Test BIOMD0000000061.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000061.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000061.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: Imex
generated code	: BIOMD0000000061.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: plot
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-10
ATOL 1.0E-10
RTOL 1.0E-6
STEP 1.0E-4

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: CNX EtOH G6P NADH GAP ATP FBP AMP GlycX ACA PEP Glyc ACAX BPG F6P EtOHX GlcX ADP NAD DHAP Pyr Glc
Simulators: ByoDyn copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner Jarnac SBToolbox2 VCell Oscill8 Core SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

CNX

EtOH

G6P

NADH

GAP

ATP

FBP

AMP

GlycX

ACA

PEP

Glyc

ACAX

BPG

F6P

EtOHX

GlcX

ADP

NAD

DHAP

Pyr

Glc

0.0

BioUML

5,20358E0

1,92379E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68478E0

1,48153E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28836E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64514E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73074E-1

0.0

ByoDyn

5,20358E0

1,92379E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68478E0

1,48153E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28836E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64514E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73074E-1

0.0

Jarnac

5,20358E0

1,92379E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68478E0

1,48153E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28836E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64514E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73074E-1

0.0

MathSBML

5,20358E0

1,92379E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68478E0

1,48153E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28836E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64514E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73074E-1

0.0

Oscill8 Core

5,20358E0

1,92379E1

4,20000E0

1,15000E-1

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68478E0

1,48153E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28836E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64514E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73074E-1

0.0

SBToolbox2

5,20360E0

1,92380E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68480E0

1,48150E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28840E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64510E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73070E-1

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,20358E0

1,92379E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68478E0

1,48153E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28836E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64514E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73074E-1

0.0

VCell

5,20358E0

1,92379E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68478E0

1,48153E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28836E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64514E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73074E-1

0.0

copasi

5,20358E0

1,92379E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68478E0

1,48153E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28836E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64514E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73074E-1

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20358E0

1,92379E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68478E0

1,48153E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28836E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64514E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73074E-1

0.0

jsim

5,20358E0

1,92379E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68478E0

1,48153E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28836E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64514E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73074E-1

0.0

min

5,20358E0

1,92379E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68478E0

1,48150E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28836E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64510E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73070E-1

0.0

max

5,20360E0

1,92380E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68480E0

1,48153E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28840E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64514E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73074E-1

