31669E-14

9,93997E1

1,40812E-14

2,83523E-4

5,47303E-1

4,46702E-20

7,91732E-15

2,67509E-5

2,08111E-12

6,58410E-3

5.4

min

1,85092E0

1,22914E-26

4,15128E-14

4,99997E1

9,03037E-26

8,95979E-9

1,42574E-11

1,59190E-1

1,95055E0

5,86966E-15

2,41389E-13

1,08930E-10

6,00000E1

-1,34029E-13

9,78051E-2

1,30821E-3

1,09589E-26

5,69427E-3

8,69345E-1

1,50387E-4

9,99415E2

1,33935E0

2,68390E-21

1,83671E-15

9,93997E1

1,13587E-15

1,12116E-4

5,86452E-4

1,51632E-27

7,32512E-19

2,67509E-5

2,08111E-12

4,49423E-7

5.4

max

2,17867E0

1,43518E-21

8,27715E-12

5,00000E1

2,46591E-19

1,21437E-8

7,39324E-8

2,79273E0

3,27491E0

1,29013E-10

1,68988E-10

1,65656E-9

6,00000E1

2,37872E-13

8,39318E-1

2,23434E-3

2,17629E-17

2,46677E-2

2,39248E0

5,29867E-2

9,99991E2

1,75311E0

6,48823E-16

7,31669E-14

9,99993E1

1,16826E-10

2,83523E-4

5,47303E-1

4,46702E-20

7,91732E-15

2,70758E-3

4,19539E-12

6,58410E-3

5.4

mean

2,17867E0

1,22969E-26

3,20535E-13

4,99999E1

9,03479E-26

9,02375E-9

7,39298E-8

2,79258E0

3,27417E0

1,43810E-11

1,67656E-10

1,64429E-9

6,00000E1

7,61458E-15

8,39317E-1

1,30871E-3

1,09645E-26

5,69696E-3

8,69550E-1

1,50387E-4

9,99991E2

1,33935E0

2,68480E-21

1,83696E-15

9,99993E1

1,24637E-15

1,12116E-4

5,86453E-4

1,51706E-27

7,32673E-19

2,70429E-3

4,07487E-12

4,49424E-7

5.4

relative error(%)

0,00

5.6

BioUML

2,14552E0

2,39895E-26

5,21270E-13

4,99999E1

1,79045E-25

1,19982E-8

1,05634E-7

2,70383E0

3,29498E0

2,24398E-11

2,50221E-10

2,45177E-9

6,00000E1

1,23561E-14

8,03791E-1

1,43379E-3

2,26005E-26

6,35025E-3

9,19198E-1

1,71279E-4

9,99990E2

1,34173E0

4,57865E-21

2,86895E-15

9,99991E1

1,92691E-15

1,36372E-4

6,81165E-4

3,07510E-27

1,19624E-18

3,16146E-3

6,34253E-12

5,46701E-7

5.6

ByoDyn

2,14552E0

2,39895E-26

5,21270E-13

4,99999E1

1,79045E-25

1,19982E-8

1,05634E-7

2,70383E0

3,29498E0

2,24398E-11

2,50221E-10

2,45177E-9

6,00000E1

1,23561E-14

8,03791E-1

1,43379E-3

2,26005E-26

6,35025E-3

9,19198E-1

1,71279E-4

9,99990E2

1,34173E0

4,57865E-21

2,86895E-15

9,99991E1

1,92691E-15

1,36372E-4

6,81165E-4

3,07510E-27

1,19624E-18

3,16146E-3

6,34253E-12

5,46701E-7

5.6

MathSBML

2,14552E0

2,39864E-26

5,21274E-13

4,99999E1

1,79067E-25

1,19982E-8

1,05634E-7

2,70383E0

3,29498E0

2,24399E-11

2,50221E-10

2,45178E-9

6,00000E1

1,23562E-14

8,03791E-1

1,43379E-3

2,26041E-26

6,35025E-3

9,19198E-1

1,71279E-4

9,99990E2

1,34173E0

4,57877E-21

2,86896E-15

9,99991E1

1,92695E-15

1,36372E-4

6,81165E-4

3,07503E-27

1,19625E-18

3,16146E-3

6,34255E-12

5,46701E-7

5.6

Oscill8 Core

2,42080E-26

9,53047E-12

4,99999E1

1,80894E-25

1,05638E-7

2,70383E0

3,29498E0

1,41162E-10

2,50243E-10

2,45187E-9

6,00000E1

8,03791E-1

1,43379E-3

2,28671E-26

6,35026E-3

9,19198E-1

9,99990E2

1,34173E0

4,59984E-21

2,86991E-15

9,99991E1

1,20797E-10

6,81168E-4

3,10631E-27

1,19781E-18

3,16147E-3

5,46706E-7

5.6

SBToolbox2

2,14510E0

2,72561E-26

5,61512E-13

5,00000E1

2,05436E-25

1,19329E-8

1,05133E-7

2,70396E0

3,29574E0

2,34184E-11

2,54164E-10

2,48901E-9

6,00000E1

1,32799E-14

8,03233E-1

1,43322E-3

2,60844E-26

6,34704E-3

9,19002E-1

1,71290E-4

9,99990E2

1,34184E0

5,16995E-21

2,99620E-15

9,99990E1

2,16134E-15

1,37021E-4

6,81571E-4

3,49466E-27

1,29371E-18

3,16530E-3

6,60566E-12

5,49309E-7

5.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,14552E0

2,39927E-26

5,21302E-13

4,99999E1

1,79068E-25

1,19985E-8

1,05638E-7

2,70383E0

3,29498E0

2,24410E-11

2,50231E-10

2,45188E-9

6,00000E1

1,23568E-14

8,03791E-1

1,43379E-3

2,26038E-26

6,35026E-3

9,19198E-1

1,71280E-4

9,99990E2

1,34173E0

4,57901E-21

2,86910E-15

9,99991E1

1,92705E-15

1,36373E-4

6,81168E-4

3,07552E-27

1,19632E-18

3,16148E-3

6,34286E-12

5,46706E-7

5.6

VCell

2,14552E0

2,39898E-26

5,21273E-13

4,99999E1

1,79047E-25

1,19983E-8

1,05635E-7

2,70383E0

3,29498E0

2,24400E-11

2,50222E-10

2,45178E-9

6,00000E1

1,23562E-14

8,03791E-1

1,43379E-3

2,26007E-26

6,35025E-3

9,19198E-1

1,71280E-4

9,99990E2

1,34173E0

4,57870E-21

2,86896E-15

9,99991E1

1,92693E-15

1,36373E-4

6,81166E-4

3,07514E-27

1,19625E-18

3,16146E-3

6,34256E-12

5,46702E-7

5.6

copasi

2,14552E0

2,40053E-26

5,23931E-13

4,99999E1

1,79193E-25

1,19982E-8

1,05636E-7

2,70383E0

3,29498E0

2,24719E-11

2,50229E-10

2,45186E-9

6,00000E1

-8,86475E-15

8,03791E-1

1,43379E-3

2,26240E-26

6,35025E-3

9,19198E-1

1,71279E-4

9,99990E2

1,34173E0

4,58025E-21

2,86920E-15

9,99991E1

3,26247E-14

1,36372E-4

6,81165E-4

3,07745E-27

1,19646E-18

3,16146E-3

6,34406E-12

5,46701E-7

5.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,14552E0

2,39843E-26

5,23247E-13

4,99999E1

1,79004E-25

1,19982E-8

1,05634E-7

2,70383E0

3,29498E0

2,24382E-11

2,50214E-10

2,45178E-9

6,00000E1

-9,19484E-14

8,03791E-1

1,43379E-3

2,25957E-26

6,35025E-3

9,19198E-1

1,71279E-4

9,99990E2

1,34173E0

4,57778E-21

2,86878E-15

9,99991E1

1,26771E-15

1,36372E-4

6,81165E-4

3,07447E-27

1,19611E-18

3,16146E-3

6,31928E-12

5,46701E-7

5.6

jsim

1,80492E0

1,78618E-21

4,75752E-14

4,99997E1

3,20503E-19

1,32292E-8

1,49662E-11

1,49575E-1

1,90550E0

6,46515E-15

2,55174E-13

1,20108E-10

6,00000E1

2,79217E-13

9,39902E-2

2,24973E-3

2,97011E-17

2,50053E-2

2,40716E0

5,58115E-2

9,99381E2

1,71093E0

7,97711E-16

8,15523E-14

9,93644E1

1,72407E-14

3,01776E-4

5,79768E-1

5,86347E-20

9,29202E-15

2,73086E-5

2,31318E-12

7,05622E-3

5.6

min

1,80492E0

2,39843E-26

4,75752E-14

4,99997E1

1,79004E-25

1,19329E-8

1,49662E-11

1,49575E-1

1,90550E0

6,46515E-15

2,55174E-13

1,20108E-10

6,00000E1

-9,19484E-14

9,39902E-2

1,43322E-3

2,25957E-26

6,34704E-3

9,19002E-1

1,71279E-4

9,99381E2

1,34173E0

4,57778E-21

2,86878E-15

9,93644E1

1,26771E-15

1,36372E-4

6,81165E-4

3,07447E-27

1,19611E-18

2,73086E-5

2,31318E-12

5,46701E-7

5.6

max

2,14552E0

1,78618E-21

9,53047E-12

5,00000E1

3,20503E-19

1,32292E-8

1,05638E-7

2,70396E0

3,29574E0

1,41162E-10

2,54164E-10

2,48901E-9

6,00000E1

2,79217E-13

8,03791E-1

2,24973E-3

2,97011E-17

2,50053E-2

2,40716E0

5,58115E-2

9,99990E2

1,71093E0

7,97711E-16

8,15523E-14

9,99991E1

1,20797E-10

3,01776E-4

5,79768E-1

5,86347E-20

9,29202E-15

3,16530E-3

6,60566E-12

7,05622E-3

5.6

mean

2,14552E0

2,39927E-26

5,21302E-13

4,99999E1

1,79068E-25

1,19982E-8

1,05634E-7

2,70383E0

3,29498E0

2,24400E-11

2,50222E-10

2,45178E-9

6,00000E1

1,23562E-14

8,03791E-1

1,43379E-3

2,26041E-26

6,35025E-3

9,19198E-1

1,71280E-4

9,99990E2

1,34173E0

4,57901E-21

2,86910E-15

9,99991E1

1,92705E-15

1,36372E-4

6,81166E-4

3,07552E-27

1,19632E-18

3,16146E-3

6,34256E-12

5,46702E-7

5.6

relative error(%)

0,00

5.8

BioUML

2,11444E0

4,54942E-26

8,30164E-13

4,99998E1

3,44497E-25

1,57340E-8

1,48465E-7

2,61755E0

3,31314E0

3,43401E-11

3,66773E-10

3,59044E-9

6,00000E1

1,96333E-14

7,70755E-1

1,56341E-3

4,51584E-26

7,03705E-3

9,67856E-1

1,93838E-4

9,99988E2

1,34369E0

7,63609E-21

4,39439E-15

9,99990E1

3,19632E-15

1,64387E-4

7,85246E-4

6,05023E-27

1,91273E-18

3,66842E-3

9,68112E-12

6,59067E-7

5.8

ByoDyn

2,11444E0

4,54942E-26

8,30164E-13

4,99998E1

3,44497E-25

1,57340E-8

1,48465E-7

2,61755E0

3,31314E0

3,43401E-11

3,66773E-10

3,59044E-9

6,00000E1

1,96333E-14

7,70755E-1

1,56341E-3

4,51584E-26

7,03705E-3

9,67856E-1

1,93838E-4

9,99988E2

1,34369E0

7,63609E-21

4,39439E-15

9,99990E1

3,19632E-15

1,64387E-4

7,85246E-4

6,05023E-27

1,91273E-18

3,66842E-3

9,68112E-12

6,59067E-7

5.8

MathSBML

2,11444E0

4,55008E-26

8,30170E-13

4,99998E1

3,44519E-25

1,57340E-8

1,48465E-7

2,61755E0

3,31314E0

3,43402E-11

3,66773E-10

3,59044E-9

6,00000E1

1,96334E-14

7,70755E-1

1,56341E-3

4,51629E-26

7,03705E-3

9,67856E-1

1,93838E-4

9,99988E2

1,34369E0

7,63624E-21

4,39440E-15

9,99990E1

3,19638E-15

1,64387E-4

7,85246E-4

6,05123E-27

1,91275E-18

3,66842E-3

9,68114E-12

6,59067E-7

5.8

Oscill8 Core

4,57816E-26

1,08965E-11

4,99998E1

3,46950E-25

1,48469E-7

2,61755E0

3,31314E0

1,56942E-10

3,66799E-10

3,59057E-9

6,00000E1

7,70756E-1

1,56341E-3

4,55248E-26

7,03706E-3

9,67856E-1

9,99988E2

1,34369E0

7,66060E-21

4,39547E-15

9,99990E1

1,24526E-10

7,85249E-4

6,09277E-27

1,91450E-18

3,66844E-3

6,59072E-7

5.8

SBToolbox2

2,11397E0

5,01766E-26

8,87822E-13

5,00000E1

3,82739E-25

1,56364E-8

1,47454E-7

2,61764E0

3,31384E0

3,56670E-11

3,71385E-10

3,63348E-9

6,00000E1

2,09519E-14

7,70212E-1

1,56277E-3

5,00333E-26

7,03358E-3

9,67682E-1

1,93841E-4

9,99990E2

1,34380E0

8,52690E-21

4,56729E-15

9,99990E1

3,54689E-15

1,65110E-4

7,85625E-4

6,62196E-27

2,05338E-18

3,67241E-3

1,00353E-11

6,61980E-7

5.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,11444E0

4,54993E-26

8,30212E-13

4,99998E1

3,44537E-25

1,57343E-8

1,48469E-7

2,61755E0

3,31314E0

3,43418E-11

3,66786E-10

3,59057E-9

6,00000E1

1,96344E-14

7,70756E-1

1,56341E-3

4,51644E-26

7,03706E-3

9,67856E-1

1,93838E-4

9,99988E2

1,34369E0

7,63662E-21

4,39459E-15

9,99990E1

3,19654E-15

1,64388E-4

7,85249E-4

6,05099E-27

1,91284E-18

3,66844E-3

9,68157E-12

6,59072E-7

5.8

VCell

2,11444E0

4,54947E-26

8,30169E-13

4,99998E1

3,44501E-25

1,57340E-8

1,48465E-7

2,61755E0

3,31314E0

3,43403E-11

3,66774E-10

3,59045E-9

6,00000E1

1,96334E-14

7,70755E-1

1,56341E-3

4,51589E-26

7,03705E-3

9,67856E-1

1,93838E-4

9,99988E2

1,34369E0

7,63615E-21

4,39441E-15

9,99990E1

3,19635E-15

1,64387E-4

7,85246E-4

6,05029E-27

1,91274E-18

3,66843E-3

9,68116E-12

6,59068E-7

5.8

copasi

2,11444E0

4,55284E-26

8,33145E-13

4,99998E1

3,44862E-25

1,57340E-8

1,48467E-7

2,61755E0

3,31314E0

3,43729E-11

3,66788E-10

3,59059E-9

6,00000E1

9,86056E-14

7,70755E-1

1,56341E-3

4,52205E-26

7,03705E-3

9,67856E-1

1,93838E-4

9,99988E2

1,34369E0

7,63909E-21

4,39485E-15

9,99990E1

3,29770E-14

1,64387E-4

7,85246E-4

6,05571E-27

1,91314E-18

3,66842E-3

9,67474E-12

6,59067E-7

5.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,11444E0

4,54874E-26

8,32029E-13

4,99998E1

3,44447E-25

1,57340E-8

1,48465E-7

2,61755E0

3,31314E0

3,43363E-11

3,66766E-10

3,59044E-9

6,00000E1

-3,98592E-14

7,70755E-1

1,56341E-3

4,51533E-26

7,03705E-3

9,67856E-1

1,93838E-4

9,99988E2

1,34369E0

7,63502E-21

4,39420E-15

9,99990E1

4,05736E-16

1,64387E-4

7,85246E-4

6,04947E-27

1,91257E-18

3,66842E-3

9,65558E-12

6,59067E-7

5.8

jsim

1,76163E0

2,19571E-21

5,41836E-14

4,99997E1

4,11249E-19

1,43357E-8

1,56602E-11

1,41197E-1

1,86342E0

7,09667E-15

2,68782E-13

1,31647E-10

6,00000E1

3,24863E-13

9,06073E-2

2,26229E-3

3,98601E-17

2,53117E-2

2,41884E0

5,85785E-2

9,99347E2

1,67102E0

9,69879E-16

9,03139E-14

9,93295E1

2,08936E-14

3,20025E-4

6,11885E-1

7,58352E-20

1,08093E-14

2,78392E-5

2,55457E-12

7,53444E-3

5.8

min

1,76163E0

4,54874E-26

5,41836E-14

4,99997E1

3,44447E-25

1,43357E-8

1,56602E-11

1,41197E-1

1,86342E0

7,09667E-15

2,68782E-13

1,31647E-10

6,00000E1

-3,98592E-14

9,06073E-2

1,56277E-3

4,51533E-26

7,03358E-3

9,67682E-1

1,93838E-4

9,99347E2

1,34369E0

7,63502E-21

4,39420E-15

9,93295E1

4,05736E-16

1,64387E-4

7,85246E-4

6,04947E-27

1,91257E-18

2,78392E-5

2,55457E-12

6,59067E-7

5.8

max

2,11444E0

2,19571E-21

1,08965E-11

5,00000E1

4,11249E-19

1,57343E-8

1,48469E-7

2,61764E0

3,31384E0

1,56942E-10

3,71385E-10

3,63348E-9

6,00000E1

3,24863E-13

7,70756E-1

2,26229E-3

3,98601E-17

2,53117E-2

2,41884E0

5,85785E-2

9,99990E2

1,67102E0

9,69879E-16

9,03139E-14

9,99990E1

1,24526E-10

3,20025E-4

6,11885E-1

7,58352E-20

1,08093E-14

3,67241E-3

1,00353E-11

7,53444E-3

5.8

mean

2,11444E0

4,55008E-26

8,30212E-13

4,99998E1

3,44537E-25

1,57340E-8

1,48465E-7

2,61755E0

3,31314E0

3,43403E-11

3,66774E-10

3,59045E-9

6,00000E1

1,96339E-14

7,70755E-1

1,56341E-3

4,51644E-26

7,03705E-3

9,67856E-1

1,93838E-4

9,99988E2

1,34369E0

7,63662E-21

4,39459E-15

9,99990E1

3,19654E-15

1,64387E-4

7,85246E-4

6,05123E-27

1,91284E-18

3,66842E-3

9,68113E-12

6,59068E-7

5.8

relative error(%)

