Test: BIOMD0000000044.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000044.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000044.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000044.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6622948601.JPG

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: Agonist_stimulated_production_of_IP3  A  EC  Ca_dependant_IP3_degradation  Ca_independant_IP3_degradation  Y  Z 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  Jarnac  SBToolbox2  VCell  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult Agonist_stimulated_production_of_IP3 A EC Ca_dependant_IP3_degradation Ca_independant_IP3_degradation Y Z
0.0BioUML0,00000E04,50000E-11,00000E30,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn0,00000E04,50000E-11,00000E30,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E0
0.0Jarnac0,00000E04,50000E-11,00000E30,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E0
0.0MathSBML0,00000E04,50000E-11,00000E30,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E0
0.0Oscill8 Core0,00000E04,50000E-11,00000E30,00000E0--0,00000E0
0.0SBToolbox20,00000E04,50000E-11,00000E30,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver0,00000E04,50000E-11,00000E30,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E0
0.0VCell0,00000E04,50000E-11,00000E30,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E0
0.0copasi0,00000E04,50000E-11,00000E30,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E0
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner0,00000E04,50000E-11,00000E30,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E0
0.0jsim0,00000E04,50000E-11,00000E30,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E0
0.0min 0,00000E0 4,50000E-1 1,00000E3 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,60000E-1 0,00000E0
0.0max 0,00000E0 4,50000E-1 1,00000E3 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,60000E-1 0,00000E0
0.0mean 0,00000E0 4,50000E-1 1,00000E3 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,60000E-1 0,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML-2,50000E-16,84753E-19,99632E23,88005E-31,13672E-26,50975E-17,69956E-2
0.2ByoDyn-2,50000E-16,84753E-19,99632E23,88005E-31,13672E-26,50975E-17,69956E-2
0.2Jarnac-2,50000E-16,84753E-19,99632E23,88005E-31,13672E-26,50975E-17,69956E-2
0.2MathSBML-2,50000E-16,84753E-19,99632E23,88005E-31,13672E-26,50975E-17,69956E-2
0.2Oscill8 Core-2,50000E-16,84753E-19,99632E23,88020E-3--7,69956E-2
0.2SBToolbox2-2,50000E-16,84750E-19,99630E23,87785E-31,13674E-26,50971E-17,69964E-2
0.2SBWOdeSolver-2,50000E-16,84753E-19,99632E23,88021E-31,13673E-26,50974E-17,69956E-2
0.2VCell-2,50000E-16,68164E-19,99702E22,05826E-21,12532E-28,36579E-11,19151E-1
0.2copasi-2,50000E-16,84753E-19,99632E23,88005E-31,13672E-26,50975E-17,69956E-2
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,50000E-16,84753E-19,99632E23,88005E-31,13672E-26,50975E-17,69956E-2
0.2jsim-2,50000E-16,84753E-19,99632E23,88005E-31,13672E-26,50975E-17,69956E-2
0.2min -2,50000E-1 6,68164E-1 9,99630E2 3,87785E-3 1,12532E-2 6,50971E-1 7,69956E-2
0.2max -2,50000E-1 6,84753E-1 9,99702E2 2,05826E-2 1,13674E-2 8,36579E-1 1,19151E-1
0.2mean -2,50000E-1 6,84753E-1 9,99632E2 3,88005E-3 1,13672E-2 6,50975E-1 7,69956E-2
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML-5,00000E-19,08318E-19,99294E21,43639E-22,73178E-29,81670E-18,46649E-2
0.4ByoDyn-5,00000E-19,08318E-19,99294E21,43639E-22,73178E-29,81670E-18,46649E-2
0.4Jarnac-5,00000E-19,08318E-19,99294E21,43639E-22,73178E-29,81670E-18,46649E-2
0.4MathSBML-5,00000E-19,08318E-19,99294E21,43639E-22,73178E-29,81670E-18,46649E-2
0.4Oscill8 Core-5,00000E-19,08318E-19,99294E21,43643E-2--8,46649E-2
0.4SBToolbox2-5,00000E-19,08335E-19,99291E21,43484E-22,73169E-29,81673E-18,46585E-2
0.4SBWOdeSolver-5,00000E-19,08318E-19,99294E21,43643E-22,73180E-29,81669E-18,46649E-2
0.4VCell-5,00000E-18,40900E-19,99458E28,26629E-22,64369E-21,30610E01,37587E-1
0.4copasi-5,00000E-19,08318E-19,99294E21,43639E-22,73178E-29,81670E-18,46649E-2
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,00000E-19,08318E-19,99294E21,43639E-22,73178E-29,81670E-18,46649E-2
0.4jsim-5,00000E-19,08318E-19,99294E21,43639E-22,73178E-29,81670E-18,46649E-2
0.4min -5,00000E-1 8,40900E-1 9,99291E2 1,43484E-2 2,64369E-2 9,81669E-1 8,46585E-2
0.4max -5,00000E-1 9,08335E-1 9,99458E2 8,26629E-2 2,73180E-2 1,30610E0 1,37587E-1
0.4mean -5,00000E-1 9,08318E-1 9,99294E2 1,43639E-2 2,73178E-2 9,81670E-1 8,46649E-2
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML-7,50000E-11,11837E09,98971E23,40179E-24,76100E-21,29652E09,26078E-2
0.6ByoDyn-7,50000E-11,11837E09,98971E23,40179E-24,76100E-21,29652E09,26078E-2
0.6Jarnac-7,50000E-11,11837E09,98971E23,40179E-24,76100E-21,29652E09,26078E-2
0.6MathSBML-7,50000E-11,11837E09,98971E23,40179E-24,76100E-21,29652E09,26078E-2
0.6Oscill8 Core-7,50000E-11,11837E09,98971E23,40188E-2--9,26079E-2
0.6SBToolbox2-7,50000E-11,11839E09,98971E23,39657E-24,76092E-21,29658E09,25946E-2
0.6SBWOdeSolver-7,50000E-11,11837E09,98971E23,40188E-24,76103E-21,29652E09,26079E-2
0.6VCell-7,50000E-19,30201E-19,99259E22,25445E-14,43537E-21,67529E01,66902E-1
0.6copasi-7,50000E-11,11837E09,98971E23,40179E-24,76100E-21,29652E09,26078E-2
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-7,50000E-11,11837E09,98971E23,40179E-24,76100E-21,29652E09,26078E-2
0.6jsim-7,50000E-11,11837E09,98971E23,40179E-24,76100E-21,29652E09,26078E-2
0.6min -7,50000E-1 9,30201E-1 9,98971E2 3,39657E-2 4,43537E-2 1,29652E0 9,25946E-2
0.6max -7,50000E-1 1,11839E0 9,99259E2 2,25445E-1 4,76103E-2 1,67529E0 1,66902E-1
0.6mean -7,50000E-1 1,11837E0 9,98971E2 3,40179E-2 4,76100E-2 1,29652E0 9,26078E-2
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML-1,00000E01,31124E09,98664E26,68254E-27,19384E-21,59452E01,01050E-1
0.8ByoDyn-1,00000E01,31124E09,98664E26,68254E-27,19384E-21,59452E01,01050E-1
0.8Jarnac-1,00000E01,31124E09,98664E26,68254E-27,19384E-21,59452E01,01050E-1
0.8MathSBML-1,00000E01,31124E09,98664E26,68254E-27,19384E-21,59452E01,01050E-1
0.8Oscill8 Core-1,00000E01,31123E09,98664E26,68271E-2--1,01050E-1
0.8SBToolbox2-1,00000E01,31136E09,98662E26,67037E-27,19355E-21,59455E01,01025E-1
0.8SBWOdeSolver-1,00000E01,31123E09,98664E26,68271E-27,19387E-21,59452E01,01050E-1
0.8VCell-1,00000E02,83144E-19,99338E21,10701E05,98435E-21,05393E06,29988E-1
0.8copasi-1,00000E01,31124E09,98664E26,68254E-27,19384E-21,59452E01,01050E-1
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,00000E01,31124E09,98664E26,68254E-27,19384E-21,59452E01,01050E-1
0.8jsim-1,00000E01,31124E09,98664E26,68254E-27,19384E-21,59452E01,01050E-1
0.8min -1,00000E0 2,83144E-1 9,98662E2 6,67037E-2 5,98435E-2 1,05393E0 1,01025E-1
0.8max -1,00000E0 1,31136E0 9,99338E2 1,10701E0 7,19387E-2 1,59455E0 6,29988E-1
0.8mean -1,00000E0 1,31124E0 9,98664E2 6,68254E-2 7,19384E-2 1,59452E0 1,01050E-1
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML-1,25000E01,48181E09,98376E21,18274E-19,99114E-21,87408E01,10309E-1
1.0ByoDyn-1,25000E01,48181E09,98376E21,18274E-19,99114E-21,87408E01,10309E-1
1.0Jarnac-1,25000E01,48181E09,98376E21,18274E-19,99114E-21,87408E01,10309E-1
1.0MathSBML-1,25000E01,48181E09,98376E21,18274E-19,99114E-21,87408E01,10309E-1
1.0Oscill8 Core-1,25000E01,48181E09,98376E21,18277E-1--1,10309E-1
1.0SBToolbox2-1,25004E01,48211E09,98372E21,18027E-19,99116E-21,87424E01,10271E-1
1.0SBWOdeSolver-1,25000E01,48181E09,98376E21,18277E-19,99118E-21,87407E01,10309E-1
1.0VCell-1,25000E02,51729E-19,99613E21,38434E06,39293E-29,47425E-11,87294E-1
