Test BIOMD0000000090.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000090.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000090.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: DormandPrince
generated code	: BIOMD0000000090.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: plot
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: A2m A3c aco aps A3m sul S2 S1 N1 cys eth N2 pap A2c oxy hyd oah
Simulators: ByoDyn edu.kgi.roadRunner copasi SBToolbox2 Oscill8 Core SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

A2m

A3c

aco

aps

A3m

sul

cys

eth

pap

A2c

oxy

hyd

oah

0.0

BioUML

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,00000E0

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.0

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,00000E0

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.0

MathSBML

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,00000E0

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.0

Oscill8 Core

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

7,00000E0

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.0

SBToolbox2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,00000E0

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

7,00000E0

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.0

copasi

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,00000E0

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

7,00000E0

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.0

jsim

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,00000E0

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.0

min

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,00000E0

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.0

max

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,00000E0

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.0

mean

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,00000E0

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

4,11583E-1

1,50762E0

2,86933E-1

4,93583E-1

1,58842E0

3,80271E-1

4,35263E-1

1,56474E0

6,35875E-2

3,07765E-1

4,26594E0

1,93641E0

3,98929E-1

4,92383E-1

7,07978E0

5,13841E-1

1,47203E0

0.2

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,50762E0

2,86933E-1

4,93583E-1

1,58842E0

3,80271E-1

5,00000E-1

1,56474E0

0,00000E0

3,07765E-1

4,26594E0

1,93641E0

3,98929E-1

5,00000E-1

7,07978E0

5,13841E-1

1,47203E0

0.2

MathSBML

4,11583E-1

1,50762E0

2,86933E-1

4,93583E-1

1,58842E0

3,80271E-1

4,35263E-1

1,56474E0

6,35875E-2

3,07765E-1

4,26594E0

1,93641E0

3,98929E-1

4,92383E-1

7,07978E0

5,13841E-1

1,47203E0

0.2

Oscill8 Core

1,42501E0

4,06045E-2

4,93685E-1

1,25910E0

3,80617E-1

1,62970E0

3,07123E-1

4,80000E0

7,22783E-1

4,09215E-1

7,41799E0

5,03776E-1

1,32896E0

0.2

SBToolbox2

4,11365E-1

1,50769E0

2,86934E-1

4,93587E-1

1,58861E0

3,80269E-1

4,35251E-1

1,56475E0

6,35744E-2

3,07762E-1

4,26594E0

1,93639E0

3,98931E-1

4,92334E-1

7,07984E0

5,13836E-1

1,47202E0

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,50762E0

2,86933E-1

4,93583E-1

1,58841E0

3,80271E-1

1,56474E0

3,07765E-1

4,26595E0

1,93641E0

3,98929E-1

7,07979E0

5,13841E-1

1,47203E0

0.2

copasi

4,11583E-1

1,50762E0

2,86933E-1

4,93583E-1

1,58842E0

3,80271E-1

4,35263E-1

1,56474E0

6,35875E-2

3,07765E-1

4,26594E0

1,93641E0

3,98929E-1

4,92383E-1

7,07978E0

5,13841E-1

1,47203E0

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,32000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

4,80000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

2,30000E1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.2

jsim

4,11583E-1

1,50762E0

2,86933E-1

4,93583E-1

1,58842E0

3,80271E-1

4,35263E-1

1,56474E0

6,35875E-2

3,07765E-1

4,26594E0

1,93641E0

3,98929E-1

4,92383E-1

7,07978E0

5,13841E-1

1,47203E0

0.2

min

4,11365E-1

1,42501E0

4,06045E-2

4,93583E-1

1,25910E0

3,80269E-1

4,35251E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

4,26594E0

7,22783E-1

3,98929E-1

4,92334E-1

7,07978E0

5,00000E-1

1,32896E0

0.2

max

5,00000E-1

1,50769E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,58861E0

4,32000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,62970E0

6,35875E-2

3,07765E-1

4,80000E0

2,00000E0

4,09215E-1

5,00000E-1

2,30000E1

5,13841E-1

1,50000E0

0.2

mean

4,11583E-1

1,50762E0

2,86933E-1

4,93583E-1

1,58842E0

3,80271E-1

4,35263E-1

1,56474E0

6,35875E-2

3,07765E-1

4,26594E0

1,93641E0

3,98929E-1

4,92383E-1

7,07979E0

5,13841E-1

1,47203E0

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

4,30558E-1

1,50567E0

2,91658E-1

4,86388E-1

1,56944E0

3,61279E-1

3,89384E-1

1,61062E0

5,76395E-2

3,15512E-1

4,53355E0

1,94236E0

3,97577E-1

4,94332E-1

7,13139E0

5,27431E-1

1,45381E0

0.4

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,50567E0

2,91658E-1

4,86388E-1

1,56944E0

3,61279E-1

5,00000E-1

1,61062E0

0,00000E0

3,15512E-1

4,53355E0

1,94236E0

3,97577E-1

5,00000E-1

7,13139E0

5,27431E-1

1,45381E0

0.4

MathSBML

4,30558E-1

1,50567E0

2,91658E-1

4,86388E-1

1,56944E0

3,61279E-1

3,89384E-1

1,61062E0

5,76395E-2

3,15512E-1

4,53355E0

1,94236E0

3,97577E-1

4,94332E-1

7,13139E0

5,27431E-1

1,45381E0

0.4

Oscill8 Core

1,08988E0

5,49574E-3

4,87675E-1

7,22042E-1

3,65077E-1

1,64725E0

3,11808E-1

5,60000E0

2,55266E-1

4,26703E-1

7,75772E0

4,97159E-1

1,09253E0

0.4

SBToolbox2

4,30228E-1

1,50581E0

2,91682E-1

4,86385E-1

1,56975E0

3,61277E-1

3,89294E-1

1,61072E0

5,76151E-2

3,15514E-1

4,53345E0

1,94239E0

3,97573E-1

4,94200E-1

7,13151E0

5,27433E-1

1,45373E0

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,50567E0

2,91658E-1

4,86388E-1

1,56944E0

3,61279E-1

1,61061E0

3,15512E-1

4,53355E0

1,94236E0

3,97577E-1

7,13139E0

5,27431E-1

1,45381E0

0.4

copasi

4,30558E-1

1,50567E0

2,91658E-1

4,86388E-1

1,56944E0

3,61279E-1

3,89384E-1

1,61062E0

5,76398E-2

3,15512E-1

4,53355E0

1,94236E0

3,97577E-1

4,94333E-1

7,13139E0

5,27431E-1

1,45381E0

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,64000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,60000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

3,90000E1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.4

jsim

4,30558E-1

1,50567E0

2,91658E-1

4,86388E-1

1,56944E0

3,61279E-1

3,89384E-1

1,61062E0

5,76395E-2

3,15512E-1

4,53355E0

1,94236E0

3,97577E-1

4,94332E-1

7,13139E0

5,27431E-1

1,45381E0

0.4

min

4,30228E-1

1,08988E0

5,49574E-3

4,86385E-1

7,22042E-1

3,61277E-1

3,89294E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

4,53345E0

2,55266E-1

3,97573E-1

4,94200E-1

7,13139E0

4,97159E-1

1,09253E0

0.4

max

5,00000E-1

1,50581E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,56975E0

4,64000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,64725E0

5,76398E-2

3,15514E-1

5,60000E0

2,00000E0

4,26703E-1

5,00000E-1

3,90000E1

5,27433E-1

1,50000E0

0.4

mean

4,30558E-1

1,50567E0

2,91658E-1

4,86388E-1

1,56944E0

3,61279E-1

3,89384E-1

1,61062E0

5,76395E-2

3,15512E-1

4,53355E0

1,94236E0

3,97577E-1

4,94332E-1

7,13139E0

5,27431E-1

1,45381E0

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

4,59045E-1

1,49961E0

2,94798E-1

4,78551E-1

1,54096E0

3,43158E-1

3,51488E-1

1,64851E0

5,23383E-2

3,23308E-1

4,82009E0

1,94766E0

3,95719E-1

5,00392E-1

7,17705E0

5,40696E-1

1,44217E0

0.6

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,49961E0

2,94798E-1

4,78551E-1

1,54096E0

3,43158E-1

5,00000E-1

1,64851E0

0,00000E0

3,23308E-1

4,82009E0

1,94766E0

3,95719E-1

5,00000E-1

7,17705E0

5,40696E-1

1,44217E0

0.6

MathSBML

4,59045E-1

1,49961E0

2,94798E-1

4,78551E-1

1,54096E0

3,43158E-1

3,51488E-1

1,64851E0

5,23383E-2

3,23308E-1

4,82009E0

1,94766E0

3,95719E-1

5,00392E-1

7,17705E0

5,40696E-1

1,44217E0

0.6

Oscill8 Core

6,95132E-1

7,43836E-4

4,83223E-1

3,58659E-1

3,55573E-1

1,64963E0

3,14022E-1

6,40000E0

8,67363E-2

4,41242E-1

7,90861E0

4,88173E-1

8,87792E-1

0.6

SBToolbox2

4,58719E-1

1,49972E0

2,94862E-1

4,78555E-1

1,54129E0

3,43153E-1

3,51284E-1

1,64870E0

5,22998E-2

3,23307E-1

4,81991E0

1,94769E0

3,95717E-1

5,00280E-1

7,17717E0

5,40691E-1

1,44212E0

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,49961E0

2,94798E-1

4,78551E-1

1,54095E0

3,43158E-1

1,64851E0

3,23308E-1

4,82010E0

1,94766E0

3,95719E-1

7,17705E0

5,40695E-1

1,44217E0

0.6

copasi

4,59047E-1

1,49961E0

2,94798E-1

4,78551E-1

1,54095E0

3,43158E-1

3,51489E-1

1,64851E0

5,23383E-2

3,23308E-1

4,82009E0

1,94766E0

3,95719E-1

5,00393E-1

7,17705E0

5,40696E-1

1,44217E0

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4,96000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

6,40000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,50000E1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.6

