Test BIOMD0000000042.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000042.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000042.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: DormandPrince
generated code	: BIOMD0000000042.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: -
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000042.gif

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: PYR EtOH NADH GAP ATP AMP FBP DPG ACA PEP F6P ADP NAD P GLC
Simulators: ByoDyn copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner Jarnac SBToolbox2 VCell Oscill8 Core SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

PYR

EtOH

NADH

GAP

ATP

AMP

FBP

DPG

ACA

PEP

F6P

ADP

NAD

GLC

0.0

BioUML

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

ByoDyn

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

Jarnac

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

MathSBML

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

Oscill8 Core

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

SBToolbox2

4,22700E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16120E-1

1,90920E-3

4,49060E0

2,61150E-3

7,70140E-3

2,99110E-1

7,38330E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08370E-1

3,62060E0

0,00000E0

1,12820E-2

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

VCell

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

copasi

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

jsim

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

min

4,22700E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49060E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38330E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

max

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16120E-1

1,90920E-3

4,49064E0

2,61150E-3

7,70140E-3

2,99110E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08370E-1

3,62060E0

0,00000E0

1,12820E-2

0.0

mean

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85412E-2

0.2

ByoDyn

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85412E-2

0.2

Jarnac

4,78980E-3

3,47863E-1

6,10731E-1

4,33157E-3

4,44435E0

4,74526E-3

3,08750E-2

2,96168E-1

7,06388E-2

2,29101E-3

6,57437E-1

1,52522E-1

3,62596E0

6,57424E-3

8,85422E-2

0.2

MathSBML

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85411E-2

0.2

Oscill8 Core

4,50072E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96703E-3

4,46668E0

3,64531E-3

8,31891E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05278E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31286E-1

3,62719E0

6,67138E-3

8,85408E-2

0.2

SBToolbox2

4,50154E-3

3,47852E-1

6,09506E-1

1,96764E-3

4,46664E0

3,64464E-3

8,31997E-3

2,95444E-1

7,05298E-2

2,19193E-3

6,81716E-1

1,31306E-1

3,62719E0

6,67200E-3

8,85191E-2

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

4,50072E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96703E-3

4,46668E0

3,64531E-3

8,31891E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05278E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31286E-1

3,62719E0

6,67138E-3

8,85407E-2

0.2

VCell

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85412E-2

0.2

copasi

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85412E-2

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,47546E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09399E-1

1,76289E-3

4,46849E0

3,56072E-3

6,50742E-3

2,95379E-1

7,05176E-2

2,18348E-3

6,83655E-1

1,29566E-1

3,62730E0

6,67987E-3

8,85411E-2

0.2

jsim

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85412E-2

0.2

min

4,47546E-3

3,47852E-1

6,09399E-1

1,76289E-3

4,44435E0

3,56072E-3

6,50742E-3

2,95379E-1

7,05176E-2

2,18348E-3

6,57437E-1

1,29566E-1

3,62596E0

6,57424E-3

8,85191E-2

0.2

max

4,78980E-3

3,47863E-1

6,10731E-1

4,33157E-3

4,46849E0

4,74526E-3

3,08750E-2

2,96168E-1

7,06388E-2

2,29101E-3

6,83655E-1

1,52522E-1

3,62730E0

6,67987E-3

8,85422E-2

0.2

mean

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85411E-2

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

ByoDyn

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

Jarnac

7,41739E-3

3,55596E-1

6,15192E-1

1,60733E-2

4,31191E0

1,51333E-2

1,27045E-1

2,98316E-1

6,96342E-2

2,97429E-3

5,93657E-1

2,74568E-1

3,62151E0

1,29176E-2

1,45205E-1

0.4

MathSBML

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

Oscill8 Core

5,55897E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49799E-3

4,42310E0

6,30695E-3

1,28296E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85144E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72206E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45194E-1

0.4

SBToolbox2

5,55944E-3

3,55465E-1

6,03700E-1

2,49849E-3

4,42310E0

6,30499E-3

1,28233E-2

2,90362E-1

6,85173E-2

2,40960E-3

7,19773E-1

1,72217E-1

3,63299E0

1,36537E-2

1,45167E-1

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,55897E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49799E-3

4,42310E0

6,30694E-3

1,28297E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85144E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72206E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45194E-1

0.4

VCell

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

copasi

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,43194E-3

3,55450E-1

6,02817E-1

1,56158E-3

4,43006E0

5,87400E-3

5,86986E-3

2,89733E-1

6,84292E-2

2,37314E-3

7,27571E-1

1,65680E-1

3,63389E0

1,37047E-2

1,45194E-1

0.4

jsim

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

min

5,43194E-3

3,55450E-1

6,02817E-1

1,56158E-3

4,31191E0

5,87400E-3

5,86986E-3

2,89733E-1

6,84292E-2

2,37314E-3

5,93657E-1

1,65680E-1

3,62151E0

1,29176E-2

1,45167E-1

0.4

max

7,41739E-3

3,55596E-1

6,15192E-1

1,60733E-2

4,43006E0

1,51333E-2

1,27045E-1

2,98316E-1

6,96342E-2

2,97429E-3

7,27571E-1

2,74568E-1

3,63389E0

1,37047E-2

1,45205E-1

0.4

mean

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81432E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

ByoDyn

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81432E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

Jarnac

1,39728E-2

3,63721E-1

6,49553E-1

4,34656E-2

4,08336E0

4,85630E-2

3,30600E-1

3,20422E-1

7,38599E-2

4,44122E-3

4,09509E-1

4,69680E-1

3,58716E0

1,79564E-2

1,92947E-1

0.6

MathSBML

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81433E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

Oscill8 Core

7,24322E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81466E-3

4,36313E0

1,10993E-2

3,01108E-2

2,84793E-1

6,84749E-2

2,68974E-3

7,51523E-1

2,27378E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

SBToolbox2

7,24395E-3

3,62858E-1

6,00065E-1

4,81433E-3

4,36312E0

1,10938E-2

3,00854E-2

2,84795E-1

6,84789E-2

2,68992E-3

7,51566E-1

2,27374E-1

3,63660E0

2,09876E-2

1,92876E-1

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

7,24322E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81467E-3

4,36313E0

1,10994E-2

3,01108E-2

2,84793E-1

6,84749E-2

2,68974E-3

7,51523E-1

2,27378E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

VCell

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81432E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

copasi

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81433E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,78417E-3

3,62790E-1

5,96280E-1

1,52655E-3

4,38661E0

9,21364E-3

6,39917E-3

2,81968E-1

6,81073E-2

2,56339E-3

7,78594E-1

2,05781E-1

3,64043E0

2,11938E-2

1,92896E-1

0.6

jsim

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81432E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

min

6,78417E-3

3,62790E-1

5,96280E-1

1,52655E-3

4,08336E0

9,21364E-3

6,39917E-3

2,81968E-1

6,81073E-2

2,56339E-3

4,09509E-1

2,05781E-1

3,58716E0

1,79564E-2

1,92876E-1

0.6

max

1,39728E-2

3,63721E-1

6,49553E-1

4,34656E-2

4,38661E0

4,85630E-2

3,30600E-1

3,20422E-1

7,38599E-2

4,44122E-3

7,78594E-1

4,69680E-1

3,64043E0

2,11938E-2

1,92947E-1

0.6

mean

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81433E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

9,72472E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33668E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

ByoDyn

9,72472E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33668E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

Jarnac

2,44300E-2

3,73737E-1

7,21743E-1

6,91040E-2

3,86554E0

9,84084E-2

5,44825E-1

3,67485E-1

8,65542E-2

6,41064E-3

2,02807E-1

6,37655E-1

3,51497E0

2,09661E-2

2,35383E-1

0.8

MathSBML

9,72472E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33669E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

Oscill8 Core

9,72488E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03171E-1

1,21390E-2

4,26824E0

2,10931E-2

8,33738E-2

2,82557E-1

7,08973E-2

3,12837E-3

7,46339E-1

3,12273E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

SBToolbox2

9,72613E-3

3,70359E-1

6,03193E-1

1,21396E-2

4,26829E0

2,10805E-2

8,33422E-2

2,82574E-1

7,09037E-2

3,12856E-3

7,46381E-1

3,12280E-1

3,63353E0

2,84713E-2

2,35239E-1

0.8

SBWOdeSolver

9,72488E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03171E-1

1,21390E-2

4,26824E0

2,10931E-2

8,33736E-2

2,82557E-1

7,08973E-2

3,12837E-3

7,46339E-1

3,12273E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

VCell

9,72472E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33668E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

copasi

9,72473E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33669E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,24164E-3

3,70096E-1

5,90001E-1

1,90417E-3

4,34006E0

1,35910E-2

9,42189E-3

2,72556E-1

6,96131E-2

2,72713E-3

8,31415E-1

2,47955E-1

3,64672E0

2,91890E-2

2,35246E-1

0.8

jsim

9,72472E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33668E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

min

8,24164E-3

3,70096E-1

5,90001E-1

1,90417E-3

3,86554E0

1,35910E-2

9,42189E-3

2,72556E-1

6,96131E-2

2,72713E-3

2,02807E-1

2,47955E-1

3,51497E0

2,09661E-2

2,35239E-1

0.8

max

2,44300E-2

3,73737E-1

7,21743E-1

6,91040E-2

4,34006E0

9,84084E-2

5,44825E-1

3,67485E-1

8,65542E-2

6,41064E-3

8,31415E-1

6,37655E-1

3,64672E0

2,91890E-2

2,35383E-1

0.8

mean

9,72473E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33668E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46665E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

ByoDyn

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46665E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

Jarnac

3,74792E-2

3,87791E-1

8,18418E-1

8,56090E-2

3,72342E0

1,42020E-1

6,96290E-1

4,26892E-1

1,08689E-1

8,48794E-3

5,44437E-2

7,36165E-1

3,41831E0

2,20956E-2

2,74192E-1

1.0

MathSBML

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46665E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

Oscill8 Core

1,39438E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23711E-1

2,90911E-2

4,11043E0

4,45022E-2

2,07643E-1

2,92203E-1

7,67160E-2

3,97722E-3

6,60171E-1

4,46667E-1

3,61301E0

3,55106E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

SBToolbox2

1,39466E-2

3,78477E-1

6,23753E-1

2,91027E-2

4,11034E0

4,44916E-2

2,07699E-1

2,92236E-1

7,67251E-2

3,97790E-3

6,60106E-1

4,46760E-1

3,61297E0

3,55102E-2

2,73944E-1

1.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,39438E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23711E-1

2,90910E-2

4,11043E0

4,45019E-2

2,07642E-1

2,92203E-1

7,67160E-2

3,97722E-3

6,60172E-1

4,46666E-1

3,61301E0

3,55106E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

VCell

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46665E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

copasi

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46664E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,69991E-3

3,77580E-1

5,84727E-1

3,13931E-3

4,28894E0

1,92951E-2

1,75166E-2

2,62518E-1

7,27633E-2

2,87518E-3

8,81079E-1

2,93363E-1

3,65200E0

3,76830E-2

2,73928E-1

1.0

jsim

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46665E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

min

9,69991E-3

3,77580E-1

5,84727E-1

3,13931E-3

3,72342E0

1,92951E-2

1,75166E-2

2,62518E-1

7,27633E-2

2,87518E-3

5,44437E-2

2,93363E-1

3,41831E0

2,20956E-2

2,73928E-1

1.0

max

3,74792E-2

3,87791E-1

8,18418E-1

8,56090E-2

4,28894E0

1,42020E-1

6,96290E-1

4,26892E-1

1,08689E-1

8,48794E-3

8,81079E-1

7,36165E-1

3,65200E0

3,76830E-2

2,74192E-1

1.0

mean

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46665E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63867E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02254E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

ByoDyn

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63867E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02254E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

Jarnac

4,97967E-2

4,08317E-1

9,20873E-1

8,98542E-2

3,69484E0

1,53162E-1

7,24497E-1

4,86214E-1

1,37968E-1

1,00162E-2

3,26084E-2

7,53598E-1

3,31586E0

2,24317E-2

3,10294E-1

1.2

MathSBML

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63867E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02253E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

Oscill8 Core

2,10585E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73304E-1

5,23462E-2

3,91304E0

8,63880E-2

3,88930E-1

3,22255E-1

8,77251E-2

5,38821E-3

5,02251E-1

6,02173E-1

3,56343E0

4,12748E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

SBToolbox2

2,10628E-2

3,88165E-1

6,73374E-1

5,23706E-2

3,91289E0

8,63841E-2

3,89044E-1

3,22301E-1

8,77390E-2

5,38923E-3

5,02102E-1

6,02311E-1

3,56338E0

4,12731E-2

3,09971E-1

1.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,10585E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73304E-1

5,23461E-2

3,91304E0

8,63878E-2

3,88930E-1

3,22254E-1

8,77250E-2

5,38820E-3

5,02252E-1

6,02173E-1

3,56343E0

4,12748E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

VCell

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63867E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02254E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

copasi

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63866E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02254E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,12137E-2

3,85441E-1

5,82143E-1

6,01265E-3

4,22903E0

2,71094E-2

3,54623E-2

2,53653E-1

7,73566E-2

3,04200E-3

9,20589E-1

3,45461E-1

3,65459E0

4,66111E-2

3,09892E-1

1.2

jsim

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63867E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02254E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

min

1,12137E-2

3,85441E-1

5,82143E-1

6,01265E-3

3,69484E0

2,71094E-2

3,54623E-2

2,53653E-1

7,73566E-2

3,04200E-3

3,26084E-2

3,45461E-1

3,31586E0

2,24317E-2

3,09892E-1

1.2

max

4,97967E-2

4,08317E-1

9,20873E-1

8,98542E-2

4,22903E0

1,53162E-1

7,24497E-1

4,86214E-1

1,37968E-1

1,00162E-2

9,20589E-1

7,53598E-1

3,65459E0

4,66111E-2

3,10294E-1

1.2

mean

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63867E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02254E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

3,13741E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

ByoDyn

3,13741E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

Jarnac

5,99927E-2

4,37225E-1

1,01641E0

9,09190E-2

3,69138E0

1,54637E-1

7,34175E-1

5,38516E-1

1,69789E-1

1,12294E-2

3,21195E-2

7,55578E-1

3,22033E0

2,27036E-2

3,44266E-1

1.4

MathSBML

3,13742E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

Oscill8 Core

3,13746E-2

4,00921E-1

7,51149E-1

7,32350E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80112E-1

3,69928E-1

1,05707E-1

7,25555E-3

3,23526E-1

7,36590E-1

3,48559E0

4,53088E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

SBToolbox2

3,13777E-2

4,00936E-1

7,51238E-1

7,32631E-2

3,72640E0

1,38439E-1

5,80261E-1

3,69996E-1

1,05727E-1

7,25655E-3

3,23329E-1

7,36751E-1

3,48552E0

4,53049E-2

3,43928E-1

1.4

SBWOdeSolver

3,13745E-2

4,00921E-1

7,51149E-1

7,32350E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80112E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05707E-1

7,25554E-3

3,23526E-1

7,36591E-1

3,48559E0

4,53088E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

VCell

3,13741E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

copasi

3,13741E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,30078E-2

3,93900E-1

5,85426E-1

1,17497E-2

4,15269E0

3,87536E-2

7,17317E-2

2,48903E-1

8,33372E-2

3,29378E-3

9,38714E-1

4,10147E-1

3,65131E0

5,58189E-2

3,43739E-1

1.4

jsim

3,13742E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

min

1,30078E-2

3,93900E-1

5,85426E-1

1,17497E-2

3,69138E0

3,87536E-2

7,17317E-2

2,48903E-1

8,33372E-2

3,29378E-3

3,21195E-2

4,10147E-1

3,22033E0

2,27036E-2

3,43739E-1

1.4

max

5,99927E-2

4,37225E-1

1,01641E0

9,09190E-2

4,15269E0

1,54637E-1

7,34175E-1

5,38516E-1

1,69789E-1

1,12294E-2

9,38714E-1

7,55578E-1

3,65131E0

5,58189E-2

3,44266E-1

1.4

mean

3,13742E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

1.6

BioUML

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91495E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

ByoDyn

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91495E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

Jarnac

6,85508E-2

4,75550E-1

1,10267E0

9,18987E-2

3,69660E0

1,53198E-1

7,44322E-1

5,84271E-1

2,00725E-1

1,22321E-2

3,26291E-2

7,51792E-1

3,13408E0

2,29768E-2

3,76509E-1

1.6

MathSBML

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91495E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

Oscill8 Core

4,43619E-2

4,18843E-1

8,48026E-1

8,91483E-2

3,58207E0

1,87431E-1

7,46162E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31228E-1

9,33004E-3

1,63504E-1

8,32094E-1

3,38872E0

4,76063E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

SBToolbox2

4,43591E-2

4,18860E-1

8,48119E-1

8,91817E-2

3,58180E0

1,87474E-1

7,46506E-1

4,26288E-1

1,31250E-1

9,33137E-3

1,63100E-1

8,32350E-1

3,38862E0

4,76015E-2

3,76197E-1

1.6

SBWOdeSolver

4,43619E-2

4,18843E-1

8,48026E-1

8,91485E-2

3,58206E0

1,87432E-1

7,46164E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31228E-1

9,33004E-3

1,63502E-1

8,32095E-1

3,38872E0

4,76063E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

VCell

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91495E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

copasi

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91494E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,55393E-2

4,03272E-1

5,99663E-1

2,17970E-2

4,04977E0

5,74283E-2

1,38844E-1

2,52536E-1

9,09553E-2

3,74106E-3

9,19390E-1

4,94396E-1

3,63708E0

6,50148E-2

3,75881E-1

1.6

jsim

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91494E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

min

1,55393E-2

4,03272E-1

5,99663E-1

2,17970E-2

3,58180E0

5,74283E-2

1,38844E-1

2,52536E-1

9,09553E-2

3,74106E-3

3,26291E-2

4,94396E-1

3,13408E0

2,29768E-2

3,75881E-1

1.6

max

6,85508E-2

4,75550E-1

1,10267E0

9,18987E-2

4,04977E0

1,87474E-1

7,46506E-1

5,84271E-1

2,00725E-1

1,22321E-2

9,19390E-1

8,32350E-1

3,63708E0

6,50148E-2

3,76509E-1

1.6

mean

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91495E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

1.8

BioUML

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72259E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

ByoDyn

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72259E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

Jarnac

7,57338E-2

5,23554E-1

1,17945E0

9,29317E-2

3,70823E0

1,49685E-1

7,55325E-1

6,24988E-1

2,28776E-1

1,30575E-2

3,33580E-2

7,43675E-1

3,05730E0

2,32558E-2

4,07311E-1

1.8

MathSBML

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72258E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

Oscill8 Core

5,83235E-2

4,44319E-1

9,52751E-1

9,81274E-2

3,51468E0

2,14660E-1

8,37116E-1

4,83432E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11793E-2

7,67936E-2

8,72252E-1

3,28400E0

4,86220E-2

4,07088E-1

1.8

SBToolbox2

5,83306E-2

4,44350E-1

9,52859E-1

9,81529E-2

3,51453E0

2,14728E-1

8,37357E-1

4,83510E-1

1,62938E-1

1,11824E-2

7,64914E-2

8,72340E-1

3,28385E0

4,86151E-2

4,07068E-1

1.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,83235E-2

4,44319E-1

9,52751E-1

9,81275E-2

3,51467E0

2,14660E-1

8,37116E-1

4,83432E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11793E-2

7,67929E-2

8,72252E-1

3,28400E0

4,86220E-2

4,07088E-1

1.8

VCell

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72259E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

copasi

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72259E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,95250E-2

4,14082E-1

6,31015E-1

3,65272E-2

3,91559E0

8,70292E-2

2,46183E-1

2,69137E-1

1,00931E-1

4,52326E-3

8,49854E-1

5,98966E-1

3,60574E0

7,37512E-2

4,06618E-1

1.8

jsim

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72259E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

min

1,95250E-2

4,14082E-1

6,31015E-1

3,65272E-2

3,51453E0

8,70292E-2

2,46183E-1

2,69137E-1

1,00931E-1

4,52326E-3

3,33580E-2

5,98966E-1

3,05730E0

2,32558E-2

4,06618E-1

1.8

max

7,57338E-2

5,23554E-1

1,17945E0

9,81529E-2

3,91559E0

2,14728E-1

8,37357E-1

6,24988E-1

2,28776E-1

1,30575E-2

8,49854E-1

8,72340E-1

3,60574E0

7,37512E-2

4,07311E-1

1.8

mean

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72259E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

relative error(%)

0,00

2.0

BioUML

7,08457E-2

4,79472E-1

1,05352E0

1,00884E-1

3,51042E0

2,17705E-1

8,61502E-1

5,35864E-1

1,97343E-1

1,25619E-2

5,83609E-2

8,73458E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

ByoDyn

7,08457E-2

4,79472E-1

1,05352E0

1,00884E-1

3,51042E0

2,17705E-1

8,61502E-1

5,35864E-1

1,97343E-1

1,25619E-2

5,83609E-2

8,73458E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

Jarnac

8,16906E-2

5,80885E-1

1,24722E0

9,40005E-2

3,72476E0

1,44642E-1

7,66955E-1

6,61974E-1

2,52913E-1

1,37361E-2

3,42751E-2

7,32183E-1

2,98954E0

2,35423E-2

4,36885E-1

2.0

MathSBML

7,08457E-2

4,79472E-1

1,05352E0

1,00884E-1

3,51042E0

2,17705E-1

8,61502E-1

5,35864E-1

1,97343E-1

1,25619E-2

5,83609E-2

8,73458E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

Oscill8 Core

7,08453E-2

4,79474E-1

1,05352E0

1,00883E-1

3,51042E0

2,17703E-1

8,61500E-1

5,35862E-1

1,97342E-1

1,25618E-2

5,83636E-2

8,73456E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

SBToolbox2

7,08564E-2

4,79506E-1

1,05364E0

1,00888E-1

3,51040E0

2,17710E-1

8,61538E-1

5,35938E-1

1,97366E-1

1,25640E-2

5,82722E-2

8,73440E-1

3,18316E0

4,91532E-2

4,36730E-1

2.0

SBWOdeSolver

7,08453E-2

4,79474E-1

1,05352E0

1,00883E-1

3,51042E0

2,17703E-1

8,61500E-1

5,35862E-1

1,97342E-1

1,25618E-2

5,83636E-2

8,73457E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

VCell

7,08457E-2

4,79472E-1

1,05352E0

1,00884E-1

3,51042E0

2,17705E-1

8,61502E-1

5,35864E-1

1,97343E-1

1,25619E-2

5,83609E-2

8,73458E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

copasi

7,08457E-2

4,79472E-1

1,05352E0

1,00884E-1

3,51042E0

2,17705E-1

8,61502E-1

5,35864E-1

1,97343E-1

1,25619E-2

5,83609E-2

8,73458E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,57349E-2

4,27198E-1

6,83443E-1

5,37384E-2

3,76229E0

1,28256E-1

3,86985E-1

3,00618E-1

1,14457E-1

5,72867E-3

7,35819E-1

7,11037E-1

3,55332E0

8,15378E-2

4,36177E-1

2.0

jsim

7,08457E-2

4,79472E-1

1,05352E0

1,00884E-1

3,51042E0

2,17705E-1

8,61502E-1

5,35864E-1

1,97343E-1

1,25619E-2

5,83609E-2

8,73458E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

min

2,57349E-2

4,27198E-1

6,83443E-1

5,37384E-2

3,51040E0

1,28256E-1

3,86985E-1

3,00618E-1

1,14457E-1

5,72867E-3

3,42751E-2

7,11037E-1

2,98954E0

2,35423E-2

4,36177E-1

2.0

max

8,16906E-2

5,80885E-1

1,24722E0

1,00888E-1

3,76229E0

2,17710E-1

8,61538E-1

6,61974E-1

2,52913E-1

1,37361E-2

7,35819E-1

8,73458E-1

3,55332E0

8,15378E-2

4,36885E-1

2.0

mean

7,08457E-2

4,79472E-1

1,05352E0

1,00884E-1

3,51042E0

2,17705E-1

8,61502E-1

5,35864E-1

1,97343E-1

1,25619E-2

5,83609E-2

8,73457E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

relative error(%)

