Test: BIOMD0000000047.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000047.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000047.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000047.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6623415355.JPG

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: CaER  p3  p2  p1  n  Ca_Cyt 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  SBToolbox2  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult CaER p3 p2 p1 n Ca_Cyt
0.0BioUML0,00000E09,50000E-10,00000E03,33333E-11,00000E00,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn0,00000E09,50000E-10,00000E03,33333E-11,00000E00,00000E0
0.0MathSBML0,00000E0----0,00000E0
0.0Oscill8 Core0,00000E0-----
0.0SBToolbox20,00000E09,50000E-10,00000E03,33330E-11,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver0,00000E09,50000E-1---0,00000E0
0.0copasi0,00000E0----0,00000E0
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner0,00000E0----0,00000E0
0.0jsim0,00000E09,50000E-10,00000E03,33333E-11,00000E00,00000E0
0.0min 0,00000E0 9,50000E-1 0,00000E0 3,33330E-1 1,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0max 0,00000E0 9,50000E-1 0,00000E0 3,33333E-1 1,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0mean 0,00000E0 9,50000E-1 0,00000E0 3,33333E-1 1,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML-3,99026E-29,50996E-15,39296E-23,73105E-11,38065E03,99026E-2
0.2ByoDyn-3,99026E-29,50996E-15,39296E-23,73105E-11,38065E03,99026E-2
0.2MathSBML-3,99026E-2----3,99026E-2
0.2Oscill8 Core-3,05389E-2-----
0.2SBToolbox2-3,99242E-29,51000E-15,39574E-23,73104E-11,38064E03,99242E-2
0.2SBWOdeSolver-3,99022E-29,50996E-1---3,99022E-2
0.2copasi-3,99026E-2----3,99026E-2
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,99026E-2----3,99026E-2
0.2jsim-3,99026E-29,50996E-15,39296E-23,73105E-11,38065E03,99026E-2
0.2min -3,99242E-2 9,50996E-1 5,39296E-2 3,73104E-1 1,38064E0 3,99022E-2
0.2max -3,05389E-2 9,51000E-1 5,39574E-2 3,73105E-1 1,38065E0 3,99242E-2
0.2mean -3,99026E-2 9,50996E-1 5,39296E-2 3,73105E-1 1,38065E0 3,99026E-2
0.2relative error(%) 0,050,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML-5,05925E-29,50081E-16,74034E-24,05211E-11,72508E05,05925E-2
0.4ByoDyn-5,05925E-29,50081E-16,74034E-24,05211E-11,72508E05,05925E-2
0.4MathSBML-5,05925E-2----5,05925E-2
0.4Oscill8 Core-3,30442E-2-----
0.4SBToolbox2-5,06275E-29,50083E-16,74469E-24,05212E-11,72504E05,06275E-2
0.4SBWOdeSolver-5,05923E-29,50081E-1---5,05923E-2
0.4copasi-5,05925E-2----5,05925E-2
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,05925E-2----5,05925E-2
0.4jsim-5,05925E-29,50081E-16,74034E-24,05211E-11,72508E05,05925E-2
0.4min -5,06275E-2 9,50081E-1 6,74034E-2 4,05211E-1 1,72504E0 5,05923E-2
0.4max -3,30442E-2 9,50083E-1 6,74469E-2 4,05212E-1 1,72508E0 5,06275E-2
0.4mean -5,05925E-2 9,50081E-1 6,74034E-2 4,05211E-1 1,72508E0 5,05925E-2
0.4relative error(%) 0,070,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML-5,62745E-29,48535E-17,44101E-24,31554E-12,03673E05,62745E-2
0.6ByoDyn-5,62745E-29,48535E-17,44101E-24,31554E-12,03673E05,62745E-2
0.6MathSBML-5,62745E-2----5,62745E-2
0.6Oscill8 Core-3,33029E-2-----
0.6SBToolbox2-5,62978E-29,48545E-17,44386E-24,31557E-12,03671E05,62978E-2
0.6SBWOdeSolver-5,62744E-29,48535E-1---5,62744E-2
0.6copasi-5,62745E-2----5,62745E-2
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,62745E-2----5,62745E-2
0.6jsim-5,62745E-29,48535E-17,44101E-24,31554E-12,03673E05,62745E-2
0.6min -5,62978E-2 9,48535E-1 7,44101E-2 4,31554E-1 2,03671E0 5,62744E-2
0.6max -3,33029E-2 9,48545E-1 7,44386E-2 4,31557E-1 2,03673E0 5,62978E-2
0.6mean -5,62745E-2 9,48535E-1 7,44101E-2 4,31554E-1 2,03673E0 5,62745E-2
0.6relative error(%) 0,040,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML-6,04895E-29,46663E-17,95403E-24,53456E-12,31872E06,04895E-2
0.8ByoDyn-6,04895E-29,46663E-17,95403E-24,53456E-12,31872E06,04895E-2
0.8MathSBML-6,04895E-2----6,04895E-2
0.8Oscill8 Core-3,33301E-2-----
0.8SBToolbox2-6,05114E-29,46668E-17,95671E-24,53459E-12,31872E06,05114E-2
0.8SBWOdeSolver-6,04895E-29,46663E-1---6,04895E-2
0.8copasi-6,04895E-2----6,04895E-2
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,04895E-2----6,04895E-2
0.8jsim-6,04895E-29,46663E-17,95403E-24,53456E-12,31872E06,04895E-2
0.8min -6,05114E-2 9,46663E-1 7,95403E-2 4,53456E-1 2,31872E0 6,04895E-2
0.8max -3,33301E-2 9,46668E-1 7,95671E-2 4,53459E-1 2,31872E0 6,05114E-2
0.8mean -6,04895E-2 9,46663E-1 7,95403E-2 4,53456E-1 2,31872E0 6,04895E-2
0.8relative error(%) 0,040,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML-6,41688E-29,44572E-18,39720E-24,71869E-12,57388E06,41688E-2
1.0ByoDyn-6,41688E-29,44572E-18,39720E-24,71869E-12,57388E06,41688E-2
1.0MathSBML-6,41688E-2----6,41688E-2
1.0Oscill8 Core-3,33330E-2-----
1.0SBToolbox2-6,41833E-29,44580E-18,39897E-24,71865E-12,57388E06,41833E-2
1.0SBWOdeSolver-6,41688E-29,44572E-1---6,41688E-2
1.0copasi-6,41688E-2----6,41688E-2
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,41688E-2----6,41688E-2
1.0jsim-6,41688E-29,44572E-18,39720E-24,71869E-12,57388E06,41688E-2
1.0min -6,41833E-2 9,44572E-1 8,39720E-2 4,71865E-1 2,57388E0 6,41688E-2
