Test BIOMD0000000026.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000026.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000026.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: DormandPrince
generated code	: BIOMD0000000026.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: -
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000026.gif

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: Mp_MKP3_dep M_MAPKK Mpp Mp_MKP3 Mpp_MKP3 M_MKP3 M MKP3 Mp_MAPKK Mp MAPKK
Simulators: ByoDyn copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner Jarnac SBToolbox2 VCell SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

Mp_MKP3_dep

M_MAPKK

Mpp

Mp_MKP3

Mpp_MKP3

M_MKP3

MKP3

Mp_MAPKK

MAPKK

0.0

BioUML

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

ByoDyn

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

Jarnac

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

MathSBML

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

SBToolbox2

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

VCell

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

copasi

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

jsim

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

min

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

max

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

mean

0,00000E0

5,00000E2

1,00000E2

0,00000E0

5,00000E1

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

3,15221E-3

3,94154E1

8,08242E-4

3,06654E-3

1,89602E-4

9,71008E0

4,50822E2

9,02835E1

7,56963E-4

4,48078E-2

1,05839E1

0.2

ByoDyn

3,15221E-3

3,94154E1

8,08242E-4

3,06654E-3

1,89602E-4

9,71008E0

4,50822E2

9,02835E1

7,56963E-4

4,48078E-2

1,05839E1

0.2

Jarnac

3,15223E-3

3,94155E1

8,08232E-4

3,06655E-3

1,89605E-4

9,71008E0

4,50822E2

9,02835E1

7,56959E-4

4,48077E-2

1,05838E1

0.2

MathSBML

3,15221E-3

3,94154E1

8,08242E-4

3,06654E-3

1,89602E-4

9,71008E0

4,50822E2

9,02835E1

7,56963E-4

4,48078E-2

1,05839E1

0.2

SBToolbox2

3,15215E-3

3,94233E1

8,09734E-4

3,06632E-3

1,90431E-4

9,71018E0

4,50811E2

9,02838E1

7,57943E-4

4,47961E-2

1,05757E1

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

3,15242E-3

3,94148E1

8,08258E-4

3,06674E-3

1,89630E-4

9,71005E0

4,50822E2

9,02835E1

7,56938E-4

4,48079E-2

1,05844E1

0.2

VCell

3,15221E-3

3,94154E1

8,08242E-4

3,06654E-3

1,89602E-4

9,71008E0

4,50822E2

9,02835E1

7,56963E-4

4,48078E-2

1,05839E1

0.2

copasi

3,15221E-3

3,94154E1

8,08242E-4

3,06654E-3

1,89602E-4

9,71008E0

4,50822E2

9,02835E1

7,56963E-4

4,48078E-2

1,05839E1

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,15221E-3

3,94154E1

8,08239E-4

3,06654E-3

1,89602E-4

9,71008E0

4,50822E2

9,02835E1

7,56964E-4

4,48078E-2

1,05839E1

0.2

jsim

3,15221E-3

3,94154E1

8,08242E-4

3,06654E-3

1,89602E-4

9,71008E0

4,50822E2

9,02835E1

7,56963E-4

4,48078E-2

1,05839E1

0.2

min

3,15215E-3

3,94148E1

8,08232E-4

3,06632E-3

1,89602E-4

9,71005E0

4,50811E2

9,02835E1

7,56938E-4

4,47961E-2

1,05757E1

0.2

max

3,15242E-3

3,94233E1

8,09734E-4

3,06674E-3

1,90431E-4

9,71018E0

4,50822E2

9,02838E1

7,57943E-4

4,48079E-2

1,05844E1

0.2

mean

3,15221E-3

3,94154E1

8,08242E-4

3,06654E-3

1,89602E-4

9,71008E0

4,50822E2

9,02835E1

7,56963E-4

4,48078E-2

1,05839E1

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

1,43519E-2

4,41120E1

2,54504E-3

1,35456E-2

1,32724E-3

1,78739E1

4,37877E2

8,20969E1

1,12508E-3

1,04146E-1

5,88683E0

0.4

ByoDyn

1,43519E-2

4,41120E1

2,54504E-3

1,35456E-2

1,32724E-3

1,78739E1

4,37877E2

8,20969E1

1,12508E-3

1,04146E-1

5,88683E0

0.4

Jarnac

1,43521E-2

4,41121E1

2,54501E-3

1,35457E-2

1,32726E-3

1,78738E1

4,37877E2

8,20969E1

1,12507E-3

1,04145E-1

5,88679E0

0.4

MathSBML

1,43519E-2

4,41120E1

2,54504E-3

1,35456E-2

1,32724E-3

1,78739E1

4,37877E2

8,20969E1

1,12508E-3

1,04146E-1

5,88683E0

0.4

SBToolbox2

1,43507E-2

4,41170E1

2,54658E-3

1,35441E-2

1,32915E-3

1,78738E1

4,37868E2

8,20963E1

1,12506E-3

1,04138E-1

5,88185E0

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,43521E-2

4,41119E1

2,54504E-3

1,35458E-2

1,32728E-3

1,78738E1

4,37877E2

8,20969E1

1,12509E-3

1,04145E-1

5,88696E0

0.4

VCell

1,43519E-2

4,41120E1

2,54504E-3

1,35456E-2

1,32724E-3

1,78739E1

4,37877E2

8,20969E1

1,12508E-3

1,04146E-1

5,88683E0

0.4

copasi

1,43519E-2

4,41120E1

2,54504E-3

1,35456E-2

1,32724E-3

1,78739E1

4,37877E2

8,20969E1

1,12508E-3

1,04146E-1

5,88683E0

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,43519E-2

4,41120E1

2,54504E-3

1,35456E-2

1,32724E-3

1,78739E1

4,37877E2

8,20969E1

1,12508E-3

1,04146E-1

5,88685E0

0.4

jsim

1,43519E-2

4,41120E1

2,54504E-3

1,35456E-2

1,32724E-3

1,78739E1

4,37877E2

8,20969E1

1,12508E-3

1,04146E-1

5,88683E0

0.4

min

1,43507E-2

4,41119E1

2,54501E-3

1,35441E-2

1,32724E-3

1,78738E1

4,37868E2

8,20963E1

1,12506E-3

1,04138E-1

5,88185E0

0.4

max

1,43521E-2

4,41170E1

2,54658E-3

1,35458E-2

1,32915E-3

1,78739E1

4,37877E2

8,20969E1

1,12509E-3

1,04146E-1

5,88696E0

0.4

mean

1,43519E-2

4,41120E1

2,54504E-3

1,35456E-2

1,32724E-3

1,78739E1

4,37877E2

8,20969E1

1,12508E-3

1,04146E-1

5,88683E0

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

3,04325E-2

4,46774E1

4,48487E-3

2,78519E-2

3,28186E-3

2,49935E1

4,30105E2

7,49449E1

1,52172E-3

1,56403E-1

5,32104E0

0.6

ByoDyn

3,04325E-2

4,46774E1

4,48487E-3

2,78519E-2

3,28186E-3

2,49935E1

4,30105E2

7,49449E1

1,52172E-3

1,56403E-1

5,32104E0

0.6

Jarnac

3,04329E-2

4,46774E1

4,48496E-3

2,78521E-2

3,28202E-3

2,49933E1

4,30105E2

7,49451E1

1,52172E-3

1,56402E-1

5,32108E0

0.6

MathSBML

3,04325E-2

4,46774E1

4,48487E-3

2,78519E-2

3,28186E-3

2,49935E1

4,30105E2

7,49449E1

1,52172E-3

1,56403E-1

5,32104E0

0.6

SBToolbox2

3,04319E-2

4,46806E1

4,48465E-3

2,78508E-2

3,28541E-3

2,49939E1

4,30101E2

7,49442E1

1,52094E-3

1,56402E-1

5,31773E0

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

3,04326E-2

4,46774E1

4,48492E-3

2,78520E-2

3,28190E-3

2,49934E1

4,30105E2

7,49450E1

1,52172E-3

1,56403E-1

5,32106E0

0.6

VCell

3,04325E-2

4,46774E1

4,48487E-3

2,78519E-2

3,28186E-3

2,49935E1

4,30105E2

7,49449E1

1,52172E-3

1,56403E-1

5,32104E0

0.6

copasi

3,04325E-2

4,46774E1

4,48488E-3

2,78519E-2

3,28186E-3

2,49935E1

4,30105E2

7,49449E1

1,52172E-3

1,56403E-1

5,32104E0

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,04325E-2

4,46774E1

4,48488E-3

2,78519E-2

3,28186E-3

2,49935E1

4,30105E2

7,49449E1

1,52172E-3

1,56403E-1

5,32105E0

0.6

jsim

3,04325E-2

4,46774E1

4,48487E-3

2,78519E-2

3,28186E-3

2,49935E1

4,30105E2

7,49449E1

1,52172E-3

1,56403E-1

5,32104E0

0.6

min

3,04319E-2

4,46774E1

4,48465E-3

2,78508E-2

3,28186E-3

2,49933E1

4,30101E2

7,49442E1

1,52094E-3

1,56402E-1

5,31773E0

0.6

max

3,04329E-2

4,46806E1

4,48496E-3

2,78521E-2

3,28541E-3

2,49939E1

4,30105E2

7,49451E1

1,52172E-3

1,56403E-1

5,32108E0

0.6

mean

3,04325E-2

4,46774E1

4,48487E-3

2,78519E-2

3,28186E-3

2,49935E1

4,30105E2

7,49449E1

1,52172E-3

1,56403E-1

5,32104E0

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

4,84484E-2

4,46951E1

7,01114E-3

4,30235E-2

5,94974E-3

3,12491E1

4,23746E2

6,86535E1

2,00284E-3

2,03395E-1

5,30291E0

0.8

ByoDyn

4,84484E-2

4,46951E1

7,01114E-3

4,30235E-2

5,94974E-3

3,12491E1

4,23746E2

6,86535E1

2,00284E-3

2,03395E-1

5,30291E0

0.8

Jarnac

4,84489E-2

4,46951E1

7,01139E-3

4,30234E-2

5,95021E-3

3,12487E1

4,23746E2

6,86539E1

2,00284E-3

2,03393E-1

5,30292E0

0.8

MathSBML

4,84484E-2

4,46951E1

7,01114E-3

4,30235E-2

5,94974E-3

3,12491E1

4,23746E2

6,86535E1

2,00284E-3

2,03395E-1

5,30291E0

0.8

SBToolbox2

4,84516E-2

4,46962E1

7,00621E-3

4,30278E-2

5,95562E-3

3,12504E1

4,23744E2

6,86527E1

2,00173E-3

2,03388E-1

5,30144E0

0.8

SBWOdeSolver

4,84484E-2

4,46951E1

7,01121E-3

4,30234E-2

5,94981E-3

3,12490E1

4,23746E2

6,86535E1

2,00284E-3

2,03394E-1

5,30291E0

0.8

VCell

4,84484E-2

4,46951E1

7,01114E-3

4,30235E-2

5,94974E-3

3,12491E1

4,23746E2

6,86535E1

2,00284E-3

2,03395E-1

5,30291E0

0.8

copasi

4,84484E-2

4,46951E1

7,01114E-3

4,30235E-2

5,94975E-3

3,12491E1

4,23746E2

6,86535E1

2,00285E-3

2,03395E-1

5,30291E0

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,84484E-2

4,46951E1

7,01114E-3

4,30235E-2

5,94975E-3

3,12491E1

4,23746E2

6,86535E1

2,00285E-3

2,03395E-1

5,30292E0

0.8

jsim

4,84484E-2

4,46951E1

7,01114E-3

4,30235E-2

5,94974E-3

3,12491E1

4,23746E2

6,86535E1

2,00284E-3

2,03395E-1

5,30291E0

0.8

min

4,84484E-2

4,46951E1

7,00621E-3

4,30234E-2

5,94974E-3

3,12487E1

4,23744E2

6,86527E1

2,00173E-3

2,03388E-1

5,30144E0

0.8

max

4,84516E-2

4,46962E1

7,01139E-3

4,30278E-2

5,95562E-3

3,12504E1

4,23746E2

6,86539E1

2,00285E-3

2,03395E-1

5,30292E0

0.8

mean

4,84484E-2

4,46951E1

7,01114E-3

4,30235E-2

5,94975E-3

3,12491E1

4,23746E2

6,86535E1

2,00284E-3

2,03395E-1

5,30291E0

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

6,67369E-2

4,46419E1

1,02234E-2

5,75789E-2

9,34956E-3

3,67639E1

4,18200E2

6,31025E1

2,49859E-3

2,47744E-1

5,35561E0

1.0

ByoDyn

6,67369E-2

4,46419E1

1,02234E-2

5,75789E-2

9,34956E-3

3,67639E1

4,18200E2

6,31025E1

2,49859E-3

2,47744E-1

5,35561E0

1.0

Jarnac

6,67371E-2

4,46419E1

1,02238E-2

5,75784E-2

9,35049E-3

3,67632E1

4,18201E2

6,31032E1

2,49856E-3

2,47741E-1

5,35561E0

1.0

MathSBML

6,67369E-2

4,46419E1

1,02234E-2

5,75789E-2

9,34956E-3

3,67639E1

4,18200E2

6,31025E1

2,49859E-3

2,47744E-1

5,35561E0

1.0

SBToolbox2

6,67485E-2

4,46423E1

1,02142E-2

5,75939E-2

9,35705E-3

3,67651E1

4,18196E2

6,31011E1

2,49781E-3

2,47721E-1

5,35520E0

1.0

SBWOdeSolver

6,67368E-2

4,46419E1

1,02235E-2

5,75788E-2

9,34964E-3

3,67638E1

4,18200E2

6,31025E1

2,49859E-3

2,47744E-1

5,35561E0

1.0

VCell

6,67369E-2

4,46419E1

1,02234E-2

5,75789E-2

9,34956E-3

3,67639E1

4,18200E2

6,31025E1

2,49859E-3

2,47744E-1

5,35561E0

1.0

copasi

6,67369E-2

4,46419E1

1,02234E-2

5,75789E-2

9,34956E-3

3,67639E1

4,18200E2

6,31025E1

2,49859E-3

2,47744E-1

5,35561E0

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,67369E-2

4,46419E1

1,02234E-2

5,75790E-2

9,34957E-3

3,67639E1

4,18200E2

6,31025E1

2,49859E-3

2,47744E-1

5,35562E0

1.0

jsim

6,67369E-2

4,46419E1

1,02234E-2

5,75790E-2

9,34956E-3

3,67639E1

4,18200E2

6,31025E1

2,49859E-3

2,47744E-1

5,35561E0

1.0

min

6,67368E-2

4,46419E1

1,02142E-2

5,75784E-2

9,34956E-3

3,67632E1

4,18196E2

6,31011E1

2,49781E-3

2,47721E-1

5,35520E0

1.0

max

6,67485E-2

4,46423E1

1,02238E-2

5,75939E-2

9,35705E-3

3,67651E1

4,18201E2

6,31032E1

2,49859E-3

2,47744E-1

5,35562E0

1.0

mean

6,67369E-2

4,46419E1

1,02234E-2

5,75789E-2

9,34956E-3

3,67639E1

4,18200E2

6,31025E1

2,49859E-3

2,47744E-1

5,35561E0

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

8,44319E-2

4,45837E1

1,41375E-2

7,08911E-2

1,34669E-2

4,16376E1

4,13302E2

5,81936E1

2,99510E-3

2,90999E-1

5,41331E0

1.2

ByoDyn

8,44319E-2

4,45837E1

1,41375E-2

7,08911E-2

1,34669E-2

4,16376E1

4,13302E2

5,81936E1

2,99510E-3

2,90999E-1

5,41331E0

1.2

Jarnac

8,44316E-2

4,45837E1

1,41382E-2

7,08899E-2

1,34684E-2

4,16366E1

4,13303E2

5,81946E1

2,99506E-3

2,90996E-1

5,41330E0

1.2

MathSBML

8,44319E-2

4,45837E1

1,41375E-2

7,08911E-2

1,34669E-2

4,16376E1

4,13302E2

5,81936E1

2,99510E-3

2,90999E-1

5,41331E0

1.2

SBToolbox2

8,44554E-2

4,45834E1

1,41234E-2

7,09172E-2

1,34762E-2

4,16394E1

4,13298E2

5,81917E1

2,99431E-3

2,90952E-1

5,41316E0

1.2

SBWOdeSolver

8,44318E-2

4,45837E1

1,41376E-2

7,08909E-2

1,34670E-2

4,16375E1

4,13302E2

5,81937E1

2,99510E-3

2,90999E-1

5,41331E0

1.2

VCell

8,44319E-2

4,45837E1

1,41375E-2

7,08911E-2

1,34669E-2

4,16376E1

4,13302E2

5,81936E1

2,99510E-3

2,90999E-1

5,41331E0

1.2

copasi

8,44319E-2

4,45837E1

1,41375E-2

7,08911E-2

1,34669E-2

4,16376E1

4,13302E2

5,81936E1

2,99510E-3

2,90999E-1

5,41331E0

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,44320E-2

4,45837E1

1,41375E-2