0,00

2.2

BioUML

8,11403E-2

5,25498E-1

1,14413E0

1,01830E-1

3,52766E0

2,11775E-1

8,70011E-1

5,81739E-1

2,30722E-1

1,36133E-2

5,72604E-2

8,62140E-1

3,09264E0

4,96255E-2

4,65344E-1

2.2

ByoDyn

8,11403E-2

5,25498E-1

1,14413E0

1,01830E-1

3,52766E0

2,11775E-1

8,70011E-1

5,81739E-1

2,30722E-1

1,36133E-2

5,72604E-2

8,62140E-1

3,09264E0

4,96255E-2

4,65344E-1

2.2

Jarnac

8,65502E-2

6,46760E-1

1,30683E0

9,50873E-2

3,74498E0

1,38520E-1

7,79011E-1

6,96298E-1

2,72773E-1

1,42958E-2

3,53839E-2

7,18081E-1

2,92994E0

2,38383E-2

4,65395E-1

2.2

MathSBML

8,11403E-2

5,25498E-1

1,14413E0

1,01830E-1

3,52766E0

2,11775E-1

8,70011E-1

5,81739E-1

2,30722E-1

1,36133E-2

5,72604E-2

8,62140E-1

3,09264E0

4,96255E-2

4,65344E-1

2.2

Oscill8 Core

8,11398E-2

5,25500E-1

1,14412E0

1,01830E-1

3,52767E0

2,11774E-1

8,70011E-1

5,81737E-1

2,30721E-1

1,36132E-2

5,72610E-2

8,62139E-1

3,09264E0

4,96255E-2

4,65343E-1

2.2

SBToolbox2

8,11501E-2

5,25532E-1

1,14425E0

1,01831E-1

3,52774E0

2,11748E-1

8,69985E-1

5,81807E-1

2,30748E-1

1,36149E-2

5,72366E-2

8,62101E-1

3,09252E0

4,96169E-2

4,65330E-1

2.2

SBWOdeSolver

8,11398E-2

5,25500E-1

1,14412E0

1,01830E-1

3,52767E0

2,11774E-1

8,70011E-1

5,81737E-1

2,30721E-1

1,36132E-2

5,72609E-2

8,62139E-1

3,09264E0

4,96255E-2

4,65343E-1

2.2

VCell

8,11403E-2

5,25498E-1

1,14413E0

1,01830E-1

3,52766E0

2,11775E-1

8,70011E-1

5,81739E-1

2,30722E-1

1,36133E-2

5,72604E-2

8,62140E-1

3,09264E0

4,96255E-2

4,65344E-1

2.2

copasi

8,11403E-2

5,25498E-1

1,14413E0

1,01830E-1

3,52766E0

2,11775E-1

8,70011E-1

5,81739E-1

2,30722E-1

1,36133E-2

5,72604E-2

8,62140E-1

3,09264E0

4,96255E-2

4,65344E-1

2.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,45879E-2

4,43911E-1

7,55854E-1

7,03367E-2

3,61183E0

1,76337E-1

5,42033E-1

3,44244E-1

1,32789E-1

7,32126E-3

5,98123E-1

8,13411E-1

3,48091E0

8,80311E-2

4,64729E-1

2.2

jsim

8,11403E-2

5,25498E-1

1,14413E0

1,01830E-1

3,52766E0

2,11775E-1

8,70011E-1

5,81739E-1

2,30722E-1

1,36133E-2

5,72604E-2

8,62140E-1

3,09264E0

4,96255E-2

4,65344E-1

2.2

min

3,45879E-2

4,43911E-1

7,55854E-1

7,03367E-2

3,52766E0

1,38520E-1

5,42033E-1

3,44244E-1

1,32789E-1

7,32126E-3

3,53839E-2

7,18081E-1

2,92994E0

2,38383E-2

4,64729E-1

2.2

max

8,65502E-2

6,46760E-1

1,30683E0

1,01831E-1

3,74498E0

2,11775E-1

8,70011E-1

6,96298E-1

2,72773E-1

1,42958E-2

5,98123E-1

8,62140E-1

3,48091E0

8,80311E-2

4,65395E-1

2.2

mean

8,11403E-2

5,25498E-1

1,14413E0

1,01830E-1

3,52767E0

2,11775E-1

8,70011E-1

5,81739E-1

2,30722E-1

1,36133E-2

5,72604E-2

8,62140E-1

3,09264E0

4,96255E-2

4,65344E-1

2.2

relative error(%)

0,00

2.4

BioUML

8,93747E-2

5,82558E-1

1,22341E0

1,02486E-1

3,55393E0

2,02423E-1

8,76255E-1

6,22147E-1

2,60541E-1

1,44251E-2

5,94124E-2

8,45221E-1

3,01337E0

5,00979E-2

4,93003E-1

2.4

ByoDyn

8,93747E-2

5,82558E-1

1,22341E0

1,02486E-1

3,55393E0

2,02423E-1

8,76255E-1

6,22147E-1

2,60541E-1

1,44251E-2

5,94124E-2

8,45221E-1

3,01337E0

5,00979E-2

4,93003E-1

2.4

Jarnac

9,04414E-2

7,20150E-1

1,35937E0

9,61787E-2

3,76791E0

1,31685E-1

7,91328E-1

7,28817E-1

2,88436E-1

1,47607E-2

3,66957E-2

7,01982E-1

2,87740E0

2,41458E-2

4,92973E-1

2.4

MathSBML

8,93747E-2

5,82558E-1

1,22341E0

1,02486E-1

3,55393E0

2,02423E-1

8,76255E-1

6,22147E-1

2,60541E-1

1,44251E-2

5,94124E-2

8,45221E-1

3,01337E0

5,00979E-2

4,93003E-1

2.4

Oscill8 Core

8,93743E-2

5,82561E-1

1,22340E0

1,02486E-1

3,55393E0

2,02422E-1

8,76255E-1

6,22146E-1

2,60540E-1

1,44250E-2

5,94127E-2

8,45220E-1

3,01337E0

5,00979E-2

4,93003E-1

2.4

SBToolbox2

8,93889E-2

5,82564E-1

1,22351E0

1,02483E-1

3,55396E0

2,02395E-1

8,76228E-1

6,22229E-1

2,60579E-1

1,44276E-2

5,93979E-2

8,45198E-1

3,01319E0

5,00900E-2

4,92984E-1

2.4

SBWOdeSolver

8,93743E-2

5,82561E-1

1,22340E0

1,02486E-1

3,55393E0

2,02422E-1

8,76255E-1

6,22146E-1

2,60540E-1

1,44250E-2

5,94126E-2

8,45220E-1

3,01337E0

5,00979E-2

4,93003E-1

2.4

VCell

8,93747E-2

5,82558E-1

1,22341E0

1,02486E-1

3,55393E0

2,02423E-1

8,76255E-1

6,22147E-1

2,60541E-1

1,44251E-2

5,94124E-2

8,45221E-1

3,01337E0

5,00979E-2

4,93003E-1

2.4

copasi

8,93747E-2

5,82558E-1

1,22341E0

1,02486E-1

3,55393E0

2,02423E-1

8,76255E-1

6,22147E-1

2,60541E-1

1,44251E-2

5,94124E-2

8,45221E-1

3,01337E0

5,00979E-2

4,93003E-1

2.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,59281E-2

4,65936E-1

8,43307E-1

8,46658E-2

3,48218E0

2,23841E-1

6,92710E-1

3,94753E-1

1,56549E-1

9,15840E-3

4,57818E-1

8,95555E-1

3,39347E0

9,31056E-2

4,92406E-1

2.4

jsim

8,93747E-2

5,82558E-1

1,22341E0

1,02486E-1

3,55393E0

2,02423E-1

8,76255E-1

6,22147E-1

2,60541E-1

1,44251E-2

5,94124E-2

8,45221E-1

3,01337E0

5,00979E-2

4,93003E-1

2.4

min

4,59281E-2

4,65936E-1

8,43307E-1

8,46658E-2

3,48218E0

1,31685E-1

6,92710E-1

3,94753E-1

1,56549E-1

9,15840E-3

3,66957E-2

7,01982E-1

2,87740E0

2,41458E-2

4,92406E-1

2.4

max

9,04414E-2

7,20150E-1

1,35937E0

1,02486E-1

3,76791E0

2,23841E-1

8,76255E-1

7,28817E-1

2,88436E-1

1,47607E-2

4,57818E-1

8,95555E-1

3,39347E0

9,31056E-2

4,93003E-1

2.4

mean

8,93747E-2

5,82558E-1

1,22341E0

1,02486E-1

3,55393E0

2,02423E-1

8,76255E-1

6,22147E-1

2,60541E-1

1,44251E-2

5,94124E-2

8,45221E-1

3,01337E0

5,00979E-2

4,93003E-1

2.4

relative error(%)

0,00

2.6

BioUML

9,58031E-2

6,50016E-1

1,29191E0

1,03084E-1

3,58574E0

1,91226E-1

8,82153E-1

6,58563E-1

2,85567E-1

1,50508E-2

6,27065E-2

8,24612E-1

2,94487E0

5,05970E-2

5,19828E-1

2.6

ByoDyn

9,58031E-2

6,50016E-1

1,29191E0

1,03084E-1

3,58574E0

1,91226E-1

8,82153E-1

6,58563E-1

2,85567E-1

1,50508E-2

6,27065E-2

8,24612E-1

2,94487E0

5,05970E-2

5,19828E-1

2.6

Jarnac

9,34926E-2

7,99932E-1

1,40602E0

9,72644E-2

3,79276E0

1,24430E-1

8,03768E-1

7,60214E-1

3,00236E-1

1,51508E-2

3,82274E-2

6,84380E-1

2,83076E0

2,44667E-2

5,19720E-1

2.6

MathSBML

9,58031E-2

6,50016E-1

1,29191E0

1,03084E-1

3,58574E0

1,91226E-1

8,82153E-1

6,58563E-1

2,85567E-1

1,50508E-2

6,27065E-2

8,24612E-1

2,94487E0

5,05970E-2

5,19828E-1

2.6

Oscill8 Core

9,58028E-2

6,50018E-1

1,29191E0

1,03084E-1

3,58574E0

1,91226E-1

8,82153E-1

6,58562E-1

2,85566E-1

1,50507E-2

6,27067E-2

8,24611E-1

2,94487E0

5,05970E-2

5,19828E-1

2.6

SBToolbox2

9,58267E-2

6,49989E-1

1,29207E0

1,03082E-1

3,58576E0

1,91193E-1

8,82125E-1

6,58638E-1

2,85636E-1

1,50547E-2

6,26876E-2

8,24609E-1

2,94473E0

5,05892E-2

5,19807E-1

2.6

SBWOdeSolver

9,58028E-2

6,50018E-1

1,29191E0

1,03084E-1

3,58574E0

1,91226E-1

8,82154E-1

6,58562E-1

2,85566E-1

1,50507E-2

6,27066E-2

8,24611E-1

2,94487E0

5,05970E-2

5,19828E-1

2.6

VCell

9,58031E-2

6,50016E-1

1,29191E0

1,03084E-1

3,58574E0

1,91226E-1

8,82153E-1

6,58563E-1

2,85567E-1

1,50508E-2

6,27065E-2

8,24612E-1

2,94487E0

5,05970E-2

5,19828E-1

2.6

copasi

9,58032E-2

6,50015E-1

1,29191E0

1,03084E-1

3,58573E0

1,91226E-1

8,82154E-1

6,58563E-1

2,85567E-1

1,50508E-2

6,27064E-2

8,24612E-1

2,94487E0

5,05970E-2

5,19828E-1

2.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,90577E-2

4,95265E-1

9,39429E-1

9,60802E-2

3,38577E0

2,63130E-1

8,22906E-1

4,47189E-1

1,85212E-1

1,10446E-2

3,33360E-1

9,52670E-1

3,29735E0

9,68317E-2

5,19306E-1

2.6

jsim

9,58031E-2

6,50016E-1

1,29191E0

1,03084E-1

3,58574E0

1,91226E-1

8,82153E-1

6,58563E-1

2,85567E-1

1,50508E-2

6,27065E-2

8,24612E-1

2,94487E0

5,05970E-2

5,19828E-1

2.6

min

5,90577E-2

4,95265E-1

9,39429E-1

9,60802E-2

3,38577E0

1,24430E-1

8,03768E-1

4,47189E-1

1,85212E-1

1,10446E-2

3,82274E-2

6,84380E-1

2,83076E0

2,44667E-2

5,19306E-1

2.6

max

9,58267E-2

7,99932E-1

1,40602E0

1,03084E-1

3,79276E0

2,63130E-1

8,82154E-1

7,60214E-1

3,00236E-1

1,51508E-2

3,33360E-1

9,52670E-1

3,29735E0

9,68317E-2

5,19828E-1

2.6

mean

9,58031E-2

6,50016E-1

1,29191E0

1,03084E-1

3,58574E0

1,91226E-1

8,82153E-1

6,58563E-1

2,85567E-1

1,50508E-2

6,27065E-2

8,24612E-1

2,94487E0

5,05970E-2

5,19828E-1

2.6

relative error(%)

0,00

2.8

BioUML

1,00660E-1

7,26717E-1

1,35082E0

1,03652E-1

3,62128E0

1,78989E-1

8,87879E-1

6,92240E-1

3,05458E-1

1,55312E-2

6,68444E-2

8,01304E-1

2,88597E0

5,11321E-2

5,45905E-1

2.8

ByoDyn

1,00660E-1

7,26717E-1

1,35082E0

1,03652E-1

3,62128E0

1,78989E-1

8,87879E-1

6,92240E-1

3,05458E-1

1,55312E-2

6,68444E-2

8,01304E-1

2,88597E0

5,11321E-2

5,45905E-1

2.8

Jarnac

9,58254E-2

8,84997E-1

1,44789E0

9,83366E-2

3,81892E0

1,16979E-1

8,16214E-1

7,91024E-1

3,08630E-1

1,54826E-2

3,99996E-2

6,65672E-1

2,78889E0

2,48034E-2

5,45725E-1

2.8

MathSBML

1,00660E-1

7,26717E-1

1,35082E0

1,03652E-1

3,62128E0

1,78989E-1

8,87879E-1

6,92240E-1

3,05458E-1

1,55312E-2

6,68444E-2

8,01304E-1

2,88597E0

5,11321E-2

5,45905E-1

2.8

Oscill8 Core

1,00660E-1

7,26719E-1

1,35082E0

1,03652E-1

3,62128E0

1,78989E-1

8,87879E-1

6,92240E-1

3,05457E-1

1,55312E-2

6,68446E-2

8,01303E-1

2,88597E0

5,11322E-2

5,45904E-1

2.8

SBToolbox2

1,00691E-1

7,26649E-1

1,35104E0

1,03652E-1

3,62130E0

1,78956E-1

8,87862E-1

6,92311E-1

3,05554E-1

1,55351E-2

6,68167E-2

8,01312E-1

2,88576E0

5,11242E-2

5,45889E-1

2.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,00660E-1

7,26719E-1

1,35082E0

1,03652E-1

3,62128E0

1,78989E-1

8,87879E-1

6,92240E-1

3,05457E-1

1,55312E-2

6,68446E-2

8,01303E-1

2,88597E0

5,11321E-2

5,45904E-1

2.8

VCell

1,00660E-1

7,26717E-1

1,35082E0

1,03652E-1

3,62128E0

1,78989E-1

8,87879E-1

6,92240E-1

3,05458E-1

1,55312E-2

6,68444E-2

8,01304E-1

2,88597E0

5,11321E-2

5,45905E-1

2.8

copasi

1,00660E-1

7,26717E-1

1,35082E0

1,03652E-1

3,62128E0

1,78989E-1

8,87879E-1

6,92240E-1

3,05458E-1

1,55312E-2

6,68444E-2

8,01304E-1

2,88597E0

5,11322E-2

5,45905E-1

2.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,28557E-2

5,33876E-1

1,03757E0

1,04170E-1

3,33092E0

2,87639E-1

9,18470E-1

4,97920E-1

2,17081E-1

1,27764E-2

2,41124E-1

9,83011E-1

3,19922E0

9,94561E-2

5,45500E-1

2.8

jsim

1,00660E-1

7,26717E-1

1,35082E0

1,03652E-1

3,62128E0

1,78989E-1

8,87879E-1

6,92240E-1

3,05458E-1

1,55312E-2

6,68444E-2

8,01304E-1

2,88597E0

5,11321E-2

5,45905E-1

2.8

min

7,28557E-2

5,33876E-1

1,03757E0

9,83366E-2

3,33092E0

1,16979E-1

8,16214E-1

4,97920E-1

2,17081E-1

1,27764E-2

3,99996E-2

6,65672E-1

2,78889E0

2,48034E-2

5,45500E-1

2.8

max

1,00691E-1

8,84997E-1

1,44789E0

1,04170E-1

3,81892E0

2,87639E-1

9,18470E-1

7,91024E-1

3,08630E-1

1,55351E-2

2,41124E-1

9,83011E-1

3,19922E0

9,94561E-2

5,45905E-1

2.8

mean

1,00660E-1

7,26717E-1

1,35082E0

1,03652E-1

3,62128E0

1,78989E-1

8,87879E-1

6,92240E-1

3,05458E-1

1,55312E-2

6,68444E-2

8,01304E-1

2,88597E0

5,11321E-2

5,45904E-1

2.8

relative error(%)

0,00

3.0

BioUML

1,04165E-1

8,11256E-1

1,40159E0

1,04185E-1

3,65930E0

1,66265E-1

8,93353E-1

7,24175E-1

3,20413E-1

1,58991E-2

7,18081E-2

7,76004E-1

2,83521E0

5,17116E-2

5,71303E-1

3.0

ByoDyn

1,04165E-1

8,11256E-1

1,40159E0

1,04185E-1

3,65930E0

1,66265E-1

8,93353E-1

7,24175E-1

3,20413E-1

1,58991E-2

7,18081E-2

7,76004E-1

2,83521E0

5,17116E-2

5,71303E-1

3.0

Jarnac

9,75509E-2

9,74318E-1

1,48603E0

9,93894E-2

3,84588E0

1,09506E-1

8,28570E-1

8,21665E-1

3,14109E-1

1,57691E-2

4,20360E-2

6,46180E-1

2,75076E0

2,51584E-2

5,71057E-1

3.0

MathSBML

1,04165E-1

8,11256E-1

1,40159E0

1,04185E-1

3,65930E0

1,66265E-1

8,93353E-1

7,24175E-1

3,20413E-1

1,58991E-2

7,18081E-2

7,76004E-1

2,83520E0

5,17116E-2

5,71303E-1

3.0

Oscill8 Core

1,04165E-1

8,11258E-1

1,40159E0

1,04185E-1

3,65930E0

1,66265E-1

8,93353E-1

7,24175E-1

3,20411E-1

1,58991E-2

7,18083E-2

7,76004E-1

2,83521E0

5,17116E-2

5,71303E-1

3.0

SBToolbox2

1,04205E-1

8,11170E-1

1,40181E0

1,04184E-1

3,65933E0

1,66232E-1

8,93342E-1

7,24239E-1

3,20528E-1

1,59032E-2

7,17753E-2

7,76010E-1

2,83499E0

5,17037E-2

5,71285E-1

3.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,04165E-1

8,11258E-1

1,40159E0

1,04185E-1

3,65930E0

1,66265E-1

8,93353E-1

7,24175E-1

3,20411E-1

1,58991E-2

7,18083E-2

7,76004E-1

2,83521E0

5,17116E-2

5,71303E-1

3.0

VCell

1,04165E-1

8,11256E-1

1,40159E0

1,04185E-1

3,65930E0

1,66265E-1

8,93353E-1

7,24175E-1

3,20413E-1

1,58991E-2

7,18081E-2

7,76004E-1

2,83521E0

5,17116E-2

5,71303E-1

3.0

copasi

1,04165E-1

8,11256E-1

1,40159E0

1,04185E-1

3,65930E0

1,66265E-1

8,93353E-1

7,24175E-1

3,20413E-1

1,58991E-2

7,18082E-2

7,76004E-1

2,83520E0

5,17116E-2

5,71303E-1

3.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,60189E-2

5,83313E-1

1,13158E0

1,09012E-1

3,31720E0

2,95020E-1

9,75210E-1

5,44717E-1

2,49701E-1

1,42065E-2

1,87139E-1

9,89344E-1

3,10521E0

1,01347E-1

5,71042E-1

3.0

jsim

1,04165E-1

8,11256E-1

1,40159E0

1,04185E-1

3,65930E0

1,66265E-1

8,93353E-1

7,24175E-1

3,20413E-1

1,58991E-2

7,18081E-2

7,76004E-1

2,83521E0

5,17116E-2

5,71303E-1

3.0

min

8,60189E-2

5,83313E-1

1,13158E0

9,93894E-2

3,31720E0

1,09506E-1

8,28570E-1

5,44717E-1

2,49701E-1

1,42065E-2

4,20360E-2

6,46180E-1

2,75076E0

2,51584E-2

5,71042E-1

3.0

max

1,04205E-1

9,74318E-1

1,48603E0

1,09012E-1

3,84588E0

2,95020E-1

9,75210E-1

8,21665E-1

3,20528E-1

1,59032E-2

1,87139E-1

9,89344E-1

3,10521E0

1,01347E-1

5,71303E-1

3.0

mean

1,04165E-1

8,11256E-1

1,40159E0

1,04185E-1

3,65930E0

1,66265E-1

8,93353E-1

7,24175E-1

3,20413E-1

1,58991E-2

7,18081E-2

7,76004E-1

2,83521E0

5,17116E-2

5,71303E-1

3.0

relative error(%)

