Test BIOMD0000000058.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000058.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000058.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: DormandPrince
generated code	: BIOMD0000000058.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: plot
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: Phi3_c1 c1 c2 Phi3_c2 Phi_minus1_c1 Phi_minus1_c2 Phi1_c2 Phi2_c1 h1 Phi2_c2 Phi1_c1 h2
Simulators: ByoDyn copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner SBToolbox2 VCell Oscill8 Core SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

Phi3_c1

Phi3_c2

Phi_minus1_c1

Phi_minus1_c2

Phi1_c2

Phi2_c1

Phi2_c2

Phi1_c1

0.0

BioUML

8,42105E-1

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

9,41176E-1

8,74751E-1

8,78244E-1

1,63934E0

6,46123E-1

8,00000E-1

5,68862E-1

4,76190E0

1,00000E-1

0.0

ByoDyn

8,42105E-1

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

9,41176E-1

8,74751E-1

8,78244E-1

1,63934E0

6,46123E-1

8,00000E-1

5,68862E-1

4,76190E0

1,00000E-1

0.0

MathSBML

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

8,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

0.0

Oscill8 Core

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

8,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

0.0

SBToolbox2

8,42110E-1

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

9,41180E-1

8,74750E-1

8,78240E-1

1,63930E0

6,46120E-1

8,00000E-1

5,68860E-1

4,76190E0

1,00000E-1

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

8,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

0.0

VCell

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

8,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

0.0

copasi

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

8,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

8,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

0.0

jsim

8,42105E-1

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

9,41176E-1

8,74751E-1

8,78244E-1

1,63934E0

6,46123E-1

8,00000E-1

5,68862E-1

4,76190E0

1,00000E-1

0.0

min

8,42105E-1

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

9,41176E-1

8,74750E-1

8,78240E-1

1,63930E0

6,46120E-1

8,00000E-1

5,68860E-1

4,76190E0

1,00000E-1

0.0

max

8,42110E-1

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

9,41180E-1

8,74751E-1

8,78244E-1

1,63934E0

6,46123E-1

8,00000E-1

5,68862E-1

4,76190E0

1,00000E-1

0.0

mean

8,42105E-1

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

9,41176E-1

8,74751E-1

8,78244E-1

1,63934E0

6,46123E-1

8,00000E-1

5,68862E-1

4,76190E0

1,00000E-1

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

7,40389E-1

5,61027E-1

8,93888E-2

9,47088E-1

8,70235E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46794E0

7,46040E-1

7,62359E-1

5,64746E-1

8,55090E0

2,48903E-1

0.2

ByoDyn

7,40389E-1

5,61027E-1

8,93888E-2

9,47088E-1

8,70235E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46794E0

7,46040E-1

7,62359E-1

5,64746E-1

8,55090E0

2,48903E-1

0.2

MathSBML

5,61027E-1

8,93888E-2

7,62359E-1

2,48903E-1

0.2

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

0.2

SBToolbox2

7,39984E-1

5,62229E-1

8,93765E-2

9,47096E-1

8,70216E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46771E0

7,46493E-1

7,62248E-1

5,64742E-1

8,56756E0

2,48916E-1

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,61027E-1

8,93890E-2

7,62358E-1

2,48902E-1

0.2

VCell

5,61027E-1

8,93888E-2

7,62359E-1

2,48903E-1

0.2

copasi

5,61026E-1

8,93888E-2

7,62359E-1

2,48903E-1

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,61027E-1

8,93888E-2

7,62359E-1

2,48903E-1

0.2

jsim

7,40389E-1

5,61027E-1

8,93888E-2

9,47088E-1

8,70235E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46794E0

7,46040E-1

7,62359E-1

5,64746E-1

8,55090E0

2,48903E-1

0.2

min

7,39984E-1

0,00000E0

9,47088E-1

8,70216E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46771E0

7,46040E-1

0,00000E0

5,64742E-1

8,55090E0

0,00000E0

0.2

max

7,40389E-1

5,62229E-1

8,93890E-2

9,47096E-1

8,70235E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46794E0

7,46493E-1

7,62359E-1

5,64746E-1

8,56756E0

2,48916E-1

0.2

mean

7,40389E-1

5,61027E-1

8,93888E-2

9,47088E-1

8,70235E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46794E0

7,46040E-1

7,62359E-1

5,64746E-1

8,55090E0

2,48903E-1

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

6,20837E-1

9,77166E-1

8,56881E-2

9,49167E-1

8,63132E-1

8,78494E-1

1,40803E0

9,03215E-1

7,03881E-1

5,63310E-1

1,40052E1

3,68666E-1

0.4

ByoDyn

6,20837E-1

9,77166E-1

8,56881E-2

9,49167E-1

8,63132E-1

8,78494E-1

1,40803E0

9,03215E-1

7,03881E-1

5,63310E-1

1,40052E1

3,68666E-1

0.4

MathSBML

9,77166E-1

8,56881E-2

7,03881E-1

3,68666E-1

0.4

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

0.4

SBToolbox2

6,20157E-1

9,79998E-1

8,56764E-2

9,49178E-1

8,63084E-1

8,78490E-1

1,40786E0

9,04280E-1

7,03604E-1

5,63302E-1

1,40405E1

3,68685E-1

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

9,77158E-1

8,56883E-2

7,03880E-1

3,68665E-1

0.4

VCell

9,77166E-1

8,56881E-2

7,03881E-1

3,68666E-1

0.4

copasi

9,77164E-1

8,56881E-2

7,03881E-1

3,68666E-1

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,77166E-1

8,56881E-2

7,03881E-1

3,68666E-1

0.4

jsim

6,20837E-1

9,77166E-1

8,56881E-2

9,49167E-1

8,63132E-1

8,78494E-1

1,40803E0

9,03215E-1

7,03881E-1

5,63310E-1

1,40052E1

3,68666E-1

0.4

min

6,20157E-1

0,00000E0

9,49167E-1

8,63084E-1

8,78490E-1

1,40786E0

9,03215E-1

0,00000E0

5,63302E-1

1,40052E1

0,00000E0

0.4

max

6,20837E-1

9,79998E-1

8,56883E-2

9,49178E-1

8,63132E-1

8,78494E-1

1,40803E0

9,04280E-1

7,03881E-1

5,63310E-1

1,40405E1

3,68685E-1

0.4

mean

6,20837E-1

9,77166E-1

8,56881E-2

9,49167E-1

8,63132E-1

8,78494E-1

1,40803E0

9,03215E-1

7,03881E-1

5,63310E-1

1,40052E1

3,68666E-1

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

5,44640E-1

1,33772E0

8,53800E-2

9,49341E-1

8,57070E-1

8,78500E-1

1,40303E0

1,03734E0

6,32756E-1

5,63190E-1

1,82307E1

4,64613E-1

0.6

ByoDyn

5,44640E-1

1,33772E0

8,53800E-2

9,49341E-1

8,57070E-1

8,78500E-1

1,40303E0

1,03734E0

6,32756E-1

5,63190E-1

1,82307E1

4,64613E-1

0.6

MathSBML

1,33772E0

8,53800E-2

6,32756E-1

4,64613E-1

0.6

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

0.6

SBToolbox2

5,44318E-1

1,33945E0

8,53398E-2

9,49361E-1

8,57044E-1

8,78500E-1

1,40236E0

1,03799E0

6,32518E-1

5,63179E-1

1,82496E1

4,64702E-1

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,33770E0

8,53801E-2

6,32758E-1

4,64611E-1

0.6

VCell

1,33772E0

8,53800E-2

6,32756E-1

4,64613E-1

0.6

copasi

1,33772E0

8,53800E-2

6,32756E-1

4,64613E-1

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,33772E0

8,53800E-2

6,32756E-1

4,64613E-1

0.6

jsim

5,44640E-1

1,33772E0

8,53800E-2

9,49341E-1

8,57070E-1

8,78500E-1

1,40303E0

1,03734E0

6,32756E-1

5,63190E-1

1,82307E1

4,64613E-1

0.6

min

5,44318E-1

0,00000E0

9,49341E-1

8,57044E-1

8,78500E-1

1,40236E0

1,03734E0

0,00000E0

5,63179E-1

1,82307E1

0,00000E0

0.6

max

5,44640E-1

1,33945E0

8,53801E-2

9,49361E-1

8,57070E-1

8,78500E-1

1,40303E0

1,03799E0

6,32758E-1

5,63190E-1

1,82496E1

4,64702E-1

0.6

mean

5,44640E-1

1,33772E0

8,53800E-2

9,49341E-1

8,57070E-1

8,78500E-1

1,40303E0

1,03734E0

6,32756E-1

5,63190E-1

1,82307E1

4,64613E-1

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

5,10032E-1

1,53706E0

8,68451E-2

9,48516E-1

8,53755E-1

8,78474E-1

1,42677E0

1,11068E0

5,63699E-1

5,63759E-1

2,03933E1

5,41135E-1

0.8

ByoDyn

5,10032E-1

1,53706E0

8,68451E-2

9,48516E-1

8,53755E-1

8,78474E-1

1,42677E0

1,11068E0

5,63699E-1

5,63759E-1

2,03933E1

5,41135E-1

0.8

MathSBML

1,53706E0

8,68451E-2

5,63699E-1

5,41135E-1

0.8

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

0.8

SBToolbox2

5,10022E-1

1,53710E0

8,67868E-2

9,48545E-1

8,53749E-1

8,78480E-1

1,42577E0

1,11072E0

5,63548E-1

5,63737E-1

2,03946E1

5,41266E-1

0.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,53703E0

8,68451E-2

5,63702E-1

5,41134E-1

0.8

VCell

1,53706E0

8,68451E-2

5,63699E-1

5,41135E-1

0.8

copasi

1,53706E0

8,68451E-2

5,63700E-1

5,41135E-1

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,53706E0

8,68451E-2

5,63699E-1

5,41135E-1

0.8

jsim

5,10032E-1

1,53706E0

8,68451E-2

9,48516E-1

8,53755E-1

8,78474E-1

1,42677E0

1,11068E0

5,63699E-1

5,63759E-1

2,03933E1

5,41135E-1

0.8

min

5,10022E-1

0,00000E0

9,48516E-1

8,53749E-1

8,78474E-1

1,42577E0

1,11068E0

0,00000E0

5,63737E-1

2,03933E1

0,00000E0

0.8

max

5,10032E-1

1,53710E0

8,68451E-2

9,48545E-1

8,53755E-1

8,78480E-1

1,42677E0

1,11072E0

5,63702E-1

5,63759E-1

2,03946E1

5,41266E-1

0.8

mean

5,10032E-1

1,53706E0

8,68451E-2

9,48516E-1

8,53755E-1

8,78474E-1

1,42677E0

1,11068E0

5,63699E-1

5,63759E-1

2,03933E1

5,41135E-1

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

4,99910E-1

1,60058E0

8,93839E-2

9,47091E-1

8,52704E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46787E0

1,13393E0

5,05960E-1

5,64744E-1

2,10586E1

6,01860E-1

1.0

ByoDyn

4,99910E-1

1,60058E0

8,93839E-2

9,47091E-1

8,52704E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46787E0

1,13393E0

5,05960E-1

5,64744E-1

2,10586E1

6,01860E-1

1.0

MathSBML

1,60058E0

8,93839E-2

5,05960E-1

6,01860E-1

1.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

1.0

SBToolbox2

4,99932E-1

1,60042E0

8,93122E-2

9,47129E-1

8,52702E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46667E0

1,13387E0

5,05906E-1

5,64714E-1

2,10572E1

6,02058E-1

1.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,60056E0

8,93840E-2

5,05963E-1

6,01859E-1

1.0

VCell

1,60058E0

8,93839E-2

5,05960E-1

6,01860E-1

1.0

copasi

1,60058E0

8,93839E-2

5,05960E-1

6,01860E-1

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,60058E0

8,93839E-2

5,05960E-1

6,01860E-1

1.0

jsim

4,99910E-1

1,60058E0

8,93839E-2

9,47091E-1

8,52704E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46787E0

1,13393E0

5,05960E-1

5,64744E-1

2,10586E1

6,01860E-1

1.0

min

4,99910E-1

0,00000E0

9,47091E-1

8,52702E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46667E0

1,13387E0

0,00000E0

5,64714E-1

2,10572E1

0,00000E0

1.0

max

4,99932E-1

1,60058E0

8,93840E-2

9,47129E-1

8,52704E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46787E0

1,13393E0

5,05963E-1

5,64744E-1

2,10586E1

6,02058E-1

1.0

mean

4,99910E-1

1,60058E0

8,93839E-2

9,47091E-1

8,52704E-1

8,78430E-1

1,46787E0

1,13393E0

5,05960E-1