0.0

mean

5,20358E0

1,92379E1

4,20000E0

3,30000E-1

1,15000E-1

2,10000E0

4,64000E0

3,30000E-1

1,68478E0

1,48153E0

4,00000E-2

4,19600E0

1,28836E0

2,70000E-4

4,90000E-1

1,64514E1

6,70000E0

1,50000E0

6,50000E-1

2,95000E0

8,70000E0

5,73074E-1

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

5,20358E0

1,92560E1

4,10898E0

3,48611E-1

1,19827E-1

1,92314E0

5,00468E0

4,08747E-1

1,68482E0

1,46785E0

4,04959E-2

4,21658E0

1,28796E0

2,41447E-4

4,71655E-1

1,64517E1

6,66383E0

1,59811E0

6,31389E-1

3,05281E0

8,77828E0

2,74248E0

0.2

ByoDyn

5,20358E0

1,92560E1

4,10886E0

3,48641E-1

1,19826E-1

1,92247E0

5,00447E0

4,09064E-1

1,68482E0

1,46783E0

4,04962E-2

4,21645E0

1,28796E0

2,41337E-4

4,71613E-1

1,64517E1

6,66382E0

1,59846E0

6,31359E-1

3,05272E0

8,77798E0

2,74325E0

0.2

Jarnac

5,20358E0

1,92560E1

4,10886E0

3,48641E-1

1,19826E-1

1,92247E0

5,00447E0

4,09064E-1

1,68482E0

1,46783E0

4,04962E-2

4,21645E0

1,28796E0

2,41337E-4

4,71613E-1

1,64517E1

6,66382E0

1,59846E0

6,31359E-1

3,05272E0

8,77798E0

2,74325E0

0.2

MathSBML

5,20358E0

1,92560E1

4,10886E0

3,48641E-1

1,19826E-1

1,92247E0

5,00447E0

4,09064E-1

1,68482E0

1,46783E0

4,04962E-2

4,21645E0

1,28796E0

2,41337E-4

4,71613E-1

1,64517E1

6,66382E0

1,59846E0

6,31359E-1

3,05272E0

8,77798E0

2,74325E0

0.2

Oscill8 Core

5,20358E0

1,92560E1

4,10886E0

1,19826E-1

5,00447E0

4,09060E-1

1,68482E0

1,46783E0

4,04962E-2

4,21645E0

1,28796E0

2,41339E-4

4,71614E-1

1,64517E1

6,66382E0

1,59846E0

6,31360E-1

3,05272E0

8,77799E0

2,74324E0

0.2

SBToolbox2

5,20360E0

1,92560E1

4,10923E0

3,48627E-1

1,19822E-1

1,92261E0

5,00397E0

4,08968E-1

1,68480E0

1,46782E0

4,04964E-2

4,21645E0

1,28800E0

2,41364E-4

4,71659E-1

1,64520E1

6,66380E0

1,59835E0

6,31373E-1

3,05261E0

8,77803E0

2,74433E0

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,20358E0

1,92560E1

4,10886E0

3,48640E-1

1,19826E-1

1,92248E0

5,00447E0

4,09060E-1

1,68482E0

1,46783E0

4,04962E-2

4,21645E0

1,28796E0

2,41339E-4

4,71614E-1

1,64517E1

6,66382E0

1,59846E0

6,31360E-1

3,05272E0

8,77799E0

2,74324E0

0.2

VCell

5,20358E0

1,92560E1

4,10886E0

3,48641E-1

1,19826E-1

1,92247E0

5,00447E0

4,09064E-1

1,68482E0

1,46783E0

4,04962E-2

4,21645E0

1,28796E0

2,41337E-4

4,71613E-1

1,64517E1

6,66382E0

1,59846E0

6,31359E-1

3,05272E0

8,77798E0

2,74325E0

0.2

copasi

5,20358E0

1,92560E1

4,10886E0

3,48641E-1

1,19826E-1

1,92247E0

5,00447E0

4,09064E-1

1,68482E0

1,46783E0

4,04962E-2

4,21645E0

1,28796E0

2,41337E-4

4,71613E-1

1,64517E1

6,66382E0

1,59846E0

6,31359E-1

3,05272E0

8,77798E0

2,74325E0

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20358E0

1,92560E1

4,10886E0

3,48641E-1

1,19826E-1

1,92247E0

5,00447E0

4,09064E-1

1,68482E0

1,46783E0

4,04962E-2

4,21645E0

1,28796E0

2,41337E-4

4,71613E-1

1,64517E1

6,66382E0

1,59846E0

6,31359E-1

3,05272E0

8,77798E0

2,74325E0

0.2

jsim

5,20358E0

1,92560E1

4,10881E0

3,48644E-1

1,19828E-1

1,92246E0

5,00456E0

4,09066E-1

1,68482E0

1,46783E0

4,04964E-2

4,21645E0

1,28796E0

2,41336E-4

4,71607E-1

1,64517E1

6,66382E0

1,59847E0

6,31356E-1

3,05275E0

8,77801E0

2,74323E0

0.2

min

5,20358E0

1,92560E1

4,10881E0

3,48627E-1

1,19822E-1

1,92246E0

5,00397E0

4,08968E-1

1,68480E0

1,46782E0

4,04962E-2

4,21645E0

1,28796E0

2,41336E-4

4,71607E-1

1,64517E1

6,66380E0

1,59835E0

6,31356E-1

3,05261E0

8,77798E0

2,74323E0

0.2

max

5,20360E0

1,92560E1

4,10923E0

3,48644E-1

1,19828E-1

1,92261E0

5,00456E0

4,09066E-1

1,68482E0

1,46783E0

4,04964E-2

4,21645E0

1,28800E0

2,41364E-4

4,71659E-1

1,64520E1

6,66382E0

1,59847E0

6,31373E-1

3,05275E0

8,77803E0

2,74433E0

0.2

mean

5,20358E0

1,92560E1

4,10886E0

3,48641E-1

1,19826E-1

1,92247E0

5,00447E0

4,09064E-1

1,68482E0

1,46783E0

4,04962E-2

4,21645E0

1,28796E0

2,41337E-4

4,71613E-1

1,64517E1

6,66382E0

1,59846E0

6,31359E-1

3,05272E0

8,77798E0

2,74325E0

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

5,20358E0

1,92752E1

4,02314E0

3,58244E-1

1,25864E-1

1,99207E0

5,49731E0

3,77181E-1

1,68517E0

1,45692E0

4,09162E-2

4,29237E0

1,28632E0

2,55711E-4

4,64986E-1

1,64534E1

6,66349E0

1,56075E0

6,21756E-1

3,20522E0

8,99297E0

2,80427E0

0.4

ByoDyn

5,20358E0

1,92752E1

4,02204E0

3,58313E-1

1,25888E-1

1,99175E0

5,49925E0

3,77301E-1

1,68517E0

1,45686E0

4,09180E-2

4,29242E0

1,28632E0

2,55652E-4

4,64844E-1

1,64534E1

6,66349E0

1,56095E0

6,21687E-1

3,20577E0

8,99311E0

2,80459E0

0.4

Jarnac

5,20358E0

1,92752E1

4,02204E0

3,58313E-1

1,25888E-1

1,99175E0

5,49925E0

3,77301E-1

1,68517E0

1,45686E0

4,09180E-2

4,29242E0

1,28632E0

2,55652E-4

4,64844E-1

1,64534E1

6,66349E0

1,56095E0

6,21687E-1

3,20577E0

8,99311E0

2,80459E0

0.4

MathSBML

5,20358E0

1,92752E1

4,02204E0

3,58313E-1

1,25888E-1

1,99175E0

5,49925E0

3,77301E-1

1,68517E0

1,45686E0

4,09180E-2

4,29242E0

1,28632E0

2,55652E-4

4,64844E-1

1,64534E1

6,66349E0

1,56095E0

6,21687E-1

3,20577E0

8,99311E0

2,80459E0

0.4

Oscill8 Core

5,20358E0

1,92752E1

4,02206E0

1,25888E-1

5,49921E0

3,77298E-1

1,68517E0

1,45687E0

4,09180E-2

4,29242E0

1,28632E0

2,55653E-4

4,64847E-1

1,64534E1

6,66349E0

1,56095E0

6,21688E-1

3,20576E0

8,99310E0

2,80458E0

0.4

SBToolbox2

5,20360E0

1,92750E1

4,02022E0

3,58477E-1

1,25904E-1

1,98912E0

5,49991E0

3,78393E-1

1,68520E0

1,45680E0

4,09197E-2

4,29203E0

1,28630E0

2,55131E-4

4,64503E-1

1,64530E1

6,66350E0

1,56251E0

6,21523E-1

3,20574E0

8,99264E0

2,80491E0

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,20358E0

1,92752E1

4,02206E0

3,58312E-1

1,25888E-1

1,99175E0

5,49921E0

3,77300E-1

1,68517E0

1,45687E0

4,09180E-2

4,29242E0

1,28632E0

2,55653E-4

4,64847E-1

1,64534E1

6,66349E0

1,56095E0

6,21688E-1

3,20576E0

8,99310E0

2,80458E0

0.4

VCell

5,20358E0

1,92752E1

4,02204E0

3,58313E-1

1,25888E-1

1,99175E0

5,49925E0

3,77301E-1

1,68517E0

1,45686E0

4,09180E-2

4,29242E0

1,28632E0

2,55652E-4

4,64844E-1

1,64534E1

6,66349E0

1,56095E0

6,21687E-1

3,20577E0

8,99311E0

2,80459E0

0.4

copasi

5,20358E0

1,92752E1

4,02204E0

3,58313E-1

1,25888E-1

1,99175E0

5,49925E0

3,77301E-1

1,68517E0

1,45687E0

4,09180E-2

4,29242E0

1,28632E0

2,55652E-4

4,64844E-1

1,64534E1

6,66349E0

1,56095E0

6,21687E-1

3,20577E0

8,99311E0

2,80458E0

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20358E0

1,92752E1

4,02204E0

3,58313E-1

1,25888E-1

1,99175E0

5,49925E0

3,77301E-1

1,68517E0

1,45686E0

4,09180E-2

4,29242E0

1,28632E0

2,55652E-4

4,64844E-1

1,64534E1

6,66349E0

1,56095E0

6,21687E-1

3,20577E0

8,99311E0

2,80459E0

0.4

jsim

5,20358E0

1,92752E1

4,02205E0

3,58313E-1

1,25888E-1

1,99176E0

5,49927E0

3,77280E-1

1,68517E0

1,45687E0

4,09181E-2

4,29243E0

1,28632E0

2,55650E-4

4,64844E-1

1,64534E1

6,66348E0

1,56096E0

6,21687E-1

3,20578E0

8,99314E0

2,80458E0

0.4

min

5,20358E0

1,92750E1

4,02022E0

3,58312E-1

1,25888E-1

1,98912E0

5,49921E0

3,77280E-1

1,68517E0

1,45680E0

4,09180E-2

4,29203E0

1,28630E0

2,55131E-4

4,64503E-1

1,64530E1

6,66348E0

1,56095E0

6,21523E-1

3,20574E0

8,99264E0

2,80458E0

0.4

max

5,20360E0

1,92752E1

4,02206E0

3,58477E-1

1,25904E-1

1,99176E0

5,49991E0

3,78393E-1

1,68520E0

1,45687E0

4,09197E-2

4,29243E0

1,28632E0

2,55653E-4

4,64847E-1

1,64534E1

6,66350E0

1,56251E0

6,21688E-1

3,20578E0

8,99314E0

2,80491E0

0.4

mean

5,20358E0

1,92752E1

4,02204E0

3,58313E-1

1,25888E-1

1,99175E0

5,49925E0

3,77301E-1

1,68517E0

1,45686E0

4,09180E-2

4,29242E0

1,28632E0

2,55652E-4

4,64844E-1

1,64534E1

6,66349E0

1,56095E0

6,21687E-1

3,20577E0

8,99311E0

2,80459E0

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

5,20359E0

1,92652E1

4,29511E0

3,44512E-1

1,23835E-1

2,17137E0

5,34432E0

3,01375E-1

1,68600E0

1,46645E0

4,07614E-2

4,35113E0

1,28483E0

2,89589E-4

5,04254E-1

1,64551E1

6,66455E0

1,45725E0

6,35488E-1

3,17178E0

9,16781E0

2,74197E0

0.6

ByoDyn

5,20359E0

1,92652E1

4,29605E0

3,44434E-1

1,23834E-1

2,17281E0

5,34432E0

3,00812E-1

1,68600E0

1,46648E0

4,07607E-2

4,35136E0

1,28483E0

2,89890E-4

5,04438E-1

1,64551E1

6,66455E0

1,45638E0

6,35566E-1

3,17190E0

9,16815E0

2,74189E0

0.6

Jarnac

5,20359E0

1,92652E1

4,29605E0

3,44434E-1

1,23834E-1

2,17281E0

5,34432E0

3,00812E-1

1,68600E0

1,46648E0

4,07607E-2

4,35136E0

1,28483E0

2,89890E-4

5,04438E-1

1,64551E1

6,66455E0

1,45638E0

6,35566E-1

3,17190E0

9,16815E0

2,74189E0

0.6

MathSBML

5,20359E0

1,92652E1

4,29605E0

3,44434E-1

1,23834E-1

2,17281E0

5,34432E0

3,00812E-1

1,68600E0

1,46648E0

4,07607E-2

4,35136E0

1,28483E0

2,89890E-4

5,04438E-1

1,64551E1

6,66455E0

1,45638E0

6,35566E-1

3,17190E0

9,16815E0

2,74189E0

0.6

Oscill8 Core

5,20359E0

1,92652E1

4,29603E0

1,23834E-1

5,34432E0

3,00823E-1

1,68600E0

1,46648E0

4,07608E-2

4,35136E0

1,28483E0

2,89884E-4

5,04434E-1

1,64551E1

6,66455E0

1,45640E0

6,35565E-1

3,17190E0

9,16814E0

2,74190E0

0.6

SBToolbox2

5,20360E0

1,92661E1

4,28892E0

3,44817E-1

1,23994E-1

2,17204E0

5,35697E0

3,01094E-1

1,68600E0

1,46606E0

4,07720E-2

4,35201E0

1,28481E0

2,89760E-4

5,03585E-1

1,64550E1

6,66450E0

1,45686E0

6,35183E-1

3,17563E0

9,17014E0

2,74397E0

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,20359E0

1,92652E1

4,29602E0

3,44436E-1

1,23834E-1

2,17277E0

5,34435E0

3,00825E-1

1,68600E0

1,46647E0

4,07608E-2

4,35136E0

1,28483E0

2,89883E-4

5,04432E-1

1,64551E1

6,66455E0

1,45640E0

6,35564E-1

3,17191E0

9,16815E0

2,74190E0

0.6

VCell

5,20359E0

1,92652E1

4,29605E0

3,44434E-1

1,23834E-1

2,17281E0

5,34432E0

3,00812E-1

1,68600E0

1,46648E0

4,07607E-2

4,35136E0

1,28483E0

2,89890E-4

5,04438E-1

1,64551E1

6,66455E0

1,45638E0

6,35566E-1

3,17190E0

9,16815E0

2,74189E0

0.6

copasi

5,20359E0

1,92652E1

4,29606E0

3,44433E-1

1,23834E-1

2,17282E0

5,34432E0

3,00809E-1

1,68600E0

1,46648E0

4,07607E-2

4,35136E0

1,28483E0

2,89891E-4

5,04439E-1

1,64551E1

6,66455E0

1,45638E0

6,35567E-1

3,17190E0

9,16815E0

2,74189E0

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20359E0

1,92652E1

4,29605E0

3,44434E-1

1,23834E-1

2,17281E0

5,34432E0

3,00812E-1

1,68600E0

1,46648E0

4,07607E-2

4,35136E0

1,28483E0

2,89890E-4

5,04438E-1

1,64551E1

6,66455E0

1,45638E0

6,35566E-1

3,17190E0

9,16815E0

2,74189E0

0.6

jsim

5,20359E0

1,92652E1

4,29607E0

3,44433E-1

1,23834E-1

2,17282E0

5,34430E0

3,00806E-1

1,68600E0

1,46648E0

4,07608E-2

4,35137E0

1,28483E0

2,89892E-4

5,04441E-1

1,64551E1

6,66455E0

1,45637E0

6,35567E-1

3,17190E0

9,16818E0

2,74189E0

0.6

min

5,20359E0

1,92652E1

4,28892E0

3,44433E-1

1,23834E-1

2,17204E0

5,34430E0

3,00806E-1

1,68600E0

1,46606E0

4,07607E-2

4,35136E0

1,28481E0

2,89760E-4

5,03585E-1

1,64550E1

6,66450E0

1,45637E0

6,35183E-1

3,17190E0

9,16814E0

2,74189E0

0.6

max

5,20360E0

1,92661E1

4,29607E0

3,44817E-1

1,23994E-1

2,17282E0

5,35697E0

3,01094E-1

1,68600E0

1,46648E0

4,07720E-2

4,35201E0

1,28483E0

2,89892E-4

5,04441E-1

1,64551E1

6,66455E0

1,45686E0

6,35567E-1

3,17563E0

9,17014E0

2,74397E0

0.6

mean

5,20359E0

1,92652E1

4,29605E0

3,44434E-1

1,23834E-1

2,17281E0

5,34432E0

3,00812E-1

1,68600E0

1,46648E0

4,07607E-2

4,35136E0

1,28483E0

2,89890E-4

5,04438E-1

1,64551E1

6,66455E0

1,45638E0

6,35566E-1

3,17190E0

9,16815E0

2,74189E0

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

5,20360E0

1,92612E1

4,35878E0

3,46600E-1

1,22096E-1

2,05468E0

5,19444E0

3,48808E-1

1,68701E0

1,46845E0

4,07093E-2

4,36056E0

1,28422E0

2,65768E-4

5,05112E-1

1,64561E1

6,66507E0

1,52651E0

6,33400E-1

3,11772E0

9,27668E0

2,70131E0

0.8

ByoDyn

5,20360E0

1,92611E1

4,35919E0

3,46585E-1

1,22086E-1

2,05455E0

5,19358E0

3,48853E-1

1,68701E0

1,46847E0

4,07086E-2

4,36050E0

1,28423E0

2,65733E-4

5,05148E-1

1,64561E1

6,66507E0

1,52660E0

6,33415E-1

3,11745E0

9,27651E0

2,70114E0

0.8

Jarnac

5,20360E0

1,92611E1

4,35919E0

3,46585E-1

1,22086E-1

2,05455E0

5,19358E0

3,48853E-1

1,68701E0

1,46847E0

4,07086E-2

4,36050E0

1,28423E0

2,65733E-4

5,05148E-1

1,64561E1

6,66507E0

1,52660E0

6,33415E-1

3,11745E0

9,27651E0

2,70114E0

0.8

MathSBML

5,20360E0

1,92611E1

4,35919E0

3,46585E-1

1,22086E-1

2,05455E0

5,19358E0

3,48853E-1

1,68701E0

1,46847E0

4,07086E-2

4,36050E0

1,28423E0

2,65733E-4

5,05148E-1

1,64561E1

6,66507E0

1,52660E0

6,33415E-1

3,11745E0

9,27651E0

2,70114E0

0.8

Oscill8 Core

5,20360E0

1,92611E1

4,35915E0

1,22087E-1

5,19365E0

3,48850E-1

1,68701E0

1,46847E0

4,07087E-2

4,36051E0

1,28423E0

2,65736E-4

5,05145E-1

1,64561E1

6,66507E0

1,52659E0

6,33414E-1

3,11747E0

9,27652E0

2,70116E0

0.8

SBToolbox2

5,20360E0

1,92609E1

4,36838E0

3,45943E-1

1,21979E-1

2,06266E0

5,18550E0

3,45312E-1

1,68700E0

1,46894E0

4,06990E-2

4,36136E0

1,28420E0

2,67197E-4

5,06570E-1

1,64560E1

6,66510E0

1,52200E0

6,34057E-1

3,11562E0

9,27764E0

2,69950E0

0.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,20360E0

1,92611E1

4,35917E0

3,46585E-1

1,22086E-1

2,05457E0

5,19363E0

3,48844E-1

1,68701E0

1,46847E0

4,07086E-2

4,36051E0

1,28423E0

2,65739E-4

5,05148E-1

1,64561E1

6,66507E0

1,52658E0

6,33415E-1

3,11746E0

9,27652E0

2,70115E0

0.8

VCell

5,20360E0

1,92611E1

4,35919E0

3,46585E-1

1,22086E-1

2,05455E0

5,19358E0

3,48853E-1

1,68701E0

1,46847E0

4,07086E-2

4,36050E0

1,28423E0

2,65733E-4

5,05148E-1

1,64561E1

6,66507E0

1,52660E0

6,33415E-1

3,11745E0

9,27651E0

2,70114E0

0.8

copasi

5,20360E0

1,92611E1

4,35919E0

3,46585E-1

1,22086E-1

2,05454E0

5,19356E0

3,48855E-1

1,68701E0

1,46847E0

4,07086E-2

4,36050E0

1,28423E0

2,65732E-4

5,05149E-1

1,64561E1

6,66507E0

1,52660E0

6,33415E-1

3,11744E0

9,27651E0

2,70114E0

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20360E0

1,92611E1

4,35919E0

3,46585E-1

1,22086E-1

2,05455E0

5,19358E0

3,48853E-1

1,68701E0

1,46847E0

4,07086E-2

4,36050E0

1,28423E0

2,65733E-4

5,05148E-1

1,64561E1

6,66507E0

1,52660E0

6,33415E-1

3,11745E0

9,27651E0

2,70114E0

0.8

jsim

5,20360E0

1,92611E1

4,35916E0

3,46587E-1

1,22086E-1

2,05453E0

5,19361E0

3,48862E-1

1,68701E0

1,46847E0

4,07086E-2

4,36051E0

1,28423E0

2,65729E-4

5,05144E-1

1,64561E1

6,66507E0

1,52661E0

6,33413E-1

3,11745E0

9,27654E0

2,70114E0

0.8

min

5,20360E0

1,92609E1

4,35915E0

3,45943E-1

1,21979E-1

2,05453E0

5,18550E0

3,45312E-1

1,68700E0

1,46847E0

4,06990E-2

4,36050E0

1,28420E0

2,65729E-4

5,05144E-1

1,64560E1

6,66507E0

1,52200E0

6,33413E-1

3,11562E0

9,27651E0

2,69950E0

0.8

max

5,20360E0

1,92611E1

4,36838E0

3,46587E-1

1,22087E-1

2,06266E0

5,19365E0

3,48862E-1

1,68701E0

1,46894E0

4,07087E-2

4,36136E0

1,28423E0

2,67197E-4

5,06570E-1

1,64561E1

6,66510E0

1,52661E0

6,34057E-1

3,11747E0

9,27764E0

2,70116E0

0.8

mean

5,20360E0

1,92611E1

4,35919E0

3,46585E-1

1,22086E-1

2,05455E0

5,19358E0

3,48853E-1

1,68701E0

1,46847E0

4,07086E-2

4,36050E0

1,28423E0

2,65733E-4

5,05148E-1

1,64561E1

6,66507E0

1,52660E0

6,33415E-1

3,11745E0

9,27651E0

2,70114E0

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

5,20362E0

1,92807E1

4,13129E0

3,60913E-1

1,27046E-1

1,97912E0

5,59395E0

3,82861E-1

1,68812E0

1,45581E0

4,10514E-2

4,39777E0

1,28300E0

2,54183E-4

4,76356E-1

1,64576E1

6,66447E0

1,56802E0

6,19087E-1

3,23156E0

9,48348E0

2,76303E0

1.0

ByoDyn

5,20362E0

1,92807E1

4,13020E0

3,60985E-1

1,27062E-1

1,97831E0

5,59514E0

3,83229E-1

1,68812E0

1,45576E0

4,10527E-2

4,39772E0

1,28300E0

2,54049E-4

4,76201E-1

1,64576E1

6,66447E0

1,56846E0

6,19015E-1

3,23187E0

9,48342E0

2,76328E0

1.0

Jarnac

5,20362E0

1,92807E1

4,13020E0

3,60985E-1

1,27062E-1

1,97831E0

5,59514E0

3,83229E-1

1,68812E0

1,45576E0

4,10527E-2

4,39772E0

1,28300E0

2,54049E-4

4,76201E-1

1,64576E1

6,66447E0

1,56846E0

6,19015E-1

3,23187E0

9,48342E0

2,76328E0

1.0

MathSBML

5,20362E0

1,92807E1

4,13020E0

3,60985E-1

1,27062E-1

1,97831E0

5,59514E0

3,83228E-1

1,68812E0

1,45576E0

4,10527E-2

4,39772E0

1,28300E0

2,54049E-4

4,76201E-1

1,64576E1

6,66447E0

1,56846E0

6,19015E-1

3,23187E0

9,48342E0

2,76328E0

1.0

Oscill8 Core

5,20362E0

1,92807E1

4,13024E0

1,27061E-1

5,59509E0

3,83214E-1

1,68812E0

1,45576E0

4,10526E-2

4,39772E0

1,28300E0

2,54054E-4

4,76207E-1

1,64576E1

6,66447E0

1,56844E0

6,19018E-1

3,23185E0

9,48342E0

2,76327E0

1.0

SBToolbox2

5,20360E0

1,92800E1

4,13525E0

3,60841E-1

1,26898E-1

1,97418E0

5,58088E0

3,85085E-1

1,68810E0

1,45603E0

4,10438E-2

4,39643E0

1,28301E0

2,53257E-4

4,76579E-1

1,64580E1

6,66450E0

1,57077E0

6,19159E-1

3,22754E0

9,48050E0

2,76104E0

1.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,20362E0

1,92807E1

4,13025E0

3,60982E-1

1,27061E-1

1,97834E0

5,59507E0

3,83217E-1

1,68812E0

1,45576E0

4,10526E-2

4,39772E0

1,28300E0

2,54054E-4

4,76207E-1

1,64576E1

6,66447E0

1,56845E0

6,19018E-1

3,23185E0

9,48341E0

2,76327E0

1.0

VCell

5,20362E0

1,92807E1

4,13020E0

3,60985E-1

1,27062E-1

1,97831E0

5,59514E0

3,83229E-1

1,68812E0

1,45576E0

4,10527E-2

4,39772E0

1,28300E0

2,54049E-4

4,76201E-1

1,64576E1

6,66447E0

1,56846E0

6,19015E-1

3,23187E0

9,48342E0

2,76328E0

1.0

copasi

5,20362E0

1,92807E1

4,13018E0

3,60986E-1

1,27062E-1

1,97830E0

5,59516E0

3,83232E-1

1,68812E0

1,45576E0

4,10527E-2

4,39772E0

1,28300E0

2,54048E-4

4,76199E-1

1,64576E1

6,66447E0

1,56846E0

6,19014E-1

3,23187E0

9,48342E0

2,76329E0

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20362E0

1,92807E1

4,13020E0

3,60985E-1

1,27062E-1

1,97831E0

5,59514E0

3,83229E-1

1,68812E0

1,45576E0

4,10527E-2

4,39772E0

1,28300E0

2,54049E-4

4,76201E-1

1,64576E1

6,66447E0

1,56846E0

6,19015E-1

3,23187E0

9,48342E0

2,76328E0

1.0

jsim

5,20362E0

1,92807E1

4,13018E0

3,60986E-1

1,27063E-1

1,97833E0

5,59519E0

3,83220E-1

1,68812E0

1,45576E0

4,10527E-2

4,39773E0

1,28300E0

2,54052E-4

4,76199E-1

1,64576E1

6,66447E0

1,56845E0

6,19014E-1

3,23188E0

9,48346E0

2,76329E0

1.0

min

5,20360E0

1,92800E1

4,13018E0

3,60841E-1

1,26898E-1

1,97418E0

5,58088E0

3,83214E-1

1,68810E0

1,45576E0

4,10438E-2

4,39643E0

1,28300E0

2,53257E-4

4,76199E-1

1,64576E1

6,66447E0

1,56844E0

6,19014E-1

3,22754E0

9,48050E0

2,76104E0

1.0

max

5,20362E0

1,92807E1

4,13525E0

3,60986E-1

1,27063E-1

1,97834E0

5,59519E0

3,85085E-1

1,68812E0

1,45603E0

4,10527E-2

4,39773E0

1,28301E0

2,54054E-4

4,76579E-1

1,64580E1

6,66450E0

1,57077E0

6,19159E-1

3,23188E0

9,48346E0

2,76329E0

1.0

mean

5,20362E0

1,92807E1

4,13020E0

3,60985E-1

1,27062E-1

1,97831E0

5,59514E0

3,83229E-1

1,68812E0

1,45576E0

4,10527E-2

4,39772E0

1,28300E0

2,54049E-4

4,76201E-1

1,64576E1

6,66447E0

1,56846E0

6,19015E-1

3,23187E0

9,48342E0

2,76328E0

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

5,20363E0

1,92791E1

4,24275E0

3,52426E-1

1,27030E-1

2,14408E0

5,60525E0

3,12323E-1

1,68953E0

1,45993E0

4,10117E-2

4,44584E0

1,28147E0

2,85533E-4

4,96834E-1

1,64597E1

6,66483E0

1,47360E0

6,27574E-1

3,24606E0

9,69895E0

2,75136E0

1.2

ByoDyn

5,20363E0

1,92792E1

4,24240E0

3,52434E-1

1,27044E-1

2,14451E0

5,60641E0

3,12136E-1

1,68953E0

1,45991E0

4,10124E-2

4,44598E0

1,28147E0

2,85618E-4

4,96815E-1

1,64597E1

6,66483E0

1,47336E0

6,27566E-1

3,24643E0

9,69925E0

2,75152E0

1.2

Jarnac

5,20363E0

1,92792E1

4,24240E0

3,52434E-1

1,27044E-1

2,14451E0

5,60641E0

3,12136E-1

1,68953E0

1,45991E0

4,10124E-2

4,44598E0

1,28147E0

2,85618E-4

4,96815E-1

1,64597E1

6,66483E0

1,47336E0

6,27566E-1

3,24643E0

9,69925E0

2,75152E0

1.2

MathSBML

5,20363E0

1,92792E1

4,24240E0

3,52434E-1

1,27044E-1

2,14451E0

5,60641E0

3,12136E-1

1,68953E0

1,45991E0

4,10124E-2

4,44598E0

1,28147E0

2,85618E-4

4,96815E-1

1,64597E1

6,66483E0

1,47336E0

6,27566E-1

3,24643E0

9,69925E0

2,75152E0

1.2

Oscill8 Core

5,20363E0

1,92792E1

4,24243E0

1,27043E-1

5,60634E0

3,12147E-1

1,68953E0

1,45991E0

4,10123E-2

4,44597E0

1,28147E0

2,85613E-4

4,96816E-1

1,64597E1

6,66483E0

1,47337E0

6,27567E-1

3,24640E0

9,69923E0

2,75151E0

1.2

SBToolbox2

5,20360E0

1,92801E1

4,22513E0

3,53534E-1

1,27322E-1

2,13472E0

5,62838E0

3,16009E-1

1,68950E0

1,45912E0

4,10327E-2

4,44581E0

1,28150E0

2,83695E-4

4,94335E-1

1,64600E1

6,66479E0

1,47925E0

6,26466E-1

3,25213E0

9,70047E0

2,75546E0

1.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,20363E0

1,92792E1

4,24240E0

3,52435E-1

1,27043E-1

2,14447E0

5,60637E0

3,12153E-1

1,68953E0

1,45991E0

4,10123E-2

4,44597E0

1,28147E0

2,85612E-4

4,96812E-1

1,64597E1

6,66483E0

1,47338E0

6,27565E-1

3,24641E0

9,69923E0

2,75152E0

1.2

VCell

5,20363E0

1,92792E1

4,24240E0

3,52434E-1

1,27044E-1

2,14451E0

5,60641E0

3,12136E-1

1,68953E0

1,45991E0

4,10124E-2

4,44598E0

1,28147E0

2,85618E-4

4,96815E-1

1,64597E1

6,66483E0

1,47336E0

6,27566E-1

3,24643E0

9,69925E0

2,75152E0

1.2

copasi

5,20363E0

1,92792E1

4,24240E0

3,52434E-1

1,27044E-1

2,14452E0

5,60644E0

3,12130E-1

1,68953E0

1,45991E0

4,10124E-2

4,44598E0

1,28147E0

2,85621E-4

4,96815E-1

1,64597E1

6,66483E0

1,47335E0

6,27566E-1

3,24644E0

9,69926E0

2,75153E0

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20363E0

1,92792E1

4,24240E0

3,52434E-1

1,27044E-1

2,14451E0

5,60641E0

3,12136E-1

1,68953E0

1,45991E0

4,10124E-2

4,44598E0

1,28147E0

2,85618E-4

4,96815E-1

1,64597E1

6,66483E0

1,47336E0

6,27566E-1

3,24643E0

9,69925E0

2,75152E0

1.2

jsim

5,20363E0

1,92792E1

4,24242E0

3,52433E-1

1,27043E-1

2,14452E0

5,60640E0

3,12121E-1

1,68953E0

1,45991E0

4,10125E-2

4,44599E0

1,28147E0

2,85616E-4

4,96816E-1

1,64597E1

6,66483E0

1,47336E0

6,27567E-1

3,24643E0

9,69929E0

2,75152E0

1.2

min

5,20360E0

1,92792E1

4,22513E0

3,52433E-1

1,27043E-1

2,13472E0

5,60634E0

3,12121E-1

1,68950E0

1,45912E0

4,10123E-2

4,44581E0

1,28147E0

2,83695E-4

4,94335E-1

1,64597E1

6,66479E0

1,47335E0

6,26466E-1

3,24640E0

9,69923E0

2,75151E0

1.2

max

5,20363E0

1,92801E1

4,24243E0

3,53534E-1

1,27322E-1

2,14452E0

5,62838E0

3,16009E-1

1,68953E0

1,45991E0

4,10327E-2

4,44599E0

1,28150E0

2,85621E-4

4,96816E-1

1,64600E1

6,66483E0

1,47925E0

6,27567E-1

3,25213E0

9,70047E0

2,75546E0

1.2

mean

5,20363E0

1,92792E1

4,24240E0

3,52434E-1

1,27044E-1

2,14451E0

5,60641E0

3,12136E-1

1,68953E0

1,45991E0

4,10124E-2

4,44598E0

1,28147E0

2,85618E-4

4,96815E-1

1,64597E1

6,66483E0

1,47336E0

6,27566E-1

3,24643E0

9,69925E0

2,75152E0

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

5,20366E0

1,92654E1

4,44276E0

3,43188E-1

1,22645E-1

2,14062E0

5,24576E0

3,13163E-1

1,69107E0

1,47005E0

4,07442E-2

4,44324E0

1,28089E0

2,82948E-4

5,19010E-1

1,64609E1

6,66560E0

1,47621E0

6,36812E-1

3,13924E0

9,81053E0

2,68733E0

1.4

ByoDyn

5,20366E0

1,92653E1

4,44435E0

3,43094E-1

1,22616E-1

2,14125E0

5,24349E0

3,12895E-1

1,69107E0

1,47013E0

4,07420E-2

4,44321E0

1,28089E0

2,83052E-4

5,19220E-1

1,64609E1

6,66561E0

1,47585E0

6,36906E-1

3,13859E0

9,81034E0

2,68693E0

1.4

Jarnac

5,20366E0

1,92653E1

4,44435E0

3,43094E-1

1,22616E-1

2,14125E0

5,24349E0

3,12895E-1

1,69107E0

1,47013E0

4,07420E-2

4,44321E0

1,28089E0

2,83052E-4

5,19220E-1

1,64609E1

6,66561E0

1,47585E0

6,36906E-1

3,13859E0

9,81034E0

2,68693E0

1.4

MathSBML

5,20366E0

1,92653E1

4,44435E0

3,43094E-1

1,22616E-1

2,14125E0

5,24349E0

3,12895E-1

1,69107E0

1,47013E0

4,07420E-2

4,44321E0

1,28089E0

2,83052E-4

5,19220E-1

1,64609E1

6,66561E0

1,47585E0

6,36906E-1

3,13859E0

9,81034E0

2,68693E0

1.4

Oscill8 Core

5,20366E0

1,92653E1

4,44425E0

1,22618E-1

5,24363E0

3,12911E-1

1,69107E0

1,47013E0

4,07422E-2

4,44321E0

1,28089E0

2,83046E-4

5,19207E-1

1,64609E1

6,66561E0

1,47587E0

6,36900E-1

3,13863E0

9,81035E0

2,68696E0

1.4

SBToolbox2

5,20370E0

1,92651E1

4,44732E0

3,42601E-1

1,22715E-1

2,15485E0

5,25270E0

3,07498E-1

1,69109E0

1,47019E0

4,07444E-2

4,44573E0

1,28080E0

2,85886E-4

5,20317E-1

1,64610E1

6,66560E0

1,46770E0

6,37399E-1

3,14239E0

9,81563E0

2,68831E0

1.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,20366E0

1,92653E1

4,44426E0

3,43099E-1

1,22618E-1

2,14124E0

5,24364E0

3,12901E-1

1,69107E0

1,47013E0

4,07422E-2

4,44322E0

1,28089E0

2,83052E-4

5,19210E-1

1,64609E1

6,66561E0

1,47586E0

6,36901E-1

3,13864E0

9,81036E0

2,68696E0

1.4

VCell

5,20366E0

1,92653E1

4,44435E0

3,43094E-1

1,22616E-1

2,14125E0

5,24349E0

3,12895E-1

1,69107E0

1,47013E0

4,07420E-2

4,44321E0

1,28089E0

2,83052E-4

5,19220E-1

1,64609E1

6,66561E0

1,47585E0

6,36906E-1

3,13859E0

9,81034E0

2,68693E0

1.4

copasi

5,20366E0

1,92653E1

4,44440E0

3,43091E-1

1,22615E-1

2,14127E0

5,24341E0

3,12890E-1

1,69107E0

1,47014E0

4,07420E-2

4,44321E0

1,28089E0

2,83054E-4

5,19227E-1

1,64609E1

6,66561E0

1,47585E0

6,36909E-1

3,13857E0

9,81032E0

2,68692E0

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20366E0

1,92653E1

4,44435E0

3,43094E-1

1,22616E-1

2,14125E0

5,24349E0

3,12895E-1

1,69107E0

1,47013E0

4,07420E-2

4,44321E0

1,28089E0

2,83052E-4

5,19220E-1

1,64609E1

6,66561E0

1,47585E0

6,36906E-1

3,13859E0

9,81034E0

2,68693E0

1.4

jsim

5,20366E0

1,92653E1

4,44436E0

3,43095E-1

1,22616E-1

2,14124E0

5,24346E0

3,12891E-1

1,69107E0

1,47013E0

4,07421E-2

4,44321E0

1,28089E0

2,83041E-4

5,19219E-1

1,64609E1

6,66561E0

1,47587E0

6,36905E-1

3,13858E0

9,81036E0

2,68693E0

1.4

min

5,20366E0

1,92651E1

4,44425E0

3,42601E-1

1,22615E-1

2,14124E0

5,24341E0

3,07498E-1

1,69107E0

1,47013E0

4,07420E-2

4,44321E0

1,28080E0

2,83041E-4

5,19207E-1

1,64609E1

6,66560E0

1,46770E0

6,36900E-1

3,13857E0

9,81032E0

2,68692E0

1.4

max

5,20370E0

1,92653E1

4,44732E0

3,43099E-1

1,22715E-1

2,15485E0

5,25270E0

3,12911E-1

1,69109E0

1,47019E0

4,07444E-2

4,44573E0

1,28089E0

2,85886E-4

5,20317E-1

1,64610E1

6,66561E0

1,47587E0

6,37399E-1

3,14239E0

9,81563E0

2,68831E0

1.4

mean

5,20366E0

1,92653E1

4,44435E0

3,43094E-1

1,22616E-1

2,14125E0

5,24349E0

3,12895E-1

1,69107E0

1,47013E0

4,07420E-2

4,44321E0

1,28089E0

2,83052E-4

5,19220E-1

1,64609E1

6,66561E0

1,47585E0

6,36906E-1

3,13859E0

9,81034E0

2,68693E0

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

1.6

BioUML

5,20368E0

1,92811E1

4,21508E0

3,58575E-1

1,25953E-1

1,97695E0

5,50294E0

3,83640E-1

1,69253E0

1,45880E0

4,09989E-2

4,44530E0

1,28027E0

2,53462E-4

4,85532E-1

1,64622E1

6,66503E0

1,56941E0

6,21425E-1

3,20442E0

9,97129E0

2,73434E0

1.6

ByoDyn

5,20368E0

1,92811E1

4,21427E0

3,58641E-1

1,25958E-1

1,97584E0

5,50321E0

3,84148E-1

1,69253E0

1,45876E0

4,09995E-2

4,44515E0

1,28028E0

2,53272E-4

4,85395E-1

1,64622E1

6,66503E0

1,57001E0

6,21359E-1

3,20445E0

9,97103E0

2,73444E0

1.6

Jarnac

5,20368E0

1,92811E1

4,21427E0

3,58641E-1

1,25958E-1

1,97584E0

5,50321E0

3,84148E-1

1,69253E0

1,45876E0

4,09995E-2

4,44515E0

1,28028E0

2,53272E-4

4,85395E-1

1,64622E1

6,66503E0

1,57001E0

6,21359E-1

3,20445E0

9,97103E0

2,73444E0

1.6

MathSBML

5,20368E0

1,92811E1

4,21427E0

3,58641E-1

1,25958E-1

1,97584E0

5,50321E0

3,84148E-1

1,69253E0

1,45876E0

4,09995E-2

4,44515E0

1,28028E0

2,53271E-4

4,85394E-1

1,64622E1

6,66503E0

1,57001E0

6,21359E-1

3,20445E0

9,97103E0

2,73444E0

1.6

Oscill8 Core

5,20368E0

1,92811E1

4,21431E0

1,25957E-1

5,50319E0

3,84120E-1

1,69253E0

1,45877E0

4,09995E-2

4,44516E0

1,28028E0

2,53282E-4

4,85402E-1

1,64622E1

6,66503E0

1,56998E0

6,21363E-1

3,20444E0

9,97104E0

2,73443E0

1.6

SBToolbox2

5,20370E0

1,92798E1

4,23371E0

3,57633E-1

1,25558E-1

1,97904E0

5,47026E0

3,82609E-1

1,69250E0

1,45971E0

4,09743E-2

4,44402E0

1,28030E0

2,53658E-4

4,87679E-1

1,64620E1

6,66510E0

1,56831E0

6,22367E-1

3,19492E0

9,96754E0

2,72849E0

1.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,20368E0

1,92811E1

4,21435E0

3,58636E-1

1,25957E-1

1,97590E0

5,50314E0

3,84119E-1

1,69253E0

1,45877E0

4,09995E-2

4,44516E0

1,28028E0

2,53282E-4

4,85406E-1

1,64622E1

6,66503E0

1,56998E0

6,21364E-1

3,20443E0

9,97103E0

2,73442E0

1.6

VCell

5,20368E0

1,92811E1

4,21427E0

3,58641E-1

1,25958E-1

1,97584E0

5,50321E0

3,84148E-1

1,69253E0

1,45876E0

4,09995E-2

4,44515E0

1,28028E0

2,53272E-4

4,85395E-1

1,64622E1

6,66503E0

1,57001E0

6,21359E-1

3,20445E0

9,97103E0

2,73444E0

1.6

copasi

5,20368E0

1,92811E1

4,21424E0

3,58643E-1

1,25958E-1

1,97581E0

5,50323E0

3,84163E-1

1,69253E0

1,45876E0

4,09996E-2

4,44515E0

1,28028E0

2,53266E-4

4,85390E-1

1,64622E1

6,66503E0

1,57003E0

6,21357E-1

3,20445E0

9,97102E0

2,73445E0

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20368E0

1,92811E1

4,21427E0

3,58641E-1

1,25958E-1

1,97584E0

5,50321E0

3,84148E-1

1,69253E0

1,45876E0

4,09995E-2

4,44515E0

1,28028E0

2,53272E-4

4,85395E-1

1,64622E1

6,66503E0

1,57001E0

6,21359E-1

3,20445E0

9,97103E0

2,73444E0

1.6

jsim

5,20368E0

1,92811E1

4,21422E0

3,58643E-1

1,25958E-1

1,97583E0

5,50328E0

3,84151E-1

1,69253E0

1,45876E0

4,09996E-2

4,44516E0

1,28028E0

2,53271E-4

4,85389E-1

1,64622E1

6,66503E0

1,57002E0

6,21357E-1

3,20447E0

9,97107E0

2,73445E0

1.6

min

5,20368E0

1,92798E1

4,21422E0

3,57633E-1

1,25558E-1

1,97581E0

5,47026E0

3,82609E-1

1,69250E0

1,45876E0

4,09743E-2

4,44402E0

1,28028E0

2,53266E-4

4,85389E-1

1,64620E1

6,66503E0

1,56831E0

6,21357E-1

3,19492E0

9,96754E0

2,72849E0

1.6

max

5,20370E0

1,92811E1

4,23371E0

3,58643E-1

1,25958E-1

1,97904E0

5,50328E0

3,84163E-1

1,69253E0

1,45971E0

4,09996E-2

4,44516E0

1,28030E0

2,53658E-4

4,87679E-1

1,64622E1

6,66510E0

1,57003E0

6,22367E-1

3,20447E0

9,97107E0

2,73445E0

1.6

mean

5,20368E0

1,92811E1

4,21427E0

3,58641E-1

1,25958E-1

1,97584E0

5,50321E0

3,84148E-1

1,69253E0

1,45876E0

4,09995E-2

4,44515E0

1,28028E0

2,53272E-4

4,85395E-1

1,64622E1

6,66503E0

1,57001E0

6,21359E-1

3,20445E0

9,97103E0

2,73444E0

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

1.8

BioUML

5,20370E0

1,92890E1

4,17158E0

3,58327E-1

1,28396E-1

2,08443E0

5,71506E0

3,36828E-1

1,69411E0

1,45618E0

4,11245E-2

4,48296E0

1,27896E0

2,74203E-4

4,85750E-1

1,64642E1

6,66487E0

1,50874E0

6,21673E-1

3,27352E0

1,01937E1

2,76431E0

1.8

ByoDyn

5,20370E0

1,92891E1

4,17082E0

3,58366E-1

1,28414E-1

2,08442E0

5,71652E0

3,36818E-1

1,69411E0

1,45615E0

4,11256E-2

4,48304E0

1,27896E0

2,74199E-4

4,85660E-1

1,64642E1

6,66486E0

1,50877E0

6,21634E-1

3,27394E0

1,01939E1

2,76454E0

1.8

Jarnac

5,20370E0

1,92891E1

4,17082E0

3,58366E-1

1,28414E-1

2,08442E0

5,71652E0

3,36818E-1

1,69411E0

1,45615E0

4,11256E-2

4,48304E0

1,27896E0

2,74199E-4

4,85660E-1

1,64642E1

6,66486E0

1,50877E0

6,21634E-1

3,27394E0

1,01939E1

2,76454E0

1.8

MathSBML

5,20370E0

1,92891E1

4,17082E0

3,58366E-1

1,28414E-1

2,08442E0

5,71652E0

3,36818E-1

1,69411E0

1,45615E0

4,11256E-2

4,48304E0

1,27896E0

2,74199E-4

4,85660E-1

1,64642E1

6,66486E0

1,50877E0

6,21634E-1

3,27394E0

1,01939E1

2,76454E0

1.8

Oscill8 Core

5,20370E0

1,92891E1

4,17090E0

1,28412E-1

5,71638E0

3,36818E-1

1,69411E0

1,45615E0

4,11255E-2

4,48303E0

1,27896E0

2,74201E-4

4,85670E-1

1,64642E1

6,66487E0

1,50876E0

6,21638E-1

3,27390E0

1,01939E1

2,76452E0

1.8

SBToolbox2

5,20370E0

1,92900E1

4,15491E0

3,59567E-1

1,28545E-1

2,06663E0

5,72649E0

3,44256E-1

1,69408E0

1,45545E0

4,11389E-2

4,48098E0

1,27902E0

2,70783E-4

4,82986E-1

1,64640E1

6,66480E0

1,51907E0

6,20433E-1

3,27556E0

1,01912E1

2,76694E0

1.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,20370E0

1,92891E1

4,17087E0

3,58364E-1

1,28412E-1

2,08439E0

5,71640E0

3,36831E-1

1,69411E0

1,45615E0

4,11255E-2

4,48303E0

1,27896E0

2,74195E-4

4,85665E-1

1,64642E1

6,66486E0

1,50878E0

6,21636E-1

3,27390E0

1,01939E1

2,76453E0

1.8

VCell

5,20370E0

1,92891E1

4,17082E0

3,58366E-1

1,28414E-1

2,08442E0

5,71652E0

3,36818E-1

1,69411E0

1,45615E0

4,11256E-2

4,48304E0

1,27896E0

2,74199E-4

4,85660E-1

1,64642E1

6,66486E0

1,50877E0

6,21634E-1

3,27394E0

1,01939E1

2,76454E0

1.8

copasi

5,20370E0

1,92891E1

4,17080E0

3,58367E-1

1,28414E-1

2,08442E0

5,71657E0

3,36815E-1

1,69411E0

1,45615E0

4,11256E-2

4,48304E0

1,27896E0

2,74201E-4

4,85658E-1

1,64642E1

6,66486E0

1,50876E0

6,21633E-1

3,27396E0

1,01939E1

2,76455E0

1.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20370E0

1,92891E1

4,17082E0

3,58366E-1

1,28414E-1

2,08442E0

5,71652E0

3,36818E-1

1,69411E0

1,45615E0

4,11256E-2

4,48304E0

1,27896E0

2,74199E-4

4,85660E-1

1,64642E1

6,66486E0

1,50877E0

6,21634E-1

3,27394E0

1,01939E1

2,76454E0

1.8

jsim

5,20370E0

1,92891E1

4,17082E0

3,58365E-1

1,28414E-1

2,08444E0

5,71653E0

3,36807E-1

1,69411E0

1,45615E0

4,11256E-2

4,48305E0

1,27896E0

2,74204E-4

4,85662E-1

1,64642E1

6,66486E0

1,50875E0

6,21635E-1

3,27395E0

1,01940E1

2,76454E0

1.8

min

5,20370E0

1,92891E1

4,15491E0

3,58364E-1

1,28412E-1

2,06663E0

5,71638E0

3,36807E-1

1,69408E0

1,45545E0

4,11255E-2

4,48098E0

1,27896E0

2,70783E-4

4,82986E-1

1,64640E1

6,66480E0

1,50875E0

6,20433E-1

3,27390E0

1,01912E1

2,76452E0

1.8

max

5,20370E0

1,92900E1

4,17090E0

3,59567E-1

1,28545E-1

2,08444E0

5,72649E0

3,44256E-1

1,69411E0

1,45615E0

4,11389E-2

4,48305E0

1,27902E0

2,74204E-4

4,85670E-1

1,64642E1

6,66487E0

1,51907E0

6,21638E-1

3,27556E0

1,01940E1

2,76694E0

1.8

mean

5,20370E0

1,92891E1

4,17082E0

3,58366E-1

1,28414E-1

2,08442E0

5,71652E0

3,36818E-1

1,69411E0

1,45615E0

4,11256E-2

4,48304E0

1,27896E0

2,74199E-4

4,85660E-1

1,64642E1

6,66486E0

1,50877E0

6,21634E-1

3,27394E0

1,01939E1

2,76454E0

1.8

relative error(%)

0,00

2.0

BioUML

5,20373E0

1,92734E1

4,43230E0

3,42952E-1

1,23822E-1

2,19130E0

5,34534E0

2,93454E-1

1,69584E0

1,46900E0

4,08096E-2

4,48650E0

1,27830E0

2,94192E-4

5,20760E-1

1,64658E1

6,66571E0

1,44525E0

6,37048E-1

3,17297E0

1,03232E1

2,69884E0

2.0

ByoDyn

5,20373E0

1,92733E1

4,43344E0

3,42873E-1

1,23806E-1

2,19213E0

5,34411E0

2,93133E-1

1,69584E0

1,46906E0

4,08081E-2

4,48655E0

1,27830E0

2,94360E-4

5,20936E-1

1,64658E1

6,66571E0

1,44474E0

6,37127E-1

3,17267E0

1,03232E1

2,69863E0

2.0

Jarnac

5,20373E0

1,92733E1

4,43344E0

3,42873E-1

1,23806E-1

2,19213E0

5,34411E0

2,93133E-1

1,69584E0

1,46906E0

4,08081E-2

4,48655E0

1,27830E0

2,94360E-4

5,20936E-1

1,64658E1

6,66571E0

1,44474E0

6,37127E-1

3,17267E0

1,03232E1

2,69863E0

2.0

MathSBML

5,20373E0

1,92733E1

4,43344E0

3,42873E-1

1,23806E-1

2,19213E0

5,34411E0

2,93133E-1

1,69584E0

1,46906E0

4,08081E-2

4,48655E0

1,27830E0

2,94360E-4

5,20936E-1

1,64658E1

6,66571E0

1,44474E0

6,37127E-1

3,17267E0

1,03232E1

2,69863E0

2.0

Oscill8 Core

5,20373E0

1,92734E1

4,43333E0

1,23807E-1

5,34423E0

2,93168E-1

1,69584E0

1,46905E0

4,08082E-2

4,48655E0

1,27830E0

2,94342E-4

5,20918E-1

1,64658E1

6,66571E0

1,44479E0

6,37119E-1

3,17269E0

1,03232E1

2,69865E0

2.0

SBToolbox2

5,20370E0

1,92752E1

4,41350E0

3,43718E-1

1,24334E-1

2,19754E0

5,38756E0

2,91136E-1

1,69588E0

1,46796E0

4,08394E-2

4,48978E0

1,27820E0

2,95802E-4

5,19028E-1

1,64660E1

6,66560E0

1,44130E0

6,36282E-1

3,18604E0

1,03322E1

2,70574E0

2.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,20373E0

1,92734E1

4,43329E0

3,42882E-1

1,23808E-1

2,19205E0

5,34430E0

2,93163E-1

1,69584E0

1,46905E0

4,08082E-2

4,48655E0

1,27830E0

2,94345E-4

5,20915E-1

1,64658E1

6,66571E0

1,44479E0

6,37118E-1

3,17272E0

1,03232E1

2,69866E0

2.0

VCell

5,20373E0

1,92733E1

4,43344E0

3,42873E-1

1,23806E-1

2,19213E0

5,34411E0

2,93133E-1

1,69584E0

1,46906E0

4,08081E-2

4,48655E0

1,27830E0

2,94360E-4

5,20936E-1

1,64658E1

6,66571E0

1,44474E0

6,37127E-1

3,17267E0

1,03232E1

2,69863E0

2.0

copasi

5,20373E0

1,92733E1

4,43350E0

3,42869E-1

1,23805E-1

2,19216E0

5,34404E0

2,93121E-1

1,69584E0

1,46906E0

4,08080E-2

4,48655E0

1,27830E0

2,94367E-4

5,20944E-1

1,64658E1

6,66571E0

1,44472E0

6,37131E-1

3,17265E0

1,03232E1

2,69861E0

2.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20373E0

1,92733E1

4,43344E0

3,42873E-1

1,23806E-1

2,19213E0

5,34411E0

2,93133E-1

1,69584E0

1,46906E0

4,08081E-2

4,48655E0

1,27830E0

2,94360E-4

5,20936E-1

1,64658E1

6,66571E0

1,44474E0

6,37127E-1

3,17267E0

1,03232E1

2,69863E0

2.0

jsim

5,20373E0

1,92733E1

4,43348E0

3,42871E-1

1,23805E-1

2,19215E0

5,34405E0

2,93126E-1

1,69584E0

1,46906E0

4,08080E-2

4,48655E0

1,27830E0

2,94363E-4

5,20941E-1

1,64658E1

6,66571E0

1,44473E0

6,37129E-1

3,17265E0

1,03233E1

2,69862E0

2.0

min

5,20370E0

1,92733E1

4,41350E0

3,42869E-1

1,23805E-1

2,19205E0

5,34404E0

2,91136E-1

1,69584E0

1,46796E0

4,08080E-2

4,48655E0

1,27820E0

2,94342E-4

5,19028E-1

1,64658E1

6,66560E0

1,44130E0

6,36282E-1

3,17265E0

1,03232E1

2,69861E0

2.0

max

5,20373E0

1,92752E1

4,43350E0

3,43718E-1

1,24334E-1

2,19754E0

5,38756E0

2,93168E-1

1,69588E0

1,46906E0

4,08394E-2

4,48978E0

1,27830E0

2,95802E-4

5,20944E-1

1,64660E1

6,66571E0

1,44479E0

6,37131E-1

3,18604E0

1,03322E1

2,70574E0

2.0

mean

5,20373E0

1,92733E1

4,43344E0

3,42873E-1

1,23806E-1

2,19213E0

5,34411E0

2,93133E-1

1,69584E0

1,46906E0

4,08081E-2

4,48655E0

1,27830E0

2,94360E-4

5,20936E-1

1,64658E1

6,66571E0

1,44474E0

6,37127E-1

3,17267E0

1,03232E1

2,69863E0

2.0

relative error(%)

0,00

2.2

BioUML

5,20376E0

1,92793E1

4,31541E0

3,53270E-1

1,24239E-1

2,00914E0

5,36473E0

3,68861E-1

1,69744E0

1,46399E0

4,08908E-2

4,46653E0

1,27820E0

2,58503E-4

4,98091E-1

1,64668E1

6,66554E0

1,55200E0

6,26730E-1

3,16546E0

1,04332E1

2,70631E0

2.2

ByoDyn

5,20376E0

1,92793E1

4,31546E0

3,53278E-1

1,24233E-1

2,00874E0

5,36418E0

3,69032E-1

1,69744E0

1,46400E0

4,08906E-2

4,46644E0

1,27820E0

2,58427E-4

4,98078E-1

1,64668E1

6,66554E0

1,55223E0

6,26722E-1

3,16527E0

1,04330E1

2,70622E0

2.2

Jarnac

5,20376E0

1,92793E1

4,31546E0

3,53278E-1

1,24233E-1

2,00874E0

5,36418E0

3,69032E-1

1,69744E0

1,46400E0

4,08906E-2

4,46644E0

1,27820E0

2,58427E-4

4,98078E-1

1,64668E1

6,66554E0

1,55223E0

6,26722E-1

3,16527E0

1,04330E1

2,70622E0

2.2

MathSBML

5,20376E0

1,92793E1

4,31546E0

3,53278E-1

1,24233E-1

2,00874E0

5,36418E0

3,69032E-1

1,69744E0

1,46400E0

4,08906E-2

4,46644E0

1,27820E0

2,58427E-4

4,98078E-1

1,64668E1

6,66554E0

1,55223E0

6,26722E-1

3,16527E0

1,04330E1

2,70622E0

2.2

Oscill8 Core

5,20376E0

1,92793E1

4,31546E0

1,24234E-1

5,36427E0

3,69004E-1

1,69744E0

1,46400E0

4,08906E-2

4,46646E0

1,27820E0

2,58440E-4

4,98081E-1

1,64668E1

6,66554E0

1,55219E0

6,26724E-1

3,16530E0

1,04330E1

2,70623E0

2.2

SBToolbox2

5,20380E0

1,92768E1

4,34897E0

3,51195E-1

1,23704E-1

2,02781E0

5,32279E0

3,60466E-1

1,69748E0

1,46565E0

4,08535E-2

4,46727E0

1,27820E0

2,61645E-4

5,02683E-1

1,64670E1

6,66562E0

1,54171E0

6,28805E-1

3,15415E0

1,04325E1

2,69832E0

2.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,20376E0

1,92793E1

4,31552E0

3,53273E-1

1,24233E-1

2,00884E0

5,36419E0

3,68991E-1

1,69744E0

1,46400E0

4,08905E-2

4,46646E0

1,27820E0

2,58445E-4

4,98089E-1

1,64668E1

6,66554E0

1,55217E0

6,26727E-1

3,16528E0

1,04330E1

2,70622E0

2.2

VCell

5,20376E0

1,92793E1

4,31546E0

3,53278E-1

1,24233E-1

2,00874E0

5,36418E0

3,69032E-1

1,69744E0

1,46400E0

4,08906E-2

4,46644E0

1,27820E0

2,58427E-4

4,98078E-1

1,64668E1

6,66554E0

1,55223E0

6,26722E-1

3,16527E0

1,04330E1

2,70622E0

2.2

copasi

5,20376E0

1,92793E1

4,31546E0

3,53279E-1

1,24233E-1

2,00870E0

5,36416E0

3,69048E-1

1,69744E0

1,46400E0

4,08905E-2

4,46644E0

1,27820E0

2,58420E-4

4,98075E-1

1,64668E1

6,66554E0

1,55225E0

6,26721E-1

3,16526E0

1,04330E1

2,70622E0

2.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20376E0

1,92793E1

4,31546E0

3,53278E-1

1,24233E-1

2,00874E0

5,36418E0

3,69032E-1

1,69744E0

1,46400E0

4,08906E-2

4,46644E0

1,27820E0

2,58427E-4

4,98078E-1

1,64668E1

6,66554E0

1,55223E0

6,26722E-1

3,16527E0

1,04330E1

2,70622E0

2.2

jsim

5,20376E0

1,92793E1

4,31541E0

3,53281E-1

1,24234E-1

2,00870E0

5,36424E0

3,69040E-1

1,69744E0

1,46399E0

4,08907E-2

4,46645E0

1,27820E0

2,58417E-4

4,98069E-1

1,64668E1

6,66554E0

1,55226E0

6,26719E-1

3,16529E0

1,04330E1

2,70623E0

2.2

min

5,20376E0

1,92768E1

4,31541E0

3,51195E-1

1,23704E-1

2,00870E0

5,32279E0

3,60466E-1

1,69744E0

1,46399E0

4,08535E-2

4,46644E0

1,27820E0

2,58417E-4

4,98069E-1

1,64668E1

6,66554E0

1,54171E0

6,26719E-1

3,15415E0

1,04325E1

2,69832E0

2.2

max

5,20380E0

1,92793E1

4,34897E0

3,53281E-1

1,24234E-1

2,02781E0

5,36427E0

3,69048E-1

1,69748E0

1,46565E0

4,08907E-2

4,46727E0

1,27820E0

2,61645E-4

5,02683E-1

1,64670E1

6,66562E0

1,55226E0

6,28805E-1

3,16530E0

1,04330E1

2,70623E0

2.2

mean

5,20376E0

1,92793E1

4,31546E0

3,53278E-1

1,24233E-1

2,00874E0

5,36418E0

3,69032E-1

1,69744E0

1,46400E0

4,08906E-2

4,46644E0

1,27820E0

2,58427E-4

4,98078E-1

1,64668E1

6,66554E0

1,55223E0

6,26722E-1

3,16527E0

1,04330E1

2,70622E0

2.2

relative error(%)

0,00

2.4

BioUML

5,20379E0

1,92951E1

4,13702E0

3,61583E-1

1,28481E-1

2,02296E0

5,71767E0

3,63264E-1

1,69903E0

1,45515E0

4,11514E-2

4,49151E0

1,27726E0

2,62679E-4

4,78937E-1

1,64686E1

6,66497E0

1,54378E0

6,18417E-1

3,27014E0

1,06394E1

2,76637E0

2.4

ByoDyn

5,20379E0

1,92952E1

4,13584E0

3,61652E-1

1,28501E-1

2,02246E0

5,71933E0

3,63479E-1

1,69903E0

1,45509E0

4,11529E-2

4,49151E0

1,27726E0

2,62592E-4

4,78782E-1

1,64686E1

6,66497E0

1,54406E0

6,18348E-1

3,27059E0

1,06395E1

2,76668E0

2.4

Jarnac

5,20379E0

1,92952E1

4,13584E0

3,61652E-1

1,28501E-1

2,02246E0

5,71933E0

3,63479E-1

1,69903E0

1,45509E0

4,11529E-2

4,49151E0

1,27726E0

2,62592E-4

4,78782E-1

1,64686E1

6,66497E0

1,54406E0

6,18348E-1

3,27059E0

1,06395E1

2,76668E0

2.4

MathSBML

5,20379E0

1,92952E1

4,13584E0

3,61652E-1

1,28501E-1

2,02246E0

5,71933E0

3,63479E-1

1,69903E0

1,45509E0

4,11529E-2

4,49151E0

1,27726E0

2,62593E-4

4,78782E-1

1,64686E1

6,66497E0

1,54406E0

6,18348E-1

3,27059E0

1,06395E1

2,76668E0

2.4

Oscill8 Core

5,20379E0

1,92952E1

4,13595E0

1,28499E-1

5,71917E0

3,63462E-1

1,69903E0

1,45510E0

4,11528E-2

4,49151E0

1,27726E0

2,62602E-4

4,78797E-1

1,64686E1

6,66497E0

1,54404E0

6,18354E-1

3,27055E0

1,06395E1

2,76665E0

2.4

SBToolbox2

5,20380E0

1,92948E1

4,13580E0

3,62072E-1

1,28269E-1

2,00444E0

5,69856E0

3,71411E-1

1,69908E0

1,45512E0

4,11436E-2

4,48767E0

1,27732E0

2,59222E-4

4,77948E-1

1,64688E1

6,66500E0

1,55416E0

6,17928E-1

3,26341E0

1,06324E1

2,76409E0

2.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,20379E0

1,92952E1

4,13595E0

3,61647E-1

1,28499E-1

2,02247E0

5,71914E0

3,63476E-1

1,69903E0

1,45510E0

4,11528E-2

4,49150E0

1,27726E0

2,62595E-4

4,78794E-1

1,64686E1

6,66497E0

1,54406E0

6,18353E-1

3,27054E0

1,06395E1

2,76664E0

2.4

VCell

5,20379E0

1,92952E1

4,13584E0

3,61652E-1

1,28501E-1

2,02246E0

5,71933E0

3,63479E-1

1,69903E0

1,45509E0

4,11529E-2

4,49151E0

1,27726E0

2,62592E-4

4,78782E-1

1,64686E1

6,66497E0

1,54406E0

6,18348E-1

3,27059E0

1,06395E1

2,76668E0

2.4

copasi

5,20379E0

1,92952E1

4,13579E0

3,61655E-1

1,28502E-1

2,02244E0

5,71940E0

3,63485E-1

1,69903E0

1,45509E0

4,11530E-2

4,49151E0

1,27726E0

2,62590E-4

4,78776E-1

1,64686E1

6,66497E0

1,54407E0

6,18345E-1

3,27061E0

1,06395E1

2,76669E0

2.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20379E0

1,92952E1

4,13584E0

3,61652E-1

1,28501E-1

2,02246E0

5,71933E0

3,63479E-1

1,69903E0

1,45509E0

4,11529E-2

4,49151E0

1,27726E0

2,62592E-4

4,78782E-1

1,64686E1

6,66497E0

1,54406E0

6,18348E-1

3,27059E0

1,06395E1

2,76668E0

2.4

jsim

5,20379E0

1,92952E1

4,13582E0

3,61653E-1

1,28502E-1

2,02247E0

5,71938E0

3,63466E-1

1,69903E0

1,45509E0

4,11530E-2

4,49152E0

1,27726E0

2,62592E-4

4,78780E-1

1,64686E1

6,66497E0

1,54406E0

6,18347E-1

3,27060E0

1,06395E1

2,76668E0

2.4

min

5,20379E0

1,92948E1

4,13579E0

3,61647E-1

1,28269E-1

2,00444E0

5,69856E0

3,63462E-1

1,69903E0

1,45509E0

4,11436E-2

4,48767E0

1,27726E0

2,59222E-4

4,77948E-1

1,64686E1

6,66497E0

1,54404E0

6,17928E-1

3,26341E0

1,06324E1

2,76409E0

2.4

max

5,20380E0

1,92952E1

4,13595E0

3,62072E-1

1,28502E-1

2,02247E0

5,71940E0

3,71411E-1

1,69908E0

1,45512E0

4,11530E-2

4,49152E0

1,27732E0

2,62602E-4

4,78797E-1

1,64688E1

6,66500E0

1,55416E0

6,18354E-1

3,27061E0

1,06395E1

2,76669E0

2.4

mean

5,20379E0

1,92952E1

4,13584E0

3,61652E-1

1,28501E-1

2,02246E0

5,71933E0

3,63479E-1

1,69903E0

1,45509E0

4,11529E-2

4,49151E0

1,27726E0

2,62592E-4

4,78782E-1

1,64686E1

6,66497E0

1,54406E0

6,18348E-1

3,27059E0

1,06395E1

2,76668E0

2.4

relative error(%)