0,00

3.2

BioUML

1,06522E-1

9,02169E-1

1,44571E0

1,04679E-1

3,69884E0

1,53454E-1

8,98457E-1

7,55141E-1

3,30917E-1

1,61804E-2

7,76386E-2

7,49264E-1

2,79110E0

5,23436E-2

5,96083E-1

3.2

ByoDyn

1,06522E-1

9,02169E-1

1,44571E0

1,04679E-1

3,69884E0

1,53454E-1

8,98457E-1

7,55141E-1

3,30917E-1

1,61804E-2

7,76386E-2

7,49264E-1

2,79110E0

5,23436E-2

5,96083E-1

3.2

Jarnac

9,87668E-2

1,06698E0

1,52134E0

1,00418E-1

3,87325E0

1,02141E-1

8,40754E-1

8,52460E-1

3,17145E-1

1,60205E-2

4,43627E-2

6,26171E-1

2,71546E0

2,55344E-2

5,95777E-1

3.2

MathSBML

1,06522E-1

9,02169E-1

1,44571E0

1,04679E-1

3,69884E0

1,53454E-1

8,98457E-1

7,55141E-1

3,30917E-1

1,61804E-2

7,76386E-2

7,49264E-1

2,79110E0

5,23436E-2

5,96083E-1

3.2

Oscill8 Core

1,06522E-1

9,02170E-1

1,44570E0

1,04679E-1

3,69884E0

1,53454E-1

8,98457E-1

7,55141E-1

3,30916E-1

1,61804E-2

7,76389E-2

7,49264E-1

2,79110E0

5,23436E-2

5,96083E-1

3.2

SBToolbox2

1,06561E-1

9,02082E-1

1,44593E0

1,04680E-1

3,69886E0

1,53415E-1

8,98450E-1

7,55197E-1

3,31042E-1

1,61838E-2

7,76035E-2

7,49258E-1

2,79087E0

5,23354E-2

5,96066E-1

3.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,06522E-1

9,02170E-1

1,44570E0

1,04679E-1

3,69884E0

1,53454E-1

8,98457E-1

7,55141E-1

3,30916E-1

1,61804E-2

7,76389E-2

7,49263E-1

2,79110E0

5,23436E-2

5,96083E-1

3.2

VCell

1,06522E-1

9,02169E-1

1,44571E0

1,04679E-1

3,69884E0

1,53454E-1

8,98457E-1

7,55141E-1

3,30917E-1

1,61804E-2

7,76386E-2

7,49264E-1

2,79110E0

5,23436E-2

5,96083E-1

3.2

copasi

1,06522E-1

9,02169E-1

1,44571E0

1,04679E-1

3,69884E0

1,53454E-1

8,98457E-1

7,55141E-1

3,30917E-1

1,61804E-2

7,76386E-2

7,49264E-1

2,79110E0

5,23436E-2

5,96083E-1

3.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,75080E-2

6,44325E-1

1,21705E0

1,11488E-1

3,33409E0

2,88829E-1

1,00302E0

5,86738E-1

2,80560E-1

1,52988E-2

1,62523E-1

9,78646E-1

3,01975E0

1,02851E-1

5,95977E-1

3.2

jsim

1,06522E-1

9,02169E-1

1,44571E0

1,04679E-1

3,69884E0

1,53454E-1

8,98457E-1

7,55141E-1

3,30917E-1

1,61804E-2

7,76386E-2

7,49264E-1

2,79110E0

5,23436E-2

5,96083E-1

3.2

min

9,75080E-2

6,44325E-1

1,21705E0

1,00418E-1

3,33409E0

1,02141E-1

8,40754E-1

5,86738E-1

2,80560E-1

1,52988E-2

4,43627E-2

6,26171E-1

2,71546E0

2,55344E-2

5,95777E-1

3.2

max

1,06561E-1

1,06698E0

1,52134E0

1,11488E-1

3,87325E0

2,88829E-1

1,00302E0

8,52460E-1

3,31042E-1

1,61838E-2

1,62523E-1

9,78646E-1

3,01975E0

1,02851E-1

5,96083E-1

3.2

mean

1,06522E-1

9,02169E-1

1,44571E0

1,04679E-1

3,69884E0

1,53454E-1

8,98457E-1

7,55141E-1

3,30917E-1

1,61804E-2

7,76386E-2

7,49264E-1

2,79110E0

5,23436E-2

5,96083E-1

3.2

relative error(%)

0,00

3.4

BioUML

1,07917E-1

9,98063E-1

1,48457E0

1,05125E-1

3,73919E0

1,40848E-1

9,03067E-1

7,85731E-1

3,37569E-1

1,63955E-2

8,43997E-2

7,21524E-1

2,75224E0

5,30371E-2

6,20296E-1

3.4

ByoDyn

1,07917E-1

9,98063E-1

1,48457E0

1,05125E-1

3,73919E0

1,40848E-1

9,03067E-1

7,85731E-1

3,37569E-1

1,63955E-2

8,43997E-2

7,21524E-1

2,75224E0

5,30371E-2

6,20296E-1

3.4

Jarnac

9,95573E-2

1,16221E0

1,55457E0

1,01420E-1

3,90072E0

9,49784E-2

8,52695E-1

8,83657E-1

3,18162E-1

1,62452E-2

4,70077E-2

6,05863E-1

2,68224E0

2,59344E-2

6,19937E-1

3.4

MathSBML

1,07917E-1

9,98063E-1

1,48457E0

1,05125E-1

3,73919E0

1,40848E-1

9,03067E-1

7,85732E-1

3,37569E-1

1,63955E-2

8,43997E-2

7,21524E-1

2,75224E0

5,30371E-2

6,20296E-1

3.4

Oscill8 Core

1,07917E-1

9,98064E-1

1,48456E0

1,05125E-1

3,73919E0

1,40848E-1

9,03066E-1

7,85732E-1

3,37568E-1

1,63955E-2

8,44000E-2

7,21524E-1

2,75225E0

5,30371E-2

6,20296E-1

3.4

SBToolbox2

1,07953E-1

9,97991E-1

1,48479E0

1,05123E-1

3,73922E0

1,40811E-1

9,03065E-1

7,85773E-1

3,37695E-1

1,63979E-2

8,43619E-2

7,21509E-1

2,75201E0

5,30288E-2

6,20282E-1

3.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,07917E-1

9,98064E-1

1,48456E0

1,05125E-1

3,73919E0

1,40848E-1

9,03066E-1

7,85731E-1

3,37568E-1

1,63955E-2

8,44000E-2

7,21524E-1

2,75225E0

5,30371E-2

6,20296E-1

3.4

VCell

1,07917E-1

9,98063E-1

1,48457E0

1,05125E-1

3,73919E0

1,40848E-1

9,03067E-1

7,85731E-1

3,37569E-1

1,63955E-2

8,43997E-2

7,21524E-1

2,75224E0

5,30371E-2

6,20296E-1

3.4

copasi

1,07917E-1

9,98063E-1

1,48456E0

1,05125E-1

3,73919E0

1,40848E-1

9,03067E-1

7,85732E-1

3,37569E-1

1,63955E-2

8,43997E-2

7,21524E-1

2,75224E0

5,30371E-2

6,20296E-1

3.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,06812E-1

7,16751E-1

1,29190E0

1,12633E-1

3,36971E0

2,74449E-1

1,01461E0

6,24315E-1

3,07730E-1

1,60943E-2

1,54875E-1

9,57396E-1

2,94491E0

1,04201E-1

6,20346E-1

3.4

jsim

1,07917E-1

9,98063E-1

1,48457E0

1,05125E-1

3,73919E0

1,40848E-1

9,03067E-1

7,85731E-1

3,37569E-1

1,63955E-2

8,43997E-2

7,21524E-1

2,75224E0

5,30371E-2

6,20296E-1

3.4

min

9,95573E-2

7,16751E-1

1,29190E0

1,01420E-1

3,36971E0

9,49784E-2

8,52695E-1

6,24315E-1

3,07730E-1

1,60943E-2

4,70077E-2

6,05863E-1

2,68224E0

2,59344E-2

6,19937E-1

3.4

max

1,07953E-1

1,16221E0

1,55457E0

1,12633E-1

3,90072E0

2,74449E-1

1,01461E0

8,83657E-1

3,37695E-1

1,63979E-2

1,54875E-1

9,57396E-1

2,94491E0

1,04201E-1

6,20346E-1

3.4

mean

1,07917E-1

9,98063E-1

1,48457E0

1,05125E-1

3,73919E0

1,40848E-1

9,03067E-1

7,85731E-1

3,37569E-1

1,63955E-2

8,43997E-2

7,21524E-1

2,75224E0

5,30371E-2

6,20296E-1

3.4

relative error(%)

0,00

3.6

BioUML

1,08514E-1

1,09769E0

1,51941E0

1,05519E-1

3,77976E0

1,28652E-1

9,07060E-1

8,16400E-1

3,40973E-1

1,65598E-2

9,21701E-2

6,93143E-1

2,71741E0

5,38016E-2

6,43987E-1

3.6

ByoDyn

1,08514E-1

1,09769E0

1,51941E0

1,05519E-1

3,77976E0

1,28652E-1

9,07060E-1

8,16400E-1

3,40973E-1

1,65598E-2

9,21701E-2

6,93143E-1

2,71741E0

5,38016E-2

6,43987E-1

3.6

Jarnac

9,99936E-2

1,25933E0

1,58638E0

1,02391E-1

3,92802E0

8,80889E-2

8,64334E-1

9,15446E-1

3,17528E-1

1,64493E-2

4,99998E-2

5,85444E-1

2,65044E0

2,63616E-2

6,43581E-1

3.6

MathSBML

1,08514E-1

1,09769E0

1,51941E0

1,05519E-1

3,77976E0

1,28652E-1

9,07060E-1

8,16400E-1

3,40973E-1

1,65598E-2

9,21701E-2

6,93143E-1

2,71741E0

5,38016E-2

6,43987E-1

3.6

Oscill8 Core

1,08514E-1

1,09769E0

1,51941E0

1,05519E-1

3,77976E0

1,28652E-1

9,07060E-1

8,16401E-1

3,40972E-1

1,65598E-2

9,21705E-2

6,93143E-1

2,71741E0

5,38016E-2

6,43987E-1

3.6

SBToolbox2

1,08546E-1

1,09766E0

1,51959E0

1,05523E-1

3,77984E0

1,28606E-1

9,07065E-1

8,16432E-1

3,41084E-1

1,65621E-2

9,21286E-2

6,93118E-1

2,71721E0

5,37936E-2

6,43969E-1

3.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,08514E-1

1,09769E0

1,51941E0

1,05519E-1

3,77976E0

1,28652E-1

9,07060E-1

8,16400E-1

3,40972E-1

1,65598E-2

9,21705E-2

6,93143E-1

2,71741E0

5,38016E-2

6,43987E-1

3.6

VCell

1,08514E-1

1,09769E0

1,51941E0

1,05519E-1

3,77976E0

1,28652E-1

9,07060E-1

8,16400E-1

3,40973E-1

1,65598E-2

9,21701E-2

6,93143E-1

2,71741E0

5,38016E-2

6,43987E-1

3.6

copasi

1,08514E-1

1,09769E0

1,51941E0

1,05519E-1

3,77976E0

1,28652E-1

9,07060E-1

8,16401E-1

3,40973E-1

1,65598E-2

9,21701E-2

6,93143E-1

2,71741E0

5,38016E-2

6,43987E-1

3.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,13846E-1

7,99661E-1

1,35598E0

1,13099E-1

3,41617E0

2,55791E-1

1,01794E0

6,58389E-1

3,30128E-1

1,66530E-2

1,56313E-1

9,29594E-1

2,88084E0

1,05520E-1

6,44186E-1

3.6

jsim

1,08514E-1

1,09769E0

1,51941E0

1,05519E-1

3,77976E0

1,28652E-1

9,07060E-1

8,16400E-1

3,40973E-1

1,65598E-2

9,21701E-2

6,93143E-1

2,71741E0

5,38016E-2

6,43987E-1

3.6

min

9,99936E-2

7,99661E-1

1,35598E0

1,02391E-1

3,41617E0

8,80889E-2

8,64334E-1

6,58389E-1

3,17528E-1

1,64493E-2

4,99998E-2

5,85444E-1

2,65044E0

2,63616E-2

6,43581E-1

3.6

max

1,13846E-1

1,25933E0

1,58638E0

1,13099E-1

3,92802E0

2,55791E-1

1,01794E0

9,15446E-1

3,41084E-1

1,66530E-2

1,56313E-1

9,29594E-1

2,88084E0

1,05520E-1

6,44186E-1

3.6

mean

1,08514E-1

1,09769E0

1,51941E0

1,05519E-1

3,77976E0

1,28652E-1

9,07060E-1

8,16400E-1

3,40973E-1

1,65598E-2

9,21701E-2

6,93143E-1

2,71741E0

5,38016E-2

6,43987E-1

3.6

relative error(%)

0,00

3.8

BioUML

1,08453E-1

1,19996E0

1,55128E0

1,05853E-1

3,82012E0

1,17009E-1

9,10318E-1

8,47489E-1

3,41688E-1

1,66851E-2

1,01041E-1

6,64418E-1

2,68554E0

5,46474E-2

6,67195E-1

3.8

ByoDyn

1,08453E-1

1,19996E0

1,55128E0

1,05853E-1

3,82012E0

1,17009E-1

9,10318E-1

8,47489E-1

3,41688E-1

1,66851E-2

1,01041E-1

6,64418E-1

2,68554E0

5,46474E-2

6,67195E-1

3.8

Jarnac

1,00135E-1

1,35780E0

1,61726E0

1,03330E-1

3,95496E0

8,15206E-2

8,75621E-1

9,47964E-1

3,15553E-1

1,66380E-2

5,33686E-2

5,65069E-1

2,61957E0

2,68196E-2

6,66747E-1

3.8

MathSBML

1,08453E-1

1,19996E0

1,55128E0

1,05853E-1

3,82013E0

1,17009E-1

9,10318E-1

8,47489E-1

3,41688E-1

1,66851E-2

1,01041E-1

6,64418E-1

2,68554E0

5,46474E-2

6,67195E-1

3.8

Oscill8 Core

1,08453E-1

1,19996E0

1,55128E0

1,05853E-1

3,82012E0

1,17009E-1

9,10318E-1

8,47489E-1

3,41687E-1

1,66851E-2

1,01041E-1

6,64418E-1

2,68554E0

5,46474E-2

6,67195E-1

3.8

SBToolbox2

1,08484E-1

1,19992E0

1,55143E0

1,05852E-1

3,82024E0

1,16963E-1

9,10327E-1

8,47513E-1

3,41791E-1

1,66871E-2

1,00998E-1

6,64387E-1

2,68537E0

5,46389E-2

6,67173E-1

3.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,08453E-1

1,19996E0

1,55128E0

1,05853E-1

3,82012E0

1,17009E-1

9,10318E-1

8,47489E-1

3,41687E-1

1,66851E-2

1,01041E-1

6,64418E-1

2,68554E0

5,46474E-2

6,67195E-1

3.8

VCell

1,08453E-1

1,19996E0

1,55128E0

1,05853E-1

3,82012E0

1,17009E-1

9,10318E-1

8,47489E-1

3,41688E-1

1,66851E-2

1,01041E-1

6,64418E-1

2,68554E0

5,46474E-2

6,67195E-1

3.8

copasi

1,08453E-1

1,19996E0

1,55128E0

1,05853E-1

3,82012E0

1,17009E-1

9,10318E-1

8,47489E-1

3,41688E-1

1,66851E-2

1,01040E-1

6,64419E-1

2,68554E0

5,46474E-2

6,67195E-1

3.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,18752E-1

8,91628E-1

1,41019E0

1,13197E-1

3,46892E0

2,35161E-1

1,01678E0

6,90030E-1

3,47414E-1

1,70288E-2

1,63049E-1

8,97471E-1

2,82663E0

1,06880E-1

6,67533E-1

3.8

jsim

1,08453E-1

1,19996E0

1,55128E0

1,05853E-1

3,82012E0

1,17009E-1

9,10318E-1

8,47489E-1

3,41688E-1

1,66851E-2

1,01041E-1

6,64418E-1

2,68554E0

5,46474E-2

6,67195E-1

3.8

min

1,00135E-1

8,91628E-1

1,41019E0

1,03330E-1

3,46892E0

8,15206E-2

8,75621E-1

6,90030E-1

3,15553E-1

1,66380E-2

5,33686E-2

5,65069E-1

2,61957E0

2,68196E-2

6,66747E-1

3.8

max

1,18752E-1

1,35780E0

1,61726E0

1,13197E-1

3,95496E0

2,35161E-1

1,01678E0

9,47964E-1

3,47414E-1

1,70288E-2

1,63049E-1

8,97471E-1

2,82663E0

1,06880E-1

6,67533E-1

3.8

mean

1,08453E-1

1,19996E0

1,55128E0

1,05853E-1

3,82012E0

1,17009E-1

9,10318E-1

8,47489E-1

3,41688E-1

1,66851E-2

1,01041E-1

6,64418E-1

2,68554E0

5,46474E-2

6,67195E-1

3.8

relative error(%)

0,00

4.0

BioUML

1,07851E-1

1,30397E0

1,58105E0

1,06120E-1

3,85994E0

1,06011E-1

9,12722E-1

8,79250E-1

3,40199E-1

1,67804E-2

1,11112E-1

6,35600E-1

2,65578E0

5,55859E-2

6,89953E-1

4.0

ByoDyn

1,07851E-1

1,30397E0

1,58105E0

1,06120E-1

3,85994E0

1,06011E-1

9,12722E-1

8,79250E-1

3,40199E-1

1,67804E-2

1,11112E-1

6,35600E-1

2,65578E0

5,55859E-2

6,89953E-1

4.0

Jarnac

1,00033E-1

1,45715E0

1,64762E0

1,04235E-1

3,98137E0

7,53057E-2

8,86514E-1

9,81312E-1

3,12492E-1

1,68152E-2

5,71437E-2

5,44874E-1

2,58921E0

2,73123E-2

6,89469E-1

4.0

MathSBML

1,07851E-1

1,30397E0

1,58105E0

1,06120E-1

3,85994E0

1,06011E-1

9,12722E-1

8,79250E-1

3,40199E-1

1,67804E-2

1,11112E-1

6,35600E-1

2,65578E0

5,55859E-2

6,89953E-1

4.0

Oscill8 Core

1,07851E-1

1,30397E0

1,58105E0

1,06120E-1

3,85994E0

1,06012E-1

9,12721E-1

8,79251E-1

3,40198E-1

1,67804E-2

1,11112E-1

6,35600E-1

2,65578E0

5,55859E-2

6,89953E-1

4.0

SBToolbox2

1,07876E-1

1,30398E0

1,58120E0

1,06122E-1

3,86000E0

1,05966E-1

9,12730E-1

8,79266E-1

3,40288E-1

1,67824E-2

1,11064E-1

6,35560E-1

2,65566E0

5,55774E-2

6,89938E-1

4.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,07851E-1

1,30397E0

1,58105E0

1,06120E-1

3,85994E0

1,06012E-1

9,12721E-1

8,79250E-1

3,40198E-1

1,67804E-2

1,11112E-1

6,35600E-1

2,65578E0

5,55859E-2

6,89953E-1

4.0

VCell

1,07851E-1

1,30397E0

1,58105E0

1,06120E-1

3,85994E0

1,06011E-1

9,12722E-1

8,79250E-1

3,40199E-1

1,67804E-2

1,11112E-1

6,35600E-1

2,65578E0

5,55859E-2

6,89953E-1

4.0

copasi

1,07851E-1

1,30397E0

1,58105E0

1,06120E-1

3,85994E0

1,06012E-1

9,12722E-1

8,79251E-1

3,40198E-1

1,67804E-2

1,11112E-1

6,35601E-1

2,65578E0

5,55859E-2

6,89953E-1

4.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,21767E-1

9,90995E-1

1,45596E0

1,13060E-1

3,52534E0

2,13886E-1

1,01272E0

7,20200E-1

3,59760E-1

1,72646E-2

1,73476E-1

8,62325E-1

2,78087E0

1,08323E-1

6,90419E-1

4.0

jsim

1,07851E-1

1,30397E0

1,58105E0

1,06120E-1

3,85994E0

1,06011E-1

9,12722E-1

8,79250E-1

3,40199E-1

1,67804E-2

1,11112E-1

6,35600E-1

2,65578E0

5,55859E-2

6,89953E-1

4.0

min

1,00033E-1

9,90995E-1

1,45596E0

1,04235E-1

3,52534E0

7,53057E-2

8,86514E-1

7,20200E-1

3,12492E-1

1,67804E-2

5,71437E-2

5,44874E-1

2,58921E0

2,73123E-2

6,89469E-1

4.0

max

1,21767E-1

1,45715E0

1,64762E0

1,13060E-1

3,98137E0

2,13886E-1

1,01272E0

9,81312E-1

3,59760E-1

1,72646E-2

1,73476E-1

8,62325E-1

2,78087E0

1,08323E-1

6,90419E-1

4.0

mean

1,07851E-1

1,30397E0

1,58105E0

1,06120E-1

3,85994E0

1,06011E-1

9,12722E-1

8,79250E-1

3,40199E-1

1,67804E-2

1,11112E-1

6,35600E-1

2,65578E0

5,55859E-2

6,89953E-1

4.0

relative error(%)

0,00

4.2

BioUML

1,06805E-1

1,40894E0

1,60942E0

1,06315E-1

3,89893E0

9,57161E-2

9,14156E-1

9,11869E-1

3,36914E-1

1,68525E-2

1,22493E-1

6,06901E-1

2,62742E0

5,66293E-2

7,12292E-1

4.2

ByoDyn

1,06805E-1

1,40894E0

1,60942E0

1,06315E-1

3,89893E0

9,57161E-2

9,14156E-1

9,11869E-1

3,36914E-1

1,68525E-2

1,22493E-1

6,06901E-1

2,62742E0

5,66293E-2

7,12292E-1

4.2

Jarnac

9,97269E-2

1,55700E0

1,67781E0

1,05104E-1

4,00711E0

6,94635E-2

8,96977E-1

1,01556E0

3,08558E-1

1,69842E-2

6,13537E-2

5,24975E-1

2,55903E0

2,78437E-2

7,11777E-1

4.2

MathSBML

1,06805E-1

1,40894E0

1,60942E0

1,06315E-1

3,89893E0

9,57161E-2

9,14156E-1

9,11869E-1

3,36914E-1

1,68525E-2

1,22493E-1

6,06901E-1

2,62742E0

5,66293E-2

7,12292E-1

4.2

Oscill8 Core

1,06805E-1

1,40894E0

1,60942E0

1,06315E-1

3,89893E0

9,57164E-2

9,14156E-1

9,11870E-1

3,36913E-1

1,68525E-2

1,22494E-1

6,06901E-1

2,62742E0

5,66294E-2

7,12292E-1

4.2

SBToolbox2

1,06825E-1

1,40897E0

1,60951E0

1,06316E-1

3,89900E0

9,56692E-2

9,14179E-1

9,11873E-1

3,36994E-1

1,68537E-2

1,22438E-1

6,06861E-1

2,62729E0

5,66209E-2

7,12274E-1

4.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,06805E-1

1,40894E0

1,60942E0

1,06315E-1

3,89893E0

9,57163E-2

9,14156E-1

9,11869E-1

3,36913E-1

1,68525E-2

1,22494E-1

6,06901E-1

2,62742E0

5,66294E-2

7,12292E-1

4.2

VCell

1,06805E-1

1,40894E0

1,60942E0

1,06315E-1

3,89893E0

9,57161E-2

9,14156E-1

9,11869E-1

3,36914E-1

1,68525E-2

1,22493E-1

6,06901E-1

2,62742E0

5,66293E-2

7,12292E-1

4.2

copasi

1,06805E-1

1,40894E0

1,60942E0

1,06315E-1

3,89893E0

9,57163E-2

9,14157E-1

9,11870E-1

3,36914E-1

1,68525E-2

1,22493E-1

6,06902E-1

2,62742E0

5,66293E-2

7,12292E-1

4.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,23153E-1

1,09608E0

1,49483E0

1,12740E-1

3,58380E0

1,92761E-1

1,00633E0

7,49690E-1

3,67612E-1

1,73928E-2

1,87003E-1

8,24981E-1

2,74201E0

1,09883E-1

7,12874E-1

4.2

jsim

1,06805E-1

1,40894E0

1,60942E0

1,06315E-1

3,89893E0

9,57161E-2

9,14156E-1

9,11869E-1

3,36914E-1

1,68525E-2

1,22493E-1

6,06901E-1

2,62742E0

5,66293E-2

7,12292E-1

4.2

min

9,97269E-2

1,09608E0

1,49483E0

1,05104E-1

3,58380E0

6,94635E-2

8,96977E-1

7,49690E-1

3,08558E-1

1,68525E-2

6,13537E-2

5,24975E-1

2,55903E0

2,78437E-2

7,11777E-1

4.2

max

1,23153E-1

1,55700E0

1,67781E0

1,12740E-1

4,00711E0

1,92761E-1

1,00633E0

1,01556E0

3,67612E-1

1,73928E-2

1,87003E-1

8,24981E-1

2,74201E0

1,09883E-1

7,12874E-1

4.2

mean

1,06805E-1

1,40894E0

1,60942E0

1,06315E-1

3,89893E0

9,57161E-2

9,14156E-1

9,11869E-1

3,36914E-1

1,68525E-2

1,22493E-1

6,06901E-1

2,62742E0

5,66293E-2

7,12292E-1

4.2

relative error(%)