jsim

4,59045E-1

1,49961E0

2,94798E-1

4,78551E-1

1,54096E0

3,43158E-1

3,51488E-1

1,64851E0

5,23383E-2

3,23308E-1

4,82009E0

1,94766E0

3,95719E-1

5,00392E-1

7,17705E0

5,40696E-1

1,44217E0

0.6

min

4,58719E-1

6,95132E-1

7,43836E-4

4,78551E-1

3,58659E-1

3,43153E-1

3,51284E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

4,81991E0

8,67363E-2

3,95717E-1

5,00000E-1

7,17705E0

4,88173E-1

8,87792E-1

0.6

max

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,54129E0

4,96000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,64963E0

5,23383E-2

3,23308E-1

6,40000E0

2,00000E0

4,41242E-1

5,00393E-1

5,50000E1

5,40696E-1

1,50000E0

0.6

mean

4,59045E-1

1,49961E0

2,94798E-1

4,78551E-1

1,54095E0

3,43158E-1

3,51488E-1

1,64851E0

5,23383E-2

3,23308E-1

4,82009E0

1,94766E0

3,95719E-1

5,00392E-1

7,17705E0

5,40695E-1

1,44217E0

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

4,90445E-1

1,49244E0

2,96795E-1

4,70177E-1

1,50955E0

3,25909E-1

3,19466E-1

1,68053E0

4,76143E-2

3,31193E-1

5,12396E0

1,95239E0

3,93332E-1

5,07564E-1

7,21968E0

5,53546E-1

1,43468E0

0.8

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,49244E0

2,96795E-1

4,70177E-1

1,50955E0

3,25909E-1

5,00000E-1

1,68053E0

0,00000E0

3,31193E-1

5,12396E0

1,95239E0

3,93332E-1

5,00000E-1

7,21968E0

5,53546E-1

1,43468E0

0.8

MathSBML

4,90445E-1

1,49244E0

2,96795E-1

4,70177E-1

1,50955E0

3,25909E-1

3,19466E-1

1,68053E0

4,76143E-2

3,31193E-1

5,12396E0

1,95239E0

3,93332E-1

5,07564E-1

7,21968E0

5,53546E-1

1,43468E0

0.8

Oscill8 Core

3,93213E-1

1,00676E-4

4,80475E-1

1,64087E-1

3,51270E-1

1,64995E0

3,14232E-1

7,20000E0

2,83311E-2

4,50606E-1

7,96745E0

4,79419E-1

7,20146E-1

0.8

SBToolbox2

4,90041E-1

1,49253E0

2,96914E-1

4,70184E-1

1,50994E0

3,25898E-1

3,19139E-1

1,68088E0

4,75455E-2

3,31198E-1

5,12365E0

1,95248E0

3,93330E-1

5,07440E-1

7,21983E0

5,53540E-1

1,43462E0

0.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,49244E0

2,96795E-1

4,70177E-1

1,50955E0

3,25910E-1

1,68053E0

3,31193E-1

5,12396E0

1,95239E0

3,93331E-1

7,21968E0

5,53546E-1

1,43468E0

0.8

copasi

4,90446E-1

1,49244E0

2,96794E-1

4,70177E-1

1,50955E0

3,25909E-1

3,19467E-1

1,68053E0

4,76144E-2

3,31193E-1

5,12396E0

1,95239E0

3,93332E-1

5,07564E-1

7,21968E0

5,53546E-1

1,43468E0

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

5,28000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

7,20000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

7,10000E1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

0.8

jsim

4,90445E-1

1,49244E0

2,96795E-1

4,70177E-1

1,50955E0

3,25909E-1

3,19466E-1

1,68053E0

4,76144E-2

3,31193E-1

5,12396E0

1,95239E0

3,93332E-1

5,07564E-1

7,21968E0

5,53546E-1

1,43468E0

0.8

min

4,90041E-1

3,93213E-1

1,00676E-4

4,70177E-1

1,64087E-1

3,25898E-1

3,19139E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

5,12365E0

2,83311E-2

3,93330E-1

5,00000E-1

7,21968E0

4,79419E-1

7,20146E-1

0.8

max

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50994E0

5,28000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,68088E0

4,76144E-2

3,31198E-1

7,20000E0

2,00000E0

4,50606E-1

5,07564E-1

7,10000E1

5,53546E-1

1,50000E0

0.8

mean

4,90445E-1

1,49244E0

2,96795E-1

4,70177E-1

1,50955E0

3,25909E-1

3,19466E-1

1,68053E0

4,76143E-2

3,31193E-1

5,12396E0

1,95239E0

3,93332E-1

5,07564E-1

7,21968E0

5,53546E-1

1,43468E0

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

5,23781E-1

1,48450E0

2,97919E-1

4,61355E-1

1,47622E0

3,09513E-1

2,91921E-1

1,70808E0

4,34092E-2

3,39180E-1

5,44377E0

1,95659E0

3,90425E-1

5,15499E-1

7,25945E0

5,65916E-1

1,42967E0

1.0

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,48450E0

2,97919E-1

4,61355E-1

1,47622E0

3,09513E-1

5,00000E-1

1,70808E0

0,00000E0

3,39180E-1

5,44377E0

1,95659E0

3,90425E-1

5,00000E-1

7,25945E0

5,65916E-1

1,42967E0

1.0

MathSBML

5,23781E-1

1,48450E0

2,97919E-1

4,61355E-1

1,47622E0

3,09513E-1

2,91921E-1

1,70808E0

4,34092E-2

3,39180E-1

5,44377E0

1,95659E0

3,90425E-1

5,15499E-1

7,25945E0

5,65916E-1

1,42967E0

1.0

Oscill8 Core

2,04680E-1

1,36262E-5

4,78976E-1

7,10147E-2

3,50468E-1

1,64999E0

3,12884E-1

8,00000E0

8,92980E-3

4,55874E-1

7,98893E0

4,71642E-1

5,84064E-1

1.0

SBToolbox2

5,23359E-1

1,48464E0

2,98076E-1

4,61365E-1

1,47667E0

3,09500E-1

2,91559E-1

1,70847E0

4,33428E-2

3,39180E-1

5,44336E0

1,95668E0

3,90426E-1

5,15358E-1

7,25961E0

5,65909E-1

1,42972E0

1.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,48450E0

2,97919E-1

4,61355E-1

1,47622E0

3,09513E-1

1,70808E0

3,39180E-1

5,44378E0

1,95659E0

3,90425E-1

7,25945E0

5,65916E-1

1,42967E0

1.0

copasi

5,23781E-1

1,48450E0

2,97919E-1

4,61355E-1

1,47622E0

3,09513E-1

2,91923E-1

1,70808E0

4,34092E-2

3,39180E-1

5,44377E0

1,95659E0

3,90425E-1

5,15500E-1

7,25945E0

5,65916E-1

1,42967E0

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

5,60000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

8,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

8,70000E1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1.0

jsim

5,23781E-1

1,48450E0

2,97919E-1

4,61355E-1

1,47622E0

3,09513E-1

2,91921E-1

1,70808E0

4,34092E-2

3,39180E-1

5,44377E0

1,95659E0

3,90425E-1

5,15499E-1

7,25945E0

5,65916E-1

1,42967E0

1.0

min

5,00000E-1

2,04680E-1

1,36262E-5

4,61355E-1

7,10147E-2

3,09500E-1

2,91559E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

5,44336E0

8,92980E-3

3,90425E-1

5,00000E-1

7,25945E0

4,71642E-1

5,84064E-1

1.0

max

5,23781E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

5,60000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,70847E0

4,34092E-2

3,39180E-1

8,00000E0

2,00000E0

4,55874E-1

5,15500E-1

8,70000E1

5,65916E-1

1,50000E0

1.0

mean

5,23781E-1

1,48450E0

2,97919E-1

4,61355E-1

1,47622E0

3,09513E-1

2,91921E-1

1,70808E0

4,34092E-2

3,39180E-1

5,44377E0

1,95659E0

3,90425E-1

5,15499E-1

7,25945E0

5,65916E-1

1,42967E0

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

5,58676E-1

1,47586E0

2,98382E-1

4,52170E-1

1,44132E0

2,93942E-1

2,67921E-1

1,73208E0

3,96704E-2

3,47273E-1

5,77833E0

1,96033E0

3,87016E-1

5,24142E-1

7,29629E0

5,77754E-1

1,42598E0

1.2

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,47586E0

2,98382E-1

4,52170E-1

1,44132E0

2,93942E-1

5,00000E-1

1,73208E0

0,00000E0

3,47273E-1

5,77833E0

1,96033E0

3,87016E-1

5,00000E-1

7,29629E0

5,77754E-1

1,42598E0

1.2

MathSBML

5,58676E-1

1,47586E0

2,98382E-1

4,52170E-1

1,44132E0

2,93942E-1

2,67921E-1

1,73208E0

3,96704E-2

3,47273E-1

5,77833E0

1,96033E0

3,87016E-1

5,24142E-1

7,29629E0

5,77754E-1

1,42598E0

1.2

Oscill8 Core

1,00261E-1

1,84425E-6

4,78225E-1

2,95221E-2

3,51760E-1

1,65000E0

3,10339E-1

8,80000E0

2,72901E-3

4,58592E-1

7,99638E0

4,64930E-1

4,73740E-1

1.2

SBToolbox2

5,58236E-1

1,47605E0

2,98559E-1

4,52176E-1

1,44172E0

2,93921E-1

2,67556E-1

1,73247E0

3,96082E-2

3,47272E-1

5,77776E0

1,96038E0

3,87022E-1

5,23986E-1

7,29648E0

5,77742E-1

1,42612E0

1.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,47586E0

2,98382E-1

4,52170E-1

1,44132E0

2,93942E-1

1,73208E0

3,47273E-1

5,77833E0

1,96033E0

3,87016E-1

7,29629E0

5,77754E-1

1,42598E0

1.2

copasi

5,58677E-1

1,47586E0

2,98381E-1

4,52170E-1

1,44132E0

2,93942E-1

2,67923E-1

1,73208E0

3,96704E-2

3,47273E-1

5,77833E0

1,96033E0

3,87016E-1

5,24142E-1

7,29629E0

5,77754E-1

1,42599E0

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

5,92000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

8,80000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

1,03000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1.2

jsim

5,58676E-1

1,47586E0

2,98382E-1

4,52170E-1

1,44132E0

2,93942E-1

2,67921E-1

1,73208E0

3,96704E-2

3,47273E-1

5,77833E0

1,96033E0

3,87016E-1

5,24142E-1

7,29629E0

5,77754E-1

1,42598E0

1.2

min

5,00000E-1

1,00261E-1

1,84425E-6

4,52170E-1

2,95221E-2

2,93921E-1

2,67556E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

5,77776E0

2,72901E-3

3,87016E-1

5,00000E-1

7,29629E0

4,64930E-1

4,73740E-1

1.2

max

5,58677E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

5,92000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,73247E0

3,96704E-2

3,47273E-1

8,80000E0

2,00000E0

4,58592E-1

5,24142E-1

1,03000E2

5,77754E-1

1,50000E0

1.2

mean

5,58676E-1

1,47586E0

2,98382E-1

4,52170E-1

1,44132E0

2,93942E-1

2,67921E-1

1,73208E0

3,96704E-2

3,47273E-1

5,77833E0

1,96033E0

3,87016E-1

5,24142E-1

7,29629E0

5,77754E-1

1,42598E0

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

5,94801E-1

1,46654E0

2,98349E-1

4,42698E-1

1,40520E0

2,79168E-1

2,46819E-1

1,75318E0

3,63498E-2

3,55461E-1

6,12649E0

1,96365E0

3,83126E-1

5,33462E-1

7,33018E0

5,89023E-1

1,42288E0

1.4

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,46654E0

2,98349E-1

4,42698E-1

1,40520E0

2,79168E-1

5,00000E-1

1,75318E0

0,00000E0

3,55461E-1

6,12649E0

1,96365E0

3,83126E-1

5,00000E-1

7,33018E0

5,89023E-1

1,42288E0

1.4

MathSBML

5,94801E-1

1,46654E0

2,98349E-1

4,42698E-1

1,40520E0

2,79168E-1

2,46819E-1

1,75318E0

3,63498E-2

3,55461E-1

6,12649E0

1,96365E0

3,83126E-1

5,33462E-1

7,33018E0

5,89023E-1

1,42288E0

1.4

Oscill8 Core

4,68956E-2

2,49612E-7

4,77872E-1

1,19091E-2

3,54253E-1

1,65000E0

3,06881E-1

9,60000E0

8,12187E-4

4,59910E-1

7,99886E0

4,59160E-1

3,84299E-1

1.4

SBToolbox2

5,94364E-1

1,46667E0

2,98531E-1

4,42707E-1

1,40565E0

2,79151E-1

2,46460E-1

1,75356E0

3,63013E-2

3,55463E-1

6,12582E0

1,96369E0

3,83129E-1

5,33291E-1

7,33028E0

5,89013E-1

1,42311E0

1.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,46654E0

2,98350E-1

4,42698E-1

1,40520E0

2,79168E-1

1,75318E0

3,55461E-1

6,12649E0

1,96365E0

3,83126E-1

7,33018E0

5,89023E-1

1,42288E0

1.4

copasi

5,94802E-1

1,46654E0

2,98349E-1

4,42698E-1

1,40520E0

2,79168E-1

2,46819E-1

1,75318E0

3,63498E-2

3,55461E-1

6,12649E0

1,96365E0

3,83126E-1

5,33462E-1

7,33018E0

5,89023E-1

1,42288E0

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

6,24000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

9,60000E0

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

1,19000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1.4

jsim

5,94801E-1

1,46654E0

2,98349E-1

4,42698E-1

1,40520E0

2,79168E-1

2,46819E-1

1,75318E0

3,63498E-2

3,55462E-1

6,12649E0

1,96365E0

3,83126E-1

5,33462E-1

7,33018E0

5,89023E-1

1,42288E0

1.4

min

5,00000E-1

4,68956E-2

2,49612E-7

4,42698E-1

1,19091E-2

2,79151E-1

2,46460E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

6,12582E0

8,12187E-4

3,83126E-1

5,00000E-1

7,33018E0

4,59160E-1

3,84299E-1

1.4

max

5,94802E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

6,24000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,75356E0

3,63498E-2

3,55463E-1

9,60000E0

2,00000E0

4,59910E-1

5,33462E-1

1,19000E2

5,89023E-1

1,50000E0

1.4

mean

5,94801E-1

1,46654E0

2,98349E-1

4,42698E-1

1,40520E0

2,79168E-1

2,46819E-1

1,75318E0

3,63498E-2

3,55461E-1

6,12649E0

1,96365E0

3,83126E-1

5,33462E-1

7,33018E0

5,89023E-1

1,42288E0

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

1.6

BioUML

6,31801E-1

1,45658E0

2,97958E-1

4,33006E-1

1,36820E0

2,65163E-1

2,28145E-1

1,77185E0

3,34028E-2

3,63729E-1

6,48719E0

1,96660E0

3,78778E-1

5,43417E-1

7,36117E0

5,99696E-1

1,41989E0

1.6

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,45658E0

2,97958E-1

4,33006E-1

1,36820E0

2,65163E-1

5,00000E-1

1,77185E0

0,00000E0

3,63729E-1

6,48719E0

1,96660E0

3,78778E-1

5,00000E-1

7,36117E0

5,99696E-1

1,41989E0

1.6

MathSBML

6,31801E-1

1,45658E0

2,97958E-1

4,33006E-1

1,36820E0

2,65163E-1

2,28145E-1

1,77185E0

3,34028E-2

3,63729E-1

6,48719E0

1,96660E0

3,78778E-1

5,43417E-1

7,36117E0

5,99696E-1

1,41989E0

1.6

Oscill8 Core

2,11563E-2

3,37837E-8

4,77714E-1

4,69574E-3

3,57454E-1

1,65000E0

3,02732E-1

1,04000E1

2,36263E-4

4,60521E-1

7,99965E0

4,54175E-1

3,11778E-1

1.6

SBToolbox2

6,31361E-1

1,45678E0

2,98145E-1

4,33018E-1

1,36860E0

2,65139E-1

2,27801E-1

1,77217E0

3,33716E-2

3,63733E-1

6,48637E0

1,96658E0

3,78787E-1

5,43228E-1

7,36126E0

5,99677E-1

1,42022E0

1.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,45658E0

2,97957E-1

4,33006E-1

1,36820E0

2,65163E-1

1,77185E0

3,63729E-1

6,48719E0

1,96660E0

3,78778E-1

7,36117E0

5,99696E-1

1,41989E0

1.6

copasi

6,31801E-1

1,45658E0

2,97958E-1

4,33006E-1

1,36820E0

2,65163E-1

2,28145E-1

1,77185E0

3,34028E-2

3,63729E-1

6,48719E0

1,96660E0

3,78778E-1

5,43417E-1

7,36117E0

5,99696E-1

1,41989E0

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

6,56000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

1,04000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

1,35000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1.6

jsim

6,31801E-1

1,45658E0

2,97958E-1

4,33006E-1

1,36820E0

2,65163E-1

2,28145E-1

1,77185E0

3,34028E-2

3,63729E-1

6,48719E0

1,96660E0

3,78778E-1

5,43417E-1

7,36117E0

5,99696E-1

1,41989E0

1.6

min

5,00000E-1

2,11563E-2

3,37837E-8

4,33006E-1

4,69574E-3

2,65139E-1

2,27801E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

6,48637E0

2,36263E-4

3,78778E-1

5,00000E-1

7,36117E0

4,54175E-1

3,11778E-1

1.6

max

6,31801E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

6,56000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,77217E0

3,34028E-2

3,63733E-1

1,04000E1

2,00000E0

4,60521E-1

5,43417E-1

1,35000E2

5,99696E-1

1,50000E0

1.6

mean

6,31801E-1

1,45658E0

2,97958E-1

4,33006E-1

1,36820E0

2,65163E-1

2,28145E-1

1,77185E0

3,34028E-2

3,63729E-1

6,48719E0

1,96660E0

3,78778E-1

5,43417E-1

7,36117E0

5,99696E-1

1,41989E0

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

1.8

BioUML

6,69291E-1

1,44605E0

2,97319E-1

4,23159E-1

1,33071E0

2,51895E-1

2,11544E-1

1,78846E0

3,07884E-2

3,72055E-1

6,85939E0

1,96921E0

3,74000E-1

5,53951E-1

7,38937E0

6,09752E-1

1,41672E0

1.8

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,44605E0

2,97319E-1

4,23159E-1

1,33071E0

2,51895E-1

5,00000E-1

1,78846E0

0,00000E0

3,72055E-1

6,85939E0

1,96921E0

3,74000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,38937E0

6,09752E-1

1,41672E0

1.8

MathSBML

6,69291E-1

1,44605E0

2,97319E-1

4,23159E-1

1,33071E0

2,51895E-1

2,11544E-1

1,78846E0

3,07884E-2

3,72055E-1

6,85939E0

1,96921E0

3,74000E-1

5,53951E-1

7,38937E0

6,09752E-1

1,41672E0

1.8

Oscill8 Core

9,27306E-3

4,57245E-9

4,77645E-1

1,81963E-3

3,61128E-1

1,65000E0

2,98065E-1

1,12000E1

6,73798E-5

4,60794E-1

7,99990E0

4,49826E-1

2,52965E-1

1.8

SBToolbox2

6,68822E-1

1,44629E0

2,97515E-1

4,23170E-1

1,33114E0

2,51867E-1

2,11220E-1

1,78876E0

3,07440E-2

3,72064E-1

6,85842E0

1,96928E0

3,74015E-1

5,53743E-1

7,38947E0

6,09732E-1

1,41714E0

1.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,44605E0

2,97319E-1

4,23159E-1

1,33071E0

2,51896E-1

1,78846E0

3,72055E-1

6,85940E0

1,96921E0

3,74000E-1

7,38937E0

6,09752E-1

1,41672E0

1.8

copasi

6,69291E-1

1,44605E0

2,97319E-1

4,23159E-1

1,33071E0

2,51895E-1

2,11543E-1

1,78846E0

3,07884E-2

3,72055E-1

6,85940E0

1,96921E0

3,74000E-1

5,53951E-1

7,38937E0

6,09752E-1

1,41672E0

1.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

6,88000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

1,12000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

1,51000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1.8

jsim

6,69291E-1

1,44605E0

2,97319E-1

4,23159E-1

1,33071E0

2,51895E-1

2,11544E-1

1,78846E0

3,07884E-2

3,72055E-1

6,85939E0

1,96921E0

3,74000E-1

5,53951E-1

7,38937E0

6,09752E-1

1,41672E0

1.8

min

5,00000E-1

9,27306E-3

4,57245E-9

4,23159E-1

1,81963E-3

2,51867E-1

2,11220E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,98065E-1

6,85842E0

6,73798E-5

3,74000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,38937E0

4,49826E-1

2,52965E-1

1.8

max

6,69291E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

6,88000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,78876E0

3,07884E-2

3,72064E-1

1,12000E1

2,00000E0

4,60794E-1

5,53951E-1

1,51000E2

6,09752E-1

1,50000E0

1.8

mean

6,69291E-1

1,44605E0

2,97319E-1

4,23159E-1

1,33071E0

2,51895E-1

2,11544E-1

1,78846E0

3,07884E-2

3,72055E-1

6,85939E0

1,96921E0

3,74000E-1

5,53951E-1

7,38937E0

6,09752E-1

1,41672E0

1.8

relative error(%)

0,00

2.0

BioUML

7,06865E-1

1,43501E0

2,96525E-1

4,13212E-1

1,29314E0

2,39335E-1

1,96732E-1

1,80327E0

2,84691E-2

3,80416E-1

7,24211E0

1,97153E0

3,68822E-1

5,64988E-1

7,41490E0

6,19179E-1

1,41326E0

2.0

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,43501E0

2,96525E-1

4,13212E-1

1,29314E0

2,39335E-1

5,00000E-1

1,80327E0

0,00000E0

3,80416E-1

7,24211E0

1,97153E0

3,68822E-1

5,00000E-1

7,41490E0

6,19179E-1

1,41326E0

2.0

MathSBML

7,06865E-1

1,43501E0

2,96524E-1

4,13212E-1

1,29314E0

2,39335E-1

1,96732E-1

1,80327E0

2,84691E-2

3,80416E-1

7,24211E0

1,97153E0

3,68822E-1

5,64988E-1

7,41490E0

6,19179E-1

1,41326E0

2.0

Oscill8 Core

3,97049E-3

6,18854E-10

4,77616E-1

6,95850E-4

3,65177E-1

1,65000E0

2,93016E-1

1,20000E1

1,88848E-5

4,60913E-1

7,99997E0

4,45990E-1

2,05264E-1

2.0

SBToolbox2

7,06404E-1

1,43522E0

2,96718E-1

4,13220E-1

1,29358E0

2,39302E-1

1,96440E-1

1,80356E0

2,84270E-2

3,80426E-1

7,24102E0

1,97158E0

3,68842E-1

5,64758E-1

7,41496E0

6,19158E-1

1,41374E0

2.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,43501E0

2,96525E-1

4,13212E-1

1,29314E0

2,39335E-1

1,80327E0

3,80416E-1

7,24211E0

1,97153E0

3,68822E-1

7,41490E0

6,19179E-1

1,41326E0

2.0

copasi

7,06865E-1

1,43501E0

2,96525E-1

4,13212E-1

1,29314E0

2,39335E-1

1,96732E-1

1,80327E0

2,84691E-2

3,80416E-1

7,24211E0

1,97153E0

3,68822E-1

5,64988E-1

7,41490E0

6,19179E-1

1,41326E0

2.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

7,20000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

1,20000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

1,67000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

2.0

jsim

7,06865E-1

1,43501E0

2,96524E-1

4,13212E-1

1,29314E0

2,39335E-1

1,96732E-1

1,80327E0

2,84691E-2

3,80416E-1

7,24211E0

1,97153E0

3,68822E-1

5,64988E-1

7,41490E0

6,19179E-1

1,41326E0

2.0

min

5,00000E-1

3,97049E-3

6,18854E-10

4,13212E-1

6,95850E-4

2,39302E-1

1,96440E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,93016E-1

7,24102E0

1,88848E-5

3,68822E-1

5,00000E-1

7,41490E0

4,45990E-1

2,05264E-1

2.0

max

7,06865E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

7,20000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,80356E0

2,84691E-2

3,80426E-1

1,20000E1

2,00000E0

4,60913E-1

5,64988E-1

1,67000E2

6,19179E-1

1,50000E0

2.0

mean

7,06865E-1

1,43501E0

2,96525E-1

4,13212E-1

1,29314E0

2,39335E-1

1,96732E-1

1,80327E0

2,84691E-2

3,80416E-1

7,24211E0

1,97153E0

3,68822E-1

5,64988E-1

7,41490E0

6,19179E-1

1,41326E0

2.0

relative error(%)

0,00

2.2

BioUML

7,44103E-1

1,42357E0

2,95655E-1

4,03213E-1

1,25590E0

2,27450E-1

1,83479E-1

1,81652E0

2,64112E-2

3,88789E-1

7,63438E0

1,97359E0

3,63276E-1

5,76430E-1

7,43791E0

6,27965E-1

1,40947E0

2.2

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,42357E0

2,95655E-1

4,03213E-1

1,25590E0

2,27450E-1

5,00000E-1

1,81652E0

0,00000E0

3,88789E-1

7,63438E0

1,97359E0

3,63276E-1

5,00000E-1

7,43791E0

6,27965E-1

1,40947E0

2.2

MathSBML

7,44103E-1

1,42357E0

2,95655E-1

4,03213E-1

1,25590E0

2,27450E-1

1,83479E-1

1,81652E0

2,64112E-2

3,88789E-1

7,63438E0

1,97359E0

3,63276E-1

5,76430E-1

7,43791E0

6,27965E-1

1,40947E0

2.2

Oscill8 Core

1,66769E-3

8,37580E-11

4,77605E-1

2,63439E-4

3,69578E-1

1,65000E0

2,87693E-1

1,28000E1

5,21186E-6

4,60964E-1

7,99999E0

4,42568E-1

1,66569E-1

2.2

SBToolbox2

7,43653E-1

1,42383E0

2,95839E-1

4,03222E-1

1,25632E0

2,27415E-1

1,83209E-1

1,81677E0

2,63858E-2

3,88808E-1

7,63314E0

1,97358E0

3,63294E-1

5,76192E-1

7,43796E0

6,27938E-1

1,41004E0

2.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,42357E0

2,95655E-1

4,03213E-1

1,25590E0

2,27451E-1

1,81652E0

3,88789E-1

7,63438E0

1,97359E0

3,63276E-1

7,43791E0

6,27965E-1

1,40947E0

2.2

copasi

7,44103E-1

1,42357E0

2,95655E-1

4,03213E-1

1,25590E0

2,27450E-1

1,83479E-1

1,81652E0

2,64112E-2

3,88790E-1

7,63438E0

1,97359E0

3,63276E-1

5,76430E-1

7,43791E0

6,27965E-1

1,40947E0

2.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

7,52000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

1,28000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

1,83000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

2.2

jsim

7,44103E-1

1,42357E0

2,95655E-1

4,03213E-1

1,25590E0

2,27450E-1

1,83479E-1

1,81652E0

2,64112E-2

3,88789E-1

7,63438E0

1,97359E0

3,63276E-1

5,76430E-1

7,43791E0

6,27965E-1

1,40947E0

2.2

min

5,00000E-1

1,66769E-3

8,37580E-11

4,03213E-1

2,63439E-4

2,27415E-1

1,83209E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,87693E-1

7,63314E0

5,21186E-6

3,63276E-1

5,00000E-1

7,43791E0

4,42568E-1

1,66569E-1

2.2

max

7,44103E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

7,52000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,81677E0

2,64112E-2

3,88808E-1

1,28000E1

2,00000E0

4,60964E-1

5,76430E-1

1,83000E2

6,27965E-1

1,50000E0

2.2

mean

7,44103E-1

1,42357E0

2,95655E-1

4,03213E-1

1,25590E0

2,27450E-1

1,83479E-1

1,81652E0

2,64112E-2

3,88789E-1

7,63438E0

1,97359E0

3,63276E-1

5,76430E-1

7,43791E0

6,27965E-1

1,40947E0

2.2

relative error(%)

0,00

2.4

BioUML

7,80583E-1

1,41184E0

2,94781E-1

3,93208E-1

1,21942E0

2,16210E-1

1,71592E-1

1,82841E0

2,45846E-2

3,97151E-1

8,03527E0

1,97542E0

3,57397E-1

5,88160E-1

7,45857E0

6,36106E-1

1,40540E0

2.4

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,41184E0

2,94781E-1

3,93208E-1

1,21942E0

2,16210E-1

5,00000E-1

1,82841E0

0,00000E0

3,97151E-1

8,03527E0

1,97542E0

3,57397E-1

5,00000E-1

7,45857E0

6,36106E-1

1,40540E0

2.4

MathSBML

7,80583E-1

1,41184E0

2,94781E-1

3,93208E-1

1,21942E0

2,16210E-1

1,71592E-1

1,82841E0

2,45846E-2

3,97151E-1

8,03527E0

1,97542E0

3,57397E-1

5,88160E-1

7,45857E0

6,36106E-1

1,40540E0

2.4

Oscill8 Core

6,89374E-4

1,13361E-11

4,77600E-1

9,89794E-5

3,74344E-1

1,65000E0

2,82181E-1

1,36000E1

1,41859E-6

4,60985E-1

8,00000E0

4,39478E-1

1,35178E-1

2.4

SBToolbox2

7,80108E-1

1,41212E0

2,94970E-1

3,93220E-1

1,21993E0

2,16170E-1

1,71334E-1

1,82866E0

2,45534E-2

3,97169E-1

8,03385E0

1,97548E0

3,57422E-1

5,87898E-1

7,45866E0

6,36076E-1

1,40605E0

2.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,41184E0

2,94781E-1

3,93208E-1

1,21942E0

2,16210E-1

1,82841E0

3,97151E-1

8,03527E0

1,97542E0

3,57397E-1

7,45856E0

6,36106E-1

1,40540E0

2.4

copasi

7,80583E-1

1,41184E0

2,94781E-1

3,93208E-1

1,21942E0

2,16210E-1

1,71591E-1

1,82841E0

2,45848E-2

3,97151E-1

8,03527E0

1,97542E0

3,57397E-1

5,88160E-1

7,45857E0

6,36106E-1

1,40540E0

2.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

7,84000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

1,36000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

1,99000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

2.4

jsim

7,80583E-1

1,41184E0

2,94781E-1

3,93208E-1

1,21942E0

2,16210E-1

1,71592E-1

1,82841E0

2,45846E-2

3,97151E-1

8,03527E0

1,97542E0

3,57397E-1

5,88160E-1

7,45857E0

6,36106E-1

1,40540E0

2.4

min

5,00000E-1

6,89374E-4

1,13361E-11

3,93208E-1

9,89794E-5

2,16170E-1

1,71334E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,82181E-1

8,03385E0

1,41859E-6

3,57397E-1

5,00000E-1

7,45856E0

4,39478E-1

1,35178E-1

2.4

max

7,80583E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

7,84000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,82866E0

2,45848E-2

3,97169E-1

1,36000E1

2,00000E0

4,60985E-1

5,88160E-1

1,99000E2

6,36106E-1

1,50000E0

2.4

mean

7,80583E-1

1,41184E0

2,94781E-1

3,93208E-1

1,21942E0

2,16210E-1

1,71592E-1

1,82841E0

2,45846E-2

3,97151E-1

8,03527E0

1,97542E0

3,57397E-1

5,88160E-1

7,45857E0

6,36106E-1

1,40540E0

2.4

relative error(%)