0,00

6.0

BioUML

2,08523E0

8,40322E-26

1,29663E-12

4,99998E1

6,44878E-25

2,03711E-8

2,05502E-7

2,53378E0

3,32897E0

5,16101E-11

5,28717E-10

5,17084E-9

6,00000E1

3,05947E-14

7,39966E-1

1,69734E-3

8,76552E-26

7,75627E-3

1,01544E0

2,18081E-4

9,99987E2

1,34527E0

1,24732E-20

6,61036E-15

9,99989E1

5,19281E-15

1,96510E-4

8,98968E-4

1,15773E-26

2,99949E-18

4,22746E-3

1,45121E-11

7,87925E-7

6.0

ByoDyn

2,08523E0

8,40322E-26

1,29663E-12

4,99998E1

6,44878E-25

2,03711E-8

2,05502E-7

2,53378E0

3,32897E0

5,16101E-11

5,28717E-10

5,17084E-9

6,00000E1

3,05947E-14

7,39966E-1

1,69734E-3

8,76552E-26

7,75627E-3

1,01544E0

2,18081E-4

9,99987E2

1,34527E0

1,24732E-20

6,61036E-15

9,99989E1

5,19281E-15

1,96510E-4

8,98968E-4

1,15773E-26

2,99949E-18

4,22746E-3

1,45121E-11

7,87925E-7

6.0

MathSBML

2,08523E0

8,40362E-26

1,29663E-12

4,99998E1

6,44908E-25

2,03711E-8

2,05502E-7

2,53378E0

3,32897E0

5,16102E-11

5,28717E-10

5,17084E-9

6,00000E1

3,05948E-14

7,39966E-1

1,69734E-3

8,76610E-26

7,75626E-3

1,01544E0

2,18081E-4

9,99987E2

1,34527E0

1,24734E-20

6,61037E-15

9,99989E1

5,19288E-15

1,96510E-4

8,98968E-4

1,15781E-26

2,99951E-18

4,22746E-3

1,45121E-11

7,87925E-7

6.0

Oscill8 Core

8,44065E-26

1,24220E-11

4,99998E1

6,48098E-25

2,05508E-7

2,53378E0

3,32897E0

1,77897E-10

5,28748E-10

5,17101E-9

6,00000E1

7,39967E-1

1,69734E-3

8,81528E-26

7,75627E-3

1,01544E0

9,99987E2

1,34527E0

1,25015E-20

6,61158E-15

9,99989E1

1,28029E-10

8,98971E-4

1,16347E-26

3,00149E-18

4,22748E-3

7,87931E-7

6.0

SBToolbox2

2,08484E0

9,19912E-26

1,38002E-12

5,00000E1

7,10520E-25

2,02132E-8

2,03524E-7

2,53382E0

3,32962E0

5,33990E-11

5,33686E-10

5,21636E-9

6,00000E1

3,24912E-14

7,39474E-1

1,69672E-3

9,62760E-26

7,75258E-3

1,01532E0

2,18074E-4

9,99990E2

1,34534E0

1,38438E-20

6,84418E-15

9,99990E1

5,72734E-15

1,97292E-4

8,99290E-4

1,25772E-26

3,20454E-18

4,23146E-3

1,49850E-11

7,91062E-7

6.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,08523E0

8,40400E-26

1,29669E-12

4,99998E1

6,44947E-25

2,03715E-8

2,05508E-7

2,53378E0

3,32897E0

5,16123E-11

5,28735E-10

5,17101E-9

6,00000E1

3,05962E-14

7,39967E-1

1,69734E-3

8,76656E-26

7,75627E-3

1,01544E0

2,18082E-4

9,99987E2

1,34527E0

1,24740E-20

6,61064E-15

9,99989E1

5,19313E-15

1,96512E-4

8,98971E-4

1,15787E-26

2,99965E-18

4,22748E-3

1,45127E-11

7,87931E-7

6.0

VCell

2,08523E0

8,40329E-26

1,29663E-12

4,99998E1

6,44884E-25

2,03712E-8

2,05503E-7

2,53378E0

3,32897E0

5,16103E-11

5,28718E-10

5,17086E-9

6,00000E1

3,05948E-14

7,39966E-1

1,69734E-3

8,76560E-26

7,75627E-3

1,01544E0

2,18082E-4

9,99987E2

1,34527E0

1,24733E-20

6,61039E-15

9,99989E1

5,19285E-15

1,96511E-4

8,98969E-4

1,15775E-26

2,99951E-18

4,22746E-3

1,45121E-11

7,87926E-7

6.0

copasi

2,08523E0

8,40562E-26

1,29986E-12

4,99998E1

6,45398E-25

2,03711E-8

2,05504E-7

2,53378E0

3,32897E0

5,16413E-11

5,28731E-10

5,17098E-9

6,00000E1

4,03710E-14

7,39966E-1

1,69734E-3

8,77497E-26

7,75627E-3

1,01544E0

2,18081E-4

9,99987E2

1,34527E0

1,24769E-20

6,61084E-15

9,99989E1

3,32031E-14

1,96510E-4

8,98968E-4

1,15804E-26

2,99996E-18

4,22746E-3

1,44952E-11

7,87925E-7

6.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,08523E0

8,40228E-26

1,29837E-12

4,99998E1

6,44809E-25

2,03711E-8

2,05503E-7

2,53378E0

3,32897E0

5,16047E-11

5,28710E-10

5,17085E-9

6,00000E1

-8,77537E-14

7,39966E-1

1,69734E-3

8,76485E-26

7,75627E-3

1,01544E0

2,18081E-4

9,99987E2

1,34527E0

1,24719E-20

6,61015E-15

9,99989E1

9,68514E-16

1,96510E-4

8,98968E-4

1,15763E-26

2,99931E-18

4,22746E-3

1,44828E-11

7,87925E-7

6.0

jsim

1,72081E0

2,66902E-21

6,13655E-14

4,99997E1

5,21518E-19

1,54609E-8

1,63406E-11

1,33869E-1

1,82409E0

7,76588E-15

2,82226E-13

1,43522E-10

6,00000E1

3,74947E-13

8,75859E-2

2,27236E-3

5,26788E-17

2,55900E-2

2,42786E0

6,12842E-2

9,99314E2

1,63323E0

1,16725E-15

9,94377E-14

9,92951E1

2,50846E-14

3,38245E-4

6,43608E-1

9,67660E-20

1,24736E-14

2,83456E-5

2,80482E-12

8,01819E-3

6.0

min

1,72081E0

8,40228E-26

6,13655E-14

4,99997E1

6,44809E-25

1,54609E-8

1,63406E-11

1,33869E-1

1,82409E0

7,76588E-15

2,82226E-13

1,43522E-10

6,00000E1

-8,77537E-14

8,75859E-2

1,69672E-3

8,76485E-26

7,75258E-3

1,01532E0

2,18074E-4

9,99314E2

1,34527E0

1,24719E-20

6,61015E-15

9,92951E1

9,68514E-16

1,96510E-4

8,98968E-4

1,15763E-26

2,99931E-18

2,83456E-5

2,80482E-12

7,87925E-7

6.0

max

2,08523E0

2,66902E-21

1,24220E-11

5,00000E1

5,21518E-19

2,03715E-8

2,05508E-7

2,53382E0

3,32962E0

1,77897E-10

5,33686E-10

5,21636E-9

6,00000E1

3,74947E-13

7,39967E-1

2,27236E-3

5,26788E-17

2,55900E-2

2,42786E0

6,12842E-2

9,99990E2

1,63323E0

1,16725E-15

9,94377E-14

9,99990E1

1,28029E-10

3,38245E-4

6,43608E-1

9,67660E-20

1,24736E-14

4,23146E-3

1,49850E-11

8,01819E-3

6.0

mean

2,08523E0

8,40400E-26

1,29669E-12

4,99998E1

6,44947E-25

2,03711E-8

2,05503E-7

2,53378E0

3,32897E0

5,16103E-11

5,28718E-10

5,17086E-9

6,00000E1

3,05955E-14

7,39966E-1

1,69734E-3

8,76656E-26

7,75627E-3

1,01544E0

2,18081E-4

9,99987E2

1,34527E0

1,24740E-20

6,61064E-15

9,99989E1

5,19313E-15

1,96510E-4

8,98969E-4

1,15787E-26

2,99965E-18

4,22746E-3

1,45121E-11

7,87926E-7

6.0

relative error(%)

0,00

6.2

BioUML

2,05771E0

1,51459E-25

1,98890E-12

4,99998E1

1,17677E-24

2,60650E-8

2,80460E-7

2,45253E0

3,34277E0

7,62743E-11

7,50457E-10

7,33240E-9

6,00000E1

4,68207E-14

7,11209E-1

1,83536E-3

1,65625E-25

8,50673E-3

1,06188E0

2,44026E-4

9,99985E2

1,34650E0

1,99846E-20

9,77831E-15

9,99987E1

8,27464E-15

2,33100E-4

1,02257E-3

2,15882E-26

4,61954E-18

4,84075E-3

2,13911E-11

9,34716E-7

6.2

ByoDyn

2,05771E0

1,51459E-25

1,98890E-12

4,99998E1

1,17677E-24

2,60650E-8

2,80460E-7

2,45253E0

3,34277E0

7,62743E-11

7,50457E-10

7,33240E-9

6,00000E1

4,68207E-14

7,11209E-1

1,83536E-3

1,65625E-25

8,50673E-3

1,06188E0

2,44026E-4

9,99985E2

1,34650E0

1,99846E-20

9,77831E-15

9,99987E1

8,27464E-15

2,33100E-4

1,02257E-3

2,15882E-26

4,61954E-18

4,84075E-3

2,13911E-11

9,34716E-7

6.2

MathSBML

2,05771E0

1,51464E-25

1,98891E-12

4,99998E1

1,17681E-24

2,60650E-8

2,80460E-7

2,45253E0

3,34277E0

7,62744E-11

7,50457E-10

7,33240E-9

6,00000E1

4,68209E-14

7,11209E-1

1,83536E-3

1,65632E-25

8,50673E-3

1,06188E0

2,44026E-4

9,99985E2

1,34650E0

1,99848E-20

9,77832E-15

9,99987E1

8,27473E-15

2,33100E-4

1,02257E-3

2,15890E-26

4,61957E-18

4,84075E-3

2,13912E-11

9,34716E-7

6.2

Oscill8 Core

1,51943E-25

1,41731E-11

4,99998E1

1,18096E-24

2,80467E-7

2,45253E0

3,34277E0

2,06058E-10

7,50493E-10

7,33262E-9

6,00000E1

7,11209E-1

1,83537E-3

1,66294E-25

8,50674E-3

1,06188E0

9,99985E2

1,34650E0

2,00171E-20

9,77969E-15

9,99987E1

1,31313E-10

1,02257E-3

2,16647E-26

4,62180E-18

4,84077E-3

9,34721E-7

6.2

SBToolbox2

2,05731E0

1,74159E-25

2,15538E-12

5,00000E1

1,36646E-24

2,59173E-8

2,79236E-7

2,45248E0

3,34347E0

7,99531E-11

7,63951E-10

7,45882E-9

6,00000E1

5,06047E-14

7,10668E-1

1,83466E-3

1,93611E-25

8,50225E-3

1,06177E0

2,44009E-4

9,99990E2

1,34660E0

2,27581E-20

1,02586E-14

9,99990E1

9,35080E-15

2,34105E-4

1,02293E-3

2,48555E-26

5,02959E-18

4,84560E-3

2,23678E-11

9,38747E-7

6.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,05771E0

1,51473E-25

1,98900E-12

4,99998E1

1,17689E-24

2,60654E-8

2,80467E-7

2,45253E0

3,34277E0

7,62772E-11

7,50480E-10

7,33262E-9

6,00000E1

4,68229E-14

7,11209E-1

1,83537E-3

1,65643E-25

8,50674E-3

1,06188E0

2,44027E-4

9,99985E2

1,34650E0

1,99858E-20

9,77869E-15

9,99987E1

8,27511E-15

2,33101E-4

1,02257E-3

2,15904E-26

4,61976E-18

4,84077E-3

2,13919E-11

9,34721E-7

6.2

VCell

2,05771E0

1,51460E-25

1,98891E-12

4,99998E1

1,17678E-24

2,60651E-8

2,80461E-7

2,45253E0

3,34277E0

7,62746E-11

7,50459E-10

7,33242E-9

6,00000E1

4,68209E-14

7,11209E-1

1,83536E-3

1,65626E-25

8,50673E-3

1,06188E0

2,44026E-4

9,99985E2

1,34650E0

1,99847E-20

9,77834E-15

9,99987E1

8,27469E-15

2,33100E-4

1,02257E-3

2,15883E-26

4,61957E-18

4,84075E-3

2,13912E-11

9,34717E-7

6.2

copasi

2,05771E0

1,51482E-25

1,99239E-12

4,99998E1

1,17759E-24

2,60650E-8

2,80461E-7

2,45253E0

3,34277E0

7,63078E-11

7,50471E-10

7,33255E-9

6,00000E1

5,28042E-14

7,11209E-1

1,83536E-3

1,65780E-25

8,50673E-3

1,06188E0

2,44026E-4

9,99985E2

1,34650E0

1,99895E-20

9,77887E-15

9,99987E1

3,78957E-14

2,33100E-4

1,02257E-3

2,15894E-26

4,62013E-18

4,84075E-3

2,13880E-11

9,34716E-7

6.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,05771E0

1,51447E-25

1,99050E-12

4,99998E1

1,17668E-24

2,60650E-8

2,80460E-7

2,45253E0

3,34277E0

7,62655E-11

7,50449E-10

7,33242E-9

6,00000E1

-6,84756E-14

7,11209E-1

1,83536E-3

1,65617E-25

8,50673E-3

1,06188E0

2,44026E-4

9,99985E2

1,34650E0

1,99830E-20

9,77807E-15

9,99987E1

7,47629E-16

2,33100E-4

1,02257E-3

2,15869E-26

4,61932E-18

4,84075E-3

2,13650E-11

9,34716E-7

6.2

jsim

1,68228E0

3,21137E-21

6,91495E-14

4,99996E1

6,54241E-19

1,66022E-8

1,70085E-11

1,27435E-1

1,78729E0

8,47436E-15

2,95520E-13

1,55710E-10

6,00000E1

4,29597E-13

8,48690E-2

2,28024E-3

6,86457E-17

2,58431E-2

2,43455E0

6,39260E-2

9,99282E2

1,59741E0

1,39173E-15

1,08910E-13

9,92612E1

2,98591E-14

3,56414E-4

6,74895E-1

1,21956E-19

1,42892E-14

2,88302E-5

3,06348E-12

8,50696E-3

6.2

min

1,68228E0

1,51447E-25

6,91495E-14

4,99996E1

1,17668E-24

1,66022E-8

1,70085E-11

1,27435E-1

1,78729E0

8,47436E-15

2,95520E-13

1,55710E-10

6,00000E1

-6,84756E-14

8,48690E-2

1,83466E-3

1,65617E-25

8,50225E-3

1,06177E0

2,44009E-4

9,99282E2

1,34650E0

1,99830E-20

9,77807E-15

9,92612E1

7,47629E-16

2,33100E-4

1,02257E-3

2,15869E-26

4,61932E-18

2,88302E-5

3,06348E-12

9,34716E-7

6.2

max

2,05771E0

3,21137E-21

1,41731E-11

5,00000E1

6,54241E-19

2,60654E-8

2,80467E-7

2,45253E0

3,34347E0

2,06058E-10

7,63951E-10

7,45882E-9

6,00000E1

4,29597E-13

7,11209E-1

2,28024E-3

6,86457E-17

2,58431E-2

2,43455E0

6,39260E-2

9,99990E2

1,59741E0

1,39173E-15

1,08910E-13

9,99990E1

1,31313E-10

3,56414E-4

6,74895E-1

1,21956E-19

1,42892E-14

4,84560E-3

2,23678E-11

8,50696E-3

6.2

mean

2,05771E0

1,51473E-25

1,98900E-12

4,99998E1

1,17689E-24

2,60650E-8

2,80460E-7

2,45253E0

3,34277E0

7,62746E-11

7,50459E-10

7,33242E-9

6,00000E1

4,68219E-14

7,11209E-1

1,83536E-3

1,65643E-25

8,50673E-3

1,06188E0

2,44026E-4

9,99985E2

1,34650E0

1,99858E-20

9,77869E-15

9,99987E1

8,27511E-15

2,33100E-4

1,02257E-3

2,15894E-26

4,61976E-18

4,84075E-3

2,13911E-11

9,34717E-7

6.2

relative error(%)

0,00

6.4

BioUML

2,03172E0

2,66830E-25

2,99984E-12

4,99997E1

2,09701E-24

3,29869E-8

3,77768E-7

2,37380E0

3,35481E0

1,10978E-10

1,04997E-9

1,02488E-8

6,00000E1

7,04544E-14

6,84294E-1

1,97728E-3

3,05202E-25

9,28726E-3

1,10714E0

2,71683E-4

9,99984E2

1,34743E0

3,14479E-20

1,42403E-14

9,99986E1

1,29498E-14

2,74520E-4

1,15626E-3

3,92964E-26

6,99592E-18

5,51037E-3

3,10417E-11

1,10090E-6

6.4

ByoDyn

2,03172E0

2,66830E-25

2,99984E-12

4,99997E1

2,09701E-24

3,29869E-8

3,77768E-7

2,37380E0

3,35481E0

1,10978E-10

1,04997E-9

1,02488E-8

6,00000E1

7,04544E-14

6,84294E-1

1,97728E-3

3,05202E-25

9,28726E-3

1,10714E0

2,71683E-4

9,99984E2

1,34743E0

3,14479E-20

1,42403E-14

9,99986E1

1,29498E-14

2,74520E-4

1,15626E-3

3,92964E-26

6,99592E-18

5,51037E-3

3,10417E-11

1,10090E-6

6.4

MathSBML

2,03172E0

2,66845E-25

2,99987E-12

4,99997E1

2,09714E-24

3,29869E-8

3,77769E-7

2,37380E0

3,35481E0

1,10979E-10

1,04997E-9

1,02489E-8

6,00000E1

7,04552E-14

6,84294E-1

1,97728E-3

3,05227E-25

9,28726E-3

1,10714E0

2,71683E-4

9,99984E2

1,34743E0

3,14487E-20

1,42404E-14

9,99986E1

1,29501E-14

2,74520E-4

1,15626E-3

3,92992E-26

6,99601E-18

5,51037E-3

3,10419E-11

1,10090E-6

6.4

Oscill8 Core

2,67449E-25

1,62403E-11

4,99997E1

2,10241E-24

3,77776E-7

2,37381E0

3,35481E0

2,44084E-10

1,05001E-9

1,02491E-8

6,00000E1

6,84295E-1

1,97728E-3

3,06091E-25

9,28727E-3

1,10714E0

9,99984E2

1,34743E0

3,14851E-20

1,42419E-14

9,99986E1

1,34391E-10

1,15627E-3

3,93977E-26

6,99846E-18

5,51038E-3

1,10091E-6

6.4

SBToolbox2

2,03133E0

2,83038E-25

3,17394E-12

5,00000E1

2,23234E-24

3,27029E-8

3,73318E-7

2,37380E0

3,35542E0

1,14380E-10

1,05685E-9

1,03097E-8

6,00000E1

7,43855E-14

6,83822E-1

1,97659E-3

3,20201E-25

9,28286E-3

1,10703E0

2,71655E-4

9,99980E2

1,34754E0

3,45767E-20

1,46869E-14

9,99990E1

1,41530E-14

2,75502E-4

1,15652E-3

4,09396E-26

7,42960E-18

5,51480E-3

3,19285E-11

1,10487E-6

6.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,03172E0

2,66852E-25

2,99996E-12

4,99997E1

2,09719E-24

3,29873E-8

3,77776E-7

2,37381E0

3,35481E0

1,10982E-10

1,05000E-9

1,02491E-8

6,00000E1

7,04573E-14

6,84295E-1

1,97728E-3

3,05231E-25

9,28727E-3

1,10714E0

2,71683E-4

9,99984E2

1,34743E0

3,14495E-20

1,42408E-14

9,99986E1

1,29505E-14

2,74521E-4

1,15627E-3

3,93000E-26

6,99622E-18

5,51038E-3

3,10428E-11

1,10091E-6

6.4

VCell

2,03172E0

2,66832E-25

2,99985E-12

4,99997E1

2,09702E-24

3,29869E-8

3,77769E-7

2,37380E0

3,35481E0

1,10979E-10

1,04997E-9

1,02489E-8

6,00000E1

7,04547E-14

6,84295E-1

1,97728E-3

3,05204E-25

9,28726E-3

1,10714E0

2,71683E-4

9,99984E2

1,34743E0

3,14481E-20

1,42404E-14

9,99986E1

1,29499E-14

2,74520E-4

1,15626E-3

3,92967E-26

6,99595E-18

5,51037E-3

3,10418E-11

1,10091E-6

6.4

copasi

2,03172E0

2,66937E-25

3,00362E-12

4,99997E1

2,09827E-24

3,29869E-8

3,77769E-7

2,37380E0

3,35481E0

1,11012E-10

1,04998E-9

1,02490E-8

6,00000E1

1,41655E-13

6,84294E-1

1,97728E-3

3,05449E-25

9,28726E-3

1,10714E0

2,71683E-4

9,99984E2

1,34743E0

3,14551E-20

1,42410E-14

9,99986E1

4,12633E-14

2,74520E-4

1,15626E-3

3,93124E-26

6,99674E-18

5,51037E-3

3,10308E-11

1,10090E-6

6.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,03172E0

2,66814E-25

3,00125E-12

4,99997E1

2,09689E-24

3,29869E-8

3,77768E-7

2,37380E0

3,35481E0

1,10966E-10

1,04996E-9

1,02489E-8

6,00000E1

3,22025E-14

6,84294E-1

1,97728E-3

3,05192E-25

9,28726E-3

1,10714E0

2,71683E-4

9,99984E2

1,34743E0

3,14459E-20

1,42400E-14

9,99986E1

2,52975E-15

2,74520E-4

1,15626E-3

3,92948E-26

6,99566E-18

5,51037E-3

3,10124E-11

1,10090E-6

6.4

jsim

1,64585E0

3,82804E-21

7,75650E-14

4,99996E1

8,12594E-19

1,77577E-8

1,76651E-11

1,21763E-1

1,75283E0

9,22366E-15

3,08681E-13

1,68189E-10

6,00000E1

4,88932E-13

8,24104E-2

2,28618E-3

8,82997E-17

2,60735E-2

2,43920E0

6,65016E-2

9,99250E2

1,56344E0

1,64522E-15

1,18719E-13

9,92278E1

3,52638E-14

3,74514E-4

7,05713E-1

1,51967E-19

1,62597E-14

2,92953E-5

3,33013E-12

9,00029E-3

6.4

min

1,64585E0

2,66814E-25

7,75650E-14

4,99996E1

2,09689E-24

1,77577E-8

1,76651E-11

1,21763E-1

1,75283E0

9,22366E-15

3,08681E-13

1,68189E-10

6,00000E1

3,22025E-14

8,24104E-2

1,97659E-3

3,05192E-25

9,28286E-3

1,10703E0

2,71655E-4

9,99250E2

1,34743E0

3,14459E-20

1,42400E-14

9,92278E1

2,52975E-15

2,74520E-4

1,15626E-3

3,92948E-26

6,99566E-18

2,92953E-5

3,33013E-12

1,10090E-6

6.4

max

2,03172E0

3,82804E-21

1,62403E-11

5,00000E1

8,12594E-19

3,29873E-8

3,77776E-7

2,37381E0

3,35542E0

2,44084E-10

1,05685E-9

1,03097E-8

6,00000E1

4,88932E-13

6,84295E-1

2,28618E-3

8,82997E-17

2,60735E-2

2,43920E0

6,65016E-2

9,99984E2

1,56344E0

1,64522E-15

1,18719E-13

9,99990E1

1,34391E-10

3,74514E-4

7,05713E-1

1,51967E-19

1,62597E-14

5,51480E-3

3,19285E-11

9,00029E-3

6.4

mean

2,03172E0

2,66852E-25

2,99996E-12

4,99997E1

2,09719E-24

3,29869E-8

3,77769E-7

2,37380E0

3,35481E0

1,10979E-10

1,04997E-9

1,02489E-8

6,00000E1

7,04563E-14

6,84294E-1

1,97728E-3

3,05231E-25

9,28726E-3

1,10714E0

2,71683E-4

9,99984E2

1,34743E0

3,14495E-20

1,42408E-14

9,99986E1

1,29505E-14

2,74520E-4

1,15626E-3

3,93000E-26

6,99622E-18

5,51037E-3

3,10417E-11

1,10091E-6

6.4

relative error(%)