1.0max -3,33330E-2 9,44580E-1 8,39897E-2 4,71869E-1 2,57388E0 6,41833E-2
1.0mean -6,41688E-2 9,44572E-1 8,39720E-2 4,71869E-1 2,57388E0 6,41688E-2
1.0relative error(%) 0,020,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML-6,76185E-29,42313E-18,80887E-24,87492E-12,80475E06,76185E-2
1.2ByoDyn-6,76185E-29,42313E-18,80887E-24,87492E-12,80475E06,76185E-2
1.2MathSBML-6,76185E-2----6,76185E-2
1.2Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
1.2SBToolbox2-6,76378E-29,42314E-18,81110E-24,87492E-12,80478E06,76378E-2
1.2SBWOdeSolver-6,76185E-29,42313E-1---6,76185E-2
1.2copasi-6,76185E-2----6,76185E-2
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,76185E-2----6,76185E-2
1.2jsim-6,76185E-29,42313E-18,80887E-24,87492E-12,80475E06,76185E-2
1.2min -6,76378E-2 9,42313E-1 8,80887E-2 4,87492E-1 2,80475E0 6,76185E-2
1.2max -3,33333E-2 9,42314E-1 8,81110E-2 4,87492E-1 2,80478E0 6,76378E-2
1.2mean -6,76185E-2 9,42313E-1 8,80887E-2 4,87492E-1 2,80475E0 6,76185E-2
1.2relative error(%) 0,030,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML-7,09559E-29,39913E-19,20363E-25,00852E-13,01366E07,09559E-2
1.4ByoDyn-7,09559E-29,39913E-19,20363E-25,00852E-13,01366E07,09559E-2
1.4MathSBML-7,09559E-2----7,09559E-2
1.4Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
1.4SBToolbox2-7,09649E-29,39917E-19,20467E-25,00853E-13,01370E07,09649E-2
1.4SBWOdeSolver-7,09559E-29,39913E-1---7,09559E-2
1.4copasi-7,09559E-2----7,09559E-2
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-7,09559E-2----7,09559E-2
1.4jsim-7,09559E-29,39913E-19,20363E-25,00852E-13,01366E07,09559E-2
1.4min -7,09649E-2 9,39913E-1 9,20363E-2 5,00852E-1 3,01366E0 7,09559E-2
1.4max -3,33333E-2 9,39917E-1 9,20467E-2 5,00853E-1 3,01370E0 7,09649E-2
1.4mean -7,09559E-2 9,39913E-1 9,20363E-2 5,00852E-1 3,01366E0 7,09559E-2
1.4relative error(%) 0,010,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML-7,42324E-29,37392E-19,58787E-25,12355E-13,20268E07,42324E-2
1.6ByoDyn-7,42324E-29,37392E-19,58787E-25,12355E-13,20268E07,42324E-2
1.6MathSBML-7,42324E-2----7,42324E-2
1.6Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
1.6SBToolbox2-7,42449E-29,37401E-19,58934E-25,12354E-13,20266E07,42449E-2
1.6SBWOdeSolver-7,42324E-29,37392E-1---7,42324E-2
1.6copasi-7,42324E-2----7,42324E-2
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-7,42324E-2----7,42324E-2
1.6jsim-7,42324E-29,37392E-19,58787E-25,12355E-13,20268E07,42324E-2
1.6min -7,42449E-2 9,37392E-1 9,58787E-2 5,12354E-1 3,20266E0 7,42324E-2
1.6max -3,33333E-2 9,37401E-1 9,58934E-2 5,12355E-1 3,20268E0 7,42449E-2
1.6mean -7,42324E-2 9,37392E-1 9,58787E-2 5,12355E-1 3,20268E0 7,42324E-2
1.6relative error(%) 0,020,000,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML-7,74737E-29,34765E-19,96480E-25,22315E-13,37372E07,74737E-2
1.8ByoDyn-7,74737E-29,34765E-19,96480E-25,22315E-13,37372E07,74737E-2
1.8MathSBML-7,74737E-2----7,74737E-2
1.8Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
1.8SBToolbox2-7,74682E-29,34765E-19,96415E-25,22315E-13,37372E07,74682E-2
1.8SBWOdeSolver-7,74737E-29,34765E-1---7,74737E-2
1.8copasi-7,74737E-2----7,74737E-2
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-7,74737E-2----7,74737E-2
1.8jsim-7,74737E-29,34765E-19,96480E-25,22315E-13,37372E07,74737E-2
1.8min -7,74737E-2 9,34765E-1 9,96415E-2 5,22315E-1 3,37372E0 7,74682E-2
1.8max -3,33333E-2 9,34765E-1 9,96480E-2 5,22315E-1 3,37372E0 7,74737E-2
1.8mean -7,74737E-2 9,34765E-1 9,96480E-2 5,22315E-1 3,37372E0 7,74737E-2
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML-8,06948E-29,32044E-11,03363E-15,30983E-13,52848E08,06948E-2
2.0ByoDyn-8,06948E-29,32044E-11,03363E-15,30983E-13,52848E08,06948E-2
2.0MathSBML-8,06948E-2----8,06948E-2
2.0Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
2.0SBToolbox2-8,06750E-29,32048E-11,03342E-15,30980E-13,52852E08,06750E-2
2.0SBWOdeSolver-8,06948E-29,32044E-1---8,06948E-2
2.0copasi-8,06948E-2----8,06948E-2
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-8,06948E-2----8,06948E-2
2.0jsim-8,06948E-29,32044E-11,03363E-15,30983E-13,52848E08,06948E-2
2.0min -8,06948E-2 9,32044E-1 1,03342E-1 5,30980E-1 3,52848E0 8,06750E-2
2.0max -3,33333E-2 9,32048E-1 1,03363E-1 5,30983E-1 3,52852E0 8,06948E-2
2.0mean -8,06948E-2 9,32044E-1 1,03363E-1 5,30983E-1 3,52848E0 8,06948E-2
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML-8,39057E-29,29240E-11,07035E-15,38560E-13,66852E08,39057E-2
2.2ByoDyn-8,39057E-29,29240E-11,07035E-15,38560E-13,66852E08,39057E-2
2.2MathSBML-8,39057E-2----8,39057E-2
2.2Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
2.2SBToolbox2-8,38808E-29,29251E-11,07008E-15,38561E-13,66853E08,38808E-2
2.2SBWOdeSolver-8,39057E-29,29240E-1---8,39057E-2
2.2copasi-8,39057E-2----8,39057E-2
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-8,39057E-2----8,39057E-2
2.2jsim-8,39057E-29,29240E-11,07035E-15,38560E-13,66852E08,39057E-2
2.2min -8,39057E-2 9,29240E-1 1,07008E-1 5,38560E-1 3,66852E0 8,38808E-2
2.2max -3,33333E-2 9,29251E-1 1,07035E-1 5,38561E-1 3,66853E0 8,39057E-2
2.2mean -8,39057E-2 9,29240E-1 1,07035E-1 5,38560E-1 3,66852E0 8,39057E-2
2.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.4BioUML-8,71140E-29,26360E-11,10675E-15,45208E-13,79522E08,71140E-2
