Test: BIOMD0000000043.xml - Ok


test: BIOMD0000000043.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000043.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000043.gif


Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6622689184.JPG


Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: Rho  EC  Fraction_Inactive_Channels 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  Jarnac  SBToolbox2  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult Rho EC Y Fraction_Inactive_Channels Z
0.0BioUML0,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn0,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Jarnac0,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0MathSBML0,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Oscill8 Core0,00000E00,00000E0--0,00000E0
0.0SBToolbox20,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver0,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0copasi0,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner0,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0jsim0,00000E00,00000E03,60000E-10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0min 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,60000E-1 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0max 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,60000E-1 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0mean 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,60000E-1 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML6,27407E-1-2,85094E-15,76446E-1-6,27407E-16,86479E-2
0.2ByoDyn6,27407E-1-2,85094E-15,76446E-1-6,27407E-16,86479E-2
0.2Jarnac6,27407E-1-2,85094E-15,76446E-1-6,27407E-16,86479E-2
0.2MathSBML6,27407E-1-2,85094E-15,76446E-1-6,27407E-16,86479E-2
0.2Oscill8 Core6,27398E-1-2,85093E-1--6,86480E-2
0.2SBToolbox26,27682E-1-2,85107E-15,76478E-1-6,27682E-16,86232E-2
0.2SBWOdeSolver6,27398E-1-2,85093E-15,76445E-1-6,27398E-16,86480E-2
0.2copasi6,27407E-1-2,85094E-15,76446E-1-6,27407E-16,86479E-2
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner6,27407E-1-2,85094E-15,76446E-1-6,27407E-16,86479E-2
0.2jsim6,27407E-1-2,85094E-15,76446E-1-6,27407E-16,86479E-2
0.2min 6,27398E-1 -2,85107E-1 5,76445E-1 -6,27682E-1 6,86232E-2
0.2max 6,27682E-1 -2,85093E-1 5,76478E-1 -6,27398E-1 6,86480E-2
0.2mean 6,27407E-1 -2,85094E-1 5,76446E-1 -6,27407E-1 6,86479E-2
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML8,46243E-1-5,35526E-18,13537E-1-8,46243E-18,19892E-2
0.4ByoDyn8,46243E-1-5,35526E-18,13537E-1-8,46243E-18,19892E-2
0.4Jarnac8,46243E-1-5,35526E-18,13537E-1-8,46243E-18,19892E-2
0.4MathSBML8,46243E-1-5,35526E-18,13537E-1-8,46243E-18,19892E-2
0.4Oscill8 Core8,46236E-1-5,35524E-1--8,19900E-2
0.4SBToolbox28,46701E-1-5,35586E-18,13651E-1-8,46701E-18,19342E-2
0.4SBWOdeSolver8,46236E-1-5,35524E-18,13534E-1-8,46236E-18,19900E-2
0.4copasi8,46242E-1-5,35526E-18,13536E-1-8,46242E-18,19892E-2
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner8,46243E-1-5,35526E-18,13537E-1-8,46243E-18,19892E-2
0.4jsim8,46243E-1-5,35526E-18,13537E-1-8,46243E-18,19892E-2
0.4min 8,46236E-1 -5,35586E-1 8,13534E-1 -8,46701E-1 8,19342E-2
0.4max 8,46701E-1 -5,35524E-1 8,13651E-1 -8,46236E-1 8,19900E-2
0.4mean 8,46243E-1 -5,35526E-1 8,13537E-1 -8,46243E-1 8,19892E-2
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML7,43928E-2-6,70042E-16,12273E-1-7,43928E-24,17769E-1
0.6ByoDyn7,43928E-2-6,70042E-16,12273E-1-7,43928E-24,17769E-1
0.6Jarnac7,43928E-2-6,70042E-16,12273E-1-7,43928E-24,17769E-1
0.6MathSBML7,43891E-2-6,70040E-16,12274E-1-7,43891E-24,17766E-1
0.6Oscill8 Core7,70494E-2-6,70178E-1--4,17478E-1
0.6SBToolbox29,07618E-2-6,73078E-16,12737E-1-9,07618E-24,20342E-1
0.6SBWOdeSolver7,70840E-2-6,70193E-16,12694E-1-7,70840E-24,17500E-1
0.6copasi7,43562E-2-6,70023E-16,12281E-1-7,43562E-24,17742E-1
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner7,43928E-2-6,70042E-16,12273E-1-7,43928E-24,17769E-1
0.6jsim7,43929E-2-6,70042E-16,12273E-1-7,43929E-24,17769E-1
0.6min 7,43562E-2 -6,73078E-1 6,12273E-1 -9,07618E-2 4,17478E-1
0.6max 9,07618E-2 -6,70023E-1 6,12737E-1 -7,43562E-2 4,20342E-1
0.6mean 7,43928E-2 -6,70042E-1 6,12274E-1 -7,43928E-2 4,17769E-1
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,050,00
0.8BioUML1,58236E-1-5,92368E-16,33264E-1-1,58236E-13,19104E-1
0.8ByoDyn1,58236E-1-5,92368E-16,33264E-1-1,58236E-13,19104E-1
0.8Jarnac1,58236E-1-5,92368E-16,33264E-1-1,58236E-13,19104E-1
0.8MathSBML1,58235E-1-5,92367E-16,33263E-1-1,58235E-13,19104E-1
0.8Oscill8 Core1,59237E-1-5,92403E-1--3,18672E-1
0.8SBToolbox21,60909E-1-5,92963E-16,34482E-1-1,60909E-13,18491E-1
0.8SBWOdeSolver1,59253E-1-5,92414E-16,33737E-1-1,59253E-13,18677E-1
0.8copasi1,58223E-1-5,92359E-16,33255E-1-1,58223E-13,19103E-1
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner1,58236E-1-5,92368E-16,33264E-1-1,58236E-13,19104E-1
0.8jsim1,58237E-1-5,92368E-16,33264E-1-1,58237E-13,19105E-1
0.8min 1,58223E-1 -5,92963E-1 6,33255E-1 -1,60909E-1 3,18491E-1
0.8max 1,60909E-1 -5,92359E-1 6,34482E-1 -1,58223E-1 3,19105E-1
0.8mean 1,58236E-1 -5,92368E-1 6,33264E-1 -1,58236E-1 3,19104E-1
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,010,00
1.0BioUML1,68889E-1-4,85337E-15,82324E-1-1,68889E-12,63013E-1
1.0ByoDyn1,68889E-1-4,85337E-15,82324E-1-1,68889E-12,63013E-1
1.0Jarnac1,68889E-1-4,85337E-15,82324E-1-1,68889E-12,63013E-1
1.0MathSBML1,68889E-1-4,85337E-15,82323E-1-1,68889E-12,63013E-1
1.0Oscill8 Core1,69069E-1-4,85371E-1--2,63007E-1
1.0SBToolbox21,68740E-1-4,85719E-15,81576E-1-1,68740E-12,64143E-1
1.0SBWOdeSolver1,69067E-1-4,85378E-15,82367E-1-1,69067E-12,63011E-1
1.0copasi1,68888E-1-4,85331E-15,82319E-1-1,68888E-12,63012E-1
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,68889E-1-4,85337E-15,82324E-1-1,68889E-12,63013E-1