1.0copasi-1,25000E01,48181E09,98376E21,18274E-19,99114E-21,87408E01,10309E-1
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,25000E01,48181E09,98376E21,18274E-19,99114E-21,87408E01,10309E-1
1.0jsim-1,25000E01,48181E09,98376E21,18274E-19,99114E-21,87408E01,10309E-1
1.0min -1,25004E0 2,51729E-1 9,98372E2 1,18027E-1 6,39293E-2 9,47425E-1 1,10271E-1
1.0max -1,25000E0 1,48211E0 9,99613E2 1,38434E0 9,99118E-2 1,87424E0 1,87294E-1
1.0mean -1,25000E0 1,48181E0 9,98376E2 1,18274E-1 9,99114E-2 1,87408E0 1,10309E-1
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML-1,50000E01,62218E09,98107E21,96809E-11,31011E-12,13242E01,20988E-1
1.2ByoDyn-1,50000E01,62218E09,98107E21,96809E-11,31011E-12,13242E01,20988E-1
1.2Jarnac-1,50000E01,62218E09,98107E21,96809E-11,31011E-12,13242E01,20988E-1
1.2MathSBML-1,50000E01,62218E09,98107E21,96809E-11,31011E-12,13242E01,20988E-1
1.2Oscill8 Core-1,50000E01,62217E09,98107E21,96815E-1--1,20988E-1
1.2SBToolbox2-1,50000E01,62257E09,98102E21,96388E-11,31006E-12,13261E01,20930E-1
1.2SBWOdeSolver-1,50000E01,62217E09,98107E21,96814E-11,31011E-12,13242E01,20988E-1
1.2VCell-1,50000E04,64095E-19,99403E21,41480E07,11081E-21,41108E01,42035E-1
1.2copasi-1,50000E01,62218E09,98107E21,96810E-11,31011E-12,13242E01,20988E-1
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,50000E01,62218E09,98107E21,96809E-11,31011E-12,13242E01,20988E-1
1.2jsim-1,50000E01,62218E09,98107E21,96809E-11,31011E-12,13242E01,20988E-1
1.2min -1,50000E0 4,64095E-1 9,98102E2 1,96388E-1 7,11081E-2 1,41108E0 1,20930E-1
1.2max -1,50000E0 1,62257E0 9,99403E2 1,41480E0 1,31011E-1 2,13261E0 1,42035E-1
1.2mean -1,50000E0 1,62218E0 9,98107E2 1,96809E-1 1,31011E-1 2,13242E0 1,20988E-1
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML-1,75000E01,71758E09,97862E23,17918E-11,64503E-12,36381E01,34688E-1
1.4ByoDyn-1,75000E01,71758E09,97862E23,17918E-11,64503E-12,36381E01,34688E-1
1.4Jarnac-1,75000E01,71758E09,97862E23,17918E-11,64503E-12,36381E01,34688E-1
1.4MathSBML-1,75000E01,71758E09,97862E23,17918E-11,64503E-12,36381E01,34688E-1
1.4Oscill8 Core-1,75000E01,71757E09,97862E23,17930E-1--1,34689E-1
1.4SBToolbox2-1,75004E01,71824E09,97861E23,17223E-11,64499E-12,36410E01,34587E-1
1.4SBWOdeSolver-1,75000E01,71757E09,97862E23,17929E-11,64503E-12,36381E01,34688E-1
1.4VCell-1,75000E06,12873E-19,99217E21,50505E08,20736E-21,74688E01,78516E-1
1.4copasi-1,75000E01,71758E09,97862E23,17920E-11,64503E-12,36381E01,34688E-1
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,75000E01,71758E09,97862E23,17918E-11,64503E-12,36381E01,34688E-1
1.4jsim-1,75000E01,71758E09,97862E23,17918E-11,64503E-12,36381E01,34688E-1
1.4min -1,75004E0 6,12873E-1 9,97861E2 3,17223E-1 8,20736E-2 1,74688E0 1,34587E-1
1.4max -1,75000E0 1,71824E0 9,99217E2 1,50505E0 1,64503E-1 2,36410E0 1,78516E-1
1.4mean -1,75000E0 1,71758E0 9,97862E2 3,17918E-1 1,64503E-1 2,36381E0 1,34688E-1
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML-2,00000E01,72506E09,97652E25,25779E-11,99159E-12,54810E01,59907E-1
1.6ByoDyn-2,00000E01,72506E09,97652E25,25779E-11,99159E-12,54810E01,59907E-1
1.6Jarnac-2,00000E01,72506E09,97652E25,25779E-11,99159E-12,54810E01,59907E-1
1.6MathSBML-2,00000E01,72506E09,97652E25,25779E-11,99159E-12,54810E01,59907E-1
1.6Oscill8 Core-2,00000E01,72501E09,97652E25,25834E-1--1,59923E-1
1.6SBToolbox2-2,00000E01,72662E09,97652E25,24199E-11,99173E-12,54890E01,59526E-1
1.6SBWOdeSolver-2,00000E01,72502E09,97652E25,25818E-11,99159E-12,54808E01,59917E-1
1.6VCell-2,00000E01,87877E-19,99450E22,17079E09,13352E-29,39843E-15,19263E-1
1.6copasi-2,00000E01,72506E09,97652E25,25785E-11,99159E-12,54810E01,59908E-1
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,00000E01,72506E09,97652E25,25779E-11,99159E-12,54810E01,59907E-1
1.6jsim-2,00000E01,72506E09,97652E25,25779E-11,99159E-12,54810E01,59907E-1
1.6min -2,00000E0 1,87877E-1 9,97652E2 5,24199E-1 9,13352E-2 9,39843E-1 1,59526E-1
1.6max -2,00000E0 1,72662E0 9,99450E2 2,17079E0 1,99173E-1 2,54890E0 5,19263E-1
1.6mean -2,00000E0 1,72506E0 9,97652E2 5,25779E-1 1,99159E-1 2,54810E0 1,59907E-1
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML-2,25000E02,67795E-19,97877E22,20704E02,25163E-11,56294E09,20108E-1
1.8ByoDyn-2,25000E02,67795E-19,97877E22,20704E02,25163E-11,56294E09,20108E-1
1.8Jarnac-2,25000E02,67795E-19,97877E22,20704E02,25163E-11,56294E09,20108E-1
1.8MathSBML-2,25000E02,67793E-19,97877E22,20704E02,25163E-11,56294E09,20109E-1
1.8Oscill8 Core-2,25000E02,68736E-19,97877E22,20610E0--9,18345E-1
1.8SBToolbox2-2,25003E02,75507E-19,97867E22,19905E02,25418E-11,58245E09,13632E-1
1.8SBWOdeSolver-2,25000E02,68851E-19,97877E22,20598E02,25164E-11,56482E09,18263E-1
1.8VCell-2,25000E02,91970E-19,99538E22,31241E09,56182E-21,11549E01,69292E-1
1.8copasi-2,25000E02,67767E-19,97877E22,20707E02,25161E-11,56287E09,20127E-1
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,25000E02,67795E-19,97877E22,20704E02,25163E-11,56294E09,20108E-1
1.8jsim-2,25000E02,67795E-19,97877E22,20704E02,25163E-11,56294E09,20108E-1
1.8min -2,25003E0 2,67767E-1 9,97867E2 2,19905E0 9,56182E-2 1,11549E0 1,69292E-1
1.8max -2,25000E0 2,91970E-1 9,99538E2 2,31241E0 2,25418E-1 1,58245E0 9,20127E-1
1.8mean -2,25000E0 2,67795E-1 9,97877E2 2,20704E0 2,25163E-1 1,56294E0 9,20108E-1
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML-2,50000E01,73812E-19,98612E22,54768E02,28504E-11,43637E03,11536E-1
2.0ByoDyn-2,50000E01,73812E-19,98612E22,54768E02,28504E-11,43637E03,11536E-1
2.0Jarnac-2,50000E01,73812E-19,98612E22,54768E02,28504E-11,43637E03,11536E-1
2.0MathSBML-2,50000E01,73812E-19,98612E22,54768E02,28504E-11,43637E03,11536E-1
2.0Oscill8 Core-2,50000E01,73839E-19,98612E22,54766E0--3,11708E-1
2.0SBToolbox2-2,50000E01,72588E-19,98608E22,54860E02,28776E-11,43716E03,13566E-1
2.0SBWOdeSolver-2,50000E01,73822E-19,98612E22,54767E02,28509E-11,43630E03,11749E-1
2.0VCell-2,50000E04,94381E-19,99334E22,35209E01,03533E-11,54190E01,50837E-1
2.0copasi-2,50000E01,73816E-19,98612E22,54768E02,28503E-11,43637E03,11526E-1
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,50000E01,73812E-19,98612E22,54768E02,28504E-11,43637E03,11536E-1
2.0jsim-2,50000E01,73812E-19,98612E22,54768E02,28504E-11,43637E03,11536E-1
2.0min -2,50000E0 1,72588E-1 9,98608E2 2,35209E0 1,03533E-1 1,43630E0 1,50837E-1
2.0max -2,50000E0 4,94381E-1 9,99334E2 2,54860E0 2,28776E-1 1,54190E0 3,13566E-1
2.0mean -2,50000E0 1,73812E-1 9,98612E2 2,54768E0 2,28504E-1 1,43637E0 3,11536E-1
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML-2,75000E02,03608E-19,98744E22,76346E02,32930E-11,14226E04,73538E-1
2.2ByoDyn-2,75000E02,03608E-19,98744E22,76346E02,32930E-11,14226E04,73538E-1
2.2Jarnac-2,75000E02,03608E-19,98744E22,76346E02,32930E-11,14226E04,73538E-1
2.2MathSBML-2,75000E02,03608E-19,98744E22,76346E02,32930E-11,14225E04,73539E-1
2.2Oscill8 Core-2,75000E02,03706E-19,98744E22,76337E0--4,72893E-1
2.2SBToolbox2-2,75003E02,06451E-19,98736E22,76033E02,33204E-11,15307E04,71137E-1
2.2SBWOdeSolver-2,75000E02,03710E-19,98744E22,76336E02,32933E-11,14289E04,72862E-1
2.2VCell-2,75000E05,90604E-19,99180E22,49462E01,14772E-11,77791E02,21530E-1
2.2copasi-2,75000E02,03610E-19,98744E22,76346E02,32929E-11,14225E04,73545E-1
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-2,75000E02,03608E-19,98744E22,76346E02,32930E-11,14226E04,73538E-1
2.2jsim-2,75000E02,03608E-19,98744E22,76346E02,32930E-11,14226E04,73538E-1
2.2min -2,75003E0 2,03608E-1 9,98736E2 2,49462E0 1,14772E-1 1,14225E0 2,21530E-1
2.2max -2,75000E0 5,90604E-1 9,99180E2 2,76346E0 2,33204E-1 1,77791E0 4,73545E-1
2.2mean -2,75000E0 2,03609E-1 9,98744E2 2,76346E0 2,32930E-1 1,14226E0 4,73538E-1