0,00

4.4

BioUML

1,05394E-1

1,51426E0

1,63693E0

1,06431E-1

3,93688E0

8,61520E-2

9,14511E-1

9,45474E-1

3,32172E-1

1,69064E-2

1,35301E-1

5,78505E-1

2,59991E0

5,77912E-2

7,34238E-1

4.4

ByoDyn

1,05394E-1

1,51426E0

1,63693E0

1,06431E-1

3,93688E0

8,61520E-2

9,14511E-1

9,45474E-1

3,32172E-1

1,69064E-2

1,35301E-1

5,78505E-1

2,59991E0

5,77912E-2

7,34238E-1

4.4

Jarnac

9,92539E-2

1,65706E0

1,70806E0

1,05938E-1

4,03207E0

6,40034E-2

9,06984E-1

1,05075E0

3,03924E-1

1,71476E-2

6,60261E-2

5,05472E-1

2,52879E0

2,84184E-2

7,33697E-1

4.4

MathSBML

1,05394E-1

1,51426E0

1,63693E0

1,06431E-1

3,93688E0

8,61520E-2

9,14511E-1

9,45474E-1

3,32172E-1

1,69064E-2

1,35301E-1

5,78505E-1

2,59991E0

5,77912E-2

7,34238E-1

4.4

Oscill8 Core

1,05394E-1

1,51426E0

1,63693E0

1,06431E-1

3,93688E0

8,61522E-2

9,14510E-1

9,45474E-1

3,32171E-1

1,69064E-2

1,35301E-1

5,78505E-1

2,59991E0

5,77913E-2

7,34238E-1

4.4

SBToolbox2

1,05415E-1

1,51427E0

1,63703E0

1,06430E-1

3,93696E0

8,61044E-2

9,14534E-1

9,45468E-1

3,32239E-1

1,69077E-2

1,35241E-1

5,78460E-1

2,59982E0

5,77822E-2

7,34220E-1

4.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,05394E-1

1,51426E0

1,63693E0

1,06431E-1

3,93688E0

8,61522E-2

9,14510E-1

9,45474E-1

3,32171E-1

1,69064E-2

1,35301E-1

5,78505E-1

2,59991E0

5,77913E-2

7,34238E-1

4.4

VCell

1,05394E-1

1,51426E0

1,63693E0

1,06431E-1

3,93688E0

8,61520E-2

9,14511E-1

9,45474E-1

3,32172E-1

1,69064E-2

1,35301E-1

5,78505E-1

2,59991E0

5,77912E-2

7,34238E-1

4.4

copasi

1,05394E-1

1,51426E0

1,63693E0

1,06431E-1

3,93688E0

8,61522E-2

9,14511E-1

9,45474E-1

3,32172E-1

1,69064E-2

1,35301E-1

5,78506E-1

2,59991E0

5,77912E-2

7,34238E-1

4.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,23158E-1

1,20531E0

1,52823E0

1,12250E-1

3,64325E0

1,72277E-1

9,97734E-1

7,79124E-1

3,71528E-1

1,74369E-2

2,03509E-1

7,86012E-1

2,70861E0

1,11589E-1

7,34925E-1

4.4

jsim

1,05394E-1

1,51426E0

1,63693E0

1,06431E-1

3,93688E0

8,61520E-2

9,14511E-1

9,45474E-1

3,32172E-1

1,69064E-2

1,35301E-1

5,78505E-1

2,59991E0

5,77912E-2

7,34238E-1

4.4

min

9,92539E-2

1,20531E0

1,52823E0

1,05938E-1

3,64325E0

6,40034E-2

9,06984E-1

7,79124E-1

3,03924E-1

1,69064E-2

6,60261E-2

5,05472E-1

2,52879E0

2,84184E-2

7,33697E-1

4.4

max

1,23158E-1

1,65706E0

1,70806E0

1,12250E-1

4,03207E0

1,72277E-1

9,97734E-1

1,05075E0

3,71528E-1

1,74369E-2

2,03509E-1

7,86012E-1

2,70861E0

1,11589E-1

7,34925E-1

4.4

mean

1,05394E-1

1,51426E0

1,63693E0

1,06431E-1

3,93688E0

8,61520E-2

9,14511E-1

9,45474E-1

3,32172E-1

1,69064E-2

1,35301E-1

5,78505E-1

2,59991E0

5,77912E-2

7,34238E-1

4.4

relative error(%)

0,00

4.6

BioUML

1,03683E-1

1,61939E0

1,66401E0

1,06461E-1

3,97364E0

7,73273E-2

9,13676E-1

9,80146E-1

3,26247E-1

1,69461E-2

1,49655E-1

5,50570E-1

2,57284E0

5,90861E-2

7,55815E-1

4.6

ByoDyn

1,03683E-1

1,61939E0

1,66401E0

1,06461E-1

3,97364E0

7,73273E-2

9,13676E-1

9,80146E-1

3,26247E-1

1,69461E-2

1,49655E-1

5,50570E-1

2,57284E0

5,90861E-2

7,55815E-1

4.6

Jarnac

9,86441E-2

1,75704E0

1,73857E0

1,06735E-1

4,05616E0

5,89262E-2

9,16510E-1

1,08690E0

2,98734E-1

1,73075E-2

7,11862E-2

4,86452E-1

2,49828E0

2,90408E-2

7,55253E-1

4.6

MathSBML

1,03683E-1

1,61939E0

1,66401E0

1,06461E-1

3,97364E0

7,73273E-2

9,13676E-1

9,80146E-1

3,26247E-1

1,69461E-2

1,49655E-1

5,50570E-1

2,57284E0

5,90861E-2

7,55815E-1

4.6

Oscill8 Core

1,03683E-1

1,61939E0

1,66401E0

1,06461E-1

3,97364E0

7,73275E-2

9,13676E-1

9,80146E-1

3,26247E-1

1,69461E-2

1,49655E-1

5,50571E-1

2,57284E0

5,90862E-2

7,55815E-1

4.6

SBToolbox2

1,03701E-1

1,61946E0

1,66410E0

1,06460E-1

3,97377E0

7,72816E-2

9,13712E-1

9,80140E-1

3,26307E-1

1,69471E-2

1,49585E-1

5,50519E-1

2,57274E0

5,90767E-2

7,55798E-1

4.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,03683E-1

1,61939E0

1,66401E0

1,06461E-1

3,97364E0

7,73275E-2

9,13676E-1

9,80146E-1

3,26246E-1

1,69461E-2

1,49656E-1

5,50571E-1

2,57284E0

5,90862E-2

7,55815E-1

4.6

VCell

1,03683E-1

1,61939E0

1,66401E0

1,06461E-1

3,97364E0

7,73273E-2

9,13676E-1

9,80146E-1

3,26247E-1

1,69461E-2

1,49655E-1

5,50570E-1

2,57284E0

5,90861E-2

7,55815E-1

4.6

copasi

1,03683E-1

1,61939E0

1,66401E0

1,06461E-1

3,97364E0

7,73274E-2

9,13676E-1

9,80146E-1

3,26247E-1

1,69461E-2

1,49655E-1

5,50571E-1

2,57284E0

5,90861E-2

7,55815E-1

4.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,22004E-1

1,31726E0

1,55746E0

1,11589E-1

3,70294E0

1,52749E-1

9,86850E-1

8,08982E-1

3,72068E-1

1,74141E-2

2,23095E-1

7,45855E-1

2,67939E0

1,13472E-1

7,56595E-1

4.6

jsim

1,03683E-1

1,61939E0

1,66401E0

1,06461E-1

3,97364E0

7,73273E-2

9,13676E-1

9,80146E-1

3,26247E-1

1,69461E-2

1,49655E-1

5,50570E-1

2,57284E0

5,90861E-2

7,55815E-1

4.6

min

9,86441E-2

1,31726E0

1,55746E0

1,06460E-1

3,70294E0

5,89262E-2

9,13676E-1

8,08982E-1

2,98734E-1

1,69461E-2

7,11862E-2

4,86452E-1

2,49828E0

2,90408E-2

7,55253E-1

4.6

max

1,22004E-1

1,75704E0

1,73857E0

1,11589E-1

4,05616E0

1,52749E-1

9,86850E-1

1,08690E0

3,72068E-1

1,74141E-2

2,23095E-1

7,45855E-1

2,67939E0

1,13472E-1

7,56595E-1

4.6

mean

1,03683E-1

1,61939E0

1,66401E0

1,06461E-1

3,97364E0

7,73273E-2

9,13676E-1

9,80146E-1

3,26247E-1

1,69461E-2

1,49655E-1

5,50570E-1

2,57284E0

5,90861E-2

7,55815E-1

4.6

relative error(%)

0,00

4.8

BioUML

1,01726E-1

1,72392E0

1,69099E0

1,06397E-1

4,00906E0

6,92346E-2

9,11551E-1

1,01593E0

3,19365E-1

1,69747E-2

1,65678E-1

5,23236E-1

2,54586E0

6,05298E-2

7,77045E-1

4.8

ByoDyn

1,01726E-1

1,72392E0

1,69099E0

1,06397E-1

4,00906E0

6,92346E-2

9,11551E-1

1,01593E0

3,19365E-1

1,69747E-2

1,65678E-1

5,23236E-1

2,54586E0

6,05298E-2

7,77045E-1

4.8

Jarnac

9,79239E-2

1,85676E0

1,76950E0

1,07495E-1

4,07932E0

5,42268E-2

9,25541E-1

1,12401E0

2,93108E-1

1,74657E-2

7,68566E-2

4,67987E-1

2,46736E0

2,97160E-2

7,76467E-1

4.8

MathSBML

1,01726E-1

1,72392E0

1,69099E0

1,06397E-1

4,00906E0

6,92346E-2

9,11551E-1

1,01593E0

3,19365E-1

1,69747E-2

1,65678E-1

5,23236E-1

2,54586E0

6,05298E-2

7,77045E-1

4.8

Oscill8 Core

1,01726E-1

1,72392E0

1,69099E0

1,06397E-1

4,00906E0

6,92349E-2

9,11551E-1

1,01593E0

3,19364E-1

1,69747E-2

1,65678E-1

5,23236E-1

2,54586E0

6,05298E-2

7,77045E-1

4.8

SBToolbox2

1,01738E-1

1,72400E0

1,69103E0

1,06400E-1

4,00918E0

6,91928E-2

9,11597E-1

1,01594E0

3,19413E-1

1,69755E-2

1,65602E-1

5,23178E-1

2,54582E0

6,05205E-2

7,77026E-1

4.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,01726E-1

1,72392E0

1,69099E0

1,06397E-1

4,00906E0

6,92348E-2

9,11551E-1

1,01593E0

3,19364E-1

1,69747E-2

1,65678E-1

5,23236E-1

2,54586E0

6,05298E-2

7,77045E-1

4.8

VCell

1,01726E-1

1,72392E0

1,69099E0

1,06397E-1

4,00906E0

6,92346E-2

9,11551E-1

1,01593E0

3,19365E-1

1,69747E-2

1,65678E-1

5,23236E-1

2,54586E0

6,05298E-2

7,77045E-1

4.8

copasi

1,01726E-1

1,72392E0

1,69099E0

1,06397E-1

4,00906E0

6,92346E-2

9,11551E-1

1,01593E0

3,19365E-1

1,69747E-2

1,65677E-1

5,23237E-1

2,54586E0

6,05298E-2

7,77046E-1

4.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,19877E-1

1,43072E0

1,58358E0

1,10742E-1

3,76229E0

1,34377E-1

9,73495E-1

8,39624E-1

3,69743E-1

1,73364E-2

2,45973E-1

7,04870E-1

2,65328E0

1,15563E-1

7,77906E-1

4.8

jsim

1,01726E-1

1,72392E0

1,69099E0

1,06397E-1

4,00906E0

6,92346E-2

9,11551E-1

1,01593E0

3,19365E-1

1,69747E-2

1,65678E-1

5,23236E-1

2,54586E0

6,05298E-2

7,77045E-1

4.8

min

9,79239E-2

1,43072E0

1,58358E0

1,06397E-1

3,76229E0

5,42268E-2

9,11551E-1

8,39624E-1

2,93108E-1

1,69747E-2

7,68566E-2

4,67987E-1

2,46736E0

2,97160E-2

7,76467E-1

4.8

max

1,19877E-1

1,85676E0

1,76950E0

1,10742E-1

4,07932E0

1,34377E-1

9,73495E-1

1,12401E0

3,69743E-1

1,74657E-2

2,45973E-1

7,04870E-1

2,65328E0

1,15563E-1

7,77906E-1

4.8

mean

1,01726E-1

1,72392E0

1,69099E0

1,06397E-1

4,00906E0

6,92346E-2

9,11551E-1

1,01593E0

3,19365E-1

1,69747E-2

1,65678E-1

5,23236E-1

2,54586E0

6,05298E-2

7,77045E-1

4.8

relative error(%)

0,00

5.0

BioUML

9,95673E-2

1,82747E0

1,71811E0

1,06235E-1

4,04305E0

6,18549E-2

9,08040E-1

1,05284E0

3,11709E-1

1,69945E-2

1,83490E-1

4,96624E-1

2,51875E0

6,21392E-2

7,97948E-1

5.0

ByoDyn

9,95673E-2

1,82747E0

1,71811E0

1,06235E-1

4,04305E0

6,18549E-2

9,08040E-1

1,05284E0

3,11709E-1

1,69945E-2

1,83490E-1

4,96624E-1

2,51875E0

6,21392E-2

7,97948E-1

5.0

Jarnac

9,71164E-2

1,95602E0

1,80095E0

1,08218E-1

4,10150E0

4,98951E-2

9,34067E-1

1,16206E0

2,87145E-1

1,76238E-2

8,30566E-2

4,50137E-1

2,43592E0

3,04489E-2

7,97357E-1

5.0

MathSBML

9,95673E-2

1,82747E0

1,71811E0

1,06235E-1

4,04305E0

6,18549E-2

9,08040E-1

1,05284E0

3,11709E-1

1,69945E-2

1,83490E-1

4,96624E-1

2,51875E0

6,21392E-2

7,97948E-1

5.0

Oscill8 Core

9,95673E-2

1,82747E0

1,71811E0

1,06234E-1

4,04305E0

6,18552E-2

9,08040E-1

1,05284E0

3,11709E-1

1,69945E-2

1,83490E-1

4,96624E-1

2,51875E0

6,21392E-2

7,97948E-1

5.0

SBToolbox2

9,95775E-2

1,82755E0

1,71815E0

1,06235E-1

4,04315E0

6,18140E-2

9,08085E-1

1,05285E0

3,11750E-1

1,69955E-2

1,83410E-1

4,96565E-1

2,51870E0

6,21295E-2

7,97930E-1

5.0

SBWOdeSolver

9,95672E-2

1,82747E0

1,71811E0

1,06234E-1

4,04305E0

6,18552E-2

9,08040E-1

1,05284E0

3,11709E-1

1,69945E-2

1,83490E-1

4,96624E-1

2,51875E0

6,21392E-2

7,97948E-1

5.0

VCell

9,95673E-2

1,82747E0

1,71811E0

1,06235E-1

4,04305E0

6,18549E-2

9,08040E-1

1,05284E0

3,11709E-1

1,69945E-2

1,83490E-1

4,96624E-1

2,51875E0

6,21392E-2

7,97948E-1

5.0

copasi

9,95674E-2

1,82747E0

1,71811E0

1,06235E-1

4,04305E0

6,18550E-2

9,08041E-1

1,05284E0

3,11709E-1

1,69945E-2

1,83489E-1

4,96624E-1

2,51875E0

6,21392E-2

7,97948E-1

5.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,16933E-1

1,54463E0

1,60746E0

1,09695E-1

3,82086E0

1,17290E-1

9,57450E-1

8,71318E-1

3,64988E-1

1,72126E-2

2,72407E-1

6,63377E-1

2,62941E0

1,17895E-1

7,98879E-1

5.0

jsim

9,95673E-2

1,82747E0

1,71811E0

1,06235E-1

4,04305E0

6,18550E-2

9,08040E-1

1,05284E0

3,11709E-1

1,69945E-2

1,83490E-1

4,96624E-1

2,51875E0

6,21392E-2

7,97948E-1

5.0

min

9,71164E-2

1,54463E0

1,60746E0

1,06234E-1

3,82086E0

4,98951E-2

9,08040E-1

8,71318E-1

2,87145E-1

1,69945E-2

8,30566E-2

4,50137E-1

2,43592E0

3,04489E-2

7,97357E-1

5.0

max

1,16933E-1

1,95602E0

1,80095E0

1,09695E-1

4,10150E0

1,17290E-1

9,57450E-1

1,16206E0

3,64988E-1

1,76238E-2

2,72407E-1

6,63377E-1

2,62941E0

1,17895E-1

7,98879E-1

5.0

mean

9,95673E-2

1,82747E0

1,71811E0

1,06235E-1

4,04305E0

6,18549E-2

9,08040E-1

1,05284E0

3,11709E-1

1,69945E-2

1,83490E-1

4,96624E-1

2,51875E0

6,21392E-2

7,97948E-1

5.0

relative error(%)

0,00

5.2

BioUML

9,72460E-2

1,92974E0

1,74555E0

1,05966E-1

4,07553E0

5,51608E-2

9,03060E-1

1,09085E0

3,03433E-1

1,70077E-2

2,03206E-1

4,70838E-1

2,49133E0

6,39324E-2

8,18540E-1

5.2

ByoDyn

9,72460E-2

1,92974E0

1,74555E0

1,05966E-1

4,07553E0

5,51608E-2

9,03060E-1

1,09085E0

3,03433E-1

1,70077E-2

2,03206E-1

4,70838E-1

2,49133E0

6,39324E-2

8,18540E-1

5.2

Jarnac

9,62426E-2

2,05469E0

1,83299E0

1,08906E-1

4,12266E0

4,59169E-2

9,42084E-1

1,20102E0

2,80933E-1

1,77830E-2

8,98017E-2

4,32951E-1

2,40388E0

3,12449E-2

8,17940E-1

5.2

MathSBML

9,72460E-2

1,92974E0

1,74555E0

1,05966E-1

4,07553E0

5,51607E-2

9,03060E-1

1,09085E0

3,03433E-1

1,70077E-2

2,03206E-1

4,70838E-1

2,49133E0

6,39324E-2

8,18540E-1

5.2

Oscill8 Core

9,72460E-2

1,92974E0

1,74555E0

1,05966E-1

4,07553E0

5,51610E-2

9,03060E-1

1,09085E0

3,03433E-1

1,70077E-2

2,03207E-1

4,70839E-1

2,49133E0

6,39325E-2

8,18540E-1

5.2

SBToolbox2

9,72534E-2

1,92985E0

1,74557E0

1,05970E-1

4,07567E0

5,51214E-2

9,03111E-1

1,09081E0

3,03464E-1

1,70080E-2

2,03124E-1

4,70770E-1

2,49133E0

6,39226E-2

8,18520E-1

5.2

SBWOdeSolver

9,72460E-2

1,92974E0

1,74555E0

1,05966E-1

4,07553E0

5,51610E-2

9,03060E-1

1,09085E0

3,03433E-1

1,70077E-2

2,03207E-1

4,70839E-1

2,49133E0

6,39325E-2

8,18540E-1

5.2

VCell

9,72460E-2

1,92974E0

1,74555E0

1,05966E-1

4,07553E0

5,51608E-2

9,03060E-1

1,09085E0

3,03433E-1

1,70077E-2

2,03206E-1

4,70838E-1

2,49133E0

6,39324E-2

8,18540E-1

5.2

copasi

9,72460E-2

1,92974E0

1,74555E0

1,05966E-1

4,07553E0

5,51608E-2

9,03061E-1

1,09085E0

3,03433E-1

1,70077E-2

2,03206E-1

4,70838E-1

2,49133E0

6,39324E-2

8,18540E-1

5.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,13300E-1

1,65810E0

1,62978E0

1,08429E-1

3,87828E0

1,01563E-1

9,38498E-1

9,04251E-1

3,58164E-1

1,70489E-2

3,02681E-1

6,21682E-1

2,60710E0

1,20505E-1

8,19530E-1

5.2

jsim

9,72460E-2

1,92974E0

1,74555E0

1,05966E-1

4,07553E0

5,51608E-2

9,03060E-1

1,09085E0

3,03433E-1

1,70076E-2

2,03206E-1

4,70838E-1

2,49133E0

6,39324E-2

8,18540E-1

5.2

min

9,62426E-2

1,65810E0

1,62978E0

1,05966E-1

3,87828E0

4,59169E-2

9,03060E-1

9,04251E-1

2,80933E-1

1,70076E-2

8,98017E-2

4,32951E-1

2,40388E0

3,12449E-2

8,17940E-1

5.2

max

1,13300E-1

2,05469E0

1,83299E0

1,08906E-1

4,12266E0

1,01563E-1

9,42084E-1

1,20102E0

3,58164E-1

1,77830E-2

3,02681E-1

6,21682E-1

2,60710E0

1,20505E-1

8,19530E-1

5.2

mean

9,72460E-2

1,92974E0

1,74555E0

1,05966E-1

4,07553E0

5,51608E-2

9,03060E-1

1,09085E0

3,03433E-1

1,70077E-2

2,03206E-1

4,70838E-1

2,49133E0

6,39324E-2

8,18540E-1

5.2

relative error(%)

0,00

5.4

BioUML

9,47963E-2

2,03048E0

1,77341E0

1,05586E-1

4,10643E0

4,91185E-2

8,96541E-1

1,12991E0

2,94667E-1

1,70158E-2

2,24934E-1

4,45973E-1

2,46347E0

6,59286E-2

8,38838E-1

5.4

ByoDyn

9,47963E-2

2,03048E0

1,77341E0

1,05586E-1

4,10643E0

4,91185E-2

8,96541E-1

1,12991E0

2,94667E-1

1,70158E-2

2,24934E-1

4,45973E-1

2,46347E0

6,59286E-2

8,38838E-1

5.4

Jarnac

9,53209E-2

2,15264E0

1,86569E0

1,09558E-1

4,14278E0

4,22755E-2

9,49595E-1

1,24086E0

2,74546E-1

1,79444E-2

9,71024E-2

4,16468E-1

2,37119E0

3,21093E-2

8,38233E-1

5.4

MathSBML

9,47963E-2

2,03048E0

1,77341E0

1,05586E-1

4,10643E0

4,91185E-2

8,96541E-1

1,12991E0

2,94667E-1

1,70158E-2

2,24934E-1

4,45973E-1

2,46347E0

6,59286E-2

8,38838E-1

5.4

Oscill8 Core

9,47963E-2

2,03048E0

1,77341E0

1,05586E-1

4,10643E0

4,91187E-2

8,96541E-1

1,12991E0

2,94667E-1

1,70158E-2

2,24934E-1

4,45973E-1

2,46347E0

6,59286E-2

8,38838E-1

5.4

SBToolbox2

9,48005E-2

2,03060E0

1,77344E0

1,05591E-1

4,10654E0

4,90834E-2

8,96590E-1

1,12992E0

2,94693E-1

1,70160E-2

2,24854E-1

4,45899E-1

2,46346E0

6,59183E-2

8,38820E-1

5.4

SBWOdeSolver

9,47962E-2

2,03048E0

1,77341E0

1,05586E-1

4,10643E0

4,91185E-2

8,96542E-1

1,12992E0

2,94667E-1

1,70158E-2

2,24934E-1

4,45975E-1

2,46347E0

6,59286E-2

8,38838E-1

5.4

VCell

9,47963E-2

2,03048E0

1,77341E0

1,05586E-1

4,10643E0

4,91185E-2

8,96541E-1

1,12991E0

2,94667E-1

1,70158E-2

2,24934E-1

4,45973E-1

2,46347E0

6,59286E-2

8,38838E-1

5.4

copasi

9,47964E-2

2,03048E0

1,77341E0

1,05586E-1

4,10643E0

4,91185E-2

8,96541E-1

1,12991E0

2,94667E-1

1,70158E-2

2,24933E-1

4,45973E-1

2,46347E0

6,59286E-2

8,38838E-1

5.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,09088E-1

1,77034E0

1,65106E0

1,06925E-1

3,93419E0

8,72399E-2

9,16447E-1

9,38541E-1

3,49564E-1

1,68505E-2

3,37062E-1

5,80093E-1

2,58582E0

1,23432E-1

8,39877E-1

5.4

jsim

9,47964E-2

2,03048E0

1,77341E0

1,05586E-1

4,10643E0

4,91186E-2

8,96541E-1

1,12991E0

2,94667E-1

1,70158E-2

2,24934E-1

4,45973E-1

2,46347E0

6,59286E-2

8,38838E-1

5.4

min

9,47962E-2

1,77034E0

1,65106E0

1,05586E-1

3,93419E0

4,22755E-2

8,96541E-1

9,38541E-1

2,74546E-1

1,68505E-2

9,71024E-2

4,16468E-1

2,37119E0

3,21093E-2

8,38233E-1

5.4

max

1,09088E-1

2,15264E0

1,86569E0

1,09558E-1

4,14278E0

8,72399E-2

9,49595E-1

1,24086E0

3,49564E-1

1,79444E-2

3,37062E-1

5,80093E-1

2,58582E0

1,23432E-1

8,39877E-1

5.4

mean

9,47963E-2

2,03048E0

1,77341E0

1,05586E-1

4,10643E0

4,91185E-2

8,96541E-1

1,12991E0

2,94667E-1

1,70158E-2

2,24934E-1

4,45973E-1

2,46347E0

6,59286E-2

8,38838E-1

5.4

relative error(%)