0,00

2.6

BioUML

5,20382E0

1,92847E1

4,35259E0

3,46901E-1

1,25703E-1

2,19180E0

5,49959E0

2,93473E-1

1,70078E0

1,46529E0

4,09315E-2

4,50883E0

1,27648E0

2,95178E-4

5,11835E-1

1,64705E1

6,66561E0

1,44472E0

6,33099E-1

3,21868E0

1,07982E1

2,72379E0

2.6

ByoDyn

5,20382E0

1,92847E1

4,35292E0

3,46870E-1

1,25702E-1

2,19235E0

5,49958E0

2,93260E-1

1,70078E0

1,46530E0

4,09311E-2

4,50891E0

1,27648E0

2,95297E-4

5,11903E-1

1,64705E1

6,66561E0

1,44438E0

6,33130E-1

3,21873E0

1,07984E1

2,72377E0

2.6

Jarnac

5,20382E0

1,92847E1

4,35292E0

3,46870E-1

1,25702E-1

2,19235E0

5,49958E0

2,93260E-1

1,70078E0

1,46530E0

4,09311E-2

4,50891E0

1,27648E0

2,95297E-4

5,11903E-1

1,64705E1

6,66561E0

1,44438E0

6,33130E-1

3,21873E0

1,07984E1

2,72377E0

2.6

MathSBML

5,20382E0

1,92847E1

4,35293E0

3,46869E-1

1,25702E-1

2,19236E0

5,49958E0

2,93260E-1

1,70078E0

1,46530E0

4,09311E-2

4,50891E0

1,27648E0

2,95297E-4

5,11903E-1

1,64705E1

6,66561E0

1,44438E0

6,33131E-1

3,21873E0

1,07984E1

2,72377E0

2.6

Oscill8 Core

5,20382E0

1,92847E1

4,35288E0

1,25702E-1

5,49955E0

2,93296E-1

1,70078E0

1,46530E0

4,09311E-2

4,50889E0

1,27648E0

2,95277E-4

5,11894E-1

1,64705E1

6,66561E0

1,44444E0

6,33126E-1

3,21871E0

1,07983E1

2,72377E0

2.6

SBToolbox2

5,20380E0

1,92873E1

4,31137E0

3,49279E-1

1,26490E-1

2,17874E0

5,56317E0

2,98533E-1

1,70077E0

1,46322E0

4,09849E-2

4,51043E0

1,27643E0

2,92670E-4

5,06434E-1

1,64707E1

6,66547E0

1,45271E0

6,30721E-1

3,23636E0

1,08054E1

2,73449E0

2.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,20382E0

1,92847E1

4,35281E0

3,46878E-1

1,25704E-1

2,19224E0

5,49968E0

2,93304E-1

1,70078E0

1,46530E0

4,09312E-2

4,50890E0

1,27648E0

2,95273E-4

5,11884E-1

1,64705E1

6,66561E0

1,44445E0

6,33122E-1

3,21874E0

1,07983E1

2,72379E0

2.6

VCell

5,20382E0

1,92847E1

4,35292E0

3,46870E-1

1,25702E-1

2,19235E0

5,49958E0

2,93260E-1

1,70078E0

1,46530E0

4,09311E-2

4,50891E0

1,27648E0

2,95297E-4

5,11903E-1

1,64705E1

6,66561E0

1,44438E0

6,33130E-1

3,21873E0

1,07984E1

2,72377E0

2.6

copasi

5,20382E0

1,92847E1

4,35297E0

3,46866E-1

1,25702E-1

2,19240E0

5,49955E0

2,93243E-1

1,70078E0

1,46531E0

4,09310E-2

4,50891E0

1,27648E0

2,95307E-4

5,11911E-1

1,64705E1

6,66561E0

1,44436E0

6,33134E-1

3,21872E0

1,07984E1

2,72377E0

2.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20382E0

1,92847E1

4,35292E0

3,46870E-1

1,25702E-1

2,19235E0

5,49958E0

2,93260E-1

1,70078E0

1,46530E0

4,09311E-2

4,50891E0

1,27648E0

2,95297E-4

5,11903E-1

1,64705E1

6,66561E0

1,44438E0

6,33130E-1

3,21873E0

1,07984E1

2,72377E0

2.6

jsim

5,20382E0

1,92847E1

4,35296E0

3,46867E-1

1,25702E-1

2,19238E0

5,49954E0

2,93247E-1

1,70078E0

1,46531E0

4,09311E-2

4,50891E0

1,27648E0

2,95303E-4

5,11908E-1

1,64705E1

6,66561E0

1,44437E0

6,33133E-1

3,21872E0

1,07984E1

2,72377E0

2.6

min

5,20380E0

1,92847E1

4,31137E0

3,46866E-1

1,25702E-1

2,17874E0

5,49954E0

2,93243E-1

1,70077E0

1,46322E0

4,09310E-2

4,50889E0

1,27643E0

2,92670E-4

5,06434E-1

1,64705E1

6,66547E0

1,44436E0

6,30721E-1

3,21871E0

1,07983E1

2,72377E0

2.6

max

5,20382E0

1,92873E1

4,35297E0

3,49279E-1

1,26490E-1

2,19240E0

5,56317E0

2,98533E-1

1,70078E0

1,46531E0

4,09849E-2

4,51043E0

1,27648E0

2,95307E-4

5,11911E-1

1,64707E1

6,66561E0

1,45271E0

6,33134E-1

3,23636E0

1,08054E1

2,73449E0

2.6

mean

5,20382E0

1,92847E1

4,35292E0

3,46870E-1

1,25702E-1

2,19235E0

5,49958E0

2,93260E-1

1,70078E0

1,46530E0

4,09311E-2

4,50891E0

1,27648E0

2,95297E-4

5,11903E-1

1,64705E1

6,66561E0

1,44438E0

6,33130E-1

3,21873E0

1,07984E1

2,72377E0

2.6

relative error(%)

0,00

2.8

BioUML

5,20385E0

1,92781E1

4,41374E0

3,46800E-1

1,22837E-1

2,07672E0

5,25646E0

3,39378E-1

1,70244E0

1,46952E0

4,07899E-2

4,48192E0

1,27664E0

2,70463E-4

5,12318E-1

1,64715E1

6,66599E0

1,51391E0

6,33200E-1

3,13771E0

1,08743E1

2,68553E0

2.8

ByoDyn

5,20385E0

1,92781E1

4,41415E0

3,46782E-1

1,22827E-1

2,07665E0

5,25563E0

3,39403E-1

1,70244E0

1,46954E0

4,07892E-2

4,48186E0

1,27664E0

2,70443E-4

5,12358E-1

1,64715E1

6,66599E0

1,51395E0

6,33218E-1

3,13745E0

1,08741E1

2,68539E0

2.8

Jarnac

5,20385E0

1,92781E1

4,41415E0

3,46782E-1

1,22827E-1

2,07665E0

5,25563E0

3,39403E-1

1,70244E0

1,46954E0

4,07892E-2

4,48186E0

1,27664E0

2,70443E-4

5,12358E-1

1,64715E1

6,66599E0

1,51395E0

6,33218E-1

3,13745E0

1,08741E1

2,68539E0

2.8

MathSBML

5,20385E0

1,92781E1

4,41415E0

3,46782E-1

1,22827E-1

2,07665E0

5,25563E0

3,39404E-1

1,70244E0

1,46954E0

4,07892E-2

4,48186E0

1,27664E0

2,70443E-4

5,12358E-1

1,64715E1

6,66599E0

1,51395E0

6,33218E-1

3,13745E0

1,08741E1

2,68539E0

2.8

Oscill8 Core

5,20385E0

1,92781E1

4,41404E0

1,22829E-1

5,25584E0

3,39402E-1

1,70244E0

1,46953E0

4,07894E-2

4,48187E0

1,27664E0

2,70449E-4

5,12348E-1

1,64715E1

6,66599E0

1,51394E0

6,33213E-1

3,13752E0

1,08741E1

2,68543E0

2.8

SBToolbox2

5,20390E0

1,92767E1

4,44293E0

3,44535E-1

1,22582E-1

2,11026E0

5,23880E0

3,25388E-1

1,70247E0

1,47088E0

4,07643E-2

4,48599E0

1,27657E0

2,76864E-4

5,17329E-1

1,64720E1

6,66603E0

1,49435E0

6,35465E-1

3,13481E0

1,08809E1

2,68176E0

2.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,20385E0

1,92781E1

4,41413E0

3,46780E-1

1,22828E-1

2,07675E0

5,25578E0

3,39364E-1

1,70244E0

1,46954E0

4,07893E-2

4,48188E0

1,27664E0

2,70465E-4

5,12363E-1

1,64715E1

6,66599E0

1,51388E0

6,33220E-1

3,13751E0

1,08741E1

2,68541E0

2.8

VCell

5,20385E0

1,92781E1

4,41415E0

3,46782E-1

1,22827E-1

2,07665E0

5,25563E0

3,39403E-1

1,70244E0

1,46954E0

4,07892E-2

4,48186E0

1,27664E0

2,70443E-4

5,12358E-1

1,64715E1

6,66599E0

1,51395E0

6,33218E-1

3,13745E0

1,08741E1

2,68539E0

2.8

copasi

5,20385E0

1,92781E1

4,41419E0

3,46781E-1

1,22826E-1

2,07663E0

5,25554E0

3,39411E-1

1,70244E0

1,46954E0

4,07892E-2

4,48185E0

1,27664E0

2,70438E-4

5,12362E-1

1,64715E1

6,66599E0

1,51396E0

6,33219E-1

3,13742E0

1,08741E1

2,68537E0

2.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20385E0

1,92781E1

4,41415E0

3,46782E-1

1,22827E-1

2,07665E0

5,25563E0

3,39403E-1

1,70244E0

1,46954E0

4,07892E-2

4,48186E0

1,27664E0

2,70443E-4

5,12358E-1

1,64715E1

6,66599E0

1,51395E0

6,33218E-1

3,13745E0

1,08741E1

2,68539E0

2.8

jsim

5,20385E0

1,92781E1

4,41413E0

3,46784E-1

1,22827E-1

2,07662E0

5,25562E0

3,39416E-1

1,70244E0

1,46954E0

4,07892E-2

4,48186E0

1,27664E0

2,70437E-4

5,12355E-1

1,64715E1

6,66599E0

1,51397E0

6,33216E-1

3,13745E0

1,08741E1

2,68539E0

2.8

min

5,20385E0

1,92767E1

4,41404E0

3,44535E-1

1,22582E-1

2,07662E0

5,23880E0

3,25388E-1

1,70244E0

1,46953E0

4,07643E-2

4,48185E0

1,27657E0

2,70437E-4

5,12348E-1

1,64715E1

6,66599E0

1,49435E0

6,33213E-1

3,13481E0

1,08741E1

2,68176E0

2.8

max

5,20390E0

1,92781E1

4,44293E0

3,46784E-1

1,22829E-1

2,11026E0

5,25584E0

3,39416E-1

1,70247E0

1,47088E0

4,07894E-2

4,48599E0

1,27664E0

2,76864E-4

5,17329E-1

1,64720E1

6,66603E0

1,51397E0

6,35465E-1

3,13752E0

1,08809E1

2,68543E0

2.8

mean

5,20385E0

1,92781E1

4,41415E0

3,46782E-1

1,22827E-1

2,07665E0

5,25563E0

3,39403E-1

1,70244E0

1,46954E0

4,07892E-2

4,48186E0

1,27664E0

2,70443E-4

5,12358E-1

1,64715E1

6,66599E0

1,51395E0

6,33218E-1

3,13745E0

1,08741E1

2,68539E0

2.8

relative error(%)

0,00

3.0

BioUML

5,20388E0

1,92975E1

4,15679E0

3,61497E-1

1,27485E-1

1,98156E0

5,63131E0

3,81727E-1

1,70398E0

1,45700E0

4,11051E-2

4,48927E0

1,27621E0

2,54930E-4

4,79275E-1

1,64729E1

6,66523E0

1,56671E0

6,18503E-1

3,24246E0

1,10441E1

2,75402E0

3.0

ByoDyn

5,20388E0

1,92976E1

4,15452E0

3,61643E-1

1,27516E-1

1,97996E0

5,63375E0

3,82452E-1

1,70398E0

1,45689E0

4,11075E-2

4,48913E0

1,27621E0

2,54657E-4

4,78953E-1

1,64729E1

6,66522E0

1,56759E0

6,18357E-1

3,24308E0

1,10439E1

2,75454E0

3.0

Jarnac

5,20388E0

1,92976E1

4,15452E0

3,61643E-1

1,27516E-1

1,97996E0

5,63375E0

3,82452E-1

1,70398E0

1,45689E0

4,11075E-2

4,48913E0

1,27621E0

2,54657E-4

4,78953E-1

1,64729E1

6,66522E0

1,56759E0

6,18357E-1

3,24308E0

1,10439E1

2,75454E0

3.0

MathSBML

5,20388E0

1,92976E1

4,15452E0

3,61643E-1

1,27516E-1

1,97996E0

5,63375E0

3,82452E-1

1,70398E0

1,45689E0

4,11075E-2

4,48913E0

1,27621E0

2,54657E-4

4,78953E-1

1,64729E1

6,66522E0

1,56759E0

6,18357E-1

3,24308E0

1,10439E1

2,75454E0

3.0

Oscill8 Core

5,20388E0

1,92976E1

4,15463E0

1,27515E-1

5,63364E0

3,82415E-1

1,70398E0

1,45690E0

4,11074E-2

4,48914E0

1,27621E0

2,54671E-4

4,78969E-1

1,64729E1

6,66522E0

1,56754E0

6,18364E-1

3,24305E0

1,10439E1

2,75452E0

3.0

SBToolbox2

5,20390E0

1,92957E1

4,18012E0

3,60579E-1

1,26838E-1

1,97250E0

5,57672E0

3,85788E-1

1,70397E0

1,45815E0

4,10675E-2

4,48511E0

1,27630E0

2,53102E-4

4,81470E-1

1,64730E1

6,66530E0

1,57168E0

6,19421E-1

3,22597E0

1,10340E1

2,74505E0

3.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,20388E0

1,92976E1

4,15469E0

3,61634E-1

1,27513E-1

1,98002E0

5,63350E0

3,82427E-1

1,70398E0

1,45690E0

4,11073E-2

4,48913E0

1,27621E0

2,54666E-4

4,78974E-1

1,64729E1

6,66522E0

1,56756E0

6,18366E-1

3,24301E0

1,10439E1

2,75449E0

3.0

VCell

5,20388E0

1,92976E1

4,15452E0

3,61643E-1

1,27516E-1

1,97996E0

5,63375E0

3,82452E-1

1,70398E0

1,45689E0

4,11075E-2

4,48913E0

1,27621E0

2,54657E-4

4,78953E-1

1,64729E1

6,66522E0

1,56759E0

6,18357E-1

3,24308E0

1,10439E1

2,75454E0

3.0

copasi

5,20388E0

1,92976E1

4,15447E0

3,61646E-1

1,27517E-1

1,97992E0

5,63381E0

3,82469E-1

1,70398E0

1,45689E0

4,11075E-2

4,48913E0

1,27621E0

2,54651E-4

4,78946E-1

1,64729E1

6,66522E0

1,56761E0

6,18354E-1

3,24310E0

1,10439E1

2,75455E0

3.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20388E0

1,92976E1

4,15452E0

3,61643E-1

1,27516E-1

1,97996E0

5,63375E0

3,82452E-1

1,70398E0

1,45689E0

4,11075E-2

4,48913E0

1,27621E0

2,54657E-4

4,78953E-1

1,64729E1

6,66522E0

1,56759E0

6,18357E-1

3,24308E0

1,10439E1

2,75454E0

3.0

jsim

5,20388E0

1,92976E1

4,15448E0

3,61645E-1

1,27517E-1

1,97996E0

5,63383E0

3,82450E-1

1,70398E0

1,45689E0

4,11076E-2

4,48914E0

1,27621E0

2,54658E-4

4,78949E-1

1,64729E1

6,66522E0

1,56759E0

6,18355E-1

3,24310E0

1,10440E1

2,75455E0

3.0

min

5,20388E0

1,92957E1

4,15447E0

3,60579E-1

1,26838E-1

1,97250E0

5,57672E0

3,82415E-1

1,70397E0

1,45689E0

4,10675E-2

4,48511E0

1,27621E0

2,53102E-4

4,78946E-1

1,64729E1

6,66522E0

1,56754E0

6,18354E-1

3,22597E0

1,10340E1

2,74505E0

3.0

max

5,20390E0

1,92976E1

4,18012E0

3,61646E-1

1,27517E-1

1,98002E0

5,63383E0

3,85788E-1

1,70398E0

1,45815E0

4,11076E-2

4,48914E0

1,27630E0

2,54671E-4

4,81470E-1

1,64730E1

6,66530E0

1,57168E0

6,19421E-1

3,24310E0

1,10440E1

2,75455E0

3.0

mean

5,20388E0

1,92976E1

4,15452E0

3,61643E-1

1,27516E-1

1,97996E0

5,63375E0

3,82452E-1

1,70398E0

1,45689E0

4,11075E-2

4,48913E0

1,27621E0

2,54657E-4

4,78953E-1

1,64729E1

6,66522E0

1,56759E0

6,18357E-1

3,24308E0

1,10439E1

2,75454E0

3.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0,18

0,00

0,10

0,00

3.2

BioUML

5,20392E0

1,92964E1

4,24778E0

3,53070E-1

1,27508E-1

2,14738E0

5,64614E0

3,11011E-1

1,70565E0

1,46101E0

4,10624E-2

4,51742E0

1,27538E0

2,86554E-4

4,97564E-1

1,64749E1

6,66546E0

1,47161E0

6,26930E-1

3,25819E0

1,12277E1

2,74965E0

3.2

ByoDyn

5,20392E0

1,92964E1

4,24763E0

3,53073E-1

1,27513E-1

2,14752E0

5,64659E0

3,10954E-1

1,70565E0

1,46100E0

4,10626E-2

4,51746E0

1,27538E0

2,86585E-4

4,97554E-1

1,64749E1

6,66546E0

1,47153E0

6,26927E-1

3,25833E0

1,12277E1

2,74972E0

3.2

Jarnac

5,20392E0

1,92964E1

4,24763E0

3,53073E-1

1,27513E-1

2,14752E0

5,64659E0

3,10954E-1

1,70565E0

1,46100E0

4,10626E-2

4,51746E0

1,27538E0

2,86585E-4

4,97554E-1

1,64749E1

6,66546E0

1,47153E0

6,26927E-1

3,25833E0

1,12277E1

2,74972E0

3.2

MathSBML

5,20392E0

1,92964E1

4,24763E0

3,53073E-1

1,27513E-1

2,14752E0

5,64659E0

3,10954E-1

1,70565E0

1,46100E0

4,10626E-2

4,51746E0

1,27538E0

2,86585E-4

4,97555E-1

1,64749E1

6,66546E0

1,47153E0

6,26927E-1

3,25833E0

1,12277E1

2,74972E0

3.2

Oscill8 Core

5,20392E0

1,92964E1

4,24770E0

1,27511E-1

5,64642E0

3,10974E-1

1,70565E0

1,46100E0

4,10625E-2

4,51744E0

1,27538E0

2,86577E-4

4,97560E-1

1,64749E1

6,66546E0

1,47155E0

6,26929E-1

3,25828E0

1,12277E1

2,74969E0

3.2

SBToolbox2

5,20390E0

1,92990E1

4,20266E0

3,56046E-1

1,28145E-1

2,11633E0

5,69678E0

3,23496E-1

1,70567E0

1,45894E0

4,11108E-2

4,51558E0

1,27540E0

2,80432E-4

4,90835E-1

1,64750E1

6,66530E0

1,49016E0

6,23954E-1

3,27056E0

1,12278E1

2,75904E0

3.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,20392E0

1,92964E1

4,24757E0

3,53079E-1

1,27513E-1

2,14740E0

5,64656E0

3,11005E-1

1,70565E0

1,46100E0

4,10626E-2

4,51744E0

1,27538E0

2,86562E-4

4,97542E-1

1,64749E1

6,66546E0

1,47160E0

6,26921E-1

3,25831E0

1,12277E1

2,74972E0

3.2

VCell

5,20392E0

1,92964E1

4,24763E0

3,53073E-1

1,27513E-1

2,14752E0

5,64659E0

3,10954E-1

1,70565E0

1,46100E0

4,10626E-2

4,51746E0

1,27538E0

2,86585E-4

4,97554E-1

1,64749E1

6,66546E0

1,47153E0

6,26927E-1

3,25833E0

1,12277E1

2,74972E0

3.2

copasi

5,20392E0

1,92964E1

4,24762E0

3,53073E-1

1,27514E-1

2,14755E0

5,64664E0

3,10942E-1

1,70565E0

1,46100E0

4,10626E-2

4,51746E0

1,27538E0

2,86592E-4

4,97556E-1

1,64749E1

6,66546E0

1,47151E0

6,26927E-1

3,25835E0

1,12277E1

2,74972E0

3.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20392E0

1,92964E1

4,24763E0

3,53073E-1

1,27513E-1

2,14752E0

5,64659E0

3,10954E-1

1,70565E0

1,46100E0

4,10626E-2

4,51746E0

1,27538E0

2,86585E-4

4,97554E-1

1,64749E1

6,66546E0

1,47153E0

6,26927E-1

3,25833E0

1,12277E1

2,74972E0

3.2

jsim

5,20392E0

1,92964E1

4,24765E0

3,53072E-1

1,27513E-1

2,14755E0

5,64659E0

3,10934E-1

1,70565E0

1,46100E0

4,10627E-2

4,51747E0

1,27538E0

2,86586E-4

4,97557E-1

1,64749E1

6,66546E0

1,47152E0

6,26928E-1

3,25833E0

1,12278E1

2,74971E0

3.2

min

5,20390E0

1,92964E1

4,20266E0

3,53072E-1

1,27511E-1

2,11633E0

5,64642E0

3,10934E-1

1,70565E0

1,45894E0

4,10625E-2

4,51558E0

1,27538E0

2,80432E-4

4,90835E-1

1,64749E1

6,66530E0

1,47151E0

6,23954E-1

3,25828E0

1,12277E1

2,74969E0

3.2

max

5,20392E0

1,92990E1

4,24770E0

3,56046E-1

1,28145E-1

2,14755E0

5,69678E0

3,23496E-1

1,70567E0

1,46100E0

4,11108E-2

4,51747E0

1,27540E0

2,86592E-4

4,97560E-1

1,64750E1

6,66546E0

1,49016E0

6,26929E-1

3,27056E0

1,12278E1

2,75904E0

3.2

mean

5,20392E0

1,92964E1

4,24763E0

3,53073E-1

1,27513E-1

2,14752E0

5,64659E0

3,10954E-1

1,70565E0

1,46100E0

4,10626E-2

4,51746E0

1,27538E0

2,86585E-4

4,97554E-1

1,64749E1

6,66546E0

1,47153E0

6,26927E-1

3,25833E0

1,12277E1

2,74972E0

3.2

relative error(%)

0,00

3.4

BioUML

5,20395E0

1,92809E1

4,46505E0

3,42182E-1

1,22567E-1

2,15342E0

5,24132E0

3,08064E-1

1,70733E0

1,47272E0

4,07543E-2

4,49823E0

1,27551E0

2,85679E-4

5,22226E-1

1,64761E1

6,66625E0

1,46852E0

6,37818E-1

3,13897E0

1,13000E1

2,68223E0

3.4

ByoDyn

5,20395E0

1,92808E1

4,46708E0

3,42061E-1

1,22530E-1

2,15424E0

5,23844E0

3,07715E-1

1,70733E0

1,47282E0

4,07515E-2

4,49819E0

1,27551E0

2,85817E-4

5,22494E-1

1,64761E1

6,66625E0

1,46805E0

6,37939E-1

3,13817E0

1,12997E1

2,68173E0

3.4

Jarnac

5,20395E0

1,92808E1

4,46708E0

3,42061E-1

1,22530E-1

2,15424E0

5,23844E0

3,07715E-1

1,70733E0

1,47282E0

4,07515E-2

4,49819E0

1,27551E0

2,85817E-4

5,22494E-1

1,64761E1

6,66625E0

1,46805E0

6,37939E-1

3,13817E0

1,12997E1

2,68173E0

3.4

MathSBML

5,20395E0

1,92808E1

4,46708E0

3,42061E-1

1,22530E-1

2,15424E0

5,23844E0

3,07715E-1

1,70733E0

1,47282E0

4,07515E-2

4,49819E0

1,27551E0

2,85817E-4

5,22494E-1

1,64761E1

6,66625E0

1,46805E0

6,37939E-1

3,13817E0

1,12997E1

2,68173E0

3.4

Oscill8 Core

5,20395E0

1,92808E1

4,46688E0

1,22534E-1

5,23872E0

3,07753E-1

1,70733E0

1,47281E0

4,07518E-2

4,49820E0

1,27551E0

2,85804E-4

5,22468E-1

1,64761E1

6,66625E0

1,46809E0

6,37927E-1

3,13824E0

1,12997E1

2,68178E0

3.4

SBToolbox2

5,20400E0

1,92820E1

4,46210E0

3,41540E-1

1,23015E-1

2,18364E0

5,27981E0

2,96260E-1

1,70737E0

1,47230E0

4,07724E-2

4,50468E0

1,27540E0

2,92227E-4

5,23642E-1

1,64760E1

6,66620E0

1,45004E0

6,38460E-1

3,15294E0

1,13143E1

2,68828E0

3.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,20395E0

1,92808E1

4,46689E0

3,42070E-1

1,22535E-1

2,15424E0

5,23879E0

3,07718E-1

1,70733E0

1,47281E0

4,07518E-2

4,49821E0

1,27551E0

2,85822E-4

5,22474E-1

1,64761E1

6,66625E0

1,46804E0

6,37930E-1

3,13827E0

1,12997E1

2,68179E0

3.4

VCell

5,20395E0

1,92808E1

4,46708E0

3,42061E-1

1,22530E-1

2,15424E0

5,23844E0

3,07715E-1

1,70733E0

1,47282E0

4,07515E-2

4,49819E0

1,27551E0

2,85817E-4

5,22494E-1

1,64761E1

6,66625E0

1,46805E0

6,37939E-1

3,13817E0

1,12997E1

2,68173E0

3.4

copasi

5,20395E0

1,92808E1

4,46716E0

3,42056E-1

1,22529E-1

2,15426E0

5,23830E0

3,07705E-1

1,70733E0

1,47283E0

4,07514E-2

4,49819E0

1,27551E0

2,85821E-4

5,22505E-1

1,64761E1

6,66625E0

1,46803E0

6,37944E-1

3,13813E0

1,12996E1

2,68171E0

3.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20395E0

1,92808E1

4,46708E0

3,42061E-1

1,22530E-1

2,15424E0

5,23844E0

3,07715E-1

1,70733E0

1,47282E0

4,07515E-2

4,49819E0

1,27551E0

2,85817E-4

5,22494E-1

1,64761E1

6,66625E0

1,46805E0

6,37939E-1

3,13817E0

1,12997E1

2,68173E0

3.4

jsim

5,20395E0

1,92808E1

4,46711E0

3,42060E-1

1,22529E-1

2,15423E0

5,23836E0

3,07708E-1

1,70734E0

1,47282E0

4,07516E-2

4,49819E0

1,27551E0

2,85807E-4

5,22496E-1

1,64761E1

6,66625E0

1,46806E0

6,37940E-1

3,13814E0

1,12997E1

2,68172E0

3.4

min

5,20395E0

1,92808E1

4,46210E0

3,41540E-1

1,22529E-1

2,15423E0

5,23830E0

2,96260E-1

1,70733E0

1,47230E0

4,07514E-2

4,49819E0

1,27540E0

2,85804E-4

5,22468E-1

1,64760E1

6,66620E0

1,45004E0

6,37927E-1

3,13813E0

1,12996E1

2,68171E0

3.4

max

5,20400E0

1,92820E1

4,46716E0

3,42070E-1

1,23015E-1

2,18364E0

5,27981E0

3,07753E-1

1,70737E0

1,47283E0

4,07724E-2

4,50468E0

1,27551E0

2,92227E-4

5,23642E-1

1,64761E1

6,66625E0

1,46809E0

6,38460E-1

3,15294E0

1,13143E1

2,68828E0

3.4

mean

5,20395E0

1,92808E1

4,46708E0

3,42061E-1

1,22530E-1

2,15424E0

5,23844E0

3,07715E-1

1,70733E0

1,47282E0

4,07515E-2

4,49819E0

1,27551E0

2,85817E-4

5,22494E-1

1,64761E1

6,66625E0

1,46805E0

6,37939E-1

3,13817E0

1,12997E1

2,68173E0

3.4

relative error(%)

0,00

3.6

BioUML

5,20399E0

1,92968E1

4,22478E0

3,58251E-1

1,25780E-1

1,97298E0

5,48927E0

3,85439E-1

1,70884E0

1,46138E0

4,10070E-2

4,48573E0

1,27561E0

2,52812E-4

4,86431E-1

1,64772E1

6,66562E0

1,57158E0

6,21749E-1

3,20030E0

1,14198E1

2,73052E0

3.6

ByoDyn

5,20399E0

1,92968E1

4,22436E0

3,58286E-1

1,25782E-1

1,97237E0

5,48938E0

3,85719E-1

1,70884E0

1,46136E0

4,10074E-2

4,48564E0

1,27562E0

2,52709E-4

4,86359E-1

1,64772E1

6,66562E0

1,57191E0

6,21714E-1

3,20030E0

1,14195E1

2,73057E0

3.6

Jarnac

5,20399E0

1,92968E1

4,22436E0

3,58286E-1

1,25782E-1

1,97237E0

5,48938E0

3,85719E-1

1,70884E0

1,46136E0

4,10074E-2

4,48564E0

1,27562E0

2,52709E-4

4,86359E-1

1,64772E1

6,66562E0

1,57191E0

6,21714E-1

3,20030E0

1,14195E1

2,73057E0

3.6

MathSBML

5,20399E0

1,92968E1

4,22436E0

3,58286E-1

1,25782E-1

1,97237E0

5,48938E0

3,85719E-1

1,70884E0

1,46136E0

4,10074E-2

4,48564E0

1,27562E0

2,52709E-4

4,86359E-1

1,64772E1

6,66562E0

1,57191E0

6,21714E-1

3,20030E0

1,14195E1

2,73057E0

3.6

Oscill8 Core

5,20399E0

1,92968E1

4,22443E0

1,25782E-1

5,48936E0

3,85669E-1

1,70884E0

1,46136E0

4,10073E-2

4,48565E0

1,27562E0

2,52728E-4

4,86372E-1

1,64772E1

6,66562E0

1,57185E0

6,21721E-1

3,20030E0

1,14196E1

2,73056E0

3.6

SBToolbox2

5,20400E0

1,92926E1

4,27664E0

3,55420E-1

1,24779E-1

1,98712E0

5,40781E0

3,78842E-1

1,70886E0

1,46399E0

4,09415E-2

4,48379E0

1,27564E0

2,54885E-4

4,92789E-1

1,64770E1

6,66580E0

1,56405E0

6,24580E-1

3,17707E0

1,14128E1

2,71559E0

3.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,20399E0

1,92968E1

4,22455E0

3,58273E-1

1,25779E-1

1,97250E0

5,48916E0

3,85658E-1

1,70884E0

1,46137E0

4,10072E-2

4,48565E0

1,27562E0

2,52731E-4

4,86387E-1

1,64772E1

6,66562E0

1,57184E0

6,21727E-1

3,20024E0

1,14195E1

2,73053E0

3.6

VCell

5,20399E0

1,92968E1

4,22436E0

3,58286E-1

1,25782E-1

1,97237E0

5,48938E0

3,85719E-1

1,70884E0

1,46136E0

4,10074E-2

4,48564E0

1,27562E0

2,52709E-4

4,86359E-1

1,64772E1

6,66562E0

1,57191E0

6,21714E-1

3,20030E0

1,14195E1

2,73057E0

3.6

copasi

5,20399E0

1,92968E1

4,22432E0

3,58289E-1

1,25782E-1

1,97232E0

5,48939E0

3,85744E-1

1,70884E0

1,46136E0

4,10074E-2

4,48563E0

1,27562E0

2,52700E-4

4,86353E-1

1,64772E1

6,66562E0

1,57194E0

6,21711E-1

3,20030E0

1,14195E1

2,73058E0

3.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20399E0

1,92968E1

4,22436E0

3,58286E-1

1,25782E-1

1,97237E0

5,48938E0

3,85719E-1

1,70884E0

1,46136E0

4,10074E-2

4,48564E0

1,27562E0

2,52709E-4

4,86359E-1

1,64772E1

6,66562E0

1,57191E0

6,21714E-1

3,20030E0

1,14195E1

2,73057E0

3.6

jsim

5,20399E0

1,92968E1

4,22429E0

3,58290E-1

1,25783E-1

1,97235E0

5,48946E0

3,85731E-1

1,70884E0

1,46135E0

4,10074E-2

4,48564E0

1,27562E0

2,52705E-4

4,86351E-1

1,64772E1

6,66562E0

1,57192E0

6,21710E-1

3,20032E0

1,14196E1

2,73059E0

3.6

min

5,20399E0

1,92926E1

4,22429E0

3,55420E-1

1,24779E-1

1,97232E0

5,40781E0

3,78842E-1

1,70884E0

1,46135E0

4,09415E-2

4,48379E0

1,27562E0

2,52700E-4

4,86351E-1

1,64770E1

6,66562E0

1,56405E0

6,21710E-1

3,17707E0

1,14128E1

2,71559E0

3.6

max

5,20400E0

1,92968E1

4,27664E0

3,58290E-1

1,25783E-1

1,98712E0

5,48946E0

3,85744E-1

1,70886E0

1,46399E0

4,10074E-2

4,48565E0

1,27564E0

2,54885E-4

4,92789E-1

1,64772E1

6,66580E0

1,57194E0

6,24580E-1

3,20032E0

1,14196E1

2,73059E0

3.6

mean

5,20399E0

1,92968E1

4,22436E0

3,58286E-1

1,25782E-1

1,97237E0

5,48938E0

3,85719E-1

1,70884E0

1,46136E0

4,10074E-2

4,48564E0

1,27562E0

2,52709E-4

4,86359E-1

1,64772E1

6,66562E0

1,57191E0

6,21714E-1

3,20030E0

1,14195E1

2,73057E0

3.6

relative error(%)