0,00

2.6

BioUML

8,15893E-1

1,39996E0

2,93962E-1

3,83234E-1

1,18411E0

2,05582E-1

1,60903E-1

1,83910E0

2,29627E-2

4,05479E-1

8,44391E0

1,97704E0

3,51220E-1

6,00041E-1

7,47702E0

6,43597E-1

1,40115E0

2.6

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,39996E0

2,93962E-1

3,83234E-1

1,18411E0

2,05582E-1

5,00000E-1

1,83910E0

0,00000E0

4,05479E-1

8,44391E0

1,97704E0

3,51220E-1

5,00000E-1

7,47702E0

6,43597E-1

1,40115E0

2.6

MathSBML

8,15893E-1

1,39996E0

2,93962E-1

3,83234E-1

1,18411E0

2,05582E-1

1,60903E-1

1,83910E0

2,29627E-2

4,05479E-1

8,44391E0

1,97704E0

3,51220E-1

6,00041E-1

7,47702E0

6,43597E-1

1,40115E0

2.6

Oscill8 Core

2,81177E-4

1,53425E-12

4,77598E-1

3,69771E-5

3,79507E-1

1,65000E0

2,76545E-1

1,44000E1

3,81293E-7

4,60994E-1

8,00000E0

4,36656E-1

1,09709E-1

2.6

SBToolbox2

8,15440E-1

1,40026E0

2,94150E-1

3,83240E-1

1,18454E0

2,05535E-1

1,60673E-1

1,83937E0

2,29320E-2

4,05503E-1

8,44234E0

1,97707E0

3,51251E-1

5,99774E-1

7,47707E0

6,43556E-1

1,40185E0

2.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,39996E0

2,93962E-1

3,83234E-1

1,18411E0

2,05582E-1

1,83910E0

4,05479E-1

8,44391E0

1,97704E0

3,51220E-1

7,47702E0

6,43597E-1

1,40115E0

2.6

copasi

8,15893E-1

1,39996E0

2,93962E-1

3,83234E-1

1,18411E0

2,05582E-1

1,60903E-1

1,83910E0

2,29627E-2

4,05479E-1

8,44391E0

1,97704E0

3,51220E-1

6,00041E-1

7,47702E0

6,43597E-1

1,40115E0

2.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

8,16000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

1,44000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

2,15000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

2.6

jsim

8,15893E-1

1,39996E0

2,93962E-1

3,83234E-1

1,18411E0

2,05582E-1

1,60903E-1

1,83910E0

2,29627E-2

4,05479E-1

8,44391E0

1,97704E0

3,51220E-1

6,00041E-1

7,47702E0

6,43597E-1

1,40115E0

2.6

min

5,00000E-1

2,81177E-4

1,53425E-12

3,83234E-1

3,69771E-5

2,05535E-1

1,60673E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,76545E-1

8,44234E0

3,81293E-7

3,51220E-1

5,00000E-1

7,47702E0

4,36656E-1

1,09709E-1

2.6

max

8,15893E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

8,16000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,83937E0

2,29627E-2

4,05503E-1

1,44000E1

2,00000E0

4,60994E-1

6,00041E-1

2,15000E2

6,43597E-1

1,50000E0

2.6

mean

8,15893E-1

1,39996E0

2,93962E-1

3,83234E-1

1,18411E0

2,05582E-1

1,60903E-1

1,83910E0

2,29627E-2

4,05479E-1

8,44391E0

1,97704E0

3,51220E-1

6,00041E-1

7,47702E0

6,43597E-1

1,40115E0

2.6

relative error(%)

0,00

2.8

BioUML

8,49644E-1

1,38808E0

2,93255E-1

3,73322E-1

1,15036E0

1,95534E-1

1,51272E-1

1,84873E0

2,15219E-2

4,13753E-1

8,85941E0

1,97848E0

3,44780E-1

6,11918E-1

7,49341E0

6,50436E-1

1,39684E0

2.8

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,38808E0

2,93255E-1

3,73322E-1

1,15036E0

1,95534E-1

5,00000E-1

1,84873E0

0,00000E0

4,13753E-1

8,85941E0

1,97848E0

3,44780E-1

5,00000E-1

7,49341E0

6,50436E-1

1,39684E0

2.8

MathSBML

8,49644E-1

1,38808E0

2,93255E-1

3,73322E-1

1,15036E0

1,95534E-1

1,51272E-1

1,84873E0

2,15219E-2

4,13753E-1

8,85941E0

1,97848E0

3,44780E-1

6,11918E-1

7,49341E0

6,50436E-1

1,39684E0

2.8

Oscill8 Core

1,13394E-4

2,07649E-13

4,77597E-1

1,37554E-5

3,85109E-1

1,65000E0

2,70838E-1

1,52000E1

1,01309E-7

4,60997E-1

8,00000E0

4,34053E-1

8,90435E-2

2.8

SBToolbox2

8,49198E-1

1,38837E0

2,93438E-1

3,73327E-1

1,15078E0

1,95487E-1

1,51059E-1

1,84896E0

2,15096E-2

4,13785E-1

8,85765E0

1,97847E0

3,44812E-1

6,11652E-1

7,49338E0

6,50390E-1

1,39756E0

2.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,38808E0

2,93256E-1

3,73322E-1

1,15036E0

1,95534E-1

1,84873E0

4,13753E-1

8,85941E0

1,97848E0

3,44780E-1

7,49341E0

6,50436E-1

1,39684E0

2.8

copasi

8,49644E-1

1,38808E0

2,93255E-1

3,73322E-1

1,15036E0

1,95534E-1

1,51271E-1

1,84873E0

2,15219E-2

4,13753E-1

8,85941E0

1,97848E0

3,44780E-1

6,11918E-1

7,49341E0

6,50436E-1

1,39684E0

2.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

8,48000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

1,52000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

2,31000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

2.8

jsim

8,49644E-1

1,38808E0

2,93255E-1

3,73322E-1

1,15036E0

1,95534E-1

1,51272E-1

1,84873E0

2,15219E-2

4,13753E-1

8,85941E0

1,97848E0

3,44780E-1

6,11918E-1

7,49341E0

6,50436E-1

1,39684E0

2.8

min

5,00000E-1

1,13394E-4

2,07649E-13

3,73322E-1

1,37554E-5

1,95487E-1

1,51059E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,70838E-1

8,85765E0

1,01309E-7

3,44780E-1

5,00000E-1

7,49338E0

4,34053E-1

8,90435E-2

2.8

max

8,49644E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

8,48000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,84896E0

2,15219E-2

4,13785E-1

1,52000E1

2,00000E0

4,60997E-1

6,11918E-1

2,31000E2

6,50436E-1

1,50000E0

2.8

mean

8,49644E-1

1,38808E0

2,93255E-1

3,73322E-1

1,15036E0

1,95534E-1

1,51272E-1

1,84873E0

2,15219E-2

4,13753E-1

8,85941E0

1,97848E0

3,44780E-1

6,11918E-1

7,49341E0

6,50436E-1

1,39684E0

2.8

relative error(%)

0,00

3.0

BioUML

8,81476E-1

1,37638E0

2,92708E-1

3,63499E-1

1,11852E0

1,86034E-1

1,42573E-1

1,85743E0

2,02416E-2

4,21955E-1

9,28095E0

1,97976E0

3,38117E-1

6,23622E-1

7,50788E0

6,56622E-1

1,39263E0

3.0

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,37638E0

2,92708E-1

3,63499E-1

1,11852E0

1,86034E-1

5,00000E-1

1,85743E0

0,00000E0

4,21955E-1

9,28095E0

1,97976E0

3,38117E-1

5,00000E-1

7,50788E0

6,56622E-1

1,39263E0

3.0

MathSBML

8,81476E-1

1,37638E0

2,92708E-1

3,63499E-1

1,11852E0

1,86034E-1

1,42573E-1

1,85743E0

2,02416E-2

4,21955E-1

9,28095E0

1,97976E0

3,38117E-1

6,23622E-1

7,50788E0

6,56622E-1

1,39263E0

3.0

Oscill8 Core

4,52906E-5

2,81036E-14

4,77597E-1

5,10096E-6

3,91198E-1

1,65000E0

2,65103E-1

1,60000E1

2,66314E-8

4,60999E-1

8,00000E0

4,31626E-1

7,22744E-2

3.0

SBToolbox2

8,81021E-1

1,37668E0

2,92899E-1

3,63507E-1

1,11898E0

1,85988E-1

1,42373E-1

1,85765E0

2,02160E-2

4,21997E-1

9,27901E0

1,97977E0

3,38152E-1

6,23329E-1

7,50789E0

6,56573E-1

1,39346E0

3.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,37638E0

2,92708E-1

3,63499E-1

1,11852E0

1,86034E-1

1,85743E0

4,21955E-1

9,28095E0

1,97976E0

3,38117E-1

7,50788E0

6,56622E-1

1,39263E0

3.0

copasi

8,81476E-1

1,37638E0

2,92708E-1

3,63499E-1

1,11852E0

1,86034E-1

1,42573E-1

1,85743E0

2,02416E-2

4,21955E-1

9,28095E0

1,97976E0

3,38117E-1

6,23622E-1

7,50788E0

6,56622E-1

1,39263E0

3.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

8,80000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

1,60000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

2,47000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3.0

jsim

8,81476E-1

1,37638E0

2,92708E-1

3,63499E-1

1,11852E0

1,86034E-1

1,42573E-1

1,85743E0

2,02416E-2

4,21955E-1

9,28095E0

1,97976E0

3,38117E-1

6,23622E-1

7,50788E0

6,56622E-1

1,39263E0

3.0

min

5,00000E-1

4,52906E-5

2,81036E-14

3,63499E-1

5,10096E-6

1,85988E-1

1,42373E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,65103E-1

9,27901E0

2,66314E-8

3,38117E-1

5,00000E-1

7,50788E0

4,31626E-1

7,22744E-2

3.0

max

8,81476E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

8,80000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,85765E0

2,02416E-2

4,21997E-1

1,60000E1

2,00000E0

4,60999E-1

6,23622E-1

2,47000E2

6,56622E-1

1,50000E0

3.0

mean

8,81476E-1

1,37638E0

2,92708E-1

3,63499E-1

1,11852E0

1,86034E-1

1,42573E-1

1,85743E0

2,02416E-2

4,21955E-1

9,28095E0

1,97976E0

3,38117E-1

6,23622E-1

7,50788E0

6,56622E-1

1,39263E0

3.0

relative error(%)

0,00

3.2

BioUML

9,11072E-1

1,36502E0

2,92368E-1

3,53787E-1

1,08893E0

1,77052E-1

1,34698E-1

1,86530E0

1,91038E-2

4,30072E-1

9,70770E0

1,98090E0

3,31267E-1

6,34977E-1

7,52056E0

6,62157E-1

1,38868E0

3.2

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,36502E0

2,92368E-1

3,53787E-1

1,08893E0

1,77052E-1

5,00000E-1

1,86530E0

0,00000E0

4,30072E-1

9,70770E0

1,98090E0

3,31267E-1

5,00000E-1

7,52056E0

6,62157E-1

1,38868E0

3.2

MathSBML

9,11072E-1

1,36502E0

2,92368E-1

3,53787E-1

1,08893E0

1,77052E-1

1,34698E-1

1,86530E0

1,91038E-2

4,30072E-1

9,70770E0

1,98090E0

3,31267E-1

6,34977E-1

7,52056E0

6,62157E-1

1,38868E0

3.2

Oscill8 Core

1,79402E-5

3,80357E-15

4,77597E-1

1,88725E-6

3,97827E-1

1,65000E0

2,59371E-1

1,68000E1

6,93092E-9

4,60999E-1

8,00000E0

4,29342E-1

5,86660E-2

3.2

SBToolbox2

9,10642E-1

1,36529E0

2,92553E-1

3,53787E-1

1,08935E0

1,77001E-1

1,34522E-1

1,86547E0

1,90876E-2

4,30119E-1

9,70555E0

1,98090E0

3,31302E-1

6,34701E-1

7,52051E0

6,62104E-1

1,38946E0

3.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,36502E0

2,92369E-1

3,53787E-1

1,08893E0

1,77052E-1

1,86530E0

4,30072E-1

9,70770E0

1,98090E0

3,31267E-1

7,52055E0

6,62157E-1

1,38868E0

3.2

copasi

9,11073E-1

1,36502E0

2,92368E-1

3,53787E-1

1,08893E0

1,77052E-1

1,34698E-1

1,86530E0

1,91038E-2

4,30072E-1

9,70770E0

1,98090E0

3,31267E-1

6,34977E-1

7,52056E0

6,62157E-1

1,38868E0

3.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

9,12000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

1,68000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

2,63000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3.2

jsim

9,11072E-1

1,36502E0

2,92368E-1

3,53787E-1

1,08893E0

1,77052E-1

1,34698E-1

1,86530E0

1,91038E-2

4,30072E-1

9,70770E0

1,98090E0

3,31267E-1

6,34977E-1

7,52056E0

6,62157E-1

1,38868E0

3.2

min

5,00000E-1

1,79402E-5

3,80357E-15

3,53787E-1

1,88725E-6

1,77001E-1

1,34522E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,59371E-1

9,70555E0

6,93092E-9

3,31267E-1

5,00000E-1

7,52051E0

4,29342E-1

5,86660E-2

3.2

max

9,11073E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

9,12000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,86547E0

1,91038E-2

4,30119E-1

1,68000E1

2,00000E0

4,60999E-1

6,34977E-1

2,63000E2

6,62157E-1

1,50000E0

3.2

mean

9,11072E-1

1,36502E0

2,92368E-1

3,53787E-1

1,08893E0

1,77052E-1

1,34698E-1

1,86530E0

1,91038E-2

4,30072E-1

9,70770E0

1,98090E0

3,31267E-1

6,34977E-1

7,52056E0

6,62157E-1

1,38868E0

3.2

relative error(%)

0,00

3.4

BioUML

9,38159E-1

1,35420E0

2,92275E-1

3,44204E-1

1,06184E0

1,68555E-1

1,27555E-1

1,87245E0

1,80929E-2

4,38089E-1

1,01389E1

1,98191E0

3,24267E-1

6,45801E-1

7,53155E0

6,67041E-1

1,38517E0

3.4

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,35420E0

2,92275E-1

3,44204E-1

1,06184E0

1,68555E-1

5,00000E-1

1,87245E0

0,00000E0

4,38089E-1

1,01389E1

1,98191E0

3,24267E-1

5,00000E-1

7,53155E0

6,67041E-1

1,38517E0

3.4

MathSBML

9,38159E-1

1,35420E0

2,92275E-1

3,44204E-1

1,06184E0

1,68555E-1

1,27555E-1

1,87245E0

1,80929E-2

4,38089E-1

1,01389E1

1,98191E0

3,24267E-1

6,45801E-1

7,53155E0

6,67041E-1

1,38517E0

3.4

Oscill8 Core

7,05553E-6

5,14777E-16

4,77597E-1

6,97079E-7

4,05053E-1

1,65000E0

2,53668E-1

1,76000E1

1,78682E-9

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,27176E-1

4,76220E-2

3.4

SBToolbox2

9,37711E-1

1,35447E0

2,92470E-1

3,44203E-1

1,06231E0

1,68499E-1

1,27386E-1

1,87260E0

1,80760E-2

4,38144E-1

1,01365E1

1,98190E0

3,24309E-1

6,45510E-1

7,53153E0

6,66982E-1

1,38603E0

3.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,35420E0

2,92275E-1

3,44204E-1

1,06184E0

1,68555E-1

1,87244E0

4,38089E-1

1,01389E1

1,98191E0

3,24267E-1

7,53155E0

6,67041E-1

1,38517E0

3.4

copasi

9,38160E-1

1,35420E0

2,92276E-1

3,44204E-1

1,06184E0

1,68555E-1

1,27555E-1

1,87245E0

1,80929E-2

4,38089E-1

1,01389E1

1,98191E0

3,24267E-1

6,45801E-1

7,53155E0

6,67041E-1

1,38517E0

3.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

9,44000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

1,76000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

2,79000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3.4

jsim

9,38159E-1

1,35420E0

2,92275E-1

3,44204E-1

1,06184E0

1,68555E-1

1,27555E-1

1,87245E0

1,80929E-2

4,38089E-1

1,01389E1

1,98191E0

3,24267E-1

6,45801E-1

7,53155E0

6,67041E-1

1,38517E0

3.4

min

5,00000E-1

7,05553E-6

5,14777E-16

3,44203E-1

6,97079E-7

1,68499E-1

1,27386E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,53668E-1

1,01365E1

1,78682E-9

3,24267E-1

5,00000E-1

7,53153E0

4,27176E-1

4,76220E-2

3.4

max

9,38160E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

9,44000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,87260E0

1,80929E-2

4,38144E-1

1,76000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,45801E-1

2,79000E2

6,67041E-1

1,50000E0

3.4

mean

9,38159E-1

1,35420E0

2,92275E-1

3,44204E-1

1,06184E0

1,68555E-1

1,27555E-1

1,87245E0

1,80929E-2

4,38089E-1

1,01389E1

1,98191E0

3,24267E-1

6,45801E-1

7,53155E0

6,67041E-1

1,38517E0

3.4

relative error(%)

0,00

3.6

BioUML

9,62511E-1

1,34408E0

2,92470E-1

3,34762E-1

1,03749E0

1,60514E-1

1,21060E-1

1,87894E0

1,71953E-2

4,45999E-1

1,05737E1

1,98280E0

3,17155E-1

6,55916E-1

7,54096E0

6,71276E-1

1,38227E0

3.6

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,34408E0

2,92470E-1

3,34762E-1

1,03749E0

1,60514E-1

5,00000E-1

1,87894E0

0,00000E0

4,45999E-1

1,05737E1

1,98280E0

3,17155E-1

5,00000E-1

7,54096E0

6,71276E-1

1,38227E0

3.6

MathSBML

9,62511E-1

1,34408E0

2,92470E-1

3,34762E-1

1,03749E0

1,60514E-1

1,21060E-1

1,87894E0

1,71953E-2

4,45999E-1

1,05737E1

1,98280E0

3,17155E-1

6,55916E-1

7,54096E0

6,71276E-1

1,38227E0

3.6

Oscill8 Core

2,75749E-6

6,96699E-17

4,77597E-1

2,57165E-7

4,12941E-1

1,65000E0

2,48014E-1

1,84000E1

4,56528E-10

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,25105E-1

3,86588E-2

3.6

SBToolbox2

9,62076E-1

1,34438E0

2,92663E-1

3,34759E-1

1,03793E0

1,60460E-1

1,20912E-1

1,87909E0

1,71805E-2

4,46060E-1

1,05711E1

1,98280E0

3,17200E-1

6,55637E-1

7,54086E0

6,71208E-1

1,38314E0

3.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,34408E0

2,92471E-1

3,34762E-1

1,03749E0

1,60514E-1

1,87894E0

4,45999E-1

1,05737E1

1,98280E0

3,17155E-1

7,54096E0

6,71276E-1

1,38227E0

3.6

copasi

9,62511E-1

1,34408E0

2,92471E-1

3,34762E-1

1,03749E0

1,60514E-1

1,21060E-1

1,87894E0

1,71953E-2

4,45999E-1

1,05737E1

1,98280E0

3,17155E-1

6,55916E-1

7,54096E0

6,71276E-1

1,38227E0

3.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

9,76000E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

1,84000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

2,95000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3.6

jsim

9,62511E-1

1,34408E0

2,92470E-1

3,34762E-1

1,03749E0

1,60514E-1

1,21060E-1

1,87894E0

1,71953E-2

4,45999E-1

1,05737E1

1,98280E0

3,17155E-1

6,55916E-1

7,54096E0

6,71276E-1

1,38227E0

3.6

min

5,00000E-1

2,75749E-6

6,96699E-17

3,34759E-1

2,57165E-7

1,60460E-1

1,20912E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,48014E-1

1,05711E1

4,56528E-10

3,17155E-1

5,00000E-1

7,54086E0

4,25105E-1

3,86588E-2

3.6

max

9,62511E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

9,76000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,87909E0

1,71953E-2

4,46060E-1

1,84000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,55916E-1

2,95000E2

6,71276E-1

1,50000E0

3.6

mean

9,62511E-1

1,34408E0

2,92471E-1

3,34762E-1

1,03749E0

1,60514E-1

1,21060E-1

1,87894E0

1,71953E-2

4,45999E-1

1,05737E1

1,98280E0

3,17155E-1

6,55916E-1

7,54096E0

6,71276E-1

1,38227E0

3.6

relative error(%)

