Test BIOMD0000000011.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000011.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000011.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: DormandPrince
generated code	: BIOMD0000000011.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: -
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-10
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000011.gif

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: MEKRAFp MAPK MEKppMEKPH RAFpRAFPH RAFK MAPKMEKpp MEK RAF MEKpMEKPH RAFp MEKPH RAFRAFK MAPKpMAPKPH MAPKppMAPKPH MAPKpMEKpp MEKp MAPKp MAPKpp MAPKPH MEKpRAFp MEKpp RAFPH
Simulators: ByoDyn CVODE copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner Jarnac SBToolbox2 Oscill8 Core SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

MEKRAFp

MAPK

MEKppMEKPH

RAFpRAFPH

RAFK

MAPKMEKpp

MEK

RAF

MEKpMEKPH

RAFp

MEKPH

RAFRAFK

MAPKpMAPKPH

MAPKppMAPKPH

MAPKpMEKpp

MEKp

MAPKp

MAPKpp

MAPKPH

MEKpRAFp

MEKpp

RAFPH

0.0

BioUML

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

ByoDyn

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

CVODE

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

Jarnac

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

MathSBML

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

SBToolbox2

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

copasi

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

-2,77556E-17

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,77556E-17

3,00000E-1

-2,77556E-17

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

jsim

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

min

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

-2,77556E-17

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

-2,77556E-17

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

max

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,77556E-17

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

mean

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

1,00756E-17

7,10268E-7

9,27462E-2

3,03502E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18626E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

1,70305E-21

4,41284E-41

2,94375E-36

1,48625E-8

6,10834E-20

3,00425E-39

3,00000E-1

1,01930E-13

2,21935E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

ByoDyn

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

1,00755E-17

7,10268E-7

9,27462E-2

3,03501E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18626E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

1,70303E-21

4,41240E-41

2,94378E-36

1,48625E-8

6,10833E-20

3,00417E-39

3,00000E-1

1,01930E-13

2,21935E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

CVODE

3,13770E-6

3,00000E-1

1,03780E-17

7,10269E-7

9,27462E-2

3,12652E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18668E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

1,89490E-21

6,80806E-41

3,41221E-36

1,48617E-8

6,48776E-20

3,95810E-39

3,00000E-1

1,02293E-13

2,24415E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

Jarnac

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

-3,10862E-14

7,10267E-7

9,27462E-2

-2,58995E-15

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18626E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

-1,40339E-18

0,00000E0

5,75236E-32

1,48625E-8

-1,82594E-17

2,60902E-15

3,00000E-1

1,01930E-13

-3,03438E-15

2,99999E-1

0.2

MathSBML

3,13851E-6

3,00000E-1

9,24956E-18

7,10461E-7

9,27462E-2

2,78640E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,19591E-9

7,10871E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25381E-3

7,04670E-22

5,56616E-42

5,08408E-36

1,48196E-8

5,73909E-20

6,42071E-39

3,00000E-1

1,09138E-13

3,04922E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

Oscill8 Core

3,14056E-6

3,00000E-1

9,27462E-2

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18695E-9

7,10857E-5

2,00000E-1

3,34032E-12

3,21225E-21

1,48840E-8

1,11874E-11

3,00000E-1

3,34799E-11

2,99999E-1

0.2

SBToolbox2

3,20043E-6

3,00000E-1

-1,07581E-17

7,24286E-7

9,27456E-2

-3,27801E-17

2,00000E-1

3,92667E-1

1,40308E-9

7,08905E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25471E-3

-2,20362E-20

-4,64983E-38

-2,13865E-34

1,60271E-8

-2,44682E-19

-7,99737E-37

3,00000E-1

2,60526E-14

-9,90077E-18

3,00000E-1

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

3,13811E-6

3,00000E-1

1,00935E-17

7,10361E-7

9,27462E-2

3,04043E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18682E-9

7,10900E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25378E-3

1,70801E-21

4,54649E-41

2,98687E-36

1,48666E-8

6,12240E-20

3,06708E-39

3,00000E-1

1,02033E-13

2,22231E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

copasi

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

2,06837E-17

7,10268E-7

9,27462E-2

-8,65858E-35

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18631E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

-8,47276E-39

8,47276E-39

8,58763E-35

1,48625E-8

-8,44261E-19

7,09560E-37

3,00000E-1

1,01881E-13

1,96510E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

-2,82370E-17

7,10267E-7

9,27462E-2

2,77556E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18626E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

1,07460E-18

-8,89253E-16

-7,46453E-33

1,48626E-8

5,11755E-17

7,49401E-16

3,00000E-1

1,01877E-13

5,00630E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

jsim

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

1,00756E-17

7,10268E-7

9,27462E-2

3,03501E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18626E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

1,70304E-21

4,41251E-41

2,94372E-36

1,48625E-8

6,10833E-20

3,00412E-39

3,00000E-1

1,01930E-13

2,21935E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

min

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

-3,10862E-14

7,10267E-7

9,27456E-2

-2,58995E-15

1,99997E-1

3,92667E-1

1,18626E-9

7,08905E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25378E-3

-1,40339E-18

-8,89253E-16

-7,46453E-33

1,48196E-8

-1,82594E-17

-7,99737E-37

3,00000E-1

2,60526E-14

-3,03438E-15

2,99999E-1

0.2

max

3,20043E-6

3,00000E-1

2,06837E-17

7,24286E-7

9,27462E-2

3,12652E-17

2,00000E-1

3,92671E-1

1,40308E-9

7,10900E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25471E-3

3,34032E-12

8,47276E-39

3,21225E-21

1,60271E-8

1,11874E-11

2,60902E-15

3,00000E-1

1,09138E-13

3,34799E-11

3,00000E-1

0.2

mean

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

1,00755E-17

7,10268E-7

9,27462E-2

2,78640E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18650E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

1,70303E-21

4,41240E-41

3,19954E-36

1,48625E-8

6,10833E-20

3,95810E-39

3,00000E-1

1,01930E-13

2,22083E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,60583E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

1,09075E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

2,50377E-18

4,79936E-35

7,67657E-31

2,02415E-7

4,40374E-17

1,59352E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01230E-11

3,90553E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

ByoDyn

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,60583E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

1,09075E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

2,50377E-18

4,79933E-35

7,67655E-31

2,02415E-7

4,40374E-17

1,59351E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01230E-11

3,90553E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

CVODE

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,61134E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

1,09244E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

2,52614E-18

5,66908E-35

8,11903E-31

2,02415E-7

4,42151E-17

1,76659E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01240E-11

3,90702E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

Jarnac

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

-2,66454E-14

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

4,96313E-15

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

-1,33223E-17

0,00000E0

-1,29142E-30

2,02415E-7

-4,60469E-17

-4,21885E-15

3,00000E-1

1,01230E-11

3,57193E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

MathSBML

2,24435E-5

3,00000E-1

3,72025E-15

5,06039E-6

8,67928E-2

1,12533E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21473E-8

2,53940E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

2,48422E-18

3,31550E-35

9,72023E-31

2,02382E-7

4,53056E-17

2,33508E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01669E-11

3,99956E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

Oscill8 Core

2,24451E-5

3,00000E-1

8,67929E-2

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21862E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

5,17202E-12

3,27778E-21

2,02489E-7

4,66921E-12

3,00000E-1

5,88805E-12

2,99995E-1

0.4

SBToolbox2

2,26496E-5

3,00000E-1

5,15730E-15

5,10500E-6

8,67878E-2

1,56454E-14

1,99980E-1

3,86511E-1

3,67512E-8

2,53083E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32122E-2

6,91426E-18

2,98430E-34

1,07359E-30

2,12342E-7

8,42501E-17

4,54343E-33

3,00000E-1

1,02447E-11

4,44409E-14

2,99990E-1

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,24433E-5

3,00000E-1

3,60855E-15

5,06034E-6

8,67929E-2

1,09157E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21727E-8

2,53945E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32071E-2

2,50686E-18

4,83839E-35

7,71927E-31

2,02439E-7

4,40802E-17

1,60404E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01274E-11

3,90772E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

copasi

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,60912E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

1,09208E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21661E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

-3,82510E-35

3,82510E-35

7,61450E-31

2,02415E-7

4,27044E-17

1,60608E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01228E-11

3,90437E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,79590E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

9,54792E-15

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

4,01826E-17

-5,14721E-15

8,82665E-30

2,02415E-7

3,33976E-16

4,77396E-15

3,00000E-1

1,01229E-11

4,05385E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

jsim

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,60583E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

1,09075E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

2,50377E-18

4,79933E-35

7,67655E-31

2,02415E-7

4,40374E-17

1,59351E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01230E-11

3,90553E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

min

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

-2,66454E-14

5,06006E-6

8,67878E-2

4,96313E-15

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21473E-8

2,53083E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32071E-2

-1,33223E-17

-5,14721E-15

-1,29142E-30

2,02382E-7

-4,60469E-17

-4,21885E-15

3,00000E-1

1,01228E-11

3,57193E-14

2,99990E-1

0.4

max

2,26496E-5

3,00000E-1

5,15730E-15

5,10500E-6

8,67929E-2

1,56454E-14

1,99980E-1

3,86511E-1

3,67512E-8

2,53945E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32122E-2

5,17202E-12

2,98430E-34

3,27778E-21

2,12342E-7

4,66921E-12

4,77396E-15

3,00000E-1

1,02447E-11

5,88805E-12

2,99995E-1

0.4

mean

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,60912E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

1,09157E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

2,50531E-18

4,79933E-35

7,91915E-31

2,02415E-7

4,41477E-17

1,60608E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01230E-11

3,90737E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,88852E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

3,00413E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,57890E-16

1,28387E-31

8,79962E-28

8,78760E-7

1,81987E-15

2,77852E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35534E-10

7,04958E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

ByoDyn

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,88852E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

3,00413E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,57890E-16

1,28387E-31

8,79962E-28

8,78760E-7

1,81987E-15

2,77851E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35534E-10

7,04958E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

CVODE

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,89100E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

3,00490E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,58243E-16

1,34079E-31

8,87957E-28

8,78761E-7

1,82141E-15

2,84127E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35535E-10

7,04984E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

Jarnac

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

4,02733E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

2,90874E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,02507E-16

-1,11022E-16

7,09382E-28

8,78760E-7

1,61721E-15

-2,11497E-13

3,00000E-1

1,35534E-10

7,00038E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

MathSBML

6,79134E-5

3,00000E-1

9,98177E-14

1,52532E-5

8,18970E-2

3,03267E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08043E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,58345E-16

9,09594E-32

9,93997E-28

8,78845E-7

1,84793E-15

3,64094E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35581E-10

7,08483E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

Oscill8 Core

6,79166E-5

3,00000E-1

8,18971E-2

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08162E-7

5,12775E-4

2,00000E-1

5,45769E-12

2,88381E-21

8,78885E-7

1,20775E-12

3,00000E-1

1,68227E-12

2,99985E-1

0.6

SBToolbox2

6,80708E-5

3,00000E-1

1,05752E-13

1,52849E-5

8,18904E-2

3,21709E-13

1,99930E-1

3,81294E-1

2,19511E-7

5,11799E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81096E-2

2,13018E-16

-9,10750E-31

-1,14933E-27

8,94133E-7

2,15524E-15

-8,67664E-30

3,00000E-1

1,29820E-10

6,97794E-13

2,99981E-1

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

6,79154E-5

3,00000E-1

9,89293E-14

1,52536E-5

8,18971E-2

3,00547E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08129E-7

5,12778E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81029E-2

1,58006E-16

1,29321E-31

8,82986E-28

8,78820E-7

1,82092E-15

2,79244E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35570E-10

7,05188E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

copasi

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,88929E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

3,00490E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,11437E-16

1,25183E-31

8,98253E-28

8,78760E-7

1,81851E-15

2,95701E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35532E-10

7,04924E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,94981E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

2,99566E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

2,77895E-16

-5,44043E-15

1,17358E-27

8,78760E-7

2,05258E-15

5,13478E-15

3,00000E-1

1,35535E-10

7,05606E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

jsim

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,88852E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

3,00413E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,57890E-16

1,28387E-31

8,79962E-28

8,78760E-7

1,81987E-15

2,77851E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35534E-10

7,04958E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

min

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

4,02733E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18904E-2

2,90874E-13

1,99930E-1

3,81294E-1

2,08043E-7

5,11799E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81029E-2

1,02507E-16

-5,44043E-15

-1,14933E-27

8,78760E-7

1,61721E-15

-2,11497E-13

3,00000E-1

1,29820E-10

6,97794E-13

2,99981E-1

0.6

max

6,80708E-5

3,00000E-1

1,05752E-13

1,52849E-5

8,18971E-2

3,21709E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,19511E-7

5,12778E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81096E-2

5,45769E-12

1,34079E-31

2,88381E-21

8,94133E-7

1,20775E-12

5,13478E-15

3,00000E-1

1,35581E-10

1,68227E-12

2,99985E-1

0.6

mean

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,89100E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

3,00490E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,58125E-16

1,25183E-31

8,85471E-28

8,78761E-7

1,82117E-15

2,79244E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35534E-10

7,04971E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56642E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91900E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,76369E-15

2,98326E-29

1,11409E-25

2,39835E-6

2,35323E-14

4,74435E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03161E-10

5,06719E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

ByoDyn

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56642E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91900E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,76369E-15

2,98326E-29

1,11409E-25

2,39835E-6

2,35323E-14

4,74435E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03161E-10

5,06719E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

CVODE

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56768E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91940E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,76777E-15

3,15672E-29

1,12893E-25

2,39836E-6

2,35444E-14

4,89919E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03158E-10

5,06723E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

Jarnac

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

8,98503E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,90386E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,63172E-15

-2,60902E-15

1,08255E-25

2,39835E-6

2,31459E-14

-3,50553E-13

3,00000E-1

8,03161E-10

5,06043E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

MathSBML

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,60220E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,93008E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,51016E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,79469E-15

2,80886E-29

1,18472E-25

2,39836E-6

2,36995E-14

5,53159E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03266E-10

5,06336E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

Oscill8 Core

1,44750E-4

3,00000E-1

7,78648E-2

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,51104E-7

8,22025E-4

1,99999E-1

4,99958E-12

2,50746E-21

2,39853E-6

-5,32662E-13

3,00000E-1

5,15459E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

SBToolbox2

1,44810E-4

3,00000E-1

1,01365E-12

3,23947E-5

7,78557E-2

3,09753E-12

1,99851E-1

3,76857E-1

7,74344E-7

8,20942E-4

2,00000E-1

2,21443E-2

3,56736E-15

1,82452E-30

4,90158E-26

2,41964E-6

2,70749E-14

1,52643E-28

3,00000E-1

7,84370E-10

5,06122E-12

2,99970E-1

0.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,44749E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56930E-13

3,23876E-5

7,78648E-2

2,91988E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,51051E-7

8,22027E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21352E-2

2,76509E-15

2,98943E-29

1,11629E-25

2,39846E-6

2,35415E-14

4,75425E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03302E-10

5,06830E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

copasi

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56601E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91909E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,67449E-15

2,99585E-29

1,11999E-25

2,39835E-6

2,35280E-14

4,82743E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03157E-10

5,06716E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,57390E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91886E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,91686E-15

-3,36095E-15

1,13760E-25

2,39836E-6

2,36207E-14

3,41394E-15

3,00000E-1

8,03157E-10

5,06730E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

jsim

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56642E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91900E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,76369E-15

2,98326E-29

1,11409E-25

2,39835E-6

2,35323E-14

4,74435E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03161E-10

5,06719E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

min

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

8,98503E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78557E-2

2,90386E-12

1,99851E-1

3,76857E-1

7,50989E-7

8,20942E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21352E-2

2,63172E-15

-3,36095E-15

4,90158E-26

2,39835E-6

-5,32662E-13

-3,50553E-13

3,00000E-1

7,84370E-10

5,06043E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

max

1,44810E-4

3,00000E-1

1,01365E-12

3,23947E-5

7,78648E-2

3,09753E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,74344E-7

8,22027E-4

2,00000E-1

2,21443E-2

4,99958E-12

3,15672E-29

2,50746E-21

2,41964E-6

2,70749E-14

3,41394E-15

3,00000E-1

8,03302E-10

5,15459E-12

2,99970E-1

0.8

mean

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56768E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91909E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,76643E-15

2,98326E-29

1,11814E-25

2,39836E-6

2,35369E-14

4,75425E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03161E-10

5,06719E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26210E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61271E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,40878E-14

1,83659E-27

4,26938E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61910E-13

2,29373E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

ByoDyn

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26210E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61271E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,40878E-14

1,83659E-27

4,26938E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61910E-13

2,29373E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

CVODE

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26223E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61276E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,40978E-14

1,86229E-27

4,28013E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61930E-13

2,30895E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

Jarnac

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,20925E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61063E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,38082E-14

-2,38143E-14

4,23706E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61113E-13

-3,43947E-13

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21484E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

MathSBML

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26520E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61374E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97231E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,42154E-14

1,84185E-27

4,38343E-24

5,08950E-6

1,62341E-13

2,47163E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05655E-9

2,21568E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

Oscill8 Core

2,54899E-4

3,00000E-1

7,45398E-2

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97246E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

4,25389E-12

2,13375E-21

5,08972E-6

-1,19294E-12

3,00000E-1

2,20566E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

SBToolbox2

2,54810E-4

3,00000E-1

5,51656E-12

5,67965E-5

7,45291E-2

1,69326E-11

1,99740E-1

3,73057E-1

2,01175E-6

1,16244E-3

2,00000E-1

2,54709E-2

2,96260E-14

1,83315E-27

3,25888E-24

5,11543E-6

1,81196E-13

1,96722E-26

3,00000E-1

3,00870E-9

2,21812E-11

2,99940E-1

1.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,54898E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26324E-12

5,68250E-5

7,45398E-2

1,61307E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97239E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54602E-2

2,40968E-14

1,83919E-27

4,27457E-24

5,08965E-6

1,61957E-13

2,29684E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05688E-9

2,21588E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

copasi

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26205E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61271E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,40704E-14

1,84380E-27

4,27607E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61903E-13

2,30580E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26299E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61279E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,42641E-14

-2,39266E-15

4,34624E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61992E-13

2,44249E-15

3,00000E-1

3,05647E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

jsim

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26210E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61271E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,40878E-14

1,83659E-27

4,26938E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61910E-13

2,29373E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

min

2,54810E-4

3,00000E-1

5,20925E-12

5,67965E-5

7,45291E-2

1,61063E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73057E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16244E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54602E-2

2,38082E-14

-2,38143E-14

3,25888E-24

5,08949E-6

-1,19294E-12

-3,43947E-13

3,00000E-1

3,00870E-9

2,20566E-11

2,99940E-1

1.0

max

2,54899E-4

3,00000E-1

5,51656E-12

5,68250E-5

7,45398E-2

1,69326E-11

1,99740E-1

3,73064E-1

2,01175E-6

1,16358E-3

2,00000E-1

2,54709E-2

4,25389E-12

1,86229E-27

2,13375E-21

5,11543E-6

1,81196E-13

2,44249E-15

3,00000E-1

3,05688E-9

2,21812E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

mean

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26223E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61276E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,40973E-14

1,83659E-27

4,27532E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61920E-13

2,29684E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03409E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26169E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35550E-13

4,91695E-26

7,74821E-23

9,22932E-6

7,50435E-13

5,03192E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81476E-9

7,10962E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

ByoDyn

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03409E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26169E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35550E-13

4,91695E-26

7,74821E-23

9,22932E-6

7,50435E-13

5,03192E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81476E-9

7,10962E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

CVODE

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03410E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26174E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35569E-13

4,94164E-26

7,75527E-23

9,22932E-6

7,50464E-13

5,04396E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81476E-9

7,10962E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

Jarnac

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,02936E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,25909E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,34908E-13

-1,34892E-13

7,72008E-23

9,22932E-6

7,48220E-13

-2,33535E-13

3,00000E-1

8,81476E-9

7,10891E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

MathSBML

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03395E-11

8,84562E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26128E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24307E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35764E-13

4,75097E-26

7,83100E-23

9,22934E-6

7,50420E-13

5,35876E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81397E-9

7,10665E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

Oscill8 Core

3,98190E-4

3,00000E-1

7,17958E-2

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24329E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

3,52847E-12

1,67889E-21

9,22961E-6

-8,69660E-13

3,00000E-1

7,09431E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

SBToolbox2

3,97937E-4

3,00000E-1

2,08905E-11

8,83892E-5

7,17840E-2

6,43894E-11

1,99591E-1

3,69778E-1

4,29808E-6

1,52369E-3

2,00000E-1

2,82160E-2

1,55672E-13

2,48140E-26

4,59339E-23

9,25677E-6

8,06632E-13

2,92398E-25

3,00000E-1

8,65026E-9

7,06748E-11

2,99910E-1

1.2

SBWOdeSolver

3,98190E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03443E-11

8,84570E-5

7,17958E-2

6,26274E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24320E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82042E-2

1,35589E-13

4,92259E-26

7,75505E-23

9,22954E-6

7,50600E-13

5,03700E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81561E-9

7,11046E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

copasi

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03408E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26169E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35507E-13

4,94187E-26

7,76472E-23

9,22932E-6

7,50436E-13

5,06197E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81475E-9

7,10961E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,98185E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03423E-11

8,84560E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26193E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24302E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35843E-13

-2,83872E-15

7,84488E-23

9,22933E-6

7,50749E-13

2,80331E-15

3,00000E-1

8,81464E-9

7,10956E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

jsim

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03409E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26169E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35550E-13

4,91695E-26

7,74821E-23

9,22932E-6

7,50435E-13

5,03192E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81476E-9

7,10962E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

min

3,97937E-4

3,00000E-1

2,02936E-11

8,83892E-5

7,17840E-2

6,25909E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69778E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52369E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82042E-2

1,34908E-13

-1,34892E-13

4,59339E-23

9,22932E-6

-8,69660E-13

-2,33535E-13

3,00000E-1

8,65026E-9

7,06748E-11

2,99910E-1

1.2

max

3,98190E-4

3,00000E-1

2,08905E-11

8,84570E-5

7,17958E-2

6,43894E-11

1,99591E-1

3,69784E-1

4,29808E-6

1,52473E-3

2,00000E-1

2,82160E-2

3,52847E-12

4,94187E-26

1,67889E-21

9,25677E-6

8,06632E-13

2,80331E-15

3,00000E-1

8,81561E-9

7,11046E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

mean

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03409E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26169E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24302E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35579E-13