0,00

3.8

BioUML

5,20402E0

1,93057E1

4,16416E0

3,58611E-1

1,28498E-1

2,08029E0

5,72427E0

3,38586E-1

1,71040E0

1,45822E0

4,11492E-2

4,51591E0

1,27490E0

2,73550E-4

4,84713E-1

1,64792E1

6,66539E0

1,51112E0

6,21389E-1

3,27610E0

1,16110E1

2,76607E0

3.8

ByoDyn

5,20402E0

1,93058E1

4,16329E0

3,58657E-1

1,28516E-1

2,08018E0

5,72583E0

3,38618E-1

1,71040E0

1,45818E0

4,11504E-2

4,51597E0

1,27490E0

2,73530E-4

4,84607E-1

1,64792E1

6,66539E0

1,51120E0

6,21343E-1

3,27654E0

1,16111E1

2,76633E0

3.8

Jarnac

5,20402E0

1,93058E1

4,16329E0

3,58657E-1

1,28516E-1

2,08018E0

5,72583E0

3,38618E-1

1,71040E0

1,45818E0

4,11504E-2

4,51597E0

1,27490E0

2,73530E-4

4,84607E-1

1,64792E1

6,66539E0

1,51120E0

6,21343E-1

3,27654E0

1,16111E1

2,76633E0

3.8

MathSBML

5,20402E0

1,93058E1

4,16329E0

3,58657E-1

1,28516E-1

2,08018E0

5,72583E0

3,38618E-1

1,71040E0

1,45818E0

4,11504E-2

4,51597E0

1,27490E0

2,73530E-4

4,84607E-1

1,64792E1

6,66539E0

1,51120E0

6,21343E-1

3,27654E0

1,16111E1

2,76633E0

3.8

Oscill8 Core

5,20402E0

1,93057E1

4,16343E0

1,28513E-1

5,72558E0

3,38615E-1

1,71040E0

1,45819E0

4,11502E-2

4,51596E0

1,27490E0

2,73535E-4

4,84624E-1

1,64792E1

6,66539E0

1,51119E0

6,21351E-1

3,27647E0

1,16111E1

2,76629E0

3.8

SBToolbox2

5,20400E0

1,93070E1

4,13728E0

3,60826E-1

1,28619E-1

2,04194E0

5,73154E0

3,54899E-1

1,71036E0

1,45712E0

4,11674E-2

4,51045E0

1,27500E0

2,66266E-4

4,79829E-1

1,64790E1

6,66530E0

1,53318E0

6,19174E-1

3,27557E0

1,16026E1

2,76906E0

3.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,20402E0

1,93058E1

4,16335E0

3,58656E-1

1,28514E-1

2,08010E0

5,72563E0

3,38655E-1

1,71040E0

1,45819E0

4,11503E-2

4,51595E0

1,27490E0

2,73516E-4

4,84610E-1

1,64792E1

6,66539E0

1,51124E0

6,21344E-1

3,27648E0

1,16111E1

2,76630E0

3.8

VCell

5,20402E0

1,93058E1

4,16329E0

3,58657E-1

1,28516E-1

2,08018E0

5,72583E0

3,38618E-1

1,71040E0

1,45818E0

4,11504E-2

4,51597E0

1,27490E0

2,73530E-4

4,84607E-1

1,64792E1

6,66539E0

1,51120E0

6,21343E-1

3,27654E0

1,16111E1

2,76633E0

3.8

copasi

5,20402E0

1,93058E1

4,16324E0

3,58659E-1

1,28517E-1

2,08018E0

5,72593E0

3,38618E-1

1,71040E0

1,45818E0

4,11505E-2

4,51598E0

1,27490E0

2,73531E-4

4,84601E-1

1,64792E1

6,66539E0

1,51120E0

6,21341E-1

3,27657E0

1,16111E1

2,76635E0

3.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20402E0

1,93058E1

4,16329E0

3,58657E-1

1,28516E-1

2,08018E0

5,72583E0

3,38618E-1

1,71040E0

1,45818E0

4,11504E-2

4,51597E0

1,27490E0

2,73530E-4

4,84607E-1

1,64792E1

6,66539E0

1,51120E0

6,21343E-1

3,27654E0

1,16111E1

2,76633E0

3.8

jsim

5,20402E0

1,93058E1

4,16328E0

3,58657E-1

1,28517E-1

2,08020E0

5,72587E0

3,38598E-1

1,71040E0

1,45818E0

4,11505E-2

4,51598E0

1,27490E0

2,73529E-4

4,84605E-1

1,64792E1

6,66539E0

1,51120E0

6,21343E-1

3,27655E0

1,16112E1

2,76634E0

3.8

min

5,20400E0

1,93057E1

4,13728E0

3,58656E-1

1,28513E-1

2,04194E0

5,72558E0

3,38598E-1

1,71036E0

1,45712E0

4,11502E-2

4,51045E0

1,27490E0

2,66266E-4

4,79829E-1

1,64790E1

6,66530E0

1,51119E0

6,19174E-1

3,27557E0

1,16026E1

2,76629E0

3.8

max

5,20402E0

1,93070E1

4,16343E0

3,60826E-1

1,28619E-1

2,08020E0

5,73154E0

3,54899E-1

1,71040E0

1,45819E0

4,11674E-2

4,51598E0

1,27500E0

2,73535E-4

4,84624E-1

1,64792E1

6,66539E0

1,53318E0

6,21351E-1

3,27657E0

1,16112E1

2,76906E0

3.8

mean

5,20402E0

1,93058E1

4,16329E0

3,58657E-1

1,28516E-1

2,08018E0

5,72583E0

3,38618E-1

1,71040E0

1,45818E0

4,11504E-2

4,51597E0

1,27490E0

2,73530E-4

4,84607E-1

1,64792E1

6,66539E0

1,51120E0

6,21343E-1

3,27654E0

1,16111E1

2,76633E0

3.8

relative error(%)

0,00

4.0

BioUML

5,20406E0

1,92890E1

4,44150E0

3,41878E-1

1,23652E-1

2,20172E0

5,33330E0

2,89481E-1

1,71206E0

1,47216E0

4,08116E-2

4,51405E0

1,27481E0

2,96502E-4

5,22413E-1

1,64807E1

6,66626E0

1,43880E0

6,38122E-1

3,17042E0

1,17074E1

2,69782E0

4.0

ByoDyn

5,20406E0

1,92889E1

4,44239E0

3,41815E-1

1,23639E-1

2,20240E0

5,33238E0

2,89219E-1

1,71206E0

1,47220E0

4,08104E-2

4,51409E0

1,27481E0

2,96643E-4

5,22553E-1

1,64807E1

6,66627E0

1,43838E0

6,38185E-1

3,17020E0

1,17074E1

2,69766E0

4.0

Jarnac

5,20406E0

1,92889E1

4,44239E0

3,41815E-1

1,23639E-1

2,20240E0

5,33238E0

2,89219E-1

1,71206E0

1,47220E0

4,08104E-2

4,51409E0

1,27481E0

2,96643E-4

5,22553E-1

1,64807E1

6,66627E0

1,43838E0

6,38185E-1

3,17020E0

1,17074E1

2,69766E0

4.0

MathSBML

5,20406E0

1,92889E1

4,44239E0

3,41815E-1

1,23639E-1

2,20240E0

5,33238E0

2,89219E-1

1,71206E0

1,47220E0

4,08104E-2

4,51409E0

1,27481E0

2,96643E-4

5,22554E-1

1,64807E1

6,66627E0

1,43838E0

6,38185E-1

3,17020E0

1,17074E1

2,69766E0

4.0

Oscill8 Core

5,20406E0

1,92889E1

4,44223E0

1,23641E-1

5,33254E0

2,89274E-1

1,71206E0

1,47219E0

4,08105E-2

4,51408E0

1,27481E0

2,96613E-4

5,22526E-1

1,64807E1

6,66627E0

1,43847E0

6,38173E-1

3,17024E0

1,17073E1

2,69769E0

4.0

SBToolbox2

5,20410E0

1,92934E1

4,39104E0

3,44298E-1

1,24854E-1

2,20470E0

5,43154E0

2,88480E-1

1,71206E0

1,46938E0

4,08860E-2

4,51990E0

1,27470E0

2,97702E-4

5,16920E-1

1,64810E1

6,66606E0

1,43682E0

6,35702E-1

3,19988E0

1,17248E1

2,71394E0

4.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,20406E0

1,92889E1

4,44212E0

3,41831E-1

1,23644E-1

2,20228E0

5,33276E0

2,89265E-1

1,71206E0

1,47219E0

4,08107E-2

4,51409E0

1,27481E0

2,96619E-4

5,22516E-1

1,64807E1

6,66627E0

1,43845E0

6,38169E-1

3,17030E0

1,17074E1

2,69772E0

4.0

VCell

5,20406E0

1,92889E1

4,44239E0

3,41815E-1

1,23639E-1

2,20240E0

5,33238E0

2,89219E-1

1,71206E0

1,47220E0

4,08104E-2

4,51409E0

1,27481E0

2,96643E-4

5,22553E-1

1,64807E1

6,66627E0

1,43838E0

6,38185E-1

3,17020E0

1,17074E1

2,69766E0

4.0

copasi

5,20406E0

1,92889E1

4,44249E0

3,41808E-1

1,23638E-1

2,20246E0

5,33227E0

2,89196E-1

1,71206E0

1,47221E0

4,08103E-2

4,51409E0

1,27481E0

2,96656E-4

5,22568E-1

1,64807E1

6,66627E0

1,43834E0

6,38192E-1

3,17017E0

1,17073E1

2,69764E0

4.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20406E0

1,92889E1

4,44239E0

3,41815E-1

1,23639E-1

2,20240E0

5,33238E0

2,89219E-1

1,71206E0

1,47220E0

4,08104E-2

4,51409E0

1,27481E0

2,96643E-4

5,22553E-1

1,64807E1

6,66627E0

1,43838E0

6,38185E-1

3,17020E0

1,17074E1

2,69766E0

4.0

jsim

5,20406E0

1,92889E1

4,44246E0

3,41811E-1

1,23638E-1

2,20244E0

5,33228E0

2,89205E-1

1,71206E0

1,47220E0

4,08103E-2

4,51409E0

1,27481E0

2,96650E-4

5,22563E-1

1,64807E1

6,66627E0

1,43836E0

6,38189E-1

3,17018E0

1,17074E1

2,69764E0

4.0

min

5,20406E0

1,92889E1

4,39104E0

3,41808E-1

1,23638E-1

2,20228E0

5,33227E0

2,88480E-1

1,71206E0

1,46938E0

4,08103E-2

4,51408E0

1,27470E0

2,96613E-4

5,16920E-1

1,64807E1

6,66606E0

1,43682E0

6,35702E-1

3,17017E0

1,17073E1

2,69764E0

4.0

max

5,20410E0

1,92934E1

4,44249E0

3,44298E-1

1,24854E-1

2,20470E0

5,43154E0

2,89274E-1

1,71206E0

1,47221E0

4,08860E-2

4,51990E0

1,27481E0

2,97702E-4

5,22568E-1

1,64810E1

6,66627E0

1,43847E0

6,38192E-1

3,19988E0

1,17248E1

2,71394E0

4.0

mean

5,20406E0

1,92889E1

4,44239E0

3,41815E-1

1,23639E-1

2,20240E0

5,33238E0

2,89219E-1

1,71206E0

1,47220E0

4,08104E-2

4,51409E0

1,27481E0

2,96643E-4

5,22553E-1

1,64807E1

6,66627E0

1,43838E0

6,38185E-1

3,17020E0

1,17074E1

2,69766E0

4.0

relative error(%)

0,00

4.2

BioUML

5,20409E0

1,92942E1

4,32777E0

3,52224E-1

1,23813E-1

2,00856E0

5,33101E0

3,69083E-1

1,71356E0

1,46768E0

4,08820E-2

4,48662E0

1,27532E0

2,58339E-4

4,99434E-1

1,64816E1

6,66611E0

1,55236E0

6,27776E-1

3,15559E0

1,17784E1

2,70235E0

4.2

ByoDyn

5,20409E0

1,92942E1

4,32788E0

3,52227E-1

1,23806E-1

2,00820E0

5,33042E0

3,69243E-1

1,71355E0

1,46769E0

4,08816E-2

4,48653E0

1,27533E0

2,58270E-4

4,99428E-1

1,64816E1

6,66611E0

1,55256E0

6,27773E-1

3,15539E0

1,17781E1

2,70226E0

4.2

Jarnac

5,20409E0

1,92942E1

4,32788E0

3,52227E-1

1,23806E-1

2,00820E0

5,33042E0

3,69243E-1

1,71355E0

1,46769E0

4,08816E-2

4,48653E0

1,27533E0

2,58270E-4

4,99428E-1

1,64816E1

6,66611E0

1,55256E0

6,27773E-1

3,15539E0

1,17781E1

2,70226E0

4.2

MathSBML

5,20409E0

1,92942E1

4,32788E0

3,52227E-1

1,23806E-1

2,00820E0

5,33042E0

3,69244E-1

1,71355E0

1,46769E0

4,08816E-2

4,48653E0

1,27533E0

2,58270E-4

4,99428E-1

1,64816E1

6,66611E0

1,55256E0

6,27773E-1

3,15539E0

1,17781E1

2,70226E0

4.2

Oscill8 Core

5,20409E0

1,92942E1

4,32786E0

1,23808E-1

5,33056E0

3,69205E-1

1,71355E0

1,46769E0

4,08817E-2

4,48655E0

1,27533E0

2,58289E-4

4,99431E-1

1,64816E1

6,66611E0

1,55251E0

6,27774E-1

3,15544E0

1,17782E1

2,70228E0

4.2

SBToolbox2

5,20410E0

1,92900E1

4,39362E0

3,47963E-1

1,22854E-1

2,05233E0

5,25653E0

3,49747E-1

1,71356E0

1,47099E0

4,08101E-2

4,48942E0

1,27526E0

2,65914E-4

5,08833E-1

1,64820E1

6,66630E0

1,52797E0

6,32037E-1

3,13621E0

1,17799E1

2,68807E0

4.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,20409E0

1,92942E1

4,32801E0

3,52216E-1

1,23805E-1

2,00838E0

5,33036E0

3,69165E-1

1,71355E0

1,46769E0

4,08815E-2

4,48655E0

1,27533E0

2,58304E-4

4,99453E-1

1,64816E1

6,66611E0

1,55246E0

6,27784E-1

3,15539E0

1,17782E1

2,70225E0

4.2

VCell

5,20409E0

1,92942E1

4,32788E0

3,52227E-1

1,23806E-1

2,00820E0

5,33042E0

3,69243E-1

1,71355E0

1,46769E0

4,08816E-2

4,48653E0

1,27533E0

2,58270E-4

4,99428E-1

1,64816E1

6,66611E0

1,55256E0

6,27773E-1

3,15539E0

1,17781E1

2,70226E0

4.2

copasi

5,20409E0

1,92942E1

4,32788E0

3,52229E-1

1,23805E-1

2,00814E0

5,33036E0

3,69269E-1

1,71355E0

1,46769E0

4,08816E-2

4,48652E0

1,27533E0

2,58260E-4

4,99426E-1

1,64816E1

6,66611E0

1,55259E0

6,27771E-1

3,15537E0

1,17781E1

2,70225E0

4.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20409E0

1,92942E1

4,32788E0

3,52227E-1

1,23806E-1

2,00820E0

5,33042E0

3,69243E-1

1,71355E0

1,46769E0

4,08816E-2

4,48653E0

1,27533E0

2,58270E-4

4,99428E-1

1,64816E1

6,66611E0

1,55256E0

6,27773E-1

3,15539E0

1,17781E1

2,70226E0

4.2

jsim

5,20409E0

1,92942E1

4,32782E0

3,52232E-1

1,23807E-1

2,00814E0

5,33047E0

3,69261E-1

1,71355E0

1,46768E0

4,08818E-2

4,48653E0

1,27533E0

2,58257E-4

4,99418E-1

1,64816E1

6,66611E0

1,55260E0

6,27768E-1

3,15540E0

1,17782E1

2,70227E0

4.2

min

5,20409E0

1,92900E1

4,32782E0

3,47963E-1

1,22854E-1

2,00814E0

5,25653E0

3,49747E-1

1,71355E0

1,46768E0

4,08101E-2

4,48652E0

1,27526E0

2,58257E-4

4,99418E-1

1,64816E1

6,66611E0

1,52797E0

6,27768E-1

3,13621E0

1,17781E1

2,68807E0

4.2

max

5,20410E0

1,92942E1

4,39362E0

3,52232E-1

1,23808E-1

2,05233E0

5,33056E0

3,69269E-1

1,71356E0

1,47099E0

4,08818E-2

4,48942E0

1,27533E0

2,65914E-4

5,08833E-1

1,64820E1

6,66630E0

1,55260E0

6,32037E-1

3,15544E0

1,17799E1

2,70228E0

4.2

mean

5,20409E0

1,92942E1

4,32788E0

3,52227E-1

1,23806E-1

2,00820E0

5,33042E0

3,69243E-1

1,71355E0

1,46769E0

4,08816E-2

4,48653E0

1,27533E0

2,58270E-4

4,99428E-1

1,64816E1

6,66611E0

1,55256E0

6,27773E-1

3,15539E0

1,17781E1

2,70226E0

4.2

relative error(%)

0,00

4.4

BioUML

5,20412E0

1,93113E1

4,13048E0

3,61535E-1

1,28368E-1

2,01611E0

5,70898E0

3,66328E-1

1,71500E0

1,45803E0

4,11651E-2

4,50835E0

1,27491E0

2,61518E-4

4,77900E-1

1,64833E1

6,66547E0

1,54756E0

6,18465E-1

3,26748E0

1,19552E1

2,76766E0

4.4

ByoDyn

5,20412E0

1,93115E1

4,12814E0

3,61671E-1

1,28409E-1

2,01509E0

5,71225E0

3,66753E-1

1,71500E0

1,45792E0

4,11680E-2

4,50835E0

1,27491E0

2,61337E-4

4,77590E-1

1,64833E1

6,66546E0

1,54815E0

6,18329E-1

3,26836E0

1,19553E1

2,76827E0

4.4

Jarnac

5,20412E0

1,93115E1

4,12814E0

3,61671E-1

1,28409E-1

2,01509E0

5,71225E0

3,66753E-1

1,71500E0

1,45792E0

4,11680E-2

4,50835E0

1,27491E0

2,61337E-4

4,77590E-1

1,64833E1

6,66546E0

1,54815E0

6,18329E-1

3,26836E0

1,19553E1

2,76827E0

4.4

MathSBML

5,20412E0

1,93115E1

4,12814E0

3,61671E-1

1,28409E-1

2,01510E0

5,71226E0

3,66753E-1

1,71500E0

1,45792E0

4,11680E-2

4,50835E0

1,27491E0

2,61337E-4

4,77590E-1

1,64833E1

6,66546E0

1,54815E0

6,18329E-1

3,26836E0

1,19553E1

2,76827E0

4.4

Oscill8 Core

5,20412E0

1,93115E1

4,12830E0

1,28406E-1

5,71204E0

3,66725E-1

1,71500E0

1,45793E0

4,11678E-2

4,50835E0

1,27491E0

2,61349E-4

4,77611E-1

1,64833E1

6,66546E0

1,54811E0

6,18338E-1

3,26830E0

1,19553E1

2,76823E0

4.4

SBToolbox2

5,20410E0

1,93100E1

4,13839E0

3,61873E-1

1,27791E-1

1,98471E0

5,65784E0

3,80294E-1

1,71500E0

1,45853E0

4,11376E-2

4,50085E0

1,27504E0

2,55653E-4

4,77364E-1

1,64830E1

6,66550E0

1,56503E0

6,18127E-1

3,25064E0

1,19400E1

2,76054E0

4.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,20412E0

1,93115E1

4,12830E0

3,61664E-1

1,28405E-1

2,01508E0

5,71194E0

3,66760E-1

1,71500E0

1,45793E0

4,11678E-2

4,50833E0

1,27491E0

2,61335E-4

4,77607E-1

1,64833E1

6,66546E0

1,54816E0

6,18336E-1

3,26827E0

1,19553E1

2,76822E0

4.4

VCell

5,20412E0

1,93115E1

4,12814E0

3,61671E-1

1,28409E-1

2,01509E0

5,71225E0

3,66753E-1

1,71500E0

1,45792E0

4,11680E-2

4,50835E0

1,27491E0

2,61337E-4

4,77590E-1

1,64833E1

6,66546E0

1,54815E0

6,18329E-1

3,26836E0

1,19553E1

2,76827E0

4.4

copasi

5,20412E0

1,93115E1

4,12807E0

3,61675E-1

1,28410E-1

2,01507E0

5,71236E0

3,66763E-1

1,71500E0

1,45792E0

4,11681E-2

4,50835E0

1,27491E0

2,61333E-4

4,77581E-1

1,64833E1

6,66546E0

1,54816E0

6,18325E-1

3,26839E0

1,19553E1

2,76829E0

4.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20412E0

1,93115E1

4,12814E0

3,61671E-1

1,28409E-1

2,01509E0

5,71225E0

3,66753E-1

1,71500E0

1,45792E0

4,11680E-2

4,50835E0

1,27491E0

2,61337E-4

4,77590E-1

1,64833E1

6,66546E0

1,54815E0

6,18329E-1

3,26836E0

1,19553E1

2,76827E0

4.4

jsim

5,20412E0

1,93115E1

4,12811E0

3,61673E-1

1,28410E-1

2,01511E0

5,71234E0

3,66741E-1

1,71500E0

1,45792E0

4,11681E-2

4,50836E0

1,27491E0

2,61335E-4

4,77585E-1

1,64833E1

6,66546E0

1,54815E0

6,18327E-1

3,26839E0

1,19554E1

2,76828E0

4.4

min

5,20410E0

1,93100E1

4,12807E0

3,61664E-1

1,27791E-1

1,98471E0

5,65784E0

3,66725E-1

1,71500E0

1,45792E0

4,11376E-2

4,50085E0

1,27491E0

2,55653E-4

4,77364E-1

1,64830E1

6,66546E0

1,54811E0

6,18127E-1

3,25064E0

1,19400E1

2,76054E0

4.4

max

5,20412E0

1,93115E1

4,13839E0

3,61873E-1

1,28410E-1

2,01511E0

5,71236E0

3,80294E-1

1,71500E0

1,45853E0

4,11681E-2

4,50836E0

1,27504E0

2,61349E-4

4,77611E-1

1,64833E1

6,66550E0

1,56503E0

6,18338E-1

3,26839E0

1,19554E1

2,76829E0

4.4

mean

5,20412E0

1,93115E1

4,12814E0

3,61671E-1

1,28409E-1

2,01509E0

5,71225E0

3,66753E-1

1,71500E0

1,45792E0

4,11680E-2

4,50835E0

1,27491E0

2,61337E-4

4,77590E-1

1,64833E1

6,66546E0

1,54815E0

6,18329E-1

3,26836E0

1,19553E1

2,76827E0

4.4

relative error(%)

0,00

4.6

BioUML

5,20416E0

1,93007E1

4,35106E0

3,46254E-1

1,25598E-1

2,19678E0

5,49250E0

2,91592E-1

1,71660E0

1,46857E0

4,09412E-2

4,52494E0

1,27457E0

2,96348E-4

5,11955E-1

1,64851E1

6,66611E0

1,44163E0

6,33746E-1

3,21727E0

1,20876E1

2,72524E0

4.6

ByoDyn

5,20416E0

1,93007E1

4,35161E0

3,46196E-1

1,25600E-1

2,19798E0

5,49281E0

2,91129E-1

1,71660E0

1,46859E0

4,09408E-2

4,52512E0

1,27457E0

2,96610E-4

5,12084E-1

1,64851E1

6,66611E0

1,44089E0

6,33804E-1

3,21746E0

1,20879E1

2,72526E0

4.6

Jarnac

5,20416E0

1,93007E1

4,35161E0

3,46196E-1

1,25600E-1

2,19798E0

5,49281E0

2,91129E-1

1,71660E0

1,46859E0

4,09408E-2

4,52512E0

1,27457E0

2,96610E-4

5,12084E-1

1,64851E1

6,66611E0

1,44089E0

6,33804E-1

3,21746E0

1,20879E1

2,72526E0

4.6

MathSBML

5,20416E0

1,93007E1

4,35161E0

3,46196E-1

1,25600E-1

2,19798E0

5,49280E0

2,91129E-1

1,71660E0

1,46859E0

4,09408E-2

4,52512E0

1,27457E0

2,96610E-4

5,12084E-1

1,64851E1

6,66611E0

1,44089E0

6,33804E-1

3,21746E0

1,20879E1

2,72526E0

4.6

Oscill8 Core

5,20416E0

1,93007E1

4,35157E0

1,25599E-1

5,49274E0

2,91175E-1

1,71660E0

1,46859E0

4,09408E-2

4,52510E0

1,27457E0

2,96584E-4

5,12074E-1

1,64851E1

6,66611E0

1,44096E0

6,33800E-1

3,21743E0

1,20878E1

2,72526E0

4.6

SBToolbox2

5,20420E0

1,93060E1

4,27259E0

3,50940E-1

1,27000E-1

2,16529E0

5,60621E0

3,03826E-1

1,71655E0

1,46473E0

4,10387E-2

4,52661E0

1,27450E0

2,90153E-4

5,01316E-1

1,64850E1

6,66585E0

1,46085E0

6,29060E-1

3,24813E0

1,20987E1

2,74470E0

4.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,20416E0

1,93007E1

4,35140E0

3,46210E-1

1,25603E-1

2,19780E0

5,49301E0

2,91197E-1

1,71660E0

1,46858E0

4,09410E-2

4,52511E0

1,27457E0

2,96574E-4

5,12051E-1

1,64851E1

6,66611E0

1,44100E0

6,33790E-1

3,21751E0

1,20879E1

2,72530E0

4.6

VCell

5,20416E0

1,93007E1

4,35161E0

3,46196E-1

1,25600E-1

2,19798E0

5,49281E0

2,91129E-1

1,71660E0

1,46859E0

4,09408E-2

4,52512E0

1,27457E0

2,96610E-4

5,12084E-1

1,64851E1

6,66611E0

1,44089E0

6,33804E-1

3,21746E0

1,20879E1

2,72526E0

4.6

copasi

5,20416E0

1,93007E1

4,35166E0

3,46191E-1

1,25600E-1

2,19804E0

5,49277E0

2,91106E-1

1,71660E0

1,46859E0

4,09408E-2

4,52513E0

1,27457E0

2,96622E-4

5,12094E-1

1,64851E1

6,66611E0

1,44086E0

6,33809E-1

3,21746E0

1,20879E1

2,72526E0

4.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20416E0

1,93007E1

4,35161E0

3,46196E-1

1,25600E-1

2,19798E0

5,49281E0

2,91129E-1

1,71660E0

1,46859E0

4,09408E-2

4,52512E0

1,27457E0

2,96610E-4

5,12084E-1

1,64851E1

6,66611E0

1,44089E0

6,33804E-1

3,21746E0

1,20879E1

2,72526E0

4.6

jsim

5,20416E0

1,93007E1

4,35166E0

3,46192E-1

1,25600E-1

2,19803E0

5,49275E0

2,91108E-1

1,71660E0

1,46859E0

4,09409E-2

4,52513E0

1,27457E0

2,96619E-4

5,12093E-1

1,64851E1

6,66611E0

1,44086E0

6,33808E-1

3,21745E0

1,20880E1

2,72525E0

4.6

min

5,20416E0

1,93007E1

4,27259E0

3,46191E-1

1,25599E-1

2,16529E0

5,49274E0

2,91106E-1

1,71655E0

1,46473E0

4,09408E-2

4,52510E0

1,27450E0

2,90153E-4

5,01316E-1

1,64850E1

6,66585E0

1,44086E0

6,29060E-1

3,21743E0

1,20878E1

2,72525E0

4.6

max

5,20420E0

1,93060E1

4,35166E0

3,50940E-1

1,27000E-1

2,19804E0

5,60621E0

3,03826E-1

1,71660E0

1,46859E0

4,10387E-2

4,52661E0

1,27457E0

2,96622E-4

5,12094E-1

1,64851E1

6,66611E0

1,46085E0

6,33809E-1

3,24813E0

1,20987E1

2,74470E0

4.6

mean

5,20416E0

1,93007E1

4,35161E0

3,46196E-1

1,25600E-1

2,19798E0

5,49281E0

2,91129E-1

1,71660E0

1,46859E0

4,09408E-2

4,52512E0

1,27457E0

2,96610E-4

5,12084E-1

1,64851E1

6,66611E0

1,44089E0

6,33804E-1

3,21746E0

1,20879E1

2,72526E0

4.6

relative error(%)

0,00

4.8

BioUML

5,20419E0

1,92926E1

4,42902E0

3,45268E-1

1,22323E-1

2,08152E0

5,21666E0

3,37334E-1

1,71810E0

1,47398E0

4,07749E-2

4,49427E0

1,27523E0

2,71299E-4

5,14271E-1

1,64860E1

6,66655E0

1,51114E0

6,34732E-1

3,12635E0

1,21294E1

2,68167E0

4.8

ByoDyn

5,20419E0

1,92925E1

4,42985E0

3,45230E-1

1,22304E-1

2,08148E0

5,21509E0

3,37337E-1

1,71810E0

1,47403E0

4,07737E-2

4,49417E0

1,27523E0

2,71274E-4

5,14356E-1

1,64860E1

6,66655E0

1,51118E0

6,34770E-1

3,12587E0

1,21290E1

2,68139E0

4.8

Jarnac

5,20419E0

1,92925E1

4,42985E0

3,45230E-1

1,22304E-1

2,08148E0

5,21509E0

3,37337E-1

1,71810E0

1,47403E0

4,07737E-2

4,49417E0

1,27523E0

2,71274E-4

5,14356E-1

1,64860E1

6,66655E0

1,51118E0

6,34770E-1

3,12587E0

1,21290E1

2,68139E0

4.8

MathSBML

5,20419E0

1,92925E1

4,42984E0

3,45230E-1

1,22304E-1

2,08148E0

5,21509E0

3,37338E-1

1,71810E0

1,47403E0

4,07737E-2

4,49417E0

1,27523E0

2,71274E-4

5,14356E-1

1,64860E1

6,66655E0

1,51118E0

6,34770E-1

3,12587E0

1,21290E1

2,68139E0

4.8

Oscill8 Core

5,20419E0

1,92925E1

4,42969E0

1,22307E-1

5,21539E0

3,37341E-1

1,71810E0

1,47402E0

4,07739E-2

4,49419E0

1,27523E0

2,71281E-4

5,14341E-1

1,64860E1

6,66655E0

1,51117E0

6,34763E-1

3,12596E0

1,21291E1

2,68145E0

4.8

SBToolbox2

5,20420E0

1,92910E1

4,47116E0

3,41670E-1

1,22099E-1

2,14188E0

5,20392E0

3,12524E-1

1,71815E0

1,47590E0

4,07425E-2

4,50246E0

1,27505E0

2,83144E-4

5,22243E-1

1,64860E1

6,66660E0

1,47558E0

6,38330E-1

3,12701E0

1,21440E1

2,67844E0

4.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,20419E0

1,92925E1

4,42981E0

3,45227E-1

1,22306E-1

2,08162E0

5,21531E0

3,37284E-1

1,71810E0

1,47402E0

4,07738E-2

4,49420E0

1,27523E0

2,71307E-4

5,14362E-1

1,64860E1

6,66655E0

1,51109E0

6,34773E-1

3,12594E0

1,21291E1

2,68143E0

4.8

VCell

5,20419E0

1,92925E1

4,42985E0

3,45230E-1

1,22304E-1

2,08148E0

5,21509E0

3,37337E-1

1,71810E0

1,47403E0

4,07737E-2

4,49417E0

1,27523E0

2,71274E-4

5,14356E-1

1,64860E1

6,66655E0

1,51118E0

6,34770E-1

3,12587E0

1,21290E1

2,68139E0

4.8

copasi

5,20419E0

1,92925E1

4,42989E0

3,45228E-1

1,22302E-1

2,08145E0

5,21498E0

3,37350E-1

1,71810E0

1,47403E0

4,07736E-2

4,49416E0

1,27523E0

2,71268E-4

5,14360E-1

1,64860E1

6,66655E0

1,51120E0

6,34772E-1

3,12583E0

1,21290E1

2,68137E0

4.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20419E0

1,92925E1

4,42985E0

3,45230E-1

1,22304E-1

2,08148E0

5,21509E0

3,37337E-1

1,71810E0

1,47403E0

4,07737E-2

4,49417E0

1,27523E0

2,71274E-4

5,14356E-1

1,64860E1

6,66655E0

1,51118E0

6,34770E-1

3,12587E0

1,21290E1

2,68139E0

4.8

jsim

5,20419E0

1,92925E1

4,42984E0

3,45231E-1

1,22303E-1

2,08144E0

5,21504E0

3,37355E-1

1,71810E0

1,47403E0

4,07736E-2

4,49416E0

1,27523E0

2,71266E-4

5,14354E-1

1,64860E1

6,66655E0

1,51121E0

6,34769E-1

3,12585E0

1,21291E1

2,68138E0

4.8

min

5,20419E0

1,92910E1

4,42969E0

3,41670E-1

1,22099E-1

2,08144E0

5,20392E0

3,12524E-1

1,71810E0

1,47402E0

4,07425E-2

4,49416E0

1,27505E0

2,71266E-4

5,14341E-1

1,64860E1

6,66655E0

1,47558E0

6,34763E-1

3,12583E0

1,21290E1

2,67844E0

4.8

max

5,20420E0

1,92925E1

4,47116E0

3,45231E-1

1,22307E-1

2,14188E0

5,21539E0

3,37355E-1

1,71815E0

1,47590E0

4,07739E-2

4,50246E0

1,27523E0

2,83144E-4

5,22243E-1

1,64860E1

6,66660E0

1,51121E0

6,38330E-1

3,12701E0

1,21440E1

2,68145E0

4.8

mean

5,20419E0

1,92925E1

4,42985E0

3,45230E-1

1,22304E-1

2,08148E0

5,21509E0

3,37337E-1

1,71810E0

1,47403E0

4,07737E-2

4,49417E0

1,27523E0

2,71274E-4

5,14356E-1

1,64860E1

6,66655E0

1,51118E0

6,34770E-1

3,12587E0

1,21290E1

2,68139E0

4.8

relative error(%)