1.0jsim1,68889E-1-4,85338E-15,82324E-1-1,68889E-12,63014E-1
1.0min 1,68740E-1 -4,85719E-1 5,81576E-1 -1,69067E-1 2,63007E-1
1.0max 1,69069E-1 -4,85331E-1 5,82367E-1 -1,68740E-1 2,64143E-1
1.0mean 1,68889E-1 -4,85337E-1 5,82324E-1 -1,68889E-1 2,63013E-1
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,090,00
1.2BioUML2,02965E-1-3,92384E-15,09921E-1-2,02965E-12,42462E-1
1.2ByoDyn2,02965E-1-3,92384E-15,09921E-1-2,02965E-12,42462E-1
1.2Jarnac2,02965E-1-3,92384E-15,09921E-1-2,02965E-12,42462E-1
1.2MathSBML2,02966E-1-3,92383E-15,09921E-1-2,02966E-12,42462E-1
1.2Oscill8 Core2,03014E-1-3,92401E-1--2,42492E-1
1.2SBToolbox22,01276E-1-3,92444E-15,08695E-1-2,01276E-12,43749E-1
1.2SBWOdeSolver2,03011E-1-3,92407E-15,09914E-1-2,03011E-12,42493E-1
1.2copasi2,02966E-1-3,92379E-15,09918E-1-2,02966E-12,42461E-1
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner2,02965E-1-3,92384E-15,09921E-1-2,02965E-12,42462E-1
1.2jsim2,02965E-1-3,92384E-15,09922E-1-2,02965E-12,42463E-1
1.2min 2,01276E-1 -3,92444E-1 5,08695E-1 -2,03011E-1 2,42461E-1
1.2max 2,03014E-1 -3,92379E-1 5,09922E-1 -2,01276E-1 2,43749E-1
1.2mean 2,02965E-1 -3,92384E-1 5,09921E-1 -2,02965E-1 2,42462E-1
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,020,00
1.4BioUML2,31662E-1-3,12103E-14,39706E-1-2,31662E-12,32397E-1
1.4ByoDyn2,31662E-1-3,12103E-14,39706E-1-2,31662E-12,32397E-1
1.4Jarnac2,31662E-1-3,12103E-14,39706E-1-2,31662E-12,32397E-1
1.4MathSBML2,31662E-1-3,12103E-14,39706E-1-2,31662E-12,32397E-1
1.4Oscill8 Core2,31673E-1-3,12114E-1--2,32428E-1
1.4SBToolbox22,28830E-1-3,11876E-14,38209E-1-2,28830E-12,33667E-1
1.4SBWOdeSolver2,31671E-1-3,12119E-14,39690E-1-2,31671E-12,32429E-1
1.4copasi2,31666E-1-3,12100E-14,39705E-1-2,31666E-12,32394E-1
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner2,31662E-1-3,12103E-14,39706E-1-2,31662E-12,32397E-1
1.4jsim2,31662E-1-3,12103E-14,39706E-1-2,31662E-12,32397E-1
1.4min 2,28830E-1 -3,12119E-1 4,38209E-1 -2,31671E-1 2,32394E-1
1.4max 2,31673E-1 -3,11876E-1 4,39706E-1 -2,28830E-1 2,33667E-1
1.4mean 2,31662E-1 -3,12103E-1 4,39706E-1 -2,31662E-1 2,32397E-1
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML2,59429E-1-2,46796E-13,83769E-1-2,59429E-12,23027E-1
1.6ByoDyn2,59429E-1-2,46796E-13,83769E-1-2,59429E-12,23027E-1
1.6Jarnac2,59429E-1-2,46796E-13,83769E-1-2,59429E-12,23027E-1
1.6MathSBML2,59429E-1-2,46796E-13,83769E-1-2,59429E-12,23027E-1
1.6Oscill8 Core2,59438E-1-2,46807E-1--2,23058E-1
1.6SBToolbox22,54947E-1-2,46264E-13,81310E-1-2,54947E-12,24952E-1
1.6SBWOdeSolver2,59436E-1-2,46811E-13,83753E-1-2,59436E-12,23058E-1
1.6copasi2,59436E-1-2,46794E-13,83770E-1-2,59436E-12,23024E-1
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,59429E-1-2,46796E-13,83769E-1-2,59429E-12,23027E-1
1.6jsim2,59428E-1-2,46796E-13,83769E-1-2,59428E-12,23028E-1
1.6min 2,54947E-1 -2,46811E-1 3,81310E-1 -2,59436E-1 2,23024E-1
1.6max 2,59438E-1 -2,46264E-1 3,83770E-1 -2,54947E-1 2,24952E-1
1.6mean 2,59429E-1 -2,46796E-1 3,83769E-1 -2,59429E-1 2,23027E-1
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,000,00
1.8BioUML2,83828E-1-1,97413E-13,43645E-1-2,83828E-12,13768E-1
1.8ByoDyn2,83828E-1-1,97413E-13,43645E-1-2,83828E-12,13768E-1
1.8Jarnac2,83828E-1-1,97413E-13,43645E-1-2,83828E-12,13768E-1
1.8MathSBML2,83828E-1-1,97412E-13,43645E-1-2,83828E-12,13768E-1
1.8Oscill8 Core2,83878E-1-1,97434E-1--2,13790E-1
1.8SBToolbox22,76261E-1-1,96653E-13,38162E-1-2,76261E-12,18499E-1
1.8SBWOdeSolver2,83876E-1-1,97437E-13,43646E-1-2,83876E-12,13791E-1
1.8copasi2,83838E-1-1,97412E-13,43650E-1-2,83838E-12,13762E-1
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,83828E-1-1,97413E-13,43645E-1-2,83828E-12,13768E-1
1.8jsim2,83828E-1-1,97413E-13,43645E-1-2,83828E-12,13768E-1
1.8min 2,76261E-1 -1,97437E-1 3,38162E-1 -2,83876E-1 2,13762E-1
1.8max 2,83878E-1 -1,96653E-1 3,43650E-1 -2,76261E-1 2,18499E-1
1.8mean 2,83828E-1 -1,97413E-1 3,43645E-1 -2,83828E-1 2,13768E-1
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,020,00
2.0BioUML2,83422E-1-1,61568E-13,07738E-1-2,83422E-12,13830E-1
2.0ByoDyn2,83422E-1-1,61568E-13,07738E-1-2,83422E-12,13830E-1
2.0Jarnac2,83422E-1-1,61568E-13,07738E-1-2,83422E-12,13830E-1
2.0MathSBML2,83422E-1-1,61568E-13,07738E-1-2,83422E-12,13830E-1
2.0Oscill8 Core2,83619E-1-1,61618E-1--2,13814E-1
2.0SBToolbox22,76340E-1-1,62832E-12,96842E-1-2,76340E-12,25990E-1
2.0SBWOdeSolver2,83621E-1-1,61620E-13,07807E-1-2,83621E-12,13814E-1
2.0copasi2,83429E-1-1,61567E-13,07748E-1-2,83429E-12,13819E-1
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner2,83422E-1-1,61568E-13,07738E-1-2,83422E-12,13830E-1
2.0jsim2,83423E-1-1,61568E-13,07738E-1-2,83423E-12,13830E-1
2.0min 2,76340E-1 -1,62832E-1 2,96842E-1 -2,83621E-1 2,13814E-1
2.0max 2,83621E-1 -1,61567E-1 3,07807E-1 -2,76340E-1 2,25990E-1
2.0mean 2,83422E-1 -1,61568E-1 3,07738E-1 -2,83422E-1 2,13830E-1
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,070,00
2.2BioUML6,27305E-1-2,79847E-15,66296E-1-6,27305E-17,35511E-2
2.2ByoDyn6,27305E-1-2,79847E-15,66296E-1-6,27305E-17,35511E-2
2.2Jarnac6,27305E-1-2,79847E-15,66296E-1-6,27305E-17,35511E-2
2.2MathSBML6,27306E-1-2,79848E-15,66297E-1-6,27306E-17,35509E-2
2.2Oscill8 Core6,27226E-1-2,79851E-1--7,36059E-2
2.2SBToolbox25,99053E-1-2,59740E-15,44457E-1-5,99053E-17,52819E-2
2.2SBWOdeSolver6,27218E-1-2,79844E-15,66237E-1-6,27218E-17,36075E-2
2.2copasi6,27347E-1-2,79882E-15,66334E-1-6,27347E-17,35471E-2
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner6,27305E-1-2,79847E-15,66296E-1-6,27305E-17,35511E-2
2.2jsim6,27302E-1-2,79845E-15,66293E-1-6,27302E-17,35515E-2
2.2min 5,99053E-1 -2,79882E-1 5,44457E-1 -6,27347E-1 7,35471E-2
2.2max 6,27347E-1 -2,59740E-1 5,66334E-1 -5,99053E-1 7,52819E-2