2.4ByoDyn-8,71140E-29,26360E-11,10675E-15,45208E-13,79522E08,71140E-2
2.4MathSBML-8,71140E-2----8,71140E-2
2.4Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
2.4SBToolbox2-8,70846E-29,26386E-11,10644E-15,45206E-13,79524E08,70846E-2
2.4SBWOdeSolver-8,71140E-29,26360E-1---8,71140E-2
2.4copasi-8,71140E-2----8,71140E-2
2.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-8,71140E-2----8,71140E-2
2.4jsim-8,71140E-29,26360E-11,10675E-15,45208E-13,79522E08,71140E-2
2.4min -8,71140E-2 9,26360E-1 1,10644E-1 5,45206E-1 3,79522E0 8,70846E-2
2.4max -3,33333E-2 9,26386E-1 1,10675E-1 5,45208E-1 3,79524E0 8,71140E-2
2.4mean -8,71140E-2 9,26360E-1 1,10675E-1 5,45208E-1 3,79522E0 8,71140E-2
2.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.6BioUML-9,03264E-29,23412E-11,14290E-15,51060E-13,90987E09,03264E-2
2.6ByoDyn-9,03264E-29,23412E-11,14290E-15,51060E-13,90987E09,03264E-2
2.6MathSBML-9,03264E-2----9,03264E-2
2.6Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
2.6SBToolbox2-9,02874E-29,23449E-11,14243E-15,51060E-13,90987E09,02874E-2
2.6SBWOdeSolver-9,03264E-29,23412E-1---9,03264E-2
2.6copasi-9,03264E-2----9,03264E-2
2.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,03264E-2----9,03264E-2
2.6jsim-9,03264E-29,23412E-11,14290E-15,51060E-13,90987E09,03264E-2
2.6min -9,03264E-2 9,23412E-1 1,14243E-1 5,51060E-1 3,90987E0 9,02874E-2
2.6max -3,33333E-2 9,23449E-1 1,14290E-1 5,51060E-1 3,90987E0 9,03264E-2
2.6mean -9,03264E-2 9,23412E-1 1,14290E-1 5,51060E-1 3,90987E0 9,03264E-2
2.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.8BioUML-9,35492E-29,20402E-11,17887E-15,56227E-14,01361E09,35492E-2
2.8ByoDyn-9,35492E-29,20402E-11,17887E-15,56227E-14,01361E09,35492E-2
2.8MathSBML-9,35492E-2----9,35492E-2
2.8Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
2.8SBToolbox2-9,34899E-29,20432E-11,17820E-15,56223E-14,01363E09,34899E-2
2.8SBWOdeSolver-9,35492E-29,20402E-1---9,35492E-2
2.8copasi-9,35492E-2----9,35492E-2
2.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,35492E-2----9,35492E-2
2.8jsim-9,35492E-29,20402E-11,17887E-15,56227E-14,01361E09,35492E-2
2.8min -9,35492E-2 9,20402E-1 1,17820E-1 5,56223E-1 4,01361E0 9,34899E-2
2.8max -3,33333E-2 9,20432E-1 1,17887E-1 5,56227E-1 4,01363E0 9,35492E-2
2.8mean -9,35492E-2 9,20402E-1 1,17887E-1 5,56227E-1 4,01361E0 9,35492E-2
2.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.0BioUML-9,67884E-29,17337E-11,21473E-15,60801E-14,10748E09,67884E-2
3.0ByoDyn-9,67884E-29,17337E-11,21473E-15,60801E-14,10748E09,67884E-2
3.0MathSBML-9,67884E-2----9,67884E-2
3.0Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
3.0SBToolbox2-9,67154E-29,17368E-11,21396E-15,60804E-14,10745E09,67154E-2
3.0SBWOdeSolver-9,67884E-29,17337E-1---9,67884E-2
3.0copasi-9,67884E-2----9,67884E-2
3.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,67884E-2----9,67884E-2
3.0jsim-9,67884E-29,17337E-11,21473E-15,60801E-14,10748E09,67884E-2
3.0min -9,67884E-2 9,17337E-1 1,21396E-1 5,60801E-1 4,10745E0 9,67154E-2
3.0max -3,33333E-2 9,17368E-1 1,21473E-1 5,60804E-1 4,10748E0 9,67884E-2
3.0mean -9,67884E-2 9,17337E-1 1,21473E-1 5,60801E-1 4,10748E0 9,67884E-2
3.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.2BioUML-1,00051E-19,14219E-11,25055E-15,64859E-14,19241E01,00051E-1
3.2ByoDyn-1,00051E-19,14219E-11,25055E-15,64859E-14,19241E01,00051E-1
3.2MathSBML-1,00051E-1----1,00051E-1
3.2Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
3.2SBToolbox2-9,99688E-29,14258E-11,24972E-15,64859E-14,19242E09,99688E-2
3.2SBWOdeSolver-1,00051E-19,14219E-1---1,00051E-1
3.2copasi-1,00051E-1----1,00051E-1
3.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,00051E-1----1,00051E-1
3.2jsim-1,00051E-19,14219E-11,25055E-15,64859E-14,19241E01,00051E-1
3.2min -1,00051E-1 9,14219E-1 1,24972E-1 5,64859E-1 4,19241E0 9,99688E-2
3.2max -3,33333E-2 9,14258E-1 1,25055E-1 5,64859E-1 4,19242E0 1,00051E-1
3.2mean -1,00051E-1 9,14219E-1 1,25055E-1 5,64859E-1 4,19241E0 1,00051E-1
3.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.4BioUML-1,03343E-19,11053E-11,28641E-15,68466E-14,26927E01,03343E-1
3.4ByoDyn-1,03343E-19,11053E-11,28641E-15,68466E-14,26927E01,03343E-1
3.4MathSBML-1,03343E-1----1,03343E-1
3.4Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
3.4SBToolbox2-1,03256E-19,11094E-11,28549E-15,68462E-14,26924E01,03256E-1
3.4SBWOdeSolver-1,03343E-19,11053E-1---1,03343E-1
3.4copasi-1,03343E-1----1,03343E-1
3.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,03343E-1----1,03343E-1
3.4jsim-1,03343E-19,11053E-11,28641E-15,68466E-14,26927E01,03343E-1
3.4min -1,03343E-1 9,11053E-1 1,28549E-1 5,68462E-1 4,26924E0 1,03256E-1
3.4max -3,33333E-2 9,11094E-1 1,28641E-1 5,68466E-1 4,26927E0 1,03343E-1
3.4mean -1,03343E-1 9,11053E-1 1,28641E-1 5,68466E-1 4,26927E0 1,03343E-1
3.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.6BioUML-1,06673E-19,07842E-11,32238E-15,71680E-14,33880E01,06673E-1
3.6ByoDyn-1,06673E-19,07842E-11,32238E-15,71680E-14,33880E01,06673E-1
3.6MathSBML-1,06673E-1----1,06673E-1
3.6Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
3.6SBToolbox2-1,06569E-19,07888E-11,32125E-15,71676E-14,33881E01,06569E-1