7,08911E-2

1,34669E-2

4,16376E1

4,13302E2

5,81936E1

2,99510E-3

2,90999E-1

5,41332E0

1.2

jsim

8,44319E-2

4,45837E1

1,41375E-2

7,08911E-2

1,34669E-2

4,16376E1

4,13302E2

5,81936E1

2,99510E-3

2,90999E-1

5,41331E0

1.2

min

8,44316E-2

4,45834E1

1,41234E-2

7,08899E-2

1,34669E-2

4,16366E1

4,13298E2

5,81917E1

2,99431E-3

2,90952E-1

5,41316E0

1.2

max

8,44554E-2

4,45837E1

1,41382E-2

7,09172E-2

1,34762E-2

4,16394E1

4,13303E2

5,81946E1

2,99510E-3

2,90999E-1

5,41332E0

1.2

mean

8,44319E-2

4,45837E1

1,41375E-2

7,08911E-2

1,34669E-2

4,16376E1

4,13302E2

5,81936E1

2,99510E-3

2,90999E-1

5,41331E0

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

1,01101E-1

4,45295E1

1,87864E-2

8,27578E-2

1,82603E-2

4,59540E1

4,08958E2

5,38439E1

3,49449E-3

3,33939E-1

5,46704E0

1.4

ByoDyn

1,01101E-1

4,45295E1

1,87864E-2

8,27578E-2

1,82603E-2

4,59540E1

4,08958E2

5,38439E1

3,49449E-3

3,33939E-1

5,46704E0

1.4

Jarnac

1,01100E-1

4,45295E1

1,87875E-2

8,27559E-2

1,82627E-2

4,59526E1

4,08960E2

5,38453E1

3,49444E-3

3,33935E-1

5,46702E0

1.4

MathSBML

1,01101E-1

4,45295E1

1,87864E-2

8,27578E-2

1,82603E-2

4,59540E1

4,08958E2

5,38439E1

3,49449E-3

3,33939E-1

5,46704E0

1.4

SBToolbox2

1,01137E-1

4,45294E1

1,87679E-2

8,27937E-2

1,82713E-2

4,59566E1

4,08958E2

5,38408E1

3,49349E-3

3,33879E-1

5,46704E0

1.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,01101E-1

4,45295E1

1,87865E-2

8,27576E-2

1,82604E-2

4,59539E1

4,08958E2

5,38440E1

3,49449E-3

3,33939E-1

5,46704E0

1.4

VCell

1,01101E-1

4,45295E1

1,87864E-2

8,27578E-2

1,82603E-2

4,59540E1

4,08958E2

5,38439E1

3,49449E-3

3,33939E-1

5,46704E0

1.4

copasi

1,01101E-1

4,45295E1

1,87864E-2

8,27578E-2

1,82603E-2

4,59540E1

4,08958E2

5,38439E1

3,49449E-3

3,33939E-1

5,46704E0

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,01101E-1

4,45295E1

1,87864E-2

8,27578E-2

1,82603E-2

4,59540E1

4,08958E2

5,38439E1

3,49449E-3

3,33939E-1

5,46704E0

1.4

jsim

1,01101E-1

4,45295E1

1,87864E-2

8,27578E-2

1,82603E-2

4,59540E1

4,08958E2

5,38439E1

3,49449E-3

3,33939E-1

5,46704E0

1.4

min

1,01100E-1

4,45294E1

1,87679E-2

8,27559E-2

1,82603E-2

4,59526E1

4,08958E2

5,38408E1

3,49349E-3

3,33879E-1

5,46702E0

1.4

max

1,01137E-1

4,45295E1

1,87875E-2

8,27937E-2

1,82713E-2

4,59566E1

4,08960E2

5,38453E1

3,49449E-3

3,33939E-1

5,46704E0

1.4

mean

1,01101E-1

4,45295E1

1,87864E-2

8,27578E-2

1,82603E-2

4,59540E1

4,08958E2

5,38439E1

3,49449E-3

3,33939E-1

5,46704E0

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

1.6

BioUML

1,16547E-1

4,44801E1

2,42181E-2

9,31790E-2

2,36829E-2

4,97839E1

4,05098E2

4,99827E1

3,99932E-3

3,76913E-1

5,51592E0

1.6

ByoDyn

1,16547E-1

4,44801E1

2,42181E-2

9,31790E-2

2,36829E-2

4,97839E1

4,05098E2

4,99827E1

3,99932E-3

3,76913E-1

5,51592E0

1.6

Jarnac

1,16545E-1

4,44801E1

2,42196E-2

9,31766E-2

2,36863E-2

4,97821E1

4,05099E2

4,99845E1

3,99924E-3

3,76907E-1

5,51590E0

1.6

MathSBML

1,16547E-1

4,44801E1

2,42181E-2

9,31790E-2

2,36829E-2

4,97839E1

4,05098E2

4,99827E1

3,99932E-3

3,76913E-1

5,51592E0

1.6

SBToolbox2

1,16592E-1

4,44803E1

2,41934E-2

9,32229E-2

2,36972E-2

4,97870E1

4,05099E2

4,99793E1

3,99814E-3

3,76836E-1

5,51593E0

1.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,16547E-1

4,44801E1

2,42182E-2

9,31787E-2

2,36830E-2

4,97838E1

4,05098E2

4,99828E1

3,99931E-3

3,76913E-1

5,51592E0

1.6

VCell

1,16547E-1

4,44801E1

2,42181E-2

9,31790E-2

2,36829E-2

4,97839E1

4,05098E2

4,99827E1

3,99932E-3

3,76913E-1

5,51592E0

1.6

copasi

1,16547E-1

4,44801E1

2,42181E-2

9,31790E-2

2,36829E-2

4,97839E1

4,05098E2

4,99827E1

3,99932E-3

3,76913E-1

5,51592E0

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,16547E-1

4,44801E1

2,42181E-2

9,31791E-2

2,36829E-2

4,97839E1

4,05098E2

4,99827E1

3,99932E-3

3,76913E-1

5,51593E0

1.6

jsim

1,16547E-1

4,44801E1

2,42180E-2

9,31790E-2

2,36829E-2

4,97839E1

4,05098E2

4,99827E1

3,99932E-3

3,76913E-1

5,51592E0

1.6

min

1,16545E-1

4,44801E1

2,41934E-2

9,31766E-2

2,36829E-2

4,97821E1

4,05098E2

4,99793E1

3,99814E-3

3,76836E-1

5,51590E0

1.6

max

1,16592E-1

4,44803E1

2,42196E-2

9,32229E-2

2,36972E-2

4,97870E1

4,05099E2

4,99845E1

3,99932E-3

3,76913E-1

5,51593E0

1.6

mean

1,16547E-1

4,44801E1

2,42181E-2

9,31790E-2

2,36829E-2

4,97839E1

4,05098E2

4,99827E1

3,99932E-3

3,76913E-1

5,51592E0

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

1.8

BioUML

1,30704E-1

4,44353E1

3,04833E-2

1,02246E-1

2,96904E-2

5,31877E1

4,01659E2

4,65497E1

4,51036E-3

4,20038E-1

5,56022E0

1.8

ByoDyn

1,30704E-1

4,44353E1

3,04833E-2

1,02246E-1

2,96904E-2

5,31877E1

4,01659E2

4,65497E1

4,51036E-3

4,20038E-1

5,56022E0

1.8

Jarnac

1,30701E-1

4,44353E1

3,04854E-2

1,02243E-1

2,96951E-2

5,31856E1

4,01661E2

4,65518E1

4,51027E-3

4,20030E-1

5,56020E0

1.8

MathSBML

1,30704E-1

4,44353E1

3,04833E-2

1,02246E-1

2,96904E-2

5,31877E1

4,01659E2

4,65497E1

4,51036E-3

4,20038E-1

5,56022E0

1.8

SBToolbox2

1,30758E-1

4,44354E1

3,04527E-2

1,02294E-1

2,97065E-2

5,31920E1

4,01659E2

4,65453E1

4,50897E-3

4,19941E-1

5,56022E0

1.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,30703E-1

4,44353E1

3,04835E-2

1,02246E-1

2,96905E-2

5,31876E1

4,01659E2

4,65497E1

4,51037E-3

4,20038E-1

5,56022E0

1.8

VCell

1,30704E-1

4,44353E1

3,04833E-2

1,02246E-1

2,96904E-2

5,31877E1

4,01659E2

4,65497E1

4,51036E-3

4,20038E-1

5,56022E0

1.8

copasi

1,30704E-1

4,44353E1

3,04833E-2

1,02246E-1

2,96904E-2

5,31877E1

4,01659E2

4,65496E1

4,51036E-3

4,20038E-1

5,56022E0

1.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,30704E-1

4,44353E1

3,04833E-2

1,02246E-1

2,96904E-2

5,31877E1

4,01659E2

4,65497E1

4,51036E-3

4,20038E-1

5,56022E0

1.8

jsim

1,30704E-1

4,44353E1

3,04833E-2

1,02246E-1

2,96904E-2

5,31877E1

4,01659E2

4,65497E1

4,51036E-3

4,20038E-1

5,56022E0

1.8

min

1,30701E-1

4,44353E1

3,04527E-2

1,02243E-1

2,96904E-2

5,31856E1

4,01659E2

4,65453E1

4,50897E-3

4,19941E-1

5,56020E0

1.8

max

1,30758E-1

4,44354E1

3,04854E-2

1,02294E-1

2,97065E-2

5,31920E1

4,01661E2

4,65518E1

4,51037E-3

4,20038E-1

5,56022E0

1.8

mean

1,30704E-1

4,44353E1

3,04833E-2

1,02246E-1

2,96904E-2

5,31877E1

4,01659E2

4,65497E1

4,51036E-3

4,20038E-1

5,56022E0

1.8

relative error(%)

0,00

2.0

BioUML

1,43580E-1

4,43946E1

3,76294E-2

1,10088E-1

3,62435E-2

5,62174E1

3,98592E2

4,34927E1

5,02711E-3

4,63307E-1

5,60035E0

2.0

ByoDyn

1,43580E-1

4,43946E1

3,76294E-2

1,10088E-1

3,62435E-2

5,62174E1

3,98592E2

4,34927E1

5,02711E-3

4,63307E-1

5,60035E0

2.0

Jarnac

1,43578E-1

4,43947E1

3,76322E-2

1,10085E-1

3,62497E-2

5,62149E1

3,98595E2

4,34952E1

5,02698E-3

4,63296E-1

5,60032E0

2.0

MathSBML

1,43580E-1

4,43946E1

3,76294E-2

1,10087E-1

3,62435E-2

5,62174E1

3,98592E2

4,34927E1

5,02711E-3

4,63307E-1

5,60035E0

2.0

SBToolbox2

1,43638E-1

4,43944E1

3,75920E-2

1,10146E-1

3,62620E-2

5,62222E1

3,98588E2

4,34880E1

5,02560E-3

4,63206E-1

5,60040E0

2.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,43580E-1

4,43946E1

3,76296E-2

1,10087E-1

3,62436E-2

5,62173E1

3,98592E2

4,34928E1

5,02711E-3

4,63307E-1

5,60035E0

2.0

VCell

1,43580E-1

4,43946E1

3,76294E-2

1,10087E-1

3,62435E-2

5,62174E1

3,98592E2

4,34927E1

5,02711E-3

4,63307E-1

5,60035E0

2.0

copasi

1,43580E-1

4,43946E1

3,76294E-2

1,10087E-1

3,62435E-2

5,62174E1

3,98592E2

4,34927E1

5,02707E-3

4,63307E-1

5,60035E0

2.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,43581E-1

4,43946E1

3,76294E-2

1,10088E-1

3,62435E-2

5,62174E1

3,98592E2

4,34927E1

5,02711E-3

4,63307E-1

5,60035E0

2.0

jsim

1,43580E-1

4,43946E1

3,76294E-2

1,10088E-1

3,62435E-2

5,62174E1

3,98592E2

4,34927E1

5,02711E-3

4,63307E-1

5,60035E0

2.0

min

1,43578E-1

4,43944E1

3,75920E-2

1,10085E-1

3,62435E-2

5,62149E1

3,98588E2

4,34880E1

5,02560E-3

4,63206E-1

5,60032E0

2.0

max

1,43638E-1

4,43947E1

3,76322E-2

1,10146E-1

3,62620E-2

5,62222E1

3,98595E2

4,34952E1

5,02711E-3

4,63307E-1

5,60040E0

2.0

mean

1,43580E-1

4,43946E1

3,76294E-2

1,10087E-1

3,62435E-2

5,62174E1

3,98592E2

4,34927E1

5,02711E-3

4,63307E-1

5,60035E0

2.0

relative error(%)

0,00

2.2

BioUML

1,55230E-1

4,43578E1

4,56968E-2

1,16842E-1

4,33071E-2

5,89174E1

3,95852E2

4,07672E1

5,54826E-3

5,06648E-1

5,63669E0

2.2

ByoDyn

1,55230E-1

4,43578E1

4,56968E-2

1,16842E-1

4,33071E-2

5,89174E1

3,95852E2

4,07672E1

5,54826E-3

5,06648E-1

5,63669E0

2.2

Jarnac

1,55227E-1

4,43578E1

4,57003E-2

1,16839E-1

4,33150E-2

5,89146E1

3,95854E2

4,07700E1

5,54808E-3

5,06634E-1

5,63666E0

2.2

MathSBML

1,55230E-1

4,43578E1

4,56968E-2

1,16842E-1

4,33071E-2

5,89174E1

3,95852E2

4,07672E1

5,54826E-3

5,06648E-1

5,63669E0

2.2

SBToolbox2

1,55297E-1

4,43574E1

4,56521E-2

1,16902E-1

4,33285E-2

5,89228E1

3,95849E2

4,07614E1

5,54666E-3

5,06543E-1

5,63673E0

2.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,55230E-1

4,43578E1

4,56970E-2

1,16842E-1

4,33072E-2

5,89174E1

3,95852E2

4,07672E1

5,54826E-3

5,06648E-1

5,63669E0

2.2

VCell

1,55230E-1

4,43578E1

4,56968E-2

1,16842E-1

4,33071E-2

5,89174E1

3,95852E2

4,07672E1

5,54826E-3

5,06648E-1

5,63669E0

2.2

copasi

1,55230E-1

4,43578E1

4,56968E-2

1,16842E-1

4,33071E-2

5,89174E1

3,95852E2

4,07672E1

5,54831E-3

5,06648E-1

5,63669E0

2.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,55230E-1

4,43578E1

4,56968E-2

1,16842E-1

4,33071E-2

5,89174E1

3,95852E2

4,07672E1

5,54825E-3

5,06648E-1

5,63669E0

2.2

jsim

1,55230E-1

4,43578E1

4,56968E-2

1,16842E-1

4,33071E-2

5,89174E1

3,95852E2

4,07672E1

5,54826E-3

5,06648E-1

5,63669E0

2.2

min

1,55227E-1

4,43574E1

4,56521E-2

1,16839E-1

4,33071E-2

5,89146E1

3,95849E2

4,07614E1

5,54666E-3

5,06543E-1

5,63666E0

2.2

max

1,55297E-1

4,43578E1

4,57003E-2

1,16902E-1

4,33285E-2

5,89228E1

3,95854E2

4,07700E1

5,54831E-3

5,06648E-1

5,63673E0

2.2

mean

1,55230E-1

4,43578E1

4,56968E-2

1,16842E-1

4,33071E-2

5,89174E1

3,95852E2

4,07672E1

5,54826E-3

5,06648E-1

5,63669E0

2.2

relative error(%)

0,00

2.4

BioUML

1,65729E-1

4,43243E1

5,47187E-2

1,22645E-1

5,08499E-2

6,13265E1

3,93399E2

3,83342E1

6,07213E-3

5,49957E-1

5,66961E0

2.4

ByoDyn

1,65729E-1

4,43243E1

5,47187E-2

1,22645E-1

5,08499E-2

6,13265E1

3,93399E2

3,83342E1

6,07213E-3

5,49957E-1

5,66961E0

2.4

Jarnac

1,65726E-1

4,43244E1

5,47230E-2

1,22643E-1

5,08597E-2

6,13234E1

3,93402E2

3,83374E1

6,07189E-3

5,49938E-1

5,66957E0

2.4

MathSBML

1,65729E-1

4,43243E1

5,47187E-2

1,22645E-1

5,08499E-2

6,13265E1

3,93399E2

3,83342E1

6,07213E-3

5,49957E-1

5,66961E0

2.4

SBToolbox2

1,65800E-1

4,43242E1

5,46660E-2

1,22705E-1

5,08736E-2

6,13316E1

3,93396E2

3,83286E1

6,07049E-3

5,49842E-1

5,66964E0

2.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,65729E-1

4,43243E1

5,47189E-2

1,22645E-1

5,08500E-2

6,13265E1

3,93399E2

3,83343E1

6,07213E-3

5,49957E-1

5,66961E0

2.4

VCell

1,65729E-1

4,43243E1

5,47187E-2

1,22645E-1

5,08499E-2

6,13265E1

3,93399E2

3,83342E1

6,07213E-3

5,49957E-1

5,66961E0

2.4

copasi

1,65729E-1

4,43243E1

5,47187E-2

1,22645E-1

5,08499E-2

6,13266E1

3,93399E2

3,83342E1

6,07215E-3

5,49957E-1

5,66961E0

2.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,65729E-1

4,43243E1

5,47187E-2

1,22645E-1

5,08499E-2

6,13265E1

3,93399E2

3,83342E1

6,07213E-3

5,49956E-1

5,66961E0

2.4

jsim

1,65729E-1

4,43243E1

5,47187E-2

1,22645E-1

5,08499E-2

6,13265E1

3,93399E2

3,83342E1

6,07213E-3

5,49957E-1

5,66961E0

2.4

min

1,65726E-1

4,43242E1

5,46660E-2

1,22643E-1

5,08499E-2

6,13234E1

3,93396E2

3,83286E1

6,07049E-3

5,49842E-1

5,66957E0

2.4

max

1,65800E-1

4,43244E1

5,47230E-2

1,22705E-1

5,08736E-2

6,13316E1

3,93402E2

3,83374E1

6,07215E-3

5,49957E-1

5,66964E0

2.4

mean

1,65729E-1

4,43243E1

5,47187E-2

1,22645E-1

5,08499E-2

6,13265E1

3,93399E2

3,83342E1

6,07213E-3

5,49957E-1

5,66961E0

2.4

relative error(%)