4,91695E-26

7,75516E-23

9,22932E-6

7,50436E-13

5,03700E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81476E-9

7,10959E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

5,73106E-4

3,00000E-1

6,18365E-11

1,26885E-4

6,95302E-2

1,91202E-10

1,99404E-1

3,66933E-1

7,96388E-6

1,89669E-3

1,99992E-1

3,04698E-2

5,65483E-13

7,45058E-25

8,44728E-22

1,50386E-5

2,65612E-12

6,43629E-24

3,00000E-1

2,10394E-8

1,84971E-10

2,99873E-1

1.4

ByoDyn

5,73106E-4

3,00000E-1

6,18365E-11

1,26885E-4

6,95302E-2

1,91202E-10

1,99404E-1

3,66933E-1

7,96388E-6

1,89669E-3

1,99992E-1

3,04698E-2

5,65483E-13

7,45058E-25

8,44728E-22

1,50386E-5

2,65612E-12

6,43629E-24

3,00000E-1

2,10394E-8

1,84971E-10

2,99873E-1

1.4

CVODE

5,73106E-4

3,00000E-1

6,18366E-11

1,26885E-4

6,95302E-2

1,91202E-10

1,99404E-1

3,66933E-1

7,96388E-6

1,89669E-3

1,99992E-1

3,04698E-2

5,65514E-13

7,46722E-25

8,45062E-22

1,50386E-5

2,65615E-12

6,44305E-24

3,00000E-1

2,10394E-8

1,84971E-10

2,99873E-1

1.4

Jarnac

5,73106E-4

3,00000E-1

6,17927E-11

1,26885E-4

6,95302E-2

1,91171E-10

1,99404E-1

3,66933E-1

7,96388E-6

1,89669E-3

1,99992E-1

3,04698E-2

5,63687E-13

-3,19744E-13

8,42329E-22

1,50386E-5

2,64946E-12

-4,39093E-14

3,00000E-1

2,10394E-8

1,84964E-10

2,99873E-1

1.4

MathSBML

5,73107E-4

3,00000E-1

6,18055E-11

1,26886E-4

6,95302E-2

1,91111E-10

1,99404E-1

3,66933E-1

7,96393E-6

1,89669E-3

1,99992E-1

3,04698E-2

5,65733E-13

7,40453E-25

8,52964E-22

1,50386E-5

2,65711E-12

6,73662E-24

3,00000E-1

2,10390E-8

1,85057E-10

2,99873E-1

1.4

Oscill8 Core

5,73111E-4

3,00000E-1

6,95302E-2

1,99404E-1

3,66934E-1

7,96426E-6

1,89669E-3

1,99992E-1

3,17071E-12

1,49577E-21

1,50389E-5

1,05175E-12

3,00000E-1

1,84795E-10

2,99873E-1

1.4

SBToolbox2

5,72641E-4

3,00000E-1

6,31773E-11

1,26769E-4

6,95154E-2

1,95585E-10

1,99401E-1

3,66920E-1

8,04269E-6

1,89557E-3

1,99990E-1

3,04846E-2

6,31174E-13

-1,50195E-25

3,25103E-22

1,50694E-5

2,81640E-12

1,37129E-24

3,00000E-1

2,06662E-8

1,83753E-10

2,99871E-1

1.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,73111E-4

3,00000E-1

6,18446E-11

1,26886E-4

6,95303E-2

1,91227E-10

1,99404E-1

3,66934E-1

7,96416E-6

1,89669E-3

1,99992E-1

3,04697E-2

5,65612E-13

7,45738E-25

8,45309E-22

1,50389E-5

2,65658E-12

6,44135E-24

3,00000E-1

2,10410E-8

1,84988E-10

2,99873E-1

1.4

copasi

5,73106E-4

3,00000E-1

6,18364E-11

1,26885E-4

6,95302E-2

1,91201E-10

1,99404E-1

3,66933E-1

7,96388E-6

1,89669E-3

1,99992E-1

3,04698E-2

5,65431E-13

7,47796E-25

8,45682E-22

1,50386E-5

2,65614E-12

6,45919E-24

3,00000E-1

2,10394E-8

1,84970E-10

2,99873E-1

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,73106E-4

3,00000E-1

6,18374E-11

1,26885E-4

6,95302E-2

1,91203E-10

1,99404E-1

3,66933E-1

7,96390E-6

1,89669E-3

1,99992E-1

3,04698E-2

5,65945E-13

-2,06272E-15

8,49557E-22

1,50386E-5

2,65651E-12

1,99840E-15

3,00000E-1

2,10392E-8

1,84969E-10

2,99873E-1

1.4

jsim

5,73106E-4

3,00000E-1

6,18365E-11

1,26885E-4

6,95302E-2

1,91202E-10

1,99404E-1

3,66933E-1

7,96388E-6

1,89669E-3

1,99992E-1

3,04698E-2

5,65483E-13

7,45058E-25

8,44728E-22

1,50386E-5

2,65612E-12

6,43629E-24

3,00000E-1

2,10394E-8

1,84971E-10

2,99873E-1

1.4

min

5,72641E-4

3,00000E-1

6,17927E-11

1,26769E-4

6,95154E-2

1,91111E-10

1,99401E-1

3,66920E-1

7,96388E-6

1,89557E-3

1,99990E-1

3,04697E-2

5,63687E-13

-3,19744E-13

3,25103E-22

1,50386E-5

1,05175E-12

-4,39093E-14

3,00000E-1

2,06662E-8

1,83753E-10

2,99871E-1

1.4

max

5,73111E-4

3,00000E-1

6,31773E-11

1,26886E-4

6,95303E-2

1,95585E-10

1,99404E-1

3,66934E-1

8,04269E-6

1,89669E-3

1,99992E-1

3,04846E-2

3,17071E-12

7,47796E-25

1,49577E-21

1,50694E-5

2,81640E-12

1,99840E-15

3,00000E-1

2,10410E-8

1,85057E-10

2,99873E-1

1.4

mean

5,73106E-4

3,00000E-1

6,18365E-11

1,26885E-4

6,95302E-2

1,91202E-10

1,99404E-1

3,66933E-1

7,96389E-6

1,89669E-3

1,99992E-1

3,04698E-2

5,65563E-13

7,45058E-25

8,45186E-22

1,50386E-5

2,65615E-12

6,44135E-24

3,00000E-1

2,10394E-8

1,84970E-10

2,99873E-1

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

1.6

BioUML

7,77357E-4

3,00000E-1

1,58051E-10

1,71553E-4

6,76594E-2

4,90866E-10

1,99186E-1

3,64437E-1

1,35402E-5

2,27347E-3

1,99986E-1

3,23406E-2

1,89880E-12

7,47417E-24

6,37193E-21

2,26852E-5

7,73500E-12

5,57153E-23

3,00000E-1

4,37992E-8

4,13869E-10

2,99828E-1

1.6

ByoDyn

7,77357E-4

3,00000E-1

1,58051E-10

1,71553E-4

6,76594E-2

4,90866E-10

1,99186E-1

3,64437E-1

1,35402E-5

2,27347E-3

1,99986E-1

3,23406E-2

1,89880E-12

7,47417E-24

6,37193E-21

2,26852E-5

7,73500E-12

5,57153E-23

3,00000E-1

4,37992E-8

4,13869E-10

2,99828E-1

1.6

CVODE

7,77357E-4

3,00000E-1

1,58051E-10

1,71553E-4

6,76594E-2

4,90866E-10

1,99186E-1

3,64437E-1

1,35402E-5

2,27347E-3

1,99986E-1

3,23406E-2

1,89886E-12

7,49380E-24

6,37635E-21

2,26852E-5

7,73505E-12

5,57964E-23

3,00000E-1

4,37992E-8

4,13869E-10

2,99828E-1

1.6

Jarnac

7,77357E-4

3,00000E-1

1,58008E-10

1,71553E-4

6,76594E-2

4,90831E-10

1,99186E-1

3,64437E-1

1,35402E-5

2,27347E-3

1,99986E-1

3,23406E-2

1,89462E-12

-2,48079E-13

6,35973E-21

2,26852E-5

7,72425E-12

-1,10134E-13

3,00000E-1

4,37992E-8

4,13862E-10

2,99828E-1

1.6

MathSBML

7,77358E-4

3,00000E-1

1,58056E-10

1,71553E-4

6,76594E-2

4,90880E-10

1,99186E-1

3,64437E-1

1,35401E-5

2,27347E-3

1,99986E-1

3,23406E-2

1,89977E-12

7,51064E-24

6,40479E-21

2,26853E-5

7,73453E-12

5,69487E-23

3,00000E-1

4,37989E-8

4,13852E-10

2,99828E-1

1.6

Oscill8 Core

7,77362E-4

3,00000E-1

6,76594E-2

1,99186E-1

3,64437E-1

1,35406E-5

2,27347E-3

1,99986E-1

3,81797E-12

5,28799E-21

2,26856E-5

6,28155E-12

3,00000E-1

4,13686E-10

2,99828E-1

1.6

SBToolbox2

7,76452E-4

3,00000E-1

1,65422E-10

1,71331E-4

6,76388E-2

5,14834E-10

1,99192E-1

3,64419E-1

1,36686E-5

2,27228E-3

1,99990E-1

3,23612E-2

2,27898E-12

1,26237E-23

6,46347E-21

2,27222E-5

8,55337E-12

7,10536E-23

3,00000E-1

4,33872E-8

4,16416E-10

2,99830E-1

1.6

SBWOdeSolver

7,77362E-4

3,00000E-1

1,58067E-10

1,71554E-4

6,76594E-2

4,90917E-10

1,99186E-1

3,64437E-1

1,35405E-5

2,27347E-3

1,99986E-1

3,23406E-2

1,89915E-12

7,47961E-24

6,37536E-21

2,26856E-5

7,73610E-12

5,57506E-23

3,00000E-1

4,38018E-8

4,13901E-10

2,99828E-1

1.6

copasi

7,77357E-4

3,00000E-1

1,58051E-10

1,71553E-4

6,76594E-2

4,90865E-10

1,99186E-1

3,64437E-1

1,35402E-5

2,27347E-3

1,99986E-1

3,23406E-2

1,89877E-12

7,49196E-24

6,37529E-21

2,26852E-5

7,73502E-12

5,58095E-23

3,00000E-1

4,37992E-8

4,13869E-10

2,99828E-1

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,77357E-4

3,00000E-1

1,58051E-10

1,71553E-4

6,76594E-2

4,90864E-10

1,99186E-1

3,64437E-1

1,35402E-5

2,27347E-3

1,99986E-1

3,23406E-2

1,89945E-12

-1,41611E-15

6,39017E-21

2,26852E-5

7,73542E-12

1,44329E-15

3,00000E-1

4,37990E-8

4,13867E-10

2,99828E-1

1.6

jsim

7,77357E-4

3,00000E-1

1,58051E-10

1,71553E-4

6,76594E-2

4,90866E-10

1,99186E-1

3,64437E-1

1,35402E-5

2,27347E-3

1,99986E-1

3,23406E-2

1,89880E-12

7,47417E-24

6,37193E-21

2,26852E-5

7,73500E-12

5,57153E-23

3,00000E-1

4,37992E-8

4,13869E-10

2,99828E-1

1.6

min

7,76452E-4

3,00000E-1

1,58008E-10

1,71331E-4

6,76388E-2

4,90831E-10

1,99186E-1

3,64419E-1

1,35401E-5

2,27228E-3

1,99986E-1

3,23406E-2

1,89462E-12

-2,48079E-13

5,28799E-21

2,26852E-5

6,28155E-12

-1,10134E-13

3,00000E-1

4,33872E-8

4,13686E-10

2,99828E-1

1.6

max

7,77362E-4

3,00000E-1

1,65422E-10

1,71554E-4

6,76594E-2

5,14834E-10

1,99192E-1

3,64437E-1

1,36686E-5

2,27347E-3

1,99990E-1

3,23612E-2

3,81797E-12

1,26237E-23

6,46347E-21

2,27222E-5

8,55337E-12

1,44329E-15

3,00000E-1

4,38018E-8

4,16416E-10

2,99830E-1

1.6

mean

7,77357E-4

3,00000E-1

1,58051E-10

1,71553E-4

6,76594E-2

4,90866E-10

1,99186E-1

3,64437E-1

1,35402E-5

2,27347E-3

1,99986E-1

3,23406E-2

1,89901E-12

7,47961E-24

6,37532E-21

2,26852E-5

7,73501E-12

5,57964E-23

3,00000E-1

4,37992E-8

4,13869E-10

2,99828E-1

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

1.8

BioUML

1,00823E-3

3,00000E-1

3,54510E-10

2,21825E-4

6,61147E-2

1,10586E-9

1,98938E-1

3,62233E-1

2,13629E-5

2,65112E-3

1,99979E-1

3,38853E-2

5,41047E-12

5,48956E-23

3,64108E-20

3,22917E-5

1,94421E-11

3,59174E-22

3,00000E-1

8,22521E-8

8,27012E-10

2,99778E-1

1.8

ByoDyn

1,00823E-3

3,00000E-1

3,54510E-10

2,21825E-4

6,61147E-2

1,10586E-9

1,98938E-1

3,62233E-1

2,13629E-5

2,65112E-3

1,99979E-1

3,38853E-2

5,41047E-12

5,48956E-23

3,64108E-20

3,22917E-5

1,94421E-11

3,59174E-22

3,00000E-1

8,22521E-8

8,27012E-10

2,99778E-1

1.8

CVODE

1,00823E-3

3,00000E-1

3,54509E-10

2,21825E-4

6,61147E-2

1,10586E-9

1,98938E-1

3,62233E-1

2,13629E-5

2,65112E-3

1,99979E-1

3,38853E-2

5,41059E-12

5,50414E-23

3,64309E-20

3,22917E-5

1,94422E-11

3,59667E-22

3,00000E-1

8,22521E-8

8,27012E-10

2,99778E-1

1.8

Jarnac

1,00823E-3

3,00000E-1

3,54469E-10

2,21825E-4

6,61147E-2

1,10583E-9

1,98938E-1

3,62233E-1

2,13629E-5

2,65112E-3

1,99979E-1

3,38853E-2

5,40325E-12

-2,37810E-13

3,63723E-20

3,22917E-5

1,94290E-11

-1,16240E-13

3,00000E-1

8,22521E-8

8,27005E-10

2,99778E-1

1.8

MathSBML

1,00823E-3

3,00000E-1

3,54488E-10

2,21825E-4

6,61147E-2

1,10580E-9

1,98938E-1

3,62233E-1

2,13629E-5

2,65112E-3

1,99979E-1

3,38853E-2

5,41002E-12

5,49842E-23

3,64014E-20

3,22918E-5

1,94400E-11

3,62050E-22

3,00000E-1

8,22514E-8

8,27010E-10

2,99778E-1

1.8

Oscill8 Core

1,00823E-3

3,00000E-1

6,61147E-2

1,98938E-1

3,62233E-1

2,13635E-5

2,65112E-3

1,99979E-1

6,76116E-12

3,24362E-20

3,22922E-5

1,81932E-11

3,00000E-1

8,26832E-10

2,99778E-1

1.8

SBToolbox2

1,00721E-3

3,00000E-1

3,61795E-10

2,21575E-4

6,60958E-2

1,13041E-9

1,98942E-1

3,62218E-1

2,14963E-5

2,65020E-3

1,99980E-1

3,39042E-2

6,07324E-12

4,89688E-23

2,74969E-20

3,23226E-5

2,06118E-11

2,88744E-22

3,00000E-1

8,09806E-8

8,21989E-10

2,99780E-1

1.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,00823E-3

3,00000E-1

3,54540E-10

2,21826E-4

6,61147E-2

1,10596E-9

1,98938E-1

3,62233E-1

2,13634E-5

2,65112E-3

1,99979E-1

3,38853E-2

5,41130E-12

5,49289E-23

3,64281E-20

3,22921E-5

1,94444E-11

3,59366E-22

3,00000E-1

8,22561E-8

8,27063E-10

2,99778E-1

1.8

copasi

1,00823E-3

3,00000E-1

3,54509E-10

2,21825E-4

6,61147E-2

1,10586E-9

1,98938E-1

3,62233E-1

2,13629E-5

2,65112E-3

1,99979E-1

3,38853E-2

5,41048E-12

5,49712E-23

3,64204E-20

3,22917E-5

1,94421E-11

3,59474E-22

3,00000E-1

8,22521E-8

8,27012E-10

2,99778E-1

1.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,00823E-3

3,00000E-1

3,54508E-10

2,21825E-4

6,61147E-2

1,10586E-9

1,98938E-1

3,62233E-1

2,13629E-5

2,65112E-3

1,99979E-1

3,38853E-2

5,41130E-12

-4,64691E-16

3,64666E-20

3,22917E-5

1,94425E-11

4,44089E-16

3,00000E-1

8,22519E-8

8,27009E-10

2,99778E-1

1.8

jsim

1,00823E-3

3,00000E-1

3,54510E-10

2,21825E-4

6,61147E-2

1,10586E-9

1,98938E-1

3,62233E-1

2,13629E-5

2,65112E-3

1,99979E-1

3,38853E-2

5,41047E-12

5,48956E-23

3,64108E-20

3,22917E-5

1,94421E-11

3,59174E-22

3,00000E-1

8,22521E-8

8,27012E-10

2,99778E-1

1.8

min

1,00721E-3

3,00000E-1

3,54469E-10

2,21575E-4

6,60958E-2

1,10580E-9

1,98938E-1

3,62218E-1

2,13629E-5

2,65020E-3

1,99979E-1

3,38853E-2

5,40325E-12

-2,37810E-13

2,74969E-20

3,22917E-5

1,81932E-11

-1,16240E-13

3,00000E-1

8,09806E-8

8,21989E-10

2,99778E-1

1.8

max

1,00823E-3

3,00000E-1

3,61795E-10

2,21826E-4

6,61147E-2

1,13041E-9

1,98942E-1

3,62233E-1

2,14963E-5

2,65112E-3

1,99980E-1

3,39042E-2

6,76116E-12

5,50414E-23

3,64666E-20

3,23226E-5

2,06118E-11

4,44089E-16

3,00000E-1

8,22561E-8

8,27063E-10

2,99780E-1

1.8

mean

1,00823E-3

3,00000E-1

3,54509E-10

2,21825E-4

6,61147E-2

1,10586E-9

1,98938E-1

3,62233E-1

2,13629E-5

2,65112E-3

1,99979E-1

3,38853E-2

5,41054E-12

5,48956E-23

3,64108E-20

3,22917E-5

1,94421E-11

3,59366E-22

3,00000E-1

8,22521E-8

8,27011E-10

2,99778E-1

1.8

relative error(%)

0,00

2.0

BioUML

1,26287E-3

3,00000E-1

7,18383E-10

2,77048E-4

6,48399E-2

2,25072E-9

1,98661E-1

3,60273E-1

3,17960E-5

3,02708E-3

1,99968E-1

3,51601E-2

1,35613E-11

3,16104E-22

1,67614E-19

4,39429E-5

4,35738E-11

1,84016E-21

3,00000E-1

1,42568E-7

1,51402E-9

2,99723E-1

2.0

ByoDyn

1,26287E-3

3,00000E-1

7,18383E-10

2,77048E-4

6,48399E-2

2,25072E-9

1,98661E-1

3,60273E-1

3,17960E-5

3,02708E-3

1,99968E-1

3,51601E-2

1,35613E-11

3,16104E-22

1,67614E-19

4,39429E-5

4,35738E-11

1,84016E-21

3,00000E-1

1,42568E-7

1,51402E-9

2,99723E-1

2.0

CVODE

1,26287E-3

3,00000E-1

7,18383E-10

2,77048E-4

6,48399E-2

2,25072E-9

1,98661E-1

3,60273E-1

3,17960E-5

3,02708E-3

1,99968E-1

3,51601E-2

1,35614E-11

3,16666E-22

1,67667E-19

4,39429E-5

4,35739E-11

1,84171E-21

3,00000E-1

1,42568E-7

1,51402E-9

2,99723E-1

2.0

Jarnac

1,26287E-3

3,00000E-1

7,18345E-10

2,77048E-4

6,48399E-2

2,25068E-9

1,98661E-1

3,60273E-1

3,17960E-5

3,02708E-3

1,99968E-1

3,51601E-2

1,35507E-11

-2,41140E-13

1,67518E-19

4,39429E-5

4,35586E-11

-1,08136E-13

3,00000E-1

1,42568E-7

1,51402E-9

2,99723E-1

2.0

MathSBML

1,26287E-3

3,00000E-1

7,18259E-10

2,77048E-4

6,48399E-2

2,25036E-9

1,98661E-1

3,60273E-1

3,17959E-5

3,02708E-3

1,99968E-1

3,51601E-2

1,35607E-11

3,17481E-22

1,67746E-19

4,39430E-5

4,35773E-11

1,85102E-21

3,00000E-1

1,42568E-7

1,51448E-9

2,99723E-1

2.0

Oscill8 Core

1,26287E-3

3,00000E-1

6,48399E-2

1,98661E-1

3,60273E-1

3,17967E-5

3,02708E-3

1,99968E-1

1,44582E-11

1,59319E-19

4,39434E-5

4,25394E-11

3,00000E-1

1,51386E-9

2,99723E-1

2.0

SBToolbox2

1,26134E-3

3,00000E-1

7,40892E-10

2,76684E-4

6,48156E-2

2,32592E-9

1,98662E-1

3,60250E-1

3,19798E-5

3,02624E-3

1,99970E-1

3,51844E-2

1,56086E-11

4,56654E-22

1,66172E-19

4,39734E-5

4,69206E-11

2,15078E-21

3,00000E-1

1,41398E-7

1,51732E-9

2,99722E-1

2.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,26287E-3

3,00000E-1

7,18435E-10

2,77049E-4

6,48399E-2

2,25089E-9

1,98661E-1

3,60273E-1

3,17966E-5

3,02708E-3

1,99968E-1

3,51601E-2

1,35630E-11

3,16268E-22

1,67678E-19

4,39433E-5

4,35780E-11

1,84098E-21

3,00000E-1

1,42574E-7

1,51410E-9

2,99723E-1

2.0

copasi

1,26287E-3

3,00000E-1

7,18382E-10

2,77048E-4

6,48399E-2

2,25072E-9

1,98661E-1

3,60273E-1

3,17960E-5

3,02708E-3

1,99968E-1

3,51601E-2

1,35614E-11

3,17228E-22

1,67820E-19

4,39429E-5

4,35739E-11

1,84487E-21

3,00000E-1

1,42568E-7

1,51402E-9

2,99723E-1

2.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,26287E-3

3,00000E-1

7,18381E-10

2,77048E-4

6,48399E-2

2,25072E-9

1,98661E-1

3,60273E-1

3,17960E-5

3,02708E-3

1,99968E-1

3,51601E-2

1,35622E-11

7,05723E-17

1,67760E-19

4,39429E-5

4,35740E-11

3,69779E-30

3,00000E-1

1,42568E-7

1,51402E-9

2,99723E-1

2.0

jsim

1,26287E-3

3,00000E-1

7,18383E-10

2,77048E-4

6,48399E-2

2,25072E-9

1,98661E-1

3,60273E-1

3,17960E-5

3,02708E-3

1,99968E-1

3,51601E-2

1,35613E-11

3,16104E-22

1,67614E-19

4,39429E-5

4,35738E-11

1,84016E-21

3,00000E-1

1,42568E-7

1,51402E-9

2,99723E-1

2.0

min

1,26134E-3

3,00000E-1

7,18259E-10

2,76684E-4

6,48156E-2

2,25036E-9

1,98661E-1

3,60250E-1

3,17959E-5

3,02624E-3

1,99968E-1

3,51601E-2

1,35507E-11

-2,41140E-13

1,59319E-19

4,39429E-5

4,25394E-11

-1,08136E-13

3,00000E-1

1,41398E-7

1,51386E-9

2,99722E-1

2.0

max

1,26287E-3

3,00000E-1

7,40892E-10

2,77049E-4

6,48399E-2

2,32592E-9

1,98662E-1

3,60273E-1

3,19798E-5

3,02708E-3

1,99970E-1

3,51844E-2

1,56086E-11

7,05723E-17

1,67820E-19

4,39734E-5

4,69206E-11

2,15078E-21

3,00000E-1

1,42574E-7

1,51732E-9

2,99723E-1

2.0

mean

1,26287E-3

3,00000E-1

7,18383E-10

2,77048E-4

6,48399E-2

2,25072E-9

1,98661E-1

3,60273E-1

3,17960E-5

3,02708E-3

1,99968E-1

3,51601E-2

1,35614E-11

3,16666E-22

1,67641E-19

4,39429E-5

4,35739E-11

1,84098E-21

3,00000E-1

1,42568E-7

1,51402E-9

2,99723E-1

2.0

relative error(%)

0,00

2.2

BioUML

1,53842E-3

3,00000E-1

1,34251E-9

3,36584E-4

6,37887E-2

4,22431E-9

1,98358E-1

3,58514E-1

4,51683E-5

3,39982E-3

1,99955E-1

3,62113E-2

3,06736E-11

1,49808E-21

6,49299E-19

5,76935E-5

8,91097E-11

7,84596E-21

3,00000E-1

2,31818E-7

2,58554E-9

2,99663E-1

2.2

ByoDyn

1,53842E-3

3,00000E-1

1,34251E-9

3,36584E-4

6,37887E-2

4,22431E-9

1,98358E-1

3,58514E-1

4,51683E-5

3,39982E-3

1,99955E-1

3,62113E-2

3,06736E-11

1,49808E-21

6,49299E-19

5,76935E-5

8,91097E-11

7,84596E-21

3,00000E-1

2,31818E-7

2,58554E-9

2,99663E-1

2.2

CVODE

1,53842E-3

3,00000E-1

1,34251E-9

3,36584E-4

6,37887E-2

4,22431E-9

1,98358E-1

3,58514E-1

4,51683E-5

3,39982E-3

1,99955E-1

3,62113E-2

3,06738E-11

1,49973E-21

6,49416E-19

5,76935E-5

8,91097E-11

7,84985E-21

3,00000E-1

2,31818E-7

2,58554E-9

2,99663E-1

2.2

Jarnac

1,53842E-3

3,00000E-1

1,34247E-9

3,36584E-4

6,37887E-2

4,22427E-9

1,98358E-1

3,58514E-1

4,51683E-5

3,39982E-3

1,99955E-1

3,62113E-2

3,06594E-11

-2,47136E-13

6,49091E-19

5,76935E-5

8,90926E-11

-9,79223E-14

3,00000E-1

2,31818E-7

2,58553E-9

2,99663E-1

2.2

MathSBML

1,53842E-3

3,00000E-1

1,34321E-9

3,36584E-4

6,37887E-2

4,22633E-9

1,98358E-1

3,58514E-1

4,51684E-5

3,39982E-3

1,99955E-1

3,62113E-2

3,06739E-11

1,51150E-21

6,51218E-19

5,76935E-5

8,90703E-11

7,89619E-21

3,00000E-1

2,31818E-7

2,58257E-9

2,99663E-1

2.2

Oscill8 Core

1,53843E-3

3,00000E-1

6,37887E-2

1,98358E-1

3,58514E-1

4,51691E-5

3,39982E-3

1,99955E-1

3,12199E-11

6,35186E-19

5,76940E-5

8,82786E-11

3,00000E-1

2,58540E-9

2,99663E-1

2.2

SBToolbox2

1,53688E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36600E-9

3,36215E-4

6,37666E-2

4,30548E-9

1,98362E-1

3,58498E-1

4,53454E-5

3,39923E-3

1,99952E-1

3,62334E-2

3,39745E-11

1,76885E-21

5,92413E-19

5,77152E-5

9,36866E-11

7,95388E-21

3,00000E-1

2,29282E-7

2,57720E-9

2,99662E-1

2.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,53843E-3

3,00000E-1

1,34259E-9

3,36585E-4

6,37887E-2

4,22458E-9

1,98358E-1

3,58514E-1

4,51690E-5

3,39982E-3

1,99955E-1

3,62113E-2

3,06770E-11

1,49873E-21

6,49507E-19

5,76939E-5

8,91170E-11

7,84893E-21

3,00000E-1

2,31826E-7

2,58565E-9

2,99663E-1

2.2

copasi

1,53842E-3

3,00000E-1

1,34251E-9

3,36584E-4

6,37887E-2

4,22431E-9

1,98358E-1

3,58514E-1

4,51683E-5

3,39982E-3

1,99955E-1

3,62113E-2

3,06736E-11

1,50036E-21

6,49642E-19

5,76935E-5

8,91096E-11

7,86374E-21

3,00000E-1

2,31818E-7

2,58554E-9

2,99663E-1

2.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,53842E-3

3,00000E-1

1,34251E-9

3,36584E-4

6,37887E-2

4,22430E-9

1,98358E-1

3,58514E-1

4,51683E-5

3,39982E-3

1,99955E-1

3,62113E-2

3,06747E-11

4,77266E-16

6,49629E-19

5,76935E-5

8,91098E-11

-4,71845E-16

3,00000E-1

2,31818E-7

2,58554E-9

2,99663E-1

2.2

jsim

1,53842E-3

3,00000E-1

1,34251E-9

3,36584E-4

6,37887E-2

4,22431E-9

1,98358E-1

3,58514E-1

4,51683E-5

3,39982E-3

1,99955E-1

3,62113E-2

3,06736E-11

1,49808E-21

6,49299E-19

5,76935E-5

8,91097E-11

7,84596E-21

3,00000E-1

2,31818E-7

2,58554E-9

2,99663E-1

2.2

min

1,53688E-3

3,00000E-1

1,34247E-9

3,36215E-4

6,37666E-2

4,22427E-9

1,98358E-1

3,58498E-1

4,51683E-5

3,39923E-3

1,99952E-1

3,62113E-2

3,06594E-11

-2,47136E-13

5,92413E-19

5,76935E-5

8,82786E-11

-9,79223E-14

3,00000E-1

2,29282E-7

2,57720E-9

2,99662E-1

2.2

max

1,53843E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36600E-9

3,36585E-4

6,37887E-2

4,30548E-9

1,98362E-1

3,58514E-1

4,53454E-5

3,39982E-3

1,99955E-1

3,62334E-2

3,39745E-11

4,77266E-16

6,51218E-19

5,77152E-5

9,36866E-11

7,95388E-21

3,00000E-1

2,31826E-7

2,58565E-9

2,99663E-1

2.2

mean

1,53842E-3

3,00000E-1

1,34251E-9

3,36584E-4

6,37887E-2

4,22431E-9

1,98358E-1

3,58514E-1

4,51683E-5

3,39982E-3

1,99955E-1

3,62113E-2

3,06739E-11

1,49973E-21

6,49358E-19

5,76935E-5

8,91097E-11

7,84893E-21

3,00000E-1

2,31818E-7

2,58554E-9

2,99663E-1

2.2

relative error(%)

0,00

2.4

BioUML

1,83218E-3

3,00000E-1

2,34887E-9

3,99837E-4

6,29230E-2

7,42247E-9

1,98032E-1

3,56922E-1

6,17696E-5

3,76849E-3

1,99938E-1

3,70770E-2

6,37937E-11

6,05537E-21

2,18534E-18

7,35745E-5

1,69121E-10

2,87987E-20

3,00000E-1

3,57852E-7

4,17335E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

ByoDyn

1,83218E-3

3,00000E-1

2,34887E-9

3,99837E-4

6,29230E-2

7,42247E-9

1,98032E-1

3,56922E-1

6,17696E-5

3,76849E-3

1,99938E-1

3,70770E-2

6,37937E-11

6,05537E-21

2,18534E-18

7,35745E-5

1,69121E-10

2,87987E-20

3,00000E-1

3,57852E-7

4,17335E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

CVODE

1,83218E-3

3,00000E-1

2,34887E-9

3,99837E-4

6,29230E-2

7,42247E-9

1,98032E-1

3,56922E-1

6,17696E-5

3,76849E-3

1,99938E-1

3,70770E-2

6,37939E-11

6,05959E-21

2,18558E-18

7,35745E-5

1,69121E-10

2,88075E-20

3,00000E-1

3,57852E-7

4,17335E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

Jarnac

1,83218E-3

3,00000E-1

2,34884E-9

3,99837E-4

6,29230E-2

7,42243E-9

1,98032E-1

3,56922E-1

6,17696E-5

3,76849E-3

1,99938E-1

3,70770E-2

6,37757E-11

-2,50522E-13

2,18493E-18

7,35745E-5

1,69102E-10

-8,99302E-14

3,00000E-1

3,57852E-7

4,17335E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

MathSBML

1,83218E-3

3,00000E-1

2,35106E-9

3,99837E-4

6,29229E-2

7,42881E-9

1,98032E-1

3,56922E-1

6,17698E-5

3,76849E-3

1,99938E-1

3,70771E-2

6,37973E-11

6,08663E-21

2,18930E-18

7,35745E-5

1,69012E-10

2,89542E-20

3,00000E-1

3,57851E-7

4,16440E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

Oscill8 Core

1,83219E-3

3,00000E-1

6,29230E-2

1,98032E-1

3,56922E-1

6,17705E-5

3,76849E-3

1,99938E-1

6,40782E-11

2,16415E-18

7,35750E-5

1,68473E-10

3,00000E-1

4,17325E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

SBToolbox2

1,83025E-3

3,00000E-1

2,39376E-9

3,99388E-4

6,28984E-2

7,57730E-9

1,98035E-1

3,56899E-1

6,19736E-5

3,76808E-3

1,99940E-1

3,71016E-2

7,05634E-11

7,52887E-21

2,06710E-18

7,35890E-5

1,77848E-10

3,06768E-20

3,00000E-1

3,54961E-7

4,17133E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,83219E-3

3,00000E-1

2,34900E-9

3,99837E-4

6,29230E-2

7,42287E-9

1,98032E-1

3,56922E-1

6,17704E-5

3,76849E-3

1,99938E-1

3,70770E-2

6,37997E-11

6,05764E-21

2,18594E-18

7,35750E-5

1,69133E-10

2,88080E-20

3,00000E-1

3,57862E-7

4,17350E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

copasi

1,83218E-3

3,00000E-1

2,34887E-9

3,99837E-4

6,29230E-2

7,42247E-9

1,98032E-1

3,56922E-1

6,17696E-5

3,76849E-3

1,99938E-1

3,70770E-2

6,37935E-11

6,06515E-21

2,18605E-18

7,35745E-5

1,69121E-10

2,88381E-20

3,00000E-1

3,57852E-7

4,17336E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,83218E-3

3,00000E-1

2,34887E-9

3,99837E-4

6,29230E-2

7,42246E-9

1,98032E-1

3,56922E-1

6,17696E-5

3,76849E-3

1,99938E-1

3,70770E-2

6,37948E-11

6,30140E-16

2,18600E-18

7,35745E-5

1,69121E-10

-6,10623E-16

3,00000E-1

3,57852E-7

4,17335E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

jsim

1,83218E-3

3,00000E-1

2,34887E-9

3,99837E-4

6,29230E-2

7,42247E-9

1,98032E-1

3,56922E-1

6,17696E-5

3,76849E-3

1,99938E-1

3,70770E-2

6,37937E-11

6,05537E-21

2,18534E-18

7,35745E-5

1,69121E-10

2,87987E-20

3,00000E-1

3,57852E-7

4,17335E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

min

1,83025E-3

3,00000E-1

2,34884E-9

3,99388E-4

6,28984E-2

7,42243E-9

1,98032E-1

3,56899E-1

6,17696E-5

3,76808E-3

1,99938E-1

3,70770E-2

6,37757E-11

-2,50522E-13

2,06710E-18

7,35745E-5

1,68473E-10

-8,99302E-14

3,00000E-1

3,54961E-7

4,16440E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

max

1,83219E-3

3,00000E-1

2,39376E-9

3,99837E-4

6,29230E-2

7,57730E-9

1,98035E-1

3,56922E-1

6,19736E-5

3,76849E-3

1,99940E-1

3,71016E-2

7,05634E-11

6,30140E-16

2,18930E-18

7,35890E-5

1,77848E-10

3,06768E-20

3,00000E-1

3,57862E-7

4,17350E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

mean

1,83218E-3

3,00000E-1

2,34887E-9

3,99837E-4

6,29230E-2

7,42247E-9

1,98032E-1

3,56922E-1

6,17696E-5

3,76849E-3

1,99938E-1

3,70770E-2

6,37944E-11

6,05959E-21

2,18546E-18

7,35745E-5

1,69121E-10

2,88075E-20

3,00000E-1

3,57852E-7

4,17335E-9

2,99600E-1

2.4

relative error(%)

0,00

2.6

BioUML

2,14161E-3

3,00000E-1

3,89149E-9

4,66258E-4

6,22111E-2

1,23489E-8

1,97684E-1

3,55470E-1

8,18490E-5

4,13270E-3

1,99918E-1

3,77889E-2

1,23737E-10

2,14461E-20

6,54630E-18

9,15986E-5

3,01712E-10

9,33522E-20

3,00000E-1

5,29166E-7

6,43023E-9

2,99534E-1

2.6

ByoDyn

2,14161E-3

3,00000E-1

3,89149E-9

4,66258E-4

6,22111E-2

1,23489E-8

1,97684E-1

3,55470E-1

8,18490E-5

4,13270E-3

1,99918E-1

3,77889E-2

1,23737E-10

2,14461E-20

6,54630E-18

9,15986E-5

3,01712E-10

9,33522E-20

3,00000E-1

5,29166E-7

6,43023E-9

2,99534E-1

2.6

CVODE

2,14161E-3

3,00000E-1

3,89149E-9

4,66258E-4

6,22111E-2

1,23489E-8

1,97684E-1

3,55470E-1

8,18490E-5

4,13270E-3

1,99918E-1

3,77889E-2

1,23737E-10

2,14563E-20

6,54681E-18

9,15986E-5

3,01712E-10

9,33717E-20

3,00000E-1

5,29166E-7

6,43023E-9

2,99534E-1

2.6

Jarnac

2,14161E-3

3,00000E-1

3,89146E-9

4,66258E-4

6,22111E-2

1,23489E-8

1,97684E-1

3,55470E-1

8,18490E-5

4,13270E-3

1,99918E-1

3,77889E-2

1,23715E-10

-2,51077E-13

6,54555E-18

9,15986E-5

3,01691E-10

-8,47721E-14

3,00000E-1

5,29166E-7

6,43022E-9

2,99534E-1

2.6

MathSBML

2,14161E-3

3,00000E-1

3,89026E-9

4,66258E-4

6,22111E-2

1,23453E-8

1,97684E-1

3,55470E-1

8,18491E-5

4,13270E-3

1,99918E-1

3,77889E-2

1,23706E-10

2,14648E-20

6,53777E-18

9,15988E-5

3,01733E-10

9,38321E-20

3,00000E-1

5,29165E-7

6,43458E-9

2,99534E-1

2.6

Oscill8 Core

2,14161E-3

3,00000E-1

6,22112E-2

1,97684E-1

3,55470E-1

8,18500E-5

4,13270E-3

1,99918E-1

1,23834E-10

6,51745E-18

9,15992E-5

3,01226E-10

3,00000E-1

6,43017E-9

2,99534E-1

2.6

SBToolbox2

2,13969E-3

3,00000E-1

3,93854E-9

4,65811E-4

6,21893E-2

1,25167E-8

1,97685E-1

3,55448E-1

8,20390E-5

4,13249E-3

1,99920E-1

3,78107E-2

1,33946E-10

2,44264E-20

5,94553E-18

9,16050E-5

3,13226E-10

9,32272E-20

3,00000E-1

5,23804E-7

6,40849E-9

2,99533E-1

2.6

SBWOdeSolver

2,14161E-3

3,00000E-1

3,89167E-9

4,66259E-4

6,22112E-2

1,23495E-8

1,97684E-1

3,55470E-1

8,18499E-5

4,13270E-3

1,99918E-1

3,77888E-2

1,23747E-10

2,14531E-20

6,54789E-18

9,15991E-5

3,01730E-10

9,33782E-20

3,00000E-1

5,29179E-7

6,43043E-9

2,99534E-1

2.6

copasi

2,14161E-3

3,00000E-1

3,89149E-9

4,66258E-4

6,22111E-2

1,23490E-8

1,97684E-1

3,55470E-1

8,18490E-5

4,13270E-3

1,99918E-1

3,77889E-2

1,23737E-10

2,14728E-20

6,54774E-18

9,15986E-5

3,01712E-10

9,34355E-20

3,00000E-1

5,29166E-7

6,43023E-9

2,99534E-1

2.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,14161E-3

3,00000E-1

3,89149E-9

4,66258E-4

6,22111E-2

1,23489E-8

1,97684E-1

3,55470E-1

8,18490E-5

4,13270E-3

1,99918E-1

3,77889E-2

1,23738E-10

6,47242E-16

6,54753E-18

9,15986E-5

3,01712E-10

-5,82867E-16

3,00000E-1

5,29166E-7

6,43023E-9

2,99534E-1

2.6

jsim

2,14161E-3

3,00000E-1

3,89149E-9

4,66258E-4

6,22112E-2

1,23489E-8

1,97684E-1

3,55470E-1

8,18490E-5

4,13270E-3

1,99918E-1

3,77888E-2

1,23737E-10

2,14461E-20

6,54630E-18

9,15986E-5

3,01712E-10

9,33522E-20

3,00000E-1

5,29166E-7

6,43023E-9

2,99534E-1

2.6

min

2,13969E-3

3,00000E-1

3,89026E-9

4,65811E-4

6,21893E-2

1,23453E-8

1,97684E-1

3,55448E-1

8,18490E-5

4,13249E-3

1,99918E-1

3,77888E-2

1,23706E-10

-2,51077E-13

5,94553E-18

9,15986E-5

3,01226E-10

-8,47721E-14

3,00000E-1

5,23804E-7

6,40849E-9

2,99533E-1

2.6

max

2,14161E-3

3,00000E-1

3,93854E-9

4,66259E-4

6,22112E-2

1,25167E-8

1,97685E-1

3,55470E-1

8,20390E-5

4,13270E-3

1,99920E-1

3,78107E-2

1,33946E-10

6,47242E-16

6,54789E-18

9,16050E-5

3,13226E-10

9,38321E-20

3,00000E-1

5,29179E-7

6,43458E-9

2,99534E-1

2.6

mean

2,14161E-3

3,00000E-1

3,89149E-9

4,66258E-4

6,22111E-2

1,23489E-8

1,97684E-1

3,55470E-1

8,18490E-5

4,13270E-3

1,99918E-1

3,77889E-2

1,23737E-10

2,14563E-20

6,54630E-18

9,15986E-5

3,01712E-10

9,33522E-20

3,00000E-1

5,29166E-7

6,43023E-9

2,99534E-1

2.6

relative error(%)

0,00

2.8

BioUML

2,46439E-3

3,00000E-1

6,15871E-9

5,35357E-4

6,16272E-2

1,96246E-8

1,97317E-1

3,54134E-1

1,05616E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99894E-1

3,83728E-2

2,26303E-10

6,79511E-20

1,77808E-17

1,11764E-4

5,10970E-10

2,72561E-19

3,00000E-1

7,54791E-7

9,52955E-9

2,99465E-1

2.8

ByoDyn

2,46439E-3

3,00000E-1

6,15871E-9

5,35357E-4

6,16272E-2

1,96246E-8

1,97317E-1

3,54134E-1

1,05616E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99894E-1

3,83728E-2

2,26303E-10

6,79511E-20

1,77808E-17

1,11764E-4

5,10970E-10

2,72561E-19

3,00000E-1

7,54791E-7

9,52955E-9

2,99465E-1

2.8

CVODE

2,46439E-3

3,00000E-1

6,15870E-9

5,35357E-4

6,16272E-2

1,96246E-8

1,97317E-1

3,54134E-1

1,05616E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99894E-1

3,83728E-2

2,26304E-10

6,80077E-20

1,77844E-17

1,11764E-4

5,10970E-10

2,72680E-19

3,00000E-1

7,54791E-7

9,52955E-9

2,99465E-1

2.8

Jarnac

2,46439E-3

3,00000E-1

6,15868E-9

5,35357E-4

6,16272E-2

1,96245E-8

1,97317E-1

3,54134E-1

1,05616E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99894E-1

3,83728E-2

2,26277E-10

-2,51021E-13

1,77795E-17

1,11764E-4

5,10948E-10

-7,96763E-14

3,00000E-1

7,54791E-7

9,52954E-9

2,99465E-1

2.8

MathSBML

2,46439E-3

3,00000E-1

6,14761E-9

5,35357E-4

6,16272E-2

1,95920E-8

1,97317E-1

3,54134E-1

1,05616E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99894E-1

3,83728E-2

2,26190E-10

6,79414E-20

1,77203E-17

1,11765E-4

5,11389E-10

2,73959E-19

3,00000E-1

7,54790E-7

9,57248E-9

2,99465E-1

2.8

Oscill8 Core

2,46440E-3

3,00000E-1

6,16272E-2

1,97317E-1

3,54134E-1

1,05617E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99894E-1

2,26274E-10

1,77449E-17

1,11765E-4

5,10625E-10

3,00000E-1

9,52955E-9

2,99465E-1

2.8

SBToolbox2

2,46208E-3

3,00000E-1

6,26222E-9

5,34814E-4

6,16023E-2

1,99879E-8

1,97316E-1

3,54110E-1

1,05832E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99893E-1

3,83977E-2

2,47298E-10

8,81282E-20

1,74416E-17

1,11763E-4

5,33971E-10

3,01510E-19

3,00000E-1

7,49262E-7

9,53096E-9

2,99463E-1

2.8

SBWOdeSolver

2,46440E-3

3,00000E-1

6,15895E-9

5,35358E-4

6,16272E-2

1,96254E-8

1,97317E-1

3,54134E-1

1,05617E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99894E-1

3,83728E-2

2,26320E-10

6,79704E-20

1,77846E-17

1,11765E-4

5,10997E-10

2,72628E-19

3,00000E-1

7,54807E-7

9,52981E-9

2,99465E-1

2.8

copasi

2,46439E-3

3,00000E-1

6,15870E-9

5,35357E-4

6,16272E-2

1,96246E-8

1,97317E-1

3,54134E-1

1,05616E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99894E-1

3,83728E-2

2,26303E-10

6,80065E-20

1,77829E-17

1,11764E-4

5,10970E-10

2,72702E-19

3,00000E-1

7,54791E-7

9,52956E-9

2,99465E-1

2.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,46439E-3

3,00000E-1

6,15870E-9

5,35357E-4

6,16272E-2

1,96246E-8

1,97317E-1

3,54134E-1

1,05616E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99894E-1

3,83728E-2

2,26304E-10

6,60019E-16

1,77829E-17

1,11764E-4

5,10970E-10

-5,27356E-16

3,00000E-1

7,54791E-7

9,52954E-9

2,99465E-1

2.8

jsim

2,46439E-3

3,00000E-1

6,15871E-9

5,35357E-4

6,16272E-2

1,96246E-8

1,97317E-1

3,54134E-1

1,05616E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99894E-1

3,83728E-2

2,26303E-10

6,79511E-20

1,77808E-17

1,11764E-4

5,10970E-10

2,72561E-19

3,00000E-1

7,54791E-7

9,52955E-9

2,99465E-1

2.8

min

2,46208E-3

3,00000E-1

6,14761E-9

5,34814E-4

6,16023E-2

1,95920E-8

1,97316E-1

3,54110E-1

1,05616E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99893E-1

3,83728E-2

2,26190E-10

-2,51021E-13

1,74416E-17

1,11763E-4

5,10625E-10

-7,96763E-14

3,00000E-1

7,49262E-7

9,52954E-9

2,99463E-1

2.8

max

2,46440E-3

3,00000E-1

6,26222E-9

5,35358E-4

6,16272E-2

1,99879E-8

1,97317E-1

3,54134E-1

1,05832E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99894E-1

3,83977E-2

2,47298E-10

6,60019E-16

1,77846E-17

1,11765E-4

5,33971E-10

3,01510E-19

3,00000E-1

7,54807E-7

9,57248E-9

2,99465E-1

2.8

mean

2,46439E-3

3,00000E-1

6,15870E-9

5,35357E-4

6,16272E-2

1,96246E-8

1,97317E-1

3,54134E-1

1,05616E-4

4,49239E-3

1,99894E-1

3,83728E-2

2,26303E-10

6,79704E-20

1,77808E-17

1,11764E-4

5,10970E-10

2,72628E-19

3,00000E-1

7,54791E-7

9,52955E-9

2,99465E-1

2.8

relative error(%)