2.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.4BioUML-3,00000E02,10090E-19,99021E23,00328E02,36628E-11,03867E03,00499E-1
2.4ByoDyn-3,00000E02,10090E-19,99021E23,00328E02,36628E-11,03867E03,00499E-1
2.4Jarnac-3,00000E02,10090E-19,99021E23,00328E02,36628E-11,03867E03,00499E-1
2.4MathSBML-3,00000E02,10090E-19,99021E23,00328E02,36628E-11,03867E03,00498E-1
2.4Oscill8 Core-3,00000E02,10071E-19,99021E23,00330E0--3,00636E-1
2.4SBToolbox2-3,00000E02,08660E-19,99018E23,00446E02,36900E-11,04115E02,99991E-1
2.4SBWOdeSolver-3,00000E02,10062E-19,99021E23,00331E02,36632E-11,03856E03,00654E-1
2.4VCell-3,00000E01,83406E-19,99553E23,14555E01,21043E-19,28553E-13,25819E-1
2.4copasi-3,00000E02,10091E-19,99021E23,00328E02,36626E-11,03867E03,00493E-1
2.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,00000E02,10090E-19,99021E23,00328E02,36628E-11,03867E03,00499E-1
2.4jsim-3,00000E02,10090E-19,99021E23,00328E02,36628E-11,03867E03,00499E-1
2.4min -3,00000E0 1,83406E-1 9,99018E2 3,00328E0 1,21043E-1 9,28553E-1 2,99991E-1
2.4max -3,00000E0 2,10091E-1 9,99553E2 3,14555E0 2,36900E-1 1,04115E0 3,25819E-1
2.4mean -3,00000E0 2,10090E-1 9,99021E2 3,00328E0 2,36628E-1 1,03867E0 3,00499E-1
2.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.6BioUML-3,25000E01,87373E-19,99247E23,27179E02,40839E-17,28776E-13,83905E-1
2.6ByoDyn-3,25000E01,87373E-19,99247E23,27179E02,40839E-17,28776E-13,83905E-1
2.6Jarnac-3,25000E01,87373E-19,99247E23,27179E02,40839E-17,28776E-13,83905E-1
2.6MathSBML-3,25000E01,87373E-19,99247E23,27179E02,40839E-17,28775E-13,83905E-1
2.6Oscill8 Core-3,25000E01,87438E-19,99247E23,27172E0--3,83856E-1
2.6SBToolbox2-3,25002E01,87242E-19,99245E23,27162E02,41123E-17,28359E-13,90099E-1
2.6SBWOdeSolver-3,25000E01,87441E-19,99247E23,27172E02,40843E-17,28961E-13,83842E-1
2.6VCell-3,25000E03,59889E-19,99472E23,21382E01,26287E-11,26995E01,45969E-1
2.6copasi-3,25000E01,87372E-19,99247E23,27179E02,40838E-17,28763E-13,83914E-1
2.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,25000E01,87373E-19,99247E23,27179E02,40839E-17,28776E-13,83905E-1
2.6jsim-3,25000E01,87373E-19,99247E23,27179E02,40839E-17,28776E-13,83905E-1
2.6min -3,25002E0 1,87242E-1 9,99245E2 3,21382E0 1,26287E-1 7,28359E-1 1,45969E-1
2.6max -3,25000E0 3,59889E-1 9,99472E2 3,27179E0 2,41123E-1 1,26995E0 3,90099E-1
2.6mean -3,25000E0 1,87373E-1 9,99247E2 3,27179E0 2,40839E-1 7,28776E-1 3,83905E-1
2.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.8BioUML-3,50000E02,59169E-19,99359E23,44568E02,45151E-17,43338E-12,57470E-1
2.8ByoDyn-3,50000E02,59169E-19,99359E23,44568E02,45151E-17,43338E-12,57470E-1
2.8Jarnac-3,50000E02,59169E-19,99359E23,44568E02,45151E-17,43338E-12,57470E-1
2.8MathSBML-3,50000E02,59169E-19,99359E23,44568E02,45151E-17,43340E-12,57469E-1
2.8Oscill8 Core-3,50000E02,59170E-19,99359E23,44568E0--2,57475E-1
2.8SBToolbox2-3,50000E02,58354E-19,99360E23,44627E02,45400E-17,49546E-12,52353E-1
2.8SBWOdeSolver-3,50000E02,59132E-19,99359E23,44571E02,45155E-17,43227E-12,57591E-1
2.8VCell-3,50000E05,46021E-19,99270E23,26852E01,35457E-11,65772E01,61617E-1
2.8copasi-3,50000E02,59179E-19,99359E23,44567E02,45150E-17,43384E-12,57431E-1
2.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,50000E02,59169E-19,99359E23,44568E02,45151E-17,43338E-12,57470E-1
2.8jsim-3,50000E02,59169E-19,99359E23,44568E02,45151E-17,43339E-12,57470E-1
2.8min -3,50000E0 2,58354E-1 9,99270E2 3,26852E0 1,35457E-1 7,43227E-1 1,61617E-1
2.8max -3,50000E0 5,46021E-1 9,99360E2 3,44627E0 2,45400E-1 1,65772E0 2,57591E-1
2.8mean -3,50000E0 2,59169E-1 9,99359E2 3,44568E0 2,45151E-1 7,43339E-1 2,57470E-1
2.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.0BioUML-3,75000E04,02384E-19,99267E23,54612E02,51492E-19,89824E-11,02752E-1
3.0ByoDyn-3,75000E04,02384E-19,99267E23,54612E02,51492E-19,89824E-11,02752E-1
3.0Jarnac-3,75000E04,02384E-19,99267E23,54612E02,51492E-19,89824E-11,02752E-1
3.0MathSBML-3,75000E04,02407E-19,99267E23,54610E02,51492E-19,89883E-11,02734E-1
3.0Oscill8 Core-3,75000E04,02556E-19,99267E23,54595E0--1,02855E-1
3.0SBToolbox2-3,75002E04,46645E-19,99183E23,50118E02,52188E-11,09105E08,89181E-2
3.0SBWOdeSolver-3,75000E04,00148E-19,99271E23,54837E02,51480E-19,83945E-11,04848E-1
3.0VCell-3,75000E03,56794E-19,99235E23,69663E01,46577E-11,38186E05,09038E-1
3.0copasi-3,75000E04,03172E-19,99266E23,54533E02,51497E-19,91802E-11,02144E-1
3.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-3,75000E04,02384E-19,99267E23,54612E02,51492E-19,89824E-11,02752E-1
3.0jsim-3,75000E04,02387E-19,99267E23,54612E02,51492E-19,89832E-11,02750E-1
3.0min -3,75002E0 3,56794E-1 9,99183E2 3,50118E0 1,46577E-1 9,83945E-1 8,89181E-2
3.0max -3,75000E0 4,46645E-1 9,99271E2 3,69663E0 2,52188E-1 1,38186E0 5,09038E-1
3.0mean -3,75000E0 4,02385E-1 9,99267E2 3,54612E0 2,51492E-1 9,89832E-1 1,02752E-1
3.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.2BioUML-4,00000E06,32842E-19,98950E23,55530E02,61862E-11,31694E09,31101E-2
3.2ByoDyn-4,00000E06,32842E-19,98950E23,55530E02,61862E-11,31694E09,31101E-2
3.2Jarnac-4,00000E06,32842E-19,98950E23,55530E02,61862E-11,31694E09,31101E-2
3.2MathSBML-4,00000E06,32865E-19,98950E23,55527E02,61863E-11,31698E09,31113E-2
3.2Oscill8 Core-4,00000E06,32997E-19,98950E23,55513E0--9,31183E-2
3.2SBToolbox2-4,00000E06,74747E-19,98863E23,51184E02,63426E-11,40157E09,53982E-2
3.2SBWOdeSolver-4,00000E06,30656E-19,98954E23,55754E02,61805E-11,31289E09,30023E-2
3.2VCell-4,00000E02,28538E-19,99568E24,07068E01,50779E-19,94665E-12,30289E-1
3.2copasi-4,00000E06,33606E-19,98948E23,55451E02,61883E-11,31837E09,31483E-2
3.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,00000E06,32842E-19,98950E23,55530E02,61862E-11,31694E09,31101E-2
3.2jsim-4,00000E06,32845E-19,98950E23,55529E02,61862E-11,31695E09,31103E-2
3.2min -4,00000E0 2,28538E-1 9,98863E2 3,51184E0 1,50779E-1 9,94665E-1 9,30023E-2
3.2max -4,00000E0 6,74747E-1 9,99568E2 4,07068E0 2,63426E-1 1,40157E0 2,30289E-1
3.2mean -4,00000E0 6,32843E-1 9,98950E2 3,55529E0 2,61862E-1 1,31694E0 9,31108E-2
3.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.4BioUML-4,25000E08,47923E-19,98645E23,57538E02,76701E-11,61381E01,01617E-1
3.4ByoDyn-4,25000E08,47923E-19,98645E23,57538E02,76701E-11,61381E01,01617E-1
3.4Jarnac-4,25000E08,47923E-19,98645E23,57538E02,76701E-11,61381E01,01617E-1
3.4MathSBML-4,25000E08,47944E-19,98645E23,57535E02,76702E-11,61385E01,01619E-1
3.4Oscill8 Core-4,25000E08,48062E-19,98644E23,57523E0--1,01626E-1
3.4SBToolbox2-4,25002E08,85610E-19,98563E23,53536E02,79057E-11,69351E01,04084E-1
3.4SBWOdeSolver-4,25000E08,45940E-19,98649E23,57746E02,76602E-11,60999E01,01501E-1
3.4VCell-4,25000E04,29168E-19,99401E24,11352E01,57307E-11,41414E01,44519E-1
3.4copasi-4,25000E08,48614E-19,98643E23,57465E02,76736E-11,61515E01,01659E-1
3.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,25000E08,47923E-19,98645E23,57538E02,76701E-11,61381E01,01617E-1
3.4jsim-4,25000E08,47926E-19,98645E23,57537E02,76701E-11,61382E01,01618E-1
3.4min -4,25002E0 4,29168E-1 9,98563E2 3,53536E0 1,57307E-1 1,41414E0 1,01501E-1
3.4max -4,25000E0 8,85610E-1 9,99401E2 4,11352E0 2,79057E-1 1,69351E0 1,44519E-1
3.4mean -4,25000E0 8,47924E-1 9,98645E2 3,57537E0 2,76701E-1 1,61381E0 1,01618E-1
3.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.6BioUML-4,50000E01,04129E09,98357E23,61308E02,95635E-11,89208E01,10955E-1
3.6ByoDyn-4,50000E01,04129E09,98357E23,61308E02,95635E-11,89208E01,10955E-1
3.6Jarnac-4,50000E01,04129E09,98357E23,61308E02,95635E-11,89208E01,10955E-1
3.6MathSBML-4,50000E01,04130E09,98357E23,61306E02,95636E-11,89212E01,10956E-1