0,00

5.6

BioUML

9,22498E-2

2,12948E0

1,80179E0

1,05089E-1

4,13572E0

4,36908E-2

8,88431E-1

1,16997E0

2,85523E-1

1,70205E-2

2,48763E-1

4,22107E-1

2,43510E0

6,81478E-2

8,58857E-1

5.6

ByoDyn

9,22498E-2

2,12948E0

1,80179E0

1,05089E-1

4,13572E0

4,36908E-2

8,88431E-1

1,16997E0

2,85523E-1

1,70205E-2

2,48763E-1

4,22107E-1

2,43510E0

6,81478E-2

8,58857E-1

5.6

Jarnac

9,43681E-2

2,24978E0

1,89906E0

1,10177E-1

4,16186E0

3,89521E-2

9,56607E-1

1,28150E0

2,68049E-1

1,81089E-2

1,04965E-1

4,00712E-1

2,33783E0

3,30475E-2

8,58250E-1

5.6

MathSBML

9,22497E-2

2,12948E0

1,80179E0

1,05089E-1

4,13572E0

4,36908E-2

8,88431E-1

1,16997E0

2,85523E-1

1,70205E-2

2,48763E-1

4,22107E-1

2,43510E0

6,81478E-2

8,58857E-1

5.6

Oscill8 Core

9,22497E-2

2,12948E0

1,80179E0

1,05089E-1

4,13572E0

4,36910E-2

8,88431E-1

1,16997E0

2,85523E-1

1,70205E-2

2,48763E-1

4,22107E-1

2,43510E0

6,81479E-2

8,58857E-1

5.6

SBToolbox2

9,22508E-2

2,12956E0

1,80182E0

1,05091E-1

4,13582E0

4,36579E-2

8,88476E-1

1,16998E0

2,85538E-1

1,70204E-2

2,48686E-1

4,22030E-1

2,43508E0

6,81375E-2

8,58840E-1

5.6

SBWOdeSolver

9,22497E-2

2,12948E0

1,80179E0

1,05089E-1

4,13572E0

4,36911E-2

8,88429E-1

1,16997E0

2,85523E-1

1,70205E-2

2,48765E-1

4,22106E-1

2,43510E0

6,81479E-2

8,58857E-1

5.6

VCell

9,22498E-2

2,12948E0

1,80179E0

1,05089E-1

4,13572E0

4,36908E-2

8,88431E-1

1,16997E0

2,85523E-1

1,70205E-2

2,48763E-1

4,22107E-1

2,43510E0

6,81478E-2

8,58857E-1

5.6

copasi

9,22498E-2

2,12948E0

1,80179E0

1,05089E-1

4,13572E0

4,36908E-2

8,88431E-1

1,16997E0

2,85523E-1

1,70205E-2

2,48763E-1

4,22107E-1

2,43510E0

6,81478E-2

8,58857E-1

5.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,04395E-1

1,88070E0

1,67171E0

1,05165E-1

3,98824E0

7,43369E-2

8,91167E-1

9,74242E-1

3,39428E-1

1,66221E-2

3,75770E-1

5,38943E-1

2,56517E0

1,26717E-1

8,59936E-1

5.6

jsim

9,22498E-2

2,12948E0

1,80179E0

1,05089E-1

4,13572E0

4,36908E-2

8,88431E-1

1,16997E0

2,85523E-1

1,70205E-2

2,48763E-1

4,22107E-1

2,43510E0

6,81478E-2

8,58857E-1

5.6

min

9,22497E-2

1,88070E0

1,67171E0

1,05089E-1

3,98824E0

3,89521E-2

8,88429E-1

9,74242E-1

2,68049E-1

1,66221E-2

1,04965E-1

4,00712E-1

2,33783E0

3,30475E-2

8,58250E-1

5.6

max

1,04395E-1

2,24978E0

1,89906E0

1,10177E-1

4,16186E0

7,43369E-2

9,56607E-1

1,28150E0

3,39428E-1

1,81089E-2

3,75770E-1

5,38943E-1

2,56517E0

1,26717E-1

8,59936E-1

5.6

mean

9,22498E-2

2,12948E0

1,80179E0

1,05089E-1

4,13572E0

4,36908E-2

8,88431E-1

1,16997E0

2,85523E-1

1,70205E-2

2,48763E-1

4,22107E-1

2,43510E0

6,81478E-2

8,58857E-1

5.6

relative error(%)

0,00

5.8

BioUML

8,96358E-2

2,22654E0

1,83071E0

1,04472E-1

4,16337E0

3,88377E-2

8,78700E-1

1,21092E0

2,76103E-1

1,70233E-2

2,74765E-1

3,99310E-1

2,40618E0

7,06110E-2

8,78610E-1

5.8

ByoDyn

8,96358E-2

2,22654E0

1,83071E0

1,04472E-1

4,16337E0

3,88377E-2

8,78700E-1

1,21092E0

2,76103E-1

1,70233E-2

2,74765E-1

3,99310E-1

2,40618E0

7,06110E-2

8,78610E-1

5.8

Jarnac

9,33991E-2

2,34604E0

1,93311E0

1,10763E-1

4,17989E0

3,59266E-2

9,63135E-1

1,32290E0

2,61501E-1

1,82772E-2

1,13390E-1

3,85703E-1

2,30378E0

3,40650E-2

8,78003E-1

5.8

MathSBML

8,96358E-2

2,22654E0

1,83071E0

1,04472E-1

4,16337E0

3,88377E-2

8,78700E-1

1,21092E0

2,76103E-1

1,70233E-2

2,74765E-1

3,99310E-1

2,40618E0

7,06110E-2

8,78610E-1

5.8

Oscill8 Core

8,96358E-2

2,22654E0

1,83071E0

1,04472E-1

4,16337E0

3,88379E-2

8,78699E-1

1,21092E0

2,76103E-1

1,70233E-2

2,74766E-1

3,99311E-1

2,40618E0

7,06111E-2

8,78610E-1

5.8

SBToolbox2

8,96341E-2

2,22666E0

1,83073E0

1,04477E-1

4,16349E0

3,88068E-2

8,78737E-1

1,21088E0

2,76113E-1

1,70230E-2

2,74691E-1

3,99234E-1

2,40617E0

7,06002E-2

8,78592E-1

5.8

SBWOdeSolver

8,96357E-2

2,22654E0

1,83071E0

1,04472E-1

4,16337E0

3,88378E-2

8,78698E-1

1,21092E0

2,76103E-1

1,70233E-2

2,74767E-1

3,99310E-1

2,40618E0

7,06111E-2

8,78609E-1

5.8

VCell

8,96358E-2

2,22654E0

1,83071E0

1,04472E-1

4,16337E0

3,88377E-2

8,78700E-1

1,21092E0

2,76103E-1

1,70233E-2

2,74765E-1

3,99310E-1

2,40618E0

7,06110E-2

8,78610E-1

5.8

copasi

8,96358E-2

2,22654E0

1,83071E0

1,04472E-1

4,16337E0

3,88377E-2

8,78700E-1

1,21092E0

2,76103E-1

1,70233E-2

2,74765E-1

3,99310E-1

2,40618E0

7,06110E-2

8,78610E-1

5.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,93161E-2

1,98858E0

1,69202E0

1,03137E-1

4,04006E0

6,28518E-2

8,62616E-1

1,01134E0

3,27960E-1

1,63688E-2

4,18943E-1

4,98602E-1

2,54488E0

1,30404E-1

8,79719E-1

5.8

jsim

8,96358E-2

2,22654E0

1,83071E0

1,04472E-1

4,16337E0

3,88377E-2

8,78700E-1

1,21092E0

2,76103E-1

1,70233E-2

2,74765E-1

3,99310E-1

2,40618E0

7,06110E-2

8,78610E-1

5.8

min

8,96341E-2

1,98858E0

1,69202E0

1,03137E-1

4,04006E0

3,59266E-2

8,62616E-1

1,01134E0

2,61501E-1

1,63688E-2

1,13390E-1

3,85703E-1

2,30378E0

3,40650E-2

8,78003E-1

5.8

max

9,93161E-2

2,34604E0

1,93311E0

1,10763E-1

4,17989E0

6,28518E-2

9,63135E-1

1,32290E0

3,27960E-1

1,82772E-2

4,18943E-1

4,98602E-1

2,54488E0

1,30404E-1

8,79719E-1

5.8

mean

8,96358E-2

2,22654E0

1,83071E0

1,04472E-1

4,16337E0

3,88377E-2

8,78700E-1

1,21092E0

2,76103E-1

1,70233E-2

2,74765E-1

3,99310E-1

2,40618E0

7,06110E-2

8,78610E-1

5.8

relative error(%)

0,00

6.0

BioUML

8,69831E-2

2,32151E0

1,86019E0

1,03733E-1

4,18935E0

3,45182E-2

8,67344E-1

1,25264E0

2,66499E-1

1,70255E-2

3,02988E-1

3,77642E-1

2,37671E0

7,33397E-2

8,98109E-1

6.0

ByoDyn

8,69831E-2

2,32151E0

1,86019E0

1,03733E-1

4,18935E0

3,45182E-2

8,67344E-1

1,25264E0

2,66499E-1

1,70255E-2

3,02988E-1

3,77642E-1

2,37671E0

7,33397E-2

8,98109E-1

6.0

Jarnac

9,24273E-2

2,44134E0

1,96785E0

1,11319E-1

4,19689E0

3,31783E-2

9,69200E-1

1,36498E0

2,54952E-1

1,84498E-2

1,22372E-1

3,71448E-1

2,26905E0

3,51672E-2

8,97506E-1

6.0

MathSBML

8,69831E-2

2,32152E0

1,86019E0

1,03733E-1

4,18935E0

3,45182E-2

8,67344E-1

1,25264E0

2,66499E-1

1,70255E-2

3,02988E-1

3,77642E-1

2,37671E0

7,33396E-2

8,98109E-1

6.0

Oscill8 Core

8,69831E-2

2,32151E0

1,86019E0

1,03733E-1

4,18935E0

3,45183E-2

8,67344E-1

1,25264E0

2,66499E-1

1,70255E-2

3,02988E-1

3,77643E-1

2,37671E0

7,33397E-2

8,98109E-1

6.0

SBToolbox2

8,69794E-2

2,32168E0

1,86020E0

1,03734E-1

4,18948E0

3,44908E-2

8,67376E-1

1,25264E0

2,66504E-1

1,70250E-2

3,02918E-1

3,77560E-1

2,37670E0

7,33286E-2

8,98088E-1

6.0

SBWOdeSolver

8,69830E-2

2,32151E0

1,86019E0

1,03733E-1

4,18935E0

3,45183E-2

8,67343E-1

1,25264E0

2,66499E-1

1,70255E-2

3,02989E-1

3,77642E-1

2,37671E0

7,33398E-2

8,98109E-1

6.0

VCell

8,69831E-2

2,32151E0

1,86019E0

1,03733E-1

4,18935E0

3,45182E-2

8,67344E-1

1,25264E0

2,66499E-1

1,70255E-2

3,02988E-1

3,77642E-1

2,37671E0

7,33397E-2

8,98109E-1

6.0

copasi

8,69831E-2

2,32152E0

1,86019E0

1,03733E-1

4,18935E0

3,45182E-2

8,67344E-1

1,25264E0

2,66499E-1

1,70255E-2

3,02988E-1

3,77642E-1

2,37671E0

7,33396E-2

8,98109E-1

6.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,39522E-2

2,09346E0

1,71218E0

1,00834E-1

4,08926E0

5,27649E-2

8,30880E-1

1,04975E0

3,15342E-1

1,60968E-2

4,66600E-1

4,59487E-1

2,52472E0

1,34537E-1

8,99241E-1

6.0

jsim

8,69831E-2

2,32151E0

1,86019E0

1,03733E-1

4,18935E0

3,45182E-2

8,67344E-1

1,25264E0

2,66499E-1

1,70255E-2

3,02988E-1

3,77642E-1

2,37671E0

7,33396E-2

8,98109E-1

6.0

min

8,69794E-2

2,09346E0

1,71218E0

1,00834E-1

4,08926E0

3,31783E-2

8,30880E-1

1,04975E0

2,54952E-1

1,60968E-2

1,22372E-1

3,71448E-1

2,26905E0

3,51672E-2

8,97506E-1

6.0

max

9,39522E-2

2,44134E0

1,96785E0

1,11319E-1

4,19689E0

5,27649E-2

9,69200E-1

1,36498E0

3,15342E-1

1,84498E-2

4,66600E-1

4,59487E-1

2,52472E0

1,34537E-1

8,99241E-1

6.0

mean

8,69831E-2

2,32151E0

1,86019E0

1,03733E-1

4,18935E0

3,45182E-2

8,67344E-1

1,25264E0

2,66499E-1

1,70255E-2

3,02988E-1

3,77642E-1

2,37671E0

7,33397E-2

8,98109E-1

6.0

relative error(%)

0,00

6.2

BioUML

8,43198E-2

2,41427E0

1,89019E0

1,02870E-1

4,21367E0

3,06913E-2

8,54392E-1

1,29500E0

2,56797E-1

1,70286E-2

3,33446E-1

3,57155E-1

2,34671E0

7,63553E-2

9,17366E-1

6.2

ByoDyn

8,43198E-2

2,41427E0

1,89019E0

1,02870E-1

4,21367E0

3,06913E-2

8,54392E-1

1,29500E0

2,56797E-1

1,70286E-2

3,33446E-1

3,57155E-1

2,34671E0

7,63553E-2

9,17366E-1

6.2

Jarnac

9,14643E-2

2,53565E0

2,00324E0

1,11847E-1

4,21288E0

3,06862E-2

9,74826E-1

1,40766E0

2,48449E-1

1,86273E-2

1,31902E-1

3,57947E-1

2,23366E0

3,63594E-2

9,16769E-1

6.2

MathSBML

8,43198E-2

2,41427E0

1,89019E0

1,02870E-1

4,21367E0

3,06912E-2

8,54392E-1

1,29500E0

2,56797E-1

1,70286E-2

3,33446E-1

3,57154E-1

2,34671E0

7,63553E-2

9,17366E-1

6.2

Oscill8 Core

8,43198E-2

2,41427E0

1,89019E0

1,02870E-1

4,21367E0

3,06914E-2

8,54392E-1

1,29500E0

2,56797E-1

1,70286E-2

3,33446E-1

3,57155E-1

2,34671E0

7,63554E-2

9,17366E-1

6.2

SBToolbox2

8,43141E-2

2,41441E0

1,89017E0

1,02871E-1

4,21376E0

3,06666E-2

8,54422E-1

1,29500E0

2,56794E-1

1,70280E-2

3,33380E-1

3,57074E-1

2,34673E0

7,63440E-2

9,17345E-1

6.2

SBWOdeSolver

8,43198E-2

2,41427E0

1,89019E0

1,02870E-1

4,21367E0

3,06914E-2

8,54391E-1

1,29500E0

2,56797E-1

1,70286E-2

3,33447E-1

3,57155E-1

2,34671E0

7,63555E-2

9,17366E-1

6.2

VCell

8,43198E-2

2,41427E0

1,89019E0

1,02870E-1

4,21367E0

3,06913E-2

8,54392E-1

1,29500E0

2,56797E-1

1,70286E-2

3,33446E-1

3,57155E-1

2,34671E0

7,63553E-2

9,17366E-1

6.2

copasi

8,43198E-2

2,41427E0

1,89019E0

1,02870E-1

4,21367E0

3,06912E-2

8,54392E-1

1,29500E0

2,56797E-1

1,70286E-2

3,33446E-1

3,57154E-1

2,34671E0

7,63553E-2

9,17366E-1

6.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,84146E-2

2,19489E0

1,73235E0

9,82581E-2

4,13541E0

4,40385E-2

7,96193E-1

1,08932E0

3,01757E-1

1,58139E-2

5,18611E-1

4,22059E-1

2,50456E0

1,39159E-1

9,18512E-1

6.2

jsim

8,43198E-2

2,41427E0

1,89019E0

1,02870E-1

4,21367E0

3,06912E-2

8,54392E-1

1,29500E0

2,56797E-1

1,70286E-2

3,33446E-1

3,57155E-1

2,34671E0

7,63554E-2

9,17366E-1

6.2

min

8,43141E-2

2,19489E0

1,73235E0

9,82581E-2

4,13541E0

3,06666E-2

7,96193E-1

1,08932E0

2,48449E-1

1,58139E-2

1,31902E-1

3,57074E-1

2,23366E0

3,63594E-2

9,16769E-1

6.2

max

9,14643E-2

2,53565E0

2,00324E0

1,11847E-1

4,21376E0

4,40385E-2

9,74826E-1

1,40766E0

3,01757E-1

1,86273E-2

5,18611E-1

4,22059E-1

2,50456E0

1,39159E-1

9,18512E-1

6.2

mean

8,43198E-2

2,41427E0

1,89019E0

1,02870E-1

4,21367E0

3,06913E-2

8,54392E-1

1,29500E0

2,56797E-1

1,70286E-2

3,33446E-1

3,57155E-1

2,34671E0

7,63553E-2

9,17366E-1

6.2

relative error(%)

0,00

6.4

BioUML

8,16743E-2

2,50470E0

1,92069E0

1,01886E-1

4,23630E0

2,73165E-2

8,39904E-1

1,33785E0

2,47082E-1

1,70342E-2

3,66120E-1

3,37891E-1

2,31622E0

7,96798E-2

9,36391E-1

6.4

ByoDyn

8,16743E-2

2,50470E0

1,92069E0

1,01886E-1

4,23630E0

2,73165E-2

8,39904E-1

1,33785E0

2,47082E-1

1,70342E-2

3,66120E-1

3,37891E-1

2,31622E0

7,96798E-2

9,36391E-1

6.4

Jarnac

9,05203E-2

2,62893E0

2,03927E0

1,12350E-1

4,22789E0

2,84300E-2

9,80045E-1

1,45085E0

2,42031E-1

1,88098E-2

1,41963E-1

3,45192E-1

2,19765E0

3,76469E-2

9,35803E-1

6.4

MathSBML

8,16743E-2

2,50470E0

1,92069E0

1,01886E-1

4,23630E0

2,73165E-2

8,39904E-1

1,33785E0

2,47082E-1

1,70342E-2

3,66120E-1

3,37891E-1

2,31622E0

7,96798E-2

9,36391E-1

6.4

Oscill8 Core

8,16743E-2

2,50470E0

1,92069E0

1,01886E-1

4,23630E0

2,73166E-2

8,39904E-1

1,33785E0

2,47082E-1

1,70342E-2

3,66120E-1

3,37891E-1

2,31622E0

7,96799E-2

9,36391E-1

6.4

SBToolbox2

8,16675E-2

2,50482E0

1,92068E0

1,01892E-1

4,23640E0

2,72941E-2

8,39926E-1

1,33786E0

2,47074E-1

1,70340E-2

3,66058E-1

3,37815E-1

2,31622E0

7,96686E-2

9,36372E-1

6.4

SBWOdeSolver

8,16743E-2

2,50470E0

1,92069E0

1,01886E-1

4,23630E0

2,73166E-2

8,39903E-1

1,33785E0

2,47082E-1

1,70342E-2

3,66121E-1

3,37891E-1

2,31622E0

7,96799E-2

9,36391E-1

6.4

VCell

8,16743E-2

2,50470E0

1,92069E0

1,01886E-1

4,23630E0

2,73165E-2

8,39904E-1

1,33785E0

2,47082E-1

1,70342E-2

3,66120E-1

3,37891E-1

2,31622E0

7,96798E-2

9,36391E-1

6.4

copasi

8,16743E-2

2,50470E0

1,92069E0

1,01886E-1

4,23630E0

2,73165E-2

8,39904E-1

1,33785E0

2,47082E-1

1,70342E-2

3,66120E-1

3,37890E-1

2,31622E0

7,96798E-2

9,36391E-1

6.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,28286E-2

2,29247E0

1,75261E0

9,54224E-2

4,17809E0

3,66143E-2

7,58947E-1

1,12979E0

2,87402E-1

1,55298E-2

5,74681E-1

3,86806E-1

2,48431E0

1,44310E-1

9,37546E-1

6.4

jsim

8,16743E-2

2,50470E0

1,92069E0

1,01886E-1

4,23630E0

2,73165E-2

8,39904E-1

1,33785E0

2,47082E-1

1,70342E-2

3,66120E-1

3,37891E-1

2,31622E0

7,96798E-2

9,36391E-1

6.4

min

8,16675E-2

2,29247E0

1,75261E0

9,54224E-2

4,17809E0

2,72941E-2

7,58947E-1

1,12979E0

2,42031E-1

1,55298E-2

1,41963E-1

3,37815E-1

2,19765E0

3,76469E-2

9,35803E-1

6.4

max

9,05203E-2

2,62893E0

2,03927E0

1,12350E-1

4,23640E0

3,66143E-2

9,80045E-1

1,45085E0

2,87402E-1

1,88098E-2

5,74681E-1

3,86806E-1

2,48431E0

1,44310E-1

9,37546E-1

6.4

mean

8,16743E-2

2,50470E0

1,92069E0

1,01886E-1

4,23630E0

2,73165E-2

8,39904E-1

1,33785E0

2,47082E-1

1,70342E-2

3,66120E-1

3,37891E-1

2,31622E0

7,96798E-2

9,36391E-1

6.4

relative error(%)