0,00

3.0

BioUML

2,79844E-3

3,00000E-1

9,37493E-9

6,06700E-4

6,11495E-2

2,99949E-8

1,96933E-1

3,52896E-1

1,33243E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99867E-1

3,88505E-2

3,93649E-10

1,95799E-19

4,44359E-17

1,34060E-4

8,27903E-10

7,28003E-19

3,00000E-1

1,04418E-6

1,36648E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

ByoDyn

2,79844E-3

3,00000E-1

9,37493E-9

6,06700E-4

6,11495E-2

2,99949E-8

1,96933E-1

3,52896E-1

1,33243E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99867E-1

3,88505E-2

3,93649E-10

1,95799E-19

4,44359E-17

1,34060E-4

8,27903E-10

7,28003E-19

3,00000E-1

1,04418E-6

1,36648E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

CVODE

2,79844E-3

3,00000E-1

9,37492E-9

6,06700E-4

6,11495E-2

2,99949E-8

1,96933E-1

3,52896E-1

1,33243E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99867E-1

3,88505E-2

3,93650E-10

1,95960E-19

4,44433E-17

1,34060E-4

8,27903E-10

7,28301E-19

3,00000E-1

1,04418E-6

1,36648E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

Jarnac

2,79844E-3

3,00000E-1

9,37490E-9

6,06700E-4

6,11495E-2

2,99948E-8

1,96933E-1

3,52896E-1

1,33243E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99867E-1

3,88505E-2

3,93619E-10

-2,48968E-13

4,44337E-17

1,34060E-4

8,27880E-10

-7,63168E-14

3,00000E-1

1,04418E-6

1,36648E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

MathSBML

2,79844E-3

3,00000E-1

9,37161E-9

6,06699E-4

6,11494E-2

2,99851E-8

1,96933E-1

3,52896E-1

1,33243E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99867E-1

3,88506E-2

3,93587E-10

1,95856E-19

4,44247E-17

1,34060E-4

8,28003E-10

7,29864E-19

3,00000E-1

1,04418E-6

1,36773E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

Oscill8 Core

2,79845E-3

3,00000E-1

6,11495E-2

1,96933E-1

3,52896E-1

1,33244E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99867E-1

3,93542E-10

4,43956E-17

1,34061E-4

8,27681E-10

3,00000E-1

1,36649E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

SBToolbox2

2,79650E-3

3,00000E-1

9,43255E-9

6,06234E-4

6,11293E-2

3,02150E-8

1,96936E-1

3,52878E-1

1,33416E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99870E-1

3,88707E-2

4,16244E-10

1,83680E-19

3,67140E-17

1,34052E-4

8,48824E-10

6,35945E-19

3,00000E-1

1,03277E-6

1,35939E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,79845E-3

3,00000E-1

9,37524E-9

6,06700E-4

6,11495E-2

2,99959E-8

1,96933E-1

3,52896E-1

1,33244E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99867E-1

3,88505E-2

3,93674E-10

1,95848E-19

4,44441E-17

1,34061E-4

8,27941E-10

7,28158E-19

3,00000E-1

1,04420E-6

1,36652E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

copasi

2,79844E-3

3,00000E-1

9,37493E-9

6,06700E-4

6,11495E-2

2,99949E-8

1,96933E-1

3,52896E-1

1,33243E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99867E-1

3,88505E-2

3,93649E-10

1,95912E-19

4,44393E-17

1,34060E-4

8,27903E-10

7,28237E-19

3,00000E-1

1,04418E-6

1,36648E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,79844E-3

3,00000E-1

9,37492E-9

6,06700E-4

6,11495E-2

2,99949E-8

1,96933E-1

3,52896E-1

1,33243E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99867E-1

3,88505E-2

3,93650E-10

8,51334E-16

4,44468E-17

1,34060E-4

8,27902E-10

-8,60423E-16

3,00000E-1

1,04418E-6

1,36648E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

jsim

2,79844E-3

3,00000E-1

9,37493E-9

6,06700E-4

6,11495E-2

2,99949E-8

1,96933E-1

3,52896E-1

1,33243E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99867E-1

3,88505E-2

3,93649E-10

1,95799E-19

4,44359E-17

1,34060E-4

8,27903E-10

7,28003E-19

3,00000E-1

1,04418E-6

1,36648E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

min

2,79650E-3

3,00000E-1

9,37161E-9

6,06234E-4

6,11293E-2

2,99851E-8

1,96933E-1

3,52878E-1

1,33243E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99867E-1

3,88505E-2

3,93542E-10

-2,48968E-13

3,67140E-17

1,34052E-4

8,27681E-10

-7,63168E-14

3,00000E-1

1,03277E-6

1,35939E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

max

2,79845E-3

3,00000E-1

9,43255E-9

6,06700E-4

6,11495E-2

3,02150E-8

1,96936E-1

3,52896E-1

1,33416E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99870E-1

3,88707E-2

4,16244E-10

8,51334E-16

4,44468E-17

1,34061E-4

8,48824E-10

7,29864E-19

3,00000E-1

1,04420E-6

1,36773E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

mean

2,79844E-3

3,00000E-1

9,37493E-9

6,06700E-4

6,11495E-2

2,99949E-8

1,96933E-1

3,52896E-1

1,33243E-4

4,84769E-3

1,99867E-1

3,88505E-2

3,93649E-10

1,95848E-19

4,44359E-17

1,34060E-4

8,27903E-10

7,28003E-19

3,00000E-1

1,04418E-6

1,36648E-8

2,99393E-1

3.0

relative error(%)

0,00

3.2

BioUML

3,14190E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38019E-8

6,79905E-4

6,07601E-2

4,43359E-8

1,96533E-1

3,51738E-1

1,64865E-4

5,19884E-3

1,99835E-1

3,92399E-2

6,55788E-10

5,19872E-19

1,03376E-16

1,58465E-4

1,29135E-9

1,80105E-18

3,00000E-1

1,40710E-6

1,90493E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

ByoDyn

3,14190E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38019E-8

6,79905E-4

6,07601E-2

4,43359E-8

1,96533E-1

3,51738E-1

1,64865E-4

5,19884E-3

1,99835E-1

3,92399E-2

6,55788E-10

5,19872E-19

1,03376E-16

1,58465E-4

1,29135E-9

1,80105E-18

3,00000E-1

1,40710E-6

1,90493E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

CVODE

3,14190E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38019E-8

6,79905E-4

6,07601E-2

4,43359E-8

1,96533E-1

3,51738E-1

1,64865E-4

5,19884E-3

1,99835E-1

3,92399E-2

6,55789E-10

5,20229E-19

1,03389E-16

1,58465E-4

1,29135E-9

1,80163E-18

3,00000E-1

1,40710E-6

1,90493E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

Jarnac

3,14190E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38019E-8

6,79905E-4

6,07601E-2

4,43359E-8

1,96533E-1

3,51738E-1

1,64865E-4

5,19884E-3

1,99835E-1

3,92399E-2

6,55754E-10

-2,46470E-13

1,03372E-16

1,58465E-4

1,29132E-9

-7,27120E-14

3,00000E-1

1,40710E-6

1,90493E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

MathSBML

3,14190E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38460E-8

6,79905E-4

6,07601E-2

4,44650E-8

1,96533E-1

3,51738E-1

1,64865E-4

5,19884E-3

1,99835E-1

3,92399E-2

6,56079E-10

5,21164E-19

1,03905E-16

1,58465E-4

1,28951E-9

1,79679E-18

3,00000E-1

1,40710E-6

1,88761E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

Oscill8 Core

3,14190E-3

3,00000E-1

6,07601E-2

1,96533E-1

3,51738E-1

1,64867E-4

5,19884E-3

1,99835E-1

6,55646E-10

1,03337E-16

1,58466E-4

1,29123E-9

3,00000E-1

1,90494E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

SBToolbox2

3,13943E-3

3,00000E-1

1,39848E-8

6,79336E-4

6,07358E-2

4,49964E-8

1,96536E-1

3,51719E-1

1,65059E-4

5,19910E-3

1,99833E-1

3,92642E-2

7,07570E-10

6,58606E-19

1,00531E-16

1,58440E-4

1,33999E-9

1,95890E-18

3,00000E-1

1,39534E-6

1,90308E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

SBWOdeSolver

3,14190E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38023E-8

6,79905E-4

6,07601E-2

4,43373E-8

1,96533E-1

3,51738E-1

1,64866E-4

5,19884E-3

1,99835E-1

3,92399E-2

6,55825E-10

5,19987E-19

1,03393E-16

1,58466E-4

1,29140E-9

1,80139E-18

3,00000E-1

1,40713E-6

1,90497E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

copasi

3,14190E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38019E-8

6,79905E-4

6,07601E-2

4,43359E-8

1,96533E-1

3,51738E-1

1,64865E-4

5,19884E-3

1,99835E-1

3,92399E-2

6,55788E-10

5,20101E-19

1,03382E-16

1,58465E-4

1,29135E-9

1,80144E-18

3,00000E-1

1,40710E-6

1,90493E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,14190E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38019E-8

6,79905E-4

6,07601E-2

4,43359E-8

1,96533E-1

3,51738E-1

1,64865E-4

5,19884E-3

1,99835E-1

3,92399E-2

6,55790E-10

1,35366E-15

1,03407E-16

1,58465E-4

1,29135E-9

-1,33227E-15

3,00000E-1

1,40710E-6

1,90493E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

jsim

3,14190E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38019E-8

6,79905E-4

6,07601E-2

4,43359E-8

1,96533E-1

3,51738E-1

1,64865E-4

5,19884E-3

1,99835E-1

3,92399E-2

6,55788E-10

5,19872E-19

1,03376E-16

1,58465E-4

1,29135E-9

1,80105E-18

3,00000E-1

1,40710E-6

1,90493E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

min

3,13943E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38019E-8

6,79336E-4

6,07358E-2

4,43359E-8

1,96533E-1

3,51719E-1

1,64865E-4

5,19884E-3

1,99833E-1

3,92399E-2

6,55646E-10

-2,46470E-13

1,00531E-16

1,58440E-4

1,28951E-9

-7,27120E-14

3,00000E-1

1,39534E-6

1,88761E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

max

3,14190E-3

3,00000E-1

1,39848E-8

6,79905E-4

6,07601E-2

4,49964E-8

1,96536E-1

3,51738E-1

1,65059E-4

5,19910E-3

1,99835E-1

3,92642E-2

7,07570E-10

1,35366E-15

1,03905E-16

1,58466E-4

1,33999E-9

1,95890E-18

3,00000E-1

1,40713E-6

1,90497E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

mean

3,14190E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38019E-8

6,79905E-4

6,07601E-2

4,43359E-8

1,96533E-1

3,51738E-1

1,64865E-4

5,19884E-3

1,99835E-1

3,92399E-2

6,55789E-10

5,20101E-19

1,03379E-16

1,58465E-4

1,29135E-9

1,80105E-18

3,00000E-1

1,40710E-6

1,90493E-8

2,99320E-1

3.2

relative error(%)

0,00

3.4

BioUML

3,49312E-3

3,00000E-1

1,97395E-8

7,54644E-4

6,04443E-2

6,36591E-8

1,96119E-1

3,50649E-1

2,00589E-4

5,54616E-3

1,99799E-1

3,95557E-2

1,05221E-9

1,28556E-18

2,26008E-16

1,84954E-4

1,94884E-9

4,16894E-18

3,00000E-1

1,85359E-6

2,59151E-8

2,99245E-1

3.4

ByoDyn

3,49312E-3

3,00000E-1

1,97395E-8

7,54644E-4

6,04443E-2

6,36591E-8

1,96119E-1

3,50649E-1

2,00589E-4

5,54616E-3

1,99799E-1

3,95557E-2

1,05221E-9

1,28556E-18

2,26008E-16

1,84954E-4

1,94884E-9

4,16894E-18

3,00000E-1

1,85359E-6

2,59151E-8

2,99245E-1

3.4

CVODE

3,49312E-3

3,00000E-1

1,97395E-8

7,54644E-4

6,04443E-2

6,36591E-8

1,96119E-1

3,50649E-1

2,00589E-4

5,54616E-3

1,99799E-1

3,95557E-2

1,05221E-9

1,28625E-18

2,26028E-16

1,84954E-4

1,94884E-9

4,16994E-18

3,00000E-1

1,85359E-6

2,59151E-8

2,99245E-1

3.4

Jarnac

3,49312E-3

3,00000E-1

1,97395E-8

7,54644E-4

6,04443E-2

6,36591E-8

1,96119E-1

3,50649E-1

2,00589E-4

5,54616E-3

1,99799E-1

3,95557E-2

1,05217E-9

-2,43583E-13

2,26003E-16

1,84954E-4

1,94881E-9

-6,98925E-14

3,00000E-1

1,85359E-6

2,59151E-8

2,99245E-1

3.4

MathSBML

3,49312E-3

3,00000E-1

1,97829E-8

7,54644E-4

6,04443E-2

6,37860E-8

1,96119E-1

3,50648E-1

2,00589E-4

5,54616E-3

1,99799E-1

3,95557E-2

1,05250E-9

1,28928E-18

2,26424E-16

1,84954E-4

1,94704E-9

4,15986E-18

3,00000E-1

1,85359E-6

2,57451E-8

2,99245E-1

3.4

Oscill8 Core

3,49312E-3

3,00000E-1

6,04443E-2

1,96119E-1

3,50649E-1

2,00590E-4

5,54616E-3

1,99799E-1

1,05206E-9

2,25980E-16

1,84955E-4

1,94883E-9

3,00000E-1

2,59154E-8

2,99245E-1

3.4

SBToolbox2

3,49075E-3

3,00000E-1

1,99075E-8

7,54095E-4

6,04218E-2

6,42870E-8

1,96120E-1

3,50627E-1

2,00761E-4

5,54642E-3

1,99800E-1

3,95782E-2

1,11596E-9

1,26845E-18

1,93357E-16

1,84921E-4

2,00379E-9

3,80872E-18

3,00000E-1

1,83654E-6

2,58369E-8

2,99243E-1

3.4

SBWOdeSolver

3,49312E-3

3,00000E-1

1,97400E-8

7,54645E-4

6,04443E-2

6,36609E-8

1,96119E-1

3,50649E-1

2,00590E-4

5,54616E-3

1,99799E-1

3,95557E-2

1,05226E-9

1,28584E-18

2,26065E-16

1,84955E-4

1,94891E-9

4,16974E-18

3,00000E-1

1,85362E-6

2,59155E-8

2,99245E-1

3.4

copasi

3,49312E-3

3,00000E-1

1,97395E-8

7,54644E-4

6,04443E-2

6,36590E-8

1,96119E-1

3,50649E-1

2,00589E-4

5,54616E-3

1,99799E-1

3,95557E-2

1,05221E-9

1,28808E-18

2,26130E-16

1,84954E-4

1,94884E-9

4,17348E-18

3,00000E-1

1,85359E-6

2,59152E-8

2,99245E-1

3.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,49312E-3

3,00000E-1

1,97395E-8

7,54644E-4

6,04443E-2

6,36591E-8

1,96119E-1

3,50649E-1

2,00589E-4

5,54616E-3

1,99799E-1

3,95557E-2

1,05221E-9

1,88899E-15

2,26059E-16

1,84954E-4

1,94884E-9

-1,99840E-15

3,00000E-1

1,85359E-6

2,59151E-8

2,99245E-1

3.4

jsim

3,49312E-3

3,00000E-1

1,97395E-8

7,54644E-4

6,04443E-2

6,36591E-8

1,96119E-1

3,50648E-1

2,00589E-4

5,54616E-3

1,99799E-1

3,95557E-2

1,05221E-9

1,28556E-18

2,26008E-16

1,84954E-4

1,94884E-9

4,16894E-18

3,00000E-1

1,85359E-6

2,59151E-8

2,99245E-1

3.4

min

3,49075E-3

3,00000E-1

1,97395E-8

7,54095E-4

6,04218E-2

6,36590E-8

1,96119E-1

3,50627E-1

2,00589E-4

5,54616E-3

1,99799E-1

3,95557E-2

1,05206E-9

-2,43583E-13

1,93357E-16

1,84921E-4

1,94704E-9

-6,98925E-14

3,00000E-1

1,83654E-6

2,57451E-8

2,99243E-1

3.4

max

3,49312E-3

3,00000E-1

1,99075E-8

7,54645E-4

6,04443E-2

6,42870E-8

1,96120E-1

3,50649E-1

2,00761E-4

5,54642E-3

1,99800E-1

3,95782E-2

1,11596E-9

1,88899E-15

2,26424E-16

1,84955E-4

2,00379E-9

4,17348E-18

3,00000E-1

1,85362E-6

2,59155E-8

2,99245E-1

3.4

mean

3,49312E-3

3,00000E-1

1,97395E-8

7,54644E-4

6,04443E-2

6,36591E-8

1,96119E-1

3,50649E-1

2,00589E-4

5,54616E-3

1,99799E-1

3,95557E-2

1,05221E-9

1,28584E-18

2,26018E-16

1,84954E-4

1,94884E-9

4,16894E-18

3,00000E-1

1,85359E-6

2,59151E-8

2,99245E-1

3.4

relative error(%)

0,00

3.6

BioUML

3,85066E-3

3,00000E-1

2,75263E-8

8,30636E-4

6,01896E-2

8,91144E-8

1,95693E-1

3,49616E-1

2,40489E-4

5,88999E-3

1,99759E-1

3,98104E-2

1,63358E-9

2,98686E-18

4,67982E-16

2,13496E-4

2,85745E-9

9,10398E-18

3,00000E-1

2,39384E-6

3,45133E-8

2,99169E-1

3.6

ByoDyn

3,85066E-3

3,00000E-1

2,75263E-8

8,30636E-4

6,01896E-2

8,91144E-8

1,95693E-1

3,49616E-1

2,40489E-4

5,88999E-3

1,99759E-1

3,98104E-2

1,63358E-9

2,98686E-18

4,67982E-16

2,13496E-4

2,85745E-9

9,10398E-18

3,00000E-1

2,39384E-6

3,45133E-8

2,99169E-1

3.6

CVODE

3,85066E-3

3,00000E-1

2,75263E-8

8,30636E-4

6,01896E-2

8,91144E-8

1,95693E-1

3,49616E-1

2,40489E-4

5,88999E-3

1,99759E-1

3,98104E-2

1,63358E-9

2,98806E-18

4,68011E-16

2,13496E-4

2,85745E-9

9,10555E-18

3,00000E-1

2,39384E-6

3,45133E-8

2,99169E-1

3.6

Jarnac

3,85066E-3

3,00000E-1

2,75263E-8

8,30636E-4

6,01896E-2

8,91144E-8

1,95693E-1

3,49616E-1

2,40489E-4

5,88999E-3

1,99759E-1

3,98104E-2

1,63354E-9

-2,40641E-13

4,67974E-16

2,13496E-4

2,85743E-9

-6,75810E-14

3,00000E-1

2,39384E-6

3,45133E-8

2,99169E-1

3.6

MathSBML

3,85066E-3

3,00000E-1

2,73661E-8

8,30636E-4

6,01896E-2

8,86453E-8

1,95693E-1

3,49616E-1

2,40489E-4

5,88999E-3

1,99759E-1

3,98104E-2

1,63235E-9

2,98408E-18

4,63093E-16

2,13496E-4

2,86399E-9

9,15570E-18

3,00000E-1

2,39384E-6

3,51405E-8

2,99169E-1

3.6

Oscill8 Core

3,85066E-3

3,00000E-1

6,01897E-2

1,95693E-1

3,49616E-1

2,40490E-4

5,88999E-3

1,99759E-1

1,63346E-9

4,67982E-16

2,13497E-4

2,85753E-9

3,00000E-1

3,45136E-8

2,99169E-1

3.6

SBToolbox2

3,84872E-3

3,00000E-1

2,76450E-8

8,30141E-4

6,01703E-2

8,96009E-8

1,95697E-1

3,49598E-1

2,40634E-4

5,89021E-3

1,99760E-1

3,98297E-2

1,71206E-9

2,81562E-18

3,85886E-16

2,13467E-4

2,91703E-9

7,96816E-18

3,00000E-1

2,36662E-6

3,43246E-8

2,99170E-1

3.6

SBWOdeSolver

3,85066E-3

3,00000E-1

2,75269E-8

8,30636E-4

6,01897E-2

8,91166E-8

1,95693E-1

3,49616E-1

2,40490E-4

5,88999E-3

1,99759E-1

3,98103E-2

1,63365E-9

2,98752E-18

4,68063E-16

2,13497E-4

2,85754E-9

9,10580E-18

3,00000E-1

2,39387E-6

3,45138E-8

2,99169E-1

3.6

copasi

3,85066E-3

3,00000E-1

2,75262E-8

8,30636E-4

6,01897E-2

8,91142E-8

1,95693E-1

3,49616E-1

2,40489E-4

5,88999E-3

1,99759E-1

3,98103E-2

1,63358E-9

2,99997E-18

4,68557E-16

2,13496E-4

2,85745E-9

9,12622E-18

3,00000E-1

2,39384E-6

3,45134E-8

2,99169E-1

3.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,85066E-3

3,00000E-1

2,75263E-8

8,30636E-4

6,01896E-2

8,91144E-8

1,95693E-1

3,49616E-1

2,40489E-4

5,88999E-3

1,99759E-1

3,98104E-2

1,63358E-9

1,66402E-15

4,68059E-16

2,13496E-4

2,85745E-9

-1,77636E-15

3,00000E-1

2,39384E-6

3,45133E-8

2,99169E-1

3.6

jsim

3,85066E-3

3,00000E-1

2,75263E-8

8,30636E-4

6,01896E-2

8,91144E-8

1,95693E-1

3,49616E-1

2,40489E-4

5,88999E-3

1,99759E-1

3,98104E-2

1,63358E-9

2,98686E-18

4,67982E-16

2,13496E-4

2,85745E-9

9,10398E-18

3,00000E-1

2,39384E-6

3,45133E-8

2,99169E-1

3.6

min

3,84872E-3

3,00000E-1

2,73661E-8

8,30141E-4

6,01703E-2

8,86453E-8

1,95693E-1

3,49598E-1

2,40489E-4

5,88999E-3

1,99759E-1

3,98103E-2

1,63235E-9

-2,40641E-13

3,85886E-16

2,13467E-4

2,85743E-9

-6,75810E-14

3,00000E-1

2,36662E-6

3,43246E-8

2,99169E-1

3.6

max

3,85066E-3

3,00000E-1

2,76450E-8

8,30636E-4

6,01897E-2

8,96009E-8

1,95697E-1

3,49616E-1

2,40634E-4

5,89021E-3

1,99760E-1

3,98297E-2

1,71206E-9

1,66402E-15

4,68557E-16

2,13497E-4

2,91703E-9

9,15570E-18

3,00000E-1

2,39387E-6

3,51405E-8

2,99170E-1

3.6

mean

3,85066E-3

3,00000E-1

2,75263E-8

8,30636E-4

6,01896E-2

8,91144E-8

1,95693E-1

3,49616E-1

2,40489E-4

5,88999E-3

1,99759E-1

3,98104E-2

1,63358E-9

2,98686E-18

4,67982E-16

2,13496E-4

2,85745E-9

9,10398E-18

3,00000E-1

2,39384E-6

3,45133E-8

2,99169E-1

3.6

relative error(%)

0,00

3.8

BioUML

4,21326E-3

3,00000E-1

3,75397E-8

9,07639E-4

5,99859E-2

1,21993E-7

1,95255E-1

3,48631E-1

2,84617E-4

6,23068E-3

1,99715E-1

4,00141E-2

2,46351E-9

6,56810E-18

9,23724E-16

2,44058E-4

4,08457E-9

1,88859E-17

3,00000E-1

3,03816E-6

4,51127E-8

2,99092E-1

3.8

ByoDyn

4,21326E-3

3,00000E-1

3,75397E-8

9,07639E-4

5,99859E-2

1,21993E-7

1,95255E-1

3,48631E-1

2,84617E-4

6,23068E-3

1,99715E-1

4,00141E-2

2,46351E-9

6,56810E-18

9,23724E-16

2,44058E-4

4,08457E-9

1,88859E-17

3,00000E-1

3,03816E-6

4,51127E-8

2,99092E-1

3.8

CVODE

4,21326E-3

3,00000E-1

3,75397E-8

9,07639E-4

5,99859E-2

1,21993E-7

1,95255E-1

3,48631E-1

2,84617E-4

6,23068E-3

1,99715E-1

4,00141E-2

2,46351E-9

6,57010E-18

9,23765E-16

2,44058E-4

4,08457E-9

1,88883E-17

3,00000E-1

3,03816E-6

4,51127E-8

2,99092E-1

3.8

Jarnac

4,21326E-3

3,00000E-1

3,75397E-8

9,07639E-4

5,99859E-2

1,21993E-7

1,95255E-1

3,48631E-1

2,84617E-4

6,23068E-3

1,99715E-1

4,00141E-2

2,46346E-9

-2,36589E-13

9,23713E-16

2,44058E-4

4,08455E-9

-6,76481E-14

3,00000E-1

3,03816E-6

4,51127E-8

2,99092E-1

3.8

MathSBML

4,21326E-3

3,00000E-1

3,71250E-8

9,07639E-4

5,99859E-2

1,20778E-7

1,95255E-1

3,48631E-1

2,84617E-4

6,23068E-3

1,99715E-1

4,00141E-2

2,46039E-9

6,53961E-18

9,11444E-16

2,44058E-4

4,10155E-9

1,91090E-17

3,00000E-1

3,03817E-6

4,67372E-8

2,99092E-1

3.8

Oscill8 Core

4,21326E-3

3,00000E-1

5,99860E-2

1,95255E-1

3,48631E-1

2,84619E-4

6,23068E-3

1,99715E-1

2,46344E-9

9,23777E-16

2,44059E-4

4,08474E-9

3,00000E-1

4,51131E-8

2,99092E-1

3.8

SBToolbox2

4,21078E-3

3,00000E-1

3,79364E-8

9,07049E-4

5,99634E-2

1,23474E-7

1,95258E-1

3,48609E-1

2,84742E-4

6,23104E-3

1,99714E-1

4,00366E-2

2,63224E-9

8,07646E-18

8,78453E-16

2,43993E-4

4,21691E-9

2,00168E-17

3,00000E-1

3,00920E-6

4,50304E-8

2,99094E-1

3.8

SBWOdeSolver

4,21326E-3

3,00000E-1

3,75405E-8

9,07639E-4

5,99860E-2

1,21996E-7

1,95255E-1

3,48631E-1

2,84618E-4

6,23068E-3

1,99715E-1

4,00140E-2

2,46361E-9

6,56941E-18

9,23849E-16

2,44059E-4

4,08469E-9

1,88891E-17

3,00000E-1

3,03820E-6

4,51134E-8

2,99092E-1

3.8

copasi

4,21326E-3

3,00000E-1

3,75396E-8

9,07639E-4

5,99860E-2

1,21993E-7

1,95255E-1

3,48631E-1

2,84617E-4

6,23068E-3

1,99715E-1

4,00140E-2

2,46352E-9

6,60685E-18

9,25134E-16

2,44058E-4

4,08456E-9

1,89465E-17

3,00000E-1

3,03817E-6

4,51127E-8

2,99092E-1

3.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,21326E-3

3,00000E-1

3,75397E-8

9,07639E-4

5,99859E-2

1,21993E-7

1,95255E-1

3,48631E-1

2,84617E-4

6,23068E-3

1,99715E-1

4,00141E-2

2,46351E-9

1,56627E-15

9,23853E-16

2,44058E-4

4,08457E-9

-1,69309E-15

3,00000E-1

3,03816E-6

4,51127E-8

2,99092E-1

3.8

jsim

4,21326E-3

3,00000E-1

3,75397E-8

9,07639E-4

5,99860E-2

1,21993E-7

1,95255E-1

3,48631E-1

2,84617E-4

6,23068E-3

1,99715E-1

4,00140E-2

2,46351E-9

6,56810E-18

9,23724E-16

2,44058E-4

4,08457E-9

1,88859E-17

3,00000E-1

3,03816E-6

4,51127E-8

2,99092E-1

3.8

min

4,21078E-3

3,00000E-1

3,71250E-8

9,07049E-4

5,99634E-2

1,20778E-7

1,95255E-1

3,48609E-1

2,84617E-4

6,23068E-3

1,99714E-1

4,00140E-2

2,46039E-9

-2,36589E-13

8,78453E-16

2,43993E-4

4,08455E-9

-6,76481E-14

3,00000E-1

3,00920E-6

4,50304E-8

2,99092E-1

3.8

max

4,21326E-3

3,00000E-1

3,79364E-8

9,07639E-4

5,99860E-2

1,23474E-7

1,95258E-1

3,48631E-1

2,84742E-4

6,23104E-3

1,99715E-1

4,00366E-2

2,63224E-9

1,56627E-15

9,25134E-16

2,44059E-4

4,21691E-9

2,00168E-17

3,00000E-1

3,03820E-6

4,67372E-8

2,99094E-1

3.8

mean

4,21326E-3

3,00000E-1

3,75397E-8

9,07639E-4

5,99859E-2

1,21993E-7

1,95255E-1

3,48631E-1

2,84617E-4

6,23068E-3

1,99715E-1

4,00141E-2

2,46351E-9

6,56941E-18

9,23744E-16

2,44058E-4

4,08457E-9

1,88883E-17

3,00000E-1

3,03816E-6

4,51127E-8

2,99092E-1

3.8

relative error(%)

0,00

4.0

BioUML

4,57984E-3

3,00000E-1

5,01960E-8

9,85450E-4

5,98247E-2

1,63729E-7

1,94806E-1

3,47687E-1

3,33002E-4

6,56857E-3

1,99667E-1

4,01753E-2

3,62040E-9

1,37541E-17

1,74750E-15

2,76604E-4

5,70865E-9

3,74331E-17

3,00000E-1

3,79693E-6

5,79998E-8

2,99015E-1

4.0

ByoDyn

4,57984E-3

3,00000E-1

5,01960E-8

9,85450E-4

5,98247E-2

1,63729E-7

1,94806E-1

3,47687E-1

3,33002E-4

6,56857E-3

1,99667E-1

4,01753E-2

3,62040E-9

1,37541E-17

1,74750E-15

2,76604E-4

5,70865E-9

3,74331E-17

3,00000E-1

3,79693E-6

5,79998E-8

2,99015E-1

4.0

CVODE

4,57984E-3

3,00000E-1

5,01959E-8

9,85450E-4

5,98247E-2

1,63729E-7

1,94806E-1

3,47687E-1

3,33002E-4

6,56857E-3

1,99667E-1

4,01753E-2

3,62040E-9

1,37573E-17

1,74755E-15

2,76604E-4

5,70865E-9

3,74366E-17

3,00000E-1

3,79693E-6

5,79998E-8

2,99015E-1

4.0

Jarnac

4,57984E-3

3,00000E-1

5,01959E-8

9,85450E-4

5,98247E-2

1,63728E-7

1,94806E-1

3,47687E-1

3,33002E-4

6,56857E-3

1,99667E-1

4,01753E-2

3,62035E-9

-2,33091E-13

1,74748E-15

2,76604E-4

5,70862E-9

-6,54743E-14

3,00000E-1

3,79693E-6

5,79998E-8

2,99015E-1

4.0

MathSBML

4,57983E-3

3,00000E-1

5,03000E-8

9,85450E-4

5,98247E-2

1,64034E-7

1,94806E-1

3,47687E-1

3,33001E-4

6,56857E-3

1,99667E-1

4,01753E-2

3,62105E-9

1,37006E-17

1,76216E-15

2,76605E-4

5,70428E-9

3,75384E-17

3,00000E-1

3,79692E-6

5,75910E-8

2,99015E-1

4.0

Oscill8 Core

4,57984E-3

3,00000E-1

5,98247E-2

1,94806E-1

3,47687E-1

3,33003E-4

6,56857E-3

1,99667E-1

3,62039E-9

1,74764E-15

2,76604E-4

5,70889E-9

3,00000E-1

5,80004E-8

2,99015E-1

4.0

SBToolbox2

4,57714E-3

3,00000E-1

5,07816E-8

9,84816E-4

5,98008E-2

1,65914E-7

1,94808E-1

3,47666E-1

3,33098E-4

6,56908E-3

1,99670E-1

4,01992E-2

3,87658E-9

1,70506E-17

1,67106E-15

2,76518E-4

5,90340E-9

3,99548E-17

3,00000E-1

3,76426E-6

5,79542E-8

2,99014E-1

4.0

SBWOdeSolver

4,57984E-3

3,00000E-1

5,01969E-8

9,85450E-4

5,98247E-2

1,63732E-7

1,94806E-1

3,47687E-1

3,33003E-4

6,56857E-3

1,99667E-1

4,01753E-2

3,62052E-9

1,37566E-17

1,74769E-15

2,76604E-4

5,70880E-9

3,74385E-17

3,00000E-1

3,79697E-6

5,80006E-8

2,99015E-1

4.0

copasi

4,57984E-3

3,00000E-1

5,01959E-8

9,85450E-4

5,98247E-2

1,63728E-7

1,94806E-1

3,47687E-1

3,33001E-4

6,56857E-3

1,99667E-1

4,01753E-2

3,62041E-9

1,38396E-17

1,75001E-15

2,76604E-4

5,70863E-9

3,75545E-17

3,00000E-1

3,79693E-6

5,79998E-8

2,99015E-1

4.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,57984E-3

3,00000E-1

5,01959E-8

9,85450E-4

5,98247E-2

1,63728E-7

1,94806E-1

3,47687E-1

3,33002E-4

6,56857E-3

1,99667E-1

4,01753E-2

3,62040E-9

2,21372E-15

1,74800E-15

2,76604E-4

5,70864E-9

-2,33147E-15

3,00000E-1

3,79693E-6

5,79998E-8

2,99015E-1

4.0

jsim

4,57984E-3

3,00000E-1

5,01960E-8

9,85450E-4

5,98247E-2

1,63729E-7

1,94806E-1

3,47687E-1

3,33002E-4

6,56857E-3

1,99667E-1

4,01753E-2

3,62040E-9

1,37541E-17

1,74750E-15

2,76604E-4

5,70865E-9

3,74331E-17

3,00000E-1

3,79693E-6

5,79998E-8

2,99015E-1

4.0

min

4,57714E-3

3,00000E-1

5,01959E-8

9,84816E-4

5,98008E-2

1,63728E-7

1,94806E-1

3,47666E-1

3,33001E-4

6,56857E-3

1,99667E-1

4,01753E-2

3,62035E-9

-2,33091E-13

1,67106E-15

2,76518E-4

5,70428E-9

-6,54743E-14

3,00000E-1

3,76426E-6

5,75910E-8

2,99014E-1

4.0

max

4,57984E-3

3,00000E-1

5,07816E-8

9,85450E-4

5,98247E-2

1,65914E-7

1,94808E-1

3,47687E-1

3,33098E-4

6,56908E-3

1,99670E-1

4,01992E-2

3,87658E-9

2,21372E-15

1,76216E-15

2,76605E-4

5,90340E-9

3,99548E-17

3,00000E-1

3,79697E-6

5,80006E-8

2,99015E-1

4.0

mean

4,57984E-3

3,00000E-1

5,01960E-8

9,85450E-4

5,98247E-2

1,63729E-7

1,94806E-1

3,47687E-1

3,33002E-4

6,56857E-3

1,99667E-1

4,01753E-2

3,62040E-9

1,37566E-17

1,74760E-15

2,76604E-4

5,70865E-9

3,74366E-17

3,00000E-1

3,79693E-6

5,79998E-8

2,99015E-1

4.0

relative error(%)