5,64744E-1

2,10586E1

6,01860E-1

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

5,03479E-1

1,57789E0

9,27486E-2

9,45208E-1

8,53079E-1

8,78371E-1

1,52228E0

1,12563E0

4,62367E-1

5,66049E-1

2,08222E1

6,49747E-1

1.2

ByoDyn

5,03479E-1

1,57789E0

9,27486E-2

9,45208E-1

8,53079E-1

8,78371E-1

1,52228E0

1,12563E0

4,62367E-1

5,66049E-1

2,08222E1

6,49747E-1

1.2

MathSBML

1,57789E0

9,27486E-2

4,62367E-1

6,49747E-1

1.2

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

1.2

SBToolbox2

5,03471E-1

1,57800E0

9,26686E-2

9,45252E-1

8,53075E-1

8,78370E-1

1,52103E0

1,12562E0

4,62321E-1

5,66020E-1

2,08231E1

6,49984E-1

1.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,57788E0

9,27486E-2

4,62370E-1

6,49745E-1

1.2

VCell

1,57789E0

9,27486E-2

4,62367E-1

6,49747E-1

1.2

copasi

1,57789E0

9,27486E-2

4,62367E-1

6,49747E-1

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,57789E0

9,27486E-2

4,62367E-1

6,49747E-1

1.2

jsim

5,03479E-1

1,57789E0

9,27486E-2

9,45208E-1

8,53079E-1

8,78371E-1

1,52228E0

1,12563E0

4,62367E-1

5,66049E-1

2,08222E1

6,49747E-1

1.2

min

5,03471E-1

0,00000E0

9,45208E-1

8,53075E-1

8,78370E-1

1,52103E0

1,12562E0

0,00000E0

5,66020E-1

2,08222E1

0,00000E0

1.2

max

5,03479E-1

1,57800E0

9,27486E-2

9,45252E-1

8,53079E-1

8,78371E-1

1,52228E0

1,12563E0

4,62370E-1

5,66049E-1

2,08231E1

6,49984E-1

1.2

mean

5,03479E-1

1,57789E0

9,27486E-2

9,45208E-1

8,53079E-1

8,78371E-1

1,52228E0

1,12563E0

4,62367E-1

5,66049E-1

2,08222E1

6,49747E-1

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

5,15214E-1

1,50551E0

9,68888E-2

9,42902E-1

8,54278E-1

8,78298E-1

1,58915E0

1,09911E0

4,32293E-1

5,67656E-1

2,00587E1

6,87188E-1

1.4

ByoDyn

5,15214E-1

1,50551E0

9,68888E-2

9,42902E-1

8,54278E-1

8,78298E-1

1,58915E0

1,09911E0

4,32293E-1

5,67656E-1

2,00587E1

6,87188E-1

1.4

MathSBML

1,50551E0

9,68888E-2

4,32293E-1

6,87188E-1

1.4

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

1.4

SBToolbox2

5,15195E-1

1,50563E0

9,68025E-2

9,42948E-1

8,54279E-1

8,78300E-1

1,58778E0

1,09914E0

4,32219E-1

5,67619E-1

2,00597E1

6,87439E-1

1.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,50550E0

9,68889E-2

4,32296E-1

6,87186E-1

1.4

VCell

1,50551E0

9,68888E-2

4,32293E-1

6,87188E-1

1.4

copasi

1,50551E0

9,68888E-2

4,32293E-1

6,87188E-1

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,50551E0

9,68888E-2

4,32293E-1

6,87188E-1

1.4

jsim

5,15214E-1

1,50551E0

9,68888E-2

9,42902E-1

8,54278E-1

8,78298E-1

1,58915E0

1,09911E0

4,32293E-1

5,67656E-1

2,00587E1

6,87188E-1

1.4

min

5,15195E-1

0,00000E0

9,42902E-1

8,54278E-1

8,78298E-1

1,58778E0

1,09911E0

0,00000E0

5,67619E-1

2,00587E1

0,00000E0

1.4

max

5,15214E-1

1,50563E0

9,68889E-2

9,42948E-1

8,54279E-1

8,78300E-1

1,58915E0

1,09914E0

4,32296E-1

5,67656E-1

2,00597E1

6,87439E-1

1.4

mean

5,15214E-1

1,50551E0

9,68888E-2

9,42902E-1

8,54278E-1

8,78298E-1

1,58915E0

1,09911E0

4,32293E-1

5,67656E-1

2,00587E1

6,87188E-1

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

1.6

BioUML

5,32331E-1

1,40565E0

1,01848E-1

9,40155E-1

8,55937E-1

8,78211E-1

1,66913E0

1,06239E0

4,13886E-1

5,69579E-1

1,89808E1

7,16104E-1

1.6

ByoDyn

5,32331E-1

1,40565E0

1,01848E-1

9,40155E-1

8,55937E-1

8,78211E-1

1,66913E0

1,06239E0

4,13886E-1

5,69579E-1

1,89808E1

7,16104E-1

1.6

MathSBML

1,40565E0

1,01848E-1

4,13886E-1

7,16104E-1

1.6

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

1.6

SBToolbox2

5,32286E-1

1,40586E0

1,01757E-1

9,40204E-1

8,55936E-1

8,78212E-1

1,66761E0

1,06252E0

4,13779E-1

5,69542E-1

1,89834E1

7,16357E-1

1.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,40564E0

1,01848E-1

4,13888E-1

7,16103E-1

1.6

VCell

1,40565E0

1,01848E-1

4,13886E-1

7,16104E-1

1.6

copasi

1,40565E0

1,01848E-1

4,13886E-1

7,16104E-1

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,40565E0

1,01848E-1

4,13886E-1

7,16104E-1

1.6

jsim

5,32331E-1

1,40565E0

1,01848E-1

9,40155E-1

8,55937E-1

8,78211E-1

1,66913E0

1,06239E0

4,13886E-1

5,69579E-1

1,89808E1

7,16104E-1

1.6

min

5,32286E-1

0,00000E0

9,40155E-1

8,55936E-1

8,78211E-1

1,66761E0

1,06239E0

0,00000E0

5,69542E-1

1,89808E1

0,00000E0

1.6

max

5,32331E-1

1,40586E0

1,01848E-1

9,40204E-1

8,55937E-1

8,78212E-1

1,66913E0

1,06252E0

4,13888E-1

5,69579E-1

1,89834E1

7,16357E-1

1.6

mean

5,32331E-1

1,40565E0

1,01848E-1

9,40155E-1

8,55937E-1

8,78211E-1

1,66913E0

1,06239E0

4,13886E-1

5,69579E-1

1,89808E1

7,16104E-1

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

1.8

BioUML

5,53363E-1

1,29141E0

1,07736E-1

9,36913E-1

8,57843E-1

8,78108E-1

1,76392E0

1,02021E0

4,05129E-1

5,71862E-1

1,77114E1

7,38028E-1

1.8

ByoDyn

5,53363E-1

1,29141E0

1,07736E-1

9,36913E-1

8,57843E-1

8,78108E-1

1,76392E0

1,02021E0

4,05129E-1

5,71862E-1

1,77114E1

7,38028E-1

1.8

MathSBML

1,29141E0

1,07736E-1

4,05129E-1

7,38028E-1

1.8

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

1.8

SBToolbox2

5,53297E-1

1,29176E0

1,07632E-1

9,36971E-1

8,57842E-1

8,78110E-1

1,76226E0

1,02038E0

4,04973E-1

5,71818E-1

1,77151E1

7,38279E-1

1.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,29141E0

1,07736E-1

4,05131E-1

7,38027E-1

1.8

VCell

1,29141E0

1,07736E-1

4,05129E-1

7,38028E-1

1.8

copasi

1,29141E0

1,07736E-1

4,05129E-1

7,38028E-1

1.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,29141E0

1,07736E-1

4,05129E-1

7,38028E-1

1.8

jsim

5,53363E-1

1,29141E0

1,07736E-1

9,36913E-1

8,57843E-1

8,78108E-1

1,76392E0

1,02021E0

4,05129E-1

5,71862E-1

1,77114E1

7,38028E-1

1.8

min

5,53297E-1

0,00000E0

9,36913E-1

8,57842E-1

8,78108E-1

1,76226E0

1,02021E0

0,00000E0

5,71818E-1

1,77114E1

0,00000E0

1.8

max

5,53363E-1

1,29176E0

1,07736E-1

9,36971E-1

8,57843E-1

8,78110E-1

1,76392E0

1,02038E0

4,05131E-1

5,71862E-1

1,77151E1

7,38279E-1

1.8

mean

5,53363E-1

1,29141E0

1,07736E-1

9,36913E-1

8,57843E-1

8,78108E-1

1,76392E0

1,02021E0

4,05129E-1

5,71862E-1

1,77114E1

7,38028E-1

1.8

relative error(%)

0,00

2.0

BioUML

5,77452E-1

1,17079E0

1,14745E-1

9,33083E-1

8,59866E-1

8,77985E-1

1,87653E0

9,75476E-1

4,04230E-1

5,74579E-1

1,63272E1

7,54172E-1

2.0

ByoDyn

5,77452E-1

1,17079E0

1,14745E-1

9,33083E-1

8,59866E-1

8,77985E-1

1,87653E0

9,75476E-1

4,04230E-1

5,74579E-1

1,63272E1

7,54172E-1

2.0

MathSBML

1,17079E0

1,14745E-1

4,04230E-1

7,54172E-1

2.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

2.0

SBToolbox2

5,77366E-1

1,17122E0

1,14632E-1

9,33142E-1

8,59860E-1

8,77990E-1

1,87468E0

9,75634E-1

4,04036E-1

5,74532E-1

1,63322E1

7,54422E-1

2.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,17079E0

1,14745E-1

4,04232E-1

7,54171E-1

2.0

VCell

1,17079E0

1,14745E-1

4,04230E-1

7,54172E-1

2.0

copasi

1,17079E0

1,14745E-1

4,04230E-1

7,54172E-1

2.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,17079E0

1,14745E-1

4,04230E-1

7,54172E-1

2.0

jsim

5,77452E-1

1,17079E0

1,14745E-1

9,33083E-1

8,59866E-1

8,77985E-1

1,87653E0

9,75476E-1

4,04230E-1

5,74579E-1

1,63272E1

7,54172E-1

2.0

min

5,77366E-1

0,00000E0

9,33083E-1

8,59860E-1

8,77985E-1

1,87468E0

9,75476E-1

0,00000E0

5,74532E-1

1,63272E1

0,00000E0

2.0

max

5,77452E-1

1,17122E0

1,14745E-1

9,33142E-1

8,59866E-1

8,77990E-1

1,87653E0

9,75634E-1

4,04232E-1

5,74579E-1

1,63322E1

7,54422E-1

2.0

mean

5,77452E-1

1,17079E0

1,14745E-1

9,33083E-1

8,59866E-1

8,77985E-1

1,87653E0

9,75476E-1

4,04230E-1

5,74579E-1

1,63272E1

7,54172E-1

2.0

relative error(%)

0,00

2.2

BioUML

6,03993E-1

1,04904E0

1,23194E-1

9,28508E-1

8,61916E-1

8,77837E-1

2,01193E0

9,30100E-1

4,09706E-1

5,77854E-1

1,48820E1

7,65476E-1

2.2

ByoDyn

6,03993E-1

1,04904E0

1,23194E-1

9,28508E-1

8,61916E-1

8,77837E-1

2,01193E0

9,30100E-1

4,09706E-1

5,77854E-1

1,48820E1

7,65476E-1

2.2

MathSBML

1,04904E0

1,23194E-1

4,09706E-1

7,65476E-1

2.2

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

2.2

SBToolbox2

6,03889E-1

1,04952E0

1,23067E-1

9,28575E-1

8,61908E-1

8,77842E-1

2,00985E0

9,30267E-1

4,09472E-1

5,77800E-1

1,48871E1

7,65719E-1

2.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,04903E0

1,23195E-1

4,09707E-1

7,65476E-1

2.2

VCell

1,04904E0

1,23194E-1

4,09706E-1

7,65476E-1

2.2

copasi

1,04904E0

1,23194E-1

4,09706E-1

7,65476E-1

2.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,04904E0

1,23194E-1

4,09706E-1

7,65476E-1

2.2

jsim

6,03993E-1

1,04904E0

1,23194E-1

9,28508E-1

8,61916E-1

8,77837E-1

2,01193E0

9,30100E-1

4,09706E-1

5,77854E-1

1,48820E1

7,65476E-1

2.2

min

6,03889E-1

0,00000E0

9,28508E-1

8,61908E-1

8,77837E-1

2,00985E0

9,30100E-1

0,00000E0

5,77800E-1

1,48820E1

0,00000E0

2.2

max

6,03993E-1

1,04952E0

1,23195E-1

9,28575E-1

8,61916E-1

8,77842E-1

2,01193E0

9,30267E-1

4,09707E-1

5,77854E-1

1,48871E1

7,65719E-1

2.2

mean

6,03993E-1

1,04904E0

1,23194E-1

9,28508E-1

8,61916E-1

8,77837E-1

2,01193E0

9,30100E-1

4,09706E-1

5,77854E-1

1,48820E1

7,65476E-1

2.2

relative error(%)

0,00

2.4

BioUML

6,32456E-1

9,29819E-1

1,33627E-1

9,22921E-1

8,63934E-1

8,77654E-1

2,17860E0

8,85461E-1

4,20352E-1

5,81896E-1

1,34176E1

7,72640E-1

2.4

ByoDyn

6,32456E-1

9,29819E-1

1,33627E-1

9,22921E-1

8,63934E-1

8,77654E-1

2,17860E0

8,85461E-1

4,20352E-1

5,81896E-1

1,34176E1

7,72640E-1

2.4

MathSBML

9,29819E-1

1,33627E-1

4,20352E-1

7,72640E-1

2.4

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

2.4

SBToolbox2

6,32350E-1

9,30236E-1

1,33471E-1

9,23004E-1

8,63926E-1

8,77652E-1

2,17607E0

8,85618E-1

4,20096E-1

5,81835E-1

1,34225E1

7,72868E-1

2.4

SBWOdeSolver

9,29818E-1

1,33627E-1

4,20353E-1

7,72639E-1

2.4

VCell

9,29819E-1

1,33627E-1

4,20352E-1

7,72640E-1

2.4

copasi

9,29819E-1

1,33627E-1

4,20352E-1

7,72640E-1

2.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,29819E-1

1,33627E-1

4,20352E-1

7,72640E-1

2.4

jsim

6,32456E-1

9,29819E-1

1,33627E-1

9,22921E-1

8,63934E-1

8,77654E-1

2,17860E0

8,85461E-1

4,20352E-1

5,81896E-1

1,34176E1

7,72640E-1

2.4

min

6,32350E-1

0,00000E0

9,22921E-1

8,63926E-1

8,77652E-1

2,17607E0

8,85461E-1

0,00000E0

5,81835E-1

1,34176E1

0,00000E0

2.4

max

6,32456E-1

9,30236E-1

1,33627E-1

9,23004E-1

8,63934E-1

8,77654E-1

2,17860E0

8,85618E-1

4,20353E-1

5,81896E-1

1,34225E1

7,72868E-1

2.4

mean

6,32456E-1

9,29819E-1

1,33627E-1

9,22921E-1

8,63934E-1

8,77654E-1

2,17860E0

8,85461E-1

4,20352E-1

5,81896E-1

1,34176E1

7,72640E-1

2.4

relative error(%)