0,00

6.6

BioUML

2,00713E0

4,60172E-25

4,45405E-12

4,99997E1

3,65507E-24

4,13238E-8

5,02660E-7

2,29759E0

3,36531E0

1,59137E-10

1,44945E-9

1,41343E-8

6,00000E1

1,04362E-13

6,59057E-1

2,12289E-3

5,49401E-25

1,00967E-2

1,15117E0

3,01057E-4

9,99982E2

1,34807E0

4,86613E-20

2,04385E-14

9,99984E1

1,99279E-14

3,21139E-4

1,30022E-3

6,99374E-26

1,04297E-17

6,23828E-3

4,43937E-11

1,28798E-6

6.6

ByoDyn

2,00713E0

4,60172E-25

4,45405E-12

4,99997E1

3,65507E-24

4,13238E-8

5,02660E-7

2,29759E0

3,36531E0

1,59137E-10

1,44945E-9

1,41343E-8

6,00000E1

1,04362E-13

6,59057E-1

2,12289E-3

5,49401E-25

1,00967E-2

1,15117E0

3,01057E-4

9,99982E2

1,34807E0

4,86613E-20

2,04385E-14

9,99984E1

1,99279E-14

3,21139E-4

1,30022E-3

6,99374E-26

1,04297E-17

6,23828E-3

4,43937E-11

1,28798E-6

6.6

MathSBML

2,00713E0

4,60197E-25

4,45411E-12

4,99997E1

3,65532E-24

4,13238E-8

5,02660E-7

2,29759E0

3,36531E0

1,59138E-10

1,44945E-9

1,41343E-8

6,00000E1

1,04364E-13

6,59057E-1

2,12289E-3

5,49450E-25

1,00967E-2

1,15117E0

3,01057E-4

9,99982E2

1,34807E0

4,86626E-20

2,04387E-14

9,99984E1

1,99284E-14

3,21139E-4

1,30022E-3

6,99421E-26

1,04299E-17

6,23828E-3

4,43940E-11

1,28798E-6

6.6

Oscill8 Core

4,60960E-25

1,87464E-11

4,99997E1

3,66198E-24

5,02669E-7

2,29759E0

3,36531E0

2,95394E-10

1,44950E-9

1,41346E-8

6,00000E1

6,59057E-1

2,12289E-3

5,50574E-25

1,00967E-2

1,15117E0

9,99982E2

1,34807E0

4,87039E-20

2,04403E-14

9,99984E1

1,37269E-10

1,30022E-3

7,00703E-26

1,04326E-17

6,23830E-3

1,28798E-6

6.6

SBToolbox2

2,00679E0

5,05600E-25

4,75125E-12

5,00000E1

4,04068E-24

4,09614E-8

4,97121E-7

2,29751E0

3,36587E0

1,64850E-10

1,46273E-9

1,42532E-8

6,00000E1

1,11045E-13

6,58592E-1

2,12212E-3

6,04907E-25

1,00919E-2

1,15111E0

3,01013E-4

9,99980E2

1,34820E0

5,42374E-20

2,11893E-14

9,99980E1

2,20527E-14

3,22267E-4

1,30045E-3

7,62111E-26

1,11746E-17

6,24302E-3

4,58806E-11

1,29250E-6

6.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,00713E0

4,60206E-25

4,45422E-12

4,99997E1

3,65535E-24

4,13243E-8

5,02669E-7

2,29759E0

3,36531E0

1,59142E-10

1,44948E-9

1,41346E-8

6,00000E1

1,04366E-13

6,59057E-1

2,12289E-3

5,49449E-25

1,00967E-2

1,15117E0

3,01058E-4

9,99982E2

1,34807E0

4,86636E-20

2,04392E-14

9,99984E1

1,99288E-14

3,21141E-4

1,30022E-3

6,99433E-26

1,04301E-17

6,23830E-3

4,43951E-11

1,28798E-6

6.6

VCell

2,00713E0

4,60175E-25

4,45407E-12

4,99997E1

3,65509E-24

4,13238E-8

5,02661E-7

2,29759E0

3,36531E0

1,59137E-10

1,44945E-9

1,41343E-8

6,00000E1

1,04363E-13

6,59057E-1

2,12289E-3

5,49405E-25

1,00967E-2

1,15117E0

3,01057E-4

9,99982E2

1,34807E0

4,86616E-20

2,04386E-14

9,99984E1

1,99280E-14

3,21140E-4

1,30022E-3

6,99379E-26

1,04298E-17

6,23829E-3

4,43938E-11

1,28798E-6

6.6

copasi

2,00713E0

4,60365E-25

4,45812E-12

4,99997E1

3,65675E-24

4,13238E-8

5,02661E-7

2,29759E0

3,36531E0

1,59172E-10

1,44946E-9

1,41344E-8

6,00000E1

1,36192E-13

6,59057E-1

2,12289E-3

5,49730E-25

1,00967E-2

1,15117E0

3,01057E-4

9,99982E2

1,34807E0

4,86708E-20

2,04394E-14

9,99984E1

4,84933E-14

3,21139E-4

1,30022E-3

6,99726E-26

1,04307E-17

6,23828E-3

4,43750E-11

1,28798E-6

6.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,00713E0

4,60152E-25

4,45526E-12

4,99997E1

3,65492E-24

4,13238E-8

5,02660E-7

2,29759E0

3,36531E0

1,59124E-10

1,44944E-9

1,41343E-8

6,00000E1

1,41739E-14

6,59057E-1

2,12289E-3

5,49390E-25

1,00967E-2

1,15117E0

3,01057E-4

9,99982E2

1,34807E0

4,86590E-20

2,04382E-14

9,99984E1

8,11403E-15

3,21139E-4

1,30022E-3

6,99356E-26

1,04294E-17

6,23828E-3

4,43661E-11

1,28798E-6

6.6

jsim

1,61137E0

4,52428E-21

8,66427E-14

4,99996E1

9,99999E-19

1,89254E-8

1,83114E-11

1,16743E-1

1,72053E0

1,00152E-14

3,21722E-13

1,80942E-10

6,00000E1

5,53059E-13

8,01722E-2

2,29042E-3

1,12230E-16

2,62835E-2

2,44207E0

6,90096E-2

9,99218E2

1,53120E0

1,92957E-15

1,28852E-13

9,91950E1

4,13457E-14

3,92528E-4

7,36032E-1

1,87390E-19

1,83886E-14

2,97427E-5

3,60438E-12

9,49776E-3

6.6

min

1,61137E0

4,60152E-25

8,66427E-14

4,99996E1

3,65492E-24

1,89254E-8

1,83114E-11

1,16743E-1

1,72053E0

1,00152E-14

3,21722E-13

1,80942E-10

6,00000E1

1,41739E-14

8,01722E-2

2,12212E-3

5,49390E-25

1,00919E-2

1,15111E0

3,01013E-4

9,99218E2

1,34807E0

4,86590E-20

2,04382E-14

9,91950E1

8,11403E-15

3,21139E-4

1,30022E-3

6,99356E-26

1,04294E-17

2,97427E-5

3,60438E-12

1,28798E-6

6.6

max

2,00713E0

4,52428E-21

1,87464E-11

5,00000E1

9,99999E-19

4,13243E-8

5,02669E-7

2,29759E0

3,36587E0

2,95394E-10

1,46273E-9

1,42532E-8

6,00000E1

5,53059E-13

6,59057E-1

2,29042E-3

1,12230E-16

2,62835E-2

2,44207E0

6,90096E-2

9,99982E2

1,53120E0

1,92957E-15

1,28852E-13

9,99984E1

1,37269E-10

3,92528E-4

7,36032E-1

1,87390E-19

1,83886E-14

6,24302E-3

4,58806E-11

9,49776E-3

6.6

mean

2,00713E0

4,60206E-25

4,45422E-12

4,99997E1

3,65535E-24

4,13238E-8

5,02660E-7

2,29759E0

3,36531E0

1,59138E-10

1,44945E-9

1,41343E-8

6,00000E1

1,04365E-13

6,59057E-1

2,12289E-3

5,49450E-25

1,00967E-2

1,15117E0

3,01057E-4

9,99982E2

1,34807E0

4,86636E-20

2,04392E-14

9,99984E1

1,99288E-14

3,21140E-4

1,30022E-3

6,99433E-26

1,04301E-17

6,23828E-3

4,43938E-11

1,28798E-6

6.6

relative error(%)

0,00

6.8

BioUML

1,98380E0

7,77949E-25

6,51670E-12

4,99996E1

6,24035E-24

5,12789E-8

6,61266E-7

2,22387E0

3,37446E0

2,25109E-10

1,97601E-9

1,92499E-8

6,00000E1

1,52330E-13

6,35348E-1

2,27198E-3

9,67592E-25

1,09337E-2

1,19394E0

3,32151E-4

9,99980E2

1,34845E0

7,41210E-20

2,89380E-14

9,99982E1

3,01866E-14

3,73333E-4

1,45459E-3

1,21874E-25

1,53223E-17

7,02637E-3

6,26291E-11

1,49744E-6

6.8

ByoDyn

1,98380E0

7,77949E-25

6,51670E-12

4,99996E1

6,24035E-24

5,12789E-8

6,61266E-7

2,22387E0

3,37446E0

2,25109E-10

1,97601E-9

1,92499E-8

6,00000E1

1,52330E-13

6,35348E-1

2,27198E-3

9,67592E-25

1,09337E-2

1,19394E0

3,32151E-4

9,99980E2

1,34845E0

7,41210E-20

2,89380E-14

9,99982E1

3,01866E-14

3,73333E-4

1,45459E-3

1,21874E-25

1,53223E-17

7,02637E-3

6,26291E-11

1,49744E-6

6.8

MathSBML

1,98380E0

7,77994E-25

6,51678E-12

4,99996E1

6,24078E-24

5,12789E-8

6,61267E-7

2,22387E0

3,37446E0

2,25110E-10

1,97602E-9

1,92500E-8

6,00000E1

1,52332E-13

6,35348E-1

2,27198E-3

9,67679E-25

1,09337E-2

1,19394E0

3,32151E-4

9,99980E2

1,34845E0

7,41230E-20

2,89382E-14

9,99982E1

3,01873E-14

3,73333E-4

1,45459E-3

1,21883E-25

1,53225E-17

7,02637E-3

6,26295E-11

1,49744E-6

6.8

Oscill8 Core

7,78944E-25

2,18548E-11

4,99996E1

6,24913E-24

6,61277E-7

2,22387E0

3,37446E0

3,64359E-10

1,97607E-9

1,92503E-8

6,00000E1

6,35348E-1

2,27198E-3

9,69127E-25

1,09337E-2

1,19394E0

9,99980E2

1,34845E0

7,41696E-20

2,89400E-14

9,99982E1

1,39960E-10

1,45459E-3

1,22047E-25

1,53255E-17

7,02639E-3

1,49745E-6

6.8

SBToolbox2

1,98342E0

8,99699E-25

7,08196E-12

5,00000E1

7,28385E-24

5,09284E-8

6,57374E-7

2,22375E0

3,37513E0

2,36285E-10

2,01082E-9

1,95723E-8

6,00000E1

1,65028E-13

6,34832E-1

2,27110E-3

1,13600E-24

1,09278E-2

1,19387E0

3,32092E-4

9,99980E2

1,34860E0

8,48905E-20

3,04046E-14

9,99980E1

3,42677E-14

3,74776E-4

1,45476E-3

1,41060E-25

1,67420E-17

7,03222E-3

6,55486E-11

1,50325E-6

6.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,98380E0

7,78001E-25

6,51692E-12

4,99996E1

6,24079E-24

5,12794E-8

6,61277E-7

2,22387E0

3,37446E0

2,25115E-10

1,97606E-9

1,92503E-8

6,00000E1

1,52335E-13

6,35348E-1

2,27198E-3

9,67668E-25

1,09337E-2

1,19394E0

3,32152E-4

9,99980E2

1,34845E0

7,41242E-20

2,89388E-14

9,99982E1

3,01879E-14

3,73335E-4

1,45459E-3

1,21884E-25

1,53228E-17

7,02639E-3

6,26309E-11

1,49745E-6

6.8

VCell

1,98380E0

7,77953E-25

6,51672E-12

4,99996E1

6,24039E-24

5,12789E-8

6,61267E-7

2,22387E0

3,37446E0

2,25109E-10

1,97602E-9

1,92500E-8

6,00000E1

1,52331E-13

6,35348E-1

2,27198E-3

9,67599E-25

1,09337E-2

1,19394E0

3,32151E-4

9,99980E2

1,34845E0

7,41214E-20

2,89380E-14

9,99982E1

3,01868E-14

3,73333E-4

1,45459E-3

1,21875E-25

1,53223E-17

7,02637E-3

6,26293E-11

1,49744E-6

6.8

copasi

1,98380E0

7,78187E-25

6,52102E-12

4,99996E1

6,24246E-24

5,12789E-8

6,61267E-7

2,22387E0

3,37446E0

2,25144E-10

1,97603E-9

1,92501E-8

6,00000E1

6,06094E-14

6,35348E-1

2,27198E-3

9,68000E-25

1,09337E-2

1,19394E0

3,32151E-4

9,99980E2

1,34845E0

7,41328E-20

2,89389E-14

9,99982E1

5,82696E-14

3,73333E-4

1,45459E-3

1,21920E-25

1,53235E-17

7,02637E-3

6,26105E-11

1,49744E-6

6.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,98380E0

7,77923E-25

6,51770E-12

4,99996E1

6,24016E-24

5,12789E-8

6,61266E-7

2,22387E0

3,37446E0

2,25093E-10

1,97601E-9

1,92499E-8

6,00000E1

6,15185E-14

6,35348E-1

2,27198E-3

9,67581E-25

1,09337E-2

1,19394E0

3,32151E-4

9,99980E2

1,34845E0

7,41183E-20

2,89376E-14

9,99982E1

1,65765E-14

3,73333E-4

1,45459E-3

1,21872E-25

1,53219E-17

7,02637E-3

6,25968E-11

1,49744E-6

6.8

jsim

1,57869E0

5,30532E-21

9,64136E-14

4,99996E1

1,22012E-18

2,01036E-8

1,89484E-11

1,12281E-1

1,69021E0

1,08505E-14

3,34659E-13

1,93950E-10

6,00000E1

6,22078E-13

7,81235E-2

2,29316E-3

1,41075E-16

2,64752E-2

2,44336E0

7,14487E-2

9,99187E2

1,50057E0

2,24661E-15

1,39299E-13

9,91627E1

4,81529E-14

4,10443E-4

7,65831E-1

2,28846E-19

2,06792E-14

3,01744E-5

3,88589E-12

9,99900E-3

6.8

min

1,57869E0

7,77923E-25

9,64136E-14

4,99996E1

6,24016E-24

2,01036E-8

1,89484E-11

1,12281E-1

1,69021E0

1,08505E-14

3,34659E-13

1,93950E-10

6,00000E1

6,06094E-14

7,81235E-2

2,27110E-3

9,67581E-25

1,09278E-2

1,19387E0

3,32092E-4

9,99187E2

1,34845E0

7,41183E-20

2,89376E-14

9,91627E1

1,65765E-14

3,73333E-4

1,45459E-3

1,21872E-25

1,53219E-17

3,01744E-5

3,88589E-12

1,49744E-6

6.8

max

1,98380E0

5,30532E-21

2,18548E-11

5,00000E1

1,22012E-18

5,12794E-8

6,61277E-7

2,22387E0

3,37513E0

3,64359E-10

2,01082E-9

1,95723E-8

6,00000E1

6,22078E-13

6,35348E-1

2,29316E-3

1,41075E-16

2,64752E-2

2,44336E0

7,14487E-2

9,99980E2

1,50057E0

2,24661E-15

1,39299E-13

9,99982E1

1,39960E-10

4,10443E-4

7,65831E-1

2,28846E-19

2,06792E-14

7,03222E-3

6,55486E-11

9,99900E-3

6.8

mean

1,98380E0

7,78001E-25

6,51692E-12

4,99996E1

6,24079E-24

5,12789E-8

6,61267E-7

2,22387E0

3,37446E0

2,25110E-10

1,97602E-9

1,92500E-8

6,00000E1

1,52331E-13

6,35348E-1

2,27198E-3

9,67679E-25

1,09337E-2

1,19394E0

3,32151E-4

9,99980E2

1,34845E0

7,41242E-20

2,89388E-14

9,99982E1

3,01879E-14

3,73333E-4

1,45459E-3

1,21884E-25

1,53228E-17

7,02637E-3

6,26292E-11

1,49744E-6

6.8

relative error(%)

0,00

7.0

BioUML

1,96164E0

1,29083E-24

9,40413E-12

4,99996E1

1,04500E-23

6,30714E-8

8,60710E-7

2,15261E0

3,38244E0

3,14397E-10

2,66251E-9

2,59115E-8

6,00000E1

2,19301E-13

6,13036E-1

2,42438E-3

1,66954E-24

1,17973E-2

1,23545E0

3,64963E-4

9,99978E2

1,34860E0

1,11248E-19

4,04531E-14

9,99980E1

4,50556E-14

4,31477E-4

1,61948E-3

2,08224E-25

2,22024E-17

7,87640E-3

8,72344E-11

1,73081E-6

7.0

ByoDyn

1,96164E0

1,29083E-24

9,40413E-12

4,99996E1

1,04500E-23

6,30714E-8

8,60710E-7

2,15261E0

3,38244E0

3,14397E-10

2,66251E-9

2,59115E-8

6,00000E1

2,19301E-13

6,13036E-1

2,42438E-3

1,66954E-24

1,17973E-2

1,23545E0

3,64963E-4

9,99978E2

1,34860E0

1,11248E-19

4,04531E-14

9,99980E1

4,50556E-14

4,31477E-4

1,61948E-3

2,08224E-25

2,22024E-17

7,87640E-3

8,72344E-11

1,73081E-6

7.0

MathSBML

1,96164E0

1,29091E-24

9,40426E-12

4,99996E1

1,04508E-23

6,30714E-8

8,60711E-7

2,15261E0

3,38244E0

3,14399E-10

2,66252E-9

2,59116E-8

6,00000E1

2,19304E-13

6,13036E-1

2,42438E-3

1,66971E-24

1,17973E-2

1,23545E0

3,64963E-4

9,99978E2

1,34860E0

1,11251E-19

4,04534E-14

9,99980E1

4,50568E-14

4,31477E-4

1,61948E-3

2,08241E-25

2,22028E-17

7,87640E-3

8,72350E-11

1,73081E-6

7.0

Oscill8 Core

1,29208E-24

2,57802E-11

4,99996E1

1,04610E-23

8,60722E-7

2,15261E0

3,38243E0

4,56492E-10

2,66257E-9

2,59120E-8

6,00000E1

6,13037E-1

2,42438E-3

1,67153E-24

1,17973E-2

1,23545E0

9,99978E2

1,34860E0

1,11303E-19

4,04554E-14

9,99980E1

1,42476E-10

1,61949E-3

2,08448E-25

2,22061E-17

7,87641E-3

1,73082E-6

7.0

SBToolbox2

1,96127E0

1,43469E-24

1,00995E-11

5,00000E1

1,16857E-23

6,25715E-8

8,52832E-7

2,15245E0

3,38302E0

3,27218E-10

2,69386E-9

2,61953E-8

6,00000E1

2,34840E-13

6,12549E-1

2,42351E-3

1,85771E-24

1,17912E-2

1,23543E0

3,64887E-4

9,99980E2

1,34870E0

1,25264E-19

4,21410E-14

9,99980E1

5,03211E-14

4,32988E-4

1,61955E-3

2,29381E-25

2,39646E-17

7,88213E-3

9,05452E-11

1,73689E-6

7.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,96164E0

1,29092E-24

9,40443E-12

4,99996E1

1,04509E-23

6,30716E-8

8,60723E-7

2,15261E0

3,38243E0

3,14405E-10

2,66256E-9

2,59120E-8

6,00000E1

2,19308E-13

6,13037E-1

2,42438E-3

1,66972E-24

1,17973E-2

1,23545E0

3,64963E-4

9,99978E2

1,34860E0

1,11253E-19

4,04541E-14

9,99980E1

4,50575E-14

4,31479E-4

1,61949E-3

2,08245E-25

2,22032E-17

7,87641E-3

8,72366E-11

1,73082E-6

7.0

VCell

1,96164E0

1,29084E-24

9,40416E-12

4,99996E1

1,04500E-23

6,30714E-8

8,60711E-7

2,15261E0

3,38243E0

3,14397E-10

2,66251E-9

2,59116E-8

6,00000E1

2,19301E-13

6,13037E-1

2,42438E-3

1,66955E-24

1,17973E-2

1,23545E0

3,64963E-4

9,99978E2

1,34860E0

1,11248E-19

4,04532E-14

9,99980E1

4,50558E-14

4,31477E-4

1,61949E-3

2,08225E-25

2,22025E-17

7,87640E-3

8,72346E-11

1,73081E-6

7.0

copasi

1,96164E0

1,29114E-24

9,40868E-12

4,99996E1

1,04526E-23

6,30713E-8

8,60711E-7

2,15261E0

3,38244E0

3,14430E-10

2,66252E-9

2,59117E-8

6,00000E1

3,48764E-14

6,13037E-1

2,42438E-3

1,67006E-24

1,17973E-2

1,23545E0

3,64963E-4

9,99978E2

1,34860E0

1,11262E-19

4,04541E-14

9,99980E1

7,08073E-14

4,31477E-4

1,61948E-3

2,08282E-25

2,22038E-17

7,87640E-3

8,72214E-11

1,73081E-6

7.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,96164E0

1,29080E-24

9,40491E-12

4,99996E1

1,04497E-23

6,30713E-8

8,60710E-7

2,15261E0

3,38243E0

3,14380E-10

2,66250E-9

2,59115E-8

6,00000E1

2,17125E-13

6,13037E-1

2,42438E-3

1,66953E-24

1,17973E-2

1,23545E0

3,64963E-4

9,99978E2

1,34860E0

1,11245E-19

4,04527E-14

9,99980E1

3,03283E-14

4,31477E-4

1,61948E-3

2,08222E-25

2,22020E-17

7,87640E-3

8,72147E-11

1,73081E-6

7.0

jsim

1,54769E0

6,17638E-21

1,06910E-13

4,99996E1

1,47684E-18

2,12907E-8

1,95771E-11

1,08298E-1

1,66173E0

1,17307E-14

3,47505E-13

2,07196E-10

6,00000E1

6,96082E-13

7,62387E-2

2,29460E-3

1,75524E-16

2,66502E-2

2,44329E0

7,38183E-2

9,99157E2

1,47145E0

2,59814E-15

1,50050E-13

9,91311E1

5,57340E-14

4,28246E-4

7,95091E-1

2,76982E-19

2,31344E-14

3,05918E-5

4,17431E-12

1,05037E-2

7.0

min

1,54769E0

1,29080E-24

1,06910E-13

4,99996E1

1,04497E-23

2,12907E-8

1,95771E-11

1,08298E-1

1,66173E0

1,17307E-14

3,47505E-13

2,07196E-10

6,00000E1

3,48764E-14

7,62387E-2

2,29460E-3

1,66953E-24

1,17912E-2

1,23543E0

3,64887E-4

9,99157E2

1,34860E0

1,11245E-19

4,04527E-14

9,91311E1

3,03283E-14

4,28246E-4

1,61948E-3

2,08222E-25

2,22020E-17

3,05918E-5

4,17431E-12

1,73081E-6

7.0

max

1,96164E0

6,17638E-21

2,57802E-11

5,00000E1

1,47684E-18

6,30716E-8

8,60723E-7

2,15261E0

3,38302E0

4,56492E-10

2,69386E-9

2,61953E-8

6,00000E1

6,96082E-13

6,13037E-1

2,42438E-3

1,75524E-16

2,66502E-2

2,44329E0

7,38183E-2

9,99980E2

1,47145E0

2,59814E-15

1,50050E-13

9,99980E1

1,42476E-10

4,32988E-4

7,95091E-1

2,76982E-19

2,31344E-14

7,88213E-3

9,05452E-11

1,05037E-2

7.0

mean

1,96164E0

1,29092E-24

9,40443E-12

4,99996E1

1,04509E-23

6,30713E-8

8,60711E-7

2,15261E0

3,38243E0

3,14399E-10

2,66252E-9

2,59116E-8

6,00000E1

2,19302E-13

6,13037E-1

2,42438E-3

1,66972E-24

1,17973E-2

1,23545E0

3,64963E-4

9,99978E2

1,34860E0

1,11253E-19

4,04541E-14

9,99980E1

4,50575E-14

4,31477E-4

1,61949E-3

2,08245E-25

2,22032E-17

7,87640E-3

8,72345E-11

1,73081E-6

7.0

relative error(%)