0,00

3.8

BioUML

9,83946E-1

1,33485E0

2,92990E-1

3,25470E-1

1,01605E0

1,52899E-1

1,15142E-1

1,88486E0

1,63992E-2

4,53795E-1

1,10113E1

1,98360E0

3,09966E-1

6,65149E-1

7,54887E0

6,74865E-1

1,38015E0

3.8

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,33485E0

2,92990E-1

3,25470E-1

1,01605E0

1,52899E-1

5,00000E-1

1,88486E0

0,00000E0

4,53795E-1

1,10113E1

1,98360E0

3,09966E-1

5,00000E-1

7,54887E0

6,74865E-1

1,38015E0

3.8

MathSBML

9,83946E-1

1,33485E0

2,92990E-1

3,25470E-1

1,01605E0

1,52899E-1

1,15142E-1

1,88486E0

1,63992E-2

4,53795E-1

1,10113E1

1,98360E0

3,09966E-1

6,65149E-1

7,54887E0

6,74865E-1

1,38015E0

3.8

Oscill8 Core

1,07179E-6

9,42910E-18

4,77597E-1

9,47911E-8

4,21556E-1

1,65000E0

2,42425E-1

1,92000E1

1,15641E-10

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,23112E-1

3,13838E-2

3.8

SBToolbox2

9,83490E-1

1,33515E0

2,93185E-1

3,25465E-1

1,01648E0

1,52834E-1

1,14996E-1

1,88499E0

1,63891E-2

4,53862E-1

1,10086E1

1,98360E0

3,10017E-1

6,64863E-1

7,54875E0

6,74789E-1

1,38104E0

3.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,33485E0

2,92990E-1

3,25470E-1

1,01605E0

1,52899E-1

1,88486E0

4,53795E-1

1,10113E1

1,98360E0

3,09966E-1

7,54887E0

6,74865E-1

1,38015E0

3.8

copasi

9,83946E-1

1,33485E0

2,92990E-1

3,25470E-1

1,01605E0

1,52899E-1

1,15142E-1

1,88486E0

1,63993E-2

4,53795E-1

1,10113E1

1,98360E0

3,09966E-1

6,65149E-1

7,54887E0

6,74865E-1

1,38015E0

3.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,00800E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

1,92000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

3,11000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

3.8

jsim

9,83946E-1

1,33485E0

2,92990E-1

3,25470E-1

1,01605E0

1,52899E-1

1,15142E-1

1,88486E0

1,63992E-2

4,53795E-1

1,10113E1

1,98360E0

3,09966E-1

6,65149E-1

7,54887E0

6,74865E-1

1,38015E0

3.8

min

5,00000E-1

1,07179E-6

9,42910E-18

3,25465E-1

9,47911E-8

1,52834E-1

1,14996E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,42425E-1

1,10086E1

1,15641E-10

3,09966E-1

5,00000E-1

7,54875E0

4,23112E-1

3,13838E-2

3.8

max

9,83946E-1

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,00800E0

5,00000E-1

1,88499E0

1,63993E-2

4,53862E-1

1,92000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,65149E-1

3,11000E2

6,74865E-1

1,50000E0

3.8

mean

9,83946E-1

1,33485E0

2,92990E-1

3,25470E-1

1,01605E0

1,52899E-1

1,15142E-1

1,88486E0

1,63992E-2

4,53795E-1

1,10113E1

1,98360E0

3,09966E-1

6,65149E-1

7,54887E0

6,74865E-1

1,38015E0

3.8

relative error(%)

0,00

4.0

BioUML

1,00233E0

1,32666E0

2,93869E-1

3,16335E-1

9,97673E-1

1,45682E-1

1,09739E-1

1,89026E0

1,56945E-2

4,61473E-1

1,14511E1

1,98431E0

3,02735E-1

6,73342E-1

7,55537E0

6,77809E-1

1,37899E0

4.0

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,32666E0

2,93869E-1

3,16335E-1

9,97673E-1

1,45682E-1

5,00000E-1

1,89026E0

0,00000E0

4,61473E-1

1,14511E1

1,98431E0

3,02735E-1

5,00000E-1

7,55537E0

6,77809E-1

1,37899E0

4.0

MathSBML

1,00233E0

1,32666E0

2,93869E-1

3,16335E-1

9,97673E-1

1,45682E-1

1,09739E-1

1,89026E0

1,56945E-2

4,61473E-1

1,14511E1

1,98431E0

3,02735E-1

6,73342E-1

7,55537E0

6,77809E-1

1,37899E0

4.0

Oscill8 Core

4,14565E-7

1,27612E-18

4,77597E-1

3,49188E-8

4,30975E-1

1,65000E0

2,36912E-1

2,00000E1

2,90503E-11

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,21185E-1

2,54789E-2

4.0

SBToolbox2

1,00188E0

1,32696E0

2,94066E-1

3,16324E-1

9,98126E-1

1,45620E-1

1,09610E-1

1,89038E0

1,56836E-2

4,61548E-1

1,14482E1

1,98430E0

3,02784E-1

6,73074E-1

7,55528E0

6,77728E-1

1,37990E0

4.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,32666E0

2,93870E-1

3,16335E-1

9,97674E-1

1,45682E-1

1,89026E0

4,61473E-1

1,14511E1

1,98431E0

3,02735E-1

7,55537E0

6,77809E-1

1,37899E0

4.0

copasi

1,00233E0

1,32666E0

2,93869E-1

3,16335E-1

9,97673E-1

1,45682E-1

1,09739E-1

1,89026E0

1,56945E-2

4,61473E-1

1,14511E1

1,98431E0

3,02734E-1

6,73343E-1

7,55537E0

6,77809E-1

1,37899E0

4.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,04000E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,00000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

3,27000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4.0

jsim

1,00233E0

1,32666E0

2,93869E-1

3,16335E-1

9,97673E-1

1,45682E-1

1,09739E-1

1,89026E0

1,56945E-2

4,61473E-1

1,14511E1

1,98431E0

3,02735E-1

6,73342E-1

7,55537E0

6,77809E-1

1,37899E0

4.0

min

5,00000E-1

4,14565E-7

1,27612E-18

3,16324E-1

3,49188E-8

1,45620E-1

1,09610E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,36912E-1

1,14482E1

2,90503E-11

3,02734E-1

5,00000E-1

7,55528E0

4,21185E-1

2,54789E-2

4.0

max

1,00233E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,04000E0

5,00000E-1

1,89038E0

1,56945E-2

4,61548E-1

2,00000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,73343E-1

3,27000E2

6,77809E-1

1,50000E0

4.0

mean

1,00233E0

1,32666E0

2,93869E-1

3,16335E-1

9,97673E-1

1,45682E-1

1,09739E-1

1,89026E0

1,56945E-2

4,61473E-1

1,14511E1

1,98431E0

3,02735E-1

6,73342E-1

7,55537E0

6,77809E-1

1,37899E0

4.0

relative error(%)

0,00

4.2

BioUML

1,01755E0

1,31965E0

2,95144E-1

3,07359E-1

9,82449E-1

1,38837E-1

1,04796E-1

1,89520E0

1,50724E-2

4,69032E-1

1,18922E1

1,98493E0

2,95493E-1

6,80353E-1

7,56050E0

6,80113E-1

1,37896E0

4.2

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,31965E0

2,95144E-1

3,07359E-1

9,82449E-1

1,38837E-1

5,00000E-1

1,89520E0

0,00000E0

4,69032E-1

1,18922E1

1,98493E0

2,95493E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56050E0

6,80113E-1

1,37896E0

4.2

MathSBML

1,01755E0

1,31965E0

2,95144E-1

3,07359E-1

9,82449E-1

1,38837E-1

1,04796E-1

1,89520E0

1,50723E-2

4,69032E-1

1,18922E1

1,98493E0

2,95493E-1

6,80353E-1

7,56050E0

6,80113E-1

1,37896E0

4.2

Oscill8 Core

1,59658E-7

1,72709E-19

4,77597E-1

1,28578E-8

4,41275E-1

1,65000E0

2,31485E-1

2,08000E1

7,23931E-12

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,19310E-1

2,06857E-2

4.2

SBToolbox2

1,01711E0

1,31993E0

2,95341E-1

3,07345E-1

9,82926E-1

1,38769E-1

1,04671E-1

1,89532E0

1,50658E-2

4,69115E-1

1,18888E1

1,98490E0

2,95545E-1

6,80076E-1

7,56037E0

6,80028E-1

1,37990E0

4.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,31965E0

2,95144E-1

3,07359E-1

9,82450E-1

1,38837E-1

1,89520E0

4,69032E-1

1,18922E1

1,98493E0

2,95493E-1

7,56050E0

6,80113E-1

1,37896E0

4.2

copasi

1,01755E0

1,31965E0

2,95144E-1

3,07359E-1

9,82449E-1

1,38837E-1

1,04796E-1

1,89520E0

1,50724E-2

4,69032E-1

1,18922E1

1,98493E0

2,95492E-1

6,80353E-1

7,56050E0

6,80113E-1

1,37896E0

4.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,07200E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,08000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

3,43000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4.2

jsim

1,01755E0

1,31965E0

2,95144E-1

3,07359E-1

9,82449E-1

1,38837E-1

1,04796E-1

1,89520E0

1,50724E-2

4,69032E-1

1,18922E1

1,98493E0

2,95493E-1

6,80353E-1

7,56050E0

6,80113E-1

1,37896E0

4.2

min

5,00000E-1

1,59658E-7

1,72709E-19

3,07345E-1

1,28578E-8

1,38769E-1

1,04671E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,31485E-1

1,18888E1

7,23931E-12

2,95492E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56037E0

4,19310E-1

2,06857E-2

4.2

max

1,01755E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,07200E0

5,00000E-1

1,89532E0

1,50724E-2

4,69115E-1

2,08000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,80353E-1

3,43000E2

6,80113E-1

1,50000E0

4.2

mean

1,01755E0

1,31965E0

2,95144E-1

3,07359E-1

9,82449E-1

1,38837E-1

1,04796E-1

1,89520E0

1,50723E-2

4,69032E-1

1,18922E1

1,98493E0

2,95493E-1

6,80353E-1

7,56050E0

6,80113E-1

1,37896E0

4.2

relative error(%)

0,00

4.4

BioUML

1,02955E0

1,31394E0

2,96848E-1

2,98544E-1

9,70455E-1

1,32337E-1

1,00265E-1

1,89973E0

1,45253E-2

4,76474E-1

1,23339E1

1,98547E0

2,88270E-1

6,86057E-1

7,56432E0

6,81778E-1

1,38023E0

4.4

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,31394E0

2,96848E-1

2,98544E-1

9,70455E-1

1,32337E-1

5,00000E-1

1,89973E0

0,00000E0

4,76474E-1

1,23339E1

1,98547E0

2,88270E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56432E0

6,81778E-1

1,38023E0

4.4

MathSBML

1,02955E0

1,31394E0

2,96848E-1

2,98544E-1

9,70455E-1

1,32337E-1

1,00265E-1

1,89973E0

1,45253E-2

4,76474E-1

1,23339E1

1,98547E0

2,88270E-1

6,86057E-1

7,56432E0

6,81778E-1

1,38023E0

4.4

Oscill8 Core

6,12479E-8

2,33740E-20

4,77597E-1

4,73308E-9

4,52543E-1

1,65000E0

2,26150E-1

2,16000E1

1,78997E-12

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,17480E-1

1,67949E-2

4.4

SBToolbox2

1,02908E0

1,31419E0

2,97046E-1

2,98524E-1

9,70944E-1

1,32271E-1

1,00152E-1

1,89981E0

1,45184E-2

4,76567E-1

1,23303E1

1,98550E0

2,88318E-1

6,85800E-1

7,56416E0

6,81689E-1

1,38116E0

4.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,31394E0

2,96848E-1

2,98544E-1

9,70456E-1

1,32337E-1

1,89973E0

4,76474E-1

1,23339E1

1,98547E0

2,88270E-1

7,56432E0

6,81778E-1

1,38024E0

4.4

copasi

1,02954E0

1,31394E0

2,96848E-1

2,98544E-1

9,70455E-1

1,32337E-1

1,00265E-1

1,89973E0

1,45253E-2

4,76474E-1

1,23339E1

1,98547E0

2,88270E-1

6,86057E-1

7,56432E0

6,81778E-1

1,38023E0

4.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,10400E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,16000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

3,59000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4.4

jsim

1,02955E0

1,31394E0

2,96848E-1

2,98544E-1

9,70455E-1

1,32337E-1

1,00265E-1

1,89973E0

1,45253E-2

4,76474E-1

1,23339E1

1,98547E0

2,88270E-1

6,86057E-1

7,56432E0

6,81778E-1

1,38023E0

4.4

min

5,00000E-1

6,12479E-8

2,33740E-20

2,98524E-1

4,73308E-9

1,32271E-1

1,00152E-1

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,26150E-1

1,23303E1

1,78997E-12

2,88270E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56416E0

4,17480E-1

1,67949E-2

4.4

max

1,02955E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,10400E0

5,00000E-1

1,89981E0

1,45253E-2

4,76567E-1

2,16000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,86057E-1

3,59000E2

6,81778E-1

1,50000E0

4.4

mean

1,02954E0

1,31394E0

2,96848E-1

2,98544E-1

9,70455E-1

1,32337E-1

1,00265E-1

1,89973E0

1,45253E-2

4,76474E-1

1,23339E1

1,98547E0

2,88270E-1

6,86057E-1

7,56432E0

6,81778E-1

1,38023E0

4.4

relative error(%)

0,00

4.6

BioUML

1,03826E0

1,30965E0

2,99017E-1

2,89888E-1

9,61742E-1

1,26158E-1

9,61054E-2

1,90389E0

1,40468E-2

4,83804E-1

1,27753E1

1,98595E0

2,81095E-1

6,90352E-1

7,56687E0

6,82807E-1

1,38298E0

4.6

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,30965E0

2,99017E-1

2,89888E-1

9,61742E-1

1,26158E-1

5,00000E-1

1,90389E0

0,00000E0

4,83804E-1

1,27753E1

1,98595E0

2,81095E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56687E0

6,82807E-1

1,38298E0

4.6

MathSBML

1,03826E0

1,30965E0

2,99017E-1

2,89888E-1

9,61742E-1

1,26158E-1

9,61054E-2

1,90389E0

1,40468E-2

4,83804E-1

1,27753E1

1,98595E0

2,81095E-1

6,90352E-1

7,56687E0

6,82807E-1

1,38298E0

4.6

Oscill8 Core

2,34131E-8

3,16338E-21

4,77597E-1

1,74194E-9

4,64874E-1

1,65000E0

2,20912E-1

2,24000E1

4,39216E-13

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,15688E-1

1,36364E-2

4.6

SBToolbox2

1,03776E0

1,30989E0

2,99225E-1

2,89863E-1

9,62256E-1

1,26083E-1

9,59945E-2

1,90401E0

1,40411E-2

4,83910E-1

1,27709E1

1,98595E0

2,81151E-1

6,90082E-1

7,56665E0

6,82712E-1

1,38401E0

4.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,30965E0

2,99017E-1

2,89888E-1

9,61743E-1

1,26158E-1

1,90389E0

4,83804E-1

1,27753E1

1,98595E0

2,81095E-1

7,56687E0

6,82807E-1

1,38298E0

4.6

copasi

1,03826E0

1,30965E0

2,99017E-1

2,89888E-1

9,61743E-1

1,26158E-1

9,61054E-2

1,90389E0

1,40468E-2

4,83804E-1

1,27753E1

1,98595E0

2,81094E-1

6,90352E-1

7,56687E0

6,82807E-1

1,38298E0

4.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,13600E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,24000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

3,75000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4.6

jsim

1,03826E0

1,30965E0

2,99017E-1

2,89888E-1

9,61742E-1

1,26158E-1

9,61054E-2

1,90389E0

1,40470E-2

4,83804E-1

1,27753E1

1,98595E0

2,81095E-1

6,90352E-1

7,56687E0

6,82807E-1

1,38298E0

4.6

min

5,00000E-1

2,34131E-8

3,16338E-21

2,89863E-1

1,74194E-9

1,26083E-1

9,59945E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,20912E-1

1,27709E1

4,39216E-13

2,81094E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56665E0

4,15688E-1

1,36364E-2

4.6

max

1,03826E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,13600E0

5,00000E-1

1,90401E0

1,40470E-2

4,83910E-1

2,24000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,90352E-1

3,75000E2

6,82807E-1

1,50000E0

4.6

mean

1,03826E0

1,30965E0

2,99017E-1

2,89888E-1

9,61743E-1

1,26158E-1

9,61054E-2

1,90389E0

1,40468E-2

4,83804E-1

1,27753E1

1,98595E0

2,81095E-1

6,90352E-1

7,56687E0

6,82807E-1

1,38298E0

4.6

relative error(%)

0,00

4.8

BioUML

1,04365E0

1,30684E0

3,01688E-1

2,81388E-1

9,56347E-1

1,20278E-1

9,22798E-2

1,90772E0

1,36315E-2

4,91027E-1

1,32158E1

1,98637E0

2,73991E-1

6,93158E-1

7,56818E0

6,83203E-1

1,38736E0

4.8

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,30684E0

3,01688E-1

2,81388E-1

9,56347E-1

1,20278E-1

5,00000E-1

1,90772E0

0,00000E0

4,91027E-1

1,32158E1

1,98637E0

2,73991E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56818E0

6,83203E-1

1,38736E0

4.8

MathSBML

1,04365E0

1,30684E0

3,01688E-1

2,81388E-1

9,56347E-1

1,20278E-1

9,22798E-2

1,90772E0

1,36315E-2

4,91027E-1

1,32158E1

1,98637E0

2,73991E-1

6,93158E-1

7,56818E0

6,83203E-1

1,38736E0

4.8

Oscill8 Core

8,92121E-9

4,28122E-22

4,77597E-1

6,41005E-10

4,78368E-1

1,65000E0

2,15774E-1

2,32000E1

1,06970E-13

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,13926E-1

1,10723E-2

4.8

SBToolbox2

1,04310E0

1,30705E0

3,01888E-1

2,81362E-1

9,56881E-1

1,20204E-1

9,21808E-2

1,90780E0

1,36301E-2

4,91137E-1

1,32114E1

1,98640E0

2,74043E-1

6,92902E-1

7,56800E0

6,83100E-1

1,38836E0

4.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,30684E0

3,01688E-1

2,81388E-1

9,56348E-1

1,20278E-1

1,90772E0

4,91027E-1

1,32158E1

1,98637E0

2,73991E-1

7,56818E0

6,83203E-1

1,38736E0

4.8

copasi

1,04365E0

1,30684E0

3,01688E-1

2,81388E-1

9,56348E-1

1,20278E-1

9,22798E-2

1,90772E0

1,36315E-2

4,91027E-1

1,32158E1

1,98637E0

2,73991E-1

6,93158E-1

7,56818E0

6,83203E-1

1,38736E0

4.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,16800E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,32000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

3,91000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

4.8

jsim

1,04365E0

1,30684E0

3,01688E-1

2,81388E-1

9,56347E-1

1,20278E-1

9,22798E-2

1,90772E0

1,36318E-2

4,91027E-1

1,32158E1

1,98637E0

2,73991E-1

6,93158E-1

7,56818E0

6,83203E-1

1,38736E0

4.8

min

5,00000E-1

8,92121E-9

4,28122E-22

2,81362E-1

6,41005E-10

1,20204E-1

9,21808E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,15774E-1

1,32114E1

1,06970E-13

2,73991E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56800E0

4,13926E-1

1,10723E-2

4.8

max

1,04365E0

1,50000E0

3,01888E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,16800E0

5,00000E-1

1,90780E0

1,36318E-2

4,91137E-1

2,32000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,93158E-1

3,91000E2

6,83203E-1

1,50000E0

4.8

mean

1,04365E0

1,30684E0

3,01688E-1

2,81388E-1

9,56348E-1

1,20278E-1

9,22798E-2

1,90772E0

1,36315E-2

4,91027E-1

1,32158E1

1,98637E0

2,73991E-1

6,93158E-1

7,56818E0

6,83203E-1

1,38736E0

4.8

relative error(%)

0,00

5.0

BioUML

1,04570E0

1,30558E0

3,04899E-1

2,73043E-1

9,54297E-1

1,14675E-1

8,87568E-2

1,91124E0

1,32747E-2

4,98152E-1

1,36545E1

1,98673E0

2,66980E-1

6,94416E-1

7,56826E0

6,82968E-1

1,39355E0

5.0

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,30558E0

3,04899E-1

2,73043E-1

9,54297E-1

1,14675E-1

5,00000E-1

1,91124E0

0,00000E0

4,98152E-1

1,36545E1

1,98673E0

2,66980E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56826E0

6,82968E-1

1,39355E0

5.0

MathSBML

1,04570E0

1,30558E0

3,04899E-1

2,73043E-1

9,54297E-1

1,14675E-1

8,87568E-2

1,91124E0

1,32747E-2

4,98152E-1

1,36545E1

1,98673E0

2,66980E-1

6,94416E-1

7,56826E0

6,82968E-1

1,39355E0

5.0

Oscill8 Core

3,38923E-9

5,79405E-23

4,77597E-1

2,35857E-10

4,93135E-1

1,65000E0

2,10738E-1

2,40000E1

2,58615E-14

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,12192E-1

8,99067E-3

5.0

SBToolbox2

1,04515E0

1,30585E0

3,05110E-1

2,73010E-1

9,54855E-1

1,14595E-1

8,86555E-2

1,91135E0

1,32690E-2

4,98275E-1

1,36500E1

1,98670E0

2,67035E-1

6,94150E-1

7,56805E0

6,82865E-1

1,39460E0

5.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,30558E0

3,04900E-1

2,73042E-1

9,54298E-1

1,14675E-1

1,91124E0

4,98152E-1

1,36545E1

1,98673E0

2,66980E-1

7,56826E0

6,82968E-1

1,39355E0

5.0

copasi

1,04570E0

1,30558E0

3,04899E-1

2,73043E-1

9,54298E-1

1,14675E-1

8,87567E-2

1,91124E0

1,32747E-2

4,98152E-1

1,36545E1

1,98673E0

2,66980E-1

6,94416E-1

7,56826E0

6,82968E-1

1,39355E0

5.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,20000E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,40000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

