Test BIOMD0000000013.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000013.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000013.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: Imex
generated code	: BIOMD0000000013.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: -
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 23 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-10
ATOL 1.0E-12
RTOL 1.0E-6
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000013.gif

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: BPGA_ch G6P_ch G1P_ch Pi_ch Ru5P_ch F6P_ch R5P_ch ADP_ch GAP_ch X5P_ch S7P_ch ATP_ch PGA_ch DHAP_ch SBP_ch RuBP_ch E4P_ch FBP_ch
Simulators: ByoDyn CVODE copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner Jarnac SBToolbox2 Oscill8 Core MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

BPGA_ch

G6P_ch

G1P_ch

Pi_ch

Ru5P_ch

F6P_ch

R5P_ch

ADP_ch

GAP_ch

X5P_ch

S7P_ch

ATP_ch

PGA_ch

DHAP_ch

SBP_ch

RuBP_ch

E4P_ch

FBP_ch

0.0

BioUML

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

ByoDyn

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

CVODE

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

Jarnac

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

MathSBML

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

Oscill8 Core

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

SBToolbox2

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36480E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35480E0

2,93450E-1

1,56490E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

copasi

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

jsim

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

min

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36480E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

max

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35480E0

2,93450E-1

1,56490E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

mean

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

1,76547E-2

3,66959E0

2,12836E-1

1,10960E0

1,48879E-3

1,59548E0

3,72199E-3

6,01394E-3

1,17915E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25859E-4

4,93536E-1

6,93965E-1

2,59412E-1

2,39832E0

4,19077E-1

7,11172E-1

2,17177E-2

0.2

ByoDyn

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94022E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

CVODE

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94021E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

Jarnac

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94022E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

MathSBML

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94022E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

Oscill8 Core

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10947E0

1,48879E-3

1,59533E0

3,72198E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25871E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94013E-1

2,59407E-1

2,39803E0

4,19049E-1

7,11097E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

SBToolbox2

1,76584E-2

3,66949E0

2,12835E-1

1,10900E0

1,48913E-3

1,59544E0

3,72272E-3

6,01519E-3

1,17922E-2

2,22249E-3

8,26125E-4

4,93531E-1

6,94250E-1

2,59426E-1

2,39805E0

4,19134E-1

7,11051E-1

2,17199E-2

0.2

copasi

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25868E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94022E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94022E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

jsim

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94021E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

min

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10900E0

1,48879E-3

1,59533E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93531E-1

6,94013E-1

2,59407E-1

2,39803E0

4,19049E-1

7,11051E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

max

1,76584E-2

3,66949E0

2,12835E-1

1,10947E0

1,48913E-3

1,59544E0

3,72272E-3

6,01519E-3

1,17922E-2

2,22249E-3

8,26125E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94250E-1

2,59426E-1

2,39805E0

4,19134E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17199E-2

0.2

mean

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94022E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

1,74529E-2

3,53265E0

2,04894E-1

9,34447E-1

1,43138E-3

1,53593E0

3,57845E-3

6,27977E-3

1,15335E-2

2,13640E-3

7,80514E-4

4,93270E-1

7,16747E-1

2,53736E-1

2,29751E0

3,96436E-1

6,96515E-1

2,07779E-2

0.4

ByoDyn

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

CVODE

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

Jarnac

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

MathSBML

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

Oscill8 Core

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34052E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53550E0

3,57810E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16918E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

SBToolbox2

1,74531E-2

3,53194E0

2,04850E-1

9,33654E-1

1,43115E-3

1,53564E0

3,57793E-3

6,28148E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13608E-3

7,80383E-4

4,93270E-1

7,16957E-1

2,53698E-1

2,29678E0

3,96323E-1

6,96393E-1

2,07723E-2

0.4

copasi

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80437E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96322E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

jsim

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28096E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16918E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96322E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

min

1,74531E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,33654E-1

1,43115E-3

1,53550E0

3,57793E-3

6,28096E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13608E-3

7,80383E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16918E-1

2,53698E-1

2,29665E0

3,96323E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07723E-2

0.4

max

1,74538E-2

3,53194E0

2,04850E-1

9,34052E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53564E0

3,57810E-3

6,28148E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93270E-1

7,16957E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29678E0

3,96335E-1

6,96393E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

mean

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

1,74293E-2

3,36130E0

1,94955E-1

9,03395E-1

1,40725E-3

1,46143E0

3,51814E-3

6,34631E-3

1,13499E-2

2,10039E-3

7,66657E-4

4,93204E-1

7,23460E-1

2,49697E-1

2,15330E0

3,75021E-1

6,63359E-1

2,01215E-2

0.6

ByoDyn

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46076E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

CVODE

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46076E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

Jarnac

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46076E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

MathSBML

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46076E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

Oscill8 Core

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46077E0

3,51766E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74834E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

SBToolbox2

1,74291E-2

3,35971E0

1,94860E-1

9,02830E-1

1,40697E-3

1,46072E0

3,51737E-3

6,34766E-3

1,13485E-2

2,09990E-3

7,66448E-4

4,93200E-1

7,23616E-1

2,49661E-1

2,15193E0

3,74813E-1

6,63080E-1

2,01149E-2

0.6

copasi

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02983E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46077E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66565E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63044E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46076E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

jsim

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46077E0

3,51766E-3

6,34748E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66565E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74834E-1

6,63044E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

min

1,74291E-2

3,35971E0

1,94860E-1

9,02830E-1

1,40697E-3

1,46072E0

3,51737E-3

6,34748E-3

1,13481E-2

2,09990E-3

7,66448E-4

4,93200E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15193E0

3,74813E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01149E-2

0.6

max

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46077E0

3,51766E-3

6,34766E-3

1,13485E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23616E-1

2,49661E-1

2,15194E0

3,74834E-1

6,63080E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

mean

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46076E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

1,74123E-2

3,19002E0

1,85021E-1

8,79871E-1

1,38493E-3

1,38697E0

3,46235E-3

6,40040E-3

1,11674E-2

2,06708E-3

7,54687E-4

4,93150E-1

7,28991E-1

2,45682E-1

2,01028E0

3,54085E-1

6,29418E-1

1,94797E-2

0.8

ByoDyn

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

CVODE

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

Jarnac

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

MathSBML

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

Oscill8 Core

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

SBToolbox2

1,74138E-2

3,18830E0

1,84920E-1

8,79931E-1

1,38480E-3

1,38620E0

3,46187E-3

6,40070E-3

1,11648E-2

2,06686E-3

7,54703E-4

4,93150E-1

7,29091E-1

2,45618E-1

2,00836E0

3,53854E-1

6,28992E-1

1,94688E-2

0.8

copasi

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

jsim

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79450E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29003E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

min

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40070E-3

1,11648E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29091E-1

2,45618E-1

2,00836E0

3,53831E-1

6,28992E-1

1,94688E-2

0.8

max

1,74138E-2

3,18830E0

1,84920E-1

8,79931E-1

1,38480E-3

1,38620E0

3,46187E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06686E-3

7,54703E-4

4,93150E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53854E-1

6,29003E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

mean

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

1,73935E-2

3,02053E0

1,75191E-1

8,56251E-1

1,36326E-3

1,31327E0

3,40816E-3

6,45788E-3

1,09836E-2

2,03473E-3

7,43505E-4

4,93092E-1

7,34831E-1

2,41640E-1

1,87062E0

3,33621E-1

5,95489E-1

1,88440E-2

1.0

ByoDyn

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

CVODE

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

Jarnac

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

MathSBML

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

Oscill8 Core

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

SBToolbox2

1,73931E-2

3,01853E0

1,75078E-1

8,56091E-1

1,36291E-3

1,31237E0

3,40737E-3

6,45790E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03426E-3

7,43334E-4

4,93090E-1

7,34810E-1

2,41581E-1

1,86878E0

3,33350E-1

5,95087E-1

1,88342E-2

1.0

copasi

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

jsim

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55933E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34892E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95054E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

min

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36291E-3

1,31234E0

3,40737E-3

6,45790E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03426E-3

7,43334E-4

4,93090E-1

7,34810E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86878E0

3,33350E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88342E-2

1.0

max

1,73931E-2

3,01853E0

1,75078E-1

8,56091E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31237E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41581E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95087E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

mean

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

1,73734E-2

2,85300E0

1,65474E-1

8,32318E-1

1,34200E-3

1,24043E0

3,35501E-3

6,51932E-3

1,07977E-2

2,00300E-3

7,32929E-4

4,93031E-1

7,41056E-1

2,37549E-1

1,73459E0

3,13693E-1

5,61696E-1

1,82113E-2

1.2

ByoDyn

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

CVODE

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

Jarnac

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

MathSBML

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

Oscill8 Core

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

SBToolbox2

1,73701E-2

2,85000E0

1,65298E-1

8,33232E-1

1,34123E-3

1,23913E0

3,35320E-3

6,51416E-3

1,07952E-2

2,00188E-3

7,32276E-4

4,93040E-1

7,40318E-1

2,37504E-1

1,73292E0

3,13329E-1

5,61295E-1

1,82038E-2

1.2

copasi

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

jsim

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32050E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41101E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

min

1,73701E-2

2,85000E0

1,65298E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34123E-3

1,23913E0

3,35320E-3

6,51416E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00188E-3

7,32276E-4

4,93030E-1

7,40318E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13329E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

max

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,33232E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07952E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93040E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37504E-1

1,73292E0

3,13422E-1

5,61295E-1

1,82038E-2

1.2

mean

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

1,73513E-2

2,68739E0

1,55868E-1

8,07906E-1

1,32128E-3

1,16843E0

3,30321E-3

6,58586E-3

1,06099E-2

1,97208E-3

7,23070E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47771E-1

2,33417E-1

1,60230E0

2,94263E-1

5,28041E-1

1,75832E-2

1.4

ByoDyn

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

CVODE

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

Jarnac

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

MathSBML

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

Oscill8 Core

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

SBToolbox2

1,73523E-2

2,68588E0

1,55779E-1

8,06895E-1

1,32115E-3

1,16780E0

3,30279E-3

6,58962E-3

1,06093E-2

1,97184E-3

7,22973E-4

4,92960E-1

7,48236E-1

2,33398E-1

1,60130E0

2,94126E-1

5,27762E-1

1,75802E-2

1.4

copasi

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

jsim

1,73510E-2

2,68548E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22929E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33368E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

min

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,06895E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22929E-4

4,92960E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

max

1,73523E-2

2,68588E0

1,55779E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32115E-3

1,16780E0

3,30279E-3

6,58962E-3

1,06093E-2

1,97184E-3

7,22973E-4

4,92964E-1

7,48236E-1

2,33398E-1

1,60130E0

2,94126E-1

5,27762E-1

1,75802E-2

1.4

mean

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

1.6

BioUML

1,73275E-2

2,52359E0

1,46368E-1

7,82988E-1

1,30103E-3

1,09721E0

3,25258E-3

6,65815E-3

1,04197E-2

1,94185E-3

7,13894E-4

4,92892E-1

7,55052E-1

2,29232E-1

1,47376E0

2,75379E-1

4,94547E-1

1,69585E-2

1.6

ByoDyn

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

CVODE

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

Jarnac

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

MathSBML

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

Oscill8 Core

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13805E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

SBToolbox2

1,73283E-2

2,52250E0

1,46305E-1

7,83178E-1

1,30106E-3

1,09676E0

3,25252E-3

6,65769E-3

1,04206E-2

1,94184E-3

7,13822E-4

4,92890E-1

7,55040E-1

2,29245E-1

1,47332E0

2,75312E-1

4,94369E-1

1,69611E-2

1.6

copasi

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

jsim

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83017E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94286E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

min

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65769E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92890E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

max

1,73283E-2

2,52250E0

1,46305E-1

7,83178E-1

1,30106E-3

1,09676E0

3,25252E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04206E-2

1,94184E-3

7,13822E-4

4,92892E-1

7,55040E-1

2,29245E-1

1,47332E0

2,75312E-1

4,94369E-1

1,69611E-2

1.6

mean

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

1.8

BioUML

1,73007E-2

2,36227E0

1,37012E-1

7,58076E-1

1,28139E-3

1,02707E0

3,20349E-3

6,73469E-3

1,02285E-2

1,91254E-3

7,05474E-4

4,92815E-1

7,62667E-1

2,25026E-1

1,34977E0

2,57121E-1

4,61404E-1

1,63419E-2

1.8

ByoDyn

1,73007E-2

2,36121E0

1,36950E-1

7,57801E-1

1,28128E-3

1,02661E0

3,20320E-3

6,73575E-3

1,02271E-2

1,91237E-3

7,05445E-4

4,92814E-1

7,62788E-1

2,24995E-1

1,34890E0

2,56996E-1

4,61174E-1

1,63373E-2

1.8

CVODE

1,73007E-2

2,36121E0

1,36950E-1

7,57801E-1

1,28128E-3

1,02661E0

3,20320E-3

6,73575E-3

1,02271E-2

1,91237E-3

7,05445E-4

4,92814E-1

7,62788E-1

2,24995E-1

1,34890E0

2,56996E-1

4,61174E-1

1,63373E-2

1.8

Jarnac

1,73007E-2

2,36121E0

1,36950E-1

7,57801E-1

1,28128E-3

1,02661E0

3,20320E-3

6,73575E-3

1,02271E-2

1,91237E-3

7,05445E-4

4,92814E-1

7,62788E-1

2,24995E-1

1,34890E0

2,56996E-1

4,61174E-1

1,63373E-2

1.8

MathSBML

1,73007E-2

2,36121E0

1,36950E-1

7,57801E-1

1,28128E-3

1,02661E0

3,20320E-3

6,73575E-3

1,02271E-2

1,91237E-3

7,05445E-4

4,92814E-1

7,62788E-1

2,24995E-1

1,34890E0

2,56996E-1

4,61174E-1

1,63373E-2

1.8

Oscill8 Core

1,73007E-2

2,36121E0

1,36950E-1

7,57801E-1

1,28128E-3

1,02661E0

3,20320E-3

1,02271E-2

1,91237E-3

7,05445E-4

4,92814E-1

7,62788E-1

2,24995E-1

1,34890E0

2,56996E-1

4,61174E-1

1,63373E-2

1.8

SBToolbox2

1,73024E-2

2,36528E0

1,37185E-1

7,56416E-1

1,28208E-3

1,02835E0

3,20535E-3

6,74296E-3

1,02266E-2

1,91367E-3

7,06426E-4

4,92810E-1

7,63704E-1

2,24976E-1

1,35008E0

2,57282E-1

4,61617E-1

1,63344E-2

1.8

copasi

1,73007E-2

2,36121E0

1,36950E-1

7,57801E-1

1,28128E-3

1,02661E0

3,20320E-3

6,73575E-3

1,02271E-2

1,91237E-3

7,05445E-4

4,92814E-1

7,62788E-1

2,24995E-1

1,34890E0

2,56996E-1

4,61174E-1

1,63373E-2

1.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,73007E-2

2,36121E0

1,36950E-1

7,57801E-1

1,28128E-3

1,02661E0

3,20320E-3

6,73575E-3

1,02271E-2

1,91237E-3

7,05445E-4

4,92814E-1

7,62788E-1

2,24995E-1

1,34890E0

2,56996E-1

4,61174E-1

1,63373E-2

1.8

jsim

1,73007E-2

2,36121E0

1,36950E-1

7,57801E-1

1,28128E-3

1,02661E0

3,20320E-3

6,73574E-3

1,02271E-2

1,91237E-3

7,05444E-4

4,92814E-1

7,62788E-1

2,24995E-1

1,34890E0

2,56996E-1

4,61175E-1

1,63374E-2

1.8

min

1,73007E-2

2,36121E0

1,36950E-1

7,56416E-1

1,28128E-3

1,02661E0

3,20320E-3

6,73574E-3

1,02266E-2

1,91237E-3

7,05444E-4

4,92810E-1

7,62788E-1

2,24976E-1

1,34890E0

2,56996E-1

4,61174E-1

1,63344E-2

1.8

max

1,73024E-2

2,36528E0

1,37185E-1

7,57801E-1

1,28208E-3

1,02835E0

3,20535E-3

6,74296E-3

1,02271E-2

1,91367E-3

7,06426E-4

4,92814E-1

7,63704E-1

2,24995E-1

1,35008E0

2,57282E-1

4,61617E-1

1,63374E-2

1.8

mean

1,73007E-2

2,36121E0

1,36950E-1

7,57801E-1

1,28128E-3

1,02661E0

3,20320E-3

6,73575E-3

1,02271E-2

1,91237E-3

7,05445E-4

4,92814E-1

7,62788E-1

2,24995E-1

1,34890E0

2,56996E-1

4,61174E-1

1,63373E-2

1.8

relative error(%)

0,00

2.0

BioUML

1,72716E-2

2,20395E0

1,27829E-1

7,32475E-1

1,26250E-3

9,58241E-1

3,15627E-3

6,81941E-3

1,00359E-2

1,88435E-3

6,97996E-4

4,92731E-1

7,71096E-1

2,20788E-1

1,23046E0

2,39538E-1

4,28693E-1

1,57321E-2

2.0

ByoDyn

1,72715E-2

2,20237E0

1,27737E-1

7,32076E-1

1,26227E-3

9,57552E-1

3,15567E-3

6,82085E-3

1,00337E-2

1,88400E-3

6,97886E-4

4,92729E-1

7,71257E-1

2,20740E-1

1,22927E0

2,39364E-1

4,28372E-1

1,57253E-2

2.0

CVODE

1,72715E-2

2,20237E0

1,27737E-1

7,32076E-1

1,26227E-3

9,57552E-1

3,15567E-3

6,82085E-3

1,00337E-2

1,88400E-3

6,97886E-4

4,92729E-1

7,71257E-1

2,20740E-1

1,22927E0

2,39364E-1

4,28372E-1

1,57253E-2

2.0

Jarnac

1,72715E-2

2,20237E0

1,27737E-1

7,32076E-1

1,26227E-3

9,57552E-1

3,15567E-3

6,82085E-3

1,00337E-2

1,88400E-3

6,97886E-4

4,92729E-1

7,71257E-1

2,20740E-1

1,22927E0

2,39364E-1

4,28372E-1

1,57253E-2

2.0

MathSBML

1,72715E-2

2,20237E0

1,27737E-1

7,32076E-1

1,26227E-3

9,57552E-1

3,15567E-3

6,82085E-3

1,00337E-2

1,88400E-3

6,97886E-4

4,92729E-1

7,71257E-1

2,20740E-1

1,22927E0

2,39364E-1

4,28372E-1

1,57253E-2

2.0

Oscill8 Core

1,72715E-2

2,20237E0

1,27737E-1

7,32075E-1

1,26227E-3

9,57552E-1

3,15567E-3

1,00337E-2

1,88400E-3

6,97886E-4

4,92729E-1

7,71257E-1

2,20740E-1

1,22927E0

2,39364E-1

4,28372E-1

1,57253E-2

2.0

SBToolbox2

1,72734E-2

2,20320E0

1,27782E-1

7,31686E-1

1,26246E-3

9,57896E-1

3,15622E-3

6,82320E-3

1,00360E-2

1,88428E-3

6,97954E-4

4,92730E-1

7,71592E-1

2,20792E-1

1,23002E0

2,39486E-1

4,28558E-1

1,57330E-2

2.0

copasi

1,72715E-2

2,20237E0

1,27737E-1

7,32076E-1

1,26227E-3

9,57552E-1

3,15567E-3

6,82085E-3

1,00337E-2

1,88400E-3

6,97886E-4

4,92729E-1

7,71257E-1

2,20740E-1

1,22927E0

2,39364E-1

4,28372E-1

1,57253E-2

2.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,72715E-2

2,20237E0

1,27737E-1

7,32076E-1

1,26227E-3

9,57552E-1

3,15567E-3

6,82085E-3

1,00337E-2

1,88400E-3

6,97886E-4

4,92729E-1

7,71257E-1

2,20740E-1

1,22927E0

2,39364E-1

4,28372E-1

1,57253E-2

2.0

jsim

1,72715E-2

2,20237E0

1,27738E-1

7,32076E-1

1,26227E-3

9,57553E-1

3,15567E-3

6,82084E-3

1,00337E-2

1,88400E-3

6,97885E-4

4,92729E-1

7,71257E-1

2,20740E-1

1,22927E0

2,39364E-1

4,28373E-1

1,57253E-2

2.0

min

1,72715E-2

2,20237E0

1,27737E-1

7,31686E-1

1,26227E-3

9,57552E-1

3,15567E-3

6,82084E-3

1,00337E-2

1,88400E-3

6,97885E-4

4,92729E-1

7,71257E-1

2,20740E-1

1,22927E0

2,39364E-1

4,28372E-1

1,57253E-2

2.0

max

1,72734E-2

2,20320E0

1,27782E-1

7,32076E-1

1,26246E-3

9,57896E-1

3,15622E-3

6,82320E-3

1,00360E-2

1,88428E-3

6,97954E-4

4,92730E-1

7,71592E-1

2,20792E-1

1,23002E0

2,39486E-1

4,28558E-1

1,57330E-2

2.0

mean

1,72715E-2

2,20237E0

1,27737E-1

7,32076E-1

1,26227E-3

9,57552E-1

3,15567E-3

6,82085E-3

1,00337E-2

1,88400E-3

6,97886E-4

4,92729E-1

7,71257E-1

2,20740E-1

1,22927E0

2,39364E-1

4,28372E-1

1,57253E-2

2.0

relative error(%)

0,00

2.2

BioUML

1,72396E-2

2,04769E0

1,18766E-1

7,06238E-1

1,24410E-3

8,90299E-1

3,11025E-3

6,91258E-3

9,84047E-3

1,85688E-3

6,91271E-4

4,92637E-1

7,80329E-1

2,16490E-1

1,11539E0

2,22558E-1

3,96322E-1

1,51255E-2

2.2

ByoDyn

1,72390E-2

2,04577E0

1,18655E-1

7,05808E-1

1,24384E-3

8,89466E-1

3,10961E-3

6,91413E-3

9,83793E-3

1,85649E-3

6,91165E-4

4,92636E-1

7,80480E-1

2,16434E-1

1,11401E0

2,22347E-1

3,95930E-1

1,51177E-2

2.2

CVODE

1,72390E-2

2,04577E0

1,18655E-1

7,05808E-1

1,24384E-3

8,89466E-1

3,10961E-3

6,91413E-3

9,83793E-3

1,85649E-3

6,91165E-4

4,92636E-1

7,80480E-1

2,16434E-1

1,11401E0

2,22347E-1

3,95930E-1

1,51177E-2

2.2

Jarnac

1,72390E-2

2,04577E0

1,18655E-1

7,05808E-1

1,24384E-3

8,89466E-1

3,10961E-3

6,91413E-3

9,83793E-3

1,85649E-3

6,91165E-4

4,92636E-1

7,80480E-1

2,16434E-1

1,11401E0

2,22347E-1

3,95930E-1

1,51177E-2

2.2

MathSBML

1,72390E-2

2,04577E0

1,18655E-1

7,05808E-1

1,24384E-3

8,89466E-1

3,10961E-3

6,91413E-3

9,83793E-3

1,85649E-3

6,91165E-4

4,92636E-1

7,80480E-1

2,16434E-1

1,11401E0

2,22347E-1

3,95930E-1

1,51177E-2

2.2

Oscill8 Core

1,72390E-2

2,04577E0

1,18655E-1

7,05808E-1

1,24384E-3

8,89467E-1

3,10961E-3

9,83793E-3

1,85649E-3

6,91165E-4

4,92636E-1

7,80480E-1

2,16434E-1

1,11401E0

2,22347E-1

3,95930E-1

1,51177E-2

2.2

SBToolbox2

1,72394E-2

2,04769E0

1,18767E-1

7,05953E-1

1,24392E-3

8,90320E-1

3,10983E-3

6,91344E-3

9,83922E-3

1,85663E-3

6,91189E-4

4,92640E-1

7,80429E-1

2,16461E-1

1,11523E0

2,22505E-1

3,96325E-1

1,51218E-2

2.2

copasi

1,72390E-2

2,04577E0

1,18655E-1

7,05808E-1

1,24384E-3

8,89467E-1

3,10961E-3

6,91413E-3

9,83793E-3

1,85649E-3

6,91165E-4

4,92636E-1

7,80480E-1

2,16434E-1

1,11401E0

2,22347E-1

3,95931E-1

1,51177E-2

2.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,72390E-2

2,04577E0

1,18655E-1

7,05808E-1

1,24384E-3

8,89466E-1

3,10961E-3

6,91413E-3

9,83793E-3

1,85649E-3

6,91165E-4

4,92636E-1

7,80480E-1

2,16434E-1

1,11401E0

2,22347E-1

3,95930E-1

1,51177E-2

2.2

jsim

1,72390E-2

2,04577E0

1,18655E-1

7,05809E-1

1,24384E-3

8,89467E-1

3,10961E-3

6,91412E-3

9,83794E-3

1,85649E-3

6,91164E-4

4,92636E-1

7,80480E-1

2,16434E-1

1,11401E0

2,22347E-1

3,95931E-1

1,51177E-2

2.2

min

1,72390E-2

2,04577E0

1,18655E-1

7,05808E-1

1,24384E-3

8,89466E-1

3,10961E-3

6,91344E-3

9,83793E-3

1,85649E-3

6,91164E-4

4,92636E-1

7,80429E-1

2,16434E-1

1,11401E0

2,22347E-1

3,95930E-1

1,51177E-2

2.2

max

1,72394E-2

2,04769E0

1,18767E-1

7,05953E-1

1,24392E-3

8,90320E-1

3,10983E-3

6,91413E-3

9,83922E-3

1,85663E-3

6,91189E-4

4,92640E-1

7,80480E-1

2,16461E-1

1,11523E0

2,22505E-1

3,96325E-1

1,51218E-2

2.2

mean

1,72390E-2

2,04577E0

1,18655E-1

7,05808E-1

1,24384E-3

8,89466E-1

3,10961E-3

6,91413E-3

9,83793E-3

1,85649E-3

6,91165E-4

4,92636E-1

7,80480E-1

2,16434E-1

1,11401E0

2,22347E-1

3,95930E-1

1,51177E-2

2.2

relative error(%)