0,00

2.6

BioUML

6,62290E-1

8,15859E-1

1,47012E-1

9,15850E-1

8,65871E-1

8,77420E-1

2,39160E0

8,42595E-1

4,35179E-1

5,87079E-1

1,19700E1

7,76126E-1

2.6

ByoDyn

6,62290E-1

8,15859E-1

1,47012E-1

9,15850E-1

8,65871E-1

8,77420E-1

2,39160E0

8,42595E-1

4,35179E-1

5,87079E-1

1,19700E1

7,76126E-1

2.6

MathSBML

8,15859E-1

1,47012E-1

4,35179E-1

7,76126E-1

2.6

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

2.6

SBToolbox2

6,62195E-1

8,16203E-1

1,46782E-1

9,15971E-1

8,65867E-1

8,77423E-1

2,38798E0

8,42723E-1

4,34914E-1

5,86992E-1

1,19745E1

7,76337E-1

2.6

SBWOdeSolver

8,15858E-1

1,47012E-1

4,35180E-1

7,76125E-1

2.6

VCell

8,15859E-1

1,47012E-1

4,35179E-1

7,76126E-1

2.6

copasi

8,15859E-1

1,47012E-1

4,35179E-1

7,76126E-1

2.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,15859E-1

1,47012E-1

4,35179E-1

7,76126E-1

2.6

jsim

6,62290E-1

8,15859E-1

1,47012E-1

9,15850E-1

8,65871E-1

8,77420E-1

2,39160E0

8,42595E-1

4,35179E-1

5,87079E-1

1,19700E1

7,76126E-1

2.6

min

6,62195E-1

0,00000E0

9,15850E-1

8,65867E-1

8,77420E-1

2,38798E0

8,42595E-1

0,00000E0

5,86992E-1

1,19700E1

0,00000E0

2.6

max

6,62290E-1

8,16203E-1

1,47012E-1

9,15971E-1

8,65871E-1

8,77423E-1

2,39160E0

8,42723E-1

4,35180E-1

5,87079E-1

1,19745E1

7,76337E-1

2.6

mean

6,62290E-1

8,15859E-1

1,47012E-1

9,15850E-1

8,65871E-1

8,77420E-1

2,39160E0

8,42595E-1

4,35179E-1

5,87079E-1

1,19700E1

7,76126E-1

2.6

relative error(%)

0,00

2.8

BioUML

6,92895E-1

7,09151E-1

1,65200E-1

9,06413E-1

8,67693E-1

8,77102E-1

2,67955E0

8,02282E-1

4,53355E-1

5,94117E-1

1,05699E1

7,76130E-1

2.8

ByoDyn

6,92895E-1

7,09151E-1

1,65200E-1

9,06413E-1

8,67693E-1

8,77102E-1

2,67955E0

8,02282E-1

4,53355E-1

5,94117E-1

1,05699E1

7,76130E-1

2.8

MathSBML

7,09151E-1

1,65200E-1

4,53355E-1

7,76131E-1

2.8

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

2.8

SBToolbox2

6,92809E-1

7,09429E-1

1,64850E-1

9,06594E-1

8,67688E-1

8,77106E-1

2,67404E0

8,02386E-1

4,53076E-1

5,93982E-1

1,05733E1

7,76325E-1

2.8

SBWOdeSolver

7,09151E-1

1,65201E-1

4,53356E-1

7,76130E-1

2.8

VCell

7,09151E-1

1,65200E-1

4,53355E-1

7,76130E-1

2.8

copasi

7,09151E-1

1,65200E-1

4,53355E-1

7,76130E-1

2.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,09151E-1

1,65200E-1

4,53355E-1

7,76130E-1

2.8

jsim

6,92895E-1

7,09151E-1

1,65200E-1

9,06413E-1

8,67693E-1

8,77102E-1

2,67955E0

8,02282E-1

4,53355E-1

5,94117E-1

1,05699E1

7,76130E-1

2.8

min

6,92809E-1

0,00000E0

9,06413E-1

8,67688E-1

8,77102E-1

2,67404E0

8,02282E-1

0,00000E0

5,93982E-1

1,05699E1

0,00000E0

2.8

max

6,92895E-1

7,09429E-1

1,65201E-1

9,06594E-1

8,67693E-1

8,77106E-1

2,67955E0

8,02386E-1

4,53356E-1

5,94117E-1

1,05733E1

7,76325E-1

2.8

mean

6,92895E-1

7,09151E-1

1,65200E-1

9,06413E-1

8,67693E-1

8,77102E-1

2,67955E0

8,02282E-1

4,53355E-1

5,94117E-1

1,05699E1

7,76130E-1

2.8

relative error(%)

0,00

3.0

BioUML

7,23639E-1

6,11046E-1

1,92053E-1

8,92831E-1

8,69375E-1

8,76633E-1

3,10160E0

7,65069E-1

4,74160E-1

6,04499E-1

9,24281E0

7,72482E-1

3.0

ByoDyn

7,23639E-1

6,11046E-1

1,92053E-1

8,92831E-1

8,69375E-1

8,76633E-1

3,10160E0

7,65069E-1

4,74160E-1

6,04499E-1

9,24281E0

7,72482E-1

3.0

MathSBML

6,11046E-1

1,92053E-1

4,74160E-1

7,72482E-1

3.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

3.0

SBToolbox2

7,23571E-1

6,11267E-1

1,91449E-1

8,93132E-1

8,69376E-1

8,76639E-1

3,09214E0

7,65154E-1

4,73870E-1

6,04265E-1

9,24579E0

7,72657E-1

3.0

SBWOdeSolver

6,11047E-1

1,92055E-1

4,74161E-1

7,72481E-1

3.0

VCell

6,11046E-1

1,92053E-1

4,74160E-1

7,72482E-1

3.0

copasi

6,11046E-1

1,92054E-1

4,74160E-1

7,72482E-1

3.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,11046E-1

1,92053E-1

4,74160E-1

7,72482E-1

3.0

jsim

7,23639E-1

6,11046E-1

1,92053E-1

8,92831E-1

8,69375E-1

8,76633E-1

3,10160E0

7,65069E-1

4,74160E-1

6,04499E-1

9,24281E0

7,72482E-1

3.0

min

7,23571E-1

0,00000E0

8,92831E-1

8,69375E-1

8,76633E-1

3,09214E0

7,65069E-1

0,00000E0

6,04265E-1

9,24281E0

0,00000E0

3.0

max

7,23639E-1

6,11267E-1

1,92055E-1

8,93132E-1

8,69376E-1

8,76639E-1

3,10160E0

7,65154E-1

4,74161E-1

6,04499E-1

9,24579E0

7,72657E-1

3.0

mean

7,23639E-1

6,11046E-1

1,92053E-1

8,92831E-1

8,69375E-1

8,76633E-1

3,10160E0

7,65069E-1

4,74160E-1

6,04499E-1

9,24281E0

7,72482E-1

3.0

relative error(%)

0,00

3.2

BioUML

7,53905E-1

5,22284E-1

2,36383E-1

8,71278E-1

8,70903E-1

8,75859E-1

3,79039E0

7,31275E-1

4,96964E-1

6,21614E-1

8,00768E0

7,64391E-1

3.2

ByoDyn

7,53905E-1

5,22284E-1

2,36383E-1

8,71278E-1

8,70903E-1

8,75859E-1

3,79039E0

7,31275E-1

4,96964E-1

6,21614E-1

8,00768E0

7,64391E-1

3.2

MathSBML

5,22284E-1

2,36383E-1

4,96964E-1

7,64391E-1

3.2

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

3.2

SBToolbox2

7,53860E-1

5,22417E-1

2,35769E-1

8,71572E-1

8,70898E-1

8,75866E-1

3,78093E0

7,31325E-1

4,96672E-1

6,21378E-1

8,00954E0

7,64493E-1

3.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,22285E-1

2,36388E-1

4,96965E-1

7,64390E-1

3.2

VCell

5,22284E-1

2,36383E-1

4,96964E-1

7,64391E-1

3.2

copasi

5,22284E-1

2,36385E-1

4,96964E-1

7,64391E-1

3.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,22284E-1

2,36383E-1

4,96964E-1

7,64391E-1

3.2

jsim

7,53905E-1

5,22284E-1

2,36383E-1

8,71278E-1

8,70903E-1

8,75859E-1

3,79039E0

7,31275E-1

4,96964E-1

6,21614E-1

8,00768E0

7,64391E-1

3.2

min

7,53860E-1

0,00000E0

8,71278E-1

8,70898E-1

8,75859E-1

3,78093E0

7,31275E-1

0,00000E0

6,21378E-1

8,00768E0

0,00000E0

3.2

max

7,53905E-1

5,22417E-1

2,36388E-1

8,71572E-1

8,70903E-1

8,75866E-1

3,79039E0

7,31325E-1

4,96965E-1

6,21614E-1

8,00954E0

7,64493E-1

3.2

mean

7,53905E-1

5,22284E-1

2,36383E-1

8,71278E-1

8,70903E-1

8,75859E-1

3,79039E0

7,31275E-1

4,96964E-1

6,21614E-1

8,00768E0

7,64391E-1

3.2

relative error(%)

0,00

3.4

BioUML

7,83130E-1

4,43084E-1

3,18777E-1

8,33865E-1

8,72270E-1

8,74425E-1

5,04491E0

7,01021E-1

5,21220E-1

6,53345E-1

6,87689E0

7,49952E-1

3.4

ByoDyn

7,83130E-1

4,43084E-1

3,18777E-1

8,33865E-1

8,72270E-1

8,74425E-1

5,04491E0

7,01021E-1

5,21220E-1

6,53345E-1

6,87689E0

7,49952E-1

3.4

MathSBML

4,43084E-1

3,18777E-1

5,21220E-1

7,49952E-1

3.4

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

3.4

SBToolbox2

7,83134E-1

4,43062E-1

3,17999E-1

8,34206E-1

8,72270E-1

8,74441E-1

5,03323E0

7,01016E-1

5,20968E-1

6,53042E-1

6,87656E0

7,50050E-1

3.4

SBWOdeSolver

4,43085E-1

3,18788E-1

5,21221E-1

7,49951E-1

3.4

VCell

4,43084E-1

3,18777E-1

5,21220E-1

7,49952E-1

3.4

copasi

4,43084E-1

3,18779E-1

5,21220E-1

7,49952E-1

3.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,43084E-1

3,18777E-1

5,21220E-1

7,49952E-1

3.4

jsim

7,83130E-1

4,43084E-1

3,18777E-1

8,33865E-1

8,72270E-1

8,74425E-1

5,04491E0

7,01021E-1

5,21220E-1

6,53345E-1

6,87689E0

7,49952E-1

3.4

min

7,83130E-1

0,00000E0

8,33865E-1

8,72270E-1

8,74425E-1

5,03323E0

7,01016E-1

0,00000E0

6,53042E-1

6,87656E0

0,00000E0

3.4

max

7,83134E-1

4,43085E-1

3,18788E-1

8,34206E-1

8,72270E-1

8,74441E-1

5,04491E0

7,01021E-1

5,21221E-1

6,53345E-1

6,87689E0

7,50050E-1

3.4

mean

7,83130E-1

4,43084E-1

3,18777E-1

8,33865E-1

8,72270E-1

8,74425E-1

5,04491E0

7,01021E-1

5,21220E-1

6,53345E-1

6,87689E0

7,49952E-1

3.4

relative error(%)

0,00

3.6

BioUML

8,10793E-1

3,73376E-1

4,75710E-1

7,70821E-1

8,73477E-1

8,71706E-1

7,34607E0

6,74315E-1

5,46458E-1

7,13496E-1

5,85837E0

7,25779E-1

3.6

ByoDyn

8,10793E-1

3,73376E-1

4,75710E-1

7,70821E-1

8,73477E-1

8,71706E-1

7,34607E0

6,74315E-1

5,46458E-1

7,13496E-1

5,85837E0

7,25779E-1

3.6

MathSBML

3,73376E-1

4,75710E-1

5,46458E-1

7,25779E-1

3.6

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

3.6

SBToolbox2

8,10858E-1

3,73214E-1

4,75111E-1

7,71048E-1

8,73478E-1

8,71715E-1

7,33743E0

6,74250E-1

5,46266E-1

7,13266E-1

5,85595E0

7,25864E-1

3.6

SBWOdeSolver

3,73377E-1

4,75720E-1

5,46459E-1

7,25778E-1

3.6

VCell

3,73376E-1

4,75710E-1

5,46458E-1

7,25779E-1

3.6

copasi

3,73376E-1

4,75715E-1

5,46458E-1

7,25778E-1

3.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,73376E-1

4,75710E-1

5,46458E-1

7,25779E-1

3.6

jsim

8,10793E-1

3,73376E-1

4,75710E-1

7,70821E-1

8,73477E-1

8,71706E-1

7,34607E0

6,74315E-1

5,46458E-1

7,13496E-1

5,85837E0

7,25779E-1

3.6

min

8,10793E-1

0,00000E0

7,70821E-1

8,73477E-1

8,71706E-1

7,33743E0

6,74250E-1

0,00000E0

7,13266E-1

5,85595E0

0,00000E0

3.6

max

8,10858E-1

3,73377E-1

4,75720E-1

7,71048E-1

8,73478E-1

8,71715E-1

7,34607E0

6,74315E-1

5,46459E-1

7,13496E-1

5,85837E0

7,25864E-1

3.6

mean

8,10793E-1

3,73376E-1

4,75710E-1

7,70821E-1

8,73477E-1

8,71706E-1

7,34607E0

6,74315E-1

5,46458E-1

7,13496E-1

5,85837E0

7,25779E-1

3.6

relative error(%)