4,07000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

5.0

jsim

1,04570E0

1,30558E0

3,04899E-1

2,73043E-1

9,54297E-1

1,14675E-1

8,87568E-2

1,91124E0

1,32749E-2

4,98152E-1

1,36545E1

1,98673E0

2,66980E-1

6,94416E-1

7,56826E0

6,82968E-1

1,39355E0

5.0

min

5,00000E-1

3,38923E-9

5,79405E-23

2,73010E-1

2,35857E-10

1,14595E-1

8,86555E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,10738E-1

1,36500E1

2,58615E-14

2,66980E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56805E0

4,12192E-1

8,99067E-3

5.0

max

1,04570E0

1,50000E0

3,05110E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,20000E0

5,00000E-1

1,91135E0

1,32749E-2

4,98275E-1

2,40000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,94416E-1

4,07000E2

6,82968E-1

1,50000E0

5.0

mean

1,04570E0

1,30558E0

3,04899E-1

2,73043E-1

9,54298E-1

1,14675E-1

8,87568E-2

1,91124E0

1,32747E-2

4,98152E-1

1,36545E1

1,98673E0

2,66980E-1

6,94416E-1

7,56826E0

6,82968E-1

1,39355E0

5.0

relative error(%)

0,00

5.2

BioUML

1,04438E0

1,30591E0

3,08691E-1

2,64846E-1

9,55617E-1

1,09332E-1

8,55083E-2

1,91449E0

1,29726E-2

5,05189E-1

1,40905E1

1,98703E0

2,60081E-1

6,94093E-1

7,56711E0

6,82103E-1

1,40173E0

5.2

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,30591E0

3,08691E-1

2,64846E-1

9,55617E-1

1,09332E-1

5,00000E-1

1,91449E0

0,00000E0

5,05189E-1

1,40905E1

1,98703E0

2,60081E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56711E0

6,82103E-1

1,40173E0

5.2

MathSBML

1,04438E0

1,30591E0

3,08691E-1

2,64846E-1

9,55617E-1

1,09332E-1

8,55083E-2

1,91449E0

1,29726E-2

5,05189E-1

1,40905E1

1,98703E0

2,60081E-1

6,94093E-1

7,56711E0

6,82103E-1

1,40173E0

5.2

Oscill8 Core

1,28405E-9

7,84143E-24

4,77597E-1

8,67774E-11

5,09293E-1

1,65000E0

2,05807E-1

2,48000E1

6,20733E-15

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,10480E-1

7,30063E-3

5.2

SBToolbox2

1,04380E0

1,30620E0

3,08886E-1

2,64803E-1

9,56202E-1

1,09245E-1

8,54176E-2

1,91460E0

1,29788E-2

5,05328E-1

1,40851E1

1,98700E0

2,60137E-1

6,93821E-1

7,56685E0

6,81991E-1

1,40279E0

5.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,30591E0

3,08692E-1

2,64846E-1

9,55618E-1

1,09332E-1

1,91449E0

5,05189E-1

1,40905E1

1,98703E0

2,60082E-1

7,56710E0

6,82103E-1

1,40173E0

5.2

copasi

1,04438E0

1,30591E0

3,08691E-1

2,64846E-1

9,55618E-1

1,09332E-1

8,55083E-2

1,91449E0

1,29726E-2

5,05189E-1

1,40905E1

1,98703E0

2,60081E-1

6,94093E-1

7,56711E0

6,82103E-1

1,40173E0

5.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,23200E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,48000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

4,23000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

5.2

jsim

1,04438E0

1,30591E0

3,08691E-1

2,64846E-1

9,55617E-1

1,09332E-1

8,55083E-2

1,91449E0

1,29734E-2

5,05189E-1

1,40905E1

1,98703E0

2,60081E-1

6,94093E-1

7,56711E0

6,82103E-1

1,40173E0

5.2

min

5,00000E-1

1,28405E-9

7,84143E-24

2,64803E-1

8,67774E-11

1,09245E-1

8,54176E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,05807E-1

1,40851E1

6,20733E-15

2,60081E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56685E0

4,10480E-1

7,30063E-3

5.2

max

1,04438E0

1,50000E0

3,08886E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,23200E0

5,00000E-1

1,91460E0

1,29788E-2

5,05328E-1

2,48000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,94093E-1

4,23000E2

6,82103E-1

1,50000E0

5.2

mean

1,04438E0

1,30591E0

3,08691E-1

2,64846E-1

9,55617E-1

1,09332E-1

8,55083E-2

1,91449E0

1,29726E-2

5,05189E-1

1,40905E1

1,98703E0

2,60082E-1

6,94093E-1

7,56711E0

6,82103E-1

1,40173E0

5.2

relative error(%)

0,00

5.4

BioUML

1,03967E0

1,30783E0

3,13109E-1

2,56794E-1

9,60329E-1

1,04229E-1

8,25101E-2

1,91749E0

1,27221E-2

5,12152E-1

1,45230E1

1,98728E0

2,53311E-1

6,92173E-1

7,56472E0

6,80610E-1

1,41206E0

5.4

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,30783E0

3,13109E-1

2,56794E-1

9,60329E-1

1,04229E-1

5,00000E-1

1,91749E0

0,00000E0

5,12152E-1

1,45230E1

1,98728E0

2,53311E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56472E0

6,80610E-1

1,41206E0

5.4

MathSBML

1,03967E0

1,30783E0

3,13109E-1

2,56794E-1

9,60329E-1

1,04229E-1

8,25101E-2

1,91749E0

1,27221E-2

5,12152E-1

1,45230E1

1,98728E0

2,53311E-1

6,92173E-1

7,56472E0

6,80610E-1

1,41206E0

5.4

Oscill8 Core

4,85229E-10

1,06122E-24

4,77597E-1

3,19261E-11

5,26969E-1

1,65000E0

2,00980E-1

2,56000E1

1,47932E-15

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,08787E-1

5,92848E-3

5.4

SBToolbox2

1,03906E0

1,30815E0

3,13300E-1

2,56746E-1

9,60927E-1

1,04145E-1

8,24128E-2

1,91759E0

1,27189E-2

5,12296E-1

1,45177E1

1,98730E0

2,53364E-1

6,91876E-1

7,56451E0

6,80489E-1

1,41308E0

5.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,30783E0

3,13107E-1

2,56794E-1

9,60330E-1

1,04229E-1

1,91749E0

5,12152E-1

1,45230E1

1,98728E0

2,53311E-1

7,56472E0

6,80609E-1

1,41206E0

5.4

copasi

1,03967E0

1,30783E0

3,13109E-1

2,56794E-1

9,60330E-1

1,04229E-1

8,25101E-2

1,91749E0

1,27221E-2

5,12152E-1

1,45230E1

1,98728E0

2,53311E-1

6,92173E-1

7,56472E0

6,80609E-1

1,41206E0

5.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,26400E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,56000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

4,39000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

5.4

jsim

1,03967E0

1,30783E0

3,13109E-1

2,56794E-1

9,60329E-1

1,04229E-1

8,25101E-2

1,91749E0

1,27225E-2

5,12152E-1

1,45230E1

1,98728E0

2,53311E-1

6,92173E-1

7,56472E0

6,80610E-1

1,41206E0

5.4

min

5,00000E-1

4,85229E-10

1,06122E-24

2,56746E-1

3,19261E-11

1,04145E-1

8,24128E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

2,00980E-1

1,45177E1

1,47932E-15

2,53311E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56451E0

4,08787E-1

5,92848E-3

5.4

max

1,03967E0

1,50000E0

3,13300E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,26400E0

5,00000E-1

1,91759E0

1,27225E-2

5,12296E-1

2,56000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,92173E-1

4,39000E2

6,80610E-1

1,50000E0

5.4

mean

1,03967E0

1,30783E0

3,13109E-1

2,56794E-1

9,60330E-1

1,04229E-1

8,25101E-2

1,91749E0

1,27221E-2

5,12152E-1

1,45230E1

1,98728E0

2,53311E-1

6,92173E-1

7,56472E0

6,80609E-1

1,41206E0

5.4

relative error(%)

0,00

5.6

BioUML

1,03154E0

1,31133E0

3,18202E-1

2,48882E-1

9,68459E-1

9,93503E-2

7,97408E-2

1,92026E0

1,25207E-2

5,19053E-1

1,49511E1

1,98748E0

2,46681E-1

6,88667E-1

7,56108E0

6,78488E-1

1,42474E0

5.6

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,31133E0

3,18202E-1

2,48882E-1

9,68459E-1

9,93503E-2

5,00000E-1

1,92026E0

0,00000E0

5,19053E-1

1,49511E1

1,98748E0

2,46681E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56108E0

6,78488E-1

1,42474E0

5.6

MathSBML

1,03154E0

1,31133E0

3,18202E-1

2,48882E-1

9,68459E-1

9,93503E-2

7,97408E-2

1,92026E0

1,25207E-2

5,19053E-1

1,49511E1

1,98748E0

2,46681E-1

6,88667E-1

7,56108E0

6,78488E-1

1,42474E0

5.6

Oscill8 Core

1,82919E-10

1,43620E-25

4,77597E-1

1,17456E-11

5,46301E-1

1,65000E0

1,96257E-1

2,64000E1

3,50076E-16

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,07112E-1

4,81439E-3

5.6

SBToolbox2

1,03088E0

1,31169E0

3,18403E-1

2,48828E-1

9,69086E-1

9,92584E-2

7,96375E-2

1,92034E0

1,25180E-2

5,19214E-1

1,49452E1

1,98750E0

2,46739E-1

6,88348E-1

7,56087E0

6,78363E-1

1,42591E0

5.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,31133E0

3,18200E-1

2,48882E-1

9,68459E-1

9,93502E-2

1,92026E0

5,19053E-1

1,49511E1

1,98748E0

2,46681E-1

7,56108E0

6,78487E-1

1,42474E0

5.6

copasi

1,03154E0

1,31133E0

3,18203E-1

2,48882E-1

9,68459E-1

9,93503E-2

7,97406E-2

1,92026E0

1,25206E-2

5,19053E-1

1,49511E1

1,98748E0

2,46681E-1

6,88667E-1

7,56108E0

6,78487E-1

1,42474E0

5.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,29600E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,64000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

4,55000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

5.6

jsim

1,03154E0

1,31133E0

3,18202E-1

2,48882E-1

9,68459E-1

9,93503E-2

7,97407E-2

1,92026E0

1,25213E-2

5,19053E-1

1,49511E1

1,98748E0

2,46681E-1

6,88667E-1

7,56108E0

6,78488E-1

1,42474E0

5.6

min

5,00000E-1

1,82919E-10

1,43620E-25

2,48828E-1

1,17456E-11

9,92584E-2

7,96375E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,96257E-1

1,49452E1

3,50076E-16

2,46681E-1

5,00000E-1

7,56087E0

4,07112E-1

4,81439E-3

5.6

max

1,03154E0

1,50000E0

3,18403E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,29600E0

5,00000E-1

1,92034E0

1,25213E-2

5,19214E-1

2,64000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,88667E-1

4,55000E2

6,78488E-1

1,50000E0

5.6

mean

1,03154E0

1,31133E0

3,18202E-1

2,48882E-1

9,68459E-1

9,93503E-2

7,97407E-2

1,92026E0

1,25206E-2

5,19053E-1

1,49511E1

1,98748E0

2,46681E-1

6,88667E-1

7,56108E0

6,78487E-1

1,42474E0

5.6

relative error(%)

0,00

5.8

BioUML

1,01997E0

1,31640E0

3,24024E-1

2,41106E-1

9,80029E-1

9,46820E-2

7,71816E-2

1,92282E0

1,23667E-2

5,25909E-1

1,53739E1

1,98763E0

2,40201E-1

6,83604E-1

7,55614E0

6,75736E-1

1,43997E0

5.8

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,31640E0

3,24024E-1

2,41106E-1

9,80029E-1

9,46820E-2

5,00000E-1

1,92282E0

0,00000E0

5,25909E-1

1,53739E1

1,98763E0

2,40201E-1

5,00000E-1

7,55614E0

6,75736E-1

1,43997E0

5.8

MathSBML

1,01997E0

1,31640E0

3,24024E-1

2,41106E-1

9,80029E-1

9,46820E-2

7,71816E-2

1,92282E0

1,23667E-2

5,25909E-1

1,53739E1

1,98763E0

2,40201E-1

6,83604E-1

7,55614E0

6,75736E-1

1,43997E0

5.8

Oscill8 Core

6,87974E-11

1,94367E-26

4,77597E-1

4,32108E-12

5,67436E-1

1,65000E0

1,91637E-1

2,72000E1

8,22704E-17

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,05451E-1

3,90979E-3

5.8

SBToolbox2

1,01931E0

1,31673E0

3,24190E-1

2,41046E-1

9,80681E-1

9,45842E-2

7,70913E-2

1,92294E0

1,23761E-2

5,26087E-1

1,53668E1

1,98760E0

2,40266E-1

6,83234E-1

7,55597E0

6,75603E-1

1,44114E0

5.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,31640E0

3,24023E-1

2,41106E-1

9,80030E-1

9,46819E-2

1,92282E0

5,25910E-1

1,53739E1

1,98763E0

2,40201E-1

7,55614E0

6,75736E-1

1,43997E0

5.8

copasi

1,01997E0

1,31640E0

3,24024E-1

2,41106E-1

9,80030E-1

9,46820E-2

7,71814E-2

1,92282E0

1,23667E-2

5,25909E-1

1,53739E1

1,98763E0

2,40201E-1

6,83603E-1

7,55614E0

6,75736E-1

1,43997E0

5.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,32800E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,72000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

4,71000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

5.8

jsim

1,01997E0

1,31640E0

3,24024E-1

2,41106E-1

9,80029E-1

9,46820E-2

7,71816E-2

1,92282E0

1,23673E-2

5,25909E-1

1,53739E1

1,98763E0

2,40201E-1

6,83604E-1

7,55614E0

6,75736E-1

1,43997E0

5.8

min

5,00000E-1

6,87974E-11

1,94367E-26

2,41046E-1

4,32108E-12

9,45842E-2

7,70913E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,91637E-1

1,53668E1

8,22704E-17

2,40201E-1

5,00000E-1

7,55597E0

4,05451E-1

3,90979E-3

5.8

max

1,01997E0

1,50000E0

3,24190E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,32800E0

5,00000E-1

1,92294E0

1,23761E-2

5,26087E-1

2,72000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,83604E-1

4,71000E2

6,75736E-1

1,50000E0

5.8

mean

1,01997E0

1,31640E0

3,24024E-1

2,41106E-1

9,80029E-1

9,46820E-2

7,71816E-2

1,92282E0

1,23667E-2

5,25909E-1

1,53739E1

1,98763E0

2,40201E-1

6,83603E-1

7,55614E0

6,75736E-1

1,43997E0

5.8

relative error(%)

0,00

6.0

BioUML

1,00494E0

1,32296E0

3,30635E-1

2,33461E-1

9,95061E-1

9,02106E-2

7,48163E-2

1,92518E0

1,22587E-2

5,32737E-1

1,57903E1

1,98774E0

2,33879E-1

6,77037E-1

7,54988E0

6,72354E-1

1,45795E0

6.0

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,32296E0

3,30635E-1

2,33461E-1

9,95061E-1

9,02106E-2

5,00000E-1

1,92518E0

0,00000E0

5,32737E-1

1,57903E1

1,98774E0

2,33879E-1

5,00000E-1

7,54988E0

6,72354E-1

1,45795E0

6.0

MathSBML

1,00494E0

1,32296E0

3,30635E-1

2,33461E-1

9,95061E-1

9,02106E-2

7,48163E-2

1,92518E0

1,22587E-2

5,32737E-1

1,57903E1

1,98774E0

2,33879E-1

6,77037E-1

7,54988E0

6,72354E-1

1,45795E0

6.0

Oscill8 Core

2,58183E-11

2,63044E-27

4,77597E-1

1,58966E-12

5,90532E-1

1,65000E0

1,87121E-1

2,80000E1

1,92016E-17

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,03804E-1

3,17526E-3

6.0

SBToolbox2

1,00424E0

1,32342E0

3,30770E-1

2,33398E-1

9,95756E-1

9,01134E-2

7,47284E-2

1,92524E0

1,22610E-2

5,32926E-1

1,57834E1

1,98770E0

2,33942E-1

6,76592E-1

7,54968E0

6,72214E-1

1,45900E0

6.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,32296E0

3,30635E-1

2,33461E-1

9,95061E-1

9,02105E-2

1,92518E0

5,32737E-1

1,57903E1

1,98774E0

2,33879E-1

7,54988E0

6,72354E-1

1,45795E0

6.0

copasi

1,00494E0

1,32296E0

3,30635E-1

2,33461E-1

9,95062E-1

9,02106E-2

7,48162E-2

1,92518E0

1,22584E-2

5,32737E-1

1,57903E1

1,98774E0

2,33879E-1

6,77037E-1

7,54988E0

6,72354E-1

1,45796E0

6.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,36000E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,80000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

4,87000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

6.0

jsim

1,00494E0

1,32296E0

3,30635E-1

2,33461E-1

9,95061E-1

9,02106E-2

7,48162E-2

1,92518E0

1,22593E-2

5,32737E-1

1,57903E1

1,98774E0

2,33879E-1

6,77037E-1

7,54988E0

6,72354E-1

1,45795E0

6.0

min

5,00000E-1

2,58183E-11

2,63044E-27

2,33398E-1

1,58966E-12

9,01134E-2

7,47284E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,87121E-1

1,57834E1

1,92016E-17

2,33879E-1

5,00000E-1

7,54968E0

4,03804E-1

3,17526E-3

6.0

max

1,00494E0

1,50000E0

3,30770E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,36000E0

5,00000E-1

1,92524E0

1,22610E-2

5,32926E-1

2,80000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,77037E-1

4,87000E2

6,72354E-1

1,50000E0

6.0

mean

1,00494E0

1,32296E0

3,30635E-1

2,33461E-1

9,95061E-1

9,02106E-2

7,48162E-2

1,92518E0

1,22587E-2

5,32737E-1

1,57903E1

1,98774E0

2,33879E-1

6,77037E-1

7,54988E0

6,72354E-1

1,45795E0

6.0

relative error(%)

0,00

6.2

BioUML

9,86434E-1

1,33096E0

3,38102E-1

2,25943E-1

1,01357E0

8,59243E-2

7,26305E-2

1,92737E0

1,21961E-2

5,39555E-1

1,61992E1

1,98780E0

2,27720E-1

6,69043E-1

7,54221E0

6,68337E-1

1,47893E0

6.2

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,33096E0

3,38102E-1

2,25943E-1

1,01357E0

8,59243E-2

5,00000E-1

1,92737E0

0,00000E0

5,39555E-1

1,61992E1

1,98780E0

2,27720E-1

5,00000E-1

7,54221E0

6,68337E-1

1,47893E0

6.2

MathSBML

9,86434E-1

1,33096E0

3,38102E-1

2,25943E-1

1,01357E0

8,59243E-2

7,26305E-2

1,92737E0

1,21961E-2

5,39555E-1

1,61992E1

1,98780E0

2,27720E-1

6,69043E-1

7,54221E0

6,68337E-1

1,47893E0

6.2

Oscill8 Core

9,66849E-12

3,55985E-28

4,77597E-1

5,84809E-13

6,15760E-1

1,65000E0

1,82706E-1

2,88000E1

4,45117E-18

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,02169E-1

2,57882E-3

6.2

SBToolbox2

9,85686E-1

1,33145E0

3,38242E-1

2,25869E-1

1,01428E0

8,58192E-2

7,25441E-2

1,92744E0

1,21986E-2

5,39763E-1

1,61916E1

1,98780E0

2,27782E-1

6,68553E-1

7,54205E0

6,68186E-1

1,48006E0

6.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,33096E0

3,38102E-1

2,25943E-1

1,01357E0

8,59242E-2

1,92737E0

5,39555E-1

1,61992E1

1,98780E0

2,27720E-1

7,54221E0

6,68337E-1

1,47893E0

6.2

copasi

9,86433E-1

1,33096E0

3,38102E-1

2,25944E-1

1,01357E0

8,59243E-2

7,26304E-2

1,92737E0

1,21964E-2

5,39555E-1

1,61992E1

1,98780E0

2,27720E-1

6,69042E-1

7,54221E0

6,68337E-1

1,47893E0

6.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,39200E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,88000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,03000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