2.2mean 6,27305E-1 -2,79847E-1 5,66296E-1 -6,27305E-1 7,35511E-2
2.2relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,010,00
2.4BioUML8,46113E-1-5,29276E-18,07607E-1-8,46113E-18,16695E-2
2.4ByoDyn8,46113E-1-5,29276E-18,07607E-1-8,46113E-18,16695E-2
2.4Jarnac8,46113E-1-5,29276E-18,07607E-1-8,46113E-18,16695E-2
2.4MathSBML8,46113E-1-5,29278E-18,07608E-1-8,46113E-18,16696E-2
2.4Oscill8 Core8,46076E-1-5,29263E-1--8,16729E-2
2.4SBToolbox28,36970E-1-5,10520E-17,90222E-1-8,36970E-18,02990E-2
2.4SBWOdeSolver8,46074E-1-5,29256E-18,07584E-1-8,46074E-18,16723E-2
2.4copasi8,46127E-1-5,29309E-18,07637E-1-8,46127E-18,16718E-2
2.4edu.kgi.roadRunner8,46113E-1-5,29276E-18,07607E-1-8,46113E-18,16695E-2
2.4jsim8,46112E-1-5,29274E-18,07605E-1-8,46112E-18,16694E-2
2.4min 8,36970E-1 -5,29309E-1 7,90222E-1 -8,46127E-1 8,02990E-2
2.4max 8,46127E-1 -5,10520E-1 8,07637E-1 -8,36970E-1 8,16729E-2
2.4mean 8,46113E-1 -5,29276E-1 8,07607E-1 -8,46113E-1 8,16695E-2
2.4relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,000,00
2.6BioUML1,15107E-1-6,76956E-16,04032E-1-1,15107E-14,32925E-1
2.6ByoDyn1,15107E-1-6,76956E-16,04032E-1-1,15107E-14,32925E-1
2.6Jarnac1,15107E-1-6,76956E-16,04032E-1-1,15107E-14,32925E-1
2.6MathSBML1,15083E-1-6,76952E-16,04032E-1-1,15083E-14,32920E-1
2.6Oscill8 Core1,40860E-1-6,77313E-1--4,28348E-1
2.6SBToolbox27,72999E-1-7,07950E-17,87903E-1-7,72999E-12,80052E-1
2.6SBWOdeSolver1,41109E-1-6,77347E-16,08975E-1-1,41109E-14,28372E-1
2.6copasi1,14621E-1-6,76880E-16,04051E-1-1,14621E-14,32829E-1
2.6edu.kgi.roadRunner1,15107E-1-6,76956E-16,04032E-1-1,15107E-14,32925E-1
2.6jsim1,15136E-1-6,76960E-16,04030E-1-1,15136E-14,32930E-1
2.6min 1,14621E-1 -7,07950E-1 6,04030E-1 -7,72999E-1 2,80052E-1
2.6max 7,72999E-1 -6,76880E-1 7,87903E-1 -1,14621E-1 4,32930E-1
2.6mean 1,15107E-1 -6,76956E-1 6,04032E-1 -1,15107E-1 4,32920E-1
2.6relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,000,00
2.8BioUML1,79580E-1-5,96722E-16,35638E-1-1,79580E-13,21084E-1
2.8ByoDyn1,79580E-1-5,96722E-16,35638E-1-1,79580E-13,21084E-1
2.8Jarnac1,79580E-1-5,96722E-16,35638E-1-1,79580E-13,21084E-1
2.8MathSBML1,79573E-1-5,96720E-16,35636E-1-1,79573E-13,21084E-1
2.8Oscill8 Core1,82646E-1-5,96740E-1--3,19208E-1
2.8SBToolbox22,85064E-1-6,14102E-16,86524E-1-2,85064E-12,87574E-1
2.8SBWOdeSolver1,82696E-1-5,96756E-16,37552E-1-1,82696E-13,19204E-1
2.8copasi1,79419E-1-5,96683E-16,35595E-1-1,79419E-13,21088E-1
2.8edu.kgi.roadRunner1,79580E-1-5,96722E-16,35638E-1-1,79580E-13,21084E-1
2.8jsim1,79591E-1-5,96725E-16,35640E-1-1,79591E-13,21084E-1
2.8min 1,79419E-1 -6,14102E-1 6,35595E-1 -2,85064E-1 2,87574E-1
2.8max 2,85064E-1 -5,96683E-1 6,86524E-1 -1,79419E-1 3,21088E-1
2.8mean 1,79580E-1 -5,96722E-1 6,35638E-1 -1,79580E-1 3,21084E-1
2.8relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,090,00
3.0BioUML1,68588E-1-4,87384E-15,80659E-1-1,68588E-12,66725E-1
3.0ByoDyn1,68588E-1-4,87384E-15,80659E-1-1,68588E-12,66725E-1
3.0Jarnac1,68588E-1-4,87384E-15,80659E-1-1,68588E-12,66725E-1
3.0MathSBML1,68588E-1-4,87383E-15,80659E-1-1,68588E-12,66724E-1
3.0Oscill8 Core1,69101E-1-4,87465E-1--2,66638E-1
3.0SBToolbox21,79176E-1-4,99220E-15,82940E-1-1,79176E-12,76280E-1
3.0SBWOdeSolver1,69103E-1-4,87475E-15,80830E-1-1,69103E-12,66644E-1
3.0copasi1,68584E-1-4,87362E-15,80658E-1-1,68584E-12,66704E-1
3.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,68588E-1-4,87384E-15,80659E-1-1,68588E-12,66725E-1
3.0jsim1,68589E-1-4,87386E-15,80659E-1-1,68589E-12,66727E-1
3.0min 1,68584E-1 -4,99220E-1 5,80658E-1 -1,79176E-1 2,66638E-1
3.0max 1,79176E-1 -4,87362E-1 5,82940E-1 -1,68584E-1 2,76280E-1
3.0mean 1,68588E-1 -4,87384E-1 5,80659E-1 -1,68588E-1 2,66725E-1
3.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,00
3.2BioUML2,00724E-1-3,93574E-15,09351E-1-2,00724E-12,44223E-1
3.2ByoDyn2,00724E-1-3,93574E-15,09351E-1-2,00724E-12,44223E-1
3.2Jarnac2,00724E-1-3,93574E-15,09351E-1-2,00724E-12,44223E-1
3.2MathSBML2,00724E-1-3,93573E-15,09351E-1-2,00724E-12,44222E-1
3.2Oscill8 Core2,00859E-1-3,93617E-1--2,44267E-1
3.2SBToolbox21,95665E-1-4,01380E-15,09378E-1-1,95665E-12,51999E-1
3.2SBWOdeSolver2,00855E-1-3,93624E-15,09353E-1-2,00855E-12,44271E-1
3.2copasi2,00736E-1-3,93559E-15,09348E-1-2,00736E-12,44211E-1
3.2edu.kgi.roadRunner2,00724E-1-3,93574E-15,09351E-1-2,00724E-12,44223E-1
3.2jsim2,00723E-1-3,93575E-15,09352E-1-2,00723E-12,44224E-1
3.2min 1,95665E-1 -4,01380E-1 5,09348E-1 -2,00855E-1 2,44211E-1
3.2max 2,00859E-1 -3,93559E-1 5,09378E-1 -1,95665E-1 2,51999E-1
3.2mean 2,00724E-1 -3,93574E-1 5,09351E-1 -2,00724E-1 2,44223E-1
3.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,070,00
3.4BioUML2,29524E-1-3,12958E-14,39662E-1-2,29524E-12,33296E-1
3.4ByoDyn2,29524E-1-3,12958E-14,39662E-1-2,29524E-12,33296E-1
3.4Jarnac2,29524E-1-3,12958E-14,39662E-1-2,29524E-12,33296E-1
3.4MathSBML2,29524E-1-3,12957E-14,39662E-1-2,29524E-12,33295E-1
3.4Oscill8 Core2,29566E-1-3,12983E-1--2,33347E-1
3.4SBToolbox22,21353E-1-3,18596E-14,39497E-1-2,21353E-12,39099E-1
3.4SBWOdeSolver2,29561E-1-3,12989E-14,39639E-1-2,29561E-12,33350E-1
3.4copasi2,29538E-1-3,12946E-14,39658E-1-2,29538E-12,33289E-1
3.4edu.kgi.roadRunner2,29524E-1-3,12958E-14,39662E-1-2,29524E-12,33296E-1
3.4jsim2,29523E-1-3,12959E-14,39662E-1-2,29523E-12,33296E-1
3.4min 2,21353E-1 -3,18596E-1 4,39497E-1 -2,29561E-1 2,33289E-1
3.4max 2,29566E-1 -3,12946E-1 4,39662E-1 -2,21353E-1 2,39099E-1
3.4mean 2,29524E-1 -3,12958E-1 4,39662E-1 -2,29524E-1 2,33296E-1
3.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,020,00
3.6BioUML2,57148E-1-2,47360E-13,83543E-1-2,57148E-12,23817E-1
3.6ByoDyn2,57148E-1-2,47360E-13,83543E-1-2,57148E-12,23817E-1
3.6Jarnac2,57148E-1-2,47360E-13,83543E-1-2,57148E-12,23817E-1
3.6MathSBML2,57149E-1-2,47360E-13,83543E-1-2,57149E-12,23817E-1