0,00

5.0

BioUML

5,20422E0

1,93132E1

4,15338E0

3,61154E-1

1,27228E-1

1,97387E0

5,61075E0

3,85250E-1

1,71946E0

1,46060E0

4,11122E-2

4,49911E0

1,27525E0

2,53622E-4

4,78565E-1

1,64874E1

6,66572E0

1,57088E0

6,18846E-1

3,23633E0

1,22709E1

2,75423E0

5.0

ByoDyn

5,20422E0

1,93133E1

4,15111E0

3,61302E-1

1,27258E-1

1,97218E0

5,61310E0

3,86021E-1

1,71946E0

1,46049E0

4,11146E-2

4,49895E0

1,27525E0

2,53337E-4

4,78240E-1

1,64873E1

6,66572E0

1,57180E0

6,18698E-1

3,23692E0

1,22706E1

2,75475E0

5.0

Jarnac

5,20422E0

1,93133E1

4,15111E0

3,61302E-1

1,27258E-1

1,97218E0

5,61310E0

3,86021E-1

1,71946E0

1,46049E0

4,11146E-2

4,49895E0

1,27525E0

2,53337E-4

4,78240E-1

1,64873E1

6,66572E0

1,57180E0

6,18698E-1

3,23692E0

1,22706E1

2,75475E0

5.0

MathSBML

5,20422E0

1,93133E1

4,15111E0

3,61302E-1

1,27258E-1

1,97218E0

5,61310E0

3,86021E-1

1,71946E0

1,46049E0

4,11147E-2

4,49895E0

1,27525E0

2,53336E-4

4,78240E-1

1,64873E1

6,66572E0

1,57180E0

6,18698E-1

3,23692E0

1,22706E1

2,75475E0

5.0

Oscill8 Core

5,20422E0

1,93133E1

4,15124E0

1,27257E-1

5,61297E0

3,85972E-1

1,71946E0

1,46050E0

4,11145E-2

4,49896E0

1,27525E0

2,53355E-4

4,78260E-1

1,64873E1

6,66572E0

1,57174E0

6,18707E-1

3,23689E0

1,22706E1

2,75472E0

5.0

SBToolbox2

5,20420E0

1,93095E1

4,20485E0

3,58855E-1

1,25960E-1

1,96595E0

5,50460E0

3,88730E-1

1,71950E0

1,46320E0

4,10360E-2

4,49250E0

1,27540E0

2,51755E-4

4,83920E-1

1,64870E1

6,66590E0

1,57535E0

6,21145E-1

3,20470E0

1,22545E1

2,73615E0

5.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,20422E0

1,93133E1

4,15133E0

3,61290E-1

1,27254E-1

1,97225E0

5,61276E0

3,85987E-1

1,71946E0

1,46051E0

4,11144E-2

4,49895E0

1,27525E0

2,53348E-4

4,78269E-1

1,64873E1

6,66572E0

1,57176E0

6,18710E-1

3,23682E0

1,22706E1

2,75468E0

5.0

VCell

5,20422E0

1,93133E1

4,15111E0

3,61302E-1

1,27258E-1

1,97218E0

5,61310E0

3,86021E-1

1,71946E0

1,46049E0

4,11146E-2

4,49895E0

1,27525E0

2,53337E-4

4,78240E-1

1,64873E1

6,66572E0

1,57180E0

6,18698E-1

3,23692E0

1,22706E1

2,75475E0

5.0

copasi

5,20422E0

1,93134E1

4,15103E0

3,61307E-1

1,27259E-1

1,97214E0

5,61319E0

3,86041E-1

1,71946E0

1,46049E0

4,11147E-2

4,49895E0

1,27525E0

2,53329E-4

4,78230E-1

1,64873E1

6,66572E0

1,57182E0

6,18693E-1

3,23695E0

1,22706E1

2,75476E0

5.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20422E0

1,93133E1

4,15111E0

3,61302E-1

1,27258E-1

1,97218E0

5,61310E0

3,86021E-1

1,71946E0

1,46049E0

4,11146E-2

4,49895E0

1,27525E0

2,53337E-4

4,78240E-1

1,64873E1

6,66572E0

1,57180E0

6,18698E-1

3,23692E0

1,22706E1

2,75475E0

5.0

jsim

5,20422E0

1,93134E1

4,15104E0

3,61306E-1

1,27260E-1

1,97217E0

5,61321E0

3,86025E-1

1,71946E0

1,46049E0

4,11147E-2

4,49896E0

1,27525E0

2,53335E-4

4,78232E-1

1,64873E1

6,66572E0

1,57180E0

6,18694E-1

3,23696E0

1,22707E1

2,75477E0

5.0

min

5,20420E0

1,93095E1

4,15103E0

3,58855E-1

1,25960E-1

1,96595E0

5,50460E0

3,85972E-1

1,71946E0

1,46049E0

4,10360E-2

4,49250E0

1,27525E0

2,51755E-4

4,78230E-1

1,64870E1

6,66572E0

1,57174E0

6,18693E-1

3,20470E0

1,22545E1

2,73615E0

5.0

max

5,20422E0

1,93134E1

4,20485E0

3,61307E-1

1,27260E-1

1,97225E0

5,61321E0

3,88730E-1

1,71950E0

1,46320E0

4,11147E-2

4,49896E0

1,27540E0

2,53355E-4

4,83920E-1

1,64873E1

6,66590E0

1,57535E0

6,21145E-1

3,23696E0

1,22707E1

2,75477E0

5.0

mean

5,20422E0

1,93133E1

4,15111E0

3,61302E-1

1,27258E-1

1,97218E0

5,61310E0

3,86021E-1

1,71946E0

1,46049E0

4,11146E-2

4,49895E0

1,27525E0

2,53337E-4

4,78240E-1

1,64873E1

6,66572E0

1,57180E0

6,18698E-1

3,23692E0

1,22706E1

2,75475E0

5.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0,19

0,00

0,11

0,00

5.2

BioUML

5,20426E0

1,93125E1

4,24058E0

3,52701E-1

1,27421E-1

2,14767E0

5,64028E0

3,10923E-1

1,72095E0

1,46451E0

4,10777E-2

4,52808E0

1,27479E0

2,86727E-4

4,96776E-1

1,64893E1

6,66593E0

1,47140E0

6,27299E-1

3,25686E0

1,24326E1

2,75213E0

5.2

ByoDyn

5,20426E0

1,93126E1

4,24018E0

3,52714E-1

1,27433E-1

2,14795E0

5,64138E0

3,10806E-1

1,72095E0

1,46448E0

4,10784E-2

4,52818E0

1,27479E0

2,86785E-4

4,96744E-1

1,64893E1

6,66593E0

1,47125E0

6,27286E-1

3,25720E0

1,24327E1

2,75230E0

5.2

Jarnac

5,20426E0

1,93126E1

4,24018E0

3,52714E-1

1,27433E-1

2,14795E0

5,64138E0

3,10806E-1

1,72095E0

1,46448E0

4,10784E-2

4,52818E0

1,27479E0

2,86785E-4

4,96744E-1

1,64893E1

6,66593E0

1,47125E0

6,27286E-1

3,25720E0

1,24327E1

2,75230E0

5.2

MathSBML

5,20426E0

1,93126E1

4,24018E0

3,52714E-1

1,27433E-1

2,14795E0

5,64137E0

3,10805E-1

1,72095E0

1,46448E0

4,10784E-2

4,52818E0

1,27479E0

2,86785E-4

4,96744E-1

1,64893E1

6,66593E0

1,47125E0

6,27286E-1

3,25720E0

1,24327E1

2,75230E0

5.2

Oscill8 Core

5,20426E0

1,93126E1

4,24027E0

1,27431E-1

5,64115E0

3,10827E-1

1,72095E0

1,46449E0

4,10782E-2

4,52816E0

1,27479E0

2,86777E-4

4,96753E-1

1,64893E1

6,66593E0

1,47127E0

6,27290E-1

3,25713E0

1,24327E1

2,75227E0

5.2

SBToolbox2

5,20430E0

1,93165E1

4,16989E0

3,57525E-1

1,28322E-1

2,09204E0

5,71156E0

3,33549E-1

1,72095E0

1,46134E0

4,11512E-2

4,52362E0

1,27490E0

2,75799E-4

4,85916E-1

1,64890E1

6,66570E0

1,50442E0

6,22475E-1

3,27348E0

1,24304E1

2,76598E0

5.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,20426E0

1,93126E1

4,24010E0

3,52722E-1

1,27433E-1

2,14779E0

5,64135E0

3,10873E-1

1,72095E0

1,46448E0

4,10784E-2

4,52815E0

1,27479E0

2,86755E-4

4,96727E-1

1,64893E1

6,66593E0

1,47134E0

6,27278E-1

3,25718E0

1,24327E1

2,75230E0

5.2

VCell

5,20426E0

1,93126E1

4,24018E0

3,52714E-1

1,27433E-1

2,14795E0

5,64138E0

3,10806E-1

1,72095E0

1,46448E0

4,10784E-2

4,52818E0

1,27479E0

2,86785E-4

4,96744E-1

1,64893E1

6,66593E0

1,47125E0

6,27286E-1

3,25720E0

1,24327E1

2,75230E0

5.2

copasi

5,20426E0

1,93126E1

4,24018E0

3,52713E-1

1,27434E-1

2,14799E0

5,64142E0

3,10789E-1

1,72095E0

1,46448E0

4,10784E-2

4,52818E0

1,27479E0

2,86794E-4

4,96746E-1

1,64893E1

6,66593E0

1,47122E0

6,27287E-1

3,25722E0

1,24327E1

2,75231E0

5.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20426E0

1,93126E1

4,24018E0

3,52714E-1

1,27433E-1

2,14795E0

5,64138E0

3,10806E-1

1,72095E0

1,46448E0

4,10784E-2

4,52818E0

1,27479E0

2,86785E-4

4,96744E-1

1,64893E1

6,66593E0

1,47125E0

6,27286E-1

3,25720E0

1,24327E1

2,75230E0

5.2

jsim

5,20426E0

1,93126E1

4,24020E0

3,52712E-1

1,27433E-1

2,14800E0

5,64139E0

3,10786E-1

1,72095E0

1,46449E0

4,10784E-2

4,52819E0

1,27479E0

2,86795E-4

4,96749E-1

1,64893E1

6,66593E0

1,47122E0

6,27288E-1

3,25721E0

1,24328E1

2,75230E0

5.2

min

5,20426E0

1,93126E1

4,16989E0

3,52712E-1

1,27431E-1

2,09204E0

5,64115E0

3,10786E-1

1,72095E0

1,46134E0

4,10782E-2

4,52362E0

1,27479E0

2,75799E-4

4,85916E-1

1,64890E1

6,66570E0

1,47122E0

6,22475E-1

3,25713E0

1,24304E1

2,75227E0

5.2

max

5,20430E0

1,93165E1

4,24027E0

3,57525E-1

1,28322E-1

2,14800E0

5,71156E0

3,33549E-1

1,72095E0

1,46449E0

4,11512E-2

4,52819E0

1,27490E0

2,86795E-4

4,96753E-1

1,64893E1

6,66593E0

1,50442E0

6,27290E-1

3,27348E0

1,24328E1

2,76598E0

5.2

mean

5,20426E0

1,93126E1

4,24018E0

3,52714E-1

1,27433E-1

2,14795E0

5,64138E0

3,10806E-1

1,72095E0

1,46448E0

4,10784E-2

4,52818E0

1,27479E0

2,86785E-4

4,96744E-1

1,64893E1

6,66593E0

1,47125E0

6,27286E-1

3,25720E0

1,24327E1

2,75230E0

5.2

relative error(%)

0,00

5.4

BioUML

5,20429E0

1,92953E1

4,48096E0

3,40377E-1

1,22046E-1

2,16276E0

5,20150E0

3,04330E-1

1,72246E0

1,47766E0

4,07384E-2

4,50739E0

1,27530E0

2,87515E-4

5,24539E-1

1,64904E1

6,66678E0

1,46291E0

6,39623E-1

3,12802E0

1,24763E1

2,67904E0

5.4

ByoDyn

5,20429E0

1,92953E1

4,48156E0

3,40340E-1

1,22035E-1

2,16303E0

5,20068E0

3,04234E-1

1,72246E0

1,47769E0

4,07374E-2

4,50738E0

1,27530E0

2,87572E-4

5,24624E-1

1,64904E1

6,66679E0

1,46274E0

6,39660E-1

3,12779E0

1,24761E1

2,67890E0

5.4

Jarnac

5,20429E0

1,92953E1

4,48156E0

3,40340E-1

1,22035E-1

2,16303E0

5,20068E0

3,04234E-1

1,72246E0

1,47769E0

4,07374E-2

4,50738E0

1,27530E0

2,87572E-4

5,24624E-1

1,64904E1

6,66679E0

1,46274E0

6,39660E-1

3,12779E0

1,24761E1

2,67890E0

5.4

MathSBML

5,20429E0

1,92953E1

4,48156E0

3,40340E-1

1,22035E-1

2,16303E0

5,20068E0

3,04234E-1

1,72246E0

1,47769E0

4,07374E-2

4,50738E0

1,27530E0

2,87572E-4

5,24624E-1

1,64904E1

6,66679E0

1,46274E0

6,39660E-1

3,12779E0

1,24761E1

2,67890E0

5.4

Oscill8 Core

5,20429E0

1,92953E1

4,48133E0

1,22039E-1

5,20101E0

3,04282E-1

1,72246E0

1,47768E0

4,07377E-2

4,50738E0

1,27530E0

2,87554E-4

5,24592E-1

1,64904E1

6,66679E0

1,46280E0

6,39646E-1

3,12788E0

1,24761E1

2,67896E0

5.4

SBToolbox2

5,20430E0

1,92985E1

4,45840E0

3,40403E-1

1,23085E-1

2,20417E0

5,28855E0

2,88477E-1

1,72245E0

1,47608E0

4,07901E-2

4,51812E0

1,27510E0

2,96858E-4

5,24461E-1

1,64910E1

6,66665E0

1,43734E0

6,39597E-1

3,15752E0

1,25025E1

2,69304E0

5.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,20429E0

1,92953E1

4,48133E0

3,40351E-1

1,22041E-1

2,16304E0

5,20113E0

3,04235E-1

1,72246E0

1,47768E0

4,07377E-2

4,50740E0

1,27530E0

2,87580E-4

5,24599E-1

1,64904E1

6,66679E0

1,46273E0

6,39649E-1

3,12793E0

1,24761E1

2,67898E0

5.4

VCell

5,20429E0

1,92953E1

4,48156E0

3,40340E-1

1,22035E-1

2,16303E0

5,20068E0

3,04234E-1

1,72246E0

1,47769E0

4,07374E-2

4,50738E0

1,27530E0

2,87572E-4

5,24624E-1

1,64904E1

6,66679E0

1,46274E0

6,39660E-1

3,12779E0

1,24761E1

2,67890E0

5.4

copasi

5,20429E0

1,92953E1

4,48166E0

3,40334E-1

1,22033E-1

2,16305E0

5,20052E0

3,04225E-1

1,72246E0

1,47769E0

4,07372E-2

4,50737E0

1,27530E0

2,87576E-4

5,24636E-1

1,64904E1

6,66679E0

1,46273E0

6,39666E-1

3,12774E0

1,24760E1

2,67888E0

5.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20429E0

1,92953E1

4,48156E0

3,40340E-1

1,22035E-1

2,16303E0

5,20068E0

3,04234E-1

1,72246E0

1,47769E0

4,07374E-2

4,50738E0

1,27530E0

2,87572E-4

5,24624E-1

1,64904E1

6,66679E0

1,46274E0

6,39660E-1

3,12779E0

1,24761E1

2,67890E0

5.4

jsim

5,20429E0

1,92953E1

4,48164E0

3,40336E-1

1,22033E-1

2,16303E0

5,20054E0

3,04232E-1

1,72246E0

1,47769E0

4,07372E-2

4,50737E0

1,27530E0

2,87572E-4

5,24632E-1

1,64904E1

6,66679E0

1,46274E0

6,39664E-1

3,12775E0

1,24761E1

2,67888E0

5.4

min

5,20429E0

1,92953E1

4,45840E0

3,40334E-1

1,22033E-1

2,16303E0

5,20052E0

2,88477E-1

1,72245E0

1,47608E0

4,07372E-2

4,50737E0

1,27510E0

2,87554E-4

5,24461E-1

1,64904E1

6,66665E0

1,43734E0

6,39597E-1

3,12774E0

1,24760E1

2,67888E0

5.4

max

5,20430E0

1,92985E1

4,48166E0

3,40403E-1

1,23085E-1

2,20417E0

5,28855E0

3,04282E-1

1,72246E0

1,47769E0

4,07901E-2

4,51812E0

1,27530E0

2,96858E-4

5,24636E-1

1,64910E1

6,66679E0

1,46280E0

6,39666E-1

3,15752E0

1,25025E1

2,69304E0

5.4

mean

5,20429E0

1,92953E1

4,48156E0

3,40340E-1

1,22035E-1

2,16303E0

5,20068E0

3,04234E-1

1,72246E0

1,47769E0

4,07374E-2

4,50738E0

1,27530E0

2,87572E-4

5,24624E-1

1,64904E1

6,66679E0

1,46274E0

6,39660E-1

3,12779E0

1,24761E1

2,67890E0

5.4

relative error(%)

0,00

5.6

BioUML

5,20432E0

1,93119E1

4,22744E0

3,57456E-1

1,25375E-1

1,96747E0

5,45707E0

3,87965E-1

1,72377E0

1,46575E0

4,10061E-2

4,49226E0

1,27580E0

2,51848E-4

4,86489E-1

1,64914E1

6,66613E0

1,57457E0

6,22544E-1

3,19081E0

1,25687E1

2,72904E0

5.6

ByoDyn

5,20432E0

1,93119E1

4,22667E0

3,57522E-1

1,25378E-1

1,96626E0

5,45714E0

3,88526E-1

1,72377E0

1,46571E0

4,10066E-2

4,49206E0

1,27581E0

2,51641E-4

4,86353E-1

1,64914E1

6,66613E0

1,57522E0

6,22478E-1

3,19076E0

1,25682E1

2,72912E0

5.6

Jarnac

5,20432E0

1,93119E1

4,22667E0

3,57522E-1

1,25378E-1

1,96626E0

5,45714E0

3,88526E-1

1,72377E0

1,46571E0

4,10066E-2

4,49206E0

1,27581E0

2,51641E-4

4,86353E-1

1,64914E1

6,66613E0

1,57522E0

6,22478E-1

3,19076E0

1,25682E1

2,72912E0

5.6

MathSBML

5,20432E0

1,93119E1

4,22667E0

3,57522E-1

1,25378E-1

1,96626E0

5,45715E0

3,88526E-1

1,72377E0

1,46571E0

4,10066E-2

4,49206E0

1,27581E0

2,51641E-4

4,86352E-1

1,64914E1

6,66613E0

1,57522E0

6,22478E-1

3,19077E0

1,25682E1

2,72912E0

5.6

Oscill8 Core

5,20432E0

1,93119E1

4,22675E0

1,25378E-1

5,45714E0

3,88470E-1

1,72377E0

1,46571E0

4,10065E-2

4,49208E0

1,27581E0

2,51662E-4

4,86367E-1

1,64914E1

6,66613E0

1,57515E0

6,22485E-1

3,19077E0

1,25682E1

2,72911E0

5.6

SBToolbox2

5,20430E0

1,93054E1

4,31680E0

3,52406E-1

1,23729E-1

1,99849E0

5,32460E0

3,73577E-1

1,72384E0

1,47025E0

4,08958E-2

4,49036E0

1,27580E0

2,56596E-4

4,97748E-1

1,64910E1

6,66640E0

1,55798E0

6,27594E-1

3,15330E0

1,25596E1

2,70440E0

5.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,20432E0

1,93119E1

4,22692E0

3,57506E-1

1,25374E-1

1,96642E0

5,45686E0

3,88451E-1

1,72377E0

1,46572E0

4,10063E-2

4,49207E0

1,27581E0

2,51668E-4

4,86388E-1

1,64914E1

6,66613E0

1,57513E0

6,22494E-1

3,19069E0

1,25682E1

2,72906E0

5.6

VCell

5,20432E0

1,93119E1

4,22667E0

3,57522E-1

1,25378E-1

1,96626E0

5,45714E0

3,88526E-1

1,72377E0

1,46571E0

4,10066E-2

4,49206E0

1,27581E0

2,51641E-4

4,86353E-1

1,64914E1

6,66613E0

1,57522E0

6,22478E-1

3,19076E0

1,25682E1

2,72912E0

5.6

copasi

5,20432E0

1,93119E1

4,22661E0

3,57526E-1

1,25378E-1

1,96619E0

5,45718E0

3,88557E-1

1,72377E0

1,46571E0

4,10066E-2

4,49205E0

1,27581E0

2,51630E-4

4,86343E-1

1,64914E1

6,66613E0

1,57525E0

6,22474E-1

3,19077E0

1,25681E1

2,72913E0

5.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20432E0

1,93119E1

4,22667E0

3,57522E-1

1,25378E-1

1,96626E0

5,45714E0

3,88526E-1

1,72377E0

1,46571E0

4,10066E-2

4,49206E0

1,27581E0

2,51641E-4

4,86353E-1

1,64914E1

6,66613E0

1,57522E0

6,22478E-1

3,19076E0

1,25682E1

2,72912E0

5.6

jsim

5,20432E0

1,93119E1

4,22658E0

3,57527E-1

1,25379E-1

1,96621E0

5,45725E0

3,88548E-1

1,72377E0

1,46571E0

4,10067E-2

4,49206E0

1,27581E0

2,51634E-4

4,86341E-1

1,64914E1

6,66613E0

1,57524E0

6,22473E-1

3,19079E0

1,25682E1

2,72914E0

5.6

min

5,20430E0

1,93054E1

4,22658E0

3,52406E-1

1,23729E-1

1,96619E0

5,32460E0

3,73577E-1

1,72377E0

1,46571E0

4,08958E-2

4,49036E0

1,27580E0

2,51630E-4

4,86341E-1

1,64910E1

6,66613E0

1,55798E0

6,22473E-1

3,15330E0

1,25596E1

2,70440E0

5.6

max

5,20432E0

1,93119E1

4,31680E0

3,57527E-1

1,25379E-1

1,99849E0

5,45725E0

3,88557E-1

1,72384E0

1,47025E0

4,10067E-2

4,49208E0

1,27581E0

2,56596E-4

4,97748E-1

1,64914E1

6,66640E0

1,57525E0

6,27594E-1

3,19079E0

1,25682E1

2,72914E0

5.6

mean

5,20432E0

1,93119E1

4,22667E0

3,57522E-1

1,25378E-1

1,96626E0

5,45714E0

3,88526E-1

1,72377E0

1,46571E0

4,10066E-2

4,49206E0

1,27581E0

2,51641E-4

4,86353E-1

1,64914E1

6,66613E0

1,57522E0

6,22478E-1

3,19076E0

1,25682E1

2,72912E0

5.6

relative error(%)

0,00

5.8

BioUML

5,20435E0

1,93218E1

4,15495E0

3,58344E-1

1,28375E-1

2,07682E0

5,71530E0

3,40068E-1

1,72513E0

1,46205E0

4,11662E-2

4,52326E0

1,27539E0

2,72982E-4

4,83512E-1

1,64933E1

6,66585E0

1,51311E0

6,21656E-1

3,27367E0

1,27406E1

2,76868E0

5.8

ByoDyn

5,20435E0

1,93218E1

4,15409E0

3,58390E-1

1,28393E-1

2,07669E0

5,71680E0

3,40113E-1

1,72513E0

1,46201E0

4,11674E-2

4,52331E0

1,27539E0

2,72959E-4

4,83407E-1

1,64933E1

6,66585E0

1,51320E0

6,21610E-1

3,27409E0

1,27406E1

2,76893E0

5.8

Jarnac

5,20435E0

1,93218E1

4,15409E0

3,58390E-1

1,28393E-1

2,07669E0

5,71680E0

3,40113E-1

1,72513E0

1,46201E0

4,11674E-2

4,52331E0

1,27539E0

2,72959E-4

4,83407E-1

1,64933E1

6,66585E0

1,51320E0

6,21610E-1

3,27409E0

1,27406E1

2,76893E0

5.8

MathSBML

5,20435E0

1,93218E1

4,15409E0

3,58390E-1

1,28393E-1

2,07669E0

5,71680E0

3,40113E-1

1,72513E0

1,46201E0

4,11674E-2

4,52331E0

1,27539E0

2,72959E-4

4,83407E-1

1,64933E1

6,66585E0

1,51320E0

6,21610E-1

3,27409E0

1,27406E1

2,76893E0

5.8

Oscill8 Core

5,20435E0

1,93218E1

4,15424E0

1,28389E-1

5,71653E0

3,40107E-1

1,72513E0

1,46201E0

4,11672E-2

4,52329E0

1,27539E0

2,72966E-4

4,83427E-1

1,64933E1

6,66585E0

1,51318E0

6,21619E-1

3,27402E0

1,27406E1

2,76888E0

5.8

SBToolbox2

5,20430E0

1,93230E1

4,12355E0

3,61247E-1

1,28334E-1

2,01775E0

5,70737E0

3,65520E-1

1,72514E0

1,46080E0

4,11808E-2

4,51376E0

1,27560E0

2,61852E-4

4,77181E-1

1,64930E1

6,66580E0

1,54678E0

6,18753E-1

3,26743E0

1,27248E1

2,77024E0

5.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,20435E0

1,93218E1

4,15414E0

3,58389E-1

1,28390E-1

2,07658E0

5,71658E0

3,40164E-1

1,72513E0

1,46201E0

4,11673E-2

4,52328E0

1,27539E0

2,72940E-4

4,83408E-1

1,64933E1

6,66585E0

1,51326E0

6,21611E-1

3,27402E0

1,27405E1

2,76890E0

5.8

VCell

5,20435E0

1,93218E1

4,15409E0

3,58390E-1

1,28393E-1

2,07669E0

5,71680E0

3,40113E-1

1,72513E0

1,46201E0

4,11674E-2

4,52331E0

1,27539E0

2,72959E-4

4,83407E-1

1,64933E1

6,66585E0

1,51320E0

6,21610E-1

3,27409E0

1,27406E1

2,76893E0

5.8

copasi

5,20435E0

1,93218E1

4,15404E0

3,58392E-1

1,28394E-1

2,07670E0

5,71691E0

3,40109E-1

1,72513E0

1,46200E0

4,11675E-2

4,52331E0

1,27539E0

2,72962E-4

4,83402E-1

1,64933E1

6,66585E0

1,51319E0

6,21608E-1

3,27413E0

1,27406E1

2,76895E0

5.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20435E0

1,93218E1

4,15409E0

3,58390E-1

1,28393E-1

2,07669E0

5,71680E0

3,40113E-1

1,72513E0

1,46201E0

4,11674E-2

4,52331E0

1,27539E0

2,72959E-4

4,83407E-1

1,64933E1

6,66585E0

1,51320E0

6,21610E-1

3,27409E0

1,27406E1

2,76893E0

5.8

jsim

5,20435E0

1,93218E1

4,15406E0

3,58390E-1

1,28393E-1

2,07672E0

5,71688E0

3,40098E-1

1,72513E0

1,46200E0

4,11674E-2

4,52332E0

1,27539E0

2,72966E-4

4,83406E-1

1,64933E1

6,66585E0

1,51318E0

6,21610E-1

3,27412E0

1,27407E1

2,76894E0

5.8

min

5,20430E0

1,93218E1

4,12355E0

3,58389E-1

1,28334E-1

2,01775E0

5,70737E0

3,40098E-1

1,72513E0

1,46080E0

4,11672E-2

4,51376E0

1,27539E0

2,61852E-4

4,77181E-1

1,64930E1

6,66580E0

1,51318E0

6,18753E-1

3,26743E0

1,27248E1

2,76888E0

5.8

max

5,20435E0

1,93230E1

4,15424E0

3,61247E-1

1,28394E-1

2,07672E0

5,71691E0

3,65520E-1

1,72514E0

1,46201E0

4,11808E-2

4,52332E0

1,27560E0

2,72966E-4

4,83427E-1

1,64933E1

6,66585E0

1,54678E0

6,21619E-1

3,27413E0

1,27407E1

2,77024E0

5.8

mean

5,20435E0

1,93218E1

4,15409E0

3,58390E-1

1,28393E-1

2,07669E0

5,71680E0

3,40113E-1

1,72513E0

1,46201E0

4,11674E-2

4,52331E0

1,27539E0

2,72959E-4

4,83407E-1

1,64933E1

6,66585E0

1,51320E0

6,21610E-1

3,27409E0

1,27406E1

2,76893E0

5.8

relative error(%)

0,00

6.0

BioUML

5,20438E0

1,93039E1

4,44979E0

3,40388E-1

1,23264E-1

2,21029E0

5,30406E0

2,86232E-1

1,72661E0

1,47703E0

4,08060E-2

4,52147E0

1,27560E0

2,98371E-4

5,23862E-1

1,64948E1

6,66676E0

1,43348E0

6,39612E-1

3,16274E0

1,28144E1

2,69688E0

6.0

ByoDyn

5,20438E0

1,93038E1

4,45102E0

3,40296E-1

1,23250E-1

2,21143E0

5,30299E0

2,85803E-1

1,72661E0

1,47708E0

4,08044E-2

4,52156E0

1,27559E0

2,98615E-4

5,24069E-1

1,64948E1

6,66677E0

1,43277E0

6,39704E-1

3,16251E0

1,28143E1

2,69670E0

6.0

Jarnac

5,20438E0

1,93038E1

4,45102E0

3,40296E-1

1,23250E-1

2,21143E0

5,30299E0

2,85803E-1

1,72661E0

1,47708E0

4,08044E-2

4,52156E0

1,27559E0

2,98615E-4

5,24069E-1

1,64948E1

6,66677E0

1,43277E0

6,39704E-1

3,16251E0

1,28143E1

2,69670E0

6.0

MathSBML

5,20438E0

1,93038E1

4,45102E0

3,40296E-1

1,23250E-1

2,21143E0

5,30299E0

2,85803E-1

1,72661E0

1,47708E0

4,08044E-2

4,52156E0

1,27559E0

2,98615E-4

5,24069E-1

1,64948E1

6,66677E0

1,43277E0

6,39704E-1

3,16251E0

1,28143E1

2,69670E0

6.0

Oscill8 Core

5,20438E0

1,93038E1

4,45085E0

1,23251E-1

5,30314E0

2,85864E-1

1,72661E0

1,47708E0

4,08046E-2

4,52154E0

1,27559E0

2,98581E-4

5,24040E-1

1,64948E1

6,66677E0

1,43287E0

6,39692E-1

3,16254E0

1,28143E1

2,69672E0

6.0

SBToolbox2

5,20440E0

1,93106E1

4,36154E0

3,44924E-1

1,25232E-1

2,20466E0

5,46410E0

2,88528E-1

1,72660E0

1,47226E0

4,09322E-2

4,52948E0

1,27544E0

2,98006E-4

5,13582E-1

1,64950E1

6,66644E0

1,43682E0

6,35076E-1

3,20990E0

1,28398E1

2,72334E0

6.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,20438E0

1,93038E1

4,45069E0

3,40315E-1

1,23255E-1

2,21129E0

5,30346E0

2,85854E-1

1,72661E0

1,47707E0

4,08049E-2

4,52157E0

1,27559E0

2,98588E-4

5,24024E-1

1,64948E1

6,66677E0

1,43285E0

6,39685E-1

3,16264E0

1,28144E1

2,69677E0

6.0

VCell

5,20438E0

1,93038E1

4,45102E0

3,40296E-1

1,23250E-1

2,21143E0

5,30299E0

2,85803E-1

1,72661E0

1,47708E0

4,08044E-2

4,52156E0

1,27559E0

2,98615E-4

5,24069E-1

1,64948E1

6,66677E0

1,43277E0

6,39704E-1

3,16251E0

1,28143E1

2,69670E0

6.0

copasi

5,20438E0

1,93038E1

4,45112E0

3,40289E-1

1,23248E-1

2,21148E0

5,30287E0

2,85782E-1

1,72661E0

1,47709E0

4,08043E-2

4,52156E0

1,27559E0

2,98626E-4

5,24083E-1

1,64948E1

6,66677E0

1,43273E0

6,39711E-1

3,16248E0

1,28143E1

2,69667E0

6.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20438E0

1,93038E1

4,45102E0

3,40296E-1

1,23250E-1

2,21143E0

5,30299E0

2,85803E-1

1,72661E0

1,47708E0

4,08044E-2

4,52156E0

1,27559E0

2,98615E-4

5,24069E-1

1,64948E1

6,66677E0

1,43277E0

6,39704E-1

3,16251E0

1,28143E1

2,69670E0

6.0

jsim

5,20438E0

1,93038E1

4,45112E0

3,40289E-1

1,23248E-1

2,21148E0

5,30285E0

2,85783E-1

1,72661E0

1,47709E0

4,08043E-2

4,52156E0

1,27559E0

2,98625E-4

5,24083E-1

1,64948E1

6,66677E0

1,43274E0

6,39711E-1

3,16248E0

1,28144E1

2,69667E0

6.0

min

5,20438E0

1,93038E1

4,36154E0

3,40289E-1

1,23248E-1

2,20466E0

5,30285E0

2,85782E-1

1,72660E0

1,47226E0

4,08043E-2

4,52154E0

1,27544E0

2,98006E-4

5,13582E-1

1,64948E1

6,66644E0

1,43273E0

6,35076E-1

3,16248E0

1,28143E1

2,69667E0

6.0

max

5,20440E0

1,93106E1

4,45112E0

3,44924E-1

1,25232E-1

2,21148E0

5,46410E0

2,88528E-1

1,72661E0

1,47709E0

4,09322E-2

4,52948E0

1,27559E0

2,98626E-4

5,24083E-1

1,64950E1

6,66677E0

1,43682E0

6,39711E-1

3,20990E0

1,28398E1

2,72334E0

6.0

mean

5,20438E0

1,93038E1

4,45102E0

3,40296E-1

1,23250E-1

2,21143E0

5,30299E0

2,85803E-1

1,72661E0

1,47708E0

4,08044E-2

4,52156E0

1,27559E0

2,98615E-4

5,24069E-1

1,64948E1

6,66677E0

1,43277E0

6,39704E-1

3,16251E0

1,28143E1

2,69670E0

6.0

relative error(%)