6.2

jsim

9,86434E-1

1,33096E0

3,38102E-1

2,25943E-1

1,01357E0

8,59243E-2

7,26305E-2

1,92737E0

1,21968E-2

5,39555E-1

1,61992E1

1,98780E0

2,27720E-1

6,69043E-1

7,54221E0

6,68337E-1

1,47893E0

6.2

min

5,00000E-1

9,66849E-12

3,55985E-28

2,25869E-1

5,84809E-13

8,58192E-2

7,25441E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,82706E-1

1,61916E1

4,45117E-18

2,27720E-1

5,00000E-1

7,54205E0

4,02169E-1

2,57882E-3

6.2

max

9,86434E-1

1,50000E0

3,38242E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,39200E0

5,00000E-1

1,92744E0

1,21986E-2

5,39763E-1

2,88000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,69043E-1

5,03000E2

6,68337E-1

1,50000E0

6.2

mean

9,86433E-1

1,33096E0

3,38102E-1

2,25943E-1

1,01357E0

8,59243E-2

7,26305E-2

1,92737E0

1,21964E-2

5,39555E-1

1,61992E1

1,98780E0

2,27720E-1

6,69042E-1

7,54221E0

6,68337E-1

1,47893E0

6.2

relative error(%)

0,00

6.4

BioUML

9,64462E-1

1,34028E0

3,46502E-1

2,18551E-1

1,03554E0

8,18127E-2

7,06119E-2

1,92939E0

1,21789E-2

5,46382E-1

1,65996E1

1,98782E0

2,21724E-1

6,59720E-1

7,53307E0

6,63681E-1

1,50314E0

6.4

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,34028E0

3,46502E-1

2,18551E-1

1,03554E0

8,18127E-2

5,00000E-1

1,92939E0

0,00000E0

5,46382E-1

1,65996E1

1,98782E0

2,21724E-1

5,00000E-1

7,53307E0

6,63681E-1

1,50314E0

6.4

MathSBML

9,64462E-1

1,34028E0

3,46502E-1

2,18551E-1

1,03554E0

8,18127E-2

7,06119E-2

1,92939E0

1,21789E-2

5,46382E-1

1,65996E1

1,98782E0

2,21724E-1

6,59720E-1

7,53307E0

6,63681E-1

1,50314E0

6.4

Oscill8 Core

3,61320E-12

4,81764E-29

4,77597E-1

2,15140E-13

6,43298E-1

1,65000E0

1,78392E-1

2,96000E1

1,02490E-18

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

4,00545E-1

2,09448E-3

6.4

SBToolbox2

9,63642E-1

1,34088E0

3,46608E-1

2,18467E-1

1,03633E0

8,17013E-2

7,05384E-2

1,92944E0

1,21894E-2

5,46612E-1

1,65912E1

1,98780E0

2,21792E-1

6,59126E-1

7,53292E0

6,63520E-1

1,50427E0

6.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,34028E0

3,46502E-1

2,18551E-1

1,03554E0

8,18126E-2

1,92939E0

5,46382E-1

1,65996E1

1,98782E0

2,21724E-1

7,53307E0

6,63681E-1

1,50314E0

6.4

copasi

9,64461E-1

1,34028E0

3,46502E-1

2,18551E-1

1,03554E0

8,18127E-2

7,06118E-2

1,92939E0

1,21787E-2

5,46382E-1

1,65996E1

1,98782E0

2,21724E-1

6,59720E-1

7,53307E0

6,63681E-1

1,50314E0

6.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,42400E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

2,96000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,19000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

6.4

jsim

9,64462E-1

1,34028E0

3,46502E-1

2,18551E-1

1,03554E0

8,18127E-2

7,06119E-2

1,92939E0

1,21796E-2

5,46382E-1

1,65996E1

1,98782E0

2,21724E-1

6,59720E-1

7,53307E0

6,63681E-1

1,50314E0

6.4

min

5,00000E-1

3,61320E-12

4,81764E-29

2,18467E-1

2,15140E-13

8,17013E-2

7,05384E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,78392E-1

1,65912E1

1,02490E-18

2,21724E-1

5,00000E-1

7,53292E0

4,00545E-1

2,09448E-3

6.4

max

9,64462E-1

1,50000E0

3,46608E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,42400E0

5,00000E-1

1,92944E0

1,21894E-2

5,46612E-1

2,96000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,59720E-1

5,19000E2

6,63681E-1

1,50427E0

6.4

mean

9,64461E-1

1,34028E0

3,46502E-1

2,18551E-1

1,03554E0

8,18127E-2

7,06119E-2

1,92939E0

1,21789E-2

5,46382E-1

1,65996E1

1,98782E0

2,21724E-1

6,59720E-1

7,53307E0

6,63681E-1

1,50314E0

6.4

relative error(%)

0,00

6.6

BioUML

9,39058E-1

1,35081E0

3,55919E-1

2,11281E-1

1,06094E0

7,78666E-2

6,87497E-2

1,93125E0

1,22075E-2

5,53240E-1

1,69902E1

1,98779E0

2,15893E-1

6,49193E-1

7,52237E0

6,58381E-1

1,53087E0

6.6

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,35081E0

3,55919E-1

2,11281E-1

1,06094E0

7,78666E-2

5,00000E-1

1,93125E0

0,00000E0

5,53240E-1

1,69902E1

1,98779E0

2,15893E-1

5,00000E-1

7,52237E0

6,58381E-1

1,53087E0

6.6

MathSBML

9,39058E-1

1,35081E0

3,55919E-1

2,11281E-1

1,06094E0

7,78666E-2

6,87497E-2

1,93125E0

1,22075E-2

5,53240E-1

1,69902E1

1,98779E0

2,15893E-1

6,49193E-1

7,52237E0

6,58381E-1

1,53087E0

6.6

Oscill8 Core

1,34755E-12

6,51981E-30

4,77597E-1

7,91453E-14

6,73341E-1

1,65000E0

1,74177E-1

3,04000E1

2,34416E-19

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,98931E-1

1,70116E-3

6.6

SBToolbox2

9,38068E-1

1,35137E0

3,56030E-1

2,11198E-1

1,06194E0

7,77560E-2

6,87081E-2

1,93130E0

1,22180E-2

5,53479E-1

1,69815E1

1,98780E0

2,15961E-1

6,48623E-1

7,52220E0

6,58205E-1

1,53191E0

6.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,35081E0

3,55919E-1

2,11281E-1

1,06094E0

7,78664E-2

1,93125E0

5,53240E-1

1,69901E1

1,98779E0

2,15893E-1

7,52237E0

6,58381E-1

1,53087E0

6.6

copasi

9,39058E-1

1,35081E0

3,55919E-1

2,11282E-1

1,06094E0

7,78666E-2

6,87500E-2

1,93125E0

1,22076E-2

5,53240E-1

1,69902E1

1,98779E0

2,15893E-1

6,49193E-1

7,52237E0

6,58381E-1

1,53087E0

6.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,45600E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

3,04000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,35000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

6.6

jsim

9,39058E-1

1,35081E0

3,55919E-1

2,11281E-1

1,06094E0

7,78666E-2

6,87497E-2

1,93125E0

1,22082E-2

5,53240E-1

1,69902E1

1,98779E0

2,15893E-1

6,49193E-1

7,52237E0

6,58381E-1

1,53087E0

6.6

min

5,00000E-1

1,34755E-12

6,51981E-30

2,11198E-1

7,91453E-14

7,77560E-2

6,87081E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,74177E-1

1,69815E1

2,34416E-19

2,15893E-1

5,00000E-1

7,52220E0

3,98931E-1

1,70116E-3

6.6

max

9,39058E-1

1,50000E0

3,56030E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,45600E0

5,00000E-1

1,93130E0

1,22180E-2

5,53479E-1

3,04000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,49193E-1

5,35000E2

6,58381E-1

1,53191E0

6.6

mean

9,39058E-1

1,35081E0

3,55919E-1

2,11281E-1

1,06094E0

7,78666E-2

6,87497E-2

1,93125E0

1,22076E-2

5,53240E-1

1,69902E1

1,98779E0

2,15893E-1

6,49193E-1

7,52237E0

6,58381E-1

1,53087E0

6.6

relative error(%)

0,00

6.8

BioUML

9,10300E-1

1,36239E0

3,66451E-1

2,04133E-1

1,08970E0

7,40780E-2

6,70348E-2

1,93297E0

1,22832E-2

5,60150E-1

1,73695E1

1,98772E0

2,10223E-1

6,37610E-1

7,50998E0

6,52428E-1

1,56242E0

6.8

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,36239E0

3,66451E-1

2,04133E-1

1,08970E0

7,40780E-2

5,00000E-1

1,93297E0

0,00000E0

5,60150E-1

1,73695E1

1,98772E0

2,10223E-1

5,00000E-1

7,50998E0

6,52428E-1

1,56242E0

6.8

MathSBML

9,10300E-1

1,36239E0

3,66451E-1

2,04133E-1

1,08970E0

7,40780E-2

6,70348E-2

1,93297E0

1,22832E-2

5,60150E-1

1,73695E1

1,98772E0

2,10223E-1

6,37610E-1

7,50998E0

6,52428E-1

1,56242E0

6.8

Oscill8 Core

5,01564E-13

8,82335E-31

4,77597E-1

2,91158E-14

7,06091E-1

1,65000E0

1,70058E-1

3,12000E1

5,32616E-20

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,97326E-1

1,38174E-3

6.8

SBToolbox2

9,09234E-1

1,36299E0

3,66589E-1

2,04038E-1

1,09078E0

7,39655E-2

6,70131E-2

1,93300E0

1,22949E-2

5,60402E-1

1,73601E1

1,98770E0

2,10280E-1

6,37048E-1

7,50971E0

6,52241E-1

1,56351E0

6.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,36239E0

3,66451E-1

2,04133E-1

1,08970E0

7,40778E-2

1,93296E0

5,60150E-1

1,73695E1

1,98772E0

2,10223E-1

7,50998E0

6,52428E-1

1,56243E0

6.8

copasi

9,10300E-1

1,36239E0

3,66451E-1

2,04134E-1

1,08970E0

7,40780E-2

6,70350E-2

1,93297E0

1,22832E-2

5,60150E-1

1,73695E1

1,98772E0

2,10223E-1

6,37610E-1

7,50998E0

6,52428E-1

1,56242E0

6.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,48800E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

3,12000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,51000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

6.8

jsim

9,10300E-1

1,36239E0

3,66451E-1

2,04133E-1

1,08970E0

7,40780E-2

6,70347E-2

1,93297E0

1,22839E-2

5,60150E-1

1,73695E1

1,98772E0

2,10223E-1

6,37610E-1

7,50998E0

6,52428E-1

1,56242E0

6.8

min

5,00000E-1

5,01564E-13

8,82335E-31

2,04038E-1

2,91158E-14

7,39655E-2

6,70131E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,70058E-1

1,73601E1

5,32616E-20

2,10223E-1

5,00000E-1

7,50971E0

3,97326E-1

1,38174E-3

6.8

max

9,10300E-1

1,50000E0

3,66589E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,48800E0

5,00000E-1

1,93300E0

1,22949E-2

5,60402E-1

3,12000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,37610E-1

5,51000E2

6,52428E-1

1,56351E0

6.8

mean

9,10300E-1

1,36239E0

3,66451E-1

2,04133E-1

1,08970E0

7,40780E-2

6,70348E-2

1,93297E0

1,22832E-2

5,60150E-1

1,73695E1

1,98772E0

2,10223E-1

6,37610E-1

7,50998E0

6,52428E-1

1,56242E0

6.8

relative error(%)

0,00

7.0

BioUML

8,78323E-1

1,37486E0

3,78206E-1

1,97107E-1

1,12168E0

7,04400E-2

6,54592E-2

1,93454E0

1,24076E-2

5,67135E-1

1,77362E1

1,98759E0

2,04711E-1

6,25143E-1

7,49578E0

6,45812E-1

1,59815E0

7.0

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,37486E0

3,78206E-1

1,97107E-1

1,12168E0

7,04400E-2

5,00000E-1

1,93454E0

0,00000E0

5,67135E-1

1,77362E1

1,98759E0

2,04711E-1

5,00000E-1

7,49578E0

6,45812E-1

1,59815E0

7.0

MathSBML

8,78323E-1

1,37486E0

3,78206E-1

1,97107E-1

1,12168E0

7,04400E-2

6,54592E-2

1,93454E0

1,24076E-2

5,67135E-1

1,77362E1

1,98759E0

2,04711E-1

6,25143E-1

7,49578E0

6,45812E-1

1,59815E0

7.0

Oscill8 Core

1,86314E-13

1,19407E-31

4,77597E-1

1,07110E-14

7,41765E-1

1,65000E0

1,66035E-1

3,20000E1

1,20223E-20

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,95730E-1

1,12234E-3

7.0

SBToolbox2

8,77123E-1

1,37558E0

3,78296E-1

1,97005E-1

1,12291E0

7,03286E-2

6,54485E-2

1,93453E0

1,24201E-2

5,67395E-1

1,77264E1

1,98760E0

2,04769E-1

6,24435E-1

7,49556E0

6,45625E-1

1,59907E0

7.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,37486E0

3,78205E-1

1,97107E-1

1,12168E0

7,04398E-2

1,93454E0

5,67136E-1

1,77362E1

1,98759E0

2,04711E-1

7,49578E0

6,45812E-1

1,59815E0

7.0

copasi

8,78322E-1

1,37486E0

3,78207E-1

1,97107E-1

1,12168E0

7,04400E-2

6,54593E-2

1,93454E0

1,24076E-2

5,67135E-1

1,77362E1

1,98759E0

2,04711E-1

6,25143E-1

7,49578E0

6,45812E-1

1,59815E0

7.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,52000E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

3,20000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,67000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

7.0

jsim

8,78323E-1

1,37486E0

3,78206E-1

1,97107E-1

1,12168E0

7,04400E-2

6,54591E-2

1,93454E0

1,24083E-2

5,67135E-1

1,77362E1

1,98759E0

2,04711E-1

6,25143E-1

7,49578E0

6,45812E-1

1,59815E0

7.0

min

5,00000E-1

1,86314E-13

1,19407E-31

1,97005E-1

1,07110E-14

7,03286E-2

6,54485E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,66035E-1

1,77264E1

1,20223E-20

2,04711E-1

5,00000E-1

7,49556E0

3,95730E-1

1,12234E-3

7.0

max

8,78323E-1

1,50000E0

3,78296E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,52000E0

5,00000E-1

1,93454E0

1,24201E-2

5,67395E-1

3,20000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,25143E-1

5,67000E2

6,45812E-1

1,59907E0

7.0

mean

8,78322E-1

1,37486E0

3,78206E-1

1,97107E-1

1,12168E0

7,04400E-2

6,54592E-2

1,93454E0

1,24076E-2

5,67135E-1

1,77362E1

1,98759E0

2,04711E-1

6,25143E-1

7,49578E0

6,45812E-1

1,59815E0

7.0

relative error(%)

0,00

7.2

BioUML

8,43335E-1

1,38801E0

3,91309E-1

1,90202E-1

1,15667E0

6,69466E-2

6,40163E-2

1,93598E0

1,25833E-2

5,74220E-1

1,80887E1

1,98742E0

1,99350E-1

6,11986E-1

7,47961E0

6,38524E-1

1,63843E0

7.2

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,38801E0

3,91309E-1

1,90202E-1

1,15667E0

6,69466E-2

5,00000E-1

1,93598E0

0,00000E0

5,74220E-1

1,80887E1

1,98742E0

1,99350E-1

5,00000E-1

7,47961E0

6,38524E-1

1,63843E0

7.2

MathSBML

8,43335E-1

1,38801E0

3,91309E-1

1,90202E-1

1,15667E0

6,69466E-2

6,40163E-2

1,93598E0

1,25832E-2

5,74220E-1

1,80887E1

1,98742E0

1,99350E-1

6,11985E-1

7,47961E0

6,38524E-1

1,63843E0

7.2

Oscill8 Core

6,90714E-14

1,61594E-32

4,77597E-1

3,94033E-15

7,80589E-1

1,65000E0

1,62106E-1

3,28000E1

2,69608E-21

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,94142E-1

9,11663E-4

7.2

SBToolbox2

8,42038E-1

1,38880E0

3,91393E-1

1,90095E-1

1,15800E0

6,68348E-2

6,40107E-2

1,93600E0

1,25961E-2

5,74498E-1

1,80788E1

1,98740E0

1,99407E-1

6,11232E-1

7,47938E0

6,38321E-1

1,63942E0

7.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,38801E0

3,91307E-1

1,90202E-1

1,15666E0

6,69464E-2

1,93598E0

5,74220E-1

1,80887E1

1,98742E0

1,99350E-1

7,47960E0

6,38523E-1

1,63843E0

7.2

copasi

8,43334E-1

1,38801E0

3,91309E-1

1,90202E-1

1,15667E0

6,69466E-2

6,40164E-2

1,93598E0

1,25832E-2

5,74220E-1

1,80887E1

1,98742E0

1,99350E-1

6,11985E-1

7,47960E0

6,38523E-1

1,63843E0

7.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,55200E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

3,28000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,83000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

7.2

jsim

8,43335E-1

1,38801E0

3,91308E-1

1,90202E-1

1,15667E0

6,69466E-2

6,40163E-2

1,93598E0

1,25840E-2

5,74220E-1

1,80887E1

1,98742E0

1,99350E-1

6,11986E-1

7,47961E0

6,38524E-1

1,63843E0

7.2

min

5,00000E-1

6,90714E-14

1,61594E-32

1,90095E-1

3,94033E-15

6,68348E-2

6,40107E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,62106E-1

1,80788E1

2,69608E-21

1,99350E-1

5,00000E-1

7,47938E0

3,94142E-1

9,11663E-4

7.2

max

8,43335E-1

1,50000E0

3,91393E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,55200E0

5,00000E-1

1,93600E0

1,25961E-2

5,74498E-1

3,28000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

6,11986E-1

5,83000E2

6,38524E-1

1,63942E0

7.2

mean

8,43334E-1

1,38801E0

3,91308E-1

1,90202E-1

1,15667E0

6,69466E-2

6,40163E-2

1,93598E0

1,25832E-2

5,74220E-1

1,80887E1

1,98742E0

1,99350E-1

6,11985E-1

7,47961E0

6,38523E-1

1,63843E0

7.2

relative error(%)

0,00

7.4

BioUML

8,05629E-1

1,40165E0

4,05897E-1

1,83421E-1

1,19437E0

6,35927E-2

6,27009E-2

1,93730E0

1,28134E-2

5,81428E-1

1,84252E1

1,98719E0

1,94133E-1

5,98349E-1

7,46128E0

6,30548E-1

1,68370E0

7.4

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,40165E0

4,05897E-1

1,83421E-1

1,19437E0

6,35927E-2

5,00000E-1

1,93730E0

0,00000E0

5,81428E-1

1,84252E1

1,98719E0

1,94133E-1

5,00000E-1

7,46128E0

6,30548E-1

1,68370E0

7.4

MathSBML

8,05629E-1

1,40165E0

4,05897E-1

1,83421E-1

1,19437E0

6,35927E-2

6,27009E-2

1,93730E0

1,28134E-2

5,81428E-1

1,84252E1

1,98719E0

1,94133E-1

5,98349E-1

7,46128E0

6,30548E-1

1,68370E0

7.4

Oscill8 Core

2,55553E-14

2,18685E-33

4,77597E-1

1,44955E-15

8,22803E-1

1,65000E0

1,58268E-1

3,36000E1

6,00719E-22

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,92562E-1

7,40557E-4

7.4

SBToolbox2

8,04138E-1

1,40248E0

4,05970E-1

1,83312E-1

1,19589E0

6,34811E-2

6,27029E-2

1,93730E0

1,28274E-2

5,81716E-1

1,84142E1

1,98720E0

1,94185E-1

5,97541E-1

7,46107E0

6,30331E-1

1,68472E0

7.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,40165E0

4,05896E-1

1,83421E-1

1,19437E0

6,35925E-2

1,93730E0

5,81429E-1

1,84251E1

1,98719E0

1,94133E-1

7,46128E0

6,30547E-1

1,68370E0

7.4

copasi

8,05628E-1

1,40165E0

4,05897E-1

1,83421E-1

1,19437E0

6,35927E-2

6,27009E-2

1,93730E0

1,28134E-2

5,81428E-1

1,84252E1

1,98719E0

1,94133E-1

5,98349E-1

7,46128E0

6,30548E-1

1,68370E0

7.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,58400E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

3,36000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

5,99000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

7.4

jsim

8,05629E-1

1,40165E0

4,05896E-1

1,83421E-1

1,19437E0

6,35927E-2

6,27008E-2

1,93730E0

1,28142E-2

5,81428E-1

1,84252E1

1,98719E0

1,94133E-1

5,98349E-1

7,46128E0

6,30548E-1

1,68370E0

7.4

min

5,00000E-1

2,55553E-14

2,18685E-33

1,83312E-1

1,44955E-15

6,34811E-2

6,27008E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,58268E-1

1,84142E1

6,00719E-22

1,94133E-1

5,00000E-1

7,46107E0

3,92562E-1

7,40557E-4

7.4

max

8,05629E-1

1,50000E0

4,05970E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,58400E0

5,00000E-1

1,93730E0

1,28274E-2

5,81716E-1

3,36000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,98349E-1

5,99000E2

6,30548E-1

1,68472E0

7.4

mean

8,05628E-1

1,40165E0

4,05896E-1

1,83421E-1

1,19437E0

6,35927E-2

6,27009E-2

1,93730E0

1,28134E-2

5,81428E-1

1,84252E1

1,98719E0

1,94133E-1

5,98349E-1

7,46128E0

6,30548E-1

1,68370E0

7.4

relative error(%)