3.6Oscill8 Core2,57184E-1-2,47384E-1--2,23862E-1
3.6SBToolbox22,47010E-1-2,51334E-13,81211E-1-2,47010E-12,30123E-1
3.6SBWOdeSolver2,57179E-1-2,47389E-13,83524E-1-2,57179E-12,23865E-1
3.6copasi2,57166E-1-2,47353E-13,83542E-1-2,57166E-12,23811E-1
3.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,57148E-1-2,47360E-13,83543E-1-2,57148E-12,23817E-1
3.6jsim2,57147E-1-2,47361E-13,83543E-1-2,57147E-12,23818E-1
3.6min 2,47010E-1 -2,51334E-1 3,81211E-1 -2,57179E-1 2,23811E-1
3.6max 2,57184E-1 -2,47353E-1 3,83543E-1 -2,47010E-1 2,30123E-1
3.6mean 2,57148E-1 -2,47360E-1 3,83543E-1 -2,57148E-1 2,23817E-1
3.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,010,00
3.8BioUML2,80726E-1-1,97671E-13,42492E-1-2,80726E-12,15179E-1
3.8ByoDyn2,80726E-1-1,97671E-13,42492E-1-2,80726E-12,15179E-1
3.8Jarnac2,80726E-1-1,97671E-13,42492E-1-2,80726E-12,15179E-1
3.8MathSBML2,80727E-1-1,97671E-13,42493E-1-2,80727E-12,15178E-1
3.8Oscill8 Core2,80825E-1-1,97709E-1--2,15205E-1
3.8SBToolbox22,69130E-1-2,00733E-13,35435E-1-2,69130E-12,25298E-1
3.8SBWOdeSolver2,80821E-1-1,97712E-13,42505E-1-2,80821E-12,15207E-1
3.8copasi2,80750E-1-1,97667E-13,42501E-1-2,80750E-12,15166E-1
3.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,80726E-1-1,97671E-13,42492E-1-2,80726E-12,15179E-1
3.8jsim2,80725E-1-1,97672E-13,42492E-1-2,80725E-12,15180E-1
3.8min 2,69130E-1 -2,00733E-1 3,35435E-1 -2,80821E-1 2,15166E-1
3.8max 2,80825E-1 -1,97667E-1 3,42505E-1 -2,69130E-1 2,25298E-1
3.8mean 2,80726E-1 -1,97671E-1 3,42492E-1 -2,80726E-1 2,15179E-1
3.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,030,00
4.0BioUML2,79353E-1-1,62049E-13,04678E-1-2,79353E-12,17370E-1
4.0ByoDyn2,79353E-1-1,62049E-13,04678E-1-2,79353E-12,17370E-1
4.0Jarnac2,79353E-1-1,62049E-13,04678E-1-2,79353E-12,17370E-1
4.0MathSBML2,79355E-1-1,62048E-13,04679E-1-2,79355E-12,17369E-1
4.0Oscill8 Core2,79687E-1-1,62125E-1--2,17329E-1
4.0SBToolbox22,83036E-1-1,69154E-12,93898E-1-2,83036E-12,35256E-1
4.0SBWOdeSolver2,79688E-1-1,62127E-13,04796E-1-2,79688E-12,17331E-1
4.0copasi2,79374E-1-1,62043E-13,04698E-1-2,79374E-12,17345E-1
4.0edu.kgi.roadRunner2,79353E-1-1,62049E-13,04678E-1-2,79353E-12,17370E-1
4.0jsim2,79353E-1-1,62049E-13,04678E-1-2,79353E-12,17371E-1
4.0min 2,79353E-1 -1,69154E-1 2,93898E-1 -2,83036E-1 2,17329E-1
4.0max 2,83036E-1 -1,62043E-1 3,04796E-1 -2,79353E-1 2,35256E-1
4.0mean 2,79355E-1 -1,62049E-1 3,04678E-1 -2,79354E-1 2,17370E-1
4.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,00
4.2BioUML6,21679E-1-2,76556E-15,62944E-1-6,21679E-17,36115E-2
4.2ByoDyn6,21679E-1-2,76556E-15,62944E-1-6,21679E-17,36115E-2
4.2Jarnac6,21679E-1-2,76556E-15,62944E-1-6,21679E-17,36115E-2
4.2MathSBML6,21681E-1-2,76557E-15,62945E-1-6,21681E-17,36114E-2
4.2Oscill8 Core6,21566E-1-2,76565E-1--7,36964E-2
4.2SBToolbox25,60931E-1-2,37040E-15,16025E-1-5,60931E-18,10148E-2
4.2SBWOdeSolver6,21544E-1-2,76548E-15,62849E-1-6,21544E-17,36991E-2
4.2copasi6,21748E-1-2,76605E-15,62998E-1-6,21748E-17,36065E-2
4.2edu.kgi.roadRunner6,21679E-1-2,76556E-15,62944E-1-6,21679E-17,36115E-2
4.2jsim6,21674E-1-2,76551E-15,62939E-1-6,21674E-17,36120E-2
4.2min 5,60931E-1 -2,76605E-1 5,16025E-1 -6,21748E-1 7,36065E-2
4.2max 6,21748E-1 -2,37040E-1 5,62998E-1 -5,60931E-1 8,10148E-2
4.2mean 6,21679E-1 -2,76556E-1 5,62944E-1 -6,21679E-1 7,36115E-2
4.2relative error(%) 0,000,020,000,010,00
4.4BioUML8,44262E-1-5,26292E-18,04858E-1-8,44262E-18,14348E-2
4.4ByoDyn8,44262E-1-5,26292E-18,04858E-1-8,44262E-18,14348E-2
4.4Jarnac8,44262E-1-5,26292E-18,04858E-1-8,44262E-18,14348E-2
4.4MathSBML8,44263E-1-5,26293E-18,04858E-1-8,44263E-18,14348E-2
4.4Oscill8 Core8,44212E-1-5,26275E-1--8,14392E-2
4.4SBToolbox28,23936E-1-4,88283E-17,69443E-1-8,23936E-17,88417E-2
4.4SBWOdeSolver8,44205E-1-5,26259E-18,04821E-1-8,44205E-18,14380E-2
4.4copasi8,44285E-1-5,26338E-18,04900E-1-8,44285E-18,14381E-2
4.4edu.kgi.roadRunner8,44262E-1-5,26292E-18,04858E-1-8,44262E-18,14348E-2
4.4jsim8,44260E-1-5,26288E-18,04854E-1-8,44260E-18,14345E-2
4.4min 8,23936E-1 -5,26338E-1 7,69443E-1 -8,44285E-1 7,88417E-2
4.4max 8,44285E-1 -4,88283E-1 8,04900E-1 -8,23936E-1 8,14392E-2
4.4mean 8,44262E-1 -5,26292E-1 8,04858E-1 -8,44262E-1 8,14348E-2
4.4relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,000,00
4.6BioUML1,72566E-1-6,83541E-16,05272E-1-1,72566E-14,38269E-1
4.6ByoDyn1,72566E-1-6,83541E-16,05272E-1-1,72566E-14,38269E-1
4.6Jarnac1,72566E-1-6,83541E-16,05272E-1-1,72566E-14,38269E-1
4.6MathSBML1,72528E-1-6,83537E-16,05269E-1-1,72528E-14,38268E-1
4.6Oscill8 Core2,35545E-1-6,83612E-1--4,23758E-1
4.6SBToolbox28,84095E-1-7,04135E-19,32439E-1-8,84095E-11,31705E-1
4.6SBWOdeSolver2,36134E-1-6,83653E-16,19933E-1-2,36134E-14,23720E-1
4.6copasi1,71378E-1-6,83433E-16,05195E-1-1,71378E-14,38239E-1
4.6edu.kgi.roadRunner1,72566E-1-6,83541E-16,05272E-1-1,72566E-14,38269E-1
4.6jsim1,72658E-1-6,83549E-16,05277E-1-1,72658E-14,38272E-1
4.6min 1,71378E-1 -7,04135E-1 6,05195E-1 -8,84095E-1 1,31705E-1
4.6max 8,84095E-1 -6,83433E-1 9,32439E-1 -1,71378E-1 4,38272E-1
4.6mean 1,72566E-1 -6,83541E-1 6,05272E-1 -1,72566E-1 4,38268E-1
4.6relative error(%) 0,000,020,000,000,00
4.8BioUML1,94740E-1-6,00003E-16,40017E-1-1,94740E-13,19987E-1
4.8ByoDyn1,94740E-1-6,00003E-16,40017E-1-1,94740E-13,19987E-1
4.8Jarnac1,94740E-1-6,00003E-16,40017E-1-1,94740E-13,19987E-1
4.8MathSBML1,94734E-1-6,00001E-16,40014E-1-1,94734E-13,19988E-1
4.8Oscill8 Core1,98019E-1-5,99925E-1--3,17159E-1
4.8SBToolbox23,47355E-1-6,23800E-17,64771E-1-3,47355E-12,19029E-1
4.8SBWOdeSolver1,98122E-1-5,99948E-16,42802E-1-1,98122E-13,17146E-1
4.8copasi1,94486E-1-5,99950E-16,39935E-1-1,94486E-13,20015E-1
4.8edu.kgi.roadRunner1,94740E-1-6,00003E-16,40017E-1-1,94740E-13,19987E-1