0,00

4.2

BioUML

4,94944E-3

3,00000E-1

6,59498E-8

1,06390E-3

5,96988E-2

2,15898E-7

1,94349E-1

3,46777E-1

3,85651E-4

6,90396E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03012E-2

5,19925E-9

2,75713E-17

3,18304E-15

3,11096E-4

7,81988E-9

7,12385E-17

3,00000E-1

4,68054E-6

7,34784E-8

2,98936E-1

4.2

ByoDyn

4,94944E-3

3,00000E-1

6,59498E-8

1,06390E-3

5,96988E-2

2,15898E-7

1,94349E-1

3,46777E-1

3,85651E-4

6,90396E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03012E-2

5,19925E-9

2,75713E-17

3,18304E-15

3,11096E-4

7,81988E-9

7,12385E-17

3,00000E-1

4,68054E-6

7,34784E-8

2,98936E-1

4.2

CVODE

4,94944E-3

3,00000E-1

6,59497E-8

1,06390E-3

5,96988E-2

2,15898E-7

1,94349E-1

3,46777E-1

3,85651E-4

6,90396E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03012E-2

5,19925E-9

2,75762E-17

3,18312E-15

3,11096E-4

7,81988E-9

7,12437E-17

3,00000E-1

4,68054E-6

7,34784E-8

2,98936E-1

4.2

Jarnac

4,94944E-3

3,00000E-1

6,59497E-8

1,06390E-3

5,96988E-2

2,15898E-7

1,94349E-1

3,46777E-1

3,85651E-4

6,90396E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03012E-2

5,19920E-9

-2,29372E-13

3,18302E-15

3,11096E-4

7,81985E-9

-6,39122E-14

3,00000E-1

4,68054E-6

7,34784E-8

2,98936E-1

4.2

MathSBML

4,94944E-3

3,00000E-1

6,66077E-8

1,06390E-3

5,96988E-2

2,17826E-7

1,94349E-1

3,46777E-1

3,85650E-4

6,90396E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03012E-2

5,20417E-9

2,75834E-17

3,22998E-15

3,11097E-4

7,79292E-9

7,10573E-17

3,00000E-1

4,68053E-6

7,09006E-8

2,98936E-1

4.2

Oscill8 Core

4,94944E-3

3,00000E-1

5,96988E-2

1,94349E-1

3,46777E-1

3,85653E-4

6,90396E-3

1,99614E-1

5,19933E-9

3,18333E-15

3,11097E-4

7,82020E-9

3,00000E-1

7,34791E-8

2,98936E-1

4.2

SBToolbox2

4,94759E-3

3,00000E-1

6,60943E-8

1,06342E-3

5,96801E-2

2,16590E-7

1,94348E-1

3,46761E-1

3,85729E-4

6,90419E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03199E-2

5,40074E-9

2,19904E-17

2,44136E-15

3,11037E-4

7,94843E-9

5,59842E-17

3,00000E-1

4,62503E-6

7,30251E-8

2,98934E-1

4.2

SBWOdeSolver

4,94944E-3

3,00000E-1

6,59508E-8

1,06390E-3

5,96988E-2

2,15902E-7

1,94349E-1

3,46777E-1

3,85653E-4

6,90396E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03012E-2

5,19941E-9

2,75758E-17

3,18356E-15

3,11097E-4

7,82006E-9

7,12480E-17

3,00000E-1

4,68058E-6

7,34794E-8

2,98936E-1

4.2

copasi

4,94944E-3

3,00000E-1

6,59496E-8

1,06390E-3

5,96988E-2

2,15898E-7

1,94349E-1

3,46777E-1

3,85651E-4

6,90396E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03012E-2

5,19926E-9

2,77310E-17

3,18685E-15

3,11096E-4

7,81985E-9

7,14434E-17

3,00000E-1

4,68054E-6

7,34784E-8

2,98936E-1

4.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,94944E-3

3,00000E-1

6,59497E-8

1,06390E-3

5,96988E-2

2,15898E-7

1,94349E-1

3,46777E-1

3,85651E-4

6,90396E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03012E-2

5,19925E-9

4,17548E-15

3,18431E-15

3,11096E-4

7,81987E-9

-4,27436E-15

3,00000E-1

4,68054E-6

7,34784E-8

2,98936E-1

4.2

jsim

4,94944E-3

3,00000E-1

6,59498E-8

1,06390E-3

5,96988E-2

2,15898E-7

1,94349E-1

3,46777E-1

3,85651E-4

6,90396E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03012E-2

5,19925E-9

2,75713E-17

3,18304E-15

3,11096E-4

7,81988E-9

7,12385E-17

3,00000E-1

4,68054E-6

7,34784E-8

2,98936E-1

4.2

min

4,94759E-3

3,00000E-1

6,59496E-8

1,06342E-3

5,96801E-2

2,15898E-7

1,94348E-1

3,46761E-1

3,85650E-4

6,90396E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03012E-2

5,19920E-9

-2,29372E-13

2,44136E-15

3,11037E-4

7,79292E-9

-6,39122E-14

3,00000E-1

4,62503E-6

7,09006E-8

2,98934E-1

4.2

max

4,94944E-3

3,00000E-1

6,66077E-8

1,06390E-3

5,96988E-2

2,17826E-7

1,94349E-1

3,46777E-1

3,85729E-4

6,90419E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03199E-2

5,40074E-9

4,17548E-15

3,22998E-15

3,11097E-4

7,94843E-9

7,14434E-17

3,00000E-1

4,68058E-6

7,34794E-8

2,98936E-1

4.2

mean

4,94944E-3

3,00000E-1

6,59498E-8

1,06390E-3

5,96988E-2

2,15898E-7

1,94349E-1

3,46777E-1

3,85651E-4

6,90396E-3

1,99614E-1

4,03012E-2

5,19926E-9

2,75758E-17

3,18322E-15

3,11096E-4

7,81988E-9

7,12385E-17

3,00000E-1

4,68054E-6

7,34784E-8

2,98936E-1

4.2

relative error(%)

0,00

4.4

BioUML

5,32125E-3

3,00000E-1

8,52940E-8

1,14284E-3

5,96023E-2

2,80223E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45895E-1

4,42559E-4

7,23716E-3

1,99557E-1

4,03977E-2

7,31358E-9

5,31428E-17

5,60423E-15

3,47496E-4

1,05209E-8

1,30716E-16

3,00000E-1

5,69937E-6

9,18687E-8

2,98857E-1

4.4

ByoDyn

5,32125E-3

3,00000E-1

8,52940E-8

1,14284E-3

5,96023E-2

2,80223E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45895E-1

4,42559E-4

7,23716E-3

1,99557E-1

4,03977E-2

7,31358E-9

5,31428E-17

5,60423E-15

3,47496E-4

1,05209E-8

1,30716E-16

3,00000E-1

5,69937E-6

9,18687E-8

2,98857E-1

4.4

CVODE

5,32125E-3

3,00000E-1

8,52940E-8

1,14284E-3

5,96023E-2

2,80223E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45895E-1

4,42559E-4

7,23716E-3

1,99557E-1

4,03977E-2

7,31358E-9

5,31560E-17

5,60452E-15

3,47496E-4

1,05209E-8

1,30731E-16

3,00000E-1

5,69937E-6

9,18687E-8

2,98857E-1

4.4

Jarnac

5,32125E-3

3,00000E-1

8,52940E-8

1,14284E-3

5,96023E-2

2,80223E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45895E-1

4,42559E-4

7,23716E-3

1,99557E-1

4,03977E-2

7,31352E-9

-2,24931E-13

5,60421E-15

3,47496E-4

1,05208E-8

-6,37799E-14

3,00000E-1

5,69937E-6

9,18687E-8

2,98857E-1

4.4

MathSBML

5,32125E-3

3,00000E-1

8,50872E-8

1,14284E-3

5,96023E-2

2,79616E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45895E-1

4,42558E-4

7,23716E-3

1,99557E-1

4,03977E-2

7,31203E-9

5,31127E-17

5,56548E-15

3,47497E-4

1,05293E-8

1,31327E-16

3,00000E-1

5,69936E-6

9,26804E-8

2,98857E-1

4.4

Oscill8 Core

5,32125E-3

3,00000E-1

5,96023E-2

1,93883E-1

3,45895E-1

4,42560E-4

7,23716E-3

1,99557E-1

7,31375E-9

5,60474E-15

3,47497E-4

1,05213E-8

3,00000E-1

9,18695E-8

2,98857E-1

4.4

SBToolbox2

5,31952E-3

3,00000E-1

8,56610E-8

1,14234E-3

5,95838E-2

2,81778E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45878E-1

4,42592E-4

7,23730E-3

1,99560E-1

4,04162E-2

7,66319E-9

5,44618E-17

4,81741E-15

3,47412E-4

1,07426E-8

1,20911E-16

3,00000E-1

5,63245E-6

9,14084E-8

2,98860E-1

4.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,32125E-3

3,00000E-1

8,52954E-8

1,14284E-3

5,96023E-2

2,80227E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45895E-1

4,42560E-4

7,23716E-3

1,99557E-1

4,03977E-2

7,31378E-9

5,31501E-17

5,60497E-15

3,47497E-4

1,05211E-8

1,30732E-16

3,00000E-1

5,69941E-6

9,18695E-8

2,98857E-1

4.4

copasi

5,32125E-3

3,00000E-1

8,52939E-8

1,14284E-3

5,96023E-2

2,80222E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45895E-1

4,42559E-4

7,23716E-3

1,99557E-1

4,03977E-2

7,31358E-9

5,34119E-17

5,60956E-15

3,47496E-4

1,05208E-8

1,31030E-16

3,00000E-1

5,69937E-6

9,18688E-8

2,98857E-1

4.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,32125E-3

3,00000E-1

8,52940E-8

1,14284E-3

5,96023E-2

2,80222E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45895E-1

4,42559E-4

7,23716E-3

1,99557E-1

4,03977E-2

7,31358E-9

6,13720E-15

5,60625E-15

3,47496E-4

1,05208E-8

-6,21725E-15

3,00000E-1

5,69937E-6

9,18687E-8

2,98857E-1

4.4

jsim

5,32125E-3

3,00000E-1

8,52940E-8

1,14284E-3

5,96023E-2

2,80223E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45895E-1

4,42559E-4

7,23716E-3

1,99557E-1

4,03977E-2

7,31358E-9

5,31428E-17

5,60423E-15

3,47496E-4

1,05209E-8

1,30716E-16

3,00000E-1

5,69937E-6

9,18687E-8

2,98857E-1

4.4

min

5,31952E-3

3,00000E-1

8,50872E-8

1,14234E-3

5,95838E-2

2,79616E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45878E-1

4,42558E-4

7,23716E-3

1,99557E-1

4,03977E-2

7,31203E-9

-2,24931E-13

4,81741E-15

3,47412E-4

1,05208E-8

-6,37799E-14

3,00000E-1

5,63245E-6

9,14084E-8

2,98857E-1

4.4

max

5,32125E-3

3,00000E-1

8,56610E-8

1,14284E-3

5,96023E-2

2,81778E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45895E-1

4,42592E-4

7,23730E-3

1,99560E-1

4,04162E-2

7,66319E-9

6,13720E-15

5,60956E-15

3,47497E-4

1,07426E-8

1,31327E-16

3,00000E-1

5,69941E-6

9,26804E-8

2,98860E-1

4.4

mean

5,32125E-3

3,00000E-1

8,52940E-8

1,14284E-3

5,96023E-2

2,80223E-7

1,93883E-1

3,45895E-1

4,42559E-4

7,23716E-3

1,99557E-1

4,03977E-2

7,31358E-9

5,31501E-17

5,60438E-15

3,47496E-4

1,05209E-8

1,30716E-16

3,00000E-1

5,69937E-6

9,18687E-8

2,98857E-1

4.4

relative error(%)

0,00

4.6

BioUML

5,69457E-3

3,00000E-1

1,08759E-7

1,22216E-3

5,95303E-2

3,58566E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45038E-1

5,03702E-4

7,56842E-3

1,99496E-1

4,04697E-2

1,00973E-8

9,88680E-17

9,56966E-15

3,85766E-4

1,39272E-8

2,32091E-16

3,00000E-1

6,86375E-6

1,13507E-7

2,98778E-1

4.6

ByoDyn

5,69457E-3

3,00000E-1

1,08759E-7

1,22216E-3

5,95303E-2

3,58566E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45038E-1

5,03702E-4

7,56842E-3

1,99496E-1

4,04697E-2

1,00973E-8

9,88680E-17

9,56966E-15

3,85766E-4

1,39272E-8

2,32091E-16

3,00000E-1

6,86375E-6

1,13507E-7

2,98778E-1

4.6

CVODE

5,69457E-3

3,00000E-1

1,08759E-7

1,22216E-3

5,95304E-2

3,58566E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45038E-1

5,03702E-4

7,56842E-3

1,99496E-1

4,04696E-2

1,00973E-8

9,88983E-17

9,57029E-15

3,85766E-4

1,39272E-8

2,32125E-16

3,00000E-1

6,86375E-6

1,13507E-7

2,98778E-1

4.6

Jarnac

5,69457E-3

3,00000E-1

1,08759E-7

1,22216E-3

5,95303E-2

3,58566E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45038E-1

5,03702E-4

7,56842E-3

1,99496E-1

4,04697E-2

1,00972E-8

-2,21434E-13

9,56963E-15

3,85766E-4

1,39272E-8

-6,31934E-14

3,00000E-1

6,86375E-6

1,13507E-7

2,98778E-1

4.6

MathSBML

5,69457E-3

3,00000E-1

1,08585E-7

1,22216E-3

5,95303E-2

3,58053E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45038E-1

5,03702E-4

7,56842E-3

1,99496E-1

4,04697E-2

1,00959E-8

9,88706E-17

9,52472E-15

3,85766E-4

1,39344E-8

2,32514E-16

3,00000E-1

6,86374E-6

1,14193E-7

2,98778E-1

4.6

Oscill8 Core

5,69457E-3

3,00000E-1

5,95304E-2

1,93409E-1

3,45038E-1

5,03704E-4

7,56842E-3

1,99496E-1

1,00975E-8

9,57048E-15

3,85766E-4

1,39277E-8

3,00000E-1

1,13508E-7

2,98778E-1

4.6

SBToolbox2

5,69250E-3

3,00000E-1

1,09713E-7

1,22156E-3

5,95094E-2

3,62281E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45018E-1

5,03656E-4

7,56871E-3

1,99495E-1

4,04906E-2

1,07270E-8

1,19673E-16

9,05378E-15

3,85633E-4

1,43370E-8

2,43247E-16

3,00000E-1

6,79263E-6

1,13257E-7

2,98780E-1

4.6

SBWOdeSolver

5,69457E-3

3,00000E-1

1,08761E-7

1,22216E-3

5,95304E-2

3,58571E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45038E-1

5,03704E-4

7,56842E-3

1,99496E-1

4,04696E-2

1,00975E-8

9,88812E-17

9,57062E-15

3,85766E-4

1,39275E-8

2,32118E-16

3,00000E-1

6,86379E-6

1,13508E-7

2,98778E-1

4.6

copasi

5,69457E-3

3,00000E-1

1,08759E-7

1,22216E-3

5,95304E-2

3,58565E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45038E-1

5,03702E-4

7,56842E-3

1,99496E-1

4,04696E-2

1,00972E-8

9,93241E-17

9,57801E-15

3,85765E-4

1,39272E-8

2,32590E-16

3,00000E-1

6,86375E-6

1,13507E-7

2,98778E-1

4.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,69457E-3

3,00000E-1

1,08759E-7

1,22216E-3

5,95304E-2

3,58565E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45038E-1

5,03702E-4

7,56842E-3

1,99496E-1

4,04696E-2

1,00972E-8

5,75146E-15

9,57229E-15

3,85765E-4

1,39272E-8

-5,93969E-15

3,00000E-1

6,86375E-6

1,13507E-7

2,98778E-1

4.6

jsim

5,69457E-3

3,00000E-1

1,08759E-7

1,22216E-3

5,95304E-2

3,58566E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45038E-1

5,03702E-4

7,56842E-3

1,99496E-1

4,04696E-2

1,00973E-8

9,88680E-17

9,56966E-15

3,85766E-4

1,39272E-8

2,32091E-16

3,00000E-1

6,86375E-6

1,13507E-7

2,98778E-1

4.6

min

5,69250E-3

3,00000E-1

1,08585E-7

1,22156E-3

5,95094E-2

3,58053E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45018E-1

5,03656E-4

7,56842E-3

1,99495E-1

4,04696E-2

1,00959E-8

-2,21434E-13

9,05378E-15

3,85633E-4

1,39272E-8

-6,31934E-14

3,00000E-1

6,79263E-6

1,13257E-7

2,98778E-1

4.6

max

5,69457E-3

3,00000E-1

1,09713E-7

1,22216E-3

5,95304E-2

3,62281E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45038E-1

5,03704E-4

7,56871E-3

1,99496E-1

4,04906E-2

1,07270E-8

5,75146E-15

9,57801E-15

3,85766E-4

1,43370E-8

2,43247E-16

3,00000E-1

6,86379E-6

1,14193E-7

2,98780E-1

4.6

mean

5,69457E-3

3,00000E-1

1,08759E-7

1,22216E-3

5,95304E-2

3,58566E-7

1,93409E-1

3,45038E-1

5,03702E-4

7,56842E-3

1,99496E-1

4,04696E-2

1,00973E-8

9,88812E-17

9,56998E-15

3,85766E-4

1,39272E-8

2,32118E-16

3,00000E-1

6,86375E-6

1,13507E-7

2,98778E-1

4.6

relative error(%)

0,00

4.8

BioUML

6,06880E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36913E-7

1,30175E-3

5,94789E-2

4,52933E-7

1,92927E-1

3,44202E-1

5,69048E-4

7,89797E-3

1,99431E-1

4,05211E-2

1,37064E-8

1,78127E-16

1,58943E-14

4,25864E-4

1,81681E-8

3,99992E-16

3,00000E-1

8,18394E-6

1,38746E-7

2,98698E-1

4.8

ByoDyn

6,06880E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36913E-7

1,30175E-3

5,94789E-2

4,52933E-7

1,92927E-1

3,44202E-1

5,69048E-4

7,89797E-3

1,99431E-1

4,05211E-2

1,37064E-8

1,78127E-16

1,58943E-14

4,25864E-4

1,81681E-8

3,99992E-16

3,00000E-1

8,18394E-6

1,38746E-7

2,98698E-1

4.8

CVODE

6,06880E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36913E-7

1,30175E-3

5,94789E-2

4,52933E-7

1,92927E-1

3,44202E-1

5,69048E-4

7,89797E-3

1,99431E-1

4,05211E-2

1,37064E-8

1,78180E-16

1,58952E-14

4,25864E-4

1,81681E-8

4,00048E-16

3,00000E-1

8,18394E-6

1,38746E-7

2,98698E-1

4.8

Jarnac

6,06880E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36913E-7

1,30175E-3

5,94789E-2

4,52933E-7

1,92927E-1

3,44202E-1

5,69048E-4

7,89797E-3

1,99431E-1

4,05211E-2

1,37063E-8

-2,18492E-13

1,58943E-14

4,25864E-4

1,81681E-8

-6,20240E-14

3,00000E-1

8,18394E-6

1,38746E-7

2,98698E-1

4.8

MathSBML

6,06880E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36927E-7

1,30175E-3

5,94789E-2

4,52974E-7

1,92927E-1

3,44202E-1

5,69048E-4

7,89797E-3

1,99431E-1

4,05211E-2

1,37065E-8

1,78150E-16

1,58782E-14

4,25864E-4

1,81675E-8

3,99704E-16

3,00000E-1

8,18394E-6

1,38691E-7

2,98698E-1

4.8

Oscill8 Core

6,06880E-3

3,00000E-1

5,94789E-2

1,92927E-1

3,44202E-1

5,69049E-4

7,89797E-3

1,99431E-1

1,37068E-8

1,58956E-14

4,25865E-4

1,81687E-8

3,00000E-1

1,38747E-7

2,98698E-1

4.8

SBToolbox2

6,06662E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38241E-7

1,30118E-3

5,94570E-2

4,58104E-7

1,92930E-1

3,44179E-1

5,68932E-4

7,89833E-3

1,99430E-1

4,05430E-2

1,45923E-8

2,17624E-16

1,51505E-14

4,25696E-4

1,87318E-8

4,22974E-16

3,00000E-1

8,10564E-6

1,38572E-7

2,98700E-1

4.8

SBWOdeSolver

6,06880E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36915E-7

1,30175E-3

5,94789E-2

4,52939E-7

1,92927E-1

3,44202E-1

5,69049E-4

7,89797E-3

1,99431E-1

4,05211E-2

1,37067E-8

1,78152E-16

1,58957E-14

4,25865E-4

1,81684E-8

4,00037E-16

3,00000E-1

8,18399E-6

1,38747E-7

2,98698E-1

4.8

copasi

6,06880E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36913E-7

1,30175E-3

5,94789E-2

4,52933E-7

1,92927E-1

3,44202E-1

5,69047E-4

7,89797E-3

1,99431E-1

4,05211E-2

1,37063E-8

1,78867E-16

1,59079E-14

4,25864E-4

1,81680E-8

4,00773E-16

3,00000E-1

8,18394E-6

1,38746E-7

2,98698E-1

4.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,06880E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36913E-7

1,30175E-3

5,94789E-2

4,52933E-7

1,92927E-1

3,44202E-1

5,69048E-4

7,89797E-3

1,99431E-1

4,05211E-2

1,37064E-8

3,24993E-15

1,58978E-14

4,25864E-4

1,81681E-8

-3,30291E-15

3,00000E-1

8,18394E-6

1,38746E-7

2,98698E-1

4.8

jsim

6,06880E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36913E-7

1,30175E-3

5,94789E-2

4,52933E-7

1,92927E-1

3,44202E-1

5,69048E-4

7,89797E-3

1,99431E-1

4,05211E-2

1,37064E-8

1,78127E-16

1,58943E-14

4,25864E-4

1,81681E-8

3,99992E-16

3,00000E-1

8,18394E-6

1,38746E-7

2,98698E-1

4.8

min

6,06662E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36913E-7

1,30118E-3

5,94570E-2

4,52933E-7

1,92927E-1

3,44179E-1

5,68932E-4

7,89797E-3

1,99430E-1

4,05211E-2

1,37063E-8

-2,18492E-13

1,51505E-14

4,25696E-4

1,81675E-8

-6,20240E-14

3,00000E-1

8,10564E-6

1,38572E-7

2,98698E-1

4.8

max

6,06880E-3

3,00000E-1

1,38241E-7

1,30175E-3

5,94789E-2

4,58104E-7

1,92930E-1

3,44202E-1

5,69049E-4

7,89833E-3

1,99431E-1

4,05430E-2

1,45923E-8

3,24993E-15

1,59079E-14

4,25865E-4

1,87318E-8

4,22974E-16

3,00000E-1

8,18399E-6

1,38747E-7

2,98700E-1

4.8

mean

6,06880E-3

3,00000E-1

1,36913E-7

1,30175E-3

5,94789E-2

4,52933E-7

1,92927E-1

3,44202E-1

5,69048E-4

7,89797E-3

1,99431E-1

4,05211E-2

1,37064E-8

1,78152E-16

1,58948E-14

4,25864E-4

1,81681E-8

3,99992E-16

3,00000E-1

8,18394E-6

1,38746E-7

2,98698E-1

4.8

relative error(%)

0,00

5.0

BioUML

6,44343E-3

2,99999E-1

1,70359E-7

1,38153E-3

5,94444E-2

5,65473E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43384E-1

6,38551E-4

8,22603E-3

1,99361E-1

4,05556E-2

1,83211E-8

3,11690E-16

2,57423E-14

4,67753E-4

2,33869E-8

6,70943E-16

3,00000E-1

9,67010E-6

1,67952E-7

2,98618E-1

5.0

ByoDyn

6,44343E-3

2,99999E-1

1,70359E-7

1,38153E-3

5,94444E-2

5,65473E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43384E-1

6,38551E-4

8,22603E-3

1,99361E-1

4,05556E-2

1,83211E-8

3,11690E-16

2,57423E-14

4,67753E-4

2,33869E-8

6,70943E-16

3,00000E-1

9,67010E-6

1,67952E-7

2,98618E-1

5.0

CVODE

6,44343E-3

2,99999E-1

1,70359E-7

1,38153E-3

5,94444E-2

5,65473E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43384E-1

6,38551E-4

8,22603E-3

1,99361E-1

4,05556E-2

1,83211E-8

3,11773E-16

2,57435E-14

4,67753E-4

2,33868E-8

6,71024E-16

3,00000E-1

9,67010E-6

1,67952E-7

2,98618E-1

5.0

Jarnac

6,44343E-3

2,99999E-1

1,70359E-7

1,38153E-3

5,94444E-2

5,65473E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43384E-1

6,38551E-4

8,22603E-3

1,99361E-1

4,05556E-2

1,83210E-8

-2,14939E-13

2,57423E-14

4,67753E-4

2,33868E-8

-6,13804E-14

3,00000E-1

9,67010E-6

1,67952E-7

2,98618E-1

5.0

MathSBML

6,44343E-3

2,99999E-1

1,70379E-7

1,38153E-3

5,94444E-2

5,65532E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43384E-1

6,38551E-4

8,22603E-3

1,99361E-1

4,05556E-2

1,83212E-8

3,11604E-16

2,57331E-14

4,67753E-4

2,33860E-8

6,70416E-16

3,00000E-1

9,67010E-6

1,67874E-7

2,98618E-1

5.0

Oscill8 Core

6,44343E-3

2,99999E-1

5,94444E-2

1,92440E-1

3,43384E-1

6,38552E-4

8,22603E-3

1,99361E-1

1,83216E-8

2,57442E-14

4,67754E-4

2,33875E-8

3,00000E-1

1,67954E-7

2,98618E-1

5.0

SBToolbox2

6,44200E-3

3,00000E-1

1,70860E-7

1,38100E-3

5,94275E-2

5,67775E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43370E-1

6,38460E-4

8,22605E-3

1,99360E-1

4,05725E-2

1,90785E-8

2,77070E-16

2,08960E-14

4,67620E-4

2,38105E-8

5,66825E-16

3,00000E-1

9,56010E-6

1,67095E-7

2,98620E-1

5.0

SBWOdeSolver

6,44343E-3

2,99999E-1

1,70361E-7

1,38153E-3

5,94444E-2

5,65480E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43384E-1

6,38552E-4

8,22603E-3

1,99361E-1

4,05556E-2

1,83215E-8

3,11730E-16

2,57443E-14

4,67754E-4

2,33872E-8

6,71010E-16

3,00000E-1

9,67015E-6

1,67954E-7

2,98618E-1

5.0

copasi

6,44343E-3

2,99999E-1

1,70359E-7

1,38153E-3

5,94445E-2

5,65472E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43384E-1

6,38550E-4

8,22603E-3

1,99361E-1

4,05555E-2

1,83210E-8

3,12836E-16

2,57630E-14

4,67753E-4

2,33868E-8

6,72125E-16

3,00000E-1

9,67011E-6

1,67952E-7

2,98618E-1

5.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,44343E-3

2,99999E-1

1,70359E-7

1,38153E-3

5,94444E-2

5,65473E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43384E-1

6,38551E-4

8,22603E-3

1,99361E-1

4,05556E-2

1,83211E-8

1,16824E-15

2,57468E-14

4,67753E-4

2,33868E-8

-8,60423E-16

3,00000E-1

9,67010E-6

1,67952E-7

2,98618E-1

5.0

jsim

6,44343E-3

2,99999E-1

1,70359E-7

1,38153E-3

5,94444E-2

5,65473E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43384E-1

6,38551E-4

8,22603E-3

1,99361E-1

4,05556E-2

1,83211E-8

3,11690E-16

2,57423E-14

4,67753E-4

2,33869E-8

6,70943E-16

3,00000E-1

9,67010E-6

1,67952E-7

2,98618E-1

5.0

min

6,44200E-3

2,99999E-1

1,70359E-7

1,38100E-3

5,94275E-2

5,65472E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43370E-1

6,38460E-4

8,22603E-3

1,99360E-1

4,05555E-2

1,83210E-8

-2,14939E-13

2,08960E-14

4,67620E-4

2,33860E-8

-6,13804E-14

3,00000E-1

9,56010E-6

1,67095E-7

2,98618E-1

5.0

max

6,44343E-3

3,00000E-1

1,70860E-7

1,38153E-3

5,94445E-2

5,67775E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43384E-1

6,38552E-4

8,22605E-3

1,99361E-1

4,05725E-2

1,90785E-8

1,16824E-15

2,57630E-14

4,67754E-4

2,38105E-8

6,72125E-16

3,00000E-1

9,67015E-6

1,67954E-7

2,98620E-1

5.0

mean

6,44343E-3

2,99999E-1

1,70359E-7

1,38153E-3

5,94444E-2

5,65473E-7

1,92440E-1

3,43384E-1

6,38551E-4

8,22603E-3

1,99361E-1

4,05556E-2

1,83211E-8

3,11690E-16

2,57429E-14

4,67753E-4

2,33868E-8

6,70943E-16

3,00000E-1

9,67010E-6

1,67952E-7

2,98618E-1

5.0

relative error(%)

0,00

5.2

BioUML

6,81801E-3

2,99999E-1

2,09736E-7

1,46145E-3

5,94242E-2

6,98471E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42581E-1

7,12158E-4

8,55278E-3

1,99288E-1

4,05758E-2

2,41474E-8

5,31044E-16

4,07447E-14

5,11392E-4

2,97414E-8

1,09796E-15

3,00000E-1

1,13323E-5

2,01509E-7

2,98539E-1

5.2

ByoDyn

6,81801E-3

2,99999E-1

2,09736E-7

1,46145E-3

5,94242E-2

6,98471E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42581E-1

7,12158E-4

8,55278E-3

1,99288E-1

4,05758E-2

2,41474E-8

5,31044E-16

4,07447E-14

5,11392E-4

2,97414E-8

1,09796E-15

3,00000E-1

1,13323E-5

2,01509E-7

2,98539E-1

5.2

CVODE

6,81801E-3

2,99999E-1

2,09736E-7

1,46145E-3

5,94242E-2

6,98471E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42581E-1

7,12158E-4

8,55278E-3

1,99288E-1

4,05758E-2

2,41474E-8

5,31165E-16

4,07462E-14

5,11392E-4

2,97414E-8

1,09807E-15

3,00000E-1

1,13323E-5

2,01509E-7

2,98539E-1

5.2

Jarnac

6,81801E-3

2,99999E-1

2,09736E-7

1,46145E-3

5,94242E-2

6,98471E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42581E-1

7,12158E-4

8,55278E-3

1,99288E-1

4,05758E-2

2,41474E-8

-2,11497E-13

4,07446E-14

5,11392E-4

2,97413E-8

-6,02845E-14

3,00000E-1

1,13323E-5

2,01509E-7

2,98539E-1

5.2

MathSBML

6,81801E-3

2,99999E-1

2,09731E-7

1,46145E-3

5,94242E-2

6,98458E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42581E-1

7,12158E-4

8,55278E-3

1,99288E-1

4,05758E-2

2,41474E-8

5,30816E-16

4,07300E-14

5,11392E-4

2,97416E-8

1,09742E-15

3,00000E-1

1,13323E-5

2,01527E-7

2,98539E-1

5.2

Oscill8 Core

6,81801E-3

2,99999E-1

5,94242E-2

1,91946E-1

3,42581E-1

7,12159E-4

8,55278E-3

1,99288E-1

2,41481E-8

4,07474E-14

5,11393E-4

2,97421E-8

3,00000E-1

2,01510E-7

2,98539E-1

5.2

SBToolbox2

6,81708E-3

3,00000E-1

2,10052E-7

1,46102E-3

5,94095E-2

7,00234E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42571E-1

7,12039E-4

8,55252E-3

1,99290E-1

4,05905E-2

2,50591E-8

4,91876E-16

3,37128E-14

5,11260E-4

3,02108E-8

9,50680E-16

3,00000E-1

1,11958E-5

2,00314E-7

2,98540E-1

5.2

SBWOdeSolver

6,81801E-3

2,99999E-1

2,09738E-7

1,46145E-3

5,94242E-2

6,98478E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42581E-1

7,12159E-4

8,55278E-3

1,99288E-1

4,05758E-2

2,41479E-8

5,31108E-16

4,07474E-14

5,11393E-4

2,97418E-8

1,09806E-15

3,00000E-1

1,13323E-5

2,01510E-7

2,98539E-1

5.2

copasi

6,81802E-3

2,99999E-1

2,09735E-7

1,46145E-3

5,94243E-2

6,98471E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42581E-1

7,12157E-4

8,55278E-3

1,99288E-1

4,05757E-2

2,41474E-8

5,32780E-16

4,07745E-14

5,11392E-4

2,97413E-8

1,09970E-15

3,00000E-1

1,13323E-5

2,01509E-7

2,98539E-1

5.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,81801E-3

2,99999E-1

2,09735E-7

1,46145E-3

5,94242E-2

6,98471E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42581E-1

7,12158E-4

8,55278E-3

1,99288E-1

4,05758E-2

2,41474E-8

4,80425E-16

4,07532E-14

5,11392E-4

2,97414E-8

4,71845E-16

3,00000E-1

1,13323E-5

2,01509E-7

2,98539E-1

5.2

jsim

6,81801E-3

2,99999E-1

2,09736E-7

1,46145E-3

5,94242E-2

6,98471E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42581E-1

7,12158E-4

8,55278E-3

1,99288E-1

4,05758E-2

2,41474E-8

5,31044E-16

4,07447E-14

5,11392E-4

2,97414E-8

1,09796E-15

3,00000E-1

1,13323E-5

2,01509E-7

2,98539E-1

5.2

min

6,81708E-3

2,99999E-1

2,09731E-7

1,46102E-3

5,94095E-2

6,98458E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42571E-1

7,12039E-4

8,55252E-3

1,99288E-1

4,05757E-2

2,41474E-8

-2,11497E-13

3,37128E-14

5,11260E-4

2,97413E-8

-6,02845E-14

3,00000E-1

1,11958E-5

2,00314E-7

2,98539E-1

5.2

max

6,81802E-3

3,00000E-1

2,10052E-7

1,46145E-3

5,94243E-2

7,00234E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42581E-1

7,12159E-4

8,55278E-3

1,99290E-1

4,05905E-2

2,50591E-8

5,32780E-16

4,07745E-14

5,11393E-4

3,02108E-8

1,09970E-15

3,00000E-1

1,13323E-5

2,01527E-7

2,98540E-1

5.2

mean

6,81801E-3

2,99999E-1

2,09736E-7

1,46145E-3

5,94242E-2

6,98471E-7

1,91946E-1

3,42581E-1

7,12158E-4

8,55278E-3

1,99288E-1

4,05758E-2

2,41474E-8

5,31044E-16

4,07454E-14

5,11392E-4

2,97414E-8

1,09796E-15

3,00000E-1

1,13323E-5

2,01509E-7

2,98539E-1

5.2

relative error(%)