0,00

2.4

BioUML

1,72028E-2

1,89374E0

1,09837E-1

6,79519E-1

1,22626E-3

8,23365E-1

3,06567E-3

7,01445E-3

9,64279E-3

1,83026E-3

6,85387E-4

4,92536E-1

7,90305E-1

2,12141E-1

1,00491E0

2,06204E-1

3,64386E-1

1,45239E-2

2.4

ByoDyn

1,72024E-2

1,89147E0

1,09706E-1

6,78970E-1

1,22600E-3

8,22380E-1

3,06502E-3

7,01680E-3

9,63963E-3

1,82987E-3

6,85321E-4

4,92533E-1

7,90552E-1

2,12071E-1

1,00327E0

2,05964E-1

3,63908E-1

1,45144E-2

2.4

CVODE

1,72024E-2

1,89148E0

1,09706E-1

6,78970E-1

1,22600E-3

8,22380E-1

3,06502E-3

7,01680E-3

9,63963E-3

1,82987E-3

6,85321E-4

4,92533E-1

7,90552E-1

2,12071E-1

1,00327E0

2,05964E-1

3,63908E-1

1,45144E-2

2.4

Jarnac

1,72024E-2

1,89147E0

1,09706E-1

6,78970E-1

1,22600E-3

8,22380E-1

3,06502E-3

7,01680E-3

9,63963E-3

1,82987E-3

6,85321E-4

4,92533E-1

7,90552E-1

2,12071E-1

1,00327E0

2,05964E-1

3,63908E-1

1,45144E-2

2.4

MathSBML

1,72024E-2

1,89148E0

1,09706E-1

6,78970E-1

1,22600E-3

8,22380E-1

3,06502E-3

7,01680E-3

9,63963E-3

1,82987E-3

6,85321E-4

4,92533E-1

7,90552E-1

2,12071E-1

1,00327E0

2,05964E-1

3,63908E-1

1,45144E-2

2.4

Oscill8 Core

1,72024E-2

1,89148E0

1,09706E-1

6,78970E-1

1,22600E-3

8,22381E-1

3,06502E-3

9,63963E-3

1,82987E-3

6,85321E-4

4,92533E-1

7,90552E-1

2,12071E-1

1,00327E0

2,05964E-1

3,63908E-1

1,45144E-2

2.4

SBToolbox2

1,71995E-2

1,89480E0

1,09896E-1

6,78955E-1

1,22667E-3

8,23825E-1

3,06673E-3

7,01606E-3

9,64018E-3

1,83086E-3

6,86039E-4

4,92532E-1

7,90324E-1

2,12080E-1

1,00450E0

2,06235E-1

3,64344E-1

1,45160E-2

2.4

copasi

1,72024E-2

1,89148E0

1,09706E-1

6,78971E-1

1,22600E-3

8,22382E-1

3,06502E-3

7,01680E-3

9,63964E-3

1,82987E-3

6,85321E-4

4,92533E-1

7,90551E-1

2,12071E-1

1,00327E0

2,05964E-1

3,63908E-1

1,45144E-2

2.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,72024E-2

1,89147E0

1,09706E-1

6,78970E-1

1,22600E-3

8,22380E-1

3,06502E-3

7,01680E-3

9,63963E-3

1,82987E-3

6,85321E-4

4,92533E-1

7,90552E-1

2,12071E-1

1,00327E0

2,05964E-1

3,63908E-1

1,45144E-2

2.4

jsim

1,72024E-2

1,89148E0

1,09706E-1

6,78971E-1

1,22600E-3

8,22381E-1

3,06502E-3

7,01679E-3

9,63965E-3

1,82987E-3

6,85320E-4

4,92533E-1

7,90551E-1

2,12072E-1

1,00327E0

2,05964E-1

3,63908E-1

1,45144E-2

2.4

min

1,71995E-2

1,89147E0

1,09706E-1

6,78955E-1

1,22600E-3

8,22380E-1

3,06502E-3

7,01606E-3

9,63963E-3

1,82987E-3

6,85320E-4

4,92532E-1

7,90324E-1

2,12071E-1

1,00327E0

2,05964E-1

3,63908E-1

1,45144E-2

2.4

max

1,72024E-2

1,89480E0

1,09896E-1

6,78971E-1

1,22667E-3

8,23825E-1

3,06673E-3

7,01680E-3

9,64018E-3

1,83086E-3

6,86039E-4

4,92533E-1

7,90552E-1

2,12080E-1

1,00450E0

2,06235E-1

3,64344E-1

1,45160E-2

2.4

mean

1,72024E-2

1,89148E0

1,09706E-1

6,78970E-1

1,22600E-3

8,22380E-1

3,06502E-3

7,01680E-3

9,63963E-3

1,82987E-3

6,85321E-4

4,92533E-1

7,90552E-1

2,12071E-1

1,00327E0

2,05964E-1

3,63908E-1

1,45144E-2

2.4

relative error(%)

0,00

2.6

BioUML

1,71614E-2

1,74210E0

1,01042E-1

6,52099E-1

1,20899E-3

7,57436E-1

3,02249E-3

7,12764E-3

9,44172E-3

1,80449E-3

6,80428E-4

4,92422E-1

8,01308E-1

2,07717E-1

8,98955E-1

1,90489E-1

3,32906E-1

1,39245E-2

2.6

ByoDyn

1,71607E-2

1,73956E0

1,00894E-1

6,51545E-1

1,20876E-3

7,56330E-1

3,02190E-3

7,13024E-3

9,43852E-3

1,80413E-3

6,80393E-4

4,92420E-1

8,01572E-1

2,07647E-1

8,97211E-1

1,90235E-1

3,32373E-1

1,39151E-2

2.6

CVODE

1,71607E-2

1,73956E0

1,00894E-1

6,51545E-1

1,20876E-3

7,56330E-1

3,02190E-3

7,13024E-3

9,43852E-3

1,80413E-3

6,80393E-4

4,92420E-1

8,01572E-1

2,07647E-1

8,97211E-1

1,90235E-1

3,32373E-1

1,39151E-2

2.6

Jarnac

1,71607E-2

1,73956E0

1,00894E-1

6,51545E-1

1,20876E-3

7,56330E-1

3,02190E-3

7,13024E-3

9,43852E-3

1,80413E-3

6,80393E-4

4,92420E-1

8,01572E-1

2,07647E-1

8,97211E-1

1,90235E-1

3,32373E-1

1,39151E-2

2.6

MathSBML

1,71607E-2

1,73956E0

1,00894E-1

6,51545E-1

1,20876E-3

7,56330E-1

3,02190E-3

7,13024E-3

9,43852E-3

1,80413E-3

6,80393E-4

4,92420E-1

8,01572E-1

2,07647E-1

8,97211E-1

1,90235E-1

3,32373E-1

1,39151E-2

2.6

Oscill8 Core

1,71607E-2

1,73956E0

1,00894E-1

6,51544E-1

1,20876E-3

7,56330E-1

3,02190E-3

9,43852E-3

1,80413E-3

6,80393E-4

4,92420E-1

8,01573E-1

2,07647E-1

8,97212E-1

1,90236E-1

3,32373E-1

1,39151E-2

2.6

SBToolbox2

1,71578E-2

1,74092E0

1,00972E-1

6,52262E-1

1,20878E-3

7,56915E-1

3,02199E-3

7,12515E-3

9,44082E-3

1,80416E-3

6,80253E-4

4,92423E-1

8,00863E-1

2,07697E-1

8,98278E-1

1,90362E-1

3,32696E-1

1,39215E-2

2.6

copasi

1,71607E-2

1,73956E0

1,00895E-1

6,51545E-1

1,20876E-3

7,56332E-1

3,02191E-3

7,13023E-3

9,43853E-3

1,80413E-3

6,80393E-4

4,92420E-1

8,01572E-1

2,07647E-1

8,97214E-1

1,90236E-1

3,32374E-1

1,39151E-2

2.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,71607E-2

1,73956E0

1,00894E-1

6,51545E-1

1,20876E-3

7,56330E-1

3,02190E-3

7,13024E-3

9,43852E-3

1,80413E-3

6,80393E-4

4,92420E-1

8,01572E-1

2,07647E-1

8,97211E-1

1,90235E-1

3,32373E-1

1,39151E-2

2.6

jsim

1,71607E-2

1,73956E0

1,00894E-1

6,51545E-1

1,20876E-3

7,56331E-1

3,02190E-3

7,13023E-3

9,43854E-3

1,80413E-3

6,80391E-4

4,92420E-1

8,01572E-1

2,07647E-1

8,97210E-1

1,90235E-1

3,32373E-1

1,39151E-2

2.6

min

1,71578E-2

1,73956E0

1,00894E-1

6,51544E-1

1,20876E-3

7,56330E-1

3,02190E-3

7,12515E-3

9,43852E-3

1,80413E-3

6,80253E-4

4,92420E-1

8,00863E-1

2,07647E-1

8,97210E-1

1,90235E-1

3,32373E-1

1,39151E-2

2.6

max

1,71607E-2

1,74092E0

1,00972E-1

6,52262E-1

1,20878E-3

7,56915E-1

3,02199E-3

7,13024E-3

9,44082E-3

1,80416E-3

6,80393E-4

4,92423E-1

8,01573E-1

2,07697E-1

8,98278E-1

1,90362E-1

3,32696E-1

1,39215E-2

2.6

mean

1,71607E-2

1,73956E0

1,00894E-1

6,51545E-1

1,20876E-3

7,56330E-1

3,02190E-3

7,13024E-3

9,43852E-3

1,80413E-3

6,80393E-4

4,92420E-1

8,01572E-1

2,07647E-1

8,97211E-1

1,90235E-1

3,32373E-1

1,39151E-2

2.6

relative error(%)

0,00

2.8

BioUML

1,71139E-2

1,59259E0

9,23703E-2

6,23949E-1

1,19236E-3

6,92431E-1

2,98092E-3

7,25413E-3

9,23758E-3

1,77966E-3

6,76483E-4

4,92296E-1

8,13479E-1

2,03226E-1

7,97626E-1

1,75425E-1

3,01909E-1

1,33289E-2

2.8

ByoDyn

1,71129E-2

1,59015E0

9,22285E-2

6,23534E-1

1,19209E-3

6,91368E-1

2,98023E-3

7,25595E-3

9,23430E-3

1,77925E-3

6,76412E-4

4,92294E-1

8,13639E-1

2,03154E-1

7,96020E-1

1,75184E-1

3,01408E-1

1,33195E-2

2.8

CVODE

1,71129E-2

1,59015E0

9,22286E-2

6,23534E-1

1,19209E-3

6,91368E-1

2,98023E-3

7,25595E-3

9,23430E-3

1,77925E-3

6,76412E-4

4,92294E-1

8,13639E-1

2,03154E-1

7,96020E-1

1,75184E-1

3,01408E-1

1,33195E-2

2.8

Jarnac

1,71129E-2

1,59015E0

9,22285E-2

6,23534E-1

1,19209E-3

6,91368E-1

2,98023E-3

7,25595E-3

9,23430E-3

1,77925E-3

6,76412E-4

4,92294E-1

8,13639E-1

2,03154E-1

7,96020E-1

1,75184E-1

3,01408E-1

1,33195E-2

2.8

MathSBML

1,71129E-2

1,59015E0

9,22286E-2

6,23535E-1

1,19209E-3

6,91369E-1

2,98023E-3

7,25595E-3

9,23430E-3

1,77925E-3

6,76412E-4

4,92294E-1

8,13639E-1

2,03154E-1

7,96020E-1

1,75184E-1

3,01408E-1

1,33195E-2

2.8

Oscill8 Core

1,71129E-2

1,59015E0

9,22286E-2

6,23534E-1

1,19209E-3

6,91369E-1

2,98023E-3

9,23430E-3

1,77925E-3

6,76412E-4

4,92294E-1

8,13639E-1

2,03154E-1

7,96021E-1

1,75184E-1

3,01408E-1

1,33195E-2

2.8

SBToolbox2

1,71176E-2

1,59237E0

9,23574E-2

6,23316E-1

1,19312E-3

6,92342E-1

2,98282E-3

7,26016E-3

9,23991E-3

1,78076E-3

6,77154E-4

4,92290E-1

8,14335E-1

2,03274E-1

7,97273E-1

1,75477E-1

3,01738E-1

1,33354E-2

2.8

copasi

1,71129E-2

1,59015E0

9,22289E-2

6,23535E-1

1,19209E-3

6,91371E-1

2,98023E-3

7,25595E-3

9,23431E-3

1,77925E-3

6,76412E-4

4,92294E-1

8,13639E-1

2,03154E-1

7,96024E-1

1,75184E-1

3,01409E-1

1,33195E-2

2.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,71129E-2

1,59015E0

9,22285E-2

6,23534E-1

1,19209E-3

6,91368E-1

2,98023E-3

7,25595E-3

9,23430E-3

1,77925E-3

6,76412E-4

4,92294E-1

8,13639E-1

2,03154E-1

7,96020E-1

1,75184E-1

3,01408E-1

1,33195E-2

2.8

jsim

1,71129E-2

1,59015E0

9,22286E-2

6,23535E-1

1,19209E-3

6,91369E-1

2,98023E-3

7,25593E-3

9,23432E-3

1,77925E-3

6,76410E-4

4,92294E-1

8,13638E-1

2,03155E-1

7,96019E-1

1,75184E-1

3,01409E-1

1,33195E-2

2.8

min

1,71129E-2

1,59015E0

9,22285E-2

6,23316E-1

1,19209E-3

6,91368E-1

2,98023E-3

7,25593E-3

9,23430E-3

1,77925E-3

6,76410E-4

4,92290E-1

8,13638E-1

2,03154E-1

7,96019E-1

1,75184E-1

3,01408E-1

1,33195E-2

2.8

max

1,71176E-2

1,59237E0

9,23574E-2

6,23535E-1

1,19312E-3

6,92342E-1

2,98282E-3

7,26016E-3

9,23991E-3

1,78076E-3

6,77154E-4

4,92294E-1

8,14335E-1

2,03274E-1

7,97273E-1

1,75477E-1

3,01738E-1

1,33354E-2

2.8

mean

1,71129E-2

1,59015E0

9,22286E-2

6,23534E-1

1,19209E-3

6,91369E-1

2,98023E-3

7,25595E-3

9,23430E-3

1,77925E-3

6,76412E-4

4,92294E-1

8,13639E-1

2,03154E-1

7,96020E-1

1,75184E-1

3,01408E-1

1,33195E-2

2.8

relative error(%)

0,00

3.0

BioUML

1,70584E-2

1,44557E0

8,38428E-2

5,95336E-1

1,17618E-3

6,28507E-1

2,94045E-3

7,39370E-3

9,02985E-3

1,75550E-3

6,73405E-4

4,92156E-1

8,26674E-1

1,98656E-1

7,01315E-1

1,61041E-1

2,71561E-1

1,27362E-2

3.0

ByoDyn

1,70574E-2

1,44342E0

8,37186E-2

5,94986E-1

1,17596E-3

6,27576E-1

2,93990E-3

7,39541E-3

9,02664E-3

1,75517E-3

6,73392E-4

4,92155E-1

8,26821E-1

1,98586E-1

6,99910E-1

1,60834E-1

2,71114E-1

1,27271E-2

3.0

CVODE

1,70574E-2

1,44343E0

8,37187E-2

5,94986E-1

1,17596E-3

6,27576E-1

2,93990E-3

7,39541E-3

9,02664E-3

1,75517E-3

6,73392E-4

4,92155E-1

8,26821E-1

1,98586E-1

6,99911E-1

1,60834E-1

2,71114E-1

1,27271E-2

3.0

Jarnac

1,70574E-2

1,44342E0

8,37186E-2

5,94986E-1

1,17596E-3

6,27576E-1

2,93990E-3

7,39541E-3

9,02664E-3

1,75517E-3

6,73392E-4

4,92155E-1

8,26821E-1

1,98586E-1

6,99910E-1

1,60834E-1

2,71114E-1

1,27271E-2

3.0

MathSBML

1,70574E-2

1,44343E0

8,37187E-2

5,94986E-1

1,17596E-3

6,27576E-1

2,93990E-3

7,39541E-3

9,02664E-3

1,75517E-3

6,73392E-4

4,92155E-1

8,26821E-1

1,98586E-1

6,99911E-1

1,60834E-1

2,71114E-1

1,27271E-2

3.0

Oscill8 Core

1,70574E-2

1,44343E0

8,37187E-2

5,94985E-1

1,17596E-3

6,27576E-1

2,93990E-3

9,02664E-3

1,75517E-3

6,73393E-4

4,92155E-1

8,26821E-1

1,98586E-1

6,99912E-1

1,60835E-1

2,71114E-1

1,27271E-2

3.0

SBToolbox2

1,70579E-2

1,44510E0

8,38164E-2

5,95433E-1

1,17614E-3

6,28308E-1

2,94030E-3

7,39271E-3

9,02929E-3

1,75539E-3

6,73371E-4

4,92160E-1

8,26556E-1

1,98646E-1

7,01002E-1

1,60994E-1

2,71472E-1

1,27347E-2

3.0

copasi

1,70574E-2

1,44343E0

8,37191E-2

5,94987E-1

1,17596E-3

6,27579E-1

2,93990E-3

7,39540E-3

9,02665E-3

1,75518E-3

6,73393E-4

4,92155E-1

8,26820E-1

1,98586E-1

6,99915E-1

1,60835E-1

2,71115E-1

1,27272E-2

3.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,70574E-2

1,44342E0

8,37186E-2

5,94986E-1

1,17596E-3

6,27576E-1

2,93990E-3

7,39541E-3

9,02664E-3

1,75517E-3

6,73392E-4

4,92155E-1

8,26821E-1

1,98586E-1

6,99910E-1

1,60834E-1

2,71114E-1

1,27271E-2

3.0

jsim

1,70574E-2

1,44343E0

8,37187E-2

5,94986E-1

1,17596E-3

6,27577E-1

2,93990E-3

7,39540E-3

9,02667E-3

1,75517E-3

6,73390E-4

4,92155E-1

8,26820E-1

1,98586E-1

6,99910E-1

1,60834E-1

2,71114E-1

1,27272E-2

3.0

min

1,70574E-2

1,44342E0

8,37186E-2

5,94985E-1

1,17596E-3

6,27576E-1

2,93990E-3

7,39271E-3

9,02664E-3

1,75517E-3

6,73371E-4

4,92155E-1

8,26556E-1

1,98586E-1

6,99910E-1

1,60834E-1

2,71114E-1

1,27271E-2

3.0

max

1,70579E-2

1,44510E0

8,38164E-2

5,95433E-1

1,17614E-3

6,28308E-1

2,94030E-3

7,39541E-3

9,02929E-3

1,75539E-3

6,73393E-4

4,92160E-1

8,26821E-1

1,98646E-1

7,01002E-1

1,60994E-1

2,71472E-1

1,27347E-2

3.0

mean

1,70574E-2

1,44343E0

8,37187E-2

5,94986E-1

1,17596E-3

6,27576E-1

2,93990E-3

7,39541E-3

9,02664E-3

1,75517E-3

6,73392E-4

4,92155E-1

8,26821E-1

1,98586E-1

6,99911E-1

1,60834E-1

2,71114E-1

1,27271E-2

3.0

relative error(%)

0,00

3.2

BioUML

1,69934E-2

1,30190E0

7,55102E-2

5,66483E-1

1,16054E-3

5,66043E-1

2,90136E-3

7,54725E-3

8,81863E-3

1,73217E-3

6,71347E-4

4,92003E-1

8,40891E-1

1,94009E-1

6,10527E-1

1,47426E-1

2,42069E-1

1,21473E-2

3.2

ByoDyn

1,69921E-2

1,29968E0

7,53813E-2

5,66026E-1

1,16028E-3

5,65077E-1

2,90071E-3

7,54969E-3

8,81519E-3

1,73178E-3

6,71308E-4

4,92000E-1

8,41106E-1

1,93934E-1

6,09147E-1

1,47217E-1

2,41616E-1

1,21378E-2

3.2

CVODE

1,69921E-2

1,29968E0

7,53813E-2

5,66026E-1

1,16028E-3

5,65077E-1

2,90071E-3

7,54969E-3

8,81519E-3

1,73178E-3

6,71308E-4

4,92000E-1

8,41106E-1

1,93934E-1

6,09147E-1

1,47217E-1

2,41616E-1

1,21378E-2

3.2

Jarnac

1,69921E-2

1,29968E0

7,53813E-2

5,66026E-1

1,16028E-3

5,65077E-1

2,90071E-3

7,54969E-3

8,81519E-3

1,73178E-3

6,71308E-4

4,92000E-1

8,41106E-1

1,93934E-1

6,09147E-1

1,47217E-1

2,41616E-1

1,21378E-2

3.2

MathSBML

1,69921E-2

1,29968E0

7,53813E-2

5,66026E-1

1,16028E-3

5,65077E-1

2,90071E-3

7,54969E-3

8,81519E-3

1,73178E-3

6,71308E-4

4,92000E-1

8,41106E-1

1,93934E-1

6,09147E-1

1,47217E-1

2,41616E-1

1,21378E-2

3.2

Oscill8 Core

1,69921E-2

1,29968E0

7,53813E-2

5,66026E-1

1,16028E-3

5,65077E-1

2,90071E-3

8,81519E-3

1,73178E-3

6,71308E-4

4,92000E-1

8,41106E-1

1,93934E-1

6,09148E-1

1,47218E-1

2,41616E-1

1,21378E-2

3.2

SBToolbox2

1,69983E-2

1,30181E0

7,55063E-2

5,66525E-1

1,16132E-3

5,66013E-1

2,90328E-3

7,55027E-3

8,82239E-3

1,73332E-3

6,71930E-4

4,92003E-1

8,41473E-1

1,94094E-1

6,10536E-1

1,47518E-1

2,41994E-1

1,21573E-2

3.2

copasi

1,69922E-2

1,29969E0

7,53817E-2

5,66028E-1

1,16028E-3

5,65080E-1

2,90072E-3

7,54969E-3

8,81520E-3

1,73178E-3

6,71308E-4

4,92000E-1

8,41105E-1

1,93934E-1

6,09152E-1

1,47218E-1

2,41617E-1

1,21379E-2

3.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,69921E-2

1,29968E0

7,53813E-2

5,66026E-1

1,16028E-3

5,65077E-1

2,90071E-3

7,54969E-3

8,81519E-3

1,73178E-3

6,71308E-4

4,92000E-1

8,41106E-1

1,93934E-1

6,09147E-1

1,47217E-1

2,41616E-1

1,21378E-2

3.2

jsim

1,69922E-2

1,29968E0

7,53813E-2

5,66027E-1

1,16028E-3

5,65077E-1

2,90071E-3

7,54968E-3

8,81522E-3

1,73178E-3

6,71305E-4

4,92000E-1

8,41105E-1

1,93934E-1

6,09146E-1

1,47217E-1

2,41616E-1

1,21379E-2

3.2

min

1,69921E-2

1,29968E0

7,53813E-2

5,66026E-1

1,16028E-3

5,65077E-1

2,90071E-3

7,54968E-3

8,81519E-3

1,73178E-3

6,71305E-4

4,92000E-1

8,41105E-1

1,93934E-1

6,09146E-1

1,47217E-1

2,41616E-1

1,21378E-2

3.2

max

1,69983E-2

1,30181E0

7,55063E-2

5,66525E-1

1,16132E-3

5,66013E-1

2,90328E-3

7,55027E-3

8,82239E-3

1,73332E-3

6,71930E-4

4,92003E-1

8,41473E-1

1,94094E-1

6,10536E-1

1,47518E-1

2,41994E-1

1,21573E-2

3.2

mean

1,69921E-2

1,29968E0

7,53813E-2

5,66026E-1

1,16028E-3

5,65077E-1

2,90071E-3

7,54969E-3

8,81519E-3

1,73178E-3

6,71308E-4

4,92000E-1

8,41106E-1

1,93934E-1

6,09147E-1

1,47217E-1

2,41616E-1

1,21378E-2

3.2

relative error(%)