4.8jsim1,94762E-1-6,00008E-16,40023E-1-1,94762E-13,19984E-1
4.8min 1,94486E-1 -6,23800E-1 6,39935E-1 -3,47355E-1 2,19029E-1
4.8max 3,47355E-1 -5,99925E-1 7,64771E-1 -1,94486E-1 3,20015E-1
4.8mean 1,94740E-1 -6,00003E-1 6,40017E-1 -1,94740E-1 3,19987E-1
4.8relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,000,00
5.0BioUML1,69078E-1-4,89257E-15,80676E-1-1,69078E-12,68581E-1
5.0ByoDyn1,69078E-1-4,89257E-15,80676E-1-1,69078E-12,68581E-1
5.0Jarnac1,69078E-1-4,89257E-15,80676E-1-1,69078E-12,68581E-1
5.0MathSBML1,69077E-1-4,89256E-15,80676E-1-1,69077E-12,68580E-1
5.0Oscill8 Core1,69752E-1-4,89348E-1--2,68408E-1
5.0SBToolbox22,08555E-1-5,13465E-15,99690E-1-2,08555E-12,73775E-1
5.0SBWOdeSolver1,69757E-1-4,89362E-15,80943E-1-1,69757E-12,68419E-1
5.0copasi1,69066E-1-4,89226E-15,80673E-1-1,69066E-12,68553E-1
5.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,69078E-1-4,89257E-15,80676E-1-1,69078E-12,68581E-1
5.0jsim1,69079E-1-4,89260E-15,80676E-1-1,69079E-12,68584E-1
5.0min 1,69066E-1 -5,13465E-1 5,80673E-1 -2,08555E-1 2,68408E-1
5.0max 2,08555E-1 -4,89226E-1 5,99690E-1 -1,69066E-1 2,73775E-1
5.0mean 1,69078E-1 -4,89257E-1 5,80676E-1 -1,69078E-1 2,68581E-1
5.0relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,010,00
5.2BioUML1,99683E-1-3,94835E-15,09585E-1-1,99683E-12,45250E-1
5.2ByoDyn1,99683E-1-3,94835E-15,09585E-1-1,99683E-12,45250E-1
5.2Jarnac1,99683E-1-3,94835E-15,09585E-1-1,99683E-12,45250E-1
5.2MathSBML1,99683E-1-3,94835E-15,09585E-1-1,99683E-12,45250E-1
5.2Oscill8 Core1,99863E-1-3,94887E-1--2,45285E-1
5.2SBToolbox21,98378E-1-4,11666E-15,13902E-1-1,98378E-12,57764E-1
5.2SBWOdeSolver1,99858E-1-3,94896E-15,09605E-1-1,99858E-12,45292E-1
5.2copasi1,99698E-1-3,94814E-15,09581E-1-1,99698E-12,45234E-1
5.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,99683E-1-3,94835E-15,09585E-1-1,99683E-12,45250E-1
5.2jsim1,99681E-1-3,94837E-15,09585E-1-1,99681E-12,45252E-1
5.2min 1,98378E-1 -4,11666E-1 5,09581E-1 -1,99858E-1 2,45234E-1
5.2max 1,99863E-1 -3,94814E-1 5,13902E-1 -1,98378E-1 2,57764E-1
5.2mean 1,99683E-1 -3,94835E-1 5,09585E-1 -1,99683E-1 2,45250E-1
5.2relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,090,00
5.4BioUML2,28368E-1-3,13912E-14,40002E-1-2,28368E-12,33910E-1
5.4ByoDyn2,28368E-1-3,13912E-14,40002E-1-2,28368E-12,33910E-1
5.4Jarnac2,28368E-1-3,13912E-14,40002E-1-2,28368E-12,33910E-1
5.4MathSBML2,28369E-1-3,13911E-14,40002E-1-2,28369E-12,33910E-1
5.4Oscill8 Core2,28431E-1-3,13943E-1--2,33960E-1
5.4SBToolbox22,18479E-1-3,26376E-14,42332E-1-2,18479E-12,44044E-1
5.4SBWOdeSolver2,28425E-1-3,13950E-14,39986E-1-2,28425E-12,33964E-1
5.4copasi2,28387E-1-3,13896E-14,39997E-1-2,28387E-12,33899E-1
5.4edu.kgi.roadRunner2,28368E-1-3,13912E-14,40002E-1-2,28368E-12,33910E-1
5.4jsim2,28367E-1-3,13913E-14,40002E-1-2,28367E-12,33911E-1
5.4min 2,18479E-1 -3,26376E-1 4,39986E-1 -2,28425E-1 2,33899E-1
5.4max 2,28431E-1 -3,13896E-1 4,42332E-1 -2,18479E-1 2,44044E-1
5.4mean 2,28368E-1 -3,13912E-1 4,40002E-1 -2,28368E-1 2,33910E-1
5.4relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,020,00
5.6BioUML2,55899E-1-2,48050E-13,83666E-1-2,55899E-12,24384E-1
5.6ByoDyn2,55899E-1-2,48050E-13,83666E-1-2,55899E-12,24384E-1
5.6Jarnac2,55899E-1-2,48050E-13,83666E-1-2,55899E-12,24384E-1
5.6MathSBML2,55900E-1-2,48050E-13,83666E-1-2,55900E-12,24384E-1
5.6Oscill8 Core2,55949E-1-2,48078E-1--2,24427E-1
5.6SBToolbox22,43358E-1-2,57388E-13,82744E-1-2,43358E-12,34644E-1
5.6SBWOdeSolver2,55942E-1-2,48083E-13,83653E-1-2,55942E-12,24430E-1
5.6copasi2,55923E-1-2,48039E-13,83667E-1-2,55923E-12,24372E-1
5.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,55899E-1-2,48050E-13,83666E-1-2,55899E-12,24384E-1
5.6jsim2,55897E-1-2,48051E-13,83666E-1-2,55897E-12,24385E-1
5.6min 2,43358E-1 -2,57388E-1 3,82744E-1 -2,55942E-1 2,24372E-1
5.6max 2,55949E-1 -2,48039E-1 3,83667E-1 -2,43358E-1 2,34644E-1
5.6mean 2,55899E-1 -2,48050E-1 3,83666E-1 -2,55899E-1 2,24384E-1
5.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,020,00
5.8BioUML2,79274E-1-1,98127E-13,42105E-1-2,79274E-12,16022E-1
5.8ByoDyn2,79274E-1-1,98127E-13,42105E-1-2,79274E-12,16022E-1
5.8Jarnac2,79274E-1-1,98127E-13,42105E-1-2,79274E-12,16022E-1
5.8MathSBML2,79275E-1-1,98126E-13,42105E-1-2,79275E-12,16021E-1
5.8Oscill8 Core2,79388E-1-1,98167E-1--2,16042E-1
5.8SBToolbox22,68197E-1-2,05878E-13,35922E-1-2,68197E-12,29956E-1
5.8SBWOdeSolver2,79380E-1-1,98171E-13,42123E-1-2,79380E-12,16047E-1
5.8copasi2,79302E-1-1,98119E-13,42117E-1-2,79302E-12,16002E-1
5.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,79274E-1-1,98127E-13,42105E-1-2,79274E-12,16022E-1
5.8jsim2,79272E-1-1,98127E-13,42104E-1-2,79272E-12,16023E-1
5.8min 2,68197E-1 -2,05878E-1 3,35922E-1 -2,79380E-1 2,16002E-1
5.8max 2,79388E-1 -1,98119E-1 3,42123E-1 -2,68197E-1 2,29956E-1
5.8mean 2,79274E-1 -1,98127E-1 3,42105E-1 -2,79274E-1 2,16022E-1
5.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,040,00
6.0BioUML2,78369E-1-1,62545E-13,03644E-1-2,78369E-12,18901E-1
6.0ByoDyn2,78369E-1-1,62545E-13,03644E-1-2,78369E-12,18901E-1
6.0Jarnac2,78369E-1-1,62545E-13,03644E-1-2,78369E-12,18901E-1
6.0MathSBML2,78369E-1-1,62545E-13,03645E-1-2,78369E-12,18900E-1
6.0Oscill8 Core2,78721E-1-1,62619E-1--2,18846E-1
6.0SBToolbox23,00520E-1-1,75706E-12,99968E-1-3,00520E-12,35742E-1
6.0SBWOdeSolver2,78716E-1-1,62623E-13,03769E-1-2,78716E-12,18854E-1
6.0copasi2,78380E-1-1,62536E-13,03668E-1-2,78380E-12,18868E-1
6.0edu.kgi.roadRunner2,78369E-1-1,62545E-13,03644E-1-2,78369E-12,18901E-1
6.0jsim2,78368E-1-1,62546E-13,03643E-1-2,78368E-12,18903E-1
6.0min 2,78368E-1 -1,75706E-1 2,99968E-1 -3,00520E-1 2,18846E-1
6.0max 3,00520E-1 -1,62536E-1 3,03769E-1 -2,78368E-1 2,35742E-1
6.0mean 2,78369E-1 -1,62545E-1 3,03644E-1 -2,78369E-1 2,18901E-1