0,00

2.6

BioUML

1,75170E-1

4,42940E1

6,47197E-2

1,27624E-1

5,88438E-2

6,34782E1

3,91202E2

3,61601E1

6,59689E-3

5,93115E-1

5,69942E0

2.6

ByoDyn

1,75170E-1

4,42940E1

6,47197E-2

1,27624E-1

5,88438E-2

6,34782E1

3,91202E2

3,61601E1

6,59689E-3

5,93115E-1

5,69942E0

2.6

Jarnac

1,75167E-1

4,42940E1

6,47249E-2

1,27623E-1

5,88559E-2

6,34747E1

3,91205E2

3,61636E1

6,59659E-3

5,93091E-1

5,69938E0

2.6

MathSBML

1,75170E-1

4,42940E1

6,47197E-2

1,27624E-1

5,88438E-2

6,34782E1

3,91202E2

3,61601E1

6,59689E-3

5,93115E-1

5,69942E0

2.6

SBToolbox2

1,75243E-1

4,42943E1

6,46588E-2

1,27690E-1

5,88701E-2

6,34845E1

3,91196E2

3,61538E1

6,59526E-3

5,93001E-1

5,69944E0

2.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,75169E-1

4,42940E1

6,47200E-2

1,27624E-1

5,88439E-2

6,34782E1

3,91202E2

3,61602E1

6,59689E-3

5,93115E-1

5,69942E0

2.6

VCell

1,75170E-1

4,42940E1

6,47197E-2

1,27624E-1

5,88438E-2

6,34782E1

3,91202E2

3,61601E1

6,59689E-3

5,93115E-1

5,69942E0

2.6

copasi

1,75170E-1

4,42940E1

6,47198E-2

1,27624E-1

5,88438E-2

6,34782E1

3,91202E2

3,61601E1

6,59689E-3

5,93115E-1

5,69942E0

2.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,75170E-1

4,42940E1

6,47198E-2

1,27624E-1

5,88438E-2

6,34782E1

3,91202E2

3,61601E1

6,59689E-3

5,93115E-1

5,69942E0

2.6

jsim

1,75170E-1

4,42940E1

6,47197E-2

1,27624E-1

5,88438E-2

6,34782E1

3,91202E2

3,61601E1

6,59689E-3

5,93115E-1

5,69942E0

2.6

min

1,75167E-1

4,42940E1

6,46588E-2

1,27623E-1

5,88438E-2

6,34747E1

3,91196E2

3,61538E1

6,59526E-3

5,93001E-1

5,69938E0

2.6

max

1,75243E-1

4,42943E1

6,47249E-2

1,27690E-1

5,88701E-2

6,34845E1

3,91205E2

3,61636E1

6,59689E-3

5,93115E-1

5,69944E0

2.6

mean

1,75170E-1

4,42940E1

6,47197E-2

1,27624E-1

5,88438E-2

6,34782E1

3,91202E2

3,61601E1

6,59689E-3

5,93115E-1

5,69942E0

2.6

relative error(%)

0,00

2.8

BioUML

1,83648E-1

4,42664E1

7,57168E-2

1,31896E-1

6,72640E-2

6,54017E1

3,89230E2

3,42155E1

7,12070E-3

6,36003E-1

5,72643E0

2.8

ByoDyn

1,83648E-1

4,42664E1

7,57168E-2

1,31896E-1

6,72640E-2

6,54017E1

3,89230E2

3,42155E1

7,12070E-3

6,36003E-1

5,72643E0

2.8

Jarnac

1,83646E-1

4,42665E1

7,57228E-2

1,31895E-1

6,72786E-2

6,53979E1

3,89234E2

3,42193E1

7,12032E-3

6,35973E-1

5,72638E0

2.8

MathSBML

1,83648E-1

4,42664E1

7,57168E-2

1,31896E-1

6,72640E-2

6,54017E1

3,89230E2

3,42155E1

7,12070E-3

6,36003E-1

5,72643E0

2.8

SBToolbox2

1,83728E-1

4,42663E1

7,56470E-2

1,31954E-1

6,72930E-2

6,54075E1

3,89225E2

3,42088E1

7,11906E-3

6,35891E-1

5,72654E0

2.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,83648E-1

4,42664E1

7,57171E-2

1,31896E-1

6,72641E-2

6,54017E1

3,89230E2

3,42155E1

7,12070E-3

6,36002E-1

5,72643E0

2.8

VCell

1,83648E-1

4,42664E1

7,57168E-2

1,31896E-1

6,72640E-2

6,54017E1

3,89230E2

3,42155E1

7,12070E-3

6,36003E-1

5,72643E0

2.8

copasi

1,83648E-1

4,42664E1

7,57168E-2

1,31896E-1

6,72640E-2

6,54017E1

3,89230E2

3,42155E1

7,12070E-3

6,36003E-1

5,72643E0

2.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,83648E-1

4,42664E1

7,57169E-2

1,31896E-1

6,72640E-2

6,54017E1

3,89230E2

3,42155E1

7,12069E-3

6,36002E-1

5,72643E0

2.8

jsim

1,83648E-1

4,42664E1

7,57169E-2

1,31896E-1

6,72640E-2

6,54017E1

3,89230E2

3,42155E1

7,12070E-3

6,36003E-1

5,72643E0

2.8

min

1,83646E-1

4,42663E1

7,56470E-2

1,31895E-1

6,72640E-2

6,53979E1

3,89225E2

3,42088E1

7,11906E-3

6,35891E-1

5,72638E0

2.8

max

1,83728E-1

4,42665E1

7,57228E-2

1,31954E-1

6,72930E-2

6,54075E1

3,89234E2

3,42193E1

7,12070E-3

6,36003E-1

5,72654E0

2.8

mean

1,83648E-1

4,42664E1

7,57168E-2

1,31896E-1

6,72640E-2

6,54017E1

3,89230E2

3,42155E1

7,12070E-3

6,36003E-1

5,72643E0

2.8

relative error(%)

0,00

3.0

BioUML

1,91263E-1

4,42415E1

8,77188E-2

1,35564E-1

7,60884E-2

6,71225E1

3,87459E2

3,24745E1

7,64177E-3

6,78502E-1

5,75091E0

3.0

ByoDyn

1,91263E-1

4,42415E1

8,77188E-2

1,35564E-1

7,60884E-2

6,71225E1

3,87459E2

3,24745E1

7,64177E-3

6,78502E-1

5,75091E0

3.0

Jarnac

1,91261E-1

4,42415E1

8,77256E-2

1,35564E-1

7,61058E-2

6,71185E1

3,87463E2

3,24786E1

7,64130E-3

6,78466E-1

5,75085E0

3.0

MathSBML

1,91263E-1

4,42415E1

8,77188E-2

1,35564E-1

7,60884E-2

6,71225E1

3,87459E2

3,24745E1

7,64177E-3

6,78502E-1

5,75091E0

3.0

SBToolbox2

1,91342E-1

4,42413E1

8,76405E-2

1,35629E-1

7,61197E-2

6,71294E1

3,87454E2

3,24679E1

7,64010E-3

6,78387E-1

5,75097E0

3.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,91263E-1

4,42415E1

8,77190E-2

1,35564E-1

7,60886E-2

6,71225E1

3,87459E2

3,24746E1

7,64177E-3

6,78502E-1

5,75090E0

3.0

VCell

1,91263E-1

4,42415E1

8,77188E-2

1,35564E-1

7,60884E-2

6,71225E1

3,87459E2

3,24745E1

7,64177E-3

6,78502E-1

5,75091E0

3.0

copasi

1,91263E-1

4,42415E1

8,77187E-2

1,35564E-1

7,60885E-2

6,71225E1

3,87459E2

3,24746E1

7,64177E-3

6,78502E-1

5,75090E0

3.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,91263E-1

4,42415E1

8,77187E-2

1,35564E-1

7,60885E-2

6,71225E1

3,87459E2

3,24746E1

7,64175E-3

6,78502E-1

5,75090E0

3.0

jsim

1,91263E-1

4,42415E1

8,77188E-2

1,35564E-1

7,60884E-2

6,71225E1

3,87459E2

3,24745E1

7,64177E-3

6,78502E-1

5,75091E0

3.0

min

1,91261E-1

4,42413E1

8,76405E-2

1,35564E-1

7,60884E-2

6,71185E1

3,87454E2

3,24679E1

7,64010E-3

6,78387E-1

5,75085E0

3.0

max

1,91342E-1

4,42415E1

8,77256E-2

1,35629E-1

7,61197E-2

6,71294E1

3,87463E2

3,24786E1

7,64177E-3

6,78502E-1

5,75097E0

3.0

mean

1,91263E-1

4,42415E1

8,77188E-2

1,35564E-1

7,60885E-2

6,71225E1

3,87459E2

3,24745E1

7,64177E-3

6,78502E-1

5,75091E0

3.0

relative error(%)

0,00

3.2

BioUML

1,98111E-1

4,42188E1

1,00727E-1

1,38723E-1

8,52980E-2

6,86631E1

3,85867E2

3,09147E1

8,15844E-3

7,20503E-1

5,77309E0

3.2

ByoDyn

1,98111E-1

4,42188E1

1,00727E-1

1,38723E-1

8,52980E-2

6,86631E1

3,85867E2

3,09147E1

8,15844E-3

7,20503E-1

5,77309E0

3.2

Jarnac

1,98110E-1

4,42188E1

1,00734E-1

1,38724E-1

8,53183E-2

6,86588E1

3,85871E2

3,09190E1

8,15788E-3

7,20460E-1

5,77303E0

3.2

MathSBML

1,98111E-1

4,42188E1

1,00727E-1

1,38723E-1

8,52980E-2

6,86631E1

3,85867E2

3,09147E1

8,15844E-3

7,20503E-1

5,77309E0

3.2

SBToolbox2

1,98194E-1

4,42183E1

1,00636E-1

1,38782E-1

8,53326E-2

6,86696E1

3,85862E2

3,09077E1

8,15684E-3

7,20391E-1

5,77315E0

3.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,98111E-1

4,42188E1

1,00727E-1

1,38722E-1

8,52981E-2

6,86631E1

3,85867E2

3,09148E1

8,15844E-3

7,20503E-1

5,77309E0

3.2

VCell

1,98111E-1

4,42188E1

1,00727E-1

1,38723E-1

8,52980E-2

6,86631E1

3,85867E2

3,09147E1

8,15844E-3

7,20503E-1

5,77309E0

3.2

copasi

1,98111E-1

4,42188E1

1,00727E-1

1,38723E-1

8,52980E-2

6,86631E1

3,85867E2

3,09148E1

8,15844E-3

7,20503E-1

5,77309E0

3.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,98111E-1

4,42188E1

1,00727E-1

1,38723E-1

8,52980E-2

6,86631E1

3,85867E2

3,09148E1

8,15844E-3

7,20503E-1

5,77309E0

3.2

jsim

1,98111E-1

4,42188E1

1,00727E-1

1,38723E-1

8,52980E-2

6,86631E1

3,85867E2

3,09147E1

8,15844E-3

7,20503E-1

5,77309E0

3.2

min

1,98110E-1

4,42183E1

1,00636E-1

1,38722E-1

8,52980E-2

6,86588E1

3,85862E2

3,09077E1

8,15684E-3

7,20391E-1

5,77303E0

3.2

max

1,98194E-1

4,42188E1

1,00734E-1

1,38782E-1

8,53326E-2

6,86696E1

3,85871E2

3,09190E1

8,15844E-3

7,20503E-1

5,77315E0

3.2

mean

1,98111E-1

4,42188E1

1,00727E-1

1,38723E-1

8,52980E-2

6,86631E1

3,85867E2

3,09147E1

8,15844E-3

7,20503E-1

5,77309E0

3.2

relative error(%)

0,00

3.4

BioUML

2,04284E-1

4,41981E1

1,14735E-1

1,41453E-1

9,48762E-2

7,00432E1

3,84433E2

2,95162E1

8,66920E-3

7,61907E-1

5,79319E0

3.4

ByoDyn

2,04284E-1

4,41981E1

1,14735E-1

1,41453E-1

9,48762E-2

7,00432E1

3,84433E2

2,95162E1

8,66920E-3

7,61907E-1

5,79319E0

3.4

Jarnac

2,04285E-1

4,41982E1

1,14743E-1

1,41456E-1

9,48997E-2

7,00387E1

3,84437E2

2,95207E1

8,66854E-3

7,61856E-1

5,79313E0

3.4

MathSBML

2,04284E-1

4,41981E1

1,14735E-1

1,41453E-1

9,48762E-2

7,00432E1

3,84433E2

2,95162E1

8,66920E-3

7,61907E-1

5,79319E0

3.4

SBToolbox2

2,04368E-1

4,41983E1

1,14635E-1

1,41509E-1

9,49131E-2

7,00499E1

3,84424E2

2,95094E1

8,66766E-3

7,61803E-1

5,79326E0

3.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,04284E-1

4,41981E1

1,14735E-1

1,41453E-1

9,48763E-2

7,00431E1

3,84433E2

2,95162E1

8,66920E-3

7,61906E-1

5,79319E0

3.4

VCell

2,04284E-1

4,41981E1

1,14735E-1

1,41453E-1

9,48762E-2

7,00432E1

3,84433E2

2,95162E1

8,66920E-3

7,61907E-1

5,79319E0

3.4

copasi

2,04284E-1

4,41981E1

1,14734E-1

1,41453E-1

9,48762E-2

7,00432E1

3,84433E2

2,95162E1

8,66921E-3

7,61907E-1

5,79319E0

3.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,04284E-1

4,41981E1

1,14735E-1

1,41453E-1

9,48762E-2

7,00432E1

3,84433E2

2,95162E1

8,66920E-3

7,61907E-1

5,79319E0

3.4

jsim

2,04284E-1

4,41981E1

1,14735E-1

1,41453E-1

9,48762E-2

7,00432E1

3,84433E2

2,95162E1

8,66920E-3

7,61907E-1

5,79319E0

3.4

min

2,04284E-1

4,41981E1

1,14635E-1

1,41453E-1

9,48762E-2

7,00387E1

3,84424E2

2,95094E1

8,66766E-3

7,61803E-1

5,79313E0

3.4

max

2,04368E-1

4,41983E1

1,14743E-1

1,41509E-1

9,49131E-2

7,00499E1

3,84437E2

2,95207E1

8,66921E-3

7,61907E-1

5,79326E0

3.4

mean

2,04284E-1

4,41981E1

1,14735E-1

1,41453E-1

9,48762E-2

7,00432E1

3,84433E2

2,95162E1

8,66920E-3

7,61907E-1

5,79319E0

3.4

relative error(%)

0,00

3.6

BioUML

2,09871E-1

4,41794E1

1,29730E-1

1,43828E-1

1,04809E-1

7,12800E1

3,83141E2

2,82614E1

9,17271E-3

8,02624E-1

5,81143E0

3.6

ByoDyn

2,09871E-1

4,41794E1

1,29730E-1

1,43828E-1

1,04809E-1

7,12800E1

3,83141E2

2,82614E1

9,17271E-3

8,02624E-1

5,81143E0

3.6

Jarnac

2,09873E-1

4,41795E1

1,29738E-1

1,43832E-1

1,04836E-1

7,12754E1

3,83145E2

2,82661E1

9,17193E-3

8,02565E-1

5,81136E0

3.6

MathSBML

2,09871E-1

4,41794E1

1,29730E-1

1,43828E-1

1,04809E-1

7,12800E1

3,83141E2

2,82614E1

9,17270E-3

8,02624E-1

5,81143E0

3.6

SBToolbox2

2,09953E-1

4,41794E1

1,29623E-1

1,43880E-1

1,04846E-1

7,12868E1

3,83132E2

2,82546E1

9,17130E-3

8,02533E-1

5,81151E0

3.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,09871E-1

4,41794E1

1,29730E-1

1,43828E-1

1,04810E-1

7,12800E1

3,83141E2

2,82615E1

9,17271E-3

8,02624E-1

5,81143E0

3.6

VCell

2,09871E-1

4,41794E1

1,29730E-1

1,43828E-1

1,04809E-1

7,12800E1

3,83141E2

2,82614E1

9,17271E-3

8,02624E-1

5,81143E0

3.6

copasi

2,09871E-1

4,41794E1

1,29730E-1

1,43828E-1

1,04809E-1

7,12800E1

3,83141E2

2,82615E1

9,17271E-3

8,02624E-1

5,81143E0

3.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,09871E-1

4,41794E1

1,29730E-1

1,43828E-1

1,04809E-1

7,12800E1

3,83141E2

2,82615E1

9,17270E-3

8,02624E-1

5,81143E0

3.6

jsim

2,09871E-1

4,41794E1

1,29730E-1

1,43828E-1

1,04809E-1

7,12800E1

3,83141E2

2,82614E1

9,17271E-3

8,02624E-1

5,81143E0

3.6

min

2,09871E-1

4,41794E1

1,29623E-1

1,43828E-1

1,04809E-1

7,12754E1

3,83132E2

2,82546E1

9,17130E-3

8,02533E-1

5,81136E0

3.6

max

2,09953E-1

4,41795E1

1,29738E-1

1,43880E-1

1,04846E-1

7,12868E1

3,83145E2

2,82661E1

9,17271E-3

8,02624E-1

5,81151E0

3.6

mean

2,09871E-1

4,41794E1

1,29730E-1

1,43828E-1

1,04809E-1

7,12800E1

3,83141E2

2,82614E1

9,17271E-3

8,02624E-1

5,81143E0

3.6

relative error(%)