0,00

3.8

BioUML

8,36328E-1

3,13126E-1

7,17737E-1

6,90328E-1

8,74523E-1

8,67547E-1

1,06842E1

6,51172E-1

5,72263E-1

8,05532E-1

4,95992E0

6,88969E-1

3.8

ByoDyn

8,36328E-1

3,13126E-1

7,17737E-1

6,90328E-1

8,74523E-1

8,67547E-1

1,06842E1

6,51172E-1

5,72263E-1

8,05532E-1

4,95992E0

6,88969E-1

3.8

MathSBML

3,13126E-1

7,17738E-1

5,72263E-1

6,88969E-1

3.8

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

3.8

SBToolbox2

8,36446E-1

3,12850E-1

7,17646E-1

6,90366E-1

8,74531E-1

8,67547E-1

1,06827E1

6,51067E-1

5,72126E-1

8,05497E-1

4,95572E0

6,89027E-1

3.8

SBWOdeSolver

3,13127E-1

7,17714E-1

5,72263E-1

6,88969E-1

3.8

VCell

3,13126E-1

7,17737E-1

5,72263E-1

6,88969E-1

3.8

copasi

3,13126E-1

7,17744E-1

5,72263E-1

6,88968E-1

3.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,13126E-1

7,17737E-1

5,72263E-1

6,88969E-1

3.8

jsim

8,36328E-1

3,13126E-1

7,17737E-1

6,90328E-1

8,74523E-1

8,67547E-1

1,06842E1

6,51172E-1

5,72263E-1

8,05532E-1

4,95992E0

6,88969E-1

3.8

min

8,36328E-1

0,00000E0

6,90328E-1

8,74523E-1

8,67547E-1

1,06827E1

6,51067E-1

0,00000E0

8,05497E-1

4,95572E0

0,00000E0

3.8

max

8,36446E-1

3,13127E-1

7,17744E-1

6,90366E-1

8,74531E-1

8,67547E-1

1,06842E1

6,51172E-1

5,72263E-1

8,05532E-1

4,95992E0

6,89027E-1

3.8

mean

8,36328E-1

3,13126E-1

7,17737E-1

6,90328E-1

8,74523E-1

8,67547E-1

1,06842E1

6,51172E-1

5,72263E-1

8,05532E-1

4,95992E0

6,88969E-1

3.8

relative error(%)

0,00

4.0

BioUML

8,59048E-1

2,62528E-1

9,73837E-1

6,21640E-1

8,75404E-1

8,63188E-1

1,39642E1

6,31694E-1

5,98221E-1

9,01967E-1

4,19204E0

6,41756E-1

4.0

ByoDyn

8,59048E-1

2,62528E-1

9,73837E-1

6,21640E-1

8,75404E-1

8,63188E-1

1,39642E1

6,31694E-1

5,98221E-1

9,01967E-1

4,19204E0

6,41756E-1

4.0

MathSBML

2,62528E-1

9,73837E-1

5,98221E-1

6,41756E-1

4.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

4.0

SBToolbox2

8,59210E-1

2,62176E-1

9,74134E-1

6,21570E-1

8,75414E-1

8,63180E-1

1,39678E1

6,31562E-1

5,98130E-1

9,02080E-1

4,18664E0

6,41814E-1

4.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,62530E-1

9,73789E-1

5,98222E-1

6,41760E-1

4.0

VCell

2,62528E-1

9,73837E-1

5,98221E-1

6,41756E-1

4.0

copasi

2,62528E-1

9,73842E-1

5,98221E-1

6,41755E-1

4.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,62528E-1

9,73837E-1

5,98221E-1

6,41756E-1

4.0

jsim

8,59048E-1

2,62528E-1

9,73837E-1

6,21640E-1

8,75404E-1

8,63188E-1

1,39642E1

6,31694E-1

5,98221E-1

9,01967E-1

4,19204E0

6,41756E-1

4.0

min

8,59048E-1

0,00000E0

6,21570E-1

8,75404E-1

8,63180E-1

1,39642E1

6,31562E-1

0,00000E0

9,01967E-1

4,18664E0

0,00000E0

4.0

max

8,59210E-1

2,62530E-1

9,74134E-1

6,21640E-1

8,75414E-1

8,63188E-1

1,39678E1

6,31694E-1

5,98222E-1

9,02080E-1

4,19204E0

6,41814E-1

4.0

mean

8,59048E-1

2,62528E-1

9,73837E-1

6,21640E-1

8,75404E-1

8,63188E-1

1,39642E1

6,31694E-1

5,98221E-1

9,01967E-1

4,19204E0

6,41756E-1

4.0

relative error(%)

0,00

4.2

BioUML

8,78205E-1

2,21899E-1

1,16363E0

5,78949E-1

8,76112E-1

8,59986E-1

1,62436E1

6,16026E-1

6,23852E-1

9,72812E-1

3,56642E0

5,91392E-1

4.2

ByoDyn

8,78205E-1

2,21899E-1

1,16363E0

5,78949E-1

8,76112E-1

8,59986E-1

1,62436E1

6,16026E-1

6,23852E-1

9,72812E-1

3,56642E0

5,91392E-1

4.2

MathSBML

2,21899E-1

1,16363E0

6,23852E-1

5,91392E-1

4.2

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

4.2

SBToolbox2

8,78399E-1

2,21498E-1

1,16348E0

5,78974E-1

8,76117E-1

8,59990E-1

1,62417E1

6,15870E-1

6,23777E-1

9,72769E-1

3,56019E0

5,91552E-1

4.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,21901E-1

1,16359E0

6,23852E-1

5,91398E-1

4.2

VCell

2,21899E-1

1,16363E0

6,23852E-1

5,91392E-1

4.2

copasi

2,21899E-1

1,16363E0

6,23852E-1

5,91391E-1

4.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,21899E-1

1,16363E0

6,23852E-1

5,91392E-1

4.2

jsim

8,78205E-1

2,21899E-1

1,16363E0

5,78949E-1

8,76112E-1

8,59986E-1

1,62436E1

6,16026E-1

6,23852E-1

9,72812E-1

3,56642E0

5,91392E-1

4.2

min

8,78205E-1

0,00000E0

5,78949E-1

8,76112E-1

8,59986E-1

1,62417E1

6,15870E-1

0,00000E0

9,72769E-1

3,56019E0

0,00000E0

4.2

max

8,78399E-1

2,21901E-1

1,16363E0

5,78974E-1

8,76117E-1

8,59990E-1

1,62436E1

6,16026E-1

6,23852E-1

9,72812E-1

3,56642E0

5,91552E-1

4.2

mean

8,78205E-1

2,21899E-1

1,16363E0

5,78949E-1

8,76112E-1

8,59986E-1

1,62436E1

6,16026E-1

6,23852E-1

9,72812E-1

3,56642E0

5,91392E-1

4.2

relative error(%)

0,00

4.4

BioUML

8,93222E-1

1,91269E-1

1,26431E0

5,58598E-1

8,76646E-1

8,58297E-1

1,74045E1

6,04196E-1

6,48555E-1

1,01018E0

3,08933E0

5,45039E-1

4.4

ByoDyn

8,93222E-1

1,91269E-1

1,26431E0

5,58598E-1

8,76646E-1

8,58297E-1

1,74045E1

6,04196E-1

6,48555E-1

1,01018E0

3,08933E0

5,45039E-1

4.4

MathSBML

1,91269E-1

1,26431E0

6,48555E-1

5,45039E-1

4.4

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

4.4

SBToolbox2

8,93434E-1

1,90848E-1

1,26382E0

5,58692E-1

8,76651E-1

8,58302E-1

1,73989E1

6,04030E-1

6,48508E-1

1,01002E0

3,08269E0

5,45252E-1

4.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,91271E-1

1,26428E0

6,48555E-1

5,45046E-1

4.4

VCell

1,91269E-1

1,26431E0

6,48555E-1

5,45039E-1

4.4

copasi

1,91269E-1

1,26432E0

6,48555E-1

5,45038E-1

4.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,91269E-1

1,26431E0

6,48555E-1

5,45039E-1

4.4

jsim

8,93222E-1

1,91269E-1

1,26431E0

5,58598E-1

8,76646E-1

8,58297E-1

1,74045E1

6,04196E-1

6,48555E-1

1,01018E0

3,08933E0

5,45039E-1

4.4

min

8,93222E-1

0,00000E0

5,58598E-1

8,76646E-1

8,58297E-1

1,73989E1

6,04030E-1

0,00000E0

1,01002E0

3,08269E0

0,00000E0

4.4

max

8,93434E-1

1,91271E-1

1,26432E0

5,58692E-1

8,76651E-1

8,58302E-1

1,74045E1

6,04196E-1

6,48555E-1

1,01018E0

3,08933E0

5,45252E-1

4.4

mean

8,93222E-1

1,91269E-1

1,26431E0

5,58598E-1

8,76646E-1

8,58297E-1

1,74045E1

6,04196E-1

6,48555E-1

1,01018E0

3,08933E0

5,45039E-1

4.4

relative error(%)

0,00

4.6

BioUML

9,03996E-1

1,69919E-1

1,29050E0

5,53537E-1

8,77020E-1

8,57859E-1

1,77011E1

5,95942E-1

6,71651E-1

1,01988E0

2,75399E0

5,06870E-1

4.6

ByoDyn

9,03996E-1

1,69919E-1

1,29050E0

5,53537E-1

8,77020E-1

8,57859E-1

1,77011E1

5,95942E-1

6,71651E-1

1,01988E0

2,75399E0

5,06870E-1

4.6

MathSBML

1,69919E-1

1,29050E0

6,71651E-1

5,06870E-1

4.6

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

4.6

SBToolbox2

9,04238E-1

1,69446E-1

1,29069E0

5,53496E-1

8,77025E-1

8,57855E-1

1,77035E1

5,95762E-1

6,71609E-1

1,01995E0

2,74651E0

5,07113E-1

4.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,69921E-1

1,29049E0

6,71650E-1

5,06877E-1

4.6

VCell

1,69919E-1

1,29050E0

6,71651E-1

5,06870E-1

4.6

copasi

1,69919E-1

1,29050E0

6,71651E-1

5,06869E-1

4.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,69919E-1

1,29050E0

6,71651E-1

5,06870E-1

4.6

jsim

9,03996E-1

1,69919E-1

1,29050E0

5,53537E-1

8,77020E-1

8,57859E-1

1,77011E1

5,95942E-1

6,71651E-1

1,01988E0

2,75399E0

5,06870E-1

4.6

min

9,03996E-1

0,00000E0

5,53496E-1

8,77020E-1

8,57855E-1

1,77011E1

5,95762E-1

0,00000E0

1,01988E0

2,74651E0

0,00000E0

4.6

max

9,04238E-1

1,69921E-1

1,29069E0

5,53537E-1

8,77025E-1

8,57859E-1

1,77035E1

5,95942E-1

6,71651E-1

1,01995E0

2,75399E0

5,07113E-1

4.6

mean

9,03996E-1

1,69919E-1

1,29050E0

5,53537E-1

8,77020E-1

8,57859E-1

1,77011E1

5,95942E-1

6,71651E-1

1,01988E0

2,75399E0

5,06870E-1

4.6

relative error(%)

0,00

4.8

BioUML

9,10949E-1

1,56410E-1

1,26474E0

5,58515E-1

8,77256E-1

8,58290E-1

1,74093E1

5,90716E-1

6,92498E-1

1,01034E0

2,54060E0

4,78279E-1

4.8

ByoDyn

9,10949E-1

1,56410E-1

1,26474E0

5,58515E-1

8,77256E-1

8,58290E-1

1,74093E1

5,90716E-1

6,92498E-1

1,01034E0

2,54060E0

4,78279E-1

4.8

MathSBML

1,56410E-1

1,26474E0

6,92498E-1

4,78279E-1

4.8

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

4.8

SBToolbox2

9,11190E-1

1,55944E-1

1,26491E0

5,58493E-1

8,77265E-1

8,58286E-1

1,74105E1

5,90536E-1

6,92480E-1

1,01038E0

2,53324E0

4,78446E-1

4.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,56411E-1

1,26474E0

6,92498E-1

4,78284E-1

4.8

VCell

1,56410E-1

1,26474E0

6,92498E-1

4,78279E-1

4.8

copasi

1,56410E-1

1,26474E0

6,92498E-1

4,78278E-1

4.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,56410E-1

1,26474E0

6,92498E-1

4,78279E-1

4.8

jsim

9,10949E-1

1,56410E-1

1,26474E0

5,58515E-1

8,77256E-1

8,58290E-1

1,74093E1

5,90716E-1

6,92498E-1

1,01034E0

2,54060E0

4,78279E-1

4.8

min

9,10949E-1

0,00000E0

5,58493E-1

8,77256E-1

8,58286E-1

1,74093E1

5,90536E-1

0,00000E0

1,01034E0

2,53324E0

0,00000E0

4.8

max

9,11190E-1

1,56411E-1

1,26491E0

5,58515E-1

8,77265E-1

8,58290E-1

1,74105E1

5,90716E-1

6,92498E-1

1,01038E0

2,54060E0

4,78446E-1

4.8

mean

9,10949E-1

1,56410E-1

1,26474E0

5,58515E-1

8,77256E-1

8,58290E-1

1,74093E1

5,90716E-1

6,92498E-1

1,01034E0

2,54060E0

4,78279E-1

4.8

relative error(%)