0,00

3.4

BioUML

1,69160E-2

1,16142E0

6,73623E-2

5,37332E-1

1,14513E-3

5,04964E-1

2,86284E-3

7,71619E-3

8,60268E-3

1,70917E-3

6,70064E-4

4,91834E-1

8,56094E-1

1,89258E-1

5,25275E-1

1,34553E-1

2,13495E-1

1,15597E-2

3.4

ByoDyn

1,69147E-2

1,15936E0

6,72428E-2

5,36947E-1

1,14491E-3

5,04069E-1

2,86228E-3

7,71844E-3

8,59960E-3

1,70883E-3

6,70044E-4

4,91832E-1

8,56281E-1

1,89191E-1

5,24071E-1

1,34370E-1

2,13082E-1

1,15514E-2

3.4

CVODE

1,69147E-2

1,15936E0

6,72428E-2

5,36947E-1

1,14491E-3

5,04069E-1

2,86228E-3

7,71844E-3

8,59960E-3

1,70883E-3

6,70044E-4

4,91832E-1

8,56281E-1

1,89191E-1

5,24071E-1

1,34370E-1

2,13082E-1

1,15514E-2

3.4

Jarnac

1,69147E-2

1,15936E0

6,72428E-2

5,36947E-1

1,14491E-3

5,04069E-1

2,86228E-3

7,71844E-3

8,59960E-3

1,70883E-3

6,70044E-4

4,91832E-1

8,56281E-1

1,89191E-1

5,24071E-1

1,34370E-1

2,13082E-1

1,15514E-2

3.4

MathSBML

1,69147E-2

1,15936E0

6,72428E-2

5,36947E-1

1,14491E-3

5,04069E-1

2,86228E-3

7,71844E-3

8,59960E-3

1,70883E-3

6,70044E-4

4,91832E-1

8,56281E-1

1,89191E-1

5,24071E-1

1,34370E-1

2,13082E-1

1,15514E-2

3.4

Oscill8 Core

1,69147E-2

1,15936E0

6,72429E-2

5,36947E-1

1,14491E-3

5,04070E-1

2,86228E-3

8,59960E-3

1,70883E-3

6,70044E-4

4,91832E-1

8,56281E-1

1,89191E-1

5,24073E-1

1,34371E-1

2,13082E-1

1,15514E-2

3.4

SBToolbox2

1,69154E-2

1,16005E0

6,72830E-2

5,38139E-1

1,14434E-3

5,04370E-1

2,86091E-3

7,70804E-3

8,60281E-3

1,70804E-3

6,69160E-4

4,91843E-1

8,55139E-1

1,89262E-1

5,25014E-1

1,34441E-1

2,13389E-1

1,15602E-2

3.4

copasi

1,69147E-2

1,15937E0

6,72433E-2

5,36948E-1

1,14491E-3

5,04073E-1

2,86228E-3

7,71843E-3

8,59961E-3

1,70884E-3

6,70044E-4

4,91832E-1

8,56280E-1

1,89191E-1

5,24076E-1

1,34371E-1

2,13084E-1

1,15514E-2

3.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,69147E-2

1,15936E0

6,72428E-2

5,36947E-1

1,14491E-3

5,04069E-1

2,86228E-3

7,71844E-3

8,59960E-3

1,70883E-3

6,70044E-4

4,91832E-1

8,56281E-1

1,89191E-1

5,24071E-1

1,34370E-1

2,13082E-1

1,15514E-2

3.4

jsim

1,69147E-2

1,15936E0

6,72429E-2

5,36947E-1

1,14491E-3

5,04069E-1

2,86228E-3

7,71842E-3

8,59963E-3

1,70883E-3

6,70041E-4

4,91832E-1

8,56280E-1

1,89191E-1

5,24070E-1

1,34370E-1

2,13082E-1

1,15514E-2

3.4

min

1,69147E-2

1,15936E0

6,72428E-2

5,36947E-1

1,14434E-3

5,04069E-1

2,86091E-3

7,70804E-3

8,59960E-3

1,70804E-3

6,69160E-4

4,91832E-1

8,55139E-1

1,89191E-1

5,24070E-1

1,34370E-1

2,13082E-1

1,15514E-2

3.4

max

1,69154E-2

1,16005E0

6,72830E-2

5,38139E-1

1,14491E-3

5,04370E-1

2,86228E-3

7,71844E-3

8,60281E-3

1,70884E-3

6,70044E-4

4,91843E-1

8,56281E-1

1,89262E-1

5,25014E-1

1,34441E-1

2,13389E-1

1,15602E-2

3.4

mean

1,69147E-2

1,15936E0

6,72428E-2

5,36947E-1

1,14491E-3

5,04069E-1

2,86228E-3

7,71844E-3

8,59960E-3

1,70883E-3

6,70044E-4

4,91832E-1

8,56281E-1

1,89191E-1

5,24071E-1

1,34370E-1

2,13082E-1

1,15514E-2

3.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0,12

0,00

0,12

0,00

3.6

BioUML

1,68235E-2

1,02525E0

5,94642E-2

5,08818E-1

1,12979E-3

4,45759E-1

2,82448E-3

7,89449E-3

8,38314E-3

1,68627E-3

6,69330E-4

4,91656E-1

8,71401E-1

1,84429E-1

4,46303E-1

1,22521E-1

1,86148E-1

1,09772E-2

3.6

ByoDyn

1,68221E-2

1,02323E0

5,93472E-2

5,08360E-1

1,12953E-3

4,44882E-1

2,82383E-3

7,89749E-3

8,37968E-3

1,68588E-3

6,69301E-4

4,91653E-1

8,71664E-1

1,84352E-1

4,45159E-1

1,22344E-1

1,85748E-1

1,09681E-2

3.6

CVODE

1,68221E-2

1,02323E0

5,93472E-2

5,08360E-1

1,12953E-3

4,44882E-1

2,82383E-3

7,89749E-3

8,37968E-3

1,68588E-3

6,69301E-4

4,91653E-1

8,71664E-1

1,84352E-1

4,45159E-1

1,22344E-1

1,85748E-1

1,09681E-2

3.6

Jarnac

1,68221E-2

1,02323E0

5,93472E-2

5,08360E-1

1,12953E-3

4,44882E-1

2,82383E-3

7,89749E-3

8,37968E-3

1,68588E-3

6,69301E-4

4,91653E-1

8,71664E-1

1,84352E-1

4,45159E-1

1,22344E-1

1,85748E-1

1,09681E-2

3.6

MathSBML

1,68221E-2

1,02323E0

5,93473E-2

5,08360E-1

1,12953E-3

4,44882E-1

2,82383E-3

7,89749E-3

8,37968E-3

1,68588E-3

6,69301E-4

4,91653E-1

8,71664E-1

1,84352E-1

4,45160E-1

1,22344E-1

1,85748E-1

1,09681E-2

3.6

Oscill8 Core

1,68221E-2

1,02323E0

5,93473E-2

5,08361E-1

1,12953E-3

4,44882E-1

2,82383E-3

8,37968E-3

1,68588E-3

6,69301E-4

4,91653E-1

8,71663E-1

1,84352E-1

4,45161E-1

1,22344E-1

1,85748E-1

1,09681E-2

3.6

SBToolbox2

1,68228E-2

1,02466E0

5,94299E-2

5,08404E-1

1,12969E-3

4,45502E-1

2,82428E-3

7,89805E-3

8,38168E-3

1,68613E-3

6,69345E-4

4,91654E-1

8,71791E-1

1,84394E-1

4,45864E-1

1,22453E-1

1,86011E-1

1,09732E-2

3.6

copasi

1,68221E-2

1,02324E0

5,93477E-2

5,08361E-1

1,12953E-3

4,44886E-1

2,82384E-3

7,89749E-3

8,37969E-3

1,68588E-3

6,69302E-4

4,91653E-1

8,71664E-1

1,84353E-1

4,45165E-1

1,22345E-1

1,85749E-1

1,09682E-2

3.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,68221E-2

1,02323E0

5,93472E-2

5,08360E-1

1,12953E-3

4,44882E-1

2,82383E-3

7,89749E-3

8,37968E-3

1,68588E-3

6,69301E-4

4,91653E-1

8,71664E-1

1,84352E-1

4,45159E-1

1,22344E-1

1,85748E-1

1,09681E-2

3.6

jsim

1,68221E-2

1,02323E0

5,93472E-2

5,08360E-1

1,12953E-3

4,44882E-1

2,82383E-3

7,89748E-3

8,37968E-3

1,68588E-3

6,69301E-4

4,91653E-1

8,71663E-1

1,84353E-1

4,45158E-1

1,22344E-1

1,85748E-1

1,09681E-2

3.6

min

1,68221E-2

1,02323E0

5,93472E-2

5,08360E-1

1,12953E-3

4,44882E-1

2,82383E-3

7,89748E-3

8,37968E-3

1,68588E-3

6,69301E-4

4,91653E-1

8,71663E-1

1,84352E-1

4,45158E-1

1,22344E-1

1,85748E-1

1,09681E-2

3.6

max

1,68228E-2

1,02466E0

5,94299E-2

5,08404E-1

1,12969E-3

4,45502E-1

2,82428E-3

7,89805E-3

8,38168E-3

1,68613E-3

6,69345E-4

4,91654E-1

8,71791E-1

1,84394E-1

4,45864E-1

1,22453E-1

1,86011E-1

1,09732E-2

3.6

mean

1,68221E-2

1,02323E0

5,93472E-2

5,08360E-1

1,12953E-3

4,44882E-1

2,82383E-3

7,89749E-3

8,37968E-3

1,68588E-3

6,69301E-4

4,91653E-1

8,71664E-1

1,84352E-1

4,45159E-1

1,22344E-1

1,85748E-1

1,09681E-2

3.6

relative error(%)

0,00

3.8

BioUML

1,67127E-2

8,94410E-1

5,18758E-2

4,81841E-1

1,11380E-3

3,88874E-1

2,78451E-3

8,07153E-3

8,15890E-3

1,66241E-3

6,68423E-4

4,91478E-1

8,85396E-1

1,79495E-1

3,74092E-1

1,11365E-1

1,60318E-1

1,03978E-2

3.8

ByoDyn

1,67111E-2

8,92587E-1

5,17700E-2

4,81517E-1

1,11357E-3

3,88081E-1

2,78393E-3

8,07360E-3

8,15572E-3

1,66206E-3

6,68405E-4

4,91476E-1

8,85542E-1

1,79425E-1

3,73116E-1

1,11214E-1

1,59962E-1

1,03897E-2

3.8

CVODE

1,67111E-2

8,92587E-1

5,17700E-2

4,81517E-1

1,11357E-3

3,88081E-1

2,78393E-3

8,07360E-3

8,15572E-3

1,66206E-3

6,68405E-4

4,91476E-1

8,85542E-1

1,79425E-1

3,73116E-1

1,11214E-1

1,59962E-1

1,03897E-2

3.8

Jarnac

1,67111E-2

8,92587E-1

5,17700E-2

4,81517E-1

1,11357E-3

3,88081E-1

2,78393E-3

8,07360E-3

8,15572E-3

1,66206E-3

6,68405E-4

4,91476E-1

8,85542E-1

1,79425E-1

3,73116E-1

1,11214E-1

1,59962E-1

1,03897E-2

3.8

MathSBML

1,67111E-2

8,92587E-1

5,17700E-2

4,81517E-1

1,11357E-3

3,88081E-1

2,78393E-3

8,07360E-3

8,15572E-3

1,66206E-3

6,68405E-4

4,91476E-1

8,85542E-1

1,79425E-1

3,73116E-1

1,11214E-1

1,59962E-1

1,03897E-2

3.8

Oscill8 Core

1,67111E-2

8,92589E-1

5,17702E-2

4,81518E-1

1,11357E-3

3,88082E-1

2,78393E-3

8,15572E-3

1,66206E-3

6,68405E-4

4,91476E-1

8,85541E-1

1,79425E-1

3,73118E-1

1,11214E-1

1,59962E-1

1,03897E-2

3.8

SBToolbox2

1,67151E-2

8,94247E-1

5,18662E-2

4,82309E-1

1,11378E-3

3,88806E-1

2,78445E-3

8,06729E-3

8,15987E-3

1,66237E-3

6,68302E-4

4,91480E-1

8,85057E-1

1,79520E-1

3,74099E-1

1,11364E-1

1,60311E-1

1,04001E-2

3.8

copasi

1,67112E-2

8,92596E-1

5,17706E-2

4,81519E-1

1,11357E-3

3,88085E-1

2,78394E-3

8,07359E-3

8,15574E-3

1,66206E-3

6,68405E-4

4,91476E-1

8,85541E-1

1,79426E-1

3,73120E-1

1,11214E-1

1,59964E-1

1,03897E-2

3.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,67111E-2

8,92587E-1

5,17700E-2

4,81517E-1

1,11357E-3

3,88081E-1

2,78393E-3

8,07360E-3

8,15572E-3

1,66206E-3

6,68405E-4

4,91476E-1

8,85542E-1

1,79425E-1

3,73116E-1

1,11214E-1

1,59962E-1

1,03897E-2

3.8

jsim

1,67112E-2

8,92586E-1

5,17700E-2

4,81517E-1

1,11357E-3

3,88081E-1

2,78394E-3

8,07360E-3

8,15572E-3

1,66206E-3

6,68406E-4

4,91476E-1

8,85543E-1

1,79425E-1

3,73114E-1

1,11214E-1

1,59962E-1

1,03897E-2

3.8

min

1,67111E-2

8,92586E-1

5,17700E-2

4,81517E-1

1,11357E-3

3,88081E-1

2,78393E-3

8,06729E-3

8,15572E-3

1,66206E-3

6,68302E-4

4,91476E-1

8,85057E-1

1,79425E-1

3,73114E-1

1,11214E-1

1,59962E-1

1,03897E-2

3.8

max

1,67151E-2

8,94247E-1

5,18662E-2

4,82309E-1

1,11378E-3

3,88806E-1

2,78445E-3

8,07360E-3

8,15987E-3

1,66237E-3

6,68406E-4

4,91480E-1

8,85543E-1

1,79520E-1

3,74099E-1

1,11364E-1

1,60311E-1

1,04001E-2

3.8

mean

1,67111E-2

8,92587E-1

5,17700E-2

4,81517E-1

1,11357E-3

3,88081E-1

2,78393E-3

8,07360E-3

8,15572E-3

1,66206E-3

6,68405E-4

4,91476E-1

8,85542E-1

1,79425E-1

3,73116E-1

1,11214E-1

1,59962E-1

1,03897E-2

3.8

relative error(%)

0,00

4.0

BioUML

1,65822E-2

7,71380E-1

4,47401E-2

4,59114E-1

1,09629E-3

3,35383E-1

2,74073E-3

8,21306E-3

7,93258E-3

1,63627E-3

6,66067E-4

4,91337E-1

8,94140E-1

1,74516E-1

3,09855E-1

1,01233E-1

1,36577E-1

9,82893E-3

4.0

ByoDyn

1,65801E-2

7,69696E-1

4,46423E-2

4,58835E-1

1,09601E-3

3,34650E-1

2,74004E-3

8,21454E-3

7,92932E-3

1,63585E-3

6,66005E-4

4,91335E-1

8,94194E-1

1,74444E-1

3,09002E-1

1,01095E-1

1,36257E-1

9,82085E-3

4.0

CVODE

1,65801E-2

7,69696E-1

4,46424E-2

4,58835E-1

1,09601E-3

3,34650E-1

2,74004E-3

8,21454E-3

7,92932E-3

1,63585E-3

6,66005E-4

4,91335E-1

8,94194E-1

1,74445E-1

3,09002E-1

1,01095E-1

1,36258E-1

9,82085E-3

4.0

Jarnac

1,65801E-2

7,69696E-1

4,46423E-2

4,58835E-1

1,09601E-3

3,34650E-1

2,74004E-3

8,21454E-3

7,92932E-3

1,63585E-3

6,66005E-4

4,91335E-1

8,94194E-1

1,74444E-1

3,09002E-1

1,01095E-1

1,36257E-1

9,82085E-3

4.0

MathSBML

1,65801E-2

7,69696E-1

4,46424E-2

4,58835E-1

1,09601E-3

3,34650E-1

2,74004E-3

8,21454E-3

7,92932E-3

1,63585E-3

6,66005E-4

4,91335E-1

8,94194E-1

1,74445E-1

3,09002E-1

1,01095E-1

1,36258E-1

9,82085E-3

4.0

Oscill8 Core

1,65801E-2

7,69699E-1

4,46425E-2

4,58838E-1

1,09601E-3

3,34652E-1

2,74004E-3

7,92932E-3

1,63585E-3

6,66004E-4

4,91335E-1

8,94190E-1

1,74445E-1

3,09005E-1

1,01096E-1

1,36258E-1

9,82086E-3

4.0

SBToolbox2

1,65818E-2

7,71362E-1

4,47390E-2

4,58464E-1

1,09636E-3

3,35378E-1

2,74092E-3

8,21980E-3

7,93196E-3

1,63636E-3

6,66220E-4

4,91330E-1

8,94874E-1

1,74506E-1

3,09764E-1

1,01212E-1

1,36556E-1

9,82746E-3

4.0

copasi

1,65801E-2

7,69704E-1

4,46429E-2

4,58837E-1

1,09601E-3

3,34654E-1

2,74004E-3

8,21454E-3

7,92933E-3

1,63586E-3

6,66005E-4

4,91335E-1

8,94194E-1

1,74445E-1

3,09006E-1

1,01096E-1

1,36259E-1

9,82089E-3

4.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,65801E-2

7,69696E-1

4,46423E-2

4,58835E-1

1,09601E-3

3,34650E-1

2,74004E-3

8,21454E-3

7,92932E-3

1,63585E-3

6,66005E-4

4,91335E-1

8,94194E-1

1,74444E-1

3,09002E-1

1,01095E-1

1,36257E-1

9,82085E-3

4.0

jsim

1,65801E-2

7,69695E-1

4,46423E-2

4,58835E-1

1,09601E-3

3,34650E-1

2,74004E-3

8,21456E-3

7,92932E-3

1,63586E-3

6,66006E-4

4,91335E-1

8,94195E-1

1,74444E-1

3,09000E-1

1,01095E-1

1,36257E-1

9,82085E-3

4.0

min

1,65801E-2

7,69695E-1

4,46423E-2

4,58464E-1

1,09601E-3

3,34650E-1

2,74004E-3

8,21454E-3

7,92932E-3

1,63585E-3

6,66004E-4

4,91330E-1

8,94190E-1

1,74444E-1

3,09000E-1

1,01095E-1

1,36257E-1

9,82085E-3

4.0

max

1,65818E-2

7,71362E-1

4,47390E-2

4,58838E-1

1,09636E-3

3,35378E-1

2,74092E-3

8,21980E-3

7,93196E-3

1,63636E-3

6,66220E-4

4,91335E-1

8,94874E-1

1,74506E-1

3,09764E-1

1,01212E-1

1,36556E-1

9,82746E-3

4.0

mean

1,65801E-2

7,69696E-1

4,46424E-2

4,58835E-1

1,09601E-3

3,34650E-1

2,74004E-3

8,21454E-3

7,92932E-3

1,63585E-3

6,66005E-4

4,91335E-1

8,94194E-1

1,74445E-1

3,09002E-1

1,01095E-1

1,36258E-1

9,82085E-3

4.0

relative error(%)

0,00

4.2

BioUML

1,64330E-2

6,59674E-1

3,82611E-2

4,44455E-1

1,07573E-3

2,86815E-1

2,68933E-3

8,26058E-3

7,70773E-3

1,60558E-3

6,60052E-4

4,91289E-1

8,91310E-1

1,69570E-1

2,54956E-1

9,22746E-2

1,15658E-1

9,27964E-3

4.2

ByoDyn

1,64307E-2

6,58171E-1

3,81739E-2

4,44336E-1

1,07539E-3

2,86161E-1

2,68848E-3

8,26007E-3

7,70447E-3

1,60508E-3

6,59918E-4

4,91290E-1

8,91131E-1

1,69498E-1

2,54240E-1

9,21541E-2

1,15382E-1

9,27178E-3

4.2

CVODE

1,64308E-2

6,58171E-1

3,81739E-2

4,44336E-1

1,07539E-3

2,86161E-1

2,68848E-3

8,26007E-3

7,70447E-3

1,60508E-3

6,59918E-4

4,91290E-1

8,91131E-1

1,69498E-1

2,54240E-1

9,21541E-2

1,15382E-1

9,27179E-3

4.2

Jarnac

1,64307E-2

6,58171E-1

3,81739E-2

4,44336E-1

1,07539E-3

2,86161E-1

2,68848E-3

8,26007E-3

7,70447E-3

1,60508E-3

6,59918E-4

4,91290E-1

8,91131E-1

1,69498E-1

2,54240E-1

9,21541E-2

1,15382E-1

9,27178E-3

4.2

MathSBML

1,64308E-2

6,58171E-1

3,81739E-2

4,44336E-1

1,07539E-3

2,86162E-1

2,68848E-3

8,26007E-3

7,70447E-3

1,60508E-3

6,59918E-4

4,91290E-1

8,91131E-1

1,69498E-1

2,54240E-1

9,21541E-2

1,15382E-1

9,27179E-3

4.2

Oscill8 Core

1,64307E-2

6,58176E-1

3,81742E-2

4,44340E-1

1,07539E-3

2,86163E-1

2,68848E-3

7,70447E-3

1,60507E-3

6,59917E-4

4,91290E-1

8,91125E-1

1,69498E-1

2,54243E-1

9,21545E-2

1,15383E-1

9,27179E-3

4.2

SBToolbox2

1,64348E-2

6,59315E-1

3,82403E-2

4,44762E-1

1,07579E-3

2,86661E-1

2,68943E-3

8,25781E-3

7,70784E-3

1,60564E-3

6,60089E-4

4,91290E-1

8,91116E-1

1,69572E-1

2,54805E-1

9,22632E-2

1,15593E-1

9,27981E-3

4.2

copasi

1,64308E-2

6,58179E-1

3,81744E-2

4,44337E-1

1,07539E-3

2,86165E-1

2,68849E-3

8,26007E-3

7,70449E-3

1,60508E-3

6,59919E-4

4,91290E-1

8,91132E-1

1,69498E-1

2,54244E-1

9,21547E-2

1,15383E-1

9,27183E-3

4.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,64307E-2

6,58171E-1

3,81739E-2

4,44336E-1

1,07539E-3

2,86161E-1

2,68848E-3

8,26007E-3

7,70447E-3

1,60508E-3

6,59918E-4

4,91290E-1

8,91131E-1

1,69498E-1

2,54240E-1

9,21541E-2

1,15382E-1

9,27178E-3

4.2

jsim

1,64308E-2

6,58170E-1

3,81738E-2

4,44335E-1

1,07539E-3

2,86161E-1

2,68849E-3

8,26009E-3

7,70447E-3

1,60508E-3

6,59920E-4

4,91290E-1

8,91134E-1

1,69498E-1

2,54238E-1

9,21539E-2

1,15381E-1

9,27177E-3

4.2

min

1,64307E-2

6,58170E-1

3,81738E-2

4,44335E-1

1,07539E-3

2,86161E-1

2,68848E-3

8,25781E-3

7,70447E-3

1,60507E-3

6,59917E-4

4,91290E-1

8,91116E-1

1,69498E-1

2,54238E-1

9,21539E-2

1,15381E-1

9,27177E-3

4.2

max

1,64348E-2

6,59315E-1

3,82403E-2

4,44762E-1

1,07579E-3

2,86661E-1

2,68943E-3

8,26009E-3

7,70784E-3

1,60564E-3

6,60089E-4

4,91290E-1

8,91134E-1

1,69572E-1

2,54805E-1

9,22632E-2

1,15593E-1

9,27981E-3

4.2

mean

1,64308E-2

6,58171E-1

3,81739E-2

4,44336E-1

1,07539E-3

2,86161E-1

2,68848E-3

8,26007E-3

7,70447E-3

1,60508E-3

6,59918E-4

4,91290E-1

8,91131E-1

1,69498E-1

2,54240E-1

9,21541E-2

1,15382E-1

9,27179E-3

4.2

relative error(%)

0,00

4.4

BioUML

1,62704E-2

5,63549E-1

3,26859E-2

4,42312E-1

1,05102E-3

2,45022E-1

2,62757E-3

8,14799E-3

7,49055E-3

1,56871E-3

6,48390E-4

4,91402E-1

8,70262E-1

1,64792E-1

2,10539E-1

8,46451E-2

9,82774E-2

8,76406E-3

4.4

ByoDyn

1,62680E-2

5,62301E-1

3,26135E-2

4,42377E-1

1,05065E-3

2,44479E-1

2,62662E-3

8,14520E-3

7,48756E-3

1,56814E-3

6,48183E-4

4,91405E-1

8,69832E-1

1,64726E-1

2,09980E-1

8,45459E-2

9,80558E-2

8,75706E-3

4.4

CVODE

1,62680E-2

5,62301E-1

3,26135E-2

4,42377E-1

1,05065E-3

2,44479E-1

2,62662E-3

8,14520E-3

7,48756E-3

1,56814E-3

6,48183E-4

4,91405E-1

8,69832E-1

1,64726E-1

2,09980E-1

8,45459E-2

9,80558E-2

8,75706E-3

4.4

Jarnac

1,62680E-2

5,62301E-1

3,26135E-2

4,42377E-1

1,05065E-3

2,44479E-1

2,62662E-3

8,14520E-3

7,48756E-3

1,56814E-3

6,48183E-4

4,91405E-1

8,69832E-1

1,64726E-1

2,09980E-1

8,45459E-2

9,80558E-2

8,75706E-3

4.4

MathSBML

1,62680E-2

5,62301E-1

3,26135E-2

4,42377E-1

1,05065E-3

2,44479E-1

2,62662E-3

8,14520E-3

7,48756E-3

1,56814E-3

6,48183E-4

4,91405E-1

8,69832E-1

1,64726E-1

2,09980E-1

8,45459E-2

9,80558E-2

8,75706E-3

4.4

Oscill8 Core

1,62680E-2

5,62307E-1

3,26138E-2

4,42382E-1

1,05065E-3

2,44481E-1

2,62662E-3

7,48757E-3

1,56814E-3

6,48182E-4

4,91405E-1

8,69827E-1

1,64726E-1

2,09983E-1

8,45463E-2

9,80569E-2

8,75708E-3

4.4

SBToolbox2

1,62734E-2

5,63322E-1

3,26726E-2

4,43074E-1

1,05102E-3

2,44923E-1

2,62750E-3

8,13943E-3

7,49232E-3

1,56868E-3

6,48212E-4

4,91410E-1

8,69513E-1

1,64830E-1

2,10547E-1

8,46566E-2

9,82628E-2

8,76815E-3

4.4

copasi

1,62680E-2

5,62306E-1

3,26138E-2

4,42376E-1

1,05065E-3

2,44481E-1

2,62663E-3

8,14522E-3

7,48758E-3

1,56815E-3

6,48184E-4

4,91405E-1

8,69835E-1

1,64726E-1

2,09983E-1

8,45464E-2

9,80567E-2

8,75710E-3

4.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,62680E-2

5,62301E-1

3,26135E-2

4,42377E-1

1,05065E-3

2,44479E-1

2,62662E-3

8,14520E-3

7,48756E-3

1,56814E-3

6,48183E-4

4,91405E-1

8,69832E-1

1,64726E-1

2,09980E-1

8,45459E-2

9,80558E-2

8,75706E-3

4.4

jsim

1,62680E-2

5,62299E-1

3,26133E-2

4,42375E-1

1,05065E-3

2,44478E-1

2,62663E-3

8,14523E-3

7,48756E-3

1,56815E-3

6,48185E-4

4,91405E-1

8,69836E-1

1,64726E-1

2,09978E-1

8,45457E-2

9,80552E-2

8,75705E-3

4.4

min

1,62680E-2

5,62299E-1

3,26133E-2

4,42375E-1

1,05065E-3

2,44478E-1

2,62662E-3

8,13943E-3

7,48756E-3

1,56814E-3

6,48182E-4

4,91405E-1

8,69513E-1

1,64726E-1

2,09978E-1

8,45457E-2

9,80552E-2

8,75705E-3

4.4

max

1,62734E-2

5,63322E-1

3,26726E-2

4,43074E-1

1,05102E-3

2,44923E-1

2,62750E-3

8,14523E-3

7,49232E-3

1,56868E-3

6,48212E-4

4,91410E-1

8,69836E-1

1,64830E-1

2,10547E-1

8,46566E-2

9,82628E-2

8,76815E-3

4.4

mean

1,62680E-2

5,62301E-1

3,26135E-2

4,42377E-1

1,05065E-3

2,44479E-1

2,62662E-3

8,14520E-3

7,48756E-3

1,56814E-3

6,48183E-4

4,91405E-1

8,69832E-1

1,64726E-1

2,09980E-1

8,45459E-2

9,80558E-2

8,75706E-3

4.4

relative error(%)