3.6SBWOdeSolver-1,06673E-19,07842E-1---1,06673E-1
3.6copasi-1,06673E-1----1,06673E-1
3.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,06673E-1----1,06673E-1
3.6jsim-1,06673E-19,07842E-11,32238E-15,71680E-14,33880E01,06673E-1
3.6min -1,06673E-1 9,07842E-1 1,32125E-1 5,71676E-1 4,33880E0 1,06569E-1
3.6max -3,33333E-2 9,07888E-1 1,32238E-1 5,71680E-1 4,33881E0 1,06673E-1
3.6mean -1,06673E-1 9,07842E-1 1,32238E-1 5,71680E-1 4,33880E0 1,06673E-1
3.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.8BioUML-1,10050E-19,04587E-11,35856E-15,74546E-14,40173E01,10050E-1
3.8ByoDyn-1,10050E-19,04587E-11,35856E-15,74546E-14,40173E01,10050E-1
3.8MathSBML-1,10050E-1----1,10050E-1
3.8Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
3.8SBToolbox2-1,09925E-19,04641E-11,35722E-15,74547E-14,40176E01,09925E-1
3.8SBWOdeSolver-1,10050E-19,04587E-1---1,10050E-1
3.8copasi-1,10050E-1----1,10050E-1
3.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,10050E-1----1,10050E-1
3.8jsim-1,10050E-19,04587E-11,35856E-15,74546E-14,40173E01,10050E-1
3.8min -1,10050E-1 9,04587E-1 1,35722E-1 5,74546E-1 4,40173E0 1,09925E-1
3.8max -3,33333E-2 9,04641E-1 1,35856E-1 5,74547E-1 4,40176E0 1,10050E-1
3.8mean -1,10050E-1 9,04587E-1 1,35856E-1 5,74546E-1 4,40173E0 1,10050E-1
3.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.0BioUML-1,13484E-19,01290E-11,39504E-15,77107E-14,45866E01,13484E-1
4.0ByoDyn-1,13484E-19,01290E-11,39504E-15,77107E-14,45866E01,13484E-1
4.0MathSBML-1,13484E-1----1,13484E-1
4.0Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
4.0SBToolbox2-1,13352E-19,01344E-11,39368E-15,77108E-14,45862E01,13352E-1
4.0SBWOdeSolver-1,13484E-19,01290E-1---1,13484E-1
4.0copasi-1,13484E-1----1,13484E-1
4.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,13484E-1----1,13484E-1
4.0jsim-1,13484E-19,01290E-11,39504E-15,77107E-14,45866E01,13484E-1
4.0min -1,13484E-1 9,01290E-1 1,39368E-1 5,77107E-1 4,45862E0 1,13352E-1
4.0max -3,33333E-2 9,01344E-1 1,39504E-1 5,77108E-1 4,45866E0 1,13484E-1
4.0mean -1,13484E-1 9,01290E-1 1,39504E-1 5,77107E-1 4,45866E0 1,13484E-1
4.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.2BioUML-1,16987E-18,97950E-11,43193E-15,79398E-14,51017E01,16987E-1
4.2ByoDyn-1,16987E-18,97950E-11,43193E-15,79398E-14,51017E01,16987E-1
4.2MathSBML-1,16987E-1----1,16987E-1
4.2Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
4.2SBToolbox2-1,16854E-18,98011E-11,43050E-15,79394E-14,51019E01,16854E-1
4.2SBWOdeSolver-1,16987E-18,97950E-1---1,16987E-1
4.2copasi-1,16987E-1----1,16987E-1
4.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,16987E-1----1,16987E-1
4.2jsim-1,16987E-18,97950E-11,43193E-15,79398E-14,51017E01,16987E-1
4.2min -1,16987E-1 8,97950E-1 1,43050E-1 5,79394E-1 4,51017E0 1,16854E-1
4.2max -3,33333E-2 8,98011E-1 1,43193E-1 5,79398E-1 4,51019E0 1,16987E-1
4.2mean -1,16987E-1 8,97950E-1 1,43193E-1 5,79398E-1 4,51017E0 1,16987E-1
4.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.4BioUML-1,20572E-18,94567E-11,46937E-15,81449E-14,55679E01,20572E-1
4.4ByoDyn-1,20572E-18,94567E-11,46937E-15,81449E-14,55679E01,20572E-1
4.4MathSBML-1,20572E-1----1,20572E-1
4.4Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
4.4SBToolbox2-1,20421E-18,94625E-11,46781E-15,81446E-14,55679E01,20421E-1
4.4SBWOdeSolver-1,20572E-18,94567E-1---1,20572E-1
4.4copasi-1,20572E-1----1,20572E-1
4.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,20572E-1----1,20572E-1
4.4jsim-1,20572E-18,94567E-11,46937E-15,81449E-14,55679E01,20572E-1
4.4min -1,20572E-1 8,94567E-1 1,46781E-1 5,81446E-1 4,55679E0 1,20421E-1
4.4max -3,33333E-2 8,94625E-1 1,46937E-1 5,81449E-1 4,55679E0 1,20572E-1
4.4mean -1,20572E-1 8,94567E-1 1,46937E-1 5,81449E-1 4,55679E0 1,20572E-1
4.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.6BioUML-1,24257E-18,91138E-11,50750E-15,83288E-14,59896E01,24257E-1
4.6ByoDyn-1,24257E-18,91138E-11,50750E-15,83288E-14,59896E01,24257E-1
4.6MathSBML-1,24257E-1----1,24257E-1
4.6Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
4.6SBToolbox2-1,24073E-18,91208E-11,50563E-15,83289E-14,59898E01,24073E-1
4.6SBWOdeSolver-1,24257E-18,91138E-1---1,24257E-1
4.6copasi-1,24257E-1----1,24257E-1
4.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,24257E-1----1,24257E-1
4.6jsim-1,24257E-18,91138E-11,50750E-15,83288E-14,59896E01,24257E-1
4.6min -1,24257E-1 8,91138E-1 1,50563E-1 5,83288E-1 4,59896E0 1,24073E-1
4.6max -3,33333E-2 8,91208E-1 1,50750E-1 5,83289E-1 4,59898E0 1,24257E-1
4.6mean -1,24257E-1 8,91138E-1 1,50750E-1 5,83288E-1 4,59896E0 1,24257E-1
4.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.8BioUML-1,28060E-18,87660E-11,54651E-15,84939E-14,63713E01,28060E-1
4.8ByoDyn-1,28060E-18,87660E-11,54651E-15,84939E-14,63713E01,28060E-1
4.8MathSBML-1,28060E-1----1,28060E-1
4.8Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
4.8SBToolbox2-1,27869E-18,87736E-11,54454E-15,84942E-14,63714E01,27869E-1
4.8SBWOdeSolver-1,28060E-18,87660E-1---1,28060E-1
4.8copasi-1,28061E-1----1,28061E-1
4.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,28060E-1----1,28060E-1
4.8jsim-1,28060E-18,87660E-11,54651E-15,84939E-14,63713E01,28060E-1