0,00

3.8

BioUML

2,14952E-1

4,41624E1

1,45693E-1

1,45909E-1

1,15086E-1

7,23891E1

3,81975E2

2,71350E1

9,66777E-3

8,42578E-1

5,82797E0

3.8

ByoDyn

2,14952E-1

4,41624E1

1,45693E-1

1,45909E-1

1,15086E-1

7,23891E1

3,81975E2

2,71350E1

9,66777E-3

8,42578E-1

5,82797E0

3.8

Jarnac

2,14956E-1

4,41624E1

1,45702E-1

1,45915E-1

1,15117E-1

7,23842E1

3,81979E2

2,71398E1

9,66688E-3

8,42510E-1

5,82791E0

3.8

MathSBML

2,14952E-1

4,41624E1

1,45693E-1

1,45909E-1

1,15086E-1

7,23891E1

3,81975E2

2,71350E1

9,66777E-3

8,42578E-1

5,82797E0

3.8

SBToolbox2

2,15029E-1

4,41624E1

1,45578E-1

1,45956E-1

1,15122E-1

7,23959E1

3,81969E2

2,71281E1

9,66649E-3

8,42498E-1

5,82810E0

3.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,14952E-1

4,41624E1

1,45693E-1

1,45909E-1

1,15086E-1

7,23891E1

3,81975E2

2,71350E1

9,66778E-3

8,42578E-1

5,82797E0

3.8

VCell

2,14952E-1

4,41624E1

1,45693E-1

1,45909E-1

1,15086E-1

7,23891E1

3,81975E2

2,71350E1

9,66777E-3

8,42578E-1

5,82797E0

3.8

copasi

2,14952E-1

4,41624E1

1,45693E-1

1,45909E-1

1,15086E-1

7,23891E1

3,81975E2

2,71350E1

9,66773E-3

8,42578E-1

5,82797E0

3.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,14952E-1

4,41624E1

1,45693E-1

1,45909E-1

1,15086E-1

7,23891E1

3,81975E2

2,71350E1

9,66777E-3

8,42578E-1

5,82797E0

3.8

jsim

2,14952E-1

4,41624E1

1,45693E-1

1,45909E-1

1,15086E-1

7,23891E1

3,81975E2

2,71350E1

9,66777E-3

8,42578E-1

5,82797E0

3.8

min

2,14952E-1

4,41624E1

1,45578E-1

1,45909E-1

1,15086E-1

7,23842E1

3,81969E2

2,71281E1

9,66649E-3

8,42498E-1

5,82791E0

3.8

max

2,15029E-1

4,41624E1

1,45702E-1

1,45956E-1

1,15122E-1

7,23959E1

3,81979E2

2,71398E1

9,66778E-3

8,42578E-1

5,82810E0

3.8

mean

2,14952E-1

4,41624E1

1,45693E-1

1,45909E-1

1,15086E-1

7,23891E1

3,81975E2

2,71350E1

9,66777E-3

8,42578E-1

5,82797E0

3.8

relative error(%)

0,00

4.0

BioUML

2,19603E-1

4,41469E1

1,62601E-1

1,47752E-1

1,25698E-1

7,33838E1

3,80922E2

2,61231E1

1,01534E-2

8,81704E-1

5,84299E0

4.0

ByoDyn

2,19603E-1

4,41469E1

1,62601E-1

1,47752E-1

1,25698E-1

7,33838E1

3,80922E2

2,61231E1

1,01534E-2

8,81704E-1

5,84299E0

4.0

Jarnac

2,19608E-1

4,41469E1

1,62611E-1

1,47759E-1

1,25732E-1

7,33789E1

3,80927E2

2,61280E1

1,01524E-2

8,81627E-1

5,84292E0

4.0

MathSBML

2,19603E-1

4,41469E1

1,62601E-1

1,47752E-1

1,25698E-1

7,33838E1

3,80922E2

2,61231E1

1,01534E-2

8,81704E-1

5,84299E0

4.0

SBToolbox2

2,19682E-1

4,41464E1

1,62482E-1

1,47798E-1

1,25734E-1

7,33912E1

3,80910E2

2,61152E1

1,01524E-2

8,81624E-1

5,84308E0

4.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,19602E-1

4,41469E1

1,62601E-1

1,47752E-1

1,25698E-1

7,33838E1

3,80922E2

2,61231E1

1,01534E-2

8,81704E-1

5,84299E0

4.0

VCell

2,19603E-1

4,41469E1

1,62601E-1

1,47752E-1

1,25698E-1

7,33838E1

3,80922E2

2,61231E1

1,01534E-2

8,81704E-1

5,84299E0

4.0

copasi

2,19603E-1

4,41469E1

1,62601E-1

1,47752E-1

1,25698E-1

7,33838E1

3,80922E2

2,61231E1

1,01534E-2

8,81704E-1

5,84299E0

4.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,19603E-1

4,41469E1

1,62601E-1

1,47752E-1

1,25698E-1

7,33838E1

3,80922E2

2,61231E1

1,01534E-2

8,81704E-1

5,84299E0

4.0

jsim

2,19603E-1

4,41469E1

1,62601E-1

1,47752E-1

1,25698E-1

7,33838E1

3,80922E2

2,61231E1

1,01534E-2

8,81704E-1

5,84299E0

4.0

min

2,19602E-1

4,41464E1

1,62482E-1

1,47752E-1

1,25698E-1

7,33789E1

3,80910E2

2,61152E1

1,01524E-2

8,81624E-1

5,84292E0

4.0

max

2,19682E-1

4,41469E1

1,62611E-1

1,47798E-1

1,25734E-1

7,33912E1

3,80927E2

2,61280E1

1,01534E-2

8,81704E-1

5,84308E0

4.0

mean

2,19603E-1

4,41469E1

1,62601E-1

1,47752E-1

1,25698E-1

7,33838E1

3,80922E2

2,61231E1

1,01534E-2

8,81704E-1

5,84299E0

4.0

relative error(%)

0,00

4.2

BioUML

2,23890E-1

4,41328E1

1,80425E-1

1,49404E-1

1,36637E-1

7,42764E1

3,79970E2

2,52137E1

1,06287E-2

9,19947E-1

5,85662E0

4.2

ByoDyn

2,23890E-1

4,41328E1

1,80425E-1

1,49404E-1

1,36637E-1

7,42764E1

3,79970E2

2,52137E1

1,06287E-2

9,19947E-1

5,85662E0

4.2

Jarnac

2,23897E-1

4,41328E1

1,80434E-1

1,49412E-1

1,36676E-1

7,42713E1

3,79975E2

2,52187E1

1,06276E-2

9,19861E-1

5,85655E0

4.2

MathSBML

2,23890E-1

4,41328E1

1,80425E-1

1,49404E-1

1,36637E-1

7,42764E1

3,79970E2

2,52137E1

1,06287E-2

9,19947E-1

5,85662E0

4.2

SBToolbox2

2,23962E-1

4,41324E1

1,80298E-1

1,49446E-1

1,36679E-1

7,42834E1

3,79961E2

2,52065E1

1,06279E-2

9,19876E-1

5,85671E0

4.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,23890E-1

4,41328E1

1,80425E-1

1,49404E-1

1,36637E-1

7,42764E1

3,79970E2

2,52137E1

1,06287E-2

9,19947E-1

5,85662E0

4.2

VCell

2,23890E-1

4,41328E1

1,80425E-1

1,49404E-1

1,36637E-1

7,42764E1

3,79970E2

2,52137E1

1,06287E-2

9,19947E-1

5,85662E0

4.2

copasi

2,23890E-1

4,41328E1

1,80425E-1

1,49404E-1

1,36637E-1

7,42764E1

3,79970E2

2,52137E1

1,06287E-2

9,19947E-1

5,85662E0

4.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,23890E-1

4,41328E1

1,80425E-1

1,49404E-1

1,36637E-1

7,42764E1

3,79970E2

2,52137E1

1,06287E-2

9,19947E-1

5,85662E0

4.2

jsim

2,23890E-1

4,41328E1

1,80425E-1

1,49404E-1

1,36637E-1

7,42764E1

3,79970E2

2,52137E1

1,06287E-2

9,19947E-1

5,85662E0

4.2

min

2,23890E-1

4,41324E1

1,80298E-1

1,49404E-1

1,36637E-1

7,42713E1

3,79961E2

2,52065E1

1,06276E-2

9,19861E-1

5,85655E0

4.2

max

2,23962E-1

4,41328E1

1,80434E-1

1,49446E-1

1,36679E-1

7,42834E1

3,79975E2

2,52187E1

1,06287E-2

9,19947E-1

5,85671E0

4.2

mean

2,23890E-1

4,41328E1

1,80425E-1

1,49404E-1

1,36637E-1

7,42764E1

3,79970E2

2,52137E1

1,06287E-2

9,19947E-1

5,85662E0

4.2

relative error(%)

0,00

4.4

BioUML

2,27875E-1

4,41199E1

1,99132E-1

1,50903E-1

1,47898E-1

7,50774E1

3,79109E2

2,43960E1

1,10931E-2

9,57266E-1

5,86900E0

4.4

ByoDyn

2,27875E-1

4,41199E1

1,99132E-1

1,50903E-1

1,47898E-1

7,50774E1

3,79109E2

2,43960E1

1,10931E-2

9,57266E-1

5,86900E0

4.4

Jarnac

2,27885E-1

4,41200E1

1,99142E-1

1,50913E-1

1,47941E-1

7,50722E1

3,79114E2

2,44011E1

1,10918E-2

9,57169E-1

5,86893E0

4.4

MathSBML

2,27875E-1

4,41199E1

1,99132E-1

1,50903E-1

1,47898E-1

7,50774E1

3,79109E2

2,43960E1

1,10931E-2

9,57266E-1

5,86900E0

4.4

SBToolbox2

2,27946E-1

4,41200E1

1,98998E-1

1,50939E-1

1,47939E-1

7,50843E1

3,79098E2

2,43892E1

1,10919E-2

9,57210E-1

5,86914E0

4.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,27875E-1

4,41199E1

1,99132E-1

1,50903E-1

1,47899E-1

7,50774E1

3,79109E2

2,43960E1

1,10931E-2

9,57265E-1

5,86900E0

4.4

VCell

2,27875E-1

4,41199E1

1,99132E-1

1,50903E-1

1,47898E-1

7,50774E1

3,79109E2

2,43960E1

1,10931E-2

9,57266E-1

5,86900E0

4.4

copasi

2,27875E-1

4,41199E1

1,99131E-1

1,50903E-1

1,47898E-1

7,50773E1

3,79109E2

2,43960E1

1,10930E-2

9,57265E-1

5,86900E0

4.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,27875E-1

4,41199E1

1,99132E-1

1,50904E-1

1,47898E-1

7,50773E1

3,79109E2

2,43960E1

1,10931E-2

9,57265E-1

5,86900E0

4.4

jsim

2,27875E-1

4,41199E1

1,99132E-1

1,50903E-1

1,47898E-1

7,50774E1

3,79109E2

2,43960E1

1,10931E-2

9,57266E-1

5,86900E0

4.4

min

2,27875E-1

4,41199E1

1,98998E-1

1,50903E-1

1,47898E-1

7,50722E1

3,79098E2

2,43892E1

1,10918E-2

9,57169E-1

5,86893E0

4.4

max

2,27946E-1

4,41200E1

1,99142E-1

1,50939E-1

1,47941E-1

7,50843E1

3,79114E2

2,44011E1

1,10931E-2

9,57266E-1

5,86914E0

4.4

mean

2,27875E-1

4,41199E1

1,99132E-1

1,50903E-1

1,47898E-1

7,50774E1

3,79109E2

2,43960E1

1,10931E-2

9,57265E-1

5,86900E0

4.4

relative error(%)

0,00

4.6

BioUML

2,31613E-1

4,41082E1

2,18686E-1

1,52286E-1

1,59478E-1

7,57963E1

3,78328E2

2,36603E1

1,15459E-2

9,93626E-1

5,88026E0

4.6

ByoDyn

2,31613E-1

4,41082E1

2,18686E-1

1,52286E-1

1,59478E-1

7,57963E1

3,78328E2

2,36603E1

1,15459E-2

9,93626E-1

5,88026E0

4.6

Jarnac

2,31625E-1

4,41083E1

2,18696E-1

1,52296E-1

1,59526E-1

7,57910E1

3,78333E2

2,36655E1

1,15445E-2

9,93520E-1

5,88019E0

4.6

MathSBML

2,31613E-1

4,41082E1

2,18686E-1

1,52286E-1

1,59478E-1

7,57963E1

3,78328E2

2,36603E1

1,15459E-2

9,93626E-1

5,88026E0

4.6

SBToolbox2

2,31677E-1

4,41080E1

2,18540E-1

1,52322E-1

1,59519E-1

7,58034E1

3,78318E2

2,36531E1

1,15449E-2

9,93582E-1

5,88037E0

4.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,31613E-1

4,41082E1

2,18686E-1

1,52286E-1

1,59478E-1

7,57963E1

3,78328E2

2,36603E1

1,15459E-2

9,93626E-1

5,88026E0

4.6

VCell

2,31613E-1

4,41082E1

2,18686E-1

1,52286E-1

1,59478E-1

7,57963E1

3,78328E2

2,36603E1

1,15459E-2

9,93626E-1

5,88026E0

4.6

copasi

2,31613E-1

4,41082E1

2,18686E-1

1,52286E-1

1,59478E-1

7,57963E1

3,78328E2

2,36603E1

1,15462E-2

9,93626E-1

5,88026E0

4.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,31613E-1

4,41082E1

2,18686E-1

1,52286E-1

1,59478E-1

7,57963E1

3,78328E2

2,36603E1

1,15459E-2

9,93626E-1

5,88026E0

4.6

jsim

2,31613E-1

4,41082E1

2,18686E-1

1,52286E-1

1,59478E-1

7,57963E1

3,78328E2

2,36603E1

1,15459E-2

9,93626E-1

5,88026E0

4.6

min

2,31613E-1

4,41080E1

2,18540E-1

1,52286E-1

1,59478E-1

7,57910E1

3,78318E2

2,36531E1

1,15445E-2

9,93520E-1

5,88019E0

4.6

max

2,31677E-1

4,41083E1

2,18696E-1

1,52322E-1

1,59526E-1

7,58034E1

3,78333E2

2,36655E1

1,15462E-2

9,93626E-1

5,88037E0

4.6

mean

2,31613E-1

4,41082E1

2,18686E-1

1,52286E-1

1,59478E-1

7,57963E1

3,78328E2

2,36603E1

1,15459E-2

9,93626E-1

5,88026E0

4.6

relative error(%)

0,00

4.8

BioUML

2,35152E-1

4,40975E1

2,39050E-1

1,53579E-1

1,71373E-1

7,64417E1

3,77621E2

2,29982E1

1,19868E-2

1,02901E0

5,89050E0

4.8

ByoDyn

2,35152E-1

4,40975E1

2,39050E-1

1,53579E-1

1,71373E-1

7,64417E1

3,77621E2

2,29982E1

1,19868E-2

1,02901E0

5,89050E0

4.8

Jarnac

2,35165E-1

4,40976E1

2,39060E-1

1,53591E-1

1,71425E-1

7,64363E1

3,77626E2

2,30035E1

1,19853E-2

1,02889E0

5,89042E0

4.8

MathSBML

2,35152E-1

4,40975E1

2,39050E-1

1,53579E-1

1,71373E-1

7,64417E1

3,77621E2

2,29982E1

1,19868E-2

1,02901E0

5,89050E0

4.8

SBToolbox2

2,35214E-1

4,40975E1

2,38901E-1

1,53611E-1

1,71412E-1

7,64486E1

3,77614E2

2,29909E1

1,19864E-2

1,02898E0

5,89056E0

4.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,35152E-1

4,40975E1

2,39050E-1

1,53579E-1

1,71373E-1

7,64417E1

3,77621E2

2,29982E1

1,19868E-2

1,02901E0

5,89050E0

4.8

VCell

2,35152E-1

4,40975E1

2,39050E-1

1,53579E-1

1,71373E-1

7,64417E1

3,77621E2

2,29982E1

1,19868E-2

1,02901E0

5,89050E0

4.8

copasi

2,35152E-1

4,40975E1

2,39049E-1

1,53579E-1

1,71373E-1

7,64416E1

3,77621E2

2,29983E1

1,19880E-2

1,02901E0

5,89050E0

4.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,35152E-1

4,40975E1

2,39050E-1

1,53579E-1

1,71373E-1

7,64417E1

3,77621E2

2,29982E1

1,19868E-2

1,02901E0

5,89050E0

4.8

jsim

2,35152E-1

4,40975E1

2,39050E-1

1,53579E-1

1,71373E-1

7,64417E1

3,77621E2

2,29982E1

1,19868E-2

1,02901E0

5,89050E0

4.8

min

2,35152E-1

4,40975E1

2,38901E-1

1,53579E-1

1,71373E-1

7,64363E1

3,77614E2

2,29909E1

1,19853E-2

1,02889E0

5,89042E0

4.8

max

2,35214E-1

4,40976E1

2,39060E-1

1,53611E-1

1,71425E-1

7,64486E1

3,77626E2

2,30035E1

1,19880E-2

1,02901E0

5,89056E0

4.8

mean

2,35152E-1

4,40975E1

2,39050E-1

1,53579E-1

1,71373E-1

7,64417E1

3,77621E2

2,29982E1

1,19868E-2

1,02901E0

5,89050E0

4.8

relative error(%)