0,00

4.6

BioUML

1,60977E-2

4,85178E-1

2,81403E-2

4,53334E-1

1,02318E-3

2,10947E-1

2,55796E-3

7,87795E-3

7,28740E-3

1,52715E-3

6,31664E-4

4,91672E-1

8,32033E-1

1,60322E-1

1,76229E-1

7,83513E-2

8,45553E-2

8,29511E-3

4.6

ByoDyn

1,60953E-2

4,84194E-1

2,80832E-2

4,53581E-1

1,02278E-3

2,10519E-1

2,55696E-3

7,87326E-3

7,28475E-3

1,52656E-3

6,31402E-4

4,91677E-1

8,31403E-1

1,60264E-1

1,75812E-1

7,82723E-2

8,43860E-2

8,28908E-3

4.6

CVODE

1,60953E-2

4,84194E-1

2,80832E-2

4,53580E-1

1,02278E-3

2,10519E-1

2,55696E-3

7,87326E-3

7,28475E-3

1,52656E-3

6,31402E-4

4,91677E-1

8,31403E-1

1,60264E-1

1,75812E-1

7,82723E-2

8,43860E-2

8,28908E-3

4.6

Jarnac

1,60953E-2

4,84194E-1

2,80832E-2

4,53581E-1

1,02278E-3

2,10519E-1

2,55696E-3

7,87326E-3

7,28475E-3

1,52656E-3

6,31402E-4

4,91677E-1

8,31403E-1

1,60264E-1

1,75812E-1

7,82723E-2

8,43860E-2

8,28908E-3

4.6

MathSBML

1,60953E-2

4,84194E-1

2,80833E-2

4,53580E-1

1,02278E-3

2,10519E-1

2,55697E-3

7,87327E-3

7,28475E-3

1,52656E-3

6,31402E-4

4,91677E-1

8,31404E-1

1,60264E-1

1,75813E-1

7,82723E-2

8,43860E-2

8,28908E-3

4.6

Oscill8 Core

1,60953E-2

4,84199E-1

2,80835E-2

4,53583E-1

1,02278E-3

2,10521E-1

2,55696E-3

7,28476E-3

1,52656E-3

6,31402E-4

4,91677E-1

8,31401E-1

1,60264E-1

1,75815E-1

7,82727E-2

8,43869E-2

8,28910E-3

4.6

SBToolbox2

1,60996E-2

4,84869E-1

2,81221E-2

4,53547E-1

1,02319E-3

2,10811E-1

2,55796E-3

7,87750E-3

7,28888E-3

1,52717E-3

6,31535E-4

4,91671E-1

8,32059E-1

1,60356E-1

1,76180E-1

7,83451E-2

8,45182E-2

8,29839E-3

4.6

copasi

1,60953E-2

4,84199E-1

2,80835E-2

4,53580E-1

1,02278E-3

2,10521E-1

2,55697E-3

7,87328E-3

7,28476E-3

1,52656E-3

6,31404E-4

4,91677E-1

8,31406E-1

1,60264E-1

1,75814E-1

7,82727E-2

8,43868E-2

8,28911E-3

4.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,60953E-2

4,84194E-1

2,80832E-2

4,53581E-1

1,02278E-3

2,10519E-1

2,55696E-3

7,87326E-3

7,28475E-3

1,52656E-3

6,31402E-4

4,91677E-1

8,31403E-1

1,60264E-1

1,75812E-1

7,82723E-2

8,43860E-2

8,28908E-3

4.6

jsim

1,60953E-2

4,84192E-1

2,80831E-2

4,53578E-1

1,02278E-3

2,10518E-1

2,55697E-3

7,87329E-3

7,28476E-3

1,52656E-3

6,31404E-4

4,91677E-1

8,31407E-1

1,60264E-1

1,75811E-1

7,82721E-2

8,43856E-2

8,28910E-3

4.6

min

1,60953E-2

4,84192E-1

2,80831E-2

4,53547E-1

1,02278E-3

2,10518E-1

2,55696E-3

7,87326E-3

7,28475E-3

1,52656E-3

6,31402E-4

4,91671E-1

8,31401E-1

1,60264E-1

1,75811E-1

7,82721E-2

8,43856E-2

8,28908E-3

4.6

max

1,60996E-2

4,84869E-1

2,81221E-2

4,53583E-1

1,02319E-3

2,10811E-1

2,55796E-3

7,87750E-3

7,28888E-3

1,52717E-3

6,31535E-4

4,91677E-1

8,32059E-1

1,60356E-1

1,76180E-1

7,83451E-2

8,45182E-2

8,29839E-3

4.6

mean

1,60953E-2

4,84194E-1

2,80832E-2

4,53580E-1

1,02278E-3

2,10519E-1

2,55696E-3

7,87327E-3

7,28475E-3

1,52656E-3

6,31402E-4

4,91677E-1

8,31403E-1

1,60264E-1

1,75812E-1

7,82723E-2

8,43860E-2

8,28908E-3

4.6

relative error(%)

0,00

4.8

BioUML

1,59164E-2

4,22840E-1

2,45247E-2

4,73388E-1

9,94780E-4

1,83843E-1

2,48696E-3

7,52873E-3

7,10228E-3

1,48476E-3

6,12691E-4

4,92021E-1

7,85637E-1

1,56250E-1

1,50047E-1

7,32087E-2

7,38697E-2

7,87902E-3

4.8

ByoDyn

1,59138E-2

4,22075E-1

2,44804E-2

4,73738E-1

9,94381E-4

1,83511E-1

2,48596E-3

7,52334E-3

7,09980E-3

1,48417E-3

6,12413E-4

4,92027E-1

7,84935E-1

1,56195E-1

1,49732E-1

7,31437E-2

7,37400E-2

7,87353E-3

4.8

CVODE

1,59138E-2

4,22075E-1

2,44804E-2

4,73738E-1

9,94381E-4

1,83511E-1

2,48596E-3

7,52334E-3

7,09980E-3

1,48417E-3

6,12413E-4

4,92027E-1

7,84935E-1

1,56195E-1

1,49732E-1

7,31437E-2

7,37400E-2

7,87353E-3

4.8

Jarnac

1,59138E-2

4,22075E-1

2,44804E-2

4,73738E-1

9,94381E-4

1,83511E-1

2,48596E-3

7,52334E-3

7,09980E-3

1,48417E-3

6,12413E-4

4,92027E-1

7,84935E-1

1,56195E-1

1,49732E-1

7,31437E-2

7,37400E-2

7,87353E-3

4.8

MathSBML

1,59138E-2

4,22075E-1

2,44804E-2

4,73738E-1

9,94381E-4

1,83511E-1

2,48596E-3

7,52334E-3

7,09980E-3

1,48417E-3

6,12413E-4

4,92027E-1

7,84936E-1

1,56195E-1

1,49732E-1

7,31437E-2

7,37400E-2

7,87354E-3

4.8

Oscill8 Core

1,59138E-2

4,22079E-1

2,44806E-2

4,73739E-1

9,94381E-4

1,83513E-1

2,48596E-3

7,09981E-3

1,48417E-3

6,12413E-4

4,92027E-1

7,84935E-1

1,56195E-1

1,49733E-1

7,31440E-2

7,37407E-2

7,87355E-3

4.8

SBToolbox2

1,59073E-2

4,22489E-1

2,45042E-2

4,72882E-1

9,94216E-4

1,83686E-1

2,48553E-3

7,52974E-3

7,09802E-3

1,48391E-3

6,12360E-4

4,92020E-1

7,85283E-1

1,56156E-1

1,49807E-1

7,31348E-2

7,38070E-2

7,86935E-3

4.8

copasi

1,59138E-2

4,22079E-1

2,44806E-2

4,73737E-1

9,94383E-4

1,83513E-1

2,48596E-3

7,52337E-3

7,09981E-3

1,48417E-3

6,12415E-4

4,92027E-1

7,84939E-1

1,56195E-1

1,49733E-1

7,31440E-2

7,37406E-2

7,87356E-3

4.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,59138E-2

4,22075E-1

2,44804E-2

4,73738E-1

9,94381E-4

1,83511E-1

2,48596E-3

7,52334E-3

7,09980E-3

1,48417E-3

6,12413E-4

4,92027E-1

7,84935E-1

1,56195E-1

1,49732E-1

7,31437E-2

7,37400E-2

7,87353E-3

4.8

jsim

1,59138E-2

4,22073E-1

2,44803E-2

4,73736E-1

9,94383E-4

1,83510E-1

2,48596E-3

7,52335E-3

7,09981E-3

1,48417E-3

6,12414E-4

4,92027E-1

7,84937E-1

1,56195E-1

1,49730E-1

7,31436E-2

7,37397E-2

7,87355E-3

4.8

min

1,59073E-2

4,22073E-1

2,44803E-2

4,72882E-1

9,94216E-4

1,83510E-1

2,48553E-3

7,52334E-3

7,09802E-3

1,48391E-3

6,12360E-4

4,92020E-1

7,84935E-1

1,56156E-1

1,49730E-1

7,31348E-2

7,37397E-2

7,86935E-3

4.8

max

1,59138E-2

4,22489E-1

2,45042E-2

4,73739E-1

9,94383E-4

1,83686E-1

2,48596E-3

7,52974E-3

7,09981E-3

1,48417E-3

6,12415E-4

4,92027E-1

7,85283E-1

1,56195E-1

1,49807E-1

7,31440E-2

7,38070E-2

7,87356E-3

4.8

mean

1,59138E-2

4,22075E-1

2,44804E-2

4,73738E-1

9,94381E-4

1,83511E-1

2,48596E-3

7,52334E-3

7,09980E-3

1,48417E-3

6,12413E-4

4,92027E-1

7,84935E-1

1,56195E-1

1,49732E-1

7,31437E-2

7,37400E-2

7,87353E-3

4.8

relative error(%)

0,00

0,16

0,00

5.0

BioUML

1,57280E-2

3,73096E-1

2,16395E-2

4,97860E-1

9,67606E-4

1,62215E-1

2,41902E-3

7,17032E-3

6,93534E-3

1,44420E-3

5,93672E-4

4,92380E-1

7,38841E-1

1,52577E-1

1,29790E-1

6,89601E-2

6,54347E-2

7,51298E-3

5.0

ByoDyn

1,57255E-2

3,72508E-1

2,16055E-2

4,98205E-1

9,67257E-4

1,61960E-1

2,41815E-3

7,16563E-3

6,93321E-3

1,44368E-3

5,93426E-4

4,92384E-1

7,38230E-1

1,52530E-1

1,29552E-1

6,89090E-2

6,53352E-2

7,50836E-3

5.0

CVODE

1,57255E-2

3,72508E-1

2,16055E-2

4,98205E-1

9,67257E-4

1,61960E-1

2,41815E-3

7,16563E-3

6,93321E-3

1,44368E-3

5,93426E-4

4,92384E-1

7,38230E-1

1,52530E-1

1,29552E-1

6,89090E-2

6,53352E-2

7,50836E-3

5.0

Jarnac

1,57255E-2

3,72508E-1

2,16055E-2

4,98205E-1

9,67257E-4

1,61960E-1

2,41815E-3

7,16563E-3

6,93321E-3

1,44368E-3

5,93426E-4

4,92384E-1

7,38230E-1

1,52530E-1

1,29552E-1

6,89090E-2

6,53352E-2

7,50836E-3

5.0

MathSBML

1,57255E-2

3,72508E-1

2,16055E-2

4,98205E-1

9,67257E-4

1,61960E-1

2,41815E-3

7,16563E-3

6,93321E-3

1,44368E-3

5,93426E-4

4,92384E-1

7,38230E-1

1,52530E-1

1,29553E-1

6,89090E-2

6,53352E-2

7,50836E-3

5.0

Oscill8 Core

1,57255E-2

3,72511E-1

2,16056E-2

4,98206E-1

9,67257E-4

1,61961E-1

2,41815E-3

6,93321E-3

1,44368E-3

5,93426E-4

4,92384E-1

7,38231E-1

1,52530E-1

1,29554E-1

6,89092E-2

6,53357E-2

7,50838E-3

5.0

SBToolbox2

1,57290E-2

3,73130E-1

2,16415E-2

4,97455E-1

9,67855E-4

1,62230E-1

2,41965E-3

7,17530E-3

6,93575E-3

1,44460E-3

5,93945E-4

4,92370E-1

7,39415E-1

1,52585E-1

1,29780E-1

6,89715E-2

6,54280E-2

7,51380E-3

5.0

copasi

1,57255E-2

3,72511E-1

2,16056E-2

4,98204E-1

9,67258E-4

1,61961E-1

2,41815E-3

7,16565E-3

6,93322E-3

1,44368E-3

5,93427E-4

4,92384E-1

7,38232E-1

1,52530E-1

1,29554E-1

6,89092E-2

6,53357E-2

7,50839E-3

5.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,57255E-2

3,72508E-1

2,16055E-2

4,98205E-1

9,67257E-4

1,61960E-1

2,41815E-3

7,16563E-3

6,93321E-3

1,44368E-3

5,93426E-4

4,92384E-1

7,38230E-1

1,52530E-1

1,29552E-1

6,89090E-2

6,53352E-2

7,50836E-3

5.0

jsim

1,57255E-2

3,72507E-1

2,16054E-2

4,98204E-1

9,67258E-4

1,61959E-1

2,41815E-3

7,16562E-3

6,93322E-3

1,44368E-3

5,93427E-4

4,92384E-1

7,38230E-1

1,52530E-1

1,29552E-1

6,89089E-2

6,53350E-2

7,50838E-3

5.0

min

1,57255E-2

3,72507E-1

2,16054E-2

4,97455E-1

9,67257E-4

1,61959E-1

2,41815E-3

7,16562E-3

6,93321E-3

1,44368E-3

5,93426E-4

4,92370E-1

7,38230E-1

1,52530E-1

1,29552E-1

6,89089E-2

6,53350E-2

7,50836E-3

5.0

max

1,57290E-2

3,73130E-1

2,16415E-2

4,98206E-1

9,67855E-4

1,62230E-1

2,41965E-3

7,17530E-3

6,93575E-3

1,44460E-3

5,93945E-4

4,92384E-1

7,39415E-1

1,52585E-1

1,29780E-1

6,89715E-2

6,54280E-2

7,51380E-3

5.0

mean

1,57255E-2

3,72508E-1

2,16055E-2

4,98205E-1

9,67257E-4

1,61960E-1

2,41815E-3

7,16563E-3

6,93321E-3

1,44368E-3

5,93426E-4

4,92384E-1

7,38230E-1

1,52530E-1

1,29552E-1

6,89090E-2

6,53352E-2

7,50836E-3

5.0

relative error(%)

0,00

5.2

BioUML

1,55347E-2

3,32890E-1

1,93076E-2

5,23858E-1

9,42290E-4

1,44735E-1

2,35573E-3

6,83503E-3

6,78470E-3

1,40642E-3

5,75554E-4

4,92715E-1

6,95162E-1

1,49263E-1

1,13805E-1

6,53918E-2

5,86497E-2

7,19016E-3

5.2

ByoDyn

1,55323E-2

3,32445E-1

1,92818E-2

5,24225E-1

9,41976E-4

1,44541E-1

2,35495E-3

6,83073E-3

6,78295E-3

1,40595E-3

5,75320E-4

4,92719E-1

6,94611E-1

1,49224E-1

1,13632E-1

6,53514E-2

5,85756E-2

7,18644E-3

5.2

CVODE

1,55323E-2

3,32445E-1

1,92818E-2

5,24225E-1

9,41976E-4

1,44541E-1

2,35495E-3

6,83073E-3

6,78295E-3

1,40595E-3

5,75320E-4

4,92719E-1

6,94611E-1

1,49224E-1

1,13632E-1

6,53514E-2

5,85756E-2

7,18644E-3

5.2

Jarnac

1,55323E-2

3,32445E-1

1,92818E-2

5,24225E-1

9,41976E-4

1,44541E-1

2,35495E-3

6,83073E-3

6,78295E-3

1,40595E-3

5,75320E-4

4,92719E-1

6,94611E-1

1,49224E-1

1,13632E-1

6,53514E-2

5,85756E-2

7,18644E-3

5.2

MathSBML

1,55323E-2

3,32445E-1

1,92818E-2

5,24225E-1

9,41976E-4

1,44541E-1

2,35495E-3

6,83074E-3

6,78295E-3

1,40595E-3

5,75320E-4

4,92719E-1

6,94611E-1

1,49224E-1

1,13632E-1

6,53514E-2

5,85757E-2

7,18644E-3

5.2

Oscill8 Core

1,55323E-2

3,32447E-1

1,92819E-2

5,24225E-1

9,41977E-4

1,44542E-1

2,35495E-3

6,78295E-3

1,40595E-3

5,75320E-4

4,92719E-1

6,94613E-1

1,49224E-1

1,13633E-1

6,53516E-2

5,85760E-2

7,18645E-3

5.2

SBToolbox2

1,55352E-2

3,32910E-1

1,93090E-2

5,23909E-1

9,42309E-4

1,44745E-1

2,35576E-3

6,83462E-3

6,78474E-3

1,40644E-3

5,75572E-4

4,92715E-1

6,95131E-1

1,49263E-1

1,13809E-1

6,53947E-2

5,86535E-2

7,19026E-3

5.2

copasi

1,55323E-2

3,32448E-1

1,92820E-2

5,24223E-1

9,41978E-4

1,44542E-1

2,35495E-3

6,83076E-3

6,78296E-3

1,40595E-3

5,75321E-4

4,92719E-1

6,94614E-1

1,49225E-1

1,13633E-1

6,53516E-2

5,85761E-2

7,18646E-3

5.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,55323E-2

3,32445E-1

1,92818E-2

5,24225E-1

9,41976E-4

1,44541E-1

2,35495E-3

6,83073E-3

6,78295E-3

1,40595E-3

5,75320E-4

4,92719E-1

6,94611E-1

1,49224E-1

1,13632E-1

6,53514E-2

5,85756E-2

7,18644E-3

5.2

jsim

1,55323E-2

3,32444E-1

1,92818E-2

5,24224E-1

9,41978E-4

1,44541E-1

2,35495E-3

6,83073E-3

6,78295E-3

1,40595E-3

5,75321E-4

4,92719E-1

6,94611E-1

1,49225E-1

1,13631E-1

6,53514E-2

5,85755E-2

7,18645E-3

5.2

min

1,55323E-2

3,32444E-1

1,92818E-2

5,23909E-1

9,41976E-4

1,44541E-1

2,35495E-3

6,83073E-3

6,78295E-3

1,40595E-3

5,75320E-4

4,92715E-1

6,94611E-1

1,49224E-1

1,13631E-1

6,53514E-2

5,85755E-2

7,18644E-3

5.2

max

1,55352E-2

3,32910E-1

1,93090E-2

5,24225E-1

9,42309E-4

1,44745E-1

2,35576E-3

6,83462E-3

6,78474E-3

1,40644E-3

5,75572E-4

4,92719E-1

6,95131E-1

1,49263E-1

1,13809E-1

6,53947E-2

5,86535E-2

7,19026E-3

5.2

mean

1,55323E-2

3,32445E-1

1,92818E-2

5,24225E-1

9,41976E-4

1,44541E-1

2,35495E-3

6,83073E-3

6,78295E-3

1,40595E-3

5,75320E-4

4,92719E-1

6,94611E-1

1,49224E-1

1,13632E-1

6,53514E-2

5,85756E-2

7,18644E-3

5.2

relative error(%)

0,00

5.4

BioUML

1,53384E-2

2,99984E-1

1,73991E-2

5,50146E-1

9,18793E-4

1,30428E-1

2,29699E-3

6,52998E-3

6,64796E-3

1,37135E-3

5,58502E-4

4,93020E-1

6,55339E-1

1,46255E-1

1,00981E-1

6,23440E-2

5,31113E-2

6,90325E-3

5.4

ByoDyn

1,53359E-2

2,99604E-1

1,73770E-2

5,50448E-1

9,18505E-4

1,30262E-1

2,29627E-3

6,52649E-3

6,64628E-3

1,37092E-3

5,58293E-4

4,93024E-1

6,54877E-1

1,46218E-1

1,00834E-1

6,23075E-2

5,30472E-2

6,89976E-3

5.4

CVODE

1,53359E-2

2,99604E-1

1,73770E-2

5,50448E-1

9,18505E-4

1,30262E-1

2,29627E-3

6,52649E-3

6,64628E-3

1,37092E-3

5,58293E-4

4,93024E-1

6,54877E-1

1,46218E-1

1,00834E-1

6,23075E-2

5,30472E-2

6,89976E-3

5.4

Jarnac

1,53359E-2

2,99604E-1

1,73770E-2

5,50448E-1

9,18505E-4

1,30262E-1

2,29627E-3

6,52649E-3

6,64628E-3

1,37092E-3

5,58293E-4

4,93024E-1

6,54877E-1

1,46218E-1

1,00834E-1

6,23075E-2

5,30472E-2

6,89976E-3

5.4

MathSBML

1,53359E-2

2,99604E-1

1,73770E-2

5,50448E-1

9,18505E-4

1,30263E-1

2,29627E-3

6,52649E-3

6,64628E-3

1,37092E-3

5,58293E-4

4,93024E-1

6,54877E-1

1,46218E-1

1,00834E-1

6,23076E-2

5,30472E-2

6,89976E-3

5.4

Oscill8 Core

1,53359E-2

2,99605E-1

1,73771E-2

5,50448E-1

9,18505E-4

1,30263E-1

2,29627E-3

6,64628E-3

1,37092E-3

5,58294E-4

4,93024E-1

6,54878E-1

1,46218E-1

1,00834E-1

6,23077E-2

5,30475E-2

6,89977E-3

5.4

SBToolbox2

1,53374E-2

3,00256E-1

1,74151E-2

5,49888E-1

9,18833E-4

1,30546E-1

2,29712E-3

6,53157E-3

6,64763E-3

1,37137E-3

5,58574E-4

4,93019E-1

6,55441E-1

1,46246E-1

1,01054E-1

6,23530E-2

5,31553E-2

6,90239E-3

5.4

copasi

1,53359E-2

2,99606E-1

1,73771E-2

5,50446E-1

9,18506E-4

1,30263E-1

2,29627E-3

6,52651E-3

6,64629E-3

1,37092E-3

5,58294E-4

4,93023E-1

6,54880E-1

1,46218E-1

1,00834E-1

6,23077E-2

5,30475E-2

6,89978E-3

5.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,53359E-2

2,99604E-1

1,73770E-2

5,50448E-1

9,18505E-4

1,30262E-1

2,29627E-3

6,52649E-3

6,64628E-3

1,37092E-3

5,58293E-4

4,93024E-1

6,54877E-1

1,46218E-1

1,00834E-1

6,23075E-2

5,30472E-2

6,89976E-3

5.4

jsim

1,53359E-2

2,99603E-1

1,73770E-2

5,50448E-1

9,18506E-4

1,30262E-1

2,29627E-3

6,52648E-3

6,64628E-3

1,37092E-3

5,58294E-4

4,93024E-1

6,54877E-1

1,46218E-1

1,00833E-1

6,23076E-2

5,30471E-2

6,89977E-3

5.4

min

1,53359E-2

2,99603E-1

1,73770E-2

5,49888E-1

9,18505E-4

1,30262E-1

2,29627E-3

6,52648E-3

6,64628E-3

1,37092E-3

5,58293E-4

4,93019E-1

6,54877E-1

1,46218E-1

1,00833E-1

6,23075E-2

5,30471E-2

6,89976E-3

5.4

max

1,53374E-2

3,00256E-1

1,74151E-2

5,50448E-1

9,18833E-4

1,30546E-1

2,29712E-3

6,53157E-3

6,64763E-3

1,37137E-3

5,58574E-4

4,93024E-1

6,55441E-1

1,46246E-1

1,01054E-1

6,23530E-2

5,31553E-2

6,90239E-3

5.4

mean

1,53359E-2

2,99604E-1

1,73770E-2

5,50448E-1

9,18505E-4

1,30262E-1

2,29627E-3

6,52649E-3

6,64628E-3

1,37092E-3

5,58293E-4

4,93024E-1

6,54877E-1

1,46218E-1

1,00834E-1

6,23076E-2

5,30472E-2

6,89976E-3

5.4

relative error(%)