3.6Oscill8 Core-4,50000E01,04140E09,98357E23,61295E0--1,10965E-1
3.6SBToolbox2-4,50000E01,07297E09,98284E23,57833E02,98685E-11,96625E01,13736E-1
3.6SBWOdeSolver-4,50000E01,03959E09,98361E23,61491E02,95499E-11,88852E01,10824E-1
3.6VCell-4,50000E05,85068E-19,99216E24,19730E01,67634E-11,74925E01,78734E-1
3.6copasi-4,50000E01,04187E09,98356E23,61244E02,95683E-11,89333E01,11001E-1
3.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,50000E01,04129E09,98357E23,61308E02,95635E-11,89208E01,10955E-1
3.6jsim-4,50000E01,04129E09,98357E23,61308E02,95635E-11,89208E01,10955E-1
3.6min -4,50000E0 5,85068E-1 9,98284E2 3,57833E0 1,67634E-1 1,74925E0 1,10824E-1
3.6max -4,50000E0 1,07297E0 9,99216E2 4,19730E0 2,98685E-1 1,96625E0 1,78734E-1
3.6mean -4,50000E0 1,04129E0 9,98357E2 3,61308E0 2,95635E-1 1,89208E0 1,10956E-1
3.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.8BioUML-4,75000E01,20506E09,98089E23,67678E03,18156E-12,14887E01,21769E-1
3.8ByoDyn-4,75000E01,20506E09,98089E23,67678E03,18156E-12,14887E01,21769E-1
3.8Jarnac-4,75000E01,20506E09,98089E23,67678E03,18156E-12,14887E01,21769E-1
3.8MathSBML-4,75000E01,20508E09,98089E23,67676E03,18158E-12,14891E01,21770E-1
3.8Oscill8 Core-4,75000E01,20514E09,98089E23,67669E0--1,21781E-1
3.8SBToolbox2-4,75001E01,22785E09,98018E23,65039E03,21746E-12,21628E01,25163E-1
3.8SBWOdeSolver-4,75000E01,20378E09,98093E23,67823E03,17991E-12,14563E01,21611E-1
3.8VCell-4,75000E01,87335E-19,99446E24,83607E01,76592E-19,52664E-15,14425E-1
3.8copasi-4,75000E01,20550E09,98088E23,67629E03,18214E-12,15001E01,21824E-1
3.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-4,75000E01,20506E09,98089E23,67678E03,18156E-12,14887E01,21769E-1
3.8jsim-4,75000E01,20507E09,98089E23,67678E03,18157E-12,14888E01,21769E-1
3.8min -4,75001E0 1,87335E-1 9,98018E2 3,65039E0 1,76592E-1 9,52664E-1 1,21611E-1
3.8max -4,75000E0 1,22785E0 9,99446E2 4,83607E0 3,21746E-1 2,21628E0 5,14425E-1
3.8mean -4,75000E0 1,20506E0 9,98089E2 3,67678E0 3,18156E-1 2,14887E0 1,21770E-1
3.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.0BioUML-5,00000E01,32521E09,97846E23,78124E03,43550E-12,37811E01,35795E-1
4.0ByoDyn-5,00000E01,32521E09,97846E23,78124E03,43550E-12,37811E01,35795E-1
4.0Jarnac-5,00000E01,32521E09,97846E23,78124E03,43550E-12,37811E01,35795E-1
4.0MathSBML-5,00000E01,32522E09,97846E23,78123E03,43552E-12,37814E01,35798E-1
4.0Oscill8 Core-5,00000E01,32523E09,97846E23,78120E0--1,35815E-1
4.0SBToolbox2-5,00000E01,33284E09,97784E23,76968E03,47458E-12,43570E01,40836E-1
4.0SBWOdeSolver-5,00000E01,32459E09,97849E23,78204E03,43365E-12,37530E01,35572E-1
4.0VCell-5,00000E02,91458E-19,99533E24,97766E01,80878E-11,12158E01,71900E-1
4.0copasi-5,00000E01,32540E09,97845E23,78098E03,43615E-12,37909E01,35875E-1
4.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,00000E01,32521E09,97846E23,78124E03,43550E-12,37811E01,35795E-1
4.0jsim-5,00000E01,32521E09,97846E23,78124E03,43551E-12,37811E01,35796E-1
4.0min -5,00000E0 2,91458E-1 9,97784E2 3,76968E0 1,80878E-1 1,12158E0 1,35572E-1
4.0max -5,00000E0 1,33284E0 9,99533E2 4,97766E0 3,47458E-1 2,43570E0 1,71900E-1
4.0mean -5,00000E0 1,32521E0 9,97846E2 3,78124E0 3,43550E-1 2,37811E0 1,35797E-1
4.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.2BioUML-5,25000E01,35985E09,97640E23,96953E03,70628E-12,55690E01,63064E-1
4.2ByoDyn-5,25000E01,35985E09,97640E23,96953E03,70628E-12,55690E01,63064E-1
4.2Jarnac-5,25000E01,35985E09,97640E23,96953E03,70628E-12,55690E01,63064E-1
4.2MathSBML-5,25000E01,35983E09,97640E23,96954E03,70630E-12,55692E01,63072E-1
4.2Oscill8 Core-5,25000E01,35965E09,97640E23,96971E0--1,63152E-1
4.2SBToolbox2-5,25001E01,31462E09,97594E24,01108E03,74320E-12,57936E01,84494E-1
4.2SBWOdeSolver-5,25000E01,36101E09,97642E23,96855E03,70443E-12,55520E01,62421E-1
4.2VCell-5,25000E04,92963E-19,99332E25,01827E01,88770E-11,54546E01,51261E-1
4.2copasi-5,25000E01,35937E09,97639E23,96994E03,70691E-12,55746E01,63307E-1
4.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,25000E01,35985E09,97640E23,96953E03,70628E-12,55690E01,63064E-1
4.2jsim-5,25000E01,35984E09,97640E23,96953E03,70628E-12,55690E01,63065E-1
4.2min -5,25001E0 4,92963E-1 9,97594E2 3,96855E0 1,88770E-1 1,54546E0 1,51261E-1
4.2max -5,25000E0 1,36101E0 9,99332E2 5,01827E0 3,74320E-1 2,57936E0 1,84494E-1
4.2mean -5,25000E0 1,35984E0 9,97640E2 3,96953E0 3,70628E-1 2,55690E0 1,63065E-1
4.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.4BioUML-5,50000E02,12417E-19,97957E25,34768E03,89902E-11,50393E08,99384E-1
4.4ByoDyn-5,50000E02,12417E-19,97957E25,34768E03,89902E-11,50393E08,99384E-1
4.4Jarnac-5,50000E02,12417E-19,97957E25,34768E03,89902E-11,50393E08,99384E-1
4.4MathSBML-5,50000E02,12357E-19,97957E25,34774E03,89900E-11,50377E08,99360E-1
4.4Oscill8 Core-5,50000E02,12771E-19,97958E25,34734E0--8,97001E-1
4.4SBToolbox2-5,50000E01,54376E-19,98262E25,40852E03,87150E-11,39515E07,04025E-1
4.4SBWOdeSolver-5,50000E02,19111E-19,97939E25,34086E03,90028E-11,52215E08,98562E-1
4.4VCell-5,50000E05,87175E-19,99180E25,16285E01,99972E-11,77622E02,24157E-1
4.4copasi-5,50000E02,10467E-19,97963E25,34968E03,89854E-11,49869E08,98513E-1
4.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,50000E02,12417E-19,97957E25,34768E03,89902E-11,50393E08,99384E-1
4.4jsim-5,50000E02,12409E-19,97957E25,34769E03,89902E-11,50391E08,99381E-1
4.4min -5,50000E0 1,54376E-1 9,97939E2 5,16285E0 1,99972E-1 1,39515E0 2,24157E-1
4.4max -5,50000E0 5,87175E-1 9,99180E2 5,40852E0 3,90028E-1 1,77622E0 8,99384E-1
4.4mean -5,50000E0 2,12417E-1 9,97957E2 5,34768E0 3,89902E-1 1,50393E0 8,98961E-1
4.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.6BioUML-5,75000E01,85092E-19,98555E25,62177E03,93141E-11,50866E02,96466E-1
4.6ByoDyn-5,75000E01,85092E-19,98555E25,62177E03,93141E-11,50866E02,96466E-1
4.6Jarnac-5,75000E01,85092E-19,98555E25,62177E03,93141E-11,50866E02,96466E-1
4.6MathSBML-5,75000E01,85110E-19,98555E25,62175E03,93139E-11,50867E02,96443E-1
4.6Oscill8 Core-5,75000E01,85229E-19,98555E25,62164E0--2,96548E-1
4.6SBToolbox2-5,75000E02,17643E-19,98570E25,59183E03,90523E-11,51148E02,79647E-1
4.6SBWOdeSolver-5,75000E01,83465E-19,98554E25,62326E03,93278E-11,50742E02,99009E-1
4.6VCell-5,75000E01,84316E-19,99554E25,80953E02,06152E-19,30588E-13,21829E-1
4.6copasi-5,75000E01,85675E-19,98555E25,62123E03,93091E-11,50903E02,95692E-1
4.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-5,75000E01,85092E-19,98555E25,62177E03,93141E-11,50866E02,96466E-1
4.6jsim-5,75000E01,85095E-19,98555E25,62176E03,93141E-11,50867E02,96463E-1
4.6min -5,75000E0 1,83465E-1 9,98554E2 5,59183E0 2,06152E-1 9,30588E-1 2,79647E-1
4.6max -5,75000E0 2,17643E-1 9,99554E2 5,80953E0 3,93278E-1 1,51148E0 3,21829E-1
4.6mean -5,75000E0 1,85093E-1 9,98555E2 5,62177E0 3,93141E-1 1,50866E0 2,96466E-1
4.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.8BioUML-6,00000E01,80242E-19,98763E25,87241E03,97350E-11,14520E04,51470E-1
4.8ByoDyn-6,00000E01,80242E-19,98763E25,87241E03,97350E-11,14520E04,51470E-1
4.8Jarnac-6,00000E01,80242E-19,98763E25,87241E03,97350E-11,14520E04,51470E-1
4.8MathSBML-6,00000E01,80233E-19,98763E25,87242E03,97348E-11,14517E04,51448E-1
4.8Oscill8 Core-6,00000E01,80297E-19,98764E25,87236E0--4,50980E-1
4.8SBToolbox2-6,00000E01,74814E-19,98855E25,88063E03,94588E-11,11571E03,91126E-1
4.8SBWOdeSolver-6,00000E01,81273E-19,98758E25,87124E03,97488E-11,14903E04,53094E-1
4.8VCell-6,00000E03,61843E-19,99470E25,87673E02,11430E-11,27455E01,45807E-1
4.8copasi-6,00000E01,79938E-19,98765E25,87276E03,97299E-11,14407E04,50719E-1
4.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,00000E01,80242E-19,98763E25,87241E03,97350E-11,14520E04,51470E-1