0,00

5.4

BioUML

7,19217E-3

2,99999E-1

2,55717E-7

1,54144E-3

5,94158E-2

8,54352E-7

1,91447E-1

3,41791E-1

7,89809E-4

8,87837E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05842E-2

3,14191E-8

8,82919E-16

6,31470E-14

5,56743E-4

3,74046E-8

1,75654E-15

3,00000E-1

1,31804E-5

2,39812E-7

2,98459E-1

5.4

ByoDyn

7,19217E-3

2,99999E-1

2,55717E-7

1,54144E-3

5,94158E-2

8,54352E-7

1,91447E-1

3,41791E-1

7,89809E-4

8,87837E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05842E-2

3,14191E-8

8,82919E-16

6,31470E-14

5,56743E-4

3,74046E-8

1,75654E-15

3,00000E-1

1,31804E-5

2,39812E-7

2,98459E-1

5.4

CVODE

7,19217E-3

2,99999E-1

2,55717E-7

1,54144E-3

5,94158E-2

8,54352E-7

1,91447E-1

3,41791E-1

7,89809E-4

8,87837E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05842E-2

3,14191E-8

8,83093E-16

6,31490E-14

5,56743E-4

3,74046E-8

1,75669E-15

3,00000E-1

1,31804E-5

2,39812E-7

2,98459E-1

5.4

Jarnac

7,19217E-3

2,99999E-1

2,55717E-7

1,54144E-3

5,94158E-2

8,54352E-7

1,91447E-1

3,41791E-1

7,89809E-4

8,87837E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05842E-2

3,14190E-8

-2,08611E-13

6,31469E-14

5,56743E-4

3,74046E-8

-5,80399E-14

3,00000E-1

1,31804E-5

2,39812E-7

2,98459E-1

5.4

MathSBML

7,19217E-3

2,99999E-1

2,55717E-7

1,54144E-3

5,94158E-2

8,54351E-7

1,91447E-1

3,41791E-1

7,89809E-4

8,87837E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05842E-2

3,14192E-8

8,82578E-16

6,31364E-14

5,56743E-4

3,74047E-8

1,75594E-15

3,00000E-1

1,31804E-5

2,39814E-7

2,98459E-1

5.4

Oscill8 Core

7,19217E-3

2,99999E-1

5,94158E-2

1,91447E-1

3,41791E-1

7,89811E-4

8,87837E-3

1,99210E-1

3,14199E-8

6,31509E-14

5,56743E-4

3,74055E-8

3,00000E-1

2,39813E-7

2,98459E-1

5.4

SBToolbox2

7,19130E-3

3,00000E-1

2,56769E-7

1,54094E-3

5,94005E-2

8,58956E-7

1,91446E-1

3,41782E-1

7,89571E-4

8,87810E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05995E-2

3,28959E-8

9,64554E-16

5,71689E-14

5,56563E-4

3,81909E-8

1,71479E-15

3,00000E-1

1,30306E-5

2,38818E-7

2,98460E-1

5.4

SBWOdeSolver

7,19217E-3

2,99999E-1

2,55719E-7

1,54144E-3

5,94158E-2

8,54360E-7

1,91447E-1

3,41791E-1

7,89810E-4

8,87837E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05842E-2

3,14196E-8

8,83013E-16

6,31507E-14

5,56743E-4

3,74051E-8

1,75667E-15

3,00000E-1

1,31804E-5

2,39814E-7

2,98459E-1

5.4

copasi

7,19218E-3

2,99999E-1

2,55717E-7

1,54144E-3

5,94159E-2

8,54351E-7

1,91447E-1

3,41791E-1

7,89809E-4

8,87837E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05841E-2

3,14190E-8

8,85497E-16

6,31878E-14

5,56742E-4

3,74045E-8

1,75903E-15

3,00000E-1

1,31804E-5

2,39812E-7

2,98459E-1

5.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,19218E-3

2,99999E-1

2,55717E-7

1,54144E-3

5,94159E-2

8,54352E-7

1,91447E-1

3,41791E-1

7,89809E-4

8,87837E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05841E-2

3,14191E-8

-5,05017E-16

6,31655E-14

5,56742E-4

3,74046E-8

2,63678E-15

3,00000E-1

1,31804E-5

2,39812E-7

2,98459E-1

5.4

jsim

7,19217E-3

2,99999E-1

2,55717E-7

1,54144E-3

5,94158E-2

8,54352E-7

1,91447E-1

3,41791E-1

7,89809E-4

8,87837E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05842E-2

3,14191E-8

8,82919E-16

6,31470E-14

5,56743E-4

3,74046E-8

1,75654E-15

3,00000E-1

1,31804E-5

2,39812E-7

2,98459E-1

5.4

min

7,19130E-3

2,99999E-1

2,55717E-7

1,54094E-3

5,94005E-2

8,54351E-7

1,91446E-1

3,41782E-1

7,89571E-4

8,87810E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05841E-2

3,14190E-8

-2,08611E-13

5,71689E-14

5,56563E-4

3,74045E-8

-5,80399E-14

3,00000E-1

1,30306E-5

2,38818E-7

2,98459E-1

5.4

max

7,19218E-3

3,00000E-1

2,56769E-7

1,54144E-3

5,94159E-2

8,58956E-7

1,91447E-1

3,41791E-1

7,89811E-4

8,87837E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05995E-2

3,28959E-8

9,64554E-16

6,31878E-14

5,56743E-4

3,81909E-8

2,63678E-15

3,00000E-1

1,31804E-5

2,39814E-7

2,98460E-1

5.4

mean

7,19217E-3

2,99999E-1

2,55717E-7

1,54144E-3

5,94158E-2

8,54352E-7

1,91447E-1

3,41791E-1

7,89809E-4

8,87837E-3

1,99210E-1

4,05842E-2

3,14191E-8

8,82919E-16

6,31480E-14

5,56743E-4

3,74046E-8

1,75654E-15

3,00000E-1

1,31804E-5

2,39812E-7

2,98459E-1

5.4

relative error(%)

0,00

5.6

BioUML

7,56559E-3

2,99999E-1

3,09010E-7

1,62146E-3

5,94173E-2

1,03568E-6

1,90942E-1

3,41012E-1

8,71438E-4

9,20294E-3

1,99128E-1

4,05827E-2

4,03992E-8

1,43532E-15

9,59922E-14

6,03765E-4

4,65651E-8

2,75231E-15

3,00000E-1

1,52241E-5

2,83272E-7

2,98379E-1

5.6

ByoDyn

7,56559E-3

2,99999E-1

3,09010E-7

1,62146E-3

5,94173E-2

1,03568E-6

1,90942E-1

3,41012E-1

8,71438E-4

9,20294E-3

1,99128E-1

4,05827E-2

4,03992E-8

1,43532E-15

9,59922E-14

6,03765E-4

4,65651E-8

2,75231E-15

3,00000E-1

1,52241E-5

2,83272E-7

2,98379E-1

5.6

CVODE

7,56559E-3

2,99999E-1

3,09010E-7

1,62146E-3

5,94173E-2

1,03568E-6

1,90942E-1

3,41012E-1

8,71438E-4

9,20294E-3

1,99128E-1

4,05827E-2

4,03991E-8

1,43555E-15

9,59946E-14

6,03765E-4

4,65651E-8

2,75250E-15

3,00000E-1

1,52241E-5

2,83272E-7

2,98379E-1

5.6

Jarnac

7,56559E-3

2,99999E-1

3,09010E-7

1,62146E-3

5,94173E-2

1,03568E-6

1,90942E-1

3,41012E-1

8,71438E-4

9,20294E-3

1,99128E-1

4,05827E-2

4,03991E-8

-2,05613E-13

9,59921E-14

6,03765E-4

4,65651E-8

-5,56910E-14

3,00000E-1

1,52241E-5

2,83272E-7

2,98379E-1

5.6

MathSBML

7,56559E-3

2,99999E-1

3,09010E-7

1,62146E-3

5,94173E-2

1,03568E-6

1,90942E-1

3,41012E-1

8,71438E-4

9,20294E-3

1,99128E-1

4,05827E-2

4,03992E-8

1,43486E-15

9,59837E-14

6,03765E-4

4,65652E-8

2,75171E-15

3,00000E-1

1,52241E-5

2,83273E-7

2,98379E-1

5.6

Oscill8 Core

7,56559E-3

2,99999E-1

5,94173E-2

1,90942E-1

3,41012E-1

8,71439E-4

9,20294E-3

1,99128E-1

4,04001E-8

9,59976E-14

6,03765E-4

4,65660E-8

3,00000E-1

2,83274E-7

2,98379E-1

5.6

SBToolbox2

7,56463E-3

3,00000E-1

3,11020E-7

1,62096E-3

5,94010E-2

1,04396E-6

1,90947E-1

3,40997E-1

8,71059E-4

9,20273E-3

1,99130E-1

4,05990E-2

4,25921E-8

1,69512E-15

9,12640E-14

6,03512E-4

4,77499E-8

2,85924E-15

3,00000E-1

1,50661E-5

2,82595E-7

2,98380E-1

5.6

SBWOdeSolver

7,56559E-3

2,99999E-1

3,09013E-7

1,62146E-3

5,94173E-2

1,03568E-6

1,90942E-1

3,41012E-1

8,71439E-4

9,20294E-3

1,99128E-1

4,05827E-2

4,03998E-8

1,43546E-15

9,59973E-14

6,03765E-4

4,65656E-8

2,75250E-15

3,00000E-1

1,52242E-5

2,83274E-7

2,98379E-1

5.6

copasi

7,56560E-3

2,99999E-1

3,09010E-7

1,62146E-3

5,94174E-2

1,03567E-6

1,90942E-1

3,41012E-1

8,71438E-4

9,20294E-3

1,99128E-1

4,05826E-2

4,03990E-8

1,43895E-15

9,60438E-14

6,03765E-4

4,65650E-8

2,75567E-15

3,00000E-1

1,52241E-5

2,83272E-7

2,98379E-1

5.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,56559E-3

2,99999E-1

3,09010E-7

1,62146E-3

5,94174E-2

1,03567E-6

1,90942E-1

3,41012E-1

8,71438E-4

9,20294E-3

1,99128E-1

4,05826E-2

4,03991E-8

-4,93734E-16

9,60265E-14

6,03765E-4

4,65651E-8

4,16334E-15

3,00000E-1

1,52241E-5

2,83272E-7

2,98379E-1

5.6

jsim

7,56559E-3

2,99999E-1

3,09010E-7

1,62146E-3

5,94173E-2

1,03568E-6

1,90942E-1

3,41012E-1

8,71438E-4

9,20294E-3

1,99128E-1

4,05827E-2

4,03992E-8

1,43532E-15

9,59922E-14

6,03765E-4

4,65651E-8

2,75231E-15

3,00000E-1

1,52241E-5

2,83272E-7

2,98379E-1

5.6

min

7,56463E-3

2,99999E-1

3,09010E-7

1,62096E-3

5,94010E-2

1,03567E-6

1,90942E-1

3,40997E-1

8,71059E-4

9,20273E-3

1,99128E-1

4,05826E-2

4,03990E-8

-2,05613E-13

9,12640E-14

6,03512E-4

4,65650E-8

-5,56910E-14

3,00000E-1

1,50661E-5

2,82595E-7

2,98379E-1

5.6

max

7,56560E-3

3,00000E-1

3,11020E-7

1,62146E-3

5,94174E-2

1,04396E-6

1,90947E-1

3,41012E-1

8,71439E-4

9,20294E-3

1,99130E-1

4,05990E-2

4,25921E-8

1,69512E-15

9,60438E-14

6,03765E-4

4,77499E-8

4,16334E-15

3,00000E-1

1,52242E-5

2,83274E-7

2,98380E-1

5.6

mean

7,56559E-3

2,99999E-1

3,09010E-7

1,62146E-3

5,94173E-2

1,03568E-6

1,90942E-1

3,41012E-1

8,71438E-4

9,20294E-3

1,99128E-1

4,05827E-2

4,03992E-8

1,43532E-15

9,59934E-14

6,03765E-4

4,65651E-8

2,75250E-15

3,00000E-1

1,52241E-5

2,83272E-7

2,98379E-1

5.6

relative error(%)

0,00

5.8

BioUML

7,93799E-3

2,99999E-1

3,70355E-7

1,70147E-3

5,94271E-2

1,24513E-6

1,90433E-1

3,40244E-1

9,56974E-4

9,52662E-3

1,99043E-1

4,05729E-2

5,13817E-8

2,28545E-15

1,43344E-13

6,52421E-4

5,74272E-8

4,23073E-15

3,00000E-1

1,74732E-5

3,32313E-7

2,98299E-1

5.8

ByoDyn

7,93799E-3

2,99999E-1

3,70355E-7

1,70147E-3

5,94271E-2

1,24513E-6

1,90433E-1

3,40244E-1

9,56974E-4

9,52662E-3

1,99043E-1

4,05729E-2

5,13817E-8

2,28545E-15

1,43344E-13

6,52421E-4

5,74272E-8

4,23073E-15

3,00000E-1

1,74732E-5

3,32313E-7

2,98299E-1

5.8

CVODE

7,93799E-3

2,99999E-1

3,70355E-7

1,70147E-3

5,94271E-2

1,24513E-6

1,90433E-1

3,40244E-1

9,56974E-4

9,52662E-3

1,99043E-1

4,05729E-2

5,13817E-8

2,28577E-15

1,43347E-13

6,52421E-4

5,74272E-8

4,23097E-15

3,00000E-1

1,74732E-5

3,32313E-7

2,98299E-1

5.8

Jarnac

7,93799E-3

2,99999E-1

3,70355E-7

1,70147E-3

5,94271E-2

1,24513E-6

1,90433E-1

3,40244E-1

9,56974E-4

9,52662E-3

1,99043E-1

4,05729E-2

5,13816E-8

-2,01728E-13

1,43344E-13

6,52421E-4

5,74271E-8

-5,35268E-14

3,00000E-1

1,74732E-5

3,32313E-7

2,98299E-1

5.8

MathSBML

7,93799E-3

2,99999E-1

3,70348E-7

1,70147E-3

5,94271E-2

1,24511E-6

1,90433E-1

3,40244E-1

9,56974E-4

9,52662E-3

1,99043E-1

4,05729E-2

5,13819E-8

2,28522E-15

1,43342E-13

6,52421E-4

5,74276E-8

4,23077E-15

3,00000E-1

1,74732E-5

3,32340E-7

2,98299E-1

5.8

Oscill8 Core

7,93799E-3

2,99999E-1

5,94271E-2

1,90433E-1

3,40244E-1

9,56975E-4

9,52662E-3

1,99043E-1

5,13829E-8

1,43351E-13

6,52421E-4

5,74282E-8

3,00000E-1

3,32315E-7

2,98299E-1

5.8

SBToolbox2

7,93711E-3

3,00000E-1

3,72808E-7

1,70098E-3

5,94114E-2

1,25520E-6

1,90437E-1

3,40233E-1

9,56495E-4

9,52636E-3

1,99040E-1

4,05886E-2

5,41455E-8

2,68352E-15

1,36000E-13

6,52127E-4

5,88887E-8

4,38388E-15

3,00000E-1

1,73011E-5

3,31658E-7

2,98300E-1

5.8

SBWOdeSolver

7,93799E-3

2,99999E-1

3,70358E-7

1,70147E-3

5,94271E-2

1,24514E-6

1,90433E-1

3,40244E-1

9,56975E-4

9,52662E-3

1,99043E-1

4,05729E-2

5,13824E-8

2,28565E-15

1,43351E-13

6,52421E-4

5,74278E-8

4,23099E-15

3,00000E-1

1,74732E-5

3,32315E-7

2,98299E-1

5.8

copasi

7,93800E-3

2,99999E-1

3,70355E-7

1,70147E-3

5,94271E-2

1,24513E-6

1,90433E-1

3,40244E-1

9,56973E-4

9,52662E-3

1,99043E-1

4,05729E-2

5,13816E-8

2,29040E-15

1,43407E-13

6,52421E-4

5,74271E-8

4,23507E-15

3,00000E-1

1,74732E-5

3,32313E-7

2,98299E-1

5.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,93799E-3

2,99999E-1

3,70355E-7

1,70147E-3

5,94271E-2

1,24513E-6

1,90433E-1

3,40244E-1

9,56973E-4

9,52662E-3

1,99043E-1

4,05729E-2

5,13816E-8

-7,62885E-15

1,43399E-13

6,52421E-4

5,74271E-8

1,38778E-14

3,00000E-1

1,74732E-5

3,32313E-7

2,98299E-1

5.8

jsim

7,93799E-3

2,99999E-1

3,70355E-7

1,70147E-3

5,94271E-2

1,24513E-6

1,90433E-1

3,40244E-1

9,56974E-4

9,52662E-3

1,99043E-1

4,05729E-2

5,13817E-8

2,28545E-15

1,43344E-13

6,52421E-4

5,74272E-8

4,23073E-15

3,00000E-1

1,74732E-5

3,32313E-7

2,98299E-1

5.8

min

7,93711E-3

2,99999E-1

3,70348E-7

1,70098E-3

5,94114E-2

1,24511E-6

1,90433E-1

3,40233E-1

9,56495E-4

9,52636E-3

1,99040E-1

4,05729E-2

5,13816E-8

-2,01728E-13

1,36000E-13

6,52127E-4

5,74271E-8

-5,35268E-14

3,00000E-1

1,73011E-5

3,31658E-7

2,98299E-1

5.8

max

7,93800E-3

3,00000E-1

3,72808E-7

1,70147E-3

5,94271E-2

1,25520E-6

1,90437E-1

3,40244E-1

9,56975E-4

9,52662E-3

1,99043E-1

4,05886E-2

5,41455E-8

2,68352E-15

1,43407E-13

6,52421E-4

5,88887E-8

1,38778E-14

3,00000E-1

1,74732E-5

3,32340E-7

2,98300E-1

5.8

mean

7,93799E-3

2,99999E-1

3,70355E-7

1,70147E-3

5,94271E-2

1,24513E-6

1,90433E-1

3,40244E-1

9,56974E-4

9,52662E-3

1,99043E-1

4,05729E-2

5,13817E-8

2,28545E-15

1,43345E-13

6,52421E-4

5,74272E-8

4,23097E-15

3,00000E-1

1,74732E-5

3,32313E-7

2,98299E-1

5.8

relative error(%)

0,00

6.0

BioUML

8,30914E-3

2,99998E-1

4,40523E-7

1,78145E-3

5,94436E-2

1,48555E-6

1,89920E-1

3,39484E-1

1,04634E-3

9,84950E-3

1,98953E-1

4,05564E-2

6,46937E-8

3,57002E-15

2,10557E-13

7,02672E-4

7,02114E-8

6,38912E-15

3,00000E-1

1,99369E-5

3,87372E-7

2,98219E-1

6.0

ByoDyn

8,30914E-3

2,99998E-1

4,40523E-7

1,78145E-3

5,94436E-2

1,48555E-6

1,89920E-1

3,39484E-1

1,04634E-3

9,84950E-3

1,98953E-1

4,05564E-2

6,46937E-8

3,57002E-15

2,10557E-13

7,02672E-4

7,02114E-8

6,38912E-15

3,00000E-1

1,99369E-5

3,87372E-7

2,98219E-1

6.0

CVODE

8,30914E-3

2,99998E-1

4,40523E-7

1,78145E-3

5,94436E-2

1,48555E-6

1,89920E-1

3,39484E-1

1,04634E-3

9,84950E-3

1,98953E-1

4,05564E-2

6,46936E-8

3,57043E-15

2,10560E-13

7,02672E-4

7,02114E-8

6,38942E-15

3,00000E-1

1,99369E-5

3,87372E-7

2,98219E-1

6.0

Jarnac

8,30914E-3

2,99998E-1

4,40523E-7

1,78145E-3

5,94436E-2

1,48555E-6

1,89920E-1

3,39484E-1

1,04634E-3

9,84950E-3

1,98953E-1

4,05564E-2

6,46936E-8

-1,97786E-13

2,10557E-13

7,02672E-4

7,02113E-8

-5,06290E-14

3,00000E-1

1,99369E-5

3,87372E-7

2,98219E-1

6.0

MathSBML

8,30914E-3

2,99998E-1

4,40524E-7

1,78145E-3

5,94436E-2

1,48555E-6

1,89920E-1

3,39484E-1

1,04634E-3

9,84950E-3

1,98953E-1

4,05564E-2

6,46938E-8

3,57003E-15

2,10566E-13

7,02672E-4

7,02114E-8

6,38969E-15

3,00000E-1

1,99369E-5

3,87366E-7

2,98219E-1

6.0

Oscill8 Core

8,30914E-3

2,99998E-1

5,94436E-2

1,89920E-1

3,39484E-1

1,04634E-3

9,84950E-3

1,98953E-1

6,46950E-8

2,10566E-13

7,02672E-4

7,02125E-8

3,00000E-1

3,87374E-7

2,98219E-1

6.0

SBToolbox2

8,30880E-3

3,00000E-1

4,41692E-7

1,78100E-3

5,94304E-2

1,49108E-6

1,89922E-1

3,39474E-1

1,04594E-3

9,84898E-3

1,98956E-1

4,05696E-2

6,72938E-8

3,59960E-15

1,85830E-13

7,02420E-4

7,14554E-8

5,92922E-15

3,00000E-1

1,97308E-5

3,85778E-7

2,98220E-1

6.0

SBWOdeSolver

8,30914E-3

2,99998E-1

4,40526E-7

1,78145E-3

5,94436E-2

1,48556E-6

1,89920E-1

3,39484E-1

1,04634E-3

9,84950E-3

1,98953E-1

4,05564E-2

6,46945E-8

3,57029E-15

2,10566E-13

7,02672E-4

7,02120E-8

6,38947E-15

3,00000E-1

1,99370E-5

3,87374E-7

2,98219E-1

6.0

copasi

8,30915E-3

2,99998E-1

4,40523E-7

1,78145E-3

5,94437E-2

1,48555E-6

1,89920E-1

3,39484E-1

1,04634E-3

9,84950E-3

1,98953E-1

4,05563E-2

6,46934E-8

3,57691E-15

2,10637E-13

7,02671E-4

7,02113E-8

6,39491E-15

3,00000E-1

1,99369E-5

3,87372E-7

2,98219E-1

6.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,30914E-3

2,99998E-1

4,40523E-7

1,78145E-3

5,94437E-2

1,48555E-6

1,89920E-1

3,39484E-1

1,04634E-3

9,84950E-3

1,98953E-1

4,05563E-2

6,46935E-8

-2,32900E-14

2,10633E-13

7,02671E-4

7,02113E-8

3,32789E-14

3,00000E-1

1,99369E-5

3,87372E-7

2,98219E-1

6.0

jsim

8,30914E-3

2,99998E-1

4,40523E-7

1,78145E-3

5,94436E-2

1,48555E-6

1,89920E-1

3,39484E-1

1,04634E-3

9,84950E-3

1,98953E-1

4,05564E-2

6,46937E-8

3,57002E-15

2,10557E-13

7,02672E-4

7,02114E-8

6,38912E-15

3,00000E-1

1,99369E-5

3,87372E-7

2,98219E-1

6.0

min

8,30880E-3

2,99998E-1

4,40523E-7

1,78100E-3

5,94304E-2

1,48555E-6

1,89920E-1

3,39474E-1

1,04594E-3

9,84898E-3

1,98953E-1

4,05563E-2

6,46934E-8

-1,97786E-13

1,85830E-13

7,02420E-4

7,02113E-8

-5,06290E-14

3,00000E-1

1,97308E-5

3,85778E-7

2,98219E-1

6.0

max

8,30915E-3

3,00000E-1

4,41692E-7

1,78145E-3

5,94437E-2

1,49108E-6

1,89922E-1

3,39484E-1

1,04634E-3

9,84950E-3

1,98956E-1

4,05696E-2

6,72938E-8

3,59960E-15

2,10637E-13

7,02672E-4

7,14554E-8

3,32789E-14

3,00000E-1

1,99370E-5

3,87374E-7

2,98220E-1

6.0

mean

8,30914E-3

2,99998E-1

4,40523E-7

1,78145E-3

5,94436E-2

1,48555E-6

1,89920E-1

3,39484E-1

1,04634E-3

9,84950E-3

1,98953E-1

4,05564E-2

6,46937E-8

3,57003E-15

2,10563E-13

7,02672E-4

7,02114E-8

6,38942E-15

3,00000E-1

1,99369E-5

3,87372E-7

2,98219E-1

6.0

relative error(%)

0,00

6.2

BioUML

8,67884E-3

2,99998E-1

5,20315E-7

1,86138E-3

5,94659E-2

1,75987E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38731E-1

1,13946E-3

1,01717E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05341E-2

8,06961E-8

5,47833E-15

3,04600E-13

7,54479E-4

8,51550E-8

9,49160E-15

3,00000E-1

2,26245E-5

4,48898E-7

2,98139E-1

6.2

ByoDyn

8,67884E-3

2,99998E-1

5,20315E-7

1,86138E-3

5,94659E-2

1,75987E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38731E-1

1,13946E-3

1,01717E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05341E-2

8,06961E-8

5,47833E-15

3,04600E-13

7,54479E-4

8,51550E-8

9,49160E-15

3,00000E-1

2,26245E-5

4,48898E-7

2,98139E-1

6.2

CVODE

8,67884E-3

2,99998E-1

5,20315E-7

1,86138E-3

5,94659E-2

1,75987E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38731E-1

1,13946E-3

1,01717E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05341E-2

8,06960E-8

5,47885E-15

3,04604E-13

7,54479E-4

8,51550E-8

9,49197E-15

3,00000E-1

2,26245E-5

4,48898E-7

2,98139E-1

6.2

Jarnac

8,67884E-3

2,99998E-1

5,20315E-7

1,86138E-3

5,94659E-2

1,75987E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38731E-1

1,13946E-3

1,01717E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05341E-2

8,06960E-8

-1,92402E-13

3,04600E-13

7,54479E-4

8,51549E-8

-4,70834E-14

3,00000E-1

2,26245E-5

4,48898E-7

2,98139E-1

6.2

MathSBML

8,67884E-3

2,99998E-1

5,20375E-7

1,86138E-3

5,94659E-2

1,76005E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38731E-1

1,13946E-3

1,01717E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05341E-2

8,06967E-8

5,47920E-15

3,04668E-13

7,54480E-4

8,51525E-8

9,49242E-15

3,00000E-1

2,26245E-5

4,48661E-7

2,98139E-1

6.2

Oscill8 Core

8,67884E-3

2,99998E-1

5,94659E-2

1,89402E-1

3,38731E-1

1,13946E-3

1,01717E-2

1,98860E-1

8,06976E-8

3,04612E-13

7,54480E-4

8,51561E-8

3,00000E-1

4,48900E-7

2,98139E-1

6.2

SBToolbox2

8,67889E-3

3,00000E-1

5,20969E-7

1,86102E-3

5,94548E-2

1,76379E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38725E-1

1,13902E-3

1,01711E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05452E-2

8,35694E-8

5,48091E-15

2,71554E-13

7,54229E-4

8,64370E-8

8,80206E-15

3,00000E-1

2,23932E-5

4,46805E-7

2,98140E-1

6.2

SBWOdeSolver

8,67884E-3

2,99998E-1

5,20318E-7

1,86138E-3

5,94659E-2

1,75988E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38731E-1

1,13946E-3

1,01717E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05341E-2

8,06970E-8

5,47870E-15

3,04611E-13

7,54480E-4

8,51557E-8

9,49206E-15

3,00000E-1

2,26246E-5

4,48900E-7

2,98139E-1

6.2

copasi

8,67884E-3

2,99998E-1

5,20315E-7

1,86138E-3

5,94660E-2

1,75987E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38731E-1

1,13946E-3

1,01717E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05340E-2

8,06958E-8

5,48876E-15

3,04714E-13

7,54479E-4

8,51548E-8

9,50014E-15

3,00000E-1

2,26245E-5

4,48898E-7

2,98139E-1

6.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,67884E-3

2,99998E-1

5,20315E-7

1,86138E-3

5,94660E-2

1,75987E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38731E-1

1,13946E-3

1,01717E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05340E-2

8,06959E-8

-3,95733E-14

3,04691E-13

7,54479E-4

8,51548E-8

5,54001E-14

3,00000E-1

2,26245E-5

4,48898E-7

2,98139E-1

6.2

jsim

8,67884E-3

2,99998E-1

5,20315E-7

1,86138E-3

5,94659E-2

1,75987E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38731E-1

1,13946E-3

1,01717E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05341E-2

8,06961E-8

5,47833E-15

3,04600E-13

7,54479E-4

8,51550E-8

9,49160E-15

3,00000E-1

2,26245E-5

4,48898E-7

2,98139E-1

6.2

min

8,67884E-3

2,99998E-1

5,20315E-7

1,86102E-3

5,94548E-2

1,75987E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38725E-1

1,13902E-3

1,01711E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05340E-2

8,06958E-8

-1,92402E-13

2,71554E-13

7,54229E-4

8,51525E-8

-4,70834E-14

3,00000E-1

2,23932E-5

4,46805E-7

2,98139E-1

6.2

max

8,67889E-3

3,00000E-1

5,20969E-7

1,86138E-3

5,94660E-2

1,76379E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38731E-1

1,13946E-3

1,01717E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05452E-2

8,35694E-8

5,48876E-15

3,04714E-13

7,54480E-4

8,64370E-8

5,54001E-14

3,00000E-1

2,26246E-5

4,48900E-7

2,98140E-1

6.2

mean

8,67884E-3

2,99998E-1

5,20315E-7

1,86138E-3

5,94659E-2

1,75987E-6

1,89402E-1

3,38731E-1

1,13946E-3

1,01717E-2

1,98860E-1

4,05341E-2

8,06961E-8

5,47870E-15

3,04608E-13

7,54479E-4

8,51550E-8

9,49197E-15

3,00000E-1

2,26245E-5

4,48898E-7

2,98139E-1

6.2

relative error(%)

0,00

6.4

BioUML

9,04692E-3

2,99998E-1

6,10563E-7

1,94123E-3

5,94930E-2

2,07118E-6

1,88880E-1

3,37986E-1

1,23625E-3

1,04932E-2

1,98763E-1

4,05070E-2

9,97858E-8

8,26897E-15

4,34441E-13

8,07807E-4

1,02512E-7

1,38873E-14

3,00000E-1

2,55451E-5

5,17353E-7

2,98059E-1

6.4

ByoDyn

9,04692E-3

2,99998E-1

6,10563E-7

1,94123E-3

5,94930E-2

2,07118E-6

1,88880E-1

3,37986E-1

1,23625E-3

1,04932E-2

1,98763E-1

4,05070E-2

9,97858E-8

8,26897E-15

4,34441E-13

8,07807E-4

1,02512E-7

1,38873E-14

3,00000E-1

2,55451E-5

5,17353E-7

2,98059E-1

6.4

CVODE

9,04692E-3

2,99998E-1

6,10563E-7

1,94123E-3

5,94930E-2

2,07118E-6

1,88880E-1

3,37986E-1

1,23625E-3

1,04932E-2

1,98763E-1

4,05070E-2

9,97858E-8

8,26963E-15

4,34446E-13

8,07807E-4

1,02512E-7

1,38877E-14

3,00000E-1

2,55451E-5

5,17353E-7

2,98059E-1

6.4

Jarnac

9,04692E-3

2,99998E-1

6,10563E-7

1,94123E-3

5,94930E-2

2,07118E-6

1,88880E-1

3,37986E-1

1,23625E-3

1,04932E-2

1,98763E-1

4,05070E-2

9,97857E-8

-1,87350E-13

4,34441E-13

8,07807E-4

1,02512E-7

-4,13111E-14

3,00000E-1

2,55451E-5

5,17353E-7

2,98059E-1

6.4

MathSBML

9,04691E-3

2,99998E-1

6,10676E-7

1,94123E-3

5,94930E-2

2,07151E-6

1,88880E-1

3,37986E-1

1,23625E-3

1,04932E-2

1,98763E-1

4,05070E-2

9,97869E-8

8,27103E-15

4,34569E-13

8,07807E-4

1,02507E-7

1,38883E-14

3,00000E-1

2,55451E-5

5,16906E-7

2,98059E-1

6.4

Oscill8 Core

9,04691E-3

2,99998E-1

5,94930E-2

1,88880E-1

3,37986E-1

1,23625E-3

1,04932E-2

1,98763E-1

9,97875E-8

4,34457E-13

8,07808E-4

1,02513E-7

3,00000E-1

5,17355E-7

2,98059E-1

6.4

SBToolbox2

9,04712E-3

3,00000E-1

6,11842E-7

1,94084E-3

5,94827E-2

2,07765E-6

1,88879E-1

3,37976E-1

1,23570E-3

1,04928E-2

1,98766E-1

4,05173E-2

1,03576E-7

8,84065E-15

4,05455E-13

8,07512E-4

1,04209E-7

1,36104E-14

3,00000E-1

2,53007E-5

5,15403E-7

2,98060E-1

6.4

SBWOdeSolver

9,04691E-3

2,99998E-1

6,10566E-7

1,94123E-3

5,94930E-2

2,07119E-6

1,88880E-1

3,37986E-1

1,23625E-3

1,04932E-2

1,98763E-1

4,05070E-2

9,97868E-8

8,26944E-15

4,34456E-13

8,07808E-4

1,02513E-7

1,38879E-14

3,00000E-1

2,55451E-5

5,17355E-7

2,98059E-1

6.4

copasi

9,04692E-3

2,99998E-1

6,10563E-7

1,94123E-3

5,94930E-2

2,07118E-6

1,88880E-1

3,37986E-1

1,23625E-3

1,04932E-2

1,98763E-1

4,05070E-2

9,97855E-8

8,28520E-15

4,34611E-13

8,07807E-4

1,02512E-7

1,39003E-14

3,00000E-1

2,55451E-5

5,17353E-7

2,98059E-1

6.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,04692E-3

2,99998E-1

6,10563E-7

1,94123E-3

5,94930E-2

2,07118E-6

1,88880E-1

3,37986E-1

1,23625E-3

1,04932E-2

1,98763E-1

4,05070E-2

9,97856E-8

-4,31911E-14

4,34545E-13

8,07807E-4

1,02512E-7

6,71962E-14

3,00000E-1

2,55451E-5

5,17353E-7

2,98059E-1

6.4

jsim

9,04692E-3

2,99998E-1

6,10563E-7

1,94123E-3

5,94930E-2

2,07118E-6

1,88880E-1

3,37986E-1

1,23625E-3

1,04932E-2

1,98763E-1

4,05070E-2

9,97858E-8

8,26897E-15

4,34441E-13

8,07807E-4

1,02512E-7

1,38873E-14

3,00000E-1

2,55451E-5

5,17353E-7

2,98059E-1

6.4

min

9,04691E-3

2,99998E-1

6,10563E-7

1,94084E-3

5,94827E-2

2,07118E-6

1,88879E-1

3,37976E-1

1,23570E-3

1,04928E-2

1,98763E-1

4,05070E-2

9,97855E-8

-1,87350E-13

4,05455E-13

8,07512E-4

1,02507E-7

-4,13111E-14

3,00000E-1

2,53007E-5

5,15403E-7

2,98059E-1

6.4

max

9,04712E-3

3,00000E-1

6,11842E-7

1,94123E-3

5,94930E-2

2,07765E-6

1,88880E-1

3,37986E-1

1,23625E-3

1,04932E-2

1,98766E-1

4,05173E-2

1,03576E-7

8,84065E-15

4,34611E-13

8,07808E-4

1,04209E-7

6,71962E-14

3,00000E-1

2,55451E-5

5,17355E-7

2,98060E-1

6.4

mean

9,04692E-3

2,99998E-1

6,10563E-7

1,94123E-3

5,94930E-2

2,07118E-6

1,88880E-1

3,37986E-1

1,23625E-3

1,04932E-2

1,98763E-1

4,05070E-2

9,97858E-8

8,26944E-15

4,34451E-13

8,07807E-4

1,02512E-7

1,38877E-14

3,00000E-1

2,55451E-5

5,17353E-7

2,98059E-1

6.4

relative error(%)