4.8min -1,28061E-1 8,87660E-1 1,54454E-1 5,84939E-1 4,63713E0 1,27869E-1
4.8max -3,33333E-2 8,87736E-1 1,54651E-1 5,84942E-1 4,63714E0 1,28061E-1
4.8mean -1,28060E-1 8,87660E-1 1,54651E-1 5,84939E-1 4,63713E0 1,28060E-1
4.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
5.0BioUML-1,32006E-18,84129E-11,58660E-15,86421E-14,67166E01,32006E-1
5.0ByoDyn-1,32006E-18,84129E-11,58660E-15,86421E-14,67166E01,32006E-1
5.0MathSBML-1,32006E-1----1,32006E-1
5.0Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
5.0SBToolbox2-1,31805E-18,84200E-11,58455E-15,86425E-14,67165E01,31805E-1
5.0SBWOdeSolver-1,32006E-18,84129E-1---1,32006E-1
5.0copasi-1,32007E-1----1,32007E-1
5.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,32006E-1----1,32006E-1
5.0jsim-1,32006E-18,84129E-11,58660E-15,86421E-14,67166E01,32006E-1
5.0min -1,32007E-1 8,84129E-1 1,58455E-1 5,86421E-1 4,67165E0 1,31805E-1
5.0max -3,33333E-2 8,84200E-1 1,58660E-1 5,86425E-1 4,67166E0 1,32007E-1
5.0mean -1,32006E-1 8,84129E-1 1,58660E-1 5,86421E-1 4,67166E0 1,32006E-1
5.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
5.2BioUML-1,36123E-18,80538E-11,62803E-15,87752E-14,70291E01,36123E-1
5.2ByoDyn-1,36123E-18,80538E-11,62803E-15,87752E-14,70291E01,36123E-1
5.2MathSBML-1,36124E-1----1,36124E-1
5.2Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
5.2SBToolbox2-1,35886E-18,80624E-11,62561E-15,87754E-14,70292E01,35886E-1
5.2SBWOdeSolver-1,36124E-18,80538E-1---1,36124E-1
5.2copasi-1,36124E-1----1,36124E-1
5.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,36123E-1----1,36123E-1
5.2jsim-1,36123E-18,80538E-11,62803E-15,87752E-14,70291E01,36123E-1
5.2min -1,36124E-1 8,80538E-1 1,62561E-1 5,87752E-1 4,70291E0 1,35886E-1
5.2max -3,33333E-2 8,80624E-1 1,62803E-1 5,87754E-1 4,70292E0 1,36124E-1
5.2mean -1,36123E-1 8,80538E-1 1,62803E-1 5,87752E-1 4,70291E0 1,36123E-1
5.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
5.4BioUML-1,40447E-18,76878E-11,67110E-15,88950E-14,73118E01,40447E-1
5.4ByoDyn-1,40447E-18,76878E-11,67110E-15,88950E-14,73118E01,40447E-1
5.4MathSBML-1,40447E-1----1,40447E-1
5.4Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
5.4SBToolbox2-1,40141E-18,76977E-11,66811E-15,88948E-14,73120E01,40141E-1
5.4SBWOdeSolver-1,40447E-18,76878E-1---1,40447E-1
5.4copasi-1,40447E-1----1,40447E-1
5.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,40447E-1----1,40447E-1
5.4jsim-1,40447E-18,76878E-11,67110E-15,88950E-14,73118E01,40447E-1
5.4min -1,40447E-1 8,76878E-1 1,66811E-1 5,88948E-1 4,73118E0 1,40141E-1
5.4max -3,33333E-2 8,76977E-1 1,67110E-1 5,88950E-1 4,73120E0 1,40447E-1
5.4mean -1,40447E-1 8,76878E-1 1,67110E-1 5,88950E-1 4,73118E0 1,40447E-1
5.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
5.6BioUML-1,45019E-18,73140E-11,71616E-15,90028E-14,75676E01,45019E-1
5.6ByoDyn-1,45019E-18,73140E-11,71616E-15,90028E-14,75676E01,45019E-1
5.6MathSBML-1,45019E-1----1,45019E-1
5.6Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
5.6SBToolbox2-1,44706E-18,73236E-11,71311E-15,90032E-14,75673E01,44706E-1
5.6SBWOdeSolver-1,45019E-18,73140E-1---1,45019E-1
5.6copasi-1,45019E-1----1,45019E-1
5.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,45019E-1----1,45019E-1
5.6jsim-1,45019E-18,73140E-11,71616E-15,90028E-14,75676E01,45019E-1
5.6min -1,45019E-1 8,73140E-1 1,71311E-1 5,90028E-1 4,75673E0 1,44706E-1
5.6max -3,33333E-2 8,73236E-1 1,71616E-1 5,90032E-1 4,75676E0 1,45019E-1
5.6mean -1,45019E-1 8,73140E-1 1,71616E-1 5,90028E-1 4,75676E0 1,45019E-1
5.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
5.8BioUML-1,49892E-18,69309E-11,76366E-15,90998E-14,77991E01,49892E-1
5.8ByoDyn-1,49892E-18,69309E-11,76366E-15,90998E-14,77991E01,49892E-1
5.8MathSBML-1,49892E-1----1,49892E-1
5.8Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
5.8SBToolbox2-1,49565E-18,69406E-11,76051E-15,90997E-14,77986E01,49565E-1
5.8SBWOdeSolver-1,49892E-18,69309E-1---1,49892E-1
5.8copasi-1,49893E-1----1,49893E-1
5.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,49892E-1----1,49892E-1
5.8jsim-1,49892E-18,69309E-11,76366E-15,90998E-14,77991E01,49892E-1
5.8min -1,49893E-1 8,69309E-1 1,76051E-1 5,90997E-1 4,77986E0 1,49565E-1
5.8max -3,33333E-2 8,69406E-1 1,76366E-1 5,90998E-1 4,77991E0 1,49893E-1
5.8mean -1,49892E-1 8,69309E-1 1,76366E-1 5,90998E-1 4,77991E0 1,49892E-1
5.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
6.0BioUML-1,55133E-18,65370E-11,81414E-15,91872E-14,80085E01,55133E-1
6.0ByoDyn-1,55133E-18,65370E-11,81414E-15,91872E-14,80085E01,55133E-1
6.0MathSBML-1,55133E-1----1,55133E-1
6.0Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
6.0SBToolbox2-1,54684E-18,65490E-11,80990E-15,91876E-14,80086E01,54684E-1
6.0SBWOdeSolver-1,55133E-18,65370E-1---1,55133E-1
6.0copasi-1,55134E-1----1,55134E-1
6.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,55133E-1----1,55133E-1
6.0jsim-1,55133E-18,65370E-11,81414E-15,91872E-14,80085E01,55133E-1
6.0min -1,55134E-1 8,65370E-1 1,80990E-1 5,91872E-1 4,80085E0 1,54684E-1
6.0max -3,33333E-2 8,65490E-1 1,81414E-1 5,91876E-1 4,80086E0 1,55134E-1
6.0mean -1,55133E-1 8,65370E-1 1,81414E-1 5,91872E-1 4,80085E0 1,55133E-1
6.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