0,00

5.6

BioUML

1,51400E-2

2,72633E-1

1,58127E-2

5,75906E-1

8,96909E-4

1,18536E-1

2,24228E-3

6,25549E-3

6,52218E-3

1,33868E-3

5,42514E-4

4,93295E-1

6,19326E-1

1,43487E-1

9,04893E-2

5,96895E-2

4,85110E-2

6,64449E-3

5.6

ByoDyn

1,51376E-2

2,72319E-1

1,57945E-2

5,76239E-1

8,96637E-4

1,18400E-1

2,24160E-3

6,25215E-3

6,52069E-3

1,33828E-3

5,42308E-4

4,93298E-1

6,18892E-1

1,43455E-1

9,03714E-2

5,96586E-2

4,84588E-2

6,64147E-3

5.6

CVODE

1,51376E-2

2,72319E-1

1,57945E-2

5,76239E-1

8,96637E-4

1,18400E-1

2,24160E-3

6,25215E-3

6,52069E-3

1,33828E-3

5,42308E-4

4,93298E-1

6,18892E-1

1,43455E-1

9,03714E-2

5,96586E-2

4,84588E-2

6,64147E-3

5.6

Jarnac

1,51376E-2

2,72319E-1

1,57945E-2

5,76239E-1

8,96637E-4

1,18400E-1

2,24160E-3

6,25215E-3

6,52069E-3

1,33828E-3

5,42308E-4

4,93298E-1

6,18892E-1

1,43455E-1

9,03714E-2

5,96586E-2

4,84588E-2

6,64147E-3

5.6

MathSBML

1,51376E-2

2,72319E-1

1,57945E-2

5,76239E-1

8,96637E-4

1,18400E-1

2,24160E-3

6,25215E-3

6,52069E-3

1,33828E-3

5,42308E-4

4,93298E-1

6,18892E-1

1,43455E-1

9,03714E-2

5,96586E-2

4,84588E-2

6,64147E-3

5.6

Oscill8 Core

1,51376E-2

2,72320E-1

1,57946E-2

5,76239E-1

8,96637E-4

1,18400E-1

2,24160E-3

6,52070E-3

1,33828E-3

5,42309E-4

4,93298E-1

6,18893E-1

1,43455E-1

9,03719E-2

5,96587E-2

4,84590E-2

6,64148E-3

5.6

SBToolbox2

1,51416E-2

2,72630E-1

1,58129E-2

5,75752E-1

8,96960E-4

1,18538E-1

2,24241E-3

6,25602E-3

6,52277E-3

1,33880E-3

5,42528E-4

4,93294E-1

6,19439E-1

1,43498E-1

9,04987E-2

5,96941E-2

4,85126E-2

6,64571E-3

5.6

copasi

1,51376E-2

2,72321E-1

1,57946E-2

5,76237E-1

8,96638E-4

1,18400E-1

2,24160E-3

6,25217E-3

6,52070E-3

1,33828E-3

5,42309E-4

4,93298E-1

6,18894E-1

1,43455E-1

9,03720E-2

5,96588E-2

4,84591E-2

6,64149E-3

5.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,51376E-2

2,72319E-1

1,57945E-2

5,76239E-1

8,96637E-4

1,18400E-1

2,24160E-3

6,25215E-3

6,52069E-3

1,33828E-3

5,42308E-4

4,93298E-1

6,18892E-1

1,43455E-1

9,03714E-2

5,96586E-2

4,84588E-2

6,64147E-3

5.6

jsim

1,51376E-2

2,72318E-1

1,57945E-2

5,76239E-1

8,96638E-4

1,18399E-1

2,24160E-3

6,25214E-3

6,52070E-3

1,33828E-3

5,42309E-4

4,93298E-1

6,18892E-1

1,43455E-1

9,03710E-2

5,96586E-2

4,84588E-2

6,64148E-3

5.6

min

1,51376E-2

2,72318E-1

1,57945E-2

5,75752E-1

8,96637E-4

1,18399E-1

2,24160E-3

6,25214E-3

6,52069E-3

1,33828E-3

5,42308E-4

4,93294E-1

6,18892E-1

1,43455E-1

9,03710E-2

5,96586E-2

4,84588E-2

6,64147E-3

5.6

max

1,51416E-2

2,72630E-1

1,58129E-2

5,76239E-1

8,96960E-4

1,18538E-1

2,24241E-3

6,25602E-3

6,52277E-3

1,33880E-3

5,42528E-4

4,93298E-1

6,19439E-1

1,43498E-1

9,04987E-2

5,96941E-2

4,85126E-2

6,64571E-3

5.6

mean

1,51376E-2

2,72319E-1

1,57945E-2

5,76239E-1

8,96637E-4

1,18400E-1

2,24160E-3

6,25215E-3

6,52069E-3

1,33828E-3

5,42308E-4

4,93298E-1

6,18892E-1

1,43455E-1

9,03714E-2

5,96586E-2

4,84588E-2

6,64147E-3

5.6

relative error(%)

0,00

5.8

BioUML

1,49408E-2

2,49641E-1

1,44792E-2

6,00982E-1

8,76395E-4

1,08540E-1

2,19099E-3

6,00743E-3

6,40559E-3

1,30807E-3

5,27442E-4

4,93543E-1

5,86647E-1

1,40923E-1

8,17932E-2

5,73462E-2

4,46471E-2

6,40908E-3

5.8

ByoDyn

1,49383E-2

2,49371E-1

1,44635E-2

6,01296E-1

8,76150E-4

1,08422E-1

2,19038E-3

6,00447E-3

6,40415E-3

1,30770E-3

5,27266E-4

4,93546E-1

5,86257E-1

1,40891E-1

8,16908E-2

5,73187E-2

4,46012E-2

6,40620E-3

5.8

CVODE

1,49383E-2

2,49371E-1

1,44635E-2

6,01296E-1

8,76150E-4

1,08422E-1

2,19038E-3

6,00447E-3

6,40415E-3

1,30770E-3

5,27266E-4

4,93546E-1

5,86257E-1

1,40891E-1

8,16908E-2

5,73187E-2

4,46012E-2

6,40620E-3

5.8

Jarnac

1,49383E-2

2,49371E-1

1,44635E-2

6,01296E-1

8,76150E-4

1,08422E-1

2,19038E-3

6,00447E-3

6,40415E-3

1,30770E-3

5,27266E-4

4,93546E-1

5,86257E-1

1,40891E-1

8,16908E-2

5,73187E-2

4,46012E-2

6,40620E-3

5.8

MathSBML

1,49383E-2

2,49371E-1

1,44635E-2

6,01296E-1

8,76150E-4

1,08422E-1

2,19038E-3

6,00447E-3

6,40415E-3

1,30770E-3

5,27266E-4

4,93546E-1

5,86257E-1

1,40891E-1

8,16908E-2

5,73187E-2

4,46013E-2

6,40620E-3

5.8

Oscill8 Core

1,49383E-2

2,49372E-1

1,44636E-2

6,01295E-1

8,76151E-4

1,08423E-1

2,19038E-3

6,40416E-3

1,30770E-3

5,27267E-4

4,93546E-1

5,86258E-1

1,40891E-1

8,16912E-2

5,73188E-2

4,46014E-2

6,40620E-3

5.8

SBToolbox2

1,49428E-2

2,49947E-1

1,44969E-2

6,00671E-1

8,76665E-4

1,08674E-1

2,19163E-3

6,01036E-3

6,40650E-3

1,30851E-3

5,27690E-4

4,93544E-1

5,87008E-1

1,40941E-1

8,18886E-2

5,73751E-2

4,46943E-2

6,41083E-3

5.8

copasi

1,49384E-2

2,49373E-1

1,44636E-2

6,01294E-1

8,76152E-4

1,08423E-1

2,19039E-3

6,00449E-3

6,40416E-3

1,30770E-3

5,27267E-4

4,93546E-1

5,86260E-1

1,40891E-1

8,16913E-2

5,73189E-2

4,46015E-2

6,40621E-3

5.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,49383E-2

2,49371E-1

1,44635E-2

6,01296E-1

8,76150E-4

1,08422E-1

2,19038E-3

6,00447E-3

6,40415E-3

1,30770E-3

5,27266E-4

4,93546E-1

5,86257E-1

1,40891E-1

8,16908E-2

5,73187E-2

4,46012E-2

6,40620E-3

5.8

jsim

1,49384E-2

2,49371E-1

1,44635E-2

6,01295E-1

8,76151E-4

1,08422E-1

2,19039E-3

6,00447E-3

6,40416E-3

1,30770E-3

5,27267E-4

4,93546E-1

5,86257E-1

1,40891E-1

8,16905E-2

5,73187E-2

4,46012E-2

6,40620E-3

5.8

min

1,49383E-2

2,49371E-1

1,44635E-2

6,00671E-1

8,76150E-4

1,08422E-1

2,19038E-3

6,00447E-3

6,40415E-3

1,30770E-3

5,27266E-4

4,93544E-1

5,86257E-1

1,40891E-1

8,16905E-2

5,73187E-2

4,46012E-2

6,40620E-3

5.8

max

1,49428E-2

2,49947E-1

1,44969E-2

6,01296E-1

8,76665E-4

1,08674E-1

2,19163E-3

6,01036E-3

6,40650E-3

1,30851E-3

5,27690E-4

4,93546E-1

5,87008E-1

1,40941E-1

8,18886E-2

5,73751E-2

4,46943E-2

6,41083E-3

5.8

mean

1,49383E-2

2,49371E-1

1,44635E-2

6,01296E-1

8,76150E-4

1,08422E-1

2,19038E-3

6,00447E-3

6,40415E-3

1,30770E-3

5,27266E-4

4,93546E-1

5,86257E-1

1,40891E-1

8,16908E-2

5,73187E-2

4,46012E-2

6,40620E-3

5.8

relative error(%)

0,00

6.0

BioUML

1,47416E-2

2,30096E-1

1,33456E-2

6,25177E-1

8,57100E-4

1,00042E-1

2,14276E-3

5,78264E-3

6,29645E-3

1,27927E-3

5,13251E-4

4,93767E-1

5,56912E-1

1,38521E-1

7,44818E-2

5,52515E-2

4,13609E-2

6,19252E-3

6.0

ByoDyn

1,47390E-2

2,29857E-1

1,33317E-2

6,25478E-1

8,56852E-4

9,99379E-2

2,14214E-3

5,77988E-3

6,29507E-3

1,27890E-3

5,13065E-4

4,93770E-1

5,56547E-1

1,38491E-1

7,43935E-2

5,52251E-2

4,13209E-2

6,18983E-3

6.0

CVODE

1,47390E-2

2,29857E-1

1,33317E-2

6,25478E-1

8,56852E-4

9,99379E-2

2,14214E-3

5,77988E-3

6,29507E-3

1,27890E-3

5,13065E-4

4,93770E-1

5,56547E-1

1,38491E-1

7,43935E-2

5,52251E-2

4,13209E-2

6,18983E-3

6.0

Jarnac

1,47390E-2

2,29857E-1

1,33317E-2

6,25478E-1

8,56852E-4

9,99379E-2

2,14214E-3

5,77988E-3

6,29507E-3

1,27890E-3

5,13065E-4

4,93770E-1

5,56547E-1

1,38491E-1

7,43935E-2

5,52251E-2

4,13209E-2

6,18983E-3

6.0

MathSBML

1,47390E-2

2,29857E-1

1,33317E-2

6,25478E-1

8,56852E-4

9,99379E-2

2,14214E-3

5,77988E-3

6,29507E-3

1,27890E-3

5,13065E-4

4,93770E-1

5,56547E-1

1,38491E-1

7,43935E-2

5,52251E-2

4,13209E-2

6,18983E-3

6.0

Oscill8 Core

1,47390E-2

2,29858E-1

1,33318E-2

6,25477E-1

8,56852E-4

9,99383E-2

2,14214E-3

6,29508E-3

1,27890E-3

5,13066E-4

4,93770E-1

5,56548E-1

1,38491E-1

7,43939E-2

5,52252E-2

4,13211E-2

6,18983E-3

6.0

SBToolbox2

1,47462E-2

2,30194E-1

1,33512E-2

6,25008E-1

8,57358E-4

1,00084E-1

2,14340E-3

5,78488E-3

6,29880E-3

1,27966E-3

5,13364E-4

4,93764E-1

5,57292E-1

1,38574E-1

7,45454E-2

5,52750E-2

4,13816E-2

6,19714E-3

6.0

copasi

1,47391E-2

2,29859E-1

1,33318E-2

6,25476E-1

8,56854E-4

9,99385E-2

2,14214E-3

5,77990E-3

6,29508E-3

1,27890E-3

5,13066E-4

4,93770E-1

5,56549E-1

1,38491E-1

7,43941E-2

5,52253E-2

4,13212E-2

6,18984E-3

6.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,47390E-2

2,29857E-1

1,33317E-2

6,25478E-1

8,56852E-4

9,99379E-2

2,14214E-3

5,77988E-3

6,29507E-3

1,27890E-3

5,13065E-4

4,93770E-1

5,56547E-1

1,38491E-1

7,43935E-2

5,52251E-2

4,13209E-2

6,18983E-3

6.0

jsim

1,47391E-2

2,29857E-1

1,33317E-2

6,25477E-1

8,56853E-4

9,99378E-2

2,14214E-3

5,77988E-3

6,29508E-3

1,27890E-3

5,13066E-4

4,93770E-1

5,56547E-1

1,38491E-1

7,43934E-2

5,52252E-2

4,13209E-2

6,18983E-3

6.0

min

1,47390E-2

2,29857E-1

1,33317E-2

6,25008E-1

8,56852E-4

9,99378E-2

2,14214E-3

5,77988E-3

6,29507E-3

1,27890E-3

5,13065E-4

4,93764E-1

5,56547E-1

1,38491E-1

7,43934E-2

5,52251E-2

4,13209E-2

6,18983E-3

6.0

max

1,47462E-2

2,30194E-1

1,33512E-2

6,25478E-1

8,57358E-4

1,00084E-1

2,14340E-3

5,78488E-3

6,29880E-3

1,27966E-3

5,13364E-4

4,93770E-1

5,57292E-1

1,38574E-1

7,45454E-2

5,52750E-2

4,13816E-2

6,19714E-3

6.0

mean

1,47390E-2

2,29857E-1

1,33317E-2

6,25478E-1

8,56852E-4

9,99379E-2

2,14214E-3

5,77988E-3

6,29507E-3

1,27890E-3

5,13065E-4

4,93770E-1

5,56547E-1

1,38491E-1

7,43935E-2

5,52251E-2

4,13209E-2

6,18983E-3

6.0

relative error(%)

0,00

6.2

BioUML

1,45433E-2

2,13319E-1

1,23725E-2

6,48403E-1

8,38846E-4

9,27476E-2

2,09712E-3

5,57794E-3

6,19370E-3

1,25202E-3

4,99806E-4

4,93972E-1

5,29750E-1

1,36261E-1

6,82700E-2

5,33578E-2

3,85403E-2

5,99207E-3

6.2

ByoDyn

1,45404E-2

2,13098E-1

1,23597E-2

6,48724E-1

8,38585E-4

9,26514E-2

2,09647E-3

5,57512E-3

6,19224E-3

1,25163E-3

4,99615E-4

4,93975E-1

5,29375E-1

1,36229E-1

6,81881E-2

5,33315E-2

3,85032E-2

5,98924E-3

6.2

CVODE

1,45404E-2

2,13098E-1

1,23597E-2

6,48724E-1

8,38585E-4

9,26514E-2

2,09647E-3

5,57512E-3

6,19224E-3

1,25163E-3

4,99615E-4

4,93975E-1

5,29375E-1

1,36229E-1

6,81881E-2

5,33315E-2

3,85032E-2

5,98924E-3

6.2

Jarnac

1,45404E-2

2,13098E-1

1,23597E-2

6,48724E-1

8,38585E-4

9,26514E-2

2,09647E-3

5,57512E-3

6,19224E-3

1,25163E-3

4,99615E-4

4,93975E-1

5,29375E-1

1,36229E-1

6,81881E-2

5,33315E-2

3,85032E-2

5,98924E-3

6.2

MathSBML

1,45404E-2

2,13098E-1

1,23597E-2

6,48724E-1

8,38585E-4

9,26514E-2

2,09647E-3

5,57512E-3

6,19224E-3

1,25163E-3

4,99615E-4

4,93975E-1

5,29375E-1

1,36229E-1

6,81881E-2

5,33315E-2

3,85032E-2

5,98924E-3

6.2

Oscill8 Core

1,45404E-2

2,13099E-1

1,23597E-2

6,48724E-1

8,38585E-4

9,26517E-2

2,09647E-3

6,19224E-3

1,25163E-3

4,99615E-4

4,93975E-1

5,29376E-1

1,36229E-1

6,81884E-2

5,33315E-2

3,85033E-2

5,98925E-3

6.2

SBToolbox2

1,45548E-2

2,13741E-1

1,23973E-2

6,48229E-1

8,39644E-4

9,29300E-2

2,09913E-3

5,58400E-3

6,19959E-3

1,25321E-3

5,00283E-4

4,93964E-1

5,30751E-1

1,36388E-1

6,84693E-2

5,34314E-2

3,86164E-2

6,00352E-3

6.2

copasi

1,45404E-2

2,13099E-1

1,23598E-2

6,48723E-1

8,38586E-4

9,26519E-2

2,09647E-3

5,57514E-3

6,19224E-3

1,25163E-3

4,99616E-4

4,93975E-1

5,29377E-1

1,36229E-1

6,81885E-2

5,33316E-2

3,85034E-2

5,98925E-3

6.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,45404E-2

2,13098E-1

1,23597E-2

6,48724E-1

8,38585E-4

9,26514E-2

2,09647E-3

5,57512E-3

6,19224E-3

1,25163E-3

4,99615E-4

4,93975E-1

5,29375E-1

1,36229E-1

6,81881E-2

5,33315E-2

3,85032E-2

5,98924E-3

6.2

jsim

1,45404E-2

2,13098E-1

1,23597E-2

6,48724E-1

8,38586E-4

9,26514E-2

2,09647E-3

5,57512E-3

6,19224E-3

1,25163E-3

4,99615E-4

4,93975E-1

5,29375E-1

1,36229E-1

6,81880E-2

5,33315E-2

3,85032E-2

5,98925E-3

6.2

min

1,45404E-2

2,13098E-1

1,23597E-2

6,48229E-1

8,38585E-4

9,26514E-2

2,09647E-3

5,57512E-3

6,19224E-3

1,25163E-3

4,99615E-4

4,93964E-1

5,29375E-1

1,36229E-1

6,81880E-2

5,33315E-2

3,85032E-2

5,98924E-3

6.2

max

1,45548E-2

2,13741E-1

1,23973E-2

6,48724E-1

8,39644E-4

9,29300E-2

2,09913E-3

5,58400E-3

6,19959E-3

1,25321E-3

5,00283E-4

4,93975E-1

5,30751E-1

1,36388E-1

6,84693E-2

5,34314E-2

3,86164E-2

6,00352E-3

6.2

mean

1,45404E-2

2,13098E-1

1,23597E-2

6,48724E-1

8,38585E-4

9,26514E-2

2,09647E-3

5,57512E-3

6,19224E-3

1,25163E-3

4,99615E-4

4,93975E-1

5,29375E-1

1,36229E-1

6,81881E-2

5,33315E-2

3,85032E-2

5,98924E-3

6.2

relative error(%)

0,00

6.4

BioUML

1,43457E-2

1,98775E-1

1,15289E-2

6,70705E-1

8,21468E-4

8,64239E-2

2,05368E-3

5,39003E-3

6,09609E-3

1,22608E-3

4,87017E-4

4,94160E-1

5,04760E-1

1,34114E-1

6,29295E-2

5,16269E-2

3,60943E-2

5,80470E-3

6.4

ByoDyn

1,43429E-2

1,98578E-1

1,15175E-2

6,71017E-1

8,21224E-4

8,63384E-2

2,05307E-3

5,38744E-3

6,09470E-3

1,22572E-3

4,86839E-4

4,94163E-1

5,04415E-1

1,34083E-1

6,28572E-2

5,16030E-2

3,60611E-2

5,80205E-3

6.4

CVODE

1,43429E-2

1,98578E-1

1,15175E-2

6,71017E-1

8,21224E-4

8,63384E-2

2,05307E-3

5,38744E-3

6,09470E-3

1,22572E-3

4,86839E-4

4,94163E-1

5,04415E-1

1,34083E-1

6,28572E-2

5,16030E-2

3,60611E-2

5,80205E-3

6.4

Jarnac

1,43429E-2

1,98578E-1

1,15175E-2

6,71017E-1

8,21224E-4

8,63384E-2

2,05307E-3

5,38744E-3

6,09470E-3

1,22572E-3

4,86839E-4

4,94163E-1

5,04415E-1

1,34083E-1

6,28572E-2

5,16030E-2

3,60611E-2

5,80205E-3

6.4

MathSBML

1,43429E-2

1,98578E-1

1,15175E-2

6,71017E-1

8,21224E-4

8,63384E-2

2,05307E-3

5,38744E-3

6,09470E-3

1,22572E-3

4,86839E-4

4,94163E-1

5,04415E-1

1,34083E-1

6,28572E-2

5,16030E-2

3,60611E-2

5,80205E-3

6.4

Oscill8 Core

1,43429E-2

1,98579E-1

1,15176E-2

6,71016E-1

8,21224E-4

8,63386E-2

2,05307E-3

6,09470E-3

1,22572E-3

4,86839E-4

4,94163E-1

5,04415E-1

1,34083E-1

6,28574E-2

5,16030E-2

3,60612E-2

5,80205E-3

6.4

SBToolbox2

1,43528E-2

1,99072E-1

1,15460E-2

6,70877E-1

8,21959E-4

8,65530E-2

2,05492E-3

5,39154E-3

6,09939E-3

1,22680E-3

4,87338E-4

4,94154E-1

5,05134E-1

1,34188E-1

6,30527E-2

5,16743E-2

3,61460E-2

5,81092E-3

6.4

copasi

1,43429E-2

1,98579E-1

1,15176E-2

6,71015E-1

8,21225E-4

8,63388E-2

2,05307E-3

5,38745E-3

6,09471E-3

1,22572E-3

4,86839E-4

4,94163E-1

5,04416E-1

1,34083E-1

6,28576E-2

5,16031E-2

3,60613E-2

5,80206E-3

6.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,43429E-2

1,98578E-1

1,15175E-2

6,71017E-1

8,21224E-4

8,63384E-2

2,05307E-3

5,38744E-3

6,09470E-3

1,22572E-3

4,86839E-4

4,94163E-1

5,04415E-1

1,34083E-1

6,28572E-2

5,16030E-2

3,60611E-2

5,80205E-3

6.4

jsim

1,43429E-2

1,98578E-1

1,15175E-2

6,71016E-1

8,21224E-4

8,63383E-2

2,05307E-3

5,38744E-3

6,09470E-3

1,22572E-3

4,86839E-4

4,94163E-1

5,04415E-1

1,34083E-1

6,28571E-2

5,16030E-2

3,60611E-2

5,80205E-3

6.4

min

1,43429E-2

1,98578E-1

1,15175E-2

6,70877E-1

8,21224E-4

8,63383E-2

2,05307E-3

5,38744E-3

6,09470E-3

1,22572E-3

4,86839E-4

4,94154E-1

5,04415E-1

1,34083E-1

6,28571E-2

5,16030E-2

3,60611E-2

5,80205E-3

6.4

max

1,43528E-2

1,99072E-1

1,15460E-2

6,71017E-1

8,21959E-4

8,65530E-2

2,05492E-3

5,39154E-3

6,09939E-3

1,22680E-3

4,87338E-4

4,94163E-1

5,05134E-1

1,34188E-1

6,30527E-2

5,16743E-2

3,61460E-2

5,81092E-3

6.4

mean

1,43429E-2

1,98578E-1

1,15175E-2

6,71017E-1

8,21224E-4

8,63384E-2

2,05307E-3

5,38744E-3

6,09470E-3

1,22572E-3

4,86839E-4

4,94163E-1

5,04415E-1

1,34083E-1

6,28572E-2

5,16030E-2

3,60611E-2

5,80205E-3

6.4

relative error(%)

0,00

6.6

BioUML

1,41499E-2

1,86075E-1

1,07923E-2

6,92057E-1

8,04898E-4

8,09020E-2

2,01225E-3

5,21694E-3

6,00310E-3

1,20135E-3

4,74839E-4

4,94333E-1

4,81714E-1

1,32068E-1

5,83012E-2

5,00354E-2

3,39577E-2

5,62896E-3

6.6

ByoDyn

1,41471E-2

1,85899E-1

1,07821E-2

6,92357E-1

8,04668E-4

8,08256E-2

2,01168E-3

5,21455E-3

6,00174E-3

1,20101E-3

4,74675E-4

4,94335E-1

4,81393E-1

1,32038E-1

5,82364E-2

5,00132E-2

3,39276E-2

5,62641E-3

6.6

CVODE

1,41471E-2

1,85899E-1

1,07821E-2

6,92357E-1

8,04668E-4

8,08256E-2

2,01168E-3

5,21455E-3

6,00174E-3

1,20101E-3

4,74675E-4

4,94335E-1

4,81393E-1

1,32038E-1

5,82364E-2

5,00132E-2

3,39276E-2

5,62641E-3

6.6

Jarnac

1,41471E-2

1,85899E-1

1,07821E-2

6,92357E-1

8,04668E-4

8,08256E-2

2,01168E-3

5,21455E-3

6,00174E-3

1,20101E-3

4,74675E-4

4,94335E-1

4,81393E-1

1,32038E-1

5,82364E-2

5,00132E-2

3,39276E-2

5,62641E-3

6.6

MathSBML

1,41471E-2

1,85899E-1

1,07821E-2

6,92357E-1

8,04668E-4

8,08256E-2

2,01168E-3

5,21455E-3

6,00174E-3

1,20101E-3

4,74675E-4

4,94335E-1

4,81393E-1

1,32038E-1

5,82364E-2

5,00132E-2

3,39276E-2

5,62641E-3

6.6

Oscill8 Core

1,41471E-2

1,85899E-1

1,07822E-2

6,92357E-1

8,04669E-4

8,08258E-2

2,01168E-3

6,00174E-3

1,20101E-3

4,74675E-4

4,94335E-1

4,81394E-1

1,32038E-1

5,82366E-2

5,00132E-2

3,39277E-2

5,62641E-3

6.6

SBToolbox2

1,41529E-2

1,86293E-1

1,08051E-2

6,91563E-1

8,05201E-4

8,09979E-2

2,01302E-3

5,22085E-3

6,00434E-3

1,20179E-3

4,75096E-4

4,94330E-1

4,82176E-1

1,32096E-1

5,83716E-2

5,00618E-2

3,39923E-2

5,63125E-3

6.6

copasi

1,41471E-2

1,85900E-1

1,07822E-2

6,92355E-1

8,04669E-4

8,08260E-2

2,01168E-3

5,21456E-3

6,00175E-3

1,20101E-3

4,74676E-4

4,94335E-1

4,81395E-1

1,32038E-1

5,82367E-2

5,00133E-2

3,39278E-2

5,62642E-3

6.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,41471E-2

1,85899E-1

1,07821E-2

6,92357E-1

8,04668E-4

8,08256E-2

2,01168E-3

5,21455E-3

6,00174E-3

1,20101E-3

4,74675E-4

4,94335E-1

4,81393E-1

1,32038E-1

5,82364E-2

5,00132E-2

3,39276E-2

5,62641E-3

6.6

jsim

1,41471E-2

1,85899E-1

1,07821E-2

6,92357E-1

8,04669E-4

8,08256E-2

2,01168E-3

5,21455E-3

6,00175E-3

1,20101E-3

4,74676E-4

4,94335E-1

4,81393E-1

1,32038E-1

5,82363E-2

5,00132E-2

3,39276E-2

5,62641E-3

6.6

min

1,41471E-2

1,85899E-1

1,07821E-2

6,91563E-1

8,04668E-4

8,08256E-2

2,01168E-3

5,21455E-3

6,00174E-3

1,20101E-3

4,74675E-4

4,94330E-1

4,81393E-1

1,32038E-1

5,82363E-2

5,00132E-2

3,39276E-2

5,62641E-3

6.6

max

1,41529E-2

1,86293E-1

1,08051E-2

6,92357E-1

8,05201E-4

8,09979E-2

2,01302E-3

5,22085E-3

6,00434E-3

1,20179E-3

4,75096E-4

4,94335E-1

4,82176E-1

1,32096E-1

5,83716E-2

5,00618E-2

3,39923E-2

5,63125E-3

6.6

mean

1,41471E-2

1,85899E-1

1,07821E-2

6,92357E-1

8,04668E-4

8,08256E-2

2,01168E-3

5,21455E-3

6,00174E-3

1,20101E-3

4,74675E-4

4,94335E-1

4,81393E-1

1,32038E-1

5,82364E-2

5,00132E-2

3,39276E-2

5,62641E-3

6.6

relative error(%)