4.8jsim-6,00000E01,80241E-19,98763E25,87241E03,97350E-11,14520E04,51467E-1
4.8min -6,00000E0 1,74814E-1 9,98758E2 5,87124E0 2,11430E-1 1,11571E0 1,45807E-1
4.8max -6,00000E0 3,61843E-1 9,99470E2 5,88063E0 3,97488E-1 1,27455E0 4,53094E-1
4.8mean -6,00000E0 1,80242E-1 9,98763E2 5,87241E0 3,97350E-1 1,14520E0 4,51457E-1
4.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
5.0BioUML-6,25000E02,13214E-19,98985E26,08566E04,01130E-11,04210E03,32406E-1
5.0ByoDyn-6,25000E02,13214E-19,98985E26,08566E04,01130E-11,04210E03,32406E-1
5.0Jarnac-6,25000E02,13214E-19,98985E26,08566E04,01130E-11,04210E03,32406E-1
5.0MathSBML-6,25000E02,13217E-19,98986E26,08565E04,01129E-11,04206E03,32424E-1
5.0Oscill8 Core-6,25000E02,13149E-19,98986E26,08573E0--3,32711E-1
5.0SBToolbox2-6,25000E02,09085E-19,99035E26,09235E03,98565E-19,45240E-13,76480E-1
5.0SBWOdeSolver-6,25000E02,12832E-19,98983E26,08591E04,01260E-11,04563E03,30927E-1
5.0VCell-6,25000E05,47281E-19,99269E25,93209E02,20634E-11,66093E01,62021E-1
5.0copasi-6,25000E02,13309E-19,98986E26,08561E04,01083E-11,04074E03,33014E-1
5.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,25000E02,13214E-19,98985E26,08566E04,01130E-11,04210E03,32406E-1
5.0jsim-6,25000E02,13214E-19,98985E26,08566E04,01130E-11,04210E03,32409E-1
5.0min -6,25000E0 2,09085E-1 9,98983E2 5,93209E0 2,20634E-1 9,45240E-1 1,62021E-1
5.0max -6,25000E0 5,47281E-1 9,99269E2 6,09235E0 4,01260E-1 1,66093E0 3,76480E-1
5.0mean -6,25000E0 2,13214E-1 9,98986E2 6,08566E0 4,01130E-1 1,04210E0 3,32407E-1
5.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
5.2BioUML-6,50000E01,95219E-19,99232E26,34965E04,05127E-17,84437E-13,43408E-1
5.2ByoDyn-6,50000E01,95219E-19,99232E26,34965E04,05127E-17,84437E-13,43408E-1
5.2Jarnac-6,50000E01,95219E-19,99232E26,34965E04,05127E-17,84437E-13,43408E-1
5.2MathSBML-6,50000E01,95225E-19,99232E26,34965E04,05125E-17,84429E-13,43390E-1
5.2Oscill8 Core-6,50000E01,95295E-19,99232E26,34959E0--3,43336E-1
5.2SBToolbox2-6,50000E02,07623E-19,99275E26,33986E04,02501E-17,68473E-13,18059E-1
5.2SBWOdeSolver-6,50000E01,94738E-19,99230E26,35000E04,05261E-17,85209E-13,45180E-1
5.2VCell-6,50000E03,46003E-19,99240E26,37229E02,31711E-11,36007E05,19931E-1
5.2copasi-6,50000E01,95407E-19,99233E26,34952E04,05078E-17,84178E-13,42808E-1
5.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,50000E01,95219E-19,99232E26,34965E04,05127E-17,84437E-13,43408E-1
5.2jsim-6,50000E01,95220E-19,99232E26,34965E04,05126E-17,84435E-13,43406E-1
5.2min -6,50000E0 1,94738E-1 9,99230E2 6,33986E0 2,31711E-1 7,68473E-1 3,18059E-1
5.2max -6,50000E0 3,46003E-1 9,99275E2 6,37229E0 4,05261E-1 1,36007E0 5,19931E-1
5.2mean -6,50000E0 1,95223E-1 9,99232E2 6,34965E0 4,05126E-1 7,84437E-1 3,43407E-1
5.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
5.4BioUML-6,75000E02,19494E-19,99386E26,57105E04,09452E-16,11024E-13,62860E-1
5.4ByoDyn-6,75000E02,19494E-19,99386E26,57105E04,09452E-16,11024E-13,62860E-1
5.4Jarnac-6,75000E02,19494E-19,99386E26,57105E04,09452E-16,11024E-13,62860E-1
5.4MathSBML-6,75000E02,19486E-19,99386E26,57106E04,09450E-16,10976E-13,62876E-1
5.4Oscill8 Core-6,75000E02,19418E-19,99386E26,57114E0--3,62819E-1
5.4SBToolbox2-6,75000E02,08148E-19,99445E26,58499E04,06887E-15,42763E-13,71228E-1
5.4SBWOdeSolver-6,75000E02,20163E-19,99383E26,57026E04,09579E-16,15590E-13,61207E-1
5.4VCell-6,75000E02,30263E-19,99567E26,73385E02,35888E-19,97684E-12,28179E-1
5.4copasi-6,75000E02,19246E-19,99387E26,57135E04,09405E-16,09449E-13,63377E-1
5.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-6,75000E02,19494E-19,99386E26,57105E04,09452E-16,11024E-13,62860E-1
5.4jsim-6,75000E02,19493E-19,99386E26,57106E04,09452E-16,11018E-13,62862E-1
5.4min -6,75000E0 2,08148E-1 9,99383E2 6,57026E0 2,35888E-1 5,42763E-1 2,28179E-1
5.4max -6,75000E0 2,30263E-1 9,99567E2 6,73385E0 4,09579E-1 9,97684E-1 3,71228E-1
5.4mean -6,75000E0 2,19493E-1 9,99386E2 6,57106E0 4,09452E-1 6,11024E-1 3,62860E-1
5.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
5.6BioUML-7,00000E02,41611E-19,99549E26,79465E04,13738E-15,58840E-12,51711E-1
5.6ByoDyn-7,00000E02,41611E-19,99549E26,79465E04,13738E-15,58840E-12,51711E-1
5.6Jarnac-7,00000E02,41611E-19,99549E26,79465E04,13738E-15,58840E-12,51711E-1
5.6MathSBML-7,00000E02,41629E-19,99549E26,79463E04,13737E-15,58873E-12,51678E-1
5.6Oscill8 Core-7,00000E02,41816E-19,99549E26,79445E0--2,51312E-1
5.6SBToolbox2-7,00000E02,80319E-19,99536E26,75828E04,11393E-16,49511E-11,73779E-1
5.6SBWOdeSolver-7,00000E02,40025E-19,99549E26,79611E04,13861E-15,56089E-12,54641E-1
5.6VCell-7,00000E04,31213E-19,99398E26,77633E02,42457E-11,41836E01,44651E-1
5.6copasi-7,00000E02,42208E-19,99549E26,79410E04,13693E-15,59957E-12,50598E-1
5.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-7,00000E02,41611E-19,99549E26,79465E04,13738E-15,58840E-12,51711E-1
5.6jsim-7,00000E02,41613E-19,99549E26,79465E04,13738E-15,58844E-12,51707E-1
5.6min -7,00000E0 2,40025E-1 9,99398E2 6,75828E0 2,42457E-1 5,56089E-1 1,44651E-1
5.6max -7,00000E0 4,31213E-1 9,99549E2 6,79611E0 4,13861E-1 1,41836E0 2,54641E-1
5.6mean -7,00000E0 2,41621E-1 9,99549E2 6,79464E0 4,13738E-1 5,58844E-1 2,51692E-1
5.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
5.8BioUML-7,25000E04,58614E-19,99306E26,82080E04,20589E-19,69059E-18,44799E-2
5.8ByoDyn-7,25000E04,58614E-19,99306E26,82080E04,20589E-19,69059E-18,44799E-2
5.8Jarnac-7,25000E04,58614E-19,99306E26,82080E04,20589E-19,69059E-18,44799E-2
5.8MathSBML-7,25000E04,58648E-19,99306E26,82076E04,20588E-19,69105E-18,44808E-2
5.8Oscill8 Core-7,25000E04,58841E-19,99306E26,82057E0--8,44910E-2
5.8SBToolbox2-7,24999E05,14199E-19,99232E26,76647E04,19324E-11,04312E08,60985E-2
5.8SBWOdeSolver-7,25000E04,55465E-19,99311E26,82388E04,20654E-19,64682E-18,44063E-2
5.8VCell-7,25000E05,85887E-19,99215E26,86130E02,52815E-11,75145E01,79463E-1
5.8copasi-7,25000E04,59724E-19,99305E26,81971E04,20565E-19,70602E-18,45087E-2
5.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-7,25000E04,58614E-19,99306E26,82080E04,20589E-19,69059E-18,44799E-2
5.8jsim-7,25000E04,58619E-19,99306E26,82079E04,20589E-19,69065E-18,44800E-2
5.8min -7,25000E0 4,55465E-1 9,99215E2 6,76647E0 2,52815E-1 9,64682E-1 8,44063E-2
5.8max -7,24999E0 5,85887E-1 9,99311E2 6,86130E0 4,20654E-1 1,75145E0 1,79463E-1
5.8mean -7,25000E0 4,58633E-1 9,99306E2 6,82079E0 4,20589E-1 9,69065E-1 8,44804E-2
5.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
6.0BioUML-7,50000E06,87541E-19,98983E26,83039E04,32073E-11,28474E09,22643E-2
6.0ByoDyn-7,50000E06,87541E-19,98983E26,83039E04,32073E-11,28474E09,22643E-2
6.0Jarnac-7,50000E06,87541E-19,98983E26,83039E04,32073E-11,28474E09,22643E-2
6.0MathSBML-7,50000E06,87572E-19,98983E26,83036E04,32073E-11,28479E09,22655E-2
6.0Oscill8 Core-7,50000E06,87753E-19,98983E26,83017E0--9,22725E-2
6.0SBToolbox2-7,50000E07,39870E-19,98912E26,77826E04,31886E-11,35488E09,41262E-2
6.0SBWOdeSolver-7,50000E06,84571E-19,98987E26,83335E04,32077E-11,28061E09,21549E-2
6.0VCell-7,50000E01,85838E-19,99452E27,50247E02,61691E-19,48781E-15,07538E-1
6.0copasi-7,50000E06,88586E-19,98981E26,82934E04,32070E-11,28620E09,23031E-2
6.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-7,50000E06,87541E-19,98983E26,83039E04,32073E-11,28474E09,22643E-2
6.0jsim-7,50000E06,87545E-19,98983E26,83038E04,32073E-11,28475E09,22645E-2
6.0min -7,50000E0 1,85838E-1 9,98912E2 6,77826E0 2,61691E-1 9,48781E-1 9,21549E-2
6.0max -7,50000E0 7,39870E-1 9,99452E2 7,50247E0 4,32077E-1 1,35488E0 5,07538E-1
6.0mean -7,50000E0 6,87543E-1 9,98983E2 6,83038E0 4,32073E-1 1,28474E0 9,22650E-2