0,00

6.2

BioUML

5,20441E0

1,93087E1

4,33567E0

3,51018E-1

1,23296E-1

2,00603E0

5,29044E0

3,70197E-1

1,72791E0

1,47272E0

4,08740E-2

4,49130E0

1,27645E0

2,57835E-4

5,00195E-1

1,64956E1

6,66662E0

1,55377E0

6,28982E-1

3,14365E0

1,28586E1

2,69961E0

6.2

ByoDyn

5,20441E0

1,93087E1

4,33593E0

3,51018E-1

1,23284E-1

2,00549E0

5,28938E0

3,70430E-1

1,72791E0

1,47274E0

4,08733E-2

4,49115E0

1,27645E0

2,57730E-4

5,00196E-1

1,64955E1

6,66662E0

1,55408E0

6,28982E-1

3,14329E0

1,28581E1

2,69944E0

6.2

Jarnac

5,20441E0

1,93087E1

4,33593E0

3,51018E-1

1,23284E-1

2,00549E0

5,28938E0

3,70430E-1

1,72791E0

1,47274E0

4,08733E-2

4,49115E0

1,27645E0

2,57730E-4

5,00196E-1

1,64955E1

6,66662E0

1,55408E0

6,28982E-1

3,14329E0

1,28581E1

2,69944E0

6.2

MathSBML

5,20441E0

1,93087E1

4,33592E0

3,51019E-1

1,23284E-1

2,00549E0

5,28938E0

3,70430E-1

1,72791E0

1,47274E0

4,08733E-2

4,49115E0

1,27645E0

2,57729E-4

5,00196E-1

1,64955E1

6,66662E0

1,55408E0

6,28981E-1

3,14329E0

1,28581E1

2,69944E0

6.2

Oscill8 Core

5,20441E0

1,93087E1

4,33590E0

1,23285E-1

5,28953E0

3,70391E-1

1,72791E0

1,47274E0

4,08734E-2

4,49117E0

1,27645E0

2,57749E-4

5,00199E-1

1,64955E1

6,66662E0

1,55403E0

6,28983E-1

3,14334E0

1,28582E1

2,69947E0

6.2

SBToolbox2

5,20440E0

1,93030E1

4,43320E0

3,44487E-1

1,21969E-1

2,07884E0

5,18892E0

3,38406E-1

1,72794E0

1,47757E0

4,07699E-2

4,49701E0

1,27630E0

2,70712E-4

5,14580E-1

1,64960E1

6,66690E0

1,51281E0

6,35513E-1

3,11800E0

1,28641E1

2,67996E0

6.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,20441E0

1,93087E1

4,33612E0

3,51004E-1

1,23282E-1

2,00571E0

5,28927E0

3,70334E-1

1,72791E0

1,47275E0

4,08732E-2

4,49118E0

1,27645E0

2,57770E-4

5,00228E-1

1,64955E1

6,66662E0

1,55396E0

6,28996E-1

3,14327E0

1,28582E1

2,69942E0

6.2

VCell

5,20441E0

1,93087E1

4,33593E0

3,51018E-1

1,23284E-1

2,00549E0

5,28938E0

3,70430E-1

1,72791E0

1,47274E0

4,08733E-2

4,49115E0

1,27645E0

2,57730E-4

5,00196E-1

1,64955E1

6,66662E0

1,55408E0

6,28982E-1

3,14329E0

1,28581E1

2,69944E0

6.2

copasi

5,20441E0

1,93087E1

4,33592E0

3,51020E-1

1,23283E-1

2,00543E0

5,28934E0

3,70456E-1

1,72791E0

1,47274E0

4,08733E-2

4,49114E0

1,27645E0

2,57719E-4

5,00192E-1

1,64955E1

6,66662E0

1,55412E0

6,28980E-1

3,14327E0

1,28581E1

2,69944E0

6.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20441E0

1,93087E1

4,33593E0

3,51018E-1

1,23284E-1

2,00549E0

5,28938E0

3,70430E-1

1,72791E0

1,47274E0

4,08733E-2

4,49115E0

1,27645E0

2,57730E-4

5,00196E-1

1,64955E1

6,66662E0

1,55408E0

6,28982E-1

3,14329E0

1,28581E1

2,69944E0

6.2

jsim

5,20441E0

1,93087E1

4,33586E0

3,51023E-1

1,23284E-1

2,00542E0

5,28941E0

3,70461E-1

1,72791E0

1,47273E0

4,08734E-2

4,49114E0

1,27645E0

2,57717E-4

5,00186E-1

1,64955E1

6,66662E0

1,55412E0

6,28977E-1

3,14330E0

1,28582E1

2,69945E0

6.2

min

5,20440E0

1,93030E1

4,33586E0

3,44487E-1

1,21969E-1

2,00542E0

5,18892E0

3,38406E-1

1,72791E0

1,47273E0

4,07699E-2

4,49114E0

1,27630E0

2,57717E-4

5,00186E-1

1,64955E1

6,66662E0

1,51281E0

6,28977E-1

3,11800E0

1,28581E1

2,67996E0

6.2

max

5,20441E0

1,93087E1

4,43320E0

3,51023E-1

1,23285E-1

2,07884E0

5,28953E0

3,70461E-1

1,72794E0

1,47757E0

4,08734E-2

4,49701E0

1,27645E0

2,70712E-4

5,14580E-1

1,64960E1

6,66690E0

1,55412E0

6,35513E-1

3,14334E0

1,28641E1

2,69947E0

6.2

mean

5,20441E0

1,93087E1

4,33593E0

3,51018E-1

1,23284E-1

2,00549E0

5,28938E0

3,70430E-1

1,72791E0

1,47274E0

4,08733E-2

4,49115E0

1,27645E0

2,57730E-4

5,00196E-1

1,64955E1

6,66662E0

1,55408E0

6,28982E-1

3,14329E0

1,28581E1

2,69944E0

6.2

relative error(%)

0,00

6.4

BioUML

5,20443E0

1,93272E1

4,12162E0

3,61236E-1

1,28179E-1

2,00997E0

5,69438E0

3,69063E-1

1,72916E0

1,46222E0

4,11808E-2

4,51325E0

1,27629E0

2,60488E-4

4,76636E-1

1,64972E1

6,66592E0

1,55097E0

6,18764E-1

3,26330E0

1,30173E1

2,76984E0

6.4

ByoDyn

5,20443E0

1,93273E1

4,12018E0

3,61321E-1

1,28203E-1

2,00931E0

5,69637E0

3,69344E-1

1,72916E0

1,46215E0

4,11826E-2

4,51323E0

1,27630E0

2,60374E-4

4,76444E-1

1,64972E1

6,66592E0

1,55134E0

6,18679E-1

3,26383E0

1,30172E1

2,77021E0

6.4

Jarnac

5,20443E0

1,93273E1

4,12018E0

3,61321E-1

1,28203E-1

2,00931E0

5,69637E0

3,69344E-1

1,72916E0

1,46215E0

4,11826E-2

4,51323E0

1,27630E0

2,60374E-4

4,76444E-1

1,64972E1

6,66592E0

1,55134E0

6,18679E-1

3,26383E0

1,30172E1

2,77021E0

6.4

MathSBML

5,20443E0

1,93273E1

4,12018E0

3,61321E-1

1,28203E-1

2,00932E0

5,69637E0

3,69343E-1

1,72916E0

1,46215E0

4,11826E-2

4,51323E0

1,27630E0

2,60375E-4

4,76444E-1

1,64972E1

6,66592E0

1,55134E0

6,18679E-1

3,26383E0

1,30172E1

2,77021E0

6.4

Oscill8 Core

5,20443E0

1,93273E1

4,12034E0

1,28201E-1

5,69616E0

3,69314E-1

1,72916E0

1,46216E0

4,11824E-2

4,51323E0

1,27630E0

2,60388E-4

4,76465E-1

1,64972E1

6,66592E0

1,55130E0

6,18688E-1

3,26377E0

1,30172E1

2,77017E0

6.4

SBToolbox2

5,20440E0

1,93244E1

4,14669E0

3,60954E-1

1,27093E-1

1,96907E0

5,60024E0

3,87436E-1

1,72920E0

1,46366E0

4,11240E-2

4,50201E0

1,27650E0

2,52840E-4

4,77614E-1

1,64970E1

6,66600E0

1,57348E0

6,19046E-1

3,23329E0

1,29942E1

2,75582E0

6.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,20443E0

1,93273E1

4,12035E0

3,61314E-1

1,28199E-1

2,00928E0

5,69602E0

3,69361E-1

1,72916E0

1,46216E0

4,11823E-2

4,51321E0

1,27630E0

2,60368E-4

4,76462E-1

1,64972E1

6,66592E0

1,55136E0

6,18686E-1

3,26373E0

1,30172E1

2,77015E0

6.4

VCell

5,20443E0

1,93273E1

4,12018E0

3,61321E-1

1,28203E-1

2,00931E0

5,69637E0

3,69344E-1

1,72916E0

1,46215E0

4,11826E-2

4,51323E0

1,27630E0

2,60374E-4

4,76444E-1

1,64972E1

6,66592E0

1,55134E0

6,18679E-1

3,26383E0

1,30172E1

2,77021E0

6.4

copasi

5,20443E0

1,93273E1

4,12011E0

3,61325E-1

1,28205E-1

2,00929E0

5,69648E0

3,69353E-1

1,72916E0

1,46215E0

4,11827E-2

4,51323E0

1,27630E0

2,60371E-4

4,76436E-1

1,64972E1

6,66592E0

1,55135E0

6,18675E-1

3,26386E0

1,30172E1

2,77023E0

6.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20443E0

1,93273E1

4,12018E0

3,61321E-1

1,28203E-1

2,00931E0

5,69637E0

3,69344E-1

1,72916E0

1,46215E0

4,11826E-2

4,51323E0

1,27630E0

2,60374E-4

4,76444E-1

1,64972E1

6,66592E0

1,55134E0

6,18679E-1

3,26383E0

1,30172E1

2,77021E0

6.4

jsim

5,20443E0

1,93273E1

4,12012E0

3,61324E-1

1,28205E-1

2,00932E0

5,69649E0

3,69333E-1

1,72916E0

1,46215E0

4,11828E-2

4,51324E0

1,27630E0

2,60372E-4

4,76436E-1

1,64972E1

6,66592E0

1,55135E0

6,18676E-1

3,26387E0

1,30173E1

2,77023E0

6.4

min

5,20440E0

1,93244E1

4,12011E0

3,60954E-1

1,27093E-1

1,96907E0

5,60024E0

3,69314E-1

1,72916E0

1,46215E0

4,11240E-2

4,50201E0

1,27630E0

2,52840E-4

4,76436E-1

1,64970E1

6,66592E0

1,55130E0

6,18675E-1

3,23329E0

1,29942E1

2,75582E0

6.4

max

5,20443E0

1,93273E1

4,14669E0

3,61325E-1

1,28205E-1

2,00932E0

5,69649E0

3,87436E-1

1,72920E0

1,46366E0

4,11828E-2

4,51324E0

1,27650E0

2,60388E-4

4,77614E-1

1,64972E1

6,66600E0

1,57348E0

6,19046E-1

3,26387E0

1,30173E1

2,77023E0

6.4

mean

5,20443E0

1,93273E1

4,12018E0

3,61321E-1

1,28203E-1

2,00931E0

5,69637E0

3,69344E-1

1,72916E0

1,46215E0

4,11826E-2

4,51323E0

1,27630E0

2,60374E-4

4,76444E-1

1,64972E1

6,66592E0

1,55134E0

6,18679E-1

3,26383E0

1,30172E1

2,77021E0

6.4

relative error(%)

0,00

6.6

BioUML

5,20446E0

1,93160E1

4,35281E0

3,45102E-1

1,25309E-1

2,20305E0

5,47091E0

2,89217E-1

1,73057E0

1,47336E0

4,09449E-2

4,53091E0

1,27618E0

2,97768E-4

5,12521E-1

1,64990E1

6,66658E0

1,43774E0

6,34898E-1

3,21181E0

1,31320E1

2,72589E0

6.6

ByoDyn

5,20446E0

1,93160E1

4,35325E0

3,45047E-1

1,25315E-1

2,20429E0

5,47145E0

2,88741E-1

1,73056E0

1,47337E0

4,09447E-2

4,53111E0

1,27618E0

2,98042E-4

5,12641E-1

1,64990E1

6,66658E0

1,43697E0

6,34953E-1

3,21208E0

1,31322E1

2,72595E0

6.6

Jarnac

5,20446E0

1,93160E1

4,35325E0

3,45047E-1

1,25315E-1

2,20429E0

5,47145E0

2,88741E-1

1,73056E0

1,47337E0

4,09447E-2

4,53111E0

1,27618E0

2,98042E-4

5,12641E-1

1,64990E1

6,66658E0

1,43697E0

6,34953E-1

3,21208E0

1,31322E1

2,72595E0

6.6

MathSBML

5,20446E0

1,93160E1

4,35326E0

3,45047E-1

1,25315E-1

2,20429E0

5,47145E0

2,88740E-1

1,73056E0

1,47337E0

4,09447E-2

4,53111E0

1,27618E0

2,98042E-4

5,12642E-1

1,64990E1

6,66658E0

1,43697E0

6,34953E-1

3,21208E0

1,31322E1

2,72595E0

6.6

Oscill8 Core

5,20446E0

1,93160E1

4,35323E0

1,25314E-1

5,47137E0

2,88784E-1

1,73056E0

1,47337E0

4,09447E-2

4,53109E0

1,27618E0

2,98017E-4

5,12633E-1

1,64990E1

6,66658E0

1,43704E0

6,34949E-1

3,21205E0

1,31322E1

2,72594E0

6.6

SBToolbox2

5,20450E0

1,93237E1

4,23704E0

3,52206E-1

1,27288E-1

2,14913E0

5,63014E0

3,10290E-1

1,73053E0

1,46767E0

4,10869E-2

4,53177E0

1,27620E0

2,87047E-4

4,96439E-1

1,64990E1

6,66623E0

1,47063E0

6,27794E-1

3,25437E0

1,31447E1

2,75351E0

6.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,20446E0

1,93160E1

4,35298E0

3,45066E-1

1,25319E-1

2,20409E0

5,47176E0

2,88818E-1

1,73056E0

1,47335E0

4,09450E-2

4,53110E0

1,27618E0

2,98000E-4

5,12599E-1

1,64990E1

6,66658E0

1,43709E0

6,34934E-1

3,21215E0

1,31322E1

2,72601E0

6.6

VCell

5,20446E0

1,93160E1

4,35325E0

3,45047E-1

1,25315E-1

2,20429E0

5,47145E0

2,88741E-1

1,73056E0

1,47337E0

4,09447E-2

4,53111E0

1,27618E0

2,98042E-4

5,12641E-1

1,64990E1

6,66658E0

1,43697E0

6,34953E-1

3,21208E0

1,31322E1

2,72595E0

6.6

copasi

5,20446E0

1,93160E1

4,35331E0

3,45043E-1

1,25314E-1

2,20435E0

5,47141E0

2,88717E-1

1,73056E0

1,47337E0

4,09447E-2

4,53111E0

1,27618E0

2,98055E-4

5,12652E-1

1,64990E1

6,66658E0

1,43693E0

6,34957E-1

3,21207E0

1,31322E1

2,72595E0

6.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20446E0

1,93160E1

4,35325E0

3,45047E-1

1,25315E-1

2,20429E0

5,47145E0

2,88741E-1

1,73056E0

1,47337E0

4,09447E-2

4,53111E0

1,27618E0

2,98042E-4

5,12641E-1

1,64990E1

6,66658E0

1,43697E0

6,34953E-1

3,21208E0

1,31322E1

2,72595E0

6.6

jsim

5,20446E0

1,93160E1

4,35333E0

3,45042E-1

1,25314E-1

2,20436E0

5,47138E0

2,88711E-1

1,73056E0

1,47337E0

4,09448E-2

4,53112E0

1,27618E0

2,98055E-4

5,12653E-1

1,64990E1

6,66658E0

1,43693E0

6,34958E-1

3,21207E0

1,31323E1

2,72594E0

6.6

min

5,20446E0

1,93160E1

4,23704E0

3,45042E-1

1,25314E-1

2,14913E0

5,47137E0

2,88711E-1

1,73053E0

1,46767E0

4,09447E-2

4,53109E0

1,27618E0

2,87047E-4

4,96439E-1

1,64990E1

6,66623E0

1,43693E0

6,27794E-1

3,21205E0

1,31322E1

2,72594E0

6.6

max

5,20450E0

1,93237E1

4,35333E0

3,52206E-1

1,27288E-1

2,20436E0

5,63014E0

3,10290E-1

1,73056E0

1,47337E0

4,10869E-2

4,53177E0

1,27620E0

2,98055E-4

5,12653E-1

1,64990E1

6,66658E0

1,47063E0

6,34958E-1

3,25437E0

1,31447E1

2,75351E0

6.6

mean

5,20446E0

1,93160E1

4,35325E0

3,45047E-1

1,25315E-1

2,20429E0

5,47145E0

2,88741E-1

1,73056E0

1,47337E0

4,09447E-2

4,53111E0

1,27618E0

2,98042E-4

5,12641E-1

1,64990E1

6,66658E0

1,43697E0

6,34953E-1

3,21208E0

1,31322E1

2,72595E0

6.6

relative error(%)

0,00

6.8

BioUML

5,20449E0

1,93067E1

4,44152E0

3,43663E-1

1,21726E-1

2,08321E0

5,17048E0

3,36583E-1

1,73188E0

1,47959E0

4,07607E-2

4,49786E0

1,27712E0

2,71525E-4

5,15747E-1

1,64998E1

6,66706E0

1,51021E0

6,36337E-1

3,11288E0

1,31488E1

2,67819E0

6.8

ByoDyn

5,20449E0

1,93066E1

4,44224E0

3,43626E-1

1,21710E-1

2,08326E0

5,16921E0

3,36560E-1

1,73188E0

1,47963E0

4,07596E-2

4,49778E0

1,27712E0

2,71526E-4

5,15830E-1

1,64998E1

6,66706E0

1,51018E0

6,36374E-1

3,11249E0

1,31484E1

2,67797E0

6.8

Jarnac

5,20449E0

1,93066E1

4,44224E0

3,43626E-1

1,21710E-1

2,08326E0

5,16921E0

3,36560E-1

1,73188E0

1,47963E0

4,07596E-2

4,49778E0

1,27712E0

2,71526E-4

5,15830E-1

1,64998E1

6,66706E0

1,51018E0

6,36374E-1

3,11249E0

1,31484E1

2,67797E0

6.8

MathSBML

5,20449E0

1,93066E1

4,44224E0

3,43626E-1

1,21710E-1

2,08326E0

5,16921E0

3,36560E-1

1,73188E0

1,47963E0

4,07596E-2

4,49778E0

1,27712E0

2,71526E-4

5,15830E-1

1,64998E1

6,66706E0

1,51018E0

6,36374E-1

3,11249E0

1,31484E1

2,67797E0

6.8

Oscill8 Core

5,20449E0

1,93066E1

4,44209E0

1,21714E-1

5,16949E0

3,36566E-1

1,73188E0

1,47962E0

4,07599E-2

4,49780E0

1,27712E0

2,71532E-4

5,15815E-1

1,64998E1

6,66706E0

1,51017E0

6,36367E-1

3,11258E0

1,31484E1

2,67802E0

6.8

SBToolbox2

5,20450E0

1,93050E1

4,48948E0

3,39106E-1

1,21685E-1

2,16921E0

5,17430E0

3,01789E-1

1,73193E0

1,48163E0

4,07300E-2

4,51056E0

1,27683E0

2,88807E-4

5,25863E-1

1,65000E1

6,66710E0

1,45905E0

6,40894E-1

3,12058E0

1,31740E1

2,67762E0

6.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,20449E0

1,93066E1

4,44227E0

3,43620E-1

1,21712E-1

2,08346E0

5,16938E0

3,36484E-1

1,73188E0

1,47963E0

4,07597E-2

4,49782E0

1,27712E0

2,71569E-4

5,15844E-1

1,64998E1

6,66706E0

1,51006E0

6,36380E-1

3,11256E0

1,31485E1

2,67800E0

6.8

VCell

5,20449E0

1,93066E1

4,44224E0

3,43626E-1

1,21710E-1

2,08326E0

5,16921E0

3,36560E-1

1,73188E0

1,47963E0

4,07596E-2

4,49778E0

1,27712E0

2,71526E-4

5,15830E-1

1,64998E1

6,66706E0

1,51018E0

6,36374E-1

3,11249E0

1,31484E1

2,67797E0

6.8

copasi

5,20449E0

1,93066E1

4,44230E0

3,43624E-1

1,21709E-1

2,08323E0

5,16908E0

3,36572E-1

1,73188E0

1,47963E0

4,07596E-2

4,49777E0

1,27712E0

2,71520E-4

5,15834E-1

1,64998E1

6,66706E0

1,51020E0

6,36376E-1

3,11245E0

1,31483E1

2,67795E0

6.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20449E0

1,93066E1

4,44224E0

3,43626E-1

1,21710E-1

2,08326E0

5,16921E0

3,36560E-1

1,73188E0

1,47963E0

4,07596E-2

4,49778E0

1,27712E0

2,71526E-4

5,15830E-1

1,64998E1

6,66706E0

1,51018E0

6,36374E-1

3,11249E0

1,31484E1

2,67797E0

6.8

jsim

5,20449E0

1,93066E1

4,44226E0

3,43628E-1

1,21709E-1

2,08320E0

5,16912E0

3,36577E-1

1,73188E0

1,47963E0

4,07596E-2

4,49778E0

1,27712E0

2,71511E-4

5,15826E-1

1,64998E1

6,66706E0

1,51022E0

6,36372E-1

3,11246E0

1,31484E1

2,67795E0

6.8

min

5,20449E0

1,93050E1

4,44209E0

3,39106E-1

1,21685E-1

2,08320E0

5,16908E0

3,01789E-1

1,73188E0

1,47962E0

4,07300E-2

4,49777E0

1,27683E0

2,71511E-4

5,15815E-1

1,64998E1

6,66706E0

1,45905E0

6,36367E-1

3,11245E0

1,31483E1

2,67762E0

6.8

max

5,20450E0

1,93066E1

4,48948E0

3,43628E-1

1,21714E-1

2,16921E0

5,17430E0

3,36577E-1

1,73193E0

1,48163E0

4,07599E-2

4,51056E0

1,27712E0

2,88807E-4

5,25863E-1

1,65000E1

6,66710E0

1,51022E0

6,40894E-1

3,12058E0

1,31740E1

2,67802E0

6.8

mean

5,20449E0

1,93066E1

4,44224E0

3,43626E-1

1,21710E-1

2,08326E0

5,16921E0

3,36560E-1

1,73188E0

1,47963E0

4,07596E-2

4,49778E0

1,27712E0

2,71526E-4

5,15830E-1

1,64998E1

6,66706E0

1,51018E0

6,36374E-1

3,11249E0

1,31484E1

2,67797E0

6.8

relative error(%)

0,00

7.0

BioUML

5,20451E0

1,93287E1

4,14742E0

3,60675E-1

1,26940E-1

1,96662E0

5,58809E0

3,88600E-1

1,73304E0

1,46522E0

4,11232E-2

4,50209E0

1,27738E0

2,52422E-4

4,77595E-1

1,65011E1

6,66617E0

1,57478E0

6,19325E-1

3,22972E0

1,32724E1

2,75535E0

7.0

ByoDyn

5,20451E0

1,93288E1

4,14592E0

3,60774E-1

1,26960E-1

1,96542E0

5,58957E0

3,89147E-1

1,73304E0

1,46515E0

4,11248E-2

4,50195E0

1,27738E0

2,52222E-4

4,77379E-1

1,65011E1

6,66617E0

1,57543E0

6,19226E-1

3,23009E0

1,32720E1

2,75569E0

7.0

Jarnac

5,20451E0

1,93288E1

4,14592E0

3,60774E-1

1,26960E-1

1,96542E0

5,58957E0

3,89147E-1

1,73304E0

1,46515E0

4,11248E-2

4,50195E0

1,27738E0

2,52222E-4

4,77379E-1

1,65011E1

6,66617E0

1,57543E0

6,19226E-1

3,23009E0

1,32720E1

2,75569E0

7.0

MathSBML

5,20451E0

1,93288E1

4,14592E0

3,60774E-1

1,26960E-1

1,96542E0

5,58957E0

3,89147E-1

1,73304E0

1,46515E0

4,11248E-2

4,50195E0

1,27738E0

2,52222E-4

4,77379E-1

1,65011E1

6,66617E0

1,57543E0

6,19226E-1

3,23009E0

1,32720E1

2,75569E0

7.0

Oscill8 Core

5,20451E0

1,93288E1

4,14604E0

1,26958E-1

5,58945E0

3,89103E-1

1,73304E0

1,46515E0

4,11247E-2

4,50196E0

1,27738E0

2,52238E-4

4,77396E-1

1,65011E1

6,66617E0

1,57538E0

6,19234E-1

3,23006E0

1,32720E1

2,75566E0

7.0

SBToolbox2

5,20450E0

1,93223E1

4,23110E0

3,56687E-1

1,25010E-1

1,96380E0

5,42761E0

3,89657E-1

1,73310E0

1,46949E0

4,10030E-2

4,49354E0

1,27750E0

2,51190E-4

4,86733E-1

1,65010E1

6,66647E0

1,57658E0

6,23313E-1

3,18216E0

1,32504E1

2,72735E0

7.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,20451E0

1,93288E1

4,14617E0

3,60761E-1

1,26954E-1

1,96548E0

5,58915E0

3,89123E-1

1,73304E0

1,46516E0

4,11245E-2

4,50194E0

1,27738E0

2,52229E-4

4,77409E-1

1,65011E1

6,66617E0

1,57540E0

6,19239E-1

3,22997E0

1,32720E1

2,75561E0

7.0

VCell

5,20451E0

1,93288E1

4,14592E0

3,60774E-1

1,26960E-1

1,96542E0

5,58957E0

3,89147E-1

1,73304E0

1,46515E0

4,11248E-2

4,50195E0

1,27738E0

2,52222E-4

4,77379E-1

1,65011E1

6,66617E0

1,57543E0

6,19226E-1

3,23009E0

1,32720E1

2,75569E0

7.0

copasi

5,20451E0

1,93288E1

4,14585E0

3,60779E-1

1,26961E-1

1,96538E0

5,58965E0

3,89169E-1

1,73304E0

1,46514E0

4,11249E-2

4,50194E0

1,27738E0

2,52214E-4

4,77369E-1

1,65011E1

6,66617E0

1,57545E0

6,19221E-1

3,23011E0

1,32720E1

2,75570E0

7.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20451E0

1,93288E1

4,14592E0

3,60774E-1

1,26960E-1

1,96542E0

5,58957E0

3,89147E-1

1,73304E0

1,46515E0

4,11248E-2

4,50195E0

1,27738E0

2,52222E-4

4,77379E-1

1,65011E1

6,66617E0

1,57543E0

6,19226E-1

3,23009E0

1,32720E1

2,75569E0

7.0

jsim

5,20451E0

1,93288E1

4,14583E0

3,60779E-1

1,26961E-1

1,96540E0

5,58971E0

3,89158E-1

1,73304E0

1,46514E0

4,11249E-2

4,50196E0

1,27738E0

2,52218E-4

4,77367E-1

1,65011E1

6,66617E0

1,57544E0

6,19221E-1

3,23013E0

1,32721E1

2,75571E0

7.0

min

5,20450E0

1,93223E1

4,14583E0

3,56687E-1

1,25010E-1

1,96380E0

5,42761E0

3,89103E-1

1,73304E0

1,46514E0

4,10030E-2

4,49354E0

1,27738E0

2,51190E-4

4,77367E-1

1,65010E1

6,66617E0

1,57538E0

6,19221E-1

3,18216E0

1,32504E1

2,72735E0

7.0

max

5,20451E0

1,93288E1

4,23110E0

3,60779E-1

1,26961E-1

1,96548E0

5,58971E0

3,89657E-1

1,73310E0

1,46949E0

4,11249E-2

4,50196E0

1,27750E0

2,52238E-4

4,86733E-1

1,65011E1

6,66647E0

1,57658E0

6,23313E-1

3,23013E0

1,32721E1

2,75571E0

7.0

mean

5,20451E0

1,93288E1

4,14592E0

3,60774E-1

1,26960E-1

1,96542E0

5,58957E0

3,89147E-1

1,73304E0

1,46515E0

4,11248E-2

4,50195E0

1,27738E0

2,52222E-4

4,77379E-1

1,65011E1

6,66617E0

1,57543E0

6,19226E-1

3,23009E0

1,32720E1

2,75569E0

7.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0,13

0,00

7.2

BioUML

5,20453E0

1,93280E1

4,23731E0

3,51853E-1

1,27186E-1

2,15040E0

5,62273E0

3,09863E-1

1,73434E0

1,46927E0

4,10884E-2

4,53252E0

1,27708E0

2,87378E-4

4,96561E-1

1,65030E1

6,66638E0

1,46974E0

6,28147E-1

3,25241E0

1,34198E1

2,75375E0

7.2

ByoDyn

5,20453E0

1,93281E1

4,23666E0

3,51879E-1

1,27205E-1

2,15070E0

5,62433E0

3,09731E-1

1,73433E0

1,46923E0

4,10894E-2

4,53264E0

1,27708E0

2,87440E-4

4,96500E-1

1,65030E1

6,66638E0

1,46957E0

6,28121E-1

3,25290E0

1,34198E1

2,75400E0

7.2

Jarnac

5,20453E0

1,93281E1

4,23666E0

3,51879E-1

1,27205E-1

2,15070E0

5,62433E0

3,09731E-1

1,73433E0

1,46923E0

4,10894E-2

4,53264E0

1,27708E0

2,87440E-4

4,96500E-1

1,65030E1

6,66638E0

1,46957E0

6,28121E-1

3,25290E0

1,34198E1

2,75400E0

7.2

MathSBML

5,20453E0

1,93281E1

4,23666E0

3,51879E-1

1,27205E-1

2,15070E0

5,62433E0

3,09730E-1

1,73433E0

1,46923E0

4,10894E-2

4,53264E0

1,27708E0

2,87441E-4

4,96500E-1

1,65030E1

6,66638E0

1,46957E0

6,28121E-1

3,25290E0

1,34198E1

2,75400E0

7.2

Oscill8 Core

5,20453E0

1,93281E1

4,23675E0

1,27202E-1

5,62412E0

3,09748E-1

1,73433E0

1,46923E0

4,10893E-2

4,53262E0

1,27708E0

2,87435E-4

4,96509E-1

1,65030E1

6,66638E0

1,46959E0

6,28125E-1

3,25284E0

1,34198E1

2,75397E0

7.2

SBToolbox2

5,20450E0

1,93330E1

4,14514E0

3,58317E-1

1,28273E-1

2,07025E0

5,70712E0

3,42731E-1

1,73433E0

1,46511E0

4,11810E-2

4,52502E0

1,27720E0

2,71732E-4

4,82073E-1

1,65030E1

6,66610E0

1,51704E0

6,21683E-1

3,27116E0

1,34130E1

2,77086E0

7.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,20453E0

1,93281E1

4,23650E0

3,51891E-1

1,27206E-1

2,15050E0

5,62440E0

3,09812E-1

1,73433E0

1,46922E0

4,10896E-2

4,53261E0

1,27708E0

2,87402E-4

4,96473E-1

1,65030E1

6,66638E0

1,46969E0

6,28109E-1

3,25290E0

1,34198E1

2,75402E0

7.2

VCell

5,20453E0

1,93281E1

4,23666E0

3,51879E-1

1,27205E-1

2,15070E0

5,62433E0

3,09731E-1

1,73433E0

1,46923E0

4,10894E-2

4,53264E0

1,27708E0

2,87440E-4

4,96500E-1

1,65030E1

6,66638E0

1,46957E0

6,28121E-1

3,25290E0

1,34198E1

2,75400E0

7.2

copasi

5,20453E0

1,93281E1

4,23666E0

3,51878E-1

1,27206E-1

2,15074E0

5,62438E0

3,09715E-1

1,73433E0

1,46923E0

4,10895E-2

4,53264E0

1,27708E0

2,87449E-4

4,96502E-1

1,65030E1

6,66638E0

1,46955E0

6,28122E-1

3,25292E0

1,34198E1

2,75400E0

7.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20453E0

1,93281E1

4,23666E0

3,51879E-1

1,27205E-1

2,15070E0

5,62433E0

3,09731E-1

1,73433E0

1,46923E0

4,10894E-2

4,53264E0

1,27708E0

2,87440E-4

4,96500E-1

1,65030E1

6,66638E0

1,46957E0

6,28121E-1

3,25290E0

1,34198E1

2,75400E0

7.2

jsim

5,20453E0

1,93281E1

4,23668E0

3,51877E-1

1,27205E-1

2,15076E0

5,62436E0

3,09703E-1

1,73433E0

1,46923E0

4,10895E-2

4,53265E0

1,27708E0

2,87451E-4

4,96504E-1

1,65030E1

6,66638E0

1,46954E0

6,28123E-1

3,25291E0

1,34199E1

2,75400E0

7.2

min

5,20450E0

1,93281E1

4,14514E0

3,51877E-1

1,27202E-1

2,07025E0

5,62412E0

3,09703E-1

1,73433E0

1,46511E0

4,10893E-2

4,52502E0

1,27708E0

2,71732E-4

4,82073E-1

1,65030E1

6,66610E0

1,46954E0

6,21683E-1

3,25284E0

1,34130E1

2,75397E0

7.2

max

5,20453E0

1,93330E1

4,23675E0

3,58317E-1

1,28273E-1

2,15076E0

5,70712E0

3,42731E-1

1,73433E0

1,46923E0

4,11810E-2

4,53265E0

1,27720E0

2,87451E-4

4,96509E-1

1,65030E1

6,66638E0

1,51704E0

6,28125E-1

3,27116E0

1,34199E1

2,77086E0

7.2

mean

5,20453E0

1,93281E1

4,23666E0

3,51879E-1

1,27205E-1

2,15070E0

5,62433E0

3,09731E-1

1,73433E0

1,46923E0

4,10894E-2

4,53264E0

1,27708E0

2,87440E-4

4,96500E-1

1,65030E1

6,66638E0

1,46957E0

6,28121E-1

3,25290E0

1,34198E1

2,75400E0

7.2

relative error(%)