0,00

5.0

BioUML

2,38533E-1

4,40878E1

2,60184E-1

1,54807E-1

1,83581E-1

7,70210E1

3,76978E2

2,24020E1

1,24156E-2

1,06339E0

5,89982E0

5.0

ByoDyn

2,38533E-1

4,40878E1

2,60184E-1

1,54807E-1

1,83581E-1

7,70210E1

3,76978E2

2,24020E1

1,24156E-2

1,06339E0

5,89982E0

5.0

Jarnac

2,38549E-1

4,40878E1

2,60193E-1

1,54820E-1

1,83638E-1

7,70156E1

3,76984E2

2,24074E1

1,24139E-2

1,06326E0

5,89974E0

5.0

MathSBML

2,38533E-1

4,40878E1

2,60184E-1

1,54807E-1

1,83581E-1

7,70210E1

3,76978E2

2,24020E1

1,24156E-2

1,06339E0

5,89982E0

5.0

SBToolbox2

2,38590E-1

4,40875E1

2,60030E-1

1,54830E-1

1,83620E-1

7,70285E1

3,76975E2

2,23950E1

1,24155E-2

1,06335E0

5,89990E0

5.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,38533E-1

4,40878E1

2,60184E-1

1,54807E-1

1,83581E-1

7,70210E1

3,76978E2

2,24021E1

1,24156E-2

1,06339E0

5,89982E0

5.0

VCell

2,38533E-1

4,40878E1

2,60184E-1

1,54807E-1

1,83581E-1

7,70210E1

3,76978E2

2,24020E1

1,24156E-2

1,06339E0

5,89982E0

5.0

copasi

2,38533E-1

4,40878E1

2,60182E-1

1,54807E-1

1,83581E-1

7,70210E1

3,76978E2

2,24021E1

1,24173E-2

1,06339E0

5,89982E0

5.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,38533E-1

4,40878E1

2,60184E-1

1,54807E-1

1,83581E-1

7,70210E1

3,76978E2

2,24021E1

1,24156E-2

1,06339E0

5,89982E0

5.0

jsim

2,38533E-1

4,40878E1

2,60184E-1

1,54807E-1

1,83581E-1

7,70210E1

3,76978E2

2,24020E1

1,24156E-2

1,06339E0

5,89982E0

5.0

min

2,38533E-1

4,40875E1

2,60030E-1

1,54807E-1

1,83581E-1

7,70156E1

3,76975E2

2,23950E1

1,24139E-2

1,06326E0

5,89974E0

5.0

max

2,38590E-1

4,40878E1

2,60193E-1

1,54830E-1

1,83638E-1

7,70285E1

3,76984E2

2,24074E1

1,24173E-2

1,06339E0

5,89990E0

5.0

mean

2,38533E-1

4,40878E1

2,60184E-1

1,54807E-1

1,83581E-1

7,70210E1

3,76978E2

2,24020E1

1,24156E-2

1,06339E0

5,89982E0

5.0

relative error(%)

0,00

5.2

BioUML

2,41794E-1

4,40789E1

2,82046E-1

1,55989E-1

1,96100E-1

7,75411E1

3,76395E2

2,18650E1

1,28320E-2

1,09678E0

5,90831E0

5.2

ByoDyn

2,41794E-1

4,40789E1

2,82046E-1

1,55989E-1

1,96100E-1

7,75411E1

3,76395E2

2,18650E1

1,28320E-2

1,09678E0

5,90831E0

5.2

Jarnac

2,41812E-1

4,40789E1

2,82056E-1

1,56004E-1

1,96163E-1

7,75356E1

3,76400E2

2,18704E1

1,28302E-2

1,09664E0

5,90823E0

5.2

MathSBML

2,41794E-1

4,40789E1

2,82046E-1

1,55989E-1

1,96100E-1

7,75411E1

3,76395E2

2,18650E1

1,28320E-2

1,09678E0

5,90831E0

5.2

SBToolbox2

2,41847E-1

4,40790E1

2,81883E-1

1,56014E-1

1,96142E-1

7,75480E1

3,76386E2

2,18580E1

1,28316E-2

1,09677E0

5,90839E0

5.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,41794E-1

4,40789E1

2,82047E-1

1,55989E-1

1,96100E-1

7,75411E1

3,76395E2

2,18650E1

1,28320E-2

1,09678E0

5,90831E0

5.2

VCell

2,41794E-1

4,40789E1

2,82046E-1

1,55989E-1

1,96100E-1

7,75411E1

3,76395E2

2,18650E1

1,28320E-2

1,09678E0

5,90831E0

5.2

copasi

2,41794E-1

4,40789E1

2,82046E-1

1,55989E-1

1,96100E-1

7,75410E1

3,76395E2

2,18651E1

1,28322E-2

1,09678E0

5,90831E0

5.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,41794E-1

4,40789E1

2,82046E-1

1,55989E-1

1,96100E-1

7,75411E1

3,76395E2

2,18651E1

1,28320E-2

1,09678E0

5,90831E0

5.2

jsim

2,41794E-1

4,40789E1

2,82046E-1

1,55989E-1

1,96100E-1

7,75411E1

3,76395E2

2,18650E1

1,28320E-2

1,09678E0

5,90831E0

5.2

min

2,41794E-1

4,40789E1

2,81883E-1

1,55989E-1

1,96100E-1

7,75356E1

3,76386E2

2,18580E1

1,28302E-2

1,09664E0

5,90823E0

5.2

max

2,41847E-1

4,40790E1

2,82056E-1

1,56014E-1

1,96163E-1

7,75480E1

3,76400E2

2,18704E1

1,28322E-2

1,09678E0

5,90839E0

5.2

mean

2,41794E-1

4,40789E1

2,82046E-1

1,55989E-1

1,96100E-1

7,75411E1

3,76395E2

2,18650E1

1,28320E-2

1,09678E0

5,90831E0

5.2

relative error(%)

0,00

5.4

BioUML

2,44966E-1

4,40707E1

3,04597E-1

1,57142E-1

2,08929E-1

7,80079E1

3,75863E2

2,13811E1

1,32360E-2

1,12916E0

5,91605E0

5.4

ByoDyn

2,44966E-1

4,40707E1

3,04597E-1

1,57142E-1

2,08929E-1

7,80079E1

3,75863E2

2,13811E1

1,32360E-2

1,12916E0

5,91605E0

5.4

Jarnac

2,44986E-1

4,40708E1

3,04605E-1

1,57158E-1

2,08997E-1

7,80024E1

3,75869E2

2,13865E1

1,32341E-2

1,12901E0

5,91597E0

5.4

MathSBML

2,44966E-1

4,40707E1

3,04597E-1

1,57142E-1

2,08929E-1

7,80079E1

3,75863E2

2,13811E1

1,32360E-2

1,12916E0

5,91605E0

5.4

SBToolbox2

2,45014E-1

4,40705E1

3,04434E-1

1,57163E-1

2,08959E-1

7,80151E1

3,75856E2

2,13744E1

1,32362E-2

1,12914E0

5,91614E0

5.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,44966E-1

4,40707E1

3,04597E-1

1,57142E-1

2,08929E-1

7,80079E1

3,75863E2

2,13811E1

1,32360E-2

1,12916E0

5,91605E0

5.4

VCell

2,44966E-1

4,40707E1

3,04597E-1

1,57142E-1

2,08929E-1

7,80079E1

3,75863E2

2,13811E1

1,32360E-2

1,12916E0

5,91605E0

5.4

copasi

2,44966E-1

4,40707E1

3,04596E-1

1,57142E-1

2,08929E-1

7,80078E1

3,75863E2

2,13812E1

1,32359E-2

1,12916E0

5,91605E0

5.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,44966E-1

4,40707E1

3,04597E-1

1,57142E-1

2,08929E-1

7,80078E1

3,75863E2

2,13811E1

1,32360E-2

1,12916E0

5,91605E0

5.4

jsim

2,44966E-1

4,40707E1

3,04597E-1

1,57142E-1

2,08929E-1

7,80079E1

3,75863E2

2,13811E1

1,32360E-2

1,12916E0

5,91605E0

5.4

min

2,44966E-1

4,40705E1

3,04434E-1

1,57142E-1

2,08929E-1

7,80024E1

3,75856E2

2,13744E1

1,32341E-2

1,12901E0

5,91597E0

5.4

max

2,45014E-1

4,40708E1

3,04605E-1

1,57163E-1

2,08997E-1

7,80151E1

3,75869E2

2,13865E1

1,32362E-2

1,12916E0

5,91614E0

5.4

mean

2,44966E-1

4,40707E1

3,04597E-1

1,57142E-1

2,08929E-1

7,80079E1

3,75863E2

2,13811E1

1,32360E-2

1,12916E0

5,91605E0

5.4

relative error(%)

0,00

5.6

BioUML

2,48075E-1

4,40633E1

3,27793E-1

1,58279E-1

2,22066E-1

7,84267E1

3,75380E2

2,09448E1

1,36277E-2

1,16055E0

5,92311E0

5.6

ByoDyn

2,48075E-1

4,40633E1

3,27793E-1

1,58279E-1

2,22066E-1

7,84267E1

3,75380E2

2,09448E1

1,36277E-2

1,16055E0

5,92311E0

5.6

Jarnac

2,48098E-1

4,40633E1

3,27801E-1

1,58295E-1

2,22140E-1

7,84212E1

3,75385E2

2,09502E1

1,36256E-2

1,16039E0

5,92303E0

5.6

MathSBML

2,48075E-1

4,40633E1

3,27793E-1

1,58279E-1

2,22066E-1

7,84267E1

3,75380E2

2,09448E1

1,36277E-2

1,16055E0

5,92311E0

5.6

SBToolbox2

2,48120E-1

4,40630E1

3,27619E-1

1,58296E-1

2,22100E-1

7,84338E1

3,75371E2

2,09378E1

1,36278E-2

1,16056E0

5,92323E0

5.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,48075E-1

4,40633E1

3,27793E-1

1,58279E-1

2,22066E-1

7,84267E1

3,75380E2

2,09448E1

1,36277E-2

1,16055E0

5,92311E0

5.6

VCell

2,48075E-1

4,40633E1

3,27793E-1

1,58279E-1

2,22066E-1

7,84267E1

3,75380E2

2,09448E1

1,36277E-2

1,16055E0

5,92311E0

5.6

copasi

2,48076E-1

4,40633E1

3,27793E-1

1,58279E-1

2,22066E-1

7,84267E1

3,75380E2

2,09449E1

1,36277E-2

1,16055E0

5,92310E0

5.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,48076E-1

4,40633E1

3,27793E-1

1,58279E-1

2,22066E-1

7,84267E1

3,75380E2

2,09449E1

1,36277E-2

1,16055E0

5,92310E0

5.6

jsim

2,48075E-1

4,40633E1

3,27793E-1

1,58279E-1

2,22066E-1

7,84267E1

3,75380E2

2,09448E1

1,36277E-2

1,16055E0

5,92311E0

5.6

min

2,48075E-1

4,40630E1

3,27619E-1

1,58279E-1

2,22066E-1

7,84212E1

3,75371E2

2,09378E1

1,36256E-2

1,16039E0

5,92303E0

5.6

max

2,48120E-1

4,40633E1

3,27801E-1

1,58296E-1

2,22140E-1

7,84338E1

3,75385E2

2,09502E1

1,36278E-2

1,16056E0

5,92323E0

5.6

mean

2,48075E-1

4,40633E1

3,27793E-1

1,58279E-1

2,22066E-1

7,84267E1

3,75380E2

2,09448E1

1,36277E-2

1,16055E0

5,92311E0

5.6

relative error(%)

0,00

5.8

BioUML

2,51145E-1

4,40564E1

3,51595E-1

1,59408E-1

2,35510E-1

7,88026E1

3,74938E2

2,05514E1

1,40071E-2

1,19096E0

5,92955E0

5.8

ByoDyn

2,51145E-1

4,40564E1

3,51595E-1

1,59408E-1

2,35510E-1

7,88026E1

3,74938E2

2,05514E1

1,40071E-2

1,19096E0

5,92955E0

5.8

Jarnac

2,51170E-1

4,40565E1

3,51602E-1

1,59426E-1

2,35589E-1

7,87971E1

3,74944E2

2,05567E1

1,40049E-2

1,19079E0

5,92947E0

5.8

MathSBML

2,51145E-1

4,40564E1

3,51595E-1

1,59408E-1

2,35510E-1

7,88026E1

3,74938E2

2,05514E1

1,40071E-2

1,19096E0

5,92955E0

5.8

SBToolbox2

2,51183E-1

4,40560E1

3,51424E-1

1,59421E-1

2,35536E-1

7,88096E1

3,74932E2

2,05444E1

1,40076E-2

1,19103E0

5,92963E0

5.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,51145E-1

4,40564E1

3,51596E-1

1,59408E-1

2,35510E-1

7,88025E1

3,74938E2

2,05514E1

1,40071E-2

1,19096E0

5,92955E0

5.8

VCell

2,51145E-1

4,40564E1

3,51595E-1

1,59408E-1

2,35510E-1

7,88026E1

3,74938E2

2,05514E1

1,40071E-2

1,19096E0

5,92955E0

5.8

copasi

2,51145E-1

4,40564E1

3,51594E-1

1,59409E-1

2,35510E-1

7,88025E1

3,74938E2

2,05514E1

1,40076E-2

1,19096E0

5,92955E0

5.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,51145E-1

4,40564E1

3,51595E-1

1,59408E-1

2,35510E-1

7,88025E1

3,74938E2

2,05514E1

1,40071E-2

1,19096E0

5,92955E0

5.8

jsim

2,51145E-1

4,40564E1

3,51595E-1

1,59408E-1

2,35510E-1

7,88026E1

3,74938E2

2,05514E1

1,40071E-2

1,19096E0

5,92955E0

5.8

min

2,51145E-1

4,40560E1

3,51424E-1

1,59408E-1

2,35510E-1

7,87971E1

3,74932E2

2,05444E1

1,40049E-2

1,19079E0

5,92947E0

5.8

max

2,51183E-1

4,40565E1

3,51602E-1

1,59426E-1

2,35589E-1

7,88096E1

3,74944E2

2,05567E1

1,40076E-2

1,19103E0

5,92963E0

5.8

mean

2,51145E-1

4,40564E1

3,51595E-1

1,59408E-1

2,35510E-1

7,88026E1

3,74938E2

2,05514E1

1,40071E-2

1,19096E0

5,92955E0

5.8

relative error(%)

0,00

6.0

BioUML

2,54194E-1

4,40502E1

3,75963E-1

1,60540E-1

2,49259E-1

7,91396E1

3,74535E2

2,01964E1

1,43744E-2

1,22041E0

5,93545E0

6.0

ByoDyn

2,54194E-1

4,40502E1

3,75963E-1

1,60540E-1

2,49259E-1

7,91396E1

3,74535E2

2,01964E1

1,43744E-2

1,22041E0

5,93545E0

6.0

Jarnac

2,54220E-1

4,40503E1

3,75968E-1

1,60557E-1

2,49342E-1

7,91342E1

3,74541E2

2,02017E1

1,43721E-2

1,22023E0

5,93537E0

6.0

MathSBML

2,54194E-1

4,40502E1

3,75963E-1

1,60540E-1

2,49259E-1

7,91396E1

3,74535E2

2,01964E1

1,43744E-2

1,22041E0

5,93545E0

6.0

SBToolbox2

2,54230E-1

4,40500E1

3,75782E-1

1,60554E-1

2,49290E-1

7,91464E1

3,74532E2

2,01892E1

1,43752E-2

1,22046E0

5,93552E0

6.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,54194E-1

4,40502E1

3,75963E-1

1,60540E-1

2,49259E-1

7,91396E1

3,74535E2

2,01964E1

1,43744E-2

1,22041E0

5,93545E0

6.0

VCell

2,54194E-1

4,40502E1

3,75963E-1

1,60540E-1

2,49259E-1

7,91396E1

3,74535E2

2,01964E1

1,43744E-2

1,22041E0

5,93545E0

6.0

copasi

2,54194E-1

4,40502E1

3,75960E-1

1,60540E-1

2,49259E-1

7,91395E1

3,74536E2

2,01965E1

1,43768E-2

1,22041E0

5,93544E0

6.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,54194E-1

4,40502E1

3,75963E-1

1,60540E-1

2,49258E-1

7,91396E1

3,74536E2

2,01964E1

1,43744E-2

1,22041E0

5,93545E0

6.0

jsim

2,54194E-1

4,40502E1

3,75963E-1

1,60540E-1

2,49259E-1

7,91396E1

3,74535E2

2,01964E1

1,43744E-2

1,22041E0

5,93545E0

6.0

min

2,54194E-1

4,40500E1

3,75782E-1

1,60540E-1

2,49258E-1

7,91342E1

3,74532E2

2,01892E1

1,43721E-2

1,22023E0

5,93537E0

6.0

max

2,54230E-1

4,40503E1

3,75968E-1

1,60557E-1

2,49342E-1

7,91464E1

3,74541E2

2,02017E1

1,43768E-2

1,22046E0

5,93552E0

6.0

mean

2,54194E-1

4,40502E1

3,75963E-1

1,60540E-1

2,49259E-1

7,91396E1

3,74535E2

2,01964E1

1,43744E-2

1,22041E0

5,93545E0

6.0

relative error(%)

0,00

6.2

BioUML

2,57236E-1

4,40444E1

4,00857E-1

1,61678E-1

2,63309E-1

7,94418E1

3,74167E2

1,98760E1

1,47299E-2

1,24891E0

5,94084E0

6.2

ByoDyn

2,57236E-1

4,40444E1

4,00857E-1

1,61678E-1

2,63309E-1

7,94418E1

3,74167E2

1,98760E1

1,47299E-2

1,24891E0

5,94084E0

6.2

Jarnac

2,57265E-1

4,40445E1

4,00860E-1

1,61696E-1

2,63397E-1

7,94364E1

3,74172E2

1,98813E1

1,47275E-2

1,24872E0

5,94076E0

6.2

MathSBML

2,57236E-1

4,40444E1

4,00857E-1

1,61678E-1

2,63309E-1

7,94418E1

3,74167E2

1,98760E1

1,47299E-2

1,24891E0

5,94084E0

6.2

SBToolbox2

2,57267E-1

4,40440E1

4,00679E-1

1,61683E-1

2,63330E-1

7,94493E1

3,74162E2

1,98683E1

1,47305E-2

1,24893E0

5,94091E0

6.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,57236E-1

4,40444E1

4,00857E-1

1,61678E-1

2,63309E-1

7,94418E1

3,74167E2

1,98760E1

1,47299E-2

1,24891E0

5,94084E0

6.2

VCell

2,57236E-1

4,40444E1

4,00857E-1

1,61678E-1

2,63309E-1

7,94418E1

3,74167E2

1,98760E1

1,47299E-2

1,24891E0

5,94084E0

6.2

copasi

2,57237E-1

4,40444E1

4,00856E-1

1,61678E-1

2,63309E-1

7,94417E1

3,74167E2

1,98761E1

1,47302E-2

1,24891E0

5,94084E0

6.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,57237E-1

4,40444E1

4,00857E-1

1,61678E-1

2,63309E-1

7,94417E1

3,74167E2

1,98760E1

1,47299E-2

1,24891E0

5,94084E0

6.2

jsim

2,57236E-1

4,40444E1

4,00857E-1

1,61678E-1

2,63309E-1

7,94418E1

3,74167E2

1,98760E1

1,47299E-2

1,24891E0

5,94084E0

6.2

min

2,57236E-1

4,40440E1

4,00679E-1

1,61678E-1

2,63309E-1

7,94364E1

3,74162E2

1,98683E1

1,47275E-2

1,24872E0

5,94076E0

6.2

max

2,57267E-1

4,40445E1

4,00860E-1

1,61696E-1

2,63397E-1

7,94493E1

3,74172E2

1,98813E1

1,47305E-2

1,24893E0

5,94091E0

6.2

mean

2,57236E-1

4,40444E1

4,00857E-1

1,61678E-1

2,63309E-1

7,94418E1

3,74167E2

1,98760E1

1,47299E-2

1,24891E0

5,94084E0

6.2

relative error(%)