0,00

6.6

BioUML

7,90748E-2

2,59272E0

1,95161E0

1,00785E-1

4,25726E0

2,43547E-2

8,23979E-1

1,38100E0

2,37433E-1

1,70439E-2

4,00951E-1

3,19886E-1

2,28531E0

8,33341E-2

9,55194E-1

6.6

ByoDyn

7,90748E-2

2,59272E0

1,95161E0

1,00785E-1

4,25726E0

2,43547E-2

8,23979E-1

1,38100E0

2,37433E-1

1,70439E-2

4,00951E-1

3,19886E-1

2,28531E0

8,33341E-2

9,55194E-1

6.6

Jarnac

8,96041E-2

2,72117E0

2,07588E0

1,12829E-1

4,24195E0

2,63894E-2

9,84890E-1

1,49448E0

2,35734E-1

1,89976E-2

1,52535E-1

3,33169E-1

2,16104E0

3,90347E-2

9,54616E-1

6.6

MathSBML

7,90748E-2

2,59272E0

1,95161E0

1,00785E-1

4,25726E0

2,43547E-2

8,23979E-1

1,38100E0

2,37433E-1

1,70439E-2

4,00951E-1

3,19886E-1

2,28531E0

8,33341E-2

9,55194E-1

6.6

Oscill8 Core

7,90748E-2

2,59272E0

1,95161E0

1,00785E-1

4,25726E0

2,43548E-2

8,23979E-1

1,38100E0

2,37433E-1

1,70439E-2

4,00952E-1

3,19887E-1

2,28531E0

8,33342E-2

9,55194E-1

6.6

SBToolbox2

7,90665E-2

2,59286E0

1,95161E0

1,00790E-1

4,25734E0

2,43351E-2

8,23998E-1

1,38101E0

2,37417E-1

1,70433E-2

4,00902E-1

3,19808E-1

2,28529E0

8,33229E-2

9,55176E-1

6.6

SBWOdeSolver

7,90748E-2

2,59272E0

1,95161E0

1,00785E-1

4,25726E0

2,43548E-2

8,23978E-1

1,38100E0

2,37433E-1

1,70439E-2

4,00952E-1

3,19887E-1

2,28531E0

8,33342E-2

9,55194E-1

6.6

VCell

7,90748E-2

2,59272E0

1,95161E0

1,00785E-1

4,25726E0

2,43547E-2

8,23979E-1

1,38100E0

2,37433E-1

1,70439E-2

4,00951E-1

3,19886E-1

2,28531E0

8,33341E-2

9,55194E-1

6.6

copasi

7,90748E-2

2,59272E0

1,95161E0

1,00785E-1

4,25726E0

2,43547E-2

8,23979E-1

1,38100E0

2,37433E-1

1,70439E-2

4,00951E-1

3,19886E-1

2,28531E0

8,33341E-2

9,55194E-1

6.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,73314E-2

2,38586E0

1,77298E0

9,23507E-2

4,21689E0

3,04107E-2

7,19675E-1

1,17083E0

2,72506E-1

1,52551E-2

6,34363E-1

3,54201E-1

2,46394E0

1,50029E-1

9,56351E-1

6.6

jsim

7,90748E-2

2,59272E0

1,95161E0

1,00785E-1

4,25726E0

2,43547E-2

8,23979E-1

1,38100E0

2,37433E-1

1,70439E-2

4,00951E-1

3,19886E-1

2,28531E0

8,33341E-2

9,55194E-1

6.6

min

7,73314E-2

2,38586E0

1,77298E0

9,23507E-2

4,21689E0

2,43351E-2

7,19675E-1

1,17083E0

2,35734E-1

1,52551E-2

1,52535E-1

3,19808E-1

2,16104E0

3,90347E-2

9,54616E-1

6.6

max

8,96041E-2

2,72117E0

2,07588E0

1,12829E-1

4,25734E0

3,04107E-2

9,84890E-1

1,49448E0

2,72506E-1

1,89976E-2

6,34363E-1

3,54201E-1

2,46394E0

1,50029E-1

9,56351E-1

6.6

mean

7,90748E-2

2,59272E0

1,95161E0

1,00785E-1

4,25726E0

2,43547E-2

8,23979E-1

1,38100E0

2,37433E-1

1,70439E-2

4,00951E-1

3,19886E-1

2,28531E0

8,33341E-2

9,55194E-1

6.6

relative error(%)

0,00

6.8

BioUML

7,65497E-2

2,67829E0

1,98287E0

9,95723E-2

4,27656E0

2,17683E-2

8,06752E-1

1,42427E0

2,27931E-1

1,70595E-2

4,37840E-1

3,03170E-1

2,25406E0

8,73387E-2

9,73785E-1

6.8

ByoDyn

7,65497E-2

2,67829E0

1,98287E0

9,95723E-2

4,27656E0

2,17683E-2

8,06752E-1

1,42427E0

2,27931E-1

1,70595E-2

4,37840E-1

3,03170E-1

2,25406E0

8,73387E-2

9,73785E-1

6.8

Jarnac

8,87227E-2

2,81236E0

2,11302E0

1,13289E-1

4,25510E0

2,45454E-2

9,89402E-1

1,53846E0

2,29588E-1

1,91906E-2

1,63594E-1

3,21860E-1

2,12390E0

4,05274E-2

9,73219E-1

6.8

MathSBML

7,65497E-2

2,67829E0

1,98287E0

9,95723E-2

4,27656E0

2,17683E-2

8,06752E-1

1,42427E0

2,27931E-1

1,70595E-2

4,37840E-1

3,03170E-1

2,25406E0

8,73387E-2

9,73785E-1

6.8

Oscill8 Core

7,65497E-2

2,67829E0

1,98287E0

9,95723E-2

4,27656E0

2,17684E-2

8,06752E-1

1,42427E0

2,27931E-1

1,70595E-2

4,37840E-1

3,03171E-1

2,25406E0

8,73388E-2

9,73785E-1

6.8

SBToolbox2

7,65403E-2

2,67844E0

1,98288E0

9,95738E-2

4,27669E0

2,17503E-2

8,06765E-1

1,42430E0

2,27916E-1

1,70593E-2

4,37795E-1

3,03094E-1

2,25409E0

8,73272E-2

9,73768E-1

6.8

SBWOdeSolver

7,65497E-2

2,67829E0

1,98287E0

9,95722E-2

4,27656E0

2,17685E-2

8,06752E-1

1,42427E0

2,27931E-1

1,70595E-2

4,37841E-1

3,03171E-1

2,25406E0

8,73389E-2

9,73785E-1

6.8

VCell

7,65497E-2

2,67829E0

1,98287E0

9,95723E-2

4,27656E0

2,17683E-2

8,06752E-1

1,42427E0

2,27931E-1

1,70595E-2

4,37840E-1

3,03170E-1

2,25406E0

8,73387E-2

9,73785E-1

6.8

copasi

7,65496E-2

2,67829E0

1,98287E0

9,95723E-2

4,27656E0

2,17683E-2

8,06752E-1

1,42427E0

2,27931E-1

1,70595E-2

4,37840E-1

3,03170E-1

2,25406E0

8,73387E-2

9,73785E-1

6.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,20638E-2

2,47482E0

1,79347E0

8,90768E-2

4,25153E0

2,53217E-2

6,79011E-1

1,21201E0

2,57329E-1

1,50011E-2

6,97097E-1

3,24650E-1

2,44345E0

1,56347E-1

9,74939E-1

6.8

jsim

7,65497E-2

2,67829E0

1,98287E0

9,95723E-2

4,27656E0

2,17683E-2

8,06752E-1

1,42427E0

2,27931E-1

1,70595E-2

4,37840E-1

3,03170E-1

2,25406E0

8,73387E-2

9,73785E-1

6.8

min

7,20638E-2

2,47482E0

1,79347E0

8,90768E-2

4,25153E0

2,17503E-2

6,79011E-1

1,21201E0

2,27916E-1

1,50011E-2

1,63594E-1

3,03094E-1

2,12390E0

4,05274E-2

9,73219E-1

6.8

max

8,87227E-2

2,81236E0

2,11302E0

1,13289E-1

4,27669E0

2,53217E-2

9,89402E-1

1,53846E0

2,57329E-1

1,91906E-2

6,97097E-1

3,24650E-1

2,44345E0

1,56347E-1

9,74939E-1

6.8

mean

7,65497E-2

2,67829E0

1,98287E0

9,95723E-2

4,27656E0

2,17683E-2

8,06752E-1

1,42427E0

2,27931E-1

1,70595E-2

4,37840E-1

3,03170E-1

2,25406E0

8,73387E-2

9,73785E-1

6.8

relative error(%)

0,00

7.0

BioUML

7,41269E-2

2,76137E0

2,01438E0

9,82584E-2

4,29422E0

1,95215E-2

7,88397E-1

1,46744E0

2,18652E-1

1,70828E-2

4,76643E-1

2,87762E-1

2,22256E0

9,17127E-2

9,92171E-1

7.0

ByoDyn

7,41269E-2

2,76137E0

2,01438E0

9,82584E-2

4,29422E0

1,95215E-2

7,88397E-1

1,46744E0

2,18652E-1

1,70828E-2

4,76643E-1

2,87762E-1

2,22256E0

9,17127E-2

9,92171E-1

7.0

Jarnac

8,78821E-2

2,90251E0

2,15065E0

1,13732E-1

4,26738E0

2,28798E-2

9,93622E-1

1,58269E0

2,23617E-1

1,93889E-2

1,75109E-1

3,11241E-1

2,08628E0

4,21297E-2

9,91618E-1

7.0

MathSBML

7,41269E-2

2,76137E0

2,01438E0

9,82584E-2

4,29422E0

1,95215E-2

7,88397E-1

1,46744E0

2,18652E-1

1,70828E-2

4,76643E-1

2,87762E-1

2,22256E0

9,17127E-2

9,92171E-1

7.0

Oscill8 Core

7,41270E-2

2,76137E0

2,01438E0

9,82584E-2

4,29422E0

1,95216E-2

7,88396E-1

1,46744E0

2,18652E-1

1,70828E-2

4,76643E-1

2,87762E-1

2,22256E0

9,17128E-2

9,92171E-1

7.0

SBToolbox2

7,41176E-2

2,76153E0

2,01438E0

9,82603E-2

4,29434E0

1,95048E-2

7,88408E-1

1,46746E0

2,18632E-1

1,70823E-2

4,76597E-1

2,87688E-1

2,22255E0

9,17014E-2

9,92153E-1

7.0

SBWOdeSolver

7,41270E-2

2,76137E0

2,01438E0

9,82584E-2

4,29421E0

1,95216E-2

7,88397E-1

1,46744E0

2,18652E-1

1,70828E-2

4,76643E-1

2,87763E-1

2,22256E0

9,17129E-2

9,92171E-1

7.0

VCell

7,41269E-2

2,76137E0

2,01438E0

9,82584E-2

4,29422E0

1,95215E-2

7,88397E-1

1,46744E0

2,18652E-1

1,70828E-2

4,76643E-1

2,87762E-1

2,22256E0

9,17127E-2

9,92171E-1

7.0

copasi

7,41269E-2

2,76137E0

2,01438E0

9,82584E-2

4,29422E0

1,95215E-2

7,88396E-1

1,46744E0

2,18652E-1

1,70828E-2

4,76643E-1

2,87761E-1

2,22256E0

9,17127E-2

9,92171E-1

7.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,71569E-2

2,55920E0

1,81401E0

8,56410E-2

4,28184E0

2,12210E-2

6,37629E-1

1,25284E0

2,42167E-1

1,47775E-2

7,62261E-1

2,98433E-1

2,42292E0

1,63290E-1

9,93319E-1

7.0

jsim

7,41269E-2

2,76137E0

2,01438E0

9,82584E-2

4,29422E0

1,95215E-2

7,88397E-1

1,46744E0

2,18652E-1

1,70828E-2

4,76643E-1

2,87762E-1

2,22256E0

9,17127E-2

9,92171E-1

7.0

min

6,71569E-2

2,55920E0

1,81401E0

8,56410E-2

4,26738E0

1,95048E-2

6,37629E-1

1,25284E0

2,18632E-1

1,47775E-2

1,75109E-1

2,87688E-1

2,08628E0

4,21297E-2

9,91618E-1

7.0

max

8,78821E-2

2,90251E0

2,15065E0

1,13732E-1

4,29434E0

2,28798E-2

9,93622E-1

1,58269E0

2,42167E-1

1,93889E-2

7,62261E-1

3,11241E-1

2,42292E0

1,63290E-1

9,93319E-1

7.0

mean

7,41269E-2

2,76137E0

2,01438E0

9,82584E-2

4,29422E0

1,95215E-2

7,88397E-1

1,46744E0

2,18652E-1

1,70828E-2

4,76643E-1

2,87762E-1

2,22256E0

9,17127E-2

9,92171E-1

7.0

relative error(%)

0,00

7.2

BioUML

7,18335E-2

2,84197E0

2,04602E0

9,68552E-2

4,31025E0

1,75802E-2

7,69119E-1

1,51032E0

2,09672E-1

1,71154E-2

5,17177E-1

2,73669E-1

2,19093E0

9,64735E-2

1,01036E0

7.2

ByoDyn

7,18335E-2

2,84197E0

2,04602E0

9,68552E-2

4,31025E0

1,75802E-2

7,69119E-1

1,51032E0

2,09672E-1

1,71154E-2

5,17177E-1

2,73669E-1

2,19093E0

9,64735E-2

1,01036E0

7.2

Jarnac

8,70865E-2

2,99162E0

2,18869E0

1,14162E-1

4,27884E0

2,13757E-2

9,97594E-1

1,62710E0

2,17843E-1

1,95923E-2

1,87049E-1

3,01284E-1

2,04825E0

4,38456E-2

1,00982E0

7.2

MathSBML

7,18335E-2

2,84197E0

2,04602E0

9,68552E-2

4,31025E0

1,75802E-2

7,69119E-1

1,51032E0

2,09672E-1

1,71154E-2

5,17177E-1

2,73669E-1

2,19093E0

9,64735E-2

1,01036E0

7.2

Oscill8 Core

7,18335E-2

2,84197E0

2,04602E0

9,68551E-2

4,31025E0

1,75803E-2

7,69119E-1

1,51032E0

2,09672E-1

1,71154E-2

5,17177E-1

2,73669E-1

2,19093E0

9,64736E-2

1,01036E0

7.2

SBToolbox2

7,18239E-2

2,84212E0

2,04605E0

9,68568E-2

4,31032E0

1,75661E-2

7,69126E-1

1,51032E0

2,09647E-1

1,71146E-2

5,17140E-1

2,73602E-1

2,19095E0

9,64617E-2

1,01035E0

7.2

SBWOdeSolver

7,18336E-2

2,84197E0

2,04602E0

9,68552E-2

4,31025E0

1,75804E-2

7,69119E-1

1,51032E0

2,09672E-1

1,71154E-2

5,17177E-1

2,73669E-1

2,19093E0

9,64737E-2

1,01036E0

7.2

VCell

7,18335E-2

2,84197E0

2,04602E0

9,68552E-2

4,31025E0

1,75802E-2

7,69119E-1

1,51032E0

2,09672E-1

1,71154E-2

5,17177E-1

2,73669E-1

2,19093E0

9,64735E-2

1,01036E0

7.2

copasi

7,18334E-2

2,84197E0

2,04602E0

9,68551E-2

4,31025E0

1,75802E-2

7,69118E-1

1,51032E0

2,09672E-1

1,71154E-2

5,17177E-1

2,73669E-1

2,19092E0

9,64735E-2

1,01036E0

7.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,27171E-2

2,63893E0

1,83449E0

8,20864E-2

4,30786E0

1,79692E-2

5,96181E-1

1,29277E0

2,27334E-1

1,45915E-2

8,29239E-1

2,75665E-1

2,40245E0

1,70879E-1

1,01150E0

7.2

jsim

7,18335E-2

2,84197E0

2,04602E0

9,68552E-2

4,31025E0

1,75802E-2

7,69119E-1

1,51032E0

2,09672E-1

1,71154E-2

5,17177E-1

2,73669E-1

2,19093E0

9,64735E-2

1,01036E0

7.2

min

6,27171E-2

2,63893E0

1,83449E0

8,20864E-2

4,27884E0

1,75661E-2

5,96181E-1

1,29277E0

2,09647E-1

1,45915E-2

1,87049E-1

2,73602E-1

2,04825E0

4,38456E-2

1,00982E0

7.2

max

8,70865E-2

2,99162E0

2,18869E0

1,14162E-1

4,31032E0

2,13757E-2

9,97594E-1

1,62710E0

2,27334E-1

1,95923E-2

8,29239E-1

3,01284E-1

2,40245E0

1,70879E-1

1,01150E0

7.2

mean

7,18335E-2

2,84197E0

2,04602E0

9,68552E-2

4,31025E0

1,75802E-2

7,69119E-1

1,51032E0

2,09672E-1

1,71154E-2

5,17177E-1

2,73669E-1

2,19093E0

9,64735E-2

1,01036E0

7.2

relative error(%)

0,00

7.4

BioUML

6,96943E-2

2,92012E0

2,07767E0

9,53775E-2

4,32469E0

1,59124E-2

7,49154E-1

1,55267E0

2,01062E-1

1,71591E-2

5,59223E-1

2,60889E-1

2,15928E0

1,01637E-1

1,02836E0

7.4

ByoDyn

6,96943E-2

2,92012E0

2,07767E0

9,53775E-2

4,32469E0

1,59124E-2

7,49154E-1

1,55267E0

2,01062E-1

1,71591E-2

5,59223E-1

2,60889E-1

2,15928E0

1,01637E-1

1,02836E0

7.4

Jarnac

8,63394E-2

3,07972E0

2,22709E0

1,14582E-1

4,28951E0

2,00172E-2

1,00137E0

1,67159E0

2,12281E-1

1,98004E-2

1,99378E-1

2,91961E-1

2,00986E0

4,56790E-2

1,02784E0

7.4

MathSBML

6,96943E-2

2,92012E0

2,07767E0

9,53775E-2

4,32469E0

1,59124E-2

7,49154E-1

1,55267E0

2,01062E-1

1,71591E-2

5,59223E-1

2,60889E-1

2,15928E0

1,01637E-1

1,02836E0

7.4

Oscill8 Core

6,96944E-2

2,92012E0

2,07767E0

9,53775E-2

4,32469E0

1,59125E-2

7,49154E-1

1,55267E0

2,01062E-1

1,71591E-2

5,59223E-1

2,60890E-1

2,15928E0

1,01637E-1

1,02836E0

7.4

SBToolbox2

6,96845E-2

2,92021E0

2,07769E0

9,53792E-2

4,32478E0

1,59000E-2

7,49157E-1

1,55275E0

2,01041E-1

1,71585E-2

5,59186E-1

2,60824E-1

2,15928E0

1,01620E-1

1,02833E0

7.4

SBWOdeSolver

6,96945E-2

2,92012E0

2,07767E0

9,53775E-2

4,32469E0

1,59125E-2

7,49154E-1

1,55267E0

2,01062E-1

1,71591E-2

5,59223E-1

2,60890E-1

2,15928E0

1,01637E-1

1,02836E0

7.4

VCell

6,96943E-2

2,92012E0

2,07767E0

9,53775E-2

4,32469E0

1,59124E-2

7,49154E-1

1,55267E0

2,01062E-1

1,71591E-2

5,59223E-1

2,60889E-1

2,15928E0

1,01637E-1

1,02836E0

7.4

copasi

6,96942E-2

2,92012E0

2,07767E0

9,53774E-2

4,32469E0

1,59124E-2

7,49153E-1

1,55267E0

2,01062E-1

1,71591E-2

5,59224E-1

2,60889E-1

2,15928E0

1,01636E-1

1,02836E0

7.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,88146E-2

2,71408E0

1,85473E0

7,84555E-2

4,32978E0

1,54248E-2

5,55250E-1

1,33125E0

2,13138E-1

1,44467E-2

8,97460E-1

2,56290E-1

2,38222E0

1,79127E-1

1,02949E0

7.4

jsim

6,96943E-2

2,92012E0

2,07767E0

9,53775E-2

4,32469E0

1,59124E-2

7,49154E-1

1,55267E0

2,01062E-1

1,71591E-2

5,59223E-1

2,60889E-1

2,15928E0

1,01637E-1

1,02836E0

7.4

min

5,88146E-2

2,71408E0

1,85473E0

7,84555E-2

4,28951E0

1,54248E-2

5,55250E-1

1,33125E0

2,01041E-1

1,44467E-2

1,99378E-1

2,56290E-1

2,00986E0

4,56790E-2

1,02784E0

7.4

max

8,63394E-2

3,07972E0

2,22709E0

1,14582E-1

4,32978E0

2,00172E-2

1,00137E0

1,67159E0

2,13138E-1

1,98004E-2

8,97460E-1

2,91961E-1

2,38222E0

1,79127E-1

1,02949E0

7.4

mean

6,96943E-2

2,92012E0

2,07767E0

9,53775E-2

4,32469E0

1,59124E-2

7,49154E-1

1,55267E0

2,01062E-1

1,71591E-2

5,59223E-1

2,60889E-1

2,15928E0

1,01637E-1

1,02836E0

7.4

relative error(%)

0,00

7.6

BioUML

6,77317E-2

2,99588E0

2,10920E0

9,38427E-2

4,33759E0

1,44882E-2

7,28759E-1

1,59427E0

1,92888E-1

1,72153E-2

6,02530E-1

2,49407E-1

2,12776E0

1,07215E-1

1,04618E0

7.6

ByoDyn

6,77317E-2

2,99588E0

2,10920E0

9,38427E-2

4,33759E0

1,44882E-2

7,28759E-1

1,59427E0

1,92888E-1

1,72153E-2

6,02530E-1

2,49407E-1

2,12776E0

1,07215E-1

1,04618E0

7.6

Jarnac

8,56427E-2

3,16683E0

2,26577E0

1,14996E-1

4,29946E0

1,87899E-2

1,00498E0

1,71608E0

2,06943E-1

2,00130E-2

2,12057E-1

2,83239E-1

1,97119E0

4,76332E-2

1,04567E0

7.6

MathSBML

6,77318E-2

2,99588E0

2,10920E0

9,38427E-2

4,33759E0

1,44882E-2

7,28759E-1

1,59427E0

1,92888E-1

1,72153E-2

6,02530E-1

2,49407E-1

2,12776E0

1,07215E-1

1,04618E0

7.6

Oscill8 Core

6,77318E-2

2,99588E0

2,10920E0

9,38427E-2

4,33759E0

1,44882E-2

7,28759E-1

1,59427E0

1,92888E-1

1,72153E-2

6,02530E-1

2,49407E-1

2,12776E0

1,07215E-1

1,04618E0

7.6

SBToolbox2

6,77224E-2

2,99599E0

2,10918E0

9,38443E-2

4,33764E0

1,44764E-2

7,28763E-1

1,59430E0

1,92864E-1

1,72147E-2

6,02496E-1

2,49348E-1

2,12774E0

1,07200E-1

1,04619E0

7.6

SBWOdeSolver

6,77319E-2

2,99588E0

2,10920E0

9,38427E-2

4,33759E0

1,44883E-2

7,28760E-1

1,59427E0

1,92889E-1

1,72153E-2

6,02530E-1

2,49407E-1

2,12776E0

1,07215E-1

1,04618E0

7.6

VCell

6,77317E-2

2,99588E0

2,10920E0

9,38427E-2

4,33759E0

1,44882E-2

7,28759E-1

1,59427E0

1,92888E-1

1,72153E-2

6,02530E-1

2,49407E-1

2,12776E0

1,07215E-1

1,04618E0

7.6

copasi

6,77317E-2

2,99588E0

2,10920E0

9,38426E-2

4,33759E0

1,44882E-2

7,28758E-1

1,59427E0

1,92888E-1

1,72153E-2

6,02531E-1

2,49407E-1

2,12776E0

1,07215E-1

1,04618E0

7.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,54782E-2

2,78481E0

1,87450E0

7,47871E-2

4,34794E0

1,34537E-2

5,15323E-1

1,36774E0

1,99854E-1

1,43430E-2

9,66435E-1

2,40100E-1

2,36245E0

1,88042E-1

1,04729E0

7.6

jsim

6,77317E-2

2,99588E0

2,10920E0

9,38427E-2

4,33759E0

1,44882E-2

7,28759E-1

1,59427E0

1,92888E-1

1,72153E-2

6,02530E-1

2,49407E-1

2,12776E0

1,07215E-1

1,04618E0

7.6

min

5,54782E-2

2,78481E0

1,87450E0

7,47871E-2

4,29946E0

1,34537E-2

5,15323E-1

1,36774E0

1,92864E-1

1,43430E-2

2,12057E-1

2,40100E-1

1,97119E0

4,76332E-2

1,04567E0

7.6

max

8,56427E-2

3,16683E0

2,26577E0

1,14996E-1

4,34794E0

1,87899E-2

1,00498E0

1,71608E0

2,06943E-1

2,00130E-2

9,66435E-1

2,83239E-1

2,36245E0

1,88042E-1

1,04729E0

7.6

mean

6,77317E-2

2,99588E0

2,10920E0

9,38427E-2

4,33759E0

1,44882E-2

7,28759E-1

1,59427E0

1,92888E-1

1,72153E-2

6,02530E-1

2,49407E-1

2,12776E0

1,07215E-1

1,04618E0

7.6

relative error(%)