0,00

6.6

BioUML

9,41323E-3

2,99997E-1

7,12126E-7

2,02100E-3

5,95240E-2

2,42266E-6

1,88355E-1

3,37247E-1

1,33663E-3

1,08142E-2

1,98663E-1

4,04760E-2

1,22397E-7

1,22905E-14

6,11500E-13

8,62618E-4

1,22554E-7

2,00323E-14

3,00000E-1

2,87074E-5

5,93210E-7

2,97979E-1

6.6

ByoDyn

9,41323E-3

2,99997E-1

7,12126E-7

2,02100E-3

5,95240E-2

2,42266E-6

1,88355E-1

3,37247E-1

1,33663E-3

1,08142E-2

1,98663E-1

4,04760E-2

1,22397E-7

1,22905E-14

6,11500E-13

8,62618E-4

1,22554E-7

2,00323E-14

3,00000E-1

2,87074E-5

5,93210E-7

2,97979E-1

6.6

CVODE

9,41323E-3

2,99997E-1

7,12126E-7

2,02100E-3

5,95240E-2

2,42266E-6

1,88355E-1

3,37247E-1

1,33663E-3

1,08142E-2

1,98663E-1

4,04760E-2

1,22397E-7

1,22913E-14

6,11505E-13

8,62618E-4

1,22554E-7

2,00328E-14

3,00000E-1

2,87074E-5

5,93210E-7

2,97979E-1

6.6

Jarnac

9,41323E-3

2,99997E-1

7,12126E-7

2,02100E-3

5,95240E-2

2,42266E-6

1,88355E-1

3,37247E-1

1,33663E-3

1,08142E-2

1,98663E-1

4,04760E-2

1,22397E-7

-1,79856E-13

6,11500E-13

8,62618E-4

1,22554E-7

-3,48502E-14

3,00000E-1

2,87074E-5

5,93210E-7

2,97979E-1

6.6

MathSBML

9,41322E-3

2,99997E-1

7,12138E-7

2,02100E-3

5,95240E-2

2,42270E-6

1,88355E-1

3,37247E-1

1,33663E-3

1,08142E-2

1,98663E-1

4,04760E-2

1,22397E-7

1,22937E-14

6,11521E-13

8,62618E-4

1,22553E-7

2,00356E-14

3,00000E-1

2,87074E-5

5,93165E-7

2,97979E-1

6.6

Oscill8 Core

9,41322E-3

2,99997E-1

5,95240E-2

1,88355E-1

3,37247E-1

1,33663E-3

1,08142E-2

1,98663E-1

1,22399E-7

6,11521E-13

8,62618E-4

1,22555E-7

3,00000E-1

5,93212E-7

2,97979E-1

6.6

SBToolbox2

9,41352E-3

3,00000E-1

7,14303E-7

2,02066E-3

5,95137E-2

2,43273E-6

1,88360E-1

3,37236E-1

1,33593E-3

1,08134E-2

1,98667E-1

4,04863E-2

1,27315E-7

1,36792E-14

5,87546E-13

8,62265E-4

1,24774E-7

2,03542E-14

3,00000E-1

2,84548E-5

5,91560E-7

2,97980E-1

6.6

SBWOdeSolver

9,41322E-3

2,99997E-1

7,12130E-7

2,02100E-3

5,95240E-2

2,42268E-6

1,88355E-1

3,37247E-1

1,33663E-3

1,08142E-2

1,98663E-1

4,04760E-2

1,22398E-7

1,22911E-14

6,11518E-13

8,62618E-4

1,22554E-7

2,00330E-14

3,00000E-1

2,87074E-5

5,93212E-7

2,97979E-1

6.6

copasi

9,41323E-3

2,99997E-1

7,12126E-7

2,02100E-3

5,95240E-2

2,42266E-6

1,88355E-1

3,37247E-1

1,33663E-3

1,08142E-2

1,98663E-1

4,04760E-2

1,22397E-7

1,23134E-14

6,11717E-13

8,62617E-4

1,22553E-7

2,00500E-14

3,00000E-1

2,87074E-5

5,93210E-7

2,97979E-1

6.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,41323E-3

2,99997E-1

7,12126E-7

2,02100E-3

5,95240E-2

2,42266E-6

1,88355E-1

3,37247E-1

1,33663E-3

1,08142E-2

1,98663E-1

4,04760E-2

1,22397E-7

-4,12073E-14

6,11618E-13

8,62618E-4

1,22554E-7

7,64666E-14

3,00000E-1

2,87074E-5

5,93210E-7

2,97979E-1

6.6

jsim

9,41323E-3

2,99997E-1

7,12126E-7

2,02100E-3

5,95240E-2

2,42266E-6

1,88355E-1

3,37247E-1

1,33663E-3

1,08142E-2

1,98663E-1

4,04760E-2

1,22397E-7

1,22905E-14

6,11500E-13

8,62618E-4

1,22554E-7

2,00323E-14

3,00000E-1

2,87074E-5

5,93210E-7

2,97979E-1

6.6

min

9,41322E-3

2,99997E-1

7,12126E-7

2,02066E-3

5,95137E-2

2,42266E-6

1,88355E-1

3,37236E-1

1,33593E-3

1,08134E-2

1,98663E-1

4,04760E-2

1,22397E-7

-1,79856E-13

5,87546E-13

8,62265E-4

1,22553E-7

-3,48502E-14

3,00000E-1

2,84548E-5

5,91560E-7

2,97979E-1

6.6

max

9,41352E-3

3,00000E-1

7,14303E-7

2,02100E-3

5,95240E-2

2,43273E-6

1,88360E-1

3,37247E-1

1,33663E-3

1,08142E-2

1,98667E-1

4,04863E-2

1,27315E-7

1,36792E-14

6,11717E-13

8,62618E-4

1,24774E-7

7,64666E-14

3,00000E-1

2,87074E-5

5,93212E-7

2,97980E-1

6.6

mean

9,41323E-3

2,99997E-1

7,12126E-7

2,02100E-3

5,95240E-2

2,42266E-6

1,88355E-1

3,37247E-1

1,33663E-3

1,08142E-2

1,98663E-1

4,04760E-2

1,22397E-7

1,22911E-14

6,11512E-13

8,62618E-4

1,22554E-7

2,00330E-14

3,00000E-1

2,87074E-5

5,93210E-7

2,97979E-1

6.6

relative error(%)

0,00

6.8

BioUML

9,77764E-3

2,99997E-1

8,25892E-7

2,10067E-3

5,95583E-2

2,81765E-6

1,87827E-1

3,36513E-1

1,44051E-3

1,11347E-2

1,98559E-1

4,04417E-2

1,49003E-7

1,80072E-14

8,50176E-13

9,18874E-4

1,45569E-7

2,85161E-14

3,00000E-1

3,21201E-5

6,76952E-7

2,97899E-1

6.8

ByoDyn

9,77764E-3

2,99997E-1

8,25892E-7

2,10067E-3

5,95583E-2

2,81765E-6

1,87827E-1

3,36513E-1

1,44051E-3

1,11347E-2

1,98559E-1

4,04417E-2

1,49003E-7

1,80072E-14

8,50176E-13

9,18874E-4

1,45569E-7

2,85161E-14

3,00000E-1

3,21201E-5

6,76952E-7

2,97899E-1

6.8

CVODE

9,77764E-3

2,99997E-1

8,25892E-7

2,10067E-3

5,95583E-2

2,81765E-6

1,87827E-1

3,36513E-1

1,44051E-3

1,11347E-2

1,98559E-1

4,04417E-2

1,49003E-7

1,80082E-14

8,50182E-13

9,18874E-4

1,45569E-7

2,85168E-14

3,00000E-1

3,21201E-5

6,76952E-7

2,97899E-1

6.8

Jarnac

9,77764E-3

2,99997E-1

8,25892E-7

2,10067E-3

5,95583E-2

2,81765E-6

1,87827E-1

3,36513E-1

1,44051E-3

1,11347E-2

1,98559E-1

4,04417E-2

1,49003E-7

-1,72029E-13

8,50175E-13

9,18874E-4

1,45569E-7

-2,56127E-14

3,00000E-1

3,21201E-5

6,76952E-7

2,97899E-1

6.8

MathSBML

9,77764E-3

2,99997E-1

8,25547E-7

2,10067E-3

5,95583E-2

2,81663E-6

1,87827E-1

3,36513E-1

1,44052E-3

1,11347E-2

1,98559E-1

4,04417E-2

1,49000E-7

1,80089E-14

8,49664E-13

9,18874E-4

1,45583E-7

2,85251E-14

3,00000E-1

3,21201E-5

6,78307E-7

2,97899E-1

6.8

Oscill8 Core

9,77764E-3

2,99997E-1

5,95583E-2

1,87827E-1

3,36513E-1

1,44052E-3

1,11347E-2

1,98559E-1

1,49005E-7

8,50201E-13

9,18875E-4

1,45570E-7

3,00000E-1

6,76955E-7

2,97899E-1

6.8

SBToolbox2

9,77802E-3

3,00000E-1

8,28363E-7

2,10035E-3

5,95486E-2

2,82906E-6

1,87830E-1

3,36507E-1

1,43970E-3

1,11341E-2

1,98560E-1

4,04514E-2

1,54780E-7

1,99960E-14

8,17823E-13

9,18482E-4

1,48127E-7

2,90329E-14

3,00000E-1

3,18546E-5

6,75282E-7

2,97900E-1

6.8

SBWOdeSolver

9,77764E-3

2,99997E-1

8,25895E-7

2,10067E-3

5,95583E-2

2,81766E-6

1,87827E-1

3,36513E-1

1,44052E-3

1,11347E-2

1,98559E-1

4,04417E-2

1,49004E-7

1,80080E-14

8,50198E-13

9,18875E-4

1,45570E-7

2,85171E-14

3,00000E-1

3,21201E-5

6,76955E-7

2,97899E-1

6.8

copasi

9,77765E-3

2,99997E-1

8,25892E-7

2,10067E-3

5,95583E-2

2,81765E-6

1,87827E-1

3,36513E-1

1,44051E-3

1,11347E-2

1,98559E-1

4,04417E-2

1,49002E-7

1,80392E-14

8,50450E-13

9,18874E-4

1,45568E-7

2,85399E-14

3,00000E-1

3,21201E-5

6,76952E-7

2,97899E-1

6.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,77765E-3

2,99997E-1

8,25892E-7

2,10067E-3

5,95583E-2

2,81765E-6

1,87827E-1

3,36513E-1

1,44051E-3

1,11347E-2

1,98559E-1

4,04417E-2

1,49002E-7

-3,59146E-14

8,50310E-13

9,18874E-4

1,45569E-7

8,65141E-14

3,00000E-1

3,21201E-5

6,76952E-7

2,97899E-1

6.8

jsim

9,77764E-3

2,99997E-1

8,25892E-7

2,10067E-3

5,95583E-2

2,81765E-6

1,87827E-1

3,36513E-1

1,44051E-3

1,11347E-2

1,98559E-1

4,04417E-2

1,49003E-7

1,80072E-14

8,50176E-13

9,18874E-4

1,45569E-7

2,85161E-14

3,00000E-1

3,21201E-5

6,76952E-7

2,97899E-1

6.8

min

9,77764E-3

2,99997E-1

8,25547E-7

2,10035E-3

5,95486E-2

2,81663E-6

1,87827E-1

3,36507E-1

1,43970E-3

1,11341E-2

1,98559E-1

4,04417E-2

1,49000E-7

-1,72029E-13

8,17823E-13

9,18482E-4

1,45568E-7

-2,56127E-14

3,00000E-1

3,18546E-5

6,75282E-7

2,97899E-1

6.8

max

9,77802E-3

3,00000E-1

8,28363E-7

2,10067E-3

5,95583E-2

2,82906E-6

1,87830E-1

3,36513E-1

1,44052E-3

1,11347E-2

1,98560E-1

4,04514E-2

1,54780E-7

1,99960E-14

8,50450E-13

9,18875E-4

1,48127E-7

8,65141E-14

3,00000E-1

3,21201E-5

6,78307E-7

2,97900E-1

6.8

mean

9,77764E-3

2,99997E-1

8,25892E-7

2,10067E-3

5,95583E-2

2,81765E-6

1,87827E-1

3,36513E-1

1,44051E-3

1,11347E-2

1,98559E-1

4,04417E-2

1,49003E-7

1,80080E-14

8,50179E-13

9,18874E-4

1,45569E-7

2,85171E-14

3,00000E-1

3,21201E-5

6,76952E-7

2,97899E-1

6.8

relative error(%)

0,00

7.0

BioUML

1,01401E-2

2,99996E-1

9,52773E-7

2,18023E-3

5,95953E-2

3,25956E-6

1,87295E-1

3,35785E-1

1,54782E-3

1,14546E-2

1,98451E-1

4,04047E-2

1,80115E-7

2,60307E-14

1,16846E-12

9,76541E-4

1,71863E-7

4,00933E-14

3,00000E-1

3,57915E-5

7,69076E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

ByoDyn

1,01401E-2

2,99996E-1

9,52773E-7

2,18023E-3

5,95953E-2

3,25956E-6

1,87295E-1

3,35785E-1

1,54782E-3

1,14546E-2

1,98451E-1

4,04047E-2

1,80115E-7

2,60307E-14

1,16846E-12

9,76541E-4

1,71863E-7

4,00933E-14

3,00000E-1

3,57915E-5

7,69076E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

CVODE

1,01401E-2

2,99996E-1

9,52773E-7

2,18023E-3

5,95953E-2

3,25956E-6

1,87295E-1

3,35785E-1

1,54782E-3

1,14546E-2

1,98451E-1

4,04047E-2

1,80115E-7

2,60319E-14

1,16847E-12

9,76541E-4

1,71863E-7

4,00940E-14

3,00000E-1

3,57915E-5

7,69076E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

Jarnac

1,01401E-2

2,99996E-1

9,52773E-7

2,18023E-3

5,95953E-2

3,25956E-6

1,87295E-1

3,35785E-1

1,54782E-3

1,14546E-2

1,98451E-1

4,04047E-2

1,80115E-7

-1,61315E-13

1,16846E-12

9,76541E-4

1,71863E-7

-1,34377E-14

3,00000E-1

3,57915E-5

7,69076E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

MathSBML

1,01401E-2

2,99996E-1

9,51755E-7

2,18023E-3

5,95953E-2

3,25655E-6

1,87295E-1

3,35785E-1

1,54782E-3

1,14546E-2

1,98451E-1

4,04047E-2

1,80108E-7

2,60351E-14

1,16692E-12

9,76541E-4

1,71905E-7

4,01272E-14

3,00000E-1

3,57915E-5

7,73083E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

Oscill8 Core

1,01401E-2

2,99996E-1

5,95953E-2

1,87295E-1

3,35785E-1

1,54782E-3

1,14546E-2

1,98451E-1

1,80118E-7

1,16849E-12

9,76542E-4

1,71865E-7

3,00000E-1

7,69079E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

SBToolbox2

1,01404E-2

3,00000E-1

9,53543E-7

2,17990E-3

5,95876E-2

3,26480E-6

1,87294E-1

3,35778E-1

1,54715E-3

1,14538E-2

1,98450E-1

4,04124E-2

1,85611E-7

2,66497E-14

1,08158E-12

9,76189E-4

1,74087E-7

3,85366E-14

3,00000E-1

3,54947E-5

7,66314E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,01401E-2

2,99996E-1

9,52776E-7

2,18023E-3

5,95953E-2

3,25957E-6

1,87295E-1

3,35785E-1

1,54782E-3

1,14546E-2

1,98451E-1

4,04047E-2

1,80117E-7

2,60317E-14

1,16849E-12

9,76542E-4

1,71864E-7

4,00944E-14

3,00000E-1

3,57916E-5

7,69079E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

copasi

1,01401E-2

2,99996E-1

9,52773E-7

2,18024E-3

5,95953E-2

3,25955E-6

1,87295E-1

3,35785E-1

1,54782E-3

1,14546E-2

1,98451E-1

4,04047E-2

1,80115E-7

2,60743E-14

1,16880E-12

9,76541E-4

1,71863E-7

4,01243E-14

3,00000E-1

3,57915E-5

7,69076E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,01401E-2

2,99996E-1

9,52773E-7

2,18024E-3

5,95953E-2

3,25955E-6

1,87295E-1

3,35785E-1

1,54782E-3

1,14546E-2

1,98451E-1

4,04047E-2

1,80115E-7

-3,04898E-14

1,16862E-12

9,76541E-4

1,71863E-7

1,01835E-13

3,00000E-1

3,57915E-5

7,69076E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

jsim

1,01401E-2

2,99996E-1

9,52773E-7

2,18023E-3

5,95953E-2

3,25956E-6

1,87295E-1

3,35785E-1

1,54782E-3

1,14546E-2

1,98451E-1

4,04047E-2

1,80115E-7

2,60307E-14

1,16846E-12

9,76541E-4

1,71863E-7

4,00933E-14

3,00000E-1

3,57915E-5

7,69076E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

min

1,01401E-2

2,99996E-1

9,51755E-7

2,17990E-3

5,95876E-2

3,25655E-6

1,87294E-1

3,35778E-1

1,54715E-3

1,14538E-2

1,98450E-1

4,04047E-2

1,80108E-7

-1,61315E-13

1,08158E-12

9,76189E-4

1,71863E-7

-1,34377E-14

3,00000E-1

3,54947E-5

7,66314E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

max

1,01404E-2

3,00000E-1

9,53543E-7

2,18024E-3

5,95953E-2

3,26480E-6

1,87295E-1

3,35785E-1

1,54782E-3

1,14546E-2

1,98451E-1

4,04124E-2

1,85611E-7

2,66497E-14

1,16880E-12

9,76542E-4

1,74087E-7

1,01835E-13

3,00000E-1

3,57916E-5

7,73083E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

mean

1,01401E-2

2,99996E-1

9,52773E-7

2,18023E-3

5,95953E-2

3,25956E-6

1,87295E-1

3,35785E-1

1,54782E-3

1,14546E-2

1,98451E-1

4,04047E-2

1,80115E-7

2,60317E-14

1,16846E-12

9,76541E-4

1,71863E-7

4,00940E-14

3,00000E-1

3,57915E-5

7,69076E-7

2,97820E-1

7.0

relative error(%)

0,00

7.2

BioUML

1,05004E-2

2,99996E-1

1,09371E-6

2,25969E-3

5,96346E-2

3,75193E-6

1,86760E-1

3,35061E-1

1,65845E-3

1,17742E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03654E-2

2,16289E-7

3,71580E-14

1,58864E-12

1,03558E-3

2,01762E-7

5,57200E-14

3,00000E-1

3,97299E-5

8,70087E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

ByoDyn

1,05004E-2

2,99996E-1

1,09371E-6

2,25969E-3

5,96346E-2

3,75193E-6

1,86760E-1

3,35061E-1

1,65845E-3

1,17742E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03654E-2

2,16289E-7

3,71580E-14

1,58864E-12

1,03558E-3

2,01762E-7

5,57200E-14

3,00000E-1

3,97299E-5

8,70087E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

CVODE

1,05004E-2

2,99996E-1

1,09371E-6

2,25969E-3

5,96346E-2

3,75193E-6

1,86760E-1

3,35061E-1

1,65845E-3

1,17742E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03654E-2

2,16289E-7

3,71600E-14

1,58865E-12

1,03558E-3

2,01762E-7

5,57214E-14

3,00000E-1

3,97299E-5

8,70087E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

Jarnac

1,05004E-2

2,99996E-1

1,09371E-6

2,25969E-3

5,96346E-2

3,75193E-6

1,86760E-1

3,35061E-1

1,65845E-3

1,17742E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03654E-2

2,16289E-7

-1,47826E-13

1,58864E-12

1,03558E-3

2,01762E-7

2,64432E-15

3,00000E-1

3,97299E-5

8,70087E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

MathSBML

1,05004E-2

2,99996E-1

1,09174E-6

2,25969E-3

5,96346E-2

3,74612E-6

1,86760E-1

3,35061E-1

1,65845E-3

1,17742E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03654E-2

2,16274E-7

3,71544E-14

1,58515E-12

1,03558E-3

2,01843E-7

5,57874E-14

3,00000E-1

3,97299E-5

8,77845E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

Oscill8 Core

1,05004E-2

2,99996E-1

5,96346E-2

1,86760E-1

3,35061E-1

1,65846E-3

1,17742E-2

1,98340E-1

2,16292E-7

1,58868E-12

1,03558E-3

2,01763E-7

3,00000E-1

8,70089E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

SBToolbox2

1,05010E-2

3,00000E-1

1,09367E-6

2,25942E-3

5,96278E-2

3,75438E-6

1,86762E-1

3,35052E-1

1,65777E-3

1,17735E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03722E-2

2,22130E-7

3,76744E-14

1,47499E-12

1,03524E-3

2,03981E-7

5,33621E-14

3,00000E-1

3,94088E-5

8,66718E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,05004E-2

2,99996E-1

1,09371E-6

2,25969E-3

5,96346E-2

3,75195E-6

1,86760E-1

3,35061E-1

1,65846E-3

1,17742E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03654E-2

2,16291E-7

3,71592E-14

1,58867E-12

1,03558E-3

2,01763E-7

5,57215E-14

3,00000E-1

3,97300E-5

8,70089E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

copasi

1,05004E-2

2,99996E-1

1,09371E-6

2,25969E-3

5,96346E-2

3,75193E-6

1,86760E-1

3,35061E-1

1,65845E-3

1,17742E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03654E-2

2,16288E-7

3,72135E-14

1,58903E-12

1,03558E-3

2,01761E-7

5,57577E-14

3,00000E-1

3,97299E-5

8,70087E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,05004E-2

2,99996E-1

1,09371E-6

2,25969E-3

5,96346E-2

3,75193E-6

1,86760E-1

3,35061E-1

1,65845E-3

1,17742E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03654E-2

2,16289E-7

-2,37174E-14

1,58882E-12

1,03558E-3

2,01762E-7

1,22929E-13

3,00000E-1

3,97299E-5

8,70087E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

jsim

1,05004E-2

2,99996E-1

1,09371E-6

2,25969E-3

5,96346E-2

3,75193E-6

1,86760E-1

3,35061E-1

1,65845E-3

1,17742E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03654E-2

2,16289E-7

3,71580E-14

1,58864E-12

1,03558E-3

2,01762E-7

5,57200E-14

3,00000E-1

3,97299E-5

8,70087E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

min

1,05004E-2

2,99996E-1

1,09174E-6

2,25942E-3

5,96278E-2

3,74612E-6

1,86760E-1

3,35052E-1

1,65777E-3

1,17735E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03654E-2

2,16274E-7

-1,47826E-13

1,47499E-12

1,03524E-3

2,01761E-7

2,64432E-15

3,00000E-1

3,94088E-5

8,66718E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

max

1,05010E-2

3,00000E-1

1,09371E-6

2,25969E-3

5,96346E-2

3,75438E-6

1,86762E-1

3,35061E-1

1,65846E-3

1,17742E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03722E-2

2,22130E-7

3,76744E-14

1,58903E-12

1,03558E-3

2,03981E-7

1,22929E-13

3,00000E-1

3,97300E-5

8,77845E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

mean

1,05004E-2

2,99996E-1

1,09371E-6

2,25969E-3

5,96346E-2

3,75193E-6

1,86760E-1

3,35061E-1

1,65845E-3

1,17742E-2

1,98340E-1

4,03654E-2

2,16289E-7

3,71580E-14

1,58865E-12

1,03558E-3

2,01762E-7

5,57214E-14

3,00000E-1

3,97299E-5

8,70087E-7

2,97740E-1

7.2

relative error(%)

0,00

7.4

BioUML

1,08586E-2

2,99995E-1

1,24966E-6

2,33904E-3

5,96758E-2

4,29843E-6

1,86223E-1

3,34341E-1

1,77234E-3

1,20934E-2

1,98226E-1

4,03242E-2

2,58120E-7

5,24178E-14

2,13811E-12

1,09596E-3

2,35606E-7

7,65985E-14

3,00000E-1

4,39431E-5

9,80498E-7

2,97661E-1

7.4

ByoDyn

1,08586E-2

2,99995E-1

1,24966E-6

2,33904E-3

5,96758E-2

4,29843E-6

1,86223E-1

3,34341E-1

1,77234E-3

1,20934E-2

1,98226E-1

4,03242E-2

2,58120E-7

5,24178E-14

2,13811E-12

1,09596E-3

2,35606E-7

7,65985E-14

3,00000E-1

4,39431E-5

9,80498E-7

2,97661E-1

7.4

CVODE

1,08586E-2

2,99995E-1

1,24966E-6

2,33904E-3

5,96758E-2

4,29843E-6

1,86223E-1

3,34341E-1

1,77234E-3

1,20934E-2

1,98226E-1

4,03242E-2

2,58120E-7

5,24217E-14

2,13814E-12

1,09596E-3

2,35606E-7

7,66011E-14

3,00000E-1

4,39431E-5

9,80498E-7

2,97661E-1

7.4

Jarnac

1,08586E-2

2,99995E-1

1,24966E-6

2,33904E-3

5,96758E-2

4,29843E-6

1,86223E-1

3,34341E-1

1,77234E-3

1,20934E-2

1,98226E-1

4,03242E-2

2,58120E-7

-1,30285E-13

2,13811E-12

1,09596E-3

2,35606E-7

2,35478E-14

3,00000E-1

4,39431E-5

9,80498E-7

2,97661E-1

7.4

MathSBML

1,08586E-2

2,99995E-1

1,24700E-6

2,33904E-3

5,96758E-2

4,29059E-6

1,86223E-1

3,34341E-1

1,77234E-3

1,20934E-2

1,98226E-1

4,03242E-2

2,58100E-7

5,24127E-14

2,13313E-12

1,09596E-3

2,35716E-7

7,67094E-14

3,00000E-1

4,39431E-5

9,90960E-7

2,97661E-1

7.4

Oscill8 Core

1,08586E-2

2,99995E-1

5,96758E-2

1,86223E-1

3,34341E-1

1,77234E-3

1,20934E-2

1,98226E-1

2,58123E-7

2,13816E-12

1,09597E-3

2,35608E-7

3,00000E-1

9,80501E-7

2,97661E-1

7.4

SBToolbox2

1,08597E-2

3,00000E-1

1,25013E-6

2,33874E-3

5,96695E-2

4,30304E-6

1,86222E-1

3,34332E-1

1,77158E-3

1,20922E-2

1,98227E-1

4,03305E-2

2,65226E-7

5,49668E-14

2,03457E-12

1,09558E-3

2,38326E-7

7,55160E-14

3,00000E-1

4,36094E-5

9,77225E-7

2,97660E-1

7.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,08586E-2

2,99995E-1

1,24966E-6

2,33904E-3

5,96758E-2

4,29844E-6

1,86223E-1

3,34341E-1

1,77234E-3

1,20934E-2

1,98226E-1

4,03242E-2

2,58122E-7

5,24194E-14

2,13815E-12

1,09597E-3

2,35607E-7

7,66002E-14

3,00000E-1

4,39432E-5

9,80501E-7

2,97661E-1

7.4

copasi

1,08586E-2

2,99995E-1

1,24966E-6

2,33904E-3

5,96758E-2

4,29843E-6

1,86223E-1

3,34341E-1

1,77234E-3

1,20934E-2

1,98226E-1

4,03242E-2

2,58120E-7

5,24879E-14

2,13855E-12

1,09596E-3

2,35606E-7

7,66438E-14

3,00000E-1

4,39431E-5

9,80498E-7

2,97661E-1

7.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,08586E-2

2,99995E-1

1,24966E-6

2,33904E-3

5,96758E-2

4,29843E-6

1,86223E-1

3,34341E-1

1,77234E-3

1,20934E-2

1,98226E-1

4,03242E-2

2,58120E-7

-1,01232E-14

2,13832E-12

1,09596E-3

2,35606E-7

1,46660E-13

3,00000E-1

4,39431E-5

9,80498E-7

2,97661E-1

7.4

jsim

1,08586E-2

2,99995E-1

1,24966E-6

2,33904E-3

5,96758E-2

4,29843E-6

1,86223E-1

3,34341E-1

1,77234E-3

1,20934E-2

1,98226E-1

4,03242E-2

2,58120E-7

5,24178E-14

2,13811E-12

1,09596E-3

2,35606E-7

7,65985E-14

3,00000E-1

4,39431E-5

9,80498E-7

2,97661E-1

7.4

min

1,08586E-2

2,99995E-1

1,24700E-6

2,33874E-3

5,96695E-2

4,29059E-6

1,86222E-1

3,34332E-1

1,77158E-3

1,20922E-2

1,98226E-1

4,03242E-2

2,58100E-7

-1,30285E-13

2,03457E-12

1,09558E-3

2,35606E-7

2,35478E-14

3,00000E-1

4,36094E-5

9,77225E-7

2,97660E-1

7.4

max

1,08597E-2

3,00000E-1

1,25013E-6

2,33904E-3

5,96758E-2

4,30304E-6

1,86223E-1

3,34341E-1

1,77234E-3

1,20934E-2

1,98227E-1

4,03305E-2

2,65226E-7

5,49668E-14

2,13855E-12

1,09597E-3

2,38326E-7

1,46660E-13

3,00000E-1

4,39432E-5

9,90960E-7

2,97661E-1

7.4

mean

1,08586E-2

2,99995E-1

1,24966E-6

2,33904E-3

5,96758E-2

4,29843E-6

1,86223E-1

3,34341E-1

1,77234E-3

1,20934E-2

1,98226E-1

4,03242E-2

2,58120E-7

5,24178E-14

2,13813E-12

1,09596E-3

2,35606E-7

7,66002E-14

3,00000E-1

4,39431E-5

9,80498E-7

2,97661E-1

7.4

relative error(%)