0,00

7.2

BioUML

1,94055E0

2,10462E-24

1,33966E-11

4,99995E1

1,71844E-23

7,69364E-8

1,10921E-6

2,08376E0

3,38939E0

4,33882E-10

3,54834E-9

3,44973E-8

6,00000E1

3,11653E-13

5,92007E-1

2,57989E-3

2,82586E-24

1,26862E-2

1,27569E0

3,99487E-4

9,99976E2

1,34854E0

1,64674E-19

5,58784E-14

9,99978E1

6,63217E-14

4,95950E-4

1,79499E-3

3,49210E-25

3,17592E-17

8,79003E-3

1,20060E-10

1,98961E-6

7.2

ByoDyn

1,94055E0

2,10462E-24

1,33966E-11

4,99995E1

1,71844E-23

7,69364E-8

1,10921E-6

2,08376E0

3,38939E0

4,33882E-10

3,54834E-9

3,44973E-8

6,00000E1

3,11653E-13

5,92007E-1

2,57989E-3

2,82586E-24

1,26862E-2

1,27569E0

3,99487E-4

9,99976E2

1,34854E0

1,64674E-19

5,58784E-14

9,99978E1

6,63217E-14

4,95950E-4

1,79499E-3

3,49210E-25

3,17592E-17

8,79003E-3

1,20060E-10

1,98961E-6

7.2

MathSBML

1,94055E0

2,10483E-24

1,33969E-11

4,99995E1

1,71866E-23

7,69364E-8

1,10921E-6

2,08376E0

3,38939E0

4,33887E-10

3,54835E-9

3,44975E-8

6,00000E1

3,11659E-13

5,92007E-1

2,57989E-3

2,82633E-24

1,26862E-2

1,27569E0

3,99487E-4

9,99976E2

1,34854E0

1,64681E-19

5,58790E-14

9,99978E1

6,63242E-14

4,95950E-4

1,79499E-3

3,49255E-25

3,17599E-17

8,79003E-3

1,20061E-10

1,98961E-6

7.2

Oscill8 Core

2,10618E-24

3,08016E-11

4,99995E1

1,71983E-23

1,10922E-6

2,08376E0

3,38939E0

5,78677E-10

3,54841E-9

3,44979E-8

6,00000E1

5,92007E-1

2,57989E-3

2,82842E-24

1,26862E-2

1,27569E0

9,99976E2

1,34854E0

1,64736E-19

5,58810E-14

9,99978E1

1,44820E-10

1,79500E-3

3,49496E-25

3,17633E-17

8,79004E-3

1,98962E-6

7.2

SBToolbox2

1,94022E0

2,32568E-24

1,42940E-11

4,99997E1

1,90755E-23

7,62780E-8

1,09732E-6

2,08355E0

3,38991E0

4,49257E-10

3,57699E-9

3,47474E-8

6,00000E1

3,31570E-13

5,91562E-1

2,57898E-3

3,12032E-24

1,26806E-2

1,27573E0

3,99396E-4

9,99980E2

1,34867E0

1,83922E-19

5,79106E-14

9,99980E1

7,34766E-14

4,97515E-4

1,79495E-3

3,82765E-25

3,40544E-17

8,79557E-3

1,23980E-10

1,99594E-6

7.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,94055E0

2,10476E-24

1,33970E-11

4,99995E1

1,71857E-23

7,69367E-8

1,10922E-6

2,08376E0

3,38939E0

4,33893E-10

3,54840E-9

3,44979E-8

6,00000E1

3,11662E-13

5,92007E-1

2,57989E-3

2,82611E-24

1,26862E-2

1,27569E0

3,99487E-4

9,99976E2

1,34854E0

1,64680E-19

5,58797E-14

9,99978E1

6,63241E-14

4,95952E-4

1,79500E-3

3,49238E-25

3,17601E-17

8,79005E-3

1,20063E-10

1,98962E-6

7.2

VCell

1,94055E0

2,10463E-24

1,33966E-11

4,99995E1

1,71845E-23

7,69364E-8

1,10921E-6

2,08376E0

3,38939E0

4,33883E-10

3,54834E-9

3,44974E-8

6,00000E1

3,11654E-13

5,92007E-1

2,57989E-3

2,82587E-24

1,26862E-2

1,27569E0

3,99487E-4

9,99976E2

1,34854E0

1,64674E-19

5,58785E-14

9,99978E1

6,63219E-14

4,95950E-4

1,79500E-3

3,49211E-25

3,17593E-17

8,79003E-3

1,20061E-10

1,98962E-6

7.2

copasi

1,94055E0

2,10505E-24

1,34014E-11

4,99995E1

1,71882E-23

7,69364E-8

1,10921E-6

2,08376E0

3,38939E0

4,33912E-10

3,54836E-9

3,44976E-8

6,00000E1

7,45073E-14

5,92007E-1

2,57989E-3

2,82660E-24

1,26862E-2

1,27569E0

3,99487E-4

9,99976E2

1,34854E0

1,64692E-19

5,58797E-14

9,99978E1

8,63358E-14

4,95950E-4

1,79499E-3

3,49293E-25

3,17610E-17

8,79003E-3

1,20040E-10

1,98961E-6

7.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,94055E0

2,10458E-24

1,33972E-11

4,99995E1

1,71842E-23

7,69364E-8

1,10921E-6

2,08376E0

3,38939E0

4,33868E-10

3,54833E-9

3,44973E-8

6,00000E1

4,25133E-13

5,92007E-1

2,57989E-3

2,82586E-24

1,26862E-2

1,27569E0

3,99487E-4

9,99976E2

1,34854E0

1,64670E-19

5,58780E-14

9,99978E1

5,35028E-14

4,95950E-4

1,79499E-3

3,49208E-25

3,17588E-17

8,79003E-3

1,20036E-10

1,98961E-6

7.2

jsim

1,51824E0

7,14263E-21

1,18164E-13

4,99996E1

1,77430E-18

2,24852E-8

2,01985E-11

1,04729E-1

1,63493E0

1,26572E-14

3,60272E-13

2,20667E-10

6,00000E1

7,75156E-13

7,44968E-2

2,29489E-3

2,16311E-16

2,68104E-2

2,44203E0

7,61182E-2

9,99127E2

1,44374E0

2,98590E-15

1,61094E-13

9,91001E1

6,41380E-14

4,45928E-4

8,23796E-1

3,32468E-19

2,57567E-14

3,09964E-5

4,46934E-12

1,10115E-2

7.2

min

1,51824E0

2,10458E-24

1,18164E-13

4,99995E1

1,71842E-23

2,24852E-8

2,01985E-11

1,04729E-1

1,63493E0

1,26572E-14

3,60272E-13

2,20667E-10

6,00000E1

7,45073E-14

7,44968E-2

2,29489E-3

2,82586E-24

1,26806E-2

1,27569E0

3,99396E-4

9,99127E2

1,34854E0

1,64670E-19

5,58780E-14

9,91001E1

5,35028E-14

4,45928E-4

1,79495E-3

3,49208E-25

3,17588E-17

3,09964E-5

4,46934E-12

1,98961E-6

7.2

max

1,94055E0

7,14263E-21

3,08016E-11

4,99997E1

1,77430E-18

7,69367E-8

1,10922E-6

2,08376E0

3,38991E0

5,78677E-10

3,57699E-9

3,47474E-8

6,00000E1

7,75156E-13

5,92007E-1

2,57989E-3

2,16311E-16

2,68104E-2

2,44203E0

7,61182E-2

9,99980E2

1,44374E0

2,98590E-15

1,61094E-13

9,99980E1

1,44820E-10

4,97515E-4

8,23796E-1

3,32468E-19

2,57567E-14

8,79557E-3

1,23980E-10

1,10115E-2

7.2

mean

1,94055E0

2,10483E-24

1,33970E-11

4,99995E1

1,71866E-23

7,69364E-8

1,10921E-6

2,08376E0

3,38939E0

4,33887E-10

3,54835E-9

3,44975E-8

6,00000E1

3,11660E-13

5,92007E-1

2,57989E-3

2,82633E-24

1,26862E-2

1,27569E0

3,99487E-4

9,99976E2

1,34854E0

1,64681E-19

5,58797E-14

9,99978E1

6,63241E-14

4,95950E-4

1,79499E-3

3,49255E-25

3,17601E-17

8,79003E-3

1,20060E-10

1,98962E-6

7.2

relative error(%)

0,00

7.4

BioUML

1,92045E0

3,37532E-24

1,88535E-11

4,99994E1

2,77810E-23

9,31250E-8

1,41616E-6

2,01728E0

3,39545E0

5,92092E-10

4,68042E-9

4,54568E-8

6,00000E1

4,37538E-13

5,72154E-1

2,73834E-3

4,69736E-24

1,35992E-2

1,31466E0

4,35715E-4

9,99974E2

1,34829E0

2,40600E-19

7,63237E-14

9,99976E1

9,63587E-14

5,67131E-4

1,98118E-3

5,75511E-25

4,48814E-17

9,76885E-3

1,63390E-10

2,27538E-6

7.4

ByoDyn

1,92045E0

3,37532E-24

1,88535E-11

4,99994E1

2,77810E-23

9,31250E-8

1,41616E-6

2,01728E0

3,39545E0

5,92092E-10

4,68042E-9

4,54568E-8

6,00000E1

4,37538E-13

5,72154E-1

2,73834E-3

4,69736E-24

1,35992E-2

1,31466E0

4,35715E-4

9,99974E2

1,34829E0

2,40600E-19

7,63237E-14

9,99976E1

9,63587E-14

5,67131E-4

1,98118E-3

5,75511E-25

4,48814E-17

9,76885E-3

1,63390E-10

2,27538E-6

7.4

MathSBML

1,92045E0

3,37550E-24

1,88537E-11

4,99994E1

2,77830E-23

9,31250E-8

1,41616E-6

2,01728E0

3,39545E0

5,92095E-10

4,68043E-9

4,54569E-8

6,00000E1

4,37543E-13

5,72154E-1

2,73834E-3

4,69784E-24

1,35992E-2

1,31466E0

4,35715E-4

9,99974E2

1,34829E0

2,40606E-19

7,63241E-14

9,99976E1

9,63608E-14

5,67131E-4

1,98118E-3

5,75540E-25

4,48820E-17

9,76885E-3

1,63391E-10

2,27538E-6

7.4

Oscill8 Core

3,37725E-24

3,72770E-11

4,99994E1

2,77982E-23

1,41618E-6

2,01728E0

3,39545E0

7,39448E-10

4,68050E-9

4,54575E-8

6,00000E1

5,72154E-1

2,73835E-3

4,70064E-24

1,35992E-2

1,31466E0

9,99974E2

1,34829E0

2,40671E-19

7,63266E-14

9,99976E1

1,47005E-10

1,98119E-3

5,75875E-25

4,48860E-17

9,76886E-3

2,27539E-6

7.4

SBToolbox2

1,92007E0

3,88373E-24

2,03523E-11

4,99990E1

3,21848E-23

9,24792E-8

1,40687E-6

2,01704E0

3,39598E0

6,18152E-10

4,74418E-9

4,60331E-8

6,00000E1

4,70746E-13

5,71680E-1

2,73738E-3

5,46287E-24

1,35922E-2

1,31469E0

4,35601E-4

9,99970E2

1,34840E0

2,73553E-19

7,97650E-14

9,99980E1

1,08523E-13

5,68998E-4

1,98110E-3

6,62470E-25

4,87315E-17

9,77508E-3

1,70054E-10

2,28293E-6

7.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,92045E0

3,37552E-24

1,88539E-11

4,99994E1

2,77827E-23

9,31254E-8

1,41618E-6

2,01728E0

3,39545E0

5,92104E-10

4,68049E-9

4,54575E-8

6,00000E1

4,37550E-13

5,72154E-1

2,73835E-3

4,69771E-24

1,35992E-2

1,31466E0

4,35715E-4

9,99974E2

1,34829E0

2,40608E-19

7,63253E-14

9,99976E1

9,63618E-14

5,67133E-4

1,98119E-3

5,75551E-25

4,48826E-17

9,76886E-3

1,63393E-10

2,27539E-6

7.4

VCell

1,92045E0

3,37534E-24

1,88535E-11

4,99994E1

2,77811E-23

9,31250E-8

1,41616E-6

2,01728E0

3,39545E0

5,92093E-10

4,68043E-9

4,54569E-8

6,00000E1

4,37540E-13

5,72154E-1

2,73834E-3

4,69738E-24

1,35992E-2

1,31466E0

4,35715E-4

9,99974E2

1,34829E0

2,40600E-19

7,63239E-14

9,99976E1

9,63590E-14

5,67132E-4

1,98118E-3

5,75513E-25

4,48815E-17

9,76885E-3

1,63390E-10

2,27538E-6

7.4

copasi

1,92045E0

3,37599E-24

1,88585E-11

4,99994E1

2,77870E-23

9,31250E-8

1,41616E-6

2,01728E0

3,39545E0

5,92117E-10

4,68045E-9

4,54572E-8

6,00000E1

2,36949E-13

5,72154E-1

2,73834E-3

4,69858E-24

1,35992E-2

1,31466E0

4,35715E-4

9,99974E2

1,34829E0

2,40625E-19

7,63254E-14

9,99976E1

1,07893E-13

5,67131E-4

1,98118E-3

5,75642E-25

4,48838E-17

9,76885E-3

1,63362E-10

2,27538E-6

7.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,92045E0

3,37541E-24

1,88539E-11

4,99994E1

2,77819E-23

9,31250E-8

1,41616E-6

2,01728E0

3,39545E0

5,92082E-10

4,68041E-9

4,54569E-8

6,00000E1

5,11182E-13

5,72154E-1

2,73834E-3

4,69766E-24

1,35992E-2

1,31466E0

4,35715E-4

9,99974E2

1,34829E0

2,40597E-19

7,63234E-14

9,99976E1

8,77761E-14

5,67131E-4

1,98118E-3

5,75541E-25

4,48811E-17

9,76885E-3

1,63365E-10

2,27538E-6

7.4

jsim

1,49024E0

8,20918E-21

1,30208E-13

4,99995E1

2,11685E-18

2,36859E-8

2,08133E-11

1,01518E-1

1,60970E0

1,36311E-14

3,72975E-13

2,34348E-10

6,00000E1

8,59378E-13

7,28799E-2

2,29419E-3

2,64220E-16

2,69571E-2

2,43973E0

7,83482E-2

9,99098E2

1,41736E0

3,41160E-15

1,72425E-13

9,90697E1

7,34147E-14

4,63480E-4

8,51937E-1

3,95997E-19

2,85486E-14

3,13893E-5

4,77071E-12

1,15221E-2

7.4

min

1,49024E0

3,37532E-24

1,30208E-13

4,99990E1

2,77810E-23

2,36859E-8

2,08133E-11

1,01518E-1

1,60970E0

1,36311E-14

3,72975E-13

2,34348E-10

6,00000E1

2,36949E-13

7,28799E-2

2,29419E-3

4,69736E-24

1,35922E-2

1,31466E0

4,35601E-4

9,99098E2

1,34829E0

2,40597E-19

7,63234E-14

9,90697E1

7,34147E-14

4,63480E-4

1,98110E-3

5,75511E-25

4,48811E-17

3,13893E-5

4,77071E-12

2,27538E-6

7.4

max

1,92045E0

8,20918E-21

3,72770E-11

4,99995E1

2,11685E-18

9,31254E-8

1,41618E-6

2,01728E0

3,39598E0

7,39448E-10

4,74418E-9

4,60331E-8

6,00000E1

8,59378E-13

5,72154E-1

2,73835E-3

2,64220E-16

2,69571E-2

2,43973E0

7,83482E-2

9,99974E2

1,41736E0

3,41160E-15

1,72425E-13

9,99980E1

1,47005E-10

5,68998E-4

8,51937E-1

3,95997E-19

2,85486E-14

9,77508E-3

1,70054E-10

1,15221E-2

7.4

mean

1,92045E0

3,37552E-24

1,88539E-11

4,99994E1

2,77830E-23

9,31250E-8

1,41616E-6

2,01728E0

3,39545E0

5,92095E-10

4,68043E-9

4,54569E-8

6,00000E1

4,37546E-13

5,72154E-1

2,73834E-3

4,69784E-24

1,35992E-2

1,31466E0

4,35715E-4

9,99974E2

1,34829E0

2,40608E-19

7,63253E-14

9,99976E1

9,63608E-14

5,67131E-4

1,98118E-3

5,75551E-25

4,48826E-17

9,76885E-3

1,63390E-10

2,27538E-6

7.4

relative error(%)

0,00

7.6

BioUML

1,90126E0

5,32982E-24

2,62311E-11

4,99994E1

4,41967E-23

1,11904E-7

1,79228E-6

1,95313E0

3,40072E0

7,99497E-10

6,11418E-9

5,93202E-8

6,00000E1

6,07272E-13

5,53385E-1

2,89957E-3

7,67655E-24

1,45352E-2

1,35236E0

4,73634E-4

9,99972E2

1,34787E0

3,47242E-19

1,03154E-13

9,99973E1

1,38287E-13

6,45400E-4

2,17809E-3

9,32975E-25

6,27045E-17

1,08143E-2

2,20016E-10

2,58963E-6

7.6

ByoDyn

1,90126E0

5,32982E-24

2,62311E-11

4,99994E1

4,41967E-23

1,11904E-7

1,79228E-6

1,95313E0

3,40072E0

7,99497E-10

6,11418E-9

5,93202E-8

6,00000E1

6,07272E-13

5,53385E-1

2,89957E-3

7,67655E-24

1,45352E-2

1,35236E0

4,73634E-4

9,99972E2

1,34787E0

3,47242E-19

1,03154E-13

9,99973E1

1,38287E-13

6,45400E-4

2,17809E-3

9,32975E-25

6,27045E-17

1,08143E-2

2,20016E-10

2,58963E-6

7.6

MathSBML

1,90126E0

5,33012E-24

2,62313E-11

4,99994E1

4,41994E-23

1,11904E-7

1,79228E-6

1,95313E0

3,40072E0

7,99500E-10

6,11419E-9

5,93203E-8

6,00000E1

6,07277E-13

5,53385E-1

2,89957E-3

7,67721E-24

1,45352E-2

1,35236E0

4,73634E-4

9,99972E2

1,34787E0

3,47249E-19

1,03154E-13

9,99973E1

1,38290E-13

6,45400E-4

2,17809E-3

9,33029E-25

6,27051E-17

1,08143E-2

2,20017E-10

2,58963E-6

7.6

Oscill8 Core

5,33220E-24

4,56615E-11

4,99994E1

4,42181E-23

1,79230E-6

1,95313E0

3,40072E0

9,49285E-10

6,11428E-9

5,93210E-8

6,00000E1

5,53386E-1

2,89957E-3

7,68071E-24

1,45352E-2

1,35236E0

9,99972E2

1,34787E0

3,47322E-19

1,03157E-13

9,99973E1

1,49042E-10

2,17809E-3

9,33436E-25

6,27097E-17

1,08143E-2

2,58964E-6

7.6

SBToolbox2

1,90088E0

6,10553E-24

2,82718E-11

4,99990E1

5,09846E-23

1,11170E-7

1,78132E-6

1,95283E0

3,40125E0

8,33792E-10

6,19492E-9

6,00477E-8

6,00000E1

6,52265E-13

5,52912E-1

2,89854E-3

8,87866E-24

1,45283E-2

1,35246E0

4,73496E-4

9,99970E2

1,34800E0

3,94044E-19

1,07690E-13

9,99970E1

1,55418E-13

6,47444E-4

2,17782E-3

1,06774E-24

6,79812E-17

1,08210E-2

2,28726E-10

2,59786E-6

7.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,90126E0

5,33010E-24

2,62317E-11

4,99994E1

4,41991E-23

1,11904E-7

1,79230E-6

1,95313E0

3,40072E0

7,99511E-10

6,11427E-9

5,93210E-8

6,00000E1

6,07286E-13

5,53386E-1

2,89957E-3

7,67705E-24

1,45352E-2

1,35236E0

4,73634E-4

9,99972E2

1,34787E0

3,47252E-19

1,03156E-13

9,99973E1

1,38291E-13

6,45402E-4

2,17809E-3

9,33032E-25

6,27060E-17

1,08143E-2

2,20020E-10

2,58964E-6

7.6

VCell

1,90126E0

5,32984E-24

2,62312E-11

4,99994E1

4,41969E-23

1,11904E-7

1,79228E-6

1,95313E0

3,40072E0

7,99498E-10

6,11419E-9

5,93203E-8

6,00000E1

6,07273E-13

5,53385E-1

2,89957E-3

7,67658E-24

1,45352E-2

1,35236E0

4,73634E-4

9,99972E2

1,34787E0

3,47243E-19

1,03154E-13

9,99973E1

1,38288E-13

6,45400E-4

2,17809E-3

9,32979E-25

6,27047E-17

1,08143E-2

2,20017E-10

2,58964E-6

7.6

copasi

1,90126E0

5,33063E-24

2,62362E-11

4,99994E1

4,42047E-23

1,11904E-7

1,79228E-6

1,95313E0

3,40072E0

7,99513E-10

6,11421E-9

5,93205E-8

6,00000E1

4,26687E-13

5,53385E-1

2,89957E-3

7,67821E-24

1,45352E-2

1,35236E0

4,73634E-4

9,99972E2

1,34787E0

3,47272E-19

1,03156E-13

9,99973E1

1,41604E-13

6,45400E-4

2,17809E-3

9,33136E-25

6,27072E-17

1,08143E-2

2,19989E-10

2,58963E-6

7.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,90126E0

5,33018E-24

2,62316E-11

4,99994E1

4,42002E-23

1,11904E-7

1,79228E-6

1,95313E0

3,40072E0

7,99491E-10

6,11418E-9

5,93203E-8

6,00000E1

6,69747E-13

5,53385E-1

2,89957E-3

7,67751E-24

1,45352E-2

1,35236E0

4,73634E-4

9,99972E2

1,34787E0

3,47243E-19

1,03154E-13

9,99973E1

1,32756E-13

6,45400E-4

2,17809E-3

9,33076E-25

6,27045E-17

1,08143E-2

2,19993E-10

2,58964E-6

7.6

jsim

1,46360E0

9,38113E-21

1,43077E-13

4,99995E1

2,50904E-18

2,48916E-8

2,14223E-11

9,86156E-2

1,58590E0

1,46536E-14

3,85623E-13

2,48228E-10

6,00000E1

9,48820E-13

7,13735E-2

2,29261E-3

3,20076E-16

2,70916E-2

2,43655E0

8,05088E-2

9,99069E2

1,39223E0

3,87690E-15

1,84033E-13

9,90400E1

8,36141E-14

4,80895E-4

8,79503E-1

4,68278E-19

3,15124E-14

3,17718E-5

5,07816E-12

1,20354E-2

7.6

min

1,46360E0

5,32982E-24

1,43077E-13

4,99990E1

4,41967E-23

2,48916E-8

2,14223E-11

9,86156E-2

1,58590E0

1,46536E-14

3,85623E-13

2,48228E-10

6,00000E1

4,26687E-13

7,13735E-2

2,29261E-3

7,67655E-24

1,45283E-2

1,35236E0

4,73496E-4

9,99069E2

1,34787E0

3,47242E-19

1,03154E-13

9,90400E1

8,36141E-14

4,80895E-4

2,17782E-3

9,32975E-25

6,27045E-17

3,17718E-5

5,07816E-12

2,58963E-6

7.6

max

1,90126E0

9,38113E-21

4,56615E-11

4,99995E1

2,50904E-18

1,11904E-7

1,79230E-6

1,95313E0

3,40125E0

9,49285E-10

6,19492E-9

6,00477E-8

6,00000E1

9,48820E-13

5,53386E-1

2,89957E-3

3,20076E-16

2,70916E-2

2,43655E0

8,05088E-2

9,99972E2

1,39223E0

3,87690E-15

1,84033E-13

9,99973E1

1,49042E-10

6,47444E-4

8,79503E-1

4,68278E-19

3,15124E-14

1,08210E-2

2,28726E-10

1,20354E-2

7.6

mean

1,90126E0

5,33018E-24

2,62316E-11

4,99994E1

4,42002E-23

1,11904E-7

1,79228E-6

1,95313E0

3,40072E0

7,99500E-10

6,11419E-9

5,93203E-8

6,00000E1

6,07281E-13

5,53385E-1

2,89957E-3

7,67751E-24

1,45352E-2

1,35236E0

4,73634E-4

9,99972E2

1,34787E0

3,47252E-19

1,03156E-13

9,99973E1

1,38290E-13

6,45400E-4

2,17809E-3

9,33076E-25

6,27060E-17

1,08143E-2

2,20017E-10

2,58964E-6

7.6

relative error(%)