6.2BioUML-1,60822E-18,61300E-11,86824E-15,92660E-14,81980E01,60822E-1
6.2ByoDyn-1,60822E-18,61300E-11,86824E-15,92660E-14,81980E01,60822E-1
6.2MathSBML-1,60822E-1----1,60822E-1
6.2Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
6.2SBToolbox2-1,60244E-18,61444E-11,86276E-15,92661E-14,81984E01,60244E-1
6.2SBWOdeSolver-1,60822E-18,61300E-1---1,60822E-1
6.2copasi-1,60824E-1----1,60824E-1
6.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,60822E-1----1,60822E-1
6.2jsim-1,60822E-18,61300E-11,86824E-15,92660E-14,81980E01,60822E-1
6.2min -1,60824E-1 8,61300E-1 1,86276E-1 5,92660E-1 4,81980E0 1,60244E-1
6.2max -3,33333E-2 8,61444E-1 1,86824E-1 5,92661E-1 4,81984E0 1,60824E-1
6.2mean -1,60822E-1 8,61300E-1 1,86824E-1 5,92660E-1 4,81980E0 1,60822E-1
6.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
6.4BioUML-1,67064E-18,57075E-11,92678E-15,93370E-14,83695E01,67064E-1
6.4ByoDyn-1,67064E-18,57075E-11,92678E-15,93370E-14,83695E01,67064E-1
6.4MathSBML-1,67064E-1----1,67064E-1
6.4Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
6.4SBToolbox2-1,66499E-18,57201E-11,92152E-15,93371E-14,83699E01,66499E-1
6.4SBWOdeSolver-1,67064E-18,57075E-1---1,67064E-1
6.4copasi-1,67066E-1----1,67066E-1
6.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,67064E-1----1,67064E-1
6.4jsim-1,67064E-18,57075E-11,92678E-15,93370E-14,83695E01,67064E-1
6.4min -1,67066E-1 8,57075E-1 1,92152E-1 5,93370E-1 4,83695E0 1,66499E-1
6.4max -3,33333E-2 8,57201E-1 1,92678E-1 5,93371E-1 4,83699E0 1,67066E-1
6.4mean -1,67064E-1 8,57075E-1 1,92678E-1 5,93370E-1 4,83695E0 1,67064E-1
6.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
6.6BioUML-1,73989E-18,52661E-11,99074E-15,94010E-14,85247E01,73989E-1
6.6ByoDyn-1,73989E-18,52661E-11,99074E-15,94010E-14,85247E01,73989E-1
6.6MathSBML-1,73989E-1----1,73989E-1
6.6Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
6.6SBToolbox2-1,73446E-18,52762E-11,98576E-15,94010E-14,85247E01,73446E-1
6.6SBWOdeSolver-1,73989E-18,52660E-1---1,73989E-1
6.6copasi-1,73991E-1----1,73991E-1
6.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,73989E-1----1,73989E-1
6.6jsim-1,73989E-18,52660E-11,99074E-15,94010E-14,85247E01,73989E-1
6.6min -1,73991E-1 8,52660E-1 1,98576E-1 5,94010E-1 4,85247E0 1,73446E-1
6.6max -3,33333E-2 8,52762E-1 1,99074E-1 5,94010E-1 4,85247E0 1,73991E-1
6.6mean -1,73989E-1 8,52661E-1 1,99074E-1 5,94010E-1 4,85247E0 1,73989E-1
6.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
6.8BioUML-1,81762E-18,48017E-12,06135E-15,94588E-14,86651E01,81762E-1
6.8ByoDyn-1,81762E-18,48017E-12,06135E-15,94588E-14,86651E01,81762E-1
6.8MathSBML-1,81762E-1----1,81762E-1
6.8Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
6.8SBToolbox2-1,81098E-18,48123E-12,05535E-15,94590E-14,86652E01,81098E-1
6.8SBWOdeSolver-1,81762E-18,48016E-1---1,81762E-1
6.8copasi-1,81764E-1----1,81764E-1
6.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,81762E-1----1,81762E-1
6.8jsim-1,81762E-18,48017E-12,06135E-15,94588E-14,86651E01,81762E-1
6.8min -1,81764E-1 8,48016E-1 2,05535E-1 5,94588E-1 4,86651E0 1,81098E-1
6.8max -3,33333E-2 8,48123E-1 2,06135E-1 5,94590E-1 4,86652E0 1,81764E-1
6.8mean -1,81762E-1 8,48017E-1 2,06135E-1 5,94588E-1 4,86651E0 1,81762E-1
6.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
7.0BioUML-1,90595E-18,43092E-12,14009E-15,95109E-14,87921E01,90595E-1
7.0ByoDyn-1,90595E-18,43092E-12,14009E-15,95109E-14,87921E01,90595E-1
7.0MathSBML-1,90596E-1----1,90596E-1
7.0Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
7.0SBToolbox2-1,89781E-18,43242E-12,13293E-15,95109E-14,87918E01,89781E-1
7.0SBWOdeSolver-1,90596E-18,43092E-1---1,90596E-1
7.0copasi-1,90599E-1----1,90599E-1
7.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,90595E-1----1,90595E-1
7.0jsim-1,90595E-18,43092E-12,14009E-15,95109E-14,87921E01,90595E-1
7.0min -1,90599E-1 8,43092E-1 2,13293E-1 5,95109E-1 4,87918E0 1,89781E-1
7.0max -3,33333E-2 8,43242E-1 2,14009E-1 5,95109E-1 4,87921E0 1,90599E-1
7.0mean -1,90595E-1 8,43092E-1 2,14009E-1 5,95109E-1 4,87921E0 1,90595E-1
7.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
7.2BioUML-2,00761E-18,37822E-12,22879E-15,95580E-14,89071E02,00761E-1
7.2ByoDyn-2,00761E-18,37822E-12,22879E-15,95580E-14,89071E02,00761E-1
7.2MathSBML-2,00761E-1----2,00761E-1
7.2Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
7.2SBToolbox2-1,99851E-18,37994E-12,22092E-15,95578E-14,89074E01,99851E-1
7.2SBWOdeSolver-2,00761E-18,37822E-1---2,00761E-1
7.2copasi-2,00765E-1----2,00765E-1
7.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,00761E-1----2,00761E-1
7.2jsim-2,00761E-18,37822E-12,22879E-15,95580E-14,89071E02,00761E-1
7.2min -2,00765E-1 8,37822E-1 2,22092E-1 5,95578E-1 4,89071E0 1,99851E-1
7.2max -3,33333E-2 8,37994E-1 2,22879E-1 5,95580E-1 4,89074E0 2,00765E-1
7.2mean -2,00761E-1 8,37822E-1 2,22879E-1 5,95580E-1 4,89071E0 2,00761E-1
7.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
7.4BioUML-2,12603E-18,32126E-12,32964E-15,96005E-14,90111E02,12603E-1
7.4ByoDyn-2,12603E-18,32126E-12,32964E-15,96005E-14,90111E02,12603E-1
7.4MathSBML-2,12604E-1----2,12604E-1
7.4Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