0,00

6.4

BioUML

2,60286E-1

4,40391E1

4,26240E-1

1,62828E-1

2,77658E-1

7,97125E1

3,73830E2

1,95867E1

1,50738E-2

1,27650E0

5,94578E0

6.4

ByoDyn

2,60286E-1

4,40391E1

4,26240E-1

1,62828E-1

2,77658E-1

7,97125E1

3,73830E2

1,95867E1

1,50738E-2

1,27650E0

5,94578E0

6.4

Jarnac

2,60316E-1

4,40392E1

4,26241E-1

1,62846E-1

2,77751E-1

7,97072E1

3,73835E2

1,95919E1

1,50713E-2

1,27630E0

5,94570E0

6.4

MathSBML

2,60286E-1

4,40391E1

4,26240E-1

1,62828E-1

2,77658E-1

7,97125E1

3,73830E2

1,95867E1

1,50738E-2

1,27650E0

5,94578E0

6.4

SBToolbox2

2,60314E-1

4,40390E1

4,26054E-1

1,62832E-1

2,77683E-1

7,97187E1

3,73823E2

1,95800E1

1,50741E-2

1,27657E0

5,94587E0

6.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,60286E-1

4,40391E1

4,26240E-1

1,62828E-1

2,77658E-1

7,97125E1

3,73830E2

1,95867E1

1,50738E-2

1,27650E0

5,94578E0

6.4

VCell

2,60286E-1

4,40391E1

4,26240E-1

1,62828E-1

2,77658E-1

7,97125E1

3,73830E2

1,95867E1

1,50738E-2

1,27650E0

5,94578E0

6.4

copasi

2,60286E-1

4,40391E1

4,26239E-1

1,62828E-1

2,77658E-1

7,97124E1

3,73830E2

1,95868E1

1,50738E-2

1,27649E0

5,94578E0

6.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,60286E-1

4,40391E1

4,26239E-1

1,62828E-1

2,77658E-1

7,97125E1

3,73830E2

1,95868E1

1,50738E-2

1,27649E0

5,94578E0

6.4

jsim

2,60286E-1

4,40391E1

4,26240E-1

1,62828E-1

2,77658E-1

7,97125E1

3,73830E2

1,95867E1

1,50738E-2

1,27650E0

5,94578E0

6.4

min

2,60286E-1

4,40390E1

4,26054E-1

1,62828E-1

2,77658E-1

7,97072E1

3,73823E2

1,95800E1

1,50713E-2

1,27630E0

5,94570E0

6.4

max

2,60316E-1

4,40392E1

4,26241E-1

1,62846E-1

2,77751E-1

7,97187E1

3,73835E2

1,95919E1

1,50741E-2

1,27657E0

5,94587E0

6.4

mean

2,60286E-1

4,40391E1

4,26240E-1

1,62828E-1

2,77658E-1

7,97125E1

3,73830E2

1,95867E1

1,50738E-2

1,27650E0

5,94578E0

6.4

relative error(%)

0,00

6.6

BioUML

2,63352E-1

4,40343E1

4,52076E-1

1,63992E-1

2,92302E-1

7,99549E1

3,73520E2

1,93254E1

1,54065E-2

1,30318E0

5,95031E0

6.6

ByoDyn

2,63352E-1

4,40343E1

4,52076E-1

1,63992E-1

2,92302E-1

7,99549E1

3,73520E2

1,93254E1

1,54065E-2

1,30318E0

5,95031E0

6.6

Jarnac

2,63384E-1

4,40344E1

4,52075E-1

1,64010E-1

2,92400E-1

7,99497E1

3,73526E2

1,93305E1

1,54038E-2

1,30298E0

5,95024E0

6.6

MathSBML

2,63352E-1

4,40343E1

4,52076E-1

1,63992E-1

2,92302E-1

7,99549E1

3,73520E2

1,93254E1

1,54065E-2

1,30318E0

5,95031E0

6.6

SBToolbox2

2,63374E-1

4,40340E1

4,51885E-1

1,63997E-1

2,92322E-1

7,99621E1

3,73513E2

1,93179E1

1,54074E-2

1,30324E0

5,95040E0

6.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,63352E-1

4,40343E1

4,52076E-1

1,63992E-1

2,92302E-1

7,99549E1

3,73520E2

1,93254E1

1,54064E-2

1,30318E0

5,95031E0

6.6

VCell

2,63352E-1

4,40343E1

4,52076E-1

1,63992E-1

2,92302E-1

7,99549E1

3,73520E2

1,93254E1

1,54065E-2

1,30318E0

5,95031E0

6.6

copasi

2,63353E-1

4,40343E1

4,52075E-1

1,63992E-1

2,92302E-1

7,99549E1

3,73521E2

1,93255E1

1,54057E-2

1,30318E0

5,95031E0

6.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,63352E-1

4,40343E1

4,52075E-1

1,63992E-1

2,92302E-1

7,99549E1

3,73521E2

1,93255E1

1,54065E-2

1,30318E0

5,95031E0

6.6

jsim

2,63352E-1

4,40343E1

4,52076E-1

1,63992E-1

2,92302E-1

7,99549E1

3,73520E2

1,93254E1

1,54065E-2

1,30318E0

5,95031E0

6.6

min

2,63352E-1

4,40340E1

4,51885E-1

1,63992E-1

2,92302E-1

7,99497E1

3,73513E2

1,93179E1

1,54038E-2

1,30298E0

5,95024E0

6.6

max

2,63384E-1

4,40344E1

4,52076E-1

1,64010E-1

2,92400E-1

7,99621E1

3,73526E2

1,93305E1

1,54074E-2

1,30324E0

5,95040E0

6.6

mean

2,63352E-1

4,40343E1

4,52076E-1

1,63992E-1

2,92302E-1

7,99549E1

3,73520E2

1,93254E1

1,54065E-2

1,30318E0

5,95031E0

6.6

relative error(%)

0,00

6.8

BioUML

2,66443E-1

4,40298E1

4,78330E-1

1,65172E-1

3,07237E-1

8,01718E1

3,73236E2

1,90893E1

1,57282E-2

1,32901E0

5,95448E0

6.8

ByoDyn

2,66443E-1

4,40298E1

4,78330E-1

1,65172E-1

3,07237E-1

8,01718E1

3,73236E2

1,90893E1

1,57282E-2

1,32901E0

5,95448E0

6.8

Jarnac

2,66475E-1

4,40299E1

4,78328E-1

1,65190E-1

3,07338E-1

8,01667E1

3,73242E2

1,90943E1

1,57255E-2

1,32880E0

5,95440E0

6.8

MathSBML

2,66443E-1

4,40298E1

4,78330E-1

1,65172E-1

3,07237E-1

8,01718E1

3,73236E2

1,90893E1

1,57282E-2

1,32901E0

5,95448E0

6.8

SBToolbox2

2,66461E-1

4,40300E1

4,78146E-1

1,65169E-1

3,07250E-1

8,01782E1

3,73227E2

1,90825E1

1,57291E-2

1,32912E0

5,95456E0

6.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,66443E-1

4,40298E1

4,78330E-1

1,65172E-1

3,07237E-1

8,01718E1

3,73236E2

1,90893E1

1,57283E-2

1,32901E0

5,95448E0

6.8

VCell

2,66443E-1

4,40298E1

4,78330E-1

1,65172E-1

3,07237E-1

8,01718E1

3,73236E2

1,90893E1

1,57282E-2

1,32901E0

5,95448E0

6.8

copasi

2,66443E-1

4,40298E1

4,78330E-1

1,65172E-1

3,07237E-1

8,01718E1

3,73236E2

1,90894E1

1,57281E-2

1,32901E0

5,95448E0

6.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,66443E-1

4,40298E1

4,78330E-1

1,65172E-1

3,07237E-1

8,01718E1

3,73236E2

1,90893E1

1,57282E-2

1,32901E0

5,95448E0

6.8

jsim

2,66443E-1

4,40298E1

4,78330E-1

1,65172E-1

3,07237E-1

8,01718E1

3,73236E2

1,90893E1

1,57282E-2

1,32901E0

5,95448E0

6.8

min

2,66443E-1

4,40298E1

4,78146E-1

1,65169E-1

3,07237E-1

8,01667E1

3,73227E2

1,90825E1

1,57255E-2

1,32880E0

5,95440E0

6.8

max

2,66475E-1

4,40300E1

4,78330E-1

1,65190E-1

3,07338E-1

8,01782E1

3,73242E2

1,90943E1

1,57291E-2

1,32912E0

5,95456E0

6.8

mean

2,66443E-1

4,40298E1

4,78330E-1

1,65172E-1

3,07237E-1

8,01718E1

3,73236E2

1,90893E1

1,57282E-2

1,32901E0

5,95448E0

6.8

relative error(%)

0,00

7.0

BioUML

2,69563E-1

4,40257E1

5,04971E-1

1,66368E-1

3,22457E-1

8,03658E1

3,72975E2

1,88759E1

1,60394E-2

1,35400E0

5,95831E0

7.0

ByoDyn

2,69563E-1

4,40257E1

5,04971E-1

1,66368E-1

3,22457E-1

8,03658E1

3,72975E2

1,88759E1

1,60394E-2

1,35400E0

5,95831E0

7.0

Jarnac

2,69596E-1

4,40257E1

5,04967E-1

1,66387E-1

3,22562E-1

8,03608E1

3,72980E2

1,88807E1

1,60366E-2

1,35378E0

5,95823E0

7.0

MathSBML

2,69563E-1

4,40257E1

5,04971E-1

1,66368E-1

3,22457E-1

8,03658E1

3,72975E2

1,88759E1

1,60394E-2

1,35400E0

5,95831E0

7.0

SBToolbox2

2,69578E-1

4,40257E1

5,04775E-1

1,66368E-1

3,22471E-1

8,03727E1

3,72967E2

1,88690E1

1,60405E-2

1,35409E0

5,95836E0

7.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,69563E-1

4,40257E1

5,04971E-1

1,66368E-1

3,22457E-1

8,03658E1

3,72975E2

1,88759E1

1,60395E-2

1,35400E0

5,95831E0

7.0

VCell

2,69563E-1

4,40257E1

5,04971E-1

1,66368E-1

3,22457E-1

8,03658E1

3,72975E2

1,88759E1

1,60394E-2

1,35400E0

5,95831E0

7.0

copasi

2,69563E-1

4,40257E1

5,04970E-1

1,66369E-1

3,22458E-1

8,03657E1

3,72975E2

1,88759E1

1,60398E-2

1,35400E0

5,95831E0

7.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,69563E-1

4,40257E1

5,04971E-1

1,66368E-1

3,22457E-1

8,03657E1

3,72975E2

1,88759E1

1,60394E-2

1,35400E0

5,95831E0

7.0

jsim

2,69563E-1

4,40257E1

5,04971E-1

1,66368E-1

3,22457E-1

8,03658E1

3,72975E2

1,88759E1

1,60394E-2

1,35400E0

5,95831E0

7.0

min

2,69563E-1

4,40257E1

5,04775E-1

1,66368E-1

3,22457E-1

8,03608E1

3,72967E2

1,88690E1

1,60366E-2

1,35378E0

5,95823E0

7.0

max

2,69596E-1

4,40257E1

5,04971E-1

1,66387E-1

3,22562E-1

8,03727E1

3,72980E2

1,88807E1

1,60405E-2

1,35409E0

5,95836E0

7.0

mean

2,69563E-1

4,40257E1

5,04971E-1

1,66368E-1

3,22457E-1

8,03658E1

3,72975E2

1,88759E1

1,60394E-2

1,35400E0

5,95831E0

7.0

relative error(%)

0,00

7.2

BioUML

2,72716E-1

4,40218E1

5,31968E-1

1,67582E-1

3,37957E-1

8,05389E1

3,72734E2

1,86828E1

1,63405E-2

1,37818E0

5,96183E0

7.2

ByoDyn

2,72716E-1

4,40218E1

5,31968E-1

1,67582E-1

3,37957E-1

8,05389E1

3,72734E2

1,86828E1

1,63405E-2

1,37818E0

5,96183E0

7.2

Jarnac

2,72751E-1

4,40219E1

5,31962E-1

1,67600E-1

3,38066E-1

8,05341E1

3,72739E2

1,86875E1

1,63376E-2

1,37796E0

5,96176E0

7.2

MathSBML

2,72716E-1

4,40218E1

5,31968E-1

1,67582E-1

3,37957E-1

8,05389E1

3,72734E2

1,86828E1

1,63405E-2

1,37818E0

5,96183E0

7.2

SBToolbox2

2,72725E-1

4,40220E1

5,31771E-1

1,67577E-1

3,37958E-1

8,05462E1

3,72727E2

1,86755E1

1,63422E-2

1,37834E0

5,96196E0

7.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,72716E-1

4,40218E1

5,31968E-1

1,67582E-1

3,37957E-1

8,05389E1

3,72734E2

1,86828E1

1,63405E-2

1,37818E0

5,96183E0

7.2

VCell

2,72717E-1

4,40218E1

5,31968E-1

1,67582E-1

3,37957E-1

8,05389E1

3,72734E2

1,86828E1

1,63405E-2

1,37818E0

5,96183E0

7.2

copasi

2,72717E-1

4,40218E1

5,31967E-1

1,67582E-1

3,37958E-1

8,05389E1

3,72735E2

1,86828E1

1,63409E-2

1,37818E0

5,96183E0

7.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,72717E-1

4,40218E1

5,31968E-1

1,67582E-1

3,37957E-1

8,05389E1

3,72735E2

1,86828E1

1,63405E-2

1,37818E0

5,96183E0

7.2

jsim

2,72716E-1

4,40218E1

5,31968E-1

1,67582E-1

3,37957E-1

8,05389E1

3,72734E2

1,86828E1

1,63405E-2

1,37818E0

5,96183E0

7.2

min

2,72716E-1

4,40218E1

5,31771E-1

1,67577E-1

3,37957E-1

8,05341E1

3,72727E2

1,86755E1

1,63376E-2

1,37796E0

5,96176E0

7.2

max

2,72751E-1

4,40220E1

5,31968E-1

1,67600E-1

3,38066E-1

8,05462E1

3,72739E2

1,86875E1

1,63422E-2

1,37834E0

5,96196E0

7.2

mean

2,72717E-1

4,40218E1

5,31968E-1

1,67582E-1

3,37957E-1

8,05389E1

3,72734E2

1,86828E1

1,63405E-2

1,37818E0

5,96183E0

7.2

relative error(%)

0,00

7.4

BioUML

2,75907E-1

4,40183E1

5,59292E-1

1,68812E-1

3,53731E-1

8,06934E1

3,72512E2

1,85081E1

1,66317E-2

1,40159E0

5,96509E0

7.4

ByoDyn

2,75907E-1

4,40183E1

5,59292E-1

1,68812E-1

3,53731E-1

8,06934E1

3,72512E2

1,85081E1

1,66317E-2

1,40159E0

5,96509E0

7.4

Jarnac

2,75941E-1

4,40184E1

5,59284E-1

1,68830E-1

3,53842E-1

8,06887E1

3,72517E2

1,85127E1

1,66288E-2

1,40137E0

5,96502E0

7.4

MathSBML

2,75907E-1

4,40183E1

5,59292E-1

1,68812E-1

3,53731E-1

8,06934E1

3,72512E2

1,85081E1

1,66317E-2

1,40159E0

5,96509E0

7.4

SBToolbox2

2,75912E-1

4,40180E1

5,59099E-1

1,68806E-1

3,53728E-1

8,06998E1

3,72507E2

1,85019E1

1,66329E-2

1,40171E0

5,96515E0

7.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,75907E-1

4,40183E1

5,59292E-1

1,68812E-1

3,53731E-1

8,06934E1

3,72512E2

1,85081E1

1,66317E-2

1,40159E0

5,96509E0

7.4

VCell

2,75907E-1

4,40183E1

5,59292E-1

1,68812E-1

3,53731E-1

8,06934E1

3,72512E2

1,85081E1

1,66317E-2

1,40159E0

5,96509E0

7.4

copasi

2,75907E-1

4,40183E1

5,59291E-1

1,68812E-1

3,53731E-1

8,06934E1

3,72512E2

1,85082E1

1,66318E-2

1,40159E0

5,96509E0

7.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,75907E-1

4,40183E1

5,59292E-1

1,68812E-1

3,53731E-1

8,06934E1

3,72512E2

1,85081E1

1,66317E-2

1,40159E0

5,96509E0

7.4

jsim

2,75907E-1

4,40183E1

5,59292E-1

1,68812E-1

3,53731E-1

8,06934E1

3,72512E2

1,85081E1

1,66317E-2

1,40159E0

5,96509E0

7.4

min

2,75907E-1

4,40180E1

5,59099E-1

1,68806E-1

3,53728E-1

8,06887E1

3,72507E2

1,85019E1

1,66288E-2

1,40137E0

5,96502E0

7.4

max

2,75941E-1

4,40184E1

5,59292E-1

1,68830E-1

3,53842E-1

8,06998E1

3,72517E2

1,85127E1

1,66329E-2

1,40171E0

5,96515E0

7.4

mean

2,75907E-1

4,40183E1

5,59292E-1

1,68812E-1

3,53731E-1

8,06934E1

3,72512E2

1,85081E1

1,66317E-2

1,40159E0

5,96509E0

7.4

relative error(%)