0,00

7.8

BioUML

1,88291E0

8,29367E-24

3,61039E-11

4,99993E1

6,92570E-23

1,33555E-7

2,24966E-6

1,89124E0

3,40531E0

1,06886E-9

7,91465E-9

7,67082E-8

6,00000E1

8,33787E-13

5,35617E-1

3,06341E-3

1,23455E-23

1,54931E-2

1,38881E0

5,13230E-4

9,99969E2

1,34730E0

4,95376E-19

1,38034E-13

9,99971E1

1,96170E-13

7,31134E-4

2,38572E-3

1,48915E-24

8,66661E-17

1,19278E-2

2,93327E-10

2,93391E-6

7.8

ByoDyn

1,88291E0

8,29367E-24

3,61039E-11

4,99993E1

6,92570E-23

1,33555E-7

2,24966E-6

1,89124E0

3,40531E0

1,06886E-9

7,91465E-9

7,67082E-8

6,00000E1

8,33787E-13

5,35617E-1

3,06341E-3

1,23455E-23

1,54931E-2

1,38881E0

5,13230E-4

9,99969E2

1,34730E0

4,95376E-19

1,38034E-13

9,99971E1

1,96170E-13

7,31134E-4

2,38572E-3

1,48915E-24

8,66661E-17

1,19278E-2

2,93327E-10

2,93391E-6

7.8

MathSBML

1,88291E0

8,29414E-24

3,61041E-11

4,99993E1

6,92605E-23

1,33554E-7

2,24966E-6

1,89124E0

3,40531E0

1,06886E-9

7,91465E-9

7,67082E-8

6,00000E1

8,33792E-13

5,35617E-1

3,06341E-3

1,23464E-23

1,54931E-2

1,38881E0

5,13230E-4

9,99969E2

1,34730E0

4,95385E-19

1,38035E-13

9,99971E1

1,96173E-13

7,31134E-4

2,38572E-3

1,48926E-24

8,66668E-17

1,19278E-2

2,93327E-10

2,93391E-6

7.8

Oscill8 Core

8,29659E-24

5,65286E-11

4,99993E1

6,92833E-23

2,24968E-6

1,89124E0

3,40531E0

1,22095E-9

7,91476E-9

7,67091E-8

6,00000E1

5,35617E-1

3,06341E-3

1,23507E-23

1,54931E-2

1,38881E0

9,99969E2

1,34730E0

4,95467E-19

1,38038E-13

9,99971E1

1,50940E-10

2,38572E-3

1,48973E-24

8,66719E-17

1,19279E-2

2,93391E-6

7.8

SBToolbox2

1,88260E0

9,17203E-24

3,83324E-11

4,99990E1

7,69049E-23

1,32545E-7

2,22874E-6

1,89092E0

3,40574E0

1,10280E-9

7,96582E-9

7,71395E-8

6,00000E1

8,82535E-13

5,35201E-1

3,06243E-3

1,36448E-23

1,54866E-2

1,38890E0

5,13084E-4

9,99970E2

1,34740E0

5,50330E-19

1,42553E-13

9,99970E1

2,16052E-13

7,33120E-4

2,38535E-3

1,63554E-24

9,25049E-17

1,19338E-2

3,01788E-10

2,94188E-6

7.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,88291E0

8,29406E-24

3,61046E-11

4,99993E1

6,92604E-23

1,33555E-7

2,24968E-6

1,89124E0

3,40531E0

1,06887E-9

7,91475E-9

7,67091E-8

6,00000E1

8,33804E-13

5,35617E-1

3,06341E-3

1,23462E-23

1,54931E-2

1,38881E0

5,13230E-4

9,99969E2

1,34730E0

4,95390E-19

1,38037E-13

9,99971E1

1,96175E-13

7,31136E-4

2,38572E-3

1,48923E-24

8,66679E-17

1,19279E-2

2,93331E-10

2,93392E-6

7.8

VCell

1,88291E0

8,29370E-24

3,61039E-11

4,99993E1

6,92572E-23

1,33555E-7

2,24966E-6

1,89124E0

3,40531E0

1,06886E-9

7,91466E-9

7,67083E-8

6,00000E1

8,33789E-13

5,35617E-1

3,06341E-3

1,23456E-23

1,54931E-2

1,38881E0

5,13230E-4

9,99969E2

1,34730E0

4,95378E-19

1,38035E-13

9,99971E1

1,96170E-13

7,31135E-4

2,38572E-3

1,48915E-24

8,66663E-17

1,19279E-2

2,93327E-10

2,93391E-6

7.8

copasi

1,88291E0

8,29503E-24

3,61090E-11

4,99993E1

6,92693E-23

1,33554E-7

2,24966E-6

1,89124E0

3,40531E0

1,06887E-9

7,91469E-9

7,67086E-8

6,00000E1

6,70132E-13

5,35617E-1

3,06341E-3

1,23482E-23

1,54931E-2

1,38881E0

5,13230E-4

9,99969E2

1,34730E0

4,95417E-19

1,38037E-13

9,99971E1

1,89835E-13

7,31134E-4

2,38572E-3

1,48944E-24

8,66696E-17

1,19278E-2

2,93315E-10

2,93391E-6

7.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,88291E0

8,29437E-24

3,61044E-11

4,99993E1

6,92636E-23

1,33554E-7

2,24966E-6

1,89124E0

3,40531E0

1,06885E-9

7,91465E-9

7,67083E-8

6,00000E1

8,60431E-13

5,35617E-1

3,06341E-3

1,23473E-23

1,54931E-2

1,38881E0

5,13230E-4

9,99969E2

1,34730E0

4,95383E-19

1,38034E-13

9,99971E1

1,91909E-13

7,31134E-4

2,38572E-3

1,48934E-24

8,66665E-17

1,19278E-2

2,93303E-10

2,93391E-6

7.8

jsim

1,43822E0

1,06635E-20

1,56804E-13

4,99995E1

2,95563E-18

2,61013E-8

2,20264E-11

9,59832E-2

1,56343E0

1,57257E-14

3,98227E-13

2,62295E-10

6,00000E1

1,04355E-12

6,99651E-2

2,29028E-3

3,84749E-16

2,72150E-2

2,43258E0

8,26003E-2

9,99041E2

1,36826E0

4,38341E-15

1,95911E-13

9,90109E1

9,47865E-14

4,98168E-4

9,06491E-1

5,50041E-19

3,46501E-14

3,21448E-5

5,39144E-12

1,25510E-2

7.8

min

1,43822E0

8,29367E-24

1,56804E-13

4,99990E1

6,92570E-23

2,61013E-8

2,20264E-11

9,59832E-2

1,56343E0

1,57257E-14

3,98227E-13

2,62295E-10

6,00000E1

6,70132E-13

6,99651E-2

2,29028E-3

1,23455E-23

1,54866E-2

1,38881E0

5,13084E-4

9,99041E2

1,34730E0

4,95376E-19

1,38034E-13

9,90109E1

9,47865E-14

4,98168E-4

2,38535E-3

1,48915E-24

8,66661E-17

3,21448E-5

5,39144E-12

2,93391E-6

7.8

max

1,88291E0

1,06635E-20

5,65286E-11

4,99995E1

2,95563E-18

1,33555E-7

2,24968E-6

1,89124E0

3,40574E0

1,22095E-9

7,96582E-9

7,71395E-8

6,00000E1

1,04355E-12

5,35617E-1

3,06341E-3

3,84749E-16

2,72150E-2

2,43258E0

8,26003E-2

9,99970E2

1,36826E0

4,38341E-15

1,95911E-13

9,99971E1

1,50940E-10

7,33120E-4

9,06491E-1

5,50041E-19

3,46501E-14

1,19338E-2

3,01788E-10

1,25510E-2

7.8

mean

1,88291E0

8,29437E-24

3,61044E-11

4,99993E1

6,92636E-23

1,33554E-7

2,24966E-6

1,89124E0

3,40531E0

1,06886E-9

7,91466E-9

7,67083E-8

6,00000E1

8,33798E-13

5,35617E-1

3,06341E-3

1,23473E-23

1,54931E-2

1,38881E0

5,13230E-4

9,99969E2

1,34730E0

4,95390E-19

1,38037E-13

9,99971E1

1,96170E-13

7,31134E-4

2,38572E-3

1,48934E-24

8,66679E-17

1,19278E-2

2,93327E-10

2,93391E-6

7.8

relative error(%)

0,00

8.0

BioUML

1,86535E0

1,27283E-23

4,91884E-11

4,99992E1

1,06989E-22

1,58374E-7

2,80192E-6

1,83157E0

3,40930E0

1,41560E-9

1,01576E-8

9,83427E-8

6,00000E1

1,13316E-12

5,18775E-1

3,22971E-3

1,95556E-23

1,64719E-2

1,42403E0

5,54486E-4

9,99967E2

1,34658E0

6,99007E-19

1,82981E-13

9,99968E1

2,75243E-13

8,24710E-4

2,60407E-3

2,34222E-24

1,18571E-16

1,31107E-2

3,87400E-10

3,30972E-6

8.0

ByoDyn

1,86535E0

1,27283E-23

4,91884E-11

4,99992E1

1,06989E-22

1,58374E-7

2,80192E-6

1,83157E0

3,40930E0

1,41560E-9

1,01576E-8

9,83427E-8

6,00000E1

1,13316E-12

5,18775E-1

3,22971E-3

1,95556E-23

1,64719E-2

1,42403E0

5,54486E-4

9,99967E2

1,34658E0

6,99007E-19

1,82981E-13

9,99968E1

2,75243E-13

8,24710E-4

2,60407E-3

2,34222E-24

1,18571E-16

1,31107E-2

3,87400E-10

3,30972E-6

8.0

MathSBML

1,86535E0

1,27293E-23

4,91890E-11

4,99992E1

1,06996E-22

1,58374E-7

2,80192E-6

1,83157E0

3,40930E0

1,41561E-9

1,01576E-8

9,83429E-8

6,00000E1

1,13318E-12

5,18775E-1

3,22971E-3

1,95574E-23

1,64719E-2

1,42403E0

5,54486E-4

9,99967E2

1,34658E0

6,99025E-19

1,82982E-13

9,99968E1

2,75249E-13

8,24710E-4

2,60407E-3

2,34244E-24

1,18572E-16

1,31107E-2

3,87402E-10

3,30972E-6

8.0

Oscill8 Core

1,27319E-23

7,05940E-11

4,99992E1

1,07021E-22

2,80195E-6

1,83157E0

3,40930E0

1,56989E-9

1,01577E-8

9,83437E-8

6,00000E1

5,18775E-1

3,22971E-3

1,95621E-23

1,64719E-2

1,42403E0

9,99967E2

1,34658E0

6,99109E-19

1,82985E-13

9,99968E1

1,52713E-10

2,60407E-3

2,34294E-24

1,18577E-16

1,31107E-2

3,30972E-6

8.0

SBToolbox2

1,86504E0

1,44696E-23

5,25620E-11

4,99990E1

1,22294E-22

1,57356E-7

2,78380E-6

1,83120E0

3,40974E0

1,46736E-9

1,02576E-8

9,92220E-8

6,00000E1

1,20674E-12

5,18346E-1

3,22868E-3

2,24054E-23

1,64648E-2

1,42414E0

5,54310E-4

9,99970E2

1,34670E0

7,84506E-19

1,89868E-13

9,99970E1

3,05930E-13

8,26952E-4

2,60354E-3

2,66226E-24

1,27452E-16

1,31172E-2

4,00318E-10

3,31874E-6

8.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,86535E0

1,27288E-23

4,91893E-11

4,99992E1

1,06993E-22

1,58375E-7

2,80195E-6

1,83157E0

3,40930E0

1,41562E-9

1,01577E-8

9,83438E-8

6,00000E1

1,13318E-12

5,18775E-1

3,22971E-3

1,95566E-23

1,64719E-2

1,42403E0

5,54487E-4

9,99967E2

1,34658E0

6,99024E-19

1,82984E-13

9,99968E1

2,75249E-13

8,24712E-4

2,60407E-3

2,34233E-24

1,18573E-16

1,31107E-2

3,87405E-10

3,30972E-6

8.0

VCell

1,86535E0

1,27284E-23

4,91885E-11

4,99992E1

1,06989E-22

1,58374E-7

2,80193E-6

1,83157E0

3,40930E0

1,41560E-9

1,01576E-8

9,83429E-8

6,00000E1

1,13317E-12

5,18775E-1

3,22971E-3

1,95557E-23

1,64719E-2

1,42403E0

5,54486E-4

9,99967E2

1,34658E0

6,99009E-19

1,82982E-13

9,99968E1

2,75244E-13

8,24711E-4

2,60407E-3

2,34223E-24

1,18571E-16

1,31107E-2

3,87401E-10

3,30972E-6

8.0

copasi

1,86535E0

1,27302E-23

4,91937E-11

4,99992E1

1,07007E-22

1,58374E-7

2,80193E-6

1,83157E0

3,40930E0

1,41561E-9

1,01576E-8

9,83432E-8

6,00000E1

1,02622E-12

5,18775E-1

3,22971E-3

1,95596E-23

1,64719E-2

1,42403E0

5,54486E-4

9,99967E2

1,34658E0

6,99062E-19

1,82984E-13

9,99968E1

2,60910E-13

8,24710E-4

2,60407E-3

2,34262E-24

1,18575E-16

1,31107E-2

3,87395E-10

3,30972E-6

8.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,86535E0

1,27292E-23

4,91890E-11

4,99992E1

1,06997E-22

1,58374E-7

2,80192E-6

1,83157E0

3,40930E0

1,41560E-9

1,01576E-8

9,83429E-8

6,00000E1

1,13918E-12

5,18775E-1

3,22971E-3

1,95579E-23

1,64719E-2

1,42403E0

5,54486E-4

9,99967E2

1,34658E0

6,99017E-19

1,82982E-13

9,99968E1

2,75738E-13

8,24710E-4

2,60407E-3

2,34246E-24

1,18571E-16

1,31107E-2

3,87376E-10

3,30972E-6

8.0

jsim

1,41402E0

1,20613E-20

1,71422E-13

4,99995E1

3,46158E-18

2,73141E-8

2,26260E-11

9,35859E-2

1,54220E0

1,68484E-14

4,10799E-13

2,76540E-10

6,00000E1

1,14363E-12

6,86440E-2

2,28729E-3

4,59147E-16

2,73285E-2

2,42796E0

8,46235E-2

9,99013E2

1,34538E0

4,93266E-15

2,08052E-13

9,89825E1

1,06983E-13

5,15293E-4

9,32897E-1

6,42027E-19

3,79635E-14

3,25092E-5

5,71035E-12

1,30689E-2

8.0

min

1,41402E0

1,27283E-23

1,71422E-13

4,99990E1

1,06989E-22

2,73141E-8

2,26260E-11

9,35859E-2

1,54220E0

1,68484E-14

4,10799E-13

2,76540E-10

6,00000E1

1,02622E-12

6,86440E-2

2,28729E-3

1,95556E-23

1,64648E-2

1,42403E0

5,54310E-4

9,99013E2

1,34538E0

6,99007E-19

1,82981E-13

9,89825E1

1,06983E-13

5,15293E-4

2,60354E-3

2,34222E-24

1,18571E-16

3,25092E-5

5,71035E-12

3,30972E-6

8.0

max

1,86535E0

1,20613E-20

7,05940E-11

4,99995E1

3,46158E-18

1,58375E-7

2,80195E-6

1,83157E0

3,40974E0

1,56989E-9

1,02576E-8

9,92220E-8

6,00000E1

1,20674E-12

5,18775E-1

3,22971E-3

4,59147E-16

2,73285E-2

2,42796E0

8,46235E-2

9,99970E2

1,34670E0

4,93266E-15

2,08052E-13

9,99970E1

1,52713E-10

8,26952E-4

9,32897E-1

6,42027E-19

3,79635E-14

1,31172E-2

4,00318E-10

1,30689E-2

8.0

mean

1,86535E0

1,27293E-23

4,91890E-11

4,99992E1

1,06997E-22

1,58374E-7

2,80192E-6

1,83157E0

3,40930E0

1,41561E-9

1,01576E-8

9,83429E-8

6,00000E1

1,13318E-12

5,18775E-1

3,22971E-3

1,95579E-23

1,64719E-2

1,42403E0

5,54486E-4

9,99967E2

1,34658E0

6,99025E-19

1,82984E-13

9,99968E1

2,75249E-13

8,24710E-4

2,60407E-3

2,34246E-24

1,18573E-16

1,31107E-2

3,87400E-10

3,30972E-6

8.0

relative error(%)

0,00

8.2

BioUML

1,84853E0

1,92802E-23

6,63720E-11

4,99991E1

1,63063E-22

1,86673E-7

3,46429E-6

1,77405E0

3,41277E0

1,85825E-9

1,29308E-8

1,25058E-7

6,00000E1

1,52524E-12

5,02790E-1

3,39832E-3

3,05358E-23

1,74705E-2

1,45803E0

5,97383E-4

9,99964E2

1,34574E0

9,76174E-19

2,40419E-13

9,99966E1

3,82200E-13

9,26502E-4

2,83311E-3

3,63313E-24

1,60666E-16

1,43641E-2

5,07112E-10

3,71857E-6

8.2

ByoDyn

1,84853E0

1,92802E-23

6,63720E-11

4,99991E1

1,63063E-22

1,86673E-7

3,46429E-6

1,77405E0

3,41277E0

1,85825E-9

1,29308E-8

1,25058E-7

6,00000E1

1,52524E-12

5,02790E-1

3,39832E-3

3,05358E-23

1,74705E-2

1,45803E0

5,97383E-4

9,99964E2

1,34574E0

9,76174E-19

2,40419E-13

9,99966E1

3,82200E-13

9,26502E-4

2,83311E-3

3,63313E-24

1,60666E-16

1,43641E-2

5,07112E-10

3,71857E-6

8.2

MathSBML

1,84853E0

1,92812E-23

6,63726E-11

4,99991E1

1,63071E-22

1,86673E-7

3,46429E-6

1,77405E0

3,41277E0

1,85826E-9

1,29308E-8

1,25059E-7

6,00000E1

1,52525E-12

5,02790E-1

3,39832E-3

3,05379E-23

1,74705E-2

1,45803E0

5,97383E-4

9,99964E2

1,34574E0

9,76195E-19

2,40420E-13

9,99966E1

3,82207E-13

9,26502E-4

2,83311E-3

3,63336E-24

1,60668E-16

1,43641E-2

5,07113E-10

3,71857E-6

8.2

Oscill8 Core

1,92845E-23

8,87440E-11

4,99991E1

1,63102E-22

3,46432E-6

1,77405E0

3,41277E0

2,01462E-9

1,29309E-8

1,25060E-7

6,00000E1

5,02790E-1

3,39832E-3

3,05440E-23

1,74705E-2

1,45803E0

9,99964E2

1,34574E0

9,76288E-19

2,40424E-13

9,99966E1

1,54372E-10

2,83311E-3

3,63403E-24

1,60673E-16

1,43642E-2

3,71858E-6

8.2

SBToolbox2

1,84824E0

2,20095E-23

7,09764E-11

4,99990E1

1,87257E-22

1,85610E-7

3,44668E-6

1,77360E0

3,41322E0

1,92789E-9

1,30727E-8

1,26308E-7

6,00000E1

1,62529E-12

5,02360E-1

3,39723E-3

3,51839E-23

1,74622E-2

1,45821E0

5,97174E-4

9,99960E2

1,34588E0

1,09697E-18

2,49686E-13

9,99970E1

4,25190E-13

9,28958E-4

2,83242E-3

4,15045E-24

1,72857E-16

1,43705E-2

5,24407E-10

3,72853E-6

8.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,84853E0

1,92809E-23

6,63731E-11

4,99991E1

1,63069E-22

1,86674E-7

3,46432E-6

1,77405E0

3,41277E0

1,85828E-9

1,29309E-8

1,25060E-7

6,00000E1

1,52526E-12

5,02790E-1

3,39832E-3

3,05372E-23

1,74705E-2

1,45803E0

5,97384E-4

9,99964E2

1,34574E0

9,76195E-19

2,40422E-13

9,99966E1

3,82208E-13

9,26503E-4

2,83311E-3

3,63329E-24

1,60669E-16

1,43642E-2

5,07118E-10

3,71858E-6

8.2

VCell

1,84853E0

1,92803E-23

6,63722E-11

4,99991E1

1,63063E-22

1,86674E-7

3,46430E-6

1,77405E0

3,41277E0

1,85826E-9

1,29308E-8

1,25059E-7

6,00000E1

1,52524E-12

5,02790E-1

3,39832E-3

3,05359E-23

1,74705E-2

1,45803E0

5,97383E-4

9,99964E2

1,34574E0

9,76177E-19

2,40420E-13

9,99966E1

3,82201E-13

9,26502E-4

2,83311E-3

3,63315E-24

1,60667E-16

1,43642E-2

5,07112E-10

3,71857E-6

8.2

copasi

1,84853E0

1,92849E-23

6,63787E-11

4,99991E1

1,63115E-22

1,86673E-7

3,46430E-6

1,77405E0

3,41277E0

1,85827E-9

1,29309E-8

1,25059E-7

6,00000E1

1,42896E-12

5,02790E-1

3,39832E-3

3,05484E-23

1,74705E-2

1,45803E0

5,97383E-4

9,99964E2

1,34574E0

9,76285E-19

2,40425E-13

9,99966E1

3,59212E-13

9,26502E-4

2,83311E-3

3,63422E-24

1,60675E-16

1,43641E-2

5,07105E-10

3,71857E-6

8.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,84853E0

1,92812E-23

6,63727E-11

4,99991E1

1,63072E-22

1,86673E-7

3,46429E-6

1,77405E0

3,41277E0

1,85825E-9

1,29308E-8

1,25059E-7

6,00000E1

1,48487E-12

5,02790E-1

3,39832E-3

3,05384E-23

1,74705E-2

1,45803E0

5,97383E-4

9,99964E2

1,34574E0

9,76186E-19

2,40419E-13

9,99966E1

3,82031E-13

9,26502E-4

2,83311E-3

3,63340E-24

1,60667E-16

1,43641E-2

5,07092E-10

3,71857E-6

8.2

jsim

1,39093E0

1,35795E-20

1,86966E-13

4,99995E1

4,03202E-18

2,85291E-8

2,32220E-11

9,13946E-2

1,52210E0

1,80227E-14

4,23346E-13

2,90952E-10

6,00000E1

1,24911E-12

6,74014E-2

2,28373E-3

5,44218E-16

2,74329E-2

2,42277E0

8,65793E-2

9,98986E2

1,32353E0

5,52618E-15

2,20451E-13

9,89547E1

1,20254E-13

5,32267E-4

9,58719E-1

7,44990E-19

4,14542E-14

3,28657E-5

6,03467E-12

1,35887E-2

8.2

min

1,39093E0

1,92802E-23

1,86966E-13

4,99990E1

1,63063E-22

2,85291E-8

2,32220E-11

9,13946E-2

1,52210E0

1,80227E-14

4,23346E-13

2,90952E-10

6,00000E1

1,24911E-12

6,74014E-2

2,28373E-3

3,05358E-23

1,74622E-2

1,45803E0

5,97174E-4

9,98986E2

1,32353E0

9,76174E-19

2,20451E-13

9,89547E1

1,20254E-13

5,32267E-4

2,83242E-3

3,63313E-24

1,60666E-16

3,28657E-5

6,03467E-12

3,71857E-6

8.2

max

1,84853E0

1,35795E-20

8,87440E-11

4,99995E1

4,03202E-18

1,86674E-7

3,46432E-6

1,77405E0

3,41322E0

2,01462E-9

1,30727E-8

1,26308E-7

6,00000E1

1,62529E-12

5,02790E-1

3,39832E-3

5,44218E-16

2,74329E-2

2,42277E0

8,65793E-2

9,99964E2

1,34588E0

5,52618E-15

2,49686E-13

9,99970E1

1,54372E-10

9,28958E-4

9,58719E-1

7,44990E-19

4,14542E-14

1,43705E-2

5,24407E-10

1,35887E-2

8.2

mean

1,84853E0

1,92812E-23

6,63727E-11

4,99991E1

1,63072E-22

1,86673E-7

3,46429E-6

1,77405E0

3,41277E0

1,85826E-9

1,29308E-8

1,25059E-7

6,00000E1

1,52524E-12

5,02790E-1

3,39832E-3

3,05384E-23

1,74705E-2

1,45803E0

5,97383E-4

9,99964E2

1,34574E0

9,76195E-19

2,40420E-13

9,99966E1

3,82201E-13

9,26502E-4

2,83311E-3

3,63340E-24

1,60669E-16

1,43641E-2

5,07112E-10

3,71857E-6

8.2

relative error(%)