7.4SBToolbox2-2,11456E-18,32362E-12,31998E-15,96005E-14,90113E02,11456E-1
7.4SBWOdeSolver-2,12604E-18,32126E-1---2,12604E-1
7.4copasi-2,12608E-1----2,12608E-1
7.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,12603E-1----2,12603E-1
7.4jsim-2,12603E-18,32126E-12,32964E-15,96005E-14,90111E02,12603E-1
7.4min -2,12608E-1 8,32126E-1 2,31998E-1 5,96005E-1 4,90111E0 2,11456E-1
7.4max -3,33333E-2 8,32362E-1 2,32964E-1 5,96005E-1 4,90113E0 2,12608E-1
7.4mean -2,12603E-1 8,32126E-1 2,32964E-1 5,96005E-1 4,90111E0 2,12603E-1
7.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
7.6BioUML-2,26564E-18,25904E-12,44520E-15,96388E-14,91052E02,26564E-1
7.6ByoDyn-2,26564E-18,25904E-12,44520E-15,96388E-14,91052E02,26564E-1
7.6MathSBML-2,26564E-1----2,26564E-1
7.6Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
7.6SBToolbox2-2,25322E-18,26163E-12,43506E-15,96385E-14,91052E02,25322E-1
7.6SBWOdeSolver-2,26564E-18,25904E-1---2,26564E-1
7.6copasi-2,26570E-1----2,26570E-1
7.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,26564E-1----2,26564E-1
7.6jsim-2,26564E-18,25904E-12,44520E-15,96388E-14,91052E02,26564E-1
7.6min -2,26570E-1 8,25904E-1 2,43506E-1 5,96385E-1 4,91052E0 2,25322E-1
7.6max -3,33333E-2 8,26163E-1 2,44520E-1 5,96388E-1 4,91052E0 2,26570E-1
7.6mean -2,26564E-1 8,25904E-1 2,44520E-1 5,96388E-1 4,91052E0 2,26564E-1
7.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
7.8BioUML-2,43194E-18,19029E-12,57841E-15,96735E-14,91903E02,43194E-1
7.8ByoDyn-2,43194E-18,19029E-12,57841E-15,96735E-14,91903E02,43194E-1
7.8MathSBML-2,43194E-1----2,43194E-1
7.8Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
7.8SBToolbox2-2,41638E-18,19361E-12,56616E-15,96734E-14,91899E02,41638E-1
7.8SBWOdeSolver-2,43195E-18,19029E-1---2,43195E-1
7.8copasi-2,43201E-1----2,43201E-1
7.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,43194E-1----2,43194E-1
7.8jsim-2,43194E-18,19029E-12,57841E-15,96735E-14,91903E02,43194E-1
7.8min -2,43201E-1 8,19029E-1 2,56616E-1 5,96734E-1 4,91899E0 2,41638E-1
7.8max -3,33333E-2 8,19361E-1 2,57841E-1 5,96735E-1 4,91903E0 2,43201E-1
7.8mean -2,43194E-1 8,19029E-1 2,57841E-1 5,96735E-1 4,91903E0 2,43194E-1
7.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
8.0BioUML-2,63174E-18,11346E-12,73236E-15,97048E-14,92674E02,63174E-1
8.0ByoDyn-2,63174E-18,11346E-12,73236E-15,97048E-14,92674E02,63174E-1
8.0MathSBML-2,63175E-1----2,63175E-1
8.0Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
8.0SBToolbox2-2,61476E-18,11718E-12,71954E-15,97044E-14,92676E02,61476E-1
8.0SBWOdeSolver-2,63175E-18,11346E-1---2,63175E-1
8.0copasi-2,63183E-1----2,63183E-1
8.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,63174E-1----2,63174E-1
8.0jsim-2,63174E-18,11346E-12,73236E-15,97048E-14,92674E02,63174E-1
8.0min -2,63183E-1 8,11346E-1 2,71954E-1 5,97044E-1 4,92674E0 2,61476E-1
8.0max -3,33333E-2 8,11718E-1 2,73236E-1 5,97048E-1 4,92676E0 2,63183E-1
8.0mean -2,63174E-1 8,11346E-1 2,73236E-1 5,97048E-1 4,92674E0 2,63174E-1
8.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
8.2BioUML-2,87313E-18,02667E-12,91005E-15,97331E-14,93371E02,87313E-1
8.2ByoDyn-2,87313E-18,02667E-12,91005E-15,97331E-14,93371E02,87313E-1
8.2MathSBML-2,87313E-1----2,87313E-1
8.2Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
8.2SBToolbox2-2,85258E-18,03127E-12,89521E-15,97332E-14,93367E02,85258E-1
8.2SBWOdeSolver-2,87313E-18,02667E-1---2,87313E-1
8.2copasi-2,87322E-1----2,87322E-1
8.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,87313E-1----2,87313E-1
8.2jsim-2,87313E-18,02667E-12,91005E-15,97331E-14,93371E02,87313E-1
8.2min -2,87322E-1 8,02667E-1 2,89521E-1 5,97331E-1 4,93367E0 2,85258E-1
8.2max -3,33333E-2 8,03127E-1 2,91005E-1 5,97332E-1 4,93371E0 2,87322E-1
8.2mean -2,87313E-1 8,02667E-1 2,91005E-1 5,97331E-1 4,93371E0 2,87313E-1
8.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
8.4BioUML-3,16519E-17,92771E-13,11375E-15,97586E-14,94002E03,16519E-1
8.4ByoDyn-3,16519E-17,92771E-13,11375E-15,97586E-14,94002E03,16519E-1
8.4MathSBML-3,16520E-1----3,16520E-1
8.4Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
8.4SBToolbox2-3,14143E-17,93317E-13,09763E-15,97583E-14,94005E03,14143E-1
8.4SBWOdeSolver-3,16520E-17,92770E-1---3,16520E-1
8.4copasi-3,16531E-1----3,16531E-1
8.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,16519E-1----3,16519E-1
8.4jsim-3,16519E-17,92771E-13,11375E-15,97586E-14,94002E03,16519E-1
8.4min -3,16531E-1 7,92770E-1 3,09763E-1 5,97583E-1 4,94002E0 3,14143E-1
8.4max -3,33333E-2 7,93317E-1 3,11375E-1 5,97586E-1 4,94005E0 3,16531E-1
8.4mean -3,16519E-1 7,92771E-1 3,11375E-1 5,97586E-1 4,94002E0 3,16519E-1
8.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
8.6BioUML-3,51730E-17,81408E-13,34430E-15,97817E-14,94573E03,51730E-1
8.6ByoDyn-3,51730E-17,81408E-13,34430E-15,97817E-14,94573E03,51730E-1
8.6MathSBML-3,51731E-1----3,51731E-1
8.6Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
8.6SBToolbox2-3,48989E-17,82055E-13,32691E-15,97821E-14,94574E03,48989E-1
8.6SBWOdeSolver-3,51731E-17,81407E-1---3,51731E-1
8.6copasi-3,51744E-1----3,51744E-1
8.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,51730E-1----3,51730E-1
8.6jsim-3,51730E-17,81408E-13,34430E-15,97817E-14,94573E03,51730E-1