6.0relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,000,00
6.2BioUML6,16668E-1-2,72984E-15,58918E-1-6,16668E-17,40663E-2
6.2ByoDyn6,16668E-1-2,72984E-15,58918E-1-6,16668E-17,40663E-2
6.2Jarnac6,16668E-1-2,72984E-15,58918E-1-6,16668E-17,40663E-2
6.2MathSBML6,16670E-1-2,72986E-15,58919E-1-6,16670E-17,40662E-2
6.2Oscill8 Core6,16552E-1-2,72992E-1--7,41623E-2
6.2SBToolbox25,21861E-1-2,16283E-14,83711E-1-5,21861E-19,25713E-2
6.2SBWOdeSolver6,16521E-1-2,72970E-15,58805E-1-6,16521E-17,41656E-2
6.2copasi6,16800E-1-2,73085E-15,59033E-1-6,16800E-17,40520E-2
6.2edu.kgi.roadRunner6,16668E-1-2,72984E-15,58918E-1-6,16668E-17,40663E-2
6.2jsim6,16660E-1-2,72978E-15,58911E-1-6,16660E-17,40672E-2
6.2min 5,21861E-1 -2,73085E-1 4,83711E-1 -6,16800E-1 7,40520E-2
6.2max 6,16800E-1 -2,16283E-1 5,59033E-1 -5,21861E-1 9,25713E-2
6.2mean 6,16668E-1 -2,72984E-1 5,58918E-1 -6,16668E-1 7,40663E-2
6.2relative error(%) 0,000,040,000,020,00
6.4BioUML8,42607E-1-5,22920E-18,01726E-1-8,42607E-18,11939E-2
6.4ByoDyn8,42607E-1-5,22920E-18,01726E-1-8,42607E-18,11939E-2
6.4Jarnac8,42607E-1-5,22920E-18,01726E-1-8,42607E-18,11939E-2
6.4MathSBML8,42608E-1-5,22921E-18,01728E-1-8,42608E-18,11940E-2
6.4Oscill8 Core8,42557E-1-5,22899E-1--8,11974E-2
6.4SBToolbox28,10003E-1-4,65994E-17,48484E-1-8,10003E-17,75082E-2
6.4SBWOdeSolver8,42547E-1-5,22879E-18,01683E-1-8,42547E-18,11960E-2
6.4copasi8,42651E-1-5,23016E-18,01815E-1-8,42651E-18,12005E-2
6.4edu.kgi.roadRunner8,42607E-1-5,22920E-18,01726E-1-8,42607E-18,11939E-2
6.4jsim8,42605E-1-5,22914E-18,01721E-1-8,42605E-18,11935E-2
6.4min 8,10003E-1 -5,23016E-1 7,48484E-1 -8,42651E-1 7,75082E-2
6.4max 8,42651E-1 -4,65994E-1 8,01815E-1 -8,10003E-1 8,12005E-2
6.4mean 8,42607E-1 -5,22920E-1 8,01726E-1 -8,42607E-1 8,11939E-2
6.4relative error(%) 0,000,020,000,010,00
6.6BioUML2,74681E-1-6,90210E-16,15693E-1-2,74681E-14,34517E-1
6.6ByoDyn2,74682E-1-6,90210E-16,15693E-1-2,74682E-14,34517E-1
6.6Jarnac2,74681E-1-6,90210E-16,15693E-1-2,74681E-14,34517E-1
6.6MathSBML2,74611E-1-6,90206E-16,15683E-1-2,74611E-14,34523E-1
6.6Oscill8 Core3,25586E-1-6,89506E-1--4,10732E-1
6.6SBToolbox28,90691E-1-6,89389E-19,39016E-1-8,90691E-11,10380E-1
6.6SBWOdeSolver3,26269E-1-6,89550E-16,38932E-1-3,26269E-14,10618E-1
6.6copasi2,70963E-1-6,90014E-16,15199E-1-2,70963E-14,34815E-1
6.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,74681E-1-6,90210E-16,15693E-1-2,74681E-14,34517E-1
6.6jsim2,74901E-1-6,90221E-16,15722E-1-2,74901E-14,34499E-1
6.6min 2,70963E-1 -6,90221E-1 6,15199E-1 -8,90691E-1 1,10380E-1
6.6max 8,90691E-1 -6,89389E-1 9,39016E-1 -2,70963E-1 4,34815E-1
6.6mean 2,74682E-1 -6,90206E-1 6,15693E-1 -2,74681E-1 4,34517E-1
6.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,00
6.8BioUML2,13236E-1-6,03348E-16,46234E-1-2,13236E-13,17114E-1
6.8ByoDyn2,13236E-1-6,03348E-16,46234E-1-2,13236E-13,17114E-1
6.8Jarnac2,13236E-1-6,03348E-16,46234E-1-2,13236E-13,17114E-1
6.8MathSBML2,13227E-1-6,03346E-16,46230E-1-2,13227E-13,17116E-1
6.8Oscill8 Core2,14856E-1-6,03175E-1--3,14398E-1
6.8SBToolbox23,38417E-1-6,23665E-17,99088E-1-3,38417E-11,84577E-1
6.8SBWOdeSolver2,14996E-1-6,03202E-16,48833E-1-2,14996E-13,14369E-1
6.8copasi2,12676E-1-6,03250E-16,46025E-1-2,12676E-13,17224E-1
6.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,13236E-1-6,03348E-16,46234E-1-2,13236E-13,17114E-1
6.8jsim2,13271E-1-6,03354E-16,46247E-1-2,13271E-13,17107E-1
6.8min 2,12676E-1 -6,23665E-1 6,46025E-1 -3,38417E-1 1,84577E-1
6.8max 3,38417E-1 -6,03175E-1 7,99088E-1 -2,12676E-1 3,17224E-1
6.8mean 2,13236E-1 -6,03348E-1 6,46234E-1 -2,13236E-1 3,17114E-1
6.8relative error(%) 0,000,030,000,000,00
7.0BioUML1,69988E-1-4,91214E-15,80683E-1-1,69988E-12,70530E-1
7.0ByoDyn1,69988E-1-4,91214E-15,80683E-1-1,69988E-12,70530E-1
7.0Jarnac1,69988E-1-4,91214E-15,80683E-1-1,69988E-12,70530E-1
7.0MathSBML1,69987E-1-4,91212E-15,80683E-1-1,69987E-12,70530E-1
7.0Oscill8 Core1,70606E-1-4,91285E-1--2,70318E-1
7.0SBToolbox22,39736E-1-5,25493E-16,30209E-1-2,39736E-12,55291E-1
7.0SBWOdeSolver1,70615E-1-4,91302E-15,80970E-1-1,70615E-12,70332E-1
7.0copasi1,69954E-1-4,91154E-15,80678E-1-1,69954E-12,70477E-1
7.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,69988E-1-4,91214E-15,80683E-1-1,69988E-12,70530E-1
7.0jsim1,69990E-1-4,91217E-15,80683E-1-1,69990E-12,70534E-1
7.0min 1,69954E-1 -5,25493E-1 5,80678E-1 -2,39736E-1 2,55291E-1
7.0max 2,39736E-1 -4,91154E-1 6,30209E-1 -1,69954E-1 2,70534E-1
7.0mean 1,69988E-1 -4,91214E-1 5,80683E-1 -1,69988E-1 2,70530E-1
7.0relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,020,00
7.2BioUML1,98638E-1-3,96121E-15,09727E-1-1,98638E-12,46394E-1
7.2ByoDyn1,98638E-1-3,96121E-15,09727E-1-1,98638E-12,46394E-1
7.2Jarnac1,98638E-1-3,96121E-15,09727E-1-1,98638E-12,46394E-1
7.2MathSBML1,98638E-1-3,96120E-15,09727E-1-1,98638E-12,46393E-1
7.2Oscill8 Core1,98804E-1-3,96165E-1--2,46409E-1
7.2SBToolbox22,08565E-1-4,22428E-15,23665E-1-2,08565E-12,58763E-1
7.2SBWOdeSolver1,98796E-1-3,96177E-15,09760E-1-1,98796E-12,46417E-1
7.2copasi1,98666E-1-3,96082E-15,09722E-1-1,98666E-12,46360E-1
7.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,98638E-1-3,96121E-15,09727E-1-1,98638E-12,46394E-1
7.2jsim1,98636E-1-3,96124E-15,09727E-1-1,98636E-12,46396E-1
7.2min 1,98636E-1 -4,22428E-1 5,09722E-1 -2,08565E-1 2,46360E-1
7.2max 2,08565E-1 -3,96082E-1 5,23665E-1 -1,98636E-1 2,58763E-1
7.2mean 1,98638E-1 -3,96121E-1 5,09727E-1 -1,98638E-1 2,46394E-1
7.2relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,000,00
7.4BioUML2,27144E-1-3,14872E-14,40274E-1-2,27144E-12,34598E-1
7.4ByoDyn2,27144E-1-3,14872E-14,40274E-1-2,27144E-12,34598E-1
7.4Jarnac2,27144E-1-3,14872E-14,40274E-1-2,27144E-12,34598E-1
7.4MathSBML2,27144E-1-3,14871E-14,40273E-1-2,27144E-12,34598E-1