0,00

8.4

BioUML

1,83239E0

2,88448E-23

8,87447E-11

4,99990E1

2,45374E-22

2,18778E-7

4,25372E-6

1,71862E0

3,41578E0

2,41891E-9

1,63352E-8

1,57814E-7

6,00000E1

2,03428E-12

4,87602E-1

3,56911E-3

4,70389E-23

1,84878E-2

1,49083E0

6,41900E-4

9,99962E2

1,34479E0

1,34992E-18

3,13243E-13

9,99963E1

5,25525E-13

1,03688E-3

3,07279E-3

5,56180E-24

2,15731E-16

1,56893E-2

6,58250E-10

4,16197E-6

8.4

ByoDyn

1,83239E0

2,88448E-23

8,87447E-11

4,99990E1

2,45374E-22

2,18778E-7

4,25372E-6

1,71862E0

3,41578E0

2,41891E-9

1,63352E-8

1,57814E-7

6,00000E1

2,03428E-12

4,87602E-1

3,56911E-3

4,70389E-23

1,84878E-2

1,49083E0

6,41900E-4

9,99962E2

1,34479E0

1,34992E-18

3,13243E-13

9,99963E1

5,25525E-13

1,03688E-3

3,07279E-3

5,56180E-24

2,15731E-16

1,56893E-2

6,58250E-10

4,16197E-6

8.4

MathSBML

1,83239E0

2,88459E-23

8,87453E-11

4,99990E1

2,45384E-22

2,18778E-7

4,25372E-6

1,71862E0

3,41578E0

2,41891E-9

1,63352E-8

1,57814E-7

6,00000E1

2,03429E-12

4,87602E-1

3,56911E-3

4,70413E-23

1,84878E-2

1,49083E0

6,41900E-4

9,99962E2

1,34479E0

1,34994E-18

3,13244E-13

9,99963E1

5,25533E-13

1,03688E-3

3,07279E-3

5,56206E-24

2,15732E-16

1,56893E-2

6,58252E-10

4,16197E-6

8.4

Oscill8 Core

2,88500E-23

1,12068E-10

4,99990E1

2,45421E-22

4,25375E-6

1,71862E0

3,41578E0

2,57724E-9

1,63353E-8

1,57815E-7

6,00000E1

4,87602E-1

3,56911E-3

4,70489E-23

1,84879E-2

1,49083E0

9,99962E2

1,34479E0

1,35005E-18

3,13248E-13

9,99963E1

1,55935E-10

3,07280E-3

5,56290E-24

2,15738E-16

1,56893E-2

4,16197E-6

8.4

SBToolbox2

1,83207E0

3,18019E-23

9,36170E-11

4,99990E1

2,71562E-22

2,17362E-7

4,22055E-6

1,71817E0

3,41613E0

2,48585E-9

1,64212E-8

1,58520E-7

6,00000E1

2,13913E-12

4,87222E-1

3,56808E-3

5,18730E-23

1,84803E-2

1,49106E0

6,41683E-4

9,99960E2

1,34488E0

1,48718E-18

3,22210E-13

9,99960E1

5,73779E-13

1,03923E-3

3,07205E-3

6,09918E-24

2,28810E-16

1,56949E-2

6,74531E-10

4,17150E-6

8.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,83239E0

2,88457E-23

8,87458E-11

4,99990E1

2,45381E-22

2,18779E-7

4,25375E-6

1,71862E0

3,41578E0

2,41893E-9

1,63353E-8

1,57815E-7

6,00000E1

2,03430E-12

4,87602E-1

3,56911E-3

4,70407E-23

1,84879E-2

1,49083E0

6,41900E-4

9,99962E2

1,34479E0

1,34995E-18

3,13247E-13

9,99963E1

5,25534E-13

1,03688E-3

3,07280E-3

5,56200E-24

2,15734E-16

1,56893E-2

6,58256E-10

4,16198E-6

8.4

VCell

1,83239E0

2,88449E-23

8,87448E-11

4,99990E1

2,45375E-22

2,18778E-7

4,25373E-6

1,71862E0

3,41578E0

2,41891E-9

1,63352E-8

1,57814E-7

6,00000E1

2,03428E-12

4,87602E-1

3,56911E-3

4,70391E-23

1,84878E-2

1,49083E0

6,41900E-4

9,99962E2

1,34479E0

1,34992E-18

3,13244E-13

9,99963E1

5,25526E-13

1,03688E-3

3,07280E-3

5,56182E-24

2,15731E-16

1,56893E-2

6,58251E-10

4,16197E-6

8.4

copasi

1,83239E0

2,88485E-23

8,87509E-11

4,99990E1

2,45436E-22

2,18778E-7

4,25373E-6

1,71862E0

3,41578E0

2,41892E-9

1,63353E-8

1,57815E-7

6,00000E1

1,86997E-12

4,87602E-1

3,56911E-3

4,70547E-23

1,84878E-2

1,49083E0

6,41900E-4

9,99962E2

1,34479E0

1,35004E-18

3,13249E-13

9,99963E1

4,93751E-13

1,03688E-3

3,07279E-3

5,56251E-24

2,15740E-16

1,56893E-2

6,58252E-10

4,16197E-6

8.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,83239E0

2,88459E-23

8,87453E-11

4,99990E1

2,45384E-22

2,18778E-7

4,25372E-6

1,71862E0

3,41578E0

2,41891E-9

1,63352E-8

1,57814E-7

6,00000E1

2,00644E-12

4,87602E-1

3,56911E-3

4,70417E-23

1,84878E-2

1,49083E0

6,41900E-4

9,99962E2

1,34479E0

1,34993E-18

3,13243E-13

9,99963E1

5,24401E-13

1,03688E-3

3,07279E-3

5,56209E-24

2,15731E-16

1,56893E-2

6,58227E-10

4,16197E-6

8.4

jsim

1,36888E0

1,52229E-20

2,03470E-13

4,99995E1

4,67225E-18

2,97456E-8

2,38148E-11

8,93845E-2

1,50305E0

1,92495E-14

4,35877E-13

3,05523E-10

6,00000E1

1,36005E-12

6,62296E-2

2,27969E-3

6,40941E-16

2,75291E-2

2,41710E0

8,84686E-2

9,98960E2

1,30265E0

6,16541E-15

2,33100E-13

9,89276E1

1,34650E-13

5,49087E-4

9,83959E-1

8,59695E-19

4,51238E-14

3,32153E-5

6,36424E-12

1,41103E-2

8.4

min

1,36888E0

2,88448E-23

2,03470E-13

4,99990E1

2,45374E-22

2,97456E-8

2,38148E-11

8,93845E-2

1,50305E0

1,92495E-14

4,35877E-13

3,05523E-10

6,00000E1

1,36005E-12

6,62296E-2

2,27969E-3

4,70389E-23

1,84803E-2

1,49083E0

6,41683E-4

9,98960E2

1,30265E0

1,34992E-18

2,33100E-13

9,89276E1

1,34650E-13

5,49087E-4

3,07205E-3

5,56180E-24

2,15731E-16

3,32153E-5

6,36424E-12

4,16197E-6

8.4

max

1,83239E0

1,52229E-20

1,12068E-10

4,99995E1

4,67225E-18

2,18779E-7

4,25375E-6

1,71862E0

3,41613E0

2,57724E-9

1,64212E-8

1,58520E-7

6,00000E1

2,13913E-12

4,87602E-1

3,56911E-3

6,40941E-16

2,75291E-2

2,41710E0

8,84686E-2

9,99962E2

1,34488E0

6,16541E-15

3,22210E-13

9,99963E1

1,55935E-10

1,03923E-3

9,83959E-1

8,59695E-19

4,51238E-14

1,56949E-2

6,74531E-10

1,41103E-2

8.4

mean

1,83239E0

2,88459E-23

8,87453E-11

4,99990E1

2,45384E-22

2,18778E-7

4,25372E-6

1,71862E0

3,41578E0

2,41891E-9

1,63352E-8

1,57814E-7

6,00000E1

2,03428E-12

4,87602E-1

3,56911E-3

4,70417E-23

1,84878E-2

1,49083E0

6,41900E-4

9,99962E2

1,34479E0

1,34995E-18

3,13244E-13

9,99963E1

5,25526E-13

1,03688E-3

3,07279E-3

5,56209E-24

2,15734E-16

1,56893E-2

6,58251E-10

4,16197E-6

8.4

relative error(%)

0,00

8.6

BioUML

1,81690E0

4,26500E-23

1,17636E-10

4,99988E1

3,64795E-22

2,55026E-7

5,18899E-6

1,66523E0

3,41838E0

3,12374E-9

2,04866E-8

1,97706E-7

6,00000E1

2,68978E-12

4,73156E-1

3,74193E-3

7,15351E-23

1,95230E-2

1,52247E0

6,88012E-4

9,99959E2

1,34374E0

1,84945E-18

4,04889E-13

9,99960E1

7,15884E-13

1,15621E-3

3,32306E-3

8,40858E-24

2,87173E-16

1,70871E-2

8,47644E-10

4,64139E-6

8.6

ByoDyn

1,81690E0

4,26500E-23

1,17636E-10

4,99988E1

3,64795E-22

2,55026E-7

5,18899E-6

1,66523E0

3,41838E0

3,12374E-9

2,04866E-8

1,97706E-7

6,00000E1

2,68978E-12

4,73156E-1

3,74193E-3

7,15351E-23

1,95230E-2

1,52247E0

6,88012E-4

9,99959E2

1,34374E0

1,84945E-18

4,04889E-13

9,99960E1

7,15884E-13

1,15621E-3

3,32306E-3

8,40858E-24

2,87173E-16

1,70871E-2

8,47644E-10

4,64139E-6

8.6

MathSBML

1,81690E0

4,26517E-23

1,17637E-10

4,99988E1

3,64811E-22

2,55026E-7

5,18899E-6

1,66523E0

3,41838E0

3,12376E-9

2,04866E-8

1,97706E-7

6,00000E1

2,68980E-12

4,73156E-1

3,74193E-3

7,15390E-23

1,95230E-2

1,52247E0

6,88012E-4

9,99959E2

1,34374E0

1,84949E-18

4,04891E-13

9,99960E1

7,15896E-13

1,15621E-3

3,32306E-3

8,40900E-24

2,87176E-16

1,70871E-2

8,47647E-10

4,64139E-6

8.6

Oscill8 Core

4,26562E-23

1,41895E-10

4,99988E1

3,64851E-22

5,18902E-6

1,66523E0

3,41838E0

3,28395E-9

2,04867E-8

1,97707E-7

6,00000E1

4,73156E-1

3,74193E-3

7,15473E-23

1,95230E-2

1,52247E0

9,99959E2

1,34374E0

1,84959E-18

4,04894E-13

9,99960E1

1,57416E-10

3,32306E-3

8,40992E-24

2,87182E-16

1,70871E-2

4,64139E-6

8.6

SBToolbox2

1,81660E0

4,77752E-23

1,24418E-10

4,99990E1

4,10469E-22

2,53540E-7

5,15698E-6

1,66474E0

3,41871E0

3,21678E-9

2,06298E-8

1,98915E-7

6,00000E1

2,83529E-12

4,72781E-1

3,74082E-3

8,05809E-23

1,95153E-2

1,52271E0

6,87769E-4

9,99960E2

1,34389E0

2,04648E-18

4,17353E-13

9,99960E1

7,84558E-13

1,15877E-3

3,32209E-3

9,41222E-24

3,05487E-16

1,70931E-2

8,70247E-10

4,65170E-6

8.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,81690E0

4,26511E-23

1,17637E-10

4,99988E1

3,64805E-22

2,55027E-7

5,18902E-6

1,66523E0

3,41838E0

3,12377E-9

2,04867E-8

1,97707E-7

6,00000E1

2,68981E-12

4,73156E-1

3,74193E-3

7,15374E-23

1,95230E-2

1,52247E0

6,88012E-4

9,99959E2

1,34374E0

1,84948E-18

4,04892E-13

9,99960E1

7,15895E-13

1,15621E-3

3,32306E-3

8,40884E-24

2,87177E-16

1,70871E-2

8,47651E-10

4,64139E-6

8.6

VCell

1,81690E0

4,26501E-23

1,17636E-10

4,99988E1

3,64796E-22

2,55026E-7

5,18899E-6

1,66523E0

3,41838E0

3,12375E-9

2,04866E-8

1,97706E-7

6,00000E1

2,68979E-12

4,73156E-1

3,74193E-3

7,15353E-23

1,95230E-2

1,52247E0

6,88012E-4

9,99959E2

1,34374E0

1,84946E-18

4,04889E-13

9,99960E1

7,15886E-13

1,15621E-3

3,32306E-3

8,40861E-24

2,87174E-16

1,70871E-2

8,47645E-10

4,64139E-6

8.6

copasi

1,81690E0

4,26516E-23

1,17642E-10

4,99988E1

3,64872E-22

2,55026E-7

5,18899E-6

1,66523E0

3,41838E0

3,12374E-9

2,04866E-8

1,97707E-7

6,00000E1

2,51077E-12

4,73156E-1

3,74193E-3

7,15556E-23

1,95230E-2

1,52247E0

6,88012E-4

9,99959E2

1,34374E0

1,84959E-18

4,04894E-13

9,99960E1

6,78117E-13

1,15621E-3

3,32306E-3

8,40847E-24

2,87183E-16

1,70871E-2

8,47650E-10

4,64139E-6

8.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,81690E0

4,26512E-23

1,17636E-10

4,99988E1

3,64806E-22

2,55026E-7

5,18899E-6

1,66523E0

3,41838E0

3,12374E-9

2,04866E-8

1,97706E-7

6,00000E1

2,68002E-12

4,73156E-1

3,74193E-3

7,15382E-23

1,95230E-2

1,52247E0

6,88012E-4

9,99959E2

1,34374E0

1,84947E-18

4,04889E-13

9,99960E1

7,12537E-13

1,15621E-3

3,32306E-3

8,40891E-24

2,87174E-16

1,70871E-2

8,47622E-10

4,64139E-6

8.6

jsim

1,34781E0

1,69963E-20

2,20968E-13

4,99994E1

5,38772E-18

3,09628E-8

2,44049E-11

8,75340E-2

1,48498E0

2,05296E-14

4,48401E-13

3,20247E-10

6,00000E1

1,47649E-12

6,51219E-2

2,27524E-3

7,50330E-16

2,76178E-2

2,41103E0

9,02925E-2

9,98934E2

1,28269E0

6,85175E-15

2,45995E-13

9,89011E1

1,50224E-13

5,65751E-4

1,00862E0

9,86912E-19

4,89737E-14

3,35584E-5

6,69887E-12

1,46336E-2

8.6

min

1,34781E0

4,26500E-23

2,20968E-13

4,99988E1

3,64795E-22

3,09628E-8

2,44049E-11

8,75340E-2

1,48498E0

2,05296E-14

4,48401E-13

3,20247E-10

6,00000E1

1,47649E-12

6,51219E-2

2,27524E-3

7,15351E-23

1,95153E-2

1,52247E0

6,87769E-4

9,98934E2

1,28269E0

1,84945E-18

2,45995E-13

9,89011E1

1,50224E-13

5,65751E-4

3,32209E-3

8,40847E-24

2,87173E-16

3,35584E-5

6,69887E-12

4,64139E-6

8.6

max

1,81690E0

1,69963E-20

1,41895E-10

4,99994E1

5,38772E-18

2,55027E-7

5,18902E-6

1,66523E0

3,41871E0

3,28395E-9

2,06298E-8

1,98915E-7

6,00000E1

2,83529E-12

4,73156E-1

3,74193E-3

7,50330E-16

2,76178E-2

2,41103E0

9,02925E-2

9,99960E2

1,34389E0

6,85175E-15

4,17353E-13

9,99960E1

1,57416E-10

1,15877E-3

1,00862E0

9,86912E-19

4,89737E-14

1,70931E-2

8,70247E-10

1,46336E-2

8.6

mean

1,81690E0

4,26516E-23

1,17637E-10

4,99988E1

3,64811E-22

2,55026E-7

5,18899E-6

1,66523E0

3,41838E0

3,12375E-9

2,04866E-8

1,97706E-7

6,00000E1

2,68978E-12

4,73156E-1

3,74193E-3

7,15390E-23

1,95230E-2

1,52247E0

6,88012E-4

9,99959E2

1,34374E0

1,84949E-18

4,04891E-13

9,99960E1

7,15886E-13

1,15621E-3

3,32306E-3

8,40891E-24

2,87177E-16

1,70871E-2

8,47646E-10

4,64139E-6

8.6

relative error(%)