0,00

7.6

BioUML

2,79135E-1

4,40150E1

5,86916E-1

1,70058E-1

3,69771E-1

8,08310E1

3,72307E2

1,83500E1

1,69136E-2

1,42426E0

5,96810E0

7.6

ByoDyn

2,79135E-1

4,40150E1

5,86916E-1

1,70058E-1

3,69771E-1

8,08310E1

3,72307E2

1,83500E1

1,69136E-2

1,42426E0

5,96810E0

7.6

Jarnac

2,79170E-1

4,40151E1

5,86906E-1

1,70075E-1

3,69885E-1

8,08264E1

3,72312E2

1,83544E1

1,69106E-2

1,42403E0

5,96803E0

7.6

MathSBML

2,79135E-1

4,40150E1

5,86916E-1

1,70058E-1

3,69771E-1

8,08310E1

3,72307E2

1,83500E1

1,69136E-2

1,42426E0

5,96810E0

7.6

SBToolbox2

2,79138E-1

4,40150E1

5,86714E-1

1,70054E-1

3,69772E-1

8,08374E1

3,72298E2

1,83433E1

1,69154E-2

1,42439E0

5,96822E0

7.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,79135E-1

4,40150E1

5,86916E-1

1,70058E-1

3,69771E-1

8,08310E1

3,72307E2

1,83500E1

1,69136E-2

1,42426E0

5,96810E0

7.6

VCell

2,79135E-1

4,40150E1

5,86916E-1

1,70058E-1

3,69771E-1

8,08310E1

3,72307E2

1,83500E1

1,69136E-2

1,42426E0

5,96810E0

7.6

copasi

2,79135E-1

4,40150E1

5,86916E-1

1,70058E-1

3,69772E-1

8,08310E1

3,72307E2

1,83501E1

1,69136E-2

1,42426E0

5,96810E0

7.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,79135E-1

4,40150E1

5,86916E-1

1,70058E-1

3,69771E-1

8,08310E1

3,72307E2

1,83500E1

1,69136E-2

1,42426E0

5,96810E0

7.6

jsim

2,79135E-1

4,40150E1

5,86916E-1

1,70058E-1

3,69771E-1

8,08310E1

3,72307E2

1,83500E1

1,69136E-2

1,42426E0

5,96810E0

7.6

min

2,79135E-1

4,40150E1

5,86714E-1

1,70054E-1

3,69771E-1

8,08264E1

3,72298E2

1,83433E1

1,69106E-2

1,42403E0

5,96803E0

7.6

max

2,79170E-1

4,40151E1

5,86916E-1

1,70075E-1

3,69885E-1

8,08374E1

3,72312E2

1,83544E1

1,69154E-2

1,42439E0

5,96822E0

7.6

mean

2,79135E-1

4,40150E1

5,86916E-1

1,70058E-1

3,69771E-1

8,08310E1

3,72307E2

1,83500E1

1,69136E-2

1,42426E0

5,96810E0

7.6

relative error(%)

0,00

7.8

BioUML

2,82402E-1

4,40119E1

6,14816E-1

1,71318E-1

3,86071E-1

8,09534E1

3,72117E2

1,82068E1

1,71865E-2

1,44622E0

5,97088E0

7.8

ByoDyn

2,82402E-1

4,40119E1

6,14816E-1

1,71318E-1

3,86071E-1

8,09534E1

3,72117E2

1,82068E1

1,71865E-2

1,44622E0

5,97088E0

7.8

Jarnac

2,82436E-1

4,40120E1

6,14803E-1

1,71334E-1

3,86186E-1

8,09489E1

3,72121E2

1,82111E1

1,71835E-2

1,44599E0

5,97082E0

7.8

MathSBML

2,82402E-1

4,40119E1

6,14816E-1

1,71318E-1

3,86071E-1

8,09534E1

3,72117E2

1,82068E1

1,71865E-2

1,44622E0

5,97088E0

7.8

SBToolbox2

2,82397E-1

4,40120E1

6,14610E-1

1,71313E-1

3,86050E-1

8,09603E1

3,72108E2

1,81997E1

1,71889E-2

1,44642E0

5,97102E0

7.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,82401E-1

4,40119E1

6,14816E-1

1,71318E-1

3,86071E-1

8,09534E1

3,72117E2

1,82068E1

1,71865E-2

1,44622E0

5,97088E0

7.8

VCell

2,82402E-1

4,40119E1

6,14816E-1

1,71318E-1

3,86071E-1

8,09534E1

3,72117E2

1,82068E1

1,71865E-2

1,44622E0

5,97088E0

7.8

copasi

2,82402E-1

4,40119E1

6,14815E-1

1,71318E-1

3,86071E-1

8,09533E1

3,72117E2

1,82069E1

1,71861E-2

1,44622E0

5,97088E0

7.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,82402E-1

4,40119E1

6,14815E-1

1,71318E-1

3,86071E-1

8,09534E1

3,72117E2

1,82069E1

1,71865E-2

1,44622E0

5,97088E0

7.8

jsim

2,82402E-1

4,40119E1

6,14816E-1

1,71318E-1

3,86071E-1

8,09534E1

3,72117E2

1,82068E1

1,71865E-2

1,44622E0

5,97088E0

7.8

min

2,82397E-1

4,40119E1

6,14610E-1

1,71313E-1

3,86050E-1

8,09489E1

3,72108E2

1,81997E1

1,71835E-2

1,44599E0

5,97082E0

7.8

max

2,82436E-1

4,40120E1

6,14816E-1

1,71334E-1

3,86186E-1

8,09603E1

3,72121E2

1,82111E1

1,71889E-2

1,44642E0

5,97102E0

7.8

mean

2,82402E-1

4,40119E1

6,14816E-1

1,71318E-1

3,86071E-1

8,09534E1

3,72117E2

1,82068E1

1,71865E-2

1,44622E0

5,97088E0

7.8

relative error(%)

0,00

8.0

BioUML

2,85706E-1

4,40091E1

6,42967E-1

1,72591E-1

4,02622E-1

8,10620E1

3,71940E2

1,80771E1

1,74509E-2

1,46750E0

5,97347E0

8.0

ByoDyn

2,85706E-1

4,40091E1

6,42967E-1

1,72591E-1

4,02622E-1

8,10620E1

3,71940E2

1,80771E1

1,74509E-2

1,46750E0

5,97347E0

8.0

Jarnac

2,85740E-1

4,40092E1

6,42952E-1

1,72607E-1

4,02739E-1

8,10577E1

3,71944E2

1,80812E1

1,74478E-2

1,46727E0

5,97340E0

8.0

MathSBML

2,85706E-1

4,40091E1

6,42967E-1

1,72591E-1

4,02622E-1

8,10620E1

3,71940E2

1,80771E1

1,74509E-2

1,46750E0

5,97347E0

8.0

SBToolbox2

2,85704E-1

4,40090E1

6,42774E-1

1,72582E-1

4,02606E-1

8,10680E1

3,71938E2

1,80708E1

1,74526E-2

1,46770E0

5,97354E0

8.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,85706E-1

4,40091E1

6,42967E-1

1,72591E-1

4,02622E-1

8,10620E1

3,71940E2

1,80771E1

1,74509E-2

1,46750E0

5,97347E0

8.0

VCell

2,85706E-1

4,40091E1

6,42967E-1

1,72591E-1

4,02622E-1

8,10620E1

3,71940E2

1,80771E1

1,74509E-2

1,46750E0

5,97347E0

8.0

copasi

2,85707E-1

4,40091E1

6,42966E-1

1,72591E-1

4,02622E-1

8,10619E1

3,71940E2

1,80771E1

1,74508E-2

1,46750E0

5,97347E0

8.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,85706E-1

4,40091E1

6,42967E-1

1,72591E-1

4,02622E-1

8,10620E1

3,71940E2

1,80771E1

1,74509E-2

1,46750E0

5,97347E0

8.0

jsim

2,85706E-1

4,40091E1

6,42967E-1

1,72591E-1

4,02622E-1

8,10620E1

3,71940E2

1,80771E1

1,74509E-2

1,46750E0

5,97347E0

8.0

min

2,85704E-1

4,40090E1

6,42774E-1

1,72582E-1

4,02606E-1

8,10577E1

3,71938E2

1,80708E1

1,74478E-2

1,46727E0

5,97340E0

8.0

max

2,85740E-1

4,40092E1

6,42967E-1

1,72607E-1

4,02739E-1

8,10680E1

3,71944E2

1,80812E1

1,74526E-2

1,46770E0

5,97354E0

8.0

mean

2,85706E-1

4,40091E1

6,42967E-1

1,72591E-1

4,02622E-1

8,10620E1

3,71940E2

1,80771E1

1,74509E-2

1,46750E0

5,97347E0

8.0

relative error(%)

0,00

8.2

BioUML

2,89048E-1

4,40064E1

6,71349E-1

1,73876E-1

4,19417E-1

8,11582E1

3,71776E2

1,79595E1

1,77070E-2

1,48814E0

5,97587E0

8.2

ByoDyn

2,89048E-1

4,40064E1

6,71349E-1

1,73876E-1

4,19417E-1

8,11582E1

3,71776E2

1,79595E1

1,77070E-2

1,48814E0

5,97587E0

8.2

Jarnac

2,89082E-1

4,40065E1

6,71332E-1

1,73890E-1

4,19534E-1

8,11540E1

3,71780E2

1,79635E1

1,77039E-2

1,48790E0

5,97580E0

8.2

MathSBML

2,89048E-1

4,40064E1

6,71349E-1

1,73876E-1

4,19417E-1

8,11582E1

3,71776E2

1,79595E1

1,77070E-2

1,48814E0

5,97587E0

8.2

SBToolbox2

2,89041E-1

4,40060E1

6,71147E-1

1,73871E-1

4,19403E-1

8,11639E1

3,71768E2

1,79539E1

1,77092E-2

1,48828E0

5,97592E0

8.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,89048E-1

4,40064E1

6,71349E-1

1,73876E-1

4,19417E-1

8,11582E1

3,71776E2

1,79595E1

1,77070E-2

1,48814E0

5,97587E0

8.2

VCell

2,89048E-1

4,40064E1

6,71349E-1

1,73876E-1

4,19417E-1

8,11582E1

3,71776E2

1,79595E1

1,77070E-2

1,48814E0

5,97587E0

8.2

copasi

2,89048E-1

4,40064E1

6,71348E-1

1,73876E-1

4,19417E-1

8,11581E1

3,71776E2

1,79595E1

1,77069E-2

1,48814E0

5,97587E0

8.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,89048E-1

4,40064E1

6,71349E-1

1,73876E-1

4,19417E-1

8,11582E1

3,71776E2

1,79595E1

1,77070E-2

1,48814E0

5,97587E0

8.2

jsim

2,89048E-1

4,40064E1

6,71349E-1

1,73876E-1

4,19417E-1

8,11582E1

3,71776E2

1,79595E1

1,77070E-2

1,48814E0

5,97587E0

8.2

min

2,89041E-1

4,40060E1

6,71147E-1

1,73871E-1

4,19403E-1

8,11540E1

3,71768E2

1,79539E1

1,77039E-2

1,48790E0

5,97580E0

8.2

max

2,89082E-1

4,40065E1

6,71349E-1

1,73890E-1

4,19534E-1

8,11639E1

3,71780E2

1,79635E1

1,77092E-2

1,48828E0

5,97592E0

8.2

mean

2,89048E-1

4,40064E1

6,71349E-1

1,73876E-1

4,19417E-1

8,11582E1

3,71776E2

1,79595E1

1,77070E-2

1,48814E0

5,97587E0

8.2

relative error(%)

0,00

8.4

BioUML

2,92426E-1

4,40039E1

6,99942E-1

1,75170E-1

4,36446E-1

8,12431E1

3,71623E2

1,78528E1

1,79554E-2

1,50815E0

5,97810E0

8.4

ByoDyn

2,92426E-1

4,40039E1

6,99942E-1

1,75170E-1

4,36446E-1

8,12431E1

3,71623E2

1,78528E1

1,79554E-2

1,50815E0

5,97810E0

8.4

Jarnac

2,92459E-1

4,40040E1

6,99923E-1

1,75184E-1

4,36564E-1

8,12392E1

3,71627E2

1,78566E1

1,79523E-2

1,50791E0

5,97804E0

8.4

MathSBML

2,92426E-1

4,40039E1

6,99942E-1

1,75170E-1

4,36446E-1

8,12431E1

3,71623E2

1,78528E1

1,79554E-2

1,50815E0

5,97810E0

8.4

SBToolbox2

2,92417E-1

4,40040E1

6,99730E-1

1,75160E-1

4,36418E-1

8,12496E1

3,71618E2

1,78462E1

1,79579E-2

1,50836E0

5,97822E0

8.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,92426E-1

4,40039E1

6,99942E-1

1,75170E-1

4,36446E-1

8,12431E1

3,71623E2

1,78528E1

1,79554E-2

1,50815E0

5,97810E0

8.4

VCell

2,92426E-1

4,40039E1

6,99942E-1

1,75170E-1

4,36446E-1

8,12431E1

3,71623E2

1,78528E1

1,79554E-2

1,50815E0

5,97810E0

8.4

copasi

2,92426E-1

4,40039E1

6,99942E-1

1,75170E-1

4,36446E-1

8,12431E1

3,71623E2

1,78529E1

1,79547E-2

1,50815E0

5,97810E0

8.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,92426E-1

4,40039E1

6,99941E-1

1,75170E-1

4,36446E-1

8,12431E1

3,71623E2

1,78528E1

1,79554E-2

1,50815E0

5,97810E0

8.4

jsim

2,92426E-1

4,40039E1

6,99942E-1

1,75170E-1

4,36446E-1

8,12431E1

3,71623E2

1,78528E1

1,79554E-2

1,50815E0

5,97810E0

8.4

min

2,92417E-1

4,40039E1

6,99730E-1

1,75160E-1

4,36418E-1

8,12392E1

3,71618E2

1,78462E1

1,79523E-2

1,50791E0

5,97804E0

8.4

max

2,92459E-1

4,40040E1

6,99942E-1

1,75184E-1

4,36564E-1

8,12496E1

3,71627E2

1,78566E1

1,79579E-2

1,50836E0

5,97822E0

8.4

mean

2,92426E-1

4,40039E1

6,99942E-1

1,75170E-1

4,36446E-1

8,12431E1

3,71623E2

1,78528E1

1,79554E-2

1,50815E0

5,97810E0

8.4

relative error(%)

0,00

8.6

BioUML

2,95838E-1

4,40016E1

7,28727E-1

1,76472E-1

4,53701E-1

8,13180E1

3,71480E2

1,77560E1

1,81963E-2

1,52758E0

5,98019E0

8.6

ByoDyn

2,95838E-1

4,40016E1

7,28727E-1

1,76472E-1

4,53701E-1

8,13180E1

3,71480E2

1,77560E1

1,81963E-2

1,52758E0

5,98019E0

8.6

Jarnac

2,95870E-1

4,40017E1

7,28706E-1

1,76485E-1

4,53819E-1

8,13142E1

3,71484E2

1,77597E1

1,81932E-2

1,52734E0

5,98013E0

8.6

MathSBML

2,95838E-1

4,40016E1

7,28727E-1

1,76472E-1

4,53701E-1

8,13180E1

3,71480E2

1,77560E1

1,81963E-2

1,52758E0

5,98019E0

8.6

SBToolbox2

2,95824E-1

4,40019E1

7,28532E-1

1,76458E-1

4,53650E-1

8,13246E1

3,71470E2

1,77493E1

1,81987E-2

1,52783E0

5,98031E0

8.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,95837E-1

4,40016E1

7,28727E-1

1,76472E-1

4,53701E-1

8,13180E1

3,71480E2

1,77560E1

1,81963E-2

1,52758E0

5,98019E0

8.6

VCell

2,95838E-1

4,40016E1

7,28727E-1

1,76472E-1

4,53701E-1

8,13180E1

3,71480E2

1,77560E1

1,81963E-2

1,52758E0

5,98019E0

8.6

copasi

2,95838E-1

4,40016E1

7,28728E-1

1,76473E-1

4,53701E-1

8,13179E1

3,71480E2

1,77560E1

1,81944E-2

1,52758E0

5,98019E0

8.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,95838E-1

4,40016E1

7,28726E-1

1,76472E-1

4,53701E-1

8,13180E1

3,71480E2

1,77560E1

1,81963E-2

1,52758E0

5,98019E0

8.6

jsim

2,95838E-1

4,40016E1

7,28727E-1

1,76472E-1

4,53701E-1

8,13180E1

3,71480E2

1,77560E1

1,81963E-2

1,52758E0

5,98019E0

8.6

min

2,95824E-1

4,40016E1

7,28532E-1

1,76458E-1

4,53650E-1

8,13142E1

3,71470E2

1,77493E1

1,81932E-2

1,52734E0

5,98013E0

8.6

max

2,95870E-1

4,40019E1

7,28728E-1

1,76485E-1

4,53819E-1

8,13246E1

3,71484E2

1,77597E1

1,81987E-2

1,52783E0

5,98031E0

8.6

mean

2,95838E-1

4,40016E1

7,28727E-1

1,76472E-1

4,53701E-1

8,13180E1

3,71480E2

1,77560E1

1,81963E-2

1,52758E0

5,98019E0

8.6

relative error(%)