0,00

7.8

BioUML

6,59643E-2

3,06934E0

2,14047E0

9,22701E-2

4,34901E0

1,32796E-2

7,08207E-1

1,63492E0

1,85211E-1

1,72852E-2

6,46821E-1

2,39192E-1

2,09649E0

1,13218E-1

1,06382E0

7.8

ByoDyn

6,59643E-2

3,06934E0

2,14047E0

9,22701E-2

4,34901E0

1,32796E-2

7,08207E-1

1,63492E0

1,85211E-1

1,72852E-2

6,46821E-1

2,39192E-1

2,09649E0

1,13218E-1

1,06382E0

7.8

Jarnac

8,49976E-2

3,25299E0

2,30465E0

1,15406E-1

4,30872E0

1,76804E-2

1,00849E0

1,76049E0

2,01838E-1

2,02297E-2

2,25050E-1

2,75086E-1

1,93231E0

4,97115E-2

1,06333E0

7.8

MathSBML

6,59643E-2

3,06934E0

2,14047E0

9,22701E-2

4,34901E0

1,32796E-2

7,08207E-1

1,63492E0

1,85211E-1

1,72852E-2

6,46821E-1

2,39192E-1

2,09649E0

1,13218E-1

1,06382E0

7.8

Oscill8 Core

6,59643E-2

3,06934E0

2,14047E0

9,22701E-2

4,34901E0

1,32796E-2

7,08207E-1

1,63492E0

1,85211E-1

1,72852E-2

6,46822E-1

2,39192E-1

2,09649E0

1,13218E-1

1,06382E0

7.8

SBToolbox2

6,59547E-2

3,06949E0

2,14045E0

9,22724E-2

4,34911E0

1,32689E-2

7,08213E-1

1,63494E0

1,85189E-1

1,72849E-2

6,46783E-1

2,39134E-1

2,09647E0

1,13208E-1

1,06380E0

7.8

SBWOdeSolver

6,59644E-2

3,06934E0

2,14047E0

9,22701E-2

4,34901E0

1,32797E-2

7,08207E-1

1,63492E0

1,85211E-1

1,72852E-2

6,46821E-1

2,39193E-1

2,09649E0

1,13218E-1

1,06382E0

7.8

VCell

6,59643E-2

3,06934E0

2,14047E0

9,22701E-2

4,34901E0

1,32796E-2

7,08207E-1

1,63492E0

1,85211E-1

1,72852E-2

6,46821E-1

2,39192E-1

2,09649E0

1,13218E-1

1,06382E0

7.8

copasi

6,59642E-2

3,06934E0

2,14048E0

9,22700E-2

4,34901E0

1,32796E-2

7,08205E-1

1,63492E0

1,85210E-1

1,72852E-2

6,46823E-1

2,39192E-1

2,09649E0

1,13218E-1

1,06382E0

7.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,26980E-2

2,85140E0

1,89352E0

7,11155E-2

4,36276E0

1,19374E-2

4,76784E-1

1,40175E0

1,87698E-1

1,42769E-2

1,03576E0

2,26784E-1

2,34344E0

1,97629E-1

1,06492E0

7.8

jsim

6,59643E-2

3,06934E0

2,14047E0

9,22701E-2

4,34901E0

1,32796E-2

7,08207E-1

1,63492E0

1,85211E-1

1,72852E-2

6,46821E-1

2,39192E-1

2,09649E0

1,13218E-1

1,06382E0

7.8

min

5,26980E-2

2,85140E0

1,89352E0

7,11155E-2

4,30872E0

1,19374E-2

4,76784E-1

1,40175E0

1,85189E-1

1,42769E-2

2,25050E-1

2,26784E-1

1,93231E0

4,97115E-2

1,06333E0

7.8

max

8,49976E-2

3,25299E0

2,30465E0

1,15406E-1

4,36276E0

1,76804E-2

1,00849E0

1,76049E0

2,01838E-1

2,02297E-2

1,03576E0

2,75086E-1

2,34344E0

1,97629E-1

1,06492E0

7.8

mean

6,59643E-2

3,06934E0

2,14047E0

9,22701E-2

4,34901E0

1,32796E-2

7,08207E-1

1,63492E0

1,85211E-1

1,72852E-2

6,46821E-1

2,39192E-1

2,09649E0

1,13218E-1

1,06382E0

7.8

relative error(%)

0,00

8.0

BioUML

6,44061E-2

3,14063E0

2,17136E0

9,06807E-2

4,35902E0

1,22609E-2

6,87776E-1

1,67440E0

1,78079E-1

1,73696E-2

6,91806E-1

2,30203E-1

2,06561E0

1,19655E-1

1,08130E0

8.0

ByoDyn

6,44061E-2

3,14063E0

2,17136E0

9,06807E-2

4,35902E0

1,22609E-2

6,87776E-1

1,67440E0

1,78079E-1

1,73696E-2

6,91806E-1

2,30203E-1

2,06561E0

1,19655E-1

1,08130E0

8.0

Jarnac

8,44043E-2

3,33824E0

2,34367E0

1,15817E-1

4,31734E0

1,66766E-2

1,01195E0

1,80475E0

1,96969E-1

2,04500E-2

2,38316E-1

2,67469E-1

1,89329E0

5,19163E-2

1,08082E0

8.0

MathSBML

6,44062E-2

3,14063E0

2,17136E0

9,06807E-2

4,35902E0

1,22609E-2

6,87776E-1

1,67440E0

1,78079E-1

1,73696E-2

6,91806E-1

2,30203E-1

2,06561E0

1,19655E-1

1,08130E0

8.0

Oscill8 Core

6,44062E-2

3,14063E0

2,17136E0

9,06807E-2

4,35902E0

1,22610E-2

6,87776E-1

1,67440E0

1,78079E-1

1,73696E-2

6,91806E-1

2,30203E-1

2,06561E0

1,19655E-1

1,08130E0

8.0

SBToolbox2

6,43974E-2

3,14072E0

2,17140E0

9,06832E-2

4,35910E0

1,22516E-2

6,87786E-1

1,67448E0

1,78052E-1

1,73690E-2

6,91762E-1

2,30146E-1

2,06560E0

1,19646E-1

1,08128E0

8.0

SBWOdeSolver

6,44062E-2

3,14063E0

2,17136E0

9,06807E-2

4,35902E0

1,22610E-2

6,87776E-1

1,67440E0

1,78080E-1

1,73696E-2

6,91805E-1

2,30203E-1

2,06561E0

1,19655E-1

1,08130E0

8.0

VCell

6,44061E-2

3,14063E0

2,17136E0

9,06807E-2

4,35902E0

1,22609E-2

6,87776E-1

1,67440E0

1,78079E-1

1,73696E-2

6,91806E-1

2,30203E-1

2,06561E0

1,19655E-1

1,08130E0

8.0

copasi

6,44061E-2

3,14063E0

2,17136E0

9,06806E-2

4,35902E0

1,22610E-2

6,87774E-1

1,67440E0

1,78079E-1

1,73696E-2

6,91807E-1

2,30203E-1

2,06561E0

1,19655E-1

1,08130E0

8.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,04339E-2

2,91417E0

1,91148E0

6,74703E-2

4,37473E0

1,07759E-2

4,39922E-1

1,43289E0

1,76812E-1

1,42426E-2

1,10512E0

2,15980E-1

2,32549E0

2,07888E-1

1,08238E0

8.0

jsim

6,44062E-2

3,14063E0

2,17136E0

9,06807E-2

4,35902E0

1,22609E-2

6,87776E-1

1,67440E0

1,78079E-1

1,73696E-2

6,91806E-1

2,30203E-1

2,06561E0

1,19655E-1

1,08130E0

8.0

min

5,04339E-2

2,91417E0

1,91148E0

6,74703E-2

4,31734E0

1,07759E-2

4,39922E-1

1,43289E0

1,76812E-1

1,42426E-2

2,38316E-1

2,15980E-1

1,89329E0

5,19163E-2

1,08082E0

8.0

max

8,44043E-2

3,33824E0

2,34367E0

1,15817E-1

4,37473E0

1,66766E-2

1,01195E0

1,80475E0

1,96969E-1

2,04500E-2

1,10512E0

2,67469E-1

2,32549E0

2,07888E-1

1,08238E0

8.0

mean

6,44061E-2

3,14063E0

2,17136E0

9,06807E-2

4,35902E0

1,22609E-2

6,87776E-1

1,67440E0

1,78079E-1

1,73696E-2

6,91806E-1

2,30203E-1

2,06561E0

1,19655E-1

1,08130E0

8.0

relative error(%)

0,00

8.2

BioUML

6,30669E-2

3,20988E0

2,20172E0

8,90967E-2

4,36768E0

1,14090E-2

6,67744E-1

1,71254E0

1,71534E-1

1,74689E-2

7,37179E-1

2,22386E-1

2,03526E0

1,26529E-1

1,09861E0

8.2

ByoDyn

6,30669E-2

3,20988E0

2,20172E0

8,90967E-2

4,36768E0

1,14090E-2

6,67744E-1

1,71254E0

1,71534E-1

1,74689E-2

7,37179E-1

2,22386E-1

2,03526E0

1,26529E-1

1,09861E0

8.2

Jarnac

8,38621E-2

3,42261E0

2,38276E0

1,16231E-1

4,32536E0

1,57674E-2

1,01538E0

1,84878E0

1,92338E-1

2,06735E-2

2,51816E-1

2,60355E-1

1,85421E0

5,42500E-2

1,09815E0

8.2

MathSBML

6,30670E-2

3,20988E0

2,20172E0

8,90967E-2

4,36768E0

1,14090E-2

6,67744E-1

1,71254E0

1,71534E-1

1,74690E-2

7,37179E-1

2,22386E-1

2,03526E0

1,26529E-1

1,09861E0

8.2

Oscill8 Core

6,30670E-2

3,20988E0

2,20172E0

8,90967E-2

4,36768E0

1,14090E-2

6,67744E-1

1,71254E0

1,71534E-1

1,74690E-2

7,37179E-1

2,22386E-1

2,03526E0

1,26529E-1

1,09861E0

8.2

SBToolbox2

6,30588E-2

3,21001E0

2,20177E0

8,90998E-2

4,36777E0

1,14010E-2

6,67762E-1

1,71254E0

1,71504E-1

1,74689E-2

7,37129E-1

2,22335E-1

2,03523E0

1,26515E-1

1,09856E0

8.2

SBWOdeSolver

6,30670E-2

3,20988E0

2,20172E0

8,90968E-2

4,36768E0

1,14090E-2

6,67744E-1

1,71254E0

1,71534E-1

1,74690E-2

7,37178E-1

2,22386E-1

2,03526E0

1,26529E-1

1,09861E0

8.2

VCell

6,30669E-2

3,20988E0

2,20172E0

8,90967E-2

4,36768E0

1,14090E-2

6,67744E-1

1,71254E0

1,71534E-1

1,74689E-2

7,37179E-1

2,22386E-1

2,03526E0

1,26529E-1

1,09861E0

8.2

copasi

6,30670E-2

3,20988E0

2,20172E0

8,90966E-2

4,36768E0

1,14090E-2

6,67742E-1

1,71254E0

1,71534E-1

1,74690E-2

7,37180E-1

2,22386E-1

2,03526E0

1,26529E-1

1,09861E0

8.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,86271E-2

2,97351E0

1,92805E0

6,38767E-2

4,38427E0

9,88896E-3

4,04942E-1

1,46082E0

1,67263E-1

1,42329E-2

1,17425E0

2,07318E-1

2,30892E0

2,18815E-1

1,09968E0

8.2

jsim

6,30669E-2

3,20988E0

2,20172E0

8,90967E-2

4,36768E0

1,14089E-2

6,67744E-1

1,71254E0

1,71534E-1

1,74690E-2

7,37179E-1

2,22386E-1

2,03526E0

1,26529E-1

1,09861E0

8.2

min

4,86271E-2

2,97351E0

1,92805E0

6,38767E-2

4,32536E0

9,88896E-3

4,04942E-1

1,46082E0

1,67263E-1

1,42329E-2

2,51816E-1

2,07318E-1

1,85421E0

5,42500E-2

1,09815E0

8.2

max

8,38621E-2

3,42261E0

2,38276E0

1,16231E-1

4,38427E0

1,57674E-2

1,01538E0

1,84878E0

1,92338E-1

2,06735E-2

1,17425E0

2,60355E-1

2,30892E0

2,18815E-1

1,09968E0

8.2

mean

6,30670E-2

3,20988E0

2,20172E0

8,90967E-2

4,36768E0

1,14090E-2

6,67744E-1

1,71254E0

1,71534E-1

1,74690E-2

7,37179E-1

2,22386E-1

2,03526E0

1,26529E-1

1,09861E0

8.2

relative error(%)

0,00

8.4

BioUML

6,19518E-2

3,27726E0

2,23141E0

8,75412E-2

4,37509E0

1,07028E-2

6,48385E-1

1,74916E0

1,65603E-1

1,75833E-2

7,82632E-1

2,15679E-1

2,00557E0

1,33842E-1

1,11576E0

8.4

ByoDyn

6,19518E-2

3,27726E0

2,23141E0

8,75412E-2

4,37509E0

1,07028E-2

6,48385E-1

1,74916E0

1,65603E-1

1,75833E-2

7,82632E-1

2,15679E-1

2,00557E0

1,33842E-1

1,11576E0

8.4

Jarnac

8,33700E-2

3,50615E0

2,42185E0

1,16651E-1

4,33282E0

1,49430E-2

1,01885E0

1,89252E0

1,87942E-1

2,08996E-2

2,65512E-1

2,53711E-1

1,81513E0

5,67145E-2

1,11532E0

8.4

MathSBML

6,19519E-2

3,27726E0

2,23141E0

8,75412E-2

4,37509E0

1,07028E-2

6,48385E-1

1,74916E0

1,65603E-1

1,75833E-2

7,82632E-1

2,15679E-1

2,00557E0

1,33842E-1

1,11576E0

8.4

Oscill8 Core

6,19519E-2

3,27726E0

2,23141E0

8,75412E-2

4,37509E0

1,07028E-2

6,48385E-1

1,74916E0

1,65603E-1

1,75833E-2

7,82632E-1

2,15680E-1

2,00557E0

1,33842E-1

1,11576E0

8.4

SBToolbox2

6,19440E-2

3,27734E0

2,23144E0

8,75448E-2

4,37515E0

1,06949E-2

6,48408E-1

1,74919E0

1,65575E-1

1,75830E-2

7,82573E-1

2,15630E-1

2,00556E0

1,33831E-1

1,11574E0

8.4

SBWOdeSolver

6,19519E-2

3,27726E0

2,23141E0

8,75412E-2

4,37509E0

1,07028E-2

6,48385E-1

1,74916E0

1,65603E-1

1,75833E-2

7,82631E-1

2,15680E-1

2,00557E0

1,33842E-1

1,11576E0

8.4

VCell

6,19518E-2

3,27726E0

2,23141E0

8,75412E-2

4,37509E0

1,07028E-2

6,48385E-1

1,74916E0

1,65603E-1

1,75833E-2

7,82632E-1

2,15679E-1

2,00557E0

1,33842E-1

1,11576E0

8.4

copasi

6,19520E-2

3,27726E0

2,23141E0

8,75411E-2

4,37509E0

1,07028E-2

6,48384E-1

1,74916E0

1,65603E-1

1,75834E-2

7,82633E-1

2,15680E-1

2,00557E0

1,33842E-1

1,11576E0

8.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,72106E-2

3,02983E0

1,94293E0

6,03563E-2

4,39181E0

9,21376E-3

3,71988E-1

1,48532E0

1,59046E-1

1,42405E-2

1,24296E0

2,00455E-1

2,29405E0

2,30408E-1

1,11681E0

8.4

jsim

6,19518E-2

3,27726E0

2,23141E0

8,75412E-2

4,37509E0

1,07028E-2

6,48385E-1

1,74916E0

1,65603E-1

1,75833E-2

7,82632E-1

2,15679E-1

2,00557E0

1,33842E-1

1,11576E0

8.4

min

4,72106E-2

3,02983E0

1,94293E0

6,03563E-2

4,33282E0

9,21376E-3

3,71988E-1

1,48532E0

1,59046E-1

1,42405E-2

2,65512E-1

2,00455E-1

1,81513E0

5,67145E-2

1,11532E0

8.4

max

8,33700E-2

3,50615E0

2,42185E0

1,16651E-1

4,39181E0

1,49430E-2

1,01885E0

1,89252E0

1,87942E-1

2,08996E-2

1,24296E0

2,53711E-1

2,29405E0

2,30408E-1

1,11681E0

8.4

mean

6,19518E-2

3,27726E0

2,23141E0

8,75412E-2

4,37509E0

1,07028E-2

6,48385E-1

1,74916E0

1,65603E-1

1,75833E-2

7,82632E-1

2,15679E-1

2,00557E0

1,33842E-1

1,11576E0

8.4

relative error(%)

0,00

8.6

BioUML

6,10621E-2

3,34296E0

2,26033E0

8,60378E-2

4,38133E0

1,01241E-2

6,29962E-1

1,78413E0

1,60302E-1

1,77126E-2

8,27853E-1

2,10019E-1

1,97666E0

1,41592E-1

1,13275E0

8.6

ByoDyn

6,10621E-2

3,34296E0

2,26033E0

8,60378E-2

4,38133E0

1,01241E-2

6,29962E-1

1,78413E0

1,60302E-1

1,77126E-2

8,27853E-1

2,10019E-1

1,97666E0

1,41592E-1

1,13275E0

8.6

Jarnac

8,29261E-2

3,58890E0

2,46086E0

1,17080E-1

4,33977E0

1,41945E-2

1,02239E0

1,93591E0

1,83779E-1

2,11279E-2

2,79365E-1

2,47507E-1

1,77612E0

5,93112E-2

1,13233E0

8.6

MathSBML

6,10621E-2

3,34296E0

2,26033E0

8,60378E-2

4,38133E0

1,01241E-2

6,29962E-1

1,78413E0

1,60302E-1

1,77126E-2

8,27853E-1

2,10019E-1

1,97666E0

1,41592E-1

1,13275E0

8.6

Oscill8 Core

6,10621E-2

3,34296E0

2,26033E0

8,60378E-2

4,38133E0

1,01241E-2

6,29962E-1

1,78413E0

1,60302E-1

1,77126E-2

8,27853E-1

2,10019E-1

1,97666E0

1,41592E-1

1,13275E0

8.6

SBToolbox2

6,10547E-2

3,34306E0

2,26031E0

8,60428E-2

4,38134E0

1,01174E-2

6,29985E-1

1,78415E0

1,60275E-1

1,77128E-2

8,27785E-1

2,09974E-1

1,97660E0

1,41576E-1

1,13273E0

8.6

SBWOdeSolver

6,10621E-2

3,34296E0

2,26033E0

8,60379E-2

4,38133E0

1,01241E-2

6,29963E-1

1,78413E0

1,60302E-1

1,77126E-2

8,27852E-1

2,10019E-1

1,97666E0

1,41592E-1

1,13275E0

8.6

VCell

6,10621E-2

3,34296E0

2,26033E0

8,60378E-2

4,38133E0

1,01241E-2

6,29962E-1

1,78413E0

1,60302E-1

1,77126E-2

8,27853E-1

2,10019E-1

1,97666E0

1,41592E-1

1,13275E0

8.6

copasi

6,10623E-2

3,34296E0

2,26033E0

8,60377E-2

4,38133E0

1,01241E-2

6,29961E-1

1,78413E0

1,60302E-1

1,77127E-2

8,27854E-1

2,10019E-1

1,97665E0

1,41592E-1

1,13275E0

8.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,61178E-2

3,08352E0

1,95583E0

5,69284E-2

4,39768E0

8,70267E-3

3,41149E-1

1,50623E0

1,52104E-1

1,42586E-2

1,31108E0

1,95090E-1

2,28116E0

2,42658E-1

1,13380E0

8.6

jsim

6,10621E-2

3,34296E0

2,26033E0

8,60378E-2

4,38133E0

1,01241E-2

6,29962E-1

1,78413E0

1,60302E-1

1,77126E-2

8,27853E-1

2,10019E-1

1,97666E0

1,41592E-1

1,13275E0

8.6

min

4,61178E-2

3,08352E0

1,95583E0

5,69284E-2

4,33977E0

8,70267E-3

3,41149E-1

1,50623E0

1,52104E-1

1,42586E-2

2,79365E-1

1,95090E-1

1,77612E0

5,93112E-2

1,13233E0

8.6

max

8,29261E-2

3,58890E0

2,46086E0

1,17080E-1

4,39768E0

1,41945E-2

1,02239E0

1,93591E0

1,83779E-1

2,11279E-2

1,31108E0

2,47507E-1

2,28116E0

2,42658E-1

1,13380E0

8.6

mean

6,10621E-2

3,34296E0

2,26033E0

8,60378E-2

4,38133E0

1,01241E-2

6,29962E-1

1,78413E0

1,60302E-1

1,77126E-2

8,27853E-1

2,10019E-1

1,97666E0

1,41592E-1

1,13275E0

8.6

relative error(%)