0,00

7.6

BioUML

7,65594E-1

1,41554E0

4,22127E-1

1,76766E-1

1,23441E0

6,03740E-2

6,15085E-2

1,93849E0

1,31021E-2

5,88786E-1

1,87437E1

1,98690E0

1,89052E-1

5,84457E-1

7,44059E0

6,21870E-1

1,73445E0

7.6

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,41554E0

4,22127E-1

1,76766E-1

1,23441E0

6,03740E-2

5,00000E-1

1,93849E0

0,00000E0

5,88786E-1

1,87437E1

1,98690E0

1,89052E-1

5,00000E-1

7,44059E0

6,21870E-1

1,73445E0

7.6

MathSBML

7,65594E-1

1,41554E0

4,22127E-1

1,76766E-1

1,23441E0

6,03740E-2

6,15085E-2

1,93849E0

1,31021E-2

5,88786E-1

1,87437E1

1,98690E0

1,89052E-1

5,84457E-1

7,44059E0

6,21870E-1

1,73445E0

7.6

Oscill8 Core

9,43590E-15

2,95944E-34

4,77597E-1

5,33254E-16

8,68654E-1

1,65000E0

1,54520E-1

3,44000E1

1,32992E-22

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,90990E-1

6,01585E-4

7.6

SBToolbox2

7,63978E-1

1,41627E0

4,22226E-1

1,76651E-1

1,23600E0

6,02641E-2

6,15236E-2

1,93850E0

1,31188E-2

5,89081E-1

1,87326E1

1,98690E0

1,89100E-1

5,83704E-1

7,44034E0

6,21642E-1

1,73535E0

7.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,41554E0

4,22127E-1

1,76766E-1

1,23441E0

6,03738E-2

1,93849E0

5,88787E-1

1,87436E1

1,98690E0

1,89052E-1

7,44059E0

6,21869E-1

1,73445E0

7.6

copasi

7,65593E-1

1,41554E0

4,22127E-1

1,76766E-1

1,23441E0

6,03740E-2

6,15086E-2

1,93849E0

1,31021E-2

5,88786E-1

1,87437E1

1,98690E0

1,89052E-1

5,84457E-1

7,44059E0

6,21870E-1

1,73445E0

7.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,61600E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

3,44000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

6,15000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

7.6

jsim

7,65594E-1

1,41554E0

4,22127E-1

1,76766E-1

1,23441E0

6,03740E-2

6,15084E-2

1,93849E0

1,31029E-2

5,88786E-1

1,87437E1

1,98690E0

1,89052E-1

5,84457E-1

7,44059E0

6,21870E-1

1,73445E0

7.6

min

5,00000E-1

9,43590E-15

2,95944E-34

1,76651E-1

5,33254E-16

6,02641E-2

6,15084E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,54520E-1

1,87326E1

1,32992E-22

1,89052E-1

5,00000E-1

7,44034E0

3,90990E-1

6,01585E-4

7.6

max

7,65594E-1

1,50000E0

4,22226E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,61600E0

5,00000E-1

1,93850E0

1,31188E-2

5,89081E-1

3,44000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,84457E-1

6,15000E2

6,21870E-1

1,73535E0

7.6

mean

7,65593E-1

1,41554E0

4,22127E-1

1,76766E-1

1,23441E0

6,03740E-2

6,15086E-2

1,93849E0

1,31021E-2

5,88786E-1

1,87437E1

1,98690E0

1,89052E-1

5,84457E-1

7,44059E0

6,21870E-1

1,73445E0

7.6

relative error(%)

0,00

7.8

BioUML

7,23710E-1

1,42946E0

4,40174E-1

1,70242E-1

1,27629E0

5,72867E-2

6,04359E-2

1,93956E0

1,34544E-2

5,96319E-1

1,90421E1

1,98655E0

1,84097E-1

5,70535E-1

7,41731E0

6,12473E-1

1,79122E0

7.8

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,42946E0

4,40174E-1

1,70242E-1

1,27629E0

5,72867E-2

5,00000E-1

1,93956E0

0,00000E0

5,96319E-1

1,90421E1

1,98655E0

1,84097E-1

5,00000E-1

7,41731E0

6,12473E-1

1,79122E0

7.8

MathSBML

7,23710E-1

1,42946E0

4,40174E-1

1,70242E-1

1,27629E0

5,72867E-2

6,04359E-2

1,93956E0

1,34544E-2

5,96319E-1

1,90421E1

1,98655E0

1,84097E-1

5,70535E-1

7,41731E0

6,12473E-1

1,79122E0

7.8

Oscill8 Core

3,47688E-15

4,00497E-35

4,77597E-1

1,96171E-16

9,18401E-1

1,65000E0

1,50860E-1

3,52000E1

2,92560E-23

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,89425E-1

4,88707E-4

7.8

SBToolbox2

7,22017E-1

1,43015E0

4,40299E-1

1,70120E-1

1,27798E0

5,71788E-2

6,04570E-2

1,93952E0

1,34704E-2

5,96626E-1

1,90301E1

1,98650E0

1,84145E-1

5,69796E-1

7,41701E0

6,12234E-1

1,79226E0

7.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,42946E0

4,40175E-1

1,70242E-1

1,27629E0

5,72865E-2

1,93956E0

5,96320E-1

1,90420E1

1,98654E0

1,84097E-1

7,41730E0

6,12472E-1

1,79123E0

7.8

copasi

7,23709E-1

1,42947E0

4,40175E-1

1,70242E-1

1,27629E0

5,72867E-2

6,04360E-2

1,93956E0

1,34544E-2

5,96319E-1

1,90421E1

1,98655E0

1,84098E-1

5,70535E-1

7,41731E0

6,12473E-1

1,79123E0

7.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,64800E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

3,52000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

6,31000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

7.8

jsim

7,23710E-1

1,42946E0

4,40174E-1

1,70242E-1

1,27629E0

5,72867E-2

6,04359E-2

1,93956E0

1,34552E-2

5,96319E-1

1,90421E1

1,98654E0

1,84097E-1

5,70535E-1

7,41731E0

6,12473E-1

1,79122E0

7.8

min

5,00000E-1

3,47688E-15

4,00497E-35

1,70120E-1

1,96171E-16

5,71788E-2

6,04359E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,50860E-1

1,90301E1

2,92560E-23

1,84097E-1

5,00000E-1

7,41701E0

3,89425E-1

4,88707E-4

7.8

max

7,23710E-1

1,50000E0

4,40299E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,64800E0

5,00000E-1

1,93956E0

1,34704E-2

5,96626E-1

3,52000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,70535E-1

6,31000E2

6,12473E-1

1,79226E0

7.8

mean

7,23709E-1

1,42946E0

4,40174E-1

1,70242E-1

1,27629E0

5,72867E-2

6,04360E-2

1,93956E0

1,34544E-2

5,96319E-1

1,90421E1

1,98655E0

1,84098E-1

5,70535E-1

7,41731E0

6,12473E-1

1,79122E0

7.8

relative error(%)

0,00

8.0

BioUML

6,80541E-1

1,44320E0

4,60233E-1

1,63851E-1

1,31946E0

5,43276E-2

5,94810E-2

1,94052E0

1,38761E-2

6,04054E-1

1,93180E1

1,98612E0

1,79260E-1

5,56803E-1

7,39115E0

6,02338E-1

1,85464E0

8.0

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,44320E0

4,60233E-1

1,63851E-1

1,31946E0

5,43276E-2

5,00000E-1

1,94052E0

0,00000E0

6,04054E-1

1,93180E1

1,98612E0

1,79260E-1

5,00000E-1

7,39115E0

6,02338E-1

1,85464E0

8.0

MathSBML

6,80541E-1

1,44320E0

4,60233E-1

1,63851E-1

1,31946E0

5,43276E-2

5,94809E-2

1,94052E0

1,38761E-2

6,04054E-1

1,93180E1

1,98612E0

1,79260E-1

5,56803E-1

7,39115E0

6,02338E-1

1,85464E0

8.0

Oscill8 Core

1,27844E-15

5,41984E-36

4,77597E-1

7,21661E-17

9,72311E-1

1,65000E0

1,47286E-1

3,60000E1

6,39537E-24

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,87867E-1

3,97021E-4

8.0

SBToolbox2

6,78794E-1

1,44394E0

4,60382E-1

1,63728E-1

1,32122E0

5,42220E-2

5,95082E-2

1,94050E0

1,38946E-2

6,04368E-1

1,93056E1

1,98610E0

1,79302E-1

5,56084E-1

7,39082E0

6,02094E-1

1,85558E0

8.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,44320E0

4,60235E-1

1,63851E-1

1,31946E0

5,43273E-2

1,94052E0

6,04056E-1

1,93180E1

1,98612E0

1,79259E-1

7,39115E0

6,02337E-1

1,85465E0

8.0

copasi

6,80540E-1

1,44320E0

4,60234E-1

1,63851E-1

1,31946E0

5,43276E-2

5,94810E-2

1,94052E0

1,38761E-2

6,04055E-1

1,93180E1

1,98612E0

1,79260E-1

5,56803E-1

7,39115E0

6,02338E-1

1,85465E0

8.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,68000E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

3,60000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

6,47000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

8.0

jsim

6,80541E-1

1,44320E0

4,60233E-1

1,63851E-1

1,31946E0

5,43276E-2

5,94809E-2

1,94052E0

1,38769E-2

6,04054E-1

1,93180E1

1,98612E0

1,79260E-1

5,56803E-1

7,39115E0

6,02338E-1

1,85464E0

8.0

min

5,00000E-1

1,27844E-15

5,41984E-36

1,63728E-1

7,21661E-17

5,42220E-2

5,94809E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,47286E-1

1,93056E1

6,39537E-24

1,79259E-1

5,00000E-1

7,39082E0

3,87867E-1

3,97021E-4

8.0

max

6,80541E-1

1,50000E0

4,60382E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,68000E0

5,00000E-1

1,94052E0

1,38946E-2

6,04368E-1

3,60000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,56803E-1

6,47000E2

6,02338E-1

1,85558E0

8.0

mean

6,80540E-1

1,44320E0

4,60233E-1

1,63851E-1

1,31946E0

5,43276E-2

5,94810E-2

1,94052E0

1,38761E-2

6,04054E-1

1,93180E1

1,98612E0

1,79260E-1

5,56803E-1

7,39115E0

6,02338E-1

1,85464E0

8.0

relative error(%)

0,00

8.2

BioUML

6,36707E-1

1,45654E0

4,82516E-1

1,57598E-1

1,36329E0

5,14937E-2

5,86424E-2

1,94136E0

1,43743E-2

6,12018E-1

1,95689E1

1,98563E0

1,74529E-1

5,43464E-1

7,36183E0

5,91445E-1

1,92539E0

8.2

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,45654E0

4,82516E-1

1,57598E-1

1,36329E0

5,14937E-2

5,00000E-1

1,94136E0

0,00000E0

6,12018E-1

1,95689E1

1,98563E0

1,74529E-1

5,00000E-1

7,36183E0

5,91445E-1

1,92539E0

8.2

MathSBML

6,36707E-1

1,45654E0

4,82516E-1

1,57598E-1

1,36329E0

5,14937E-2

5,86424E-2

1,94136E0

1,43743E-2

6,12018E-1

1,95689E1

1,98563E0

1,74529E-1

5,43464E-1

7,36183E0

5,91445E-1

1,92539E0

8.2

Oscill8 Core

4,69068E-16

7,33454E-37

4,77597E-1

2,65480E-17

1,03066E0

1,65000E0

1,43796E-1

3,68000E1

1,38930E-24

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,86316E-1

3,22546E-4

8.2

SBToolbox2

6,34924E-1

1,45721E0

4,82682E-1

1,57474E-1

1,36510E0

5,13910E-2

5,86742E-2

1,94132E0

1,43930E-2

6,12342E-1

1,95562E1

1,98560E0

1,74567E-1

5,42793E-1

7,36143E0

5,91189E-1

1,92638E0

8.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,45654E0

4,82518E-1

1,57598E-1

1,36329E0

5,14935E-2

1,94136E0

6,12020E-1

1,95688E1

1,98562E0

1,74529E-1

7,36182E0

5,91444E-1

1,92541E0

8.2

copasi

6,36706E-1

1,45654E0

4,82517E-1

1,57598E-1

1,36329E0

5,14937E-2

5,86424E-2

1,94136E0

1,43743E-2

6,12018E-1

1,95689E1

1,98563E0

1,74529E-1

5,43463E-1

7,36183E0

5,91445E-1

1,92539E0

8.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,71200E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

3,68000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

6,63000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

8.2

jsim

6,36707E-1

1,45654E0

4,82516E-1

1,57598E-1

1,36329E0

5,14937E-2

5,86423E-2

1,94136E0

1,43752E-2

6,12018E-1

1,95689E1

1,98562E0

1,74529E-1

5,43464E-1

7,36183E0

5,91445E-1

1,92539E0

8.2

min

5,00000E-1

4,69068E-16

7,33454E-37

1,57474E-1

2,65480E-17

5,13910E-2

5,86423E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,43796E-1

1,95562E1

1,38930E-24

1,74529E-1

5,00000E-1

7,36143E0

3,86316E-1

3,22546E-4

8.2

max

6,36707E-1

1,50000E0

4,82682E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,71200E0

5,00000E-1

1,94136E0

1,43930E-2

6,12342E-1

3,68000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,43464E-1

6,63000E2

5,91445E-1

1,92638E0

8.2

mean

6,36706E-1

1,45654E0

4,82516E-1

1,57598E-1

1,36329E0

5,14937E-2

5,86424E-2

1,94136E0

1,43743E-2

6,12018E-1

1,95689E1

1,98563E0

1,74529E-1

5,43463E-1

7,36183E0

5,91444E-1

1,92539E0

8.2

relative error(%)

0,00

8.4

BioUML

5,92855E-1

1,46931E0

5,07254E-1

1,51489E-1

1,40714E0

4,87823E-2

5,79199E-2

1,94208E0

1,49571E-2

6,20237E-1

1,97919E1

1,98504E0

1,69896E-1

5,30691E-1

7,32901E0

5,79773E-1

2,00424E0

8.4

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,46931E0

5,07254E-1

1,51489E-1

1,40714E0

4,87823E-2

5,00000E-1

1,94208E0

0,00000E0

6,20237E-1

1,97919E1

1,98504E0

1,69896E-1

5,00000E-1

7,32901E0

5,79773E-1

2,00424E0

8.4

MathSBML

5,92855E-1

1,46931E0

5,07254E-1

1,51489E-1

1,40714E0

4,87823E-2

5,79199E-2

1,94208E0

1,49571E-2

6,20237E-1

1,97919E1

1,98504E0

1,69896E-1

5,30691E-1

7,32901E0

5,79773E-1

2,00424E0

8.4

Oscill8 Core

1,71723E-16

9,92560E-38

4,77597E-1

9,76631E-18

1,09372E0

1,65000E0

1,40388E-1

3,76000E1

2,99937E-25

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,84771E-1

2,62050E-4

8.4

SBToolbox2

5,91151E-1

1,46990E0

5,07470E-1

1,51362E-1

1,40885E0

4,86827E-2

5,79567E-2

1,94202E0

1,49790E-2

6,20567E-1

1,97778E1

1,98500E0

1,69923E-1

5,30082E-1

7,32853E0

5,79512E-1

2,00537E0

8.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,46931E0

5,07256E-1

1,51489E-1

1,40715E0

4,87821E-2

1,94208E0

6,20238E-1

1,97918E1

1,98504E0

1,69896E-1

7,32901E0

5,79771E-1

2,00425E0

8.4

copasi

5,92853E-1

1,46931E0

5,07255E-1

1,51489E-1

1,40715E0

4,87823E-2

5,79200E-2

1,94208E0

1,49572E-2

6,20237E-1

1,97919E1

1,98504E0

1,69897E-1

5,30691E-1

7,32901E0

5,79772E-1

2,00424E0

8.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,74400E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

3,76000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

6,79000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

8.4

jsim

5,92855E-1

1,46931E0

5,07254E-1

1,51489E-1

1,40714E0

4,87823E-2

5,79199E-2

1,94208E0

1,49580E-2

6,20237E-1

1,97919E1

1,98504E0

1,69896E-1

5,30691E-1

7,32901E0

5,79773E-1

2,00424E0

8.4

min

5,00000E-1

1,71723E-16

9,92560E-38

1,51362E-1

9,76631E-18

4,86827E-2

5,79199E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,40388E-1

1,97778E1

2,99937E-25

1,69896E-1

5,00000E-1

7,32853E0

3,84771E-1

2,62050E-4

8.4

max

5,92855E-1

1,50000E0

5,07470E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,74400E0

5,00000E-1

1,94208E0

1,49790E-2

6,20567E-1

3,76000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,30691E-1

6,79000E2

5,79773E-1

2,00537E0

8.4

mean

5,92853E-1

1,46931E0

5,07254E-1

1,51489E-1

1,40715E0

4,87823E-2

5,79200E-2

1,94208E0

1,49572E-2

6,20237E-1

1,97919E1

1,98504E0

1,69897E-1

5,30691E-1

7,32901E0

5,79772E-1

2,00424E0

8.4

relative error(%)

0,00

8.6

BioUML

5,49619E-1

1,48137E0

5,34689E-1

1,45527E-1

1,45038E0

4,61909E-2

5,73141E-2

1,94269E0

1,56339E-2

6,28735E-1

1,99837E1

1,98437E0

1,65353E-1

5,18626E-1

7,29235E0

5,67300E-1

2,09202E0

8.6

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,48137E0

5,34689E-1

1,45527E-1

1,45038E0

4,61909E-2

5,00000E-1

1,94269E0

0,00000E0

6,28735E-1

1,99837E1

1,98437E0

1,65353E-1

5,00000E-1

7,29235E0

5,67300E-1

2,09202E0

8.6

MathSBML

5,49619E-1

1,48137E0

5,34689E-1

1,45527E-1

1,45038E0

4,61909E-2

5,73141E-2

1,94269E0

1,56339E-2

6,28735E-1

1,99837E1

1,98437E0

1,65353E-1

5,18626E-1

7,29235E0

5,67300E-1

2,09202E0

8.6

Oscill8 Core

6,27232E-17

1,34319E-38

4,77597E-1

3,59276E-18

1,16178E0

1,65000E0

1,37060E-1

3,84000E1

6,43558E-26

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,83234E-1

2,12907E-4

8.6

SBToolbox2

5,47972E-1

1,48188E0

5,34943E-1

1,45399E-1

1,45201E0

4,60944E-2

5,73551E-2

1,94261E0

1,56572E-2

6,29070E-1

1,99693E1

1,98430E0

1,65378E-1

5,18079E-1

7,29183E0

5,67029E-1

2,09316E0

8.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,48138E0

5,34693E-1

1,45527E-1

1,45038E0

4,61907E-2

1,94269E0

6,28737E-1

1,99836E1

1,98437E0

1,65353E-1

7,29234E0

5,67298E-1

2,09203E0

8.6

copasi

5,49617E-1

1,48137E0

5,34690E-1

1,45527E-1

1,45038E0

4,61909E-2

5,73142E-2

1,94269E0

1,56340E-2

6,28735E-1

1,99837E1

1,98437E0

1,65353E-1

5,18625E-1

7,29234E0

5,67300E-1

2,09202E0

8.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,77600E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

3,84000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

6,95000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

8.6

jsim

5,49619E-1

1,48137E0

5,34689E-1

1,45527E-1

1,45038E0

4,61909E-2

5,73141E-2

1,94269E0

1,56348E-2

6,28735E-1

1,99837E1

1,98437E0

1,65353E-1

5,18626E-1

7,29235E0

5,67300E-1

2,09202E0

8.6

min

5,00000E-1

6,27232E-17

1,34319E-38

1,45399E-1

3,59276E-18

4,60944E-2

5,73141E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,37060E-1

1,99693E1

6,43558E-26

1,65353E-1

5,00000E-1

7,29183E0

3,83234E-1

2,12907E-4

8.6

max

5,49619E-1

1,50000E0

5,34943E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,77600E0

5,00000E-1

1,94269E0

1,56572E-2

6,29070E-1

3,84000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,18626E-1

6,95000E2

5,67300E-1

2,09316E0

8.6

mean

5,49617E-1

1,48137E0

5,34689E-1

1,45527E-1

1,45038E0

4,61909E-2

5,73142E-2

1,94269E0

1,56340E-2

6,28735E-1

1,99837E1

1,98437E0

1,65353E-1

5,18625E-1

7,29235E0

5,67299E-1

2,09202E0

8.6

relative error(%)