6.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
6.2BioUML-7,75000E09,00516E-19,98676E26,85150E04,47984E-11,58344E01,00700E-1
6.2ByoDyn-7,75000E09,00516E-19,98676E26,85150E04,47984E-11,58344E01,00700E-1
6.2Jarnac-7,75000E09,00516E-19,98676E26,85150E04,47984E-11,58344E01,00700E-1
6.2MathSBML-7,75000E09,00545E-19,98676E26,85147E04,47985E-11,58348E01,00701E-1
6.2Oscill8 Core-7,75000E09,00708E-19,98676E26,85130E0--1,00709E-1
6.2SBToolbox2-7,74999E09,48490E-19,98606E26,80271E04,48801E-11,64963E01,02701E-1
6.2SBWOdeSolver-7,75000E08,97790E-19,98680E26,85428E04,47931E-11,57954E01,00582E-1
6.2VCell-7,75000E02,93554E-19,99532E27,64045E02,65999E-11,12620E01,70540E-1
6.2copasi-7,75000E09,01472E-19,98674E26,85053E04,48001E-11,58482E01,00741E-1
6.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-7,75000E09,00516E-19,98676E26,85150E04,47984E-11,58344E01,00700E-1
6.2jsim-7,75000E09,00519E-19,98676E26,85150E04,47984E-11,58345E01,00700E-1
6.2min -7,75000E0 2,93554E-1 9,98606E2 6,80271E0 2,65999E-1 1,12620E0 1,00582E-1
6.2max -7,74999E0 9,48490E-1 9,99532E2 7,64045E0 4,48801E-1 1,64963E0 1,70540E-1
6.2mean -7,75000E0 9,00517E-1 9,98676E2 6,85150E0 4,47984E-1 1,58344E0 1,00700E-1
6.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
6.4BioUML-8,00000E01,09218E09,98386E26,88987E04,67952E-11,86376E01,09924E-1
6.4ByoDyn-8,00000E01,09218E09,98386E26,88987E04,67952E-11,86376E01,09924E-1
6.4Jarnac-8,00000E01,09218E09,98386E26,88987E04,67952E-11,86376E01,09924E-1
6.4MathSBML-8,00000E01,09220E09,98386E26,88984E04,67953E-11,86380E01,09925E-1
6.4Oscill8 Core-8,00000E01,09235E09,98386E26,88969E0--1,09934E-1
6.4SBToolbox2-8,00000E01,13440E09,98323E26,84601E04,69667E-11,92545E01,12164E-1
6.4SBWOdeSolver-8,00000E01,08978E09,98390E26,89237E04,67848E-11,86012E01,09793E-1
6.4VCell-8,00000E04,94790E-19,99330E27,68128E02,73933E-11,54926E01,51532E-1
6.4copasi-8,00000E01,09301E09,98385E26,88900E04,67987E-11,86504E01,09970E-1
6.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-8,00000E01,09218E09,98386E26,88987E04,67952E-11,86376E01,09924E-1
6.4jsim-8,00000E01,09218E09,98386E26,88987E04,67952E-11,86377E01,09924E-1
6.4min -8,00000E0 4,94790E-1 9,98323E2 6,84601E0 2,73933E-1 1,54926E0 1,09793E-1
6.4max -8,00000E0 1,13440E0 9,99330E2 7,68128E0 4,69667E-1 1,92545E0 1,51532E-1
6.4mean -8,00000E0 1,09218E0 9,98386E2 6,88987E0 4,67952E-1 1,86376E0 1,09925E-1
6.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
6.6BioUML-8,25000E01,25503E09,98116E26,95349E04,91480E-12,12301E01,20532E-1
6.6ByoDyn-8,25000E01,25503E09,98116E26,95349E04,91480E-12,12301E01,20532E-1
6.6Jarnac-8,25000E01,25503E09,98116E26,95349E04,91480E-12,12301E01,20532E-1
6.6MathSBML-8,25000E01,25505E09,98116E26,95346E04,91482E-12,12304E01,20533E-1
6.6Oscill8 Core-8,25000E01,25516E09,98116E26,95334E0--1,20544E-1
6.6SBToolbox2-8,24998E01,28918E09,98057E26,91693E04,93959E-12,17931E01,23221E-1
6.6SBWOdeSolver-8,25000E01,25308E09,98120E26,95559E04,91332E-12,11968E01,20376E-1
6.6VCell-8,25000E05,85749E-19,99179E27,82910E02,85154E-11,77427E02,27119E-1
6.6copasi-8,25000E01,25570E09,98115E26,95277E04,91530E-12,12418E01,20587E-1
6.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-8,25000E01,25503E09,98116E26,95349E04,91480E-12,12301E01,20532E-1
6.6jsim-8,25000E01,25504E09,98116E26,95348E04,91481E-12,12301E01,20532E-1
6.6min -8,25000E0 5,85749E-1 9,98057E2 6,91693E0 2,85154E-1 1,77427E0 1,20376E-1
6.6max -8,24998E0 1,28918E0 9,99179E2 7,82910E0 4,93959E-1 2,17931E0 2,27119E-1
6.6mean -8,25000E0 1,25503E0 9,98116E2 6,95349E0 4,91480E-1 2,12301E0 1,20532E-1
6.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
6.8BioUML-8,50000E01,37587E09,97870E27,05625E05,17877E-12,35564E01,34052E-1
6.8ByoDyn-8,50000E01,37587E09,97870E27,05625E05,17877E-12,35564E01,34052E-1
6.8Jarnac-8,50000E01,37587E09,97870E27,05625E05,17877E-12,35564E01,34052E-1
6.8MathSBML-8,50000E01,37589E09,97870E27,05623E05,17878E-12,35567E01,34054E-1
6.8Oscill8 Core-8,50000E01,37594E09,97870E27,05617E0--1,34070E-1
6.8SBToolbox2-8,50000E01,39718E09,97817E27,03194E05,20908E-12,40440E01,37891E-1
6.8SBWOdeSolver-8,50000E01,37462E09,97873E27,05768E05,17696E-12,35273E01,33836E-1
6.8VCell-8,50000E01,85276E-19,99555E28,47347E02,91251E-19,31747E-13,17789E-1
6.8copasi-8,50000E01,37629E09,97869E27,05577E05,17937E-12,35666E01,34128E-1
6.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-8,50000E01,37587E09,97870E27,05625E05,17877E-12,35564E01,34052E-1
6.8jsim-8,50000E01,37588E09,97870E27,05625E05,17877E-12,35564E01,34052E-1
6.8min -8,50000E0 1,85276E-1 9,97817E2 7,03194E0 2,91251E-1 9,31747E-1 1,33836E-1
6.8max -8,50000E0 1,39718E0 9,99555E2 8,47347E0 5,20908E-1 2,40440E0 3,17789E-1
6.8mean -8,50000E0 1,37587E0 9,97870E2 7,05625E0 5,17877E-1 2,35564E0 1,34053E-1
6.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
7.0BioUML-8,75000E01,41837E09,97659E27,23561E05,46018E-12,54290E01,58224E-1
7.0ByoDyn-8,75000E01,41837E09,97659E27,23561E05,46018E-12,54290E01,58224E-1
7.0Jarnac-8,75000E01,41837E09,97659E27,23561E05,46018E-12,54290E01,58224E-1
7.0MathSBML-8,75000E01,41836E09,97659E27,23562E05,46020E-12,54292E01,58230E-1
7.0Oscill8 Core-8,75000E01,41827E09,97659E27,23570E0--1,58285E-1
7.0SBToolbox2-8,74998E01,40506E09,97617E27,24570E05,49210E-12,57112E01,70056E-1
7.0SBWOdeSolver-8,75000E01,41875E09,97661E27,23543E05,45825E-12,54094E01,57691E-1
7.0VCell-8,75000E03,64016E-19,99468E28,53942E02,96566E-11,27914E01,45524E-1
7.0copasi-8,75000E01,41819E09,97658E27,23573E05,46082E-12,54357E01,58423E-1
7.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-8,75000E01,41837E09,97659E27,23561E05,46018E-12,54290E01,58224E-1
7.0jsim-8,75000E01,41837E09,97659E27,23561E05,46018E-12,54291E01,58225E-1
7.0min -8,75000E0 3,64016E-1 9,97617E2 7,23543E0 2,96566E-1 1,27914E0 1,45524E-1
7.0max -8,74998E0 1,41875E0 9,99468E2 8,53942E0 5,49210E-1 2,57112E0 1,70056E-1
7.0mean -8,75000E0 1,41837E0 9,97659E2 7,23561E0 5,46018E-1 2,54290E0 1,58225E-1
7.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
7.2BioUML-9,00000E02,78978E-19,97823E28,60257E05,68450E-11,66414E08,73265E-1
7.2ByoDyn-9,00000E02,78978E-19,97823E28,60257E05,68450E-11,66414E08,73265E-1
7.2Jarnac-9,00000E02,78978E-19,97823E28,60257E05,68450E-11,66414E08,73265E-1
7.2MathSBML-9,00000E02,78852E-19,97823E28,60270E05,68449E-11,66384E08,73382E-1
7.2Oscill8 Core-9,00000E02,79785E-19,97824E28,60178E0--8,71622E-1
7.2SBToolbox2-9,00000E01,78043E-19,98107E28,70558E05,66370E-11,40744E08,49054E-1
7.2SBWOdeSolver-9,00000E02,93089E-19,97806E28,58835E05,68559E-11,69441E08,59165E-1
7.2VCell-9,00000E05,48743E-19,99267E28,59545E03,05808E-11,66415E01,62424E-1
7.2copasi-9,00000E02,74922E-19,97829E28,60667E05,68405E-11,65442E08,76990E-1
7.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,00000E02,78978E-19,97823E28,60257E05,68450E-11,66414E08,73265E-1
7.2jsim-9,00000E02,78962E-19,97823E28,60259E05,68450E-11,66410E08,73280E-1
7.2min -9,00000E0 1,78043E-1 9,97806E2 8,58835E0 3,05808E-1 1,40744E0 1,62424E-1
7.2max -9,00000E0 5,48743E-1 9,99267E2 8,70558E0 5,68559E-1 1,69441E0 8,76990E-1
7.2mean -9,00000E0 2,78978E-1 9,97823E2 8,60257E0 5,68450E-1 1,66414E0 8,73265E-1
7.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
7.4BioUML-9,25000E01,72059E-19,98553E28,95611E05,71826E-11,48801E03,19018E-1
7.4ByoDyn-9,25000E01,72059E-19,98553E28,95611E05,71826E-11,48801E03,19018E-1
7.4Jarnac-9,25000E01,72059E-19,98553E28,95611E05,71826E-11,48801E03,19018E-1
7.4MathSBML-9,25000E01,72076E-19,98553E28,95610E05,71825E-11,48803E03,18979E-1
7.4Oscill8 Core-9,25000E01,72207E-19,98553E28,95598E0--3,18984E-1