7.4Oscill8 Core2,27203E-1-3,14899E-1--2,34632E-1
7.4SBToolbox22,20156E-1-3,34775E-14,47411E-1-2,20156E-12,47364E-1
7.4SBWOdeSolver2,27194E-1-3,14908E-14,40271E-1-2,27194E-12,34637E-1
7.4copasi2,27179E-1-3,14843E-14,40266E-1-2,27179E-12,34577E-1
7.4edu.kgi.roadRunner2,27144E-1-3,14872E-14,40274E-1-2,27144E-12,34598E-1
7.4jsim2,27141E-1-3,14874E-14,40274E-1-2,27141E-12,34600E-1
7.4min 2,20156E-1 -3,34775E-1 4,40266E-1 -2,27194E-1 2,34577E-1
7.4max 2,27203E-1 -3,14843E-1 4,47411E-1 -2,20156E-1 2,47364E-1
7.4mean 2,27144E-1 -3,14872E-1 4,40274E-1 -2,27144E-1 2,34598E-1
7.4relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,020,00
7.6BioUML2,54565E-1-2,48742E-13,83729E-1-2,54565E-12,25013E-1
7.6ByoDyn2,54565E-1-2,48742E-13,83729E-1-2,54565E-12,25013E-1
7.6Jarnac2,54565E-1-2,48742E-13,83729E-1-2,54565E-12,25013E-1
7.6MathSBML2,54565E-1-2,48741E-13,83729E-1-2,54565E-12,25012E-1
7.6Oscill8 Core2,54609E-1-2,48764E-1--2,25040E-1
7.6SBToolbox22,43516E-1-2,64042E-13,86156E-1-2,43516E-12,37894E-1
7.6SBWOdeSolver2,54600E-1-2,48772E-13,83726E-1-2,54600E-12,25045E-1
7.6copasi2,54605E-1-2,48721E-13,83728E-1-2,54605E-12,24993E-1
7.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,54565E-1-2,48742E-13,83729E-1-2,54565E-12,25013E-1
7.6jsim2,54562E-1-2,48743E-13,83729E-1-2,54562E-12,25014E-1
7.6min 2,43516E-1 -2,64042E-1 3,83726E-1 -2,54605E-1 2,24993E-1
7.6max 2,54609E-1 -2,48721E-1 3,86156E-1 -2,43516E-1 2,37894E-1
7.6mean 2,54565E-1 -2,48742E-1 3,83729E-1 -2,54565E-1 2,25013E-1
7.6relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,020,00
7.8BioUML2,77714E-1-1,98587E-13,41636E-1-2,77714E-12,16952E-1
7.8ByoDyn2,77714E-1-1,98587E-13,41636E-1-2,77714E-12,16952E-1
7.8Jarnac2,77714E-1-1,98587E-13,41636E-1-2,77714E-12,16952E-1
7.8MathSBML2,77714E-1-1,98587E-13,41636E-1-2,77714E-12,16951E-1
7.8Oscill8 Core2,77800E-1-1,98617E-1--2,16962E-1
7.8SBToolbox22,72076E-1-2,11616E-13,39407E-1-2,72076E-12,32209E-1
7.8SBWOdeSolver2,77790E-1-1,98622E-13,41653E-1-2,77790E-12,16969E-1
7.8copasi2,77760E-1-1,98573E-13,41650E-1-2,77760E-12,16923E-1
7.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,77714E-1-1,98587E-13,41636E-1-2,77714E-12,16952E-1
7.8jsim2,77711E-1-1,98588E-13,41635E-1-2,77711E-12,16954E-1
7.8min 2,72076E-1 -2,11616E-1 3,39407E-1 -2,77790E-1 2,16923E-1
7.8max 2,77800E-1 -1,98573E-1 3,41653E-1 -2,72076E-1 2,32209E-1
7.8mean 2,77714E-1 -1,98587E-1 3,41636E-1 -2,77714E-1 2,16952E-1
7.8relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,030,00
8.0BioUML2,77299E-1-1,63102E-13,02466E-1-2,77299E-12,20636E-1
8.0ByoDyn2,77299E-1-1,63102E-13,02466E-1-2,77299E-12,20636E-1
8.0Jarnac2,77299E-1-1,63102E-13,02466E-1-2,77299E-12,20636E-1
8.0MathSBML2,77299E-1-1,63102E-13,02466E-1-2,77299E-12,20636E-1
8.0Oscill8 Core2,77545E-1-1,63151E-1--2,20591E-1
8.0SBToolbox23,21288E-1-1,81724E-13,12870E-1-3,21288E-12,28854E-1
8.0SBWOdeSolver2,77543E-1-1,63156E-13,02555E-1-2,77543E-12,20601E-1
8.0copasi2,77323E-1-1,63085E-13,02499E-1-2,77323E-12,20585E-1
8.0edu.kgi.roadRunner2,77299E-1-1,63102E-13,02466E-1-2,77299E-12,20636E-1
8.0jsim2,77298E-1-1,63103E-13,02464E-1-2,77298E-12,20639E-1
8.0min 2,77298E-1 -1,81724E-1 3,02464E-1 -3,21288E-1 2,20585E-1
8.0max 3,21288E-1 -1,63085E-1 3,12870E-1 -2,77298E-1 2,28854E-1
8.0mean 2,77299E-1 -1,63102E-1 3,02466E-1 -2,77299E-1 2,20636E-1
8.0relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,000,00
8.2BioUML6,11506E-1-2,69460E-15,54921E-1-6,11506E-17,45394E-2
8.2ByoDyn6,11506E-1-2,69460E-15,54921E-1-6,11506E-17,45394E-2
8.2Jarnac6,11506E-1-2,69460E-15,54921E-1-6,11506E-17,45394E-2
8.2MathSBML6,11509E-1-2,69462E-15,54923E-1-6,11509E-17,45391E-2
8.2Oscill8 Core6,11422E-1-2,69459E-1--7,46094E-2
8.2SBToolbox24,80227E-1-1,97680E-14,46932E-1-4,80227E-11,10759E-1
8.2SBWOdeSolver6,11373E-1-2,69423E-15,54808E-1-6,11373E-17,46157E-2
8.2copasi6,11676E-1-2,69578E-15,55057E-1-6,11676E-17,45216E-2
8.2edu.kgi.roadRunner6,11506E-1-2,69460E-15,54921E-1-6,11506E-17,45394E-2
8.2jsim6,11495E-1-2,69452E-15,54911E-1-6,11495E-17,45407E-2
8.2min 4,80227E-1 -2,69578E-1 4,46932E-1 -6,11676E-1 7,45216E-2
8.2max 6,11676E-1 -1,97680E-1 5,55057E-1 -4,80227E-1 1,10759E-1
8.2mean 6,11506E-1 -2,69460E-1 5,54921E-1 -6,11506E-1 7,45394E-2
8.2relative error(%) 0,000,040,000,030,00
8.4BioUML8,40894E-1-5,19588E-17,98631E-1-8,40894E-18,09571E-2
8.4ByoDyn8,40894E-1-5,19588E-17,98631E-1-8,40894E-18,09571E-2
8.4Jarnac8,40894E-1-5,19588E-17,98631E-1-8,40894E-18,09571E-2
8.4MathSBML8,40895E-1-5,19589E-17,98632E-1-8,40895E-18,09572E-2
8.4Oscill8 Core8,40860E-1-5,19567E-1--8,09585E-2
8.4SBToolbox27,94100E-1-4,42848E-17,26622E-1-7,94100E-17,62214E-2
8.4SBWOdeSolver8,40844E-1-5,19533E-17,98577E-1-8,40844E-18,09561E-2
8.4copasi8,40951E-1-5,19700E-17,98735E-1-8,40951E-18,09649E-2
8.4edu.kgi.roadRunner8,40894E-1-5,19588E-17,98631E-1-8,40894E-18,09571E-2
8.4jsim8,40890E-1-5,19580E-17,98623E-1-8,40890E-18,09565E-2
8.4min 7,94100E-1 -5,19700E-1 7,26622E-1 -8,40951E-1 7,62214E-2
8.4max 8,40951E-1 -4,42848E-1 7,98735E-1 -7,94100E-1 8,09649E-2
8.4mean 8,40894E-1 -5,19588E-1 7,98631E-1 -8,40894E-1 8,09571E-2
8.4relative error(%) 0,000,020,000,010,00
8.6BioUML4,25379E-1-6,96566E-16,41158E-1-4,25379E-14,15408E-1
8.6ByoDyn4,25379E-1-6,96566E-16,41158E-1-4,25379E-14,15408E-1
8.6Jarnac4,25379E-1-6,96566E-16,41158E-1-4,25379E-14,15408E-1
8.6MathSBML4,25257E-1-6,96561E-16,41132E-1-4,25257E-14,15429E-1
8.6Oscill8 Core4,10857E-1-6,95658E-1--4,03618E-1
8.6SBToolbox28,90944E-1-6,71661E-19,30258E-1-8,90944E-11,01412E-1
8.6SBWOdeSolver4,12393E-1-6,95724E-16,52373E-1-4,12393E-14,03351E-1
8.6copasi4,19449E-1-6,96350E-16,39949E-1-4,19449E-14,16400E-1
8.6edu.kgi.roadRunner4,25379E-1-6,96566E-16,41158E-1-4,25379E-14,15408E-1
8.6jsim4,25766E-1-6,96580E-16,41237E-1-4,25766E-14,15343E-1