0,00

5.0

BioUML

9,14766E-1

1,49080E-1

1,20577E0

5,70253E-1

8,77384E-1

8,59278E-1

1,67334E1

5,87879E-1

7,10623E-1

9,88472E-1

2,42443E0

4,59019E-1

5.0

ByoDyn

9,14766E-1

1,49080E-1

1,20577E0

5,70253E-1

8,77384E-1

8,59278E-1

1,67334E1

5,87879E-1

7,10623E-1

9,88472E-1

2,42443E0

4,59019E-1

5.0

MathSBML

1,49080E-1

1,20577E0

7,10623E-1

4,59019E-1

5.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

5.0

SBToolbox2

9,15045E-1

1,48550E-1

1,20720E0

5,69965E-1

8,77395E-1

8,59250E-1

1,67495E1

5,87675E-1

7,10670E-1

9,88995E-1

2,41600E0

4,59035E-1

5.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,49082E-1

1,20578E0

7,10623E-1

4,59023E-1

5.0

VCell

1,49080E-1

1,20577E0

7,10623E-1

4,59019E-1

5.0

copasi

1,49080E-1

1,20577E0

7,10623E-1

4,59019E-1

5.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,49080E-1

1,20577E0

7,10623E-1

4,59019E-1

5.0

jsim

9,14766E-1

1,49080E-1

1,20577E0

5,70253E-1

8,77384E-1

8,59278E-1

1,67334E1

5,87879E-1

7,10623E-1

9,88472E-1

2,42443E0

4,59019E-1

5.0

min

9,14766E-1

0,00000E0

5,69965E-1

8,77384E-1

8,59250E-1

1,67334E1

5,87675E-1

0,00000E0

9,88472E-1

2,41600E0

0,00000E0

5.0

max

9,15045E-1

1,49082E-1

1,20720E0

5,70253E-1

8,77395E-1

8,59278E-1

1,67495E1

5,87879E-1

7,10670E-1

9,88995E-1

2,42443E0

4,59035E-1

5.0

mean

9,14766E-1

1,49080E-1

1,20577E0

5,70253E-1

8,77384E-1

8,59278E-1

1,67334E1

5,87879E-1

7,10623E-1

9,88472E-1

2,42443E0

4,59019E-1

5.0

relative error(%)

0,00

5.2

BioUML

9,16103E-1

1,46529E-1

1,12687E0

5,86754E-1

8,77429E-1

8,60604E-1

1,58115E1

5,86892E-1

7,25761E-1

9,59131E-1

2,38393E0

4,48118E-1

5.2

ByoDyn

9,16103E-1

1,46529E-1

1,12687E0

5,86754E-1

8,77429E-1

8,60604E-1

1,58115E1

5,86892E-1

7,25761E-1

9,59131E-1

2,38393E0

4,48118E-1

5.2

MathSBML

1,46529E-1

1,12687E0

7,25761E-1

4,48118E-1

5.2

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

5.2

SBToolbox2

9,16435E-1

1,45900E-1

1,12924E0

5,86252E-1

8,77440E-1

8,60564E-1

1,58390E1

5,86645E-1

7,25886E-1

9,60007E-1

2,37391E0

4,47897E-1

5.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,46530E-1

1,12687E0

7,25760E-1

4,48121E-1

5.2

VCell

1,46529E-1

1,12687E0

7,25761E-1

4,48118E-1

5.2

copasi

1,46529E-1

1,12686E0

7,25761E-1

4,48118E-1

5.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,46529E-1

1,12687E0

7,25761E-1

4,48118E-1

5.2

jsim

9,16103E-1

1,46529E-1

1,12687E0

5,86754E-1

8,77429E-1

8,60604E-1

1,58115E1

5,86892E-1

7,25761E-1

9,59131E-1

2,38393E0

4,48118E-1

5.2

min

9,16103E-1

0,00000E0

5,86252E-1

8,77429E-1

8,60564E-1

1,58115E1

5,86645E-1

0,00000E0

9,59131E-1

2,37391E0

0,00000E0

5.2

max

9,16435E-1

1,46530E-1

1,12924E0

5,86754E-1

8,77440E-1

8,60604E-1

1,58390E1

5,86892E-1

7,25886E-1

9,60007E-1

2,38393E0

4,48121E-1

5.2

mean

9,16103E-1

1,46529E-1

1,12687E0

5,86754E-1

8,77429E-1

8,60604E-1

1,58115E1

5,86892E-1

7,25761E-1

9,59131E-1

2,38393E0

4,48118E-1

5.2

relative error(%)

0,00

5.4

BioUML

9,15423E-1

1,47826E-1

1,03703E0

6,06744E-1

8,77406E-1

8,62119E-1

1,47367E1

5,87394E-1

7,37827E-1

9,25613E-1

2,40452E0

4,44391E-1

5.4

ByoDyn

9,15423E-1

1,47826E-1

1,03703E0

6,06744E-1

8,77406E-1

8,62119E-1

1,47367E1

5,87394E-1

7,37827E-1

9,25613E-1

2,40452E0

4,44391E-1

5.4

MathSBML

1,47826E-1

1,03703E0

7,37827E-1

4,44391E-1

5.4

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

5.4

SBToolbox2

9,15778E-1

1,47149E-1

1,03958E0

6,06162E-1

8,77420E-1

8,62077E-1

1,47672E1

5,87133E-1

7,38044E-1

9,26560E-1

2,39376E0

4,44006E-1

5.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,47827E-1

1,03704E0

7,37827E-1

4,44393E-1

5.4

VCell

1,47826E-1

1,03703E0

7,37827E-1

4,44391E-1

5.4

copasi

1,47826E-1

1,03702E0

7,37827E-1

4,44391E-1

5.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,47826E-1

1,03703E0

7,37827E-1

4,44391E-1

5.4

jsim

9,15423E-1

1,47826E-1

1,03703E0

6,06744E-1

8,77406E-1

8,62119E-1

1,47367E1

5,87394E-1

7,37827E-1

9,25613E-1

2,40452E0

4,44391E-1

5.4

min

9,15423E-1

0,00000E0

6,06162E-1

8,77406E-1

8,62077E-1

1,47367E1

5,87133E-1

0,00000E0

9,25613E-1

2,39376E0

0,00000E0

5.4

max

9,15778E-1

1,47827E-1

1,03958E0

6,06744E-1

8,77420E-1

8,62119E-1

1,47672E1

5,87394E-1

7,38044E-1

9,26560E-1

2,40452E0

4,44393E-1

5.4

mean

9,15423E-1

1,47826E-1

1,03703E0

6,06744E-1

8,77406E-1

8,62119E-1

1,47367E1

5,87394E-1

7,37827E-1

9,25613E-1

2,40452E0

4,44391E-1

5.4

relative error(%)

0,00

5.6

BioUML

9,12952E-1

1,52557E-1

9,42420E-1

6,29322E-1

8,77323E-1

8,63720E-1

1,35748E1

5,89225E-1

7,46846E-1

8,90189E-1

2,47957E0

4,46680E-1

5.6

ByoDyn

9,12952E-1

1,52557E-1

9,42420E-1

6,29322E-1

8,77323E-1

8,63720E-1

1,35748E1

5,89225E-1

7,46846E-1

8,90189E-1

2,47957E0

4,46680E-1

5.6

MathSBML

1,52557E-1

9,42420E-1

7,46846E-1

4,46680E-1

5.6

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

5.6

SBToolbox2

9,13345E-1

1,51801E-1

9,44951E-1

6,28699E-1

8,77336E-1

8,63675E-1

1,36060E1

5,88933E-1

7,47143E-1

8,91142E-1

2,46760E0

4,46176E-1

5.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,52558E-1

9,42431E-1

7,46845E-1

4,46681E-1

5.6

VCell

1,52557E-1

9,42420E-1

7,46846E-1

4,46680E-1

5.6

copasi

1,52557E-1

9,42418E-1

7,46846E-1

4,46681E-1

5.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,52557E-1

9,42420E-1

7,46846E-1

4,46680E-1

5.6

jsim

9,12952E-1

1,52557E-1

9,42420E-1

6,29322E-1

8,77323E-1

8,63720E-1

1,35748E1

5,89225E-1

7,46846E-1

8,90189E-1

2,47957E0

4,46680E-1

5.6

min

9,12952E-1

0,00000E0

6,28699E-1

8,77323E-1

8,63675E-1

1,35748E1

5,88933E-1

0,00000E0

8,90189E-1

2,46760E0

0,00000E0

5.6

max

9,13345E-1

1,52558E-1

9,44951E-1

6,29322E-1

8,77336E-1

8,63720E-1

1,36060E1

5,89225E-1

7,47143E-1

8,91142E-1

2,47957E0

4,46681E-1

5.6

mean

9,12952E-1

1,52557E-1

9,42420E-1

6,29322E-1

8,77323E-1

8,63720E-1

1,35748E1

5,89225E-1

7,46846E-1

8,90189E-1

2,47957E0

4,46680E-1

5.6

relative error(%)

0,00

5.8

BioUML

9,08641E-1

1,60871E-1

8,47377E-1

6,53761E-1

8,77178E-1

8,65335E-1

1,23752E1

5,92442E-1

7,52869E-1

8,54470E-1

2,61117E0

4,53938E-1

5.8

ByoDyn

9,08641E-1

1,60871E-1

8,47377E-1

6,53761E-1

8,77178E-1

8,65335E-1

1,23752E1

5,92442E-1

7,52869E-1

8,54470E-1

2,61117E0

4,53938E-1

5.8

MathSBML

1,60871E-1

8,47377E-1

7,52869E-1

4,53938E-1

5.8

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

5.8

SBToolbox2

9,09101E-1

1,59984E-1

8,49792E-1

6,53119E-1

8,77196E-1

8,65294E-1

1,24058E1

5,92094E-1

7,53237E-1

8,55377E-1

2,59710E0

4,53333E-1

5.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,60873E-1

8,47388E-1

7,52868E-1

4,53938E-1

5.8

VCell

1,60871E-1

8,47377E-1

7,52869E-1

4,53938E-1

5.8

copasi

1,60871E-1

8,47375E-1

7,52869E-1

4,53938E-1

5.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,60871E-1

8,47377E-1

7,52869E-1

4,53938E-1

5.8

jsim

9,08641E-1

1,60871E-1

8,47377E-1

6,53761E-1

8,77178E-1

8,65335E-1

1,23752E1

5,92442E-1

7,52869E-1

8,54470E-1

2,61117E0

4,53938E-1

5.8

min

9,08641E-1

0,00000E0

6,53119E-1

8,77178E-1

8,65294E-1

1,23752E1

5,92094E-1

0,00000E0

8,54470E-1

2,59710E0

0,00000E0

5.8

max

9,09101E-1

1,60873E-1

8,49792E-1

6,53761E-1

8,77196E-1

8,65335E-1

1,24058E1

5,92442E-1

7,53237E-1

8,55377E-1

2,61117E0

4,53938E-1

5.8

mean

9,08641E-1

1,60871E-1

8,47377E-1

6,53761E-1

8,77178E-1

8,65335E-1

1,23752E1

5,92442E-1

7,52869E-1

8,54470E-1

2,61117E0

4,53938E-1

5.8

relative error(%)

0,00

6.0

BioUML

9,02092E-1

1,73655E-1

7,54986E-1

6,79410E-1

8,76954E-1

8,66910E-1

1,11767E1

5,97387E-1

7,55891E-1

8,19618E-1

2,81285E0

4,65240E-1

6.0

ByoDyn

9,02092E-1

1,73655E-1

7,54986E-1

6,79410E-1

8,76954E-1

8,66910E-1

1,11767E1

5,97387E-1

7,55891E-1

8,19618E-1

2,81285E0

4,65240E-1

6.0

MathSBML

1,73655E-1

7,54986E-1

7,55891E-1

4,65240E-1

6.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

6.0

SBToolbox2

9,02660E-1

1,72538E-1

7,57208E-1

6,78770E-1

8,76976E-1

8,66872E-1

1,12060E1

5,96960E-1

7,56332E-1

8,20456E-1

2,79528E0

4,64560E-1

6.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,73658E-1

7,54996E-1

7,55890E-1

4,65239E-1

6.0

VCell

1,73655E-1

7,54986E-1

7,55891E-1

4,65240E-1

6.0

copasi

1,73656E-1

7,54984E-1

7,55891E-1

4,65240E-1

6.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,73655E-1

7,54986E-1

7,55891E-1

4,65240E-1

6.0

jsim

9,02092E-1

1,73655E-1

7,54986E-1

6,79410E-1

8,76954E-1

8,66910E-1

1,11767E1

5,97387E-1

7,55891E-1

8,19618E-1

2,81285E0

4,65240E-1

6.0

min

9,02092E-1

0,00000E0

6,78770E-1

8,76954E-1

8,66872E-1

1,11767E1

5,96960E-1

0,00000E0

8,19618E-1

2,79528E0

0,00000E0

6.0

max

9,02660E-1

1,73658E-1

7,57208E-1

6,79410E-1

8,76976E-1

8,66910E-1

1,12060E1

5,97387E-1

7,56332E-1

8,20456E-1

2,81285E0

4,65240E-1

6.0

mean

9,02092E-1

1,73655E-1

7,54986E-1

6,79410E-1

8,76954E-1

8,66910E-1

1,11767E1

5,97387E-1

7,55891E-1

8,19618E-1

2,81285E0

4,65240E-1

6.0

relative error(%)

0,00

6.2

BioUML

8,92326E-1

1,93067E-1

6,67418E-1

7,05648E-1

8,76615E-1

8,68408E-1

1,00101E1

6,04891E-1

7,55749E-1

7,86469E-1

3,11747E0

4,79778E-1

6.2

ByoDyn

8,92326E-1

1,93067E-1

6,67418E-1

7,05648E-1

8,76615E-1

8,68408E-1

1,00101E1

6,04891E-1

7,55749E-1

7,86469E-1

3,11747E0

4,79778E-1

6.2

MathSBML

1,93067E-1

6,67418E-1

7,55749E-1

4,79778E-1

6.2

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

6.2

SBToolbox2

8,93092E-1

1,91532E-1

6,69399E-1

7,05032E-1

8,76642E-1

8,68377E-1

1,00370E1

6,04295E-1

7,56266E-1

7,87218E-1

3,09341E0

4,79050E-1

6.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,93071E-1

6,67429E-1

7,55748E-1

4,79777E-1

6.2

VCell

1,93067E-1

6,67418E-1

7,55749E-1

4,79778E-1

6.2

copasi

1,93067E-1

6,67416E-1

7,55749E-1

4,79778E-1

6.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,93067E-1

6,67418E-1

7,55749E-1

4,79778E-1

6.2

jsim

8,92326E-1

1,93067E-1

6,67418E-1

7,05648E-1

8,76615E-1

8,68408E-1

1,00101E1

6,04891E-1

7,55749E-1

7,86469E-1

3,11747E0

4,79778E-1

6.2

min

8,92326E-1

0,00000E0

7,05032E-1

8,76615E-1

8,68377E-1

1,00101E1

6,04295E-1

0,00000E0

7,86469E-1

3,09341E0

0,00000E0

6.2

max

8,93092E-1

1,93071E-1

6,69399E-1

7,05648E-1

8,76642E-1

8,68408E-1

1,00370E1

6,04891E-1

7,56266E-1

7,87218E-1

3,11747E0

4,79778E-1

6.2

mean

8,92326E-1

1,93067E-1

6,67418E-1

7,05648E-1

8,76615E-1

8,68408E-1

1,00101E1

6,04891E-1

7,55749E-1

7,86469E-1

3,11747E0

4,79778E-1

6.2

relative error(%)