8.6min -3,51744E-1 7,81407E-1 3,32691E-1 5,97817E-1 4,94573E0 3,48989E-1
8.6max -3,33333E-2 7,82055E-1 3,34430E-1 5,97821E-1 4,94574E0 3,51744E-1
8.6mean -3,51730E-1 7,81408E-1 3,34430E-1 5,97817E-1 4,94573E0 3,51730E-1
8.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
8.8BioUML-3,93777E-17,68318E-13,60016E-15,98026E-14,95089E03,93777E-1
8.8ByoDyn-3,93777E-17,68318E-13,60016E-15,98026E-14,95089E03,93777E-1
8.8MathSBML-3,93779E-1----3,93779E-1
8.8Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
8.8SBToolbox2-3,90614E-17,69086E-13,58161E-15,98021E-14,95092E03,90614E-1
8.8SBWOdeSolver-3,93778E-17,68318E-1---3,93778E-1
8.8copasi-3,93794E-1----3,93794E-1
8.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,93777E-1----3,93777E-1
8.8jsim-3,93777E-17,68318E-13,60016E-15,98026E-14,95089E03,93777E-1
8.8min -3,93794E-1 7,68318E-1 3,58161E-1 5,98021E-1 4,95089E0 3,90614E-1
8.8max -3,33333E-2 7,69086E-1 3,60016E-1 5,98026E-1 4,95092E0 3,93794E-1
8.8mean -3,93777E-1 7,68318E-1 3,60016E-1 5,98026E-1 4,95089E0 3,93777E-1
8.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
9.0BioUML-4,43187E-17,53260E-13,87677E-15,98215E-14,95556E04,43187E-1
9.0ByoDyn-4,43187E-17,53260E-13,87677E-15,98215E-14,95556E04,43187E-1
9.0MathSBML-4,43189E-1----4,43189E-1
9.0Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
9.0SBToolbox2-4,39635E-17,54159E-13,85772E-15,98211E-14,95553E04,39635E-1
9.0SBWOdeSolver-4,43188E-17,53259E-1---4,43188E-1
9.0copasi-4,43207E-1----4,43207E-1
9.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,43187E-1----4,43187E-1
9.0jsim-4,43187E-17,53260E-13,87677E-15,98215E-14,95556E04,43187E-1
9.0min -4,43207E-1 7,53259E-1 3,85772E-1 5,98211E-1 4,95553E0 4,39635E-1
9.0max -3,33333E-2 7,54159E-1 3,87677E-1 5,98215E-1 4,95556E0 4,43207E-1
9.0mean -4,43187E-1 7,53260E-1 3,87677E-1 5,98215E-1 4,95556E0 4,43187E-1
9.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
9.2BioUML-4,99961E-17,36049E-14,16648E-15,98385E-14,95979E04,99961E-1
9.2ByoDyn-4,99961E-17,36049E-14,16648E-15,98385E-14,95979E04,99961E-1
9.2MathSBML-4,99963E-1----4,99963E-1
9.2Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
9.2SBToolbox2-4,96081E-17,37076E-14,14758E-15,98381E-14,95982E04,96081E-1
9.2SBWOdeSolver-4,99961E-17,36049E-1---4,99961E-1
9.2copasi-4,99983E-1----4,99983E-1
9.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,99961E-1----4,99961E-1
9.2jsim-4,99961E-17,36049E-14,16648E-15,98385E-14,95979E04,99961E-1
9.2min -4,99983E-1 7,36049E-1 4,14758E-1 5,98381E-1 4,95979E0 4,96081E-1
9.2max -3,33333E-2 7,37076E-1 4,16648E-1 5,98385E-1 4,95982E0 4,99983E-1
9.2mean -4,99961E-1 7,36049E-1 4,16648E-1 5,98385E-1 4,95979E0 4,99961E-1
9.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
9.4BioUML-5,63392E-17,16613E-14,45936E-15,98539E-14,96362E05,63392E-1
9.4ByoDyn-5,63392E-17,16613E-14,45936E-15,98539E-14,96362E05,63392E-1
9.4MathSBML-5,63394E-1----5,63394E-1
9.4Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
9.4SBToolbox2-5,59199E-17,17769E-14,44088E-15,98541E-14,96361E05,59199E-1
9.4SBWOdeSolver-5,63392E-17,16613E-1---5,63392E-1
9.4copasi-5,63417E-1----5,63417E-1
9.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,63392E-1----5,63392E-1
9.4jsim-5,63392E-17,16613E-14,45936E-15,98539E-14,96362E05,63392E-1
9.4min -5,63417E-1 7,16613E-1 4,44088E-1 5,98539E-1 4,96361E0 5,59199E-1
9.4max -3,33333E-2 7,17769E-1 4,45936E-1 5,98541E-1 4,96362E0 5,63417E-1
9.4mean -5,63392E-1 7,16613E-1 4,45936E-1 5,98539E-1 4,96362E0 5,63392E-1
9.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
9.6BioUML-6,32005E-16,95033E-14,74476E-15,98679E-14,96708E06,32005E-1
9.6ByoDyn-6,32005E-16,95033E-14,74476E-15,98679E-14,96708E06,32005E-1
9.6MathSBML-6,32007E-1----6,32007E-1
9.6Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
9.6SBToolbox2-6,27691E-16,96305E-14,72766E-15,98680E-14,96710E06,27691E-1
9.6SBWOdeSolver-6,32005E-16,95033E-1---6,32005E-1
9.6copasi-6,32032E-1----6,32032E-1
9.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,32005E-1----6,32005E-1
9.6jsim-6,32005E-16,95033E-14,74476E-15,98679E-14,96708E06,32005E-1
9.6min -6,32032E-1 6,95033E-1 4,72766E-1 5,98679E-1 4,96708E0 6,27691E-1
9.6max -3,33333E-2 6,96305E-1 4,74476E-1 5,98680E-1 4,96710E0 6,32032E-1
9.6mean -6,32005E-1 6,95033E-1 4,74476E-1 5,98679E-1 4,96708E0 6,32005E-1
9.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
9.8BioUML-7,03651E-16,71574E-15,01300E-15,98805E-14,97021E07,03651E-1
9.8ByoDyn-7,03651E-16,71574E-15,01300E-15,98805E-14,97021E07,03651E-1
9.8MathSBML-7,03653E-1----7,03653E-1
9.8Oscill8 Core-3,33333E-2-----
9.8SBToolbox2-6,99502E-16,72906E-14,99816E-15,98800E-14,97020E06,99502E-1
9.8SBWOdeSolver-7,03651E-16,71574E-1---7,03651E-1
9.8copasi-7,03678E-1----7,03678E-1
9.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-7,03651E-1----7,03651E-1
9.8jsim-7,03651E-16,71574E-15,01300E-15,98805E-14,97021E07,03651E-1
9.8min -7,03678E-1 6,71574E-1 4,99816E-1 5,98800E-1 4,97020E0 6,99502E-1
9.8max -3,33333E-2 6,72906E-1 5,01300E-1 5,98805E-1 4,97021E0 7,03678E-1
9.8mean -7,03651E-1 6,71574E-1 5,01300E-1 5,98805E-1 4,97021E0 7,03651E-1
9.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00