7.4SBToolbox2-9,24998E01,99158E-19,98570E28,93126E05,69602E-11,50719E02,80487E-1
7.4SBWOdeSolver-9,25000E01,70570E-19,98551E28,95746E05,71971E-11,48620E03,22892E-1
7.4VCell-9,25000E03,35659E-19,99246E29,04750E03,16842E-11,33841E05,30227E-1
7.4copasi-9,25000E01,72607E-19,98554E28,95562E05,71771E-11,48860E03,17768E-1
7.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,25000E01,72060E-19,98553E28,95611E05,71826E-11,48801E03,19018E-1
7.4jsim-9,25000E01,72062E-19,98553E28,95611E05,71826E-11,48801E03,19013E-1
7.4min -9,25000E0 1,70570E-1 9,98551E2 8,93126E0 3,16842E-1 1,33841E0 2,80487E-1
7.4max -9,24998E0 3,35659E-1 9,99246E2 9,04750E0 5,71971E-1 1,50719E0 5,30227E-1
7.4mean -9,25000E0 1,72069E-1 9,98553E2 8,95611E0 5,71826E-1 1,48801E0 3,19015E-1
7.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
7.6BioUML-9,50000E01,91097E-19,98723E29,18285E05,76049E-11,17414E04,62565E-1
7.6ByoDyn-9,50000E01,91097E-19,98723E29,18285E05,76049E-11,17414E04,62565E-1
7.6Jarnac-9,50000E01,91097E-19,98723E29,18285E05,76049E-11,17414E04,62565E-1
7.6MathSBML-9,50000E01,91081E-19,98723E29,18287E05,76047E-11,17407E04,62569E-1
7.6Oscill8 Core-9,50000E01,91071E-19,98724E29,18289E0--4,62116E-1
7.6SBToolbox2-9,50000E01,75266E-19,98812E29,20089E05,73813E-11,11396E04,35642E-1
7.6SBWOdeSolver-9,50000E01,92770E-19,98718E29,18104E05,76186E-11,18095E04,61443E-1
7.6VCell-9,50000E02,32007E-19,99567E29,39700E03,20996E-11,00073E02,26080E-1
7.6copasi-9,50000E01,90550E-19,98725E29,18345E05,75995E-11,17197E04,62693E-1
7.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,50000E01,91097E-19,98723E29,18285E05,76049E-11,17414E04,62565E-1
7.6jsim-9,50000E01,91095E-19,98723E29,18286E05,76048E-11,17413E04,62565E-1
7.6min -9,50000E0 1,75266E-1 9,98718E2 9,18104E0 3,20996E-1 1,00073E0 2,26080E-1
7.6max -9,50000E0 2,32007E-1 9,99567E2 9,39700E0 5,76186E-1 1,18095E0 4,62693E-1
7.6mean -9,50000E0 1,91096E-1 9,98723E2 9,18286E0 5,76048E-1 1,17413E0 4,62565E-1
7.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
7.8BioUML-9,75000E02,09805E-19,98977E29,41043E05,79767E-11,06441E03,19032E-1
7.8ByoDyn-9,75000E02,09805E-19,98977E29,41043E05,79767E-11,06441E03,19032E-1
7.8Jarnac-9,75000E02,09805E-19,98977E29,41043E05,79767E-11,06441E03,19032E-1
7.8MathSBML-9,75000E02,09812E-19,98977E29,41042E05,79765E-11,06439E03,19039E-1
7.8Oscill8 Core-9,75000E02,09819E-19,98977E29,41042E0--3,19216E-1
7.8SBToolbox2-9,74997E02,15884E-19,99012E29,40647E05,77668E-11,00791E03,42032E-1
7.8SBWOdeSolver-9,75000E02,09061E-19,98975E29,41104E05,79901E-11,06672E03,18569E-1
7.8VCell-9,75000E04,33266E-19,99396E29,43913E03,27606E-11,42257E01,44787E-1
7.8copasi-9,75000E02,10050E-19,98977E29,41024E05,79715E-11,06351E03,19269E-1
7.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,75000E02,09805E-19,98977E29,41043E05,79767E-11,06441E03,19032E-1
7.8jsim-9,75000E02,09806E-19,98977E29,41043E05,79766E-11,06441E03,19033E-1
7.8min -9,75000E0 2,09061E-1 9,98975E2 9,40647E0 3,27606E-1 1,00791E0 1,44787E-1
7.8max -9,74997E0 4,33266E-1 9,99396E2 9,43913E0 5,79901E-1 1,42257E0 3,42032E-1
7.8mean -9,75000E0 2,09809E-1 9,98977E2 9,41043E0 5,79766E-1 1,06441E0 3,19032E-1
7.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
8.0BioUML-1,00000E11,91113E-19,99217E29,67507E05,83821E-17,82854E-13,60210E-1
8.0ByoDyn-1,00000E11,91113E-19,99217E29,67507E05,83821E-17,82854E-13,60210E-1
8.0Jarnac-1,00000E11,91113E-19,99217E29,67507E05,83821E-17,82854E-13,60210E-1
8.0MathSBML-1,00000E11,91117E-19,99217E29,67506E05,83819E-17,82843E-13,60188E-1
8.0Oscill8 Core-1,00000E11,91170E-19,99217E29,67502E0--3,60069E-1
8.0SBToolbox2-1,00000E11,98194E-19,99262E29,67016E05,81640E-17,68330E-13,32974E-1
8.0SBWOdeSolver-1,00000E11,90862E-19,99214E29,67518E05,83959E-17,83942E-13,62188E-1
8.0VCell-1,00000E15,86688E-19,99213E29,52532E03,37997E-11,75360E01,80213E-1
8.0copasi-1,00000E11,91222E-19,99218E29,67501E05,83767E-17,82500E-13,59510E-1
8.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,00000E11,91113E-19,99217E29,67507E05,83821E-17,82854E-13,60210E-1
8.0jsim-1,00000E11,91114E-19,99217E29,67507E05,83821E-17,82853E-13,60207E-1
8.0min -1,00000E1 1,90862E-1 9,99213E2 9,52532E0 3,37997E-1 7,68330E-1 1,80213E-1
8.0max -1,00000E1 5,86688E-1 9,99262E2 9,67518E0 5,83959E-1 1,75360E0 3,62188E-1
8.0mean -1,00000E1 1,91115E-1 9,99217E2 9,67506E0 5,83821E-1 7,82854E-1 3,60198E-1
8.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
8.2BioUML-1,02500E12,27841E-19,99364E29,88406E05,88096E-16,52378E-13,43325E-1
8.2ByoDyn-1,02500E12,27841E-19,99364E29,88406E05,88096E-16,52378E-13,43325E-1
8.2Jarnac-1,02500E12,27841E-19,99364E29,88406E05,88096E-16,52378E-13,43325E-1
8.2MathSBML-1,02500E12,27837E-19,99364E29,88407E05,88094E-16,52328E-13,43348E-1
8.2Oscill8 Core-1,02500E12,27763E-19,99365E29,88415E0--3,43497E-1
8.2SBToolbox2-1,02502E12,19469E-19,99412E29,89449E05,86048E-15,83085E-13,69610E-1
8.2SBWOdeSolver-1,02500E12,28198E-19,99362E29,88358E05,88225E-16,56896E-13,41238E-1
8.2VCell-1,02500E11,84461E-19,99457E21,01687E13,46790E-19,45239E-15,00591E-1
8.2copasi-1,02500E12,27689E-19,99365E29,88426E05,88046E-16,50736E-13,44076E-1
8.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,02500E12,27841E-19,99364E29,88406E05,88096E-16,52378E-13,43325E-1
8.2jsim-1,02500E12,27841E-19,99364E29,88406E05,88096E-16,52372E-13,43328E-1
8.2min -1,02502E1 1,84461E-1 9,99362E2 9,88358E0 3,46790E-1 5,83085E-1 3,41238E-1
8.2max -1,02500E1 2,28198E-1 9,99457E2 1,01687E1 5,88225E-1 9,45239E-1 5,00591E-1
8.2mean -1,02500E1 2,27839E-1 9,99364E2 9,88407E0 5,88096E-1 6,52378E-1 3,43338E-1
8.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
8.4BioUML-1,05000E12,27088E-19,99553E21,01306E15,92359E-15,30941E-12,76081E-1
8.4ByoDyn-1,05000E12,27088E-19,99553E21,01306E15,92359E-15,30941E-12,76081E-1
8.4Jarnac-1,05000E12,27088E-19,99553E21,01306E15,92359E-15,30941E-12,76081E-1
8.4MathSBML-1,05000E12,27103E-19,99553E21,01305E15,92357E-15,30963E-12,76051E-1
8.4Oscill8 Core-1,05000E12,27224E-19,99553E21,01304E1--2,75842E-1
8.4SBToolbox2-1,05001E12,49672E-19,99560E21,01098E15,90360E-15,70740E-12,29781E-1
8.4SBWOdeSolver-1,05000E12,25799E-19,99552E21,01317E15,92488E-15,29061E-12,78778E-1
8.4VCell-1,05000E12,95658E-19,99530E21,03032E13,51120E-11,13083E01,69214E-1
8.4copasi-1,05000E12,27567E-19,99553E21,01301E15,92309E-15,31670E-12,75102E-1
8.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,05000E12,27088E-19,99553E21,01306E15,92359E-15,30941E-12,76081E-1
8.4jsim-1,05000E12,27090E-19,99553E21,01306E15,92359E-15,30944E-12,76077E-1
8.4min -1,05001E1 2,25799E-1 9,99530E2 1,01098E1 3,51120E-1 5,29061E-1 1,69214E-1
8.4max -1,05000E1 2,95658E-1 9,99560E2 1,03032E1 5,92488E-1 1,13083E0 2,78778E-1
8.4mean -1,05000E1 2,27096E-1 9,99553E2 1,01306E1 5,92359E-1 5,30944E-1 2,76064E-1
8.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
8.6BioUML-1,07500E14,31778E-19,99347E21,01695E15,98722E-19,28985E-18,38190E-2
8.6ByoDyn-1,07500E14,31778E-19,99347E21,01695E15,98722E-19,28985E-18,38190E-2
8.6Jarnac-1,07500E14,31778E-19,99347E21,01695E15,98722E-19,28984E-18,38190E-2
8.6MathSBML-1,07500E14,31813E-19,99347E21,01695E15,98721E-19,29033E-18,38194E-2
8.6Oscill8 Core-1,07500E14,32009E-19,99347E21,01693E1--8,38290E-2
8.6SBToolbox2-1,07498E14,75682E-19,99287E21,01270E15,97527E-19,86637E-18,47704E-2
8.6SBWOdeSolver-1,07500E14,28592E-19,99352E21,01726E15,98796E-19,24547E-18,37862E-2
8.6VCell-1,07500E14,96608E-19,99328E21,03443E13,59096E-11,55304E01,51807E-1
8.6copasi-1,07500E14,32906E-19,99346E21,01684E15,98691E-19,30553E-18,38350E-2