0,00

8.8

BioUML

1,80201E0

6,23625E-23

1,54657E-10

4,99987E1

5,36150E-22

2,95770E-7

6,29082E-6

1,61381E0

3,42062E0

4,00361E-9

2,55166E-8

2,45979E-7

6,00000E1

3,52736E-12

4,59401E-1

3,91667E-3

1,07468E-22

2,05751E-2

1,55297E0

7,35696E-4

9,99956E2

1,34261E0

2,51152E-18

5,19409E-13

9,99957E1

9,66592E-13

1,28485E-3

3,58382E-3

1,25625E-23

3,79151E-16

1,85587E-2

1,08330E-9

5,15829E-6

8.8

ByoDyn

1,80201E0

6,23625E-23

1,54657E-10

4,99987E1

5,36150E-22

2,95770E-7

6,29082E-6

1,61381E0

3,42062E0

4,00361E-9

2,55166E-8

2,45979E-7

6,00000E1

3,52736E-12

4,59401E-1

3,91667E-3

1,07468E-22

2,05751E-2

1,55297E0

7,35696E-4

9,99956E2

1,34261E0

2,51152E-18

5,19409E-13

9,99957E1

9,66592E-13

1,28485E-3

3,58382E-3

1,25625E-23

3,79151E-16

1,85587E-2

1,08330E-9

5,15829E-6

8.8

MathSBML

1,80201E0

6,23646E-23

1,54658E-10

4,99987E1

5,36171E-22

2,95770E-7

6,29082E-6

1,61381E0

3,42062E0

4,00362E-9

2,55166E-8

2,45980E-7

6,00000E1

3,52739E-12

4,59401E-1

3,91667E-3

1,07473E-22

2,05751E-2

1,55297E0

7,35696E-4

9,99956E2

1,34261E0

2,51156E-18

5,19411E-13

9,99957E1

9,66606E-13

1,28485E-3

3,58382E-3

1,25630E-23

3,79155E-16

1,85587E-2

1,08330E-9

5,15829E-6

8.8

Oscill8 Core

6,23698E-23

1,79835E-10

4,99987E1

5,36217E-22

6,29085E-6

1,61381E0

3,42062E0

4,16559E-9

2,55168E-8

2,45981E-7

6,00000E1

4,59401E-1

3,91667E-3

1,07483E-22

2,05751E-2

1,55297E0

9,99956E2

1,34261E0

2,51167E-18

5,19414E-13

9,99957E1

1,58840E-10

3,58382E-3

1,25641E-23

3,79160E-16

1,85587E-2

5,15830E-6

8.8

SBToolbox2

1,80172E0

7,04602E-23

1,63904E-10

4,99990E1

6,08796E-22

2,94269E-7

6,26226E-6

1,61330E0

3,42091E0

4,13046E-9

2,57395E-8

2,47902E-7

6,00000E1

3,72515E-12

4,59020E-1

3,91556E-3

1,22432E-22

2,05674E-2

1,55318E0

7,35422E-4

9,99960E2

1,34270E0

2,78732E-18

5,36400E-13

9,99960E1

1,06197E-12

1,28760E-3

3,58270E-3

1,42125E-23

4,04252E-16

1,85650E-2

1,11412E-9

5,16963E-6

8.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,80201E0

6,23637E-23

1,54658E-10

4,99987E1

5,36163E-22

2,95770E-7

6,29085E-6

1,61381E0

3,42062E0

4,00364E-9

2,55167E-8

2,45981E-7

6,00000E1

3,52739E-12

4,59401E-1

3,91667E-3

1,07471E-22

2,05751E-2

1,55297E0

7,35696E-4

9,99956E2

1,34261E0

2,51155E-18

5,19413E-13

9,99957E1

9,66604E-13

1,28485E-3

3,58382E-3

1,25628E-23

3,79155E-16

1,85587E-2

1,08331E-9

5,15830E-6

8.8

VCell

1,80201E0

6,23626E-23

1,54657E-10

4,99987E1

5,36152E-22

2,95770E-7

6,29083E-6

1,61381E0

3,42062E0

4,00361E-9

2,55166E-8

2,45980E-7

6,00000E1

3,52737E-12

4,59401E-1

3,91667E-3

1,07469E-22

2,05751E-2

1,55297E0

7,35696E-4

9,99956E2

1,34261E0

2,51152E-18

5,19410E-13

9,99957E1

9,66594E-13

1,28485E-3

3,58382E-3

1,25625E-23

3,79152E-16

1,85587E-2

1,08330E-9

5,15830E-6

8.8

copasi

1,80201E0

6,23657E-23

1,54663E-10

4,99987E1

5,36263E-22

2,95770E-7

6,29082E-6

1,61381E0

3,42062E0

4,00361E-9

2,55167E-8

2,45980E-7

6,00000E1

3,41816E-12

4,59401E-1

3,91667E-3

1,07499E-22

2,05751E-2

1,55297E0

7,35696E-4

9,99956E2

1,34261E0

2,51169E-18

5,19415E-13

9,99957E1

9,22400E-13

1,28485E-3

3,58382E-3

1,25623E-23

3,79163E-16

1,85587E-2

1,08332E-9

5,15829E-6

8.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,80201E0

6,23640E-23

1,54657E-10

4,99987E1

5,36165E-22

2,95770E-7

6,29082E-6

1,61381E0

3,42062E0

4,00360E-9

2,55166E-8

2,45980E-7

6,00000E1

3,45050E-12

4,59401E-1

3,91667E-3

1,07472E-22

2,05751E-2

1,55297E0

7,35696E-4

9,99956E2

1,34261E0

2,51154E-18

5,19409E-13

9,99957E1

9,60106E-13

1,28485E-3

3,58382E-3

1,25629E-23

3,79152E-16

1,85587E-2

1,08328E-9

5,15829E-6

8.8

jsim

1,32765E0

1,89047E-20

2,39494E-13

4,99994E1

6,18401E-18

3,21802E-8

2,49929E-11

8,58250E-2

1,46782E0

2,18639E-14

4,60923E-13

3,35116E-10

6,00000E1

1,59849E-12

6,40726E-2

2,27044E-3

8,73427E-16

2,76998E-2

2,40463E0

9,20524E-2

9,98909E2

1,26358E0

7,58654E-15

2,59131E-13

9,88752E1

1,67027E-13

5,82257E-4

1,03270E0

1,12742E-18

5,30051E-14

3,38956E-5

7,03842E-12

1,51585E-2

8.8

min

1,32765E0

6,23625E-23

2,39494E-13

4,99987E1

5,36150E-22

3,21802E-8

2,49929E-11

8,58250E-2

1,46782E0

2,18639E-14

4,60923E-13

3,35116E-10

6,00000E1

1,59849E-12

6,40726E-2

2,27044E-3

1,07468E-22

2,05674E-2

1,55297E0

7,35422E-4

9,98909E2

1,26358E0

2,51152E-18

2,59131E-13

9,88752E1

1,67027E-13

5,82257E-4

3,58270E-3

1,25623E-23

3,79151E-16

3,38956E-5

7,03842E-12

5,15829E-6

8.8

max

1,80201E0

1,89047E-20

1,79835E-10

4,99994E1

6,18401E-18

2,95770E-7

6,29085E-6

1,61381E0

3,42091E0

4,16559E-9

2,57395E-8

2,47902E-7

6,00000E1

3,72515E-12

4,59401E-1

3,91667E-3

8,73427E-16

2,76998E-2

2,40463E0

9,20524E-2

9,99960E2

1,34270E0

7,58654E-15

5,36400E-13

9,99960E1

1,58840E-10

1,28760E-3

1,03270E0

1,12742E-18

5,30051E-14

1,85650E-2

1,11412E-9

1,51585E-2

8.8

mean

1,80201E0

6,23646E-23

1,54658E-10

4,99987E1

5,36171E-22

2,95770E-7

6,29082E-6

1,61381E0

3,42062E0

4,00361E-9

2,55166E-8

2,45980E-7

6,00000E1

3,52737E-12

4,59401E-1

3,91667E-3

1,07473E-22

2,05751E-2

1,55297E0

7,35696E-4

9,99956E2

1,34261E0

2,51156E-18

5,19411E-13

9,99957E1

9,66594E-13

1,28485E-3

3,58382E-3

1,25629E-23

3,79155E-16

1,85587E-2

1,08330E-9

5,15830E-6

8.8

relative error(%)

0,00

9.0

BioUML

1,78769E0

9,02238E-23

2,01747E-10

4,99986E1

7,79458E-22

3,41372E-7

7,58198E-6

1,56431E0

3,42255E0

5,09463E-9

3,15747E-8

3,04044E-7

6,00000E1

4,58972E-12

4,46293E-1

4,09321E-3

1,59590E-22

2,16432E-2

1,58235E0

7,84925E-4

9,99953E2

1,34139E0

3,38201E-18

6,61558E-13

9,99954E1

1,29415E-12

1,42316E-3

3,85499E-3

1,85579E-23

4,96700E-16

2,01049E-2

1,37456E-9

5,71413E-6

9.0

ByoDyn

1,78769E0

9,02238E-23

2,01747E-10

4,99986E1

7,79458E-22

3,41372E-7

7,58198E-6

1,56431E0

3,42255E0

5,09463E-9

3,15747E-8

3,04044E-7

6,00000E1

4,58972E-12

4,46293E-1

4,09321E-3

1,59590E-22

2,16432E-2

1,58235E0

7,84925E-4

9,99953E2

1,34139E0

3,38201E-18

6,61558E-13

9,99954E1

1,29415E-12

1,42316E-3

3,85499E-3

1,85579E-23

4,96700E-16

2,01049E-2

1,37456E-9

5,71413E-6

9.0

MathSBML

1,78769E0

9,02268E-23

2,01748E-10

4,99986E1

7,79486E-22

3,41372E-7

7,58199E-6

1,56431E0

3,42255E0

5,09465E-9

3,15747E-8

3,04044E-7

6,00000E1

4,58975E-12

4,46293E-1

4,09321E-3

1,59597E-22

2,16432E-2

1,58235E0

7,84925E-4

9,99953E2

1,34139E0

3,38207E-18

6,61560E-13

9,99954E1

1,29416E-12

1,42316E-3

3,85499E-3

1,85586E-23

4,96704E-16

2,01049E-2

1,37457E-9

5,71413E-6

9.0

Oscill8 Core

9,02323E-23

2,27829E-10

4,99986E1

7,79537E-22

7,58201E-6

1,56431E0

3,42255E0

5,25830E-9

3,15748E-8

3,04045E-7

6,00000E1

4,46293E-1

4,09321E-3

1,59608E-22

2,16432E-2

1,58235E0

9,99953E2

1,34139E0

3,38218E-18

6,61563E-13

9,99954E1

1,60222E-10

3,85499E-3

1,85598E-23

4,96710E-16

2,01049E-2

5,71413E-6

9.0

SBToolbox2

1,78743E0

9,84854E-23

2,11299E-10

4,99990E1

8,53841E-22

3,39399E-7

7,52917E-6

1,56385E0

3,42281E0

5,21436E-9

3,17049E-8

3,05064E-7

6,00000E1

4,79203E-12

4,45946E-1

4,09219E-3

1,74168E-22

2,16354E-2

1,58255E0

7,84650E-4

9,99950E2

1,34149E0

3,68699E-18

6,77691E-13

9,99950E1

1,39824E-12

1,42582E-3

3,85378E-3

2,01504E-23

5,22985E-16

2,01100E-2

1,40292E-9

5,72498E-6

9.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,78769E0

9,02254E-23

2,01749E-10

4,99986E1

7,79473E-22

3,41373E-7

7,58201E-6

1,56431E0

3,42255E0

5,09466E-9

3,15748E-8

3,04045E-7

6,00000E1

4,58975E-12

4,46293E-1

4,09321E-3

1,59593E-22

2,16432E-2

1,58235E0

7,84925E-4

9,99953E2

1,34139E0

3,38205E-18

6,61562E-13

9,99954E1

1,29416E-12

1,42316E-3

3,85499E-3

1,85583E-23

4,96704E-16

2,01049E-2

1,37457E-9

5,71413E-6

9.0

VCell

1,78769E0

9,02240E-23

2,01747E-10

4,99986E1

7,79460E-22

3,41372E-7

7,58199E-6

1,56431E0

3,42255E0

5,09464E-9

3,15747E-8

3,04044E-7

6,00000E1

4,58973E-12

4,46293E-1

4,09321E-3

1,59590E-22

2,16432E-2

1,58235E0

7,84925E-4

9,99953E2

1,34139E0

3,38202E-18

6,61558E-13

9,99954E1

1,29415E-12

1,42316E-3

3,85499E-3

1,85579E-23

4,96701E-16

2,01049E-2

1,37456E-9

5,71413E-6

9.0

copasi

1,78769E0

9,02345E-23

2,01753E-10

4,99986E1

7,79577E-22

3,41372E-7

7,58199E-6

1,56431E0

3,42255E0

5,09463E-9

3,15747E-8

3,04045E-7

6,00000E1

4,43942E-12

4,46293E-1

4,09321E-3

1,59621E-22

2,16432E-2

1,58235E0

7,84925E-4

9,99953E2

1,34139E0

3,38221E-18

6,61564E-13

9,99954E1

1,24512E-12

1,42316E-3

3,85499E-3

1,85604E-23

4,96714E-16

2,01049E-2

1,37458E-9

5,71413E-6

9.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,78769E0

9,02256E-23

2,01748E-10

4,99986E1

7,79476E-22

3,41372E-7

7,58199E-6

1,56431E0

3,42255E0

5,09463E-9

3,15747E-8

3,04044E-7

6,00000E1

4,50927E-12

4,46293E-1

4,09321E-3

1,59595E-22

2,16432E-2

1,58235E0

7,84925E-4

9,99953E2

1,34139E0

3,38204E-18

6,61558E-13

9,99954E1

1,28547E-12

1,42316E-3

3,85499E-3

1,85584E-23

4,96701E-16

2,01049E-2

1,37454E-9

5,71413E-6

9.0

jsim

1,30836E0

2,09526E-20

2,59083E-13

4,99994E1

7,06683E-18

3,33973E-8

2,55791E-11

8,42418E-2

1,45151E0

2,32531E-14

4,73452E-13

3,50123E-10

6,00000E1

1,72607E-12

6,30767E-2

2,26534E-3

1,01130E-15

2,77756E-2

2,39795E0

9,37494E-2

9,98884E2

1,24528E0

8,37109E-15

2,72502E-13

9,88500E1

1,85110E-13

5,98606E-4

1,05621E0

1,28200E-18

5,72191E-14

3,42276E-5

7,38274E-12

1,56848E-2

9.0

min

1,30836E0

9,02238E-23

2,59083E-13

4,99986E1

7,79458E-22

3,33973E-8

2,55791E-11

8,42418E-2

1,45151E0

2,32531E-14

4,73452E-13

3,50123E-10

6,00000E1

1,72607E-12

6,30767E-2

2,26534E-3

1,59590E-22

2,16354E-2

1,58235E0

7,84650E-4

9,98884E2

1,24528E0

3,38201E-18

2,72502E-13

9,88500E1

1,85110E-13

5,98606E-4

3,85378E-3

1,85579E-23

4,96700E-16

3,42276E-5

7,38274E-12

5,71413E-6

9.0

max

1,78769E0

2,09526E-20

2,27829E-10

4,99994E1

7,06683E-18

3,41373E-7

7,58201E-6

1,56431E0

3,42281E0

5,25830E-9

3,17049E-8

3,05064E-7

6,00000E1

4,79203E-12

4,46293E-1

4,09321E-3

1,01130E-15

2,77756E-2

2,39795E0

9,37494E-2

9,99953E2

1,34149E0

8,37109E-15

6,77691E-13

9,99954E1

1,60222E-10

1,42582E-3

1,05621E0

1,28200E-18

5,72191E-14

2,01100E-2

1,40292E-9

1,56848E-2

9.0

mean

1,78769E0

9,02268E-23

2,01748E-10

4,99986E1

7,79486E-22

3,41372E-7

7,58199E-6

1,56431E0

3,42255E0

5,09464E-9

3,15747E-8

3,04044E-7

6,00000E1

4,58972E-12

4,46293E-1

4,09321E-3

1,59597E-22

2,16432E-2

1,58235E0

7,84925E-4

9,99953E2

1,34139E0

3,38207E-18

6,61560E-13

9,99954E1

1,29415E-12

1,42316E-3

3,85499E-3

1,85586E-23

4,96704E-16

2,01049E-2

1,37456E-9

5,71413E-6

9.0

relative error(%)

0,00

9.2

BioUML

1,77390E0

1,29222E-22

2,61228E-10

4,99984E1

1,12150E-21

3,92209E-7

9,08740E-6

1,51666E0

3,42420E0

6,43892E-9

3,88293E-8

3,73486E-7

6,00000E1

5,92776E-12

4,33789E-1

4,27142E-3

2,34390E-22

2,27265E-2

1,61065E0

8,35671E-4

9,99950E2

1,34011E0

4,51790E-18

8,36882E-13

9,99950E1

1,71885E-12

1,57149E-3

4,13645E-3

2,71216E-23

6,45884E-16

2,17265E-2

1,73226E-9

6,31031E-6

9.2

ByoDyn

1,77390E0

1,29222E-22

2,61228E-10

4,99984E1

1,12150E-21

3,92209E-7

9,08740E-6

1,51666E0

3,42420E0

6,43892E-9

3,88293E-8

3,73486E-7

6,00000E1

5,92776E-12

4,33789E-1

4,27142E-3

2,34390E-22

2,27265E-2

1,61065E0

8,35671E-4

9,99950E2

1,34011E0

4,51790E-18

8,36882E-13

9,99950E1

1,71885E-12

1,57149E-3

4,13645E-3

2,71216E-23

6,45884E-16

2,17265E-2

1,73226E-9

6,31031E-6

9.2

MathSBML

1,77390E0

1,29226E-22

2,61229E-10

4,99984E1

1,12154E-21

3,92209E-7

9,08740E-6

1,51666E0

3,42420E0

6,43894E-9

3,88293E-8

3,73487E-7

6,00000E1

5,92780E-12

4,33789E-1

4,27142E-3

2,34400E-22

2,27265E-2

1,61065E0

8,35671E-4

9,99950E2

1,34011E0

4,51797E-18

8,36885E-13

9,99950E1

1,71888E-12

1,57149E-3

4,13645E-3

2,71226E-23

6,45889E-16

2,17265E-2

1,73226E-9

6,31031E-6

9.2

Oscill8 Core

1,29232E-22

2,88195E-10

4,99984E1

1,12159E-21

9,08742E-6

1,51666E0

3,42420E0

6,60418E-9

3,88294E-8

3,73488E-7

6,00000E1

4,33789E-1

4,27142E-3

2,34411E-22

2,27265E-2

1,61065E0

9,99950E2

1,34011E0

4,51808E-18

8,36887E-13

9,99950E1

1,61587E-10

4,13645E-3

2,71239E-23

6,45894E-16

2,17265E-2

6,31032E-6

9.2

SBToolbox2

1,77364E0

1,41684E-22

2,73486E-10

4,99980E1

1,23429E-21

3,89954E-7

9,02563E-6

1,51612E0

3,42441E0

6,58952E-9

3,89964E-8

3,74800E-7

6,00000E1

6,18600E-12

4,33461E-1

4,27041E-3

2,57581E-22

2,27184E-2

1,61091E0

8,35366E-4

9,99950E2

1,34019E0

4,92422E-18

8,57203E-13

9,99950E1

1,85624E-12

1,57422E-3

4,13505E-3

2,96458E-23

6,79874E-16

2,17316E-2

1,76775E-9

6,32157E-6

9.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,77390E0

1,29224E-22

2,61229E-10

4,99984E1

1,12152E-21

3,92210E-7

9,08742E-6

1,51666E0

3,42420E0

6,43895E-9

3,88294E-8

3,73488E-7

6,00000E1

5,92780E-12

4,33789E-1

4,27142E-3

2,34394E-22

2,27265E-2

1,61065E0

8,35671E-4

9,99950E2

1,34011E0

4,51794E-18

8,36886E-13

9,99950E1

1,71887E-12

1,57149E-3

4,13645E-3

2,71221E-23

6,45888E-16

2,17265E-2

1,73226E-9

6,31032E-6

9.2

VCell

1,77390E0

1,29224E-22

2,61230E-10

4,99984E1

1,12152E-21

3,92210E-7

9,08742E-6

1,51666E0

3,42420E0

6,43896E-9

3,88295E-8

3,73488E-7

6,00000E1

5,92780E-12

4,33789E-1

4,27142E-3

2,34393E-22

2,27265E-2

1,61065E0

8,35671E-4

9,99950E2

1,34011E0

4,51795E-18

8,36887E-13

9,99950E1

1,71887E-12

1,57149E-3

4,13645E-3

2,71220E-23

6,45889E-16

2,17265E-2

1,73227E-9

6,31032E-6

9.2

copasi

1,77390E0

1,29236E-22

2,61233E-10

4,99984E1

1,12164E-21

3,92209E-7

9,08740E-6

1,51666E0

3,42420E0

6,43891E-9

3,88294E-8

3,73487E-7

6,00000E1

5,77502E-12

4,33789E-1

4,27142E-3

2,34425E-22

2,27265E-2

1,61065E0

8,35671E-4

9,99950E2

1,34011E0

4,51813E-18

8,36889E-13

9,99950E1

1,66607E-12

1,57149E-3

4,13645E-3

2,71253E-23

6,45898E-16

2,17265E-2

1,73226E-9

6,31031E-6

9.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,77390E0

1,29224E-22

2,61228E-10

4,99984E1

1,12152E-21

3,92209E-7

9,08740E-6

1,51666E0

3,42420E0

6,43891E-9

3,88293E-8

3,73487E-7

6,00000E1

5,80045E-12

4,33789E-1

4,27142E-3

2,34396E-22

2,27265E-2

1,61065E0

8,35671E-4

9,99950E2

1,34011E0

4,51793E-18

8,36882E-13

9,99950E1

1,70721E-12

1,57149E-3

4,13645E-3

2,71222E-23

6,45885E-16

2,17265E-2

1,73224E-9

6,31031E-6

9.2

jsim

1,28988E0

2,31449E-20

2,79768E-13

4,99994E1

8,04201E-18

3,46136E-8

2,61641E-11

8,27705E-2

1,43598E0

2,46979E-14

4,85992E-13

3,65264E-10

6,00000E1

1,85929E-12

6,21299E-2

2,26000E-3

1,16504E-15

2,78457E-2

2,39104E0

9,53851E-2

9,98860E2

1,22775E0

9,20665E-15

2,86105E-13

9,88255E1

2,04525E-13

6,14795E-4

1,07915E0

1,45143E-18

6,16167E-14

3,45546E-5

7,73169E-12

1,62124E-2

9.2

min

1,28988E0

1,29222E-22

2,79768E-13

4,99980E1

1,12150E-21

3,46136E-8

2,61641E-11

8,27705E-2

1,43598E0

2,46979E-14

4,85992E-13

3,65264E-10

6,00000E1

1,85929E-12

6,21299E-2

2,26000E-3

2,34390E-22

2,27184E-2

1,61065E0

8,35366E-4

9,98860E2

1,22775E0

4,51790E-18

2,86105E-13

9,88255E1

2,04525E-13

6,14795E-4

4,13505E-3

2,71216E-23

6,45884E-16

3,45546E-5

7,73169E-12

6,31031E-6

9.2

max

1,77390E0

2,31449E-20

2,88195E-10

4,99994E1

8,04201E-18

3,92210E-7

9,08742E-6

1,51666E0

3,42441E0

6,60418E-9

3,89964E-8

3,74800E-7

6,00000E1

6,18600E-12

4,33789E-1

4,27142E-3

1,16504E-15

2,78457E-2

2,39104E0

9,53851E-2

9,99950E2

1,34019E0

9,20665E-15

8,57203E-13

9,99950E1

1,61587E-10

1,57422E-3

1,07915E0

1,45143E-18

6,16167E-14

2,17316E-2

1,76775E-9

1,62124E-2

9.2

mean

1,77390E0

1,29226E-22

2,61229E-10

4,99984E1

1,12154E-21

3,92209E-7

9,08740E-6

1,51666E0

3,42420E0

6,43894E-9

3,88294E-8

3,73487E-7

6,00000E1

5,92778E-12

4,33789E-1

4,27142E-3

2,34400E-22

2,27265E-2

1,61065E0

8,35671E-4

9,99950E2

1,34011E0

4,51797E-18

8,36886E-13

9,99950E1

1,71887E-12

1,57149E-3

4,13645E-3

2,71226E-23

6,45889E-16

2,17265E-2

1,73226E-9

6,31032E-6

9.2

relative error(%)