0,00

6.4

BioUML

8,77254E-1

2,23873E-1

5,86111E-1

7,31893E-1

8,76077E-1

8,69804E-1

8,89919E0

6,16788E-1

7,51959E-1

7,55587E-1

3,59701E0

4,96841E-1

6.4

ByoDyn

8,77254E-1

2,23873E-1

5,86111E-1

7,31893E-1

8,76077E-1

8,69804E-1

8,89919E0

6,16788E-1

7,51959E-1

7,55587E-1

3,59701E0

4,96841E-1

6.4

MathSBML

2,23873E-1

5,86111E-1

7,51959E-1

4,96841E-1

6.4

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

6.4

SBToolbox2

8,78292E-1

2,21716E-1

5,87812E-1

7,31328E-1

8,76116E-1

8,69775E-1

8,92266E0

6,15954E-1

7,52556E-1

7,56234E-1

3,56357E0

4,96088E-1

6.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,23879E-1

5,86120E-1

7,51958E-1

4,96840E-1

6.4

VCell

2,23873E-1

5,86111E-1

7,51959E-1

4,96841E-1

6.4

copasi

2,23875E-1

5,86109E-1

7,51959E-1

4,96841E-1

6.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,23873E-1

5,86111E-1

7,51959E-1

4,96841E-1

6.4

jsim

8,77254E-1

2,23873E-1

5,86111E-1

7,31893E-1

8,76077E-1

8,69804E-1

8,89919E0

6,16788E-1

7,51959E-1

7,55587E-1

3,59701E0

4,96841E-1

6.4

min

8,77254E-1

0,00000E0

7,31328E-1

8,76077E-1

8,69775E-1

8,89919E0

6,15954E-1

0,00000E0

7,55587E-1

3,56357E0

0,00000E0

6.4

max

8,78292E-1

2,23879E-1

5,87812E-1

7,31893E-1

8,76116E-1

8,69804E-1

8,92266E0

6,16788E-1

7,52556E-1

7,56234E-1

3,59701E0

4,96841E-1

6.4

mean

8,77254E-1

2,23873E-1

5,86111E-1

7,31893E-1

8,76077E-1

8,69804E-1

8,89919E0

6,16788E-1

7,51959E-1

7,55587E-1

3,59701E0

4,96841E-1

6.4

relative error(%)

0,00

6.6

BioUML

8,52609E-1

2,76594E-1

5,11880E-1

7,57619E-1

8,75159E-1

8,71082E-1

7,86071E0

6,37113E-1

7,43433E-1

7,27306E-1

4,40675E0

5,15807E-1

6.6

ByoDyn

8,52609E-1

2,76594E-1

5,11880E-1

7,57619E-1

8,75159E-1

8,71082E-1

7,86071E0

6,37113E-1

7,43433E-1

7,27306E-1

4,40675E0

5,15807E-1

6.6

MathSBML

2,76594E-1

5,11880E-1

7,43433E-1

5,15807E-1

6.6

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

6.6

SBToolbox2

8,54086E-1

2,73349E-1

5,13213E-1

7,57142E-1

8,75220E-1

8,71060E-1

7,87957E0

6,35862E-1

7,44170E-1

7,27811E-1

4,35724E0

5,15080E-1

6.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,76603E-1

5,11889E-1

7,43431E-1

5,15806E-1

6.6

VCell

2,76594E-1

5,11880E-1

7,43433E-1

5,15807E-1

6.6

copasi

2,76596E-1

5,11878E-1

7,43432E-1

5,15808E-1

6.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,76594E-1

5,11880E-1

7,43433E-1

5,15807E-1

6.6

jsim

8,52608E-1

2,76594E-1

5,11880E-1

7,57619E-1

8,75159E-1

8,71082E-1

7,86071E0

6,37113E-1

7,43433E-1

7,27306E-1

4,40675E0

5,15807E-1

6.6

min

8,52608E-1

0,00000E0

7,57142E-1

8,75159E-1

8,71060E-1

7,86071E0

6,35862E-1

0,00000E0

7,27306E-1

4,35724E0

0,00000E0

6.6

max

8,54086E-1

2,76603E-1

5,13213E-1

7,57619E-1

8,75220E-1

8,71082E-1

7,87957E0

6,37113E-1

7,44170E-1

7,27811E-1

4,40675E0

5,15808E-1

6.6

mean

8,52609E-1

2,76594E-1

5,11880E-1

7,57619E-1

8,75159E-1

8,71082E-1

7,86071E0

6,37113E-1

7,43433E-1

7,27306E-1

4,40675E0

5,15807E-1

6.6

relative error(%)

0,00

6.8

BioUML

8,11233E-1

3,72307E-1

4,45066E-1

7,82371E-1

8,73496E-1

8,72236E-1

6,90552E0

6,73905E-1

7,28101E-1

7,01779E-1

5,84257E0

5,36138E-1

6.8

ByoDyn

8,11233E-1

3,72307E-1

4,45066E-1

7,82371E-1

8,73496E-1

8,72236E-1

6,90552E0

6,73905E-1

7,28101E-1

7,01779E-1

5,84257E0

5,36138E-1

6.8

MathSBML

3,72307E-1

4,45065E-1

7,28101E-1

5,36138E-1

6.8

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

6.8

SBToolbox2

8,13278E-1

3,67360E-1

4,46036E-1

7,82000E-1

8,73585E-1

8,72219E-1

6,91954E0

6,72001E-1

7,29050E-1

7,02150E-1

5,76933E0

5,35466E-1

6.8

SBWOdeSolver

3,72321E-1

4,45073E-1

7,28099E-1

5,36136E-1

6.8

VCell

3,72307E-1

4,45066E-1

7,28101E-1

5,36138E-1

6.8

copasi

3,72308E-1

4,45064E-1

7,28100E-1

5,36139E-1

6.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,72307E-1

4,45066E-1

7,28101E-1

5,36138E-1

6.8

jsim

8,11233E-1

3,72307E-1

4,45066E-1

7,82371E-1

8,73496E-1

8,72236E-1

6,90552E0

6,73905E-1

7,28101E-1

7,01779E-1

5,84257E0

5,36138E-1

6.8

min

8,11233E-1

0,00000E0

7,82000E-1

8,73496E-1

8,72219E-1

6,90552E0

6,72001E-1

0,00000E0

7,01779E-1

5,76933E0

0,00000E0

6.8

max

8,13278E-1

3,72321E-1

4,46036E-1

7,82371E-1

8,73585E-1

8,72236E-1

6,91954E0

6,73905E-1

7,29050E-1

7,02150E-1

5,84257E0

5,36139E-1

6.8

mean

8,11233E-1

3,72307E-1

4,45066E-1

7,82371E-1

8,73496E-1

8,72236E-1

6,90552E0

6,73905E-1

7,28101E-1

7,01779E-1

5,84257E0

5,36138E-1

6.8

relative error(%)

0,00

7.0

BioUML

7,49061E-1

5,36009E-1

3,85711E-1

8,05757E-1

8,70666E-1

8,73263E-1

6,04021E0

7,36508E-1

7,03155E-1

6,79046E-1

8,20086E0

5,57370E-1

7.0

ByoDyn

7,49061E-1

5,36009E-1

3,85711E-1

8,05757E-1

8,70666E-1

8,73263E-1

6,04021E0

7,36508E-1

7,03155E-1

6,79046E-1

8,20086E0

5,57370E-1

7.0

MathSBML

5,36009E-1

3,85711E-1

7,03155E-1

5,57370E-1

7.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

7.0

SBToolbox2

7,51400E-1

5,29362E-1

3,86330E-1

8,05509E-1

8,70779E-1

8,73255E-1

6,04934E0

7,33977E-1

7,04384E-1

6,79286E-1

8,10734E0

5,56764E-1

7.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,36023E-1

3,85717E-1

7,03153E-1

5,57368E-1

7.0

VCell

5,36009E-1

3,85711E-1

7,03155E-1

5,57370E-1

7.0

copasi

5,36012E-1

3,85709E-1

7,03154E-1

5,57371E-1

7.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,36009E-1

3,85711E-1

7,03155E-1

5,57370E-1

7.0

jsim

7,49061E-1

5,36009E-1

3,85711E-1

8,05757E-1

8,70666E-1

8,73263E-1

6,04021E0

7,36508E-1

7,03155E-1

6,79046E-1

8,20086E0

5,57370E-1

7.0

min

7,49061E-1

0,00000E0

8,05509E-1

8,70666E-1

8,73255E-1

6,04021E0

7,33977E-1

0,00000E0

6,79046E-1

8,10734E0

0,00000E0

7.0

max

7,51400E-1

5,36023E-1

3,86330E-1

8,05757E-1

8,70779E-1

8,73263E-1

6,04934E0

7,36508E-1

7,04384E-1

6,79286E-1

8,20086E0

5,57371E-1

7.0

mean

7,49061E-1

5,36009E-1

3,85711E-1

8,05757E-1

8,70666E-1

8,73263E-1

6,04021E0

7,36508E-1

7,03155E-1

6,79046E-1

8,20086E0

5,57370E-1

7.0

relative error(%)

0,00

7.2

BioUML

6,79330E-1

7,55262E-1

3,33748E-1

8,27409E-1

8,66905E-1

8,74165E-1

5,26935E0

8,19723E-1

6,67447E-1

6,59100E-1

1,11804E1

5,79101E-1

7.2

ByoDyn

6,79330E-1

7,55262E-1

3,33748E-1

8,27409E-1

8,66905E-1

8,74165E-1

5,26935E0

8,19723E-1

6,67447E-1

6,59100E-1

1,11804E1

5,79101E-1

7.2

MathSBML

7,55262E-1

3,33748E-1

6,67447E-1

5,79101E-1

7.2

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

7.2

SBToolbox2

6,81216E-1

7,48759E-1

3,34060E-1

8,27281E-1

8,67017E-1

8,74161E-1

5,27394E0

8,17264E-1

6,68894E-1

6,59220E-1

1,10950E1

5,78578E-1

7.2

SBWOdeSolver

7,55257E-1

3,33754E-1

6,67446E-1

5,79099E-1

7.2

VCell

7,55262E-1

3,33748E-1

6,67447E-1

5,79101E-1

7.2

copasi

7,55267E-1

3,33746E-1

6,67446E-1

5,79101E-1

7.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,55262E-1

3,33748E-1

6,67447E-1

5,79101E-1

7.2

jsim

6,79330E-1

7,55262E-1

3,33748E-1

8,27409E-1

8,66905E-1

8,74165E-1

5,26935E0

8,19723E-1

6,67447E-1

6,59100E-1

1,11804E1

5,79101E-1

7.2

min

6,79330E-1

0,00000E0

8,27281E-1

8,66905E-1

8,74161E-1

5,26935E0

8,17264E-1

0,00000E0

6,59100E-1

1,10950E1

0,00000E0

7.2

max

6,81216E-1

7,55267E-1

3,34060E-1

8,27409E-1

8,67017E-1

8,74165E-1

5,27394E0

8,19723E-1

6,68894E-1

6,59220E-1

1,11804E1

5,79101E-1

7.2

mean

6,79330E-1

7,55262E-1

3,33748E-1

8,27409E-1

8,66905E-1

8,74165E-1

5,26935E0

8,19723E-1

6,67447E-1

6,59100E-1

1,11804E1

5,79101E-1

7.2

relative error(%)

0,00

7.4

BioUML

6,23458E-1

9,66331E-1

2,89093E-1

8,46967E-1

8,63315E-1

8,74941E-1

4,59674E0

8,99155E-1

6,24275E-1

6,41926E-1

1,38714E1

6,00963E-1

7.4

ByoDyn

6,23458E-1

9,66331E-1

2,89093E-1

8,46967E-1

8,63315E-1

8,74941E-1

4,59674E0

8,99155E-1

6,24275E-1

6,41926E-1

1,38714E1

6,00963E-1

7.4

MathSBML

9,66331E-1

2,89093E-1

6,24275E-1

6,00963E-1

7.4

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

7.4

SBToolbox2

6,24485E-1

9,62119E-1

2,89147E-1

8,46942E-1

8,63388E-1

8,74940E-1

4,59759E0

8,97578E-1

6,25715E-1

6,41945E-1

1,38194E1

6,00516E-1

7.4

SBWOdeSolver

9,66313E-1

2,89098E-1

6,24276E-1

6,00961E-1

7.4

VCell

9,66331E-1

2,89093E-1

6,24275E-1

6,00963E-1

7.4

copasi

9,66332E-1

2,89092E-1

6,24274E-1

6,00964E-1

7.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,66331E-1

2,89093E-1

6,24275E-1

6,00963E-1

7.4

jsim

6,23458E-1

9,66331E-1

2,89093E-1

8,46967E-1

8,63315E-1

8,74941E-1

4,59674E0

8,99155E-1

6,24275E-1

6,41926E-1

1,38714E1

6,00963E-1

7.4

min

6,23458E-1

0,00000E0

8,46942E-1

8,63315E-1

8,74940E-1

4,59674E0

8,97578E-1

0,00000E0

6,41926E-1

1,38194E1

0,00000E0

7.4

max

6,24485E-1

9,66332E-1

2,89147E-1

8,46967E-1

8,63388E-1

8,74941E-1

4,59759E0

8,99155E-1

6,25715E-1

6,41945E-1

1,38714E1

6,00964E-1

7.4

mean

6,23458E-1

9,66331E-1

2,89093E-1

8,46967E-1

8,63315E-1

8,74941E-1

4,59674E0

8,99155E-1

6,24275E-1

6,41926E-1

1,38714E1

6,00963E-1

7.4

relative error(%)