8.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,07500E14,31778E-19,99347E21,01695E15,98722E-19,28985E-18,38190E-2
8.6jsim-1,07500E14,31783E-19,99347E21,01695E15,98721E-19,28990E-18,38190E-2
8.6min -1,07500E1 4,28592E-1 9,99287E2 1,01270E1 3,59096E-1 9,24547E-1 8,37862E-2
8.6max -1,07498E1 4,96608E-1 9,99352E2 1,03443E1 5,98796E-1 1,55304E0 1,51807E-1
8.6mean -1,07500E1 4,31798E-1 9,99347E2 1,01695E1 5,98721E-1 9,28990E-1 8,38192E-2
8.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
8.8BioUML-1,10000E16,62242E-19,99022E21,01781E16,09683E-11,24689E09,12660E-2
8.8ByoDyn-1,10000E16,62242E-19,99022E21,01781E16,09683E-11,24689E09,12660E-2
8.8Jarnac-1,10000E16,62242E-19,99022E21,01781E16,09683E-11,24689E09,12660E-2
8.8MathSBML-1,10000E16,62275E-19,99022E21,01780E16,09683E-11,24694E09,12672E-2
8.8Oscill8 Core-1,10000E16,62460E-19,99022E21,01779E1--9,12741E-2
8.8SBToolbox2-1,09996E17,03734E-19,98968E21,01371E16,09344E-11,30135E09,26841E-2
8.8SBWOdeSolver-1,10000E16,59230E-19,99026E21,01811E16,09696E-11,24273E09,11571E-2
8.8VCell-1,10000E15,84144E-19,99179E21,04955E13,70335E-11,77197E02,30293E-1
8.8copasi-1,10000E16,63308E-19,99020E21,01770E16,09675E-11,24837E09,13047E-2
8.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,10000E16,62242E-19,99022E21,01781E16,09683E-11,24689E09,12660E-2
8.8jsim-1,10000E16,62246E-19,99022E21,01781E16,09683E-11,24690E09,12662E-2
8.8min -1,10000E1 5,84144E-1 9,98968E2 1,01371E1 3,70335E-1 1,24273E0 9,11571E-2
8.8max -1,09996E1 7,03734E-1 9,99179E2 1,04955E1 6,09696E-1 1,77197E0 2,30293E-1
8.8mean -1,10000E1 6,62244E-1 9,99022E2 1,01781E1 6,09683E-1 1,24690E0 9,12667E-2
8.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
9.0BioUML-1,12500E18,77338E-19,98713E21,01976E16,25109E-11,54773E09,96300E-2
9.0ByoDyn-1,12500E18,77338E-19,98713E21,01976E16,25109E-11,54773E09,96300E-2
9.0Jarnac-1,12500E18,77338E-19,98713E21,01976E16,25109E-11,54773E09,96300E-2
9.0MathSBML-1,12500E18,77368E-19,98713E21,01975E16,25109E-11,54777E09,96313E-2
9.0Oscill8 Core-1,12500E18,77538E-19,98712E21,01973E1--9,96386E-2
9.0SBToolbox2-1,12502E19,15599E-19,98659E21,01591E16,25562E-11,59915E01,01144E-1
9.0SBWOdeSolver-1,12500E18,74564E-19,98717E21,02004E16,25064E-11,54379E09,95136E-2
9.0VCell-1,12500E11,86276E-19,99557E21,11374E13,76350E-19,32966E-13,13852E-1
9.0copasi-1,12500E18,78317E-19,98711E21,01966E16,25121E-11,54912E09,96714E-2
9.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,12500E18,77338E-19,98713E21,01976E16,25109E-11,54773E09,96300E-2
9.0jsim-1,12500E18,77342E-19,98713E21,01975E16,25109E-11,54773E09,96302E-2
9.0min -1,12502E1 1,86276E-1 9,98659E2 1,01591E1 3,76350E-1 9,32966E-1 9,95136E-2
9.0max -1,12500E1 9,15599E-1 9,99557E2 1,11374E1 6,25562E-1 1,59915E0 3,13852E-1
9.0mean -1,12500E1 8,77340E-1 9,98713E2 1,01976E1 6,25109E-1 1,54773E0 9,96307E-2
9.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
9.2BioUML-1,15000E11,07185E09,98421E21,02335E16,44640E-11,83042E01,08733E-1
9.2ByoDyn-1,15000E11,07185E09,98421E21,02335E16,44640E-11,83042E01,08733E-1
9.2Jarnac-1,15000E11,07185E09,98421E21,02335E16,44640E-11,83042E01,08733E-1
9.2MathSBML-1,15000E11,07188E09,98421E21,02335E16,44641E-11,83046E01,08735E-1
9.2Oscill8 Core-1,15000E11,07203E09,98421E21,02333E1--1,08743E-1
9.2SBToolbox2-1,15000E11,10581E09,98369E21,01982E16,45809E-11,87848E01,10410E-1
9.2SBWOdeSolver-1,15000E11,06939E09,98425E21,02361E16,44542E-11,82674E01,08604E-1
9.2VCell-1,15000E13,66187E-19,99466E21,12021E13,81702E-11,28371E01,45264E-1
9.2copasi-1,15000E11,07271E09,98420E21,02326E16,44670E-11,83172E01,08779E-1
9.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,15000E11,07185E09,98421E21,02335E16,44640E-11,83042E01,08733E-1
9.2jsim-1,15000E11,07185E09,98421E21,02335E16,44640E-11,83042E01,08734E-1
9.2min -1,15000E1 3,66187E-1 9,98369E2 1,01982E1 3,81702E-1 1,28371E0 1,08604E-1
9.2max -1,15000E1 1,10581E0 9,99466E2 1,12021E1 6,45809E-1 1,87848E0 1,45264E-1
9.2mean -1,15000E1 1,07185E0 9,98421E2 1,02335E1 6,44640E-1 1,83042E0 1,08734E-1
9.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
9.4BioUML-1,17500E11,23866E09,98148E21,02935E16,67799E-12,09246E01,19120E-1
9.4ByoDyn-1,17500E11,23866E09,98148E21,02935E16,67799E-12,09246E01,19120E-1
9.4Jarnac-1,17500E11,23866E09,98148E21,02935E16,67799E-12,09246E01,19120E-1
9.4MathSBML-1,17500E11,23869E09,98148E21,02935E16,67801E-12,09250E01,19122E-1
9.4Oscill8 Core-1,17500E11,23881E09,98148E21,02934E1--1,19132E-1
9.4SBToolbox2-1,17498E11,26673E09,98099E21,02633E16,69586E-12,13654E01,21106E-1
9.4SBWOdeSolver-1,17500E11,23664E09,98152E21,02957E16,67656E-12,08909E01,18968E-1
9.4VCell-1,17500E15,50191E-19,99265E21,12588E13,90982E-11,66735E01,62833E-1
9.4copasi-1,17500E11,23937E09,98147E21,02928E16,67845E-12,09365E01,19174E-1
9.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,17500E11,23866E09,98148E21,02935E16,67799E-12,09246E01,19120E-1
9.4jsim-1,17500E11,23867E09,98148E21,02935E16,67799E-12,09246E01,19121E-1
9.4min -1,17500E1 5,50191E-1 9,98099E2 1,02633E1 3,90982E-1 1,66735E0 1,18968E-1
9.4max -1,17498E1 1,26673E0 9,99265E2 1,12588E1 6,69586E-1 2,13654E0 1,62833E-1
9.4mean -1,17500E1 1,23867E0 9,98148E2 1,02935E1 6,67799E-1 2,09246E0 1,19121E-1
9.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
9.6BioUML-1,20000E11,36565E09,97899E21,03904E16,93924E-12,32887E01,32119E-1
9.6ByoDyn-1,20000E11,36565E09,97899E21,03904E16,93924E-12,32887E01,32119E-1
9.6Jarnac-1,20000E11,36565E09,97899E21,03904E16,93924E-12,32887E01,32119E-1
9.6MathSBML-1,20000E11,36567E09,97899E21,03904E16,93926E-12,32890E01,32122E-1
9.6Oscill8 Core-1,20000E11,36575E09,97899E21,03903E1--1,32135E-1
9.6SBToolbox2-1,19995E11,38468E09,97860E21,03693E16,96186E-12,36762E01,34843E-1
9.6SBWOdeSolver-1,20000E11,36430E09,97902E21,03920E16,93747E-12,32590E01,31914E-1
9.6VCell-1,20000E13,25768E-19,99252E21,17223E14,01971E-11,31705E05,39822E-1
9.6copasi-1,20000E11,36612E09,97898E21,03899E16,93982E-12,32991E01,32192E-1
9.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,20000E11,36565E09,97899E21,03904E16,93924E-12,32887E01,32119E-1
9.6jsim-1,20000E11,36565E09,97899E21,03904E16,93924E-12,32887E01,32120E-1
9.6min -1,20000E1 3,25768E-1 9,97860E2 1,03693E1 4,01971E-1 1,31705E0 1,31914E-1
9.6max -1,19995E1 1,38468E0 9,99252E2 1,17223E1 6,96186E-1 2,36762E0 5,39822E-1
9.6mean -1,20000E1 1,36565E0 9,97899E2 1,03904E1 6,93924E-1 2,32887E0 1,32121E-1
9.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
9.8BioUML-1,22500E11,42220E09,97682E21,05558E17,21973E-12,52437E01,53640E-1
9.8ByoDyn-1,22500E11,42220E09,97682E21,05558E17,21973E-12,52437E01,53640E-1
9.8Jarnac-1,22500E11,42220E09,97682E21,05558E17,21973E-12,52437E01,53640E-1
9.8MathSBML-1,22500E11,42220E09,97682E21,05558E17,21975E-12,52440E01,53645E-1
9.8Oscill8 Core-1,22500E11,42219E09,97682E21,05558E1--1,53675E-1
9.8SBToolbox2-1,22502E11,42054E09,97650E21,05553E17,24438E-12,55123E01,60178E-1
9.8SBWOdeSolver-1,22500E11,42226E09,97685E21,05560E17,21780E-12,52223E01,53190E-1
9.8VCell-1,22500E12,33765E-19,99566E21,20601E14,06105E-11,00383E02,24004E-1
9.8copasi-1,22500E11,42215E09,97681E21,05558E17,22036E-12,52513E01,53802E-1
9.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-1,22500E11,42220E09,97682E21,05558E17,21973E-12,52437E01,53640E-1
9.8jsim-1,22500E11,42220E09,97682E21,05558E17,21974E-12,52438E01,53641E-1
9.8min -1,22502E1 2,33765E-1 9,97650E2 1,05553E1 4,06105E-1 1,00383E0 1,53190E-1
9.8max -1,22500E1 1,42226E0 9,99566E2 1,20601E1 7,24438E-1 2,55123E0 2,24004E-1
9.8mean -1,22500E1 1,42220E0 9,97682E2 1,05558E1 7,21973E-1 2,52437E0 1,53643E-1
9.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00