0,00

6.8

BioUML

1,39563E-2

1,74905E-1

1,01445E-2

7,12456E-1

7,89078E-4

7,60458E-2

1,97270E-3

5,05690E-3

5,91414E-3

1,17774E-3

4,63249E-4

4,94493E-1

4,60396E-1

1,30111E-1

5,42556E-2

4,85633E-2

3,20767E-2

5,46335E-3

6.8

ByoDyn

1,39534E-2

1,74749E-1

1,01355E-2

7,12758E-1

7,88840E-4

7,59780E-2

1,97211E-3

5,05456E-3

5,91280E-3

1,17739E-3

4,63073E-4

4,94495E-1

4,60085E-1

1,30081E-1

5,41992E-2

4,85416E-2

3,20506E-2

5,46089E-3

6.8

CVODE

1,39534E-2

1,74749E-1

1,01355E-2

7,12758E-1

7,88840E-4

7,59780E-2

1,97211E-3

5,05456E-3

5,91280E-3

1,17739E-3

4,63073E-4

4,94495E-1

4,60085E-1

1,30081E-1

5,41992E-2

4,85416E-2

3,20506E-2

5,46089E-3

6.8

Jarnac

1,39534E-2

1,74749E-1

1,01355E-2

7,12758E-1

7,88840E-4

7,59780E-2

1,97211E-3

5,05456E-3

5,91280E-3

1,17739E-3

4,63073E-4

4,94495E-1

4,60085E-1

1,30081E-1

5,41992E-2

4,85416E-2

3,20506E-2

5,46089E-3

6.8

MathSBML

1,39534E-2

1,74749E-1

1,01355E-2

7,12758E-1

7,88840E-4

7,59780E-2

1,97211E-3

5,05455E-3

5,91280E-3

1,17739E-3

4,63073E-4

4,94495E-1

4,60085E-1

1,30081E-1

5,41992E-2

4,85416E-2

3,20506E-2

5,46089E-3

6.8

Oscill8 Core

1,39534E-2

1,74750E-1

1,01355E-2

7,12758E-1

7,88840E-4

7,59782E-2

1,97211E-3

5,91280E-3

1,17739E-3

4,63073E-4

4,94495E-1

4,60085E-1

1,30081E-1

5,41994E-2

4,85416E-2

3,20506E-2

5,46089E-3

6.8

SBToolbox2

1,39674E-2

1,75256E-1

1,01650E-2

7,12678E-1

7,89875E-4

7,62001E-2

1,97469E-3

5,06053E-3

5,91951E-3

1,17891E-3

4,63756E-4

4,94490E-1

4,61102E-1

1,30228E-1

5,44092E-2

4,86318E-2

3,21391E-2

5,47328E-3

6.8

copasi

1,39534E-2

1,74750E-1

1,01355E-2

7,12757E-1

7,88841E-4

7,59783E-2

1,97211E-3

5,05457E-3

5,91281E-3

1,17739E-3

4,63074E-4

4,94495E-1

4,60086E-1

1,30081E-1

5,41995E-2

4,85417E-2

3,20507E-2

5,46090E-3

6.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,39534E-2

1,74749E-1

1,01355E-2

7,12758E-1

7,88840E-4

7,59780E-2

1,97211E-3

5,05456E-3

5,91280E-3

1,17739E-3

4,63073E-4

4,94495E-1

4,60085E-1

1,30081E-1

5,41992E-2

4,85416E-2

3,20506E-2

5,46089E-3

6.8

jsim

1,39534E-2

1,74749E-1

1,01355E-2

7,12758E-1

7,88841E-4

7,59780E-2

1,97211E-3

5,05456E-3

5,91281E-3

1,17739E-3

4,63074E-4

4,94495E-1

4,60085E-1

1,30081E-1

5,41992E-2

4,85416E-2

3,20506E-2

5,46089E-3

6.8

min

1,39534E-2

1,74749E-1

1,01355E-2

7,12678E-1

7,88840E-4

7,59780E-2

1,97211E-3

5,05455E-3

5,91280E-3

1,17739E-3

4,63073E-4

4,94490E-1

4,60085E-1

1,30081E-1

5,41992E-2

4,85416E-2

3,20506E-2

5,46089E-3

6.8

max

1,39674E-2

1,75256E-1

1,01650E-2

7,12758E-1

7,89875E-4

7,62001E-2

1,97469E-3

5,06053E-3

5,91951E-3

1,17891E-3

4,63756E-4

4,94495E-1

4,61102E-1

1,30228E-1

5,44092E-2

4,86318E-2

3,21391E-2

5,47328E-3

6.8

mean

1,39534E-2

1,74749E-1

1,01355E-2

7,12758E-1

7,88840E-4

7,59780E-2

1,97211E-3

5,05456E-3

5,91280E-3

1,17739E-3

4,63073E-4

4,94495E-1

4,60085E-1

1,30081E-1

5,41992E-2

4,85416E-2

3,20506E-2

5,46089E-3

6.8

relative error(%)

0,00

7.0

BioUML

1,37648E-2

1,65016E-1

9,57093E-3

7,31958E-1

7,73888E-4

7,17461E-2

1,93473E-3

4,90800E-3

5,82863E-3

1,15507E-3

4,52148E-4

4,94642E-1

4,40577E-1

1,28229E-1

5,06943E-2

4,71911E-2

3,04109E-2

5,30651E-3

7.0

ByoDyn

1,37621E-2

1,64884E-1

9,56327E-3

7,32239E-1

7,73675E-4

7,16887E-2

1,93419E-3

4,90592E-3

5,82744E-3

1,15475E-3

4,51991E-4

4,94644E-1

4,40302E-1

1,28203E-1

5,06471E-2

4,71722E-2

3,03887E-2

5,30436E-3

7.0

CVODE

1,37621E-2

1,64884E-1

9,56327E-3

7,32239E-1

7,73675E-4

7,16887E-2

1,93419E-3

4,90592E-3

5,82744E-3

1,15475E-3

4,51991E-4

4,94644E-1

4,40302E-1

1,28203E-1

5,06471E-2

4,71722E-2

3,03887E-2

5,30436E-3

7.0

Jarnac

1,37621E-2

1,64884E-1

9,56327E-3

7,32239E-1

7,73675E-4

7,16887E-2

1,93419E-3

4,90592E-3

5,82744E-3

1,15475E-3

4,51991E-4

4,94644E-1

4,40302E-1

1,28203E-1

5,06471E-2

4,71722E-2

3,03887E-2

5,30436E-3

7.0

MathSBML

1,37621E-2

1,64884E-1

9,56327E-3

7,32239E-1

7,73675E-4

7,16886E-2

1,93419E-3

4,90592E-3

5,82744E-3

1,15475E-3

4,51991E-4

4,94644E-1

4,40302E-1

1,28203E-1

5,06471E-2

4,71722E-2

3,03887E-2

5,30436E-3

7.0

Oscill8 Core

1,37621E-2

1,64884E-1

9,56328E-3

7,32239E-1

7,73675E-4

7,16888E-2

1,93419E-3

5,82744E-3

1,15475E-3

4,51991E-4

4,94644E-1

4,40302E-1

1,28203E-1

5,06472E-2

4,71723E-2

3,03888E-2

5,30436E-3

7.0

SBToolbox2

1,37713E-2

1,65332E-1

9,58916E-3

7,31311E-1

7,74408E-4

7,18827E-2

1,93603E-3

4,91301E-3

5,83167E-3

1,15587E-3

4,52518E-4

4,94633E-1

4,41242E-1

1,28293E-1

5,08092E-2

4,72372E-2

3,04646E-2

5,31202E-3

7.0

copasi

1,37621E-2

1,64885E-1

9,56330E-3

7,32238E-1

7,73676E-4

7,16889E-2

1,93420E-3

4,90593E-3

5,82745E-3

1,15475E-3

4,51991E-4

4,94644E-1

4,40303E-1

1,28203E-1

5,06473E-2

4,71723E-2

3,03888E-2

5,30437E-3

7.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,37621E-2

1,64884E-1

9,56327E-3

7,32239E-1

7,73675E-4

7,16887E-2

1,93419E-3

4,90592E-3

5,82744E-3

1,15475E-3

4,51991E-4

4,94644E-1

4,40302E-1

1,28203E-1

5,06471E-2

4,71722E-2

3,03887E-2

5,30436E-3

7.0

jsim

1,37621E-2

1,64884E-1

9,56326E-3

7,32239E-1

7,73676E-4

7,16886E-2

1,93420E-3

4,90592E-3

5,82745E-3

1,15475E-3

4,51991E-4

4,94644E-1

4,40302E-1

1,28203E-1

5,06471E-2

4,71723E-2

3,03887E-2

5,30436E-3

7.0

min

1,37621E-2

1,64884E-1

9,56326E-3

7,31311E-1

7,73675E-4

7,16886E-2

1,93419E-3

4,90592E-3

5,82744E-3

1,15475E-3

4,51991E-4

4,94633E-1

4,40302E-1

1,28203E-1

5,06471E-2

4,71722E-2

3,03887E-2

5,30436E-3

7.0

max

1,37713E-2

1,65332E-1

9,58916E-3

7,32239E-1

7,74408E-4

7,18827E-2

1,93603E-3

4,91301E-3

5,83167E-3

1,15587E-3

4,52518E-4

4,94644E-1

4,41242E-1

1,28293E-1

5,08092E-2

4,72372E-2

3,04646E-2

5,31202E-3

7.0

mean

1,37621E-2

1,64884E-1

9,56327E-3

7,32239E-1

7,73675E-4

7,16887E-2

1,93419E-3

4,90592E-3

5,82744E-3

1,15475E-3

4,51991E-4

4,94644E-1

4,40302E-1

1,28203E-1

5,06471E-2

4,71722E-2

3,03887E-2

5,30436E-3

7.0

relative error(%)

0,00

7.2

BioUML

1,35761E-2

1,56214E-1

9,06039E-3

7,50575E-1

7,59314E-4

6,79190E-2

1,89829E-3

4,76915E-3

5,74637E-3

1,13332E-3

4,41534E-4

4,94781E-1

4,22124E-1

1,26420E-1

4,75405E-2

4,59089E-2

2,89272E-2

5,15780E-3

7.2

ByoDyn

1,35736E-2

1,56106E-1

9,05414E-3

7,50823E-1

7,59123E-4

6,78721E-2

1,89781E-3

4,76735E-3

5,74532E-3

1,13303E-3

4,41393E-4

4,94783E-1

4,21887E-1

1,26397E-1

4,75023E-2

4,58925E-2

2,89092E-2

5,15591E-3

7.2

CVODE

1,35736E-2

1,56106E-1

9,05414E-3

7,50823E-1

7,59123E-4

6,78721E-2

1,89781E-3

4,76735E-3

5,74532E-3

1,13303E-3

4,41393E-4

4,94783E-1

4,21887E-1

1,26397E-1

4,75023E-2

4,58925E-2

2,89092E-2

5,15591E-3

7.2

Jarnac

1,35736E-2

1,56106E-1

9,05414E-3

7,50823E-1

7,59123E-4

6,78721E-2

1,89781E-3

4,76735E-3

5,74532E-3

1,13303E-3

4,41393E-4

4,94783E-1

4,21887E-1

1,26397E-1

4,75023E-2

4,58925E-2

2,89092E-2

5,15591E-3

7.2

MathSBML

1,35736E-2

1,56106E-1

9,05414E-3

7,50823E-1

7,59123E-4

6,78721E-2

1,89781E-3

4,76735E-3

5,74532E-3

1,13303E-3

4,41393E-4

4,94783E-1

4,21887E-1

1,26397E-1

4,75023E-2

4,58924E-2

2,89092E-2

5,15591E-3

7.2

Oscill8 Core

1,35736E-2

1,56106E-1

9,05415E-3

7,50823E-1

7,59123E-4

6,78722E-2

1,89781E-3

5,74532E-3

1,13303E-3

4,41393E-4

4,94783E-1

4,21888E-1

1,26397E-1

4,75024E-2

4,58925E-2

2,89092E-2

5,15591E-3

7.2

SBToolbox2

1,35818E-2

1,56547E-1

9,07996E-3

7,50176E-1

7,59850E-4

6,80655E-2

1,89962E-3

4,77336E-3

5,74868E-3

1,13412E-3

4,41979E-4

4,94780E-1

4,22666E-1

1,26470E-1

4,76457E-2

4,59549E-2

2,89808E-2

5,16188E-3

7.2

copasi

1,35736E-2

1,56106E-1

9,05417E-3

7,50822E-1

7,59124E-4

6,78723E-2

1,89782E-3

4,76736E-3

5,74533E-3

1,13303E-3

4,41393E-4

4,94783E-1

4,21888E-1

1,26397E-1

4,75024E-2

4,58925E-2

2,89093E-2

5,15592E-3

7.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,35736E-2

1,56106E-1

9,05414E-3

7,50823E-1

7,59123E-4

6,78721E-2

1,89781E-3

4,76735E-3

5,74532E-3

1,13303E-3

4,41393E-4

4,94783E-1

4,21887E-1

1,26397E-1

4,75023E-2

4,58925E-2

2,89092E-2

5,15591E-3

7.2

jsim

1,35736E-2

1,56106E-1

9,05414E-3

7,50823E-1

7,59124E-4

6,78721E-2

1,89782E-3

4,76735E-3

5,74532E-3

1,13303E-3

4,41393E-4

4,94783E-1

4,21887E-1

1,26397E-1

4,75022E-2

4,58925E-2

2,89092E-2

5,15591E-3

7.2

min

1,35736E-2

1,56106E-1

9,05414E-3

7,50176E-1

7,59123E-4

6,78721E-2

1,89781E-3

4,76735E-3

5,74532E-3

1,13303E-3

4,41393E-4

4,94780E-1

4,21887E-1

1,26397E-1

4,75022E-2

4,58924E-2

2,89092E-2

5,15591E-3

7.2

max

1,35818E-2

1,56547E-1

9,07996E-3

7,50823E-1

7,59850E-4

6,80655E-2

1,89962E-3

4,77336E-3

5,74868E-3

1,13412E-3

4,41979E-4

4,94783E-1

4,22666E-1

1,26470E-1

4,76457E-2

4,59549E-2

2,89808E-2

5,16188E-3

7.2

mean

1,35736E-2

1,56106E-1

9,05414E-3

7,50823E-1

7,59123E-4

6,78721E-2

1,89781E-3

4,76735E-3

5,74532E-3

1,13303E-3

4,41393E-4

4,94783E-1

4,21887E-1

1,26397E-1

4,75023E-2

4,58925E-2

2,89092E-2

5,15591E-3

7.2

relative error(%)

0,00

7.4

BioUML

1,33906E-2

1,48359E-1

8,60482E-3

7,68311E-1

7,45333E-4

6,45039E-2

1,86334E-3

4,63947E-3

5,66720E-3

1,11245E-3

4,31391E-4

4,94910E-1

4,04931E-1

1,24678E-1

4,47382E-2

4,47078E-2

2,76024E-2

5,01665E-3

7.4

ByoDyn

1,33882E-2

1,48257E-1

8,59888E-3

7,68532E-1

7,45143E-4

6,44594E-2

1,86286E-3

4,63780E-3

5,66617E-3

1,11217E-3

4,31250E-4

4,94912E-1

4,04709E-1

1,24655E-1

4,47025E-2

4,46921E-2

2,75853E-2

5,01483E-3

7.4

CVODE

1,33882E-2

1,48257E-1

8,59888E-3

7,68532E-1

7,45143E-4

6,44594E-2

1,86286E-3

4,63780E-3

5,66617E-3

1,11217E-3

4,31250E-4

4,94912E-1

4,04709E-1

1,24655E-1

4,47025E-2

4,46921E-2

2,75853E-2

5,01482E-3

7.4

Jarnac

1,33882E-2

1,48257E-1

8,59888E-3

7,68532E-1

7,45143E-4

6,44594E-2

1,86286E-3

4,63780E-3

5,66617E-3

1,11217E-3

4,31250E-4

4,94912E-1

4,04709E-1

1,24655E-1

4,47025E-2

4,46921E-2

2,75853E-2

5,01483E-3

7.4

MathSBML

1,33882E-2

1,48257E-1

8,59888E-3

7,68533E-1

7,45143E-4

6,44594E-2

1,86286E-3

4,63780E-3

5,66617E-3

1,11217E-3

4,31250E-4

4,94912E-1

4,04709E-1

1,24655E-1

4,47025E-2

4,46920E-2

2,75853E-2

5,01482E-3

7.4

Oscill8 Core

1,33882E-2

1,48257E-1

8,59889E-3

7,68532E-1

7,45143E-4

6,44595E-2

1,86286E-3

5,66617E-3

1,11217E-3

4,31250E-4

4,94912E-1

4,04710E-1

1,24655E-1

4,47026E-2

4,46921E-2

2,75854E-2

5,01483E-3

7.4

SBToolbox2

1,33984E-2

1,48646E-1

8,62134E-3

7,67490E-1

7,45862E-4

6,46285E-2

1,86471E-3

4,64496E-3

5,67056E-3

1,11321E-3

4,31750E-4

4,94903E-1

4,05646E-1

1,24754E-1

4,48443E-2

4,47534E-2

2,76523E-2

5,02257E-3

7.4

copasi

1,33882E-2

1,48257E-1

8,59890E-3

7,68531E-1

7,45144E-4

6,44596E-2

1,86287E-3

4,63781E-3

5,66617E-3

1,11217E-3

4,31251E-4

4,94912E-1

4,04710E-1

1,24655E-1

4,47026E-2

4,46921E-2

2,75854E-2

5,01483E-3

7.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,33882E-2

1,48257E-1

8,59888E-3

7,68532E-1

7,45143E-4

6,44594E-2

1,86286E-3

4,63780E-3

5,66617E-3

1,11217E-3

4,31250E-4

4,94912E-1

4,04709E-1

1,24655E-1

4,47025E-2

4,46921E-2

2,75853E-2

5,01483E-3

7.4

jsim

1,33882E-2

1,48257E-1

8,59888E-3

7,68532E-1

7,45143E-4

6,44594E-2

1,86286E-3

4,63780E-3

5,66617E-3

1,11217E-3

4,31250E-4

4,94912E-1

4,04709E-1

1,24655E-1

4,47025E-2

4,46921E-2

2,75853E-2

5,01483E-3

7.4

min

1,33882E-2

1,48257E-1

8,59888E-3

7,67490E-1

7,45143E-4

6,44594E-2

1,86286E-3

4,63780E-3

5,66617E-3

1,11217E-3

4,31250E-4

4,94903E-1

4,04709E-1

1,24655E-1

4,47025E-2

4,46920E-2

2,75853E-2

5,01482E-3

7.4

max

1,33984E-2

1,48646E-1

8,62134E-3

7,68533E-1

7,45862E-4

6,46285E-2

1,86471E-3

4,64496E-3

5,67056E-3

1,11321E-3

4,31750E-4

4,94912E-1

4,05646E-1

1,24754E-1

4,48443E-2

4,47534E-2

2,76523E-2

5,02257E-3

7.4

mean

1,33882E-2

1,48257E-1

8,59888E-3

7,68532E-1

7,45143E-4

6,44594E-2

1,86286E-3

4,63780E-3

5,66617E-3

1,11217E-3

4,31250E-4

4,94912E-1

4,04709E-1

1,24655E-1

4,47025E-2

4,46921E-2

2,75853E-2

5,01483E-3

7.4

relative error(%)

0,00

7.6

BioUML

1,32088E-2

1,41306E-1

8,19577E-3

7,85143E-1

7,31902E-4

6,14376E-2

1,82976E-3

4,51816E-3

5,59091E-3

1,09240E-3

4,21684E-4

4,95032E-1

3,88893E-1

1,23000E-1

4,22330E-2

4,35796E-2

2,64122E-2

4,88249E-3

7.6

ByoDyn

1,32060E-2

1,41207E-1

8,18999E-3

7,85392E-1

7,31701E-4

6,13942E-2

1,82926E-3

4,51637E-3

5,58977E-3

1,09210E-3

4,21538E-4

4,95034E-1

3,88656E-1

1,22975E-1

4,21976E-2

4,35628E-2

2,63955E-2

4,88051E-3

7.6

CVODE

1,32060E-2

1,41207E-1

8,18999E-3

7,85392E-1

7,31701E-4

6,13942E-2

1,82926E-3

4,51637E-3

5,58977E-3

1,09210E-3

4,21538E-4

4,95034E-1

3,88656E-1

1,22975E-1

4,21976E-2

4,35628E-2

2,63955E-2

4,88051E-3

7.6

Jarnac

1,32060E-2

1,41207E-1

8,18999E-3

7,85392E-1

7,31701E-4

6,13942E-2

1,82926E-3

4,51637E-3

5,58977E-3

1,09210E-3

4,21538E-4

4,95034E-1

3,88656E-1

1,22975E-1

4,21976E-2

4,35628E-2

2,63955E-2

4,88051E-3

7.6

MathSBML

1,32060E-2

1,41207E-1

8,18998E-3

7,85392E-1

7,31701E-4

6,13942E-2

1,82926E-3

4,51637E-3

5,58977E-3

1,09210E-3

4,21538E-4

4,95034E-1

3,88656E-1

1,22975E-1

4,21976E-2

4,35628E-2

2,63955E-2

4,88051E-3

7.6

Oscill8 Core

1,32060E-2

1,41207E-1

8,19000E-3

7,85391E-1

7,31701E-4

6,13943E-2

1,82926E-3

5,58978E-3

1,09210E-3

4,21538E-4

4,95034E-1

3,88656E-1

1,22975E-1

4,21977E-2

4,35628E-2

2,63955E-2

4,88051E-3

7.6

SBToolbox2

1,32151E-2

1,41571E-1

8,21101E-3

7,84632E-1

7,32406E-4

6,15522E-2

1,83102E-3

4,52228E-3

5,59351E-3

1,09316E-3

4,22070E-4

4,95030E-1

3,89438E-1

1,23061E-1

4,23206E-2

4,36213E-2

2,64558E-2

4,88699E-3

7.6

copasi

1,32060E-2

1,41207E-1

8,19000E-3

7,85391E-1

7,31701E-4

6,13943E-2

1,82926E-3

4,51637E-3

5,58978E-3

1,09210E-3

4,21539E-4

4,95034E-1

3,88657E-1

1,22975E-1

4,21977E-2

4,35628E-2

2,63955E-2

4,88051E-3

7.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,32060E-2

1,41207E-1

8,18999E-3

7,85392E-1

7,31701E-4

6,13942E-2

1,82926E-3

4,51637E-3

5,58977E-3

1,09210E-3

4,21538E-4

4,95034E-1

3,88656E-1

1,22975E-1

4,21976E-2

4,35628E-2

2,63955E-2

4,88051E-3

7.6

jsim

1,32060E-2

1,41207E-1

8,18999E-3

7,85392E-1

7,31701E-4

6,13942E-2

1,82926E-3

4,51637E-3

5,58978E-3

1,09210E-3

4,21538E-4

4,95034E-1

3,88656E-1

1,22975E-1

4,21976E-2

4,35628E-2

2,63955E-2

4,88051E-3

7.6

min

1,32060E-2

1,41207E-1

8,18998E-3

7,84632E-1

7,31701E-4

6,13942E-2

1,82926E-3

4,51637E-3

5,58977E-3

1,09210E-3

4,21538E-4

4,95030E-1

3,88656E-1

1,22975E-1

4,21976E-2

4,35628E-2

2,63955E-2

4,88051E-3

7.6

max

1,32151E-2

1,41571E-1

8,21101E-3

7,85392E-1

7,32406E-4

6,15522E-2

1,83102E-3

4,52228E-3

5,59351E-3

1,09316E-3

4,22070E-4

4,95034E-1

3,89438E-1

1,23061E-1

4,23206E-2

4,36213E-2

2,64558E-2

4,88699E-3

7.6

mean

1,32060E-2

1,41207E-1

8,18999E-3

7,85392E-1

7,31701E-4

6,13942E-2

1,82926E-3

4,51637E-3

5,58977E-3

1,09210E-3

4,21538E-4

4,95034E-1

3,88656E-1

1,22975E-1

4,21976E-2

4,35628E-2

2,63955E-2

4,88051E-3

7.6

relative error(%)