0,00

7.6

BioUML

5,89106E-1

1,11598E0

2,51694E-1

8,64074E-1

8,60788E-1

8,75592E-1

4,02601E0

9,55075E-1

5,79875E-1

6,27519E-1

1,56827E1

6,22597E-1

7.6

ByoDyn

5,89106E-1

1,11598E0

2,51694E-1

8,64074E-1

8,60788E-1

8,75592E-1

4,02601E0

9,55075E-1

5,79875E-1

6,27519E-1

1,56827E1

6,22597E-1

7.6

MathSBML

1,11598E0

2,51694E-1

5,79875E-1

6,22597E-1

7.6

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

7.6

SBToolbox2

5,89655E-1

1,11347E0

2,51554E-1

8,64140E-1

8,60828E-1

8,75597E-1

4,02386E0

9,54136E-1

5,81322E-1

6,27464E-1

1,56531E1

6,22209E-1

7.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,11596E0

2,51698E-1

5,79876E-1

6,22595E-1

7.6

VCell

1,11598E0

2,51694E-1

5,79875E-1

6,22597E-1

7.6

copasi

1,11598E0

2,51693E-1

5,79874E-1

6,22598E-1

7.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,11598E0

2,51694E-1

5,79875E-1

6,22597E-1

7.6

jsim

5,89106E-1

1,11598E0

2,51694E-1

8,64074E-1

8,60788E-1

8,75592E-1

4,02601E0

9,55075E-1

5,79875E-1

6,27519E-1

1,56827E1

6,22597E-1

7.6

min

5,89106E-1

0,00000E0

8,64074E-1

8,60788E-1

8,75592E-1

4,02386E0

9,54136E-1

0,00000E0

6,27464E-1

1,56531E1

0,00000E0

7.6

max

5,89655E-1

1,11598E0

2,51698E-1

8,64140E-1

8,60828E-1

8,75597E-1

4,02601E0

9,55075E-1

5,81322E-1

6,27519E-1

1,56827E1

6,22598E-1

7.6

mean

5,89106E-1

1,11598E0

2,51694E-1

8,64074E-1

8,60788E-1

8,75592E-1

4,02601E0

9,55075E-1

5,79875E-1

6,27519E-1

1,56827E1

6,22597E-1

7.6

relative error(%)

0,00

7.8

BioUML

5,72974E-1

1,19245E0

2,21504E-1

8,78395E-1

8,59502E-1

8,76119E-1

3,56029E0

9,83523E-1

5,39756E-1

6,15873E-1

1,65792E1

6,43615E-1

7.8

ByoDyn

5,72974E-1

1,19245E0

2,21504E-1

8,78395E-1

8,59502E-1

8,76119E-1

3,56029E0

9,83523E-1

5,39756E-1

6,15873E-1

1,65792E1

6,43615E-1

7.8

MathSBML

1,19245E0

2,21504E-1

5,39756E-1

6,43615E-1

7.8

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

7.8

SBToolbox2

5,73113E-1

1,19176E0

2,21197E-1

8,78541E-1

8,59513E-1

8,76124E-1

3,55557E0

9,83274E-1

5,41023E-1

6,15756E-1

1,65715E1

6,43299E-1

7.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,19244E0

2,21507E-1

5,39758E-1

6,43613E-1

7.8

VCell

1,19245E0

2,21504E-1

5,39756E-1

6,43615E-1

7.8

copasi

1,19245E0

2,21503E-1

5,39756E-1

6,43616E-1

7.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,19245E0

2,21504E-1

5,39756E-1

6,43615E-1

7.8

jsim

5,72974E-1

1,19245E0

2,21504E-1

8,78395E-1

8,59502E-1

8,76119E-1

3,56029E0

9,83523E-1

5,39756E-1

6,15873E-1

1,65792E1

6,43615E-1

7.8

min

5,72974E-1

0,00000E0

8,78395E-1

8,59502E-1

8,76119E-1

3,55557E0

9,83274E-1

0,00000E0

6,15756E-1

1,65715E1

0,00000E0

7.8

max

5,73113E-1

1,19245E0

2,21507E-1

8,78541E-1

8,59513E-1

8,76124E-1

3,56029E0

9,83523E-1

5,41023E-1

6,15873E-1

1,65792E1

6,43616E-1

7.8

mean

5,72974E-1

1,19245E0

2,21504E-1

8,78395E-1

8,59502E-1

8,76119E-1

3,56029E0

9,83523E-1

5,39756E-1

6,15873E-1

1,65792E1

6,43615E-1

7.8

relative error(%)

0,00

8.0

BioUML

5,69780E-1

1,20810E0

1,98336E-1

8,89711E-1

8,59239E-1

8,76523E-1

3,19982E0

9,89336E-1

5,07049E-1

6,06927E-1

1,67603E1

6,63590E-1

8.0

ByoDyn

5,69780E-1

1,20810E0

1,98336E-1

8,89711E-1

8,59239E-1

8,76523E-1

3,19982E0

9,89336E-1

5,07049E-1

6,06927E-1

1,67603E1

6,63590E-1

8.0

MathSBML

1,20810E0

1,98336E-1

5,07049E-1

6,63590E-1

8.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

8.0

SBToolbox2

5,69408E-1

1,20992E0

1,97892E-1

8,89928E-1

8,59210E-1

8,76532E-1

3,19290E0

9,90010E-1

5,08052E-1

6,06754E-1

1,67812E1

6,63334E-1

8.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,20810E0

1,98339E-1

5,07051E-1

6,63588E-1

8.0

VCell

1,20810E0

1,98336E-1

5,07049E-1

6,63590E-1

8.0

copasi

1,20810E0

1,98335E-1

5,07049E-1

6,63591E-1

8.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,20810E0

1,98336E-1

5,07049E-1

6,63590E-1

8.0

jsim

5,69780E-1

1,20810E0

1,98336E-1

8,89711E-1

8,59239E-1

8,76523E-1

3,19982E0

9,89336E-1

5,07049E-1

6,06927E-1

1,67603E1

6,63590E-1

8.0

min

5,69408E-1

0,00000E0

8,89711E-1

8,59210E-1

8,76523E-1

3,19290E0

9,89336E-1

0,00000E0

6,06754E-1

1,67603E1

0,00000E0

8.0

max

5,69780E-1

1,20992E0

1,98339E-1

8,89928E-1

8,59239E-1

8,76532E-1

3,19982E0

9,90010E-1

5,08052E-1

6,06927E-1

1,67812E1

6,63591E-1

8.0

mean

5,69780E-1

1,20810E0

1,98336E-1

8,89711E-1

8,59239E-1

8,76523E-1

3,19982E0

9,89336E-1

5,07049E-1

6,06927E-1

1,67603E1

6,63590E-1

8.0

relative error(%)

0,00

8.2

BioUML

5,75438E-1

1,18049E0

1,81705E-1

8,98016E-1

8,59703E-1

8,76814E-1

2,93941E0

9,79080E-1

4,82792E-1

6,00500E-1

1,64402E1

6,82076E-1

8.2

ByoDyn

5,75438E-1

1,18049E0

1,81705E-1

8,98016E-1

8,59703E-1

8,76814E-1

2,93941E0

9,79080E-1

4,82792E-1

6,00500E-1

1,64402E1

6,82076E-1

8.2

MathSBML

1,18049E0

1,81705E-1

4,82792E-1

6,82076E-1

8.2

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

8.2

SBToolbox2

5,74769E-1

1,18372E0

1,81166E-1

8,98291E-1

8,59647E-1

8,76822E-1

2,93087E0

9,80280E-1

4,83406E-1

6,00291E-1

1,64777E1

6,81898E-1

8.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,18049E0

1,81707E-1

4,82794E-1

6,82074E-1

8.2

VCell

1,18049E0

1,81705E-1

4,82792E-1

6,82076E-1

8.2

copasi

1,18049E0

1,81705E-1

4,82792E-1

6,82077E-1

8.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,18049E0

1,81705E-1

4,82792E-1

6,82076E-1

8.2

jsim

5,75438E-1

1,18049E0

1,81705E-1

8,98016E-1

8,59703E-1

8,76814E-1

2,93941E0

9,79080E-1

4,82792E-1

6,00500E-1

1,64402E1

6,82076E-1

8.2

min

5,74769E-1

0,00000E0

8,98016E-1

8,59647E-1

8,76814E-1

2,93087E0

9,79080E-1

0,00000E0

6,00291E-1

1,64402E1

0,00000E0

8.2

max

5,75438E-1

1,18372E0

1,81707E-1

8,98291E-1

8,59703E-1

8,76822E-1

2,93941E0

9,80280E-1

4,83406E-1

6,00500E-1

1,64777E1

6,82077E-1

8.2

mean

5,75438E-1

1,18049E0

1,81705E-1

8,98016E-1

8,59703E-1

8,76814E-1

2,93941E0

9,79080E-1

4,82792E-1

6,00500E-1

1,64402E1

6,82076E-1

8.2

relative error(%)

0,00

8.4

BioUML

5,87250E-1

1,12456E0

1,70855E-1

9,03519E-1

8,60643E-1

8,77003E-1

2,76874E0

9,58272E-1

4,66768E-1

5,96304E-1

1,57843E1

6,98663E-1

8.4

ByoDyn

5,87250E-1

1,12456E0

1,70855E-1

9,03519E-1

8,60643E-1

8,77003E-1

2,76874E0

9,58272E-1

4,66768E-1

5,96304E-1

1,57843E1

6,98663E-1

8.4

MathSBML

1,12456E0

1,70855E-1

4,66768E-1

6,98663E-1

8.4

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

8.4

SBToolbox2

5,86342E-1

1,12879E0

1,70253E-1

9,03824E-1

8,60570E-1

8,77012E-1

2,75924E0

9,59846E-1

4,66999E-1

5,96074E-1

1,58339E1

6,98585E-1

8.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,12456E0

1,70856E-1

4,66769E-1

6,98661E-1

8.4

VCell

1,12456E0

1,70855E-1

4,66768E-1

6,98663E-1

8.4

copasi

1,12456E0

1,70854E-1

4,66768E-1

6,98663E-1

8.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,12456E0

1,70855E-1

4,66768E-1

6,98663E-1

8.4

jsim

5,87250E-1

1,12456E0

1,70855E-1

9,03519E-1

8,60643E-1

8,77003E-1

2,76874E0

9,58272E-1

4,66768E-1

5,96304E-1

1,57843E1

6,98663E-1

8.4

min

5,86342E-1

0,00000E0

9,03519E-1

8,60570E-1

8,77003E-1

2,75924E0

9,58272E-1

0,00000E0

5,96074E-1

1,57843E1

0,00000E0

8.4

max

5,87250E-1

1,12879E0

1,70856E-1

9,03824E-1

8,60643E-1

8,77012E-1

2,76874E0

9,59846E-1

4,66999E-1

5,96304E-1

1,58339E1

6,98663E-1

8.4

mean

5,87250E-1

1,12456E0

1,70855E-1

9,03519E-1

8,60643E-1

8,77003E-1

2,76874E0

9,58272E-1

4,66768E-1

5,96304E-1

1,57843E1

6,98663E-1

8.4

relative error(%)

0,00

8.6

BioUML

6,03473E-1

1,05132E0

1,64946E-1

9,06544E-1

8,61878E-1

8,77107E-1

2,67554E0

9,30954E-1

4,58168E-1

5,94019E-1

1,49096E1

7,13028E-1

8.6

ByoDyn

6,03473E-1

1,05132E0

1,64946E-1

9,06544E-1

8,61878E-1

8,77107E-1

2,67554E0

9,30954E-1

4,58168E-1

5,94019E-1

1,49096E1

7,13028E-1

8.6

MathSBML

1,05132E0

1,64946E-1

4,58168E-1

7,13028E-1

8.6

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

8.6

SBToolbox2

6,02325E-1

1,05635E0

1,64255E-1

9,06903E-1

8,61790E-1

8,77120E-1

2,66459E0

9,32844E-1

4,58012E-1

5,93750E-1

1,49704E1

7,13054E-1

8.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,05132E0

1,64946E-1

4,58169E-1

7,13026E-1

8.6

VCell

1,05132E0

1,64946E-1

4,58168E-1

7,13028E-1

8.6

copasi

1,05132E0

1,64945E-1

4,58168E-1

7,13028E-1

8.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,05132E0

1,64946E-1

4,58168E-1

7,13028E-1

8.6

jsim

6,03473E-1

1,05132E0

1,64946E-1

9,06544E-1

8,61878E-1

8,77106E-1

2,67554E0

9,30954E-1

4,58168E-1

5,94019E-1

1,49096E1

7,13028E-1

8.6

min

6,02325E-1

0,00000E0

9,06544E-1

8,61790E-1

8,77106E-1

2,66459E0

9,30954E-1

0,00000E0

5,93750E-1

1,49096E1

0,00000E0

8.6

max

6,03473E-1

1,05635E0

1,64946E-1

9,06903E-1

8,61878E-1

8,77120E-1

2,67554E0

9,32844E-1

4,58169E-1

5,94019E-1

1,49704E1

7,13054E-1

8.6

mean

6,03473E-1

1,05132E0

1,64946E-1

9,06544E-1

8,61878E-1

8,77107E-1

2,67554E0

9,30954E-1

4,58168E-1

5,94019E-1

1,49096E1

7,13028E-1

8.6

relative error(%)