0,00

8.8

BioUML

6,03960E-2

3,40717E0

2,28837E0

8,46105E-2

4,38648E0

9,65708E-3

6,12728E-1

1,81735E0

1,55636E-1

1,78566E-2

8,72532E-1

2,05337E-1

1,94863E0

1,49774E-1

1,14960E0

8.8

ByoDyn

6,03960E-2

3,40717E0

2,28837E0

8,46105E-2

4,38648E0

9,65708E-3

6,12728E-1

1,81735E0

1,55636E-1

1,78566E-2

8,72532E-1

2,05337E-1

1,94863E0

1,49774E-1

1,14960E0

8.8

Jarnac

8,25283E-2

3,67091E0

2,49974E0

1,17521E-1

4,34624E0

1,35138E-2

1,02605E0

1,97889E0

1,79841E-1

2,13578E-2

2,93341E-1

2,41711E-1

1,73725E0

6,20411E-2

1,14920E0

8.8

MathSBML

6,03961E-2

3,40717E0

2,28837E0

8,46106E-2

4,38648E0

9,65708E-3

6,12728E-1

1,81735E0

1,55636E-1

1,78566E-2

8,72532E-1

2,05337E-1

1,94863E0

1,49774E-1

1,14960E0

8.8

Oscill8 Core

6,03961E-2

3,40717E0

2,28836E0

8,46106E-2

4,38647E0

9,65709E-3

6,12728E-1

1,81735E0

1,55636E-1

1,78566E-2

8,72532E-1

2,05337E-1

1,94863E0

1,49774E-1

1,14960E0

8.8

SBToolbox2

6,03896E-2

3,40728E0

2,28837E0

8,46158E-2

4,38652E0

9,65142E-3

6,12760E-1

1,81739E0

1,55604E-1

1,78560E-2

8,72456E-1

2,05295E-1

1,94863E0

1,49760E-1

1,14960E0

8.8

SBWOdeSolver

6,03961E-2

3,40717E0

2,28836E0

8,46106E-2

4,38647E0

9,65710E-3

6,12729E-1

1,81735E0

1,55636E-1

1,78566E-2

8,72531E-1

2,05337E-1

1,94863E0

1,49774E-1

1,14960E0

8.8

VCell

6,03960E-2

3,40717E0

2,28837E0

8,46105E-2

4,38648E0

9,65708E-3

6,12728E-1

1,81735E0

1,55636E-1

1,78566E-2

8,72532E-1

2,05337E-1

1,94863E0

1,49774E-1

1,14960E0

8.8

copasi

6,03962E-2

3,40717E0

2,28837E0

8,46105E-2

4,38647E0

9,65712E-3

6,12728E-1

1,81735E0

1,55636E-1

1,78566E-2

8,72532E-1

2,05337E-1

1,94863E0

1,49774E-1

1,14960E0

8.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,52882E-2

3,13498E0

1,96650E0

5,36106E-2

4,40217E0

8,32016E-3

3,12480E-1

1,52346E0

1,46342E-1

1,42812E-2

1,37850E0

1,90977E-1

2,27049E0

2,55559E-1

1,15063E0

8.8

jsim

6,03960E-2

3,40717E0

2,28837E0

8,46105E-2

4,38648E0

9,65708E-3

6,12728E-1

1,81735E0

1,55636E-1

1,78566E-2

8,72532E-1

2,05337E-1

1,94863E0

1,49774E-1

1,14960E0

8.8

min

4,52882E-2

3,13498E0

1,96650E0

5,36106E-2

4,34624E0

8,32016E-3

3,12480E-1

1,52346E0

1,46342E-1

1,42812E-2

2,93341E-1

1,90977E-1

1,73725E0

6,20411E-2

1,14920E0

8.8

max

8,25283E-2

3,67091E0

2,49974E0

1,17521E-1

4,40217E0

1,35138E-2

1,02605E0

1,97889E0

1,79841E-1

2,13578E-2

1,37850E0

2,41711E-1

2,27049E0

2,55559E-1

1,15063E0

8.8

mean

6,03961E-2

3,40717E0

2,28837E0

8,46105E-2

4,38648E0

9,65708E-3

6,12728E-1

1,81735E0

1,55636E-1

1,78566E-2

8,72532E-1

2,05337E-1

1,94863E0

1,49774E-1

1,14960E0

8.8

relative error(%)

0,00

9.0

BioUML

5,99503E-2

3,47012E0

2,31543E0

8,32837E-2

4,39061E0

9,28856E-3

5,96925E-1

1,84873E0

1,51599E-1

1,80148E-2

9,16357E-1

2,01572E-1

1,92157E0

1,58380E-1

1,16631E0

9.0

ByoDyn

5,99503E-2

3,47012E0

2,31543E0

8,32837E-2

4,39061E0

9,28856E-3

5,96925E-1

1,84873E0

1,51599E-1

1,80148E-2

9,16357E-1

2,01572E-1

1,92157E0

1,58380E-1

1,16631E0

9.0

Jarnac

8,21741E-2

3,75222E0

2,53842E0

1,17977E-1

4,35228E0

1,28938E-2

1,02985E0

2,02140E0

1,76122E-1

2,15889E-2

3,07405E-1

2,36296E-1

1,69858E0

6,49052E-2

1,16591E0

9.0

MathSBML

5,99503E-2

3,47012E0

2,31543E0

8,32837E-2

4,39061E0

9,28857E-3

5,96925E-1

1,84873E0

1,51599E-1

1,80148E-2

9,16357E-1

2,01572E-1

1,92157E0

1,58380E-1

1,16631E0

9.0

Oscill8 Core

5,99503E-2

3,47012E0

2,31543E0

8,32837E-2

4,39061E0

9,28857E-3

5,96925E-1

1,84873E0

1,51599E-1

1,80148E-2

9,16357E-1

2,01572E-1

1,92157E0

1,58380E-1

1,16631E0

9.0

SBToolbox2

5,99433E-2

3,47031E0

2,31544E0

8,32916E-2

4,39062E0

9,28300E-3

5,96975E-1

1,84876E0

1,51571E-1

1,80148E-2

9,16247E-1

2,01524E-1

1,92156E0

1,58364E-1

1,16628E0

9.0

SBWOdeSolver

5,99504E-2

3,47012E0

2,31543E0

8,32837E-2

4,39061E0

9,28858E-3

5,96925E-1

1,84873E0

1,51599E-1

1,80148E-2

9,16356E-1

2,01572E-1

1,92157E0

1,58380E-1

1,16631E0

9.0

VCell

5,99503E-2

3,47012E0

2,31543E0

8,32837E-2

4,39061E0

9,28856E-3

5,96925E-1

1,84873E0

1,51599E-1

1,80148E-2

9,16357E-1

2,01572E-1

1,92157E0

1,58380E-1

1,16631E0

9.0

copasi

5,99505E-2

3,47012E0

2,31543E0

8,32837E-2

4,39061E0

9,28861E-3

5,96925E-1

1,84873E0

1,51599E-1

1,80149E-2

9,16357E-1

2,01572E-1

1,92157E0

1,58380E-1

1,16631E0

9.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,46701E-2

3,18454E0

1,97477E0

5,04193E-2

4,40551E0

8,04018E-3

2,86004E-1

1,53702E0

1,41643E-1

1,43036E-2

1,44509E0

1,87915E-1

2,26223E0

2,69101E-1

1,16732E0

9.0

jsim

5,99503E-2

3,47012E0

2,31543E0

8,32837E-2

4,39061E0

9,28856E-3

5,96925E-1

1,84873E0

1,51599E-1

1,80148E-2

9,16357E-1

2,01572E-1

1,92157E0

1,58380E-1

1,16631E0

9.0

min

4,46701E-2

3,18454E0

1,97477E0

5,04193E-2

4,35228E0

8,04018E-3

2,86004E-1

1,53702E0

1,41643E-1

1,43036E-2

3,07405E-1

1,87915E-1

1,69858E0

6,49052E-2

1,16591E0

9.0

max

8,21741E-2

3,75222E0

2,53842E0

1,17977E-1

4,40551E0

1,28938E-2

1,02985E0

2,02140E0

1,76122E-1

2,15889E-2

1,44509E0

2,36296E-1

2,26223E0

2,69101E-1

1,16732E0

9.0

mean

5,99503E-2

3,47012E0

2,31543E0

8,32837E-2

4,39061E0

9,28856E-3

5,96925E-1

1,84873E0

1,51599E-1

1,80148E-2

9,16357E-1

2,01572E-1

1,92157E0

1,58380E-1

1,16631E0

9.0

relative error(%)

0,00

9.2

BioUML

5,97210E-2

3,53200E0

2,34145E0

8,20819E-2

4,39379E0

9,00774E-3

5,82787E-1

1,87823E0

1,48179E-1

1,81872E-2

9,59013E-1

1,98666E-1

1,89555E0

1,67400E-1

1,18287E0

9.2

ByoDyn

5,97210E-2

3,53200E0

2,34145E0

8,20819E-2

4,39379E0

9,00774E-3

5,82787E-1

1,87823E0

1,48179E-1

1,81872E-2

9,59013E-1

1,98666E-1

1,89555E0

1,67400E-1

1,18287E0

9.2

Jarnac

8,18609E-2

3,83288E0

2,57683E0

1,18449E-1

4,35790E0

1,23281E-2

1,03384E0

2,06340E0

1,72613E-1

2,18205E-2

3,21525E-1

2,31232E-1

1,66017E0

6,79037E-2

1,18249E0

9.2

MathSBML

5,97210E-2

3,53200E0

2,34145E0

8,20819E-2

4,39379E0

9,00774E-3

5,82787E-1

1,87823E0

1,48179E-1

1,81872E-2

9,59013E-1

1,98666E-1

1,89555E0

1,67400E-1

1,18287E0

9.2

Oscill8 Core

5,97210E-2

3,53200E0

2,34145E0

8,20819E-2

4,39379E0

9,00775E-3

5,82787E-1

1,87823E0

1,48179E-1

1,81872E-2

9,59013E-1

1,98666E-1

1,89555E0

1,67400E-1

1,18287E0

9.2

SBToolbox2

5,97145E-2

3,53215E0

2,34150E0

8,20914E-2

4,39382E0

9,00234E-3

5,82847E-1

1,87831E0

1,48147E-1

1,81877E-2

9,58888E-1

1,98620E-1

1,89550E0

1,67378E-1

1,18286E0

9.2

SBWOdeSolver

5,97210E-2

3,53200E0

2,34145E0

8,20819E-2

4,39379E0

9,00775E-3

5,82787E-1

1,87823E0

1,48179E-1

1,81872E-2

9,59012E-1

1,98666E-1

1,89555E0

1,67400E-1

1,18287E0

9.2

VCell

5,97210E-2

3,53200E0

2,34145E0

8,20819E-2

4,39379E0

9,00774E-3

5,82787E-1

1,87823E0

1,48179E-1

1,81872E-2

9,59013E-1

1,98666E-1

1,89555E0

1,67400E-1

1,18287E0

9.2

copasi

5,97212E-2

3,53200E0

2,34145E0

8,20819E-2

4,39379E0

9,00778E-3

5,82787E-1

1,87823E0

1,48179E-1

1,81873E-2

9,59012E-1

1,98666E-1

1,89555E0

1,67400E-1

1,18287E0

9.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,42213E-2

3,23254E0

1,98051E0

4,73706E-2

4,40787E0

7,84387E-3

2,61727E-1

1,54694E0

1,37887E-1

1,43223E-2

1,51076E0

1,85752E-1

2,25650E0

2,83273E-1

1,18387E0

9.2

jsim

5,97210E-2

3,53200E0

2,34145E0

8,20818E-2

4,39379E0

9,00774E-3

5,82787E-1

1,87823E0

1,48179E-1

1,81872E-2

9,59013E-1

1,98666E-1

1,89555E0

1,67400E-1

1,18287E0

9.2

min

4,42213E-2

3,23254E0

1,98051E0

4,73706E-2

4,35790E0

7,84387E-3

2,61727E-1

1,54694E0

1,37887E-1

1,43223E-2

3,21525E-1

1,85752E-1

1,66017E0

6,79037E-2

1,18249E0

9.2

max

8,18609E-2

3,83288E0

2,57683E0

1,18449E-1

4,40787E0

1,23281E-2

1,03384E0

2,06340E0

1,72613E-1

2,18205E-2

1,51076E0

2,31232E-1

2,25650E0

2,83273E-1

1,18387E0

9.2

mean

5,97210E-2

3,53200E0

2,34145E0

8,20819E-2

4,39379E0

9,00774E-3

5,82787E-1

1,87823E0

1,48179E-1

1,81872E-2

9,59013E-1

1,98666E-1

1,89555E0

1,67400E-1

1,18287E0

9.2

relative error(%)

0,00

9.4

BioUML

5,97049E-2

3,59305E0

2,36641E0

8,10301E-2

4,39608E0

8,80619E-3

5,70543E-1

1,90582E0

1,45358E-1

1,83739E-2

1,00018E0

1,96571E-1

1,87061E0

1,76819E-1

1,19930E0

9.4

ByoDyn

5,97049E-2

3,59305E0

2,36641E0

8,10301E-2

4,39608E0

8,80619E-3

5,70543E-1

1,90582E0

1,45358E-1

1,83739E-2

1,00018E0

1,96571E-1

1,87061E0

1,76819E-1

1,19930E0

9.4

Jarnac

8,15859E-2

3,91293E0

2,61494E0

1,18941E-1

4,36315E0

1,18112E-2

1,03804E0

2,10485E0

1,69304E-1

2,20521E-2

3,35671E-1

2,26495E-1

1,62208E0

7,10369E-2

1,19894E0

9.4

MathSBML

5,97049E-2

3,59305E0

2,36641E0

8,10302E-2

4,39608E0

8,80619E-3

5,70543E-1

1,90582E0

1,45358E-1

1,83739E-2

1,00018E0

1,96571E-1

1,87061E0

1,76818E-1

1,19930E0

9.4

Oscill8 Core

5,97049E-2

3,59305E0

2,36641E0

8,10302E-2

4,39608E0

8,80619E-3

5,70543E-1

1,90582E0

1,45358E-1

1,83739E-2

1,00018E0

1,96571E-1

1,87061E0

1,76819E-1

1,19930E0

9.4

SBToolbox2

5,96953E-2

3,59319E0

2,36647E0

8,10391E-2

4,39611E0

8,80101E-3

5,70606E-1

1,90588E0

1,45322E-1

1,83726E-2

1,00003E0

1,96515E-1

1,87053E0

1,76799E-1

1,19925E0

9.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,97049E-2

3,59305E0

2,36641E0

8,10302E-2

4,39608E0

8,80619E-3

5,70543E-1

1,90582E0

1,45358E-1

1,83739E-2

1,00018E0

1,96571E-1

1,87061E0

1,76818E-1

1,19930E0

9.4

VCell

5,97049E-2

3,59305E0

2,36641E0

8,10301E-2

4,39608E0

8,80619E-3

5,70543E-1

1,90582E0

1,45358E-1

1,83739E-2

1,00018E0

1,96571E-1

1,87061E0

1,76819E-1

1,19930E0

9.4

copasi

5,97051E-2

3,59305E0

2,36641E0

8,10302E-2

4,39608E0

8,80622E-3

5,70544E-1

1,90582E0

1,45358E-1

1,83739E-2

1,00018E0

1,96572E-1

1,87061E0

1,76818E-1

1,19930E0

9.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,39093E-2

3,27922E0

1,98364E0

4,44806E-2

4,40937E0

7,71790E-3

2,39640E-1

1,55330E0

1,34956E-1

1,43349E-2

1,57541E0

1,84371E-1

2,25337E0

2,98065E-1

1,20029E0

9.4

jsim

5,97049E-2

3,59305E0

2,36641E0

8,10301E-2

4,39608E0

8,80619E-3

5,70543E-1

1,90582E0

1,45358E-1

1,83739E-2

1,00018E0

1,96571E-1

1,87061E0

1,76819E-1

1,19930E0

9.4

min

4,39093E-2

3,27922E0

1,98364E0

4,44806E-2

4,36315E0

7,71790E-3

2,39640E-1

1,55330E0

1,34956E-1

1,43349E-2

3,35671E-1

1,84371E-1

1,62208E0

7,10369E-2

1,19894E0

9.4

max

8,15859E-2

3,91293E0

2,61494E0

1,18941E-1

4,40937E0

1,18112E-2

1,03804E0

2,10485E0

1,69304E-1

2,20521E-2

1,57541E0

2,26495E-1

2,25337E0

2,98065E-1

1,20029E0

9.4

mean

5,97049E-2

3,59305E0

2,36641E0

8,10302E-2

4,39608E0

8,80619E-3

5,70543E-1

1,90582E0

1,45358E-1

1,83739E-2

1,00018E0

1,96571E-1

1,87061E0

1,76819E-1

1,19930E0

9.4

relative error(%)

0,00

9.6

BioUML

5,99008E-2

3,65347E0

2,39027E0

8,01543E-2

4,39753E0

8,67774E-3

5,60425E-1

1,93153E0

1,43113E-1

1,85752E-2

1,03952E0

1,95252E-1

1,84675E0

1,86619E-1

1,21560E0

9.6

ByoDyn

5,99008E-2

3,65347E0

2,39027E0

8,01543E-2

4,39753E0

8,67774E-3

5,60425E-1

1,93153E0

1,43113E-1

1,85752E-2

1,03952E0

1,95252E-1

1,84675E0

1,86619E-1

1,21560E0

9.6

Jarnac

8,13463E-2

3,99240E0

2,65268E0

1,19452E-1

4,36806E0

1,13379E-2

1,04249E0

2,14571E0

1,66186E-1

2,22835E-2

3,49815E-1

2,22060E-1

1,58434E0

7,43045E-2

1,21524E0

9.6

MathSBML

5,99009E-2

3,65347E0

2,39027E0

8,01543E-2

4,39753E0

8,67774E-3

5,60425E-1

1,93153E0

1,43113E-1

1,85752E-2

1,03952E0

1,95252E-1

1,84675E0

1,86619E-1

1,21560E0

9.6

Oscill8 Core

5,99008E-2

3,65347E0

2,39027E0

8,01543E-2

4,39753E0

8,67774E-3

5,60425E-1

1,93153E0

1,43113E-1

1,85752E-2

1,03952E0

1,95252E-1

1,84675E0

1,86619E-1

1,21560E0

9.6

SBToolbox2

5,98896E-2

3,65362E0

2,39035E0

8,01644E-2

4,39760E0

8,67151E-3

5,60482E-1

1,93165E0

1,43076E-1

1,85744E-2

1,03938E0

1,95188E-1

1,84666E0

1,86590E-1

1,21554E0

9.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,99009E-2

3,65347E0

2,39027E0

8,01543E-2

4,39753E0

8,67774E-3

5,60425E-1

1,93153E0

1,43113E-1

1,85752E-2

1,03952E0

1,95252E-1

1,84675E0

1,86619E-1

1,21560E0

9.6

VCell

5,99008E-2

3,65347E0

2,39027E0

8,01543E-2

4,39753E0

8,67774E-3

5,60425E-1

1,93153E0

1,43113E-1

1,85752E-2

1,03952E0

1,95252E-1

1,84675E0

1,86619E-1

1,21560E0

9.6

copasi

5,99010E-2

3,65347E0

2,39027E0

8,01544E-2

4,39753E0

8,67777E-3

5,60426E-1

1,93153E0

1,43114E-1

1,85752E-2

1,03952E0

1,95253E-1

1,84675E0

1,86619E-1

1,21560E0

9.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,37098E-2

3,32484E0

1,98417E0

4,17657E-2

4,41012E0

7,65305E-3

2,19725E-1

1,55622E0

1,32742E-1

1,43400E-2

1,63896E0

1,83687E-1

2,25285E0

3,13466E-1

1,21658E0

9.6

jsim

5,99008E-2

3,65347E0

2,39027E0

8,01543E-2

4,39753E0

8,67774E-3

5,60425E-1

1,93153E0

1,43113E-1

1,85752E-2

1,03952E0

1,95252E-1

1,84675E0

1,86619E-1

1,21560E0

9.6

min

4,37098E-2

3,32484E0

1,98417E0

4,17657E-2

4,36806E0

7,65305E-3

2,19725E-1

1,55622E0

1,32742E-1

1,43400E-2

3,49815E-1

1,83687E-1

1,58434E0

7,43045E-2

1,21524E0

9.6

max

8,13463E-2

3,99240E0

2,65268E0

1,19452E-1

4,41012E0

1,13379E-2

1,04249E0

2,14571E0

1,66186E-1

2,22835E-2

1,63896E0

2,22060E-1

2,25285E0

3,13466E-1

1,21658E0

9.6

mean

5,99008E-2

3,65347E0

2,39027E0

8,01543E-2

4,39753E0

8,67774E-3

5,60425E-1

1,93153E0

1,43113E-1

1,85752E-2

1,03952E0

1,95252E-1

1,84675E0

1,86619E-1

1,21560E0

9.6

relative error(%)

0,00

9.8

BioUML

6,03105E-2

3,71349E0

2,41307E0

7,94809E-2

4,39815E0

8,61841E-3

5,52670E-1

1,95538E0

1,41425E-1

1,87921E-2

1,07669E0

1,94684E-1

1,82396E0

1,96780E-1

1,23177E0

9.8

ByoDyn

6,03105E-2

3,71349E0

2,41307E0

7,94809E-2

4,39815E0

8,61841E-3

5,52670E-1

1,95538E0

1,41425E-1

1,87921E-2

1,07669E0

1,94684E-1

1,82396E0

1,96780E-1

1,23177E0

9.8

Jarnac

8,11394E-2

4,07134E0

2,69000E0

1,19986E-1

4,37264E0

1,09039E-2

1,04721E0

2,18594E0

1,63247E-1

2,25139E-2

3,63931E-1

2,17905E-1

1,54703E0

7,77061E-2

1,23142E0

9.8

MathSBML

6,03105E-2

3,71349E0

2,41307E0

7,94809E-2

4,39815E0

8,61841E-3

5,52670E-1

1,95538E0

1,41425E-1

1,87921E-2

1,07669E0

1,94684E-1

1,82396E0

1,96780E-1

1,23177E0

9.8

Oscill8 Core

6,03105E-2

3,71349E0

2,41307E0

7,94809E-2

4,39815E0

8,61841E-3

5,52670E-1

1,95538E0

1,41425E-1

1,87921E-2

1,07669E0

1,94684E-1

1,82396E0

1,96780E-1

1,23177E0

9.8

SBToolbox2

6,02915E-2

3,71376E0

2,41322E0

7,94924E-2

4,39830E0

8,60957E-3

5,52744E-1

1,95552E0

1,41369E-1

1,87892E-2

1,07644E0

1,94590E-1

1,82388E0

1,96740E-1

1,23172E0

9.8

SBWOdeSolver

6,03105E-2

3,71349E0

2,41307E0

7,94809E-2

4,39815E0

8,61841E-3

5,52670E-1

1,95538E0

1,41425E-1

1,87921E-2

1,07669E0

1,94684E-1

1,82396E0

1,96780E-1

1,23177E0

9.8

VCell

6,03105E-2

3,71349E0

2,41307E0

7,94809E-2

4,39815E0

8,61841E-3

5,52670E-1

1,95538E0

1,41425E-1

1,87921E-2

1,07669E0

1,94684E-1

1,82396E0

1,96780E-1

1,23177E0

9.8

copasi

6,03107E-2

3,71349E0

2,41307E0

7,94810E-2

4,39815E0

8,61844E-3

5,52671E-1

1,95538E0

1,41425E-1

1,87921E-2

1,07669E0

1,94684E-1

1,82396E0

1,96780E-1

1,23177E0

9.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,36057E-2

3,36958E0

1,98213E0

3,92427E-2

4,41017E0

7,64335E-3

2,01960E-1

1,55588E0

1,31155E-1

1,43371E-2

1,70130E0

1,83644E-1

2,25489E0

3,29461E-1

1,23273E0

9.8

jsim

6,03105E-2

3,71349E0

2,41307E0

7,94809E-2

4,39815E0

8,61841E-3

5,52670E-1

1,95538E0

1,41425E-1

1,87921E-2

1,07669E0

1,94684E-1

1,82396E0

1,96780E-1

1,23177E0

9.8

min

4,36057E-2

3,36958E0

1,98213E0

3,92427E-2

4,37264E0

7,64335E-3

2,01960E-1

1,55588E0

1,31155E-1

1,43371E-2

3,63931E-1

1,83644E-1

1,54703E0

7,77061E-2

1,23142E0

9.8

max

8,11394E-2

4,07134E0

2,69000E0

1,19986E-1

4,41017E0

1,09039E-2

1,04721E0

2,18594E0

1,63247E-1

2,25139E-2

1,70130E0

2,17905E-1

2,25489E0

3,29461E-1

1,23273E0

9.8

mean

6,03105E-2

3,71349E0

2,41307E0

7,94809E-2

4,39815E0

8,61841E-3

5,52670E-1

1,95538E0

1,41425E-1

1,87921E-2

1,07669E0

1,94684E-1

1,82396E0

1,96780E-1

1,23177E0

9.8

relative error(%)

0,00