0,00

8.8

BioUML

2,99281E-1

4,39994E1

7,57687E-1

1,77781E-1

4,71173E-1

8,13836E1

3,71346E2

1,76681E1

1,84301E-2

1,54645E0

5,98213E0

8.8

ByoDyn

2,99281E-1

4,39994E1

7,57687E-1

1,77781E-1

4,71173E-1

8,13836E1

3,71346E2

1,76681E1

1,84301E-2

1,54645E0

5,98213E0

8.8

Jarnac

2,99313E-1

4,39995E1

7,57664E-1

1,77793E-1

4,71291E-1

8,13800E1

3,71350E2

1,76716E1

1,84270E-2

1,54621E0

5,98208E0

8.8

MathSBML

2,99281E-1

4,39994E1

7,57687E-1

1,77781E-1

4,71173E-1

8,13836E1

3,71346E2

1,76681E1

1,84302E-2

1,54645E0

5,98213E0

8.8

SBToolbox2

2,99270E-1

4,39990E1

7,57494E-1

1,77768E-1

4,71136E-1

8,13894E1

3,71339E2

1,76625E1

1,84324E-2

1,54662E0

5,98221E0

8.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,99281E-1

4,39994E1

7,57687E-1

1,77781E-1

4,71173E-1

8,13836E1

3,71346E2

1,76681E1

1,84302E-2

1,54645E0

5,98213E0

8.8

VCell

2,99281E-1

4,39994E1

7,57687E-1

1,77781E-1

4,71173E-1

8,13836E1

3,71346E2

1,76681E1

1,84301E-2

1,54645E0

5,98213E0

8.8

copasi

2,99282E-1

4,39994E1

7,57687E-1

1,77781E-1

4,71174E-1

8,13836E1

3,71346E2

1,76682E1

1,84297E-2

1,54645E0

5,98213E0

8.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,99281E-1

4,39994E1

7,57687E-1

1,77781E-1

4,71173E-1

8,13836E1

3,71346E2

1,76681E1

1,84301E-2

1,54645E0

5,98213E0

8.8

jsim

2,99281E-1

4,39994E1

7,57687E-1

1,77781E-1

4,71173E-1

8,13836E1

3,71346E2

1,76681E1

1,84301E-2

1,54645E0

5,98213E0

8.8

min

2,99270E-1

4,39990E1

7,57494E-1

1,77768E-1

4,71136E-1

8,13800E1

3,71339E2

1,76625E1

1,84270E-2

1,54621E0

5,98208E0

8.8

max

2,99313E-1

4,39995E1

7,57687E-1

1,77793E-1

4,71291E-1

8,13894E1

3,71350E2

1,76716E1

1,84324E-2

1,54662E0

5,98221E0

8.8

mean

2,99281E-1

4,39994E1

7,57687E-1

1,77781E-1

4,71173E-1

8,13836E1

3,71346E2

1,76681E1

1,84301E-2

1,54645E0

5,98213E0

8.8

relative error(%)

0,00

9.0

BioUML

3,02755E-1

4,39974E1

7,86808E-1

1,79095E-1

4,88854E-1

8,14410E1

3,71221E2

1,75883E1

1,86573E-2

1,56479E0

5,98396E0

9.0

ByoDyn

3,02755E-1

4,39974E1

7,86808E-1

1,79095E-1

4,88854E-1

8,14410E1

3,71221E2

1,75883E1

1,86573E-2

1,56479E0

5,98396E0

9.0

Jarnac

3,02785E-1

4,39974E1

7,86783E-1

1,79105E-1

4,88971E-1

8,14376E1

3,71224E2

1,75916E1

1,86542E-2

1,56455E0

5,98391E0

9.0

MathSBML

3,02755E-1

4,39974E1

7,86808E-1

1,79095E-1

4,88854E-1

8,14410E1

3,71221E2

1,75883E1

1,86573E-2

1,56479E0

5,98396E0

9.0

SBToolbox2

3,02738E-1

4,39970E1

7,86606E-1

1,79086E-1

4,88819E-1

8,14463E1

3,71219E2

1,75826E1

1,86601E-2

1,56499E0

5,98401E0

9.0

SBWOdeSolver

3,02755E-1

4,39974E1

7,86808E-1

1,79095E-1

4,88854E-1

8,14410E1

3,71221E2

1,75883E1

1,86573E-2

1,56479E0

5,98396E0

9.0

VCell

3,02755E-1

4,39974E1

7,86808E-1

1,79095E-1

4,88854E-1

8,14410E1

3,71221E2

1,75883E1

1,86573E-2

1,56479E0

5,98396E0

9.0

copasi

3,02755E-1

4,39974E1

7,86807E-1

1,79095E-1

4,88854E-1

8,14410E1

3,71221E2

1,75883E1

1,86573E-2

1,56479E0

5,98396E0

9.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,02755E-1

4,39974E1

7,86807E-1

1,79095E-1

4,88854E-1

8,14410E1

3,71221E2

1,75883E1

1,86573E-2

1,56479E0

5,98396E0

9.0

jsim

3,02755E-1

4,39974E1

7,86808E-1

1,79095E-1

4,88854E-1

8,14410E1

3,71221E2

1,75883E1

1,86573E-2

1,56479E0

5,98396E0

9.0

min

3,02738E-1

4,39970E1

7,86606E-1

1,79086E-1

4,88819E-1

8,14376E1

3,71219E2

1,75826E1

1,86542E-2

1,56455E0

5,98391E0

9.0

max

3,02785E-1

4,39974E1

7,86808E-1

1,79105E-1

4,88971E-1

8,14463E1

3,71224E2

1,75916E1

1,86601E-2

1,56499E0

5,98401E0

9.0

mean

3,02755E-1

4,39974E1

7,86808E-1

1,79095E-1

4,88854E-1

8,14410E1

3,71221E2

1,75883E1

1,86573E-2

1,56479E0

5,98396E0

9.0

relative error(%)

0,00

9.2

BioUML

3,06256E-1

4,39954E1

8,16074E-1

1,80411E-1

5,06733E-1

8,14910E1

3,71103E2

1,75156E1

1,88781E-2

1,58262E0

5,98568E0

9.2

ByoDyn

3,06256E-1

4,39954E1

8,16074E-1

1,80411E-1

5,06733E-1

8,14910E1

3,71103E2

1,75156E1

1,88781E-2

1,58262E0

5,98568E0

9.2

Jarnac

3,06285E-1

4,39955E1

8,16047E-1

1,80421E-1

5,06849E-1

8,14876E1

3,71106E2

1,75188E1

1,88750E-2

1,58238E0

5,98563E0

9.2

MathSBML

3,06256E-1

4,39954E1

8,16074E-1

1,80411E-1

5,06733E-1

8,14910E1

3,71103E2

1,75156E1

1,88781E-2

1,58262E0

5,98568E0

9.2

SBToolbox2

3,06234E-1

4,39950E1

8,15858E-1

1,80405E-1

5,06682E-1

8,14972E1

3,71099E2

1,75097E1

1,88809E-2

1,58287E0

5,98580E0

9.2

SBWOdeSolver

3,06256E-1

4,39954E1

8,16074E-1

1,80411E-1

5,06733E-1

8,14910E1

3,71103E2

1,75156E1

1,88781E-2

1,58262E0

5,98568E0

9.2

VCell

3,06256E-1

4,39954E1

8,16074E-1

1,80411E-1

5,06733E-1

8,14910E1

3,71103E2

1,75156E1

1,88781E-2

1,58262E0

5,98568E0

9.2

copasi

3,06256E-1

4,39954E1

8,16073E-1

1,80412E-1

5,06733E-1

8,14909E1

3,71103E2

1,75157E1

1,88781E-2

1,58262E0

5,98568E0

9.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,06256E-1

4,39954E1

8,16073E-1

1,80412E-1

5,06733E-1

8,14909E1

3,71103E2

1,75157E1

1,88781E-2

1,58262E0

5,98568E0

9.2

jsim

3,06256E-1

4,39954E1

8,16074E-1

1,80411E-1

5,06733E-1

8,14910E1

3,71103E2

1,75156E1

1,88781E-2

1,58262E0

5,98568E0

9.2

min

3,06234E-1

4,39950E1

8,15858E-1

1,80405E-1

5,06682E-1

8,14876E1

3,71099E2

1,75097E1

1,88750E-2

1,58238E0

5,98563E0

9.2

max

3,06285E-1

4,39955E1

8,16074E-1

1,80421E-1

5,06849E-1

8,14972E1

3,71106E2

1,75188E1

1,88809E-2

1,58287E0

5,98580E0

9.2

mean

3,06256E-1

4,39954E1

8,16074E-1

1,80411E-1

5,06733E-1

8,14910E1

3,71103E2

1,75156E1

1,88781E-2

1,58262E0

5,98568E0

9.2

relative error(%)

0,00

9.4

BioUML

3,09782E-1

4,39936E1

8,45472E-1

1,81730E-1

5,24803E-1

8,15341E1

3,70991E2

1,74496E1

1,90928E-2

1,59998E0

5,98729E0

9.4

ByoDyn

3,09782E-1

4,39936E1

8,45472E-1

1,81730E-1

5,24803E-1

8,15341E1

3,70991E2

1,74496E1

1,90928E-2

1,59998E0

5,98729E0

9.4

Jarnac

3,09809E-1

4,39937E1

8,45444E-1

1,81738E-1

5,24916E-1

8,15310E1

3,70995E2

1,74526E1

1,90898E-2

1,59974E0

5,98724E0

9.4

MathSBML

3,09782E-1

4,39936E1

8,45472E-1

1,81730E-1

5,24803E-1

8,15341E1

3,70991E2

1,74496E1

1,90928E-2

1,59998E0

5,98729E0

9.4

SBToolbox2

3,09760E-1

4,39939E1

8,45259E-1

1,81714E-1

5,24725E-1

8,15411E1

3,70989E2

1,74428E1

1,90966E-2

1,60025E0

5,98741E0

9.4

SBWOdeSolver

3,09782E-1

4,39936E1

8,45472E-1

1,81730E-1

5,24803E-1

8,15341E1

3,70991E2

1,74496E1

1,90929E-2

1,59998E0

5,98729E0

9.4

VCell

3,09782E-1

4,39936E1

8,45472E-1

1,81730E-1

5,24803E-1

8,15341E1

3,70991E2

1,74496E1

1,90928E-2

1,59998E0

5,98729E0

9.4

copasi

3,09782E-1

4,39936E1

8,45471E-1

1,81730E-1

5,24803E-1

8,15341E1

3,70991E2

1,74496E1

1,90935E-2

1,59998E0

5,98729E0

9.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,09782E-1

4,39936E1

8,45472E-1

1,81730E-1

5,24803E-1

8,15341E1

3,70991E2

1,74496E1

1,90928E-2

1,59998E0

5,98729E0

9.4

jsim

3,09782E-1

4,39936E1

8,45472E-1

1,81730E-1

5,24803E-1

8,15341E1

3,70991E2

1,74496E1

1,90928E-2

1,59998E0

5,98729E0

9.4

min

3,09760E-1

4,39936E1

8,45259E-1

1,81714E-1

5,24725E-1

8,15310E1

3,70989E2

1,74428E1

1,90898E-2

1,59974E0

5,98724E0

9.4

max

3,09809E-1

4,39939E1

8,45472E-1

1,81738E-1

5,24916E-1

8,15411E1

3,70995E2

1,74526E1

1,90966E-2

1,60025E0

5,98741E0

9.4

mean

3,09782E-1

4,39936E1

8,45472E-1

1,81730E-1

5,24803E-1

8,15341E1

3,70991E2

1,74496E1

1,90928E-2

1,59998E0

5,98729E0

9.4

relative error(%)

0,00

9.6

BioUML

3,13331E-1

4,39919E1

8,74991E-1

1,83049E-1

5,43053E-1

8,15711E1

3,70886E2

1,73894E1

1,93019E-2

1,61688E0

5,98881E0

9.6

ByoDyn

3,13331E-1

4,39919E1

8,74991E-1

1,83049E-1

5,43053E-1

8,15711E1

3,70886E2

1,73894E1

1,93019E-2

1,61688E0

5,98881E0

9.6

Jarnac

3,13357E-1

4,39919E1

8,74961E-1

1,83056E-1

5,43164E-1

8,15681E1

3,70889E2

1,73923E1

1,92989E-2

1,61664E0

5,98877E0

9.6

MathSBML

3,13331E-1

4,39919E1

8,74991E-1

1,83049E-1

5,43053E-1

8,15711E1

3,70886E2

1,73894E1

1,93019E-2

1,61688E0

5,98881E0

9.6

SBToolbox2

3,13297E-1

4,39920E1

8,74810E-1

1,83032E-1

5,42947E-1

8,15771E1

3,70880E2

1,73829E1

1,93054E-2

1,61714E0

5,98890E0

9.6

SBWOdeSolver

3,13331E-1

4,39919E1

8,74992E-1

1,83049E-1

5,43053E-1

8,15711E1

3,70886E2

1,73894E1

1,93019E-2

1,61688E0

5,98881E0

9.6

VCell

3,13331E-1

4,39919E1

8,74991E-1

1,83049E-1

5,43053E-1

8,15711E1

3,70886E2

1,73894E1

1,93019E-2

1,61688E0

5,98881E0

9.6

copasi

3,13331E-1

4,39919E1

8,74991E-1

1,83049E-1

5,43053E-1

8,15711E1

3,70886E2

1,73895E1

1,93020E-2

1,61688E0

5,98881E0

9.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,13331E-1

4,39919E1

8,74991E-1

1,83049E-1

5,43053E-1

8,15711E1

3,70886E2

1,73894E1

1,93019E-2

1,61688E0

5,98881E0

9.6

jsim

3,13331E-1

4,39919E1

8,74991E-1

1,83049E-1

5,43053E-1

8,15711E1

3,70886E2

1,73894E1

1,93019E-2

1,61688E0

5,98881E0

9.6

min

3,13297E-1

4,39919E1

8,74810E-1

1,83032E-1

5,42947E-1

8,15681E1

3,70880E2

1,73829E1

1,92989E-2

1,61664E0

5,98877E0

9.6

max

3,13357E-1

4,39920E1

8,74992E-1

1,83056E-1

5,43164E-1

8,15771E1

3,70889E2

1,73923E1

1,93054E-2

1,61714E0

5,98890E0

9.6

mean

3,13331E-1

4,39919E1

8,74991E-1

1,83049E-1

5,43053E-1

8,15711E1

3,70886E2

1,73894E1

1,93019E-2

1,61688E0

5,98881E0

9.6

relative error(%)

0,00

9.8

BioUML

3,16900E-1

4,39902E1

9,04620E-1

1,84367E-1

5,61475E-1

8,16026E1

3,70787E2

1,73346E1

1,95055E-2

1,63335E0

5,99025E0

9.8

ByoDyn

3,16900E-1

4,39902E1

9,04620E-1

1,84367E-1

5,61475E-1

8,16026E1

3,70787E2

1,73346E1

1,95055E-2

1,63335E0

5,99025E0

9.8

Jarnac

3,16924E-1

4,39903E1

9,04589E-1

1,84373E-1

5,61584E-1

8,15998E1

3,70790E2

1,73373E1

1,95025E-2

1,63312E0

5,99021E0

9.8

MathSBML

3,16900E-1

4,39902E1

9,04620E-1

1,84367E-1

5,61475E-1

8,16026E1

3,70787E2

1,73346E1

1,95055E-2

1,63335E0

5,99025E0

9.8

SBToolbox2

3,16864E-1

4,39900E1

9,04490E-1

1,84351E-1

5,61329E-1

8,16080E1

3,70780E2

1,73290E1

1,95092E-2

1,63362E0

5,99030E0

9.8

SBWOdeSolver

3,16900E-1

4,39902E1

9,04620E-1

1,84367E-1

5,61475E-1

8,16026E1

3,70787E2

1,73346E1

1,95055E-2

1,63335E0

5,99025E0

9.8

VCell

3,16900E-1

4,39902E1

9,04620E-1

1,84367E-1

5,61475E-1

8,16026E1

3,70787E2

1,73346E1

1,95055E-2

1,63335E0

5,99025E0

9.8

copasi

3,16900E-1

4,39902E1

9,04619E-1

1,84367E-1

5,61475E-1

8,16026E1

3,70787E2

1,73346E1

1,95055E-2

1,63335E0

5,99025E0

9.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,16900E-1

4,39902E1

9,04619E-1

1,84367E-1

5,61476E-1

8,16026E1

3,70787E2

1,73346E1

1,95055E-2

1,63335E0

5,99025E0

9.8

jsim

3,16900E-1

4,39902E1

9,04620E-1

1,84367E-1

5,61475E-1

8,16026E1

3,70787E2

1,73346E1

1,95055E-2

1,63335E0

5,99025E0

9.8

min

3,16864E-1

4,39900E1

9,04490E-1

1,84351E-1

5,61329E-1

8,15998E1

3,70780E2

1,73290E1

1,95025E-2

1,63312E0

5,99021E0

9.8

max

3,16924E-1

4,39903E1

9,04620E-1

1,84373E-1

5,61584E-1

8,16080E1

3,70790E2

1,73373E1

1,95092E-2

1,63362E0

5,99030E0

9.8

mean

3,16900E-1

4,39902E1

9,04620E-1

1,84367E-1

5,61475E-1

8,16026E1

3,70787E2

1,73346E1

1,95055E-2

1,63335E0

5,99025E0

9.8

relative error(%)

0,00