0,00

8.8

BioUML

6,22923E-1

9,68534E-1

1,63280E-1

9,07400E-1

8,63278E-1

8,77136E-1

2,64924E0

8,99980E-1

4,55992E-1

5,93374E-1

1,38987E1

7,24956E-1

8.8

ByoDyn

6,22923E-1

9,68534E-1

1,63280E-1

9,07400E-1

8,63278E-1

8,77136E-1

2,64924E0

8,99980E-1

4,55992E-1

5,93374E-1

1,38987E1

7,24956E-1

8.8

MathSBML

9,68534E-1

1,63280E-1

4,55992E-1

7,24956E-1

8.8

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

8.8

SBToolbox2

6,21554E-1

9,74205E-1

1,62471E-1

9,07819E-1

8,63180E-1

8,77150E-1

2,63642E0

9,02107E-1

4,55444E-1

5,93061E-1

1,39686E1

7,25085E-1

8.8

SBWOdeSolver

9,68538E-1

1,63280E-1

4,55992E-1

7,24955E-1

8.8

VCell

9,68534E-1

1,63280E-1

4,55992E-1

7,24956E-1

8.8

copasi

9,68533E-1

1,63280E-1

4,55992E-1

7,24956E-1

8.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,68534E-1

1,63280E-1

4,55992E-1

7,24956E-1

8.8

jsim

6,22923E-1

9,68534E-1

1,63280E-1

9,07400E-1

8,63278E-1

8,77136E-1

2,64924E0

8,99980E-1

4,55992E-1

5,93374E-1

1,38987E1

7,24956E-1

8.8

min

6,21554E-1

0,00000E0

9,07400E-1

8,63180E-1

8,77136E-1

2,63642E0

8,99980E-1

0,00000E0

5,93061E-1

1,38987E1

0,00000E0

8.8

max

6,22923E-1

9,74205E-1

1,63280E-1

9,07819E-1

8,63278E-1

8,77150E-1

2,64924E0

9,02107E-1

4,55992E-1

5,93374E-1

1,39686E1

7,25085E-1

8.8

mean

6,22923E-1

9,68534E-1

1,63280E-1

9,07400E-1

8,63278E-1

8,77136E-1

2,64924E0

8,99980E-1

4,55992E-1

5,93374E-1

1,38987E1

7,24956E-1

8.8

relative error(%)

0,00

9.0

BioUML

6,44724E-1

8,81681E-1

1,65464E-1

9,06277E-1

8,64751E-1

8,77097E-1

2,68373E0

8,67377E-1

4,59235E-1

5,94219E-1

1,28120E1

7,34323E-1

9.0

ByoDyn

6,44724E-1

8,81681E-1

1,65464E-1

9,06277E-1

8,64751E-1

8,77097E-1

2,68373E0

8,67377E-1

4,59235E-1

5,94219E-1

1,28120E1

7,34323E-1

9.0

MathSBML

8,81680E-1

1,65464E-1

4,59235E-1

7,34323E-1

9.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

9.0

SBToolbox2

6,43253E-1

8,87373E-1

1,64530E-1

9,06759E-1

8,64657E-1

8,77110E-1

2,66901E0

8,69516E-1

4,58387E-1

5,93858E-1

1,28844E1

7,34561E-1

9.0

SBWOdeSolver

8,81683E-1

1,65464E-1

4,59235E-1

7,34322E-1

9.0

VCell

8,81681E-1

1,65464E-1

4,59235E-1

7,34323E-1

9.0

copasi

8,81679E-1

1,65464E-1

4,59235E-1

7,34323E-1

9.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,81681E-1

1,65464E-1

4,59235E-1

7,34323E-1

9.0

jsim

6,44724E-1

8,81681E-1

1,65464E-1

9,06277E-1

8,64751E-1

8,77097E-1

2,68373E0

8,67377E-1

4,59235E-1

5,94219E-1

1,28120E1

7,34323E-1

9.0

min

6,43253E-1

0,00000E0

9,06277E-1

8,64657E-1

8,77097E-1

2,66901E0

8,67377E-1

0,00000E0

5,93858E-1

1,28120E1

0,00000E0

9.0

max

6,44724E-1

8,87373E-1

1,65464E-1

9,06759E-1

8,64751E-1

8,77110E-1

2,68373E0

8,69516E-1

4,59235E-1

5,94219E-1

1,28844E1

7,34561E-1

9.0

mean

6,44724E-1

8,81681E-1

1,65464E-1

9,06277E-1

8,64751E-1

8,77097E-1

2,68373E0

8,67377E-1

4,59235E-1

5,94219E-1

1,28120E1

7,34323E-1

9.0

relative error(%)

0,00

9.2

BioUML

6,68150E-1

7,94672E-1

1,71541E-1

9,03169E-1

8,66233E-1

8,76991E-1

2,77954E0

8,34604E-1

4,66968E-1

5,96570E-1

1,16955E1

7,41048E-1

9.2

ByoDyn

6,68150E-1

7,94672E-1

1,71541E-1

9,03169E-1

8,66233E-1

8,76991E-1

2,77954E0

8,34604E-1

4,66968E-1

5,96570E-1

1,16955E1

7,41048E-1

9.2

MathSBML

7,94672E-1

1,71541E-1

4,66968E-1

7,41048E-1

9.2

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

9.2

SBToolbox2

6,66626E-1

8,00155E-1

1,70393E-1

9,03753E-1

8,66136E-1

8,77009E-1

2,76151E0

8,36670E-1

4,65898E-1

5,96123E-1

1,17665E1

7,41402E-1

9.2

SBWOdeSolver

7,94675E-1

1,71540E-1

4,66967E-1

7,41047E-1

9.2

VCell

7,94672E-1

1,71541E-1

4,66968E-1

7,41048E-1

9.2

copasi

7,94669E-1

1,71541E-1

4,66968E-1

7,41048E-1

9.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,94672E-1

1,71541E-1

4,66968E-1

7,41048E-1

9.2

jsim

6,68150E-1

7,94672E-1

1,71541E-1

9,03169E-1

8,66233E-1

8,76991E-1

2,77954E0

8,34604E-1

4,66968E-1

5,96570E-1

1,16955E1

7,41048E-1

9.2

min

6,66626E-1

0,00000E0

9,03169E-1

8,66136E-1

8,76991E-1

2,76151E0

8,34604E-1

0,00000E0

5,96123E-1

1,16955E1

0,00000E0

9.2

max

6,68150E-1

8,00155E-1

1,71541E-1

9,03753E-1

8,66233E-1

8,77009E-1

2,77954E0

8,36670E-1

4,66968E-1

5,96570E-1

1,17665E1

7,41402E-1

9.2

mean

6,68150E-1

7,94672E-1

1,71541E-1

9,03169E-1

8,66233E-1

8,76991E-1

2,77954E0

8,34604E-1

4,66968E-1

5,96570E-1

1,16955E1

7,41048E-1

9.2

relative error(%)

0,00

9.4

BioUML

6,92550E-1

7,10302E-1

1,82191E-1

8,97771E-1

8,67674E-1

8,76805E-1

2,94704E0

8,02717E-1

4,78352E-1

6,00688E-1

1,05853E1

7,45033E-1

9.4

ByoDyn

6,92550E-1

7,10302E-1

1,82191E-1

8,97771E-1

8,67674E-1

8,76805E-1

2,94704E0

8,02717E-1

4,78352E-1

6,00688E-1

1,05853E1

7,45033E-1

9.4

MathSBML

7,10302E-1

1,82191E-1

4,78352E-1

7,45033E-1

9.4

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

9.4

SBToolbox2

6,91014E-1

7,15442E-1

1,80710E-1

8,98520E-1

8,67584E-1

8,76829E-1

2,92372E0

8,04666E-1

4,77098E-1

6,00115E-1

1,06537E1

7,45498E-1

9.4

SBWOdeSolver

7,10305E-1

1,82190E-1

4,78351E-1

7,45033E-1

9.4

VCell

7,10302E-1

1,82191E-1

4,78352E-1

7,45033E-1

9.4

copasi

7,10300E-1

1,82192E-1

4,78352E-1

7,45033E-1

9.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,10302E-1

1,82191E-1

4,78352E-1

7,45033E-1

9.4

jsim

6,92550E-1

7,10302E-1

1,82191E-1

8,97771E-1

8,67674E-1

8,76805E-1

2,94704E0

8,02718E-1

4,78352E-1

6,00688E-1

1,05853E1

7,45033E-1

9.4

min

6,91014E-1

0,00000E0

8,97771E-1

8,67584E-1

8,76805E-1

2,92372E0

8,02717E-1

0,00000E0

6,00115E-1

1,05853E1

0,00000E0

9.4

max

6,92550E-1

7,15442E-1

1,82192E-1

8,98520E-1

8,67674E-1

8,76829E-1

2,94704E0

8,04666E-1

4,78352E-1

6,00688E-1

1,06537E1

7,45498E-1

9.4

mean

6,92550E-1

7,10302E-1

1,82191E-1

8,97771E-1

8,67674E-1

8,76805E-1

2,94704E0

8,02718E-1

4,78352E-1

6,00688E-1

1,05853E1

7,45033E-1

9.4

relative error(%)

0,00

9.6

BioUML

7,17324E-1

6,30513E-1

1,99180E-1

8,89294E-1

8,69041E-1

8,76508E-1

3,21300E0

7,72464E-1

4,92643E-1

6,07253E-1

9,50926E0

7,46073E-1

9.6

ByoDyn

7,17324E-1

6,30513E-1

1,99180E-1

8,89294E-1

8,69041E-1

8,76508E-1

3,21300E0

7,72464E-1

4,92643E-1

6,07253E-1

9,50926E0

7,46073E-1

9.6

MathSBML

6,30512E-1

1,99180E-1

4,92643E-1

7,46073E-1

9.6

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

9.6

SBToolbox2

7,15820E-1

6,35185E-1

1,97161E-1

8,90290E-1

8,68962E-1

8,76540E-1

3,18144E0

7,74241E-1

4,91261E-1

6,06476E-1

9,57298E0

7,46659E-1

9.6

SBWOdeSolver

6,30515E-1

1,99178E-1

4,92642E-1

7,46073E-1

9.6

VCell

6,30513E-1

1,99180E-1

4,92643E-1

7,46073E-1

9.6

copasi

6,30510E-1

1,99181E-1

4,92643E-1

7,46072E-1

9.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,30513E-1

1,99180E-1

4,92643E-1

7,46073E-1

9.6

jsim

7,17324E-1

6,30513E-1

1,99180E-1

8,89294E-1

8,69041E-1

8,76508E-1

3,21300E0

7,72464E-1

4,92643E-1

6,07253E-1

9,50926E0

7,46073E-1

9.6

min

7,15820E-1

0,00000E0

8,89294E-1

8,68962E-1

8,76508E-1

3,18144E0

7,72464E-1

0,00000E0

6,06476E-1

9,50926E0

0,00000E0

9.6

max

7,17324E-1

6,35185E-1

1,99181E-1

8,90290E-1

8,69041E-1

8,76540E-1

3,21300E0

7,74241E-1

4,92643E-1

6,07253E-1

9,57298E0

7,46659E-1

9.6

mean

7,17324E-1

6,30513E-1

1,99180E-1

8,89294E-1

8,69041E-1

8,76508E-1

3,21300E0

7,72464E-1

4,92643E-1

6,07253E-1

9,50926E0

7,46073E-1

9.6

relative error(%)

0,00

9.8

BioUML

7,41927E-1

5,56546E-1

2,26382E-1

8,76049E-1

8,70313E-1

8,76034E-1

3,63585E0

7,44333E-1

5,09182E-1

6,17756E-1

8,48841E0

7,43717E-1

9.8

ByoDyn

7,41927E-1

5,56546E-1

2,26382E-1

8,76049E-1

8,70313E-1

8,76034E-1

3,63585E0

7,44333E-1

5,09182E-1

6,17756E-1

8,48841E0

7,43717E-1

9.8

MathSBML

5,56546E-1

2,26382E-1

5,09182E-1

7,43717E-1

9.8

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

9.8

SBToolbox2

7,40495E-1

5,60709E-1

2,23713E-1

8,77334E-1

8,70241E-1

8,76079E-1

3,59462E0

7,45923E-1

5,07697E-1

6,16723E-1

8,54651E0

7,44406E-1

9.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,56548E-1

2,26378E-1

5,09182E-1

7,43718E-1

9.8

VCell

5,56546E-1

2,26382E-1

5,09182E-1

7,43717E-1

9.8

copasi

5,56544E-1

2,26385E-1

5,09183E-1

7,43717E-1

9.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,56546E-1

2,26382E-1

5,09182E-1

7,43717E-1

9.8

jsim

7,41927E-1

5,56546E-1

2,26382E-1

8,76049E-1

8,70313E-1

8,76034E-1

3,63585E0

7,44333E-1

5,09182E-1

6,17756E-1

8,48841E0

7,43717E-1

9.8

min

7,40495E-1

0,00000E0

8,76049E-1

8,70241E-1

8,76034E-1

3,59462E0

7,44333E-1

0,00000E0

6,16723E-1

8,48841E0

0,00000E0

9.8

max

7,41927E-1

5,60709E-1

2,26385E-1

8,77334E-1

8,70313E-1

8,76079E-1

3,63585E0

7,45923E-1

5,09183E-1

6,17756E-1

8,54651E0

7,44406E-1

9.8

mean

7,41927E-1

5,56546E-1

2,26382E-1

8,76049E-1

8,70313E-1

8,76034E-1

3,63585E0

7,44333E-1

5,09182E-1

6,17756E-1

8,48841E0

7,43717E-1

9.8

relative error(%)

0,00

Test: BIOMD0000000058.xml - Ok

Reaction graph

Plots

Comparison with other simulators