8.6min 4,10857E-1 -6,96580E-1 6,39949E-1 -8,90944E-1 1,01412E-1
8.6max 8,90944E-1 -6,71661E-1 9,30258E-1 -4,12393E-1 4,16400E-1
8.6mean 4,25379E-1 -6,96561E-1 6,41158E-1 -4,25379E-1 4,15408E-1
8.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,00
8.8BioUML2,33068E-1-6,06570E-16,54276E-1-2,33068E-13,12294E-1
8.8ByoDyn2,33068E-1-6,06570E-16,54276E-1-2,33068E-13,12294E-1
8.8Jarnac2,33068E-1-6,06570E-16,54276E-1-2,33068E-13,12294E-1
8.8MathSBML2,33055E-1-6,06567E-16,54270E-1-2,33055E-13,12298E-1
8.8Oscill8 Core2,32978E-1-6,06440E-1--3,11041E-1
8.8SBToolbox23,06328E-1-6,19679E-18,04502E-1-3,06328E-11,75178E-1
8.8SBWOdeSolver2,33181E-1-6,06473E-16,55492E-1-2,33181E-13,10980E-1
8.8copasi2,32366E-1-6,06458E-16,53963E-1-2,32366E-13,12495E-1
8.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,33068E-1-6,06570E-16,54276E-1-2,33068E-13,12294E-1
8.8jsim2,33116E-1-6,06577E-16,54297E-1-2,33116E-13,12281E-1
8.8min 2,32366E-1 -6,19679E-1 6,53963E-1 -3,06328E-1 1,75178E-1
8.8max 3,06328E-1 -6,06440E-1 8,04502E-1 -2,32366E-1 3,12495E-1
8.8mean 2,33068E-1 -6,06570E-1 6,54276E-1 -2,33068E-1 3,12294E-1
8.8relative error(%) 0,000,020,000,000,00
9.0BioUML1,71346E-1-4,93218E-15,80908E-1-1,71346E-12,72310E-1
9.0ByoDyn1,71346E-1-4,93218E-15,80908E-1-1,71346E-12,72310E-1
9.0Jarnac1,71346E-1-4,93218E-15,80908E-1-1,71346E-12,72310E-1
9.0MathSBML1,71345E-1-4,93216E-15,80908E-1-1,71345E-12,72309E-1
9.0Oscill8 Core1,71631E-1-4,93249E-1--2,72190E-1
9.0SBToolbox22,51374E-1-5,33691E-16,61624E-1-2,51374E-12,32067E-1
9.0SBWOdeSolver1,71648E-1-4,93270E-15,81063E-1-1,71648E-12,72207E-1
9.0copasi1,71291E-1-4,93146E-15,80894E-1-1,71291E-12,72252E-1
9.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,71346E-1-4,93218E-15,80908E-1-1,71346E-12,72310E-1
9.0jsim1,71350E-1-4,93223E-15,80909E-1-1,71350E-12,72314E-1
9.0min 1,71291E-1 -5,33691E-1 5,80894E-1 -2,51374E-1 2,32067E-1
9.0max 2,51374E-1 -4,93146E-1 6,61624E-1 -1,71291E-1 2,72314E-1
9.0mean 1,71346E-1 -4,93218E-1 5,80908E-1 -1,71346E-1 2,72309E-1
9.0relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,030,00
9.2BioUML1,97732E-1-3,97439E-15,09900E-1-1,97732E-12,47539E-1
9.2ByoDyn1,97732E-1-3,97439E-15,09900E-1-1,97732E-12,47539E-1
9.2Jarnac1,97732E-1-3,97439E-15,09900E-1-1,97732E-12,47539E-1
9.2MathSBML1,97733E-1-3,97438E-15,09899E-1-1,97733E-12,47538E-1
9.2Oscill8 Core1,97798E-1-3,97459E-1--2,47542E-1
9.2SBToolbox22,22389E-1-4,33000E-15,39801E-1-2,22389E-12,53190E-1
9.2SBWOdeSolver1,97791E-1-3,97473E-15,09920E-1-1,97791E-12,47553E-1
9.2copasi1,97761E-1-3,97391E-15,09892E-1-1,97761E-12,47500E-1
9.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,97732E-1-3,97439E-15,09900E-1-1,97732E-12,47539E-1
9.2jsim1,97730E-1-3,97442E-15,09900E-1-1,97730E-12,47542E-1
9.2min 1,97730E-1 -4,33000E-1 5,09892E-1 -2,22389E-1 2,47500E-1
9.2max 2,22389E-1 -3,97391E-1 5,39801E-1 -1,97730E-1 2,53190E-1
9.2mean 1,97733E-1 -3,97439E-1 5,09900E-1 -1,97733E-1 2,47539E-1
9.2relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,000,00
9.4BioUML2,25979E-1-3,15853E-14,40544E-1-2,25979E-12,35309E-1
9.4ByoDyn2,25979E-1-3,15853E-14,40544E-1-2,25979E-12,35309E-1
9.4Jarnac2,25979E-1-3,15853E-14,40544E-1-2,25979E-12,35309E-1
9.4MathSBML2,25980E-1-3,15852E-14,40544E-1-2,25980E-12,35308E-1
9.4Oscill8 Core2,25997E-1-3,15864E-1--2,35319E-1
9.4SBToolbox22,26013E-1-3,43703E-14,55970E-1-2,26013E-12,47732E-1
9.4SBWOdeSolver2,25986E-1-3,15874E-14,40547E-1-2,25986E-12,35327E-1
9.4copasi2,26019E-1-3,15817E-14,40534E-1-2,26019E-12,35283E-1
9.4edu.kgi.roadRunner2,25979E-1-3,15853E-14,40544E-1-2,25979E-12,35309E-1
9.4jsim2,25977E-1-3,15855E-14,40545E-1-2,25977E-12,35310E-1
9.4min 2,25977E-1 -3,43703E-1 4,40534E-1 -2,26019E-1 2,35283E-1
9.4max 2,26019E-1 -3,15817E-1 4,55970E-1 -2,25977E-1 2,47732E-1
9.4mean 2,25980E-1 -3,15853E-1 4,40544E-1 -2,25980E-1 2,35309E-1
9.4relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,000,00
9.6BioUML2,53283E-1-2,49453E-13,83792E-1-2,53283E-12,25661E-1
9.6ByoDyn2,53283E-1-2,49453E-13,83792E-1-2,53283E-12,25661E-1
9.6Jarnac2,53283E-1-2,49453E-13,83792E-1-2,53283E-12,25661E-1
9.6MathSBML2,53284E-1-2,49452E-13,83792E-1-2,53284E-12,25660E-1
9.6Oscill8 Core2,53291E-1-2,49460E-1--2,25667E-1
9.6SBToolbox22,47097E-1-2,71245E-13,92291E-1-2,47097E-12,38954E-1
9.6SBWOdeSolver2,53277E-1-2,49467E-13,83792E-1-2,53277E-12,25675E-1
9.6copasi2,53329E-1-2,49427E-13,83792E-1-2,53329E-12,25635E-1
9.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,53283E-1-2,49453E-13,83792E-1-2,53283E-12,25661E-1
9.6jsim2,53280E-1-2,49455E-13,83792E-1-2,53280E-12,25662E-1
9.6min 2,47097E-1 -2,71245E-1 3,83792E-1 -2,53329E-1 2,25635E-1
9.6max 2,53329E-1 -2,49427E-1 3,92291E-1 -2,47097E-1 2,38954E-1
9.6mean 2,53283E-1 -2,49453E-1 3,83792E-1 -2,53283E-1 2,25661E-1
9.6relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,020,00
9.8BioUML2,76255E-1-1,99076E-13,41195E-1-2,76255E-12,17882E-1
9.8ByoDyn2,76255E-1-1,99076E-13,41195E-1-2,76255E-12,17882E-1
9.8Jarnac2,76255E-1-1,99076E-13,41195E-1-2,76255E-12,17882E-1
9.8MathSBML2,76256E-1-1,99076E-13,41195E-1-2,76256E-12,17881E-1
9.8Oscill8 Core2,76260E-1-1,99081E-1--2,17885E-1
9.8SBToolbox22,78763E-1-2,17596E-13,46237E-1-2,78763E-12,31349E-1
9.8SBWOdeSolver2,76246E-1-1,99087E-13,41190E-1-2,76246E-12,17897E-1
9.8copasi2,76304E-1-1,99058E-13,41213E-1-2,76304E-12,17844E-1
9.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,76255E-1-1,99076E-13,41195E-1-2,76255E-12,17882E-1
9.8jsim2,76251E-1-1,99078E-13,41194E-1-2,76251E-12,17884E-1
9.8min 2,76246E-1 -2,17596E-1 3,41190E-1 -2,78763E-1 2,17844E-1
9.8max 2,78763E-1 -1,99058E-1 3,46237E-1 -2,76246E-1 2,31349E-1
9.8mean 2,76255E-1 -1,99076E-1 3,41195E-1 -2,76255E-1 2,17882E-1
9.8relative error(%) 0,000,010,000,000,00