0,00

9.4

BioUML

1,76063E0

1,83306E-22

3,35861E-10

4,99983E1

1,59781E-21

4,48667E-7

1,08342E-5

1,47080E0

3,42560E0

8,08528E-9

4,74697E-8

4,56086E-7

6,00000E1

7,60183E-12

4,21852E-1

4,45121E-3

3,40652E-22

2,38240E-2

1,63790E0

8,87907E-4

9,99947E2

1,33877E0

5,98942E-18

1,05182E-12

9,99947E1

2,26556E-12

1,73019E-3

4,42808E-3

3,92336E-23

8,33961E-16

2,34244E-2

2,16888E-9

6,94825E-6

9.4

ByoDyn

1,76063E0

1,83306E-22

3,35861E-10

4,99983E1

1,59781E-21

4,48667E-7

1,08342E-5

1,47080E0

3,42560E0

8,08528E-9

4,74697E-8

4,56086E-7

6,00000E1

7,60183E-12

4,21852E-1

4,45121E-3

3,40652E-22

2,38240E-2

1,63790E0

8,87907E-4

9,99947E2

1,33877E0

5,98942E-18

1,05182E-12

9,99947E1

2,26556E-12

1,73019E-3

4,42808E-3

3,92336E-23

8,33961E-16

2,34244E-2

2,16888E-9

6,94825E-6

9.4

MathSBML

1,76063E0

1,83314E-22

3,35863E-10

4,99983E1

1,59789E-21

4,48667E-7

1,08342E-5

1,47080E0

3,42560E0

8,08530E-9

4,74697E-8

4,56086E-7

6,00000E1

7,60187E-12

4,21852E-1

4,45121E-3

3,40672E-22

2,38240E-2

1,63790E0

8,87907E-4

9,99947E2

1,33877E0

5,98952E-18

1,05182E-12

9,99947E1

2,26559E-12

1,73019E-3

4,42808E-3

3,92355E-23

8,33968E-16

2,34244E-2

2,16889E-9

6,94825E-6

9.4

Oscill8 Core

1,83317E-22

3,63697E-10

4,99983E1

1,59792E-21

1,08343E-5

1,47080E0

3,42560E0

8,25206E-9

4,74698E-8

4,56087E-7

6,00000E1

4,21852E-1

4,45121E-3

3,40677E-22

2,38240E-2

1,63790E0

9,99947E2

1,33877E0

5,98961E-18

1,05183E-12

9,99947E1

1,62968E-10

4,42808E-3

3,92362E-23

8,33972E-16

2,34244E-2

6,94825E-6

9.4

SBToolbox2

1,76036E0

2,04519E-22

3,53408E-10

4,99980E1

1,79065E-21

4,46369E-7

1,07806E-5

1,47026E0

3,42590E0

8,30679E-9

4,78058E-8

4,58925E-7

6,00000E1

7,97128E-12

4,21515E-1

4,45014E-3

3,82701E-22

2,38154E-2

1,63818E0

8,87569E-4

9,99950E2

1,33889E0

6,57812E-18

1,08164E-12

9,99950E1

2,46336E-12

1,73329E-3

4,42649E-3

4,38038E-23

8,82731E-16

2,34302E-2

2,22150E-9

6,96069E-6

9.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,76063E0

1,83309E-22

3,35862E-10

4,99983E1

1,59783E-21

4,48668E-7

1,08343E-5

1,47080E0

3,42560E0

8,08531E-9

4,74698E-8

4,56087E-7

6,00000E1

7,60186E-12

4,21852E-1

4,45121E-3

3,40657E-22

2,38240E-2

1,63790E0

8,87907E-4

9,99947E2

1,33877E0

5,98946E-18

1,05183E-12

9,99947E1

2,26557E-12

1,73019E-3

4,42808E-3

3,92341E-23

8,33965E-16

2,34244E-2

2,16889E-9

6,94825E-6

9.4

VCell

1,76063E0

1,83308E-22

3,35863E-10

4,99983E1

1,59783E-21

4,48668E-7

1,08343E-5

1,47080E0

3,42560E0

8,08532E-9

4,74699E-8

4,56087E-7

6,00000E1

7,60188E-12

4,21852E-1

4,45121E-3

3,40657E-22

2,38240E-2

1,63790E0

8,87907E-4

9,99947E2

1,33877E0

5,98947E-18

1,05183E-12

9,99947E1

2,26558E-12

1,73019E-3

4,42808E-3

3,92341E-23

8,33967E-16

2,34244E-2

2,16889E-9

6,94826E-6

9.4

copasi

1,76063E0

1,83322E-22

3,35866E-10

4,99983E1

1,59797E-21

4,48667E-7

1,08342E-5

1,47080E0

3,42560E0

8,08527E-9

4,74698E-8

4,56086E-7

6,00000E1

7,55177E-12

4,21852E-1

4,45121E-3

3,40692E-22

2,38240E-2

1,63790E0

8,87907E-4

9,99947E2

1,33877E0

5,98968E-18

1,05183E-12

9,99947E1

2,20957E-12

1,73019E-3

4,42808E-3

3,92377E-23

8,33977E-16

2,34244E-2

2,16890E-9

6,94825E-6

9.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,76063E0

1,83309E-22

3,35861E-10

4,99983E1

1,59784E-21

4,48667E-7

1,08342E-5

1,47080E0

3,42560E0

8,08527E-9

4,74697E-8

4,56086E-7

6,00000E1

7,52176E-12

4,21852E-1

4,45121E-3

3,40659E-22

2,38240E-2

1,63790E0

8,87907E-4

9,99947E2

1,33877E0

5,98945E-18

1,05182E-12

9,99947E1

2,24893E-12

1,73019E-3

4,42808E-3

3,92343E-23

8,33963E-16

2,34244E-2

2,16887E-9

6,94825E-6

9.4

jsim

1,27217E0

2,54860E-20

3,01583E-13

4,99994E1

9,11546E-18

3,58287E-8

2,67481E-11

8,13997E-2

1,42118E0

2,61991E-14

4,98550E-13

3,80533E-10

6,00000E1

1,99817E-12

6,12283E-2

2,25447E-3

1,33577E-15

2,79107E-2

2,38396E0

9,69606E-2

9,98836E2

1,21094E0

1,00944E-14

2,99936E-13

9,88015E1

2,25323E-13

6,30826E-4

1,10154E0

1,63650E-18

6,61989E-14

3,48773E-5

8,08518E-12

1,67411E-2

9.4

min

1,27217E0

1,83306E-22

3,01583E-13

4,99980E1

1,59781E-21

3,58287E-8

2,67481E-11

8,13997E-2

1,42118E0

2,61991E-14

4,98550E-13

3,80533E-10

6,00000E1

1,99817E-12

6,12283E-2

2,25447E-3

3,40652E-22

2,38154E-2

1,63790E0

8,87569E-4

9,98836E2

1,21094E0

5,98942E-18

2,99936E-13

9,88015E1

2,25323E-13

6,30826E-4

4,42649E-3

3,92336E-23

8,33961E-16

3,48773E-5

8,08518E-12

6,94825E-6

9.4

max

1,76063E0

2,54860E-20

3,63697E-10

4,99994E1

9,11546E-18

4,48668E-7

1,08343E-5

1,47080E0

3,42590E0

8,30679E-9

4,78058E-8

4,58925E-7

6,00000E1

7,97128E-12

4,21852E-1

4,45121E-3

1,33577E-15

2,79107E-2

2,38396E0

9,69606E-2

9,99950E2

1,33889E0

1,00944E-14

1,08164E-12

9,99950E1

1,62968E-10

1,73329E-3

1,10154E0

1,63650E-18

6,61989E-14

2,34302E-2

2,22150E-9

1,67411E-2

9.4

mean

1,76063E0

1,83314E-22

3,35863E-10

4,99983E1

1,59789E-21

4,48667E-7

1,08342E-5

1,47080E0

3,42560E0

8,08530E-9

4,74698E-8

4,56086E-7

6,00000E1

7,60184E-12

4,21852E-1

4,45121E-3

3,40672E-22

2,38240E-2

1,63790E0

8,87907E-4

9,99947E2

1,33877E0

5,98952E-18

1,05183E-12

9,99947E1

2,26557E-12

1,73019E-3

4,42808E-3

3,92355E-23

8,33968E-16

2,34244E-2

2,16889E-9

6,94825E-6

9.4

relative error(%)

0,00

9.6

BioUML

1,74783E0

2,57655E-22

4,28915E-10

4,99981E1

2,25513E-21

5,11144E-7

1,28520E-5

1,42667E0

3,42679E0

1,00900E-8

5,77077E-8

5,53828E-7

6,00000E1

9,68303E-12

4,10447E-1

4,63247E-3

4,90157E-22

2,49351E-2

1,66412E0

9,41602E-4

9,99943E2

1,33738E0

7,88265E-18

1,31382E-12

9,99943E1

2,96446E-12

1,89958E-3

4,72975E-3

5,62031E-23

1,06958E-15

2,51992E-2

2,69879E-9

7,62931E-6

9.6

ByoDyn

1,74783E0

2,57655E-22

4,28915E-10

4,99981E1

2,25513E-21

5,11144E-7

1,28520E-5

1,42667E0

3,42679E0

1,00900E-8

5,77077E-8

5,53828E-7

6,00000E1

9,68303E-12

4,10447E-1

4,63247E-3

4,90157E-22

2,49351E-2

1,66412E0

9,41602E-4

9,99943E2

1,33738E0

7,88265E-18

1,31382E-12

9,99943E1

2,96446E-12

1,89958E-3

4,72975E-3

5,62031E-23

1,06958E-15

2,51992E-2

2,69879E-9

7,62931E-6

9.6

MathSBML

1,74783E0

2,57661E-22

4,28916E-10

4,99981E1

2,25519E-21

5,11144E-7

1,28520E-5

1,42667E0

3,42679E0

1,00900E-8

5,77077E-8

5,53827E-7

6,00000E1

9,68306E-12

4,10447E-1

4,63247E-3

4,90172E-22

2,49351E-2

1,66412E0

9,41602E-4

9,99943E2

1,33738E0

7,88273E-18

1,31382E-12

9,99943E1

2,96448E-12

1,89958E-3

4,72975E-3

5,62049E-23

1,06958E-15

2,51992E-2

2,69880E-9

7,62931E-6

9.6

Oscill8 Core

2,57668E-22

4,57601E-10

4,99981E1

2,25525E-21

1,28521E-5

1,42667E0

3,42679E0

1,02582E-8

5,77078E-8

5,53828E-7

6,00000E1

4,10447E-1

4,63247E-3

4,90186E-22

2,49351E-2

1,66412E0

9,99943E2

1,33738E0

7,88285E-18

1,31382E-12

9,99943E1

1,64398E-10

4,72975E-3

5,62062E-23

1,06959E-15

2,51992E-2

7,62931E-6

9.6

SBToolbox2

1,74758E0

2,86976E-22

4,51084E-10

4,99980E1

2,52295E-21

5,08661E-7

1,27933E-5

1,42611E0

3,42700E0

1,03665E-8

5,81322E-8

5,57412E-7

6,00000E1

1,01478E-11

4,10108E-1

4,63136E-3

5,49548E-22

2,49262E-2

1,66445E0

9,41229E-4

9,99940E2

1,33750E0

8,64858E-18

1,35099E-12

9,99940E1

3,21967E-12

1,90285E-3

4,72792E-3

6,26236E-23

1,13155E-15

2,52046E-2

2,76408E-9

7,64241E-6

9.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,74783E0

2,57655E-22

4,28916E-10

4,99981E1

2,25515E-21

5,11144E-7

1,28521E-5

1,42667E0

3,42679E0

1,00901E-8

5,77078E-8

5,53828E-7

6,00000E1

9,68306E-12

4,10447E-1

4,63248E-3

4,90163E-22

2,49351E-2

1,66412E0

9,41602E-4

9,99943E2

1,33738E0

7,88269E-18

1,31382E-12

9,99943E1

2,96447E-12

1,89958E-3

4,72975E-3

5,62038E-23

1,06958E-15

2,51992E-2

2,69880E-9

7,62931E-6

9.6

VCell

1,74783E0

2,57658E-22

4,28918E-10

4,99981E1

2,25516E-21

5,11144E-7

1,28521E-5

1,42667E0

3,42679E0

1,00901E-8

5,77079E-8

5,53830E-7

6,00000E1

9,68309E-12

4,10447E-1

4,63247E-3

4,90163E-22

2,49351E-2

1,66412E0

9,41602E-4

9,99943E2

1,33738E0

7,88271E-18

1,31382E-12

9,99943E1

2,96448E-12

1,89958E-3

4,72975E-3

5,62038E-23

1,06959E-15

2,51992E-2

2,69881E-9

7,62931E-6

9.6

copasi

1,74783E0

2,57675E-22

4,28920E-10

4,99981E1

2,25532E-21

5,11144E-7

1,28520E-5

1,42667E0

3,42679E0

1,00900E-8

5,77078E-8

5,53828E-7

6,00000E1

9,79598E-12

4,10447E-1

4,63247E-3

4,90207E-22

2,49351E-2

1,66412E0

9,41602E-4

9,99943E2

1,33738E0

7,88295E-18

1,31382E-12

9,99943E1

2,90775E-12

1,89958E-3

4,72975E-3

5,62084E-23

1,06960E-15

2,51992E-2

2,69882E-9

7,62931E-6

9.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,74783E0

2,57658E-22

4,28915E-10

4,99981E1

2,25516E-21

5,11144E-7

1,28520E-5

1,42667E0

3,42679E0

1,00900E-8

5,77077E-8

5,53828E-7

6,00000E1

9,56323E-12

4,10447E-1

4,63247E-3

4,90166E-22

2,49351E-2

1,66412E0

9,41602E-4

9,99943E2

1,33738E0

7,88268E-18

1,31382E-12

9,99943E1

2,94409E-12

1,89958E-3

4,72975E-3

5,62041E-23

1,06958E-15

2,51992E-2

2,69878E-9

7,62931E-6

9.6

jsim

1,25518E0

2,79806E-20

3,24562E-13

4,99994E1

1,02932E-17

3,70421E-8

2,73315E-11

8,01189E-2

1,40707E0

2,77573E-14

5,11130E-13

3,95926E-10

6,00000E1

2,14274E-12

6,03686E-2

2,24877E-3

1,52460E-15

2,79710E-2

2,37675E0

9,84777E-2

9,98813E2

1,19481E0

1,10355E-14

3,13991E-13

9,87782E1

2,47556E-13

6,46700E-4

1,12337E0

1,83799E-18

7,09665E-14

3,51959E-5

8,44307E-12

1,72710E-2

9.6

min

1,25518E0

2,57655E-22

3,24562E-13

4,99980E1

2,25513E-21

3,70421E-8

2,73315E-11

8,01189E-2

1,40707E0

2,77573E-14

5,11130E-13

3,95926E-10

6,00000E1

2,14274E-12

6,03686E-2

2,24877E-3

4,90157E-22

2,49262E-2

1,66412E0

9,41229E-4

9,98813E2

1,19481E0

7,88265E-18

3,13991E-13

9,87782E1

2,47556E-13

6,46700E-4

4,72792E-3

5,62031E-23

1,06958E-15

3,51959E-5

8,44307E-12

7,62931E-6

9.6

max

1,74783E0

2,79806E-20

4,57601E-10

4,99994E1

1,02932E-17

5,11144E-7

1,28521E-5

1,42667E0

3,42700E0

1,03665E-8

5,81322E-8

5,57412E-7

6,00000E1

1,01478E-11

4,10447E-1

4,63248E-3

1,52460E-15

2,79710E-2

2,37675E0

9,84777E-2

9,99943E2

1,33750E0

1,10355E-14

1,35099E-12

9,99943E1

1,64398E-10

1,90285E-3

1,12337E0

1,83799E-18

7,09665E-14

2,52046E-2

2,76408E-9

1,72710E-2

9.6

mean

1,74783E0

2,57661E-22

4,28916E-10

4,99981E1

2,25519E-21

5,11144E-7

1,28520E-5

1,42667E0

3,42679E0

1,00900E-8

5,77078E-8

5,53828E-7

6,00000E1

9,68306E-12

4,10447E-1

4,63247E-3

4,90172E-22

2,49351E-2

1,66412E0

9,41602E-4

9,99943E2

1,33738E0

7,88273E-18

1,31382E-12

9,99943E1

2,96447E-12

1,89958E-3

4,72975E-3

5,62049E-23

1,06959E-15

2,51992E-2

2,69880E-9

7,62931E-6

9.6

relative error(%)

0,00

9.8

BioUML

1,73549E0

3,59006E-22

5,44238E-10

4,99979E1

3,15448E-21

5,80045E-7

1,51728E-5

1,38422E0

3,42778E0

1,25179E-8

6,97793E-8

6,68921E-7

6,00000E1

1,22548E-11

3,99543E-1

4,81511E-3

6,98574E-22

2,60590E-2

1,68934E0

9,96727E-4

9,99940E2

1,33595E0

1,03025E-17

1,63142E-12

9,99940E1

3,85206E-12

2,08001E-3

5,04132E-3

7,97658E-23

1,36298E-15

2,70516E-2

3,33840E-9

8,35484E-6

9.8

ByoDyn

1,73549E0

3,59006E-22

5,44238E-10

4,99979E1

3,15448E-21

5,80045E-7

1,51728E-5

1,38422E0

3,42778E0

1,25179E-8

6,97793E-8

6,68921E-7

6,00000E1

1,22548E-11

3,99543E-1

4,81511E-3

6,98574E-22

2,60590E-2

1,68934E0

9,96727E-4

9,99940E2

1,33595E0

1,03025E-17

1,63142E-12

9,99940E1

3,85206E-12

2,08001E-3

5,04132E-3

7,97658E-23

1,36298E-15

2,70516E-2

3,33840E-9

8,35484E-6

9.8

MathSBML

1,73549E0

3,59019E-22

5,44240E-10

4,99979E1

3,15458E-21

5,80045E-7

1,51728E-5

1,38422E0

3,42778E0

1,25179E-8

6,97793E-8

6,68921E-7

6,00000E1

1,22548E-11

3,99543E-1

4,81512E-3

6,98600E-22

2,60590E-2

1,68934E0

9,96727E-4

9,99940E2

1,33595E0

1,03026E-17

1,63143E-12

9,99940E1

3,85210E-12

2,08001E-3

5,04132E-3

7,97695E-23

1,36298E-15

2,70516E-2

3,33840E-9

8,35484E-6

9.8

Oscill8 Core

3,59020E-22

5,73757E-10

4,99979E1

3,15461E-21

1,51728E-5

1,38422E0

3,42778E0

1,26874E-8

6,97793E-8

6,68921E-7

6,00000E1

3,99543E-1

4,81511E-3

6,98606E-22

2,60590E-2

1,68934E0

9,99940E2

1,33595E0

1,03027E-17

1,63143E-12

9,99940E1

1,65917E-10

5,04132E-3

7,97692E-23

1,36299E-15

2,70516E-2

8,35484E-6

9.8

SBToolbox2

1,73529E0

3,96931E-22

5,69093E-10

4,99980E1

3,49666E-21

5,77553E-7

1,51085E-5

1,38366E0

3,42800E0

1,28107E-8

7,01441E-8

6,71875E-7

6,00000E1

1,27719E-11

3,99229E-1

4,81408E-3

7,75463E-22

2,60511E-2

1,68963E0

9,96346E-4

9,99940E2

1,33600E0

1,12069E-17

1,67115E-12

9,99940E1

4,14996E-12

2,08319E-3

5,03942E-3

8,82588E-23

1,43324E-15

2,70559E-2

3,40671E-9

8,36775E-6

9.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,73549E0

3,59007E-22

5,44239E-10

4,99979E1

3,15450E-21

5,80045E-7

1,51728E-5

1,38422E0

3,42778E0

1,25179E-8

6,97793E-8

6,68921E-7

6,00000E1

1,22548E-11

3,99543E-1

4,81511E-3

6,98579E-22

2,60590E-2

1,68934E0

9,96727E-4

9,99940E2

1,33595E0

1,03025E-17

1,63143E-12

9,99940E1

3,85207E-12

2,08001E-3

5,04132E-3

7,97664E-23

1,36298E-15

2,70516E-2

3,33840E-9

8,35484E-6

9.8

VCell

1,73549E0

3,59010E-22

5,44241E-10

4,99979E1

3,15451E-21

5,80046E-7

1,51728E-5

1,38422E0

3,42778E0

1,25179E-8

6,97795E-8

6,68923E-7

6,00000E1

1,22548E-11

3,99543E-1

4,81511E-3

6,98582E-22

2,60590E-2

1,68934E0

9,96727E-4

9,99940E2

1,33595E0

1,03026E-17

1,63143E-12

9,99940E1

3,85209E-12

2,08002E-3

5,04132E-3

7,97666E-23

1,36299E-15

2,70516E-2

3,33841E-9

8,35484E-6

9.8

copasi

1,73549E0

3,59037E-22

5,44245E-10

4,99979E1

3,15477E-21

5,80045E-7

1,51728E-5

1,38422E0

3,42778E0

1,25179E-8

6,97794E-8

6,68922E-7

6,00000E1

1,24944E-11

3,99543E-1

4,81511E-3

6,98651E-22

2,60590E-2

1,68934E0

9,96727E-4

9,99940E2

1,33595E0

1,03029E-17

1,63144E-12

9,99940E1

3,80050E-12

2,08001E-3

5,04132E-3

7,97739E-23

1,36300E-15

2,70516E-2

3,33843E-9

8,35484E-6

9.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,73549E0

3,59010E-22

5,44238E-10

4,99979E1

3,15452E-21

5,80045E-7

1,51728E-5

1,38422E0

3,42778E0

1,25179E-8

6,97793E-8

6,68921E-7

6,00000E1

1,21159E-11

3,99543E-1

4,81511E-3

6,98584E-22

2,60590E-2

1,68934E0

9,96727E-4

9,99940E2

1,33595E0

1,03025E-17

1,63142E-12

9,99940E1

3,82787E-12

2,08001E-3

5,04132E-3

7,97669E-23

1,36298E-15

2,70516E-2

3,33838E-9

8,35484E-6

9.8

jsim

1,23888E0

3,06333E-20

3,48738E-13

4,99993E1

1,15812E-17

3,82536E-8

2,79146E-11

7,89194E-2

1,39360E0

2,93731E-14

5,23738E-13

4,11439E-10

6,00000E1

2,29304E-12

5,95476E-2

2,24295E-3

1,73269E-15

2,80270E-2

2,36944E0

9,99377E-2

9,98791E2

1,17933E0

1,20311E-14

3,28266E-13

9,87554E1

2,71275E-13

6,62416E-4

1,14466E0

2,05667E-18

7,59201E-14

3,55109E-5

8,80527E-12

1,78018E-2

9.8

min

1,23888E0

3,59006E-22

3,48738E-13

4,99979E1

3,15448E-21

3,82536E-8

2,79146E-11

7,89194E-2

1,39360E0

2,93731E-14

5,23738E-13

4,11439E-10

6,00000E1

2,29304E-12

5,95476E-2

2,24295E-3

6,98574E-22

2,60511E-2

1,68934E0

9,96346E-4

9,98791E2

1,17933E0

1,03025E-17

3,28266E-13

9,87554E1

2,71275E-13

6,62416E-4

5,03942E-3

7,97658E-23

1,36298E-15

3,55109E-5

8,80527E-12

8,35484E-6

9.8

max

1,73549E0

3,06333E-20

5,73757E-10

4,99993E1

1,15812E-17

5,80046E-7

1,51728E-5

1,38422E0

3,42800E0

1,28107E-8

7,01441E-8

6,71875E-7

6,00000E1

1,27719E-11

3,99543E-1

4,81512E-3

1,73269E-15

2,80270E-2

2,36944E0

9,99377E-2

9,99940E2

1,33600E0

1,20311E-14

1,67115E-12

9,99940E1

1,65917E-10

2,08319E-3

1,14466E0

2,05667E-18

7,59201E-14

2,70559E-2

3,40671E-9

1,78018E-2

9.8

mean

1,73549E0

3,59019E-22

5,44240E-10

4,99979E1

3,15458E-21

5,80045E-7

1,51728E-5

1,38422E0

3,42778E0

1,25179E-8

6,97793E-8

6,68921E-7

6,00000E1

1,22548E-11

3,99543E-1

4,81511E-3

6,98600E-22

2,60590E-2

1,68934E0

9,96727E-4

9,99940E2

1,33595E0

1,03026E-17

1,63143E-12

9,99940E1

3,85207E-12

2,08001E-3

5,04132E-3

7,97692E-23

1,36299E-15

2,70516E-2

3,33840E-9

8,35484E-6

9.8

relative error(%)

0,00

Test: BIOMD0000000093.xml - Ok

Reaction graph

Plots

Comparison with other simulators