0,00

7.6

BioUML

1,12145E-2

2,99995E-1

1,42161E-6

2,41827E-3

5,97185E-2

4,90280E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33625E-1

1,88938E-3

1,24122E-2

1,98109E-1

4,02815E-2

3,06249E-7

7,31260E-14

2,85030E-12

1,15765E-3

2,73756E-7

1,04227E-13

3,00000E-1

4,84390E-5

1,10084E-6

2,97582E-1

7.6

ByoDyn

1,12145E-2

2,99995E-1

1,42161E-6

2,41827E-3

5,97185E-2

4,90280E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33625E-1

1,88938E-3

1,24122E-2

1,98109E-1

4,02815E-2

3,06249E-7

7,31260E-14

2,85030E-12

1,15765E-3

2,73756E-7

1,04227E-13

3,00000E-1

4,84390E-5

1,10084E-6

2,97582E-1

7.6

CVODE

1,12145E-2

2,99995E-1

1,42161E-6

2,41827E-3

5,97185E-2

4,90280E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33625E-1

1,88938E-3

1,24122E-2

1,98109E-1

4,02815E-2

3,06249E-7

7,31321E-14

2,85035E-12

1,15765E-3

2,73756E-7

1,04231E-13

3,00000E-1

4,84390E-5

1,10084E-6

2,97582E-1

7.6

Jarnac

1,12145E-2

2,99995E-1

1,42161E-6

2,41827E-3

5,97185E-2

4,90280E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33625E-1

1,88938E-3

1,24122E-2

1,98109E-1

4,02815E-2

3,06249E-7

-1,07359E-13

2,85030E-12

1,15765E-3

2,73756E-7

5,18760E-14

3,00000E-1

4,84390E-5

1,10084E-6

2,97582E-1

7.6

MathSBML

1,12145E-2

2,99995E-1

1,42074E-6

2,41827E-3

5,97185E-2

4,90025E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33625E-1

1,88938E-3

1,24122E-2

1,98109E-1

4,02815E-2

3,06242E-7

7,31415E-14

2,84995E-12

1,15765E-3

2,73792E-7

1,04302E-13

3,00000E-1

4,84390E-5

1,10424E-6

2,97582E-1

7.6

Oscill8 Core

1,12145E-2

2,99995E-1

5,97185E-2

1,85683E-1

3,33625E-1

1,88938E-3

1,24122E-2

1,98109E-1

3,06252E-7

2,85036E-12

1,15765E-3

2,73758E-7

3,00000E-1

1,10084E-6

2,97582E-1

7.6

SBToolbox2

1,12161E-2

2,99990E-1

1,42288E-6

2,41796E-3

5,97135E-2

4,91086E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33620E-1

1,88852E-3

1,24108E-2

1,98110E-1

4,02865E-2

3,14896E-7

7,85268E-14

2,76034E-12

1,15724E-3

2,77104E-7

1,04998E-13

3,00000E-1

4,80967E-5

1,09781E-6

2,97580E-1

7.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,12145E-2

2,99995E-1

1,42161E-6

2,41827E-3

5,97185E-2

4,90281E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33625E-1

1,88938E-3

1,24122E-2

1,98109E-1

4,02815E-2

3,06251E-7

7,31279E-14

2,85035E-12

1,15765E-3

2,73757E-7

1,04229E-13

3,00000E-1

4,84391E-5

1,10084E-6

2,97582E-1

7.6

copasi

1,12145E-2

2,99995E-1

1,42161E-6

2,41827E-3

5,97186E-2

4,90280E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33625E-1

1,88938E-3

1,24122E-2

1,98109E-1

4,02814E-2

3,06248E-7

7,32145E-14

2,85082E-12

1,15765E-3

2,73756E-7

1,04282E-13

3,00000E-1

4,84390E-5

1,10084E-6

2,97582E-1

7.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,12145E-2

2,99995E-1

1,42161E-6

2,41827E-3

5,97185E-2

4,90280E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33625E-1

1,88938E-3

1,24122E-2

1,98109E-1

4,02815E-2

3,06249E-7

1,02672E-14

2,85053E-12

1,15765E-3

2,73756E-7

1,75859E-13

3,00000E-1

4,84390E-5

1,10084E-6

2,97582E-1

7.6

jsim

1,12145E-2

2,99995E-1

1,42161E-6

2,41827E-3

5,97185E-2

4,90280E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33625E-1

1,88938E-3

1,24122E-2

1,98109E-1

4,02815E-2

3,06249E-7

7,31260E-14

2,85030E-12

1,15765E-3

2,73756E-7

1,04227E-13

3,00000E-1

4,84390E-5

1,10084E-6

2,97582E-1

7.6

min

1,12145E-2

2,99990E-1

1,42074E-6

2,41796E-3

5,97135E-2

4,90025E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33620E-1

1,88852E-3

1,24108E-2

1,98109E-1

4,02814E-2

3,06242E-7

-1,07359E-13

2,76034E-12

1,15724E-3

2,73756E-7

5,18760E-14

3,00000E-1

4,80967E-5

1,09781E-6

2,97580E-1

7.6

max

1,12161E-2

2,99995E-1

1,42288E-6

2,41827E-3

5,97186E-2

4,91086E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33625E-1

1,88938E-3

1,24122E-2

1,98110E-1

4,02865E-2

3,14896E-7

7,85268E-14

2,85082E-12

1,15765E-3

2,77104E-7

1,75859E-13

3,00000E-1

4,84391E-5

1,10424E-6

2,97582E-1

7.6

mean

1,12145E-2

2,99995E-1

1,42161E-6

2,41827E-3

5,97185E-2

4,90280E-6

1,85683E-1

3,33625E-1

1,88938E-3

1,24122E-2

1,98109E-1

4,02815E-2

3,06249E-7

7,31279E-14

2,85033E-12

1,15765E-3

2,73756E-7

1,04231E-13

3,00000E-1

4,84390E-5

1,10084E-6

2,97582E-1

7.6

relative error(%)

0,00

7.8

BioUML

1,15682E-2

2,99994E-1

1,61056E-6

2,49738E-3

5,97626E-2

5,56890E-6

1,85140E-1

3,32913E-1

2,00950E-3

1,27307E-2

1,97989E-1

4,02374E-2

3,61360E-7

1,00951E-13

3,76570E-12

1,22061E-3

3,16592E-7

1,40458E-13

3,00000E-1

5,32249E-5

1,23163E-6

2,97503E-1

7.8

ByoDyn

1,15682E-2

2,99994E-1

1,61056E-6

2,49738E-3

5,97626E-2

5,56890E-6

1,85140E-1

3,32913E-1

2,00950E-3

1,27307E-2

1,97989E-1

4,02374E-2

3,61360E-7

1,00951E-13

3,76570E-12

1,22061E-3

3,16592E-7

1,40458E-13

3,00000E-1

5,32249E-5

1,23163E-6

2,97503E-1

7.8

CVODE

1,15682E-2

2,99994E-1

1,61056E-6

2,49738E-3

5,97626E-2

5,56890E-6

1,85140E-1

3,32913E-1

2,00950E-3

1,27307E-2

1,97989E-1

4,02374E-2

3,61360E-7

1,00959E-13

3,76576E-12

1,22061E-3

3,16592E-7

1,40464E-13

3,00000E-1

5,32249E-5

1,23163E-6

2,97503E-1

7.8

Jarnac

1,15682E-2

2,99994E-1

1,61056E-6

2,49738E-3

5,97626E-2

5,56890E-6

1,85140E-1

3,32913E-1

2,00950E-3

1,27307E-2

1,97989E-1

4,02374E-2

3,61360E-7

-7,71050E-14

3,76570E-12

1,22061E-3

3,16592E-7

8,86032E-14

3,00000E-1

5,32249E-5

1,23163E-6

2,97503E-1

7.8

MathSBML

1,15682E-2

2,99994E-1

1,61070E-6

2,49738E-3

5,97626E-2

5,56933E-6

1,85140E-1

3,32913E-1

2,00950E-3

1,27307E-2

1,97989E-1

4,02374E-2

3,61361E-7

1,00993E-13

3,76749E-12

1,22061E-3

3,16586E-7

1,40527E-13

3,00000E-1

5,32249E-5

1,23107E-6

2,97503E-1

7.8

Oscill8 Core

1,15682E-2

2,99994E-1

5,97626E-2

1,85140E-1

3,32913E-1

2,00950E-3

1,27307E-2

1,97989E-1

3,61363E-7

3,76577E-12

1,22061E-3

3,16593E-7

3,00000E-1

1,23163E-6

2,97503E-1

7.8

SBToolbox2

1,15697E-2

2,99990E-1

1,61206E-6

2,49708E-3

5,97574E-2

5,57778E-6

1,85143E-1

3,32911E-1

2,00854E-3

1,27295E-2

1,97990E-1

4,02426E-2

3,71128E-7

1,08355E-13

3,65226E-12

1,22010E-3

3,20332E-7

1,41807E-13

3,00000E-1

5,28703E-5

1,22860E-6

2,97500E-1

7.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,15682E-2

2,99994E-1

1,61056E-6

2,49738E-3

5,97626E-2

5,56892E-6

1,85140E-1

3,32913E-1

2,00950E-3

1,27307E-2

1,97989E-1

4,02374E-2

3,61362E-7

1,00953E-13

3,76576E-12

1,22061E-3

3,16593E-7

1,40461E-13

3,00000E-1

5,32250E-5

1,23163E-6

2,97503E-1

7.8

copasi

1,15682E-2

2,99994E-1

1,61056E-6

2,49738E-3

5,97626E-2

5,56890E-6

1,85140E-1

3,32913E-1

2,00950E-3

1,27307E-2

1,97989E-1

4,02374E-2

3,61359E-7

1,01063E-13

3,76634E-12

1,22061E-3

3,16591E-7

1,40526E-13

3,00000E-1

5,32249E-5

1,23163E-6

2,97503E-1

7.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,15682E-2

2,99994E-1

1,61056E-6

2,49738E-3

5,97626E-2

5,56890E-6

1,85140E-1

3,32913E-1

2,00950E-3

1,27307E-2

1,97989E-1

4,02374E-2

3,61360E-7

3,82118E-14

3,76595E-12

1,22061E-3

3,16591E-7

2,13218E-13

3,00000E-1

5,32249E-5

1,23163E-6

2,97503E-1

7.8

jsim

1,15682E-2

2,99994E-1

1,61056E-6

2,49738E-3

5,97626E-2

5,56890E-6

1,85140E-1

3,32913E-1

2,00950E-3

1,27307E-2

1,97989E-1

4,02374E-2

3,61360E-7

1,00951E-13

3,76570E-12

1,22061E-3

3,16592E-7

1,40458E-13

3,00000E-1

5,32249E-5

1,23163E-6

2,97503E-1

7.8

min

1,15682E-2

2,99990E-1

1,61056E-6

2,49708E-3

5,97574E-2

5,56890E-6

1,85140E-1

3,32911E-1

2,00854E-3

1,27295E-2

1,97989E-1

4,02374E-2

3,61359E-7

-7,71050E-14

3,65226E-12

1,22010E-3

3,16586E-7

8,86032E-14

3,00000E-1

5,28703E-5

1,22860E-6

2,97500E-1

7.8

max

1,15697E-2

2,99994E-1

1,61206E-6

2,49738E-3

5,97626E-2

5,57778E-6

1,85143E-1

3,32913E-1

2,00950E-3

1,27307E-2

1,97990E-1

4,02426E-2

3,71128E-7

1,08355E-13

3,76749E-12

1,22061E-3

3,20332E-7

2,13218E-13

3,00000E-1

5,32250E-5

1,23163E-6

2,97503E-1

7.8

mean

1,15682E-2

2,99994E-1

1,61056E-6

2,49738E-3

5,97626E-2

5,56890E-6

1,85140E-1

3,32913E-1

2,00950E-3

1,27307E-2

1,97989E-1

4,02374E-2

3,61360E-7

1,00953E-13

3,76576E-12

1,22061E-3

3,16592E-7

1,40464E-13

3,00000E-1

5,32249E-5

1,23163E-6

2,97503E-1

7.8

relative error(%)

0,00

8.0

BioUML

1,19195E-2

2,99993E-1

1,81755E-6

2,57638E-3

5,98076E-2

6,30070E-6

1,84595E-1

3,32205E-1

2,13260E-3

1,30488E-2

1,97866E-1

4,01924E-2

4,24183E-7

1,37990E-13

4,93305E-12

1,28481E-3

3,64509E-7

1,87569E-13

3,00000E-1

5,83081E-5

1,37343E-6

2,97424E-1

8.0

ByoDyn

1,19195E-2

2,99993E-1

1,81755E-6

2,57638E-3

5,98076E-2

6,30070E-6

1,84595E-1

3,32205E-1

2,13260E-3

1,30488E-2

1,97866E-1

4,01924E-2

4,24183E-7

1,37990E-13

4,93305E-12

1,28481E-3

3,64509E-7

1,87569E-13

3,00000E-1

5,83081E-5

1,37343E-6

2,97424E-1

8.0

CVODE

1,19195E-2

2,99993E-1

1,81755E-6

2,57638E-3

5,98076E-2

6,30070E-6

1,84595E-1

3,32205E-1

2,13260E-3

1,30488E-2

1,97866E-1

4,01924E-2

4,24183E-7

1,38001E-13

4,93312E-12

1,28481E-3

3,64509E-7

1,87576E-13

3,00000E-1

5,83081E-5

1,37343E-6

2,97424E-1

8.0

Jarnac

1,19195E-2

2,99993E-1

1,81755E-6

2,57638E-3

5,98076E-2

6,30070E-6

1,84595E-1

3,32205E-1

2,13260E-3

1,30488E-2

1,97866E-1

4,01924E-2

4,24183E-7

-3,79696E-14

4,93305E-12

1,28481E-3

3,64509E-7

1,36508E-13

3,00000E-1

5,83081E-5

1,37343E-6

2,97424E-1

8.0

MathSBML

1,19195E-2

2,99993E-1

1,81750E-6

2,57638E-3

5,98077E-2

6,30056E-6

1,84595E-1

3,32205E-1

2,13260E-3

1,30488E-2

1,97866E-1

4,01923E-2

4,24183E-7

1,38068E-13

4,93790E-12

1,28481E-3

3,64511E-7

1,87706E-13

3,00000E-1

5,83081E-5

1,37361E-6

2,97424E-1

8.0

Oscill8 Core

1,19195E-2

2,99993E-1

5,98076E-2

1,84595E-1

3,32205E-1

2,13260E-3

1,30488E-2

1,97866E-1

4,24186E-7

4,93312E-12

1,28481E-3

3,64510E-7

3,00000E-1

1,37343E-6

2,97424E-1

8.0

SBToolbox2

1,19214E-2

2,99990E-1

1,81696E-6

2,57610E-3

5,98034E-2

6,30180E-6

1,84594E-1

3,32202E-1

2,13174E-3

1,30472E-2

1,97868E-1

4,01966E-2

4,33476E-7

1,41222E-13

4,67688E-12

1,28436E-3

3,67764E-7

1,83086E-13

3,00000E-1

5,79252E-5

1,36916E-6

2,97420E-1

8.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,19195E-2

2,99993E-1

1,81755E-6

2,57638E-3

5,98076E-2

6,30071E-6

1,84595E-1

3,32205E-1

2,13260E-3

1,30488E-2

1,97866E-1

4,01924E-2

4,24185E-7

1,37993E-13

4,93311E-12

1,28481E-3

3,64510E-7

1,87572E-13

3,00000E-1

5,83082E-5

1,37343E-6

2,97424E-1

8.0

copasi

1,19195E-2

2,99993E-1

1,81755E-6

2,57638E-3

5,98077E-2

6,30070E-6

1,84595E-1

3,32205E-1

2,13260E-3

1,30488E-2

1,97866E-1

4,01923E-2

4,24182E-7

1,38143E-13

4,93400E-12

1,28481E-3

3,64508E-7

1,87662E-13

3,00000E-1

5,83081E-5

1,37343E-6

2,97424E-1

8.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,19195E-2

2,99993E-1

1,81755E-6

2,57638E-3

5,98077E-2

6,30070E-6

1,84595E-1

3,32205E-1

2,13260E-3

1,30488E-2

1,97866E-1

4,01923E-2

4,24183E-7

7,47917E-14

4,93333E-12

1,28481E-3

3,64508E-7

2,62124E-13

3,00000E-1

5,83081E-5

1,37343E-6

2,97424E-1

8.0

jsim

1,19195E-2

2,99993E-1

1,81755E-6

2,57638E-3

5,98076E-2

6,30070E-6

1,84595E-1

3,32205E-1

2,13260E-3

1,30488E-2

1,97866E-1

4,01924E-2

4,24183E-7

1,37990E-13

4,93305E-12

1,28481E-3

3,64509E-7

1,87569E-13

3,00000E-1

5,83081E-5

1,37343E-6

2,97424E-1

8.0

min

1,19195E-2

2,99990E-1

1,81696E-6

2,57610E-3

5,98034E-2

6,30056E-6

1,84594E-1

3,32202E-1

2,13174E-3

1,30472E-2

1,97866E-1

4,01923E-2

4,24182E-7

-3,79696E-14

4,67688E-12

1,28436E-3

3,64508E-7

1,36508E-13

3,00000E-1

5,79252E-5

1,36916E-6

2,97420E-1

8.0

max

1,19214E-2

2,99993E-1

1,81755E-6

2,57638E-3

5,98077E-2

6,30180E-6

1,84595E-1

3,32205E-1

2,13260E-3

1,30488E-2

1,97868E-1

4,01966E-2

4,33476E-7

1,41222E-13

4,93790E-12

1,28481E-3

3,67764E-7

2,62124E-13

3,00000E-1

5,83082E-5

1,37361E-6

2,97424E-1

8.0

mean

1,19195E-2

2,99993E-1

1,81755E-6

2,57638E-3

5,98076E-2

6,30070E-6

1,84595E-1

3,32205E-1

2,13260E-3

1,30488E-2

1,97866E-1

4,01924E-2

4,24183E-7

1,37993E-13

4,93311E-12

1,28481E-3

3,64509E-7

1,87572E-13

3,00000E-1

5,83081E-5

1,37343E-6

2,97424E-1

8.0

relative error(%)

0,00

8.2

BioUML

1,22685E-2

2,99992E-1

2,04361E-6

2,65526E-3

5,98536E-2

7,10223E-6

1,84048E-1

3,31500E-1

2,25861E-3

1,33667E-2

1,97739E-1

4,01464E-2

4,95495E-7

1,86864E-13

6,41063E-12

1,35021E-3

4,17923E-7

2,48335E-13

3,00000E-1

6,36957E-5

1,52678E-6

2,97345E-1

8.2

ByoDyn

1,22685E-2

2,99992E-1

2,04361E-6

2,65526E-3

5,98536E-2

7,10223E-6

1,84048E-1

3,31500E-1

2,25861E-3

1,33667E-2

1,97739E-1

4,01464E-2

4,95495E-7

1,86864E-13

6,41063E-12

1,35021E-3

4,17923E-7

2,48335E-13

3,00000E-1

6,36957E-5

1,52678E-6

2,97345E-1

8.2

CVODE

1,22685E-2

2,99992E-1

2,04361E-6

2,65526E-3

5,98536E-2

7,10223E-6

1,84048E-1

3,31500E-1

2,25861E-3

1,33667E-2

1,97739E-1

4,01464E-2

4,95495E-7

1,86878E-13

6,41071E-12

1,35021E-3

4,17923E-7

2,48343E-13

3,00000E-1

6,36957E-5

1,52678E-6

2,97345E-1

8.2

Jarnac

1,22685E-2

2,99992E-1

2,04361E-6

2,65526E-3

5,98536E-2

7,10223E-6

1,84048E-1

3,31500E-1

2,25861E-3

1,33667E-2

1,97739E-1

4,01464E-2

4,95495E-7

1,31006E-14

6,41063E-12

1,35021E-3

4,17923E-7

1,97749E-13

3,00000E-1

6,36957E-5

1,52678E-6

2,97345E-1

8.2

MathSBML

1,22685E-2

2,99992E-1

2,04193E-6

2,65526E-3

5,98536E-2

7,09733E-6

1,84048E-1

3,31500E-1

2,25861E-3

1,33667E-2

1,97739E-1

4,01464E-2

4,95482E-7

1,86990E-13

6,42178E-12

1,35021E-3

4,17992E-7

2,48670E-13

3,00000E-1

6,36957E-5

1,53334E-6

2,97345E-1

8.2

Oscill8 Core

1,22685E-2

2,99992E-1

5,98536E-2

1,84048E-1

3,31500E-1

2,25861E-3

1,33667E-2

1,97739E-1

4,95498E-7

6,41072E-12

1,35021E-3

4,17924E-7

3,00000E-1

1,52678E-6

2,97345E-1

8.2

SBToolbox2

1,22701E-2

2,99990E-1

2,04202E-6

2,65500E-3

5,98504E-2

7,09944E-6

1,84046E-1

3,31495E-1

2,25775E-3

1,33657E-2

1,97738E-1

4,01496E-2

5,05145E-7

1,89706E-13

6,08175E-12

1,34979E-3

4,21121E-7

2,41492E-13

3,00000E-1

6,32889E-5

1,52174E-6

2,97348E-1

8.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,22685E-2

2,99992E-1

2,04362E-6

2,65526E-3

5,98536E-2

7,10224E-6

1,84048E-1

3,31500E-1

2,25861E-3

1,33667E-2

1,97739E-1

4,01464E-2

4,95497E-7

1,86867E-13

6,41070E-12

1,35021E-3

4,17924E-7

2,48338E-13

3,00000E-1

6,36957E-5

1,52678E-6

2,97345E-1

8.2

copasi

1,22685E-2

2,99992E-1

2,04361E-6

2,65526E-3

5,98537E-2

7,10223E-6

1,84048E-1

3,31500E-1

2,25861E-3

1,33667E-2

1,97739E-1

4,01463E-2

4,95494E-7

1,87061E-13

6,41193E-12

1,35021E-3

4,17922E-7

2,48456E-13

3,00000E-1

6,36957E-5

1,52678E-6

2,97345E-1

8.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,22685E-2

2,99992E-1

2,04361E-6

2,65526E-3

5,98536E-2

7,10223E-6

1,84048E-1

3,31500E-1

2,25861E-3

1,33667E-2

1,97739E-1

4,01464E-2

4,95494E-7

1,22823E-13

6,41094E-12

1,35021E-3

4,17923E-7

3,24990E-13

3,00000E-1

6,36957E-5

1,52678E-6

2,97345E-1

8.2

jsim

1,22685E-2

2,99992E-1

2,04361E-6

2,65526E-3

5,98536E-2

7,10223E-6

1,84048E-1

3,31500E-1

2,25861E-3

1,33667E-2

1,97739E-1

4,01464E-2

4,95495E-7

1,86864E-13

6,41063E-12

1,35021E-3

4,17923E-7

2,48335E-13

3,00000E-1

6,36957E-5

1,52678E-6

2,97345E-1

8.2

min

1,22685E-2

2,99990E-1

2,04193E-6

2,65500E-3

5,98504E-2

7,09733E-6

1,84046E-1

3,31495E-1

2,25775E-3

1,33657E-2

1,97738E-1

4,01463E-2

4,95482E-7

1,31006E-14

6,08175E-12

1,34979E-3

4,17922E-7

1,97749E-13

3,00000E-1

6,32889E-5

1,52174E-6

2,97345E-1

8.2

max

1,22701E-2

2,99992E-1

2,04362E-6

2,65526E-3

5,98537E-2

7,10224E-6

1,84048E-1

3,31500E-1

2,25861E-3

1,33667E-2

1,97739E-1

4,01496E-2

5,05145E-7

1,89706E-13

6,42178E-12

1,35021E-3

4,21121E-7

3,24990E-13

3,00000E-1

6,36957E-5

1,53334E-6

2,97348E-1

8.2

mean

1,22685E-2

2,99992E-1

2,04361E-6

2,65526E-3

5,98536E-2

7,10223E-6

1,84048E-1

3,31500E-1

2,25861E-3

1,33667E-2

1,97739E-1

4,01464E-2

4,95495E-7

1,86867E-13

6,41071E-12

1,35021E-3

4,17923E-7

2,48338E-13

3,00000E-1

6,36957E-5

1,52678E-6

2,97345E-1

8.2

relative error(%)

0,00

8.4

BioUML

1,26150E-2

2,99991E-1

2,28982E-6

2,73402E-3

5,99003E-2

7,97764E-6

1,83499E-1

3,30798E-1

2,38743E-3

1,36843E-2

1,97610E-1

4,00997E-2

5,76120E-7

2,50816E-13

8,26778E-12

1,41678E-3

4,77268E-7

3,26121E-13

2,99999E-1

6,93943E-5

1,69223E-6

2,97266E-1

8.4

ByoDyn

1,26150E-2

2,99991E-1

2,28982E-6

2,73402E-3

5,99003E-2

7,97764E-6

1,83499E-1

3,30798E-1

2,38743E-3

1,36843E-2

1,97610E-1

4,00997E-2

5,76120E-7

2,50816E-13

8,26778E-12

1,41678E-3

4,77268E-7

3,26121E-13

2,99999E-1

6,93943E-5

1,69223E-6

2,97266E-1

8.4

CVODE

1,26150E-2

2,99991E-1

2,28982E-6

2,73402E-3

5,99003E-2

7,97764E-6

1,83499E-1

3,30798E-1

2,38743E-3

1,36843E-2

1,97610E-1

4,00997E-2

5,76120E-7

2,50834E-13

8,26787E-12

1,41678E-3

4,77268E-7

3,26131E-13

2,99999E-1

6,93943E-5

1,69223E-6

2,97266E-1

8.4

Jarnac

1,26150E-2

2,99991E-1

2,28982E-6

2,73402E-3

5,99003E-2

7,97764E-6

1,83499E-1

3,30798E-1

2,38743E-3

1,36843E-2

1,97610E-1

4,00997E-2

5,76120E-7

7,88258E-14

8,26778E-12

1,41678E-3

4,77268E-7

2,76390E-13

2,99999E-1

6,93943E-5

1,69223E-6

2,97266E-1

8.4

MathSBML

1,26150E-2

2,99991E-1

2,28820E-6

2,73402E-3

5,99003E-2

7,97295E-6

1,83499E-1

3,30798E-1

2,38743E-3

1,36843E-2

1,97610E-1

4,00997E-2

5,76108E-7

2,51051E-13

8,29256E-12

1,41678E-3

4,77334E-7

3,26738E-13

2,99999E-1

6,93943E-5

1,69854E-6

2,97266E-1

8.4

Oscill8 Core

1,26150E-2

2,99991E-1

5,99003E-2

1,83499E-1

3,30798E-1

2,38743E-3

1,36843E-2

1,97610E-1

5,76123E-7

8,26787E-12

1,41678E-3

4,77270E-7

2,99999E-1

1,69224E-6

2,97266E-1

8.4

SBToolbox2

1,26167E-2

2,99990E-1

2,28856E-6

2,73374E-3

5,98973E-2

7,97656E-6

1,83497E-1

3,30795E-1

2,38654E-3

1,36826E-2

1,97610E-1

4,01027E-2

5,87342E-7

2,59498E-13

7,95828E-12

1,41634E-3

4,81027E-7

3,22462E-13

3,00000E-1

6,89749E-5

1,68728E-6

2,97268E-1

8.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,26150E-2

2,99991E-1

2,28982E-6

2,73402E-3

5,99003E-2

7,97765E-6

1,83499E-1

3,30798E-1

2,38743E-3

1,36843E-2

1,97610E-1

4,00997E-2

5,76122E-7

2,50820E-13

8,26785E-12

1,41678E-3

4,77269E-7

3,26125E-13

2,99999E-1

6,93944E-5

1,69224E-6

2,97266E-1

8.4

copasi

1,26150E-2

2,99991E-1

2,28982E-6

2,73402E-3

5,99003E-2

7,97764E-6

1,83499E-1

3,30798E-1

2,38743E-3

1,36842E-2

1,97610E-1

4,00997E-2

5,76118E-7

2,51078E-13

8,26961E-12

1,41678E-3

4,77267E-7

3,26284E-13

2,99999E-1

6,93943E-5

1,69223E-6

2,97266E-1

8.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,26150E-2

2,99991E-1

2,28982E-6

2,73402E-3

5,99003E-2

7,97764E-6

1,83499E-1

3,30798E-1

2,38743E-3

1,36843E-2

1,97610E-1

4,00997E-2

5,76119E-7

1,87341E-13

8,26811E-12

1,41678E-3

4,77268E-7

4,03427E-13

2,99999E-1

6,93943E-5

1,69223E-6

2,97266E-1

8.4

jsim

1,26150E-2

2,99991E-1

2,28982E-6

2,73402E-3

5,99003E-2

7,97764E-6

1,83499E-1

3,30798E-1

2,38743E-3

1,36842E-2

1,97610E-1

4,00997E-2

5,76120E-7

2,50816E-13

8,26778E-12

1,41678E-3

4,77268E-7

3,26121E-13

2,99999E-1

6,93943E-5

1,69224E-6

2,97266E-1

8.4

min

1,26150E-2

2,99990E-1

2,28820E-6

2,73374E-3

5,98973E-2

7,97295E-6

1,83497E-1

3,30795E-1

2,38654E-3

1,36826E-2

1,97610E-1

4,00997E-2

5,76108E-7

7,88258E-14

7,95828E-12

1,41634E-3

4,77267E-7

2,76390E-13

2,99999E-1

6,89749E-5

1,68728E-6

2,97266E-1

8.4

max

1,26167E-2

2,99991E-1

2,28982E-6

2,73402E-3

5,99003E-2

7,97765E-6

1,83499E-1

3,30798E-1

2,38743E-3

1,36843E-2

1,97610E-1

4,01027E-2

5,87342E-7

2,59498E-13

8,29256E-12

1,41678E-3

4,81027E-7

4,03427E-13

3,00000E-1

6,93944E-5

1,69854E-6

2,97268E-1

8.4

mean

1,26150E-2

2,99991E-1

2,28982E-6

2,73402E-3

5,99003E-2

7,97764E-6

1,83499E-1

3,30798E-1

2,38743E-3

1,36843E-2

1,97610E-1

4,00997E-2

5,76120E-7

2,50820E-13

8,26786E-12

1,41678E-3

4,77268E-7

3,26125E-13

2,99999E-1

6,93943E-5

1,69223E-6

2,97266E-1

8.4

relative error(%)

0,00

8.6

BioUML

1,29591E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55725E-6

2,81267E-3

5,99476E-2

8,93115E-6

1,82949E-1

3,30099E-1

2,51899E-3

1,40015E-2

1,97478E-1

4,00524E-2

6,66930E-7

3,33842E-13

1,05865E-11

1,48450E-3

5,42997E-7

4,24981E-13

2,99999E-1

7,54106E-5

1,87036E-6

2,97187E-1

8.6

ByoDyn

1,29591E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55725E-6

2,81267E-3

5,99476E-2

8,93115E-6

1,82949E-1

3,30099E-1

2,51899E-3

1,40015E-2

1,97478E-1

4,00524E-2

6,66930E-7

3,33842E-13

1,05865E-11

1,48450E-3

5,42997E-7

4,24981E-13

2,99999E-1

7,54106E-5

1,87036E-6

2,97187E-1

8.6

CVODE

1,29591E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55725E-6

2,81267E-3

5,99476E-2

8,93115E-6

1,82949E-1

3,30099E-1

2,51899E-3

1,40015E-2

1,97478E-1

4,00524E-2

6,66930E-7

3,33864E-13

1,05866E-11

1,48450E-3

5,42997E-7

4,24993E-13

2,99999E-1

7,54106E-5

1,87036E-6

2,97187E-1

8.6

Jarnac

1,29591E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55725E-6

2,81267E-3

5,99476E-2

8,93115E-6

1,82949E-1

3,30099E-1

2,51899E-3

1,40015E-2

1,97478E-1

4,00524E-2

6,66930E-7

1,63647E-13

1,05865E-11

1,48450E-3

5,42997E-7

3,75937E-13

2,99999E-1

7,54106E-5

1,87036E-6

2,97187E-1

8.6

MathSBML

1,29591E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55722E-6

2,81267E-3

5,99476E-2

8,93117E-6

1,82949E-1

3,30099E-1

2,51899E-3

1,40015E-2

1,97478E-1

4,00524E-2

6,66930E-7

3,34293E-13

1,06144E-11

1,48450E-3

5,42997E-7

4,25965E-13

2,99999E-1

7,54106E-5

1,87038E-6

2,97187E-1

8.6

Oscill8 Core

1,29591E-2

2,99990E-1

5,99476E-2

1,82949E-1

3,30099E-1

2,51899E-3

1,40015E-2

1,97478E-1

6,66933E-7

1,05866E-11

1,48450E-3

5,42998E-7

2,99999E-1

1,87037E-6

2,97187E-1

8.6

SBToolbox2

1,29614E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55676E-6

2,81245E-3

5,99444E-2

8,93319E-6

1,82946E-1

3,30096E-1

2,51794E-3

1,40002E-2

1,97479E-1

4,00556E-2

6,80079E-7

3,50595E-13

1,03062E-11

1,48398E-3

5,47480E-7

4,26016E-13

3,00000E-1

7,49833E-5

1,86560E-6

2,97189E-1

8.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,29591E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55726E-6

2,81267E-3

5,99476E-2

8,93117E-6

1,82949E-1

3,30099E-1

2,51899E-3

1,40015E-2

1,97478E-1

4,00524E-2

6,66932E-7

3,33846E-13

1,05865E-11

1,48450E-3

5,42998E-7

4,24985E-13

2,99999E-1

7,54107E-5

1,87037E-6

2,97187E-1

8.6

copasi

1,29591E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55725E-6

2,81267E-3

5,99476E-2

8,93115E-6

1,82949E-1

3,30099E-1

2,51899E-3

1,40015E-2

1,97478E-1

4,00524E-2

6,66928E-7

3,34174E-13

1,05888E-11

1,48450E-3

5,42996E-7

4,25188E-13

2,99999E-1

7,54106E-5

1,87036E-6

2,97187E-1

8.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,29591E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55725E-6

2,81267E-3

5,99476E-2

8,93115E-6

1,82949E-1

3,30099E-1

2,51899E-3

1,40015E-2

1,97478E-1

4,00524E-2

6,66929E-7

2,72208E-13

1,05868E-11

1,48450E-3

5,42997E-7

5,01765E-13

2,99999E-1

7,54106E-5

1,87036E-6

2,97187E-1

8.6

jsim

1,29591E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55725E-6

2,81267E-3

5,99476E-2

8,93115E-6

1,82949E-1

3,30099E-1

2,51899E-3

1,40015E-2

1,97478E-1

4,00524E-2

6,66930E-7

3,33842E-13

1,05865E-11

1,48450E-3

5,42997E-7

4,24981E-13

2,99999E-1

7,54106E-5

1,87036E-6

2,97187E-1

8.6

min

1,29591E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55676E-6

2,81245E-3

5,99444E-2

8,93115E-6

1,82946E-1

3,30096E-1

2,51794E-3

1,40002E-2

1,97478E-1

4,00524E-2

6,66928E-7

1,63647E-13

1,03062E-11

1,48398E-3

5,42996E-7

3,75937E-13

2,99999E-1

7,49833E-5

1,86560E-6

2,97187E-1

8.6

max

1,29614E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55726E-6

2,81267E-3

5,99476E-2

8,93319E-6

1,82949E-1

3,30099E-1

2,51899E-3

1,40015E-2

1,97479E-1

4,00556E-2

6,80079E-7

3,50595E-13

1,06144E-11

1,48450E-3

5,47480E-7

5,01765E-13

3,00000E-1

7,54107E-5

1,87038E-6

2,97189E-1

8.6

mean

1,29591E-2

2,99990E-1

2,55725E-6

2,81267E-3

5,99476E-2

8,93115E-6

1,82949E-1

3,30099E-1

2,51899E-3

1,40015E-2

1,97478E-1

4,00524E-2

6,66930E-7

3,33846E-13

1,05866E-11

1,48450E-3

5,42997E-7

4,24993E-13

2,99999E-1

7,54106E-5

1,87036E-6

2,97187E-1

8.6

relative error(%)