0,00

8.8

BioUML

5,07585E-1

1,49263E0

5,65070E-1

1,39718E-1

1,49242E0

4,37166E-2

5,68266E-2

1,94317E0

1,64150E-2

6,37537E-1

2,01410E1

1,98359E0

1,60891E-1

5,07369E-1

7,25147E0

5,54005E-1

2,18965E0

8.8

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,49263E0

5,65070E-1

1,39718E-1

1,49242E0

4,37166E-2

5,00000E-1

1,94317E0

0,00000E0

6,37537E-1

2,01410E1

1,98359E0

1,60891E-1

5,00000E-1

7,25147E0

5,54005E-1

2,18965E0

8.8

MathSBML

5,07585E-1

1,49263E0

5,65070E-1

1,39718E-1

1,49242E0

4,37166E-2

5,68266E-2

1,94317E0

1,64150E-2

6,37537E-1

2,01410E1

1,98359E0

1,60891E-1

5,07369E-1

7,25147E0

5,54005E-1

2,18965E0

8.8

Oscill8 Core

2,28564E-17

1,81769E-39

4,77597E-1

1,32168E-18

1,23513E0

1,65000E0

1,33812E-1

3,92000E1

1,37243E-26

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,81702E-1

1,72985E-4

8.8

SBToolbox2

5,06053E-1

1,49307E0

5,65382E-1

1,39595E-1

1,49395E0

4,36236E-2

5,68705E-2

1,94310E0

1,64400E-2

6,37874E-1

2,01258E1

1,98359E0

1,60912E-1

5,06896E-1

7,25085E0

5,53718E-1

2,19092E0

8.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,49263E0

5,65074E-1

1,39718E-1

1,49242E0

4,37164E-2

1,94317E0

6,37539E-1

2,01409E1

1,98359E0

1,60891E-1

7,25146E0

5,54004E-1

2,18967E0

8.8

copasi

5,07583E-1

1,49263E0

5,65071E-1

1,39718E-1

1,49242E0

4,37166E-2

5,68266E-2

1,94317E0

1,64148E-2

6,37537E-1

2,01410E1

1,98359E0

1,60891E-1

5,07369E-1

7,25147E0

5,54005E-1

2,18965E0

8.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,80800E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

3,92000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

7,11000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

8.8

jsim

5,07585E-1

1,49263E0

5,65070E-1

1,39718E-1

1,49242E0

4,37166E-2

5,68265E-2

1,94317E0

1,64160E-2

6,37537E-1

2,01410E1

1,98358E0

1,60891E-1

5,07369E-1

7,25147E0

5,54005E-1

2,18965E0

8.8

min

5,00000E-1

2,28564E-17

1,81769E-39

1,39595E-1

1,32168E-18

4,36236E-2

5,68265E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,33812E-1

2,01258E1

1,37243E-26

1,60891E-1

5,00000E-1

7,25085E0

3,81702E-1

1,72985E-4

8.8

max

5,07585E-1

1,50000E0

5,65382E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,80800E0

5,00000E-1

1,94317E0

1,64400E-2

6,37874E-1

3,92000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,07369E-1

7,11000E2

5,54005E-1

2,19092E0

8.8

mean

5,07583E-1

1,49263E0

5,65070E-1

1,39718E-1

1,49242E0

4,37166E-2

5,68266E-2

1,94317E0

1,64150E-2

6,37537E-1

2,01410E1

1,98359E0

1,60891E-1

5,07369E-1

7,25147E0

5,54004E-1

2,18965E0

8.8

relative error(%)

0,00

9.0

BioUML

4,67260E-1

1,50302E0

5,98636E-1

1,34065E-1

1,53274E0

4,13569E-2

5,64595E-2

1,94354E0

1,73116E-2

6,46663E-1

2,02600E1

1,98269E0

1,56503E-1

4,96985E-1

7,20602E0

5,39870E-1

2,29811E0

9.0

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,50302E0

5,98636E-1

1,34065E-1

1,53274E0

4,13569E-2

5,00000E-1

1,94354E0

0,00000E0

6,46663E-1

2,02600E1

1,98269E0

1,56503E-1

5,00000E-1

7,20602E0

5,39870E-1

2,29811E0

9.0

MathSBML

4,67260E-1

1,50302E0

5,98636E-1

1,34065E-1

1,53274E0

4,13569E-2

5,64595E-2

1,94354E0

1,73116E-2

6,46663E-1

2,02600E1

1,98269E0

1,56503E-1

4,96985E-1

7,20602E0

5,39870E-1

2,29811E0

9.0

Oscill8 Core

8,30869E-18

2,45979E-40

4,77597E-1

4,86209E-19

1,31404E0

1,65000E0

1,30639E-1

4,00000E1

2,90909E-27

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,80177E-1

1,40553E-4

9.0

SBToolbox2

4,65854E-1

1,50345E0

5,99007E-1

1,33942E-1

1,53410E0

4,12675E-2

5,65055E-2

1,94350E0

1,73389E-2

6,47006E-1

2,02444E1

1,98269E0

1,56518E-1

4,96571E-1

7,20536E0

5,39577E-1

2,29957E0

9.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,50302E0

5,98640E-1

1,34065E-1

1,53274E0

4,13567E-2

1,94354E0

6,46665E-1

2,02598E1

1,98269E0

1,56503E-1

7,20601E0

5,39868E-1

2,29812E0

9.0

copasi

4,67259E-1

1,50302E0

5,98636E-1

1,34065E-1

1,53274E0

4,13568E-2

5,64595E-2

1,94354E0

1,73113E-2

6,46663E-1

2,02600E1

1,98269E0

1,56504E-1

4,96985E-1

7,20602E0

5,39870E-1

2,29811E0

9.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,84000E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

4,00000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

7,27000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

9.0

jsim

4,67260E-1

1,50302E0

5,98635E-1

1,34065E-1

1,53274E0

4,13569E-2

5,64595E-2

1,94354E0

1,73126E-2

6,46663E-1

2,02600E1

1,98269E0

1,56503E-1

4,96985E-1

7,20602E0

5,39870E-1

2,29811E0

9.0

min

4,65854E-1

8,30869E-18

2,45979E-40

1,33942E-1

4,86209E-19

4,12675E-2

5,64595E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,30639E-1

2,02444E1

2,90909E-27

1,56503E-1

4,96571E-1

7,20536E0

3,80177E-1

1,40553E-4

9.0

max

5,00000E-1

1,50345E0

5,99007E-1

5,00000E-1

1,53410E0

1,84000E0

5,00000E-1

1,94354E0

1,73389E-2

6,47006E-1

4,00000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,27000E2

5,39870E-1

2,29957E0

9.0

mean

4,67260E-1

1,50302E0

5,98636E-1

1,34065E-1

1,53274E0

4,13569E-2

5,64595E-2

1,94354E0

1,73116E-2

6,46663E-1

2,02600E1

1,98269E0

1,56504E-1

4,96985E-1

7,20602E0

5,39869E-1

2,29811E0

9.0

relative error(%)

0,00

9.2

BioUML

4,29065E-1

1,51250E0

6,35598E-1

1,28571E-1

1,57094E0

3,91086E-2

5,62162E-2

1,94378E0

1,83357E-2

6,56129E-1

2,03367E1

1,98166E0

1,52186E-1

4,87503E-1

7,15566E0

5,24879E-1

2,41839E0

9.2

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,51250E0

6,35598E-1

1,28571E-1

1,57094E0

3,91086E-2

5,00000E-1

1,94378E0

0,00000E0

6,56129E-1

2,03367E1

1,98166E0

1,52186E-1

5,00000E-1

7,15566E0

5,24879E-1

2,41839E0

9.2

MathSBML

4,29065E-1

1,51250E0

6,35598E-1

1,28571E-1

1,57094E0

3,91086E-2

5,62162E-2

1,94378E0

1,83357E-2

6,56129E-1

2,03367E1

1,98166E0

1,52186E-1

4,87503E-1

7,15566E0

5,24879E-1

2,41839E0

9.2

Oscill8 Core

3,01280E-18

3,32870E-41

4,77597E-1

1,78863E-19

1,39879E0

1,65000E0

1,27542E-1

4,08000E1

6,12933E-28

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,78659E-1

1,14205E-4

9.2

SBToolbox2

4,27753E-1

1,51284E0

6,36016E-1

1,28448E-1

1,57224E0

3,90233E-2

5,62653E-2

1,94370E0

1,83664E-2

6,56478E-1

2,03202E1

1,98160E0

1,52192E-1

4,87144E-1

7,15488E0

5,24578E-1

2,41991E0

9.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,51250E0

6,35602E-1

1,28571E-1

1,57094E0

3,91084E-2

1,94378E0

6,56131E-1

2,03366E1

1,98166E0

1,52185E-1

7,15565E0

5,24877E-1

2,41841E0

9.2

copasi

4,29064E-1

1,51250E0

6,35598E-1

1,28571E-1

1,57094E0

3,91086E-2

5,62162E-2

1,94378E0

1,83357E-2

6,56129E-1

2,03367E1

1,98166E0

1,52186E-1

4,87503E-1

7,15566E0

5,24878E-1

2,41839E0

9.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,87200E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

4,08000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

7,43000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

9.2

jsim

4,29065E-1

1,51250E0

6,35598E-1

1,28571E-1

1,57094E0

3,91086E-2

5,62162E-2

1,94378E0

1,83359E-2

6,56129E-1

2,03367E1

1,98166E0

1,52186E-1

4,87503E-1

7,15566E0

5,24879E-1

2,41839E0

9.2

min

4,27753E-1

3,01280E-18

3,32870E-41

1,28448E-1

1,78863E-19

3,90233E-2

5,62162E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,27542E-1

2,03202E1

6,12933E-28

1,52185E-1

4,87144E-1

7,15488E0

3,78659E-1

1,14205E-4

9.2

max

5,00000E-1

1,51284E0

6,36016E-1

5,00000E-1

1,57224E0

1,87200E0

5,00000E-1

1,94378E0

1,83664E-2

6,56478E-1

4,08000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,43000E2

5,24879E-1

2,41991E0

9.2

mean

4,29065E-1

1,51250E0

6,35598E-1

1,28571E-1

1,57094E0

3,91086E-2

5,62162E-2

1,94378E0

1,83357E-2

6,56129E-1

2,03367E1

1,98166E0

1,52186E-1

4,87503E-1

7,15566E0

5,24877E-1

2,41839E0

9.2

relative error(%)

0,00

9.4

BioUML

3,93321E-1

1,52108E0

6,76109E-1

1,23240E-1

1,60668E0

3,69688E-2

5,61003E-2

1,94390E0

1,94992E-2

6,65945E-1

2,03670E1

1,98050E0

1,47933E-1

4,78924E-1

7,10014E0

5,09021E-1

2,55150E0

9.4

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,52108E0

6,76109E-1

1,23240E-1

1,60668E0

3,69688E-2

5,00000E-1

1,94390E0

0,00000E0

6,65945E-1

2,03670E1

1,98050E0

1,47933E-1

5,00000E-1

7,10014E0

5,09021E-1

2,55150E0

9.4

MathSBML

3,93321E-1

1,52108E0

6,76109E-1

1,23240E-1

1,60668E0

3,69688E-2

5,61003E-2

1,94390E0

1,94992E-2

6,65945E-1

2,03670E1

1,98050E0

1,47933E-1

4,78924E-1

7,10014E0

5,09021E-1

2,55150E0

9.4

Oscill8 Core

1,08965E-18

4,50452E-42

4,77597E-1

6,57984E-20

1,48965E0

1,65000E0

1,24519E-1

4,16000E1

1,28374E-28

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,77146E-1

9,27990E-5

9.4

SBToolbox2

3,92107E-1

1,52142E0

6,76587E-1

1,23114E-1

1,60790E0

3,68877E-2

5,61518E-2

1,94381E0

1,95318E-2

6,66290E-1

2,03500E1

1,98049E0

1,47937E-1

4,78606E-1

7,09932E0

5,08701E-1

2,55322E0

9.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,52108E0

6,76113E-1

1,23240E-1

1,60668E0

3,69686E-2

1,94390E0

6,65947E-1

2,03669E1

1,98050E0

1,47933E-1

7,10013E0

5,09019E-1

2,55152E0

9.4

copasi

3,93321E-1

1,52108E0

6,76109E-1

1,23241E-1

1,60668E0

3,69688E-2

5,61004E-2

1,94390E0

1,94994E-2

6,65945E-1

2,03670E1

1,98050E0

1,47933E-1

4,78924E-1

7,10014E0

5,09021E-1

2,55150E0

9.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,90400E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

4,16000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

7,59000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

9.4

jsim

3,93321E-1

1,52108E0

6,76109E-1

1,23240E-1

1,60668E0

3,69688E-2

5,61003E-2

1,94390E0

1,94994E-2

6,65945E-1

2,03670E1

1,98050E0

1,47933E-1

4,78924E-1

7,10014E0

5,09021E-1

2,55150E0

9.4

min

3,92107E-1

1,08965E-18

4,50452E-42

1,23114E-1

6,57984E-20

3,68877E-2

5,61003E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,24519E-1

2,03500E1

1,28374E-28

1,47933E-1

4,78606E-1

7,09932E0

3,77146E-1

9,27990E-5

9.4

max

5,00000E-1

1,52142E0

6,76587E-1

5,00000E-1

1,60790E0

1,90400E0

5,00000E-1

1,94390E0

1,95318E-2

6,66290E-1

4,16000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,59000E2

5,09021E-1

2,55322E0

9.4

mean

3,93321E-1

1,52108E0

6,76109E-1

1,23240E-1

1,60668E0

3,69688E-2

5,61004E-2

1,94390E0

1,94994E-2

6,65945E-1

2,03670E1

1,98050E0

1,47933E-1

4,78924E-1

7,10014E0

5,09020E-1

2,55150E0

9.4

relative error(%)

0,00

9.6

BioUML

3,60265E-1

1,52877E0

7,20223E-1

1,18074E-1

1,63974E0

3,49342E-2

5,61164E-2

1,94388E0

2,08131E-2

6,76113E-1

2,03467E1

1,97919E0

1,43743E-1

4,71231E-1

7,03932E0

4,92295E-1

2,69834E0

9.6

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,52877E0

7,20223E-1

1,18074E-1

1,63974E0

3,49342E-2

5,00000E-1

1,94388E0

0,00000E0

6,76113E-1

2,03467E1

1,97919E0

1,43743E-1

5,00000E-1

7,03932E0

4,92295E-1

2,69834E0

9.6

MathSBML

3,60265E-1

1,52877E0

7,20223E-1

1,18074E-1

1,63973E0

3,49342E-2

5,61164E-2

1,94388E0

2,08131E-2

6,76113E-1

2,03467E1

1,97919E0

1,43743E-1

4,71231E-1

7,03932E0

4,92295E-1

2,69834E0

9.6

Oscill8 Core

3,93054E-19

6,09567E-43

4,77597E-1

2,42053E-20

1,58689E0

1,65000E0

1,21566E-1

4,24000E1

2,67283E-29

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,75640E-1

7,54075E-5

9.6

SBToolbox2

3,59147E-1

1,52902E0

7,20762E-1

1,17950E-1

1,64086E0

3,48560E-2

5,61702E-2

1,94380E0

2,08488E-2

6,76470E-1

2,03279E1

1,97920E0

1,43742E-1

4,70956E-1

7,03837E0

4,91966E-1

2,70021E0

9.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,52877E0

7,20227E-1

1,18074E-1

1,63974E0

3,49340E-2

1,94388E0

6,76115E-1

2,03466E1

1,97919E0

1,43743E-1

7,03931E0

4,92293E-1

2,69836E0

9.6

copasi

3,60265E-1

1,52877E0

7,20223E-1

1,18074E-1

1,63974E0

3,49341E-2

5,61165E-2

1,94388E0

2,08127E-2

6,76113E-1

2,03467E1

1,97919E0

1,43743E-1

4,71231E-1

7,03932E0

4,92295E-1

2,69834E0

9.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,93600E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

4,24000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

7,75000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

9.6

jsim

3,60265E-1

1,52877E0

7,20223E-1

1,18074E-1

1,63974E0

3,49342E-2

5,61164E-2

1,94388E0

2,08133E-2

6,76113E-1

2,03467E1

1,97919E0

1,43743E-1

4,71231E-1

7,03932E0

4,92295E-1

2,69834E0

9.6

min

3,59147E-1

3,93054E-19

6,09567E-43

1,17950E-1

2,42053E-20

3,48560E-2

5,61164E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,21566E-1

2,03279E1

2,67283E-29

1,43742E-1

4,70956E-1

7,03837E0

3,75640E-1

7,54075E-5

9.6

max

5,00000E-1

1,52902E0

7,20762E-1

5,00000E-1

1,64086E0

1,93600E0

5,00000E-1

1,94388E0

2,08488E-2

6,76470E-1

4,24000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,75000E2

5,00000E-1

2,70021E0

9.6

mean

3,60265E-1

1,52877E0

7,20223E-1

1,18074E-1

1,63974E0

3,49342E-2

5,61165E-2

1,94388E0

2,08131E-2

6,76113E-1

2,03467E1

1,97919E0

1,43743E-1

4,71231E-1

7,03932E0

4,92295E-1

2,69834E0

9.6

relative error(%)

0,00

9.8

BioUML

3,30050E-1

1,53561E0

7,67847E-1

1,13073E-1

1,66995E0

3,30013E-2

5,62695E-2

1,94373E0

2,22860E-2

6,86621E-1

2,02718E1

1,97771E0

1,39614E-1

4,64389E-1

6,97326E0

4,74712E-1

2,85968E0

9.8

ByoDyn

5,00000E-1

1,53561E0

7,67847E-1

1,13073E-1

1,66995E0

3,30013E-2

5,00000E-1

1,94373E0

0,00000E0

6,86621E-1

2,02718E1

1,97771E0

1,39614E-1

5,00000E-1

6,97326E0

4,74712E-1

2,85968E0

9.8

MathSBML

3,30050E-1

1,53561E0

7,67847E-1

1,13073E-1

1,66995E0

3,30013E-2

5,62695E-2

1,94373E0

2,22860E-2

6,86621E-1

2,02718E1

1,97771E0

1,39614E-1

4,64389E-1

6,97326E0

4,74712E-1

2,85968E0

9.8

Oscill8 Core

1,41394E-19

8,24883E-44

4,77597E-1

8,90444E-21

1,69074E0

1,65000E0

1,18684E-1

4,32000E1

5,53244E-30

4,61000E-1

8,00000E0

3,74140E-1

6,12772E-5

9.8

SBToolbox2

3,29011E-1

1,53591E0

7,68460E-1

1,12955E-1

1,67103E0

3,29271E-2

5,63272E-2

1,94370E0

2,23256E-2

6,86981E-1

2,02519E1

1,97770E0

1,39606E-1

4,64144E-1

6,97213E0

4,74372E-1

2,86177E0

9.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,53561E0

7,67852E-1

1,13073E-1

1,66995E0

3,30011E-2

1,94373E0

6,86623E-1

2,02716E1

1,97772E0

1,39613E-1

6,97325E0

4,74710E-1

2,85970E0

9.8

copasi

3,30051E-1

1,53561E0

7,67846E-1

1,13073E-1

1,66995E0

3,30013E-2

5,62695E-2

1,94373E0

2,22869E-2

6,86621E-1

2,02718E1

1,97771E0

1,39614E-1

4,64389E-1

6,97326E0

4,74712E-1

2,85968E0

9.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

1,96800E0

1,50000E0

3,00000E-1

4,32000E1

2,00000E0

4,00000E-1

7,91000E2

5,00000E-1

1,50000E0

9.8

jsim

3,30050E-1

1,53561E0

7,67847E-1

1,13073E-1

1,66995E0

3,30013E-2

5,62695E-2

1,94373E0

2,22862E-2

6,86621E-1

2,02718E1

1,97771E0

1,39614E-1

4,64389E-1

6,97326E0

4,74712E-1

2,85968E0

9.8

min

3,29011E-1

1,41394E-19

8,24883E-44

1,12955E-1

8,90444E-21

3,29271E-2

5,62695E-2

1,50000E0

0,00000E0

1,18684E-1

2,02519E1

5,53244E-30

1,39606E-1

4,64144E-1

6,97213E0

3,74140E-1

6,12772E-5

9.8

max

5,00000E-1

1,53591E0

7,68460E-1

5,00000E-1

1,67103E0

1,96800E0

5,00000E-1

1,94373E0

2,23256E-2

6,86981E-1

4,32000E1

2,00000E0

4,61000E-1

5,00000E-1

7,91000E2

5,00000E-1

2,86177E0

9.8

mean

3,30050E-1

1,53561E0

7,67847E-1

1,13073E-1

1,66995E0

3,30013E-2

5,62695E-2

1,94373E0

2,22862E-2

6,86621E-1

2,02718E1

1,97771E0

1,39614E-1

4,64389E-1

6,97326E0

4,74712E-1

2,85968E0

9.8

relative error(%)

0,00

Test: BIOMD0000000090.xml - Ok

Reaction graph

Plots

Comparison with other simulators