0,00

7.4

BioUML

5,20455E0

1,93094E1

4,49288E0

3,38660E-1

1,21481E-1

2,16777E0

5,15829E0

3,02379E-1

1,73566E0

1,48344E0

4,07251E-2

4,51042E0

1,27781E0

2,88509E-4

5,26173E-1

1,65041E1

6,66728E0

1,45985E0

6,41340E-1

3,11574E0

1,34420E1

2,67639E0

7.4

ByoDyn

5,20455E0

1,93092E1

4,49524E0

3,38515E-1

1,21440E-1

2,16885E0

5,15508E0

3,01933E-1

1,73565E0

1,48357E0

4,07218E-2

4,51038E0

1,27781E0

2,88699E-4

5,26495E-1

1,65040E1

6,66729E0

1,45922E0

6,41485E-1

3,11484E0

1,34415E1

2,67584E0

7.4

Jarnac

5,20455E0

1,93092E1

4,49524E0

3,38515E-1

1,21440E-1

2,16885E0

5,15508E0

3,01933E-1

1,73565E0

1,48357E0

4,07218E-2

4,51038E0

1,27781E0

2,88699E-4

5,26495E-1

1,65040E1

6,66729E0

1,45922E0

6,41485E-1

3,11484E0

1,34415E1

2,67584E0

7.4

MathSBML

5,20455E0

1,93092E1

4,49524E0

3,38515E-1

1,21440E-1

2,16884E0

5,15508E0

3,01933E-1

1,73565E0

1,48357E0

4,07218E-2

4,51038E0

1,27781E0

2,88699E-4

5,26495E-1

1,65040E1

6,66729E0

1,45922E0

6,41485E-1

3,11484E0

1,34415E1

2,67584E0

7.4

Oscill8 Core

5,20455E0

1,93093E1

4,49504E0

1,21443E-1

5,15535E0

3,01975E-1

1,73565E0

1,48356E0

4,07220E-2

4,51038E0

1,27781E0

2,88683E-4

5,26468E-1

1,65040E1

6,66729E0

1,45928E0

6,41473E-1

3,11492E0

1,34415E1

2,67589E0

7.4

SBToolbox2

5,20460E0

1,93147E1

4,44855E0

3,39557E-1

1,23139E-1

2,21783E0

5,29517E0

2,83388E-1

1,73570E0

1,48051E0

4,08131E-2

4,52506E0

1,27750E0

3,00111E-4

5,24177E-1

1,65040E1

6,66703E0

1,42876E0

6,40443E-1

3,16107E0

1,34790E1

2,69863E0

7.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,20455E0

1,93093E1

4,49504E0

3,38523E-1

1,21445E-1

2,16891E0

5,15552E0

3,01912E-1

1,73565E0

1,48355E0

4,07221E-2

4,51042E0

1,27781E0

2,88718E-4

5,26477E-1

1,65041E1

6,66729E0

1,45918E0

6,41477E-1

3,11498E0

1,34416E1

2,67592E0

7.4

VCell

5,20455E0

1,93092E1

4,49524E0

3,38515E-1

1,21440E-1

2,16885E0

5,15508E0

3,01933E-1

1,73565E0

1,48357E0

4,07218E-2

4,51038E0

1,27781E0

2,88699E-4

5,26495E-1

1,65040E1

6,66729E0

1,45922E0

6,41485E-1

3,11484E0

1,34415E1

2,67584E0

7.4

copasi

5,20455E0

1,93092E1

4,49534E0

3,38509E-1

1,21437E-1

2,16887E0

5,15491E0

3,01924E-1

1,73565E0

1,48357E0

4,07216E-2

4,51037E0

1,27781E0

2,88703E-4

5,26509E-1

1,65040E1

6,66729E0

1,45921E0

6,41491E-1

3,11479E0

1,34414E1

2,67581E0

7.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20455E0

1,93092E1

4,49524E0

3,38515E-1

1,21440E-1

2,16885E0

5,15508E0

3,01933E-1

1,73565E0

1,48357E0

4,07218E-2

4,51038E0

1,27781E0

2,88699E-4

5,26495E-1

1,65040E1

6,66729E0

1,45922E0

6,41485E-1

3,11484E0

1,34415E1

2,67584E0

7.4

jsim

5,20455E0

1,93092E1

4,49534E0

3,38510E-1

1,21437E-1

2,16885E0

5,15489E0

3,01926E-1

1,73566E0

1,48357E0

4,07217E-2

4,51038E0

1,27781E0

2,88697E-4

5,26506E-1

1,65041E1

6,66729E0

1,45922E0

6,41490E-1

3,11479E0

1,34415E1

2,67581E0

7.4

min

5,20455E0

1,93092E1

4,44855E0

3,38509E-1

1,21437E-1

2,16884E0

5,15489E0

2,83388E-1

1,73565E0

1,48051E0

4,07216E-2

4,51037E0

1,27750E0

2,88683E-4

5,24177E-1

1,65040E1

6,66703E0

1,42876E0

6,40443E-1

3,11479E0

1,34414E1

2,67581E0

7.4

max

5,20460E0

1,93147E1

4,49534E0

3,39557E-1

1,23139E-1

2,21783E0

5,29517E0

3,01975E-1

1,73570E0

1,48357E0

4,08131E-2

4,52506E0

1,27781E0

3,00111E-4

5,26509E-1

1,65041E1

6,66729E0

1,45928E0

6,41491E-1

3,16107E0

1,34790E1

2,69863E0

7.4

mean

5,20455E0

1,93092E1

4,49524E0

3,38515E-1

1,21440E-1

2,16885E0

5,15508E0

3,01933E-1

1,73565E0

1,48357E0

4,07218E-2

4,51038E0

1,27781E0

2,88699E-4

5,26495E-1

1,65040E1

6,66729E0

1,45922E0

6,41485E-1

3,11484E0

1,34415E1

2,67584E0

7.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0,13

0,00

7.6

BioUML

5,20457E0

1,93269E1

4,22582E0

3,56696E-1

1,24983E-1

1,96094E0

5,42625E0

3,90985E-1

1,73677E0

1,47083E0

4,10106E-2

4,49384E0

1,27853E0

2,50748E-4

4,86033E-1

1,65050E1

6,66658E0

1,57807E0

6,23304E-1

3,18172E0

1,35159E1

2,72883E0

7.6

ByoDyn

5,20457E0

1,93269E1

4,22503E0

3,56766E-1

1,24984E-1

1,95955E0

5,42617E0

3,91631E-1

1,73677E0

1,47079E0

4,10111E-2

4,49360E0

1,27853E0

2,50511E-4

4,85887E-1

1,65049E1

6,66658E0

1,57882E0

6,23234E-1

3,18162E0

1,35151E1

2,72888E0

7.6

Jarnac

5,20457E0

1,93269E1

4,22503E0

3,56766E-1

1,24984E-1

1,95955E0

5,42617E0

3,91631E-1

1,73677E0

1,47079E0

4,10111E-2

4,49360E0

1,27853E0

2,50511E-4

4,85887E-1

1,65049E1

6,66658E0

1,57882E0

6,23234E-1

3,18162E0

1,35151E1

2,72888E0

7.6

MathSBML

5,20457E0

1,93269E1

4,22503E0

3,56766E-1

1,24984E-1

1,95955E0

5,42617E0

3,91631E-1

1,73677E0

1,47079E0

4,10111E-2

4,49360E0

1,27853E0

2,50511E-4

4,85887E-1

1,65049E1

6,66658E0

1,57882E0

6,23234E-1

3,18162E0

1,35151E1

2,72888E0

7.6

Oscill8 Core

5,20457E0

1,93269E1

4,22509E0

1,24984E-1

5,42617E0

3,91586E-1

1,73677E0

1,47079E0

4,10110E-2

4,49361E0

1,27853E0

2,50528E-4

4,85898E-1

1,65049E1

6,66658E0

1,57876E0

6,23240E-1

3,18163E0

1,35152E1

2,72888E0

7.6

SBToolbox2

5,20460E0

1,93182E1

4,35352E0

3,49292E-1

1,22715E-1

2,01205E0

5,24484E0

3,67419E-1

1,73682E0

1,47738E0

4,08548E-2

4,49258E0

1,27850E0

2,58775E-4

5,02444E-1

1,65050E1

6,66698E0

1,55054E0

6,30708E-1

3,13064E0

1,35060E1

2,69486E0

7.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,20457E0

1,93269E1

4,22533E0

3,56748E-1

1,24979E-1

1,95970E0

5,42578E0

3,91560E-1

1,73677E0

1,47081E0

4,10107E-2

4,49360E0

1,27853E0

2,50535E-4

4,85926E-1

1,65049E1

6,66659E0

1,57874E0

6,23252E-1

3,18152E0

1,35151E1

2,72881E0

7.6

VCell

5,20457E0

1,93269E1

4,22503E0

3,56766E-1

1,24984E-1

1,95955E0

5,42617E0

3,91631E-1

1,73677E0

1,47079E0

4,10111E-2

4,49360E0

1,27853E0

2,50511E-4

4,85887E-1

1,65049E1

6,66658E0

1,57882E0

6,23234E-1

3,18162E0

1,35151E1

2,72888E0

7.6

copasi

5,20457E0

1,93269E1

4,22498E0

3,56770E-1

1,24985E-1

1,95948E0

5,42620E0

3,91664E-1

1,73677E0

1,47079E0

4,10111E-2

4,49359E0

1,27853E0

2,50499E-4

4,85878E-1

1,65049E1

6,66659E0

1,57885E0

6,23230E-1

3,18163E0

1,35151E1

2,72889E0

7.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20457E0

1,93269E1

4,22503E0

3,56766E-1

1,24984E-1

1,95955E0

5,42617E0

3,91631E-1

1,73677E0

1,47079E0

4,10111E-2

4,49360E0

1,27853E0

2,50511E-4

4,85887E-1

1,65049E1

6,66658E0

1,57882E0

6,23234E-1

3,18162E0

1,35151E1

2,72888E0

7.6

jsim

5,20457E0

1,93269E1

4,22493E0

3,56772E-1

1,24986E-1

1,95949E0

5,42629E0

3,91662E-1

1,73677E0

1,47078E0

4,10112E-2

4,49360E0

1,27853E0

2,50500E-4

4,85872E-1

1,65049E1

6,66658E0

1,57885E0

6,23228E-1

3,18166E0

1,35152E1

2,72891E0

7.6

min

5,20457E0

1,93182E1

4,22493E0

3,49292E-1

1,22715E-1

1,95948E0

5,24484E0

3,67419E-1

1,73677E0

1,47078E0

4,08548E-2

4,49258E0

1,27850E0

2,50499E-4

4,85872E-1

1,65049E1

6,66658E0

1,55054E0

6,23228E-1

3,13064E0

1,35060E1

2,69486E0

7.6

max

5,20460E0

1,93269E1

4,35352E0

3,56772E-1

1,24986E-1

2,01205E0

5,42629E0

3,91664E-1

1,73682E0

1,47738E0

4,10112E-2

4,49361E0

1,27853E0

2,58775E-4

5,02444E-1

1,65050E1

6,66698E0

1,57885E0

6,30708E-1

3,18166E0

1,35152E1

2,72891E0

7.6

mean

5,20457E0

1,93269E1

4,22503E0

3,56766E-1

1,24984E-1

1,95955E0

5,42617E0

3,91631E-1

1,73677E0

1,47079E0

4,10111E-2

4,49360E0

1,27853E0

2,50511E-4

4,85887E-1

1,65049E1

6,66658E0

1,57882E0

6,23234E-1

3,18162E0

1,35151E1

2,72888E0

7.6

relative error(%)

0,00

7.8

BioUML

5,20459E0

1,93373E1

4,14916E0

3,57659E-1

1,28148E-1

2,07658E0

5,69818E0

3,40200E-1

1,73794E0

1,46687E0

4,11802E-2

4,52619E0

1,27825E0

2,73035E-4

4,82857E-1

1,65068E1

6,66628E0

1,51322E0

6,22341E-1

3,26919E0

1,36753E1

2,77065E0

7.8

ByoDyn

5,20459E0

1,93374E1

4,14778E0

3,57733E-1

1,28176E-1

2,07631E0

5,70052E0

3,40292E-1

1,73794E0

1,46681E0

4,11821E-2

4,52626E0

1,27825E0

2,72982E-4

4,82685E-1

1,65068E1

6,66628E0

1,51340E0

6,22267E-1

3,26984E0

1,36752E1

2,77105E0

7.8

Jarnac

5,20459E0

1,93374E1

4,14778E0

3,57733E-1

1,28176E-1

2,07631E0

5,70052E0

3,40292E-1

1,73794E0

1,46681E0

4,11821E-2

4,52626E0

1,27825E0

2,72982E-4

4,82685E-1

1,65068E1

6,66628E0

1,51340E0

6,22267E-1

3,26984E0

1,36752E1

2,77105E0

7.8

MathSBML

5,20459E0

1,93374E1

4,14778E0

3,57733E-1

1,28176E-1

2,07631E0

5,70051E0

3,40292E-1

1,73794E0

1,46681E0

4,11821E-2

4,52626E0

1,27825E0

2,72982E-4

4,82686E-1

1,65068E1

6,66628E0

1,51340E0

6,22267E-1

3,26984E0

1,36752E1

2,77104E0

7.8

Oscill8 Core

5,20459E0

1,93374E1

4,14790E0

1,28174E-1

5,70031E0

3,40286E-1

1,73794E0

1,46681E0

4,11819E-2

4,52625E0

1,27825E0

2,72988E-4

4,82701E-1

1,65068E1

6,66628E0

1,51338E0

6,22273E-1

3,26979E0

1,36752E1

2,77101E0

7.8

SBToolbox2

5,20460E0

1,93380E1

4,11652E0

3,61047E-1

1,27896E-1

1,99870E0

5,67138E0

3,74023E-1

1,73792E0

1,46568E0

4,11873E-2

4,51272E0

1,27850E0

2,58452E-4

4,75549E-1

1,65070E1

6,66620E0

1,55729E0

6,18953E-1

3,25621E0

1,36520E1

2,76993E0

7.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,20459E0

1,93374E1

4,14776E0

3,57738E-1

1,28174E-1

2,07615E0

5,70037E0

3,40362E-1

1,73794E0

1,46681E0

4,11820E-2

4,52622E0

1,27826E0

2,72953E-4

4,82676E-1

1,65068E1

6,66628E0

1,51348E0

6,22262E-1

3,26979E0

1,36752E1

2,77103E0

7.8

VCell

5,20459E0

1,93374E1

4,14778E0

3,57733E-1

1,28176E-1

2,07631E0

5,70052E0

3,40292E-1

1,73794E0

1,46681E0

4,11821E-2

4,52626E0

1,27825E0

2,72982E-4

4,82685E-1

1,65068E1

6,66628E0

1,51340E0

6,22267E-1

3,26984E0

1,36752E1

2,77105E0

7.8

copasi

5,20459E0

1,93374E1

4,14773E0

3,57736E-1

1,28177E-1

2,07632E0

5,70063E0

3,40289E-1

1,73794E0

1,46680E0

4,11822E-2

4,52626E0

1,27825E0

2,72984E-4

4,82680E-1

1,65068E1

6,66628E0

1,51339E0

6,22264E-1

3,26988E0

1,36752E1

2,77106E0

7.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20459E0

1,93374E1

4,14778E0

3,57733E-1

1,28176E-1

2,07631E0

5,70052E0

3,40292E-1

1,73794E0

1,46681E0

4,11821E-2

4,52626E0

1,27825E0

2,72982E-4

4,82685E-1

1,65068E1

6,66628E0

1,51340E0

6,22267E-1

3,26984E0

1,36752E1

2,77105E0

7.8

jsim

5,20459E0

1,93374E1

4,14774E0

3,57735E-1

1,28177E-1

2,07635E0

5,70063E0

3,40272E-1

1,73794E0

1,46680E0

4,11822E-2

4,52627E0

1,27825E0

2,72987E-4

4,82681E-1

1,65068E1

6,66628E0

1,51338E0

6,22265E-1

3,26988E0

1,36753E1

2,77106E0

7.8

min

5,20459E0

1,93374E1

4,11652E0

3,57733E-1

1,27896E-1

1,99870E0

5,67138E0

3,40272E-1

1,73792E0

1,46568E0

4,11819E-2

4,51272E0

1,27825E0

2,58452E-4

4,75549E-1

1,65068E1

6,66620E0

1,51338E0

6,18953E-1

3,25621E0

1,36520E1

2,76993E0

7.8

max

5,20460E0

1,93380E1

4,14790E0

3,61047E-1

1,28177E-1

2,07635E0

5,70063E0

3,74023E-1

1,73794E0

1,46681E0

4,11873E-2

4,52627E0

1,27850E0

2,72988E-4

4,82701E-1

1,65070E1

6,66628E0

1,55729E0

6,22273E-1

3,26988E0

1,36753E1

2,77106E0

7.8

mean

5,20459E0

1,93374E1

4,14778E0

3,57733E-1

1,28176E-1

2,07631E0

5,70052E0

3,40292E-1

1,73794E0

1,46681E0

4,11821E-2

4,52626E0

1,27825E0

2,72982E-4

4,82685E-1

1,65068E1

6,66628E0

1,51340E0

6,22267E-1

3,26984E0

1,36752E1

2,77105E0

7.8

relative error(%)

0,00

8.0

BioUML

5,20461E0

1,93181E1

4,46013E0

3,38672E-1

1,22744E-1

2,21717E0

5,26431E0

2,83636E-1

1,73923E0

1,48284E0

4,07958E-2

4,52391E0

1,27861E0

2,99846E-4

5,25444E-1

1,65083E1

6,66724E0

1,42919E0

6,41328E-1

3,15180E0

1,37314E1

2,69503E0

8.0

ByoDyn

5,20461E0

1,93180E1

4,46244E0

3,38499E-1

1,22717E-1

2,21927E0

5,26223E0

2,82846E-1

1,73923E0

1,48295E0

4,07930E-2

4,52407E0

1,27861E0

3,00299E-4

5,25832E-1

1,65083E1

6,66725E0

1,42788E0

6,41501E-1

3,15136E0

1,37312E1

2,69468E0

8.0

Jarnac

5,20461E0

1,93180E1

4,46244E0

3,38499E-1

1,22717E-1

2,21927E0

5,26223E0

2,82846E-1

1,73923E0

1,48295E0

4,07930E-2

4,52407E0

1,27861E0

3,00299E-4

5,25832E-1

1,65083E1

6,66725E0

1,42788E0

6,41501E-1

3,15136E0

1,37312E1

2,69468E0

8.0

MathSBML

5,20461E0

1,93180E1

4,46244E0

3,38499E-1

1,22716E-1

2,21927E0

5,26223E0

2,82846E-1

1,73923E0

1,48295E0

4,07930E-2

4,52407E0

1,27861E0

3,00299E-4

5,25833E-1

1,65083E1

6,66725E0

1,42788E0

6,41501E-1

3,15136E0

1,37312E1

2,69467E0

8.0

Oscill8 Core

5,20461E0

1,93180E1

4,46232E0

1,22718E-1

5,26233E0

2,82889E-1

1,73923E0

1,48294E0

4,07931E-2

4,52406E0

1,27861E0

3,00273E-4

5,25812E-1

1,65083E1

6,66725E0

1,42795E0

6,41492E-1

3,15138E0

1,37312E1

2,69469E0

8.0

SBToolbox2

5,20460E0

1,93278E1

4,33344E0

3,45418E-1

1,25470E-1

2,20072E0

5,48458E0

2,90142E-1

1,73922E0

1,47600E0

4,09742E-2

4,53368E0

1,27842E0

2,97442E-4

5,10198E-1

1,65080E1

6,66680E0

1,43918E0

6,34582E-1

3,21604E0

1,37644E1

2,73156E0

8.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,20461E0

1,93180E1

4,46212E0

3,38517E-1

1,22723E-1

2,21920E0

5,26276E0

2,82875E-1

1,73923E0

1,48293E0

4,07934E-2

4,52409E0

1,27861E0

3,00284E-4

5,25791E-1

1,65083E1

6,66725E0

1,42793E0

6,41483E-1

3,15151E0

1,37313E1

2,69476E0

8.0

VCell

5,20461E0

1,93180E1

4,46244E0

3,38499E-1

1,22717E-1

2,21927E0

5,26223E0

2,82846E-1

1,73923E0

1,48295E0

4,07930E-2

4,52407E0

1,27861E0

3,00299E-4

5,25832E-1

1,65083E1

6,66725E0

1,42788E0

6,41501E-1

3,15136E0

1,37312E1

2,69468E0

8.0

copasi

5,20461E0

1,93179E1

4,46255E0

3,38491E-1

1,22715E-1

2,21934E0

5,26210E0

2,82820E-1

1,73923E0

1,48295E0

4,07928E-2

4,52407E0

1,27861E0

3,00313E-4

5,25849E-1

1,65083E1

6,66725E0

1,42784E0

6,41509E-1

3,15133E0

1,37311E1

2,69465E0

8.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20461E0

1,93180E1

4,46244E0

3,38499E-1

1,22717E-1

2,21927E0

5,26223E0

2,82846E-1

1,73923E0

1,48295E0

4,07930E-2

4,52407E0

1,27861E0

3,00299E-4

5,25832E-1

1,65083E1

6,66725E0

1,42788E0

6,41501E-1

3,15136E0

1,37312E1

2,69468E0

8.0

jsim

5,20461E0

1,93179E1

4,46258E0

3,38490E-1

1,22714E-1

2,21934E0

5,26205E0

2,82819E-1

1,73923E0

1,48295E0

4,07928E-2

4,52408E0

1,27861E0

3,00313E-4

5,25852E-1

1,65083E1

6,66725E0

1,42784E0

6,41510E-1

3,15131E0

1,37313E1

2,69464E0

8.0

min

5,20460E0

1,93179E1

4,33344E0

3,38490E-1

1,22714E-1

2,20072E0

5,26205E0

2,82819E-1

1,73922E0

1,47600E0

4,07928E-2

4,52406E0

1,27842E0

2,97442E-4

5,10198E-1

1,65080E1

6,66680E0

1,42784E0

6,34582E-1

3,15131E0

1,37311E1

2,69464E0

8.0

max

5,20461E0

1,93278E1

4,46258E0

3,45418E-1

1,25470E-1

2,21934E0

5,48458E0

2,90142E-1

1,73923E0

1,48295E0

4,09742E-2

4,53368E0

1,27861E0

3,00313E-4

5,25852E-1

1,65083E1

6,66725E0

1,43918E0

6,41510E-1

3,21604E0

1,37644E1

2,73156E0

8.0

mean

5,20461E0

1,93180E1

4,46244E0

3,38499E-1

1,22717E-1

2,21927E0

5,26223E0

2,82846E-1

1,73923E0

1,48295E0

4,07930E-2

4,52407E0

1,27861E0

3,00299E-4

5,25832E-1

1,65083E1

6,66725E0

1,42788E0

6,41501E-1

3,15136E0

1,37312E1

2,69468E0

8.0

relative error(%)

0,00

8.2

BioUML

5,20463E0

1,93232E1

4,33815E0

3,49992E-1

1,22809E-1

2,00046E0

5,25244E0

3,72677E-1

1,74034E0

1,47823E0

4,08718E-2

4,49172E0

1,27966E0

2,56823E-4

5,00215E-1

1,65089E1

6,66708E0

1,55686E0

6,30008E-1

3,13228E0

1,37567E1

2,69815E0

8.2

ByoDyn

5,20463E0

1,93232E1

4,33855E0

3,49984E-1

1,22794E-1

1,99998E0

5,25120E0

3,72885E-1

1,74034E0

1,47826E0

4,08710E-2

4,49157E0

1,27967E0

2,56728E-4

5,00235E-1

1,65089E1

6,66709E0

1,55713E0

6,30016E-1

3,13188E0

1,37560E1

2,69794E0

8.2

Jarnac

5,20463E0

1,93232E1

4,33855E0

3,49984E-1

1,22794E-1

1,99998E0

5,25120E0

3,72885E-1

1,74034E0

1,47826E0

4,08710E-2

4,49157E0

1,27967E0

2,56728E-4

5,00235E-1

1,65089E1

6,66709E0

1,55713E0

6,30016E-1

3,13188E0

1,37560E1

2,69794E0

8.2

MathSBML

5,20463E0

1,93232E1

4,33854E0

3,49984E-1

1,22795E-1

1,99998E0

5,25120E0

3,72886E-1

1,74034E0

1,47826E0

4,08710E-2

4,49157E0

1,27967E0

2,56728E-4

5,00234E-1

1,65089E1

6,66709E0

1,55713E0

6,30016E-1

3,13188E0

1,37560E1

2,69795E0

8.2

Oscill8 Core

5,20463E0

1,93232E1

4,33852E0

1,22796E-1

5,25131E0

3,72860E-1

1,74034E0

1,47825E0

4,08711E-2

4,49158E0

1,27967E0

2,56741E-4

5,00236E-1

1,65089E1

6,66709E0

1,55710E0

6,30017E-1

3,13192E0

1,37560E1

2,69796E0

8.2

SBToolbox2

5,20460E0

1,93160E1

4,46411E0

3,41334E-1

1,21186E-1

2,10252E0

5,12985E0

3,28463E-1

1,74042E0

1,48451E0

4,07388E-2

4,50061E0

1,27942E0

2,75125E-4

5,19276E-1

1,65090E1

6,66740E0

1,49904E0

6,38666E-1

3,10226E0

1,37682E1

2,67433E0

8.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,20463E0

1,93231E1

4,33882E0

3,49965E-1

1,22791E-1

2,00021E0

5,25094E0

3,72784E-1

1,74034E0

1,47827E0

4,08708E-2

4,49159E0

1,27967E0

2,56769E-4

5,00276E-1

1,65089E1

6,66709E0

1,55700E0

6,30035E-1

3,13182E0

1,37560E1

2,69789E0

8.2

VCell

5,20463E0

1,93232E1

4,33855E0

3,49984E-1

1,22794E-1

1,99998E0

5,25120E0

3,72885E-1

1,74034E0

1,47826E0

4,08710E-2

4,49157E0

1,27967E0

2,56728E-4

5,00235E-1

1,65089E1

6,66709E0

1,55713E0

6,30016E-1

3,13188E0

1,37560E1

2,69794E0

8.2

copasi

5,20463E0

1,93232E1

4,33855E0

3,49985E-1

1,22794E-1

1,99992E0

5,25112E0

3,72914E-1

1,74034E0

1,47826E0

4,08710E-2

4,49155E0

1,27967E0

2,56716E-4

5,00232E-1

1,65089E1

6,66709E0

1,55717E0

6,30015E-1

3,13185E0

1,37559E1

2,69793E0

8.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20463E0

1,93232E1

4,33855E0

3,49984E-1

1,22794E-1

1,99998E0

5,25120E0

3,72885E-1

1,74034E0

1,47826E0

4,08710E-2

4,49157E0

1,27967E0

2,56728E-4

5,00235E-1

1,65089E1

6,66709E0

1,55713E0

6,30016E-1

3,13188E0

1,37560E1

2,69794E0

8.2

jsim

5,20463E0

1,93232E1

4,33847E0

3,49990E-1

1,22795E-1

1,99988E0

5,25123E0

3,72919E-1

1,74034E0

1,47825E0

4,08712E-2

4,49156E0

1,27967E0

2,56706E-4

5,00220E-1

1,65089E1

6,66709E0

1,55720E0

6,30010E-1

3,13188E0

1,37560E1

2,69795E0

8.2

min

5,20460E0

1,93160E1

4,33847E0

3,41334E-1

1,21186E-1

1,99988E0

5,12985E0

3,28463E-1

1,74034E0

1,47825E0

4,07388E-2

4,49155E0

1,27942E0

2,56706E-4

5,00220E-1

1,65089E1

6,66709E0

1,49904E0

6,30010E-1

3,10226E0

1,37559E1

2,67433E0

8.2

max

5,20463E0

1,93232E1

4,46411E0

3,49990E-1

1,22796E-1

2,10252E0

5,25131E0

3,72919E-1

1,74042E0

1,48451E0

4,08712E-2

4,50061E0

1,27967E0

2,75125E-4

5,19276E-1

1,65090E1

6,66740E0

1,55720E0

6,38666E-1

3,13192E0

1,37682E1

2,69796E0

8.2

mean

5,20463E0

1,93232E1

4,33855E0

3,49984E-1

1,22794E-1

1,99998E0

5,25120E0

3,72885E-1

1,74034E0

1,47826E0

4,08710E-2

4,49157E0

1,27967E0

2,56728E-4

5,00235E-1

1,65089E1

6,66709E0

1,55713E0

6,30016E-1

3,13188E0

1,37560E1

2,69794E0

8.2

relative error(%)

0,00

8.4

BioUML

5,20464E0

1,93426E1

4,11529E0

3,60593E-1

1,27930E-1

2,00763E0

5,67536E0

3,70143E-1

1,74140E0

1,46717E0

4,11951E-2

4,51480E0

1,27962E0

2,60162E-4

4,75830E-1

1,65106E1

6,66634E0

1,55222E0

6,19407E-1

3,25813E0

1,39040E1

2,77173E0

8.4

ByoDyn

5,20464E0

1,93427E1

4,11275E0

3,60744E-1

1,27972E-1

2,00641E0

5,67878E0

3,70660E-1

1,74139E0

1,46705E0

4,11982E-2

4,51476E0

1,27962E0

2,59945E-4

4,75489E-1

1,65105E1

6,66634E0

1,55293E0

6,19256E-1

3,25905E0

1,39038E1

2,77238E0

8.4

Jarnac

5,20464E0

1,93427E1

4,11275E0

3,60744E-1

1,27972E-1

2,00641E0

5,67878E0

3,70660E-1

1,74139E0

1,46705E0

4,11982E-2

4,51476E0

1,27962E0

2,59945E-4

4,75489E-1

1,65105E1

6,66634E0

1,55293E0

6,19256E-1

3,25905E0

1,39038E1

2,77238E0

8.4

MathSBML

5,20464E0

1,93427E1

4,11275E0

3,60744E-1

1,27972E-1

2,00641E0

5,67878E0

3,70660E-1

1,74139E0

1,46705E0

4,11982E-2

4,51476E0

1,27962E0

2,59945E-4

4,75489E-1

1,65105E1

6,66634E0

1,55293E0

6,19256E-1

3,25905E0

1,39038E1

2,77238E0

8.4

Oscill8 Core

5,20464E0

1,93427E1

4,11285E0

1,27971E-1

5,67865E0

3,70640E-1

1,74139E0

1,46706E0

4,11981E-2

4,51476E0

1,27962E0

2,59944E-4

4,75503E-1

1,65105E1

6,66634E0

1,55290E0

6,19262E-1

3,25901E0

1,39038E1

2,77236E0

8.4

SBToolbox2

5,20460E0

1,93382E1

4,15730E0

3,59677E-1

1,26352E-1

1,95795E0

5,53969E0

3,92550E-1

1,74142E0

1,46952E0

4,11096E-2

4,50006E0

1,27990E0

2,50831E-4

4,78320E-1

1,65100E1

6,66650E0

1,57946E0

6,20323E-1

3,21536E0

1,38733E1

2,75099E0

8.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,20464E0

1,93427E1

4,11286E0

3,60741E-1

1,27969E-1

2,00632E0

5,67848E0

3,70705E-1

1,74139E0

1,46706E0

4,11980E-2

4,51473E0

1,27962E0

2,59927E-4

4,75496E-1

1,65105E1

6,66634E0

1,55298E0

6,19259E-1

3,25895E0

1,39037E1

2,77233E0

8.4

VCell

5,20464E0

1,93427E1

4,11275E0

3,60744E-1

1,27972E-1

2,00641E0

5,67878E0

3,70660E-1

1,74139E0

1,46705E0

4,11982E-2

4,51476E0

1,27962E0

2,59945E-4

4,75489E-1

1,65105E1

6,66634E0

1,55293E0

6,19256E-1

3,25905E0

1,39038E1

2,77238E0

8.4

copasi

5,20464E0

1,93427E1

4,11267E0

3,60749E-1

1,27974E-1

2,00638E0

5,67891E0

3,70676E-1

1,74139E0

1,46705E0

4,11983E-2

4,51476E0

1,27962E0

2,59939E-4

4,75478E-1

1,65105E1

6,66634E0

1,55295E0

6,19251E-1

3,25908E0

1,39037E1

2,77241E0

8.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20464E0

1,93427E1

4,11275E0

3,60744E-1

1,27972E-1

2,00641E0

5,67878E0

3,70660E-1

1,74139E0

1,46705E0

4,11982E-2

4,51476E0

1,27962E0

2,59945E-4

4,75489E-1

1,65105E1

6,66634E0

1,55293E0

6,19256E-1

3,25905E0

1,39038E1

2,77238E0

8.4

jsim

5,20464E0

1,93427E1

4,11267E0

3,60748E-1

1,27974E-1

2,00641E0

5,67894E0

3,70651E-1

1,74140E0

1,46705E0

4,11984E-2

4,51477E0

1,27962E0

2,59941E-4

4,75479E-1

1,65105E1

6,66634E0

1,55294E0

6,19252E-1

3,25909E0

1,39039E1

2,77241E0

8.4

min

5,20460E0

1,93382E1

4,11267E0

3,59677E-1

1,26352E-1

1,95795E0

5,53969E0

3,70640E-1

1,74139E0

1,46705E0

4,11096E-2

4,50006E0

1,27962E0

2,50831E-4

4,75478E-1

1,65100E1

6,66634E0

1,55290E0

6,19251E-1

3,21536E0

1,38733E1

2,75099E0

8.4

max

5,20464E0

1,93427E1

4,15730E0

3,60749E-1

1,27974E-1

2,00641E0

5,67894E0

3,92550E-1

1,74142E0

1,46952E0

4,11984E-2

4,51477E0

1,27990E0

2,59945E-4

4,78320E-1

1,65105E1

6,66650E0

1,57946E0

6,20323E-1

3,25909E0

1,39039E1

2,77241E0

8.4

mean

5,20464E0

1,93427E1

4,11275E0

3,60744E-1

1,27972E-1

2,00641E0

5,67878E0

3,70660E-1

1,74139E0

1,46705E0

4,11982E-2

4,51476E0

1,27962E0

2,59945E-4

4,75489E-1

1,65105E1

6,66634E0

1,55293E0

6,19256E-1

3,25905E0

1,39038E1

2,77238E0

8.4

relative error(%)

0,00

8.6

BioUML

5,20466E0

1,93304E1

4,36012E0

3,43498E-1

1,24868E-1

2,21119E0

5,43712E0

2,86131E-1

1,74262E0

1,47905E0

4,09410E-2

4,53297E0

1,27961E0

2,99562E-4

5,13825E-1

1,65123E1

6,66704E0

1,43268E0

6,36502E-1

3,20295E0

1,40048E1

2,72511E0

8.6

ByoDyn

5,20466E0

1,93304E1

4,36032E0

3,43467E-1

1,24874E-1

2,21199E0

5,43764E0

2,85831E-1

1,74262E0

1,47905E0

4,09409E-2

4,53309E0

1,27961E0

2,99740E-4

5,13893E-1

1,65123E1

6,66704E0

1,43218E0

6,36533E-1

3,20317E0

1,40047E1

2,72518E0

8.6

Jarnac

5,20466E0

1,93304E1

4,36032E0

3,43467E-1

1,24874E-1

2,21199E0

5,43764E0

2,85831E-1

1,74262E0

1,47905E0

4,09409E-2

4,53309E0

1,27961E0

2,99740E-4

5,13893E-1

1,65123E1

6,66704E0

1,43218E0

6,36533E-1

3,20317E0

1,40047E1

2,72518E0

8.6

MathSBML

5,20466E0

1,93304E1

4,36032E0

3,43467E-1

1,24874E-1

2,21199E0

5,43764E0

2,85830E-1

1,74262E0

1,47905E0

4,09409E-2

4,53309E0

1,27961E0

2,99740E-4

5,13894E-1

1,65123E1

6,66704E0

1,43218E0

6,36533E-1

3,20317E0

1,40047E1

2,72518E0

8.6

Oscill8 Core

5,20466E0

1,93304E1

4,36031E0

1,24873E-1

5,43758E0

2,85855E-1

1,74262E0

1,47905E0

4,09409E-2

4,53308E0

1,27961E0

2,99726E-4

5,13889E-1

1,65123E1

6,66704E0

1,43222E0

6,36531E-1

3,20315E0

1,40047E1

2,72517E0

8.6

SBToolbox2

5,20470E0

1,93399E1

4,20857E0

3,52964E-1

1,27371E-1

2,13397E0

5,63822E0

3,16371E-1

1,74260E0

1,47170E0

4,11256E-2

4,53261E0

1,27960E0

2,84149E-4

4,92428E-1

1,65120E1

6,66660E0

1,47966E0

6,27036E-1

3,25603E0

1,40186E1

2,76027E0

8.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,20466E0

1,93305E1

4,35999E0

3,43487E-1

1,24879E-1

2,21182E0

5,43808E0

2,85895E-1

1,74262E0

1,47903E0

4,09413E-2

4,53309E0

1,27961E0

2,99705E-4

5,13847E-1

1,65123E1

6,66704E0

1,43228E0

6,36513E-1

3,20328E0

1,40048E1

2,72525E0

8.6

VCell

5,20466E0

1,93304E1

4,36032E0

3,43467E-1

1,24874E-1

2,21199E0

5,43764E0

2,85831E-1

1,74262E0

1,47905E0

4,09409E-2

4,53309E0

1,27961E0

2,99740E-4

5,13893E-1

1,65123E1

6,66704E0

1,43218E0

6,36533E-1

3,20317E0

1,40047E1

2,72518E0

8.6

copasi

5,20466E0

1,93304E1

4,36037E0

3,43462E-1

1,24874E-1

2,21206E0

5,43763E0

2,85802E-1

1,74262E0

1,47905E0

4,09408E-2

4,53310E0

1,27961E0

2,99756E-4

5,13904E-1

1,65123E1

6,66704E0

1,43214E0

6,36538E-1

3,20317E0

1,40047E1

2,72518E0

8.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20466E0

1,93304E1

4,36032E0

3,43467E-1

1,24874E-1

2,21199E0

5,43764E0

2,85831E-1

1,74262E0

1,47905E0

4,09409E-2

4,53309E0

1,27961E0

2,99740E-4

5,13893E-1

1,65123E1

6,66704E0

1,43218E0

6,36533E-1

3,20317E0

1,40047E1

2,72518E0

8.6

jsim

5,20466E0

1,93304E1

4,36042E0

3,43460E-1

1,24873E-1

2,21208E0

5,43755E0

2,85793E-1

1,74262E0

1,47905E0

4,09410E-2

4,53310E0

1,27961E0

2,99758E-4

5,13909E-1

1,65123E1

6,66704E0

1,43213E0

6,36540E-1

3,20315E0

1,40048E1

2,72516E0

8.6

min

5,20466E0

1,93304E1

4,20857E0

3,43460E-1

1,24873E-1

2,13397E0

5,43755E0

2,85793E-1

1,74260E0

1,47170E0

4,09408E-2

4,53261E0

1,27960E0

2,84149E-4

4,92428E-1

1,65120E1

6,66660E0

1,43213E0

6,27036E-1

3,20315E0

1,40047E1

2,72516E0

8.6

max

5,20470E0

1,93399E1

4,36042E0

3,52964E-1

1,27371E-1

2,21208E0

5,63822E0

3,16371E-1

1,74262E0

1,47905E0

4,11256E-2

4,53310E0

1,27961E0

2,99758E-4

5,13909E-1

1,65123E1

6,66704E0

1,47966E0

6,36540E-1

3,25603E0

1,40186E1

2,76027E0

8.6

mean

5,20466E0

1,93304E1

4,36032E0

3,43467E-1

1,24874E-1

2,21199E0

5,43764E0

2,85831E-1

1,74262E0

1,47905E0

4,09409E-2

4,53309E0

1,27961E0

2,99740E-4

5,13893E-1

1,65123E1

6,66704E0

1,43218E0

6,36533E-1

3,20317E0

1,40047E1

2,72518E0

8.6

relative error(%)