0,00

7.8

BioUML

1,30303E-2

1,34949E-1

7,82705E-3

8,01171E-1

7,18974E-4

5,86735E-2

1,79744E-3

4,40411E-3

5,51708E-3

1,07311E-3

4,12387E-4

4,95146E-1

3,73869E-1

1,21375E-1

3,99810E-2

4,25146E-2

2,53384E-2

4,75440E-3

7.8

ByoDyn

1,30274E-2

1,34849E-1

7,82127E-3

8,01425E-1

7,18769E-4

5,86302E-2

1,79693E-3

4,40230E-3

5,51597E-3

1,07280E-3

4,12236E-4

4,95148E-1

3,73631E-1

1,21351E-1

3,99466E-2

4,24979E-2

2,53218E-2

4,75247E-3

7.8

CVODE

1,30274E-2

1,34849E-1

7,82127E-3

8,01425E-1

7,18769E-4

5,86302E-2

1,79693E-3

4,40230E-3

5,51597E-3

1,07280E-3

4,12236E-4

4,95148E-1

3,73631E-1

1,21351E-1

3,99466E-2

4,24979E-2

2,53218E-2

4,75247E-3

7.8

Jarnac

1,30274E-2

1,34849E-1

7,82127E-3

8,01425E-1

7,18769E-4

5,86302E-2

1,79693E-3

4,40230E-3

5,51597E-3

1,07280E-3

4,12236E-4

4,95148E-1

3,73631E-1

1,21351E-1

3,99466E-2

4,24979E-2

2,53218E-2

4,75247E-3

7.8

MathSBML

1,30274E-2

1,34849E-1

7,82127E-3

8,01425E-1

7,18769E-4

5,86302E-2

1,79693E-3

4,40230E-3

5,51597E-3

1,07280E-3

4,12236E-4

4,95148E-1

3,73631E-1

1,21351E-1

3,99466E-2

4,24979E-2

2,53218E-2

4,75247E-3

7.8

Oscill8 Core

1,30274E-2

1,34850E-1

7,82128E-3

8,01425E-1

7,18769E-4

5,86303E-2

1,79693E-3

5,51597E-3

1,07280E-3

4,12236E-4

4,95148E-1

3,73631E-1

1,21351E-1

3,99467E-2

4,24979E-2

2,53218E-2

4,75248E-3

7.8

SBToolbox2

1,30414E-2

1,35312E-1

7,84814E-3

8,00367E-1

7,19765E-4

5,88313E-2

1,79940E-3

4,41048E-3

5,52164E-3

1,07426E-3

4,12942E-4

4,95140E-1

3,74720E-1

1,21476E-1

4,01106E-2

4,25788E-2

2,54001E-2

4,76227E-3

7.8

copasi

1,30275E-2

1,34850E-1

7,82128E-3

8,01425E-1

7,18770E-4

5,86303E-2

1,79693E-3

4,40231E-3

5,51597E-3

1,07280E-3

4,12236E-4

4,95148E-1

3,73631E-1

1,21351E-1

3,99467E-2

4,24979E-2

2,53218E-2

4,75248E-3

7.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,30274E-2

1,34849E-1

7,82127E-3

8,01425E-1

7,18769E-4

5,86302E-2

1,79693E-3

4,40230E-3

5,51597E-3

1,07280E-3

4,12236E-4

4,95148E-1

3,73631E-1

1,21351E-1

3,99466E-2

4,24979E-2

2,53218E-2

4,75247E-3

7.8

jsim

1,30274E-2

1,34849E-1

7,82127E-3

8,01425E-1

7,18770E-4

5,86302E-2

1,79693E-3

4,40231E-3

5,51597E-3

1,07280E-3

4,12236E-4

4,95148E-1

3,73631E-1

1,21351E-1

3,99466E-2

4,24979E-2

2,53218E-2

4,75248E-3

7.8

min

1,30274E-2

1,34849E-1

7,82127E-3

8,00367E-1

7,18769E-4

5,86302E-2

1,79693E-3

4,40230E-3

5,51597E-3

1,07280E-3

4,12236E-4

4,95140E-1

3,73631E-1

1,21351E-1

3,99466E-2

4,24979E-2

2,53218E-2

4,75247E-3

7.8

max

1,30414E-2

1,35312E-1

7,84814E-3

8,01425E-1

7,19765E-4

5,88313E-2

1,79940E-3

4,41048E-3

5,52164E-3

1,07426E-3

4,12942E-4

4,95148E-1

3,74720E-1

1,21476E-1

4,01106E-2

4,25788E-2

2,54001E-2

4,76227E-3

7.8

mean

1,30274E-2

1,34849E-1

7,82127E-3

8,01425E-1

7,18769E-4

5,86302E-2

1,79693E-3

4,40230E-3

5,51597E-3

1,07280E-3

4,12236E-4

4,95148E-1

3,73631E-1

1,21351E-1

3,99466E-2

4,24979E-2

2,53218E-2

4,75247E-3

7.8

relative error(%)

0,00

8.0

BioUML

1,28555E-2

1,29191E-1

7,49309E-3

8,16411E-1

7,06534E-4

5,61701E-2

1,76634E-3

4,29673E-3

5,44582E-3

1,05454E-3

4,03473E-4

4,95253E-1

3,59782E-1

1,19808E-1

3,79492E-2

4,15084E-2

2,43655E-2

4,63236E-3

8.0

ByoDyn

1,28526E-2

1,29096E-1

7,48759E-3

8,16657E-1

7,06325E-4

5,61289E-2

1,76582E-3

4,29497E-3

5,44461E-3

1,05423E-3

4,03324E-4

4,95255E-1

3,59551E-1

1,19781E-1

3,79158E-2

4,14917E-2

2,43495E-2

4,63031E-3

8.0

CVODE

1,28526E-2

1,29096E-1

7,48759E-3

8,16657E-1

7,06325E-4

5,61289E-2

1,76582E-3

4,29497E-3

5,44461E-3

1,05423E-3

4,03324E-4

4,95255E-1

3,59551E-1

1,19781E-1

3,79158E-2

4,14917E-2

2,43495E-2

4,63031E-3

8.0

Jarnac

1,28526E-2

1,29096E-1

7,48759E-3

8,16657E-1

7,06325E-4

5,61289E-2

1,76582E-3

4,29497E-3

5,44461E-3

1,05423E-3

4,03324E-4

4,95255E-1

3,59551E-1

1,19781E-1

3,79158E-2

4,14917E-2

2,43495E-2

4,63031E-3

8.0

MathSBML

1,28526E-2

1,29096E-1

7,48759E-3

8,16658E-1

7,06325E-4

5,61289E-2

1,76582E-3

4,29497E-3

5,44461E-3

1,05423E-3

4,03324E-4

4,95255E-1

3,59551E-1

1,19781E-1

3,79158E-2

4,14917E-2

2,43495E-2

4,63031E-3

8.0

Oscill8 Core

1,28526E-2

1,29097E-1

7,48760E-3

8,16657E-1

7,06325E-4

5,61289E-2

1,76582E-3

5,44461E-3

1,05423E-3

4,03324E-4

4,95255E-1

3,59551E-1

1,19781E-1

3,79159E-2

4,14917E-2

2,43495E-2

4,63031E-3

8.0

SBToolbox2

1,28654E-2

1,29498E-1

7,51112E-3

8,15588E-1

7,07248E-4

5,63050E-2

1,76810E-3

4,30266E-3

5,44990E-3

1,05562E-3

4,03976E-4

4,95250E-1

3,60564E-1

1,19896E-1

3,80590E-2

4,15652E-2

2,44180E-2

4,63930E-3

8.0

copasi

1,28526E-2

1,29097E-1

7,48760E-3

8,16657E-1

7,06325E-4

5,61289E-2

1,76582E-3

4,29497E-3

5,44461E-3

1,05423E-3

4,03324E-4

4,95255E-1

3,59551E-1

1,19781E-1

3,79159E-2

4,14917E-2

2,43495E-2

4,63031E-3

8.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,28526E-2

1,29096E-1

7,48759E-3

8,16657E-1

7,06325E-4

5,61289E-2

1,76582E-3

4,29497E-3

5,44461E-3

1,05423E-3

4,03324E-4

4,95255E-1

3,59551E-1

1,19781E-1

3,79158E-2

4,14917E-2

2,43495E-2

4,63031E-3

8.0

jsim

1,28526E-2

1,29096E-1

7,48759E-3

8,16657E-1

7,06325E-4

5,61289E-2

1,76582E-3

4,29497E-3

5,44461E-3

1,05423E-3

4,03324E-4

4,95255E-1

3,59551E-1

1,19781E-1

3,79158E-2

4,14917E-2

2,43495E-2

4,63031E-3

8.0

min

1,28526E-2

1,29096E-1

7,48759E-3

8,15588E-1

7,06325E-4

5,61289E-2

1,76582E-3

4,29497E-3

5,44461E-3

1,05423E-3

4,03324E-4

4,95250E-1

3,59551E-1

1,19781E-1

3,79158E-2

4,14917E-2

2,43495E-2

4,63031E-3

8.0

max

1,28654E-2

1,29498E-1

7,51112E-3

8,16658E-1

7,07248E-4

5,63050E-2

1,76810E-3

4,30266E-3

5,44990E-3

1,05562E-3

4,03976E-4

4,95255E-1

3,60564E-1

1,19896E-1

3,80590E-2

4,15652E-2

2,44180E-2

4,63930E-3

8.0

mean

1,28526E-2

1,29096E-1

7,48759E-3

8,16657E-1

7,06325E-4

5,61289E-2

1,76582E-3

4,29497E-3

5,44461E-3

1,05423E-3

4,03324E-4

4,95255E-1

3,59551E-1

1,19781E-1

3,79158E-2

4,14917E-2

2,43495E-2

4,63031E-3

8.0

relative error(%)

0,00

8.2

BioUML

1,26849E-2

1,23968E-1

7,19014E-3

8,30848E-1

6,94570E-4

5,38991E-2

1,73643E-3

4,19567E-3

5,37688E-3

1,03668E-3

3,94946E-4

4,95354E-1

3,46585E-1

1,18291E-1

3,61103E-2

4,05570E-2

2,34821E-2

4,51583E-3

8.2

ByoDyn

1,26817E-2

1,23873E-1

7,18465E-3

8,31113E-1

6,94348E-4

5,38579E-2

1,73587E-3

4,19382E-3

5,37560E-3

1,03635E-3

3,94787E-4

4,95356E-1

3,46343E-1

1,18263E-1

3,60771E-2

4,05395E-2

2,34661E-2

4,51368E-3

8.2

CVODE

1,26817E-2

1,23873E-1

7,18465E-3

8,31114E-1

6,94348E-4

5,38579E-2

1,73587E-3

4,19382E-3

5,37560E-3

1,03635E-3

3,94787E-4

4,95356E-1

3,46343E-1

1,18263E-1

3,60771E-2

4,05395E-2

2,34661E-2

4,51368E-3

8.2

Jarnac

1,26817E-2

1,23873E-1

7,18465E-3

8,31113E-1

6,94348E-4

5,38579E-2

1,73587E-3

4,19382E-3

5,37560E-3

1,03635E-3

3,94787E-4

4,95356E-1

3,46343E-1

1,18263E-1

3,60771E-2

4,05395E-2

2,34661E-2

4,51368E-3

8.2

MathSBML

1,26817E-2

1,23873E-1

7,18465E-3

8,31114E-1

6,94347E-4

5,38579E-2

1,73587E-3

4,19382E-3

5,37560E-3

1,03635E-3

3,94787E-4

4,95356E-1

3,46343E-1

1,18263E-1

3,60771E-2

4,05395E-2

2,34661E-2

4,51368E-3

8.2

Oscill8 Core

1,26817E-2

1,23873E-1

7,18466E-3

8,31113E-1

6,94348E-4

5,38580E-2

1,73587E-3

5,37560E-3

1,03635E-3

3,94787E-4

4,95356E-1

3,46343E-1

1,18263E-1

3,60771E-2

4,05395E-2

2,34661E-2

4,51368E-3

8.2

SBToolbox2

1,26896E-2

1,24095E-1

7,19777E-3

8,29705E-1

6,94856E-4

5,39562E-2

1,73715E-3

4,20030E-3

5,37871E-3

1,03714E-3

3,95134E-4

4,95350E-1

3,47103E-1

1,18327E-1

3,61573E-2

4,05797E-2

2,35063E-2

4,51883E-3

8.2

copasi

1,26817E-2

1,23873E-1

7,18465E-3

8,31113E-1

6,94348E-4

5,38580E-2

1,73587E-3

4,19382E-3

5,37560E-3

1,03635E-3

3,94787E-4

4,95356E-1

3,46343E-1

1,18263E-1

3,60771E-2

4,05395E-2

2,34661E-2

4,51368E-3

8.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,26817E-2

1,23873E-1

7,18465E-3

8,31113E-1

6,94348E-4

5,38579E-2

1,73587E-3

4,19382E-3

5,37560E-3

1,03635E-3

3,94787E-4

4,95356E-1

3,46343E-1

1,18263E-1

3,60771E-2

4,05395E-2

2,34661E-2

4,51368E-3

8.2

jsim

1,26817E-2

1,23873E-1

7,18465E-3

8,31113E-1

6,94348E-4

5,38579E-2

1,73588E-3

4,19382E-3

5,37560E-3

1,03635E-3

3,94787E-4

4,95356E-1

3,46343E-1

1,18263E-1

3,60770E-2

4,05395E-2

2,34661E-2

4,51368E-3

8.2

min

1,26817E-2

1,23873E-1

7,18465E-3

8,29705E-1

6,94347E-4

5,38579E-2

1,73587E-3

4,19382E-3

5,37560E-3

1,03635E-3

3,94787E-4

4,95350E-1

3,46343E-1

1,18263E-1

3,60770E-2

4,05395E-2

2,34661E-2

4,51368E-3

8.2

max

1,26896E-2

1,24095E-1

7,19777E-3

8,31114E-1

6,94856E-4

5,39562E-2

1,73715E-3

4,20030E-3

5,37871E-3

1,03714E-3

3,95134E-4

4,95356E-1

3,47103E-1

1,18327E-1

3,61573E-2

4,05797E-2

2,35063E-2

4,51883E-3

8.2

mean

1,26817E-2

1,23873E-1

7,18465E-3

8,31113E-1

6,94348E-4

5,38579E-2

1,73587E-3

4,19382E-3

5,37560E-3

1,03635E-3

3,94787E-4

4,95356E-1

3,46343E-1

1,18263E-1

3,60771E-2

4,05395E-2

2,34661E-2

4,51368E-3

8.2

relative error(%)

0,00

8.4

BioUML

1,25181E-2

1,19209E-1

6,91411E-3

8,44550E-1

6,83049E-4

5,18299E-2

1,70763E-3

4,10024E-3

5,31016E-3

1,01949E-3

3,86772E-4

4,95450E-1

3,34186E-1

1,16823E-1

3,44388E-2

3,96550E-2

2,26765E-2

4,40445E-3

8.4

ByoDyn

1,25148E-2

1,19117E-1

6,90881E-3

8,44818E-1

6,82820E-4

5,17902E-2

1,70706E-3

4,09837E-3

5,30884E-3

1,01915E-3

3,86609E-4

4,95452E-1

3,33943E-1

1,16794E-1

3,44068E-2

3,96372E-2

2,26611E-2

4,40227E-3

8.4

CVODE

1,25148E-2

1,19117E-1

6,90881E-3

8,44818E-1

6,82820E-4

5,17902E-2

1,70706E-3

4,09837E-3

5,30884E-3

1,01915E-3

3,86609E-4

4,95452E-1

3,33943E-1

1,16794E-1

3,44068E-2

3,96372E-2

2,26611E-2

4,40227E-3

8.4

Jarnac

1,25148E-2

1,19117E-1

6,90881E-3

8,44818E-1

6,82820E-4

5,17902E-2

1,70706E-3

4,09837E-3

5,30884E-3

1,01915E-3

3,86609E-4

4,95452E-1

3,33943E-1

1,16794E-1

3,44068E-2

3,96372E-2

2,26611E-2

4,40227E-3

8.4

MathSBML

1,25148E-2

1,19117E-1

6,90881E-3

8,44819E-1

6,82820E-4

5,17902E-2

1,70706E-3

4,09837E-3

5,30884E-3

1,01915E-3

3,86609E-4

4,95452E-1

3,33943E-1

1,16794E-1

3,44068E-2

3,96372E-2

2,26611E-2

4,40227E-3

8.4

Oscill8 Core

1,25148E-2

1,19117E-1

6,90881E-3

8,44818E-1

6,82820E-4

5,17902E-2

1,70706E-3

5,30884E-3

1,01915E-3

3,86609E-4

4,95452E-1

3,33943E-1

1,16794E-1

3,44069E-2

3,96372E-2

2,26611E-2

4,40227E-3

8.4

SBToolbox2

1,25297E-2

1,19535E-1

6,93310E-3

8,44710E-1

6,83920E-4

5,19723E-2

1,70978E-3

4,10378E-3

5,31499E-3

1,02077E-3

3,87406E-4

4,95450E-1

3,34784E-1

1,16929E-1

3,45515E-2

3,97230E-2

2,27301E-2

4,41245E-3

8.4

copasi

1,25148E-2

1,19117E-1

6,90881E-3

8,44818E-1

6,82820E-4

5,17902E-2

1,70706E-3

4,09837E-3

5,30884E-3

1,01915E-3

3,86609E-4

4,95452E-1

3,33943E-1

1,16794E-1

3,44068E-2

3,96372E-2

2,26611E-2

4,40227E-3

8.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,25148E-2

1,19117E-1

6,90881E-3

8,44818E-1

6,82820E-4

5,17902E-2

1,70706E-3

4,09837E-3

5,30884E-3

1,01915E-3

3,86609E-4

4,95452E-1

3,33943E-1

1,16794E-1

3,44068E-2

3,96372E-2

2,26611E-2

4,40227E-3

8.4

jsim

1,25148E-2

1,19117E-1

6,90881E-3

8,44818E-1

6,82821E-4

5,17902E-2

1,70706E-3

4,09837E-3

5,30885E-3

1,01915E-3

3,86610E-4

4,95452E-1

3,33943E-1

1,16794E-1

3,44068E-2

3,96372E-2

2,26611E-2

4,40227E-3

8.4

min

1,25148E-2

1,19117E-1

6,90881E-3

8,44710E-1

6,82820E-4

5,17902E-2

1,70706E-3

4,09837E-3

5,30884E-3

1,01915E-3

3,86609E-4

4,95450E-1

3,33943E-1

1,16794E-1

3,44068E-2

3,96372E-2

2,26611E-2

4,40227E-3

8.4

max

1,25297E-2

1,19535E-1

6,93310E-3

8,44819E-1

6,83920E-4

5,19723E-2

1,70978E-3

4,10378E-3

5,31499E-3

1,02077E-3

3,87406E-4

4,95452E-1

3,34784E-1

1,16929E-1

3,45515E-2

3,97230E-2

2,27301E-2

4,41245E-3

8.4

mean

1,25148E-2

1,19117E-1

6,90881E-3

8,44818E-1

6,82820E-4

5,17902E-2

1,70706E-3

4,09837E-3

5,30884E-3

1,01915E-3

3,86609E-4

4,95452E-1

3,33943E-1

1,16794E-1

3,44068E-2

3,96372E-2

2,26611E-2

4,40227E-3

8.4

relative error(%)

0,00

8.6

BioUML

1,23553E-2

1,14854E-1

6,66155E-3

8,57561E-1

6,71934E-4

4,99366E-2

1,67984E-3

4,00987E-3

5,24547E-3

1,00290E-3

3,78923E-4

4,95540E-1

3,22509E-1

1,15400E-1

3,29129E-2

3,87973E-2

2,19390E-2

4,29780E-3

8.6

ByoDyn

1,23522E-2

1,14775E-1

6,65697E-3

8,57798E-1

6,71727E-4

4,99024E-2

1,67932E-3

4,00821E-3

5,24427E-3

1,00259E-3

3,78778E-4

4,95542E-1

3,22293E-1

1,15374E-1

3,28852E-2

3,87814E-2

2,19257E-2

4,29582E-3

8.6

CVODE

1,23522E-2

1,14775E-1

6,65697E-3

8,57798E-1

6,71727E-4

4,99024E-2

1,67932E-3

4,00820E-3

5,24427E-3

1,00259E-3

3,78778E-4

4,95542E-1

3,22293E-1

1,15374E-1

3,28852E-2

3,87814E-2

2,19257E-2

4,29582E-3

8.6

Jarnac

1,23522E-2

1,14775E-1

6,65697E-3

8,57798E-1

6,71727E-4

4,99024E-2

1,67932E-3

4,00821E-3

5,24427E-3

1,00259E-3

3,78778E-4

4,95542E-1

3,22293E-1

1,15374E-1

3,28852E-2

3,87814E-2

2,19257E-2

4,29582E-3

8.6

MathSBML

1,23522E-2

1,14775E-1

6,65697E-3

8,57798E-1

6,71727E-4

4,99023E-2

1,67932E-3

4,00820E-3

5,24427E-3

1,00259E-3

3,78778E-4

4,95542E-1

3,22293E-1

1,15373E-1

3,28852E-2

3,87814E-2

2,19257E-2

4,29582E-3

8.6

Oscill8 Core

1,23522E-2

1,14775E-1

6,65698E-3

8,57798E-1

6,71728E-4

4,99024E-2

1,67932E-3

5,24427E-3

1,00259E-3

3,78778E-4

4,95542E-1

3,22294E-1

1,15374E-1

3,28853E-2

3,87814E-2

2,19257E-2

4,29582E-3

8.6

SBToolbox2

1,23647E-2

1,15088E-1

6,67525E-3

8,56682E-1

6,72559E-4

5,00391E-2

1,68139E-3

4,01524E-3

5,24924E-3

1,00387E-3

3,79351E-4

4,95531E-1

3,23195E-1

1,15480E-1

3,29969E-2

3,88457E-2

2,19797E-2

4,30403E-3

8.6

copasi

1,23522E-2

1,14775E-1

6,65697E-3

8,57798E-1

6,71727E-4

4,99023E-2

1,67932E-3

4,00820E-3

5,24427E-3

1,00259E-3

3,78778E-4

4,95542E-1

3,22293E-1

1,15373E-1

3,28852E-2

3,87813E-2

2,19257E-2

4,29582E-3

8.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,23522E-2

1,14775E-1

6,65697E-3

8,57798E-1

6,71727E-4

4,99024E-2

1,67932E-3

4,00821E-3

5,24427E-3

1,00259E-3

3,78778E-4

4,95542E-1

3,22293E-1

1,15374E-1

3,28852E-2

3,87814E-2

2,19257E-2

4,29582E-3

8.6

jsim

1,23522E-2

1,14775E-1

6,65697E-3

8,57798E-1

6,71728E-4

4,99024E-2

1,67933E-3

4,00821E-3

5,24427E-3

1,00259E-3

3,78778E-4

4,95542E-1

3,22294E-1

1,15374E-1

3,28852E-2

3,87814E-2

2,19257E-2

4,29582E-3

8.6

min

1,23522E-2

1,14775E-1

6,65697E-3

8,56682E-1

6,71727E-4

4,99023E-2

1,67932E-3

4,00820E-3

5,24427E-3

1,00259E-3

3,78778E-4

4,95531E-1

3,22293E-1

1,15373E-1

3,28852E-2

3,87813E-2

2,19257E-2

4,29582E-3

8.6

max

1,23647E-2

1,15088E-1

6,67525E-3

8,57798E-1

6,72559E-4

5,00391E-2

1,68139E-3

4,01524E-3

5,24924E-3

1,00387E-3

3,79351E-4

4,95542E-1

3,23195E-1

1,15480E-1

3,29969E-2

3,88457E-2

2,19797E-2

4,30403E-3

8.6

mean

1,23522E-2

1,14775E-1

6,65697E-3

8,57798E-1

6,71727E-4

4,99024E-2

1,67932E-3

4,00821E-3

5,24427E-3

1,00259E-3

3,78778E-4

4,95542E-1

3,22293E-1

1,15374E-1

3,28852E-2

3,87814E-2

2,19257E-2

4,29582E-3

8.6

relative error(%)

0,00

8.8

BioUML

1,21970E-2

1,10878E-1

6,43094E-3

8,69841E-1

6,61267E-4

4,82079E-2

1,65317E-3

3,92463E-3

5,18310E-3

9,86977E-4

3,71423E-4

4,95625E-1

3,11556E-1

1,14028E-1

3,15228E-2

3,79850E-2

2,12653E-2

4,19620E-3

8.8

ByoDyn

1,21938E-2

1,10802E-1

6,42650E-3

8,70078E-1

6,61055E-4

4,81746E-2

1,65264E-3

3,92296E-3

5,18180E-3

9,86660E-4

3,71279E-4

4,95627E-1

3,11342E-1

1,13999E-1

3,14953E-2

3,79689E-2

2,12521E-2

4,19410E-3

8.8

CVODE

1,21938E-2

1,10802E-1

6,42649E-3

8,70078E-1

6,61055E-4

4,81746E-2

1,65264E-3

3,92296E-3

5,18180E-3

9,86660E-4

3,71279E-4

4,95627E-1

3,11342E-1

1,13999E-1

3,14953E-2

3,79689E-2

2,12521E-2

4,19410E-3

8.8

Jarnac

1,21938E-2

1,10802E-1

6,42650E-3

8,70078E-1

6,61055E-4

4,81746E-2

1,65264E-3

3,92296E-3

5,18180E-3

9,86660E-4

3,71279E-4

4,95627E-1

3,11342E-1

1,13999E-1

3,14953E-2

3,79689E-2

2,12521E-2

4,19410E-3

8.8

MathSBML

1,21938E-2

1,10802E-1

6,42649E-3

8,70078E-1

6,61055E-4

4,81746E-2

1,65264E-3

3,92296E-3

5,18180E-3

9,86660E-4

3,71279E-4

4,95627E-1

3,11342E-1

1,13999E-1

3,14953E-2

3,79689E-2

2,12521E-2

4,19410E-3

8.8

Oscill8 Core

1,21938E-2

1,10802E-1

6,42650E-3

8,70078E-1

6,61055E-4

4,81746E-2

1,65264E-3

5,18180E-3

9,86660E-4

3,71279E-4

4,95627E-1

3,11342E-1

1,13999E-1

3,14953E-2

3,79689E-2

2,12521E-2

4,19410E-3

8.8

SBToolbox2

1,22050E-2

1,11058E-1

6,44144E-3

8,69248E-1

6,61780E-4

4,82865E-2

1,65446E-3

3,92856E-3

5,18614E-3

9,87741E-4

3,71779E-4

4,95621E-1

3,12064E-1

1,14093E-1

3,15872E-2

3,80234E-2

2,12963E-2

4,20112E-3

8.8

copasi

1,21938E-2

1,10802E-1

6,42649E-3

8,70078E-1

6,61055E-4

4,81746E-2

1,65264E-3

3,92296E-3

5,18180E-3

9,86660E-4

3,71279E-4

4,95627E-1

3,11342E-1

1,13999E-1

3,14953E-2

3,79689E-2

2,12521E-2

4,19409E-3

8.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,21938E-2

1,10802E-1

6,42650E-3

8,70078E-1

6,61055E-4

4,81746E-2

1,65264E-3

3,92296E-3

5,18180E-3

9,86660E-4

3,71279E-4

4,95627E-1

3,11342E-1

1,13999E-1

3,14953E-2

3,79689E-2

2,12521E-2

4,19410E-3

8.8

jsim

1,21938E-2

1,10802E-1

6,42650E-3

8,70078E-1

6,61055E-4

4,81746E-2

1,65264E-3

3,92296E-3

5,18181E-3

9,86661E-4

3,71279E-4

4,95627E-1

3,11342E-1

1,13999E-1

3,14953E-2

3,79689E-2

2,12521E-2

4,19410E-3

8.8

min

1,21938E-2

1,10802E-1

6,42649E-3

8,69248E-1

6,61055E-4

4,81746E-2

1,65264E-3

3,92296E-3

5,18180E-3

9,86660E-4

3,71279E-4

4,95621E-1

3,11342E-1

1,13999E-1

3,14953E-2

3,79689E-2

2,12521E-2

4,19409E-3

8.8

max

1,22050E-2

1,11058E-1

6,44144E-3

8,70078E-1

6,61780E-4

4,82865E-2

1,65446E-3

3,92856E-3

5,18614E-3

9,87741E-4

3,71779E-4

4,95627E-1

3,12064E-1

1,14093E-1

3,15872E-2

3,80234E-2

2,12963E-2

4,20112E-3

8.8

mean

1,21938E-2

1,10802E-1

6,42650E-3

8,70078E-1

6,61055E-4

4,81746E-2

1,65264E-3

3,92296E-3

5,18180E-3

9,86660E-4

3,71279E-4

4,95627E-1

3,11342E-1

1,13999E-1

3,14953E-2

3,79689E-2

2,12521E-2

4,19410E-3

8.8

relative error(%)