0,00

8.8

BioUML

1,33008E-2

2,99989E-1

2,84701E-6

2,89120E-3

5,99953E-2

9,96709E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29403E-1

2,65319E-3

1,43186E-2

1,97344E-1

4,00047E-2

7,68847E-7

4,40828E-13

1,34631E-11

1,55332E-3

6,15580E-7

5,49771E-13

2,99999E-1

8,17508E-5

2,06174E-6

2,97109E-1

8.8

ByoDyn

1,33008E-2

2,99989E-1

2,84701E-6

2,89120E-3

5,99953E-2

9,96709E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29403E-1

2,65319E-3

1,43186E-2

1,97344E-1

4,00047E-2

7,68847E-7

4,40828E-13

1,34631E-11

1,55332E-3

6,15580E-7

5,49771E-13

2,99999E-1

8,17508E-5

2,06174E-6

2,97109E-1

8.8

CVODE

1,33008E-2

2,99989E-1

2,84701E-6

2,89120E-3

5,99953E-2

9,96709E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29403E-1

2,65319E-3

1,43186E-2

1,97344E-1

4,00047E-2

7,68846E-7

4,40854E-13

1,34632E-11

1,55332E-3

6,15580E-7

5,49785E-13

2,99999E-1

8,17508E-5

2,06174E-6

2,97109E-1

8.8

Jarnac

1,33008E-2

2,99989E-1

2,84701E-6

2,89120E-3

5,99953E-2

9,96709E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29403E-1

2,65319E-3

1,43186E-2

1,97344E-1

4,00047E-2

7,68846E-7

2,73004E-13

1,34631E-11

1,55332E-3

6,15580E-7

5,00641E-13

2,99999E-1

8,17508E-5

2,06174E-6

2,97109E-1

8.8

MathSBML

1,33008E-2

2,99989E-1

2,84791E-6

2,89120E-3

5,99953E-2

9,96978E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29403E-1

2,65319E-3

1,43186E-2

1,97344E-1

4,00047E-2

7,68853E-7

4,41564E-13

1,34757E-11

1,55332E-3

6,15544E-7

5,51007E-13

2,99999E-1

8,17508E-5

2,05816E-6

2,97109E-1

8.8

Oscill8 Core

1,33008E-2

2,99989E-1

5,99953E-2

1,82396E-1

3,29403E-1

2,65319E-3

1,43186E-2

1,97344E-1

7,68850E-7

1,34632E-11

1,55332E-3

6,15582E-7

2,99999E-1

2,06174E-6

2,97109E-1

8.8

SBToolbox2

1,33030E-2

2,99990E-1

2,84651E-6

2,89097E-3

5,99924E-2

9,96939E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29396E-1

2,65212E-3

1,43169E-2

1,97349E-1

4,00076E-2

7,83353E-7

4,62992E-13

1,31255E-11

1,55282E-3

6,20488E-7

5,52128E-13

3,00000E-1

8,13120E-5

2,05689E-6

2,97110E-1

8.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,33008E-2

2,99989E-1

2,84701E-6

2,89120E-3

5,99953E-2

9,96710E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29403E-1

2,65319E-3

1,43186E-2

1,97344E-1

4,00047E-2

7,68848E-7

4,40832E-13

1,34632E-11

1,55332E-3

6,15581E-7

5,49775E-13

2,99999E-1

8,17508E-5

2,06174E-6

2,97109E-1

8.8

copasi

1,33008E-2

2,99989E-1

2,84701E-6

2,89120E-3

5,99954E-2

9,96709E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29403E-1

2,65319E-3

1,43185E-2

1,97344E-1

4,00046E-2

7,68844E-7

4,41244E-13

1,34660E-11

1,55332E-3

6,15579E-7

5,50029E-13

2,99999E-1

8,17508E-5

2,06174E-6

2,97109E-1

8.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,33008E-2

2,99989E-1

2,84701E-6

2,89120E-3

5,99953E-2

9,96709E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29403E-1

2,65319E-3

1,43186E-2

1,97344E-1

4,00047E-2

7,68846E-7

3,81300E-13

1,34635E-11

1,55332E-3

6,15580E-7

6,25749E-13

2,99999E-1

8,17508E-5

2,06174E-6

2,97109E-1

8.8

jsim

1,33008E-2

2,99989E-1

2,84701E-6

2,89120E-3

5,99953E-2

9,96709E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29403E-1

2,65319E-3

1,43186E-2

1,97344E-1

4,00047E-2

7,68847E-7

4,40828E-13

1,34631E-11

1,55332E-3

6,15580E-7

5,49771E-13

2,99999E-1

8,17508E-5

2,06174E-6

2,97109E-1

8.8

min

1,33008E-2

2,99989E-1

2,84651E-6

2,89097E-3

5,99924E-2

9,96709E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29396E-1

2,65212E-3

1,43169E-2

1,97344E-1

4,00046E-2

7,68844E-7

2,73004E-13

1,31255E-11

1,55282E-3

6,15544E-7

5,00641E-13

2,99999E-1

8,13120E-5

2,05689E-6

2,97109E-1

8.8

max

1,33030E-2

2,99990E-1

2,84791E-6

2,89120E-3

5,99954E-2

9,96978E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29403E-1

2,65319E-3

1,43186E-2

1,97349E-1

4,00076E-2

7,83353E-7

4,62992E-13

1,34757E-11

1,55332E-3

6,20488E-7

6,25749E-13

3,00000E-1

8,17508E-5

2,06174E-6

2,97110E-1

8.8

mean

1,33008E-2

2,99989E-1

2,84701E-6

2,89120E-3

5,99953E-2

9,96709E-6

1,82396E-1

3,29403E-1

2,65319E-3

1,43186E-2

1,97344E-1

4,00047E-2

7,68847E-7

4,40832E-13

1,34632E-11

1,55332E-3

6,15580E-7

5,49785E-13

2,99999E-1

8,17508E-5

2,06174E-6

2,97109E-1

8.8

relative error(%)

0,00

9.0

BioUML

1,36399E-2

2,99987E-1

3,16019E-6

2,96961E-3

6,00434E-2

1,10898E-5

1,81842E-1

3,28710E-1

2,78996E-3

1,46353E-2

1,97207E-1

3,99566E-2

8,82840E-7

5,77711E-13

1,70107E-11

1,62322E-3

6,95508E-7

7,06274E-13

2,99999E-1

8,84209E-5

2,26694E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

ByoDyn

1,36399E-2

2,99987E-1

3,16019E-6

2,96961E-3

6,00434E-2

1,10898E-5

1,81842E-1

3,28710E-1

2,78996E-3

1,46353E-2

1,97207E-1

3,99566E-2

8,82840E-7

5,77711E-13

1,70107E-11

1,62322E-3

6,95508E-7

7,06274E-13

2,99999E-1

8,84209E-5

2,26694E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

CVODE

1,36399E-2

2,99987E-1

3,16019E-6

2,96961E-3

6,00434E-2

1,10898E-5

1,81842E-1

3,28710E-1

2,78996E-3

1,46353E-2

1,97207E-1

3,99566E-2

8,82840E-7

5,77741E-13

1,70108E-11

1,62322E-3

6,95508E-7

7,06290E-13

2,99999E-1

8,84209E-5

2,26694E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

Jarnac

1,36399E-2

2,99987E-1

3,16019E-6

2,96961E-3

6,00434E-2

1,10898E-5

1,81842E-1

3,28710E-1

2,78996E-3

1,46353E-2

1,97207E-1

3,99566E-2

8,82840E-7

4,11726E-13

1,70107E-11

1,62322E-3

6,95508E-7

6,57390E-13

2,99999E-1

8,84209E-5

2,26694E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

MathSBML

1,36399E-2

2,99987E-1

3,16008E-6

2,96961E-3

6,00434E-2

1,10896E-5

1,81842E-1

3,28710E-1

2,78996E-3

1,46353E-2

1,97207E-1

3,99566E-2

8,82839E-7

5,78812E-13

1,70305E-11

1,62322E-3

6,95513E-7

7,07783E-13

2,99999E-1

8,84209E-5

2,26732E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

Oscill8 Core

1,36399E-2

2,99987E-1

6,00434E-2

1,81842E-1

3,28710E-1

2,78997E-3

1,46353E-2

1,97207E-1

8,82843E-7

1,70108E-11

1,62322E-3

6,95510E-7

2,99999E-1

2,26694E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

SBToolbox2

1,36417E-2

2,99990E-1

3,15732E-6

2,96939E-3

6,00412E-2

1,10828E-5

1,81838E-1

3,28707E-1

2,78899E-3

1,46336E-2

1,97209E-1

3,99588E-2

8,96579E-7

5,88846E-13

1,63481E-11

1,62275E-3

6,99777E-7

6,94423E-13

3,00000E-1

8,79562E-5

2,26066E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,36399E-2

2,99987E-1

3,16019E-6

2,96961E-3

6,00434E-2

1,10898E-5

1,81842E-1

3,28710E-1

2,78997E-3

1,46353E-2

1,97207E-1

3,99566E-2

8,82841E-7

5,77716E-13

1,70108E-11

1,62322E-3

6,95509E-7

7,06279E-13

2,99999E-1

8,84210E-5

2,26694E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

copasi

1,36399E-2

2,99987E-1

3,16019E-6

2,96961E-3

6,00435E-2

1,10898E-5

1,81842E-1

3,28710E-1

2,78996E-3

1,46353E-2

1,97207E-1

3,99565E-2

8,82837E-7

5,78223E-13

1,70141E-11

1,62322E-3

6,95507E-7

7,06588E-13

2,99999E-1

8,84209E-5

2,26694E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,36399E-2

2,99987E-1

3,16019E-6

2,96961E-3

6,00434E-2

1,10898E-5

1,81842E-1

3,28710E-1

2,78996E-3

1,46353E-2

1,97207E-1

3,99566E-2

8,82839E-7

5,19740E-13

1,70111E-11

1,62322E-3

6,95508E-7

7,81847E-13

2,99999E-1

8,84209E-5

2,26694E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

jsim

1,36399E-2

2,99987E-1

3,16019E-6

2,96961E-3

6,00434E-2

1,10898E-5

1,81842E-1

3,28710E-1

2,78996E-3

1,46353E-2

1,97207E-1

3,99566E-2

8,82840E-7

5,77711E-13

1,70107E-11

1,62322E-3

6,95508E-7

7,06274E-13

2,99999E-1

8,84209E-5

2,26694E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

min

1,36399E-2

2,99987E-1

3,15732E-6

2,96939E-3

6,00412E-2

1,10828E-5

1,81838E-1

3,28707E-1

2,78899E-3

1,46336E-2

1,97207E-1

3,99565E-2

8,82837E-7

4,11726E-13

1,63481E-11

1,62275E-3

6,95507E-7

6,57390E-13

2,99999E-1

8,79562E-5

2,26066E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

max

1,36417E-2

2,99990E-1

3,16019E-6

2,96961E-3

6,00435E-2

1,10898E-5

1,81842E-1

3,28710E-1

2,78997E-3

1,46353E-2

1,97209E-1

3,99588E-2

8,96579E-7

5,88846E-13

1,70305E-11

1,62322E-3

6,99777E-7

7,81847E-13

3,00000E-1

8,84210E-5

2,26732E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

mean

1,36399E-2

2,99987E-1

3,16019E-6

2,96961E-3

6,00434E-2

1,10898E-5

1,81842E-1

3,28710E-1

2,78996E-3

1,46353E-2

1,97207E-1

3,99566E-2

8,82840E-7

5,77716E-13

1,70108E-11

1,62322E-3

6,95508E-7

7,06279E-13

2,99999E-1

8,84209E-5

2,26694E-6

2,97030E-1

9.0

relative error(%)

0,00

9.2

BioUML

1,39766E-2

2,99986E-1

3,49794E-6

3,04792E-3

6,00918E-2

1,23039E-5

1,81286E-1

3,28020E-1

2,92922E-3

1,49518E-2

1,97067E-1

3,99082E-2

1,00993E-6

7,51668E-13

2,13607E-11

1,69417E-3

7,83288E-7

9,01348E-13

2,99999E-1

9,54269E-5

2,48654E-6

2,96952E-1

9.2

ByoDyn

1,39766E-2

2,99986E-1

3,49794E-6

3,04792E-3

6,00918E-2

1,23039E-5

1,81286E-1

3,28020E-1

2,92922E-3

1,49518E-2

1,97067E-1

3,99082E-2

1,00993E-6

7,51668E-13

2,13607E-11

1,69417E-3

7,83288E-7

9,01348E-13

2,99999E-1

9,54269E-5

2,48654E-6

2,96952E-1

9.2

CVODE

1,39766E-2

2,99986E-1

3,49794E-6

3,04792E-3

6,00918E-2

1,23039E-5

1,81286E-1

3,28020E-1

2,92922E-3

1,49518E-2

1,97067E-1

3,99082E-2

1,00993E-6

7,51703E-13

2,13608E-11

1,69417E-3

7,83288E-7

9,01367E-13

2,99999E-1

9,54269E-5

2,48654E-6

2,96952E-1

9.2

Jarnac

1,39766E-2

2,99986E-1

3,49794E-6

3,04792E-3

6,00918E-2

1,23039E-5

1,81286E-1

3,28020E-1

2,92922E-3

1,49518E-2

1,97067E-1

3,99082E-2

1,00993E-6

5,86975E-13

2,13607E-11

1,69417E-3

7,83288E-7

8,53580E-13

2,99999E-1

9,54269E-5

2,48654E-6

2,96952E-1

9.2

MathSBML

1,39766E-2

2,99986E-1

3,49600E-6

3,04792E-3

6,00918E-2

1,22983E-5

1,81286E-1

3,28020E-1

2,92922E-3

1,49518E-2

1,97067E-1

3,99082E-2

1,00992E-6

7,53162E-13

2,14189E-11

1,69417E-3

7,83368E-7

9,03164E-13

2,99999E-1

9,54269E-5

2,49401E-6

2,96952E-1

9.2

Oscill8 Core

1,39766E-2

2,99986E-1

6,00918E-2

1,81286E-1

3,28020E-1

2,92922E-3

1,49518E-2

1,97067E-1

1,00993E-6

2,13608E-11

1,69417E-3

7,83290E-7

2,99999E-1

2,48654E-6

2,96952E-1

9.2

SBToolbox2

1,39784E-2

2,99990E-1

3,49381E-6

3,04771E-3

6,00902E-2

1,22920E-5

1,81288E-1

3,28018E-1

2,92827E-3

1,49503E-2

1,97069E-1

3,99098E-2

1,02394E-6

7,61418E-13

2,05271E-11

1,69369E-3

7,87430E-7

8,83451E-13

3,00000E-1

9,49407E-5

2,47950E-6

2,96950E-1

9.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,39766E-2

2,99986E-1

3,49794E-6

3,04792E-3

6,00918E-2

1,23039E-5

1,81286E-1

3,28020E-1

2,92922E-3

1,49518E-2

1,97067E-1

3,99082E-2

1,00993E-6

7,51672E-13

2,13608E-11

1,69417E-3

7,83289E-7

9,01353E-13

2,99999E-1

9,54269E-5

2,48654E-6

2,96952E-1

9.2

copasi

1,39766E-2

2,99986E-1

3,49794E-6

3,04792E-3

6,00919E-2

1,23039E-5

1,81286E-1

3,28020E-1

2,92922E-3

1,49518E-2

1,97067E-1

3,99081E-2

1,00993E-6

7,52281E-13

2,13646E-11

1,69417E-3

7,83287E-7

9,01718E-13

2,99999E-1

9,54269E-5

2,48654E-6

2,96952E-1

9.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,39766E-2

2,99986E-1

3,49794E-6

3,04792E-3

6,00918E-2

1,23039E-5

1,81286E-1

3,28020E-1

2,92922E-3

1,49518E-2

1,97067E-1

3,99082E-2

1,00993E-6

6,94479E-13

2,13612E-11

1,69417E-3

7,83288E-7

9,77413E-13

2,99999E-1

9,54269E-5

2,48654E-6

2,96952E-1

9.2

jsim

1,39766E-2

2,99986E-1

3,49794E-6

3,04792E-3

6,00918E-2

1,23039E-5

1,81286E-1

3,28020E-1

2,92922E-3

1,49518E-2

1,97067E-1

3,99082E-2

1,00993E-6

7,51668E-13

2,13607E-11

1,69417E-3

7,83288E-7

9,01348E-13

2,99999E-1

9,54269E-5

2,48654E-6

2,96952E-1

9.2

min

1,39766E-2

2,99986E-1

3,49381E-6

3,04771E-3

6,00902E-2

1,22920E-5

1,81286E-1

3,28018E-1

2,92827E-3

1,49503E-2

1,97067E-1

3,99081E-2

1,00992E-6

5,86975E-13

2,05271E-11

1,69369E-3

7,83287E-7

8,53580E-13

2,99999E-1

9,49407E-5

2,47950E-6

2,96950E-1

9.2

max

1,39784E-2

2,99990E-1

3,49794E-6

3,04792E-3

6,00919E-2

1,23039E-5

1,81288E-1

3,28020E-1

2,92922E-3

1,49518E-2

1,97069E-1

3,99098E-2

1,02394E-6

7,61418E-13

2,14189E-11

1,69417E-3

7,87430E-7

9,77413E-13

3,00000E-1

9,54269E-5

2,49401E-6

2,96952E-1

9.2

mean

1,39766E-2

2,99986E-1

3,49794E-6

3,04792E-3

6,00918E-2

1,23039E-5

1,81286E-1

3,28020E-1

2,92922E-3

1,49518E-2

1,97067E-1

3,99082E-2

1,00993E-6

7,51672E-13

2,13608E-11

1,69417E-3

7,83288E-7

9,01353E-13

2,99999E-1

9,54269E-5

2,48654E-6

2,96952E-1

9.2

relative error(%)

0,00

9.4

BioUML

1,43107E-2

2,99984E-1

3,86138E-6

3,12611E-3

6,01405E-2

1,36137E-5

1,80729E-1

3,27333E-1

3,07088E-3

1,52681E-2

1,96925E-1

3,98595E-2

1,15119E-6

9,71324E-13

2,66657E-11

1,76614E-3

8,79448E-7

1,14308E-12

2,99999E-1

1,02774E-4

2,72114E-6

2,96874E-1

9.4

ByoDyn

1,43107E-2

2,99984E-1

3,86138E-6

3,12611E-3

6,01405E-2

1,36137E-5

1,80729E-1

3,27333E-1

3,07088E-3

1,52681E-2

1,96925E-1

3,98595E-2

1,15119E-6

9,71324E-13

2,66657E-11

1,76614E-3

8,79448E-7

1,14308E-12

2,99999E-1

1,02774E-4

2,72114E-6

2,96874E-1

9.4

CVODE

1,43107E-2

2,99984E-1

3,86138E-6

3,12611E-3

6,01405E-2

1,36137E-5

1,80729E-1

3,27333E-1

3,07088E-3

1,52681E-2

1,96925E-1

3,98595E-2

1,15119E-6

9,71365E-13

2,66659E-11

1,76614E-3

8,79448E-7

1,14310E-12

2,99999E-1

1,02774E-4

2,72114E-6

2,96874E-1

9.4

Jarnac

1,43107E-2

2,99984E-1

3,86138E-6

3,12611E-3

6,01405E-2

1,36137E-5

1,80729E-1

3,27333E-1

3,07088E-3

1,52681E-2

1,96925E-1

3,98595E-2

1,15119E-6

8,08187E-13

2,66657E-11

1,76614E-3

8,79448E-7

1,09627E-12

2,99999E-1

1,02774E-4

2,72114E-6

2,96874E-1

9.4

MathSBML

1,43107E-2

2,99984E-1

3,85930E-6

3,12611E-3

6,01405E-2

1,36079E-5

1,80729E-1

3,27333E-1

3,07088E-3

1,52681E-2

1,96925E-1

3,98595E-2

1,15118E-6

9,73308E-13

2,67798E-11

1,76614E-3

8,79531E-7

1,14567E-12

2,99999E-1

1,02774E-4

2,72901E-6

2,96874E-1

9.4

Oscill8 Core

1,43107E-2

2,99984E-1

6,01405E-2

1,80729E-1

3,27333E-1

3,07088E-3

1,52681E-2

1,96925E-1

1,15119E-6

2,66659E-11

1,76614E-3

8,79449E-7

2,99999E-1

2,72114E-6

2,96874E-1

9.4

SBToolbox2

1,43130E-2

2,99980E-1

3,85753E-6

3,12583E-3

6,01391E-2

1,36031E-5

1,80728E-1

3,27328E-1

3,06993E-3

1,52669E-2

1,96929E-1

3,98609E-2

1,16706E-6

9,95270E-13

2,58609E-11

1,76562E-3

8,84195E-7

1,13204E-12

3,00000E-1

1,02273E-4

2,71403E-6

2,96870E-1

9.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,43107E-2

2,99984E-1

3,86138E-6

3,12611E-3

6,01405E-2

1,36137E-5

1,80729E-1

3,27333E-1

3,07088E-3

1,52681E-2

1,96925E-1

3,98595E-2

1,15119E-6

9,71329E-13

2,66659E-11

1,76614E-3

8,79449E-7

1,14308E-12

2,99999E-1

1,02774E-4

2,72114E-6

2,96874E-1

9.4

copasi

1,43107E-2

2,99984E-1

3,86138E-6

3,12611E-3

6,01405E-2

1,36137E-5

1,80729E-1

3,27333E-1

3,07088E-3

1,52681E-2

1,96925E-1

3,98595E-2

1,15119E-6

9,72067E-13

2,66701E-11

1,76614E-3

8,79447E-7

1,14352E-12

2,99999E-1

1,02774E-4

2,72114E-6

2,96874E-1

9.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,43107E-2

2,99984E-1

3,86138E-6

3,12611E-3

6,01405E-2

1,36137E-5

1,80729E-1

3,27333E-1

3,07088E-3

1,52681E-2

1,96925E-1

3,98595E-2

1,15119E-6

9,15100E-13

2,66662E-11

1,76614E-3

8,79448E-7

1,21939E-12

2,99999E-1

1,02774E-4

2,72114E-6

2,96874E-1

9.4

jsim

1,43107E-2

2,99984E-1

3,86138E-6

3,12611E-3

6,01405E-2

1,36137E-5

1,80729E-1

3,27333E-1

3,07088E-3

1,52681E-2

1,96925E-1

3,98595E-2

1,15119E-6

9,71324E-13

2,66657E-11

1,76614E-3

8,79448E-7

1,14308E-12

2,99999E-1

1,02774E-4

2,72114E-6

2,96874E-1

9.4

min

1,43107E-2

2,99980E-1

3,85753E-6

3,12583E-3

6,01391E-2

1,36031E-5

1,80728E-1

3,27328E-1

3,06993E-3

1,52669E-2

1,96925E-1

3,98595E-2

1,15118E-6

8,08187E-13

2,58609E-11

1,76562E-3

8,79447E-7

1,09627E-12

2,99999E-1

1,02273E-4

2,71403E-6

2,96870E-1

9.4

max

1,43130E-2

2,99984E-1

3,86138E-6

3,12611E-3

6,01405E-2

1,36137E-5

1,80729E-1

3,27333E-1

3,07088E-3

1,52681E-2

1,96929E-1

3,98609E-2

1,16706E-6

9,95270E-13

2,67798E-11

1,76614E-3

8,84195E-7

1,21939E-12

3,00000E-1

1,02774E-4

2,72901E-6

2,96874E-1

9.4

mean

1,43107E-2

2,99984E-1

3,86138E-6

3,12611E-3

6,01405E-2

1,36137E-5

1,80729E-1

3,27333E-1

3,07088E-3

1,52681E-2

1,96925E-1

3,98595E-2

1,15119E-6

9,71329E-13

2,66659E-11

1,76614E-3

8,79448E-7

1,14308E-12

2,99999E-1

1,02774E-4

2,72114E-6

2,96874E-1

9.4

relative error(%)

0,00

9.6

BioUML

1,46423E-2

2,99983E-1

4,25167E-6

3,20419E-3

6,01893E-2

1,50240E-5

1,80171E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21486E-3

1,55841E-2

1,96781E-1

3,98107E-2

1,30774E-6

1,24699E-12

3,31021E-11

1,83909E-3

9,84532E-7

1,44096E-12

2,99999E-1

1,10468E-4

2,97133E-6

2,96796E-1

9.6

ByoDyn

1,46423E-2

2,99983E-1

4,25167E-6

3,20419E-3

6,01893E-2

1,50240E-5

1,80171E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21486E-3

1,55841E-2

1,96781E-1

3,98107E-2

1,30774E-6

1,24699E-12

3,31021E-11

1,83909E-3

9,84532E-7

1,44096E-12

2,99999E-1

1,10468E-4

2,97133E-6

2,96796E-1

9.6

CVODE

1,46423E-2

2,99983E-1

4,25167E-6

3,20419E-3

6,01893E-2

1,50240E-5

1,80171E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21486E-3

1,55841E-2

1,96781E-1

3,98107E-2

1,30774E-6

1,24704E-12

3,31022E-11

1,83909E-3

9,84532E-7

1,44099E-12

2,99999E-1

1,10468E-4

2,97133E-6

2,96796E-1

9.6

Jarnac

1,46423E-2

2,99983E-1

4,25167E-6

3,20419E-3

6,01893E-2

1,50240E-5

1,80171E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21486E-3

1,55841E-2

1,96781E-1

3,98107E-2

1,30774E-6

1,08558E-12

3,31021E-11

1,83909E-3

9,84532E-7

1,39478E-12

2,99999E-1

1,10468E-4

2,97133E-6

2,96796E-1

9.6

MathSBML

1,46423E-2

2,99983E-1

4,25145E-6

3,20419E-3

6,01893E-2

1,50237E-5

1,80171E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21486E-3

1,55841E-2

1,96781E-1

3,98107E-2

1,30774E-6

1,24974E-12

3,32395E-11

1,83909E-3

9,84539E-7

1,44509E-12

2,99999E-1

1,10468E-4

2,97182E-6

2,96796E-1

9.6

Oscill8 Core

1,46423E-2

2,99983E-1

6,01893E-2

1,80171E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21486E-3

1,55841E-2

1,96781E-1

1,30774E-6

3,31022E-11

1,83909E-3

9,84533E-7

2,99999E-1

2,97133E-6

2,96796E-1

9.6

SBToolbox2

1,46446E-2

2,99980E-1

4,24841E-6

3,20396E-3

6,01881E-2

1,50159E-5

1,80169E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21379E-3

1,55826E-2

1,96780E-1

3,98119E-2

1,32593E-6

1,29036E-12

3,23512E-11

1,83855E-3

9,90082E-7

1,44018E-12

3,00000E-1

1,09966E-4

2,96442E-6

2,96800E-1

9.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,46423E-2

2,99983E-1

4,25167E-6

3,20419E-3

6,01893E-2

1,50240E-5

1,80171E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21486E-3

1,55841E-2

1,96781E-1

3,98107E-2

1,30774E-6

1,24700E-12

3,31020E-11

1,83909E-3

9,84533E-7

1,44097E-12

2,99999E-1

1,10468E-4

2,97134E-6

2,96796E-1

9.6

copasi

1,46424E-2

2,99983E-1

4,25167E-6

3,20419E-3

6,01894E-2

1,50240E-5

1,80171E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21486E-3

1,55841E-2

1,96781E-1

3,98106E-2

1,30774E-6

1,24785E-12

3,31068E-11

1,83909E-3

9,84531E-7

1,44146E-12

2,99999E-1

1,10468E-4

2,97133E-6

2,96796E-1

9.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,46423E-2

2,99983E-1

4,25167E-6

3,20419E-3

6,01893E-2

1,50240E-5

1,80171E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21486E-3

1,55841E-2

1,96781E-1

3,98107E-2

1,30774E-6

1,19268E-12

3,31026E-11

1,83909E-3

9,84532E-7

1,51651E-12

2,99999E-1

1,10468E-4

2,97133E-6

2,96796E-1

9.6

jsim

1,46424E-2

2,99983E-1

4,25167E-6

3,20419E-3

6,01893E-2

1,50240E-5

1,80171E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21486E-3

1,55841E-2

1,96781E-1

3,98107E-2

1,30774E-6

1,24699E-12

3,31021E-11

1,83909E-3

9,84532E-7

1,44096E-12

2,99999E-1

1,10468E-4

2,97133E-6

2,96796E-1

9.6

min

1,46423E-2

2,99980E-1

4,24841E-6

3,20396E-3

6,01881E-2

1,50159E-5

1,80169E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21379E-3

1,55826E-2

1,96780E-1

3,98106E-2

1,30774E-6

1,08558E-12

3,23512E-11

1,83855E-3

9,84531E-7

1,39478E-12

2,99999E-1

1,09966E-4

2,96442E-6

2,96796E-1

9.6

max

1,46446E-2

2,99983E-1

4,25167E-6

3,20419E-3

6,01894E-2

1,50240E-5

1,80171E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21486E-3

1,55841E-2

1,96781E-1

3,98119E-2

1,32593E-6

1,29036E-12

3,32395E-11

1,83909E-3

9,90082E-7

1,51651E-12

3,00000E-1

1,10468E-4

2,97182E-6

2,96800E-1

9.6

mean

1,46423E-2

2,99983E-1

4,25167E-6

3,20419E-3

6,01893E-2

1,50240E-5

1,80171E-1

3,26648E-1

3,21486E-3

1,55841E-2

1,96781E-1

3,98107E-2

1,30774E-6

1,24700E-12

3,31021E-11

1,83909E-3

9,84532E-7

1,44097E-12

2,99999E-1

1,10468E-4

2,97133E-6

2,96796E-1

9.6

relative error(%)

0,00

9.8

BioUML

1,49714E-2

2,99981E-1

4,66997E-6

3,28216E-3

6,02383E-2

1,65393E-5

1,79612E-1

3,25966E-1

3,36109E-3

1,58999E-2

1,96634E-1

3,97617E-2

1,48076E-6

1,59094E-12

4,08724E-11

1,91300E-3

1,09910E-6

1,80609E-12

2,99999E-1

1,18514E-4

3,23771E-6

2,96718E-1

9.8

ByoDyn

1,49714E-2

2,99981E-1

4,66997E-6

3,28216E-3

6,02383E-2

1,65393E-5

1,79612E-1

3,25966E-1

3,36109E-3

1,58999E-2

1,96634E-1

3,97617E-2

1,48076E-6

1,59094E-12

4,08724E-11

1,91300E-3

1,09910E-6

1,80609E-12

2,99999E-1

1,18514E-4

3,23771E-6

2,96718E-1

9.8

CVODE

1,49714E-2

2,99981E-1

4,66997E-6

3,28216E-3

6,02383E-2

1,65393E-5

1,79612E-1

3,25966E-1

3,36109E-3

1,58999E-2

1,96634E-1

3,97617E-2

1,48076E-6

1,59100E-12

4,08726E-11

1,91300E-3

1,09910E-6

1,80612E-12

2,99999E-1

1,18514E-4

3,23771E-6

2,96718E-1

9.8

Jarnac

1,49714E-2

2,99981E-1

4,66997E-6

3,28216E-3

6,02383E-2

1,65393E-5

1,79612E-1

3,25966E-1

3,36109E-3

1,58999E-2

1,96634E-1

3,97617E-2

1,48076E-6

1,43185E-12

4,08724E-11

1,91300E-3

1,09910E-6

1,76025E-12

2,99999E-1

1,18514E-4

3,23771E-6

2,96718E-1

9.8

MathSBML

1,49714E-2

2,99981E-1

4,67008E-6

3,28216E-3

6,02383E-2

1,65401E-5

1,79612E-1

3,25966E-1

3,36109E-3

1,58999E-2

1,96634E-1

3,97617E-2

1,48076E-6

1,59483E-12

4,10218E-11

1,91300E-3

1,09910E-6

1,81190E-12

2,99999E-1

1,18514E-4

3,23687E-6

2,96718E-1

9.8

Oscill8 Core

1,49714E-2

2,99981E-1

6,02383E-2

1,79612E-1

3,25966E-1

3,36109E-3

1,58999E-2

1,96634E-1

1,48076E-6

4,08725E-11

1,91300E-3

1,09911E-6

2,99999E-1

3,23771E-6

2,96718E-1

9.8

SBToolbox2

1,49733E-2

2,99980E-1

4,66663E-6

3,28188E-3

6,02370E-2

1,65306E-5

1,79609E-1

3,25969E-1

3,35995E-3

1,58983E-2

1,96640E-1

3,97630E-2

1,50048E-6

1,64679E-12

3,99973E-11

1,91247E-3

1,10512E-6

1,80780E-12

3,00000E-1

1,17998E-4

3,23058E-6

2,96720E-1

9.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,49714E-2

2,99981E-1

4,66997E-6

3,28216E-3

6,02383E-2

1,65393E-5

1,79612E-1

3,25966E-1

3,36109E-3

1,58999E-2

1,96634E-1

3,97617E-2

1,48076E-6

1,59095E-12

4,08723E-11

1,91300E-3

1,09910E-6

1,80610E-12

2,99999E-1

1,18514E-4

3,23772E-6

2,96718E-1

9.8

copasi

1,49714E-2

2,99981E-1

4,66997E-6

3,28216E-3

6,02384E-2

1,65393E-5

1,79612E-1

3,25966E-1

3,36109E-3

1,58998E-2

1,96634E-1

3,97616E-2

1,48076E-6

1,59198E-12

4,08777E-11

1,91300E-3

1,09910E-6

1,80667E-12

2,99999E-1

1,18514E-4

3,23771E-6

2,96718E-1

9.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,49714E-2

2,99981E-1

4,66997E-6

3,28216E-3

6,02383E-2

1,65393E-5

1,79612E-1

3,25966E-1

3,36109E-3

1,58999E-2

1,96634E-1

3,97617E-2

1,48076E-6

1,53924E-12

4,08730E-11

1,91300E-3

1,09910E-6

1,88019E-12

2,99999E-1

1,18514E-4

3,23771E-6

2,96718E-1

9.8

jsim

1,49714E-2

2,99981E-1

4,66997E-6

3,28216E-3

6,02383E-2

1,65393E-5

1,79612E-1

3,25966E-1

3,36109E-3

1,58998E-2

1,96634E-1

3,97617E-2

1,48076E-6

1,59094E-12

4,08724E-11

1,91300E-3

1,09910E-6

1,80609E-12

2,99999E-1

1,18514E-4

3,23771E-6

2,96718E-1

9.8

min

1,49714E-2

2,99980E-1

4,66663E-6

3,28188E-3

6,02370E-2

1,65306E-5

1,79609E-1

3,25966E-1

3,35995E-3

1,58983E-2

1,96634E-1

3,97616E-2

1,48076E-6

1,43185E-12

3,99973E-11

1,91247E-3

1,09910E-6

1,76025E-12

2,99999E-1

1,17998E-4

3,23058E-6

2,96718E-1

9.8

max

1,49733E-2

2,99981E-1

4,67008E-6

3,28216E-3

6,02384E-2

1,65401E-5

1,79612E-1

3,25969E-1

3,36109E-3

1,58999E-2

1,96640E-1

3,97630E-2

1,50048E-6

1,64679E-12

4,10218E-11

1,91300E-3

1,10512E-6

1,88019E-12

3,00000E-1

1,18514E-4

3,23772E-6

2,96720E-1

9.8

mean

1,49714E-2

2,99981E-1

4,66997E-6

3,28216E-3

6,02383E-2

1,65393E-5

1,79612E-1

3,25966E-1

3,36109E-3

1,58999E-2

1,96634E-1

3,97617E-2

1,48076E-6

1,59095E-12

4,08725E-11

1,91300E-3

1,09910E-6

1,80612E-12

2,99999E-1

1,18514E-4

3,23771E-6

2,96718E-1

9.8

relative error(%)

0,00