0,00

8.8

BioUML

5,20467E0

1,93206E1

4,44890E0

3,42299E-1

1,21148E-1

2,08043E0

5,12583E0

3,37734E-1

1,74375E0

1,48552E0

4,07511E-2

4,49751E0

1,28072E0

2,70923E-4

5,16425E-1

1,65130E1

6,66752E0

1,51184E0

6,37701E-1

3,09953E0

1,40024E1

2,67560E0

8.8

ByoDyn

5,20467E0

1,93205E1

4,44988E0

3,42248E-1

1,21127E-1

2,08052E0

5,12414E0

3,37686E-1

1,74375E0

1,48558E0

4,07497E-2

4,49742E0

1,28072E0

2,70927E-4

5,16538E-1

1,65130E1

6,66753E0

1,51179E0

6,37752E-1

3,09902E0

1,40017E1

2,67530E0

8.8

Jarnac

5,20467E0

1,93205E1

4,44988E0

3,42248E-1

1,21127E-1

2,08052E0

5,12414E0

3,37686E-1

1,74375E0

1,48558E0

4,07497E-2

4,49742E0

1,28072E0

2,70927E-4

5,16538E-1

1,65130E1

6,66753E0

1,51179E0

6,37752E-1

3,09902E0

1,40017E1

2,67530E0

8.8

MathSBML

5,20467E0

1,93205E1

4,44988E0

3,42248E-1

1,21127E-1

2,08052E0

5,12414E0

3,37688E-1

1,74375E0

1,48558E0

4,07497E-2

4,49742E0

1,28072E0

2,70927E-4

5,16537E-1

1,65130E1

6,66753E0

1,51180E0

6,37752E-1

3,09902E0

1,40017E1

2,67530E0

8.8

Oscill8 Core

5,20467E0

1,93206E1

4,44979E0

1,21129E-1

5,12430E0

3,37692E-1

1,74375E0

1,48557E0

4,07498E-2

4,49743E0

1,28072E0

2,70930E-4

5,16529E-1

1,65130E1

6,66753E0

1,51179E0

6,37748E-1

3,09906E0

1,40017E1

2,67533E0

8.8

SBToolbox2

5,20470E0

1,93199E1

4,49994E0

3,36958E-1

1,21340E-1

2,19075E0

5,14960E0

2,93463E-1

1,74380E0

1,48752E0

4,07252E-2

4,51484E0

1,28031E0

2,93461E-4

5,28308E-1

1,65130E1

6,66751E0

1,44572E0

6,43042E-1

3,11529E0

1,40379E1

2,67822E0

8.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,20467E0

1,93205E1

4,45002E0

3,42235E-1

1,21127E-1

2,08076E0

5,12414E0

3,37589E-1

1,74375E0

1,48558E0

4,07496E-2

4,49746E0

1,28072E0

2,70975E-4

5,16567E-1

1,65130E1

6,66753E0

1,51165E0

6,37765E-1

3,09903E0

1,40018E1

2,67530E0

8.8

VCell

5,20467E0

1,93205E1

4,44988E0

3,42248E-1

1,21127E-1

2,08052E0

5,12414E0

3,37686E-1

1,74375E0

1,48558E0

4,07497E-2

4,49742E0

1,28072E0

2,70927E-4

5,16538E-1

1,65130E1

6,66753E0

1,51179E0

6,37752E-1

3,09902E0

1,40017E1

2,67530E0

8.8

copasi

5,20467E0

1,93205E1

4,44997E0

3,42244E-1

1,21125E-1

2,08050E0

5,12396E0

3,37695E-1

1,74375E0

1,48558E0

4,07496E-2

4,49741E0

1,28072E0

2,70923E-4

5,16546E-1

1,65130E1

6,66753E0

1,51181E0

6,37756E-1

3,09896E0

1,40016E1

2,67527E0

8.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20467E0

1,93205E1

4,44988E0

3,42248E-1

1,21127E-1

2,08052E0

5,12414E0

3,37686E-1

1,74375E0

1,48558E0

4,07497E-2

4,49742E0

1,28072E0

2,70927E-4

5,16538E-1

1,65130E1

6,66753E0

1,51179E0

6,37752E-1

3,09902E0

1,40017E1

2,67530E0

8.8

jsim

5,20467E0

1,93205E1

4,44990E0

3,42248E-1

1,21126E-1

2,08045E0

5,12402E0

3,37714E-1

1,74375E0

1,48558E0

4,07496E-2

4,49741E0

1,28072E0

2,70914E-4

5,16537E-1

1,65130E1

6,66753E0

1,51183E0

6,37752E-1

3,09897E0

1,40018E1

2,67528E0

8.8

min

5,20467E0

1,93199E1

4,44979E0

3,36958E-1

1,21125E-1

2,08045E0

5,12396E0

2,93463E-1

1,74375E0

1,48557E0

4,07252E-2

4,49741E0

1,28031E0

2,70914E-4

5,16529E-1

1,65130E1

6,66751E0

1,44572E0

6,37748E-1

3,09896E0

1,40016E1

2,67527E0

8.8

max

5,20470E0

1,93206E1

4,49994E0

3,42248E-1

1,21340E-1

2,19075E0

5,14960E0

3,37714E-1

1,74380E0

1,48752E0

4,07498E-2

4,51484E0

1,28072E0

2,93461E-4

5,28308E-1

1,65130E1

6,66753E0

1,51183E0

6,43042E-1

3,11529E0

1,40379E1

2,67822E0

8.8

mean

5,20467E0

1,93205E1

4,44988E0

3,42248E-1

1,21127E-1

2,08052E0

5,12414E0

3,37686E-1

1,74375E0

1,48558E0

4,07497E-2

4,49742E0

1,28072E0

2,70927E-4

5,16538E-1

1,65130E1

6,66753E0

1,51179E0

6,37752E-1

3,09902E0

1,40017E1

2,67530E0

8.8

relative error(%)

0,00

9.0

BioUML

5,20468E0

1,93439E1

4,14041E0

3,60083E-1

1,26674E-1

1,96212E0

5,56769E0

3,90697E-1

1,74472E0

1,47027E0

4,11373E-2

4,50239E0

1,28107E0

2,51726E-4

4,76628E-1

1,65142E1

6,66659E0

1,57718E0

6,19917E-1

3,22396E0

1,41152E1

2,75720E0

9.0

ByoDyn

5,20468E0

1,93440E1

4,13831E0

3,60226E-1

1,26699E-1

1,96028E0

5,56956E0

3,91549E-1

1,74471E0

1,47017E0

4,11394E-2

4,50216E0

1,28108E0

2,51420E-4

4,76319E-1

1,65142E1

6,66658E0

1,57817E0

6,19774E-1

3,22442E0

1,41145E1

2,75765E0

9.0

Jarnac

5,20468E0

1,93440E1

4,13831E0

3,60226E-1

1,26699E-1

1,96028E0

5,56956E0

3,91549E-1

1,74471E0

1,47017E0

4,11394E-2

4,50216E0

1,28108E0

2,51420E-4

4,76319E-1

1,65142E1

6,66658E0

1,57817E0

6,19774E-1

3,22442E0

1,41145E1

2,75765E0

9.0

MathSBML

5,20468E0

1,93440E1

4,13831E0

3,60226E-1

1,26699E-1

1,96028E0

5,56956E0

3,91549E-1

1,74471E0

1,47017E0

4,11394E-2

4,50216E0

1,28108E0

2,51420E-4

4,76319E-1

1,65142E1

6,66658E0

1,57817E0

6,19774E-1

3,22442E0

1,41145E1

2,75765E0

9.0

Oscill8 Core

5,20468E0

1,93440E1

4,13836E0

1,26698E-1

5,56951E0

3,91527E-1

1,74471E0

1,47017E0

4,11394E-2

4,50217E0

1,28108E0

2,51428E-4

4,76327E-1

1,65142E1

6,66658E0

1,57814E0

6,19778E-1

3,22441E0

1,41145E1

2,75764E0

9.0

SBToolbox2

5,20470E0

1,93351E1

4,25612E0

3,54402E-1

1,24082E-1

1,96444E0

5,35350E0

3,89266E-1

1,74480E0

1,47622E0

4,09732E-2

4,49206E0

1,28130E0

2,51123E-4

4,89535E-1

1,65140E1

6,66699E0

1,57625E0

6,25598E-1

3,16065E0

1,40877E1

2,71948E0

9.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,20468E0

1,93440E1

4,13852E0

3,60216E-1

1,26694E-1

1,96027E0

5,56915E0

3,91556E-1

1,74471E0

1,47018E0

4,11391E-2

4,50214E0

1,28108E0

2,51415E-4

4,76342E-1

1,65142E1

6,66659E0

1,57818E0

6,19784E-1

3,22429E0

1,41144E1

2,75758E0

9.0

VCell

5,20468E0

1,93440E1

4,13831E0

3,60226E-1

1,26699E-1

1,96028E0

5,56956E0

3,91549E-1

1,74471E0

1,47017E0

4,11394E-2

4,50216E0

1,28108E0

2,51420E-4

4,76319E-1

1,65142E1

6,66658E0

1,57817E0

6,19774E-1

3,22442E0

1,41145E1

2,75765E0

9.0

copasi

5,20468E0

1,93440E1

4,13822E0

3,60231E-1

1,26700E-1

1,96021E0

5,56964E0

3,91581E-1

1,74471E0

1,47017E0

4,11395E-2

4,50215E0

1,28108E0

2,51409E-4

4,76307E-1

1,65142E1

6,66659E0

1,57820E0

6,19769E-1

3,22444E0

1,41144E1

2,75767E0

9.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20468E0

1,93440E1

4,13831E0

3,60226E-1

1,26699E-1

1,96028E0

5,56956E0

3,91549E-1

1,74471E0

1,47017E0

4,11394E-2

4,50216E0

1,28108E0

2,51420E-4

4,76319E-1

1,65142E1

6,66658E0

1,57817E0

6,19774E-1

3,22442E0

1,41145E1

2,75765E0

9.0

jsim

5,20468E0

1,93441E1

4,13819E0

3,60232E-1

1,26701E-1

1,96025E0

5,56973E0

3,91566E-1

1,74471E0

1,47017E0

4,11396E-2

4,50217E0

1,28108E0

2,51414E-4

4,76305E-1

1,65142E1

6,66658E0

1,57819E0

6,19768E-1

3,22447E0

1,41145E1

2,75768E0

9.0

min

5,20468E0

1,93351E1

4,13819E0

3,54402E-1

1,24082E-1

1,96021E0

5,35350E0

3,89266E-1

1,74471E0

1,47017E0

4,09732E-2

4,49206E0

1,28108E0

2,51123E-4

4,76305E-1

1,65140E1

6,66658E0

1,57625E0

6,19768E-1

3,16065E0

1,40877E1

2,71948E0

9.0

max

5,20470E0

1,93441E1

4,25612E0

3,60232E-1

1,26701E-1

1,96444E0

5,56973E0

3,91581E-1

1,74480E0

1,47622E0

4,11396E-2

4,50217E0

1,28130E0

2,51428E-4

4,89535E-1

1,65142E1

6,66699E0

1,57820E0

6,25598E-1

3,22447E0

1,41145E1

2,75768E0

9.0

mean

5,20468E0

1,93440E1

4,13831E0

3,60226E-1

1,26699E-1

1,96028E0

5,56956E0

3,91549E-1

1,74471E0

1,47017E0

4,11394E-2

4,50216E0

1,28108E0

2,51420E-4

4,76319E-1

1,65142E1

6,66658E0

1,57817E0

6,19774E-1

3,22442E0

1,41145E1

2,75765E0

9.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0,12

0,00

9.2

BioUML

5,20469E0

1,93428E1

4,23964E0

3,50552E-1

1,26832E-1

2,15658E0

5,59567E0

3,07422E-1

1,74584E0

1,47475E0

4,10924E-2

4,53388E0

1,28085E0

2,88715E-4

4,97162E-1

1,65162E1

6,66681E0

1,46600E0

6,29448E-1

3,24548E0

1,42514E1

2,75412E0

9.2

ByoDyn

5,20469E0

1,93428E1

4,23886E0

3,50586E-1

1,26853E-1

2,15683E0

5,59746E0

3,07311E-1

1,74583E0

1,47470E0

4,10937E-2

4,53399E0

1,28085E0

2,88768E-4

4,97084E-1

1,65162E1

6,66682E0

1,46586E0

6,29414E-1

3,24602E0

1,42513E1

2,75440E0

9.2

Jarnac

5,20469E0

1,93428E1

4,23886E0

3,50586E-1

1,26853E-1

2,15683E0

5,59746E0

3,07311E-1

1,74583E0

1,47470E0

4,10937E-2

4,53399E0

1,28085E0

2,88768E-4

4,97084E-1

1,65162E1

6,66682E0

1,46586E0

6,29414E-1

3,24602E0

1,42513E1

2,75440E0

9.2

MathSBML

5,20469E0

1,93428E1

4,23886E0

3,50586E-1

1,26853E-1

2,15683E0

5,59745E0

3,07311E-1

1,74583E0

1,47470E0

4,10937E-2

4,53399E0

1,28085E0

2,88768E-4

4,97085E-1

1,65162E1

6,66682E0

1,46586E0

6,29414E-1

3,24602E0

1,42513E1

2,75440E0

9.2

Oscill8 Core

5,20469E0

1,93428E1

4,23890E0

1,26852E-1

5,59737E0

3,07316E-1

1,74583E0

1,47471E0

4,10936E-2

4,53399E0

1,28085E0

2,88767E-4

4,97089E-1

1,65162E1

6,66682E0

1,46586E0

6,29416E-1

3,24599E0

1,42513E1

2,75439E0

9.2

SBToolbox2

5,20470E0

1,93489E1

4,12688E0

3,58621E-1

1,28068E-1

2,05149E0

5,69112E0

3,50778E-1

1,74581E0

1,46972E0

4,12037E-2

4,52314E0

1,28110E0

2,68278E-4

4,79126E-1

1,65160E1

6,66650E0

1,52770E0

6,21379E-1

3,26574E0

1,42406E1

2,77414E0

9.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,20469E0

1,93428E1

4,23860E0

3,50604E-1

1,26857E-1

2,15662E0

5,59772E0

3,07395E-1

1,74583E0

1,47469E0

4,10939E-2

4,53398E0

1,28085E0

2,88728E-4

4,97044E-1

1,65162E1

6,66682E0

1,46598E0

6,29396E-1

3,24608E0

1,42513E1

2,75445E0

9.2

VCell

5,20469E0

1,93428E1

4,23886E0

3,50586E-1

1,26853E-1

2,15683E0

5,59746E0

3,07311E-1

1,74583E0

1,47470E0

4,10937E-2

4,53399E0

1,28085E0

2,88768E-4

4,97084E-1

1,65162E1

6,66682E0

1,46586E0

6,29414E-1

3,24602E0

1,42513E1

2,75440E0

9.2

copasi

5,20469E0

1,93428E1

4,23883E0

3,50586E-1

1,26855E-1

2,15687E0

5,59756E0

3,07297E-1

1,74583E0

1,47470E0

4,10937E-2

4,53400E0

1,28085E0

2,88776E-4

4,97083E-1

1,65162E1

6,66682E0

1,46583E0

6,29414E-1

3,24605E0

1,42512E1

2,75442E0

9.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20469E0

1,93428E1

4,23886E0

3,50586E-1

1,26853E-1

2,15683E0

5,59746E0

3,07311E-1

1,74583E0

1,47470E0

4,10937E-2

4,53399E0

1,28085E0

2,88768E-4

4,97084E-1

1,65162E1

6,66682E0

1,46586E0

6,29414E-1

3,24602E0

1,42513E1

2,75440E0

9.2

jsim

5,20469E0

1,93428E1

4,23888E0

3,50583E-1

1,26854E-1

2,15691E0

5,59750E0

3,07280E-1

1,74583E0

1,47470E0

4,10936E-2

4,53401E0

1,28085E0

2,88784E-4

4,97091E-1

1,65162E1

6,66682E0

1,46581E0

6,29417E-1

3,24603E0

1,42514E1

2,75440E0

9.2

min

5,20469E0

1,93428E1

4,12688E0

3,50583E-1

1,26852E-1

2,05149E0

5,59737E0

3,07280E-1

1,74581E0

1,46972E0

4,10936E-2

4,52314E0

1,28085E0

2,68278E-4

4,79126E-1

1,65160E1

6,66650E0

1,46581E0

6,21379E-1

3,24599E0

1,42406E1

2,75439E0

9.2

max

5,20470E0

1,93489E1

4,23890E0

3,58621E-1

1,28068E-1

2,15691E0

5,69112E0

3,50778E-1

1,74583E0

1,47471E0

4,12037E-2

4,53401E0

1,28110E0

2,88784E-4

4,97091E-1

1,65162E1

6,66682E0

1,52770E0

6,29417E-1

3,26574E0

1,42514E1

2,77414E0

9.2

mean

5,20469E0

1,93428E1

4,23886E0

3,50586E-1

1,26853E-1

2,15683E0

5,59746E0

3,07311E-1

1,74583E0

1,47470E0

4,10937E-2

4,53399E0

1,28085E0

2,88768E-4

4,97084E-1

1,65162E1

6,66682E0

1,46586E0

6,29414E-1

3,24602E0

1,42513E1

2,75440E0

9.2

relative error(%)

0,00

9.4

BioUML

5,20470E0

1,93229E1

4,50548E0

3,36911E-1

1,20825E-1

2,16931E0

5,10783E0

3,01740E-1

1,74698E0

1,48973E0

4,07083E-2

4,50961E0

1,28172E0

2,88715E-4

5,27674E-1

1,65171E1

6,66775E0

1,45895E0

6,43089E-1

3,10094E0

1,42553E1

2,67293E0

9.4

ByoDyn

5,20470E0

1,93227E1

4,50770E0

3,36772E-1

1,20787E-1

2,17041E0

5,10490E0

3,01294E-1

1,74697E0

1,48985E0

4,07052E-2

4,50959E0

1,28172E0

2,88915E-4

5,27984E-1

1,65171E1

6,66776E0

1,45830E0

6,43228E-1

3,10013E0

1,42546E1

2,67244E0

9.4

Jarnac

5,20470E0

1,93227E1

4,50770E0

3,36772E-1

1,20787E-1

2,17041E0

5,10490E0

3,01294E-1

1,74697E0

1,48985E0

4,07052E-2

4,50959E0

1,28172E0

2,88915E-4

5,27984E-1

1,65171E1

6,66776E0

1,45830E0

6,43228E-1

3,10013E0

1,42546E1

2,67244E0

9.4

MathSBML

5,20470E0

1,93227E1

4,50770E0

3,36772E-1

1,20787E-1

2,17041E0

5,10490E0

3,01295E-1

1,74697E0

1,48985E0

4,07052E-2

4,50959E0

1,28172E0

2,88915E-4

5,27984E-1

1,65171E1

6,66776E0

1,45830E0

6,43228E-1

3,10013E0

1,42546E1

2,67244E0

9.4

Oscill8 Core

5,20470E0

1,93227E1

4,50763E0

1,20788E-1

5,10499E0

3,01311E-1

1,74697E0

1,48985E0

4,07053E-2

4,50959E0

1,28172E0

2,88908E-4

5,27974E-1

1,65171E1

6,66776E0

1,45832E0

6,43224E-1

3,10015E0

1,42546E1

2,67245E0

9.4

SBToolbox2

5,20470E0

1,93309E1

4,43569E0

3,38896E-1

1,23159E-1

2,22668E0

5,29940E0

2,80184E-1

1,74700E0

1,48525E0

4,08377E-2

4,52820E0

1,28131E0

3,02304E-4

5,23278E-1

1,65171E1

6,66740E0

1,42322E0

6,41104E-1

3,16349E0

1,43039E1

2,70422E0

9.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,20470E0

1,93227E1

4,50765E0

3,36769E-1

1,20790E-1

2,17058E0

5,10518E0

3,01227E-1

1,74697E0

1,48984E0

4,07054E-2

4,50963E0

1,28172E0

2,88954E-4

5,27989E-1

1,65171E1

6,66776E0

1,45819E0

6,43231E-1

3,10023E0

1,42547E1

2,67248E0

9.4

VCell

5,20470E0

1,93227E1

4,50770E0

3,36772E-1

1,20787E-1

2,17041E0

5,10490E0

3,01294E-1

1,74697E0

1,48985E0

4,07052E-2

4,50959E0

1,28172E0

2,88915E-4

5,27984E-1

1,65171E1

6,66776E0

1,45830E0

6,43228E-1

3,10013E0

1,42546E1

2,67244E0

9.4

copasi

5,20470E0

1,93227E1

4,50784E0

3,36763E-1

1,20784E-1

2,17046E0

5,10469E0

3,01275E-1

1,74697E0

1,48986E0

4,07050E-2

4,50958E0

1,28172E0

2,88924E-4

5,28003E-1

1,65171E1

6,66776E0

1,45827E0

6,43237E-1

3,10007E0

1,42545E1

2,67240E0

9.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20470E0

1,93227E1

4,50770E0

3,36772E-1

1,20787E-1

2,17041E0

5,10490E0

3,01294E-1

1,74697E0

1,48985E0

4,07052E-2

4,50959E0

1,28172E0

2,88915E-4

5,27984E-1

1,65171E1

6,66776E0

1,45830E0

6,43228E-1

3,10013E0

1,42546E1

2,67244E0

9.4

jsim

5,20470E0

1,93227E1

4,50783E0

3,36765E-1

1,20784E-1

2,17042E0

5,10466E0

3,01286E-1

1,74697E0

1,48986E0

4,07051E-2

4,50958E0

1,28172E0

2,88913E-4

5,27998E-1

1,65171E1

6,66776E0

1,45830E0

6,43235E-1

3,10006E0

1,42546E1

2,67240E0

9.4

min

5,20470E0

1,93227E1

4,43569E0

3,36763E-1

1,20784E-1

2,17041E0

5,10466E0

2,80184E-1

1,74697E0

1,48525E0

4,07050E-2

4,50958E0

1,28131E0

2,88908E-4

5,23278E-1

1,65171E1

6,66740E0

1,42322E0

6,41104E-1

3,10006E0

1,42545E1

2,67240E0

9.4

max

5,20470E0

1,93309E1

4,50784E0

3,38896E-1

1,23159E-1

2,22668E0

5,29940E0

3,01311E-1

1,74700E0

1,48986E0

4,08377E-2

4,52820E0

1,28172E0

3,02304E-4

5,28003E-1

1,65171E1

6,66776E0

1,45832E0

6,43237E-1

3,16349E0

1,43039E1

2,70422E0

9.4

mean

5,20470E0

1,93227E1

4,50770E0

3,36772E-1

1,20787E-1

2,17041E0

5,10490E0

3,01294E-1

1,74697E0

1,48985E0

4,07052E-2

4,50959E0

1,28172E0

2,88915E-4

5,27984E-1

1,65171E1

6,66776E0

1,45830E0

6,43228E-1

3,10013E0

1,42546E1

2,67244E0

9.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0,14

0,00

9.6

BioUML

5,20471E0

1,93418E1

4,21875E0

3,56146E-1

1,24678E-1

1,95353E0

5,40267E0

3,94448E-1

1,74790E0

1,47599E0

4,10224E-2

4,49281E0

1,28253E0

2,49547E-4

4,84938E-1

1,65180E1

6,66699E0

1,58202E0

6,23854E-1

3,17475E0

1,43177E1

2,73027E0

9.6

ByoDyn

5,20471E0

1,93419E1

4,21812E0

3,56205E-1

1,24677E-1

1,95227E0

5,40244E0

3,95040E-1

1,74790E0

1,47596E0

4,10227E-2

4,49257E0

1,28254E0

2,49333E-4

4,84816E-1

1,65180E1

6,66699E0

1,58269E0

6,23795E-1

3,17462E0

1,43168E1

2,73030E0

9.6

Jarnac

5,20471E0

1,93419E1

4,21812E0

3,56205E-1

1,24677E-1

1,95227E0

5,40244E0

3,95040E-1

1,74790E0

1,47596E0

4,10227E-2

4,49257E0

1,28254E0

2,49333E-4

4,84816E-1

1,65180E1

6,66699E0

1,58269E0

6,23795E-1

3,17462E0

1,43168E1

2,73030E0

9.6

MathSBML

5,20471E0

1,93419E1

4,21812E0

3,56205E-1

1,24677E-1

1,95227E0

5,40244E0

3,95040E-1

1,74790E0

1,47596E0

4,10227E-2

4,49257E0

1,28254E0

2,49333E-4

4,84816E-1

1,65180E1

6,66699E0

1,58269E0

6,23795E-1

3,17462E0

1,43168E1

2,73030E0

9.6

Oscill8 Core

5,20471E0

1,93419E1

4,21813E0

1,24677E-1

5,40245E0

3,95029E-1

1,74790E0

1,47596E0

4,10227E-2

4,49258E0

1,28254E0

2,49337E-4

4,84818E-1

1,65180E1

6,66699E0

1,58268E0

6,23796E-1

3,17462E0

1,43168E1

2,73030E0

9.6

SBToolbox2

5,20470E0

1,93300E1

4,38518E0

3,46336E-1

1,21780E-1

2,02552E0

5,17260E0

3,61400E-1

1,74800E0

1,48456E0

4,08188E-2

4,49227E0

1,28250E0

2,60989E-4

5,06578E-1

1,65180E1

6,66750E0

1,54316E0

6,33664E-1

3,11011E0

1,43072E1

2,68696E0

9.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,20471E0

1,93418E1

4,21842E0

3,56188E-1

1,24671E-1

1,95235E0

5,40197E0

3,95003E-1

1,74790E0

1,47598E0

4,10223E-2

4,49256E0

1,28254E0

2,49344E-4

4,84853E-1

1,65180E1

6,66699E0

1,58265E0

6,23812E-1

3,17448E0

1,43168E1

2,73021E0

9.6

VCell

5,20471E0

1,93419E1

4,21812E0

3,56205E-1

1,24677E-1

1,95227E0

5,40244E0

3,95040E-1

1,74790E0

1,47596E0

4,10227E-2

4,49257E0

1,28254E0

2,49333E-4

4,84816E-1

1,65180E1

6,66699E0

1,58269E0

6,23795E-1

3,17462E0

1,43168E1

2,73030E0

9.6

copasi

5,20471E0

1,93419E1

4,21807E0

3,56209E-1

1,24677E-1

1,95218E0

5,40244E0

3,95081E-1

1,74790E0

1,47596E0

4,10227E-2

4,49255E0

1,28254E0

2,49318E-4

4,84807E-1

1,65180E1

6,66699E0

1,58274E0

6,23791E-1

3,17461E0

1,43167E1

2,73031E0

9.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20471E0

1,93419E1

4,21812E0

3,56205E-1

1,24677E-1

1,95227E0

5,40244E0

3,95040E-1

1,74790E0

1,47596E0

4,10227E-2

4,49257E0

1,28254E0

2,49333E-4

4,84816E-1

1,65180E1

6,66699E0

1,58269E0

6,23795E-1

3,17462E0

1,43168E1

2,73030E0

9.6

jsim

5,20471E0

1,93419E1

4,21799E0

3,56213E-1

1,24679E-1

1,95218E0

5,40257E0

3,95079E-1

1,74790E0

1,47596E0

4,10229E-2

4,49257E0

1,28254E0

2,49319E-4

4,84799E-1

1,65180E1

6,66699E0

1,58274E0

6,23787E-1

3,17465E0

1,43169E1

2,73033E0

9.6

min

5,20470E0

1,93300E1

4,21799E0

3,46336E-1

1,21780E-1

1,95218E0

5,17260E0

3,61400E-1

1,74790E0

1,47596E0

4,08188E-2

4,49227E0

1,28250E0

2,49318E-4

4,84799E-1

1,65180E1

6,66699E0

1,54316E0

6,23787E-1

3,11011E0

1,43072E1

2,68696E0

9.6

max

5,20471E0

1,93419E1

4,38518E0

3,56213E-1

1,24679E-1

2,02552E0

5,40257E0

3,95081E-1

1,74800E0

1,48456E0

4,10229E-2

4,49258E0

1,28254E0

2,60989E-4

5,06578E-1

1,65180E1

6,66750E0

1,58274E0

6,33664E-1

3,17465E0

1,43169E1

2,73033E0

9.6

mean

5,20471E0

1,93419E1

4,21812E0

3,56205E-1

1,24677E-1

1,95227E0

5,40244E0

3,95040E-1

1,74790E0

1,47596E0

4,10227E-2

4,49257E0

1,28254E0

2,49333E-4

4,84816E-1

1,65180E1

6,66699E0

1,58269E0

6,23795E-1

3,17462E0

1,43168E1

2,73030E0

9.6

relative error(%)

0,00

9.8

BioUML

5,20471E0

1,93522E1

4,14687E0

3,56644E-1

1,27870E-1

2,08046E0

5,67721E0

3,38582E-1

1,74890E0

1,47217E0

4,11912E-2

4,52683E0

1,28230E0

2,73865E-4

4,82795E-1

1,65198E1

6,66669E0

1,51096E0

6,23356E-1

3,26389E0

1,44687E1

2,77209E0

9.8

ByoDyn

5,20471E0

1,93523E1

4,14539E0

3,56726E-1

1,27900E-1

2,08011E0

5,67965E0

3,38708E-1

1,74889E0

1,47210E0

4,11932E-2

4,52689E0

1,28230E0

2,73796E-4

4,82608E-1

1,65198E1

6,66669E0

1,51119E0

6,23274E-1

3,26457E0

1,44684E1

2,77251E0

9.8

Jarnac

5,20471E0

1,93523E1

4,14539E0

3,56726E-1

1,27900E-1

2,08011E0

5,67965E0

3,38708E-1

1,74889E0

1,47210E0

4,11932E-2

4,52689E0

1,28230E0

2,73796E-4

4,82608E-1

1,65198E1

6,66669E0

1,51119E0

6,23274E-1

3,26457E0

1,44684E1

2,77251E0

9.8

MathSBML

5,20471E0

1,93523E1

4,14539E0

3,56726E-1

1,27900E-1

2,08011E0

5,67965E0

3,38707E-1

1,74889E0

1,47210E0

4,11932E-2

4,52689E0

1,28230E0

2,73797E-4

4,82608E-1

1,65198E1

6,66669E0

1,51118E0

6,23274E-1

3,26457E0

1,44684E1

2,77251E0

9.8

Oscill8 Core

5,20471E0

1,93523E1

4,14541E0

1,27899E-1

5,67962E0

3,38704E-1

1,74889E0

1,47210E0

4,11932E-2

4,52689E0

1,28230E0

2,73799E-4

4,82611E-1

1,65198E1

6,66669E0

1,51118E0

6,23276E-1

3,26456E0

1,44684E1

2,77250E0

9.8

SBToolbox2

5,20470E0

1,93520E1

4,11315E0

3,60529E-1

1,27403E-1

1,98285E0

5,63037E0

3,81220E-1

1,74890E0

1,47100E0

4,11902E-2

4,50924E0

1,28260E0

2,55638E-4

4,74481E-1

1,65200E1

6,66660E0

1,56592E0

6,19471E-1

3,24379E0

1,44382E1

2,76894E0

9.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,20471E0

1,93523E1

4,14523E0

3,56739E-1

1,27901E-1

2,07989E0

5,67971E0

3,38800E-1

1,74889E0

1,47209E0

4,11933E-2

4,52686E0

1,28230E0

2,73755E-4

4,82579E-1

1,65198E1

6,66669E0

1,51131E0

6,23261E-1

3,26457E0

1,44684E1

2,77253E0

9.8

VCell

5,20471E0

1,93523E1

4,14539E0

3,56726E-1

1,27900E-1

2,08011E0

5,67965E0

3,38708E-1

1,74889E0

1,47210E0

4,11932E-2

4,52689E0

1,28230E0

2,73796E-4

4,82608E-1

1,65198E1

6,66669E0

1,51119E0

6,23274E-1

3,26457E0

1,44684E1

2,77251E0

9.8

copasi

5,20471E0

1,93523E1

4,14531E0

3,56730E-1

1,27902E-1

2,08010E0

5,67981E0

3,38712E-1

1,74889E0

1,47209E0

4,11933E-2

4,52689E0

1,28230E0

2,73795E-4

4,82598E-1

1,65198E1

6,66670E0

1,51119E0

6,23270E-1

3,26461E0

1,44684E1

2,77254E0

9.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,20471E0

1,93523E1

4,14539E0

3,56726E-1

1,27900E-1

2,08011E0

5,67965E0

3,38708E-1

1,74889E0

1,47210E0

4,11932E-2

4,52689E0

1,28230E0

2,73796E-4

4,82608E-1

1,65198E1

6,66669E0

1,51119E0

6,23274E-1

3,26457E0

1,44684E1

2,77251E0

9.8

jsim

5,20471E0

1,93523E1

4,14534E0

3,56727E-1

1,27901E-1

2,08015E0

5,67979E0

3,38689E-1

1,74889E0

1,47209E0

4,11933E-2

4,52690E0

1,28230E0

2,73806E-4

4,82605E-1

1,65198E1

6,66669E0

1,51116E0

6,23273E-1

3,26461E0

1,44685E1

2,77253E0

9.8

min

5,20470E0

1,93520E1

4,11315E0

3,56726E-1

1,27403E-1

1,98285E0

5,63037E0

3,38689E-1

1,74889E0

1,47100E0

4,11902E-2

4,50924E0

1,28230E0

2,55638E-4

4,74481E-1

1,65198E1

6,66660E0

1,51116E0

6,19471E-1

3,24379E0

1,44382E1

2,76894E0

9.8

max

5,20471E0

1,93523E1

4,14541E0

3,60529E-1

1,27902E-1

2,08015E0

5,67981E0

3,81220E-1

1,74890E0

1,47210E0

4,11933E-2

4,52690E0

1,28260E0

2,73806E-4

4,82611E-1

1,65200E1

6,66670E0

1,56592E0

6,23276E-1

3,26461E0

1,44685E1

2,77254E0

9.8

mean

5,20471E0

1,93523E1

4,14539E0

3,56726E-1

1,27900E-1

2,08011E0

5,67965E0

3,38708E-1

1,74889E0

1,47210E0

4,11932E-2

4,52689E0

1,28230E0

2,73796E-4

4,82608E-1

1,65198E1

6,66669E0

1,51119E0

6,23274E-1

3,26457E0

1,44684E1

2,77251E0

9.8

relative error(%)

0,00

Test: BIOMD0000000061.xml - Ok

Reaction graph

Plots

Comparison with other simulators