0,00

9.0

BioUML

1,20436E-2

1,07239E-1

6,21989E-3

8,81422E-1

6,51028E-4

4,66258E-2

1,62758E-3

3,84417E-3

5,12281E-3

9,71695E-4

3,64267E-4

4,95706E-1

3,01281E-1

1,12702E-1

3,02515E-2

3,72150E-2

2,06478E-2

4,09914E-3

9.0

ByoDyn

1,20399E-2

1,07157E-1

6,21508E-3

8,81685E-1

6,50789E-4

4,65898E-2

1,62698E-3

3,84230E-3

5,12140E-3

9,71339E-4

3,64101E-4

4,95708E-1

3,01041E-1

1,12670E-1

3,02225E-2

3,71971E-2

2,06338E-2

4,09688E-3

9.0

CVODE

1,20399E-2

1,07157E-1

6,21508E-3

8,81685E-1

6,50789E-4

4,65898E-2

1,62698E-3

3,84230E-3

5,12140E-3

9,71339E-4

3,64101E-4

4,95708E-1

3,01041E-1

1,12670E-1

3,02225E-2

3,71971E-2

2,06338E-2

4,09688E-3

9.0

Jarnac

1,20399E-2

1,07157E-1

6,21508E-3

8,81685E-1

6,50789E-4

4,65898E-2

1,62698E-3

3,84230E-3

5,12140E-3

9,71339E-4

3,64101E-4

4,95708E-1

3,01041E-1

1,12670E-1

3,02225E-2

3,71971E-2

2,06338E-2

4,09688E-3

9.0

MathSBML

1,20399E-2

1,07157E-1

6,21508E-3

8,81685E-1

6,50789E-4

4,65898E-2

1,62698E-3

3,84230E-3

5,12140E-3

9,71338E-4

3,64101E-4

4,95708E-1

3,01041E-1

1,12670E-1

3,02225E-2

3,71971E-2

2,06338E-2

4,09688E-3

9.0

Oscill8 Core

1,20399E-2

1,07157E-1

6,21509E-3

8,81685E-1

6,50790E-4

4,65898E-2

1,62698E-3

5,12140E-3

9,71339E-4

3,64101E-4

4,95708E-1

3,01041E-1

1,12670E-1

3,02225E-2

3,71971E-2

2,06338E-2

4,09688E-3

9.0

SBToolbox2

1,20483E-2

1,07363E-1

6,22701E-3

8,80810E-1

6,51333E-4

4,66787E-2

1,62838E-3

3,84721E-3

5,12433E-3

9,72150E-4

3,64497E-4

4,95701E-1

3,01622E-1

1,12734E-1

3,02892E-2

3,72375E-2

2,06681E-2

4,10157E-3

9.0

copasi

1,20399E-2

1,07156E-1

6,21508E-3

8,81685E-1

6,50789E-4

4,65898E-2

1,62698E-3

3,84229E-3

5,12140E-3

9,71338E-4

3,64101E-4

4,95708E-1

3,01041E-1

1,12670E-1

3,02225E-2

3,71971E-2

2,06337E-2

4,09688E-3

9.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,20399E-2

1,07157E-1

6,21508E-3

8,81685E-1

6,50789E-4

4,65898E-2

1,62698E-3

3,84230E-3

5,12140E-3

9,71339E-4

3,64101E-4

4,95708E-1

3,01041E-1

1,12670E-1

3,02225E-2

3,71971E-2

2,06338E-2

4,09688E-3

9.0

jsim

1,20399E-2

1,07157E-1

6,21508E-3

8,81685E-1

6,50790E-4

4,65898E-2

1,62698E-3

3,84230E-3

5,12140E-3

9,71339E-4

3,64101E-4

4,95708E-1

3,01041E-1

1,12670E-1

3,02225E-2

3,71971E-2

2,06338E-2

4,09688E-3

9.0

min

1,20399E-2

1,07156E-1

6,21508E-3

8,80810E-1

6,50789E-4

4,65898E-2

1,62698E-3

3,84229E-3

5,12140E-3

9,71338E-4

3,64101E-4

4,95701E-1

3,01041E-1

1,12670E-1

3,02225E-2

3,71971E-2

2,06337E-2

4,09688E-3

9.0

max

1,20483E-2

1,07363E-1

6,22701E-3

8,81685E-1

6,51333E-4

4,66787E-2

1,62838E-3

3,84721E-3

5,12433E-3

9,72150E-4

3,64497E-4

4,95708E-1

3,01622E-1

1,12734E-1

3,02892E-2

3,72375E-2

2,06681E-2

4,10157E-3

9.0

mean

1,20399E-2

1,07157E-1

6,21508E-3

8,81685E-1

6,50789E-4

4,65898E-2

1,62698E-3

3,84230E-3

5,12140E-3

9,71339E-4

3,64101E-4

4,95708E-1

3,01041E-1

1,12670E-1

3,02225E-2

3,71971E-2

2,06338E-2

4,09688E-3

9.0

relative error(%)

0,00

9.2

BioUML

1,18944E-2

1,03893E-1

6,02578E-3

8,92364E-1

6,41182E-4

4,51708E-2

1,60296E-3

3,76792E-3

5,06456E-3

9,56999E-4

3,57415E-4

4,95782E-1

2,91602E-1

1,11420E-1

2,90845E-2

3,64831E-2

2,00797E-2

4,00645E-3

9.2

ByoDyn

1,18904E-2

1,03806E-1

6,02075E-3

8,92646E-1

6,40918E-4

4,51331E-2

1,60230E-3

3,76592E-3

5,06300E-3

9,56605E-4

3,57231E-4

4,95784E-1

2,91348E-1

1,11386E-1

2,90543E-2

3,64635E-2

2,00650E-2

4,00398E-3

9.2

CVODE

1,18904E-2

1,03806E-1

6,02075E-3

8,92646E-1

6,40918E-4

4,51331E-2

1,60230E-3

3,76592E-3

5,06299E-3

9,56605E-4

3,57231E-4

4,95784E-1

2,91348E-1

1,11386E-1

2,90543E-2

3,64635E-2

2,00650E-2

4,00398E-3

9.2

Jarnac

1,18904E-2

1,03806E-1

6,02075E-3

8,92646E-1

6,40918E-4

4,51331E-2

1,60230E-3

3,76592E-3

5,06300E-3

9,56605E-4

3,57231E-4

4,95784E-1

2,91348E-1

1,11386E-1

2,90543E-2

3,64635E-2

2,00650E-2

4,00398E-3

9.2

MathSBML

1,18904E-2

1,03806E-1

6,02075E-3

8,92646E-1

6,40918E-4

4,51331E-2

1,60230E-3

3,76592E-3

5,06299E-3

9,56605E-4

3,57231E-4

4,95784E-1

2,91348E-1

1,11386E-1

2,90542E-2

3,64635E-2

2,00650E-2

4,00397E-3

9.2

Oscill8 Core

1,18904E-2

1,03806E-1

6,02075E-3

8,92646E-1

6,40918E-4

4,51331E-2

1,60230E-3

5,06300E-3

9,56605E-4

3,57231E-4

4,95784E-1

2,91348E-1

1,11386E-1

2,90543E-2

3,64635E-2

2,00650E-2

4,00398E-3

9.2

SBToolbox2

1,19024E-2

1,04087E-1

6,03687E-3

8,91731E-1

6,41732E-4

4,52536E-2

1,60430E-3

3,77251E-3

5,06757E-3

9,57822E-4

3,57814E-4

4,95780E-1

2,92153E-1

1,11485E-1

2,91466E-2

3,65232E-2

2,01109E-2

4,01114E-3

9.2

copasi

1,18904E-2

1,03806E-1

6,02074E-3

8,92647E-1

6,40918E-4

4,51330E-2

1,60230E-3

3,76592E-3

5,06299E-3

9,56604E-4

3,57231E-4

4,95784E-1

2,91348E-1

1,11385E-1

2,90542E-2

3,64635E-2

2,00650E-2

4,00397E-3

9.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,18904E-2

1,03806E-1

6,02075E-3

8,92646E-1

6,40918E-4

4,51331E-2

1,60230E-3

3,76592E-3

5,06300E-3

9,56605E-4

3,57231E-4

4,95784E-1

2,91348E-1

1,11386E-1

2,90543E-2

3,64635E-2

2,00650E-2

4,00398E-3

9.2

jsim

1,18904E-2

1,03806E-1

6,02075E-3

8,92646E-1

6,40918E-4

4,51331E-2

1,60230E-3

3,76592E-3

5,06300E-3

9,56605E-4

3,57231E-4

4,95784E-1

2,91348E-1

1,11386E-1

2,90543E-2

3,64635E-2

2,00650E-2

4,00398E-3

9.2

min

1,18904E-2

1,03806E-1

6,02074E-3

8,91731E-1

6,40918E-4

4,51330E-2

1,60230E-3

3,76592E-3

5,06299E-3

9,56604E-4

3,57231E-4

4,95780E-1

2,91348E-1

1,11385E-1

2,90542E-2

3,64635E-2

2,00650E-2

4,00397E-3

9.2

max

1,19024E-2

1,04087E-1

6,03687E-3

8,92647E-1

6,41732E-4

4,52536E-2

1,60430E-3

3,77251E-3

5,06757E-3

9,57822E-4

3,57814E-4

4,95784E-1

2,92153E-1

1,11485E-1

2,91466E-2

3,65232E-2

2,01109E-2

4,01114E-3

9.2

mean

1,18904E-2

1,03806E-1

6,02075E-3

8,92646E-1

6,40918E-4

4,51331E-2

1,60230E-3

3,76592E-3

5,06300E-3

9,56605E-4

3,57231E-4

4,95784E-1

2,91348E-1

1,11386E-1

2,90543E-2

3,64635E-2

2,00650E-2

4,00398E-3

9.2

relative error(%)

0,00

9.4

BioUML

1,17496E-2

1,00808E-1

5,84685E-3

9,02703E-1

6,31698E-4

4,38295E-2

1,57925E-3

3,69561E-3

5,00816E-3

9,42844E-4

3,50845E-4

4,95854E-1

2,82483E-1

1,10179E-1

2,80101E-2

3,57858E-2

1,95557E-2

3,91771E-3

9.4

ByoDyn

1,17453E-2

1,00720E-1

5,84177E-3

9,02989E-1

6,31428E-4

4,37914E-2

1,57858E-3

3,69356E-3

5,00654E-3

9,42441E-4

3,50659E-4

4,95856E-1

2,82223E-1

1,10144E-1

2,79797E-2

3,57659E-2

1,95407E-2

3,91519E-3

9.4

CVODE

1,17453E-2

1,00720E-1

5,84177E-3

9,02989E-1

6,31428E-4

4,37913E-2

1,57858E-3

3,69356E-3

5,00654E-3

9,42441E-4

3,50659E-4

4,95856E-1

2,82223E-1

1,10144E-1

2,79797E-2

3,57659E-2

1,95407E-2

3,91519E-3

9.4

Jarnac

1,17453E-2

1,00720E-1

5,84177E-3

9,02989E-1

6,31428E-4

4,37914E-2

1,57858E-3

3,69356E-3

5,00654E-3

9,42441E-4

3,50659E-4

4,95856E-1

2,82223E-1

1,10144E-1

2,79797E-2

3,57659E-2

1,95407E-2

3,91519E-3

9.4

MathSBML

1,17453E-2

1,00720E-1

5,84176E-3

9,02989E-1

6,31428E-4

4,37913E-2

1,57858E-3

3,69355E-3

5,00654E-3

9,42441E-4

3,50659E-4

4,95856E-1

2,82223E-1

1,10144E-1

2,79796E-2

3,57659E-2

1,95407E-2

3,91518E-3

9.4

Oscill8 Core

1,17453E-2

1,00720E-1

5,84177E-3

9,02989E-1

6,31428E-4

4,37914E-2

1,57858E-3

5,00654E-3

9,42441E-4

3,50659E-4

4,95856E-1

2,82223E-1

1,10144E-1

2,79797E-2

3,57659E-2

1,95407E-2

3,91519E-3

9.4

SBToolbox2

1,17616E-2

1,01043E-1

5,86058E-3

9,01981E-1

6,32489E-4

4,39328E-2

1,58125E-3

3,70139E-3

5,01297E-3

9,44028E-4

3,51385E-4

4,95850E-1

2,83216E-1

1,10287E-1

2,80945E-2

3,58434E-2

1,95958E-2

3,92521E-3

9.4

copasi

1,17453E-2

1,00720E-1

5,84176E-3

9,02989E-1

6,31428E-4

4,37913E-2

1,57857E-3

3,69355E-3

5,00654E-3

9,42440E-4

3,50658E-4

4,95856E-1

2,82222E-1

1,10144E-1

2,79796E-2

3,57659E-2

1,95407E-2

3,91518E-3

9.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,17453E-2

1,00720E-1

5,84177E-3

9,02989E-1

6,31428E-4

4,37914E-2

1,57858E-3

3,69356E-3

5,00654E-3

9,42441E-4

3,50659E-4

4,95856E-1

2,82223E-1

1,10144E-1

2,79797E-2

3,57659E-2

1,95407E-2

3,91519E-3

9.4

jsim

1,17453E-2

1,00720E-1

5,84177E-3

9,02988E-1

6,31429E-4

4,37914E-2

1,57858E-3

3,69356E-3

5,00654E-3

9,42441E-4

3,50659E-4

4,95856E-1

2,82223E-1

1,10144E-1

2,79796E-2

3,57659E-2

1,95407E-2

3,91519E-3

9.4

min

1,17453E-2

1,00720E-1

5,84176E-3

9,01981E-1

6,31428E-4

4,37913E-2

1,57857E-3

3,69355E-3

5,00654E-3

9,42440E-4

3,50658E-4

4,95850E-1

2,82222E-1

1,10144E-1

2,79796E-2

3,57659E-2

1,95407E-2

3,91518E-3

9.4

max

1,17616E-2

1,01043E-1

5,86058E-3

9,02989E-1

6,32489E-4

4,39328E-2

1,58125E-3

3,70139E-3

5,01297E-3

9,44028E-4

3,51385E-4

4,95856E-1

2,83216E-1

1,10287E-1

2,80945E-2

3,58434E-2

1,95958E-2

3,92521E-3

9.4

mean

1,17453E-2

1,00720E-1

5,84177E-3

9,02989E-1

6,31428E-4

4,37914E-2

1,57858E-3

3,69356E-3

5,00654E-3

9,42441E-4

3,50659E-4

4,95856E-1

2,82223E-1

1,10144E-1

2,79797E-2

3,57659E-2

1,95407E-2

3,91519E-3

9.4

relative error(%)

0,00

9.6

BioUML

1,16090E-2

9,79559E-2

5,68144E-3

9,12456E-1

6,22582E-4

4,25895E-2

1,55646E-3

3,62699E-3

4,95366E-3

9,29237E-4

3,44558E-4

4,95923E-1

2,73882E-1

1,08980E-1

2,70184E-2

3,51221E-2

1,90709E-2

3,83291E-3

9.6

ByoDyn

1,16048E-2

9,78725E-2

5,67660E-3

9,12740E-1

6,22308E-4

4,25532E-2

1,55577E-3

3,62495E-3

4,95199E-3

9,28828E-4

3,44371E-4

4,95925E-1

2,73628E-1

1,08943E-1

2,69892E-2

3,51022E-2

1,90566E-2

3,83033E-3

9.6

CVODE

1,16048E-2

9,78725E-2

5,67660E-3

9,12740E-1

6,22308E-4

4,25532E-2

1,55577E-3

3,62495E-3

4,95199E-3

9,28828E-4

3,44371E-4

4,95925E-1

2,73628E-1

1,08943E-1

2,69892E-2

3,51022E-2

1,90566E-2

3,83033E-3

9.6

Jarnac

1,16048E-2

9,78725E-2

5,67660E-3

9,12740E-1

6,22308E-4

4,25532E-2

1,55577E-3

3,62495E-3

4,95199E-3

9,28828E-4

3,44371E-4

4,95925E-1

2,73628E-1

1,08943E-1

2,69892E-2

3,51022E-2

1,90566E-2

3,83033E-3

9.6

MathSBML

1,16048E-2

9,78724E-2

5,67660E-3

9,12740E-1

6,22308E-4

4,25532E-2

1,55577E-3

3,62495E-3

4,95199E-3

9,28828E-4

3,44371E-4

4,95925E-1

2,73628E-1

1,08943E-1

2,69891E-2

3,51022E-2

1,90566E-2

3,83033E-3

9.6

Oscill8 Core

1,16048E-2

9,78725E-2

5,67660E-3

9,12740E-1

6,22308E-4

4,25533E-2

1,55577E-3

4,95199E-3

9,28828E-4

3,44372E-4

4,95925E-1

2,73628E-1

1,08943E-1

2,69892E-2

3,51022E-2

1,90566E-2

3,83033E-3

9.6

SBToolbox2

1,16227E-2

9,82383E-2

5,69777E-3

9,11488E-1

6,23472E-4

4,27125E-2

1,55866E-3

3,63348E-3

4,95889E-3

9,30563E-4

3,45178E-4

4,95920E-1

2,74694E-1

1,09098E-1

2,71141E-2

3,51867E-2

1,91190E-2

3,84094E-3

9.6

copasi

1,16048E-2

9,78723E-2

5,67659E-3

9,12741E-1

6,22307E-4

4,25532E-2

1,55577E-3

3,62495E-3

4,95199E-3

9,28827E-4

3,44371E-4

4,95925E-1

2,73628E-1

1,08943E-1

2,69891E-2

3,51022E-2

1,90566E-2

3,83033E-3

9.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,16048E-2

9,78725E-2

5,67660E-3

9,12740E-1

6,22308E-4

4,25532E-2

1,55577E-3

3,62495E-3

4,95199E-3

9,28828E-4

3,44371E-4

4,95925E-1

2,73628E-1

1,08943E-1

2,69892E-2

3,51022E-2

1,90566E-2

3,83033E-3

9.6

jsim

1,16048E-2

9,78725E-2

5,67660E-3

9,12740E-1

6,22308E-4

4,25532E-2

1,55578E-3

3,62495E-3

4,95199E-3

9,28828E-4

3,44372E-4

4,95925E-1

2,73628E-1

1,08944E-1

2,69891E-2

3,51022E-2

1,90566E-2

3,83033E-3

9.6

min

1,16048E-2

9,78723E-2

5,67659E-3

9,11488E-1

6,22307E-4

4,25532E-2

1,55577E-3

3,62495E-3

4,95199E-3

9,28827E-4

3,44371E-4

4,95920E-1

2,73628E-1

1,08943E-1

2,69891E-2

3,51022E-2

1,90566E-2

3,83033E-3

9.6

max

1,16227E-2

9,82383E-2

5,69777E-3

9,12741E-1

6,23472E-4

4,27125E-2

1,55866E-3

3,63348E-3

4,95889E-3

9,30563E-4

3,45178E-4

4,95925E-1

2,74694E-1

1,09098E-1

2,71141E-2

3,51867E-2

1,91190E-2

3,84094E-3

9.6

mean

1,16048E-2

9,78725E-2

5,67660E-3

9,12740E-1

6,22308E-4

4,25532E-2

1,55577E-3

3,62495E-3

4,95199E-3

9,28828E-4

3,44371E-4

4,95925E-1

2,73628E-1

1,08943E-1

2,69892E-2

3,51022E-2

1,90566E-2

3,83033E-3

9.6

relative error(%)

0,00

9.8

BioUML

1,14726E-2

9,53138E-2

5,52820E-3

9,21660E-1

6,13795E-4

4,14408E-2

1,53449E-3

3,56175E-3

4,90083E-3

9,16122E-4

3,38528E-4

4,95988E-1

2,65762E-1

1,07818E-1

2,61003E-2

3,44886E-2

1,86214E-2

3,75160E-3

9.8

ByoDyn

1,14686E-2

9,52400E-2

5,52392E-3

9,21928E-1

6,13544E-4

4,14087E-2

1,53386E-3

3,55988E-3

4,89929E-3

9,15748E-4

3,38358E-4

4,95990E-1

2,65529E-1

1,07784E-1

2,60744E-2

3,44706E-2

1,86088E-2

3,74924E-3

9.8

CVODE

1,14686E-2

9,52400E-2

5,52392E-3

9,21928E-1

6,13544E-4

4,14087E-2

1,53386E-3

3,55988E-3

4,89929E-3

9,15748E-4

3,38358E-4

4,95990E-1

2,65529E-1

1,07784E-1

2,60744E-2

3,44706E-2

1,86088E-2

3,74924E-3

9.8

Jarnac

1,14686E-2

9,52400E-2

5,52392E-3

9,21928E-1

6,13544E-4

4,14087E-2

1,53386E-3

3,55988E-3

4,89929E-3

9,15748E-4

3,38358E-4

4,95990E-1

2,65529E-1

1,07784E-1

2,60744E-2

3,44706E-2

1,86088E-2

3,74924E-3

9.8

MathSBML

1,14686E-2

9,52400E-2

5,52392E-3

9,21929E-1

6,13544E-4

4,14087E-2

1,53386E-3

3,55988E-3

4,89929E-3

9,15747E-4

3,38358E-4

4,95990E-1

2,65529E-1

1,07784E-1

2,60744E-2

3,44706E-2

1,86087E-2

3,74924E-3

9.8

Oscill8 Core

1,14686E-2

9,52400E-2

5,52392E-3

9,21928E-1

6,13544E-4

4,14087E-2

1,53387E-3

4,89929E-3

9,15748E-4

3,38358E-4

4,95990E-1

2,65529E-1

1,07784E-1

2,60744E-2

3,44706E-2

1,86088E-2

3,74924E-3

9.8

SBToolbox2

1,14869E-2

9,55895E-2

5,54415E-3

9,20699E-1

6,14702E-4

4,15609E-2

1,53678E-3

3,56854E-3

4,90606E-3

9,17478E-4

3,39164E-4

4,95980E-1

2,66583E-1

1,07929E-1

2,61932E-2

3,45534E-2

1,86676E-2

3,75963E-3

9.8

copasi

1,14686E-2

9,52398E-2

5,52391E-3

9,21929E-1

6,13543E-4

4,14086E-2

1,53386E-3

3,55988E-3

4,89929E-3

9,15747E-4

3,38358E-4

4,95990E-1

2,65529E-1

1,07784E-1

2,60743E-2

3,44705E-2

1,86087E-2

3,74923E-3

9.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,14686E-2

9,52400E-2

5,52392E-3

9,21928E-1

6,13544E-4

4,14087E-2

1,53386E-3

3,55988E-3

4,89929E-3

9,15748E-4

3,38358E-4

4,95990E-1

2,65529E-1

1,07784E-1

2,60744E-2

3,44706E-2

1,86088E-2

3,74924E-3

9.8

jsim

1,14686E-2

9,52400E-2

5,52392E-3

9,21928E-1

6,13544E-4

4,14087E-2

1,53387E-3

3,55988E-3

4,89929E-3

9,15748E-4

3,38358E-4

4,95990E-1

2,65529E-1

1,07784E-1

2,60744E-2

3,44706E-2

1,86088E-2

3,74924E-3

9.8

min

1,14686E-2

9,52398E-2

5,52391E-3

9,20699E-1

6,13543E-4

4,14086E-2

1,53386E-3

3,55988E-3

4,89929E-3

9,15747E-4

3,38358E-4

4,95980E-1

2,65529E-1

1,07784E-1

2,60743E-2

3,44705E-2

1,86087E-2

3,74923E-3

9.8

max

1,14869E-2

9,55895E-2

5,54415E-3

9,21929E-1

6,14702E-4

4,15609E-2

1,53678E-3

3,56854E-3

4,90606E-3

9,17478E-4

3,39164E-4

4,95990E-1

2,66583E-1

1,07929E-1

2,61932E-2

3,45534E-2

1,86676E-2

3,75963E-3

9.8

mean

1,14686E-2

9,52400E-2

5,52392E-3

9,21928E-1

6,13544E-4

4,14087E-2

1,53386E-3

3,55988E-3

4,89929E-3

9,15748E-4

3,38358E-4

4,95990E-1

2,65529E-1

1,07784E-1

2,60744E-2

3,44706E-2

1,86088E-2

3,74924E-3

9.8

relative error(%)

0,00